Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound...

74
Exploring Strange Matters J ¨ urgen Schaffner-Bielich Institute for Theoretical Physics and Heidelberg Graduate School for Fundamental Physics and ExtreMe Matter Institute EMMI Carl Dover Memorial Lecture Brookhaven National Laboratory, New York, USA, March 1, 2012 – p.1

Transcript of Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound...

Page 1: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Exploring Strange Matters

Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich

Institute for Theoretical Physics and

Heidelberg Graduate School for Fundamental Physics and

ExtreMe Matter Institute EMMI

Carl Dover Memorial Lecture

Brookhaven National Laboratory, New York, USA, March 1, 2012

– p.1

Page 2: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Carl B. Dover 1941–1996

(from Carl Dover memorial issue, Nucl. Phys. A 625 (1997))– p.2

Page 3: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Carl B. Dover: curriculum vitae

hand-written cv for thepost-doc position inHeidelberg

bachelor of science inexperimental physics!

PhD at MIT in 1967(advisor:Prof. Richard Lemmer)

– p.3

Page 4: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Carl B. Dover: first post-doc in Heidelberg

first post-doc positions inHeidelberg 1967-1970

’Verwalter einerwissenschaftlichenAssistentenstelle’1967-1969

’Planmäßiger Wissen-schaftlicher Assistent’1969-1970

– p.4

Page 5: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Carl B. Dover: PhD title in Germany

german ministry grants CarlDover permission for bearingthe title PhD in Germany

– p.5

Page 6: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Carl B. Dover: PhD title in Germany

german ministry grants CarlDover permission for bearingthe title PhD in Germany

to be more precise: the title’Doctor of Philosophy /Massachusetts Institute ofTechnology Cambridge / USA’

– p.5

Page 7: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Carl B. Dover: PhD title in Germany

german ministry grants CarlDover permission for bearingthe title PhD in Germany

to be more precise: the title’Doctor of Philosophy /Massachusetts Institute ofTechnology Cambridge / USA’

in short: ’Ph. D. /Massachusetts Institute ofTechnology Cambridge / USA’

– p.5

Page 8: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Carl B. Dover: PhD title in Germany

german ministry grants CarlDover permission for bearingthe title PhD in Germany

to be more precise: the title’Doctor of Philosophy /Massachusetts Institute ofTechnology Cambridge / USA’

in short: ’Ph. D. /Massachusetts Institute ofTechnology Cambridge / USA’

. . . and asks for anadministrative fee of DM 80(in a separate letter)

– p.5

Page 9: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Carl B. Dover: CV part II (abridged)

1970-71: University of Paris, Orsay, Institut de PhysiqueNucléaire, Chercheur Associé au CNRS

1971-present: Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, NYAssistant Physicist (1971-1973)Associate Physicist (1973-1975)Physicist (1975-1982)Senior Physicist (1982-present)Group Leader of Nuclear Theory (1990-present )

1989-1993 Humboldt Senior Scientist Award1991 Appointed Adjunct Professor, Yale University1993 Appointed Adjunct Professor, SUNY/Stony Brook

more than 200 publications, 14 posthumously!(2 in Dover memorial issue, 12 with E864 collaboration)

– p.6

Page 10: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Carl B. Dover and Strange Hadronic Matter (abridged)

his first talk ever on dibaryons:first hypernuclear meeting in Heidelberg 1982(Avraham Gal, private communication)

– p.7

Page 11: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Carl B. Dover and Strange Hadronic Matter (abridged)

his first talk ever on dibaryons:first hypernuclear meeting in Heidelberg 1982(Avraham Gal, private communication)

work on producing the H-dibaryon with hadronicreactions (PRL 1982 with Aerts)

– p.7

Page 12: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Carl B. Dover and Strange Hadronic Matter (abridged)

his first talk ever on dibaryons:first hypernuclear meeting in Heidelberg 1982(Avraham Gal, private communication)

work on producing the H-dibaryon with hadronicreactions (PRL 1982 with Aerts)

work on production of dibaryons in heavy-ioncollisions (1989 with P. Koch and M. May)

– p.7

Page 13: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Carl B. Dover and Strange Hadronic Matter (abridged)

his first talk ever on dibaryons:first hypernuclear meeting in Heidelberg 1982(Avraham Gal, private communication)

work on producing the H-dibaryon with hadronicreactions (PRL 1982 with Aerts)

work on production of dibaryons in heavy-ioncollisions (1989 with P. Koch and M. May)

organizing the summer program on strangeness inSeattle 1992 (where we first met)

