ESFRI ENE-SW by Pilar García - Maghrenov workshop on research infrastructures for renewable energy...

Perspec'ves for RE&EE Research and Innova'on Infrastructures

Dr Pilar Garcia Interna'onal Rela'ons and Coopera'on, CIEMAT, Spain

Spanish Delegate to Energy Strategy Working Group, ESFRI

“Workshop on Research Infrastructures for RE&EE in EU-MPC countries”

Ben Guerir, Morocco, January 16th, 2015

Overview presenta'on PART I CIEMAT

PART II European Strategy Forum on Research Infrastructures (ESFRI)

PART III (ex post) assessment of implementa'on of projects that entered ESFRI roadmap in 2008 & 2010

PART IV 2016 ESFRI Roadmap (update)

PART V Follow up

| PAGE 2

Workshop on RIs for RE&EE in EU-MPC countries 16th January, 2015, Ben Guerir, Morocco

Energy sector challenges Im

pact of the

econo

mic crisis

Energy prices set to increase with highest prices to persist in EU and Japan, well above China and US

Security of supply – import dependency of the EU as a whole is increasing

Global supply – increased energy demand and compe''on

Source of data: EC Coordination Group – SET-Plan Integrated Roadmap meetings

| PAGE 3


Energy sector vision for the future

Focus on accelera'ng the development of cost effec've

low carbon technologies

Trends in capital costs of energy technologies are

decreasing

Source: EC Coordina'on Group – SET-‐Plan Integrated Roadmap Mee'ngs

SET-‐Plan Integrated Roadmap

(1) address energy

system and innova'on

chain integra'on

(2) consolidate the (up-‐dated)

technology roadmaps of the SET Plan

(3) cover the en're

research and innova'on

(4) iden'fy clear roles and

tasks for the various

stakeholders

SET-‐Plan – European Strategic Energy Technology Plan Establishes an energy technology policy for Europe

| PAGE 4


Importance of Research Infrastructures Ø  Broad consensus that future compe''veness in globalising

knowledge economies depends on research capability, required: –  investment in educa'on and research ins'tu'ons –  access to first class research infrastructures

Ø  Coordina'on on European (and global) scale increasingly needed because: –  limited investment funds available –  increasing level of infrastructure investments needed to remain at cu[ng

edge –  problems require broad data sharing and networking between na'onal

nodes > distributed research infrastructures

Ø  Research infrastructures are innova'on and skills hubs, not (just) big machines and big datasets

| PAGE 5

RIs may be ‘single-‐sited’ (a single resource at a single loca'on), ‘distributed’ (a network of distributed resources), or ‘virtual’ (the service is provided electronically)


European Strategy Forum on Research Infrastructures

A strategic instrument to develop the scien'fic integra'on of Europe and to strengthen its interna'onal outreach

ESFRI Mandate – Council of EU in 2001

Ø  Support a coherent and strategy-‐led approach to policy-‐making on EU RI

Ø  Facilitate mul'lateral ini'a'ves to the be_er use and development of research infrastructures

Ø  Act as an incubator for pan-‐European and global research infrastructures

Ø  Facilitate decisions on their implementa'on and ensure follow-‐up a`er assessment

Mission of ESFRI

| PAGE 6


ESFRI roadmaps

Roadmaps iden'fy new pan-‐European research infrastructures or major upgrades to exis'ng ones to meet needs of European research communi'es in next 10 to 20 years in all fields of research

ü  First Roadmap published in 2006

ü Followed by two updates in 2008 and 2010

ü Now contains 48 projects

ü Requires major financial investment (~€20bn) and long term commitment for opera'on (~€2bn/year)

ü Future: ESFRI Roadmap 2016 (Trieste, Sept 2014)

| PAGE 7


Today: ESFRI Roadmap 2010

Distributed research infrastructures

Single sited research infrastructures

Social and Cultural

Innova'on ( 5 )

Health and Food ( 13 )

Environmental Sciences ( 9 )

Energy ( 7 )

Analy'cal Facili'es ( 6 )

Physics Science and Engineering

( 10 )

e-‐Infra-‐ structures

(1)

