Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue

8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue

1/146

!

"#$%

$&'

() *'"+&& ",-.%

#&/&&&%0%"1&1

&%1*'

2

'3445


2/146

i

#'

!"

#

!$%&$%

$ %


3/146

ii

#6% ' '

( ) *(+ $%,- . /

01

, $% *2- / 0 3 /

( ( ( *4-

( 5 6!1,,!4

(5/

,..


4/146

iii

'! ............................................................................................................................................... i! ............................................................................................................................... ii,& .......................................................................................................................................v, .......................................................................................................................................vi7 ..................................................................................................................................18 )'......................................................................................................................29 , ..........................................................................................................................3

97 *##- .................................................................................................398 #&:..............................................................................................................499 3# ........................................................................................................................6

9; #& .....................................................................................................79< &, ..................................................................................................................89= # ......................................................................................................119> .3 .........................................................................129? 2#2.$% ........................................................................................139@ 2#2A ..........................................................................................2097B CD ................................................................................................................25977 #............................................................................................................................31

; )'7#: ................................................34;7 + .............................................................................................................................34;8 )'......................................................................................................34;9 3D ...................................................................................................................36

;; !E ................................................................................................................39;< !.................................................................................................................................40;= 3!2 ......................................................................................................41;> ..................................................................................................................................41;? +3(&2.....................................63;@ #A!#! ...............................................................64

2..............................................................................................................................112>7 )'7 ...........................................................................................................................112>8 )'8 ...........................................................................................................................113>9 )'9 ...........................................................................................................................114>; 23.............................................................................................................115

? .....................................................................................................................117?7 2D............................................................................................117?8 $ ......................................................................................................................119

@ & ......................................................................................................................120


5/146

iv

@7 2& ..............................................................................................................120@8 #2!...................................................................................................120@9 &33(.........................................................................................120@; 2.F! ................................................................................120

7B ...............................................................................................................................121!!.D& ........................................................................................................... I!E.32# ........................................................................................................II

!2.3(&2# ............................................................III!#.C2,03D .......................................................................................IV!.33G& ...............................................................................V!&.3)& .....................................................................................VI


6/146

v

.&7H&2#&........................................................................................................ 5&8H!.................................................................. 5&9H3 ...................................................................................................................... 11&;H$%(33, ........................................................................................ 35&H33D/........................................................................................................... 42&?H .................................................................. 43&@H$)'3...................................................................................................................... 44&7BH3)'3.................................................................................................................... 44&77H$2#C ......................................................................................................... 44&78H32#C......................................................................................................... 44&79H$.................................................................................................... 44&7;H3 ................................................................................................... 44&7H$

..................................................................................................... 46&7?H3.................................................................................................... 46&7@H3,, ......................................................................................... 48&8BH27*-..................................................................................... 49&87H29*-..................................................................................... 51&88H2


7/146

vi

.'&7H&2#&........................................................................................................ 5&8H!.................................................................. 5&9H3 ...................................................................................................................... 11&;H$%(33, ........................................................................................ 35&H33D/........................................................................................................... 42&?H .................................................................. 43&@H$)'3...................................................................................................................... 44&7BH3)'3.................................................................................................................... 44&77H$2#C ......................................................................................................... 44&78H32#C......................................................................................................... 44&79H$.................................................................................................... 44&7;H3 ................................................................................................... 44&7H$..................................................................................................... 46&7?H3.................................................................................................... 46

&7@H3,, ......................................................................................... 48&8BH27*-..................................................................................... 49&87H29*-..................................................................................... 51&88H2


8/146

vii

(

## $%!! (## ! # !22 $%0# !22 $%'D

#7+ !2D)*$-

#7+$ !2D)*3-

# !2 !##8 !2!

F3!2

#88! !E !

#$! !3E !3!!# E!2#.8#$ 2#

#81 2

#$ 2!3 2(

+ 2#+7$ 2)D3 $3!D# # F10#

.8 #,

09.# #6,! F10"$# &(23!(7 0D (# (7$ 0D3 3-9 +26-$"$ +3(

3$2F3!2#

. ,$%

.&

,$%*&,3!-

,$%2

"+ (#

" ( $%-$# $+3!

F3!&

8 $2 $2!