– p.7

Page 14: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Carl B. Dover and Strange Hadronic Matter (abridged)

his first talk ever on dibaryons:first hypernuclear meeting in Heidelberg 1982(Avraham Gal, private communication)

work on producing the H-dibaryon with hadronicreactions (PRL 1982 with Aerts)

work on production of dibaryons in heavy-ioncollisions (1989 with P. Koch and M. May)

organizing the summer program on strangeness inSeattle 1992 (where we first met)

joint work on strange hadronic matter 1993, 1994(with Gal, Millener, C. Greiner, Stöcker and myself)

– p.7

Page 15: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Nuclei with hyperons: hypernuclei

– p.8

Page 16: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Nuclear chart

– p.9

Page 17: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Baryon octet and decuplet

eightfold way: baryons have three quarks

lowest multiplets: octet (spin 1/2) and decuplet (spin 3/2)

baryon mass increases with number of strange quarks (strangeness)

nucleon (no s-quark): mN = 940 MeV → nuclear chart

– p.10

Page 18: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Baryon masses

hyperons with one s-quark: mΛ = 1116 MeV, mΣ+ = 1189 MeV,mΣ0 = 1193 MeV, mΣ− = 1197 MeV

hyperons with two s-quarks: mΞ0 = 1314 MeV, mΞ− = 1321 MeV

hyperon with three s-quarks: mΩ− = 1672 MeV (spin 3/2, Pauli principle!)

bound system with nucleons and hyperons: hypernuclei!– p.11

Page 19: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

First hypernuclear event

first hypernuclearmeasurement: 1953 byDanysz and Pniewskifrom cosmic rayemulsion event

unique double-star fea-ture on emulsion plate:one from hypernuclearproduction, one from hy-pernuclear decay!

– p.12

Page 20: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Danysz and Pniewski

Polish postcard commemorating Danysz and Pniewski (check out the stamp!)

– p.13

Page 21: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Hypernuclear spectra and levels

peak structure in pionspectra

related to single-particlelevels of hypernucleus!

first surprise: tiny spin-orbitsplitting for 16

Λ O !

– p.14

Page 22: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Λ Single–Particle Energies

(Millener, Dover, Gal 1988)

measured in (π+, K+) and (K−, π−) reactions

fit to single particle energies: UΛ = −28 MeV for A → ∞

’textbook’ example for single-particle structure in nuclear physics– p.15

Page 23: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Hypernuclear chart (Bando 1990)

many light hypernuclei observed in emulsion experiments (up to A=15)

heavier systems measured spectroscopically

– p.16

Page 24: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

HypHI program at GSI (Take Saito et al.)

exploration of the whole hypernuclear chart for light systems!

determination of the hypernuclear drip-line

note: hyperons stabilize nuclei, 8Be is unbound, but 9ΛBe is bound!

evidence for 6ΛH by FINUDA collaboration (2012)!

– p.17

Page 25: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Hyperon decays

Hyperons decay mainly by weak interactions:conserves baryon number and charge but changesstrangeness by one unit

Λ → p+ π−(64%), n+ π0(36%)

Σ+ → p+ π0(52%), n+ π+(48%)

Σ0 → Λ + γ (electromagnetic)

Σ− → n+ π−

Ξ0 → Λ + π0

Ξ− → Λ + π−

typical lifetime: τ ≈ 10−10 seconds

– p.18

Page 26: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Hypernuclear decays

(Park et al., PRC61 (2000) 054004)

Hyperons in the medium can also decay non-mesonically:

Λ +N → N +N , Σ+N → N +N

Ξ +N → Σ+N or Λ +N , Λ + Λ → Σ+N or Λ+N . . .

nonmesonic decay dominates already for moderate mass number!

hypernuclear lifetime saturates around 200 ps– p.19

Page 27: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Xi hypernuclei (Dover and Gal 1983)

Hypernucleus BΞ− [MeV] B

Ξ0 [MeV]8

ΞHe 8.1∗ ± 1.2 14.2± 1.8

11

ΞB 9.2± 2.2 0.4± 2.8

13

ΞC 18.1± 3.2 −4.3± 3.8

15

ΞC 16.0± 4.7 11.1± 5.3

17

ΞO 16.0± 5.5 −4.5± 6.1

28

ΞAl 23.2± 6.8 13.3± 7.4

first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959(Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959) 397)

incoming pion beam produces first star

two short tracks towards south and north: two hypernuclei emitted!

