Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
-
Upload
mark-h-jaffe -
Category
Documents
-
view
220 -
download
0
Transcript of Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 1/74
No. 12-57302
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
CINDY LEE GARCIA, Plaintiff-Appellant
v.
GOOGLE, INC., YOUTUBE LLC, et al., Defendants-Appellees, and
NAKOULA BAS SELEY NAKOULA, a.k.a. Sam Bacile, et al., Defendants.
On Appeal from the United States District Court
for the Central District of CaliforniaD.C. No. 2:12-cv-08315-MWF-VBK
APPELLANT CINDY LEE GARCIA S EMERGENCY MOTION FOR
A FINDING OF CONTEMPT, FOR SANCTIONS AND/OR FOR
ORDER FOR IMMEDIATE COMPLIANCE
M. Cris Armenta SBN 177 403)The Armenta Law Firm APC11900 W. Olympic Blvd. Ste. 730Los Angeles, CA 90064Tel: 31 0) 826-2826
1
Credence Sol SBN 219784)a Garenne
86200 ChauvignyFranceTel: 06 74 90 22 08
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 1 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 2/74
CIRCUIT RULE 27 3 CERTIFICATION
Pursuant to Ninth Circuit Rule 27-3, counsel for Appellant Cindy
Garcia state:
1 The telephone numbers, email addresses, and office addresses
o the attorneys for the parties are:
M Cris Armenta Neal Kumar KatyalTHE ARMENTA LAW FIRM, APC Christopher Handman
11900W
Olympic Blvd, Suite 730 Dominic F. PerellaLos Angeles, CA 90064 Sean MarottaTel: 310) 826-2826 x108 HOGAN LOVELLS US [email protected] 555 Thirteenth St., N W
Washington, D.C. 20004Tel: 202) [email protected]
Credence E Sol Timothy L Alger
La Garenne Suita Bali86200 Chauvigny, France PERKINS COlE LLPTel: 06 74 90 22 08 1305 Porter [email protected] Palo Alto, CA 94306
Tel: 650) [email protected] @Qerkinscoie.com
Jason ArmstrongThe Law Office o Jason Armstrong611 West Main St.Bozeman, MT 59715Tel: 406) [email protected]
Counsel for Plaintiff /Appellant Cindy Counsel for Defendants/ Appellees
Lee Garcia Google Inc. and YouTube LL
2
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 2 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 3/74
2 A ppell ant/Plaintif f Cin dy Lee Gar cia he reby files this
emerg ency motio n for contempt a nd/o r an order f or co mpliance a gains t
De fend ants/ Appel lees G oogle, Inc ., and Y ouTube LLC (hereinafte r,
Google ).
3
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 3 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 4/74
MOT ON
3 On February 28, 2014, this Court 's amended order went into
effect, ordering Defendants/ Appellees to take down all copies of nnocence
o f Muslims from YouTube.com and from any other platforms under
Google' s control, and take all reasonable steps to prevent further uploads of
nnocence o f Muslims to those platforms. Google shall comply with this
order within twenty four hours o he issuance thereof. This order does not
preclude the posting or display of any version of nnocence o f Muslims that
does not include Cindy Lee Garcia 's performance. (Emphasis added.)
4 Google has failed to comply. As of this morning, at 7:55a.m
EST, a version of nnocence o f Muslims that includes Ms. Garcia's
performance is still available on Google's Worldwide Platform and also
viewable in Egypt, the nation in which thef tw was issued for Ms. Garcia's
execution. All a viewer needs to do to view a copy of the video that contains
the infringing material from any computer in the world and within in
Y ouTube ' s global platform and therefore is governed by the takedown
order is to change his or her settings to any country platform, such as
Egypt. Unfortunately, this failure to comply has been a recurrent issue
since the Court first ordered the infringing material taken down. Despite the
fact that Ms. Garcia's counsel has pointed out to Googlenumerous times
that
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 4 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 5/74
Google has been in contempt of this Court and despite Ms. Garcia's offer
(despite her limited resources) to show Google how and why it has failed to
comply, its lack of compliance continues to this day. Attached to this
Motion are the declarations ofM. Cris Armenta and David Hardy, which
provide ( 1 evidence of Google' s multiple violations of the order; (2)
correspondence between counsel on the issue; and (3) evidence that Google
has the technology at its fingertips that would permit it to comply with the
Court's order. See Declaration ofM. Cris Armenta and Declaration of
David Hardy, passim and attached exhibits.
5. Notwithstanding its vast technical resources and standing as
one of the largest and most sophisticated Internet companies in the world,
Google and its army of lawyers have taken the position that Google is
somehow incapable of complying with the order, that it is deploying every
resource to comply, and that Ms. Garcia who has virtually no resources-
bears the burden of advising Google of each and every individual URL that
remains on Google's platforms in defiance of the takedown order. Then and
only then, according to Google has Google complied with the Court' s
takedown order.
