GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA...

73
MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT Synopsis: Pursuant to A.R.S. §16-602(B), Maricopa County conducted the hand count/early ballot audit for the November 6, 2018 General Election, 2% of the precincts were counted as required by statute, which amounted to 15 precincts out of 748 total precincts. The hand count begin on Wednesday, November 7, 2018 at 6:08 pm when the Maricopa County Chairs of the Democratic, Libertarian and designee of the Republican Party met to select the precincts, races, early ballot audit batches, and early voting site touch screen (DRE) machine to be audited. All ballots were accounted for in the central counting location before the selection process started. The selection order was chosen by lot, and the Libertarian Party was selected to go first, followed by the Republican Party and then the Democratic Party. There were no representatives of the Green Party present. With the order established, the specific precincts to be counted were selected with the participating County Party Chairmen or designee alternating the various selections. Once the precincts were chosen, the early ballot audit batches to be counted were selected (1% of the total early ballots cast or 5,000, whichever is less). A total of 30 batches were selected to be audited to reach this 1% required audit total. Four contested races were chosen as required by law: 1 Statewide Race, 1 Statewide Proposition, 1 Federal Race, and 1 Legislative Race. Specifically, the following list of contested races that were audited: Statewide Race – Attorney General (748 precincts possible) Statewide Proposition – Proposition 127 (748 precincts possible) Federal Race – U.S. Senator (748 precincts possible) State Legislative Race – State Representative (644 precincts possible) The master precinct and race selection lists are attached for review. The physical hand count started at 9:00 a.m. on Thursday, November 8, 2018 and concluded on Friday, November 9, 2018 with the exception of Precinct 0556 that was held to balance write-in ballots. Precinct 0556 was then completed on Friday, November 16, 2018. The tabulation method used was the stacking method for the optical scan ballots and the tally method for the touch screen accessible voting devices (DRE). Thirty-four (34) boards made up of three members, of which not more than two members were from the same political party, conducted the audit. This hand count included votes cast on both the optical scan and touch screen devises from the selected precincts. Early Ballot Audit: 1% of early ballots were audited as per Arizona State Law. The early ballot audit consisted of 30 batches with at least 3 batches from every machine used for tabulation. Each batch contained approximately 175 early ballots. There were 1,182,342 early ballots cast in Maricopa County for the November 6, 2018 General Election. Comments: If a discrepancy occurred, the reason for the discrepancy is notated and described in each report. Please find the following precinct and early ballot reports for your review. Adrian Fontes Maricopa County Recorder

Transcript of GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA...

Page 1: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018

HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT Synopsis: Pursuant to A.R.S. §16-602(B), Maricopa County conducted the hand count/early ballot audit for the November 6, 2018 General Election, 2% of the precincts were counted as required by statute, which amounted to 15 precincts out of 748 total precincts. The hand count begin on Wednesday, November 7, 2018 at 6:08 pm when the Maricopa County Chairs of the Democratic, Libertarian and designee of the Republican Party met to select the precincts, races, early ballot audit batches, and early voting site touch screen (DRE) machine to be audited. All ballots were accounted for in the central counting location before the selection process started. The selection order was chosen by lot, and the Libertarian Party was selected to go first, followed by the Republican Party and then the Democratic Party. There were no representatives of the Green Party present. With the order established, the specific precincts to be counted were selected with the participating County Party Chairmen or designee alternating the various selections. Once the precincts were chosen, the early ballot audit batches to be counted were selected (1% of the total early ballots cast or 5,000, whichever is less). A total of 30 batches were selected to be audited to reach this 1% required audit total. Four contested races were chosen as required by law: 1 Statewide Race, 1 Statewide Proposition, 1 Federal Race, and 1 Legislative Race. Specifically, the following list of contested races that were audited:

Statewide Race – Attorney General (748 precincts possible) Statewide Proposition – Proposition 127 (748 precincts possible) Federal Race – U.S. Senator (748 precincts possible) State Legislative Race – State Representative (644 precincts possible)

The master precinct and race selection lists are attached for review. The physical hand count started at 9:00 a.m. on Thursday, November 8, 2018 and concluded on Friday, November 9, 2018 with the exception of Precinct 0556 that was held to balance write-in ballots. Precinct 0556 was then completed on Friday, November 16, 2018. The tabulation method used was the stacking method for the optical scan ballots and the tally method for the touch screen accessible voting devices (DRE). Thirty-four (34) boards made up of three members, of which not more than two members were from the same political party, conducted the audit. This hand count included votes cast on both the optical scan and touch screen devises from the selected precincts. Early Ballot Audit: 1% of early ballots were audited as per Arizona State Law. The early ballot audit consisted of 30 batches with at least 3 batches from every machine used for tabulation. Each batch contained approximately 175 early ballots. There were 1,182,342 early ballots cast in Maricopa County for the November 6, 2018 General Election. Comments: If a discrepancy occurred, the reason for the discrepancy is notated and described in each report. Please find the following precinct and early ballot reports for your review.

Adrian Fontes Maricopa County Recorder

Page 2: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

MARICOPA COUNTY Master Precinct and Race Selection Worksheet

Election: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018

Party Selected to: Draw 1ST _LBT_ Draw 2ND _REP_ Draw 3RD _DEM_ Draw 4TH _N/A _ SECTION A. SELECTED PRECINCTS (LIST IN ORDER SELECTED – 15 TOTAL + EV SITE SECTION A (Continued). SELECTED EV BATCHES (LIST IN ORDER SELECTED - 30 TOTAL SECTION B. NUMBER OF RACES TO COUNT PER CATEGORY

RACE CATEGORY TICK MARK TALLY

NUMBER OF RACES PER CATEGORY

RECEIVED PRECINCT HAND COUNT MARGIN

WORKSHEET 1. President 0 0 2. Statewide Candidate I I 3. Statewide Ballot Measure I I 4. Federal Candidate I I 5. State Legislative I I Additional Races Needed 0 0

SECTION C. RACES TO BE COUNTED Race To Be Counted Category of Race 1. N/A 1. President 2. Statewide Office: ATTORNEY GENERAL 2. Statewide Candidate 3. Proposition: 127 3. Statewide Ballot Measure 4. Federal Office: US SENATOR 4. Federal Candidate 5. State Legislative: STATE REPRESENTATIVE 5. State Legislative

43

1 51 11

2

38

12

44

58

22

4

13

45

41

5

42

31

6

48

7

53

49

29

17

55

EV SITE TOUCH SCREEN (DRE): E.V.I.T

0505

0380 0113

0502

0057

0630

0361

0684

0019

0277

0507

0552

0556

0445

0744

18

9

59

26

24

Page 3: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

MARICOPA COUNTY Master Precinct and Race Selection Worksheet

Election: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018

DRAWN OFFICE TYPE OFFICE NAME VOTE FOR

STATEWIDE Governor VOTE FOR 1 STATEWIDE Secretary of State VOTE FOR 1 Y STATEWIDE Attorney General VOTE FOR 1 STATEWIDE State Treasurer VOTE FOR 1 STATEWIDE Superintendent of Public Instr VOTE FOR 1 STATEWIDE State Mine Inspector VOTE FOR 1 STATEWIDE Corporation Commission VOTE FOR 2 PROPOSITIONS Proposition 125 VOTE FOR 1 PROPOSITIONS Proposition 126 VOTE FOR 1 Y PROPOSITIONS Proposition 127 VOTE FOR 1 PROPOSITIONS Proposition 305 VOTE FOR 1 PROPOSITIONS Proposition 306 VOTE FOR 1 Y FEDERAL US Senate VOTE FOR 1 FEDERAL US Rep CD 1 VOTE FOR 1 FEDERAL US Rep CD 3 VOTE FOR 1 FEDERAL US Rep CD 4 VOTE FOR 1 FEDERAL US Rep CD 5 VOTE FOR 1 FEDERAL US Rep CD 6 VOTE FOR 1 FEDERAL US Rep CD 7 VOTE FOR 1 FEDERAL US Rep CD 8 VOTE FOR 1 FEDERAL US Rep CD 9 VOTE FOR 1 Y STATE LEGISLATIVE State Rep- DIST 4 VOTE FOR 2 Y STATE LEGISLATIVE State Rep- DIST 1 VOTE FOR 2 Y STATE LEGISLATIVE State Rep- DIST 12 VOTE FOR 2 Y STATE LEGISLATIVE State Rep- DIST 13 VOTE FOR 2 Y STATE LEGISLATIVE State Rep- DIST 15 VOTE FOR 2 Y STATE LEGISLATIVE State Rep- DIST 16 VOTE FOR 2 Y STATE LEGISLATIVE State Rep- DIST 17 VOTE FOR 2 Y STATE LEGISLATIVE State Rep- DIST 18 VOTE FOR 2 Y STATE LEGISLATIVE State Rep- DIST 20 VOTE FOR 2 Y STATE LEGISLATIVE State Rep- DIST 21 VOTE FOR 2 Y STATE LEGISLATIVE State Rep- DIST 22 VOTE FOR 2 Y STATE LEGISLATIVE State Rep- DIST 23 VOTE FOR 2 Y STATE LEGISLATIVE State Rep- DIST 24 VOTE FOR 2 Y STATE LEGISLATIVE State Rep- DIST 25 VOTE FOR 2 Y STATE LEGISLATIVE State Rep- DIST 26 VOTE FOR 2 Y STATE LEGISLATIVE State Rep- DIST 28 VOTE FOR 2 Y STATE LEGISLATIVE State Rep- DIST 30 VOTE FOR 2 STATE LEGISLATIVE State Senator- DIST 1 VOTE FOR 1 STATE LEGISLATIVE State Senator- DIST 12 VOTE FOR 1 STATE LEGISLATIVE State Senator- DIST 13 VOTE FOR 1 STATE LEGISLATIVE State Senator- DIST 15 VOTE FOR 1 STATE LEGISLATIVE State Senator- DIST 16 VOTE FOR 1 STATE LEGISLATIVE State Senator- DIST 17 VOTE FOR 1 STATE LEGISLATIVE State Senator- DIST 18 VOTE FOR 1 STATE LEGISLATIVE State Senator- DIST 20 VOTE FOR 1 STATE LEGISLATIVE State Senator- DIST 21 VOTE FOR 1 STATE LEGISLATIVE State Senator- DIST 22 VOTE FOR 1 STATE LEGISLATIVE State Senator- DIST 23 VOTE FOR 1 STATE LEGISLATIVE State Senator- DIST 24 VOTE FOR 1 STATE LEGISLATIVE State Senator- DIST 25 VOTE FOR 1 STATE LEGISLATIVE State Senator- DIST 26 VOTE FOR 1 STATE LEGISLATIVE State Senator- DIST 28 VOTE FOR 1