interpretation: 8ΞB with BΞ = 8.1± 1.2 (corrected for modern value of mΞ)

Ξ reacts via Ξ +N → Λ + Λ to form two hypernuclei

– p.20

Page 28: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

ΛΛ Hypernuclei

1963 Danysz et al.: 10ΛΛBe→9

ΛBe+p + π−, BΛΛ = 4.3± 0.4 MeV

1966 Prowse: 6ΛΛHe→5

ΛHe+p + π−, BΛΛ = 4.7± 0.6 MeV

1991 E176 (KEK): 13ΛΛB→13

ΛC+π−, BΛΛ = 4.8± 0.7 MeV

(Dover, Millener, Gal, Davis 1991)

2001 E373 (KEK): 6ΛΛHe→5

ΛHe+p + π−, BΛΛ = 1.0± 0.2 MeV!

2001 E906 (BNL): 4ΛΛH→4

ΛHe+π− or 7ΛΛLi (Randeniya and Hungerford 2007)

ΛΛ interaction is weakly attractive

total binding energy of two Λ’s: BΛΛ(A

ΛΛZ) = BΛ(A

ΛΛZ) +BΛ(A−1

Λ Z)

additional bond energy: BΛΛ(A

ΛΛZ) = BΛ(A

ΛΛZ)− 2BΛ(A−1

Λ Z)

– p.21

Page 29: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Updated world data on ΛΛ hypernuclei (2011)

(Gal and Millener 2011)

three modern events, comparison to shell model and clustermodel calculations

only uniquely identified double Λ hypernucleus: 6ΛΛHe !

– p.22

Page 30: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

PANDA at GSI: Measurement of double Λ hypernuclei

production of Ξ via antiproton beam on nuclei

capture of Ξ in another nucleus

γ-spectroscopy of produced double-Λ hypernucleus– p.23

Page 31: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Summary of Hypernuclear Systems

NΛ: attractive → Λ-hypernuclei for A = 3− 209

UΛ = −30 MeV at n = n0

NΣ: 4ΣHe hypernucleus bound by isospin forcesΣ− atoms: potential is repulsive

NΞ: attractive → 7 Ξ hypernuclear eventsUΞ = −28 MeV at n = n0

quasi-free production of Ξ: UΞ = −18 MeV

ΛΛ: attractive → 5 ΛΛ hypernuclear measurements

YY: Y= Λ,Σ,Ξ, unknown!

hypernuclear programs at:DaΦne, JLab, J-PARC, MAMI, and PANDA, HYPHI @FAIR!

– p.24

Page 32: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Metastable Exotic Multihypernuclear Objects (MEMOs)

– p.25

Page 33: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Classification of strange hadronic matter: doublets

−S\Z -2 -1 0 +1 +2

0 nn np pp

1 Σ−n Λ n Λ p Σ+p

2 Σ−Σ− Ξ−n ΛΛ Ξ0p Σ+Σ+

3 Ξ−Σ− Ξ−Λ Ξ0Λ Ξ0Σ+

4 Ξ−Ξ− Ξ0Ξ− Ξ0Ξ0

5 Ξ−Ω− Ξ0Ω−

6 Ω−Ω−

(JS, C.Greiner, Stöcker 1992, JSB, Dover, Gal, Millener, C.Greiner, Stöcker 1993, 1994)

ordering according to lowest sum of vacuum masses for givenstrangeness S and charge Z

– p.26

Page 34: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Classification of strange hadronic matter: triplets

−S\Z -2 -1 0 +1 +2

1 Λnp

2

3 Ξ−Σ−n Ξ−Λn Ξ0Λ p Ξ0Σ+p

4

5 Ξ−Ξ0Λ

6

7 Ω−Ξ−Ξ0

(JS, C. Greiner, Stöcker 1992, JSB, Dover, Gal, Millener, C. Greiner, Stöcker 1993, 1994)

more than three different baryons: system not stable against strongdecay in vacuum

– p.27

Page 35: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Stability of multi-Λ hypernuclei

