Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center...
Transcript of Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center...
![Page 1: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Flight Testing
ACAT/FRRPAutomatic Collision Avoidance Technology / Fighter Risk Reduction Project
Mark SkoogACAT Project Manager
NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 2: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
BACKGROUND
88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 3: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal
Common Modular Architecture for All Aircraft
Transition Technology from Research to Production ASAP to begin Mishap Rate Reduction 5 Fatalities and 7 Mishaps Due to CFIT that were
Preventable Since Project Start
23:1 ROI
Approach
Utilize the Small Team of Experts
Primary Products Technology Guides
Modular Software Architecture
Milestones
Flying May 2009 through Mar 2010
3
Mountain Home Air Show, September 15, 2003
Lives A/C $B Type
USAF GCAS 62 81 3.7 F-16, F-22, F-35
USAF+USN 247 283 12.7 F-16, F-22, F-35, F-18
15 Jun 07 Night Spatial Disorientation
88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 4: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Auto-Collision Avoidance
Development 22 Years of Development on the AFTI/F-16
Ground & Air Collision Avoidance
AFRL Managed
Over 2500 Auto-Recoveries in Flight
Over 40 Evaluation Pilots
Prevented the Loss of the
AFTI/F-16 in 1995
Findings
1. Do No Harm
2. Do Not Interfere
3. Prevent Collisions
Collision Avoidance is a
Crosscutting Technology4
Background
88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 5: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
Design CriteriaIn Order of Priority
1. Do No Harm• Only maneuver the aircraft if there is reasonable
certainty that it will not make the situation worse
• Integrity Management
2. Do Not Impede the Pilot from Performing
Mission Operations• Nuisance free flight
• Algorithm & Flight Controls
3. Prevent Collisions• Save lives
• Algorithm & Flight Controls
88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 6: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Auto GCAS
Common Architecture
6
Integrity
Management
Integrity
Management Predict Evasion Trajectories
Predict Collision Threat
Representation
Determine Need to Evade
Notify
• Evasion Types
• Maneuvering Capability
• Evasion Trajectory Estimations
• Associated Uncertainties
• Scan/Track Pertinent Threat
• Simplify Threat Profile
• Associated Uncertainties
• Minimum Approach
• Integrity Check
• Time to Evade
• Command Evasion
• Alert
• Record
• Recall
Pilot Controls
• Mode Selection
• Interface
Sense
Own-State
• Sufficient to
support
trajectory
estimation
Trajectory Predictions
Sense
Terrain
• DTED• Map Handler
Evade
• Integrity Check
• Execute
•. Evasion
88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 7: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Auto GCAS Description
7
• Automatically Prevents Collision with the Ground
– Avionics Project Future Aircraft Trajectory Over Digital Terrain
– Avionics Request an Evasion Maneuver at Last Instance
– Flight Controls Automatically Perform Recovery
Recovery model easily tailored to different aircraft
No additional sensors required
High authority autopilot momentarily takes control from pilot
Embedded integrity monitoring prevents erroneous system behavior
Pilot selectable recovery (PARS) for disorientation cases
88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 8: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Collision AvoidanceDescription
8
Integrity
Management
Integrity
Management
Integrity
Management
Integrity
Management
Predict Evasion TrajectoriesPredict Evasion Trajectories
Predict Collision ThreatPredict Collision Threat
RepresentationRepresentation
Determine Need to EvadeDetermine Need to Evade
NotifyNotify
• Evasion Types
• Maneuvering Capability
•• Evasion Trajectory EstimationsEvasion Trajectory Estimations
•• Associated UncertaintiesAssociated Uncertainties
• Scan/Track Pertinent Threat
•• Simplify Threat ProfileSimplify Threat Profile
•• Associated UncertaintiesAssociated Uncertainties
•• Minimum ApproachMinimum Approach
•• Integrity CheckIntegrity Check
•• Time to EvadeTime to Evade
•• Command Evasion Command Evasion
•• AlertAlert
•• RecordRecord
•• RecallRecall
Pilot ControlsPilot Controls
•• Mode SelectionMode Selection
•• InterfaceInterface
Pilot ControlsPilot Controls
•• Mode SelectionMode Selection
•• InterfaceInterface
SenseSense
OwnOwn--StateState
•• Sufficient to
support
trajectory
estimation
SenseSense
OwnOwn--StateState
•• Sufficient to
support
trajectory
estimation
Trajectory Predictions
SenseSense
TerrainTerrain
• DTED• Map Handler
EvadeEvade
•• Integrity CheckIntegrity Check
•• Execute Execute
••.. EvasionEvasion
EvadeEvade
•• Integrity CheckIntegrity Check
•• Execute Execute
••.. EvasionEvasion
Advanced Data Transfer Equipment (ADTE)
Advanced Data Transfer Unit (ADTU)
Collision Avoidance Algorithms
Advanced Data Transfer Cartridge (ADTC)
Digital Terrain Elevation Data (DTED)
88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 9: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Scanning Process Overview
9
1. Generate Scan
Shape
2. Collect Terrain
Points3. Generate 2-D Profile
(max height in each
range bin)
RangeTe
rra
in E
leva
tio
n
Digital Terrain Elevation Posts
Range radii.
