EXHIBIT H · 2018-03-21 · EXHIBIT H '18CV0373AJB WVG Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10...
Transcript of EXHIBIT H · 2018-03-21 · EXHIBIT H '18CV0373AJB WVG Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10...
EXHIBIT H
'18CV0373 WVGAJB
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.212 Page 1 of 54
LICE
~ i¥a "1 ilD m7t ..:z:. 112 f51 flR ~ ~ ,/~ ic;. ~ J OL Co•
No 13. Ln 68 Nux1 Rd. Luzhu Dis t . Taoyuan City 33852 I a1wan 33852 ~ ifj jj ~ ..., ~ 68 13 "' TEL · •886-3-3242000 FAX .. 886-3-3246611 http / /\'."-''w ude-corp com/
Mr. William Malherbe GM Network Acess BU Pulse Electronics San Diego CA USA
Mar. 6, 2017
Re: Pulse ICM and Related Intellectual Property - need a response, you letter dated
Mar. 4, 2017
Dear Mr. William Malherbe
Thank you for your letter dated March 4, 2017 in response to my previous October
27, 2016 correspondence.
With regards to the letter dated in February 3, 2017, our IP team has provided these
reports respectively in respon se to following Pulse 's U.S. patents including US
6,593,840, US 6, 773,302, US 7,959,473, US 9,178,318, please see the attached files.
Since the technology of US 6,593,840, US 6,773,302, US 7,959,473, US 9,178,318
should be public used or prior art, so we consider that the corresponding exemplary
structure mentioned in these four patents should not infringe.
Shall you have further question on above statements, please don't hesitate to
contact us.
Sincerely,
Gary Chen
Chairman & CEO of UDE Corporation
No. 13, Ln. 68, Neixi Rd. , Luzhu Dist .,
Taoyuan City 33852, Taiwan.
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.213 Page 2 of 54
'
U.S. Patent No. 6,773,302 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lG ICM
U.S. Patent No. 6, 773,302 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 1G ICM
1Acautmbly compnsinc:
'~zjJ hn<nc
UDE LU 1G ICM
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.214 Page 3 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 6, 773,302 (Claim 1) vs. Exempliilry UDE 2x4 lG ICM
UDE 2XA lG ICM
U.S. Patent No. 6,773,302 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x41G ICM
• .&dto rw<•...,. at ~ut a port.on of U..CS H Mast
orw substrstt
UC£ l.M lGICM
POltJOn of
~-~ wb>tntl
rKfivff
"'"""' CllV!tl
U.S. Patent No. 6, 773,302 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lG ICM
conflptd to form on tf .ctna C«ltX1 ... 111 re:spec_tlW ones of s:a.d tenn.wi ls wt\~ H'd
""""' '• • ptuc 1s
UC£ l.M 161CM
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.215 Page 4 of 54
,.
U.S. Patent No. 6,773,302 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x41G ICM
E1«1rol
p.ltttways ,_ be,,....n
conductors
dttposad 1n
..asJ l nd -... FCC frame
Slae V'e'\
U.S. Patent No. 6,773,302 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2><4 lG ICM
a pluroloy ol Ma>fld
conductonst~
OM of Ard i:Kond condunon ~., ti.aria
commuruaot- -s.ltd It lent OM
tioctna'Jy conduct.,. pall!~ ol "'id at lu st
one~i•
UDE DA lG ICM
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.216 Page 5 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 6,773,302 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x41G ICM
UOf: 2M IG KM
U.S. Patent No. 6 ,773,302 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lG ICM
UOElMlGICM
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.217 Page 6 of 54
I
About the structures mentioned, the structural features of the RJ reductive terminal
are also well known in the art as early as before the date of the US Patent No.
