FUEL CELLS FOR MATERIAL HANDLING SYSTEMS - · PDF file23.03.2016 · FOR MATERIAL...
Transcript of FUEL CELLS FOR MATERIAL HANDLING SYSTEMS - · PDF file23.03.2016 · FOR MATERIAL...
Copyright 2016 by Plug Power Inc.
FUEL CELLSFOR MATERIAL HANDLING SYSTEMSFernando Corral
VP Sales, Western Region
MARCH 23, 2016
WHAT IS A FUEL CELL?
FUEL CELL: ELECTROCHEMICAL DEVICE
• Combines hydrogen and oxygen to produce electricity
• Water and heat as its by-products
OPERATES LIKE A FULLY-CHARGED BATTERY
• Does not run down or require recharging
RUN TIME IS DETERMINED BY QUANTITY OF FUEL STORAGE (LIKE A GENERATOR)
O2
H2
H2O
H+
E
PROTON EXCHANGE
MEMBRANE
CATALYST CATALYST
STATE OF THE INDUSTRY
APPLICATIONS USED COMMERCIALLY TODAY:
• Mobile, stationary and transport categories
FUTURE INDUSTRY DEVELOPMENT PENDING:
• Development of viable fueling options critical for growth
• Industry corporations taking charge in some markets
Source: E4Tech Fuel Cell Industry Review 2015
This presentation focuses on one segment: material handling/motive
MATERIAL HANDLING FACILITIES
Worldwide lift truck market
Region Orders Shipments
2011 2013 % Increase 2011 2012 % Increase
Europe (53 countries/territories) 330,616 310,503 -6.08% 324,073 317,726 -1.96%
Americas (55 countries/territories) 224,733 229,746 2.23% 207,485 220,069 6.07%
Asia (43 countries/territories) 379,969 362,911 -4.42% 373,697 363,816 -2.64%
Africa (56 countries/territories 17,587 20,185 14.77% 17,194 19,816 15.25%
Oceania (29 countries/territories) 21,677 21,060 -2.85% 19,359 22,297 15.18%
Total (263 countries/territories) 974,582 944,405 -3.10% 941,808 943,724 0.20%
Source: These figures are provided by the World Industrial Truck Statistics (WITS) organization.
MATERIAL HANDLING FACILITIES
~500,000 ELECTRIC FORKLIFTS AND PALLET JACKS SOLD ANNUALLY, WORLDWIDE
MULTIPLE BATTERIES REQUIRED PER UNIT
• Large battery charging rooms
BATTERY RUNTIME IS 6 TO 8 HOURS
• Batteries changed 2 to 3 times per day
Space-consuming battery room
CHALLENGES WITH STATUS QUO BATTERY USE
Space Needed to Change Batteries
• Average battery room size for large Distribution Centers and Mfg. Plants – 5,000 sq. ft.
Impacts on Productivity
• Battery change-out: 12-15 minutes per shift per lift truck
• As a lead acid battery discharges and voltage drops – MHE performance is reduced
• Performance decline up to 20% in cold storage
Cost
• 2 to 3 batteries per forklift
• Replacement every 3 to 5 years
• Battery rooms = $25 to $40 per sq. ft.
• $100k to $200k for specialized battery changing equipment
• Costly and dedicated personnel to change batteries
Safety
• 1,000 to 5,000 lbs. batteries require specialized equipment for change
• PPE & ventilation required for acid spills and gases released during charging
VALUE PROPOSITION FOR HYDROGEN AND FUEL CELLS
More Commercial Space
• Compact fueling stations replace large battery charging rooms
• ~7% of the distribution center is recovered to set up inventory and
revenue-generating operations
• Reduced electricity need & demand charges
Increased Productivity & Labor Savings
• 2-5 minutes to refuel a hydrogen fuel cell
• Constant voltage = no decrease in performance
• Full power in cold storage
• Operators refuel fuel cells – labor savings
Lower Operational Costs
• Eliminates the need to change, charge and manage batteries
Safety
• Fuel cell remains in truck at all times
• No acid or gas mitigation systems required
Sustainability
• Greenhouse gas (GHG) savings = Reduce carbon footprint by up to
80%
• No emissions
SPACE REDEPLOYMENT
BATTERY ROOM USED AS PALLET SPACE:
Converted to revenue generating
sq. ft.
