fOCY~APCTBA BOCTOl.JHOH EBPOTihi -...
Transcript of fOCY~APCTBA BOCTOl.JHOH EBPOTihi -...
POCCI1HCKASI AKA,r::(EMI1SI HAYK HHCfHTYT POCCI1MCKOI1: l1CfOPI1I1
~PEBHEfiiiiiiE fOCY~APCTBA
BOCTOl.JHOH EBPOTihi MA TEPHAJibi l111CCJIEJ];OBAHHH
· 1992-1993 rop;hi
MOCKBA HAYKA 1995
EEK 63.3(2)2 )]}3
KHuza U30a!la npu cpuHallCOBOU noooepJICKe PoccuucKow cjJoHoa cjJyHoaM.eHmfl.llbllbLX ucCJzeooaaHwt (npoeKm 93-06-10324)
0TOCTCTOCHHbiH pe)laKTOp
'IJieH-KoppecnoHACHT PAH A.n. HOBOCEJTbli,EB
PeAaKl\HOIIHall Konnemll:
'InCHbi-KOppecnon)leHTbi PAH
A.n. HOBOCEilbli,EB (oTaeTcTneHHbiii peAaKTop), 51. H. llJ,AnOB,
/IOKTOpa 11CTOp11'IeCKI1X nayK E.A. MEilbHHKOBA, H.C. '-111'-IYPOB,
Kall/111/laTbl 11CTOp11'1CCKI1X HayK r.B. rflA3biPJ.1J-IA (OTBCTCTBCIIHbll"l ceKpeTapb),
A.B. HA3APEHKO, A.B. nO,IJ,OCHHOB
PelleHJCHTbi:
'men-KoppecnonACHT AH TypKMenHcrana c.r. ArA,IJ,tKAHOB.
JIOKTOp IICTopw~ecKI1X uayK M.B. BHEHKOB
,Upeoneilmne rocyAapcTBa BoCTo~moi1 Eoponr.1. MaTepHaJlbi 11
,U73 HCCJleAOBaHHH. 1992-1993 rOAbi.- M.: HayKa, 1995.-219 c. ISBN 5-02-009784-5 O'IepcAHOI"I BbmycK C)f(CrD/IHI1Ka nocBstll\CH cnopnbiM npo6neMaM o6paJooanust ,!J,peaue
pyccKoro rocyAapcToa, o6cy)f(AaowiiMCll 11a lJTeHHstx naMliTH 'Ineua-KoppecnOII/ICHTa AH CCCP B.T. nawyTo. B ny6ni1KYCMbiX craTbstx nepecMaTPUBaioTcst Kap/llii·JanbHbiC oonpocbl o npeAnOCbinKax 11 nyTliX B03HHKHOBCHI1st rocyAapcroenHOCTII , o xapaKTepe 11 oco-6ctmOCTSIX paHII11X rocyAapCTBCIIHbiX o6pa30Balll11t y BOCTO'IHbiX cnaOstH.
,!J,Jlll IICTOpHKOB II WltpOKOrO Kpyra 'IIITaTenell, 11HTepecyiOLl\HXCSI OTC'ICCTBCIIIWJI IICTOpHCll.
0503020200-326 ( Jl ()42(02)_95 31-94-1 nonyro)lltC
EliK 63.3(2)2
ISBN 5-02-009784-5 © KoJlJleKTHB aoTopoo, 1995 © PoccHMCKaH aKaAeMiiH HayK, 1995
OT PE.IJ:KOJIJIEfl111
06pa30BaHHe )J;peBHepycCKOrO rocyAapCTBa rrpHHaAJie)KHT K TeM ~eHTpanh
llbiM MOMeHTaM OTe<reCTBeHHOH HCTOpHH, KOTOphle, orrpeAemiH Ha BeKa
CYAh6hi HapOAOB, HeH3MeHHO rrpHBJieKaJIH H rrpHBJieKaJOT BH11MaHHe KaK crre
I~HaJIHCTOB, TaK H umpoKoro Kpyra nJ06HTenei1 APeBHOCTei1. Hap»AY c cyry6o
Hay~IHhiM, 3Ta rrpo6neMa BCerAa 11Mena 11 06~eCTBeHHO-IlOJIHTH'leCKOe 3By<ra
H11e : He cnyqaf!Ho cTonhKO rrhwa 6hwo sno)KeHo B AByxcoTneTHHe AHCKyccl111
110 TaK Ha3hmaeMoMy HOpMaHHCKOMY sorrpocy. ,IJ;aneKoe rrpornnoe rrpHo6pe
Tano aKTyanhHOCTh B CBeTe C06hiTHH cerOAHHlliHero AHH H B CBOJO O<repeAh
BhiCBe~msano »BneHHH HaCTOH~ero. H rroToMy B Ka)KAYJO rrocneAyJO~YJO
1-fCTOpWieCKYJO ::moxy HayKa BHOBh H BHOBb B03Bpa~anaCh K ::naif, Ka3aJJOCh
6hi, BCeCTOpOHHe 11CCJJeAOBaHHOH TeMe, H~a H HaXOAH HOBble 11 MeTO
J~OJIOrWJeCKHe IlOAXOAhl, H HCCJJeAOBaTeJihCKHe acrreKThl, 11 MaTepHaJihl, Il03BO
JJHJO~He rrpeAJJO)KI1Th OTBe'JaJO~yJO HOBOMY ypOBHJO HayKI1 - a IlOA~IaC 11
KOHbJOHKType - HHTeprrpeTa~HJO Ha~JaJJhHhiX 3TaiTOB pa3BHTI1H BOCTO~IHO
CJJaBHHCKOrO 06~eCTBa.
06pa~eHI1e K KOMITJJeKcy rrpo6JJeM, CBH3aHHhiX C B03HHKHOBeHI1eM· 11 CTa
HOBJieHHeM pyccKOH rocyAapCTBeHHOCTH , cerOAHH rrpeACTaBJJHeTCH TeM 6oJJee
CCTeCTBCHHhiM H Ba)KHhiM, ~JeM rJJy6)Ke npHXOAHT OC03HaHHe TOrO, 'ITO
CJI0)KHBllll1eCH B OTe'IeCTBeHHOH HayKe 1930-1970-X rOAOB MeTOAOJJOrWieCKI1e
CXeMhl He HBJIHJOTCH eAHHCTBeHHO B03MO)KHhiMH H a6COJIJOTHO BepHhiMH.
Cy~ecTBYJOT 11 Tpe6yJOT TBOP'JeCKoro OCMhiCJJeHH» aJJhTepHaTHBHhJe 11CTO
puoco¢cKHe 11 CO~I10JJOrWJeCKI1e KOH~ell~1111 06~eCTBeHHOrO pa3BI1THH, BbiABH
HYThJe B OTe'JeCTBeHHOH 11 3apy6e)KH0H HCTOp110rpa¢1111 H rrpeAJJaraJO~He CBOH
perneHHH TeX )Ke BOilpOCOB. HaKOHe~, MeHHeTCH HhJHe H Harne C06CTBeHHOe
nOHHMaHHe Ba)KHeHlliHX 11CTOpH'IeCKI1X KaTerOp11H, B rrepsyJO O'IepeAh
rocyAapCTBa, KOTOpoe npHBhi'IHO paCCMaTpHBaeTCH JJI1lllh KaK KJJaCCOBhJH
CO~HaJihHO-IlOJIHTH'IeCKI1H 11HCTI1TYT C penpeCCHBHOH OCHOBHOH ¢YHK~I1eH, H
nOTOMY - COrJJaCHO 06~enp11HHTOH CXeMe - OHO B03HI1KaeT Jll1lllb BMeCTe C
YTBep)KAeHI1eM OAHOH 113 nepBbiX KnaccOBbiX o6~eCTBeHH0-3KOHOMH'IeCKHX
¢opMa~HH, pa6oBJJaAeJJh~IeCKOH 11Jilf ¢eoAaJJhHOH.
Ynpo<IHBrnrrecH B OTe~JeCTBeHHOH HayKe rrpeACTaBJJeHI1» o ¢opMupoBaHrrl1
y)Ke B IX-X BB. KnaccoBoro o6u~ecTsa 11 ¢eoAanhHoro rocyAapcTBa Ha PycH
11p11XOA11JIH B rrpOTHBOpe'IHe C AaHHhiMH HCTO'IHHKOB 11 llOTOMY e~e B KOH~e
1970-X rOAOB Bhi3BaJJH HHrHJJHCTWieCKYJO peaK~I1JO, Bblpa311BlliYJOCH B onpe
}\CJieHHll ,!J;peBHeH Pyc11 KaK naTp11apxaJJhHOrO AOKJJaCCOBOrO 11 - COOT
IleTCTBeHHO - AOrocyAapcTBeHHOro o6~eCTBa BnJJOTh AO XII-XIII BB. 0TKa3
1\pyroH 'IaCTH HCTOpHKOB OT OCMbiCJJeHI1H TeopeTH~IeCKI1X OCHOBaHU:H KOH
KpeTHO-HCTOpH'IeCKI1X 113hiCKaHI1H - HHaH, rraCCHBHa», ¢opMa OTp11~aHU»
3
AOrManP-IeCKIIX CXeM - CnOC06CTBOBaJI JIIIlllb He3piiMOCTII IIX npRCYTCTBIHI,
OnpeAeJISUI eCJIII He CaMII pellleHIIH, TO HanpaBJieHIIH nOIICKOB B pellleHIIII
BonpocoB COQIIaJibH0-3KOHOMII'IecKoro pa3BIITIIH ,IJ;peBHeif Pycii.
11MeHHO Il03TOMY ny6JIIIKyeMbiH TOM e)J(efOAHIIKa, KOTOpbiH nOAfOTOBJieH
no MaTepwanaM liTeHIIif naMHTH qJieHa-KoppecnOHAeHTa B.T. ITalllyTo B
1992 II 1993 rr., nOCBHUWHHbiX CnOpHbiM npo6JieMaM o6pa30BaHIIH ,IJ;peBHe
pycCKOrO rocyAapCTBa, IIMeeT QeJibiO He TOJlbKO II, MO)J(eT 6hiTb, He CTOJlbKO
npeACTaBIITb pe3yJibTaTbl KOHKpeTHbiX HCCJieAOBaHHH, HO B nepByiO oqepeAb
npiiBJie'lb BHIIMaHIIe K 6onee 06IQIIM, MeTOAOJIOfli'IeCKHM II TeopeTII'IeCKIIM
BOnpocaM, KaCaiOIQIIMCH KaK npeAilOCbiJIOK II nyTeif B03HIIKHOBeHIIH rocy
AapCTBeHHOCTII, TaK H COQHaJihHO-IlOJIIITH'IeCKOfO xapaKTepa paHHIIX rocyAap
CTBeHHbiX o6pa30BaHIIif B pa3JIH'!HbiX periiOHaX BOCTO~lHOCJiaBHHCKOfO MIIpa.
3TIIM BOnpOCaM IlOCBHIQeHa nepBaH rpynna CTaTeif . B IICTOpiiOrpaqm~Ie
CKOM o63ope M.E. CBepAJIOBa, cpaBHIITeJibHO-TIInonorii~IecKoM HCCJieAOBa
HIIII E.A. MeJibHRKOBOif, npo6neMHoif craTbe H.<l>. KoTJIHpa , KOHKpeTHOM
II3y'leHIIII OAHOif II3 periiOHaJihHhiX q,opM cTaHOBJieHIIH rocyAapcTBeHHOCTH
A.A. fopcKoro npeAnpiiHHThi nonhiTKII ocMbiCJIIITh KopeHHhie npOTIIBope~mH
Me)J(AY CJIO)J(IIBllJIIMIICH CXeMaMII H peaJihHbiM, XOTH H CKYAHbiM, MaTepiiaJIOM,
noKa3aTb CJIO)J(HOCTb II HepellleHHOCTb KapAIIHaJihHbiX BOilpOCOB, CBH3aJUibiX C
B03HIIKHOBeHIIeM pycCKOH roCyAapCTBeHHOCTII, II npeAJIO)J(IITb B03MO:>KHbie
HOBbie nOAXOAbi K HX aHaJIII3y. T e CHO CBH3aHO C 3TIIM KOMilJieKCOM H HCCJie
AOBaHIIe A.B. <l>oMIIHhiM AeHe)J(HO-MOHeTHoro pbiHKa B ,IJ;peBHeif Pycw X B.,
CTaHOBJieHHe KOTOporo HBJIHeTCH Ba)J(HbiM noKa3aTeJieM KOHCOJIIIAaQIIH
rocyAapCTBa. ABTOpbl He CTaBHJIH CBOeif 3aAaqeiJ AaTb IIC'IepnhiBaiOIQHe OT
BeThl Ha nOCTaBJieHHhie BOnpOCbl - pHA CTaTeif HOCIIT AHCKYCCIIOHHbiH xa
paKTep, - HO CaMO BhiABII)J(eHHe II 06Cy:>KAeHIIe 3THX BOnpOCOB, Mbl HaAeeMCH,
AaCT IIMnyJihC K AaJihHeHllJHM 6onee AeTaJibHbiM II BCe06oeMJIIOIQHM H3biC
KaHIIHM no paHHeif HCTOpiiii Pycii.
