Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion...

19
Pergamon PH: S0045-6535(99)00104-6 C~m~osphere, Vol. 39, No. 2, pp. 209-227, 1999 © 1999 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved 0045-65351991 $ - see front matter ENVIRONMENTAL TRANSFER OF ZINC IN CALCAREOUS SOILS IN ZONES NEAR OLD MINING SITES WITH SEMI-ARIDIC CLIMATE. GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. Department of Agricultural Chemistry, Geology and Pedology, Faculty of Chemistry. University of Murcia, E-30071. Spain. SUMMARY A study on the speclation and bioavailability of zinc in calcareous soils near an old mining site in semi-aridic conditions (S.E Spain) is presented. The mobility of both solid particles and soluble compounds of zinc are considered. The processes governing zinc transfer from the element-rich zone to the neighbouring soils are strongly influenced by the semi-aridic climate, while the presence of a high proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions which take place in the solid-liquid-gas interfaces are discussed. Data were obtained using both conventional methods for element speciation and a recently reported method especially adapted to highly calcareous soils. The procedure allows to outline the main speciation forms of zinc in these soils. Data obtained by means of X-ray diffraction spectrometry and SEM - EDX analyzer are used to confirm the chemical results. © 1999Elsevier ScienceLtd, All rightsreserved INTRODUCTION The fate and transfer pathways of Zn in soils are complex, and depend on the soils' mineralogy and the physical transport process involved. Transformations and transport are strongly influenced by site- specific conditions and management practices, although climatic and weather ~,onditions other than rainfall may also influence the fate. There are large areas of calcareous soils in SE Spain and many of these coincide with places where Pb and Zn are mined. These soils often present very high levels of these metals with a strong spatial dispersion of values. 209

Transcript of Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion...

Page 1: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

Pergamon

PH: S0045-6535(99)00104-6

C~m~osphere, Vol. 39, No. 2, pp. 209-227, 1999 © 1999 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved

0045-65351991 $ - see front matter

ENVIRONMENTAL TRANSFER OF ZINC IN CALCAREOUS SOILS IN ZONES NEAR OLD

MINING SITES WITH SEMI-ARIDIC CLIMATE.

GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C.

Department of Agricultural Chemistry, Geology and Pedology, Faculty of Chemistry. University of

Murcia, E-30071. Spain.

SUMMARY

A study on the speclation and bioavailability of zinc in calcareous soils near an old mining site in

semi-aridic conditions (S.E Spain) is presented. The mobility of both solid particles and soluble

compounds of zinc are considered. The processes governing zinc transfer from the element-rich zone to the

neighbouring soils are strongly influenced by the semi-aridic climate, while the presence of a high

proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions which take

place in the solid-liquid-gas interfaces are discussed.

Data were obtained using both conventional methods for element speciation and a recently reported

method especially adapted to highly calcareous soils. The procedure allows to outline the main speciation

forms of zinc in these soils. Data obtained by means of X-ray diffraction spectrometry and SEM - EDX

analyzer are used to confirm the chemical results. © 1999 Elsevier Science Ltd, All rights reserved

INTRODUCTION

The fate and transfer pathways of Zn in soils are complex, and depend on the soils' mineralogy and

the physical transport process involved. Transformations and transport are strongly influenced by site-

specific conditions and management practices, although climatic and weather ~,onditions other than rainfall

may also influence the fate.

There are large areas of calcareous soils in SE Spain and many of these coincide with places where

Pb and Zn are mined. These soils often present very high levels of these metals with a strong spatial

dispersion of values.

209

Page 2: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

210

(Mazarr6n)

• (

; ', A k

. , . . . . . ..'" , ,7' % • i + , ,] : .__?' ) ~ . . . < ~ N

" " - - -~'='L~- " ' t "-- P,.amb/a de Laa . . ~ - - - ' - ' - ~ - ~ _

Mediterranean Sea

1 0 1 2 3 4 5 K i n S04=, Zn2+, W

Ca 2+, Mff ~÷, HCO3"

C d +, Mg 2+, Na +, IC, Cl. HCO~", SO4'

Figure 1.= Location of the studied Zone

Page 3: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

211

The area around Mazarron (Murcia, SE Spain) presents ideal characteristics for a study of the kind

we describe in this paper. There are many old mining installations while the soil is calcareous and often

has a very high Zn content. The study area (Fig 1) has geomorphological, pedological and climatic

characteristics similar to other mining areas in the Mediterranean area with a scant, degraded vegetation.