$, $3 !$! $3E F3!3+1 )2A

#+$# )3! 3# 71" D'( D'7+.:5: &2 $%D

8# 2! !

8+$7# 3D! F1


9/146

viii

8# ! !$330

8$ 23 G!2#$#$;< F12## !2 3.6!

$%8. ,98 260

!660

98 62 2D


10/146

1

; A

* - ! 2 )*-2D2

&3+

)*-

$%D2!*2!K-


11/146

2

3 8+'/&'&$%

H 2 & &

+

'+'H 23*$%- 2CD

,

'''H #" #" .

' '

$ 2


12/146

3

= .8

=;

*- * - *- I J .!L3

!++

& +

! (*7@?


13/146

4

N

=3 ,

3& *!8BB7- AK

' & *E8BB


14/146

5

(*- D

&7*!&08BB7-

;'

3*8BB;-&8

3#&%&2&&%

&+

3


15/146

6

!IJ

3*- + *7@@@-

== $&

*-

EK

==; $&

3!H)

*)3!-

)C *-

3!K)

==3 &

$OA!

$$#3*$+8BB


16/146

7

$)

$!F1*$8BB

+

#($%DD)

F D

D+'

A+'#

D


17/146

8

I J I J 39@;

! A 39?=

=: .

&!2*-

! 8BBB * " 8BBB- & 0 !7>7@*E!2-BB


18/146

9

=:3 *$#

?.I(K,J A+@=?I (K,H$##!8BB9J

(K,##+F3!)8BB8&8BB9

I(K,J H

I 7 7'#8

E3 K

98:#22;)& *

=:= #

9,K8

&2)D3*2)D3-


32/146

23

2$3

$I2)D3A

3!

!A! # *8BB9- 3 A

I!$37@@>J*!7@@@-)H

2(

- "

F#2H,N*-23GD# E!

GD#+)D

223*23-)I 2J

# !3GDIJ39@;

9#2H3D36D#(!

6D#+)D

!26

%=#% 01

2H#2D'F1


33/146

24

HCCC

!F3!F1 ' $2 3#*#-

#,0*#,-

+ 3!37@

I 8BB8 G ! ' 3J *#, 8BB8-

HI! / 9!/!9:= 9'J

!2D'

=


34/146

25

= $"

' *2$58BB7-

#

+*7@@


35/146

26

!

) $

)

! 0 3TH

& #

!

!A 3=3= $%

=;4; 7%%D#

!! 6 $ 3 G # 6 ! ( G !

!

#A

A !3

A


36/146

27

!=


37/146

28

$ + 7%%630 #D"&3"

6 &3&!6

!2 ((27@@7*6L-"E$330 &3$3

! 332"&"#

3!G30 #3"&3G

(GCG

0G!"&3&!"#D

'517%%A#

=;43 7%%D*$#

!F3!#F3!2)*(#)2#) 2!,!$3-

F3!

! ! F3! !A!

!! !

A

)%B>9002!&

F3!>

$ + 7%% !,, E0

*D)-#D+3

D*3$D-


38/146

29

$ + 7%%$3& &"

!!!&3 !1FD42$+3

!*$+3!-#2.##

#&(23

!*&(23!-2#2.##"

3)*-

$3E*$3E- 33

2 2#) &"PE0DQ2 2#)P2Q 3!31 1#) &3"#3( (#) &"$ #) &"$3!F F#) &"

'@17%%A*$#

=;4= 7%%D*)

)F1+$1432F1#&

+$14*+$148BB 7%%D

!$%

0!32A0#


39/146

30

$ % 2 ) *, $% $ % !22 (-

! ! F3! $ % #

!!22,$%

F!!

3 2A 0

'23D

30

3

&!22$%' 8BB


40/146

31

!! #,0 &!& "*-

'


41/146

32

$%! =M

+

8BM9BM !

$%

$%

=;;= 78&

!$%

!

2F3! +

$%

=;;> #

!

+#+$14&

H

" &" " $%" $%


42/146

33

=;;: A$

39?88 7=>> 77;; @

3

7BB 7@@?