BTopaH rpynna cTaTeif B Toif IIJIII IIHOif cTeneHH CBH3aHa c npo6JieMOH
CJIO)J(eHitH TeppiiTOpiiii ,il;peBHepyccKOfO roCyAapCTBa II ee BOCnpHHTIIH COBpe
MeHHIIKaMII. B.A. Ky<JKIIH II 11.B. BeAIOlliKIIHa IICCJieAYIOT TeppiiTopHaJibHoe
o6pa30BaHIIe , nony~IIIBllJee B JieTOniiCHX Ha3BaHHe "PyccKaH 3eMJIH" H nopo
AHBIDee HeMaJIO cnopOB B COBpeMeHHOH IICTOpROrpaq,HII. B HX CTaTbHX
"PyccKaH 3e MJIH" paCCMaTpiiBaeTCH H KaK llCTOpHKO-reorpaq,H'IeCKaH peaJib
HOCTb, H KaK onpeAeJieHHbiH KOMnJieKC npeACTaBJieHIIH ApeBHepyccKoro JieTO
nHCQa. B.5J:. IJeTpyxHH OCBeiQaeT B3aiiMOAeHCTBIIe CJiaBHHCKOrO II Xa3apCKOrO
MHpOB H yqaCTIIe B HeM BapHrOB B XOAe q,opMIIpOBaHIIH TeppiiTOpliH
,IJ;peBHepyccKoro rocyAapcTBa. B.n. 51HIIH aHaJIH3HpyeT OAHH II3 IIHTepec
HeiflliHX naMHTHIIKOB, OTpa)J(aiOIQHH n03AHHe 3Tanhi CJIO)J(eHHH rocyAapCT
BeHHOH TeppHTOpHH PycH,- "CnwcoK ropoAOB pyccKHx AaJihHHX H 6JIH)J(HHx".
8 CBOeif COBOKynHOCTII 3TH CTaTbii, nOCBHIQeHHbie KOHKpeTHbiM HBJieHIIHM,
OCBeiQaiOT Ba:>KHeHllJHe npOQeCCbl B q,opMHpOBaHHH rocyAapcrBeHHOH Teppii
TOpHH PycH, HMeDllJHe MHOro~IHCJieHHbie XpOHOJIOfli'JeCKHe H perHOHaJibHbie
oco6eHHOCTH.
CJieAyiOIQHH KOMnJieKC CTaTeif, B onpeAeJieHHOM CMbiCJie npiiMbiKaiOIQHH K
npeAhiAYIQeMy, T.M. KaJIHHHHoif, 11.f. KoHoaanoaoif, 11.f. ,IJ;o6poAOMOBa,
COAep)J(HT xapaKTepHCTHKY npoQeCCOB HHTerpaQHH HeCJiaBHHCKHX 3THH~IeCKHX
rpynn B ,il;peBHepyccKOM rocyAapCTBe H AeMOHCTpHpyeT pa3H006pa3lle B03-
4
MO:>KHbiX MCTOAOB 11CCJICAOBaHIDI 3THX rrpOI~CCCOB: TepM11HOJIOrWieCKOrO, 11CTO'I
IIHKOBCA'ICCKOrO, 3TI1MOJIOr11'1eCKOrO.
3asepmaeT C60pHHK rpyrrrra CTaTCH C TpaAH~HOHHbiM AJIH e>KerOAH11Ka
COACp>KaHI1eM: MC>KAyHapOAHhie CBH3H )l;peBHCH Pyc11. 0AHaKO paCCMaTpH
u aeMhie 3ACCb BOI1p0Cbl, XOTH H 06Cy:>KAaJIHCb MHOrOKpaTHO, OCTaiOTCH OCTpO
JIHCKyccHOHHhiMH: 3TO H AaTa rroe3AKH KHHrHHH OnhrH B KoHcTaHTiifHOITOJih
(A.B. Ha3apeHKO), 11 OCHOBaHI1e KHSI3CM CBSITOCJiaBOM TiepeHCJiaB~a Ha
.Ll.yHae .(B.E. nepxaBKO), H reHeaJIOrRSi KHSI3CH EpCHKe H KOKHece (E.JI. Ha
'JapoBa), IifCCJICAOBaHHC KOTOpOH, KCTaTH, 6hiJIO CHJibHO OTSirO~CHO 110JII1TI1-
'ICCKHMI1 MOTHBaMH. He SiBJISISICb, O'ICBHAHO, ITOCJICAHHM CJIOBOM B A11CKyCCIDIX,
OTH CTaTbl1 BHOCSIT Ba>KHhiH BKJiaA- B rrepsy10 O'IepeAb rrpHBJIC<ICHI1CM HOBbiX
MaTep11anos. HaKoHe~, cTaThH B.A. ApyTIOHosoif-<I>HAaHHH OTKpbmaeT 11C
cneAOBaHI1e MaJIOH3Y'ICHHoro AOHhiHe HarrpasneHI1Si CBSi3eH )l;pesHeif Pyc11 c
OAHOH H3 cTpaH KasKa3cKoro perHoHa c AaBHHMI1 TpaAH~IDIHI1 xpHCTiifaHCTBa -
ApMeHI1eif.
Tiy6JIHKYCMbie CTaTbl1 B TOH 11JIH HHOil cpOpMe If CTCI1CHI1 nepecMaTp11BaiOT
CJIO>KHBUJHCCSI H YTBCpAHBUJI1CCSi B OTC'ICCTBCHHOH HCTOp11orpacpHH rrpeA
CTaBJICHHH 0 Ba>KHCHUJHX SIBJICHI1SIX 11 npo~eccax, COI1pOBO>KAaBUJHX cpopM11-
poBaHI1C rocyAapCTBCHHOCTH y BOCTO'IHbiX CJiaBSIH.
ToM e>KeroAH11Ka 3asepmaeTcH 6H6JII10rpacpHeif pa6oT cOTPYAHHKOB OTACJia
HCTOpHH APCBHCHUJHX rocyAapCTB Ha Tepp11TOpHH BocTO'IHOH Esponhi, H3AaH
HhiX B 1990-1991 rr. Hay<rHo-opraHI13a~u:OHHaH pa6oTa no rroArOTOBKe AaHHoro TOMa e>KeroA
HHKa K ne•IaTH Bbii10JIHeHa fi.B. BeAIOUJKHHOH.
raksti. Riga, 1986. 861pp.; BpeuoaK A.B. llpH6rurrmicKo-<j>HHcKHe ua3BaHIDI peK s flaTranHH II Ji3B. AH ITaTBCCP. PHra, 1973. N.! 2. C. 98-99.
73 Latvie§u konversllcijas vllrdrlica. Rigll, 1937-1938. XVI s. 31698-31700 lpp.; Avoti{la R. Vllrdi, k 1
palika ~lavi{lu jllras dzelm~ II Dabas un v~stures kalendllrs, 1991. Riga, 1990. 150 lpp. 74 J. Sjogren's Livisch-Deutsches und Deutsch-Livisches Worterbuch. SPb., 1861. S. 71. 75 Cimermane / . Op. cit 551pp.; Latvijas PSR arheologija. 186-1871pp. 76 H03apoaa E.JI. CseAeHIHI pyccKHX HCTO'IIIHKOB XVI B. o neHHHKax Mecruoro nponcxo)I(JieHHJI 11
flHBOHHH II AI' 1987 r . M., 1989. C. 290. 77 Cnpozuc H.H. YKa3. co'!. C. III.
B.A. Apymronooa-f/Juoamm
IIPABOCJIABHbiE APM~HE B CEBEPO-BOCfQqHQll PYCH
MHe CJieAOBaJIO 6bi Ha3BaTb 3Ty CTaTbiO "K BOnpocy 0 B03MO)KHOM npucyTCTBHH npaaocnaBHbiX apMgH B Ceaepo-BocTO'IHOH Pycu", nocKOJibKY npu HaCTOg~eM COCTOHHHH HCTO'IHHKOB B pa60Te TaKOrO pOAa 6yAeT 60Jibiiie BOnpOCOB, 'IeM OTBeTOB. llpeAJIO)J{eHHaH 3AeCb rHnOTe3a - CKOpee TeMa AJIH COBMeCTHOrO pa3MbiiiiJieHHjl OpHeHTaJIHCTOB H cneQHaJIHCTOB no cpeAHeBeKOBOH Pycu, npH'IeM He TOJibKO (H He CTOJibKO) HCTOpHKOB, CKOJibKO apxeOJIOrOB H HCKYCCTBOBeAOB. HH<pOpMaQHji, KOTOpyiO g nonbiTaiOCb OCMbiCJIHTb B 3TOH pa6oTe, 6hma, co6craeHHO, npeAOCTaBJieHa TPYAaMH HCKyccTBOBeAOB ..
HccneAOBaTenu ApeaHepyccKoro HCKyccTBa qacro nucanu o pacQBeTe aeJIHKonenHoB: apxuTeKTYPHOH IIIKOJihi ao BnaAHMHpo-Cy3AaJihCKOH Pycu (cepeAHHa Xll-XIII B.). llpu IOpHH .O:onropy,KOM 6biJIO B03BeAeHo fijiTb 6enoKaMeHHbiX xpaMOB, B HX 'IHCJie QepKOBb Eopuca H rne6a (3aKOH'IeHHag nocrpoB:KoB: B 1152 r.), npoAOJI)KHJI cTpouTeJibCTBO AHApeB: Eoroni06CKHH, KOTOpbiH, no CBHAeTeJibCTBY JlaapeHTbeBCKOH JieTOnHCH, npHrJiaiiiaJI HH03eMHbiX Macrepoa1. CneQHaJIHCTbi ycMaTPHBaiOT B TeXHHKe crpouTeJibCTBa H AeKopaTHBHOM y6paHCTBe naMjiTHHKOB BnaAHMHpo-Cy3AaJibCKOH apxHTeKTypHOH IIIKOJihi qepTbi, o6IQHB: c opHaMeHTaQHeB: xpaMoB 3aKaBKa3bjl. O.X. Xannax'IhHH cpaBHHBaeT pe3Hbie opHaMeHTbi AxTaMapcKoro xpaMa c BJiaAHMHpOcy3AaJihCKHM AeKopoM. Ha KaMHjiX 3onOTbiX aopoT ao BnaAHMHpe H Ha nOAHO)KHH 'IaiiiH Kuaopftjl B Eoron106oae o6Hap~eHbi rpa4J4J»TH, CXOAHhie no Ha'IepTaHHIO C apMjiHCKHMH MOHOrpaMMaMH2.
0AHaKo H.A. Op6enu, KOTOpbiH BhiHCHHJI BOCTO'IHbie KOpHH "6oraTeB:IIIeB: pe3b6bi Ha KaMHe H nJIOCKHX peJibe4JoB, KOTOpbiMH 6hiJIH yKpaiiieHbl naMHTHHKH Cy3AaJibCKOH 3eMnu", ocHoBaTeJibHO nonaran, 'ITO "nonbiTKH nepe6pocHTb qepe3 KaBKa3cKue ropbi Ha '~YAOBHIQHOM reorpa4JuqecKOM npoTH)J{eHHH MOCT H3 Cy3AaJih~HHhi HenocpeACTBeHHo Ha BaHcKoe o3epo Ha AxTaMap, nepecKaKHBaH qepe3 TPH aeKa, eABa JIH Korp-nu6o Mornu y6eAHTh". He OTpHQaH BJIHHHHjl apMjiHCKoro HCKyccraa Ha HCKYCCTBO JJ:peBHeB: Pycu, OH C'IHTaJI, 'ITO He06XOAHMO BbljiCHHTb IlyTH, 110 KOTOpbiM MOrJIO npOHHKaTb 3TO
© ApyTiouosa-«l>HAalHIH B.A.
196
8JIIDIHHe, HaHTH 8biXOA "H3 3aKa8Ka3b51 H JO)KJIOro IlpHKa8Ka3MI" Ha OKpaHHhl pyccKOH paBHHHbl3.
0 cy~eCTBOBaHHH TaKHX nyTe:B: 8 CeBepo-BoCToqHyJO Pycb CBHAeTeJihCTByeT H nopa3HTeJibHOe (npH o6~eM HenpiDITHH "apM51HCKOH Bepbi", yHaCJieAOBaHHOM pyccKo:B: QepKOBbJO OT 8H3aHTHHCKOH) B03HHKHOBeHHe KYJihTa fpHropm~ ApM51HCKOro B HoBropoAe B KOHQe XII-XVI B.
B HOBropOACKOH JIHTepaType UIHpOKO npeACTaBneHo )KJITHe fpHropH51 IlpocBeTHTemi. IlepBbie Ha PycH H3o6pa:lKeHIDI apM51HCKoro CB51Toro n0518-JI51JOTC51 TaK:lKe B Ho8ropoAe (xpaM Cnaca HepeAHQbi noCTpoeH 8 ceHT516pe 1198 r ., pacnHCaH 8 KOHQe xn - HaqaJie Xlll B., QepKOBb <l>eOAOpa CTpaTHJiaTa nocTpoeHa B 1361 r., QepKOBb B qecTb fpHropH51 ApMRHCKoro noCTpoeHa 8 XYTbiHCKOM MOHaCTbipe noA HoBropoAOM B 1445 r.). TpaAIJQHIO HKOHOllHCaHH51 apM51HCKOrO CB51TOrO Ha PycH TaK:lKe MO)KJIO OTHeCTH K Ho8ropOAY H AaTHpoBaTb ee KOHQOM XII- HaqanoM Xlll 8.4
Henb351 yTBep:lKAaTb, qTo He 6biJIO nonbiTOK nponHTb cseT Ha 3TY npo6neMy. K.B. AHBa351H B ABYX 6onbUIHX CTaTb51X npH8en en masse CBeAeHIDI o6 apM51Hax Ha PycH B nepHOA paHHero cpeAHeBeKOBb51, ynoMHHaHHSI o6 " apM51HCKOH Bepe", o6 "apM51HCKOH epecH" H KYJibTe fpHropm~ IIpocBeTHTeng 8 HoBropoAe5. HccneAOBaTeJib npH80AHT p51A B03MO:lKHbiX o6nRCHeHHB: 3araAOqHoro <PeHoMeHa noqHTaHIDI fpHropm~ ApM51HCKoro Ha pyccKOM ceBepoBOCTOKe: 1) BJIIDIHHe BH3aHTHHCKOH QepKOBHOH TpaAHQHH; 2) nepe803 MOIQeH c8. fpHropm~ H3 KoHCTaHTHHononR B HoBropoA; 3) HcnoJib30BaHHe KYJibTa fpHropm~ B 6opb6e c epeTHKaMH6• PaccMoTpHM 803MO:lKHOCTH npeBpa~eHm~ 3THX llOJIO:lKeHHH B HaAe)KJible pa6oqHe rHnOTe3bl.
