Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit...

28
Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit Analytics at TCU WCARS, November 2016 Monica Chaves

Transcript of Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit...

Page 1: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Federal Court of Accounts(TCU)

Strategy for Diffusion of Audit

Analytics at TCU

WCARS, November 2016

Monica Chaves

Page 2: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Types of Supreme Audit Institutions

• Courts of Audit or Courts of Accounts:

Brazil, France, Belgium, Luxemburg, Spain,

Italy, Greece, Portugal.

• National Audit Offices:

United States, Canada, United Kingdom,

Ireland, Denmark, Peru, Chile.

Page 3: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

To improve public administration for the

benefit of society through external control

Federal Court of Accounts (TCU)

Page 4: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Federal Court of Accounts – Main Functions

Auditing Judgment Appealing

Page 5: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Federal Court of Accounts - Outlook

Population – 206.6 million

Gross Domestic Product (GDP) – USD 2.3 trillion

Area – 8.5 million sq. km

5,570 municipalities

26 states and the Federal District

Page 6: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Federal Court of Accounts - Structure

Headquarters in Brasília

2575 Employees

9 Ministers and 4 Substitute-ministers

49 Business Units

Regional offices in all 26 states

1707 Auditors

Page 7: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Information

Reports

Auditings

Decisions

Reports

Page 8: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Information is essential ...

... In order to improve the effectivenessand timing of external control.

Is this a new reality?

Why is it so important today?

Page 9: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Complex problems

+

Abundance of information

+

Technology available

New Scenario

Page 10: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Efficiency ...

Effectiveness

Do better

&

Select better what to do

Page 11: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

• Large variety of different personal skills

• Some “panic” about the use of analytics

• Important doubts about the potential results

of applied analytics

• More information than we can deal with

Scenario - Inside the institution

2015

Page 12: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

How to increase the use of

analytics in this scenario?

How to go further using data

analysis to be more effective?

Page 13: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Governance

SkillsPlatform

Page 14: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Governance

~ Chief Data

Officer (CDO)Leadership

Organization

Page 15: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

To organize the information[from Public Administration] and make

it [easy to use] universally

accessible [when possible] and

useful [to auditors and citizens].

Page 16: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Skill

Decentralization

Empowerment

Page 17: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Data Analysis

Diagnosis

40 skills considered

491 answers

217 auditors interested in using data

analysis techniques

Page 18: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Programa de capacitaçãoTraining program

Page 19: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Decentralization

Business Unit

CDO

Page 20: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Platform

Information

Technology

Page 21: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

PublicData

CustodyData

InternalData

Central DB Applications

~56 Databases~7 terabytes

TCU Departments

Society

Page 22: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

• Virtual machine with data andanalytics tools

• Around 400 internal users and a 50 external users

• Partners – 17 Courts ofAccounts and other controlinstitutions

Control Information Lab (LabContas)

Page 23: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

This is not about using data the way we

used to do. It is about trying to figure

out how to use analytics to identify

new opportunities to plan and

perform an audit engagement in a

more efficient manner.

Page 24: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Problem

Knowledge

Internal and

external

information

Information

technology

Advanced

analytics

techniques

Page 25: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

• 300 Biddings/ day

• 6.300 Biddings/month

Timely

Bidding Judgment Procurement

Page 26: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Recent biddings ordered by

Materiality and Risk

ALICE

Page 27: Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) Strategy for Diffusion of Audit ...raw.rutgers.edu/docs/wcars/38wcars/Presentations/WCARS_Monica... · To improve public administration for the benefit

Digital Control