23+

;= 78< 89= 879 @ 7BB 97 +'/;%&

!$%H

1" #1*#+" 1+81"1" 1(118(

3 +

>; -&+

>3 &+'/

(+$%$23+$7@@=7@@@

$ ( 23&

7@@@(+

2 3D23!1!&;

# $ 3 ( ( ) $%$%'*)8BB9- . N 6


44/146

35

&

3F

>"&$$.

3+D23 2 A 3 $%

>3; -8'

! 7@@= 7@@@

!39?


45/146

36

>= $7%

!

2 0 2

H +N

6 6

!39?=;

8%:: !

!D7@@@A'D7@@@

&


46/146

37

(//2!:E$$& :$ E E

$%3+7

7A@@8-


47/146

38

3+

! ?BC

8%:E!692

$ %K3+3 * -

$% 3 + &


48/146

39

(

! E+26

77 7=A@@8= )> (& &

';;$

$ * ' C N- 2!3 .$

8%:G !4/

!

2!3#!8(T

F 3 > #!

C

2 3D23!121D18


49/146

40

% 6%2*$- D B B 2

9B S ;B =B 7 ?B@B 7S 78B78B 8 7=B7B ;S 9=B D

D*3- 2 B B D9B S ;B=B 7 ?B@B 7S 78B78B 8 7=B 17B ;S 9=B 2

';3%

1 1 ' *#-

#2!3 ! !

!62K

!2!3 279: #

2!3

H 2 )' #C D( D#


50/146

41

D

&=&7?3;>

!03(+$%,79

$ $ $%( ,$%

3+! $%230D3D

';=($$

2!303&*$-$

>5 $

!03AN C

!79@ 8!' 3+2!3$%

&=&7?

!&N!E.32#


51/146

42

>@; +

8G:: "9H

! )A'*&=L&>-+, $%7@@@

+

)A'8BBB!,$%7@@@&8BBBA'D8BBBA'

SH1 RS90 to RS317 - North / Ea st bound Fatigue Crashes

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

1988

1989

1990

1991

1992

1993

1994

1995

1996

1997

1998

1999

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012

2013

NumberofCrashes

Non Injury Minor injury Serious Injury FatalCrashes

SH1 RS90 to RS 317 - South / West bound Fatigue Crashes

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

1988

1989

1990

1991

1992

1993

1994

1995

1996

1997

1998

1999

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012

2013

NumberofCrashes

Non Injury Minorinjury Serious Injury FatalCrashes

5'$7'C @$'$7'C

@M79MM3+$%

! &?


52/146

43

B8

7@@?8BB7=BM88BB8+8BB88BB;8BM9BMA'

*X7=B-*X@9@-!78

8G:# .9

!'

'''''

'&C,2CE#)!&@&7B&C,2

SH1 RS90 to RS317 - North / East bound Fatigue Crashes

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 910

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

Driven oracco mpanied animals

Bridge/tunnel abutment, approach or handrail

Cliff,bank or retainingwall(upright)

Debris, boulder, orobject droppedfrom vehicle

Overedge of bank

Fence, letterbox, hoarding ,etc

Guardorguiderail

Houseorbuilding

Traffic island ormedian

Public furniture(ph boxes, bus shelters, signalcontrollers, etc)

Kerb (directly contributing to crash)

Landslide, washout or floodwater

Parked motor vehicle

Train

(N/A)

Utility pole

Broken down vehicle,work man's vehicle, taxis picking up,etc

Roadworks signs or barriers

Traffic signals or signalbollards

Trees

(N/A)

Ditch

Wild animal, stray, or outof control

Other

Objects thrown at ordropped onto vehicles

Intowater,river orsea

Objects struck (mayhave >1 per crash)

Non Injury

Minorinjury

Serious Injury

FatalCrashes

SH1 RS90 to RS 317 - South / West bound Fatigue Crashes

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 910

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

Driven oracco mpanied animals

Bridge/tunnelabutment, approachor handrail

Cliff,bank or retainingwall(upright)

Debris, boulder, or object droppedfromvehicle

Overedge of bank

Fence, letterbox, hoarding ,etc

Guardorguiderail

Houseorbuilding

Traffic island ormedian

Public furniture(ph boxes, bus shelters, signalcontrollers, etc)

Kerb (directly contributing to crash)