AKTHBH3aQIDI noqHTaHIDI fpHropm~ IlpocBeTHTeJig B BH3aHTHH C8R3aHa c HMeHeM llaTPHapxa <I>OTIDI (858-867; 877-886), CTpeMHBUierOCR K KOHCOJIHAaQHH CHJI 80CToqHoxpHCTHaHCKOH QepKBH nepeA JIHQOM 3anaAa. Oli n·biTancg crnaAHTb pa3Hornacm~ Me:lKAY 80CTOqHbiMH xpHCTHaHaMH, A06HBancg YHHH c apMRHCKOH MOHO<l>HCHTCKOH QepKOBbJO. fp~rOpHH - npHMaC apM51HCKOH QepKBH, BeJIHKOMyqeHHK, nonynRpHbiH CpeAH apM51H, CHpHHQeB, KOllTOB, HAeanhHO nOAXOAHJI Ha ponb QeMeHTHPYJOIQero 3BeHa. IlpH MHxaHne Ill (842-867) <l>oTHH OTKpbiBaeT B QepKBH C851TOH TpoHQbi penHK8HH fpHropm~ H CBSITbiX AeB PHnCHMe H faRHe. HM51 fpHropm~ qacTo ynoMHHaeTC51 B nepenHCKe <l>oTH51, npH HeM noR8JI5leTC51 rpeqecKa51 Bepcm~ Ara<PaHrena, )KJITHe fpHropm~ BKJIIOqaeTcR B MeHonorHH CHMeoHa MeTa<PpacTa, qTo BeCbMa cnoco6cTBOBano nonyJij{pHOCTH apM51HCKOrO IlpOCBeTHTeJIR B CTpaHaX BH3aHTHHCKOrO KYJibTypHoro Kpyra. ITo HHHQHaTH8e <l>oTHR cTeHbi c8. Co<PHH KoHcTaHTHHononbCKOH yKpaUiaJOTC51 <PpecKaMH C H306pa:lKeHH51MH OTQOB QepKBH, npH3BaHHbiMH llOATBepAHTb aBTOpHTeT BOCTOqHOH QepKBH, H fpHrOpHH IlpocBeTHTeJib oKa3biBaeTCSI 8 OAHOM p51AY co CTOnnaMH xpHCTHaHCTBa BacHnHeM BeJIHKHM, fpHropHeM Ha3HaH3HHOM, ,IJ;HOHHCHeM ApeonarHTOM, HHKOJl'aeM MHpnHKHHCKHM. MoiQH fpHropm~ ApM51HCKoro nepeHOCRTCR B Co<PHJ07. JI.M. MeJIHKCeT-BeK, A.,IJ;. EpHQ08 u K.B. AB:Ba351H CqQ:TaJOT, qTo pyccKa51 QepK08b coxpaH51Jia noqQ:TaHHe fpHropm~ IIpocBeTHTeJIR, HCXOAR H3 TPaAHQHH 8peMeHH TaK Ha3biBaeMoro "8ceneHcKoro cornacm~"8• 0AHaKo, ecnH 6hi 3TO 6bmo TaK, TO npe:lKAe Bcero ero KYJibT no518HJICR 6bl 8 KHeBe H 6bm 6bi xapaKTepeH AJIR Bce:B: pyccKo:B: QepK8H, a He TOJibKO AJij{ Ho8ropoACKOH H TOJibKO c KOHQa XII no XVI B. Peqb HAeT, no-8HAHMOMy, He o pyTHHHOM
197
noqHTaHHH O~HOrO H3 CB~ThiX BCeJieHCKOH qepKBH, a 0 BCnnecKe :liCHBOrO
HHTepeca, YHHKaJihHoro ~n~ PycH.
IIpe~nOJIO)I(eHHe, qTo B HoBropo~ 6biJIH npHBe3eHbl MOiqH rpHrop~ IIpo
CBeTHTeJI~ BMeCTe c MorqaMH <I>eo~opa CTPaTHJiaTa H Bnac~ CesaCTHiicKoro,
~oCTasneHHhiX ,IJ;o6phmeii SI~peiiKOBHqeM s Haqane XIll s.9, He Haxo~HT HH
np~MhiX, HH KOCBeHHhiX no~TBep~eHHH B HCTOqHHKaX. QqeBHAHO, MOiqH
rpHrop~ He noKH~aJIH rnaBHOrO xpaMa BH3aHTHHCKOH HMUepHH . .
H, HaKOHeq, OCHOBHM rHnOTe3a AiiBa3~Ha: KynhT rpHrop~ IIpocBeTH
TeJI~ COBna~aeT no BpeMeHH C nepBbiM MaCCOBhiM aHTHqepKOBHhiM ~BH)I(e
HHeM Ha PycH - epeCbiO CTpHrOJihHHKOB, H, no ero MHeHHIO, :3TO He ~BJI~eTC~ cnyqaiiHhiM cosna~eHHeM.
AiiBa3~H Bhi~BHraeT npe~nOJIO)I(eHHe, qTo KYJihT rpHrop~ no~BHJICK Henocpe~CTBeHHo B xo~e 6oph6hi npoTHB epecH CTPHrOJihHHKOB, KOTOp~. no
ero MHeHHIO, cB~3aHa 6Lma c epechiO naBJIHKHaH. B aToM npe~nono)l(emm
npHCyTCTBYIOT AB3 He~OKa3yeMhiX, TOqHee - He~OKa3aHHhiX, AOnyrqeHM.
IIepa.oe - epech cTpHronhHHKOB reHeTHqecKH socxo~HT K naBJIHKHaHcKoii
epecH, BTOpoe - KYJihT rpHrop~ Ap~HCKOro HCnOJih30BaJIC~ KaK op~e B
6opb6e c nasnHKHaHaMH. AHaJIH3 H~eonorHH o6eHx epeceii, npoBe~eHHhiX
Aiisa3~HOM, He oqeHh y6e~aeT, TaK KaK, so-nepBhiX, onHpaeTc~ He Heno
cpe~CTBeHHO Ha HCTOqHHKH (KaK 6bi MaJI<_> HX HH 6biJIO ), a Ha HCCJie~OBaHM, 6onee scero Ha He caMyiO HOBYIO H He caMyiO nyqrnyiO pa6oTy o naBJIH
KHaHCKOM ABH)I(eHHH c.r. MenHK-Baxrn~Ha1 0 H Hccne~oBaHHe H.A. Ka-
3aKosoii, DOCB~IqeHHOe CTpHrOJihHHKaM11 ; BO-BTOpbiX, ~a)l(e H T3KOe onocpe
~OBaHHOe H3JIO)I(eHHe fiOK33hiB3eT, ~0 oqeBH~HM 6JIH30CTh yqeHHH naBJIH
KHaH, 6orOMHJIOB H CTpHrOJihHHKOB ~eT Ha ypOBHe CXO~CTBa Me~y BceMH
aHTHqepKOBHhiMH cpe~HeBeKOBhiMH epec~MH.
Aiisa3~H npH3HaeT, qTo HeT HHKaKHX ~aHHhiX o npe6hiBaHHH apMKH
naBJIHKHaH B Hosropo~e, qTo HCTOqHHKH CBH~eTeJihCTByiOT CKOpee B ll0Jih3Y
npHCYTCTBM npasocnaBHhiX apMKH B CeBepo-BoCTo~oii PycH, HO npoxoAHT
MHMO C06CTBeHHhiX apryMeHTOB, YBJieqeHHhiH rroni>ITKOH CB~3aTh KYJihT
rpHrOpM ApMKHCKOro c 6oph6oii rrpoTHB apMKHCKHX H pyccKHX epeTHKOB12.
OH rrpHBO~HT ABa He3HaqHTeJihHhiX yrroMHHaHM o rraBJIHKHaHax B "KopMqeii
XIV Tiny nos 6e3 TOJIKOBaHHii", rrpHHa~Jie)l(aBrneii o~HOMY H3 HOBropo~cKHX apxHenHcKonoB XII-Xill BB., H B "C6opHHKe cnoB, noyqeHHii H anoKpH~t>oB" (KOHeq XII - Haqano xm B.), a TaK)I(e nhiTaeTC~ ~OKa3aTh, qTo BbiUa~hl
rrpOTHB "apMKHCKOH Bepbi" HJIH "apMKHCKOH epecH", COAep)l(arqHeC~ B rraMKT
HHKaX HOBrOpOACKOH JIHTepaTyphi, BBH~Y HX KpaiiHeH pe3KOCTH H He06oeK
THBHOCTH, HMeiOT B BHAY He MOHOcpHCHTOB, a 113BJIHKHaH13 , 3a6hiB~, qTo
apryMeHTaqHIO npOTHB "apM~HCKOH Bepbi" pyCCKOe 6orOCJIOBHe B 3HaqH
TeJibHOH CTeneHH yHaCJieAOBaJIO OT BH3aHTHHCKOrO, KOTOpoe He CTeC~JIOCh B
noneMHKe.
Bo BTopoii rronoBHHe X B. rro~BHJIOCh, HanpHMep, coqHHeHHe HHKOHa
Ka10yqeroc~. rAe Hap~~y c pa36opoM ~eiiCTBHTeJihHhiX pa3HornacHii Me~y apM~HCKOH H rpeqeCKOH qepKBaMH, apMKHCKOH qepKBH npe~o~BJI~eTC~ B
Kpafme pe3Koii cpopMe MHO)I(eCTBO H3AYMaHHhiX o6BHHeHHii14. Aiisa3~H cqH
TaeT, BIIpoqeM, qTO pyCCKHe 6orOCJIOBhl B CBOHX Hana~KaX Ha apMKHCKOe
yqeHHe, o6p~Ahl H 06bJqaH MOrJIH nyTaTb apM~H-MOHOcpHCHTOB H apMKH
naBJIHKHaH15. Ho H aTo He rrpe~CTaBn~eTc~ MHe B03MO)I(HhiM, TaK KaK K XII-
198
XIII BB. naBJJHKHaH )'}Ke He 6biJJO HH B ApMeHHH, HH B crpaHax BH3aHTHHCKoro
KYJJbTypHoro Kpyra. 0HH paCTBOpHJJHCb B TOH~paKHTax y ce6.s1 Ha po~HHe,
6oroMHJJax B Eonrapuu, qacTb ux 6e:lKaJJa B Espony, CJJHBIIIHCb c ~BH:lKeHHeM KaTapOB H aJJb6HrOHQeB. IlyTH 3THX TpaHC<f>OpMHpOBaBIIIHXCSI
apM.siHCKHX epeTHKOB yxo~HJJH, TaKHM o6pa30M, COBepiiieHHO B ~pyroM HanpaBJJeHHH. IlonbiTKa CB.si3aTb no.siBJJeHne KYJJbTa apM.siHCKoro CB.siToro c
3aAaqaMH 6opb6bJ npoTHB apMXHCKHX epeTHKOB B Bn3aHTHH H npoBeCTH
aHanornJO c co6bJTH.siMH Ha Pycu He BbirJJ.si~HT y6e~HTeJJbHOH He TOJJbKO
noTOMY, qTo ucropuqecKHe aHaJJorHH, TeM 6onee npu BpeMeHHoM pa3pbiBe B
HecKOJJbKO BeKOB (IX B. B BH3aHTHH H KOHeQ XII-XIII B. ua PycH), BcerAa
COMHHTeJJbHbl, HO e)Qe H llOTOMY, qTO cf>OTHH, KaK 6biJJO llOKa3aHO BbJIIIe,
npecJJe~OBaJJ HHbJe QeJJH, peiiiHTeJJbHO BBOA.sJ: apM.siHCKOrO CBXTOrO B naHTeOH
BHAHeHIIIHx CTOJJllOB BOCTOquoro xpHCTHaHCTBa. Ho CaMbJM OCHOBHbiM apry
MeHTOM, onpoBepraJOJQHM CB.sl3b KYJJbTa rpuropH.si (KaK, BnpoqeM, H JJJ06o
ro HHOrO CBHTOrO) C epeTHKaMH, .siBJJ.sieTC.si, llO-BH~HMOMy, npOCTOe Hano
MHHaHHe 0 TOM, qTo HKOHOrpa<f>H.si xpaMOB HHKOHM o6pa30M . He MOrJJa
llOBJJHXTb Ha epeTHKOB, npe~CTaBHTeJJeH aHTHQepKOBHbiX BepoyqeHHH,
llOCKOJJbKY OHH OTpHQaJJH xpaMbl H, CJJe~OBaTeJJbHO, He llOCeJQaJJH H He
CTpOHJJH HX.
O~HaKO BllOJJHe B03MO:lKHO HHOe 06'b.siCHeHue: KYJJhT rpuropH.si ApM.siHC- .
