February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at...

19
811 West 7 th Street, 9 th Floor, Los Angeles, California, 90017 • Phone: 424.263.9359 • www. enviro-intel.com February 27, 2019 Mr. Robert Welch Project Manager City of Beverly Hills 345 Foothill Road Beverly Hills, CA 90210 Mr. Daniel Comorre Sr. Director, Construction Management Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority One Gateway Plaza, 17th Floor Los Angeles, CA 90012 Subject: Segment 2 - Purple Line Extension Project ICM Weekly Report February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 Dear Mr. Welch and Mr. Comorre: Environmental Intelligence, LLC (EI) has been retained by the City of Beverly Hills (COBH) and the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority (Metro) to serve as the independent compliance monitor (ICM) during construction of the Purple Line Extension Project. Monitoring is required to ensure that construction is in compliance with (1) the Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) for Southern California Edison’s (SCE’s) Advance Utilities Relocation Phase of the Purple Line Extension Project Segment 2 Between the City of Beverly Hills and the Los Angeles Metropolitan Transportation Authority (City Agreement No. 384-17), (2) the MOA for the Third Party Advance Utility Relocation Phase of the Purple Line Extension Project Section 2 - Between the City of Beverly Hills and the Los Angeles Metropolitan Transportation Authority (City Agreement No. 648-17) and (3) the Agreement titled "Demolition and Public Right-of-Way Use Permit for the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority and its Contractor to Clear All Buildings and Existing Improvements at 9430 Wilshire Boulevard, Install Noise Monitoring Equipment and Sound Walls for Future Construction and a Laydown Area for the Wilshire/Rodeo Station of Section Two of the Purple Line Extension Project" (Agreement dated June 5th, 2018). The following information summarizes the ICM monitoring activities that occurred at the Segment 2 site (Rodeo Station site) during the week of February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019. Construction activities were not conducted on February 17 or 18. Construction activities during the week included installing the track beam on the sound wall and building the gates at the Ace Gallery yard, assembling scaffolding on the Wilshire perimeter of the North Canon yard, setting up fencing with sound blankets along the alley perimeter of the North Canon yard, excavating sewage lines, and fault investigation boring. EI ICMs were present during all construction activities and conducted routine noise measurements at selected noise monitoring locations as well as compliance checks in accordance with the MOAs and associated attachments, exhibits, traffic closure notifications, and traffic management plans. At the conclusion of each work shift, daily monitoring reports were prepared by each ICM. Attachment B (Daily Monitoring Reports) provides detailed daily monitoring reports and photographs of construction activities. VIOLATION SUMMARY During the week, EI ICMs identified one (1) violation during construction activities. Table I provides a summary of the violation identified during the week of February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 and Exhibit 1 provides a location map for the submitted violation. Details for the violation are included as Attachment

Transcript of February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at...

Page 1: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

811 West 7th Street, 9th Floor, Los Angeles, California, 90017 • Phone: 424.263.9359 • www. enviro-intel.com

February 27, 2019

Mr. Robert Welch

Project Manager

City of Beverly Hills

345 Foothill Road

Beverly Hills, CA 90210

Mr. Daniel Comorre

Sr. Director, Construction Management

Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority

One Gateway Plaza, 17th Floor

Los Angeles, CA 90012

Subject: Segment 2 - Purple Line Extension Project ICM Weekly Report

February 17, 2019 – February 23, 2019

Dear Mr. Welch and Mr. Comorre:

Environmental Intelligence, LLC (EI) has been retained by the City of Beverly Hills (COBH) and the Los

Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority (Metro) to serve as the independent compliance

monitor (ICM) during construction of the Purple Line Extension Project. Monitoring is required to ensure

that construction is in compliance with (1) the Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) for Southern California

Edison’s (SCE’s) Advance Utilities Relocation Phase of the Purple Line Extension Project – Segment 2 –

Between the City of Beverly Hills and the Los Angeles Metropolitan Transportation Authority (City

Agreement No. 384-17), (2) the MOA for the Third Party Advance Utility Relocation Phase of the Purple

Line Extension Project – Section 2 - Between the City of Beverly Hills and the Los Angeles Metropolitan

Transportation Authority (City Agreement No. 648-17) and (3) the Agreement titled "Demolition and

Public Right-of-Way Use Permit for the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority and

its Contractor to Clear All Buildings and Existing Improvements at 9430 Wilshire Boulevard, Install Noise

Monitoring Equipment and Sound Walls for Future Construction and a Laydown Area for the

Wilshire/Rodeo Station of Section Two of the Purple Line Extension Project" (Agreement dated June 5th,

2018). The following information summarizes the ICM monitoring activities that occurred at the Segment

2 site (Rodeo Station site) during the week of February 17, 2019 – February 23, 2019. Construction

activities were not conducted on February 17 or 18.

Construction activities during the week included installing the track beam on the sound wall and building

the gates at the Ace Gallery yard, assembling scaffolding on the Wilshire perimeter of the North Canon

yard, setting up fencing with sound blankets along the alley perimeter of the North Canon yard, excavating

sewage lines, and fault investigation boring. EI ICMs were present during all construction activities and

conducted routine noise measurements at selected noise monitoring locations as well as compliance checks

in accordance with the MOAs and associated attachments, exhibits, traffic closure notifications, and traffic

management plans. At the conclusion of each work shift, daily monitoring reports were prepared by each

ICM. Attachment B (Daily Monitoring Reports) provides detailed daily monitoring reports and photographs

of construction activities.