Landslide, washout or floodwater

Parked motorve hicle

Train

(N/A)

Utility pole

Broken down vehicle,workman's vehicle, taxis picking up,etc

Roadworks signs or barriers

Traffic signals or signalbollards

Trees

(N/A)

Ditch

Wild animal, stray, or outof control

Other

Objects thrown at ordropped onto vehicles

Intowater,river orsea

Objects struck (mayhave >1 per crash)

Non Injury

Minor injury

SeriousInjury

Fatal Crashes

Fatigue Ratio of all Crashes

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004

Year

Percentageofallcrashes

Ratio (F) Ratio (S) Ratio (M) Ratio (NI)


53/146

44


54/146

45

2!3*X9?;>-$

!&N*X>BX@B-

)&&8

A

8G:8 ",!#5 $ % 2 C $ / *&7- $

SH1 North / East bound Fatigue Crashesn = 70

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

January

February

March

April

May

June

July

August

September

October

November

December

Month

%ageofallcrashes

Crashes by Month - StudySite Crashes byMonth- All SH

SH1 South/West Crashes by Monthn= 90

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

January

February

March

April

May

June

July

August

September

October

November

December

Month

%ageofallcrashes

Crashes by Month- Study Site Month - All SH

;:'&'% ;5$'&'%


55/146

46

8G:E "2

2 &7>&7?)33

!

! 1 (3

!!7=B!

$%

2!3*X9?;>-$

SH1 North / East bound Fatigue Crashes by Dayn = 70

0

5

10

15

20

25

MON TUE WED THU FRI SAT SUN

Day


Crashes by Day - StudyLength Crashes by Day - All SH

SH1 South/West Crash by Dayn = 90

0

5

10

15

20

25

MON TUE WED THU FRI SAT SUN

Day


Crashes by Day - StudyLength Crashes by Day - All SH

;@'&' ;B$'&'

8G:F 6

!

H 3 ( 3

! 7;

8(% ' $'$ ;BM ;BM1 9@M 9BM

" 7=M 89M$ =M >M


56/146

47

';>8'8(%A$-;

?BME

>@3 *!3;97@= #$'

! 3;97 !@B

79


57/146

48

&N!#.C2,03D

3;>97 ;>99 ! 3>7

&7@

3F

;


58/146

49

8G%: 9:6

34;6%&'

;9&8B

!


59/146

50

!3;>8F*7=-

%' 7I>=

# 9< ?7M(# ? 7@M

+# B BM 8@ =>M

';5$';6%8

?BM$

&>BM *-*-

7 +N;9


60/146

51

8G%# 9%6

3;=6%&'

9@&87

!


61/146

52

!3;>8F*7>-

%' 7I3=

# 7> >;M(# = 8=M+# B BM 7; =7M

';@$'=6%8

>


62/146

53

8G%% 9E6

33:6%&'

7>&88

!


63/146

54

!3;>8F*7?-

%' 7I;@

# 79 >=M(# ; 8;M

+# B BM > ;7M

';B$':6%8

>

8G%8 99

*7@-


64/146

55

$';6%I>=

$'=6%I3=

$';6%I;@

#$'

# ?7M >;M >=M >>M(# 7@M 8=M 8;M 89M+# BM BM BM BM

=>M =7M ;7M


65/146

56

>@> #'

! 3;97 !@B

7997 ;>99 ! 3>7

&8;

3F

3=$..


66/146

57

8G8: :6

3>;6%&'

9@&8;

!


67/146

58

!3;>8F*8B-

%' 7I=@M(# ? 87M

+# B BM 7@ ;@M

'34';6%8

?BM$

&


68/146

59

8G8# %6

3:=6%&'

88&8


69/146

60

!3;>8F*8;-

%' 7I33

# 7? ?8M(# ; 7?M

+# B BM 77


70/146

61

8G8% E6

35:6%&'

7


71/146

62

!3;>8F*8


72/146

63

';6%I=


73/146

64

! !#.C2,03D

>


74/146

65

>

!2!3 )!

2!3

!! &8>

8B7

7B8B>79 '


75/146

66

3@1%&$$

>


76/146

67

: +'/3*&&

!

38!

$

%

:; $&$

+2!

! $%+

)(*3-8@ !8BB


77/146

68

! +&

!6D

!

