Fundamentals of Proposal Development Presenter: Dr. Bruce Crawford Interim Vice Chancellor for...
-
Upload
joanna-aleesha-golden -
Category
Documents
-
view
218 -
download
0
Transcript of Fundamentals of Proposal Development Presenter: Dr. Bruce Crawford Interim Vice Chancellor for...
Fundamentals of Proposal Development
Presenter:
Dr. Bruce CrawfordInterim Vice Chancellor for Instructional and Student Services
Alabama Department of Postsecondary EducationAlabama Community College System
Vice President for Instructional Services Lawson State Community College
2
Topics/Objectives Understand the Fundamentals Identify and Know Your Institutional
Strengths Understand The RFP/BAA/Cooperative
Agreement Identify 8 Basic Components of A Proposal Identify Characteristics of a Good Principal
Investigator Identify Characteristics of Winning
Proposals Identify Characteristics of Losing Proposals
3
Topics/Objectives (continued) Identify Commons Errors That
Guarantee A Losing Proposal Understand the Importance of
Performing Identify and Use Resources Available to
You Make An Accessing Your Own Internal
Processes- Policies, Procedures, Committees,
Agreements Review Samples of a RFP and BAA Questions and Answers
4
Understanding the Fundamentals Eighty (80) percent of all grants and
contracts are won before the competition
Develop and maintain contacts and networks
Be proactive Research the Agency’s (DoD, DoE, NSF,
NASA, DoL, NIH) and/or customer’s needs, priorities, thrusts
Talk, listen, listen, listen Deliver what the customer needs, not
what you want
5
Know Your Strengths Put your story together Certify your capabilities Assess your ability to deliver Cultivate resources and collaborate Differentiate your assets from other
potential customers Demonstrate proof of superiority
Know Strength: Branding Your Institution Creation and dissemination of a
particular perception An image or persona Awareness of a product, service or
organization
Strengths What is unique about you? What do you offer that is ‘best in
class?’ What do you offer that surpasses
your competition? How do you maintain your
competitive edge?
8
Strengths Demonstrate your superiority in
research or subject matter areas- Why did we select our approach?- What is the rationale?- How does it compare to alternatives or
competing ideas?- What can we deliver that no one else
can?- What are our relevant credentials and/or
experiences?
9
Characteristics of Winning Proposals Strong and continuous
contacts/marketing Thorough understanding of the BAA/RFP Use best personnel and resources Used proven writing techniques; review
successful proposals Request technical assistance for large
efforts Respond within the specific guidelines
and procedures
10
Winning Proposals Well written, responsive and persuasive The proof is in the graphics!
Graphics organize data to prove a point Accurate graphical depiction of information Graphics are not decorations
11
Winning Proposals (continued)- Provide outside, objective customer-
focused evaluation- Provide an assessment of clarity,
consistency, and persuasiveness- Keep you on schedule- Provide positive motivation
12
Wining Characteristics: Proposal Basics “Shall” and “Must” are requirements “May” and “Should” indicate desired
requirements Every winning proposal must present an
idea of design with a well thought-out plan of action
Winning proposals must use concise, straight-forward language
State the purpose and importance of the work and the specific results to be obtained
13
Winning Characteristics: Basic Fundamentals
Identify who will perform the work and their qualifications
Describe where the work will be performed and the resources available to support it
Offer a schedule or timeline demonstrating how much time the project will take
14
The RFP/BAA Test
Read the RFP/BAA twice Develop a matrix using the Solicitation
Outline The agency (customer) asks the
questions:- Who? What? When? Where? Why?- How many? How much? So what?
15
The RFP/BAA Test (Continued) You answer the questions The customer scores the answers Zeros for questions not answered Low grades for partial answers Low grades for answers they do not
understand Low grades for answers they do not like The highest grade overall wins!
Eight Basic Components of A Proposal The Executive Summary or Abstract Introduction of the Institution Problem Statement Objectives Method or Design Evaluation Future Funding The Budget
Executive Summary or Abstract Also known as the Abstract Appears at the Beginning Written Last Usually One Page Outlines the Proposed Project
Includes key summary points Communicates the objectives Cornerstone of your proposal Initial impression
Introduction of Institution Pertinent data about your institution Organizational structure Institution’s mission, goals, track record
with agency (DoD in this case), other grantors (NSF, NASA, ETC.), and success stories
Present information that is relevant to the agency
Include Institutional commitment(s) to the problem and Establish credibility
Problem Statement Key component of the proposal Problem should be relevant to the
funding agency’s requirements Include beneficiaries Make a clear, concise, well-
supported statement of the problem to be addressed in your proposal
Objectives Specific Activities to be
Accomplished Identify all Objectives Related to
the Goal (s) Consider Measurable Quantities Define Timeline Be Realistic as Stated Objectives
will be used to Evaluate your Project
Method and Design (Statement of Work) Define how the project is expected to work Define how the project will solve the stated
problem Discuss methods to be employed to achieve
the goals Define/Outline Timeline Define Data Collection Methods: Research
reports, Needs assessment in the target area, Data should be related to the problem, Relevant and Timely
Identify Activities to Occur (inputs): processes, related resources, personnel needed to operate
Method and Design (continued) Consider Flowcharts (to demonstrate)
- How the parts interrelate- Where personnel will be needed (identify all)- What they are expected to do (specific tasks/job descriptions)
Identify facilities, transportation, support services, collaborations required
Method and Design (Continued) Identify Expected Measurable Results
(outputs)- What will be achieved via inputs & throughputs
Justify the Course of Action to be Taken Outline Program Design Highlight the Innovative Features of the
Proposal Use Appendices to Provide Additional
Pertinent Details (supplemental data and references, within specified page limit)
Basic Evaluative Criteria Relationship to Agency’s Mission Scientific, Technical, Community, Merit Likelihood to enhance research capabilities
and broaden research base in field Quality of PI and other personnel Impact of interaction with Agency’s
Stakeholder Quality of Management (Methods & Design)
Plan Cost Effectiveness
Product Evaluation Present an Evaluation Plan with your
Proposal
Address results to be attributed to the Project
Address extent to which the project will satisfy specific mission and goals of the Agency
Process Evaluation Addresses how the project will be conducted
Should be consistent with the stated plan of action
Address how you will measure effectiveness of the various activities within the plan
Evaluation Can be determined by the Agency Sometimes Proposed by the PI
Internal Staff (agency) External Experts Evaluation Teams Firm (contracted)
28
Importance of Evaluating Performance Understand the evaluation criteria Treat the evaluation criteria as
requirements Write to the criteria in your text HBCU/MIs are expected to compete Competition is getting bigger and more
aggressive!