Page 4: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 1 of 70

Total Precincts Counted (2%): 15 Total Ballots Cast: 4,553 Date of Election: November 6, 2018

Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATORPrecinct # - Precinct Name Hand Count Total Machine Count Absolute Difference

0019-ANDORA 319 319 00057-BONANZA 162 162 00113-CLAY MINE 55 55 00277-GREYSTONE 100 100 00361-LAUREL 213 213 00380-LONGHORN 603 602 10445-NICOLET 274 274 00502-PIERCE 230 231 10505-PINE VALLEY 350 350 00507-PINNACLE WEST 331 331 00552-ROSE GARDEN 232 232 00556-RUBY 588 588 00630-STARLIGHT 237 237 00684-TURNEY 459 459 00744-XAVIER 369 369 0

TOTAL 4522 4522 2Aggregated Margin

2 4522 100 0.044%

Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERALPrecinct # - Precinct Name Hand Count Total Machine Count Absolute Difference

0019-ANDORA 309 309 00057-BONANZA 157 157 00113-CLAY MINE 55 55 00277-GREYSTONE 94 94 00361-LAUREL 205 205 00380-LONGHORN 589 588 10445-NICOLET 267 267 00502-PIERCE 222 222 00505-PINE VALLEY 335 335 00507-PINNACLE WEST 326 326 00552-ROSE GARDEN 228 228 00556-RUBY 572 572 00630-STARLIGHT 231 231 00684-TURNEY 447 447 00744-XAVIER 356 356 0

TOTAL 4393 4392 1Aggregated Margin

1 4392 100 0.023%*Designated Margin for PRECINCT ballots, in accordance with A.R.S. § 16-602(K)(4): 1.000%

MARICOPA COUNTY ELECTIONS DEPARTMENTAGGREGATE - PRECINCT HAND COUNT REPORT - TOTAL FROM ALL PRECINCTS

Aggregated Margin = Absolute Difference ÷ Machine Count X 100

Aggregated Margin = Absolute Difference ÷ Machine Count X 100

*Designated Margin for PRECINCT ballots, in accordance with A.R.S. § 16-602(K)(4): 1.000%

Page 5: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 2 of 70

Total Precincts Counted (2%): 15 Total Ballots Cast: 4,553 Date of Election: November 6, 2018

Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127Precinct # - Precinct Name Hand Count Total Machine Count Absolute Difference

0019-ANDORA 300 300 00057-BONANZA 151 151 00113-CLAY MINE 53 53 00277-GREYSTONE 97 97 00361-LAUREL 195 195 00380-LONGHORN 571 570 10445-NICOLET 259 259 00502-PIERCE 220 221 10505-PINE VALLEY 326 326 00507-PINNACLE WEST 301 301 00552-ROSE GARDEN 221 221 00556-RUBY 566 566 00630-STARLIGHT 221 221 00684-TURNEY 444 444 00744-XAVIER 350 350 0

TOTAL 4275 4275 2Aggregated Margin

2 4275 100 0.047%

Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVEPrecinct # - Precinct Name Hand Count Total Machine Count Absolute Difference

0019-ANDORA 515 515 00057-BONANZA 296 296 00113-CLAY MINE 98 98 00277-GREYSTONE 181 181 00361-LAUREL 301 301 00380-LONGHORN 809 808 10445-NICOLET 338 339 10502-PIERCE 293 294 10505-PINE VALLEY 460 460 00507-PINNACLE WEST 448 448 00552-ROSE GARDEN 391 391 00556-RUBY 732 732 00630-STARLIGHT 0 0 00684-TURNEY 649 649 00744-XAVIER 491 491 0

TOTAL 6002 6003 3Aggregated Margin

3 6003 100 0.050%

*Designated Margin for PRECINCT ballots, in accordance with A.R.S. § 16-602(K)(4): 1.000%

*Designated Margin for PRECINCT ballots, in accordance with A.R.S. § 16-602(K)(4): 1.000%

MARICOPA COUNTY ELECTIONS DEPARTMENTAGGREGATE - PRECINCT HAND COUNT REPORT - TOTAL FROM ALL PRECINCTS

Aggregated Margin = Absolute Difference ÷ Machine Count X 100

Aggregated Margin = Absolute Difference ÷ Machine Count X 100

Page 6: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 3 of 70

Total Precincts Counted (2%): 15 + 1 EV Site Total Ballots Cast: 1 Date of Election: November 6, 2018

Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATORPrecinct # - Precinct Name Hand Count Total Machine Count Absolute Difference

0019-ANDORA 0 0 00057-BONANZA 0 0 00113-CLAY MINE 0 0 00277-GREYSTONE 0 0 00361-LAUREL 0 0 00380-LONGHORN 0 0 00445-NICOLET 0 0 00502-PIERCE 0 0 00505-PINE VALLEY 0 0 00507-PINNACLE WEST 0 0 00552-ROSE GARDEN 0 0 00556-RUBY 0 0 00630-STARLIGHT 0 0 00684-TURNEY 1 1 00744-XAVIER 0 0 0EV SITE-E.V.I.T. 0 0 0

TOTAL 1 1 0Aggregated Margin

0 1 100 0.000%

Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERALPrecinct # - Precinct Name Hand Count Total Machine Count Absolute Difference

0019-ANDORA 0 0 00057-BONANZA 0 0 00113-CLAY MINE 0 0 00277-GREYSTONE 0 0 00361-LAUREL 0 0 00380-LONGHORN 0 0 00445-NICOLET 0 0 00502-PIERCE 0 0 00505-PINE VALLEY 0 0 00507-PINNACLE WEST 0 0 00552-ROSE GARDEN 0 0 00556-RUBY 0 0 00630-STARLIGHT 0 0 00684-TURNEY 1 1 00744-XAVIER 0 0 0EV SITE-E.V.I.T. 0 0 0

TOTAL 1 1 0Aggregated Margin

0 1 100 0.000%*Designated Margin for PRECINCT ballots, in accordance with A.R.S. § 16-602(K)(4): 1.000%

*Designated Margin for PRECINCT ballots, in accordance with A.R.S. § 16-602(K)(4): 1.000%

AGGREGATE - PRECINCT & EV SITE DRE HAND COUNT REPORT - TOTAL FROM ALL PRECINCTS

Aggregated Margin = Absolute Difference ÷ Machine Count X 100

MARICOPA COUNTY ELECTIONS DEPARTMENT

Aggregated Margin = Absolute Difference ÷ Machine Count X 100

Page 7: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 4 of 70

Total Precincts Counted (2%): 15 + 1 EV Site Total Ballots Cast: 1 Date of Election: November 6, 2018

Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127Precinct # - Precinct Name Hand Count Total Machine Count Absolute Difference

0019-ANDORA 0 0 00057-BONANZA 0 0 00113-CLAY MINE 0 0 00277-GREYSTONE 0 0 00361-LAUREL 0 0 00380-LONGHORN 0 0 00445-NICOLET 0 0 00502-PIERCE 0 0 00505-PINE VALLEY 0 0 00507-PINNACLE WEST 0 0 00552-ROSE GARDEN 0 0 00556-RUBY 0 0 00630-STARLIGHT 0 0 00684-TURNEY 1 1 00744-XAVIER 0 0 0EV SITE-E.V.I.T. 0 0 0

