Francisco Jose Alvarez Troncoso, A057 287 860 (BIA Jan. 6, 2011)

7/27/2019 Francisco Jose Alvarez Troncoso, A057 287 860 (BIA Jan. 6, 2011)

1/6a u

EDUARDO A MASFERRER, SQUIRMASFERRER & ASSOCIATES P.C6 BEACON STREET SITE 815BOSTON MA 02108

US. Deatmet f ustce

Executive Oce r Iigraon Revew

Board ofImmigration ppealsOce ofthe Cerk

5107 Leesburg Pike, Ste 2000Fal Chrc Vgna 2204

HS/ICE Oice of Chef Counsel - BOSP Box 8728Boston MA 02114

Name: ALVAREZ TRONCOSO FRNCISCO A057287860

Date of ths notce 1/6/2011

ncosed s a copy of the Board's decso and order n the above-ereced case.

Enclosure

Pel Members:Pauey, Roge

Sicerey

Dona CarCe Cerk

z. .M ...m.e.V Cite as: Francisco Jose Alvarez Troncoso, A057 287 860 (BIA Jan. 6, 2011)

For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished


2/6

AVAREZ TRONCOSO FRANCISCO20 BRADSTON STREEA057 287860BOSTON MA 02118

US. Deamet f usce

Excutv Oc Imaon Rw

Board ofImmiaion ppealsOce ofhe Cek

5107 eesbug Pi Suite2000

Fa Chu gna 22041

HS/CE Oce of Chef Counsel BOSPO. Box 8728Boston, MA 02114

Name AVAREZ TRONCOSO FRANCISCO A057287860

Date of ths notce 1/6/2011

Enclosed is a copy of the Board's decision in the above-referenced case. Ths copy is beingprovded to you as a cotesy Yor attorney or representatve has been served wth thisdecison prsan to 8 1292.5(a) If the atached decison orders that yo be removedfro the United States or airs an migraion Jdges decsion orderng tha yo beremoved, any peon for review of he atached decsion mst be fled wth and receved by the

aproriae cot of appeals withn days of the date of he decision

Encosu

Panl MmbsPauly Rog

X Sv 1

D C

Donna CaC Ck

..n. A 8Cite as: Francisco Jose Alvarez Troncoso, A057 287 860 (BIA Jan. 6, 2011)


3/6

J atmet ce

'Executive Oce r Immgraon Reew

Decson of e Board ommaon Appeals

Fas Chrc, Virginia 1

Fe 05 28 860 - Boston M Date: JAN 0 6 21 e: NCSCO OSE ALVAREZ ONCOSO aka. ancsco Avaez Toncoso

a..a Ton Motaa a.k.a Fancco Toncoso

OVAL PROCEDG

APP AND OION

ON BA OF RESPONDENT: dado A Masfee Esqie

CAE

otice Sec 23a))B)), &N Act [8 US.C. 22a)2)B))] -Convicte of contolle bstance volaton

APPAON: emand, temnaton

e espondent a natve d citizen of the Domncan Repblc who wa admed to theUnte States as an mmiant on o abot Agst 30, 2005, ed a tme appeal of an mmgatonJge s Septembe 28, 010 decion sstanng the cages of eovab aganst hi; denngs eest a contnace we awaitng acton om te Massacses state cots on s moton a nw a; a odeng his emova to the Domcan Rebc We the eponents appealwas ndng bee the Boad the eponent le a moton to eopen an emand i matte to teation Co e poceedng based on new, mateia nd pevosl navaabeevdece. The eponents eqest s pemied on the cam that te convcton wch s thebasis the onds of emova ha been vacated Speccall, he espondent as peentedevdece hat on Novembe 23, 2010, the ild Ditict Co d, Mssachse, atehe eonent's oton to Wthdaw Gilt Pea and Oe a New a We obsee that theesondents motion was pope seed on the Depatment of Homelnd Secy "DS), anthe DS a et h led no oppoton o othe esponse to ths moton, an the oton eemeoposed See 8 CF 003 2g)3 ).

Te Boad nMatter of Pickrng

23 I&N Dec. 62 BA 2003),rev'd on other ounds

Pckring . Goales 465 .3d 263 6 C 2006), hed that if a cot vacates a convction bsedpon a pocea o sbstantve dect n te ndelng poceedngs thee s no onge a convcton mmiaon poe. oweve aen emains convicte f a emovabe oene when epedcate convcton vacated ml eabilttive poses o to ad e aen n avodingadvee gaton coneqences and not becase of n pocea o sbtantve dect in theoignal convicto d at 624 see also Saleh v Goales, 495 3d 25 2d C. 200) oinngand ctng to the decons of the vaos cicits n sppot of the Boads decson n Pickrng hat

e ecod eec tat the epondent a been convcted on Jne 8, 2006, the oene ofDg oesson Cass B to wt Cocane, in volaton of.

G C 94C, 34 (x 3).