KOrO AOJJ)KeH 6biJJ llOMep:lKaTb 60pQOB 3a npaBOCJJaBHe, MOryJQHX aKTHBHO
BbiCTynHTb npoTHB "epeTHKOB apM.siH". BcnoMHHM KpacHopeqnBoe noCJJaHue
HHKOHa qepHoropQa K OTQY repacHMY B HepycaJJHM (XI B.) 16• H3 3TOro
o6CTO.SITeJJbHOrO llOCJJaHHX BbiXCH.sieTC.si, ~0 apM.siHe-xaJJKftAOHHTbl Bbl3bJBaJJH
HapeKaHH.si CO CTOpOHbl eAHHOBepQeB COXpaHeHHeM Tpa~HQHH, 06bJqaeB,
KYJJbTYPbi, a rnaBHbiM o6pa30M coxpaHeHHeM po~Horo .si3bJKa B 6orocJJ)'}Ke
HHH. He TOJJbKO crpeMJJeHHe K yHH<f>HKaQHH <f>opM penuruo3Hm':f KYJJbTypb1 17,
HO H npe:lK~e BCero CTpax nepe~ B03MO:lKHbiM npOHHKHOBeHHeM MOHO<f>H
CHTCKHX TeHAeHQHH B cpe~y apM.siH-XaJJKH~OHHTOB 3aCTaBJJHJJH e~HHOBepQeB :lKeJJaTb, qT06bl OHH BeJJH QepKOBHyJO CJJ)'}K6y Ha rpeqecKOM HJJH rpy3HHCKOM
X3bJKax. HHKOH B 3aJQHTY ux BCnOMHHaeT, qTo eJQe npu CaBBe OcBxJQeHHOM
(VI B.) H cf>eOAOCHH apM.siHaM pa3peiiiaJJOCb BeCTH 6orOCJJ)'}KeHHe Ha po~HOM
X3bJKe H TOJJbKO TpHCB.siTYJO neCHb OHH neJJH Ha rpeqecKOM H3-3a
npu6aBJJeHH.si "H:lKe pacnHbiHCH 3a Hbi", TaK KaK. 3TO ~o6aBJJeHHe coxpaHXJJH
MOHO<f>HCHTbi18•
B 6uorpa<f>HH CB. CaBBbi paccKa3bJBaeTcx, ~o apM.siHe, HBHBIIIHecH K HeMY,
llOJJyqHJJH pa3peiiieHHe COBepmaTb QepKOBHYJO CJJ)'}K6y Ha apM.siHCKOM H3b1Ke.
A B THllHKe CB. CaBBbi YKa3aHo, qTo MOHaxu MoryT qHTaTh AnocTOJJ H CB.
EBaurenue "Ha ux po~HOM H3biKe"19.
HHKOH qepHoropeQ, no~TBep:lK~aH no~JJHHHoe npaBocnaBHe 3THX apM.siH,
yKa3bJBaeT Ha HX llOJJe3HYJO ~eHTeJJbHOCTb B KaqeCTBe llOJJeMHCTOB. "H
~OAHecb OTQbi Hamu u naTpnapxu 6epyT ux c 6oroM Ha 6opb6y c Bpara
MH, KOrAa Ha co6ope B036y:lK~aeTCH 'JTO-JJH60 npOTHB epeTHKOB-apM.siH,
TaK KaK OHH CBe~yJQH B HX H3bJKe H llHCaHH.siX. H HeAaBHO e)Qe npH 6JJa
:lKeHHbiX llaTPHapxax B Harne BpeM.si CJJyqHJJOCb, KaK HeKOTOpbie H3 HHX B
BeCbMa MaJJOM KOJJHqeCTBe He ~aJJH OTHIO~b epeTHKaM (apM.siHaM) H CJJOBO
HCllYCTHTb HJJH .sl3b1KOM IIIeBeJJbHYTb, XOnl epeTHKOB-apM.siH H 6biJJO BeCbMa
MHoro"20.
199
B AOKyMeHTax MOHaCTbip.ll 3cqmrMeHa ecTb aKT OT 1037 r. nryMeHa MOH3CTbip.11 H npoTa A<PoHa <l>eOKTHCTa, apM.IIHHH3-X3JIKHAOHHTa, KOTOpbiH noAapnn ceoeMy "AYXOBHOMY 6paTy" MOHaxy HnKH<!>opy HMeHne CennHa ua A<PoHe B B03HarpiDJ<AeHHe 3a TPHAU:aTHIIIeCTnneTHIOIO MHCCHOHepcKyro Ae.IITeJibHOCTb B <PeMe XapcnaHa21 . ApM.RHe-xanKHAOHBThi eenn aKTHBHYIO MHCcnoHepcKyro Ae.RTeJibHOCTb B BH33HTHHCKHX npoBHHo;H.IIX H caMOM KoHCTaHTHHonone, Ha liaJIKaHax H B Manoii A3HB, B ApMeHHB H rpy3HH, H, MO)!{eT 6biTb, Ha Pycn. ,IJ;peeHepyccKHe noneMH'IecKHe c6opHHKH CBHAeTeJibCTBYIOT o6 aKTyanbHOCTH 6opb6bi c "apM.RHCKHM!' eeponcnoeeAaHHeM. B cnncKe cepeAHHbi XVII B. noMetu;eHbi ll.IITb CTaTeii npoTHB "apM.RHCKoii epecn", B ABYX H3 HHX HAeT pe'lb 0 DOCTe, ycTaHOBJieHHOM apM.IIHCKOH o;epKOBbiO "apaqaBOpKe", T.e. pe'lb HAeT He 0 ll3BJIHKH3Hax, a 0 MOHO<!>HCHTaX. B C3MOM H3'13Jie CT3TbH "06 apM.IIHCKOH epecn" yKa3aHo: "Cnepaa apM.IIHe [6biJIH) C H3MH o6oeAHHeHbi a npaaocnaaHoii aepe AO CB.IIToro 'leTaepToro aceneHcKoro co6opa" 22. 51cHo, 'ITO "epecbro" AJI.II pyccKHX npaaocnaBHbiX, KaK n AJI.II HHKoHa qepHoropu;a, 6biJIO aeponcnoBeAaHHe, npHH.IITOe apM.RHCKOH MOHO<PncHTCKOH u;epKOBbiO. PyKoDHCb XVI a. COAep)!{HT "KnnpnaHa, cMnpeHHoro MHTpononnTa KneacKoro H ace.11 Pycn, OTBeT A<PaHacnro, aonpocnaiiieMy o HeKOTOpbiX noTPe6HbiX Aenax", rAe TaK)!{e HAeT pe'lh o6 "apM.RHCKOH epecn". KHnpHaH B 1380 r . 6biJI MOCKOBCKHM MHTPODOJIHTOM, a B 1382 r. nepeexaJI B Knee. B Kneae y)!{e Ha py6e)!{e XI-XII BB. cytu;eCTaosana OAHa H3 ApeeHeiiiiiHX apM.IIHCKHX KOJIOHHH23, KYA3, O'leBHAHO, BXOAHJIH H MOHO<!>HCHTbl, H XaJIKHAOHHTbl.
B Kneao-IleqepcKOM naTepnKe, ao BTopoM nocnaHHH "qepHopn3u;a" IleqepcKoro MOH3CTbip.11 IlOJIHKapna K apXHM3HAPHTY AxirnAHHY paccKa3biBaeTC.II o6 HCKYCHOM apaqe-apM.IIHHHe "poAOM H aeporo". Bpaq-apMRHHH npOTHBODOCT3BJieH "6Jia)!{eHHOMY AraDHTy", KOTOpbiH HaAeJieH BCeMH xpHCTHaHCKHMH A06poAeTeJIRMH. PaccKa3 3aaepiiiaeTcR nonHbiM pacKaRHHeM "HHOBepHOrO H He'leCTHBOrO apM.IIHBHa", OTK333BIIIerOC.II OT apM.IIHCKOH Bepbi H nepeiiieAIIIero B JIOHO pyccKOH npaBOCJiaBHOH qepKBH: "If DOCTPHrC.II 3TOT apM.IIHHH B IleqepCKOM MOH3CTbipe H TYT KOH'IHJI )!{H3Hb CBOIO B A06pOM HCDOBeA3HHB"24.
JI.A. OraHeCRH C'IHTaeT HCTopnqecKH HeTO'IHbiM <PaKTOM To, 'ITO apM.RHHH "poAOM H eeporo" a XII a. oKa3aJicR He xpHCTHaHHHOM H yeepoaan a XpnCTa JIHIIIb nocne Toro, KaK npoHHKCR aeporo a CBRToro ArannTa25. K.H. rpnropbRH, noneMH3Hpy.R c 3THM YTBep~eHBeM, OTMe'laeT, 'ITO He TOJibKO a XIIxm, HO H 3H3'1HTeJibHO ll03)!{e, B XVII B., apM.IIH '13CTO H B JieTODHC.IIX, H B o<Pnu:naJihHbiX AOKYMeHTax Ha3hiBaiOT "HHoaepu;aMn"26.
B KOHo;e Xffi B. B H3JIO)KeHHH 06.1133TeJibHbiX YCJIOBHH npH H36paHBH enHCKODa yKa3biBanoch: "He no3BOMTh a caoeii enapxnn npaaocnaBHbiM BCTynaTb B 6paKH, KYMHTbC.II H 6paTaThCR c apM.RHaMH H naTHHaMH". B nocnaHHH )!{e MHTponoJIHTa KnnpnaHa K nryMeHy A<PaHacnro (1390-1405) coAep)!{HTCR HHBeKTHBa no aApecy "apMeHcKoii epecn"27. MHe npeACTaBJIReTCR, 'ITO ApeaHepyccKHii aBTOp paccKa3a o apaqe-apM.RHHHe 6bm xopoiiio ocseAOMJieH 0 TOM, 'ITO cytu;eCTBYIOT apM.RHe "pOAOM H Beporo" H apM.RHe TOJibKO "pOAOM", KOTOpbiX B cpe]:lHeBeKOBbiX HCTO'IHHK3X '13CTO 0603H3'13JIH 3THOHHM3MH TeX HapOAOB, OT o;epKBH KOTOpbiX OHH BOCDpHH.IIJIH KOH<!>eCCHI028. TaK, KH.II3.11 ra6pH3Jia (raapHHJia), npaaHTeJI.II MeJIHTHHbl B KOHU:e XI B., MnxaHJI Cnpneu:
200
Ha3biBaeT rpeKOM, aHOHHMHrul CHpHifcKrul XpOHHKa - XaJIKHAOHHTOM, a fHHOM TupcKHH nHUieT, 'ITO fa6pH3JI 6bm "rpeKOM no BepoHcnoBeAaHmo", HO apMHHHHOM "no nJieMeHH, H3biKY H 06bi'IRHM"29. 3TO KJiaCCH'IeCKaH <j>opMynupoBKa AJIH onpeAeJieHHH apMHHHHa-xoJIKHAOHHTa, qacTo ynoTpe6mmUiaHCH H B rpeqeCKHX, H B apMHHCKHX HCTO'IHHKaX, MaTTeoc YpxaeQH nHUieT o cl>HJiapeTe BpaxaMHH (Bapa)I<HYHH): "OH Ha'laJI BOHHY c BepyiOIQHMH BO XpHCTa, nOTOMY 'ITO OH 6biJI HeBepHbiH XpHCTHaHHH, ero He npH3HaBaJI [CBOHM] HH apMHHHH, HH poMeH, [TaK KaK], no 06bi'IaiO H Bepe OH 6biJI pOMeeM, a no OTQY H MaTepH apMHHHHOM"30.
B npHDHCKe AcceMaHHeBoro eBaHreJIHH (rnaroJIHQeH: B KOHQe X - Ha'laJie XI B. H3 MaKeAOHHH)31 ynoMHHaeTCH fpHropHH: IIpocBeTHTeJib- "cBHIQeHHOMY~IeHHK BeJIHKou ApMeHHH", H pHAOM c :non npHnHcKoH: noMeiQeHa npHnHcKa, OOAep)KaJQrur HMH HoaHHa BorocnoBa, 'ITO CBHAeTeJibCTByeT o BbicoKoM aBTOpHTeTe fpHropHH IIpocBeTHTeJIH B CJiaBHHCKOU QepKBH. r.B. A6-rapHH, HCCJieAOBaBUIHU apMHHCKOe "CKa3aHHe 0 fiopHce H fne6e", OTMe'laeT, 'ITO H3o6pa)KeHHe fpuropHH IIpocBeTHTeJIH 6hiJIO noMeiQeHo Ha CTeHe XpaMa Cnaca Ha HepeAHQe B HoBropoAe, KOTopoe 6hiJIO 3aKOH'IeHo nocTpouKou B 1198 r. HMeHHO B TOT MeCHQ CeHTH6pb, KOTOpblU OTMe'leH B npHllHCKe AcceMaHneBoro eBaHreJIHH. A6rapHH C'IHTaeT, 'ITO B XII-XIII BB., KOrAa pacnHCbiBaJICH xpaM Ha HepeAHQe, C03AaBanacb apMHHCKrur BepcHH "CKa3aHHH o Bopuce H fne6e". HccneAOBaTeJib npHBOAHT . H PHA Apyrux <j>aKTOB, yKa3biBaiOIQHX Ha 06IQHOCTb B3rJIHAOB apMHHCKUX H pyCCKUX AeHTeJieu KYJibTYPbi H KHU)KHOCTH B KOHQe XII- Ha'lane XIII B., H Aa)Ke AenaeT BbiBOA o APY)KeCTBeHHbiX OTHOUieHHHX Me~y pyccKou H apMHHCKOH QepKBaMH B 3TOT nepHOA BpeMeHu32.