• Assume: 60ft. X 85ft. battery
room
• Conservative calculation shows:
312 pallet positions
60
FT
85 FT
3 VERTICAL
POSITIONS
9 FT
11 FT11 FT11 FT
9 FT9 FT
11 FT
5 FT5 FT
81 FT
Pallet #s
# of Rows Pallet Positions / Row Total Pallets # of Vertical Bays Total $ / Pallet Position Total
8 13 104 3 312 750.00$ 234,000.00$
Additional Racking ($85/pallet) 85.00$ 26,520.00$
Total 207,480.00$
MOST COMMON HYDROGENREFUELING PROCESS
Liquid H2
• Transportation and storage
Gaseous H2
• Refueling process
H2 flows when all refueling
protocol checks passed
No H2 vented or released inside
the building during refill or
operation
Fill Pressure: 350 Bar at 15ºC
Gaseous HydrogenLiquid HydrogenPhase
Change
HYDROGEN INDOOR REFUELING
Refueling stations are designed to meet the following codes
• NFPA 2 [Hydrogen Technology Code]
• SAEJ2601 [Hydrogen Fueling Protocol]
• CGA H-5 [Installation Standards for Bulk Hydrogen Systems]
• ASME B31:12 [Hydrogen Piping]
Mandatory Safety Measures are built in each station
• Hydrogen Detection [Triggers at 25% LEL of H2]
• 15 feet radius electrical hazardous location (Class 1 Zone 2)
• Fire Detection
• Fire Extinguisher and Alarm Pull Station
• Fueling Protocol to identify leak check
• Emergency stops present to stop H2 flow during emergency
ONSITE HYDROGEN SUPPLY - LIQUID
ONSITE HYDROGEN SUPPLY –OTHER OPTIONS
Steam Methane Reforming
• Fuel processor reacts steam with natural gas to
extract the hydrogen molecule
• Most common method of providing bulk hydrogen
Electrolyzers
• Uses electricity to split the hydrogen molecule from
water
• Delivers hydrogen to the fuel cell refueling stations
• Essentially a “reverse fuel cell”
VALUE PROPOSITION FOR HYDROGEN AND FUEL CELLS
More Commercial Space
• Compact fueling stations replace large battery charging rooms
• ~7% of the distribution center is recovered to set up inventory and
revenue-generating operations
• Reduced electricity need & demand charges
Increased Productivity & Labor Savings
• 2-5 minutes to refuel a hydrogen fuel cell
• Constant voltage = no decrease in performance
• Full power in cold storage
• Operators refuel fuel cells – labor savings
Lower Operational Costs
• Eliminates the need to change, charge and manage batteries
Safety
• Fuel cell remains in truck at all times
• No acid or gas mitigation systems required
Sustainability
• Greenhouse gas (GHG) savings = Reduce carbon footprint by up to
80%
• No emissions
PRODUCTIVITY SAVINGS
Savings - Operator Labor
Operator Labor Rate (Loaded Rate) $ / hr $ 50.00 $ 50.00 $ 50.00
Sit Down Counter Balance Pallet Jacks Reach
Truck Count 30 30 6
Hours of Operation Per Day 24 24 24
Battery Solution
Total Changes per Day # / day 2.5 1.5 2
Travel to Battery Room minutes 4 4 4
Time to Change Battery minutes 4 4 4
Travel Back to Work Area minutes 4 4 4
Total Time Per Battery Change minutes 12 12 12
Total Minutes Per Day - Fleet minutes 900 540 144
Total Hrs Per Day Due To Changing - Fleet Hrs15 9 2.4
Hydrogen Solution
Hydrogen Fuelings per Day # / day 1.45 0.16 1.35
Travel to Dispenser minutes 0 0 0
Time to Fuel (includes 1 min travel time) minutes3 3 3
Travel Back to Work Area minutes 0 0 0
Total Time Per Refueling 3 3 3
Total Time Refueling Per Day Per Truck minutes4.35 0.48 4.05
Total Minutes Per Day - Fleet minutes 130.50 14.40 24.30
Total Hrs Per Day - Fleet hours 2.18 0.24 0.41
Hourly Savings Per Day hours 12.83 8.76 2.00
Annual Hourly Savings (Batt - FC) hours 4681.13 3197.40 728.18
Annual Cost Savings $ $234,056.25 $159,870.00 $36,408.75
Total $430,335
VALUE PROPOSITION FOR HYDROGEN AND FUEL CELLS
More Commercial Space
• Compact fueling stations replace large battery charging rooms
• ~7% of the distribution center is recovered to set up inventory and
revenue-generating operations
• Reduced electricity need & demand charges