VIOLATION SUMMARY

During the week, EI ICMs identified one (1) violation during construction activities. Table I provides a

summary of the violation identified during the week of February 17, 2019 – February 23, 2019 and Exhibit

1 provides a location map for the submitted violation. Details for the violation are included as Attachment

Page 2: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

Robert Welch

Daniel Comorre

February 27, 2019

Weekly_Report_Section_2_0217-0223_EI01_20190227

A. Daily monitoring reports and photographs of construction activities are provided as Attachment B (Daily

Monitoring Reports). Daily noise monitoring data are provided in Attachment C (Noise Monitoring Data

Log).

CONCLUSION

To date, 48 violations have been issued, four (4) of which have been rescinded since the beginning of

construction of the Purple Line Extension Project – Segment 2. Project construction activities are ongoing

and EI ICMs continue to monitor all construction activities applicable to the MOA on a daily basis.

If you have any questions or comments regarding this letter, please contact me directly at 310.469.8989 or

[email protected].

Sincerely,

ENVIRONMENTAL INTELLIGENCE, LLC

Jeremiah George

Project Manager

Attachments: Attachment A: Violations

Attachment B: Daily Monitoring Reports

Attachment C: Noise Monitoring Data Log

cc: Valerie Mudegoren, City of Beverly Hills

Alexander Cantwell, Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority

Kimberly Wilson, Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority

David Cooper, Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority

Namrata Cariapa, Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority

Stacy Sinclair, Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority

Hank Scheetz, Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority

Brett Barnett, Psomas

Bill Zein, Psomas

Farzad Vakilitabar, Psomas

Alex Kay, City of Beverly Hills

Page 3: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

811 West 7th Street, 9th Floor, Los Angeles, California, 90017 • Phone: 424.263.9359 • www. enviro-intel.com

TABLE I: VIOLATION SUMMARY (FEBRUARY 17 – FEBRUARY 23, 2019)

Violation

ID Date Time ICM Location Condition Violated

Iteration -

Violation Metro Response

48 2/19/2019 07:38 Yani Pohl 9430 S Reeves Dr

Ace Gallery

Demolition

Permit Condition

42(e) and 60

1 - Warning

Page 4: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

Exhibit 1 : Violation Location (February 17 - February 23, 2019)Section 2 - Rodeo Station | City of Beverly Hills, CA

SOUR

CE: b

ing M

aps,

ESRI

Worl

d Tran

sport

ation

and W

orld I

mage

ry Ba

se M

aps,

LACM

TA, C

ity of

Beve

rly H

ills

!( Violation Location (with Violation ID)

Envir

onme

ntal In

tellig

ence

. I:\C

ity of

Beve

rly H

ills\C

ompli

ance

Mon

itorin

g Svc

RFQ

17-3

- Marc

h 201

7\02_

GIS_

Data\

maps

\2019

\Wee

klyRe

ports

\Sec

tion2

_Rod

eo\20

1902

17_to

_201

9022

3\Exh

01_V

iol_E

I01_2

0190

226.m

xd

City ofLos Angeles

City ofBeverly Hills

«0 400200

Feet1:2,400 1 in = 200 feet

Updated: 2/26/2019

Coord

inate

Syste

m: N

AD 19

83 S

tateP

lane C

alifor

nia V

FIPS

0405

Feet,

Proj

ectio

n: La

mbert

Con

forma

l Con

ic, D

atum:

Nort

h Ame

rican

1983

Page 5: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

ICM Violation Form - Section 2 AUR MOA 648-17 (1)

Latitude:Longitude:Elevation: 228

34.066808-118.398079

UID:1395  Date:2/19/2019  ICM Violation Form - Section 2 AUR MOA 648-17

NotesAt 7:38 hours, the ICM Yani Pohl observed a CSI delivery vehicle parked on S. Reeves Blvd south of Wilshire Blvd. Parking, staging or queuing of project-related vehicles is prohibited on city streets at all times and thus parking the delivery truck on S. Reeves is a violation of Ace Gallery Demolition Permit Condition 42(e) and 60. The ICM notified Luis Garcia (Metro) of the violation. This is the first incidence of this violation at this location within the last ten days.

Violation Details1. Violation ID 482. Violation Iteration 1 - Warning3. Time of Violation 7:384. Address 9430 S Reeves Dr

Applicable Measures5. Memorandum of Agreement No. 648-176. Exhibit A: Third Party Utility Permit and City of Beverly Hills Conditions for Approval7. Exhibit D: Metro 5-Step Noise Control Plan for Advanced Utility Work in Beverly Hills8. Other Plans Other Plans (see notes)•9. Other Plan Description Ace Gallery Demolition Permit Conditions 60 and

Attachment AViolations

This report was generated by Environmental Intelligence, LLC - www.enviro-intel.com - Copyright (2019)1590 S. Pacific Coast Hwy, Suite 17 | Laguna Beach, California 92651 | (949) 497-0931 1/1

Report Tracking: Created by Yani Pohl on 2/19/2019 8:44:43 PM, Approved by Jeremiah George on 2/19/2019 11:32:28 PM