J Q @ Cite as: Francisco Jose Alvarez Troncoso, A057 287 860 (BIA Jan. 6, 2011)


4/6

0 27 860

if a r vacates an aliens criminal conviction soley on the basis of immigraon hardships orrehaiaion, raher th on he basis of a substantive or procedural dect in the derlying criminalprocdings he conviction is no eliminated r immigration puposes and will continue to seeas a valid cal predicate r a charge of removabiiy despite is vacatu); see lso

of Chavez-Mtinez 24 & Dec. 272 (BIA 2007) (in order r immigration consequenceso b eliminated, alien's convicion cannot be vacated soely r immigraion puoses)

I he matter bere us, however, i is clear ha he cminal cout judge's ling, ganing herespdents oion o Wihdraw Guil Plea and Order a ew Trial was based on a procedural adsubsttive dec in he plea enered by the responden a his ciminal ial Specically, therespdent maintains that he was provided ineecive assisance of counse ad that his plea wasno owingly, voluntay or ineligently made in vioaion of stae and federa due process SeeHenson v Mogan 426 US 637, 6444 (1976) Commonwelh v Fose 368 ass 100 02(197) Therere, the assachuses criminal cou's acton was premised upon wha it perceivedo be a procedural dec in the nderying proceedings rather han some rm of posconvicion

reie See Rumiez v Gonzles 46 3d 3, 343 (I 51 Cir 2006) (a vacated conviction is no ongera cviction wihin he meaning of the immigraion laws only "if a court wih urisdicion vacateshe onviction based on a defec in he nderlying crmina proceedings.) Heeniio v INS208 3d 299 (1 Cir 2000)

Te question here is wheher here is now a convicion r a "controed substance vioaionor a conviction rendeing the respondent no only removable but also precluding his eligibiliy rrelief or whether he proceedings should be erminaed Consequently in view of the regoing, therespndens moion will be graned, and he record wil be remanded Immigration Cou rrhr proceedings, n order to enable he Immigraion Judge o consider he new evidence oeredby te responden relaing o his removabiliy under section 237(a)(2)(B)(i) of the Act

8 USC 227(a)(2)(B)(i) and to deermine whether he respondent can now esablish hiseigibility r reief om removal, or whether he proceedings shoud be terminaed

Accordingly the record wl be remanded o he mmigation Cou r her proceedingsconsisen with he regoing opinion and the enty of a new decision

ORR The record is remanded to the Immigraion Court r her proceedings consistentwih this opinion, and the ent of a new decision

OR THE BOAR '"

& ,( w i ,. J:oc< .v.vu&t Jhd.. v.. v.vvv 1 Cite as: Francisco Jose Alvarez Troncoso, A057 287 860 (BIA Jan. 6, 2011)


5/6

JAN-11-2011 15:27 US IMMGRATON CT BTON

TTE IMITON COJFK $X , M 3

BOSN, 2

61564495

B O OF

AEZ OO PCO.

: A057-2886

O

Tis a maum of the C' Decison and ordes entred n---- Thi! mmr ia !oley f thcnveninc of h prs. T r F, d Order o on in ta c ) Bth p

l Wivcd ssUnc of a o ol n h =espqndt rd EV m the Oic ;ats o-',..f i ) n ia . ( Rpndet's lc o VLUY EP wao DI nd

P.61

espnen B mvd , n halve -,R' alic for O w G ul

, un pn9 u dpe n mo-$- o DHS wthin iv unss y om a f ir, w l d v ,.er Rpod sal prn wiehn

m h o h Or lcsEa ra dumnt fr ouy pe.

J Rndn1 r Y a ( gated n( ) _wtn w jd { ) j C dr h I sn 27 5) > Rpod kwgy d X' l cnRnn plicai o WHOG of rmol 4 3 O ( ) g ( ) dnd whd b

ju

nd'S on frHL

m e h Tovo w g ( ) w pjiRdn in o DEFR o d rCvnn d } dn w jdi

ndnt LON m d i 0 b" ", ( ) 40(a 20 (l) 2

.f IA ) d w w prejd.If r wa r h H e l :prr docesa o g f o dn > 1 < > u N u I "240A().nd o WR e t w ( g ( -d : h ( Th on" md by: sn 6 o h pon'D p Dnt u we md.Rsonde ' pli fo t d n _____f N ( ) w g C dd ( } w d It g rdr s od ny gv Ordr

S R: 88 P VZ OOO JO

Rndn ot w CIE uun . th A cn 26

3 2 l


6/6

'

..

JAN-112011 16:27 US IMMGRATON C BSON 754495 . ees

O r

':U. .. "

-

[. -Rendnt' s motion THDR his

Francisco Jose Alvarez Troncoso, A057 287 860 (BIA Jan. 6, 2011)

Documents

Transcript of Francisco Jose Alvarez Troncoso, A057 287 860 (BIA Jan. 6, 2011)