Multihypernuclei

4+nLHenL

16+nLOnL

40+nLCanL

E/

A(M

eV)

nL

-5

-6

-7

-8

-9

0 5 10 15 20

total binding energy becomes smaller for light systems

binding energy increase for heavier systems

maximum binding energy for some (magic) number of Λ’s– p.28

Page 36: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Systems of Nucleons and Hyperons

55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 100A

-12.5

-12.0

-11.5

-11.0

-10.5

-10.0

-9.5

-9.0

-8.5

EB/A

(MeV

)

N = 14N = 8N = 0

56Ni+Y

(JS, Dover, Gal, Greiner, Stöcker (1993))

Pauli–blocking of the reactions: Λ+ Λ ↔ Ξ +N , Q ≈ −25 MeV

Σs are not stable: Σ+N → Λ +N , Q ≈ −80 MeV

nuclear binding energy with Λs and Ξs increases to E/A = −12 MeV!

– p.29

Page 37: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Binding energy of multistrange nuclei

0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0fS

-25

-20

-15

-10

-5

0

EB/A

(MeV

)

180Th

56Ni

Y

310G

208Pb

132Sn

56Ni

(JS, Dover, Gal, Greiner, Stöcker (1993))

sizable increase of the binding energy to E/A = −21 MeV

large strangeness fraction of fs = |S|/A = 0.6 up to fs = 1.1– p.30

Page 38: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Charge of multistrange nuclei

-0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6Z/A

-25

-20

-15

-10

-5

0

EB/A

(MeV

)

180Th

56Ni

Y

310G

208Pb

132Sn

56Ni

(JS, Dover, Gal, Greiner, Stöcker (1993))

negatively charged nuclei possible (with positive baryon number)!

purely hyperonic nuclei exist for fs = 1.8 and Z/A ≈ −0.3– p.31

Page 39: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Lightest MEMO candidate: 6ΛΞHe

NSC97bNSC97e

ΛΞ6He

-11.2

-11.1

E (MeV)

-11.8

-8.4

ΛΛ5He+Λ

Λ5He+Ξ0

-12.9

ppn3Λ

0.0

ΛΞ6H -7.9

-3.2

E (MeV)

-9.0ΛΛ

5H+Λ

Λ5He+Ξ-

-11.6

-11.4

pnn3Λ

0.0

(Filikhin and Gal 2002)

binding energy for different light systems with an α core plus three units ofstrangeness within a Fadeev calculation

possibly the lightest MEMO: 6ΛΞHe where Ξ +N → Λ + Λ is Pauli-blocked

– p.32

Page 40: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Dibaryons

– p.33

Page 41: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Multi-Quark States: Some History (incomplete)

multi-quark states already mentioned by Gell-Mann in 1964

strange four-quark states (qsqs): Jaffe 1977

strange six-quark states (qqqqss: H-dibaryon): Jaffe 1978

heavy tetraquarks (QQqq): Ader, Richard, Taxil 1982

pentaquarks with charm (qqqsc): Lipkin 1987 and Gignoux,Silvestre-Brac, Richard 1987

. . .

light pentaquark (qqqqs) in chiral soliton model:Diakonov, Petrov, Polyakov 1997

light pentaquark in diquark model:Jaffe and Wilczek 2003

– p.34

Page 42: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

News from Lattice Data on Dibaryons

HALQCD collaboration (Inoue et al. 2011):bound H-dibaryon with BH = 20− 50 MeV (formps = 469− 1171 MeV)

NPLQCD collaboration (Beane et al. 2011):bound H-dibaryon with BH = 13.2(1.8)(4.0) MeV andbound (Ξ−Ξ−)b state with BΞΞ = 14.0(1.4)(6.7) MeV(for mπ = 390 MeV)

Shanahan, Thomas, Young 2011:H unbound by 13± 14 MeV at physical pion mass

Haidenbauer and Meißner 2011:either ΛΛ is unbound (HALQCD) ora resonant state 5 MeV below ΞN threshold(NPLQCD)

– p.35

Page 43: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Baryon-baryon potentials: SU(3) symmetry

(Stoks and Rijken 1999)

classify states according to SU(3)

coupling of two octets:

8× 8 = 1 + 8 + 8 + 10 + 10∗ + 27

NN has bound state in 3S1 −3 D1

(deuteron) → 10∗

NN has quasi-bound state in 3S0

(E = +90 keV) → 27

SU(3) symmetry: bound states in

all pure 10∗

broken SU(3): quasi-bound states

become bound as hyperons are

heavier than nucleons

– p.36

Page 44: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Baryon-baryon potentials: Nijmegen soft-core models