6, 773,302 patent application and have been disclosed in U.S. Patent Application
Serial No.5,501,608, issued Mar 26, 1996 And Serial No. 6,109,935, issued August 29,
2000 And U.S. Patent No. 6,083,047, filed July 4, 2000 Actual content (as shown in
the following figure)
U.S. Patent Mar. 26, 1996 Sheet 3 or 5
RJ-11
IG_ 5
5,501,608
7b
7c
7d
RJ reductive Terminal
curved portion
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.218 Page 7 of 54
I tr: '3
· al RJ reduct ive Termin
curved portion
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.219 Page 8 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 6,773,302 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lG ICM
E .anal
~ , ......... -conduaonond
..-na(FCC
~adlft\ltt
diroc1ly to POI~
IUZ.U lGICM
Moreover, the RJ reductive Terminal curved portion structure of the above
mentioned, the protruding portion of PCB is from the top to the bottom in the
vertical direction which is totally different structure as wrote in paragraph S of the US
Patent No. 6,773,302 "with the plane of the primary substrate 131 being
substantially parallel with the direction of run of the primary conductors 120 a (i.e.,
front-to-back).
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.220 Page 9 of 54
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.221 Page 10 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 7,959,473 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.222 Page 11 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 7,959,473 (Clilim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
~ connea:or houJlRC Compn>ll1( I p url~'V
ofpuc-n<•"'"'C rece:J.Su
UDClOG"'octuct
The structural features" Connector housing with plurality of plug-rece iving recesses"
of the above were publicly disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No. 7,959,4 73 ;
as shown in The Chinese mainland on December 31, 2003 Publication No.
CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent No. ZL02295243.8
100
21 312
[!} 1
Connector housing
w ith plurality of
plug-receiving
11
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.223 Page 12 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 7,959,473 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
UOE10G Produ<1
The structural features " Rear cavities" of the above were publicly disclosed prior to
the date of the US Patent No. 7,959,473 ; as shown in The Chinese mainland on
December 31, 2003 Publication No. CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent No.
ZL02295243.8
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.224 Page 13 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 7,959,473 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
1 ptWllitv ol tennnal w en as.sembf~ e1dt comp<n.dof 1 Tenn1N11nt«t
wb<tlntlOl!ll "''"'" ·~ (1ol4) l<Mftd ~It of , .,,.,.,,., In_,, hr./tni
1""""~---_.I Nbnant .. Dy
mnorOMpd
pattoft~
ln$eru
UDE 10G Produa
The structural features " Terminal insert assembly (1of4) having substant ially m irror
imaged pair of terminal inserts,, of the above were publicly disclosed prior to the date
of the US Patent No. 7,959,473 ; as shown in US Patent No.5531612 and The Chinese
mainland on December 31, 2003 Publication No. CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent
No. ZL02295243.8
Terminal insert
assembly (1 of 4)
having substantially
mirror imaged pair
of terminal inserts
62
~ 2
U.S. ratrnr J ul 1, 19ff """""' ' ., • 5.SJl.hl 2
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.225 Page 14 of 54
U.S. Pat.ent No. 7,959,473 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x410G ICM
such that a CfY"9ft on1
of ltlO pll.nlity of t•l"rTUnlif W«t
ls:Jembh:s. IS rwaived It lea.st pw1'y Wlthtn at
..... two~ - ptuc. rK t"ta.J;S,el; ~nd
UO(lOGPr-
The structural features " Terminals of one of inserts shown when insert assembly
installed in cavity and Pair of over-under plug-receiving recesses, each receiving one
of the terminal inserts shown above" of the above were publicly disclosed prior to
the date of the US Patent No. 7,959,473 ; as shown in The Chinese mainland on
December 31, 2003 Publication No. CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent No.
ZL02295243.8
Pai r of over-under
plug-receiving
recesses, each
receiving one of
the terminal inserts
l Q.O
Iii 1
11
Terminals of one of
inserts shown hen
insert assembly
installed in cavity
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.226 Page 15 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 7,959,473 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
l<IU<'las.wmbly
(On'v _sho_
four (41 puset1t - ··emplay COMectOt
ln.sert a.ssetr~
5hown tnMrted
Wlth lf'I r.SpKTNe
<•VJIY
The structural features " Insert assembly( Only one shown. four (4) present within
exemplary connector assembly) and Insert assembly shown inserted within
respective cavity" of the above were publicly disclosed prior to the date of the US
Patent No. 7,959,473 ; as shown in The Chinese mainland on December 31, 2003
Publication No. CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent No. ZL02295243.8
312
(J] 2
62
Insert
assembly(Only one
shown, four (4)
present within
exemplary
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.227 Page 16 of 54
Insert assembly
shown inserted
with in respective
cavity
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.228 Page 17 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 7,959,473 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
OM • IKtronK
COM-t ddl'Osed lubstant.QC th.rt<>n
Ad top tubstrue ~comons....._~
pCuni'fty of t lnNN
~.