Agriculture is intensive, both in the open air and in greenhouse, and is mainly dedicated to horticultural

crops.

The soils studied are located in Las Moreras Rambla (wadi complex) and may occasionally be

flooded when this gully fills with water after heavy rain. The soils of the area feeding the rambla are calcic

and petrocaicic Xerosols, and calcareous Regosols [1]. Nearby there is a drainage channel which carries

substantial quantities of materials from the mining area (Urbic Antrosols) in Cabezo de San Cristobal and

Las Pedreras.

MATERIALS AND METHODS.

Twenty samples were obtained from a 5 Km 2 sampling zone. The general characteristics of the

arable soil layer were determined by the methods used to draw up a soil map of the area in the LUCDEME

project [1].

The total zinc content was determined by flame atomic absorption spectrometry (FAAS). For this

purpose the samples were slurried in a dilute hydrofluoric acid solution and the suspensions were directly

introduced into the flame by means of a simple flow injection manifold [2]. A Perkin-Elmer model 1100 B

AAS spectrometer was used to obtain the measurements.

The selective extractants used were: water (1:10); 1 M ammonium acetate at pH 7.0 [3]; oxalic

acid-oxalate [4]; 0.1 M sodium pyrophosphate, [4] ; sodium dithionite + sodium citrate [5]; 0.5 M acetic

acid [6]; 0.5 M ammonium acetate + 0.02M EDTA + acetic acid at pH 4.65 [7]; DTPA [8] and sodium

bicarbonate 0.1N, pH 8.5 [9]. In addition, an acccptad sequential extraction procedure [10] based on three

successive extraction stages was also applied to the same samples and the results were comparad with those

found using the above quoted reagents. The zinc content in each fraction was analyzed by FAAS.

The mineralogical composition of the samples was determined by XRD analysis using Cu-Kc¢

radiation with a PW-1212 Philips Diffractometer, equipped with a digital recorder. The experimental

conditions were: velocity 2 °/min., automatic window, Ni filter. Using the diffraction intensities obtained

and the values for the same phases given in the bibliography, a semiquantitative analysis was made of the

treated and untreated samples. The samples were also examined using a JEOL 6100 scanning electron

microscopy (SEM) instrument, equipped with an EDX analyzer, Link Isis Oxford, with Si-Li detector and

working at 39 mm heigth and 20 KV voltage.

Page 4: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

212

RESULTS and DISCUSSION

Environmental Conditions

Annual rainfall is 185-312 mm and the average temperature is 16.5 to 18.8 °C. Mean potential

evapotranspiration is 869-935 mm and there is a very pronounced hydric deficit. Rainfall is scarce and

tends to be torrential. Flash floods may occur with occasionally disastrous consequences.

In our climatic conditions, the high temperatures cause the water contained near the surface of the

soil to evaporate rapidly. The fundamental alteration and mobilization processes occur at the unsaturated

zone or aeration zone, where the water is in the form ofvadose water. The water remains here for a longer

time and there is greater root development.

The materials which participate in the formation of these soils are sediments from soils developed

on carbonated rocks (limestones, dolomites, sandy marls and conglomerates), volcanic rocks and slags

which are found in the areas around the gully (Fig. 1) and which have undergone a process of erosion,

transport and sedimentation.

The materials which contribute Zn to the study area (Table 1) come from mine wastes, which are a

mixture of materials including: unaltered parent material (dacites and riodacites), altered parent materials,

primary mineralization products (metallic sulfides), secondary mineralization (hydrotberrnal alteration and

products of the supergenic alteration of sulfides) and remains from the mechanical and metallurgical

treatment of exploited ores. These materials therefore are of a very varied nature with a heterogeneous

granulometry [ 11 ].