TOTAL 1 1 0Aggregated Margin

0 1 100 0.000%

Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVEPrecinct # - Precinct Name Hand Count Total Machine Count Absolute Difference

0019-ANDORA 0 0 00057-BONANZA 0 0 00113-CLAY MINE 0 0 00277-GREYSTONE 0 0 00361-LAUREL 0 0 00380-LONGHORN 0 0 00445-NICOLET 0 0 00502-PIERCE 0 0 00505-PINE VALLEY 0 0 00507-PINNACLE WEST 0 0 00552-ROSE GARDEN 0 0 00556-RUBY 0 0 00630-STARLIGHT 0 0 00684-TURNEY 2 2 00744-XAVIER 0 0 0EV SITE-E.V.I.T. 0 0 0

TOTAL 2 2 0Aggregated Margin

0 2 100 0.000%

*Designated Margin for PRECINCT ballots, in accordance with A.R.S. § 16-602(K)(4): 1.000%

Aggregated Margin = Absolute Difference ÷ Machine Count X 100

MARICOPA COUNTY ELECTIONS DEPARTMENTAGGREGATE - PRECINCT & EV SITE DRE HAND COUNT REPORT - TOTAL FROM ALL PRECINCTS

Aggregated Margin = Absolute Difference ÷ Machine Count X 100

*Designated Margin for PRECINCT ballots, in accordance with A.R.S. § 16-602(K)(4): 1.000%

Page 8: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 5 of 70

Date of Election: November 6, 2018

Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOREarly Voting Batch # Hand Count Total Machine Count Absolute Difference

43 172 172 0

1 160 160 0

51 168 168 0

11 179 179 0

2 178 178 0

38 170 170 0

12 177 177 0

44 168 168 0

58 152 152 0

22 166 166 0

4 181 181 0

13 170 170 0

45 175 175 0

41 174 174 0

5 177 177 0

42 177 177 0

31 171 171 0

6 169 169 0

48 169 169 0

7 165 165 0

53 168 168 0

49 166 166 0

29 166 166 0

17 171 171 0

55 169 169 0

18 169 169 0

9 178 178 0

59 168 168 0

26 178 178 0

24 182 182 0

TOTAL 5133 5133 0

Aggregated Margin

0 5133 100 0.000%

AGGREGATE - EARLY BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - TOTAL FROM ALL BATCHES MARICOPA COUNTY ELECTIONS DEPARTMENT

Aggregated Margin = Absolute Difference ÷ Machine Count X 100

Total # of Batches: 30 # of Ballots from ALL Batches: 5,181

*Designated Margin for EARLY VOTING ballots, in accordance with A.R.S. § 16-602(K)(4): 2.000%

Page 9: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 6 of 70

Date of Election: November 6, 2018

Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERALEarly Voting Batch # Hand Count Total Machine Count Absolute Difference

43 167 167 0

1 158 158 0

51 164 164 0

11 175 175 0

2 176 176 0

38 162 162 0

12 172 172 0

44 164 164 0

58 149 149 0

22 165 165 0

4 177 177 0

13 171 171 0

45 173 173 0

41 162 162 0

5 174 174 0

42 169 169 0

31 172 172 0

6 166 166 0

48 172 172 0

7 161 161 0

53 156 156 0

49 161 161 0

29 160 160 0

17 171 171 0

55 166 166 0

18 160 160 0

9 174 174 0

59 167 167 0

26 175 175 0

24 172 172 0

TOTAL 5011 5011 0

Aggregated Margin

0 5011 100 0.000%

MARICOPA COUNTY ELECTIONS DEPARTMENTAGGREGATE - EARLY BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - TOTAL FROM ALL BATCHES

Aggregated Margin = Absolute Difference ÷ Machine Count X 100

Total # of Batches: 30 # of Ballots from ALL Batches: 5,181

*Designated Margin for EARLY VOTING ballots, in accordance with A.R.S. § 16-602(K)(4): 2.000%

Page 10: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 7 of 70

Date of Election: November 6, 2018

Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127Early Voting Batch # Hand Count Total Machine Count Absolute Difference

43 165 165 0

1 157 157 0

51 167 167 0

11 175 175 0

2 164 164 0

38 168 168 0

12 173 173 0

44 166 166 0

58 148 148 0

22 162 162 0

4 173 173 0

13 169 169 0

45 172 172 0

41 167 167 0

5 173 173 0

42 173 173 0

31 171 171 0

6 163 163 0

48 169 169 0

7 158 158 0

53 161 161 0

49 163 163 0

29 159 159 0

17 173 173 0

55 163 163 0

18 159 159 0

9 174 174 0

59 168 168 0

26 174 174 0

24 173 173 0

TOTAL 5000 5000 0

Aggregated Margin

0 5000 100 0.000%

MARICOPA COUNTY ELECTIONS DEPARTMENTAGGREGATE - EARLY BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - TOTAL FROM ALL BATCHES

Total # of Batches: 30 # of Ballots from ALL Batches: 5,181

Aggregated Margin = Absolute Difference ÷ Machine Count X 100

*Designated Margin for EARLY VOTING ballots, in accordance with A.R.S. § 16-602(K)(4): 2.000%

Page 11: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 8 of 70

Date of Election: November 6, 2018

Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVEEarly Voting Batch # Hand Count Total Machine Count Absolute Difference

43 272 272 0

1 249 249 0

51 175 175 0

11 263 263 0

2 297 297 0

38 245 245 0

12 298 298 0

44 269 269 0

58 234 234 0

22 279 279 0

4 293 293 0

13 261 261 0

45 268 268 0

41 297 297 0

5 292 292 0

42 294 294 0

31 292 292 0

6 273 273 0

48 144 144 0

7 263 263 0

53 243 243 0

49 266 266 0

29 250 250 0

17 245 245 0

55 255 255 0

18 256 256 0

9 296 296 0

59 249 249 0

26 288 288 0

24 290 290 0

TOTAL 7896 7896 0

Aggregated Margin

0 7896 100 0.000%

Comments: If a discrepancy occurred, the reason is notated and described in each of the detailed Precinct/EV Batch reports.

MARICOPA COUNTY ELECTIONS DEPARTMENTAGGREGATE - EARLY BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - TOTAL FROM ALL BATCHES

Aggregated Margin = Absolute Difference ÷ Machine Count X 100

*Designated Margin for EARLY VOTING ballots, in accordance with A.R.S. § 16-602(K)(4): 2.000%

Total # of Batches: 30 # of Ballots from ALL Batches: 5,181

Page 12: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 9 of 70

If any variances occurred, the specific Precinct or Early Ballot Hand Count Reports that follow would indicate thereasons for these variances in the "Comments" section for the affected "Race Category". Those variances arenoted as part of the designated margin calculation when "Intent" or "Machine Error" is deemed to have occurredbased on the Board's audit. For those variances noted as “Intent ” errors, this reflect votes that were unreadableby the machine but were determined by the boards to be votes for a given candidate or issue. As an example,ballots where the voter circled the candidate’s name instead of connecting the arrow pointing to the candidate’sname (as instructed) OR where there were very visible and profound bleed through marks from the back of theballot where the machine saw this as an actual readable mark on the front of the ballot, and so on. The machineis faulted for this despite it not actually being a machine read error and this occurrence is included as a machineerror variance and is part of the designated margin calculation.

For any marks not read by the machine because they were too light for the machine to accurately read them orthe board, upon their verified count, deemed the machine count to be in error, those would be listed as“machine errors” and as such those totals would also be part of the designated margin calculations, if existing. Allvariances, if any, are noted in the final result reports that follow.