Integrity
Management
Integrity
Management
Integrity
Management
Integrity
Management
Predict Avoidance TrajectoryPredict Avoidance Trajectory
Predict Collision ThreatPredict Collision Threat
RepresentationRepresentation
Determine Need to AvoidDetermine Need to Avoid
NotifyNotify
• Evasion Types
• Maneuvering Capability
•• Evasion Trajectory EstimationsEvasion Trajectory Estimations
•• Associated UncertaintiesAssociated Uncertainties
• Scan/Track Pertinent Threat
•• Simplify Threat ProfileSimplify Threat Profile
•• Associated UncertaintiesAssociated Uncertainties
•• Minimum ApproachMinimum Approach
•• Integrity CheckIntegrity Check
•• Time to EvadeTime to Evade
•• Command Evasion Command Evasion
•• AlertAlert
•• RecordRecord
•• RecallRecall
Pilot ControlsPilot Controls
•• Mode SelectionMode Selection
•• InterfaceInterface
Pilot ControlsPilot Controls
•• Mode SelectionMode Selection
•• InterfaceInterface
SenseSense
OwnOwn--StateState
•• Sufficient to
support
trajectory
estimation
SenseSense
OwnOwn--StateState
•• Sufficient to
support
trajectory
estimation
Trajectory Predictions
SenseSense
TerrainTerrain
• DTED• Map Handler
AvoidAvoid
•• Integrity CheckIntegrity Check
•• Execute Execute
••.. EvasionEvasion
AvoidAvoid
•• Integrity CheckIntegrity Check
•• Execute Execute
••.. EvasionEvasion
2pt. Fan
6pt. Fan
Circular
88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 10: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Trajectory Prediction
Model Recovery
Delay Phase
3-D Integration of A/C
States
Maneuver Phase
3-D Model of Autopilot
Straight Line Phase
Prediction of Recovery After
Flyup
10
Delay
Phase
Maneuver
Phase
Post-Maneuver
Phase
Roll to Wings Level
5-g Pull
Zoom Climb
Final Climb
• Model Aircraft
– Mass Properties
– Configuration
– Available Thrust
Integrity
Management
Integrity
Management
Integrity
Management
Integrity
Management
Predict Avoidance TrajectoryPredict Avoidance Trajectory
Predict Collision ThreatPredict Collision Threat
RepresentationRepresentation
Determine Need to AvoidDetermine Need to Avoid
NotifyNotify
• Evasion Types
• Maneuvering Capability
•• Evasion Trajectory EstimationsEvasion Trajectory Estimations
•• Associated UncertaintiesAssociated Uncertainties
• Scan/Track Pertinent Threat
•• Simplify Threat ProfileSimplify Threat Profile
•• Associated UncertaintiesAssociated Uncertainties
•• Minimum ApproachMinimum Approach
•• Integrity CheckIntegrity Check
•• Time to EvadeTime to Evade
•• Command Evasion Command Evasion
•• AlertAlert
•• RecordRecord
•• RecallRecall
Pilot ControlsPilot Controls
•• Mode SelectionMode Selection
•• InterfaceInterface
Pilot ControlsPilot Controls
•• Mode SelectionMode Selection
•• InterfaceInterface
SenseSense
OwnOwn--StateState
•• Sufficient to
support
trajectory
estimation
SenseSense
OwnOwn--StateState
•• Sufficient to
support
trajectory
estimation
Trajectory Predictions
SenseSense
TerrainTerrain
• DTED• Map Handler
AvoidAvoid
•• Integrity CheckIntegrity Check
•• Execute Execute
••.. EvasionEvasion
AvoidAvoid
•• Integrity CheckIntegrity Check
•• Execute Execute
••.. EvasionEvasion
88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 11: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
FLIGHT TEST
88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 12: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Auto GCAS Test Objectives
1. Collect data on individual subsystem contributions to
overall Auto GCAS error budget
Navigation Solution
Digital Terrain Elevation Data
Autopilot Precision
2. Evaluate the ability of Auto GCAS to stay within pilot
physiological limits during a recovery
3. Evaluate Auto GCAS in an operationally representative
envelope
Collision Prevention Across Flight Envelope
Evaluation of Mission Impact
1288ABW-2009-1524
![Page 13: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
Block Test Flow
1313
Flight Control Autopilot PARS Change
GCAS Features Added
Flight Control Autopilot & SWIM Change