Table 1.- Zn content in some parent materials

Min Max Average

Parent volcanic rock (ppm) 41 211 95

Weathered volcanic rock 158 2673 625

(ppm)

Sulfate mining waste (%) 0.34 7.67 0.98

Soil (ppm) 200 5000 620

Acidic water (ppm) 1690 40755 12285

Page 5: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

213

Transport of mat~Is; dissolved load and particulate forms: suspended and bed loads.

Floods are particularly important in the transport of sediment in this zone. Thus, the sporadic torrential

rains of the area transport large quantities of carbonated materials and materials from the slags. Excessive rates

of water flow prevent infiltration, lead to flash floods and cause soil erosion.

Slowly flowing water creates dams on the slopes of the mining areas, leading to new alteration

phenomena. This water flows for several days after the rains in the vadose zone. The soluble products

contained in the waters which leach from the slags are very rich in sulphate, Fe, A1, Mg, Zn, Mn, (major

elements, > 10 mmol/l) and Si, Cu, As, Sb, Ge, Cr, Sn, Cd, Pb (as minor elements, <10 mmoVl). The pH is

between 1.5 and 2.2. The mineralogical composition of the precipitates from acid waters are shown in Table 2

[12]. The mineralogy of these compounds is closely related with the overall chemical composition of the

samples, as found in Nova Scotia [13].

When a rapid flow of water occurs, soluble and particulated forms are dragged unchanged from their

place of origin as far as the gully. The mineralized materials contribute and generate insoluble sulfates

(anglesite, jarosite, alunite, ...), oxides and oxihydroxides and clay minerals such as kaolinite and chlorite,

with a different Zn content, which are transported with the soluble materials.

Table 2. Mineralogical composition of the precipitates in acid waters.

%

Formula Max Average

Copiapite (Zn,Fe,Mg)(AI,Fe)4(SO4)6(OH~. 20 H20 50 14

Halotrichite FeAI:~(SO4)4. 22 H20 35 18

Alunogene A12(SO4)3. 17 H20 15 8

Paracoqulmbite Fez(SO4)3.171-120 14 10

Bianehite (Zn, Fe, Mg) SO4.H20 40 15

Sedimentation processes and chemical interactions solid-liquid- gas.

The waters which run off and leach from calcareous materials have a high HCO3" content. When

this solution reacts with the above mentioned acidic waters there is a coprecipitation of basic iron

carbonates, and these retain different proportions of Zn. The Fe (SO4) 7 H20 (melanterite) and other Fe(I1)

sulphate phases are only stable at very acidic pH. The importance of these phases is that the Fe0I) sulfates

are preoursols of the genesis of Fe(OH)3, which is a Zn adsorbent, although it carries other metals besides Zn.

Page 6: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

214

The extent of Fe(OH)3 precipitation depends on pH, while Fe2 CO3(OHh is only formed at high pH

values.

The flee soluble Zn can react with HCO3 :

HCO3- + Zn +2 ::::3. ZnCO3 (s) + W [1]

1-120 + Zn +2 ~ Zn(OH)2 (s) + 21-1 + [2]

a reaction which is favored as the acidity of the medium is reduced.

If, in addition to HCO3", ligands such as CI-, SO4 =, CO3 =, OH', humic and fulvic acids, and CN"

(used in sulfide flotation processes) are also present, Zn complexation reactions may occur.

The oxidation of sulfides arises from the instability of these phases when they occur in an oxidising

and acidic medium. The most important oxidation reactions for the mobilization of Zn are those involving

pyrite and sphalerite:

4 FeS2 (s) + 15 02 (g) + (8+2x) H20 =>2 Fe203.x 1-120 + 8 SO4 = (aq) + 161-1 + (aq) [3]

ZnS (s) + 2 Fe+3+ 1.5 02 + 1-120 ~ ZnSO4+ 2 Fe +2 + 21-1 + [4]

The carbon dioxide acts in the oxidation process by carbonating the metal and supplying sulfate

ions which catalyze subsequent oxidation reactions and by increasing the medium's acidity:

ZnS + CO2 + H20 + 202 ~ ZnCO3 + SO4 = + 21-1 + [5]

Finally, Zn sorption/desorption reactions occur in the above interactions with those involving Al

and Fe oxides/hydroxides being especially important. Although humic substances act as Zn adsorbents in

soil, this effect is of little importance in our case because they are present in very small quantities (Table

3).

