G A L E N GALEN-IN-USE: Tools and MethodologySlide 1 Rubrics to Dissections to GRAIL to...

21
G A L E N SE: Tools and Methodology Slide 1 Rubrics to Dissections to GRAIL to Classifications GALEN-IN-USE A graphical overview of the tools and methodologies being used in the GALEN- IN-USE project to develop a classification of surgical procedures The slides in this presentation have accompanying notes. These are visible from the ‘V iew…N otes Pages’ option on the main PowerPoint menu. http://www.galen- organisation.com/ http://www.cs.man.ac.uk/ mig/galen/

Transcript of G A L E N GALEN-IN-USE: Tools and MethodologySlide 1 Rubrics to Dissections to GRAIL to...

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 1

Rubrics to Dissections to GRAIL to Classifications

GALEN-IN-USE

A graphical overview of the tools and methodologies being used in the GALEN-IN-USE project to develop a

classification of surgical procedures

The slides in this presentation have accompanying notes. These are visible from the ‘View…Notes Pages’ option on the main PowerPoint menu.

http://www.galen-organisation.com/

http://www.cs.man.ac.uk/mig/galen/

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 2

GALEN-IN-USE Partners

University of Manchester, VAMP Health, UK

University of Nijmegen, Holland

EFCC and its affiliates: WCC, NOMESCO, CNR Rome, U St EtienneWCC, NOMESCO, CNR Rome, U St Etienne IASIST, IDGmbH, CMITD, STAKE, U LouvainIASIST, IDGmbH, CMITD, STAKE, U Louvain

University Hospital of Geneva, LNAT, Switzerland

OLE, RAMIT, Datasoft, Belgium

GSF Medis, U Hildesheim, Germany

CNR, Rome, Italy

SPRI, U Linköping, Sweden

VTT, Oulu Univ Hospital, Medici Data, Finland

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 3

Surgical

Procedure

Entry

Tool

SPET

ICD

ICPC

SN

OM

ED

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 4

RUBRIC "dividing of papillary muscle"CODE "35.31.i1"MAIN dividing

ACTS_ON papillary muscleHAS_OTHER_FEATURE method VALUE induced arrest of heart

Dissection

SPET

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 5

RUBRIC "operations on papillary muscle"CODE "35.31"MAIN surgical deed

ACTS_ON papillary muscleHAS_OTHER_FEATURE method VALUE induced arrest of heart

RUBRIC "dividing of papillary muscle"CODE "35.31.i1"MAIN dividing

ACTS_ON papillary muscleHAS_OTHER_FEATURE method VALUE induced arrest of heart

RUBRIC "reattachment of papillary muscle"CODE "35.31.i2"MAIN repairing

ACTS_ON papillary muscleBY_TECHNIQUE reattaching

ACTS_ON papillary muscleHAS_OTHER_FEATURE method VALUE induced arrest of heart

RUBRIC "repair of papillary muscle"CODE "35.31.i3"MAIN repairing

ACTS_ON papillary muscleHAS_OTHER_FEATURE method VALUE induced arrest of heart

‘Sibling’ codes

Dissections

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 6

RUBRIC "operations on papillary muscle"CODE "35.31"MAIN surgical deed

ACTS_ON papillary muscleHAS_OTHER_FEATURE method VALUE induced arrest of heart

RUBRIC "dividing of papillary muscle"CODE "35.31.i1"MAIN dividing

ACTS_ON papillary muscleHAS_OTHER_FEATURE method VALUE induced arrest of heart

RUBRIC "reattachment of papillary muscle"CODE "35.31.i2"MAIN repairing

ACTS_ON papillary muscleBY_TECHNIQUE reattaching

ACTS_ON papillary muscleHAS_OTHER_FEATURE method VALUE induced arrest of heart

RUBRIC "repair of papillary muscle"CODE "35.31.i3"MAIN repairing

ACTS_ON papillary muscleHAS_OTHER_FEATURE method VALUE induced arrest of heart

TemplateInterpreterandGRAILGenerator

Dissections

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 7

Expansion Algorithm

Map ‘descriptors’Map ‘descriptors’to GRAIL concepts to GRAIL concepts

(usually one-to-one)(usually one-to-one)

Map ‘Links’Map ‘Links’to GRAIL link-concept-link fragmentsto GRAIL link-concept-link fragments

usually one to manyusually one to many

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 8

Dissection

GRAIL

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 9

Automatic GRAIL Classification

GALEN Terminology

Server

Browse...