SHARE BBMRI ELIXIR ICOS EURO-‐ARGO ECCSEL Euro-‐FEL ELI TIARA* PRACE

European Social Survey

ECRIN INFRA FRONTIER LIFEWATCH IAGOS Wind-‐scanner EMFL SPIRAL2 CTA

CESSDA INSTRUCT EATRIS EMSO EPOS EU-‐SOLARIS European XFEL E-‐ELT** SKA

CLARIN EU-‐OPEN-‐SCREEN EMBRC SIOS EISCAT_3D JHR ESRF

Upgrade KM3NeT FAIR

DARIAH Euro Bio-‐Imaging ERINHA COPAL IFMIF NEUTRON

ESS SLHC-‐PP* ILC-‐HIGRADE*

ISBE MIRRI HiPER ILL20/20 Upgrade

ANAEE MYRRHA

Red: 2006 Roadmap Black: 2008 Roadmap

* projects from CERN’s European Strategy for Particle Physics ** considered implemented by ESO

| PAGE 8


Coordina'on: Norway Number of par'cipa'ng countries: 10 The facility will be in opera'on in 2015 Carbon Capture, Transport and Storage is a powerful tool in climate change mi'ga'on and is an integral part of the SET Plan and the ongoing development of the SET Plan Integrated Roadmap The ECCSEL RI will be developed in two layers, one layer consis'ng of distributed complimentary laboratories and one layer of large pilots and demo sites ECCSEL was recommended for pre-‐implementa'on funding under the H2020 Infradev-‐2 call

From 2008 Roadmap

(European Carbon dioxide Capture and StoragE Laboratory)

| PAGE 9


A ne twork be tween d i s t r i bu ted WindScanner research and demonstra'on nodes embedded within leading European energy research organisa'ons. The par'cipants are all partners of EERA and the WindScanner vision is to develop a European RI that underpins the EERA Joint Programme on Wind Energy The Preparatory Phase of the project began on 1 October 2012

From 2010 Roadmap

(European WindScanner Facility) Coordina'on: Denmark

Prepara'on phase: 2010-‐2012 Construc'on phase: 2012-‐2015 Opera'on phase: 2013 onwards

| PAGE 10


The upgrading and new installa'ons are expected to be completed by 2016

Crea'on of a large European solar concentra'ng or solar thermal energy R&D facili'es

Infrastructure in Plataforma Solar de Almería (PSA) of CIEMAT and the Advanced Technology Centre for Renewable Energy Founda'on (CTAER)

This project is composed by 15 partners which represent 9 countries :

•  13 Research Centres •  Ministry of Economy and Compe''veness (MINECO)

•  European Solar Thermal Electricity Industry Associa'on (ESTELA)

From 2010 Roadmap

(European Solar Research Infrastructure for Concentra'ng Solar Power)

Coordina'on: Spain.

| PAGE 11


2016 ESFRI Roadmap: Objec've

Mandate of Council of EU (July 2014) to complete ESFRI Roadmap with fewer and more mature projects 2016 ESFRI Roadmap will be more of a strategy document:

Ø  landscape of research infrastructures in Europe and globally Ø  gaps in European research infrastructure ecosystem Ø  pan-‐European projects Ø  synergies with na'onal/regional projects Ø  synergies with exis'ng research infrastructures and strategies for

op'mal use Ø  con'nuous upgrade, sustainability and end of life perspec'ves Ø  global research infrastructure opportuni'es

| PAGE 12


2016 ESFRI Roadmap: Process Ø  Roadmap 2016 update process was launched in Sep 2014 in Trieste Ø  In the framework of this update, ESFRI is expec'ng Proposals for new

(or major upgrades of) research infrastructures of pan-‐European interest corresponding to the long term needs of the European research communi'es, covering all scien'fic areas

Ø  Proposals can be submi_ed un'l 31st March 2015 Proposals: ONLY ESFRI Delega'ons and EIROforum Members may submit online submission form containing ques'ons like: What is the value for science and for innova'on? or Cost and Schedule? How it the RI planned to be financed?, etc

Ø  In parallel, ESFRI will carry out an in-‐depth analysis of the research infrastructure Landscape in all scien'fic fields in Europe. The landscape analysis will provide a comprehensive picture of the exis'ng research infrastructures of pan-‐European scope, including the na'onal/regional research infrastructures that operate interna'onal open access

| PAGE 13


2016 ESFRI Roadmap: Overview process

| PAGE 14

SWG SWG ACTIVE LIST OF ~ 25 PROJECTS LANDSCAPE ANALYSIS, including: -  `SUCCESS

STORIES` -  `EMERGING

PROJECTS`

PROPOSAL from ESFRI Delega'on or EIROforum

Member ESFRI

EVALUATION OF SCIENTIFIC CASE

SWG SWG SWG

IG E-‐IRG Experts in all WG

Independent Experts

Peer Reviewers

ASSESSMENT OF MATURITY


2016 ESFRI Roadmap: Rules Ø  much shorter, i.e. ~ 25 projects Ø  projects automa'cally roll off a`er 10 years Ø  any project that wants to be considered again a`er 10 years must

reapply, either in a different form or with bo_lenecks resolved Ø  room for 8 to 10 new projects Ø  entry level projects will be at a more mature level:

•  successfully completed a design study •  planned its business case/delivery strategy •  obtained the financial commitment of one hos'ng country and

clearly demonstra'ng poli'cal commitment of at least two addi'onal countries

•  is ready for a decisive preparatory phase

ESFRI will assess candidate projects on scien'fic excellence, pan-‐European relevance, socio-‐economic impact, e-‐needs and maturity level

| PAGE 15


Energy RIs Landscape Analysis – Technologies

| PAGE 16

Renewable Energies

Photovoltaic

Bioenergy

Concentrated Solar Power

Wind

Geothermal

Ocean

Hydro

Efficient Energy Conversion and Use

Energy Efficiency and Use in Industry

Fuels Cells and Hydrogen

Carbon Capture, Transport and Storage

Smart Ci'es and Communi'es

Energy Distribu'on and Storage

Storage

Smart Grids

Fuels

Nuclear Energies

Fusion

Fission

Cross-‐sec'onal Energy Research Infrastructures

Materials

Compu'ng and Simula'on

Socio-‐Economic Impact


Landscape of RIs for Renewable Energies

| PAGE 17

20% ene

rgy from

rene

wab

les

Cut G

HG

Less im

port-‐dep

ende

ncy Photovoltaics (PV)

Solar EII EERA PV SOPHIA

CSP EERA JP-‐CSP

FP7 IRP STAGE-‐STE ESFRI RI EU-‐SOLARIS

SFERA ESTELA

SET-‐Plan Solar Energy EII

Pressure on Renewable Energies for fast deployment to achieve the 2020 targets

Geothermal EERA JP Geothermal

Energy Ris 2 exis'ng + 5 sites Under construc'on

TP Renewable Hea'ng and Cooling

Bioenergy EERA JP Bioenergy

EIBI Bridge PPP

Small v big plants

Wind Energy EWII

EERA JP Wind Energy TP Wind

European Academy of Wind Energy ESFRI RI

WINDSCANNER

Hydropower Stabilizing or reducing Focus on Grid Stability Integra'on with other

techs Adapta'on to market, regulatory and climate

framework cond.


2013 SET-‐Plan Technology Map – cement, iron, steel, pulp and paper industries as crucial to help achieving EU’s CO2 emission reduc'on target

Key objec've of EU Energy and climate policy (Energy Efficiency Direc've – increase energy efficiency by 30% -‐ target for 2030) Energy efficiency and

use in industry Driver for secure, sustainable, cost-‐effec've and low carbon energy system Technology related issues

(materials, products, waste, ICT) &

Non-‐technology issues (market design, effec've func'oning) Key topics include: Buildings, Hea'ng and Cooling, Industry

products and services

EU FP Programmes such as SPIRE have an integra'ng effect in MS R&D programmes ICT - major role in supporting optimisation

of energy consumption

Some pilot and demonstra'on projects throughout Europe (BRE, UK; IERC, IE; ZEB, NO)

Build on exis'ng infrastructure, and this infrastructure must be made smarter and be intelligently connected through smart communica'ons.

Smart Ci'es and Communi'es

Data is the tool of smart ci'es Relate to energy use profiles in homes, hospitals, schools, swimming pools, industry - other metadata collected: occupancy rates, ambient temperatures, transport requirements, industrial heat demand, etc.

| PAGE 18

RIs Landscape for Efficient Energy Conversion and Use


MS are involved in the CCS deployment ac'vi'es and plans through the EII on CCS. There are 3 main test infrastructures for CCS in Europe at present: -‐ The CIUDEN Compos'lla CCS plant in Ponferrada (capture) and Hontomin (storage), Spain -‐ The Technology Centre Mongstad in Norway (capture) -‐ The Ketzin storage site in Germany (100kton CO2)

ESFRI RI ECCSEL

Carbon dioxide capture, transport and storage (CCS)

ZEP (Zero Emission Technology Plaworm) EERA Joint Programme on CCS

Fuel cells and Hydrogen (FCH)

Main stakeholder organiza'ons/groups: -‐ Fuel Cells and Hydrogen Joint Undertaking (FCH JU) -‐ EERA -‐ Joint Programme on Fuel Cells and Hydrogen -‐ Hydrogen and Fuel Cells European Infrastructure Project -‐ H2FC

Many central research organiza'ons represented in more than one of these groups (e.g. CEA, ENEA, SINTEF, KIT, CNRS, CNR, JRC, VTT, FZ-‐Juelich, DTU, DLR) + na'onal organiza'ons covering the FCH area in most MS & AC.