Nijmegen soft core model NSC97a-f (newer versionsof extended soft-core model: ESC04-08)

one-boson exchange model for pseudoscalar, scalar,and vector mesons

uses SU(3) flavour symmetry

fitted to NN and NY scattering data

predictions for dibaryons (Stoks, Rijken 1999):

– p.37

Page 45: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Baryon-baryon potentials: Nijmegen soft-core models

Nijmegen soft core model NSC97a-f (newer versionsof extended soft-core model: ESC04-08)

one-boson exchange model for pseudoscalar, scalar,and vector mesons

uses SU(3) flavour symmetry

fitted to NN and NY scattering data

predictions for dibaryons (Stoks, Rijken 1999):

Σ+p, Σ−n: quasibound stateΣ+Σ+, Σ−Σ−: Eb = −1.5 to −3.2 MeVΞ0Σ+, Ξ−Σ−: Eb = −2 to −17 MeVΞ0Ξ0, Ξ0Ξ−: Eb = +1 to −16 MeVΞ−Ξ−: less bound by ≈ 1 MeV

– p.37

Page 46: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Baryon-baryon potentials: Quark-meson models

quark-meson exchange model

uses confinement potential for quarks

SU(3) symmetry for quark-meson coupling constants

describes light hypernuclei

predictions for dibaryons(Fujiwara, Suzuki, Nakamoto 2007):

– p.38

Page 47: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Baryon-baryon potentials: Quark-meson models

quark-meson exchange model

uses confinement potential for quarks

SU(3) symmetry for quark-meson coupling constants

describes light hypernuclei

predictions for dibaryons(Fujiwara, Suzuki, Nakamoto 2007):

no bound states

– p.38

Page 48: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Baryon-baryon potentials: chiral effective models

one-boson exchange of pseudoscalar mesons pluscontact terms

uses SU(3) symmetry, low-energy constants

fixed to NN and NY scattering data

predictions for dibaryons(Haidenbauer and Meißner 2010):

– p.39

Page 49: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Baryon-baryon potentials: chiral effective models

one-boson exchange of pseudoscalar mesons pluscontact terms

uses SU(3) symmetry, low-energy constants

fixed to NN and NY scattering data

predictions for dibaryons(Haidenbauer and Meißner 2010):

Ξ0Λ: Eb = −0.43 MeV or quasiboundΞ0Σ+: Eb = −2.23 to −6.15 MeVΞΞ: Eb = −2.56 to −7.28 MeV

results depend on cutoff

– p.39

Page 50: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

SU(3) model for hyperon weak decays

Matrix element of mesonic decay B → B′ + π:

M = uf(A+ Bγ5)ui · φπ

SU(3) flavour symmetry for weak interaction vertex of twobaryons and one pseudoscalar meson

L = DTrBB [P, λ6] + FTrB [P, λ6]B

+GTrBPγ5Bλ6 +HTrBλ6γ5BP + JTrBP, λ6γ5B

B: baryon octet, P : pseudoscalar nonet.Parameters: D = 4.72 and F = −1.62 for A amplitudesand G = 40.0, H = 47.8, and J = −7.1 for the Bamplitudes in units of 10−7

(JSB, Mattiello, Sorge 2000)– p.40

Page 51: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

SU(3) model for nonmesonic decay

model the nonmesonic decay

(B1B2) → B′1 + B′

2

meson exchange model: strong vertex fromone-boson exchange model

weak vertex from weak hyperon decay

use parameterized deuteron-like wavefunction(Krivoruchenko and Shchepkin 1982)

one parameter: binding energy of dibaryon system

– p.41

Page 52: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Weak decays of bound ΛN systems

0 5 10 15Binding energy [MeV]

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

Bra

nchi

ng r

atio

Λp→n+p

ΛN→N+p+π−

ΛN→N+n+π0

Λn→n+n

mesonic decay dominates for small binding energies

dominant decay mode is the nonmesonic one for larger binding energies

∆I = 1/2 rule favours nonmesonic decays with protons

– p.42

Page 53: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Dibaryon Σp

0 5 10 15Binding energy [MeV]

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

Bra

nchi

ng r

atio

Σ+p→p+n+π+

Σ+p→p+p

Σ+p→p+p+π0

Σ+p has charge +2 !