Page 6: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

This report was generated by Environmental Intelligence, LLC - www.enviro-intel.com - Copyright (2019) 1590 S. Pacific Coast Hwy, Suite 17 | Laguna Beach, California 92651 | (949) 497-0931

1/10

Attachment B Daily Monitoring Reports

2/17/2019 - 2/23/2019

Summaries (8)

Date

Monitor

Location

Time

Compliant

Summary

Tuesday, February 19, 2019

Yani Pohl

Rodeo

07:30:00 to 16:00:00

No

Contractors/Subcontractors: LBI, CSI, Silverado, TPOG, Vertical Access

Representatives On-Site: Joe De La Torre (LBI); Luis Garcia (Metro); Andrew Briggs (TPOG), Juan Castellanos (Silverado), Oscar Rivera (Vertical Access), Robert Renteria (Metro); Phil Lattuca (Psomas), Robert Espanoza (TPOG), Casey Underwood (TPOG), Nathan Burich (TPOG)

Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd

The ICM was in possession of applicable COBH-approved closure notifications, TCP for the day's work, and the Ace Gallery Demolition Permit and North Canon Property Demolition Permit. Work was conducted from 8:00 hours to 16:00 hours on February 19th, 2019. EI ICM Yani Pohl met with Metro Inspector Luis Garcia and Foreman's Jose Del Torre, Andrew Briggs, Juan Castellanos and Oscar Rivera to discuss the day's activities. At the beginning of the shift, the ICM calibrated the sound meter at (93.9) 94.00 dB.

Work for the day included installing the track beam on the sound wall and building the gates at the Ace Gallery yard, assembling scaffolding on the Wilshire perimeter of the North Canon yard, setting up fencing with sound blankets along the alley perimeter of the North Canon yard and excavating sewage lines. Traffic was closed in the curbside lane and sidewalk of Wilshire Blvd between 9:00 - 16:00 hours in accordance with COBH LCN 20 N Canon Demolition Lane and Sidewalk Closures.

Violation ID # 48 At 7:38 hours, the ICM Yani Pohl observed a CSI delivery vehicle parked on S. Reeves Blvd south of Wilshire Blvd. Parking, staging or queuing of project-related vehicles is prohibited on city streets at all times and thus parking this delivery truck on S. Reeves is a violation of Ace Gallery Demolition Permit Conditions 42(e), 60. The ICM notified Joe Del Torre (LBI) and Luis Garcia (Metro) of the violation. This is the first incidence of this violation at this location within the last ten days.

Date

Monitor

Location

Time

Compliant

Summary

Tuesday, February 19, 2019

Christian Elgabalawi

Rodeo

19:45:00 to 05:15:00

Yes

Contractors/Subcontractors: Fugro; STV; Global ASR; TPOG

Representatives On-Site: Kelly Shaw (Furgo); Shanton Rangi (Metro); Tony Perez (Psomas); Walter Lopez (Fugro)

Work Location(s): Wilshire Blvd. eastbound number two and three lanes between Santa Monica Blvd and S. Spaulding Dr.; Full closure of all S. Spalding Dr. lanes 20 meters south of Wilshire.

The ICM was in possession of applicable COBH-approved closure notifications and TCP for the night's work from 19:45 hours to 05:30 hours on February 19, 2019. EI ICM Christian Elgabalawi met with Fugro representative Kelly Shaw and Metro Inspector Shanton Rangi to discuss the night’s activities. At the beginning of the shift, the ICM calibrated the sound meter at 94.00 (94.00) dB.

Work for the night included fault investigation boring on the south side of Wilshire Blvd. several meters east of Santa Monica Blvd to S. Linden Ave.

Page 7: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

This report was generated by Environmental Intelligence, LLC - www.enviro-intel.com - Copyright (2019) 1590 S. Pacific Coast Hwy, Suite 17 | Laguna Beach, California 92651 | (949) 497-0931

2/10

Attachment B Daily Monitoring Reports

2/17/2019 - 2/23/2019

Date

Monitor

Location

Time

Compliant

Summary

Wednesday, February 20, 2019

Yani Pohl

Rodeo

07:45:00 to 16:15:00

Yes

Contractors/Subcontractors: LBI, CSI, Silverado, TPOG, Vertical Access, Star 1 MS

Representatives On-Site: Joe De La Torre (LBI); Luis Garcia (Metro); Reynaldo Avalos (CSI), Art Miranda (Star 1 MS), Andrew Briggs (TPOG), Juan Castellanos (Silverado), Oscar Rivera (Vertical Access), Phil Lattuca (Psomas), Casey Underwood (TPOG), Nathan Burich (TPOG), Alex Lapostol (Metro), Alex Kay (COBH), Darek Dumon (TPOG)

Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd

The ICM was in possession of applicable COBH-approved closure notifications, TCP for the day's work, and the Ace Gallery Demolition Permit and North Canon Property Demolition Permit. Work was conducted from 8:00 hours to 16:15 hours on February 20th, 2019. EI ICM Yani Pohl arrived on site at 7:45 hours and met with Metro Inspector Luis Garcia and Foreman's Jose Del Torre, Andrew Briggs, Juan Castellanos, Reynaldo Avalos and Oscar Rivera to discuss the day's activities. At the beginning of the shift, the ICM calibrated the sound meter at (93.9) 94.00 dB.