GCAS Avionics AddedProduction Flight Controls
USAF Avionics in Test
Avionics mux Change
New Instrumentation
Baseline
F-16
Systems
Instro
Checkout
ARegression
Of F-16
Systems
SWIM
PARS
CA
Smooth
high
CA
Mtn
high
B
Nuisance
Potential
Structured
CA
Smooth
low
CA
Mtn
low
Nuisance
Potential
Non-Structured
C E
Nuisance
Potential
-
Operational
Assessment
D
Regression
Of F-16
Systems
GCAS
Regression
New PARS
Features
New GCAS
Features
Demos
88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 14: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
Test Sites
14
Warlock Peak
GCAS Mtn
Edwards Area
88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 15: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
Test ResourcesFlight / Real-Time
Test Aircraft F-16D Block 50
M5.1 Baseline In Flight Test
Auto-GCAS Modifications
Instrumentation On-Board Recording
Hardwired
PLA
Speed Brake
Total Mux
Ethernet
HUD Video
Voice
Real-Time Hardwired PLA & Speed Brake
Select Mux
Select Ethernet
HUD Video
Hot Mike 15
• Mobile Mission Control Room (MMCR)– Front End
• Mobile
• Antenna
• Chapter 10
• Decryption
– Control Room• Modified Trailer
• 8 Workstations
• IADS
• Dual UHF Radios
• Multi-RV A-Cs
• Indep. Generator
88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 16: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Flight Test Scope Envelope
200 knots to Vmax
To 90o Dives
Upright to Inverted
Stores Variations
Terrain Variations
1688ABW-2009-1524
![Page 17: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
17
Test Safety Philosophy
Recovery
Initiation
Too Late
Available
Reaction
TimeRecovery Profile
If Delayed
Time is a Better Metric than Distance
• Measure of Performance
– Available Reaction Time
– Normalizes Dependencies on Dive & Speed
– Accounts for A/C Performance
• Uses High-Fidelity Simulation for Predictions
88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 18: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
Test Example
18
88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 19: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
The Contraption Concept
19
Ad
justa
ble
Ta
rge
tin
g S
ite
“ABORT, ABORT,
ABORT!”
88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 20: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Smooth Terrain
Test Approach Technical
Validate Simulation & PARS
Collect Data where Sim is Poor
Verify PARS Nuisance Potential Evaluation
Demonstrate Mishap Prevention
Safety Simulate all Runs First
Execute initial Runs with ≥ 4 Seconds of Available Reaction Time prior to Build Down
Build Down Specific “Mishap” Runs to No Lower than 1.5 sec. of Available Reaction Time
3, 2, 1.5 sec. Progression/Sequence
Sequence Stopped as Crew Reaches Comfort Threshold
Crew will Monitor Ground Proximity
Control Room will Monitor Abort Parameters
Altitude, Dive, Bank, Airspeed (KCAS/KTAS), System Status
20
Runs Conducted at
Lower Available
Reaction Time
88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 21: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Typical Collision Avoidance Run
a. Confirm TCB, PRTA, and Setup
Conditions with Control
b. Turn Base to IP, Call “Overflying IP, Mark”
c. “Control Ready – Cleared to Maneuver”
d. Establish Setup Conditions Aiming at
Warlock Peak
e. Confirm AGCAS ACTV & Call “On
Conditions”
f. Control Calls Count Down
g. If Control Calls ABORT Before Recovery
Initiation: Engage PARS with Gun Trigger & Manually Recover
h. After Flyup, Allow A/C to Clear Peak
Before Maneuvering
i. Rate Recovery
21
Example of Current Version of Run Card
Smooth Mountain Abort Low Alt Eval
Warlock Peak Procedures
88ABW-2009-1524
![Page 22: Flight Testing ACAT/FRRP - NASA...ACAT Project Manager NASA/Dryden Flight Research Center 88ABW-2009-1524 BACKGROUND 88ABW-2009-1524 Fighter Risk Reduction Project FRRP Goal Common](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070219/612eb0581ecc51586942f8d9/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
QUESTIONS
88ABW-2009-1524