6. Significantly, Ms. Garcia long ago advised Google via her
takedown notices issued in the fall of2012 that included Google with a list
5
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 5 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 6/74
of 852 YouTube channels and URLs that contained the infringing m te r i l -
o f the 852 infringing channels. For Google, it is a pedestrian, technical
exercise to take down those URLs, to hire an intern to just search for
Innocence of Muslims, and their suggestion that Ms. Garcia should comb
through Y ouTube again, and provide Google with the information again,
belies Google' s claim that it is in compliance.
7. Because this case is within the jurisdiction of this Circuit, Ms.
Garcia is somewhat at a loss as to how to proceed. However, were this case
within the jurisdiction of the district court, Ms. Garcia would ask for a
contempt penalty of $150,000 per violation. In this particular case, Google
has violated the Court's order (and continued to illegally profit from traffic
to the infringing material on Y ouTube) on several different channels. The
maximum penalty of$150,000 per channel is the only fair measure of the
contempt. In addition Ms. Garcia would ask the district court that Google
post a bond equal to the statutory maximum for copyright infringement for
each of the 852 channels identified in her initial takedown notices. Because
of the unusual position in which Ms. Garcia finds herself, the matter of any
contempt penalty or bond is submitted to the sound discretion of this Court.
Those damages range from $30,000.00 to $150,000 per URL that was
initially indicated in the takedown notices (852 URLs . This is because
6
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 6 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 7/74
Google has behaved with utter contempt for this Court' s (amended) orde r o f
February 28, 2014 by allowing re-uploads of the video in violation o f the
Court order and for foisting its duties to police its own platform off to Ms.
Garc ia's team. This Court should not allow Google to continue to flagrantly
defy its order without some corresponding consequences.
8 Additionally, as of the writing o f this brief, Google has not
taken down anything. Instead, it has merely disabled the various uploads
displaying Innocence o f Muslims in forms that contain infringing content,
leaving the content up and viewable via thumbnails. Moreover, Google has
failed to remove full copies o f the video from its platforms, has failed to
prevent n w uploads o f the video to Y ouTube, and continues to publish on
its Google search index platforms links to numerous sites and platforms
where the video can either be directly viewed or where it can be easily
downloaded and saved to viewers' computers. Indeed, Google has not even
made a pro forma attempt to comply with the order, choosing instead to
temporarily disable only a few copies o f the video that contain infringing
content and putting in their place a snide message to the public that states:
This video is no longer available due to a copyright claim by anactress over her 5-second appearance in the video. A US court hasordered Google to remove the video. We strongly disagree with this
copyright rulingand
willfight it
7
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 7 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 8/74
As is clear from Google s near-total disregard o the order and its ridiculing
o the Court s authority, Google is thumbing its nose at the Court and
making a mockery o our judicial system in an apparent attempt to
encourage the public to blame and harass Ms. Garcia and to continue to use
the infringing content to generate Y ouTube revenues from traffic directed
through the 852 URLs that have illegally posted the content.
March 25, 2014 s M. Cris Armenta
8
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 8 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 9/74
C E RT I F I C T E O F S E RV IC E
I her eb y certify that I e le ctronically f iled the foregoin g w ith the Clerk
o he Co urt for th e United State s C ourt o Appe als for the Ninth C i rcuit by
us ing the appe llat e CM/ECF s yste m on M arch 2 5 20 14
I certify th at a ll participant s in the case are r eg is tered CM / E C F users
a nd that service will be accompl ishe d by the app ella te CM/ECF sy s tem.
Is Heather Row la n d
H eather Row land
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 9 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 10/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 10 of 74
C 12 302 03 2 201 903080 k 6 11 f
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 11/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 11 of 74
C 12 57302 03/25/2014 ID 9030805 DktE t 67 P g 12 f 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 12/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 12 of 74
Case: 12 57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 13 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 13/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 13 of 74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 14 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 14/74
Case: 12 57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 14 of 74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 15 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 15/74
y g
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 16 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 16/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 17 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 17/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 18 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 18/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 19 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 19/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 20 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 20/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 21 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 21/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 22 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 22/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 23 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 23/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 24 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 24/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 25 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 25/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 26 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 26/74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 27/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 28 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 28/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 29 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 29/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 30 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 30/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 31 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 31/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 32 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 32/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 33 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 33/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 34 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 34/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 35 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 35/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 36 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 36/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 37 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 37/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 38 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 38/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 39 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 39/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 40 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 40/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 41 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 41/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 42 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 42/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 43 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 43/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 44 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 44/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 45 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 45/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 46 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 46/74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 47/74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 48/74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 49/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 50 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 50/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 51 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 51/74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 52/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 53 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 53/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 54 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 54/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 55 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 55/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 56 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 56/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 57 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 57/74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 58/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 59 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 59/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 60 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 60/74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 61/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 62 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 62/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 63 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 63/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 64 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 64/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 65 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 65/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 66 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 66/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 67 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 67/74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 68/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 69 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 69/74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 70/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 71 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 71/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 72 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 72/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 73 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 73/74
Case: 12-57302 03/25/2014 ID: 9030805 DktEntry: 67 Page: 74 of 74
8/12/2019 Garcia Emergency Motion for Sanctions Against Google
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/garcia-emergency-motion-for-sanctions-against-google 74/74