Work for the day included building the gates and assembling scaffolding at the Ace Gallery yard, assembling scaffolding on the Wilshire perimeter of the North Canon yard, setting up fencing with sound blankets along the alley perimeter of the North Canon ard and potholing for sewage lines in the N. Canon yard. Traffic was closed in the curbside lane and sidewalk of Wilshire Blvd between 9:00 - 15:00 hours in accordance with COBH LCN 20 N. Canon Demolition Lane and Sidewalk Closures.

Date

Monitor

Location

Time

Compliant

Summary

Wednesday, February 20, 2019

Christian Elgabalawi

Rodeo

19:45:00 to 04:30:00

Yes

Contractors/Subcontractors: Fugro; Tri-County Drilling; STV; Global ASR; TPOG

Representatives On-Site: Kelly Shaw (Furgo); Shanton Rangi (Metro); Tony Perez (Psomas); Walter Lopez (Fugro); Francisco Duarte (STV); Bill Orton (Tri County Drilling)

Work Location(s): Wilshire Blvd. eastbound number two and three lanes between Santa Monica Blvd and S. Spaulding Dr.; Full closure of all S. Spalding Dr. lanes 20 meters south of Wilshire.

The ICM was in possession of applicable COBH-approved closure notifications and TCP for the night's work from 19:45 hours to 04:30 hours on February 20, 2019. EI ICM Christian Elgabalawi met with Fugro representative Kelly Shaw and Metro Inspector Shanton Rangi to discuss the night’s activities. At the beginning of the shift, the ICM calibrated the sound meter at 94.00 (94.00) dB.

Work for the night included fault investigation boring on the south side of Wilshire Blvd. several meters east of Santa Monica Blvd to S. Linden Ave.

Page 8: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

This report was generated by Environmental Intelligence, LLC - www.enviro-intel.com - Copyright (2019) 1590 S. Pacific Coast Hwy, Suite 17 | Laguna Beach, California 92651 | (949) 497-0931

3/10

Attachment B Daily Monitoring Reports

2/17/2019 - 2/23/2019

Date

Monitor

Location

Time

Compliant

Summary

Thursday, February 21, 2019

Yani Pohl

Rodeo

07:45:00 to 18:00:00

Yes

Contractors/Subcontractors: LBI, Silverado, TPOG, Star 1 MS

Representatives On-Site: Joe De La Torre (LBI); Luis Garcia (Metro); Art Miranda (Star 1 MS), Juan Castellanos (Silverado), Phil Lattuca (Psomas), Casey Underwood (TPOG), Joe Alexander (TPOG)

Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd.

The ICM was in possession of applicable COBH-approved closure notifications, TCP for the day's work, and the Ace Gallery Demolition Permit and North Canon Property Demolition Permit. Work was conducted from 7:45 hours to 18:00 hours on February 21th, 2019. EI ICM Yani Pohl arrived on site at 7:45 hours and met with Metro Inspector Luis Garcia and Foreman's Jose Del Torre, and Juan Castellanos to discuss the day's activities. At the beginning of the shift, the ICM calibrated the sound meter at (93.9 dB) 94.00 dB.

Work for the day included hanging the gates and lug bolting the sound panels at the Ace Gallery yard and potholing for sewage lines in the N. Canon yard. At 15:40 hours TPOG's crew arrived and installed lighting in the canopy scaffolding along the Wilshire perimeter of N Canon yard until 18:00 hours.

Date

Monitor

Location

Time

Compliant

Summary

Thursday, February 21, 2019

Christian Elgabalawi

Rodeo

19:45:00 to 05:00:00

Yes

Contractors/Subcontractors: Fugro; Tri-County Drilling; STV; Global ASR

Representatives On-Site: Kelly Shaw (Furgo); Shanton Rangi (Metro); Tony Perez (Psomas); Walter Lopez (Fugro); Francisco Duarte (STV); Bill Orton (Tri County Drilling)

Work Location(s): Wilshire Blvd. eastbound number two and three lanes between Santa Monica Blvd and S. Spaulding Dr.; Full closure of all S. Spalding Dr. lanes 20 meters south of Wilshire.

The ICM was in possession of applicable COBH-approved closure notifications and TCP for the night's work from 19:45 hours to 05:00 hours on February 21, 2019. EI ICM Christian Elgabalawi met with Fugro representative Kelly Shaw and Metro Inspector Shanton Rangi to discuss the night’s activities. At the beginning of the shift, the ICM calibrated the sound meter at 94.00 (94.00) dB.

Work for the night included fault investigation boring on the south side of Wilshire Blvd. several meters east of Santa Monica Blvd to S. Linden Ave.

Page 9: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

This report was generated by Environmental Intelligence, LLC - www.enviro-intel.com - Copyright (2019) 1590 S. Pacific Coast Hwy, Suite 17 | Laguna Beach, California 92651 | (949) 497-0931

4/10

Attachment B Daily Monitoring Reports

2/17/2019 - 2/23/2019

Date

Monitor

Location

Time

Compliant

Summary

Friday, February 22, 2019

Yani Pohl

Rodeo

07:45:00 to 16:30:00

Yes

Contractors/Subcontractors: LBI, Silverado, TPOG

Representatives On-Site: Joe De La Torre (LBI); Luis Garcia (Metro); Juan Castellanos (Silverado), Phil Lattuca (Psomas), Casey Underwood (TPOG), Jerry Martinez (TPOG)

Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd

The ICM was in possession of applicable COBH-approved closure notifications, TCP for the day's work, and the Ace Gallery Demolition Permit and North Canon Property Demolition Permit. Work was conducted from 7:45 hours to 16:30 hours on February 22th, 2019. EI ICM Yani Pohl arrived on site at 7:45 hours and met with Metro Inspector Luis Garcia and Foreman's Jose Del Torre, Jerry Martinez and Juan Castellanos to discuss the day's activities. At the beginning of the shift, the ICM calibrated the sound meter at (93.9) 94.00 dB.

