Georg Hoffstaetter, Professor Cornell University / CLASSE ...
Transcript of Georg Hoffstaetter, Professor Cornell University / CLASSE ...
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
1
Status of Cornell’s ERL Project
Georg Hoffstaetter, ProfessorCornell University / CLASSE / SRF group & ERL effort
a) Vision for the Futureb) Developments since ERL workshop at Cornell in June 2009c) Planned activities
EducationDesign Research
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
2
Layout and Optics since ERL workshop
1) Quality engineering:(a) shorter building to not cross road, 14 undulators(b) No third, and reduced 2nd floor on x-ray user building(c) Tighter and shorter Turn Around
2) Analysis of one versus 2 turn ERLs3) Decision to build a 1 turn ERL to reduce operational risks1) Keep CESR as is. Later upgrade reduces North emittance by 50%2) Provide a limited number of novel experiments: 14 x-ray beamlines3) Complete layout, magnet lattice, optics: version 8.0
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
3
1) Hard x-rays: 5GeV, competitive current: up to 100mAlow charge per bunch low emittance
2) Working modes: current, emittances, energy spread, bunch lengthA) 100mA, 30/30pm, 2.e-4, 2psB) 25mA, 8/ 8pm, 2.e-4, 2psC) 25mA, 300/10pm, 2.e-3, 1ps in South, 100fs in North beamlines
D) The option of large bunch charge (1nC) with low repetition rate (100kHz),without energy recovery, is not used for x-ray users.up to 1nC is used for accelerator studies, e.g. of XFELO or HGHG FELs
Electron Beam Parameters
300pm
100fs 0
-12%
12%
24%
Energy spread at beam stop
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
4
Lattice choices for Version 8.0
Accelerator R&D area
• Completely reworked model• TA and TB have a smaller bending radius (40m), with mergers.• 0.5mrad soft bends to protect undulators• A diagnostic beamline (DB) is added • All bending magnet lengths adjusted for single power supplies. • Collimators have been added prior to all undulators • Beam abort collimators have been added prior to LB and LA. • BPMs and Corrector Coils have been added everywhere in SA, TA, TB, and NA.• Vacuum pump ports, sliding joints, and gate valves have been added everywhere.
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
5
1) Second InjectorA 30cm kicker has been placedprior to merger bends
2) TA & TB with demerger and mergerComplete
3) Isochronous NA undulator cellsA reverse bend has beenadded to these cells
4) DumpAdded
5) Path length adjuster in TB
Cut
esy
Chr
is M
ayes
Layout and Optics: Major Sections
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
6
6) Vacuum systemPump Ports, Sliding Joints, and Gate Valves have been added (YL & DR)
7) Orbit CorrectionBPMs and Correction coils have been placed everywhere
8) CollimatorsCollimators are placed prior to every undulator, and beam abort collimators have been added
9) Dispersion compensation bends at merger an dumpSecond pass merger dispersion is matched to zero from the last NA cell
10) X-ray absorbers to protect cavitiesCollimators already shield all SR prior to cavities (NA end and TA end)
Layout and Optics: Devices
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
7
11) Spurs in AutoLISPValeri has modified the AutoCADgeneration program to be more general
12) Optimize OpticsMode A (on-crest) is completeMode C (bunch compression) is in progress (CE dispersion and time of flight are difficult to adjust)
13) Adjust magnetic fields for SR lossesNeed to get Bmad to calculate. However, Relative energy change due to SR is ~10-6
14) Efficient Distribution of Power suppliesDR classified and adjusted bend lengths. These have been added to the lattice
Layout and Optics: Miscellaneous
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
8
3.0 m0.57 T, 0.31T
1.0 m0.3 T
1.5 m0.6 T
Layout and Optics: Turnaround murgers
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
9
NA
SA
Layout and Optics: Undulators
Provides 14 high spectral brightness beamlines
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
10
A Huge job – industry connections have to start nowFrom a recent RFP for the electron transport system:
Electron Beamline Elements
Furthermore the SRF linac:
64 cryomodules384 cavities with 7 cells385 RF sources, couplers, etc64 superconducting quadrupoles128 superconducting correctors64 cold bpms…
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
11
1) The engineering firm ARUP is producing a baseline for X-ray buildings, new office space, 14ft diameter tunnel, either ebtbm or mining.