only one nonmesonic decay channel possible to two protons

a bound state should show up in invariant pp-spectrum at M = 2.128GeV−Eb

– p.43

Page 54: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Weak Decays of Dibaryon ΛΛ

0 5 10 15Binding energy [MeV]

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

Bra

nchi

ng r

atio ΛΛ→Λ+n+π0

ΛΛ→Σ−+p

ΛΛ→Σ0+n

ΛΛ→Λ+n

ΛΛ→Λ+p+π−

dominant decay mode of the dihyperon is (ΛΛ)b → Σ− + p

similar to the H-dibaryon H → Σ− + p

– p.44

Page 55: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Weak Decays of Dibaryon Ξ0p

0 5 10 15Binding energy [MeV]

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

Bra

nchi

ng r

atio

Ξ0p→Σ+

+n

Ξ0p→Λ+p+π0

Ξ0p→Λ+p

Ξ0p→Σ0

+p

decay (Ξ0p)b → Λ + p dominates for Eb > 1.5 MeV

can be seen in Λp mass spectrum

weak decay has the same decay topology as Ξ− → Λ + π− and Ω− → ΛK−

– p.45

Page 56: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Weak Decays of Dibaryon Ξ0Λ

0 5 10 15Binding energy [MeV]

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

Bra

nchi

ng r

atio

Ξ0Λ→Ξ−+p

Ξ0Λ→Ξ0+N+π

Ξ0Λ→Λ+Λ+π0

Ξ0Λ→Λ+Λ,Ξ0+n

Ξ0Λ→Λ+Σ0

Ξ0Λ→Σ++Σ−

(Ξ0Λ)b decays to Λ+ Λ or Ξ− + p

look at ΛΛ and Ξ−p invariant mass spectrum

reconstruction of two Λs in a single event possible(AGS: E896, SPS: WA97, RHIC: STAR, CERN:ALICE)

– p.46

Page 57: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Weak Decays of Dibaryon Ξ0Ξ−

0 5 10 15Binding energy [MeV]

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

Bra

nchi

ng r

atio Ξ0Ξ−→Ξ0

+Σ−

Ξ0Ξ−→Ξ−+Σ0

Ξ0Ξ−→Ξ0+Λ+π−

Ξ0Ξ−→Ξ−+Λ+π0

Ξ0Ξ−→Ξ−+Λ

predicted to be bound by Nijmegen model NSC97 and Chiral EFT

can be seen by (Ξ0Ξ−)b → Ξ− + Λ in Ξ−Λ mass plots

branching ratio is only a few percent

– p.47

Page 58: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Doubly Charged Dibaryons

(Σ−Σ−)b → Σ− + n+ π− (the only decay channel!)

(Σ−Ξ−)b → Σ− + Σ−

→ Σ− + Λ+ π−

→ Ξ− + n+ π−

(Ξ−Ξ−)b → Ξ− + Σ−

→ Ξ− + Λ + π−

all decays have a unique decay prong(one track splits to two)!

experimental problem: neutral particles and/orthree-body decay, hard to measure

– p.48

Page 59: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Lifetime of dibaryons

0 5 10 15Binding energy [MeV]

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

Life

time

x 10

−10

[s]

Ξ0Ξ−

Ξ0Λ

τ(Λ)

Ξ0p

τ(Ξ−)

Σ+p

ΛΛ

bound dibaryons have just a smaller decay length than hyperonscτ = 1− 5 cm

lifetime decreases with the binding energy as baryons are sitting closertogether

– p.49

Page 60: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Meson assisted strange dibaryons

proposed by Gal and Garcilazo (2008, 2010)

bound states of mesons and two baryons

maximum isospin, attractive p-wave channel formesons

candidates: πNΞ, πΛΞ

charmed analog: πNΛc

(can only decay weakly if bound!)

– p.50

Page 61: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Finding exotic matter

– p.51

Page 62: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Timeline for strange matter detection

– p.52

Page 63: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Double hypernuclei production at the AGS

(Baltz, Dover, Kahana, Pang, Schlegel, Schnedermann 1994)

coalescence model within a relativistic transport model

first full phase-space model calculation for hypernuclear production inheavy-ion collisions

includes (significant) production rates for double Λ hypernuclei– p.53

Page 64: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Sensitivity range for detecting strange matter

(Dover, talk given at PANIC meeting 1991, preprint BNL-46322)

rough coalescence estimate: production ∝ qA · λ|S|, q = Nd/Np, λ = NY /NN

for a sensitivity of the experiment of 10−n: |S|+A ≤ n+ 3

includes (stable) dibaryon states!