Work for the day included hanging the gates and lug bolting the sound panels at the Ace Gallery yard and removing LBI's equipment from the yard. At 13:00 hours LBI crew left the project site. TPOG's crew laid sandbags at the perimeter of the N. Canon yard, removed chainlink fencing and laid gravel around the Ace Gallery yard.

Date

Monitor

Location

Time

Compliant

Summary

Friday, February 22, 2019

Daniel Chang

Rodeo

20:00:00 to 05:15:00

Yes

Contractors/Subcontractors: Fugro; Subsurface Surveys; STV

Representatives On-Site: Dustin Marlow (Fugro); Daniel Matticks (Subsurface Surveys); Shanton Rangi (Metro); Tony Perez (Psomas); Kelly Shaw (Fugro)

Work Location(s): N. Canon yard; Wilshire Blvd. eastbound number two and three lanes between Santa Monica Boulevard and Spalding Drive.

The ICM was in possession of applicable COBH-approved closure notifications and TCP for the night's work from 20:00 hours to 05:15 hours on February 22nd, 2019. EI ICM Daniel Chang met with Metro Inspector Shanton Rangi to discuss the night’s activities. At the beginning of the shift, the ICM calibrated the sound meter at 93.9 (94.00) dB.

Work for the night included fault investigation boring on the south side of Wilshire Blvd. several meters west of Spalding Drive. In addition, the TCP road closure was set up at approximately 20:30 hours and removed at 05:15 hours.

A noise reading was done outside of the North Canon Drive yard in order to determine the sound levels of the generator within the yard. Throughout the evening the condition of the canopy lights (on/off) were also monitored.

NOTE: Due to a staffing issue D. Chang spot checked swing-shift work on Section 1 between 20:00-22:30.

Page 10: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

This report was generated by Environmental Intelligence, LLC - www.enviro-intel.com - Copyright (2019) 1590 S. Pacific Coast Hwy, Suite 17 | Laguna Beach, California 92651 | (949) 497-0931

5/10

Photos

Photos (31)

UID:

Date:

1411

Feb 19, 2019

Latitude:

Longitude:

34.067

-118.409

Type:

Notes

Construction Activity Elevation: - - -

The photo shows drilling crew preparing site for fault drilling.

UID:

Date:

1412

Feb 19, 2019

Latitude:

Longitude:

34.067

-118.408

Type:

Notes

Construction Activity Elevation: - - -

The photo shows drilling crew preparing site for fault drilling.

UID: 1397 Latitude: 34.067213

Date: Feb 19, 2019 Longitude: -118.39679

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 226

Notes

The photo shows Vertical Access assembling scaffolding along perimeter of the N. Canon yard.

UID: 1399 Latitude: 34.067371

Date: Feb 19, 2019 Longitude: -118.396805

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 260

Notes

The photo shows TPOG crew installing sound blanket fencing at N Canon yard.

UID: 1396 Latitude: 34.066714

Date: Feb 19, 2019 Longitude: -118.398071

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 230

Notes

The photo shows LBI crew drilling holes for track beam at the Ace Gallery yard.

Page 11: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

This report was generated by Environmental Intelligence, LLC - www.enviro-intel.com - Copyright (2019) 1590 S. Pacific Coast Hwy, Suite 17 | Laguna Beach, California 92651 | (949) 497-0931

6/10

Photos

UID: 1402 Latitude: 34.067474

Date: Feb 19, 2019 Longitude: -118.397026

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 231

Notes

The photo shows Silverado crew excavating sewing lines in the N. Canon yard.

UID: 1401 Latitude: 34.067495

Date: Feb 19, 2019 Longitude: -118.397068

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 212

Notes

The photo shows TPOG crew setting up sound blankets around mini excavator in the N. Canon yard.

UID: 1400 Latitude: 34.066761

Date: Feb 19, 2019 Longitude: -118.398141

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 230

Notes

The photo shows LBI crew building gates in the Ace Gallery yard.

UID: 1398 Latitude: 34.0667

Date: Feb 19, 2019 Longitude: -118.398107

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 268

Notes

The photo shows LBI crew installing track beam at the Ace Gallery yard.

UID:

Date:

1418

Feb 20, 2019

Latitude:

Longitude:

34.066

-118.408

Type:

Notes

Construction Activity Elevation: - - -

The photo shows Geotech drillers preparing drill rig.

Page 12: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

Photos

This report was generated by Environmental Intelligence, LLC - www.enviro-intel.com - Copyright (2019) 1590 S. Pacific Coast Hwy, Suite 17 | Laguna Beach, California 92651 | (949) 497-0931

7/10

UID: 1404 Latitude: 34.067178

Date: Feb 20, 2019 Longitude: -118.397342

Type: General Elevation: 229

Notes

The photo shows TPOG setting out cones and signs for traffic closure of sidewalk and curb lane along Wilshire Blvd.

