F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock...

86
F A C T O R J A N U S

Transcript of F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock...

Page 1: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

F A C T O R

J A N U S

Page 2: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Jan

us

Page 3: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

“In some seasons trend following is

good; in others, reversing is good.”

Victor Niederhoffer, The Education of a Speculator

Page 4: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

1. Feedback systems

Page 5: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

1. Feedback systems

2. A binary method for

icalculating relative strength

Page 6: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

1. Feedback systems

2. A binary method for

icalculating relative strength

3. Key indicators

Page 7: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

1. Feedback systems

2. A binary method for

icalculating relative strength

3. Key indicators

4. A long strategy

Page 8: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Feedback Systems

Page 9: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 10: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 11: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 12: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 13: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Positive feedback creates

a trend.

Page 14: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 15: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 16: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 17: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Negative feedback counters

the trend.

Page 18: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 19: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 20: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

The defensive qualities of a

stock/group are most severely

tested during periods of market

weakness, when the risk of loss

is most acute.

DEFENSE

Page 21: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 22: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Since the risk of lost opportunity

is greatest as the market rises,

the offensive qualities of a

stock/group are best measured

as the market advances.

OFFENSE

Page 23: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 24: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 25: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 26: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Relative

Strength

Relative

Weakness

Page 27: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 28: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

How Feedback

Generates Systematic

Page 29: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Positive Feedback

Traders buy strength

and/or sell weakness.

Page 30: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 31: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Expanding Universe

Page 32: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Positive Feedback as the

Market Advances

Strongest stocks lead the way

higher.

Page 33: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

-300

-200

-100

0

100

200

300

400

500

-300 -200 -100 0 100 200 300 400 500

June 1999

Page 34: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

-300

-200

-100

0

100

200

300

400

500

-300 -200 -100 0 100 200 300 400 500

March 2000

Page 35: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Positive Feedback as the

Market Declines

Weakest stocks lead the way

lower.

Page 36: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

-300

-200

-100

0

100

200

300

400

500

-300 -200 -100 0 100 200 300 400 500

December 2001

Page 37: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

-300

-200

-100

0

100

200

300

400

500

-300 -200 -100 0 100 200 300 400 500

May 2002

Page 38: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Negative Feedback

Traders sell strength

and/or buy weakness.

Page 39: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 40: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Contracting Universe

Page 41: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

-300

-200

-100

0

100

200

300

400

500

-300 -200 -100 0 100 200 300 400 500

December 2002

Page 42: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

“The prime mover in

a financial market is

not value or price,

but price differences;

not averaging, but

arbitraging.”

Benoit Mandelbrot, The (Mis)

Behavior of Markets

Page 43: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Structure, Entropy

and

Traders’ Confidence

Page 44: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

1. Ace of Spades

2. King of Spades

3. Queen of Spades

4. Jack of Spades

5. Ten of Spades

6. Nine of Spades

Page 45: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

1. King of Spades

2. Three of Diamonds

3. Jack of Diamonds

4. Ten of Hearts

5. Two of Clubs

6. Seven of Hearts

Page 46: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Positive Feedback structures

the market by increasing the

relative strength difference

between winners and losers.

Page 47: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

The emergence of structure

is the trend.

Page 48: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Negative Feedback collapses

structures built up during

periods of positive feedback.

Page 49: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

The collapse of RS structure

“re-shuffles” the market.

Page 50: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

En tro py

The tendency for all matter and

energy in the universe to evolve

toward a state of inert uniformity;

deterioration of [the structure of]

a system or society.

Webster’s

Page 51: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Two distinct market

environments

driven by two opposed

trading paradigms.

Page 52: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

“In some seasons

trend following is good.”

Page 53: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

“Trading strategies that buy

past winners and sell past

losers realized significant

abnormal returns over the

1965 to 1989 period.”

Jegadeesh and Titiman, “Returns to Buying

Winners and Selling Losers: Implications for

Stock Market Efficiency”, 1993

Page 54: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

“The historically strongest stocks

produced the best future results

and the historically weakest

stocks produced the worst.”

Robert Levy, The Relative Strength Concept of

Common Stock Price Forecasting, 1968.

(Study based on data from October 1960 to October 1965)

Page 55: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

“In others, reversing is good.”

Page 56: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Harold M. Gartley, who had

pioneered relative strength to

study stock groups, abandoned

its use in the 1930s and 1940s

because it did not work.

Page 57: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

“In a narrow market, when

prices are not getting anywhere

to speak of but move within a

narrow range, there is no sense

in trying to anticipate what the

next big movement is going to

be, up or down. . . “

Jesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock

Operator (Lefevre)

Page 58: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

“Those were the lean years, 1911-

1914. The market flattened out.

Things drifted from bad to worse.

I not only lost all I had but got into

debt again. There was no money

to be made.”

Jesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator

(Lefevre)

Page 59: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

20

40

60

80

100

120

02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

Daily

Dow Industrial Average

Page 60: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Key Indicators

Page 61: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

The Relative Strength

Spread

Is feedback positive or negative?

Page 62: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 63: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 64: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 65: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

The Spread

Page 66: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Rising Spread

- result of positive feedback

rrrrrrrrrrr(momentum)

Page 67: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Falling Spread

- result of negative feedback

rrrrrrrrrrr(entropy)

Page 68: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

In what direction is momentum

(positive feedback) moving the

market?

Direction of Momentum

Page 69: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Direction of Momentum

Page 70: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Direction of Momentum

Page 71: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

Direction of Entropy

Page 72: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

The Janus Strategy The Janus Strategy The Janus Strategy

Page 73: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

The Janus Strategy The Janus Strategy

Morningstar

Sub-Industry Groups

- Stocks in each group

eequally balanced

- No survival bias

Page 74: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

The Janus Strategy The Janus Strategy

Page 75: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

The Janus Strategy The Janus Strategy

Page 76: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

The Janus Strategy The Janus Strategy

Page 77: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

The Janus Strategy The Janus Strategy

Page 78: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

The Janus Strategy The Janus Strategy

Page 79: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

The Janus Strategy The Janus Strategy

Page 80: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

The Janus Strategy The Janus Strategy December 1990 – January 2014

Long – 71%

Cash – 29%

Page 81: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

95

100

105

110

115

120

125

130

135

140

Direction of Momentum

Adaptive MA

Page 82: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

95

100

105

110

115

120

125

Performance Spread

Page 83: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

95

100

105

110

115

120

125

130

135

Performance of RM

Leaders versus SP-500

Page 84: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened
Page 85: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

“It is not the strongest of

the species that survives,

nor the most intelligent,

but the one most

responsive to change.”

Charles Darwin, The Origin of Species

Page 86: F A C T O R - afta-dfw.com Janus Factor - Gary Anderson.pdfJesse Livermore, Reminiscencs of a Stock Operator (Lefevre) “Those were the lean years, 1911-1914. The market flattened

equityPM

Advisory For The Equity Portfolio Manager

[email protected]