HTaK, c OAHOu CTOpOHbi, pe3Koe HenpHHTHe "apMHHCKOH Bepbi" pyccKHMH 6orOCJIOBaMH H KHU)KHHKaMU, a C Apyrou- "Ap~eCTBeHHbie OTHOUieHHH" - H TO H Apyroe nOATBep)KAaeTCH <j>aKTaMH. 3TO npOTHBOpe'IHe MO)KeT 6biTb pa3peUieHo, ecnu Mbi yqTeM, 'ITO cyiQeCTBOBaJio ABe apMHHCKHe QepKBH -MOHO<j>HCHTCKaH H XaJIKHAOHHTCKaH H KO BTOpOH npaBOCJiaBHbie pyCCKHe BnOJIHe MOrJIH HCnbiTbiBaTb "Ap~eCTBeHHbie" 'IYBCTBa. B.H. Jla3apeB OTMeqaeT cypoBOCTb <j>pecKoBou )KHBOnHcu HepeAHQbi, 3CxaTonorH'IecKoe COAep)KaHue pocnHceu, OTJIH'IaiOIQHXCH OT Tpe3BOrO AYXa HOBropOACKOH peJIHrH-03HOCTH. PHA HCKYCCTBOBeAOB npeAnonaraeT BJIHHHHe apMHHCKoro H rppHHcKoro ucKyccTBa Ha 3TH pocnucu33. B Ha'laJie BeKa A.,I:J;. EpHQOB H3BJieK BblllHCKH H3 "HKOHOnHCHbiX nOAJIUHHHKOB" HOBrOpOACKOU peAaKQHH KOHQa XVI B., CBUAeTeJihCTBYIOIQHX o coxpaHeHuu pyccKoH TPaAHQUORHou HKOHonHCbiO o6H3aTeJibHbiX HOpM H3o6pa)KeHHH fpuropHH IIpocBeTHTeJIH. B 3THX npaBHJiaX rOBOpHTCH 0 ero BHeUIHeM o6JIHKe: " ... IJHUieTCH TaKO: llOA06HeM BacHJIHH KecapHHCKHH; 6paAa nocBeTJiee Bacrui:beBbi, c npoceAbiO; pH3a CBHTHTeJibCKrur 6oropOAU'Ih, B OMO<j>ope, HCllOAb npa3eJieHb AbiM'IaT, naTpaXHJib Boxpa 6neA; snacbi o6poCJibiH; cyx H qepeH"34.
HcCJieAOBaTeJIH OTMe'laiOT, 'ITO C06JIIOAaH npaBHJia HKOHOnHCaHHH, perJiaMeHTHpyiOIQHe qepTbl BHeUIHero 06JIHKa CBHTOrO, HKOHOnHCQbl H306pa)KaJIH apMHHCKOrO npOCBeTHTeJIH B BOCTO'IHOM TUne, HHCKOJibKO He rpeUia HH npOTHB HaQHOHaJibHbiX npeAaHHH apMHH, HH npOTHB Tpe60BaHHH HCTOpHqecKOH TO'IHOCTH35.
H3o6pa)KeHHe fpHropHH HaXOAHTCH B anTapHOH a6CHAe, rAe oH 3aHHMaeT
201
MeCTO KpaiiHero crrpaBa B "oTe'leCKOM" pR~y. CBRTO:ii o6na'leH B cpenoHh,
qepe3 rrnequ rrepe6pomeH OMo<f>op c KpecTaMH, ronoBa OTKphiTa, rrpaBoii
pyKoii OH 6naroCJIOBJIReT ~BYMR rrepCTaMH rrepe~ rpy~hiO, a B neBoii ~ep>KHT KHHry. <I>Hrypa MOJAHlUl, KOpeHaCTaR H 60JihUierOJIOBaR, rrporrop~ YKOpO
'IeHbJ36. HeKOTopLie uccne~oBaTeJIH rronaraiOT, 'ITO aTo H3o6pax<:eHHe rpHro
pHR rroBTOpReT BH3aHTHHCKHe o6pa3Qhi (Mo3aHKa B CB. CocpHH IX B.,
MHHHaTIOpa B MeHonorHH BacHJIHR II (X B.), M03aHKa B Xocuoc JlyKac B
<I>OKH~e (XI B.), pOCilHCh B qepKBH IlaHarHH (XI B.)37 , ~pyrne C6JIIDKaiOT ero C
H3o6pa>KeHHRMH CBRToro B apMRHCKllX H rpy3HHCKHX xpaMax38. CoBepmeHHo
O'leBH~HO TOJihKO TO, 'ITO cpopMa KpeCTa Ha OMOcpope rpuropHR B BhiUie
yrroMRHYThiX BH3aHTHHCKHX HCTO'IHHKaX - 3TO pOBHhie UIHpOKHe IlOJIOChl, a
KpeCThl OMOcpopa rpuropHR xpaMa Hepe~HQhl paBHOKOHe'IHhie c pacmHpR
IO~MHCR OT QeHTPa BeTBRMH. 3TOT THil KpeCTa 6hiJI UIHpOKO pacrrpOCTpaHeH
B ApMeHHH c V-VI BB., H TO'IHO TaKHe >Ke KpecThi Ha6niO~aiOTCR B
H306pa>KeHHH rpuropHR IlpocBeTHTeJIR Ha CKeBpCKOM peJIHKBapHH 1293 r :;
BhiilOJIHeHHOM no 3aKa3y HaCTORTeJIR MOHaCThipR CKeBpa B KHJIHKHH
KoHcTaHTHHa B rraMRTh o rroru6mux 3a~HTHHKax KperrocTH PoMKJia39. B
H306pax<:eHHRX ~pyrHX CBRThiX, paCilOJIO>KeHHhiX pR~OM C rpHrOpHeM B a6c~e Hepe~HQhi, <f>opMa Kpecra- pOBHhie UIHpOKHe JIHHHH. JI.M. MenHKceT-EeK
CBR3biBaeT H306pax<:eHHe rpHrOpHR B pyCCKOM XpaMe C era H306pax<:eHHRMH B
xaJIKH~OHHTCKHX xpaMax ApMeHHH H rpy3HH (ATeHH, EeTaHH, AxTaJia,
,[J;aBH~-rape~>Ka, CaMTBHcu)40 .
. Cpe~H CBRThiX ~eB B ~HaKOHHHKe rrpe~CTaBJieHa <f>urypa BeJIHKOMy'leHH
Qhi PHilCHMe H rrpOCBeTHTeJibHHQhl rpy3HH CB. · HHHo. E~e A.M. y crreHCKHH
OTMe'laJI cBoeo6pa3HhiH rro~6op CBRThiX B Crrace Hepe~HQhi, HO, HaCKOJihKO
MHe H3BeCTHO, IlOilhiTOK 06'bRCHHTh 3TO He rrpe~rrpHHHMaJIOCh, 3a HCKJil<)
'leHHeM 6aHaJihHhiX paccy>K~eHHH 0 BHHMaHHH K apMRHCKHM CBRThiM,
BOCXO~R~eM K BpeMeHaM BCeJieHCKOrO COrJiaCHR qepKBeH. B 3TH paCCY>K
~eHHR, rrpaB~a, He O'leHh BrrHChiBaeTcR noRBJieHHe H3o6pax<:eHHR cB. HHHo,
rrocKOJihKY HaQHOHaJihHaR rpy3HHCKaR KOHQerrqHR o6 o6pa~eHHH CTPaHhi
B XpHCTHaHCTBO OKOH'IaTeJihHO ccpopMHpOBaJiaCh TOJihKO K 60-70-M ro~aM XB.41
TaKOe CO'IeTaHHe CBRThiX B HKOHOrpacpuqecKOH nporpaMMe xapaKTepHO
~JIR apMRHo-xaJIKH~OHHTCKHX xpaMOB (AxTana, qepKOBh TurpaHa 0HeHQa B
AHH). B cpe~e apMRH-XaJIKH~OHHTOB KYJih'r rpuropHR ApMRHCKoro, O~HO
BpeMeHHO H HaQHOHaJihHhiH H npaBOCJiaBHhiH, npuo6peJI oco6y10 3Ha'lliMOCTh.
A .M. JIH~OB C'IHTaeT, 'ITO crreqHaJihHhiM Bhi~eJieHHeM o6pa3a rpuropHR
IlpOCBeTHTeJIR COCTaBHTeJIH rrporpaMMbi aJITapHOH pOCilHCH AxTaJihi CTpeMH
JIHCh IlO~qepKHYTh Hepa3phiBHYJO CBR3h apMRH-XaJIKH~OHHTOB C HaQHOHaJih
HOH KYJILTYPHOH Tpa~HQHeii, yKa3aTh Ha H3Ha'laJihHOe e~HHCTBO H npaBo
cnaBHe apMRHCKOH qepKBH. B aJITapHoii arrcu~e qepKBH TurpaHa 0HeHQa B
AHH, IlOCBR~eHHOH rpuropHIO IIpocBeTliTeJIIO, cpe~H CBRTHTeJieH rrpe~CTaBJieHhl He TOJihKO rpuropHH ApMRHCKHH, HO H ~Ba era ChiHa ApuCTaKec H
BpTaHec, rrocne~oBaTeJihHO cMeHRBUIHX OTQa. Ha enucKoncKOM npeCTone
ApMeHun42.
CocraBHTeJIH HKOHorpacpuqecKoii rrporpaMMhi AxTaJihi ~eMOHCTpHpOBaJIH
He TOJihKO ~peBHHe H~QHOHaJihHhie TPa~HQHH apMRHCKoii xanKH~OHHTCKOH qepKBH, HO H TeCHYJO CBR3h C rpy3HHCKOH MOHaUieCKOH TPa~HQHeH H B QeJIOM
202
c rpy3HHCKOH u:epKOBhiO. ApM11He-xaJIKB):(OHHThi H3):(aBHa MOHarneCTBOBaJIH
BMeCTe C rpy3HHaMH, OHH 06Jia):(aJIH onpe):(eJieHHOH aBTOHOMHeH H, B 'IaCT
HOCTH, npaBOM CJiy>KHTb JIHTyprmo Ha apMJIHCKOM H3hJKe43. YHHKaJihHbiH pH):(
H3 rneCTH H306paJKeHHH HaH60Jiee nO'IHTaeMbiX npen0):(06HbiX rpy3HHCKOH
u:epKBH BOnJIO~aJI B pocnHCH AxTaJihl TeMy "apM11HO-rpy3HHCKOH o6~HOCTH" . Ty JKe TeMy pacKpbiBaeT H apMJ~Ho-xaJIKH):(OHHTCKaH pocnHcb u:epKBH TurpaHa
OHeHu:a B AHH, r):(e K KOMn03HU:HH, CHMBOJIH'lecKH npe):(CTaBJIHIO~eH: '~YAO OCHOBaHHH rpy3HHCKOH u:epKBH, COTBOpeHHOe npOCBeTHTeJibHHU:eH rpy3HH
CB. HHHO, BnJIOTHYIO npHMbiKaeT JKHTHHHaH CU:eHa "BH):(eHHe CB. rpuropHH",
KOTOpaH, B CBOIO O'Iepe):(b, H306paJKaeT 'IY):(O OCHOBaHHH apM11HCKOH u:epKBH.
HKOHOrpa<l>H'leCKHMB cpe):(CTBaMH nO):('IepKHyTa CHMBOJIH'leCKaH 06IIJ:HOCTb
):(BYX BH):(eHHH. ~Ba qy~a OCHOBaHHH rpy3HHCKOH H apMHHCKOH u:epKBeH
npe):(CTaiOT B apMJIHO-XaJIKB):(OHHTCKOH HKOHOrpa<!>H'leCKOH nporpaMMe KaK
Hepa3pbiBHO CBH3aHHble MeQy co6oH: co6hiTHH44• Oco6ag pOJib rpuropHH
ApM11HCKoro KaK npocBeTHTeJIH He TOJihKO ApMeHHH, HO H Bcero KaBKa3a,
H3):(aBHa npH3HaHHaH Ha KaBKa3e, npuo6pena oco6yro 3Ha'IHMOCTh B cpe):(e
apM11H-XaJIKB):(OHHTOB45.
KoMn03HU:HH c H3o6paJKeHHeM cB. HHHO, He H3BecTHbie B rpy3HHCKHX
pocnucgx XI-XIII BB., B03MOJKHO, cym:ecTBOBaJIH B apMHHo-xaJIKH):IOHHTCKOH
pocnucu KupaHu:a. HcKJIIO'IHTeJibHhiH HHTepec K cB. HHHO B apMHHO-xaJIKH
):IOHHTCKOH cpe):le onpe):leJieH He TOJibKO 3Ha'leHHeM :nOH CBHTOH ):IJIH HCTOpHH
rpy3HH, HO H nereH):IOH 0 COTPY):IHH'leCTBe CB. HHHo c rpuropHeM ApMHHCKHM.
JlereH):(a cJIOJKHJiacb B ApMeHHH K VI B. H H3JIOJKeHa B "HCTopuu" MoBceca
XopeHaiJ:H.
JlH):IOB cnpaBe):(JIHBO nonaraeT, 'ITO HKOHorpa<t>uqecKaH nporpaMMa poc
nHCH AxTaJihl HBJIHeTCH U:eHHeHlliHM HCTOpH'IeCKHM HCTO'IHHKOM, CnOC06HbiM
3aMeHHTb He ):IOllie):llliHe ):(0 HalliHX ):IHeH nOJIHTH'leCKHe H 6orOCJIOBCKHe
TpaKTaTbl. 0Ha BOnJIOTHJia OC060e MHpOB033peHHe apMHH-XaJIKH):IOHHTOB, B
OCHOBe K(>Toporo JieJKaJia nocJie):IOBaTeJibHaH OpHeHTaU:HH Ha BH3aHTHIO H
rpy3HIO npH coxpaHeHHH Hepa3pbiBHbiX CBH3eH C HaU:HOHaJibHOH apMHHCKOH
cpe):(oH46.
B pocnHCH xpaMa Cnaca Hepe):IHU:hl He TOJibKO B306paJKeHHe CB. rpuropHH
H cB. HHHo HanoMBHaiOT pocnHcH apMHHo-xanKH):IOHHTCKHX xpaMoB. PH):I oco-
6eHHOCTeH: HKOHorpa<t>uqecKoH nporpaMMhi: H3o6paJKeHHe XpHCTa B o6pa3e
6enoro, KaK JIYHb, CTapqa "BeTXOrO ):leHbMB", KOTOpbiH CHMBOJIH3HpOBaJI Be~I
HOCTb BToporo nuu:a TpOHIJ:bi, H3o6paJKeHHe B Kynone XpHCTa IlaHTOKpaTopa
(a He ero Bo3HeceHHH), BHHMaHHe K BeTX03aBeTHhiM nepcoHaJKaM, U:HKJI
EoroMaTepu H cu:eHbi CTpawHoro cy):la - cxo):IHhi c HKOHorpa<t>u~IeCKOH nporpaMMoH AxTaJihi, a TaKJKe c nporpaMMoH u:epKBH <l>eo):lopa CTpaTHJiaTa B
HoBropo):(e47, r):(e nOHBHJIOCb BTOpoe no BpeMeHH H306paJKeHHe rpuropHH
IlpocBeTHTeJIH.