THE FOLLOWING WORKSHEETS ARE THE SUPPORTING AND DETAILED COUNTS THAT WERE USED TO DERIVE THE ABOVE

"EARLY BALLOT BATCH SPECIFIC" HAND COUNT REPORTSFOLLOW THIS SUMMARY

"PRECINCT SPECIFIC" HAND COUNT REPORTSAND

Page 13: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 10 of 70

Precinct: 0019-ANDORA Ballots Cast: 322 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 145 145 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 166 166 0GREEN, ANGELA 8 8 0

TOTAL 319 319 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 147 147 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 162 162 0TOTAL 309 309 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 134 134 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 166 166 0

TOTAL 300 300 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 121 121 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 130 130 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 143 143 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 121 121 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 515 515 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 14: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 11 of 70

Precinct: 0057-BONANZA Ballots Cast: 162 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 97 97 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 64 64 0GREEN, ANGELA 1 1 0

TOTAL 162 162 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 105 105 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 52 52 0TOTAL 157 157 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 27 27 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 124 124 0

TOTAL 151 151 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 94 94 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 102 102 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 47 47 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 53 53 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 296 296 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 15: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 12 of 70

Precinct: 0113-CLAY MINE Ballots Cast: 55 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 42 42 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 13 13 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 55 55 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 46 46 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 9 9 0TOTAL 55 55 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 5 5 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 48 48 0

TOTAL 53 53 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 38 38 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 44 44 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 8 8 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 8 8 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 98 98 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 16: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 13 of 70

Precinct: 0277-GREYSTONE Ballots Cast: 101 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 57 57 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 43 43 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 100 100 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 59 59 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 35 35 0TOTAL 94 94 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 21 21 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 76 76 0

TOTAL 97 97 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 54 54 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 57 57 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 35 35 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 35 35 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 181 181 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 17: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 14 of 70

Precinct: 0361-LAUREL Ballots Cast: 213 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 117 117 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 92 92 0GREEN, ANGELA 4 4 0

TOTAL 213 213 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 120 120 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 85 85 0TOTAL 205 205 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 57 57 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 138 138 0

TOTAL 195 195 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 107 107 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 104 104 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 90 90 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 301 301 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 18: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 15 of 70

Precinct: 0380-LONGHORN Ballots Cast: 606 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 265 265 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 330 329 1GREEN, ANGELA 8 8 0

TOTAL 603 602 1Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 288 288 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 301 300 1TOTAL 589 588 1

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 220 219 1PROPOSITION 127 - NO 351 351 0

TOTAL 571 570 1Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 252 252 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 237 237 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 320 319 1

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 809 808 1Comments for why a discrepancy occurred: Board notes one Extra Ballot for a 607 "Ballots Cast" Total-possible misread

PRECINCT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 19: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 16 of 70

Precinct: 0445-NICOLET Ballots Cast: 276 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 98 98 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 173 173 0GREEN, ANGELA 3 3 0

TOTAL 274 274 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 100 100 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 167 167 0TOTAL 267 267 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 104 104 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 155 155 0

TOTAL 259 259 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 103 103 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 123 124 1TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 112 112 0

TOTAL 338 339 1Comments for why a discrepancy occurred: Board notes 1 Machine read light arrow as "Unintended" vote for MEZA

PRECINCT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 20: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 17 of 70

Precinct: 0502-PIERCE Ballots Cast: 234 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 72 72 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 155 156 1GREEN, ANGELA 3 3 0

TOTAL 230 231 1Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 82 82 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 140 140 0TOTAL 222 222 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 99 99 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 121 122 1

TOTAL 220 221 1Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 77 77 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 130 131 1

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 86 86 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 293 294 1Comments for why a discrepancy occurred: Board notes one missing Write-in Ballot for a 235 "Ballots Cast" Total

PRECINCT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 21: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 18 of 70

Precinct: 0505-PINE VALLEY Ballots Cast: 350 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 191 191 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 154 154 0GREEN, ANGELA 5 5 0

TOTAL 350 350 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 201 201 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 134 134 0TOTAL 335 335 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 126 126 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 200 200 0

TOTAL 326 326 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 199 199 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 126 126 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 135 135 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 460 460 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 22: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 19 of 70

Precinct: 0507-PINNACLE WEST Ballots Cast: 331 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 213 213 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 117 117 0GREEN, ANGELA 1 1 0

TOTAL 331 331 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 220 220 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 106 106 0TOTAL 326 326 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 95 95 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 206 206 0

TOTAL 301 301 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 217 217 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 127 127 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 104 104 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 448 448 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 23: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 20 of 70

Precinct: 0552-ROSE GARDEN Ballots Cast: 235 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 99 99 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 130 130 0GREEN, ANGELA 3 3 0

TOTAL 232 232 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 97 97 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 131 131 0TOTAL 228 228 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 84 84 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 137 137 0

TOTAL 221 221 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 81 81 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 94 94 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 99 99 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 117 117 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 391 391 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 24: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 21 of 70

Precinct: 0556-RUBY Ballots Cast: 594 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 180 180 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 391 391 0GREEN, ANGELA 17 17 0

TOTAL 588 588 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 197 197 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 375 375 0TOTAL 572 572 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 241 241 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 325 325 0

TOTAL 566 566 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 189 189 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 255 255 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 288 288 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 732 732 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 25: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 22 of 70

Precinct: 0630-STARLIGHT Ballots Cast: 243 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 51 51 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 181 181 0GREEN, ANGELA 5 5 0

TOTAL 237 237 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 56 56 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 175 175 0TOTAL 231 231 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 73 73 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 148 148 0

TOTAL 221 221 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred: Precinct 0630 is in LEG 29 - Not a Contested Race

PRECINCT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 26: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 23 of 70

Precinct: 0684-TURNEY Ballots Cast: 459 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 84 84 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 364 364 0GREEN, ANGELA 11 11 0

TOTAL 459 459 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 100 100 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 347 347 0TOTAL 447 447 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 255 255 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 189 189 0

TOTAL 444 444 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 89 89 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 262 262 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 298 298 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 649 649 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

END OF PRECINCT:

PRECINCT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

Page 27: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 24 of 70

Precinct: 0744-XAVIER Ballots Cast: 372 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 91 91 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 268 268 0GREEN, ANGELA 10 10 0

TOTAL 369 369 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 92 92 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 264 264 0TOTAL 356 356 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 185 185 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 165 165 0

TOTAL 350 350 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 85 85 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 202 202 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 204 204 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 491 491 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 28: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 25 of 70

Precinct: 0019-ANDORA Ballots Cast: 0 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 0 0 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 0 0 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 0 0 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 0 0 0TOTAL 0 0 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total 0PROPOSITION 127 - YES 0 0 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT & EV SITE DRE HAND COUNT REPORT - TOUCH SCREEN (DRE) BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 29: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 26 of 70

Precinct: 0057-BONANZA Ballots Cast: 0 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 0 0 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 0 0 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 0 0 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 0 0 0TOTAL 0 0 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 0 0 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT & EV SITE DRE HAND COUNT REPORT - TOUCH SCREEN (DRE) BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 30: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 27 of 70

Precinct: 0113-CLAY MINE Ballots Cast: 0 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 0 0 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 0 0 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 0 0 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 0 0 0TOTAL 0 0 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 0 0 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT & EV SITE DRE HAND COUNT REPORT - TOUCH SCREEN (DRE) BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 31: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 28 of 70

Precinct: 0277-GREYSTONE Ballots Cast: 0 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 0 0 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 0 0 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 0 0 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 0 0 0TOTAL 0 0 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 0 0 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT & EV SITE DRE HAND COUNT REPORT - TOUCH SCREEN (DRE) BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 32: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 29 of 70

Precinct: 0361-LAUREL Ballots Cast: 0 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 0 0 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 0 0 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 0 0 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 0 0 0TOTAL 0 0 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 0 0 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT & EV SITE DRE HAND COUNT REPORT - TOUCH SCREEN (DRE) BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 33: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 30 of 70

Precinct: 0380-LONGHORN Ballots Cast: 0 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 0 0 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 0 0 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 0 0 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 0 0 0TOTAL 0 0 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 0 0 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT & EV SITE DRE HAND COUNT REPORT - TOUCH SCREEN (DRE) BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 34: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 31 of 70

Precinct: 0445-NICOLET Ballots Cast: 0 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 0 0 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 0 0 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 0 0 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 0 0 0TOTAL 0 0 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 0 0 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT & EV SITE DRE HAND COUNT REPORT - TOUCH SCREEN (DRE) BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 35: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 32 of 70

Precinct: 0502-PIERCE Ballots Cast: 0 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 0 0 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 0 0 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 0 0 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 0 0 0TOTAL 0 0 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 0 0 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT & EV SITE DRE HAND COUNT REPORT - TOUCH SCREEN (DRE) BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 36: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 33 of 70

Precinct: 0505-PINE VALLEY Ballots Cast: 0 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 0 0 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 0 0 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 0 0 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 0 0 0TOTAL 0 0 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 0 0 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT & EV SITE DRE HAND COUNT REPORT - TOUCH SCREEN (DRE) BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 37: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 34 of 70

Precinct: 0507-PINNACLE WEST Ballots Cast: 0 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 0 0 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 0 0 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 0 0 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 0 0 0TOTAL 0 0 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 0 0 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT & EV SITE DRE HAND COUNT REPORT - TOUCH SCREEN (DRE) BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 38: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 35 of 70

Precinct: 0552-ROSE GARDEN Ballots Cast: 0 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 0 0 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 0 0 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 0 0 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 0 0 0TOTAL 0 0 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 0 0 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT & EV SITE DRE HAND COUNT REPORT - TOUCH SCREEN (DRE) BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 39: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 36 of 70

Precinct: 0556-RUBY Ballots Cast: 0 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 0 0 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 0 0 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 0 0 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 0 0 0TOTAL 0 0 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 0 0 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT & EV SITE DRE HAND COUNT REPORT - TOUCH SCREEN (DRE) BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 40: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 37 of 70