GRAIL

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 10

GALEN Terminology

Server

Classification of original rubrics

Browse...

GRAILGALEN

Terminology Server

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 11

Different organisationNew organisation calculated automatically, based on the structure provided in the dissection, and in the GRAIL Common Reference Model.

[35.31.i2] is now a child of [35.31.i3], not a sibling (as in the original source).

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 12

Browse...

GRAIL

Multilingual Natural Language

DissectionRubric

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 13

'037 Biopsie rénale isolée par lombotomie'

SurgicalDeed which isCharacterisedBy (performance whichG isEnactmentOf (BiopsyingProcess whichG < actsSpecificallyOn Kidney hasSpecificSubprocess (SurgicalApproaching whichG hasPhysicalMeans ((Route whichG passesThrough Loin))) >))

en: 'kidney biopsy by lumbotomie'fr: 'biopsie rénale par lombotomie'ge: 'Biopsie der Niere durch Lumbotomie'du: 'biopsie van de nier door lombotomie?'

GRAIL

Multilingual Natural Language

Rubric

Language Generation: example 1

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 14

'109 Echographie prostatique transrectale'

SurgicalDeed which isCharacterisedBy (performance whichG isEnactmentOf ((ImagingProcess which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG < actsSpecificallyOn ProstateGland hasSpecificPhysicalMeans UltrasonographyMachine hasSpecificSubprocess (SurgicalApproaching whichG hasPhysicalMeans ((Route which hasColinearityWith Rectum))) >))

en: 'transrectal prostate echographie'fr: 'echographie transrectale de la prostate'ge: 'transrektale Sonographie der Prostata'du: 'transrectale echografie van de prostaat'

GRAIL

Multilingual Natural Language

Rubric

Language Generation: example 2

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 15

'252 Exérèse d''une tumeur de la glande surrénale à ciel ouvert'

SurgicalDeed which isCharacterisedBy (performance whichG isEnactmentOf ((Excising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG < actsSpecificallyOn (NeoplasticLesion whichG hasSpecificLocation AdrenalGland) hasSpecificSubprocess (SurgicalApproaching whichG hasSurgicalOpenClosedness (SurgicalOpenClosedness whichG hasAbsoluteState surgicallyOpen)) >))

en: 'surgically open extracting of an adrenal gland neoplastic lesion'fr: 'extraction d''une tumeur de la glande surrénale à ciel ouvert'ge: 'offene Extraktion eines Tumors der Nebenniere'du: 'open extractie van een tumor van de bijnier'

GRAIL

Multilingual Natural Language

Rubric

Language Generation: example 3

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 16

RUBRIC "valgiserende osteotomie van overig gespecificeerd bot"PARAPHRASE "osteotomy of bone with purpose to create a valgising position, without humerus, without radius, without ulna, without metacarpalen and phalanx of hand, without femur, without tibia, without fibula and without metatarsalen and phalanx of foot"CODE "5-781.29"ENGLISH_RUBRIC "valgising osteotomy of other specified bone"

MAIN cuttingTO_ACHIEVE Deed:valgising

ACTS_ON Pathology:pathological postureACTS_ON bone

WITHOUT cuttingTO_ACHIEVE Deed:valgising

ACTS_ON Pathology:pathological postureACTS_ON humerus / radius / ulna / femur / tibia / fibula /

os metacarpale / os metatarsale / phalanx

Why Templates?

Small template produces large Grail ...

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 17

#printTime.#printMessage 'valgiserende osteotomie van overig gespecificeerd bot'.((SurgicalDeed which <

isCharacterisedBy (performance whichG isEnactmentOf ((Incising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG <

hasSpecificGoal ((Valgising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG

actsSpecificallyOn PathologicalStandingPosture)actsSpecificallyOn Bone

>))isCharacterisedBy (nonPerformance whichG

isEnactmentOf ((Incising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG <hasSpecificGoal ((Valgising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole)

whichG

actsSpecificallyOn PathologicalStandingPosture)actsSpecificallyOn Humerus

>))>)extrinsically hasRubric 'valgiserende osteotomie van overig gespecificeerd bot';extrinsically hasParaphrase 'osteotomy of bone with purpose to create a valgising position, without humerus, without radius, without ulna,

without metacarpalen and phalanx of hand, without femur, without tibia, without fibula and without metatarsalen and phalanx of foot';extrinsically hasCode '5-781.29';extrinsically hasEnglishRubric 'valgising osteotomy of other specified bone')extrinsically hasPhysicalSource 'wccfix.txt'.