Sustainability: Future Funding Address long term project planning Describe the plan for continuation beyond the
grant period Address equipment maintenance, if applicable Address continuation of services to
constituents
Basic Components
Budget Narrative
The first place a funder looks after the cover sheet and executive summary is the budget narrative. The following are the basic steps for completing a budget narrative: Review the program goals and
objectives. Estimate the resources needed to obtain
these goals.
Basic Components Determine other necessary costs. Explain any budget controls in place.
Depending on the individuals funder’s instructions, the budget narrative may also include an overview of additional support (fundraising, community support, etc).
Budget Preparation Grant income Institutional commitments In-kind contributions Corporate partners Include inflationary measures Justify all expenses
Budget Preparation: Vulnerable Areas Utilities Rental of buildings & equipment Salary increases Food Cellular phones Insurance Transportation
Budget Preparation: Tips Consistent with the proposal narrative Salaries consistent with institutional salaries New staff will need space & equipment Equipment purchases should be the type
allowed by the granting agency IDC (Indirect Direct Cost) rate should be clearly
specified determined by an approved agency Matching funds should be as specified – cash,
in-kind, corporate
35
Characteristics of a Good PI Scheduler Motivator Resourceful Manager Technical/subject matter expert Excellent writer Salesperson
36
Characteristics of Losing Proposals Failure to understand what the agency
or customer’s requirements are Failure to address each aspect of the
RFP/BAA Poorly written proposals Non-persuasive proposals Failure to apply best practices, proven
principles and techniques Making points that are not verifiable or
quantifiable
37
How to Lose Depend on blind luck, “wait for your
ship to come in” Wait on someone to contact you Start writing the proposal 3 days before
it is due Do not get to know the program,
manager, or customer Poor proofreading skills
38
Resources Available to You American Association of Grant
Professionals Society for Technical Communication American Philosophical Society National Science Foundation (NSF) National Endowment for the Humanities Federal and State Agency Web Sites Technical Assistance Training
Conferences
39
Internal Processes, Policies, Information Intent to submit Proposal review and certification Agency distribution Supplemental information Rates
IDC Supplemental Pay Adjunct Pay Consultancy Pay Rates
41
Non-Disclosure Agreement Used for collaborative efforts Contractors will require Subcontractors will require HBCU/MIs should require
Reminders Develop and Maintain Contacts Know Your Capabilities Understand the Solicitation Plan before you begin to Write Use Internal and External Review
Teams Develop Good Internal Processes –
Work Together
Writing Process
The following are the basic steps for the writing process of a grant proposal. Carefully read all instructions Brainstorm ideas. Gather all materials: background
information, documentation, research, current facts and statistics about the population, etc.
Writing Process Contact the funder: ask any
questions, review deadlines and expectations, and notify them of the pending proposal.
Create an outline of the proposal, followed by a first daft.
Edit the draft for content. Ask: Is everything included? Does the proposal address the funder’s stated concerns? Changes should then be incorporated into a second draft.
Writing Process Proofread the second draft, and have
others proofread it as well. Complete a final draft. Double-check
that format is consistent with the funder’s instructions and that all questions have been answered.
Basic Components
Case for Support
The main purpose of the case for support is to demonstrate the following two objectives: How the program addresses a need in a
unique manner using appropriate logic and outcomes.
What the impact of the funds will be on the program, agency, or broader community.
Basic Components
The case for support consists of the following two objectives: The organization’s mission and vision. The values and principles that guide the
organization’s work. A connection with the interests of the
donors. A conveyed sense of urgency. An emotionally motivating, yet concrete
and logical argument.
Define Your Project Clarify the purpose of your project and
write a mission statement. Define the scope of work to focus your
funding search. Determine the broad project goals, then
identify the specific objectives that define how you will focus the work to accomplish those goals.
Contact The Funders
Think of the funders as a resource.
Identify a project officer who will address your questions.
Some funders offer technical assistance, others do not. Ask for technical assistance, including a review of proposal drafts.
Inquire about how proposals are reviewed and how decisions are made.
Contact The Funders
Inquire about budgetary requirements and preferences. Are matching funds required? Is in-kind acceptable as a portion of applicants’ share? What may be counted as in-kind, and how might it be applied? Learn about payment processes, including cash flow.
Remember, the contacts you make may prove invaluable, even if not for now.
Acquire Proposal Guidelines
Guidelines usually tell you about:
Submission deadlines Eligibility Proposal format: award levels, margins,
spacing, evaluation process and restrictions on the number criteria of pages, etc.
Acquire Proposal Guidelines Review timetables Budgets Funding goals and priorities Award levels Evaluation process and criteria