Precinct: 0630-STARLIGHT Ballots Cast: 0 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 0 0 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 0 0 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 0 0 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 0 0 0TOTAL 0 0 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 0 0 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT & EV SITE DRE HAND COUNT REPORT - TOUCH SCREEN (DRE) BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 41: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 38 of 70

Precinct: 0684-TURNEY Ballots Cast: 1 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 0 0 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 1 1 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 1 1 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 0 0 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 1 1 0TOTAL 1 1 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 1 1 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 0 0 0

TOTAL 1 1 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 1 1 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 1 1 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 2 2 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

END OF PRECINCT:

PRECINCT & EV SITE DRE HAND COUNT REPORT - TOUCH SCREEN (DRE) BALLOTS

Page 42: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 39 of 70

Precinct: 0744-XAVIER Ballots Cast: 0 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 0 0 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 0 0 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 0 0 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 0 0 0TOTAL 0 0 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 0 0 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT & EV SITE DRE HAND COUNT REPORT - TOUCH SCREEN (DRE) BALLOTS

END OF PRECINCT:

Page 43: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 40 of 70

Precinct: EV SITE-E.V.I.T. Ballots Cast: 0 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 0 0 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 0 0 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 0 0 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 0 0 0TOTAL 0 0 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 0 0 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 0 0 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

PRECINCT & EV SITE DRE HAND COUNT REPORT - TOUCH SCREEN (DRE) BALLOTS

END OF EV SITE

Page 44: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 41 of 70

EV Batch# 43 #per Batch: 172 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 75 75 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 92 92 0GREEN, ANGELA 5 5 0

TOTAL 172 172 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 82 82 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 85 85 0TOTAL 167 167 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 56 56 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 109 109 0

TOTAL 165 165 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 5 5 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 5 5 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 3 3 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 3 3 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 1 1 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 7 7 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 5 5 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 3 3 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 2 2 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 5 5 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 4 4 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 1 1 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 7 7 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 5 5 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 4 4 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 3 3 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 5 5 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 3 3 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 4 4 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 3 3 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 2 2 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 2 2 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 3 3 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 8 8 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 8 8 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 13 13 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 14 14 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 5 5 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 5 5 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 8 8 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 8 8 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 5 5 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 5 5 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 5 5 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 5 5 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 2 2 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 3 3 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 3 3 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 3 3 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 3 3 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 4 4 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 1 1 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 2 2 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 1 1 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 9 9 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 10 10 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 5 5 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 5 5 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 4 4 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 8 8 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 8 8 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 12 12 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 9 9 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 3 3 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 2 2 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 1 1 0

TOTAL 272 272 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 45: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 42 of 70

EV Batch# 1 #per Batch: 162 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 94 94 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 61 61 0GREEN, ANGELA 5 5 0

TOTAL 160 160 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 101 101 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 57 57 0TOTAL 158 158 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 39 39 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 118 118 0

TOTAL 157 157 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 1 1 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 1 1 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 3 3 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 3 3 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 1 1 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 3 3 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 3 3 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 1 1 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 1 1 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 20 20 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 24 24 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 7 7 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 13 13 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 13 13 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 10 10 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 10 10 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 1 1 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 1 1 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 1 1 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 1 1 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 1 1 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 2 2 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 2 2 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 1 1 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 1 1 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 6 6 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 7 7 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 3 3 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 3 3 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 10 10 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 9 9 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 4 4 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 5 5 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 7 7 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 8 8 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 6 6 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 6 6 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 1 1 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 3 3 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 6 6 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 5 5 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 2 2 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 1 1 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 1 1 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 8 8 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 8 8 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 7 7 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 5 5 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 1 1 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 1 1 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 1 1 0

TOTAL 249 249 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 46: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 43 of 70

EV Batch# 51 #per Batch: 170 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 52 52 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 111 111 0GREEN, ANGELA 5 5 0

TOTAL 168 168 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 70 70 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 94 94 0TOTAL 164 164 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 57 57 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 110 110 0

TOTAL 167 167 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 1 1 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 1 1 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 1 1 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 2 2 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 3 3 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 2 2 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 1 1 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 2 2 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 1 1 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 1 1 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 1 1 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 2 2 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 3 3 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 4 4 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 7 7 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 7 7 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 5 5 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 5 5 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 1 1 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 7 7 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 7 7 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 4 4 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 2 2 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 10 10 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 10 10 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 2 2 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 2 2 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 1 1 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 1 1 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 2 2 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 16 16 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 17 17 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 1 1 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 1 1 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 3 3 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 1 1 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 1 1 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 3 3 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 5 5 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 13 13 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 11 11 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 1 1 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 3 3 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 1 1 0

TOTAL 175 175 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 47: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 44 of 70

EV Batch# 11 #per Batch: 180 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 95 95 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 81 81 0GREEN, ANGELA 3 3 0

TOTAL 179 179 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 109 109 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 66 66 0TOTAL 175 175 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 49 49 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 126 126 0

TOTAL 175 175 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 1 1 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 1 1 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 5 5 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 7 7 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 1 1 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 4 4 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 4 4 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 1 1 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 1 1 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 13 13 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 16 16 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 6 6 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 10 10 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 14 14 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 10 10 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 8 8 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 6 6 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 6 6 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 5 5 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 2 2 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 2 2 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 2 2 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 5 5 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 5 5 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 6 6 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 5 5 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 5 5 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 3 3 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 3 3 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 2 2 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 1 1 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 8 8 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 7 7 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 2 2 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 2 2 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 10 10 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 8 8 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 5 5 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 2 2 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 3 3 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 2 2 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 8 8 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 9 9 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 2 2 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 2 2 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 5 5 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 6 6 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 8 8 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 7 7 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 3 3 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 4 4 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 263 263 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

END OF BATCH:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

Page 48: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 45 of 70

EV Batch# 2 #per Batch: 180 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 97 97 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 77 77 0GREEN, ANGELA 4 4 0

TOTAL 178 178 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 104 104 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 72 72 0TOTAL 176 176 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 35 35 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 129 129 0

TOTAL 164 164 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 1 1 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 1 1 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 1 1 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 1 1 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 4 4 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 3 3 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 1 1 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 2 2 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 4 4 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 3 3 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 2 2 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 2 2 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 2 2 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 3 3 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 1 1 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 1 1 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 3 3 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 2 2 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 1 1 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 1 1 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 2 2 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 1 1 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 7 7 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 7 7 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 5 5 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 4 4 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 23 23 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 20 20 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 15 15 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 15 15 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 22 22 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 22 22 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 14 14 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 12 12 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 17 17 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 19 19 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 14 14 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 1 1 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 3 3 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 2 2 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 2 2 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 8 8 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 9 9 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 6 6 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 5 5 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 2 2 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 1 1 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 297 297 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 49: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 46 of 70

EV Batch# 38 #per Batch: 173 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 63 63 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 104 104 0GREEN, ANGELA 3 3 0

TOTAL 170 170 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 80 80 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 82 82 0TOTAL 162 162 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 55 55 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 113 113 0

TOTAL 168 168 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 1 1 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 1 1 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 2 2 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 2 2 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 1 1 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 1 1 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 2 2 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 2 2 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 1 1 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 1 1 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 1 1 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 1 1 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 1 1 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 1 1 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 1 1 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 1 1 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 2 2 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 2 2 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 5 5 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 6 6 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 11 11 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 12 12 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 27 27 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 19 19 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 29 29 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 29 29 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 1 1 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 1 1 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 1 1 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 1 1 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 1 1 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 11 11 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 9 9 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 9 9 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 2 2 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 3 3 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 3 3 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 9 9 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 9 9 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 11 11 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 10 10 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 1 1 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 1 1 0

TOTAL 245 245 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 50: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 47 of 70

EV Batch# 12 #per Batch: 178 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 91 91 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 84 84 0GREEN, ANGELA 2 2 0

TOTAL 177 177 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 103 103 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 69 69 0TOTAL 172 172 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 55 55 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 118 118 0

TOTAL 173 173 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 2 2 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 2 2 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 1 1 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 1 1 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 2 2 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 2 2 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 2 2 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 1 1 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 2 2 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 5 5 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 3 3 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 8 8 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 8 8 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 6 6 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 6 6 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 7 7 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 5 5 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 5 5 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 3 3 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 2 2 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 0 0 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 16 16 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 16 16 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 18 18 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 18 18 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 5 5 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 6 6 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 4 4 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 4 4 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 12 12 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 8 8 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 7 7 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 3 3 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 21 21 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 21 21 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 12 12 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 10 10 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 4 4 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 4 4 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 3 3 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 1 1 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 1 1 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 1 1 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 2 2 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 4 4 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 5 5 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 2 2 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 5 5 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 4 4 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 3 3 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 4 4 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 1 1 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 298 298 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 51: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 48 of 70

EV Batch# 44 #per Batch: 171 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 69 69 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 95 95 0GREEN, ANGELA 4 4 0

TOTAL 168 168 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 73 73 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 91 91 0TOTAL 164 164 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 63 63 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 103 103 0

