Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial...

47
Functional neuroimaging Imaging brain function in real time (not just the structure of the brain).

Transcript of Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial...

Page 1: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Functional neuroimaging

Imaging brain function in real time (not just thestructure of the brain).

Page 2: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

The brain is bloody & electric Blood

increase in neuronal activity increase in metabolic demand forglucose and oxygen increase in cerebral blood flow (CBF) to theactive region

Electricity the brain works because neurons communicate with each other and

they do this by sending out tiny electrical impulses

Blood is an indirect, slow (because blood flows slowly), measure ofneural activity.

Electricity is a direct measure of neural activity

Dendrites

Nucleus

Cell body

Axon

Synapse

Page 3: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Non-invasiverecording fromhuman brain(Functionalbrain imaging)

Positron emissiontomography (PET)

Functional magneticresonance imaging (fMRI)

Electro-encephalography(EEG)

Magneto-encephalography(MEG)

Excellent spatialresolution (~1-2mm)Poor temporalresolution (~1sec)

Poor spatialresolution (esp. EEG)Excellent temporalresolution (<1msec)

Hemodynamictechniques

Electro-magnetictechniques

Page 4: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Experimental designs forhemodynamic techniques

Page 5: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

PET

Page 6: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

PET (Positron Emission Tomography)

Radioactive labeling of some compound thatis familiar to the body (such as glucose orwater).

The radioactive material is administered to thesubject.

PET images the electromagnetic radiationinduced by the decay of the PETradioisotopes. The chosen radioactive material must have a short

half-life (must decay quickly).

PET radioisotopes emit a positron (a positively charged electron) in theprocess of decay. When this positron collides with an electron, the 2 particlesannihilate each other, and produce 2 photons traveling in opposite directions.This induces electromagnetic radiation which is what can be detectedexternally and is used to measure both the quantity and the location of thepositron emitter.

Page 7: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

PET (Positron Emission Tomography)

Dependent measure: regional CerebralBlood Flow (rCBF).

Spatial resolution about 4mm throughoutthe brain.

Temporal resolution very bad (~30-40sec). Randomization is impossible (trials

cannot be distinguished from eachother).

Blocked design is necessary.

Page 8: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

PET scanner

Page 9: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

PET pros and cons

PRO Very good spatial resolution

CONs Basically no temporal resolution Invasive.

These days it’s hard to get human subjects approval forPET studies, given that noninvasive alternatives exist:fMRI (based on MRI).

Page 10: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI)and functional MRI

Page 11: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Basics of MRIOur bodies are mostly water and have a high concentration of hydrogen nuclei.

1. The nuclei of hydrogenatoms (called protons)normally pointrandomly in differentdirections.

1.

Page 12: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Basics of MRIOur bodies are mostly water and have a high concentration of hydrogen nuclei.

1.2. However, when exposedto a strong static magneticfield, the nuclei line up inparallel formation, likerows of tiny magnets. Inan MRI set-up, a strongexternal static magneticfield is applied across thebrain in order to line upthe hydrogen nuclei. (Thisfield can be up to 80 000times stronger than theearth’s magnetic field.)

2.

Page 13: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Basics of MRIOur bodies are mostly water and have a high concentration of hydrogen nuclei.

1.3. Then this parallelformation, calledequilibrium, isdisturbed by sendingout radio waves fromthe MRI machine

2.

3.

Page 14: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Basics of MRIOur bodies are mostly water and have a high concentration of hydrogen nuclei.

1. 2.

3.

4. As the hydrogen nucleifall back into alignment,they produce a detectableradio signal. MRI signaldecay rates (T2s) aredifferent for differentbiological tissues. Forexample, tissues thatcontain little or nohydrogen (such as bone)appear black. Those thatcontain large amounts ofhydrogen (such as thebrain) produce a brightimage.

4.

Page 15: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Basics of MRI

Page 16: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Functional MRI (fMRI)

MR has the capability to measure parametersrelated to several neural physiological functions,including: changes in various metabolic byproducts

blood flow

blood volume

blood oxygenation

Page 17: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Functional MRI (fMRI)

Blood Oxygenation Level Dependent (BOLD)signal Blood is more oxygenated in an activated region of

the brain than in a nonactivated region.

Oxyhemoglobin and deoxyhemoglobin differ in theirmagnetic susceptibility: Deoxy Hb has a highermagnetization decay rate than does oxy Hb.

Page 18: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Functional MRI (fMRI) No radioactive tracers are needed. Spatial resolution: 3-6mm (in most applications). Temporal resolution: in the order of seconds.

Fast enough to distinguish between trials (i.e. event-related designsand randomization are possible)

Not fast enough to distinguish between the activation patternsassociated with different stages of stimulus processing.