UDE lOG Produa
The structural features " Electrically conductive pathways and Terminal apertures
(shown with terminals installed) and Electronic ponents disposed on top substrate "
of the above were publicly disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No. 7,959,473
as shown in The Chinese mainland on December 31, 2003 Publication No.
CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent No. ZL02295243.8
Electrically ductive
pathways
Terminal apertures
(shown with
terminals installed)
62
00 2
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.229 Page 18 of 54
~ 12
Electronic ponents
disposed on top
substrate
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.230 Page 19 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 7,959,473 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
spac• cf bodv e'9'f'Ml1t. tMO'I _,... (toro!ds)
s
UOEtoGPr-
The structural features " Pair of insert body elements" of the above were publicly
disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No. 7,959,473 ; as shown in The Chinese
mainland on December 31, 2003 Publication No. CN2596615Y Util ity Model Patent
No. ZL02295243.8
312
!!! 2
Pair of insert body
elements
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.231 Page 20 of 54
The structural features# Electronic component receiving space of body element, w ith
components (toroids) " of the above were publicly disclosed prior to the date of the
US Patent No. 7,959,473 : as shown in The Chinese mainland on January 14, 2004
Publication No. CN2599819Y Utility Model Patent No. ZL02295321.3
3222
3220
20
3 422
360 44 362
36 80 320 304a' 340
304 ' 300'
31'
Electronic component
receiving space of
body element, with
components (toroids)
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.232 Page 21 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 7,959,473 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
U0£10G--
The structural featuresh Upper conductive terminal portions h of the above were
publicly disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No. 7,959,473 ; as shown in The
Chinese mainland on December 31, 2003 Publication No. CN259661SY Utility Model
Patent No. ZL02295243.8
Upper conductive
terminal portions
312
62
Ill 2
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.233 Page 22 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 7,959,473 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x410G ICM
UDE IOG Product
The structural featuresh Lower conductive terminals" of the above were publicly
disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No. 7,959,473 ; as shown in The Chinese
mainland on December 31, 2003 Publication No. CN2596615Y Util ity Model Patent
No. ZL02295243.8
Lower conductive
terminals
312
00 2
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.234 Page 23 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 7,959,473 (Cliilm 1) vs. Exempluy UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
• plu<a>rv m--.....u thlt"" berwan the • htc!JvnK component
fK*11m\C :l~e Ind It l•1st I porbOn of tt'I loo.wr c.onductrv9 ~eonu~l portJOnS
component r~
~- ..... -.. conductNt , ..... ..... -
lower conduawe tHTNNifl
UDE10GllrodllCI
The structural features# Electronic component receiving space and Channels that run
between the electronic component receiving space and the lower conductive
terminal portions and Lower conductive terminals" of the above were publicly
disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No. 7,959,473 ; as shown in The Chinese
mainland on December 31, 2003 Publication No. CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent
No. ZL02295243.8
Electronic omponent
receiving space
Channels that run between
the electronic component
receiving space and the lower
conductive terminal portions
Lower conductive
terminals
312
~~~~~-52 ,.,--.~ -- 51
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.235 Page 24 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 7,959,473 {Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x410G ICM
,, The structural features " Channels that run between the electronic component
receiving space and at least a portion of the lower conductive terminal portions" of
the above were publicly disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No. 7,959,473 ;
as shown in The Chinese mainland on December 31, 2003 Publication No.
CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent No. ZL02295243.8
09
Channels that run between the electronic
component receiving space and at least a
portion of the lower conductive terminal
portions
29
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.236 Page 25 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 7,959,473 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
-soldplonl-.y
ofdl.\nM!s •-fo< the routlf'C olwtre be!WHn .,,. • tetn>n>C
C~'ttKaM"I
spac• 1<1d m. lowt< COnduaM rerm~
portions
The structural featuresh Lower conductive terminals and Wires of electronic
components (toroids)and the lower conductive terminal portions and Electronic
component rece iving spaceh of the above were publicly disclosed prior to the date of
the US Patent No. 7,959,473 ; as shown in The Chinese mainland on January 14, 2004
Publication No. CN2599819Y Utility Model Patent No. ZL02295321.3
28
Lower conductive terminals
64 62
Wires of electronic
components (toroids}
Electronic component
receiving space
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.237 Page 26 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 7,959,473 (Claim 1) vs. Exemph1ry UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
UOEIOGProd""
r l~~ II :.. . :··:~ "_:.:~ ......
• ~- ,, J . .. -· \' · ... ,.,,,.. ....
.,. ) .. . . :; ....
The structural features " Lower conductive terminals and Wires running from toroids
to upper terminal portions and Upper terminal portions" of the above were publicly
disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No. 7,959,473 ; as shown in The Chinese
mainland on January 14, 2004 Publication No. CN2599819Y Utility Model Patent No.
ZL02295321.3
Upper terminal portions 28
Wires running from toroids
to upper terminal portions Lower conductive terminals
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.238 Page 27 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 7,959,473 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2>l4 lOG ICM
M"l'»rna1 to.,.. outer
~fonnedtry
mated Pl'!n of W'...l«t
body .tem.ntl
UDElOGPn>du<t
The structural featuresh Outer periphery formed by mated pairs of insert body elements
and All toroid wires routed within channels and terminated within outer periphery"
of the above were publicly disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No. 7,959,473
as shown in The Chinese mainland on December 31, 2003 Publication No.
CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent No. ZL02295243.8 and the Chinese mainland
January 14, 2004 Authorized notice No. CN2599819Y utility model patent
ZL02295321.3 Actual content
JI~ 1
Outer periphery formed by
mated pairs of insert body
elements
...., ~,~ ..... _ ..
.i.p;;~-F=::tt -J~•l llO
~·~~~~~~~~-~~ t1*~1!'r.~l-l.:-.;,'
- x:i
J .
i!J 9
All toroid wires routed within
channels and terminated
within outer periphery
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.239 Page 28 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 9,178,318 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.240 Page 29 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 9,178,318 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2><4 lOG ICM
14 Art ""tcr•td conneaor module
""""''""'" I COM«tOf hous.i,,C compnsc!C I p'un lty
of ConM<tOf POfU lmin(td tn I row-.and· column fa.shlOI\
UOElOGICM
The structural features" ICM housing with plurality of plug-receiving ports in
rows/columns" of the above were publicly disclosed prior to the date of the US
Patent No.9,178,318 : as shown in The Chinese mainland on December 31, 2003
Publication No. CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent No. Zl02295243.8
lug-rece iving ports in
fl! 1 rows/columns
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.241 Page 30 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 9,178,318 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x410G ICM
one or mor-e llf\S«t
bodlasf\rtlw compnsanc 1n mt:.m1 pnnr.ct cro.1n: boMd,
UDE JOG KM
The structural features " Internal PCB and Insert bodies" of the above were publicly
disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No.9,178,318 ; as shown in The Chinese
mainland on December 31, 2003 Publication No. CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent
No. ZL02295243.8
Internal PCB
00 2
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.242 Page 31 of 54
The structural features" Sets of electronic components" of the above were publicly
disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No. 9,178,318 ; as shown in The Chinese
mainland on January 14, 2004 Publication No. CN2599819Y Utility Model Patent No.
ZL02295321.3
3222
3220
20
3420
3422
28
l!l 9 Sets of electronic
components
360
44 362
36 80 320 3040. ' 340
304 ' 300'
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.243 Page 32 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 9,178,318 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x410G ICM
Ull(lOGICM
~:;;:;~·::;--.~!.4911~-,;;--~ ™'-r--bad.,.....,,..,
Otho< EM. >1>-1<1> of
tt.."pl,...t...,.(le
ll>Md i..twfff' lh•
two tns.n bod•J of . ..,,....,,~,
a>mPme~
1l11ok1")11>1t.,,~t10!Ati0f\for
ttch S.M of --~IC
The structural features/' EMI shields (front and back pieces that comprise "body
shield") that provide electrical isolation for each set of electronic components
associated with each set of insert bodies" of the above were publicly disclosed prior
to the date of the US Patent No.9,178,318 ; as shown in The Chinese mainland on
December 31, 2003 Publication No. CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent No.