TOTAL 166 166 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 1 1 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 1 1 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 2 2 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 2 2 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 1 1 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 3 3 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 2 2 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 2 2 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 3 3 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 3 3 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 4 4 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 6 6 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 9 9 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 7 7 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 7 7 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 22 22 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 22 22 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 14 14 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 6 6 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 1 1 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 1 1 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 2 2 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 8 8 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 6 6 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 20 20 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 23 23 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 1 1 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 3 3 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 5 5 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 4 4 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 1 1 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 3 3 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 4 4 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 17 17 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 22 22 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 13 13 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 1 1 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 2 2 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 8 8 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 7 7 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 269 269 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

END OF BATCH:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

Page 52: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 49 of 70

EV Batch# 58 #per Batch: 154 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 48 48 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 103 103 0GREEN, ANGELA 1 1 0

TOTAL 152 152 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 62 62 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 87 87 0TOTAL 149 149 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 52 52 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 96 96 0

TOTAL 148 148 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 2 2 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 1 1 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 2 2 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 3 3 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 1 1 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 1 1 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 1 1 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 1 1 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 2 2 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 2 2 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 4 4 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 17 17 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 16 16 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 20 20 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 21 21 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 1 1 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 1 1 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 6 6 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 9 9 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 10 10 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 8 8 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 2 2 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 3 3 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 2 2 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 1 1 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 2 2 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 1 1 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 11 11 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 12 12 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 5 5 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 8 8 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 19 19 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 21 21 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 1 1 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 1 1 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 3 3 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 7 7 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 6 6 0

TOTAL 234 234 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 53: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 50 of 70

EV Batch# 22 #per Batch: 166 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 88 88 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 74 74 0GREEN, ANGELA 4 4 0

TOTAL 166 166 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 104 104 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 61 61 0TOTAL 165 165 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 40 40 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 122 122 0

TOTAL 162 162 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 1 1 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 1 1 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 1 1 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 1 1 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 1 1 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 1 1 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 2 2 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 1 1 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 2 2 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 3 3 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 7 7 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 7 7 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 5 5 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 5 5 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 5 5 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 1 1 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 1 1 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 3 3 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 2 2 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 3 3 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 1 1 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 3 3 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 4 4 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 4 4 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 8 8 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 9 9 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 11 11 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 8 8 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 2 2 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 2 2 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 12 12 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 11 11 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 13 13 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 10 10 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 25 25 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 30 30 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 14 14 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 17 17 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 2 2 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 1 1 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 3 3 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 2 2 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 1 1 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 1 1 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 2 2 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 9 9 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 8 8 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 5 5 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 6 6 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 2 2 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 279 279 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 54: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 51 of 70

EV Batch# 4 #per Batch: 181 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 94 94 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 82 82 0GREEN, ANGELA 5 5 0

TOTAL 181 181 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 101 101 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 76 76 0TOTAL 177 177 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 63 63 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 110 110 0

TOTAL 173 173 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 2 2 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 2 2 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 2 2 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 2 2 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 15 15 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 17 17 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 5 5 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 2 2 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 2 2 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 1 1 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 1 1 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 1 1 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 16 16 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 22 22 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 15 15 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 11 11 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 9 9 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 7 7 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 7 7 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 2 2 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 2 2 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 1 1 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 1 1 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 4 4 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 6 6 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 3 3 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 6 6 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 11 11 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 11 11 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 3 3 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 2 2 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 3 3 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 3 3 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 4 4 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 7 7 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 8 8 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 2 2 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 1 1 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 2 2 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 1 1 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 2 2 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 2 2 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 12 12 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 11 11 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 20 20 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 20 20 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 1 1 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 1 1 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 2 2 0

TOTAL 293 293 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 55: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 52 of 70

EV Batch# 13 #per Batch: 172 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 79 79 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 87 87 0GREEN, ANGELA 4 4 0

TOTAL 170 170 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 90 90 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 81 81 0TOTAL 171 171 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 46 46 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 123 123 0

TOTAL 169 169 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 2 2 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 2 2 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 5 5 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 5 5 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 13 13 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 11 11 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 3 3 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 2 2 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 2 2 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 1 1 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 1 1 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 21 21 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 23 23 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 14 14 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 16 16 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 17 17 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 15 15 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 17 17 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 1 1 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 1 1 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 2 2 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 1 1 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 1 1 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 1 1 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 5 5 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 5 5 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 5 5 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 4 4 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 2 2 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 1 1 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 8 8 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 8 8 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 3 3 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 3 3 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 7 7 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 5 5 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 3 3 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 2 2 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 2 2 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 2 2 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 2 2 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 1 1 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 1 1 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 4 4 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 3 3 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 1 1 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 1 1 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 2 2 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 2 2 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 1 1 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 1 1 0

TOTAL 261 261 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 56: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 53 of 70

EV Batch# 45 #per Batch: 177 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 90 90 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 80 80 0GREEN, ANGELA 5 5 0

TOTAL 175 175 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 94 94 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 79 79 0TOTAL 173 173 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 39 39 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 133 133 0

TOTAL 172 172 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 1 1 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 1 1 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 3 3 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 2 2 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 2 2 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 1 1 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 2 2 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 11 11 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 10 10 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 4 4 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 26 26 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 26 26 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 10 10 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 11 11 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 14 14 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 13 13 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 5 5 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 5 5 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 5 5 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 1 1 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 11 11 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 16 16 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 8 8 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 7 7 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 1 1 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 2 2 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 1 1 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 2 2 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 8 8 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 6 6 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 4 4 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 6 6 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 3 3 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 6 6 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 10 10 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 2 2 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 1 1 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 1 1 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 1 1 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 4 4 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 4 4 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 5 5 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 4 4 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 1 1 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 1 1 0

TOTAL 268 268 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 57: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 54 of 70

EV Batch# 41 #per Batch: 174 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 88 88 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 84 84 0GREEN, ANGELA 2 2 0

TOTAL 174 174 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 90 90 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 72 72 0TOTAL 162 162 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 55 55 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 112 112 0

TOTAL 167 167 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 4 4 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 5 5 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 11 11 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 11 11 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 11 11 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 1 1 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 1 1 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 1 1 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 1 1 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 20 20 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 23 23 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 19 19 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 19 19 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 2 2 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 2 2 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 1 1 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 4 4 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 4 4 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 3 3 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 4 4 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 1 1 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 4 4 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 5 5 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 1 1 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 1 1 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 1 1 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 1 1 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 1 1 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 1 1 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 7 7 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 6 6 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 5 5 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 3 3 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 27 27 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 24 24 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 24 24 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 2 2 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 2 2 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 2 2 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 1 1 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 1 1 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 8 8 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 8 8 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 7 7 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 4 4 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 2 2 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 1 1 0

TOTAL 297 297 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 58: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 55 of 70

EV Batch# 5 #per Batch: 178 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 94 94 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 81 81 0GREEN, ANGELA 2 2 0

TOTAL 177 177 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 104 104 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 70 70 0TOTAL 174 174 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 51 51 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 122 122 0

TOTAL 173 173 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 18 18 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 18 18 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 4 4 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 4 4 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 2 2 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 1 1 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 1 1 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 1 1 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 11 11 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 13 13 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 10 10 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 9 9 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 2 2 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 2 2 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 1 1 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 1 1 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 7 7 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 8 8 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 14 14 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 4 4 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 4 4 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 9 9 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 5 5 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 4 4 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 5 5 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 3 3 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 3 3 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 13 13 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 12 12 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 5 5 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 6 6 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 11 11 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 12 12 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 7 7 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 2 2 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 4 4 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 6 6 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 5 5 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 5 5 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 1 1 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 1 1 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 1 1 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 14 14 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 12 12 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 6 6 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 5 5 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 292 292 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

END OF BATCH:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

Page 59: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 56 of 70

EV Batch# 42 #per Batch: 177 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 65 65 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 106 106 0GREEN, ANGELA 6 6 0

TOTAL 177 177 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 62 62 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 107 107 0TOTAL 169 169 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 65 65 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 108 108 0

TOTAL 173 173 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 1 1 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 1 1 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 1 1 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 1 1 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 12 12 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 12 12 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 10 10 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 10 10 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 1 1 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 1 1 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 2 2 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 2 2 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 3 3 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 3 3 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 13 13 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 15 15 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 17 17 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 5 5 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 17 17 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 20 20 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 22 22 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 4 4 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 4 4 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 14 14 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 14 14 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 2 2 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 2 2 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 7 7 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 5 5 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 2 2 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 1 1 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 3 3 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 4 4 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 1 1 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 2 2 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 2 2 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 3 3 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 3 3 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 1 1 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 6 6 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 9 9 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 2 2 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 1 1 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 2 2 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 1 1 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 1 1 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 1 1 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 6 6 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 6 6 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 8 8 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 7 7 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 1 1 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 294 294 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 60: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 57 of 70