Hemodynamic lag(3-6 seconds):a: short stimulusb. rise, 6-9 secc. return to baseline, 8-20secd. undershoot

Page 19: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

The subtraction method

Page 20: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Electromagnetism:Electroencephalography (EEG) and

Magnetoencephalography (MEG)

Page 21: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Electromagnetism

Millisecond temporal resolution. Neurons communicate with each other thousands of times

per second by sending each other tiny electrical impulses Populations of neurons are connected into networks When networks fire in synchrony, the dynamics of the

electric activity can be detected and recorded outside theskull.

Page 22: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Main source of the signal: Post-synaptic current flowalong the dendrites of (pyramidal) nerve cells

Page 23: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

An electric current creates a magnetic field around it.

The right-hand rule: When the thumb of the right hand ispointing in the direction of the current, the fingers of the righthand curl in the direction of the magnetic field

Page 24: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Electromagnetism

EEGEEGMEGMEG

EEG (electroencephalography): electric potentials MEG (magnetoencephalography): magnetic fields

Page 25: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Source: http://www.allgpsy.unizh.ch/graduate/mat/180102/Lecture1.pdf

EEG electrodes on the scalp

MEG sensors outside the head,in a tank containing liquidhelium to enhancesuperconductivity

Page 26: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Source: http://www.allgpsy.unizh.ch/graduate/mat/180102/Lecture1.pdf

MEG signal is dominated bycurrents oriented tangential tothe skull.

Page 27: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Source: http://www.allgpsy.unizh.ch/graduate/mat/180102/Lecture1.pdf

Currents oriented perfectly radial tothe skull are missed in MEG. Butthere is very little signal that is soperfectly radial.

EEG picks up tangentiallyand radially orientedcurrents equally.

Page 28: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass
Page 29: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

EEGEEGMEGMEG

Page 30: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

http://neurocog.psy.tufts.edu/images/ERP_technique.gif

Page 31: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

http://neurocog.psy.tufts.edu/images/ERP_technique.gif

Page 32: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Averaging

http://neurocog.psy.tufts.edu/images/ERP_averaging.gif

Page 33: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

http://neurocog.psy.tufts.edu/images/ERP_components.gif

Labelling of ERP components(warning: a bit confusing)

P or N: whether thecomponent is negative orpositive going.

Number after the letter:indicates the approximatepeak latency of thecomponents. 1, 2, 3, etc.are short for 100ms,200ms, 300ms and soforth.

Traditionally, negative isplotted up and positivedown.

Page 34: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Temporal and spatial resolution of EEG

Millisecond temporal resolution. Localization of neural generators complicated (and

usually not done). Different tissues and the skull differ in their conductivity:

Electric potentials do not pass through these structuresundistorted.

Localization requires realistic head models.

Page 35: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

MEG

EEGEEGMEGMEG

Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters forcortex, worse for deeper sources)

Magnetic fields pass through skull and various tissues undistorted. Distribution of the magnetic field around the head tells you a lot

about the underlying current generators.

Page 36: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

The magneticfields generatedby neural activityare 100 milliontimes smallerthan the earth'smagnetic fieldand 1 milliontimes smallerthan themagnetic fieldsproduced in anurbanenvironment. 

Page 37: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

How to capture the tiny signal

Superconductive sensors Reference channels Magnetically shielded room

Page 38: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass
Page 39: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Reference channels

Placed somewhereclose to the head but farenough to not measureany brain activity. Signalmeasured by thereference channelsubtracted from the rawdata usually onlineduring acquisition.

Page 40: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Magnetically shielded room (MSR)

Page 41: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Magnetically shielded room (MSR)

Page 42: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Source: http://www.allgpsy.unizh.ch/graduate/mat/180102/Lecture1.pdf

Page 43: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

An averaged response to a 1kHz tone Magnetic field at 110ms= auditory M100

Page 44: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

Labelling of MEG response components

M50, M100, M250, etcM50, M100, M250, etc…… M = magneticM = magnetic Like in Like in ERPsERPs, the number refers to the, the number refers to the

approximate peak latency of the componentsapproximate peak latency of the components

Page 45: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

MEG components elicited by visual words

M100100-150ms

M170150-200ms

M250200-300ms

M350300-400ms

Averaged response tovisual words

100 170 250 350

We can analyze:

- either the sensor data (on the left)

- or the activity of the currents underlying the magneticfields. The locations and orientations of these currents haveto be modeled on the basis of the magnetic fielddistribution.

- Estimating the current source that generates a givenmagnetic field is called the inverse problem

Page 46: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

The single dipole modelThe single dipole model

A discrete source model. Assumes that activity is generated not by a patch ofcortex, but by point source. A good way to reduce the spatial dimensionality ofthe data. Each dipole acts as a spatial filter on the data.

Page 47: Functional neuroimaging - NYU Psychology · MEG MEG EEG Main advantage over EEG: better spatial resolution (millimeters for cortex, worse for deeper sources) Magnetic fields pass

MEG components elicited by visual wordsDipole models

M100 M170 M250 M350100-150ms 150-200ms 200-300ms 300-400ms

Averaged response tovisual words

100 170 250 350