Characteristics of the soils: chemical and mineralogical

Table 3 shows the mean values of the analytical data of the soil samples studied. All the samples

were collected from the top 30 cm (approximately, the A horizon). The scarce organic material

accompanying these soils undergoes subsequent oxidation and mineralization, which are very important

biological degradation processes in the soils of semiarid areas such as those studied [14].

All the soil samples studied had a slightly basic pH, reflecting their high calcium carbonate content.

The texture was sandy loam to clay loam and the cationic exchange capacity values were low, as it was

expected in soils with a low proportion of organic matter and illite type clay. In some cases, the

concentration of soluble salts was very high for cultivated soils.

A mineralogical study of the fine earth fraction showed that all the samples were of a similar

composition: calcite (30-40%), quartz (20-35%), illite (10-25%), feldspars (10-20%) and dolomite (0-

15%). Representing less than 5% in all samples and therefore not easily observed by XRD, were the oxides

and oxihydroxides of Fe and Mn, which are of low crystallinity or amorphous. Some samples contained

Page 7: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

215

gypsum, and others sulphates like bianchite and jarosite. R must also be noted that total Zn levels (Table 1)

were higher than those proposed as maximum acceptable concentrations (MAC) in agricultural soils

(Tables 4 and 5) [15]o

TaMe 3. Analytical data of soil samples

% % meq/100g ds/m pH (1:1) Particle Size Distribution

O.M C/N CaCO3 T" E.C ~ H20 KCI %Sand %Silt %Clay

min 1.0 3.3 27.9 7.6 2.7 7.7 7.6 23.1 11.0 12.1

max 1.9 6.7 66.7 16.0 9.4 8.0 7.8 55.0 49.4 21.5

average 1.3 4.4 39.2 11.0 3.4 7.9 7.7 42.5 24.5 16.4

* . °

Catlomc exchange capacity

+Electric conductivity obtained from saturation extract of soil.

The values also exceed some of the maximum values considered acceptable in agricultural soils by

the EU [16] and in soils to the which sewage sludge has been added.

Table 4. Reference Values in Netherland (Zn ppm)*

A level 200

B level 500

C level 3000

* from Reference [15]

Table 5.- Maximum acceptable concentrations (MAC)

ofZn (ppm) for soils in different countries*.

Austria 300

Canada 400

Poland 300

Japan 250

* from Reference [ 15]

Page 8: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

216

Examination of the samples using a scanning electron microscope equipped with EDS analyser

revealed quartz, calcite, clays, plagioclase and feldspars in different particle sizes. Mapping of the

chemical element distribution showed that the zinc was distributed widely but with no set morphology.

Figure 2 shows mapping image obtained from a representative sample (sample 3).

Figure 2.- Mapping of the chemical element distribution of sample 3 obtained by

SEM-EDS.

Page 9: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

Sequential extraction for Zn speciation

217

Chemical extraction sequences were applied to differentiate between exchangeable, carbonated,

reducible (hydrous Fe/Mn oxides), oxidizable (sulfides and organic phases) and residual Zn fractions. The

advantage of this approach lies in the fact that the rearrangement of specific solid "phases" can be

evaluated prior to the actual remobilization of certain proportions of the element into the dissolved phase

[17].

%Zn cxtr. 60

50

40

30

20

10

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

Samples

Figure 3.- Results for Zn e~traction (nine samples) using sequential extl"aetion procedure [ 10]

Figure 3 shows the fractions of Zn in the sequence of extracts obtained from nine representative

samples. The literature [10] suggests that the first extract corresponds to the acid soluble fraction representing

the metal hound in exchange positions, water soluble metal and carbonate-bound metal. The second extract

contains the reducible Zn fraction (Zn bound to iron and manganese oxides) and the third fraction, which is

oxidizable, corresponds to the organic matter and sulfide-bound metal. However other unidentified phases

may also be extracted [10, 18, 19]. Reactions involving desorption, coprecipitation or neutralization may also

occur during the extraction steps [20].