A

!AD;

)8B(*B;"9

!

H & #

E


78/146

69

:= $F

:=; $;A%$$

H 3+=C3+=


79/146

70

2 ;B + 3 3+>,D.3!$2

!0'!22!0$%

E%#: 9,

!, &2

7 !;BB

)EB2;" )FB;"94

!EEG!C

!!0

3

#H D D $ #


80/146

71

2

! .33G&

E%##

! >8 @ 8;M

3B91%&

) 7BB M

!'2

:== $=A7$$

H 3+7C37@


81/146

72

D 3 + 7 788 D


82/146

73

2

! .33G&

E%%#

!?;8H;


83/146

74

& 3*2D-

:>; "

E8:: !4

&,$%*,$%-D#A$IAAAJ

'

K/!45942&L/!45942&L/!45942&&'

HK

K1!

/!4K&

942K*&

'K

1H

$7 17 $. 8 2 2 7B@= 7


84/146

75

AA

E8:#!2

!

!

!CC" &" "

E8:% 0

&>7 &8 #9 &

; 3C!

)&23

"! $%C)E

2 3 & D0 )

$ 7 8 9 ; < = >2 0 E 2 #C&

'35*8A%1%&


85/146

76

&

$

E8:89)

!,

32D!

IJ?8;)3D!*8BB7->@

:>3 $;A%$$

&3 ! 898

!

E8#: !2

!

) 898 >

8>

, &333 23

&.; &.3#&. 7=; ?;"&. 7


86/146

77

'3@%$&$A&.$%%

7=B0'?BC7= $3A1%&$$2&3!>8

Total Trip Length (Tasman Survey)

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000

Trip Length (km)

CumulativePercentage


87/146

78

#

E8%: !2

! 2

2

8@#39;


88/146

79

. 2&33$& 63

&.; &.3#&. 7B 88?

"%%&. = 7B$%&$J >8 9>&.#&. 879"&. 87="%%&. ;BB"%%&. =9$%&$J >8

'3


89/146

80

1' ,'#&. 79; 77@"&. 78? 77@"%%&. 8?> 8>;"%%&. 8@ 7=$%&$J 9@ 7?

'=41%&$&$A&.$%%

79;77@

0 ' ?B C 79B7;B

8

!@BM9BB&97

=;1%&$&$A0&

! 2 3 33!2$

N*X88


90/146

81

$ I J

!

E8%% 9)

!

, 2&333 63

$$& >=

"$& ?"%%$& 78"%%$& B$%&$J >8

'=31%&$&$A$&$%%

!>


91/146

82

:>> $=A7$$

D&3 !=#&. 779 ?@ ?= ;8B 8>7 777"%%&. 88 78 78 78$%&$J ?; 7$&$A&.$%%

D 2

!@BM


92/146

83

==7$&$A0&

77970'?BC78;

!3$%&$J 7B

Total Trip Length (Parnassus)

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%70%

80%

90%

100%

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000

Trip Length (km)

CumulativePercenta

ge


93/146

84

'=57$&$A

0 ' ?B C 7;


94/146

85

Sleep Profile by Day

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%

45%

50%

11

hrs

Hours sleep

Percentageo

fdrivers

SaturdaySunday

Monday

=>$&7'7

E?98;!9?BM*9?-

. D&33$& 236

$$& >9"$& ?

"%%$& 78"%%$& B$%&$J ?;

'=B7$&$A$&$%%

:: $&

::; 7'#$&%&

!

! 2 2

DD

E79M 2

Marginal to Very Poor Good or Better


95/146

86

D(D!*-

!!22

EE:: 9""

& 3 2 2D

!!*AC-

)A

$2

::3 %&

&3D

EE#: I99

$%


96/146

87

!"#

C

"

'

E*(- E*-

(% H $ ,!(

E

'=


97/146

88

&9>

=@$*)K-)LM%& =B 7& 8 " $$

EE#E )99

!&9


98/146

89

&.'" &*-

D !

EE%# )9

D&A'

H .2'" &&.EEG" "

) !22 2 !0

EE%% 9

3$%C

Y

Y*-

+

3&

::> %%!

2!0'!22

! *-

E


99/146

90

!2

!