2) UTAP is a consultant on tunneling, will review ARUP in February.
Conventional Construction
ARUP
UTAP
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
12
Conceptual ERL design
accacc
x
inj
x
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
13
Significant IBS and Touschek loss challenges
1) Low emittances create very large beam density and therefore large IBS and Touschek rates leading to emittance and energy spread growth.
2) The relevant beam density is the slice density, not the rms density.
3) Small round emittances allow round, narrow undulator apertures. The IBS Halo then has to be collimated accordingly, inceasing Touschek loss rates.
4) Cornell ERL has large collimators in the tunnel to eliminate loss rates from the arcs, and smaller collimators in front of every undultor.
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
14Localization and elimination of nonlinear errors
0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.080.08
0.07
0.06
0.05
0.04
20 18 16 142
4
6
8
10
12
14
16Distortions of a regular grid of beamlets
Before cryomodule
Aftercryomodule
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
15 Nonlinear Field Error in the 2-3 regionLocalized by a beam based search
3000 3500 4000 4500 50000.00
0.05
0.10
0.15
0.20
Center of 3rd HOM absorber
Coupler 2
Coupler 3
Coupler 4
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
16
December 17, 2009 Florian Loehl
Removing inner tiles after finding that they charge up at 80K
Stress relief slots
Beamside tiles removed
Consequence of low resistivities of absorber materials:• Completely removed TT2 ferrite because some had fallen off• Tried gold coating of TTE absorbers but coating may fall off
Removed all tiles from the inside of the HOM absorber
Found loose tiles during cryomodule disassembly• Thermal stress tests confirmed
this problem Solved by cutting stress relief
slots in the tiles on top of removing TT2 ferrite
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
17Beamline String Assembly
Attach cold couplers to beamline string
Cold coupler
Cavity
Beamline HOM load
He vessel pump port
Attach cold couplers to beamline string
Cold coupler
Cavity
Beamline HOM load
He vessel pump port
Cleanroom assembly fixturing
Gate valve internalto cryomodule
Vacuum vessel interface flangeCleanroom assembly fixturing
Gate valve internalto cryomodule
Vacuum vessel interface flange
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
18Technical Details, Justification
and critical needs for R&D Projects
Cornell Electron
Storage Ring Tunnel
a) Continued Gun R&Db) ERL cryomodule constructiona-c) Hi-brightness beam physics
d) ERL Undulatorse) Other X-ray beamline R&D
a)
b)
c)
d)
e)
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
19
Example Main Linac Cost Distribution for E=16.2 MV/m
• High current, multi GeV SRF linacs for ERLs are great for hard x-ray sources• The SRF components are the cost drivers of these novel accelerators• Driving SRF challenges are the dynamics load and theirfor low loss
technology.• HOMs and their control become critical• Microphonis and control becomes critical• It is thus very much worth to invest in these research subjects.
Tunnel RF system Cryomodules Cryogenic plant0
10
20
30
40
50re
lativ
e co
st [
%]
Importance of CW SRF research
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
20
Cornell Electron
Storage Ring Tunnel
a) Continued Gun R&Db) ERL cryomodulec) Hi-brightness beam physics
d) ERL Undulatorse) Other X-ray beamline R&D
a)
b)
c)
d)
e)
Further preconstruction work:Main x-ray ERL cyromodule
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
21
21
PessimisticParameter Units Value
10 MeV Injector (Cornell ICM) Injector RF Power kW 1000Injector Cryo Heat Load W 40
ERL Eacc MV/m 20Operating Temperature K 2Qo 1.00E+10Peak Microphonics Hz 20Qe (Perfect ER) 3.30E+07RF Power per Cavity (Perfect ER) kW 6.4Pdiss per cavity W 41.6Static Load per Cavity W 2Second Pass Phase Deg 179.8Qe (Imperfect ER) 2.10E+07RF Power per Cavity (Imperfect ER) kW 10Total Number of Cavities 337RF Power Overhead % 25ERL RF Power (Perfect ER) kW 2699ERL RF Power (Imperfect ER) kW 4229ERL Cryo Power kW 14.7