B XyThiHCKOM MOHaCTbipe Ha npaBOM 6epery Bonxosa, no-BH):(HMoMy,
6biJIH nOCTpOeHhl ):IBe u:epKBH BO HMJI rpuropHH flpOCBeTHTeJIH: nepBaH - B
1445 r., BTOpaH- B 1535-1536 rr. Ilocne):IHAA B XVII B. 6bma nepeCTpoeHa, H
ee H3o6paJKeHHe coxpaHHJIOCh B aJih6oMe nYTewecTBeHHHKa XVII B. A):laMa
OneapHH H Ha HKOHe "BH):IeHHe XyThiHCKoro noHoMapH TapacHH", HaXO):IH
IIJ:eiicH B HoBropo):ICKOM Mpee. Cy):IH no 3THM H3o6paJKeHHHM, XyThiHCKaH
u:epKOBh 6hma u:eHTPB'leCKHM CTOJinoo6pa3HhiM coopyJKemieM: Xannax'lhHH
203
OTMeqaeT .IIBHO npoCJie)KHBafO~YfOC.II B AaHHOM coopy)KeHHH aJIJif03HfO Ha
3sapTHOI.\ (XpaM DA.II~Hx CHJI), nocTpoeHHhiH B KOHI.\e VII B. apM.IIHCKHM
KaTOJIHKOCOM HepcecoM III CTpOHTeJieM, npHsep)KeHI.\eM xaJIKHAOHHTCTBa.
3sapTHOI.\, HMeBIIIHH 1.\eHTPHqecKH-BbiCOTHYfO pOTOHA006pa3HYIO KOHCTpyK-
1.\HfO, 6hiJI IIOCB.IIIIJ;eH rpHrOpHIO fipocBeTHTeJif048.
11 BHOBb, TaKHM o6pa30M, Mbl CTaJIKHBaeTC.II C B03MO)KHOCTbfO cy~eCT
BOBaHH.II B HosropoAe apM.IIHo-xaJIKHAOHHTCKOH o6~HHhi. llpaoocnaBHbie
1.\epKBH He MOrJIH npHBJieKaTb apM.IIH-MOHO<l>HCHTOB, a 1.\epKBH B qeCTb
rpHropH.II ApM.IIHCKoro He MOrJIH 6biTb paccqHTaHbl TOJibKO Ha pyccKyfO
nacroy.
HaM H3BeCTHO, qTo B 3anaAHOH H IO)KHOH PycH, B KHeBCKOM H raJIHI.\KO
BoJibiHCKOM KH.II)KeCTBe c XI-XII BB. cym;ecTBOBaJIH apM.IIHCKHe KOJIOHHH,
B OCHOBHOM MOHo<PHcHTCKHe. B KHese, Jlyl\Ke, JlhBOBe, KaMeHel\ llOAOJih
CKOM H APYrHx ropoAaX 6hiJIH nocTpoeHhi apM.IIHCKHe 1.\epKBH. ApM.~~:He, )KHBIIJHe B 3THX KOJIOHH.IIX, KpOMe npaBa Ha CTpOHTeJihCTBO 1.\epKBeH,
HMeJIH npaso Ha caMoynpasneHHe H cyA, 3aHHMaJIHCh Toprosneu, peMecna
MH, ceJibCKHM X03.11HCTBOM, cJiy)KHJIH B ool'lcKe49 . A o Ceoepo-BocTo~IHOH PycH, no-BHAHMoMy, )KHJIH npasocnaBHhie apM.~~:He. 113secTHO, qTo
apM.~~:He yqacTBOBaJIH B B03BeAeHHH xpaMOB so BnaAHMHpo-Cy3AaJibc
KOM KH.II)Kecroe . BMecre c TeM yqacrHe HHOBepl\eB B cTpOHTeJibCTBe KYJih
T OBhiX coopy)KeHHH 3anpem;anocb so scex cpeAHeBeKOBhiX penHrH.IIX. CneAOBaTeJibHO, MacTepa, yqacToosasnme B CTpOHTeJihCTBe xpaMOB Cesepo
BocToqHon PycH, 6hiJIH apM.~~:HaMH-xanKHAOHHTaMH. BepoHcnoBeAHall
o6~HOCTb ll03BOJI.IIJia apM.IIHaM CTPOHTb xpaMhl BMeCTe C pyccKHMH MaCTe
paMH.
lloMHMO KOcBeHHhiX AaHHhiX o npHCYTCTBHH apM.IIH B Ceoepo-BocToqHoii
PycH (rpa<P<PHTH, TOIIOHHMbi)50 cy~eCTByeT H apryMeHT ex silentio, AOCTa
TO~IHO y6eAHTeJihHbiH B OTJIHqHe OT apryMeHTOB TaKOro pOAa. ApM.IIHe
xaJIKHAOHHTbl 06bJq~o He BhiAeJI.IIJIHCb H3 npaBOCJiaBHOH naCTBbl HX eAH
HOBepl\aMH. rpeqecKHe H rpy3HHCKHe HCTOqHHKH HMeHOBaJIH HX "rpeKaMH"
( poMe.IIMH) HJIH " rpy3HHaMH", Aa H apM.IIHCKHe cpeAHeneKOBhie aBTOpbi
OTKa3biBaJIHCb npH3HaBaTh 3a npHH.IIBIIIHMH XaJIKHAOHHTCTBO OT rpeqecKOH
HJIH rpy3HHCKOH 1.\epKBeH apM.IIHaMH apM.IIHCKOe npOHCX0)KAeHHe51. 3Ta
TpaAHI.\Hll, npHIIIeAIIIall H3 ApMeHHH H BH3aHTHH, oqeBHAHO, 6oma yHacne
AOBaHHOH pyccKHMH KHH)KHHKaMH. Bo BC.IIKOM CJiyqae, OHH Ha3hiBafOT
1.\apeBHY AHHY H3 MaKeAOHCKOH AHHaCTHH "rpeKbiH.II", apM.IIHCKa.ll )Ke 1.\epKOBh
Ha 6epery BonrH HMeHyeTc.ll "rpeqecKoif nanaTou".
A.IT. CMHpHOB cqHTaeT, qTo 1.\eHTPOM apM.IIHCKOH KOJIOHHH, B03HHKrneif B
ropoAe Eonrapbi e~e AO 3noxH MOHrOJihCKoro 3aBoesaHH.II, .IIBJI.IIJiaCb 'Tpe
qecKall naJiaTa", HaXOAHBIIIa.IIC.II Ha 3aiiaAe OT ropOAHIIJ;a H npeACTaBJI.IIfO~all pa3BaJIHHhi xpHCTHaHCKOH 1.\epKBH. K 3TOMY )Ke speMeHH OH OTHOCHT H p.IIA
apM.IIHCKHX HaArp06HH 784, 770 H 757 rr. apM.IIHCKOrO JieTOHCqHcJieHH.II
(XIV B. H .3.)52 . HaH6onee paHHHM naM.IITHHKOM, CBHAeTeJibCTBYIO~HM o npe-
6 hiBaHHH apM.IIH B Eonrapax CMHpHOB nonaraeT MOrHJihHYIO IIJIHTY 1121 r oAa,
o 6Hapy)KeHHYIO y rpeqecKOH naJiaThl , 3a npeAeJiaMH ropOAH~a53 . CMHpHOB
y cT aHaBJIHBaeT, qTo a BOJI)KCKHX 6ynrapax Hap.~~:Ay c apM.IIHaMH- ToprOBhiMH
Ji fOAhMH 6biJIH H apM.IIHe-peM e CJieHHHKH, MaCTepa, CTpOHTeJIH, K aMeHO
TeCbl.
204
BoiDKCKHH nyrh BXOAHJI a TY MarnCTpaJib, KOTopasi coeAHIDma 3aKaaKa3be c Ceaepo-Bocro'IHOH PycbiO H HMeHoaanacb "apMHHCKOH AOporoH:", oHa uma OT HpaHa K IO)I{){biM 6eperaM KacnuiicKoro MOpR 'Iepe3 ceaepo-aoCTO'IHhie rpaHH~bl rpy3HH H An6aHHIO K YCTbiO BonrH H AaJiee qepe3 BynrapcKoe ~apcTBO. C Bonroii HoaropoA 6hm CBR3aH HeCKOJibKHMH uyTHMH: CeJIHrepCKHH, MCTHHCKHH, JiaAOrO-BOJI:lKCKHH, BbiTerpo-rneKCHHHCKHH"54. 3Ta AOpOra , o~IeBHAHO, CTaJia oco6eHHO aKTyaJibHOH, KOrAa nyTb "u3 aapRr B rpeKH" (oT BanTHHCKoro MOpR 'Iepe3 HoaropoA, CMoJieHcK, Kuea BHH3 no ,[J:Henpy K qepHOMY MOpiO) 6biJI 3a6JIOKHpOBaH HarneCTBHeM CeJibA)KYKOB, a n03AHee MOHrOJIOB.
PyccKHii neTonuceQ IIoaeCTH apeMeHHbiX neT 3HaeT, 'ITO 51<PeTy AOCTaJIHCb ApMeHHH BeJIHKaH H ManaH, "Konxuc" H "AJibBaHHR", T.e. rpy3HH H An6aHHH55. )J:aBHOCTb He TOJibKO BOeHHbiX, HO H TOprOBbiX nyTeH, CBH3biBaiOuzyiX Ceaepo-Bocro'IHYIO Pycb c 3aKaBKa3heM, noATBep)I{AaeTCH apxeonor H'IeCKHMH CBHAeTeJibCTBaMH. PaccMoTpea 3TH AaHHhie, H.A. Op6enH, pe30HHO 3aMe'IaeT: "He 6yAeM )Ke Mhl 06'hRCHRTb 6paK IOHOH rpy3HHCKOH ~apH~hl C cy3AaJihCKHM KHR)KH'IeM CJiy'IaHHOCTbiO, Bbi3BaHHOH <PaHTa3HeH OAHOrO H3 'IJieHOB BbiCOKoro co6paHHR 3HaTHeHlliHX <PeoAaJIOB rppuu"56. 3MHp KapTJIH A6y-n-AcaH peKOMeHAOBan 3TOMY co6paHHIO "chiHa pyccKoro anaAeTeJIR AHApeR, aeJIHKoro QapR, KOTopoMy nOA'IHHRIOTCR TpHcTa ~apeD: TaMOlliHHX MeCT, OCHpOTearnero B IOHOM B03pacTe, H3rHaHHOrO ero AHAeH CaaaJITOM (BceBOJIOAOM BOJihlliOe rHe3AO) H BbiH~eHHOro OCTaBHTh POAHYIO CTpaHy H 6e)KaTh K KHn'IaKCKOMY Qapw a ropoA CaHHA)K (CBHH)K)". )l(eHHBlliHCh a 1185 r. Ha QapHQe TaMap, IOpuU: Boronw6cKHii ao rnaae rpy3HHCKoro aoiicKa, B KOTOpoe BJIHJIHCh H ero "pyCbi", COBeplliHJI nOXOA Ha Kapc, 3p3epyM, raHA)Ky, IIapTaB H IllupaaH. Pe3yJibTaTOM ero noXOAOB 6biJIO OCB060)I{AeHHe
· JJ:auHa57. IIpu ABOpe ~apH~hi TaMap pHA aa)I{Heiirnux rrocToa 3aHHMaJIH apMHHe-XaJIKHAOHHTbl (HaaH3 3axapHA, HarrpHMep, - CHa'IaJia yrrpaBJIRIO~HH ABOpQOM, a nOTOM aTa6er- BbiClliHH THTYJI npH rppHHCKOM ABOpe). 3MHp KapTJIH, Aenaarnuii AOKJiaA o IOpuH KaK KaHAHAaTe a )KeHHXH rpy3HHCKOH QapH~bi , 6biJI apMRHHHOM-xanKHAOHHTOM H3 poAa ApQpyHH. B Ka'IeCTBe 3MHpa ·oH nOAAep)KHBaJI ToproBhie CBH3H c Ceaepo-BocTO'IHOH PychiO, a KOrAa B pe3yJihTaTe ero nOJIHTHKH COCTORJICR 6paK TaMap C pyccKHM KHR3eM, OH rrocrpoun a T6HJIHCH xpaM a 'IeCTb IOpHR, rrocaR~eHHhiH AHApew IIepao-3BaHHoMy, H3BeCTHbiH KaK reoprHeBCKaH, HoaHHO-BorOCJIOBCKaH ~epKOBb HJIH JiypA)K-MOHacTepu. Ero AeKop, no MHeHHIO HCKyccTBOBeAOB, 6JIH30K K OpHaMeHTaJihHhiM MOTHBaM nopTaJIOB C06opa PO)I{AeCTBeHCKOrO MOHaCTblpH ao BnaAHMHpe58.
IOpuU: AHApeeau'I ynoMHHYT a ABYX apMHHCKHX HaAIIHCHx H3 CaHaHHCKoro MOHaCTblpR (1185 H 1191 rr. )59 . K 3TOMY nepHOAY OTHOCHTCR H nHCbMO MOHaxa Toro )Ke MOHaCTblpH rpuropa TyTeOpAH K KHJIHKHHCKOMy KaTOJIHKocy rpuropHIO IV 0TpoKy. rpurop TyTeOpAH npeAJIO)KHJI KaTOJIHKocy B 6opb6e C BH3aHTHHCKOH ~epKOBbiO onepeTbCR Ha nOAAep)I{Ky <l>paHKOB, CHpHHQeB H pyccKOH ~epKau60 . C.T. EpeMRH C'IHTaeT, 'ITO B nOJIOBe~KHX CTenHX, rpaHH~Ia~HX C ceaepHOH rpy3HeH, CyiiJeCTBOBaJIH apMHHCKHe TOproBbie <PaKTOpHH. B npHnHcKe apMHHCKOH pyKonHcH yKa3aHo, ~rTo oHa KynneHa B 1193 r. B CTpaHe "JJ:ernTH KHn'IaKe"61, OAHOM H3 nyHKTOB Ha TOprOBOM nyTH Me)KAY ApMeHHeH H rpy3HeH H Ceaepo-BocTO'IHOH Pycb!O. A pMHHO-XaJI-
205
KHAOHHTCKHe KOnOHHH B rpy3HH npHHHManH AeXTenhHOe yqacTHe B 3TOH
ToproBne.