EV Batch# 31 #per Batch: 177 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 85 85 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 86 86 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 171 171 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 99 99 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 73 73 0TOTAL 172 172 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 56 56 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 115 115 0

TOTAL 171 171 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 2 2 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 2 2 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 3 3 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 3 3 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 9 9 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 9 9 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 3 3 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 1 1 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 3 3 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 1 1 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 2 2 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 3 3 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 4 4 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 4 4 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 5 5 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 6 6 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 2 2 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 4 4 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 8 8 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 6 6 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 7 7 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 9 9 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 7 7 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 6 6 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 17 17 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 14 14 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 17 17 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 15 15 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 9 9 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 9 9 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 6 6 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 6 6 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 15 15 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 16 16 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 11 11 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 1 1 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 1 1 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 1 1 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 6 6 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 7 7 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 4 4 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 1 1 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 4 4 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 4 4 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 9 9 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 9 9 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 1 1 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 292 292 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

END OF BATCH:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

Page 61: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 58 of 70

EV Batch# 6 #per Batch: 171 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 93 93 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 76 76 0GREEN, ANGELA 0 0 0

TOTAL 169 169 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 98 98 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 68 68 0TOTAL 166 166 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 54 54 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 109 109 0

TOTAL 163 163 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 3 3 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 3 3 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 1 1 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 1 1 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 2 2 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 3 3 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 2 2 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 2 2 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 2 2 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 2 2 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 8 8 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 9 9 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 3 3 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 5 5 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 6 6 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 6 6 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 8 8 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 8 8 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 2 2 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 6 6 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 5 5 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 5 5 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 5 5 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 9 9 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 8 8 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 8 8 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 8 8 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 2 2 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 2 2 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 4 4 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 4 4 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 3 3 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 3 3 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 33 33 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 28 28 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 20 20 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 2 2 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 8 8 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 8 8 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 4 4 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 2 2 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 1 1 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 1 1 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 2 2 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 2 2 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 6 6 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 5 5 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 1 1 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 1 1 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 1 1 0

TOTAL 273 273 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 62: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 59 of 70

EV Batch# 48 #per Batch: 173 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 48 48 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 119 119 0GREEN, ANGELA 2 2 0

TOTAL 169 169 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 58 58 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 114 114 0TOTAL 172 172 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 107 107 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 62 62 0

TOTAL 169 169 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 1 1 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 1 1 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 4 4 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 3 3 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 4 4 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 1 1 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 1 1 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 1 1 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 2 2 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 1 1 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 2 2 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 1 1 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 8 8 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 11 11 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 9 9 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 10 10 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 10 10 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 9 9 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 9 9 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 8 8 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 3 3 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 2 2 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 2 2 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 0 0 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 0 0 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 5 5 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 5 5 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 3 3 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 3 3 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 2 2 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 2 2 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 6 6 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 6 6 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 9 9 0

TOTAL 144 144 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 63: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 60 of 70

EV Batch# 7 #per Batch: 160 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 89 89 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 73 73 0GREEN, ANGELA 3 3 0

TOTAL 165 165 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 90 90 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 71 71 0TOTAL 161 161 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 50 50 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 108 108 0

TOTAL 158 158 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 1 1 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 1 1 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 3 3 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 3 3 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 2 2 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 2 2 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 2 2 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 2 2 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 1 1 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 21 21 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 23 23 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 16 16 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 17 17 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 19 19 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 18 18 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 14 14 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 0 0 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 0 0 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 0 0 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 0 0 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 6 6 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 6 6 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 9 9 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 9 9 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 1 1 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 1 1 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 8 8 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 8 8 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 3 3 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 4 4 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 15 15 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 13 13 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 12 12 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 0 0 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 2 2 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 3 3 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 6 6 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 6 6 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 0 0 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 0 0 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 0 0 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 3 3 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 2 2 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 1 1 0

TOTAL 263 263 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 64: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 61 of 70

EV Batch# 53 #per Batch: 170 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 66 66 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 101 101 0GREEN, ANGELA 1 1 0

TOTAL 168 168 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 71 71 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 85 85 0TOTAL 156 156 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 63 63 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 98 98 0

TOTAL 161 161 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 2 2 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 2 2 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 1 1 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 1 1 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 0 0 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 1 1 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 0 0 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 0 0 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 1 1 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 1 1 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 3 3 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 3 3 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 1 1 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 1 1 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 2 2 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 19 19 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 16 16 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 27 27 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 24 24 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 0 0 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 0 0 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 1 1 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 2 2 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 3 3 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 2 2 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 4 4 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 3 3 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 14 14 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 10 10 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 17 17 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 22 22 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 12 12 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 1 1 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 5 5 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 5 5 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 16 16 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 12 12 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 3 3 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 3 3 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 3 3 0

TOTAL 243 243 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 65: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 62 of 70

EV Batch# 49 #per Batch: 168 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 88 88 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 76 76 0GREEN, ANGELA 2 2 0

TOTAL 166 166 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 88 88 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 73 73 0TOTAL 161 161 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 50 50 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 113 113 0

TOTAL 163 163 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 2 2 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 1 1 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 4 4 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 4 4 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 2 2 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 1 1 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 1 1 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 1 1 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 9 9 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 10 10 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 1 1 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 2 2 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 22 22 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 20 20 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 10 10 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 16 16 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 12 12 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 12 12 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 11 11 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 13 13 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 14 14 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 9 9 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 7 7 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 2 2 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 2 2 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 2 2 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 2 2 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 1 1 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 1 1 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 1 1 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 1 1 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 1 1 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 6 6 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 4 4 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 2 2 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 2 2 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 1 1 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 1 1 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 1 1 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 11 11 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 9 9 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 6 6 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 8 8 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 4 4 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 7 7 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 7 7 0

TOTAL 266 266 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 66: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 63 of 70

EV Batch# 29 #per Batch: 170 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 77 77 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 87 87 0GREEN, ANGELA 2 2 0

TOTAL 166 166 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 81 81 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 79 79 0TOTAL 160 160 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 41 41 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 118 118 0

TOTAL 159 159 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 2 2 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 2 2 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 1 1 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 4 4 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 4 4 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 5 5 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 5 5 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 5 5 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 5 5 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 1 1 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 12 12 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 14 14 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 7 7 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 8 8 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 1 1 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 1 1 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 11 11 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 14 14 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 10 10 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 6 6 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 3 3 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 7 7 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 5 5 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 9 9 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 9 9 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 7 7 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 7 7 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 4 4 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 5 5 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 3 3 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 2 2 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 5 5 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 6 6 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 6 6 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 5 5 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 7 7 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 6 6 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 4 4 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 5 5 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 1 1 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 1 1 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 1 1 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 3 3 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 2 2 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 8 8 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 8 8 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 1 1 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 1 1 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 1 1 0

TOTAL 250 250 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 67: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 64 of 70

EV Batch# 17 #per Batch: 174 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 71 71 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 97 97 0GREEN, ANGELA 3 3 0

TOTAL 171 171 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 78 78 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 93 93 0TOTAL 171 171 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 65 65 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 108 108 0

TOTAL 173 173 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 3 3 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 3 3 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 4 4 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 4 4 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 1 1 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 3 3 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 8 8 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 9 9 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 25 25 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 26 26 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 24 24 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 24 24 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 1 1 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 9 9 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 3 3 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 2 2 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 0 0 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 0 0 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 1 1 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 1 1 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 2 2 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 2 2 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 1 1 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 1 1 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 2 2 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 7 7 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 6 6 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 7 7 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 7 7 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 4 4 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 4 4 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 1 1 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 2 2 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 3 3 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 1 1 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 7 7 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 7 7 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 3 3 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 3 3 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 3 3 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 4 4 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 8 8 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 8 8 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 1 1 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 245 245 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 68: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 65 of 70

EV Batch# 55 #per Batch: 169 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 59 59 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 107 107 0GREEN, ANGELA 3 3 0

TOTAL 169 169 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 67 67 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 99 99 0TOTAL 166 166 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 62 62 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 101 101 0

TOTAL 163 163 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 2 2 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 2 2 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 1 1 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 2 2 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 2 2 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 1 1 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 2 2 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 4 4 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 4 4 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 5 5 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 6 6 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 1 1 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 1 1 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 1 1 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 3 3 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 2 2 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 2 2 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 5 5 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 5 5 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 6 6 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 6 6 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 6 6 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 6 6 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 1 1 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 1 1 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 4 4 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 3 3 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 1 1 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 2 2 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 17 17 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 13 13 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 32 32 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 3 3 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 11 11 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 10 10 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 7 7 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 6 6 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 2 2 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 2 2 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 1 1 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 1 1 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 11 11 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 11 11 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 15 15 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 12 12 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 7 7 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 7 7 0

TOTAL 255 255 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

END OF BATCH:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

Page 69: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 66 of 70

EV Batch# 18 #per Batch: 171 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 67 67 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 100 100 0GREEN, ANGELA 2 2 0