Total Total Dynamic Load kW 14.1Total Static Load kW 0.7Cryo Safety Factor % 50Cryo Efficiency ACW/W 800Total Cryo Capacity kW 14.8Total AC RF Power (Perfect ER) MW 7.4Total AC RF Power (Imperfect ER) MW 10.46Total AC Cryo Power MW 17.7Total AC Power (Perfect ER) MW 25.1Total AC Power (Imperfect ER) MW 28.16
OptimisticValue100040
161.8
2.00E+1010
6.50E+072
13.31
179.954.80E+07
2.842110
95012866.0
5.70.450
8006.13.9
4.577.2911.1911.86
ERL SRF Power Consumption
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
22
CLSCESR
DIAMOND
SSRF TLS
Technology transfer to industry
Technology transfer
Turn-Key Systems
Example of Industry Connection:Cornell 500MHz cavities
1999: Cornell University and ACCEL agreed on technology transfer of the 500MHz SRF module2000: 2 SRF modules for NSRRC, Taiwan; delivered operational2000: 2 SRF modules for Cornell, USA; delivered operational2000: 2 SRF modules for CLS, Canada; delivered operational2003: 3 SRF modules for DLS, Great Britain; delivered operational2005: 3 SRF modules for SSRF, China; delivered operational
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
23
30cm long prototype of Delta undulator installed inbeam line #2 at ATF (BNL)
Electron beam image on flag downstream of the undulator
Fundamental harmonics in planar mode Fundamental harmonics in helical mode
Component Prototyping: Delta Undulator
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
24
1) Specify technological choices, cost, and construction timeA) For the electron beamline done following mentioned RFPB) For gun and injector, following Phase 1a and Phase 1b funded prototypingC) For SRF linac following cryomodule construction of Phase 1bD) For x-ray beamlines a set of generic lines will be designed for costing which then can be modified by beamline teams before construction.
2) Cavity operations stability, Quality factor Q0, operations costA) We produce cavities for the Int. CW Cryomodule in DaresburyB) Operation of cavities in our Horizontal Test Cryostat for large Q0 (at NSF)C) Operation of a full ERL cryomodule in Phase 1b.
3) Undulator construction cost and construction time in Phase 1b
Component Prototyping: Phase 1a and 1b
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
25
DUSEL: Cavity design and prototyping for Project-X(ICD1 or ICD2), vendor development and qualification for Project-X and ILC. We are already part of the Project-X team via an MOU.
SRF R&D: T-map analysis as tool for process influences on high gradients and high Q, highest Qs at medium fields, frequent Q degradation in accelerator cryostat environments.
Muon collider: explosion bonded material testing(Nb on Cu for less cost and more heat transfer)with 500MHz cavities for cost and quicker turnaround(for reduced size compared to 200MHz).
SRF R&D synergetic with work for HEP
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
26 Knowledge disseminationfor Accelerators
Editor:Frank Zimmermann (CERN)Associate Editors:Georg H. Hoffstaetter (Cornell)Brand M. Johnson (BNL)Senior Assistant Editor:Debbie Brodbar
Focus IssueAccelerator and Beam Physics
Editors:Georg Hoffstaetter (Cornell)Kwang-Je Kim (ANL)Ferdinand Willeke (DESY)
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
27Education and workforce development
Undergraduate and graduate students working on ERL injector with physics faculty (Cornell, Wilson lab, L0 area)Graduate Students: 10 accelerator physics, 4 of which SRF
9 high energy physics experiment
Georg H. Hoffstaetter Future Ligh Sources Workshop – Status of Cornell’s ERL 1 March 2010
CLASSE
28
1) Layout – rather order complete2) Operations simulation – much still needed3) BBU – rather complete4) Orbit correction – 1st order analyzed5) Emittance growth – 1st order analyzed6) Shielding – 1nd order analyzed7) Front to end simulation – much still needed8) Sensitivity analysis – 1st order analyzed
Accelerator Analysis and Documentation in aComprehensive Design Report
The full concept is to be documented by this summer in a CDRA) Overview – including short science caseB) x-ray beamline – Generic beamlinesC) Accelerator – Accelerator Physics and Technolgy choicesD) Conventional FacilitiesE) Management – Including SafetyF) Operations – Transition, Reliability