UID: 1405 Latitude: 34.067004

Date: Feb 20, 2019 Longitude: -118.39817

Type: General Elevation: 228

Notes

The photo shows LBI truck removing backhoe from the Ace Gallery yard.

UID: 1409 Latitude: 34.067474

Date: Feb 20, 2019 Longitude: -118.396971

Type: Pre-Activity Elevation: 233

Notes

The photo shows TPOG crew setting up sound blanket fencing along alley perimeter of the N. Canon yard.

UID: 1408 Latitude: 34.066742

Date: Feb 20, 2019 Longitude: -118.398231

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 227

Notes

The photo shows LBI crew constructing sound wall gates in the Ace Gallery yard.

UID: 1403 Latitude: 34.066926

Date: Feb 20, 2019 Longitude: -118.398134

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 225

Notes

The photo shows CSI scaffolding truck arriving at the Ace Gallery yard.

UID: 1407 Latitude: 34.067441

Date: Feb 20, 2019 Longitude: -118.397005

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 222

Notes

The photo shows Silverado crew potholing for sewage lines in the N. Canon yard.

Page 13: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

Photos

This report was generated by Environmental Intelligence, LLC - www.enviro-intel.com - Copyright (2019) 1590 S. Pacific Coast Hwy, Suite 17 | Laguna Beach, California 92651 | (949) 497-0931

8/10

UID: 1410 Latitude: 34.066613

Date: Feb 20, 2019 Longitude: -118.398032

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 214

Notes

The photo shows LBI crew installing gates for sound wall and CSI crew assembling scaffolding in the Ace Gallery yard.

UID: 1406 Latitude: 34.067169

Date: Feb 20, 2019 Longitude: -118.396996

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 224

Notes

The photo shows Vertical Access crew setting up scaffolding along the Wilshire Blvd. perimeter of the N. Canon yard.

UID:

Date:

1419

Feb 21, 2019

Latitude:

Longitude:

34.067

-118.409

Type:

Notes

Construction Activity Elevation: - - -

The photo shows drilling crews drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

UID:

Date:

1420

Feb 21, 2019

Latitude:

Longitude:

34.067

-118.408

Type:

Notes

Construction Activity Elevation: - - -

Photo shows closeup of the drilling site.

UID: 1414 Latitude: 34.066956

Date: Feb 21, 2019 Longitude: -118.3983

Type: General Elevation: 226

Notes

The photo shows Star1MS crew cleaning up trackout at the Ace Gallery yard.

UID: 1416 Latitude: 34.067043

Date: Feb 21, 2019 Longitude: -118.397339

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 226

Notes

Photo shows TPOG crew installing lights on canopy scaffolding at the N. Canon yard.

Page 14: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

Photos

This report was generated by Environmental Intelligence, LLC - www.enviro-intel.com - Copyright (2019) 1590 S. Pacific Coast Hwy, Suite 17 | Laguna Beach, California 92651 | (949) 497-0931

9/10

UID: 1413 Latitude: 34.066677

Date: Feb 21, 2019 Longitude: -118.398399

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 233

Notes

The photo shows LBI crew installing gates at the Ace Gallery yard.

UID: 1415 Latitude: 34.06741

Date: Feb 21, 2019 Longitude: -118.397026

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 228

Notes

The photo shows Silverado crew potholing for sewage pipes in the N. Canon yard.

UID:

Date:

1422

Feb 22, 2019

Latitude:

Longitude:

34.067021

-118.409172

Type:

Notes

Construction Activity Elevation: - - -

The photo shows Fugro fault investigation boring site.

UID:

Date:

1421

Feb 22, 2019

Latitude:

Longitude:

34.067017

-118.409355

Type:

Notes

Construction Activity Elevation: - - -

The photo shows road closure on Wilshire Boulevard for fault investigation boring.

UID: 1459 Latitude: 34.066986

Date: Feb 22, 2019 Longitude: -118.398371

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 225

Notes

The photo shows TPOG crew laying gravel at Ace yard.

UID: 1457 Latitude: 34.06702

Date: Feb 22, 2019 Longitude: -118.398155

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 218

Notes

The photo shows a truck entering the Ace yard to pick up LBI equipment.

Page 15: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

Photos

This report was generated by Environmental Intelligence, LLC - www.enviro-intel.com - Copyright (2019) 1590 S. Pacific Coast Hwy, Suite 17 | Laguna Beach, California 92651 | (949) 497-0931

10/10

UID: 1456 Latitude: 34.066886

Date: Feb 22, 2019 Longitude: -118.398117

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 227

Notes

The photo shows LBI crew installing caps on the gate at the Ace yard.

UID: 1458 Latitude: 34.06722

Date: Feb 22, 2019 Longitude: -118.396959

Type: Construction Activity Elevation: 247

Notes

The photo shows TPOG crew laying sandbags around the perimeter of the N. Canon yard.

Page 16: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

1590 South Coast Highway Suite #17, Laguna Beach, California, 92651 • Phone: 949.497.0931 • www. enviro-intel.com

Attachment C – Construction Noise Monitoring Results

Receptor

ID

Time of

Measurement

Measured

Noise

Level Leq

(15-

Minute)

Applicable

Noise

Threshold

Exceeded

Threshold? Notes

February 19, 2019

RD-7 8:29 66.9 81 No LBI crew moving equipment in Ace Gallery yard.