ZL02295243.8
EMI shields (front and back pieces that
comprise "body shield" ) that provide
electrical isolation for each set of
electronic components associated with
each set of insert bodies
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.244 Page 33 of 54
The structural features" Other EMI shields of the "plurality" (i.e., shield between the
two insert bodies of each insert assembly)that provide electrical isolation for each
set of electronic components associated with each set of insert bodies " of the above
were publicly disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No.9,178,318 ; as shown in
The Chinese mainland on December 31, 2003 Publication No. CN259661SY Utility
Model Patent No. ZL02295243.8
09
29
28
Other EMI shields of the
"plurality" (i.e., shield
between the two insert bodies
of each insert assembly)
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.245 Page 34 of 54
The structural features " Other EMI shields of the "plurality" (i.e., shield between the
two insert bodies of each insert assembly)" of the above were publicly disclosed prior
to the date of the US Patent No. 9,178,318 ; as shown in The Chinese mainland on
January 14, 2004 Publication No. CN2599819Y Utility Model Patent No.
ZL02295321.3
302
306
II 7
44
300'
Other EMI shields of the
"plurality" (i .e., shield
between the two insert
bodies of each insert
assembly)
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.246 Page 35 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 9,178,318 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x410G ICM
llM phn •IV of EM -Nn:htf
EIK\ncltl conn.ctoon of
•W"ttma bodv shi• d and
mom. PCB po<.W>d pion•
lndru.nbodywntm•
shit d ,,,,_... tlecmal
ao..aton for d'le • Kttonic
Componen'lS of the WU«!
UOEIOGICM
a.ct.~ of ..,.,,,.1 PCB wrth
- ..,.,,...._ m.m "°""" btt<m_,_ , _te.al - lxa o1 f'N•
pen-) elec1na"y
lnt•rf~c:u wrth ritt<nat
PCB,,..,..11.,.ro
The structural features " Back portion of internal PCB with solder connection from
ground plane to internal (insert body) shield" of the above were publicly disclosed
prior to the date of the US Patent No. 9,178,318 ; as shown in Republic of
Chinaon(Taiwan) January 11, 2011 Publication Utility Model Patent No. M396525
4
42
41
421
2
431
Back portion of internal PCB with solder
connection from ground plane to
internal (insert body) shield
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.247 Page 36 of 54
The structural featuresn External body shield (vertical back face of rear portion)
electrically interfaces with internal PCB via rearward projecting tab of insert body
internal metallic shield" of the above were publicly disclosed prior to the date of the
US Patent No.9,178,318 ; as shown in The Chinese mainland on December 31, 2003
Publication No. CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent No. ZL02295243.8
09
29
28
External body shield {vertical back
face of rear portion) electrically
interfaces with internal PCB via
rearward projecting tab of insert
body internal metallic shield
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.248 Page 37 of 54
The structural featuresn External body shield (vertical back face of rear portion)
electrically interfaces with internal PCB via rearward project ing tab of insert body
internal metallic shield" of the above were publicly disclosed prior to the date of the
US Patent No. 9,178,318 ; as shown in The Chinese mainland on January 14, 2004
Publication No. CN2599819Y Utility Model Patent No. ZL02295321.3
302
306
300'
!!] 7
External body shield (vertical back face of
rear portion) electrically interfaces with
internal PCB via rearward projecting tab of
insert body internal metallic shield
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.249 Page 38 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 9,178,318 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
• •"'..rdrC IX> d<sposed at tn.a Plrt-4vwztl\J.n 11t
leononeofllw phlnlir, of connector
poru.
si...ld"' - 1-ui1 ;c--u•hped •a ¢ whd1 .,...,.cally
....--- '""''-"'body ,,,!Old ,_pelf port)
UOElOGKM
The structural features" Shielding tabs (metallic wrap-around U-shaped "clips" which
electrically interface with front piece of body shield (one per port) " of the above
were publicly disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No. 9,178,318 : as shown in
Republic of Chinaon(Taiwan} January 11, 2011 Publication Util ity Model Patent No.
M396525
Shielding tabs (metallic
wrap-around U-shaped "clips"
which electrically interface with
front piece of body shield (one
per port}
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.250 Page 39 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 9,178,318 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x410G ICM
tl>e sh.elcl"'C cab conficurecl l<I prOlll<M
eKUJCl CD~
... tv.Hn tM lnt«NI
pnrnecl ore>Jh boord and <M body slueld a1 •
ll'ont pon:- of the 1ntem11 ~Nd orcun
bol<d
UOElOGICM
Slueldlnc tabs on front
tabs provuUt • 'KtnC:lil
<OfVWCWltY b<!-..
front portJon of PCB and
(front! body slueld
The structural features " Shielding tabs on front portion of PCB shown projecting
through front face of connector housing when assembled (body shield removed) -
tabs provide electrical connectivity between front portion of PCB and (front) body
shield" of the above were publicly disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No.
9,178,318 ; as shown in Republic of Chinaon{Taiwan) January 11, 2011 Publication
Utility Model Patent No. M396525
Shielding tabs on front portion
of PCB shown projecting
through front face of connector
housing when assembled {body
shield removed) - tabs provide
electrical connectivity between
front portion of PCB and (front)
body shield
62
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.251 Page 40 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 6,593,840 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.252 Page 41 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 6,593,840 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
l .. • er'!''OIK
w, C'On'\Pf11tnc.
E ectron•c
Mvtee '
UOE10GICM
~
buebod•u (l)
· Note AltcmatJVetv. the recned ele<:tronoc device mri be considered as the ennre ICM, or ICM USj!fTlDled
onto mo1hefl>oard
The structural featuresn Non-conductive base bodies (2) " of the above were publicly
disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No. 6,593,840 ; as shown in The Chinese
mainland on December 31, 2003 Publication No. CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent
No. ZL02295243.8
312
531
00 2
62 Non-conductive base
bodies (2)
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.253 Page 42 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 6,593,840 (Claim 1) v~. EHmplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
The structural features n Non-conductive base bodies ... of the above were publicly
disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No. 6,593,840 ; as shown in The Chinese
mainland on December 31, 2003 Publication No. CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent
No. ZL02295243.8
Non-conducti
ve base body
31 2
62
~ 2
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.254 Page 43 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 6,593,840 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
The structural features " Plurality of channels " of the above were publicly disclosed
prior to the date of the US Patent No. 6,593,840 ; as shown in The Chinese mainland
on December 31, 2003 Publication No. CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent No.
ZL02295243.8
8 1
71
62
Plurality of channels
l!l 5
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.255 Page 44 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 6,593,840 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
U0£10GICM
The structural features " Base body and Recess" of the above were publicly disclosed
prior to the date of the US Patent No. 6,593,840 ; as shown in The Chinese mainland
on December 31, 2003 Publication No. CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent No.
ZL02295243.8
62 Recess
l!l 5 Base body
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.256 Page 45 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 6,593,840 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
shou 0... teOOl'IS of .ad}ktnt
IHd cNMels collectMfy IC!
.. .,,. .,.. 160 of 'S40
_.rat- Alt.,.,,.ti¥ely
Udl..-.... ponCM
compnw ~ •retenoon .. _,.
UO£ 10GICM
'
The structural features " Lead channels (viewed from top of sidewall) and Retention
elements (L & R for a given channel)and In one interpretation, shoulder regions of
adjacent lead channels collectively act as the " T" 160 of '840 specification.
Alternatively, each shoulder region can comprise a "retention element" of the above
were publicly disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No. 6,593,840 : as shown in
The Chinese mainland on December 31, 2003 Publication No. CN2596615Y Ut ility
Model Patent No. ZL02295243.8
62
Lead channels
Retention elements Conductive terminal
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.257 Page 46 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 6,593,840 (CJaim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2><4 lOG ICM
UDE lDGICM
The structural features" Lead channels and Recess ... of the above were pub licly
disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No. 6,593,840 ; as shown in The Chinese
mainland on December 31, 2003 Publication No. CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent
No. ZL02295243.8
312
531 52
Lead channels
Recess
~ 2
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.258 Page 47 of 54
The structural features" Electronic componentsns" of the above were publicly
disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No. 6,593,840 ; as shown in The Chinese
mainland on January 14, 2004 Publication No. CN2599819Y Utility Model Patent No.
ZL02295321.3
360
3222 44 362
36 3220 80
20 320 3040. '
3420 340
3422 304 ' 300'
31'
Electronic componentsns
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.259 Page 48 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 6,593,840 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
UO£ lOGICM
The structural featuresH Electronic components and Wire leads extending within lead
channels (shown detached from terminals)" of the above were publicly disclosed
prior to the date of the US Patent No. 6,593,840 ; as shown in The Chinese mainland
on December 31, 2003 Publication No. CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent No.
ZL02295243.8 and the Chinese mainland January 14, 2004 Authorized notice No.
CN2599819Y utility model patent ZL02295321.3 Actual content
ZS
~31
JI
lfl 2 Conductive terminal
Electronic comoonents
lead channels
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.260 Page 49 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 6,593,840 (Claim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
-. of Afd IHd ,.....,.,,.is ~on1 i-c • conouct•~t
'\f1'"itCt"" ~Wild I'
'!'! • , lllCI
111 '! ct • •ads • nd
UOEIOGICM
The structural features "' Lead channels and Wire leads contact lead terminals and
lnsertable lead terminals" of the above were publicly disclosed prior to the date of
the US Patent No. 6,593,840 ; as shown in The Chinese mainland on December 31,
2003 Publication No. CN2596615Y Utility Model Patent No. ZL02295243.8 and the
Chinese mainland January 14, 2004 Authorized notice No. CN2599819Y utility model
patent ZL02295321.3 Actual content
Jl2
Lead channels lnsertable lead
terminals
Wire leads contact
lead terminals
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.261 Page 50 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 6,593,840 (Claim l) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
U0£10GICM
The structural features " lnsertable lead terminals (received within respective lead
channels( of the above were publicly disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No.
6,593,840 ; as shown in The Chinese mainland on December 31, 2003 Publication No.
CN259661SY Utility Model Patent No. ZL02295243.8 and the Chinese mainland
January 14, 2004 Authorized notice No. CN2599819Y utility model patent
ZL02295321.3 Actual content
312 ~
28
82
531 360 3222 H
36Z J6
3220 BO 20 3CQ
304a.' 3• 20 J 40
3422 304' JGO'
Jl'
29 JI J06
1!1 9
lnsertable lead
terminals
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.262 Page 51 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 6,593,840 (Claim l ) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
- ·•Wlmowmtntol s~id fie.ct te.m"lina'J: wittun Hid p'un rtv ol INclCNftMIS is
restnctod by s.1d rettnt10n et.ment
11
U0£ 10GICM
The structural features " Lead channels and lead terminals " of the above were publicly
disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No. 6,593,840 ; as shown in The Chinese
mainland on December 31, 2003 Publication No. CN2596615Y Util ity Model Patent
No. ZL02295243.8 and the Chinese mainland January 14, 2004 Authorized notice No.
CN2599819Y utility model patent ZL02295321.3 Actual content
312
Lead channels lead terminals
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.263 Page 52 of 54
U.S. Patent No. 6,593,840 (daim 1) vs. Exemplary UDE 2x4 lOG ICM
i..od ,..,,,_. mov-. (•-.v from cavity and toward <KM< ..ii• of MM w.U, I • toward
motha<l>olrd) .....,mdby
rfl..mort•~
UOf lOG ICM
The structural features" Lead terminal movement (away from cavity and toward
outer edge of side wall; i.e., toward motherboard) restricted by retention element"
of the above were publicly disclosed prior to the date of the US Patent No. 6,593,840 ;
as shown in The Chinese mainland on December 31, 2003 Publication No.
CN259661SY Utility Model Patent No. Zl02295243.8
2 1
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.264 Page 53 of 54
Case 3:18-cv-00373-BEN-WVG Document 1-10 Filed 02/16/18 PageID.265 Page 54 of 54