::: .

&3

23!;B'

)A

'''

#2

DD2' D 79 2 ! 2


100/146

91

5 +'/=17'A!7

3 ;

3


101/146

92

5= 7%%8

!*$%-

! $ %

G ;B $

+ 7 7' 8&CG

.6CG

$% ( $ $,$% / $!224 / $32A / $!1,,! / $

!F3 G#( / $!.$3 / $

F3! !!!& / $EL0 / $

F1 F1# / $

'>4+1%&

5=; 1$

!)

'

7*- :

D7


102/146

93

7=7 ?

5> 7%%8&

5>; "&

(%#A

$%O(*(-2O $%3#8BB8

! O ( O$%3*$%3-

F8:: )9

!0( + (

F8:# 1

!(( (

( ' ! $%!

;7


103/146

94

7%%%

8

.

7&

8

9

$

C"

C%

7

$,6

$

&

%

8%*

876

176

1

&3A =

2#D

>

'>;"D$%%6

F8:% 495.

(

2!3 (,$%!3$%

5>3 .&

(%#A

G , $% 2 7 #8BB;

,$%O'H 2

, $% $ % A

,$%*D(2!K0-!

! '

!

,$%


104/146

95

F8#: )9

&,$%&3&,$%,$%

F8## 1

&3,$%$%

3

;8


105/146

96

7%%%

8

.

7&

8

9

$

C"

C%

7

$,6

$

&

%

8%*

876

176

1

&3A =

'>3.&D$%%6

F8#% 4.95.

! , $% # , $%

5>= #A6L

(%#A

!22*!22-!22$%K'$%N$%'

!222H

' ' '

' '

8BB9 , 3 ! * , $%- ZKZK=M'!22*!22-W78


106/146

97

6A

!22$%!22

!22I0J 2"

I K K KJ

!22 ' $% $ % '3=#6D$%%6


107/146

98

F8%% 4.95.

$,+3

!22 !0 2&0E!22!0! , $% $%

5>> 8$D

(%#A

$%


108/146

99

*-*'-*&9@-

%%&% %+& +'/&%%

=>8$DD$%%6

2 A 2 3D*N-!

$ % $


109/146

100

F88% 4.95.

& 2 3 D 0,$%!22 3*2 - +

!A$%

5>: #)..#

78$1%&A

!V 3 3 2 $ %K A

$33&2*-

!V332((35'3379#8BB9

![332

NA(50

(5!1,,![

'!1,,![

F8E: )9

![3 3 2 $%!1,,![6'

A


110/146

101

A

F8E# 1

!1,,![$8BB:#)...#ND$%%6

F8E% 4.95.

!1,,![ $#2*8BB


111/146

102

5>5 F&%"8

(%8#D#

(GGK9;BBB A G

*-

G(G

& &;

DZKZKH # $ 7


112/146

103

78BB7 K7&2P8BB8Q887QOO

)7@@@1A19694!56C

+7%) 2A(K 9 GK*.2-#

8#F$&&%&37@@?!2GG

F8F# 1

;=

7%%%

8

.

7&

8

9

$

C"

C%

7

$,6

$&

%

8%*

876

176

1

##2

9

D2

;

!303,E

:

#3

;

'>5"8FD$%%6

G?=M

!RDR'*@>M-


113/146

104

F8F% 4.95.

G&3 G 0 G!!

G 2*3- ,3) 3+

D!2G(#T

5>@ 8#D$,

(%8#D#

!*!-$37>=89397B,

&'$3!B$38BB8)8BM!'8BB8

F8G:)9

!K A # 1 1N I $&8$M

"&%&K$&8$M(#8BB7

8%

2E7B=K 2 (!8BB9

'H + A

)Z#KZK$3


114/146

105

@B# $3 2 # 6 ! 3 3 ,2ET!

F8G# 1

!!$3

;>

7%%%

8

.

7&

8

9

,'7

$

C"

C%

7

$,6

$&

%

8%*

876

176

1

&3A =

3 32

>

# 3

>

'>@8#D$%%6

F8G% 4.95.

!&3!$3!!