RD-5 9:00 61.2 68 No LBI installing track beam at Ace Gallery yard.

RD-5 9:43 59.3 68 No LBI crew installing track beams in Ace Gallery yard.

RD-9 10:08 70.6 80 No Vertical Access crew building scaffolding on sidewalk around N Canon yard.

RD-5 10:30 60.5 66 No LBI crew drilling holes in track beam at Ace Gallery yard.

RD-11 11:13 70.6 79 No Crew installing scaffolding and trucking unloading sandbags at N Canon yard.

RD-8 11:57 60.3 71 No LBI crew constructing gates in Ace Gallery yard.

RD-9 12:34 65.8 80 No Vertical Access crew setting up scaffolding around perimeter of N Canon yard.

RD-5 12:57 59 65 No LBI crew constructing gates in Ace Gallery yard.

RD-9 13:33 65.9 N/A No Silverado crew potholing for sewage pipes in N Canon yard.

RD-5 13:44 54.5 68 No LBI crew installing gates at Ace Gallery yard.

RD-5 14:03 54.8 65 No LBI crew installing gates in Ace Gallery yard.

RD-9 14:42 62.8 N/A No TPOG crew setting up sound fencing around N Canon yard.

RD-9 15:12 68.2 80 No TPOG crew setting up sound fencing around N Canon yard.

RD-5 15:33 59.8 66 No LBI crew constructing gates at Ace Gallery yard.

N2.17 22:30 55.7 60 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

N2.17 23:00 55.2 61 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

N2.18 23:32 51.8 61 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

February 20, 2019

N2.17 0:15 54.3 57 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

N2.17 1:01 52.6 57 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

N2.18 2:01 50.4 54 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

N2.17 4:01 51.6 54 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

N2.18 4:45 53 57 No The crew is drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

RD-5 8:28 61.4 66 No LBI crew moving equipment in Ace Gallery yard.

RD-7 8:49 69 81 No CSI unloading scaffolding in Ace Gallery yard.

RD-7 9:27 69.5 80 No Trucks entering and exiting Ace Gallery yard.

RD-15 10:00 67.2 73 No Silverado crew pot holing for sewage lines in N Canon yard.

Page 17: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

1590 South Coast Highway Suite #17, Laguna Beach, California, 92651 • Phone: 949.497.0931 • www. enviro-intel.com

Receptor

ID

Time of

Measurement

Measured

Noise

Level Leq

(15-

Minute)

Applicable

Noise

Threshold

Exceeded

Threshold? Notes

RD-9 10:41 77.9 81 No Vertical Access assembling scaffolding around Wilshire perimeter of N Canon yard.

RD-5 11:19 60.5 66 No LBI crew building gates, CSI crew assembling scaffolding at Ace Gallery yard.

RD-15 11:44 61.6 74 No TPOG crew setting up sound blanket fencing around N Canon yard.

RD-8 12:11 63.1 73 No CSI crew assembling scaffolding in Ace Gallery yard.

RD-9 12:35 70 85 No Vertical Access crew assembling scaffolding at Wilshire perimeter of N Canon yard.

RD-5 12:58 62.9 65 No CSI crew assembling scaffolding at Ace Gallery yard.

RD-5 13:34 58.4 68 No LBI crew installing gates and CSI assembling scaffolding at Ace Gallery yard.

RD-15 14:20 66 75 No TPOG crew setting up sound blanket fencing at N Canon yard.

RD-7 14:47 71.3 80 No LBI crew building gates in Ace Gallery yard.

RD-5 15:10 60.2 66 No LBI crew building gates in Ace Gallery yard.

RD-8 15:39 65 72 No LBI crew moving equipment in Ace Gallery yard.

N2.17 22:03 56.3 62 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

N2.18 22:30 54.3 60 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

N2.17 23:00 53.8 61 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

N2.18 23:30 49.6 61 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

February 21, 2019

N2.17 0:00 51.8 57 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

N2.18 1:02 50.7 57 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

N2.18 3:05 47.4 52 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

N2.17 3:53 51.6 54 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

RD-5 8:26 66.2 66 Yes

LBI hanging gates at Ace Gallery yard. Noise threshold exceeded by saw cutting

concrete at 9401 Wilshire.

RD-5 8:49 60 66 No LBI installing gates within Ace Gallery yard.

RD-7 9:14 70.7 87 No

LBI installing doors on Ace Gallery yard. Concrete cutting at 9401 Wilshire

construction site continues.

RD-5 9:39 66.5 68 No

LBI continues to install doors/lugnuts on Ace Gallery yard. Sawing at 9401 Wilshire

ongoing.

RD-5 10:01 65.4 66 No LBI continues gate installation within Ace Gallery yard.

RD-15 10:27 63 73 No Potholing ongoing within Canon card.

RD-5 10:50 61.4 66 No LBI continues lugnut installation within Ace Gallery yard.

RD-8 11:11 65.6 73 No LBI continues to install lugnuts within Ace Gallery yard.

Page 18: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

1590 South Coast Highway Suite #17, Laguna Beach, California, 92651 • Phone: 949.497.0931 • www. enviro-intel.com

Receptor

ID

Time of

Measurement

Measured

Noise

Level Leq

(15-

Minute)

Applicable

Noise

Threshold

Exceeded

Threshold? Notes

RD-5 11:31 64.9 66 No LBI continues lugnut installation within Ace Gallery yard.