((SurgicalDeed which <isCharacterisedBy (performance whichG

isEnactmentOf ((Incising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG <hasSpecificGoal ((Valgising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole)

whichG

actsSpecificallyOn PathologicalStandingPosture)actsSpecificallyOn Bone

>))isCharacterisedBy (nonPerformance whichG

isEnactmentOf ((Incising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG <hasSpecificGoal ((Valgising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole)

whichG

actsSpecificallyOn PathologicalStandingPosture)actsSpecificallyOn Radius

>))>)

1 2 3 4 5Grail

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 18

extrinsically hasRubric 'valgiserende osteotomie van overig gespecificeerd bot';extrinsically hasParaphrase 'osteotomy of bone with purpose to create a valgising position, without humerus, without radius, without ulna,

without metacarpalen and phalanx of hand, without femur, without tibia, without fibula and without metatarsalen and phalanx of foot';extrinsically hasCode '5-781.29';extrinsically hasEnglishRubric 'valgising osteotomy of other specified bone')extrinsically hasPhysicalSource 'wccfix.txt'.

((SurgicalDeed which <isCharacterisedBy (performance whichG

isEnactmentOf ((Incising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG <hasSpecificGoal ((Valgising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole)

whichG

actsSpecificallyOn PathologicalStandingPosture)actsSpecificallyOn Bone

>))isCharacterisedBy (nonPerformance whichG

isEnactmentOf ((Incising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG <hasSpecificGoal ((Valgising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole)

whichG

actsSpecificallyOn PathologicalStandingPosture)actsSpecificallyOn Ulna

>))>)extrinsically hasRubric 'valgiserende osteotomie van overig gespecificeerd bot';extrinsically hasParaphrase 'osteotomy of bone with purpose to create a valgising position, without humerus, without radius, without ulna,

without metacarpalen and phalanx of hand, without femur, without tibia, without fibula and without metatarsalen and phalanx of foot';extrinsically hasCode '5-781.29';extrinsically hasEnglishRubric 'valgising osteotomy of other specified bone')extrinsically hasPhysicalSource 'wccfix.txt'.

((SurgicalDeed which <isCharacterisedBy (performance whichG

isEnactmentOf ((Incising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG <hasSpecificGoal ((Valgising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole)

whichG

actsSpecificallyOn PathologicalStandingPosture)actsSpecificallyOn Bone

>))

1 2 3 4 5Grail

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 19

isCharacterisedBy (nonPerformance whichG isEnactmentOf ((Incising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG <

hasSpecificGoal ((Valgising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG

actsSpecificallyOn PathologicalStandingPosture)actsSpecificallyOn Femur

>))>)extrinsically hasRubric 'valgiserende osteotomie van overig gespecificeerd bot';extrinsically hasParaphrase 'osteotomy of bone with purpose to create a valgising position, without humerus, without radius, without ulna,

without metacarpalen and phalanx of hand, without femur, without tibia, without fibula and without metatarsalen and phalanx of foot';extrinsically hasCode '5-781.29';extrinsically hasEnglishRubric 'valgising osteotomy of other specified bone')extrinsically hasPhysicalSource 'wccfix.txt'.

((SurgicalDeed which <isCharacterisedBy (performance whichG

isEnactmentOf ((Incising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG <hasSpecificGoal ((Valgising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole)

whichG

actsSpecificallyOn PathologicalStandingPosture)actsSpecificallyOn Bone

>))isCharacterisedBy (nonPerformance whichG

isEnactmentOf ((Incising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG <hasSpecificGoal ((Valgising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole)

whichG

actsSpecificallyOn PathologicalStandingPosture)actsSpecificallyOn Tibia

>))>)extrinsically hasRubric 'valgiserende osteotomie van overig gespecificeerd bot';extrinsically hasParaphrase 'osteotomy of bone with purpose to create a valgising position, without humerus, without radius, without ulna,

without metacarpalen and phalanx of hand, without femur, without tibia, without fibula and without metatarsalen and phalanx of foot';extrinsically hasCode '5-781.29';extrinsically hasEnglishRubric 'valgising osteotomy of other specified bone')extrinsically hasPhysicalSource 'wccfix.txt'.