Our results with calcareous soils show that the fractions extracted from each sample at each step vary

greatly. However a relation appears to exist between the total carbonate content and the mineralogical species

in question (calcite, dolomite) [21]. In highly calcareous soils, during the first step, acetic acid can neutralize

the calcite when it represents up to 20% of the total mineral content, whereas where the calcite and dolomite

contents are above this level they remain in the residue (Figure 4). These results are in agreement with

electron microscopy observations. Figure 5 shows the distribution mappings of zinc, which may be partly

related with elements such as S, O and Fe, possibly as jarosite crystal.

Page 10: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

218

In the second step, nitric acid neutralizes the residual calcite fraction in large particle size and part of

the dolomite (Figure 4). Data obtained by SEM reveal that zinc may be associated with dolomite crystals,

sulfur compounds and silicates.

According to the mineral composition of the residue (Figure 4), acetic acid may also be involved in

the third step where it neutralizes the rest of the calcite and dolomite present. The distribution mapping of

zinc (Figure 5) suggests its association with sulfate and silicate crystals, which represent the least mobile

residual zinc phase.

1 E x t r O

c

Q 2 E x t r |

3 E x t r Q

10 2 0 30 20

Figure 4.- X- ray diffractograms obtained from the remainders after the first, second

and third extraction steps in sequential extraction procedure for sample number 3.

I = illite; Q = quartz; C = calcite; F = feldspars; D = dolomite.

When the sequential extraction method proposed by the "Community Bureau of Reference" (BCR)

is applied to highly calcareous soils, it is not possible to relate the zinc content to the different speciation

forms described in the bibliography, since carbonates are present in the different extraction steps.

To summarize, the first step corresponds to the most soluble zinc, the exchangeable Zn forms and

Zn bound to part of carbonates in the form of calcite.

Our experiments suggest that the carbonate-bound zinc is not totally extracted during the first step,

and it remains unquantified in the following extraction stages. Consequently, the zinc bound to reducible

forms (second extraction stage) also includes part of the metal still bound to calcite and dolomite. Further

zinc bound to organic matter and sulfides (third step) also results higher than the true value. This, because

it also includes the metal remaining in the carbonates which have not been neutralized in the previous

steps. Our data agree with previous reports on calcareous soils [22] and show that significant and

Page 11: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

219

substantial errors may occur in zinc speciation when using BCR methodology in soils with a high

carbonate content..

Figure 5.- Mapping of the chemical element distribution obtained by SEM-EDS after the

extraction step (acetic acid, sample number 3).

Page 12: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

220

Other extractants for Zn speciatiom

Because of the problems encountered in using the BCR speciation scheme involving sequential

extractions, other schemes using different reagents to mimic environmental conditions were used to study

Zn speeiation in calcareous soils. For comparison purposes, nine soils samples were analysed which were

the same as those studied by the conventional speeiation procedure based on sequential extraction. Results

14

12

10

8

6

4

2

0

%

/I

f 1

Z n Ext r

iiiiiiiiiii ........

i~i~ii!iiii

ii ii!!!il .... ii ! iii~iiiiii!

........ iiiiii!i~ii

iiiiii ii _iii!iiiiiii

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . tmWater Sol.

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Samples

Figure 6.- Labile extractable Zn

obtained are shown in Figs 6 and 7.

The water soluble Zn content is extremely low (0.05-0.5%) (Figure 6) in good agreement with the

mineralogy and pH of the soils studied. The exchangeable fraction, as determined by ammonium acetate

(pH = 7) [3], is also low (Figure 6) but higher than that of the water soluble phase. It varies with the

mineralogy and texture of clays, that is, with the exchange capacity of these soils.