RD-15 11:55 62 75 No Silverado crew potholing for sewage lines in N Canon yard.

RD-5 12:22 58.3 65 No LBI crew on lunch break.

RD-7 12:44 70.5 82 No LBI crews on lunch.

RD-15 13:08 60.5 77 No Silverado crew capping sewage pipes in N Canon yard.

RD-5 13:31 60.4 68 No LBI crew lug bolting sound wall panels at Ace Gallery yard.

RD-15 14:36 60.8 75 No TPOG crew repairing sound blanket fencing at N Canon yard.

RD-7 14:59 68.9 80 No LBI crew lug bolting sound wall panels at Ace Gallery yard.

RD-9 15:44 72.3 81 No TPOG crew installing lighting under canopy scaffolding at N Canon yard.

RD-9 16:29 73.4 81 No TPOG crew installing lights on canopy scaffolding at N Canon yard.

RD-9 16:52 74.2 81 No TPOG crew installing lights on canopy scaffolding at N Canon yard.

N2.17 22:38 55.2 60 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

N2.17 23:00 57 61 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

N2.18 23:40 56.7 61 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

February 22, 2019

N2.17 0:00 51.9 57 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

N2.18 1:01 50.9 57 No The crews are drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

N2.18 2:00 48.2 54 No The crew is drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

N2.17 3:27 48.5 55 No The crew is drilling on Wilshire Boulevard.

RD-5 8:32 59.7 66 No LBI crew installing caps on gate at Ace Gallery yard.

RD-7 9:01 71.6 87 No LBI crew moving equipment in Ace Gallery yard.

RD-4 9:33 72.1 76 No LBI crew loading equipment on trucks and removing it from Ace Gallery yard.

RD-15 10:04 61.6 73 No TPOG laying sandbags around perimeter of N Canon yard.

RD-9 10:42 70.8 91 No TPOG crew laying sandbags around perimeter of N Canon yard.

RD-5 11:03 63 66 No LBI crew moving equipment in Ace Gallery yard.

RD-8 11:28 64.3 73 No LBI trucks exiting Ace Gallery yard.

RD-7 12:05 67.6 82 No TPOG crew taking down sound fencing at Ace Gallery yard.

RD-5 12:29 54.4 65 No TPOG crew removing sound blanket fencing at Ace Gallery yard.

Page 19: February 17, 2019 February 23, 2019 - City Of Beverly Hills · Work Location(s): Ace Gallery at 9430 Wilshire Blvd and N. Canon yard at 9393 Wilshire Blvd The ICM was in possession

1590 South Coast Highway Suite #17, Laguna Beach, California, 92651 • Phone: 949.497.0931 • www. enviro-intel.com

Receptor

ID

Time of

Measurement

Measured

Noise

Level Leq

(15-

Minute)

Applicable

Noise

Threshold

Exceeded

Threshold? Notes

RD-8 13:06 67.8 75 No TPOG crew breaking for lunch.

RD-5 13:38 58.1 68 No TPOG laying gravel around perimeter of Ace Gallery yard.

RD-5 14:09 54.9 65 No TPOG crew laying gravel around perimeter of Ace Gallery yard.

RD-7 14:34 67.8 71 No TPOG crew laying gravel at perimeter of Ace Gallery yard.

RD-5 14:56 62.3 65 No TPOG crew laying gravel at perimeter of Ace Gallery yard.

RD-8 15:23 63.6 72 No TPOG crew laying gravel at perimeter of Ace Gallery yard.

RD-9 15:44 73.5 81 No TPOG crew installing light generator at N Canon yard.

RD-15 20:14 76.9 65 Yes

Ambient noise reading; generator running for first 2 minutes of reading, then shut off

and lights went out. Fire truck and ambulance sirens driving on Wilshire Boulevard.

Invalid ambient reading.

N2.18 22:48 61.6 73 No

Construction drilling is negligible to ambient noise reading. Non-project loading trucks

and moving equipment for event at Mosaic Hotel disturbing ambient noise.

N2.17 23:34 59.2 61 No

Construction drilling is audible but does not produce an exceedance. Mosaic Hotel

event loading and moving equipment into transport truck.

February 23, 2019

N2.18 0:03 58.5 57 Yes

Construction drilling is audible but does not produce an exceedance. Non-project

moving truck in front of Mosaic Hotel in idle causing 57.4 dB disturbance. Hotel ever

moving and banging heavy equipment as they load items into trucks.

N2.17 0:44 51.6 58 No

Construction drilling is negligible to ambient noise reading at this location. Non-project

moving trucks at Mosaic Hotel contributes most to ambient noise.

N2.18 1:30 50.1 57 No Construction drilling is audible but does not produce an exceedance.

N2.18 2:13 51.6 56 No

Construction drilling is negligible to ambient noise at this location. Loading catering

trucks at Mosaic Hotel contributes to ambient noise.

N2.17 2:46 51.9 60 No

Construction drilling is audible but does not produce an exceedance. Non-project

catering trucks loading add to ambient noise.

N2.18 3:26 52 62 No Construction drilling is audible but does not produce an exceedance.

N2.17 3:48 49.7 54 No Construction drilling is audible but does not produce an exceedance.

N2.18 4:06 51.2 54 No Construction drilling is audible but does not produce an exceedance.