((SurgicalDeed which <isCharacterisedBy (performance whichG

isEnactmentOf ((Incising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG <hasSpecificGoal ((Valgising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole)

whichG

1 2 3 4 5Grail

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 20

actsSpecificallyOn PathologicalStandingPosture)actsSpecificallyOn Bone

>))isCharacterisedBy (nonPerformance whichG

isEnactmentOf ((Incising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG <hasSpecificGoal ((Valgising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG

actsSpecificallyOn PathologicalStandingPosture)

actsSpecificallyOn Fibula>))>)extrinsically hasRubric 'valgiserende osteotomie van overig gespecificeerd bot';extrinsically hasParaphrase 'osteotomy of bone with purpose to create a valgising position, without humerus, without radius, without ulna, without

metacarpalen and phalanx of hand, without femur, without tibia, without fibula and without metatarsalen and phalanx of foot';extrinsically hasCode '5-781.29';extrinsically hasEnglishRubric 'valgising osteotomy of other specified bone')extrinsically hasPhysicalSource 'wccfix.txt'.

((SurgicalDeed which <isCharacterisedBy (performance whichG

isEnactmentOf ((Incising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG <hasSpecificGoal ((Valgising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG

actsSpecificallyOn PathologicalStandingPosture)

actsSpecificallyOn Bone>))isCharacterisedBy (nonPerformance whichG

isEnactmentOf ((Incising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG <hasSpecificGoal ((Valgising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG

actsSpecificallyOn PathologicalStandingPosture)

actsSpecificallyOn Metacarpal>))>)extrinsically hasRubric 'valgiserende osteotomie van overig gespecificeerd bot';extrinsically hasParaphrase 'osteotomy of bone with purpose to create a valgising position, without humerus, without radius, without ulna, without

metacarpalen and phalanx of hand, without femur, without tibia, without fibula and without metatarsalen and phalanx of foot';extrinsically hasCode '5-781.29';extrinsically hasEnglishRubric 'valgising osteotomy of other specified bone')extrinsically hasPhysicalSource 'wccfix.txt'.

((SurgicalDeed which <

1 2 3 4 5Grail

G A L E NGALEN-IN-USE: Tools and Methodology Slide 21

isCharacterisedBy (performance whichG isEnactmentOf ((Incising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG <

hasSpecificGoal ((Valgising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG

actsSpecificallyOn PathologicalStandingPosture)actsSpecificallyOn Bone

>))isCharacterisedBy (nonPerformance whichG

isEnactmentOf ((Incising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG <hasSpecificGoal ((Valgising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole)

whichG

actsSpecificallyOn PathologicalStandingPosture)actsSpecificallyOn Metatarsal

>))>)extrinsically hasRubric 'valgiserende osteotomie van overig gespecificeerd bot';extrinsically hasParaphrase 'osteotomy of bone with purpose to create a valgising position, without humerus, without radius, without ulna,

without metacarpalen and phalanx of hand, without femur, without tibia, without fibula and without metatarsalen and phalanx of foot';extrinsically hasCode '5-781.29';extrinsically hasEnglishRubric 'valgising osteotomy of other specified bone')extrinsically hasPhysicalSource 'wccfix.txt'.

((SurgicalDeed which <isCharacterisedBy (performance whichG

isEnactmentOf ((Incising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG <hasSpecificGoal ((Valgising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole)

whichG

actsSpecificallyOn PathologicalStandingPosture)actsSpecificallyOn Bone

>))isCharacterisedBy (nonPerformance whichG

isEnactmentOf ((Incising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole) whichG <hasSpecificGoal ((Valgising which playsClinicalRole SurgicalRole)

whichG

actsSpecificallyOn PathologicalStandingPosture)actsSpecificallyOn Phalanx

>))>)

1 2 3 4 5Grail