KaK ynoMHHanoch Bhiiiie, apMXHe, )KHBIIIHe B 3anaAHOH H IO)I{}{OH PycH, - B
OCHOBHOM MOHO<l>HCHThi, TaM CTpOHnHCh apMXHCKHe ~epKBH H yqpe:x<AanHCh
eiTHcKonaThi, nOABnaCTHhie 3qMHaA3HHCKOMY KaTonHKocy. ABO BnaAHMHpO
Cy3AanhCKOM KHX)I{eCTBe, TaK )l{e KaK H B HoBropoAe, HeT apMXHCKHX
~epKBeH H TeM 6onee apMXHCKHX CBX~eHHHKOB H enHCKOITOB, HeT AaHHbiX 0
BepOHCITOBeAHOH npHHaAne)I{HOCTH nepecenHBIIIHXCX CIOAa apMXH, OAHaKO,
ecnH yqeCTh, qTo apMXHe, <l>YHK~HOHHpOBaBUIHe BO BnaAHMHpo-Cy3AanhCKOM
KHX)I{eCTBe H B HoBropoAe, CTpoHnH H pacnHChiBanH npaBocnaBHbie xpaMbi,
TO OHH MOrnH 6biTh TOnbKO apMXHaMH-XanKHAOHHTaMH.
B npaBocnaBHhiX - rpeqecKoil, 6onrapcKoil, cep6cKoil, rpy3HHCKoil H,
oqeBHAHO, pyCCKOH ~epKBaX npaBOCnaBHhie apMXHe ITOnh30BanHCb paBHbi
MH npaBaMH C eAHHOBep~aMH H Aa)l{e HHOrAa He HMeHOBanHCb apMXHaMH.
ApMXH.e-xanKHAOHHThi - 3TO rpynna, BhiAen-HBIIIaxcx B cHny KOH<l>eccHo
HanbHOH H KynhTypHOH TpaHc<l>opMa~HH H3 apMXHCKOrO 3THOCa H ChirpaBUiax
cepbe3HYIO ponh B HCTOpHH CTpaH BH3aHTHHCKOrO KynhTYPHOrO Kpyra.
BocnpHHMqHBOCTb apMXH-xanKHAOHHTOB K pa3nH~hiM KY!fhTYPHhiM BnHX
HHeM H HX "HHAYKTOpHaSI." ponh CBSI.3aHbl C 6onee IIIHpOKHM, He)l{enH y
HX COOTeqeCTBeHHHKOB-MOHO<l>HCHTOB, Kpyrq30pOM, o6ycm;mneHHhiM BhiXO
AOM Ha KOH<l>ecCHOHanhHO 6nH3KHe HM CTpaHhl BOCTOqHOrO npaBOCnaB
HOrO MHpa. IIIHpOTa BOCllpHSI.THX CTaHOBHTCSI. 3aTeM <PaKTOpOM KynhTyp
HOrO pa3BHTHX H KynhTypHOrO BnHXHHX 3TOH rpynnhl. 0HH B onpeAeneH
HOH CTeneHH npeABOCXHTHnH COBpeMeHHbiH 3KyMeHH3M, llOMep)KHBax HAeiO
c6nH)I{eHHX H 06neAHHeHHSI. XpHCTHaHCKHX KOH<l>eCCHH, B npo~ecce ocy~e
CTBneHHSI. KOTOpOH OHH MOrnH 6hi OKa3aThCSI. B ponH He3aMeHHMbiX
nocpeAHHKOB.
IlO)I{anyif, HHKTO ceJiqac He COMHeBaeTCSI. HH B MHOronnaHOBOCTH, HH B
qacToTe KOHTaKTOB .IJ.peBHeii PycH H ApMeHHH KaK npHMbiX, TaK H ono
cpeAOBaHHhiX qepe3 BH3aHTHIO H AHacnophi: apMXHCKYIO H ApeBHepyccKyro
(IloBOn)l{be, KpbiM, EonrapHX).
CBH3H ApMeHHH c PychiO B XI-XIV BB. 6hmH MHororpaHHhiMH: o6-
~eCTBeHHo-nonHTuqecKHe, penHrH03Hbie, 3KOHOMHqeCKHe, HH<l>OpMa~HOHHhie, 3THOKynhTYPHhie. KoMnneKcHoe H3yqeHHe apMHHo-pyccKHX CBSI.3eii B
X-XIV BB. B03MO)I{H0 TOnhKO Ha OCHOBaHHH BCeH MaCChi HCTOqHHKOB, HOBOrO
npoqTeHHX y)l{e H3BeCTHbiX H BBeAeHHSI. B 060pOT HOBhiX AaHHbiX •
.SJ.P . .IJ.aiiiKeBHq cnpaBeAnHBO OTMeqaeT, qTO oqeHh Mano H3yqeHbl BOnpOChl
o6~eCTBeHHo-nonHTHqecKHX cs:sl3eil .IJ.peBHeii PycH H ApMeHHH, TpaHc<l>opMH
poBaBIIIHXCSI. B ycnOBHSI.X Hcqe3HOBeHHSI. apMSI.HCKOH rocyAapCTBeHHOCTH B
KOHTaKTbl KOH<l>eCCHOHanhHOrO xapaKTepa62•
H, A06aBniO x, OHH He MoryT 6hiTb H3yqeHhi YAOBneTBOpHTenhHbiM o6pa-
30M AO TeX nop, llOKa apMXHe paCCMaTpHBaiOTCSI. KaK KOH<l>eCCHOHanhHOe H
KynhTypHoe eAHHCTBO. HanHque B cpeAe apMXHCKoro 3THoca 3HaqHTenbHOH
xanKHAOHHTCKOH o6~HHbi H ee aKTHBHOCTb B BH3aHTHH H CTpaHax BH3aH
THHCKoro KynhTypHOrO Kpyra- npo6neMa, K KOTOpOH Mbl eABa llOAOIIInH, H ee
H3yqeHHe MO)I{eT He TOnhKO nponHTb onpeAeneHHhiH CBeT Ha BOllpOCbl
apMXHCKOH KOnOHH3a~HH, HO H 3allO~HHTh HeKOTOpbie naKYHbl HappaTHBHbiX
HCTOqHHKOB.
206
'/ 'i/9 JlaaapeB B .H . CKynbnT}'pa Bnall;HMHpO-Cy3,11aJtbcKOH Pycu II Jicropull pyccKoro ucKyccrsa. M., 1955. T. I. C. 396-441.
1 Xa11nax~bJlH O .X. KyJibT}'pHbie CBli3H Bna,IIHMHpo-Cy3AaJtbCKOH Pycu u ApMeHHH. M., 1977. \ C. 13-14; CM. TaJOKe: JleJieKOB Jl.A . JiCKYCCTBO }l;peBHeH Pycu B ero CBll3liX C BOCTOKOM II
}l;peBHepyccKoe HCKYCCTBO. M., 1973. C. 55-80. 3 Op6e11u 11.A . An(iaucKue penbe!J>bi u 6poH30Bbie KOTJibi II l'l36p. TPYAbi. Epesau, 1963.
c. 360. 3) .L --~..<... ,.)4 AUBQ3JIH K .B . KynbT rpuropHll ApMeHCKOro, "apMeHcKall Bepa" H "apMeHCKall epecb" B
Hosropo~~;e (XIII-XVI BB.) II PyccKall u apMl!HcKall cpe,IIHeBeKOBbie nurepaTypbi.JI., 1982. ~C. 255-272 u cne,11. •
A~H . . pesuepyccKHe HCTO'IHHKH nepHO,IIa KHeBCKOH Pycu (XI-XII BB.) 0 rpuropHH llpOCBeTHTeJie, "apMeHCKOH sepe" H "apMeHCKOH epecu" II nHTepaTypHbJe CBli3H. EpeBaH, 1981. T. III. c. 5-82; On xe. KyJibT rpuropHll ApMeHCKoro ... c. 255-332. CM. yKa3aHHYIO
- JIHTeparypy 0 pyccKO-apMl!HCKHX HCTOpH'IeCKHX H KYJibT}'pHbiX CBll3liX (C. 256-257 H CJie,ll.).
\ 6 AUBQ3JIH K.B. KyJibT rpHrOpHll ApMeHCKOro ... c. 271-333. 7 Ter-Nersessian S. Les portraits de Gregoire I'Illuminateur dans l'art Byzantin II Byzantion. 1966. y T. 36; fasc. 2. Bruxelles, 1967. P. 388.
AuBa311H K .B . }l;peBHepyccKBe HCTO'IHHKB .•. C. 92. 9 AUBQ3JIH K .B . KyJibT rpuropHll ApMeHCKOro ... c. 259-272.
10 MeAuK-Baxuum c.r. llaBJJHKBaucKoe ll;BIDKeHBe B ApMeuuu. Epesau, 1955. XoTll cyll\eCTByeT COJIH,IIHO <I>YHAHpOBaHHal! pa6oTa H.r. rapcol!H (The Paulician Heresy. A Study of the Origin and Development of Paulicianism in Armenia and the Eastern Provinces of the Byzantine Empire. Hague; Paris, 1967), a HCTO'IHBKH nepeBe,lleHbi P.M. BapTBKliHOM (BapmuKRH P.M . JicroqHHKH ,IIJIII H3y'leHHll HCTOpHH naBJIHKHaHCKOro ll;BIDKeHHll. EpeBaH, 1961).
ll KaaaKOBQ H.A .• Jlypbe H. C. AHTH!J>eOAaJibHbJe epeTH'IeCKHe ABHJKeHHll Ha Pycu xrv - Ha'laJia
'-/ XVI B. M.; JI., 1955. C. 35-55 u cne,11. LL .- . ..-<. ~ _ C(?v;-a._v.f) :~. AUBQ3JIH K.B. KyJibT rpuropHll ApMeHCKOro .•. c. 306-309. cr ::rt~ }U v &e?.. L 10&'.
TaM lKe. C. 309-317. p }t . .9t --? · 14 TpouqKuu 11. li3JIOlKeHHe uepbi apMl!HcKoit CTI6., 1875. C. 248. 15 AuBQ3JIH K.B. KyJibT rpuropHll ApMeHCKOro ... c. 328. 16 Mapp H.H. ApKayu, MOHrOJibCKOe Ha3Bauue xpucruau B CBli3H c BOnpocoM o6 apMl!Hax-
XaJIKH,IIOHHTax II BB. CTI6., 1905. T. XII. llpHJI. C. 33-36. 17 B 3TOH 06JiaCTB BOCTO'IHal!l(epKOBb 6biJia ropa3,110 repnBMee 3aJta,IIHOH. l8 Mapp H .H . YKa3. CO'I. C. 35. 19 TaM lKe; MypaiJRH n. Heony6JIHKOBaHHal! CTaTbll H • .SI. Mappa o6 "ApKayue" II li3B. AKa,lleMHH
uayK ApMCCP. 0611\eCTB. uayKH. 1964. N! 12. C. 51-52; J(M.umpueBcKuu A. TiyrerneCTBHe no BocroKy u ero uay'IHbie pe3yJibTaTbi. KHeB, 1890. llpun. II. C. 181.
20 Mapp H .H. YKa3. CO'I. C. 36. rc:;_2- Actes d'Esphigmenou I Ed. diplolllatique par J. Lefort. P., 1973. P. 45. ~2!);1iB. Coq,nACKal! PYKOllBCb N! 1245. JI. 229. .
23 Mnax~bJIH O.X. KyJibT}'PHbie CBII3H Bna,~~BMHJ>o-Cy3,11aJtbCKoA Pycu u ApMeHHH. C. 10-11. ~ 24 KHeBo-lle'lepcKBA narepHK no ApeBHHM pyKonuciiM. KueB, 1870. C. 88-93.
) 25 OzanecRH Jl.A . JicropHII MeABI(HHbl B ApMeHHH c ,llpeBueAIIIHx BpeMeH u ,110 uarnux AHeA. -;. EpeBaH, 1946. 'I. II. C. 68.
l rpuzopbRH K .H. Ji3 HCTOpHH pyccKo-apMIIHCKHX JIHTepaT}'pHbiX H KYJibT}'PHbiX OTHOIIIeHHH (X- Ha'l. XX B.). EpeBau, 1974. C. 24-25.
Zl-'faliH!te.-G.-25. 8 ApymKJHOBa-tz;uiJaHRwB.A. ApMIIHe-xanKH,IIOHHTbi ua BOCTO'IHbiX rpaHul(ax Bu3aHTulicKoA
HMDepHH (XI B.). Epeaau, 1980. C. 57-75. 29 KaxiJan A.ll. ApMJIHe B COCTaue rocnoACTBYIOU\ero KJiacca Bo3auTHlicKoli HMnepuu. EpeBaH,
1975. c. 129-130. 30 Mammeoc Ypxae14u. Xpouorpa!J>HII. BanaprnanaT, 1898. C. 206.
' 31 Codex Vaticanus. 3. Slavicus glagoliticus.
v 32 A6zapRH r.B. K npo6JieMe npe,llnonaraeMOli rpe'leCKOit aepCBH "CKa3aHHII 0 Bopuce H rne6e" II PyccK811 u apMl!HcKal! cpe,IIHeaeKOBbie JIBTepaT}'Pbi. C. 247-248·.