– p.54

Page 65: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Production of hypernuclei in heavy-ion collisions

(Armstrong, Dover et al. (E864 collaboration) 2004)

production of 3ΛH and 4

ΛH seen!

decay modes: 3ΛH→3He+π−, 4

ΛH→4He+π−

last paper of Carl Dover!

– p.55

Page 66: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Fishing hypernuclei out of the QGP at RHIC

(STAR collaboration, Science 2010)

production of 3ΛH and its antiparticle seen

measurement of invariant mass spectrum of π− and 3He

initiated follow-up experiments at GSI (FOPI) and LHC (ALICE)!– p.56

Page 67: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Dibaryon production rates at RHIC

−6 −4 −2 0 2 4 6ycms

10−6

10−4

10−2

100

102

dN/d

y Ξ0p*10

Ξ0Λ/10

Ξ0Ξ−/100

p

Ξ0/Ξ− Σ+ΛΣ+

p*10

ΛΛ

(JSB, Mattiello, Sorge 2000)

assuming coalescence, phase-space overlap(a QGP or a chiral phase will enhance rates)

production rates for dihyperons are between 10−2 and 10−4 per event

flat rapidity distribution, detection at forward/backward rapidity likely– p.57

Page 68: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

MEMO production at future GSI’s FAIR machine

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 810-15

10-13

10-11

10-9

10-7

10-5

10-3

10-1

7 He

2 , 2 0, 2 -

6 HeM

ultip

licity

A

H0

-, 0 He4

4

2 -, 2 0

5 He

q

2 n, 2 , 2 -

ELab = 30A GeV

(Steinheimer et al. 2009)

coalescence estimate within a hybrid model: UrQMD plus Hydro 3D code

CBM experiment is sensitive to all these extremely strange objects!

– p.58

Page 69: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

Dibaryon feasibility study for FAIR energies

(Steinheimer et al. 2010)

UrQMD event generator for Au+Au at 25 AGeV heavy-ion collisions

mock data within UrQMD event of bound (Ξ0Λ)b dibaryon states

look at invariant mass spectrum of two Λ’s

peak clearly visible over background– p.59

Page 70: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

The charming world of exotic states

talk given by Carl at the HIPAGS meeting 1990 (BNL-44520) on:’Production of rare composite objects in relativistic heavy-ioncollision’

discusses antimatter, hypernuclei, strangelets, H-dibaryon,charmed pentaquark and tetraquark state with bottom quark

probability for forming charmed states at RHIC à la Car:l

P (A,C) ≈

(

σcc

σtotal

)|C|

×

(

NN

)A

×Nπ ≈ 103−2|C|−2A

gives about 0.1 deuterons, 0.1 Λc, 10 D-mesons

for a sensitivity of 10−n: 2A+ 2|C| < 3 + n

able to find charmed hexaquark states?(JSB and Vischer 1998)

– p.60

Page 71: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

How to detect strange matter?

unique opportunity to produce and study them inheavy-ion collisions

tracking down strange dibaryons by:(A) a direct look: exotic decay tracks in TPC(B) backtracking: invariant mass spectra for bounddibaryons(C) correlations: resonances seen in correlationfunctions, reveals interaction potential

poised for discoveries!

– p.61

Page 72: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

The heritage of Carl B. Dover

(BNL Science and Technology Award 1994,

courtesy: Tony Baltz)

the exploration ofstrange matter liveson

– p.62

Page 73: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

The heritage of Carl B. Dover

(BNL Science and Technology Award 1994,

courtesy: Tony Baltz)

the exploration ofstrange matter liveson

the scientific heritageof Carl!

– p.62

Page 74: Exploring Strange Matters Jurgen Schaffner-Bielich¨ · Ξ Al 23.2 ± 6.8 13.3 ± 7.4 first bound Ξ hypernucleus seen in 1959 (Wilkinson, Lorant, Robinson, Lokanathan, PRL 3 (1959)

The heritage of Carl B. Dover

(BNL Science and Technology Award 1994,

courtesy: Tony Baltz)

the exploration ofstrange matter liveson

the scientific heritageof Carl!

thanks Carl!

– p.62