The amount of zinc bound to the amorphous forms of iron oxides and extracted with oxalic acid-

sodium oxalate at pH 3 [4] is considerable (Figure 7), even if soluble and exchangeable Zn forms, and part

of the zinc arising from the mobilization of carbonates, are included. This extractant also partially

dissolves active calcium carbonate, leading to a partial precipitation of Ca and Zn oxalates. Further,

mobilization of metals from the crystalline structure of this carbonate is revealed by the XRD diagrams of

treated samples, in which several peaks can be assigned to various phases of calcium oxalate in different

states of hydration (Figure 8).Citrate-dithionite is a reducing reagent with a pH near to neutrality which

Page 13: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

221

solubilizes amorphous minerals of low crystallinity [5], such as Fe and Mn oxides and oxihydroxides and

metals associated to them. The values of Zn extracted with this reagent are up to 70% higher than those

obtained using other selective extractants (Figure 7). Several carbonates are also solubilized by citrate-

dithionite mixture, as it appears from the quartz/calcite ratio (Figure 8). Differently from the oxalic acid-

sodium oxalate extraction, no precipitation reactions occurs in this case, and dolomite is hardly affected.

The water soluble fractions are also included in this fraction [23].

Finally, sodium pyrophosphate is able to extract Zn bound to humic substances. Also this reagent

dissolves part of the calcium carbonate and dolomite, precipitating the calcium as phosphate. Other metals

contained in the carbonate structure are also extracted by complexation. However, because of the low

humic matter content of the soils studied, this reagent mostly disolves Zn in carbonates.

% Zn extr

80 I ~ m Jmd~rat ' " - imox/oxalic

6O

40

20

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 samples

Figure 7.- Zn availability (selective extractions).

Page 14: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

222

PlrophoQphate A A

Oxalate

CaOt.

10 20

Figure 8.- X-ray diffractograms after selective extracctions (sample 3).

Zinc availability to plants

It is generally accepted that the amounts of Zn in soil extracts obtained using either 0.5 M acetic

acid [6], or EDTA-ammonium a~ate-acetic acid (pH 4.6) [7], or DTPA [8] correspond to the metal taken

up by plants. The results obtained for our soil extracts (Figure 9) apparently differ considerably fi'om one

extraoant to another, this suggesting that the above assumption is not valid when dealing with calcareous

soils.

100

80

60

40

20

0

% Zn extr.

t . ~ c -~ °~ - ° ~ II =,Tb. .................................................... !.[

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

Figure 9.- Zn bioavailability

Page 15: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

223

EDTA-ammonium acetate-acetic acid (pH 4.6) is known to complex metals that are associated to

inorganic forms of Fe and Mn with a low crystallinity and fine granulometry. In our experiments this

Q

. A c

10 20 30 20

Figure 10 - X-ray diffractograms obtained from the remainders after bioavailability extracctions (sample 3).

reagent appears also to solubilize carbonates (Figure 10). A decrease in calcite reflection and background

noise is apparent, which can be ascribed to the presence of amorphous substances. For this reason, the

values for plant-available Zn which are obtained by this procedure are low. Both soluble Zn and Zn

associated to the exchange complex and to finely divided forms are affected by complexation with DTPA.

The amounts of Zn extracted by this reagent are also variable and relatively low (Figure 9). The X-ray

diagrams obtained alter DTPA treatment show a decreased background noise, as for EDTA residues, an

increase in illite crystallinity and a constant calcite content.

Acetic acid causes most problems when evaluating plant-available Zn in carbonated soils, since

calcite dissolves totally in this reagent and dolomite does so when it is finely divided. Therefore, this

method of extraction cannot be considered suitable for the determination of plant-available Zn.

In order to ascertain the ¢xtractant that best simulates the plant availability of Zn, the Zn content of

tomato plants cultivated in the studied soils was analysed. The best correlation between the amount of Zn

extracted from the soil and the zinc content in the plant material was obtained when using DTPA (Figure

11). The low availability of Zn to tomato plants grown in calcareous soils may be reflected by the low

levels of Zn found in the root, leaves and fiuit.