207
V 33 JlaaapeB B.H. licKyCCTBo HosropoAa. M.; JI., 1947. C. 36.
1; 34 EpuqoB A.P.. nepsoHa'laJihHoe 3HaKOMCTBO apMIIH c cesepo-BOCTO'IHOii PychiO AO BOJ.IapeHHll
AOMa PoMaHOBbJX B 1613 r.// KaBKa3CKHH BeCTHHK. 1901. N!! 12. C. 50, 51. V 35 tpuzopbRH K.H. 113 HCTOpHu ... C. 20. i ' 36 KaKOBKUH A .H. 06 H306paJKeHHH fpuropHll npocBeTirrenll Ha penHKBapHH 1293 r. II BeCTH.
061J.1eCTB. HayK AH ApMCCP. 197 I. N!! II. C. 84. \ 37 Ter-Nersessian S. Les portraits de Grigoire ..• P. 386--395. \1 38 Me.tluKcem-BeK JI.M. fpy3HHcKHe HCTO'IHHKH o6 ApMeHHH u apMliHax. EpesaH, 1936. C. 260. ( 39 Ter-Nersessian S. La reliquire de Skevra et l'orfevrerie cilicienne aux xm• et XIV• siecles II Revue
. des etudes arrneniennes. P., 1964. T . I. P. 121-134, 143-147; KaKOBKUH A.H. YKa3. CO'!. c. 84-88.
\ 40 MeAuKcem-BeKJI.M. 06 apMliHo-rpy3HHo-naTHHo-pyccKOH sepcHllx roMunHii, cBll3biBaeMbJX c V IIMeHeM HoaHHa Eorocnosa II BB. M., 1960. T. XVII. C. 72.
41 MypaORH JJ.M. KaBKaJCKHH KynbT}'PHbiH MHp H KynbT fpuropHll npocBeTHTenll II KaBKa3 H I Bu3aHTHll. EpeBaH, 1982. Bbm. 3. C. 19.
\. ~ Lidov A. The mural paintings of Akhtala M., 1991. P. 39. ~ ~- J--b ( 43 Apym/OHOBa-t/JuoaHRH B.A . YKa3. co'!. C. 76. /
'Cc--! 44 Lidov A. Op. cit. P. 75. 45 Mypai>RH JJ.M. KasKa3cKHii KynbTYJ'HbJH MHp ... C. 9-20. ~A. Op. cit. P. 76.
47 0 npOToeBaHrenbCKOM J.IHKne B BH3aHTHHCKHX H ApeBHepyccKHX naMliTHHKaX CM.: JlaaapeB B.H. JiCTOpHll BH33HTHHCKOii lKHBOnHCH. M., 1986. C. 93 H cneA. r ,.-
( 48 XaAnax'lbRH O.X. ApMliHo-pyccKHe KynbrypHbJe OTHOWeHHll H ux OTPaJKeHue B apxHTeKrype. EpesaH, 1957. C. 17-18. HccneAOBaTenb nonaraeT, 'ITO 3TOT THn xpaMa (3sapTHOQ), HaWeAWHii WHpOKOe pacnpOCTP3HeHHe B ApMeHHH H fpy3HH, 3HaMeHOBan HOBbiH 3Tan H B pyccKOH a XHTeK"rype (TaM JKe).
Ai1Ba3RH K.B. KynhT fpuropull ApMeHcKoro .. . C . 305-306. 50 TaM JKe. C. 306--308. 51 Apym/OHOBa-t/JuoaHRH B.A . YKa3. co'l. C . 60--61. 52 CMupHOB A .II. BonJKCKHe 6ynrapbl// Tp. roc. HCTOp. MyJell. M.,. 1951 . Bbm. XIX. c . 59-QO. 53 TaM JKe. C. 143 54 Pbt6u~~a EA . Apxeonoru'!ecKHe oqepKH HCTOpHH HOBropOACKOii roprosnu. M., 1978. C. 23. 55 nCPJI. Cll6., 1846. T. I. C. 2. 56 Op6eJiu l1.A. YKa3. co'!. C . 360. 57 KapTnHC Uxospe6a. cn6., 1850. 'I. I , Bbln. 2. fpy3. TeKCT I liJA. Epocce. c. 284-285; 0'1epKH
- HCTOpHH CCCP. IX-XIII BB. M., 1958. c. 573. 58 XMnax'lbRH O.X. KynbTYJ'HbJe CBliJH BnaAHMHpo-Cy3A3nbcKoii Pycu H ApMeHHH. C. 34. 59 EpeMRH C. T. IOpHii Eoron106cKHii no apMliHCKHM u rpyJHHCKHM HCTO'IHHKaM II Tp. EpesaHcK.
roc. yH-Ta. 1946. T . 23. · 60 P.awKeBU'l H.P. ApeBHllll Pycb u ApMeHHll B 061J.1eCTBeHHo-nonHTH'IeCKHX CBll3liX XI- XIII BB.
(liCTO'IHHKH, uccneAOBaHHll, TeMbl) II nr. 1982 r. M., 1984. c. 180-18 I. 61 EpeMRH C.T. YKa3. co'!. C. 392-393. 62 P.awKeBU'l H.P. YKa3. CO'!. C. 194. CM. TaM JKe o63op HCTO'IHHKOB H nocBl!IJ.IeHHOii HM nHTe
parypbl (C. 179-182 H cneA.) .
CIII1COK COKPAII(EHI1H
AE
BB
BAH BH.!J.
n-1s
.ur JJ.Uf )I(MI-IIl KCHA
- ApxeorpacjJwleCKHil e>KeroAHHK
- BuJaunllicKIIi'l upeMeHHHK
- BecrHIIK ApeuHeil ucropuu
- BcnoMoraTeJJbHble ucropwleCKHe AHCL\HnJJHHbl
- rocy)1apcr8eHHall Hal\IIOH3Jlbllall 6116JJIIOTeKa (npe>K)1e: rns liM. M.E. CaJJTbiK08a-
lll,e)1p1H1a)
- .IJ.pc8Hei'lwue rocy11apcr8a Ha TeppHTOp1111 CCCP. MaTepHaJJbl 11 ucCJJeA083HHll
- .!J.yxoBHble "AOf080pHble rpaMOTbl uemiKIIX 11 yAeJJbHbiX KHliJelt XIV- XVI 88.
- )l(ypH3J1 MIIHIICTepcrua Hap0/1HOf0 npOC8ell.\eHHll
- KpaTKHe coo611.\e11Hll HHCTIITyTa apxeoJJorHII
KCHHMK - KpaTKHe co0611.\eHHll HncTuTyTa unop1111 Man:pH<tJILIIOit KYJJbTYPbl
MHA - MaTepuaJJbl 11 HCCJJe)1o8aHHll no apxeoJJonnl CCCP
1-m11 111311 llCPJl
PrBHA
PHG
C A
C B
C K. c6.
T O.IJ.Pll
- HonropoAcKall nepuall JJeTonHcb cTapwero 11 MJJa)1wero H380/10B
- llo8eCTb upeMeHHbiX JJeT
- lloJJHoe co6paHue pyccKHX JJeTonHceil
- POCCIIHCKIII"I rocyAapcr8eHHbiH BOeHUO-IICTOp11'1eCKHH apx~m
- PyccKall HCTOpl!'lecKall 6u6mloTeKa
- Co8eTcKall apxeoJJOn!ll
- Cpe11H11e 8eKa
- CKaHAlmaucKnil c6opm1K
- TpyAbl 0TAeJJa ApeuHepyccKOH JJI!TepaTypbl HHCTHTyTa pyccKort Jli!Tepnypbl
(llywKIIIICKI!It ADM) AKaAeMHH HayK CCCP
CO ,IJ;EP)J(AHI1E
OT peAKonnernn...... .. .. .......................... ................................................. .. ................................. 3
Coepo11oo M .B .
06pa3oBaHne )J.peBHepyccKoro rocyAapCTBa (11cropnorpaQ>nqecKHe JaMeTKn) ..............•. 6
MellbHUKoea EA . K TRnonor HH npel\fOCYI\3pCTBeHHbiX H paHHerocyAapCTBeHHblX o6pa30B3HHii B CeBep-HOU n CeBepo-BocroqHoii EBpone (lloCTaHOBKa npo6neMLI) ......................................... .. ... 16
Kom11JJp H .C/>.
0 COJ.IH3nbHOii cy~HOCTH )J.peBHepyccKoro rocyAapCTBa IX - nepBoii nonoBRHbl X B....... 33
TopcKuii A.A .
KpnBnqn n nonoqaHe s IX-X ss. (BonpocbJ nonHTH'JecKoii ncropHH) .................... ............ SO
C/>o.MuHA .B .
Jl.peBuepyccKne AeHelKHO-MOHeTHbJe pblHKH B 70-80-x ro11ax X B. ...................................... 63
K y 'IKUH B.A .
"PyccKall 3eMnll" no neronncHLIM AaHHbiM XI - nepBoii TpeTH XIII s............................... ... 74
BeO/OutKUHa H.B.
"Pycb" H "PyccKaJJ 3eMmt" B lloseCTH BpeMeHHbiX neT H neTOnHCHbiX CT3TbllX BTopOii TPeTn XII - nepsoii TPeTH XIII B. ............... .. ................ .. ............ ...................... .. ......... ... .. ....... I 0 I
llempyxuH B .H.
CnaBIIHe, uap11rn n xa3apbl Ha w re PycH. K npo6neMe q>opMuposaHRII TeppuTopnn JJ.pesuepyccKoro rocyAapcrsa ........ ...................... .. ...... ......... ... ............................. . ........•. ... .. ... 117
Hmm BJT.
K sonpocy o 11are cocrasneun11 o63opa "A ce HMeHa rpaAOM nceM pyccKbiM, 11anuHM 11 6nHlKilHM" ............................... ....... .........•...................•..................... ...................... ....•.. ............ 125
KUJIUHUHQ T .M .
T epMRH "nJOAR AOMa" ("axn an-6aAT") y 116H <l>311naHa no OTUOU!CHHJO i< o6tQecroy
pycoo ······ ···· ·· ······ ·····:····· ··························································· ·· ·································· ········ ······ 134
KoHOoU/Ioea H.T.
Paccxa3 o TPeX rpynnax pycoo o coqnueHHIIX apa6cKRX aoropoB XII-XIV BB. .. .. ........ ....... 139
J1o6poOoMoo H .r .
K oonpocy o "cepe6p11HbJX 6ynrapax" ..........•..•........................•....... .............. ......................... 149
HaaapeHKO A .B.
E 11.1e pa3 o AaTe noeJAKH KHilrHHH OnLrn B KoHCTBHTRHononb: ucroqHuxouew•ecxne 3aMeTKH..... ... ... ... ................................. ........................... ................................................ .. .......... 154
218
nepXalfiW IJ.I j,
JleTOn11CIIbli1 flcpCHCJi iiiiCI\ 1111 ) ~YIIaC.. ......... .. . ............................ ... .. .. . . .... . .. . . ... ......... .. . .. . .. .. . ... 168
11113/IIWIIII l U I .
PyccKO-JI<l'ITf\Ji hCK IIC KOIITiiK'I'hl B X II- X III oo. o cseTe r eHeaJJorHH KHS!Jei"l EpcHKe 11 K OKIICCC .. ... ... .. ... .................. ................. .... ... ...... .... ............... ................. ....... .. ............... .... ........ 182
Apy1111111101111- <1>111)1111111t 11.11 .
flpaooCJJallllbiC apMH IIC 11 'cocpo-13ocTO'lHOI1 Pyc11 ............................ .. ...... .................. .. ...... 196
6 H6JII10rpacl>•u• pa6 T, o ny6JIIIKOBaunbiX COTPYIIHI1KaMH OT/ICJJa HC.'TOplm /lpesuei1w 11 X rocy11apCTo illll cTuTyTa pocculkKOi'II1CTOpHH PAH o 1990- 199 1 r r ................ ... ................ .. 209
C nHCOK coKpa11WII 11 i1 ............ ..... .................. .. .... ... ... .. .. .. ... .. ... ..... .... ... .... ... ....... .. .................. .... .. 217
Ha}"'HOe Hlllanue
)J.PEBHEtllliHE fOCY)J.APCfBA BOCfOYHOH EBPOnbi
MaTepuanbi 11 IIccneiiODaHHH 1992-1993 rojlbi
Ymaep)I{Oeuo "ne•~amu /1ucnwmymoM poccuikKoiiucmopuu r AH
3aBCIIYIOU(aH pejlaKL\IICH "l-IayKa-HcTopull" 1-I.Jl. n eTpooa
Pe11aKTOP 113/laTenbCTDa C.A . Jleouua XYIIOlKeCTBeHHbiH pejlaKTOp B./0. HKOOAea TexHH'IecKHH pellaKTOp 11.H. JK.MyJ>Klii«J KoppeKTopbi fiJI. To11y6tjoaa, 3.)1,. AileKceeaa
HE N9 994 Jl.P. Ng 020297 OT 27 IIOS16pS1 1991 r.
C11a11o B ua6op 31.08.94 nojlnHcaHO K ne'laTif 13.12.94.
<l>opMaT 60x90 1/16· rapmiTypa TaiiMC. n c•!aTl.o ocjJCCTIIaSI Ycn.ne'l.n. 14. Ycn.Kp.oTT. 14,3. Y'l.-111/l.n. 15 ,6 T11paJK 1300 3K3. Tun. laK. 32 /-(>
113/laTenbCTDO "1-IayKa" 117864 rcn-7, MocKDa 8-485 npocfJCOIOlllaSI yn. , 90
CanKT-TieTep6yprcKaH THnorpac!Jnll No I PAH 199034 CanKT-neTep6ypr 8-34, 9-SI nuuull, 12