Increased Productivity & Labor Savings
• 2-5 minutes to refuel a hydrogen fuel cell
• Constant voltage = no decrease in performance
• Full power in cold storage
• Operators refuel fuel cells – labor savings
Lower Operational Costs
• Eliminates the need to change, charge and manage batteries
Safety
• Fuel cell remains in truck at all times
• No acid or gas mitigation systems required
Sustainability
• Greenhouse gas (GHG) savings = Reduce carbon footprint by up to
80%
• No emissions
HEALTH AND SAFETY BENEFITS
Safety
InfluencersFuel Cells Lead-Acid
Hazardous liquids
controls
No hazardous materials;
Eliminates chance of
spills
Sulfuric acid spills
Acid control
methods
No control methods
requiredRequire spill kits
Ventilation No ventilation requiredVentilation required in
charging room
Fueling/Charging
location
Flexible H2 dispensers
put in high traffic areas
Fixed installation generally
out of the way
Worker physical
safety
No change outs reduce
worker injuries
Potential for crushed fingers
and toes while changing
batteries
ENVIRONMENTAL VALUE: REDUCING CARBON FOOTPRINT
7512 2810 2010 6990
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
LPG Truck Emissions Grid Charging Fuel Cell Emissions -Onsite Reforming
Fuel Cell Emissions -Liquid Hydrogen
To
ns o
f C
O2 P
rod
uced
per
Year
Greenhouse Gas EmissionsLPG / Grid / Reforming / Liquid H2
Based on an actual 260 truck fleet (typical mix)
75% Reduction of
Grid Charging
90% Reduction over
LPG
Carbon Emissions Reduction:
90% compared to LPG. 75% compared to grid charging.
H2 & FUEL CELL SUCCESS IN MATERIAL HANDLING
More than 10,000 fuel cells deployed
More than 1.7M operating hours
More than 1,000,000 hydrogen fills
Whole Foods Market is
committed to healthy food
and a healthy planet. We are
fulfilling that commitment by
choosing to use greener
technology in our own
operations that will improve
our productivity and lower
our long-term costs.
— Joe Strong, Whole Foods
WHY CUSTOMERS CHOOSE FUEL CELLS
Hydrogen fuel cells not only
provide greater productivity
and lower operating costs,
but will be an important
component of a clean
energy future.
— Tom Dziki, UNFI
We would have trouble with
the performance of the jacks
with the batteries wearing
down because of the cold.
Now with hydrogen there is
just no issue with regards to
temperature.
— Cherie Shipe, Wegmans
One of the main advantages
of this project is that it uses
very little electricity. The
hydrogen is the only source
of power for the fuel cells
and this project actually
avoids 1.8 million kilowatt
hours per year of electricity
consumption to charge
batteries.
— Briggs Hamilton, BMW
WHY CUSTOMERS CHOOSE FUEL CELLS
With these fuel cell material
handling units, we will be
able to maintain
productivity, decrease
operating costs and lower
greenhouse gas emissions
by 30%.— Lauren Steele, Coca Cola
Consolidated
From a financial standpoint,
when we started doing the
analysis, there is going to be
cost savings involved. So if we
can do something that is less
expensive, something that is
good for the environment, good
for our employees, it’s pretty
obvious what the choice is. We
will be using these jacks for the
next 6-10 years.— Wegmans
I think the biggest thing is that
people are just amazed at
how easy it is. It’s very quick
and easy. And by the end of
the day, even if you have one
bar left on the hydrogen tank
as far as being empty or full,
you lose no power. It’s
fantastic.— Cherie Shipe, Wegmans
We are pleased with the
performance of the hydrogen
fuel cells that we have been
operating and are excited to
expand our program with
Plug Power.— Jeff Smith, Walmart
Logistics
Corporate Headquarters
968 Albany Shaker Road, Latham, NY 12110
West Coast
15913 E. Euclid Avenue, Spokane, WA 99216
plugpower.com