!2*3-,3)3 +

5>B ###$

78$81#D*$#

!!!&3'37@;>&77B' '!!!&N


115/146

106

!!! &

F8J: )9

!!! &K

,6*&L

! !!! & C' NK K !

,6*&L%& *-

N

'H +

8

!!!&)I#D+##2:A#5#J *37@@@-

A2 $ 2 I J I J H*7- $ 2

*8- $2

!F32D)DO##E*!!!&3"8BB;-*$"7@@?-

F8J# 1

NK H D" F42" !IJ


116/146

107

;?

7%%%

8

.

7&

8

9

8

$

C"

C%

7

$,6

$&

%

8%*

876

176

1

IF4J2

>

D

D3!

:

'>B###D$%%6

F8J% 4.95.

! !!! & ) !!! & *-

( !!! &

5>


117/146

108

F8=# 1

3

2 C

7%%%

8

.

7&

8

9

$

$

C"

C%

7

$,6

$&

%

8%*

876

176

1

#DD

>

'>;4 *)&%&

(%8#D*)

#*#-' #

F10'';B*


118/146

109

F8:$: )9

# A 6 A!

#&,&,

0 * - 0O

!(;


119/146

110

F8:$# 1

+$142

7%%%

8

.

7&

8

9

$

C"

C%

7

$,6

$&

%

8%*

876

17

6

1

+$142

>

&3 >

DD

>

':4*)&%&D$%%6

F8:$% 4.95.

+$142#

5:

!'$%)

+ % %& &%%

(

!

!

(

!+

E 0 !1,,! !!! & ''K( *-


120/146

111

(!F3!

'

$% 23D

D

)

*# " 8BB;- C

* - *-

0#Y ( (

) ! +

'

!3


121/146

112

@ '''H7 #"

8 #"9 .

''

'.

@; +'/;

@;; .

! ?BM $

&;


122/146

113

N

2!3

2!3

@3 +'/3

)'8'

&3*#-3

* 3- *2D3-

#

)

C*-

'8!8$%2

A+

) D 3+7D2 . 3 $% 2 3 $

A2+


123/146

114

2D2DDA

!2;MD77M

0

2*-H

$" '

" F" 3" 3"

@3; &%

!

H # # # . C

#

#

@= +'/=

3= $C


124/146

115

+

'

F1#F1F1#

#

)3D!

$% $ % E

)$%

F1#-)L2

$%'&$%0

0A.'

.$%1!E'

@> $%%

'H #"


125/146

116

#" .

3+ 7 3 C

+

$%


126/146

117

B 8%% $ %

9BM$%

& $ % $%

B; %&%7

B;;

! 3 9? 9@

$% !+$%F3!

J::: ("

!

J::# ("2/


127/146

118

B;3 $&$

& 33

!


128/146

119

B3

B3; 6

!!397E $%

'H #'" #"

H #A"

" " ! *

4-

B33 17%%

) A $ %

C !#4 *-


129/146

120


130/146

121

;4 8!3E*8BB8-I"+///$!3E!3H)893E$7A?>>B>7AB

E!23!&E7@@?


131/146

122

+3*8BB7- !*$8BB7

+'!30*8BB9- /,/,&22!23D28BB9!*!-99>.;8*8-3$3!

+N(*8BB;&>B6/B/(GD!!!8BB;

+5!,!*7@@


132/146

123

!*8BB7-2+)2"9!38BB7

)3D!*8BB7-2/+/4))O&8BB7

!*7@@@-!/9>:==G+99 !3!33$B7


133/146

I

#&A78&%


134/146


135/146

II

#&&!A$%%&


136/146


137/146

III

#&& A $ " %


138/146

#$GD$8$88&+83=2#$!2#

$3AH K"C

AA*"A

GAH !7BBCN*8.;

7B.=-"

!AH D" !A

"

*A-

6A

3!$!2


139/146

IV

#&&AG.($7


140/146


141/146

V

#&&1A$&$F%&


142/146


143/146

VI

#&&A$%&+8%

&


144/146


145/146

P)$Q+

.

P,Q

8

!6

,'


146/146

7%%$#

7%% 8 . 7& 8 9 7%%&

PQ

$

1 # 1 -1PQ 3 ; 3 = > :

# #

)&%%

: :

%%7%%

Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue

Documents

Transcript of Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue