Evaluation of Treated Wastewater Regulations and Standards in Palestine

23
Numan Mizyed, An-Najah University, Nablus, West Bank

description

نعمان مزيد جامعة النجاح الوطنية

Transcript of Evaluation of Treated Wastewater Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Page 1: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Numan Mizyed, An-Najah University, Nablus, West Bank

Page 2: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Importance of agriculture in WB� Contribution in GDP:

� 30% in 1960’s

� 5.3% in 2010

� Contribution to labor force:� Contribution to labor force:

� 43% in 1960’s

� 13% in the last 10 years

Page 3: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Value of Agricultural Production in

Palestine

Animal

Production

Rainfed

Agriculture

22%Production

39%

22%

Irrigated

Agriculture

39%

Page 4: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Land availability� One third of WB lands is suitable for agricultural

cultivation

� Only 11% is suitable for irrigated agriculture (610,000 dunums)dunums)

� Only 130,000 dunums are irrigated

� Limitation of water supplies

Page 5: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Water supply and water use� Groundwater: natural recharge 648 mcm/a to three

main aquifer basins

� Use:

� Domestic sector: 96 mcm/a� Domestic sector: 96 mcm/a

� Agriculture: dropped from 90-100 mcm/a to about 60-70 mcm/a recently

� Diversion to domestic sector, drying up of springs

Page 6: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Future perspectives� Increase demands for fresh water

� Less fresh water will be available for agriculture

� Only high cash crops could afford expensive water pricesprices

� More production of treated wastewater

� TWW reuse is a valid option for agricultural water

Page 7: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Status of wastewater systems� Population in about 500 villages, towns and cities in

the WB.

� Only 16 towns and cities with collection systems

� Only one treatment plant is running and effectively � Only one treatment plant is running and effectively treating wastewater.

� Many on going studies and projects for collection and treatment of wastewater.

Page 8: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Typical Quality of Raw Wastewater

BOD5 500- 600 mg/l

COD 900- 1000 mg/l

TN 150-200 mg/l

TP 200-220 mg/l

TDS 1500 – 2000 mg/l

pH 7.3 to 8.1

Page 9: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

TWW Reuse� Currently minor reuse activities at Al-Bireh WWTP

within a greenhouse.

� Most of that water dumped in an open valley due to the location of the plant.the location of the plant.

� Untreated WW which get mixed with fresh water from springs is being used in agriculture in the northern WB

Page 10: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Potential amounts and areas for

reuse� Potential volumes:

� Domestic use 96 mcm/a now to 200 mcm/a in 30 years

� TWW volumes 100-150 mcm/a in 30 years

� Nearly double the existing amount of water currently � Nearly double the existing amount of water currently used in agriculture

� Reuse could double the irrigated area

Page 11: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Palestinian Standards and

Regulations for TWW Reuse� Palestine Standards Institute:

� PSI 742-2003

� PSI 34-2012

• Ministry of agriculture:� Requires from farmers a reuse permit

� Issues reuse permits

� Reuse to be in accordance with PSI

� Requirements on the farm level

Page 12: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Classification of Treated

Wastewater Quality

Grade Quality Description

Grade A High quality BOD5 20 mg/l at most, TSS 30 mg/l, NO3-N 20 mg/l, at most and Feacal coliforms at most 200 per 100 ml

Grade B Good quality BOD5 20 mg/l at most, TSS 30 mg/l, NO3-N 20 mg/l, at most and Feacal coliforms at most 1000 per 100 ml

Grade C Average quality

BOD5 40 mg/l at most, TSS 50 mg/l, NO3-N 30 mg/l, at most and Feacal coliforms at most 1000 per 100 ml

Grade D Low quality BOD5 60 mg/l at most, TSS 90 mg/l, NO3-N 40 mg/l, at most and Feacal coliforms at most 1000 per 100 ml.

Page 13: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Number of Barriers for Crops

Irrigated with TWW

Crop/use Lowquality(D)

Mediumquality(C)

Goodquality(B)

Highquality(A)

Gardens, sports fields, parks Notallowed

Notallowed

Notallowed

0

Groundwater recharge by infiltration,discharge into seas at least 500 m in sea,

Notallowed

0 0 0discharge into seas at least 500 m in sea,Green fodders.

allowed

Crops for seeds, Dry fodders, Forests notused as parks, industrial crops and grains

0 0 0 0

Corn 4 2 2 0

Citrus irrigated without drip 4 3 3 0

Citrus irrigated by drip irrigation, Nuts(almonds, walnuts, pistachios, pine nuts),Stone fruits (peaches, cherries, apricots),Apples, tropical fruits (mangos, coco),Grapes, Cactus, Palms, Olives,Ornamentals,

3 2 2 0

Vegetables Not

allowed

Not

allowed

Not

allowed

Not

allowed

Page 14: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

World Health Organization Guidelines for

Treated Wastewater Reuse

� Public health:

� Environmental protection:

� Food security: Within the next 50 years, more than 40% of the world’s population will live in countries 40% of the world’s population will live in countries facing water stress or water scarcity

Page 15: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

FAO Guidelines� the long term influence on crop, production, soil

conditions and farms management

� the impacts of water salinity and water toxicity on the plant and crop productionplant and crop production

� management tools to deal with the quality of irrigation water in economic and environmentally sustainable ways

� Health protection recommends WHO guidelines

Page 16: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Israeli standards� Very high quality effluents are suitable for unlimited

irrigation including crops eaten fresh.

� The very high quality effluents are those with BOD5 20 mg/l and suspended solids of 30 mg/l. These effluents mg/l and suspended solids of 30 mg/l. These effluents contain no more than 10 E.Coli/100 ml.

� High quality effluents with 20/30 BOD5/SS are obligated to have two barriers in order to be used for irrigation according to the Israeli standards.

Page 17: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Farmers

acceptance

to reuseto reuse

Page 18: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Characteristics of farmers and

farms� Average cultivated area 14 dunums/ family

� Family size: 6- 8

� 3 agricultural workers per family

45% of interviewed farmers have education beyond � 45% of interviewed farmers have education beyond high school

Page 19: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Characteristics of farmers and

farms� 83% own the land they cultivate

� Income from agriculture is less than 50% of total for more than 75% of those interviewed

� No prior knowledge of TWW reuse� No prior knowledge of TWW reuse

� More than 77% never heard of reuse standards

� 80-90% believed TWW is technically possible and willing to do it

Page 20: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Farmers concerns about reuse� Safety of reuse activities

� Marketing Risks

� Willing to reuse crops produced by TWW reuse

Willing to pay 0.15 to 0.25 $/CM for TWW compared to � Willing to pay 0.15 to 0.25 $/CM for TWW compared to 0.5 $/CM for fresh water

� Significant impacts of public awareness

Page 21: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Preferences of crops� 70% preferred fruit trees

� Supplementary irrigation of olives

� 20% fodders

Apparently more education is needed on the economy � Apparently more education is needed on the economy of different crops and options

� Need to look more into the standards

Page 22: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Conclusions� Need to address farmers concerns in adopting

standards and regulation- participotry approach.

� Relax standards at initial stages

� Involvement of community in planning for TWW � Involvement of community in planning for TWW projects, locations of plants of high concerns

� Need to address master planning and zoning areas in towns and cities

Page 23: Evaluation of Treated Wastewater  Regulations and Standards in Palestine

Conclusions and recommendations� Addressing initial extra costs at farm level when TWW

is utilized

� Include storage and irrigation infrastructure in the designdesign

� Public awareness and public involvement at all stages of projects.

� Experience from nearby countries: storage of runoff with treated WW in dams and reuse.