TOTAL 169 169 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 67 67 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 93 93 0TOTAL 160 160 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 64 64 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 95 95 0

TOTAL 159 159 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 2 2 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 2 2 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 6 6 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 5 5 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 8 8 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 7 7 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 1 1 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 1 1 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 4 4 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 3 3 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 1 1 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 1 1 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 4 4 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 3 3 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 1 1 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 1 1 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 11 11 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 10 10 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 16 16 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 1 1 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 1 1 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 3 3 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 3 3 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 2 2 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 2 2 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 4 4 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 4 4 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 2 2 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 1 1 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 3 3 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 3 3 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 4 4 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 3 3 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 2 2 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 3 3 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 4 4 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 4 4 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 5 5 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 4 4 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 19 19 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 19 19 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 10 10 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 11 11 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 2 2 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 4 4 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 5 5 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 14 14 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 9 9 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 1 1 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 8 8 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 9 9 0

TOTAL 256 256 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 70: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 67 of 70

EV Batch# 9 #per Batch: 180 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 84 84 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 92 92 0GREEN, ANGELA 2 2 0

TOTAL 178 178 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 90 90 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 84 84 0TOTAL 174 174 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 59 59 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 115 115 0

TOTAL 174 174 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 1 1 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 1 1 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 41 41 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 39 39 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 36 36 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 36 36 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 1 1 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 0 0 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 0 0 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 1 1 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 1 1 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 0 0 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 0 0 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 1 1 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 1 1 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 2 2 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 1 1 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 6 6 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 5 5 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 1 1 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 17 17 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 15 15 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 15 15 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 16 16 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 0 0 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 0 0 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 1 1 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 1 1 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 0 0 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 0 0 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 0 0 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 0 0 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 1 1 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 1 1 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 0 0 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 0 0 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 0 0 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 1 1 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 0 0 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 0 0 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 1 1 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 1 1 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 12 12 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 17 17 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 17 17 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 3 3 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 2 2 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 1 1 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 0 0 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 296 296 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 71: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 68 of 70

EV Batch# 59 #per Batch: 171 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 76 76 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 89 89 0GREEN, ANGELA 3 3 0

TOTAL 168 168 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 89 89 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 78 78 0TOTAL 167 167 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 52 52 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 116 116 0

TOTAL 168 168 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 1 1 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 1 1 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 2 2 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 2 2 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 1 1 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 1 1 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 1 1 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 13 13 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 13 13 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 7 7 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 7 7 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 3 3 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 3 3 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 2 2 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 1 1 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 3 3 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 17 17 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 13 13 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 15 15 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 12 12 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 13 13 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 13 13 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 9 9 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 9 9 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 2 2 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 3 3 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 3 3 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 4 4 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 3 3 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 4 4 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 4 4 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 3 3 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 4 4 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 5 5 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 3 3 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 1 1 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 3 3 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 4 4 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 1 1 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 1 1 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 0 0 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 0 0 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 4 4 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 3 3 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 6 6 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 5 5 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 4 4 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 7 7 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 10 10 0

TOTAL 249 249 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH:

Page 72: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 69 of 70

EV Batch# 26 #per Batch: 179 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 94 94 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 81 81 0GREEN, ANGELA 3 3 0

TOTAL 178 178 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 98 98 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 77 77 0TOTAL 175 175 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 49 49 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 125 125 0

TOTAL 174 174 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 0 0 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 0 0 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 0 0 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 0 0 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 2 2 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 2 2 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 0 0 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 0 0 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 1 1 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 3 3 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 2 2 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 6 6 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 7 7 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 7 7 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 6 6 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 8 8 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 7 7 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 4 4 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 2 2 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 9 9 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 8 8 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 7 7 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 22 22 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 21 21 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 18 18 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 16 16 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 8 8 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 8 8 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 8 8 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 9 9 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 1 1 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 1 1 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 1 1 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 1 1 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 0 0 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 0 0 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 10 10 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 11 11 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 6 6 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 4 4 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 5 5 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 5 5 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 7 7 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 9 9 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 12 12 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 2 2 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 3 3 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 2 2 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 4 4 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 7 7 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 4 4 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 2 2 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 0 0 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 0 0 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 0 0 0

TOTAL 288 288 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

END OF BATCH:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

Page 73: GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 HAND COUNT/AUDIT … General... · 2019-12-17 · MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA GENERAL ELECTION – NOVEMBER 6, 2018 . HAND COUNT/AUDIT REPORT .

Page 70 of 70

EV Batch# 24 #per Batch: 183 Date of Election: November 6, 2018Race Category: FEDERAL Race: US SENATOR

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceMCSALLY, MARTHA 107 107 0

SINEMA, KYRSTEN 74 74 0GREEN, ANGELA 1 1 0

TOTAL 182 182 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATEWIDE Race: ATTORNEY GENERAL

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceBRNOVICH, MARK 111 111 0

CONTRERAS, JANUARY 61 61 0TOTAL 172 172 0

Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: PROPOSITION Race: PROPOSITION 127

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferencePROPOSITION 127 - YES 45 45 0PROPOSITION 127 - NO 128 128 0

TOTAL 173 173 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:Race Category: STATE LEGISLATIVE Race: STATE REPRESENTATIVE

Candidate’s Hand Count Total Machine Total Absolute DifferenceCAMPBELL, NOEL-LD 1 2 2 0STRINGER, DAVID-LD 1 2 2 0

GOGEK, ED-LD 1 0 0 0MANOLIS, JAN-LD 1 0 0 0

FERNANDEZ, CHARLENE-LD 4 1 1 0PETEN, GERALDINE ''GERAE''-LD 4 1 1 0

WILLIAMS, SARA MAE-LD 4 0 0 0GRANTHAM, TRAVIS-LD 12 0 0 0PETERSEN, WARREN-LD 12 0 0 0

BISACCIA, JOE-LD 12 1 1 0ROBINSON, LYNSEY-LD 12 1 1 0

DUNN, TIMOTHY ''TIM''-LD 13 6 6 0OSBORNE, JOANNE-LD 13 7 7 0

TZITZURA, THOMAS-LD 13 2 2 0ALLEN, JOHN-LD 15 13 13 0

BARTO, NANCY-LD 15 15 15 0GUNNIGLE, JULIE-LD 15 8 8 0

SAMUELS, JENNIFER-LD 15 8 8 0FILLMORE, JOHN-LD 16 0 0 0

TOWNSEND, KELLY-LD 16 0 0 0STINARD, SHARON-LD 16 0 0 0

GRAYSON, RICHARD-LD 16 0 0 0ELLEN, NORA-LD 17 10 10 0

WENINGER, JEFF-LD 17 13 13 0PAWLIK, JENNIFER-LD 17 9 9 0

NORGAARD, JILL-LD 18 3 3 0PATTERSON, GREG-LD 18 2 2 0

EPSTEIN, DENISE ''MITZI''-LD 18 3 3 0JERMAINE, JENNIFER-LD 18 4 4 0

BOLICK, SHAWNNA-LD 20 5 5 0KERN, ANTHONY-LD 20 5 5 0

CHANDLER, HAZEL-LD 20 2 2 0GILFILLAN, CHRISTOPHER ''CHRIS''-LD 20 1 1 0

PAYNE, KEVIN-LD 21 2 2 0RIVERO, TONY-LD 21 2 2 0

HUGHES, BRADLEY-LD 21 0 0 0ROMERO, GILBERT-LD 21 0 0 0

CARROLL, FRANK-LD 22 28 28 0TOMA, BEN-LD 22 29 29 0

HARRIS, VALERIE-LD 22 12 12 0SARMIENTO, TERI-LD 22 12 12 0

KAVANAGH, JOHN-LD 23 4 4 0LAWRENCE, JAY-LD 23 4 4 0KURLAND, ERIC-LD 23 3 3 0

ALGER, DAVID, SR.-LD 24 12 12 0LONGDON, JENNIFER-LD 24 10 10 0

SHAH, AMISH-LD 24 7 7 0BOWERS, RUSSELL W. ''RUSTY''-LD 25 1 1 0

UDALL, MICHELLE-LD 25 1 1 0MARTIN, JOHNNY-LD 25 0 0 0

SPEAKMAN, RAYMOND D.-LD 26 0 0 0BLANC, ISELA-LD 26 1 1 0

SALMAN, ATHENA-LD 26 1 1 0PAPPAS PETSAS, KATHY-LD 28 9 9 0

SYMS, MARIA-LD 28 10 10 0BUTLER, KELLI-LD 28 8 8 0

LIEBERMAN, AARON-LD 28 7 7 0SPEARS, GARY-LD 30 1 1 0

MEZA, ROBERT-LD 30 1 1 0TERÁN, RAQUEL-LD 30 1 1 0

TOTAL 290 290 0Comments for why a discrepancy occurred:

EARLY VOTING (EV) BALLOT AUDIT HAND COUNT REPORT - OPTICAL SCAN BALLOTS

END OF BATCH: