Euthanasia n PHI 2604 n Anthony D’Ascoli 9/15/2015 Anthony D'Ascoli 1.
-
Upload
oswald-shanon-allen -
Category
Documents
-
view
230 -
download
4
Transcript of Euthanasia n PHI 2604 n Anthony D’Ascoli 9/15/2015 Anthony D'Ascoli 1.
Euthanasia
PHI 2604
Anthony D’Ascoli
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
1
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
2
Introduction
Increasingly, Americans die in medical facilities– 85% of Americans die in some kind
of health-care facility (hospitals, nursing homes, hospices, etc.);
– Of this group, 70% (which is equivalent to almost 60% of the population as a whole) choose to withhold some kind of life-sustaining treatment
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
3
The Changing Medical Situation
Until the 1940’s, medical care was often just comfort care, alleviating pain when possible
During the last 50+ years, medicine has become increasingly capable of postponing death
Increasingly, we are forced to choose whether to allow ourselves to die.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
4
The Changing Insurance Situation
Initially, the difficult was that physicians often wanted to do more to save the dying than either the dying or their families wanted– The medical challenge– Fear of lawsuits
Now, the difficulty is that insurance companies and managed care may provide financial incentives for doing less for the dying than either they or their families want.
Close to one-third of all Medicare dollars are spent on end-of-life care
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
5
An Increasing Interest inEnd-of-life Issues
The Bill Moyers series on dying; Sept. , 2000.
JAMA issues on End-of-life decisions
New England Journal of Medicine
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
6
What are we striving for?
Euthanasia means “a good death,” “dying well.”
What is a good death?– Peaceful– Painless– Lucid– With loved ones gathered around
Part One.Cases and Laws
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
7
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
8
Karen Ann Quinlan
Karen Ann Quinlan
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
9
Karen Ann Quinlan, Web Resources
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
10
Cruzan
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
11
Cruzan, 2
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
12
Cruzan, 3
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
13
Washington v. Glucksburg
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
14
Vacco v. Quill
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
15
Vacco v. Quill. 2
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
16
Terri Schiavo
The Terri Schiavo case is, so far,
the most famous and
notorious end-of-life case of
the twenty-first century.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
17
Terri Schiavo Timeline, 1 Source: http://www.miami.edu/ethics2/schiavo_project.htm Kathy Cerminara, Nova Southeastern University, Shepard Broad Law Center Kenneth Goodman, University of Miami Ethics Programs
December 3, 1963 -- Theresa (Terri) Marie Schindler born Novermber 10, 1984 Terri Schindler and Michael Schiavo are married at Our Lady of Good Counsel
Church in Southhampton, Pennsylvania. She was 20; he was 21. 1986
The couple move to St. Petersburg, where Ms. Schiavo's parents had retired. February 25, 1990
Ms. Schiavo suffers cardiac arrest, apparently caused by a potassium imbalance and leading to brain damage due to lack of oxygen. She was taken to the Humana Northside Hospital and was later given a percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy (PEG) to provide nutrition and hydration.
May 12, 1990 Ms. Schiavo is discharged from the hospital and taken to the College Park skilled
care and rehabilitation facility.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
18
Terri Schiavo Timeline, 2 June 18, 1990 Court appoints Michael Schiavo as guardian; Ms. Schiavo’s parents do not object. June 30, 1990 Ms. Schiavo is transferred to Bayfront Hospital for further rehabilitation efforts. September 1990 Ms. Schiavo’s family brings her home, but three weeks later they return her to the
College Park facility because the family is “overwhelmed by Terri’s care needs.” November 1990 Michael Schiavo takes Ms. Schiavo to California for experimental “brain stimulator”
treatment, an experimental “thalamic stimulator implant” in her brain. January 1991 The Schiavos return to Florida; Ms. Schiavo is moved to the Mediplex Rehabilitation
Center in Brandon where she receives 24-hour care. July 19, 1991 Ms. Schiavo is transferred to Sable Palms skilled care facility where she receives
continuing neurological testing, and regular and aggressive speech/occupational therapy through 1994.
May 1992 Ms. Schiavo’s parents, Robert and Mary Schindler, and Michael Schiavo stop living
together.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
19
Terri Schiavo Timeline, 3 August 1992 Ms. Schiavo is awarded $250,000 in an out-of-court medical
malpractice settlement with one of her physicians. November 1992 The jury in the medical malpractice trial against another of Ms.
Schiavo's physicians awards more than one million dollars. In the end, after attorneys’ fees and other expenses, Michael Schiavo received about $300,000 and about $750,000 was put in a trust fund specifically for Ms. Schiavo’s medical care.
February 14, 1993 Michael Schiavo and the Schindlers have a falling-out over the
course of therapy for Ms. Schiavo; Michael Schiavo claims that the Schindlers demand that he share the malpractice money with them.
July 29, 1993 Schindlers attempt to remove Michael Schiavo as Ms. Schiavo’s
guardian; the court later dismisses the suit.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
20
Terri Schiavo Timeline, 4
March 1, 1994 First guardian ad litem, John H. Pecarek, submits his report. He states that
Michael Schiavo has acted appropriately and attentively toward Ms. Schiavo.
May 1998 Michael Schiavo petitions the court to authorize the removal of Ms.
Schiavo’s PEG tube; the Schindlers oppose, saying that she would want to remain alive. The court appoints Richard Pearse, Esq., to serve as the second guardian ad litem for Ms. Schiavo.
December 20, 1998 The second guardian ad litem, Richard Pearse, Esq., issues his report in
which he concludes that Ms. Schiavo is in a persistent vegetative state with no chance of improvement and that Michael Schiavo’s decision-making may be influenced by the potential to inherit the remainder of Ms. Schiavo’s estate.
February 11, 2000 Judge Greer rules that Ms. Schiavo would have chosen to have the PEG
tube removed, and therefore he orders it removed, which, according to doctors, will cause her death in approximately 7 to 14 days.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
21
Terri Schiavo Timeline, 5
March 18, 2005
The PEG tube is removed in mid-afternoon. This is the third time the tube has been removed in accordance with court orders.
March 31, 2005Ms. Schiavo dies at 9:05 a.m. Her body is transported to the Pinellas Country Coroners’ Office for an autopsy.
April 15, 2005In response to a motion from the media, Judge Greer orders DCF to release redacted copies of abuse reports regarding Ms. Schiavo. Newspapers report that DCF found no evidence of abuse after investigating the 89 reports filed before February 18, 2005. Thirty allegations are outstanding and still being investigated, but Judge Greer earlier had ruled that those allegations duplicated those previously filed.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
22
The Schiavo Case: Sources of Uncertainty
For the public, great uncertainty about what the actual facts of the case are—ethical responsibility of the media
For the family, uncertainty and disagreement about whether she was still there or not—ethical responsibility of science—especially neurosciences—to shed light on the connections between brain conditions and personhood. We face two questions in cases such as this:
– Is Terri there?– Is a person there?
• Central to these questions is the issue of how we define personal identity and personhood.
– Is there any hope, or any reasonable hope, for recovery or improvement? For everyone, uncertainty about what Terri’s wishes were. Conflicting
accounts of her wishes. Here we see the importance, not only of advanced directives and durable power of attorney for health care, but also of extensive discussion of these issues among family and friends.
For everyone, uncertainty about the extent of pain and discomfort associated with withdrawal of nutrition and hydration. In this and numerous related questions about the end of life, hospice and palliative care programs can shed light on the process of dying.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
23
Schiavo Autopsy
The Schiavo autopsy, released June 15 2005, showed severe and irreversible brain damage
Brain half its usual size Damaged in almost all regions,
including that region which controls vision
The Oregon Death with Dignity Act
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
24
http://www.oregon.gov/DHS/ph/pas/index.shtml
Oregon
“The most important reasons for requesting PAD…were – wanting to control the circumstances of death and die at home;
– loss of independence; and
– concerns about future pain, poor quality of life, and inability to care for one’s self.
All physical symptoms (eg, pain, dyspnea, and fatigue) at the time of the interview were rated as unimportant (median score, 1), but concerns about physical symptoms in the future were rated at a median score of 3 or higher.
“Lack of social support and depressed mood were rated as unimportant reasons for requesting PAD. :
Oregonians’ Reasons for Requesting Physician Aid in Dying. Linda Ganzini, MD, MPH; Elizabeth R. Goy, PhD; Steven K. obscha, MD.
ARCH INTERN MED/VOL 169 (NO. 5), MAR 9, 2009
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
25
Part Two.
The Philosophical Issues
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
26
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
27
Some Initial Distinctions
Active vs. Passive Euthanasia Voluntary, Non-voluntary, and
Involuntary Euthanasia Assisted vs. Unassisted Euthanasia
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
28
Active vs. Passive Euthanasia
Active euthanasia occurs in those instances in which someone takes active means, such as a lethal injection, to bring about someone’s death;
Passive euthanasia occurs in those instances in which someone simply refuses to intervene in order to prevent someone’s death.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
29
Criticisms of the Active/Passive Distinction in Euthanasia
Conceptual Clarity– Vague dividing line between active and
passive, depending on notion of “normal care”
– Principle of double effect Moral Significance
– Does passive euthanasia sometimes cause more suffering?
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
30
Active Euthanasia
Typical case for active euthanasia– there is no doubt that the patient will die
soon– the option of passive euthanasia causes
significantly more pain for the patient (and often the family as well) than active euthanasia and does nothing to enhance the remaining life of the patient, and
– passive measures will not bring about the death of the patient.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
31
Voluntary, Non-voluntary, and Involuntary Euthanasia
Voluntary: patient chooses to be put to death
Non-voluntary: patient is unable to make a choice at all
Involuntary: patient chooses not to be put to death, but is anyway
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
32
Assisted vs. Unassisted Euthanasia
Many patients who want to die are unable to do so without assistance
Some who are able to assist themselves commit suicide with guns, etc.--ways that are much harder and difficult for those who are left behind.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
33
Overview of Distinctions
Passive Active:Not Assisted
Active:Assisted
Voluntary Currently legal;often contained inliving wills
Equivalent tosuicide for thepatient
Equivalent to suicidefor the patient;Possibly equivalent tomurder for theassistant, except inOregon
Nonnvoluntary:Patient Not
Able to Choose
Sometimes legal,but only with courtpermission
Not possible Equivalent to eithersuicide or beingmurdered for thepatient;Legally equivalent tomurder for theassistant
Involuntary:Against
Patient’sWishes
Not Legal Not possible Equivalent to beingmurdered for thepatient;Equivalent to murderfor assistant
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
34
Compassion for Suffering
The larger question in many of these situations is: how do we respond to suffering?– Hospice and palliative care– Aggressive pain-killing medications– Sitting with the dying– Euthanasia
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
35
The Sanctity of Life
Life is a gift from God Respect for life is a “seamless
garment” Importance of ministering to the sick
and dying See life as “priceless” (Kant)
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
36
The Right to Die
Do we have a right to die?– Negative right (others may not interfere)– Positive right (others must help)
Do we own our own bodies and our lives? If we do own our own bodies, does that give us the right to do whatever we want with them?
Isn’t it cruel to let people suffer pointlessly?
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
37
The Slippery Slope
Worrisome examples from history:– Nazi eugenics program
• California eugenics program– Chinese orphanages
Special danger to undervalued groups in our society– The elderly– Minorities– Persons with disabilities– Groups that are typically discriminated against
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
38
Two Models
A utilitarian model, which emphasizes consequences
A Kantian model, which emphasizes autonomy, rights, and respect
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
39
The Utilitarian Model
Goes back at least to John Stuart Mill (1806-73)
The greatest good for the greatest number
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
40
Main Tenets
Morality is a matter of consequences We must count the consequences for
everyone Everyone’s suffering counts equally We must always act in a way that
produces the greatest overall good consequences and least overall bad consequences.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
41
The Calculus Morality becomes a
matter of mathematics, calculating and weighing consequences
Key insight: consequences matter
The dream: bring certainty to ethics
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
42
How much care should be given at the end of life?
Health care providers are increasingly concerned, not just about how much money is spent on patients, but about how effectively it is spent.
Disproportionate amount of money spent in final months of life.• 40 percent of Medicare dollars cover care
for people in the last month.• Nearly one third of terminally ill patients
with insurance used up most or all of their savings to cover uninsured medical expenses such as home care.
Concept of medical futility is utilitarian in character.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
43
What is a good death?
Jeremy Bentham.Hedonistic utilitarians:
a good death is a painless death.
Eudaimonistic utilitarians: a good death is a happy death.
John Stuart Mill
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
44
Understanding Bizarre Suggestions
All of the following make sense if we think of end-of-life decisions solely in terms of reducing painful consequences:
Passive euthanasia sometimes worse than active euthanasia—James Rachels
“It’s over, Debbie”—just end the suffering A duty to die
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
45
The Kantian Model
Central insight: people cannot be treated like mere things.
Key notions:– Autonomy &
Dignity– Respect– Rights
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
46
Autonomy & Respect
Kant felt that human beings were distinctive: they have the ability to reason and the ability to decide on the basis of that reasoning.– Autonomy = freedom + reason– Autonomy for Kant is the ability to
impose reason freely on oneself.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
47
Treating People as Mere Means
The Tuskegee Syphilis Experiments– More than four hundred
African American men infected with syphilis went untreated for four decades in a project the government called the Tuskegee Study of Untreated Syphilis in the Negro Male.
– Continued until 1972
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
48
Protecting Autonomy
Advanced Directives are designed to protect the autonomy of patients They derive directly from a Kantian view of what is morally important.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
49
Autonomy: Who Decides
Kantians emphasize the importance of a patient’s right to decide
Utilitarians look only at consequences
In cases such as the Siamese twins, they see radically different worlds.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
50
From Autonomy to Rights
Because human beings have the ability to make up their own minds in accord with the dictates of reason, they have certain rights.
If someone has a right, we have a correlatively duty to respect that right.
Rights Duties
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
51
Types of Rights Two types of rights
– Negative: imposes duties of non-interference on others
– Positive: imposes duties of assistance on others
Health care (including end-of-life care) as a right:– Negative right. Widespread
agreement on this.– Positive right. Much
disagreement. Do people have a right to health care even when they can’t pay? On whose shoulders does the duty fall?
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
52
Conclusion
Many of the ethical disagreements about end-of-life decisions can be seen as resulting from differing ethical frameworks, esp. Kantian vs. utilitarian.
Use these models to understand where you stand, where your patients stand, and where your organization stands in regard to end-of-life issues.
Lawrence M. HinmanSend E-mail to Larry Hinman
University of San Diego
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
53
The Interdisciplinary Characterof Moral Problems:
End-of-life Decisions
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
54
Disciplines Considering End-of-Life Issues
Philosophy Religious Studies
& Theology Literature Psychology Sociology Biology
Economics Political Science Media Studies Medicine Art Theater
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
55
Euthanasia
The word “euthanasia” comes from the Greek words for death (thanatos) and “good” or “well” (eu-). Although it is often taken in a narrow sense as referring to assisted suicide, its original sense is of more interest to us here:
how can we die well?
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
56
End-of-Life Decisions
Until recently, end-of-life decisions for most people were easy: You tried to stay alive as long as you could, and then you just died.
Today, we are lucky if we are able to “just die.” In most cases, difficult decisions have to be made about when to stop medical treatment.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
57
The Biology of Aging and Dying
Biologists and researchers in related fields are continually probing into questions central to our understanding of the biological dimensions of aging and dying, including:– Can the aging process be
slowed down?– On the biology of dying, see
Sherwin Nuland’s How We Die.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
58
Psychology
The psychological dimensions of end-of-life decisions
Classic source: Elizabeth Kübler-Ross, On Death and Dying
• Stage 1- Shock and denial
• Stage 2- Anger
• Stage 3- Bargaining
• Stage 4- Depression
• Stage 5- Acceptance
• Typically no clear demarcation b/w stages and some may occur in different order
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
59
Art
Throughout the ages, we have sought to understand death through art.
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
60
Art
Throughout the ages, we have sought to understand death through art.
Dürer, “The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse”
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
61
Art--2Jack Kevorkian
Nearer My God to Thee
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
62
Music
Whether through requiems or ragas, we have always expressed our feelings about death and end-of-life decisions through music.Mahler’s Kindestotenlieder
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
63
Literature
Leo Tolstoy, “The Death of Ivan Illych”
See The Oxford Book of Deathby D. J. Enright
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
64
Theology & Religious Studies
Consider the various ways in which different religious traditions provide us with guidance in making difficult decisions at the end of life.– Christian– Jewish– Buddhist– Muslim– Native American
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
65
Economics
Consider economic factors that have had an impact on end-of-life issues:
Increasing cost of health care Greater social mobility Percentage of health care dollars
spent in last few months of life
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
66
Sociology
Study of different social aspects of dying, such as varying mortality rates for various groups in various nations, percentage of accidental deaths, etc.
See Michael Kearl’s Guide to Sociological Thanatalogy: http://www.trinity.edu/~mkearl/death.html
04/19/23 Anthony D'Ascoli http://www.dascolihum.com
67
Anthropology Anthropologists
have long been concerned with death and the rituals surrounding it.
Celebrations of Death: The Anthropology of Mortuary Rituals.Edited by by Peter Metcalf, Richard Huntington