Page 16: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

224

35

30 • •

E 25 ID

"~ 20

• root 15 ,&& • leaf

10 && • fruit

=~ 5

0

100 200 300 400 500 600 700

Zinc concentration in tomato plants (p. g g -1)

Figure 11.- Correlation between the metal extracted from tl~ soil by DPTA and zinc level in tomato plants.

Zn mobility was also assayed by using a bicarbonate extractant ofpH 8.5, which is considered [10]

to be similar to the bicarbonate environment of soil solution in the rhizosphere. In general, the amounts of

Zn dissolved in this extractant (Figure 8) can be considered acceptable for carbonated soils.

CONCLUSION

Because of the high amounts of carbonated materials which are supplied by the Moreras Rambla

(wadi complex) in the area under study, the Zn leached from the slags is tendencially immobilized. Two

immobilizing mechanisms can be supposed to act in these conditions, the one involving the formation of

carbonates and the other the formation of sulfates. The first of these may lead to new solubilization

reactions in which CO2 and H20 play an important role. In addition, during the solid particle - CO2 - H~O

interaction, new stable phases can be formed, which are insoluble and can fix Zn in the lattice crystal.

The kinetics of these processes is strongly influenced by the peculiar climatic conditions. Low

rainfall implies soluble Zn compounds (hydrated Zn polysulphates) to remain on the surface of slag heap

for long periods of time. On the contrary, torrential rainfall transports all materials and the acidity of

leachates is neutralized by carbonates. The slow process of Zn fixation can, however, be accelerated by

water infiltration.

Page 17: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

225

Apparently, the maximum Zn immobilization can be achieved at the acid water- carbonated

material interface (bordering the ramblas) in periods of light rain, with formation of Zn (OH)2 and Zn

CO3.

Another important factor that affects Zn speciation and bioavailability in calcareous soils is the low

amount of organic matter in these soils. This condition, which is common to all semiaridic soils, explains

why the organic matter plays no relevant part in Zn transport. However, the role played by the organic

matter would become more important in the case of agricultural soils that are added with organic

fertilizers.

Finally, the zinc speeiation methodology based on the use of conventional sequential extractions

which is recommended for other soils seems to be unreliable for highly calcareous soils. A different

approach, which takes into account the particular physico-chemical characteristics and mineralogy of these

soils, appears to be necessary.

REFERENCES

1. L.J. Alias, R. Ortiz, J. Martinez and P. Linares, Mapa de Suelos, Mazarr6n, 976. ICONA, Universidad

de Murcia, (1986).

2. M . ~ Bantista, C. P~rez-Sirvent, I. L6pez-Garcia, and M. Hernhndez-C6rdoba. Flow injection atomic

absorption spectrometry for slurry atomization: Determination of manganese, lead, zinc, calcium,

magnesium, iron, sodium and potassium in cements. Fresenius J Anal Chem, 350:359-364, (1994).

3. H. Simard, Ammonium Acetate- Extractable elements, In Soil Sampling and Methods of Analysis,

(Edited by M.R. Carter. for Canadian Society of Soil Science), Lewis Publishers. Boca Raton. p 823,

(1993).

4. H.D. Chapman, InMethods of SoilAnalysis, (Edited by C.A. B lack )pa r t 2. 891-900. Amer. Soc.

Agronomy, Inc. Madison, Wis. (1965).

5. O.P. Mehra and M.L. Jackson, Clays and Clay minerals, Monograph n°5, Earth Science. Series: 317-

327, (1960).

6. Ministly Of Agriculture, Fisheries And Food. The Analysis of Agricultural Materials Her Majesty's Stacionery Office. London, (1981).

7. E. Lakanem and R. Ervio, A comparison of eight extractants for the determination of plant available

micronutrients in soils. Acta Agric. Ferm. 123, pp. 223-232, (1971).

8. W.L. Lindsay and W.A. Norvell, Development of a DTPA test for zinc, iron, manganese and copper.

SoilSci. Am. J., 42; pp. 421- 428, (1978).

S.R. Olsen and L.E. Sommers, Phosphorus, InMethods of soil analysis. Part 2. 2edn (Edited by A.L.

Page) Ed. American Society of Agronomy, Madison, WI, (1982).

9.

Page 18: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

226

10. A. M. Ure, Ph. Quevauviller, H. Muntau, and B. Griepink, Speciation of heavy metals in soils and

sediments. An account of improvement and harmonization of extraction techniques undertaken under

the auspices of the BCR of the Commission of the European Communities. Int. J. Environ. Anal.

Chem., 51,135- 151, (1993).

11. g. Arana, C. P6rez- Sirvont and g. Ortiz- Gonzalez, Expiotaciones mineras e impacto ambiental on el

sector de Mazarron (Murcia), Actas V Reunion de Geologla Ambiental y Ordenaci6n del Territorio.

Problemdtica Geoambiental y Desarroilo. Vol. 2. pp 811-835. Murcia, ( 1993 ).

12. F. Lopez-Aguayo, C. P6rez- Sirvent, 1L Ortiz Gonzalez and R. Arana, Composici6n quimiea de las

aguas de lixiviaci6n minera on el Cabezo de San Cristobal (Mazarron, Murcia). Rev. Soc. Geol.

Espa~. 5, (3-4), pp. 73-79, (1992).

13. E. Zodrow, Hydrated sulfates from Sydney Coalfield, Cape- Breton Island, Nova- Scotia, Canada. The

copiapite group. Am. Mineralogist, 65, 961= 967, (1980).

14. M.L. Tudela and J. Martinez- Sanchez, Desertizaci6n progresiva en el sureste peninsular y su relaci6n

con la puesta on cultivo. In Recursos Naturales y Medio Ambiente en el Sureste Peninsular, (Edited by

L. Garcia- Rosseli, and A. Navarre), Institute de Estudios Almerionses. pp 433-444, (1997).

15. A. Kabata-Pondias and H. Pondias, Trace Elements m Soils and Plants. 2rid Ed. p 365. CRC Press.

Florida, (1992).

16. CEC Directive. 1986. Council Directive of 12 June 1986 on the protection of the environment and in

particular of the soil when sewage sludge is used in agriculture, Official Journal of the European

Communities n ° L 181/6-12, (4 july 1986).

17. U. F6rstner, Chemical forms and reactivities of metal in sediments, In Chemical Methods for Assessing

Bio- Available Metals m Sludges and Soils, (Edited by R. Leschber, R.D. Davis and P. L'Hermite).

Elsevier Applied Science. London. pp 1-30, (1985).

18. A. Tessier, P.G.C. Campbell and M. Bisson, Sequential extraction procedure for the speciation of

particulat¢ trace metals. ,4na/. Chem. 51,844-851, (1979)

19. M. Kerston and U. FOrstner, Chemical fractionation of heavy metals in anoxic estuadn¢ and coastal

sediments. Water Sci. Technol. 18. 121-130, (1986).

20. C. Khebonian and C.F. Bauer, Accuracy of selective extraction procedures for metal speciation in

model aquatic sediments. Anal. Chem., 59, 1417-1423, (1987).

21. Martinez- Sanchez, J., Perez- Sirvent, C. and C. Garcia Rizo, Errores de Evaluaci6n de riesgos on la

movilizaci6n de metales pesados on suelos carbonatados. Actas III Congreso del Medio Ambiente. pp.

1053-1101. Madrid. (1996).

22. F.X. Han and A. Banin, Selective sequential dissolution techniques for trace metals in add-zone soils:

the carbonate dissolution step. Commun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal. 26 (3&4), 553-576, (1995)

Page 19: Geology - garcia-rizo.com · GARCIA-RIZO C., MARTINEZ-SANCHEZ J., PEREZ-SIRVENT C. ... proportion of carbonates is also an important factor in the mobilization of the metal. Reactions

227

23. Perez-Sirvent, C., Martinez- Sanchez, J. and C. Garcia-Rizo, Assessment of the risk of heavy metal

mobilization in calcareous agricultural soils, In: Contaminated Soils: Third International Conference

on the Biogeochemistry of Trace Elements. (Edited by Prost R.) INRA. Paris,

D:\d~t~communic\110.PDF. (1997).