+ Industry actors have their own RIs, which normally is applied for in-‐house R&D, tes'ng & valida'on.

H2FC: established to optimise the use and further development of the hydrogen and fuel cell research infrastructures existing in Europe. ~20 partners from MSs and ACs offer external use of parts of their RI. Ongoing activities: include an RI gap analysis, development plan for European hydrogen and fuel cells RI (late 2015).

| PAGE 19

RIs Landscape for Efficient Energy Conversion and Use


Landscape of RIs for Energy Distribu'on and Storage

Smart energy networks to accomodate: -‐  High penetra'on of RES -‐  Final energy demand of electricity to

con'nue increasing

While ensuring: -‐  Cost op'misa'on -‐  Environmental performance -‐  Stability (high security and quality of supply)

Smart Grids / Storage systems

Established community with world leading capacity in some areas Nearly 500 Smart Grid projects launched since 2002 DERlab – European Distributed Energy Resources Associa'on (27 research ins'tutes and EU-‐US coopera'on) EERA JP Smart Grids – 20 research organiza'ons from 17 European countries + 14 research ins'tutes as associated partners

Vision: Focus on Grid opera'on

Focus on development of possible

communica'on solu'ons for mixture of energy carriers

Innova'on case: -‐  Device companies to test new equipment. -‐  Power producers. -‐  Network operators new knowledge about

how to operate a future energy network.


Landscape of RIs for Nuclear Energies

Global Challenges: -  Innovative reactor concepts -  Advanced fuel cycle technologies -  Secure, clean and efficient energy system.

Nuclear Fission and Fusion With a share of about 30% in EU’s electricity production, nuclear energy provides today most of the low-carbon electricity consumed in the EU.

Nuclear Fusion à success ITER

Nuclear Fission -  Maintain high levels of safety in the

operation facilities. -  Small but very radioactive quantities of

nuclear waste produced must be managed appropiately.

International competitive

EURATOM programme cooperation with Argentina, Australia, Belarus, Canada,

China, Japan, Kazakhstan, Russia, South Africa, South Korea, Ukraine, USA and

Uzbekistan

ITER (Europe, China, India, Japan, Korea, Russia and USA)


Simula'on – modeling capaci'es – advanced characteriza'on – tes'ng facili'es

Energy materials

Research

Infrastructures

Cri'cal for research in energy systems, energy conversion

phenomena, designing advanced materials

Scien'fic community already exploits: -‐ Large-‐scale facili'es such as synchrotrons (ESRF, PSI, DESY, Diamond, ALBA, Soleil, BESSY, ANKA, ELETTRA and the neutron facili'es ILL, ISIS, FRM-‐2 Munich, and SINQ) -‐ aberra'on corrected electron microscopes used for analy'cal and func'onal characteriza'on at the atomic level -‐ first rank supercompu'ng capaci'es

Need for concerted R&D efforts and common methodological approaches in the energy materials sector

Future…

| PAGE 22

Landscape for Cross-‐Sec'onal Energy RIs


PRACE – Partnership for Advanced Compu'ng in Europe 26 Member countries Peer Reviewed Access to 6 Tier-‐0 HPC systems Several Tier-‐1 systems at na'onal level

Computing and simulation

Cri'cal for research in energy systems, energy conversion phenomena, designing advanced material

Role of other e-‐infrastructures such as data infrastructure and cloud/grid infrastructure to be considered

HPC Scien'fic Case includes energy relevant topics such as: -‐ Explora'on of natural resources -‐ Lean combus'on technology -‐ Fluid turbulence -‐ Power and waste management -‐ Photovoltaics and new material design -‐ Fusion reactor modelling

Towards a scale-‐bridiging approach to study materials, processes and func'onali'es

| PAGE 23



Economic, Environmental and Social Impacts

WHAT? – Energy Systems Analysis

HOW? – Exploring and modelling the impact of a number of key data and indicators –socio-economic, environmental as well as technological – on energy systems’ transition

WHY? – Crucial role in supporting a successful EU transition to a low carbon energy system

WITH? – Interplay of Energy RIs with virtual infrastructures such as networks, archives and databases / need for specialized energy focused E2S

Existing RIs: - Partial (e.g. JRC ELCD (European reference Life Cycle Database) - Too Generalistic (Euromanifestos)



q  25-‐09-‐2014: launch of call for proposals q  15-‐12-‐2014: deadline no'fica'on of assessment of implementa'on q  31-‐01-‐2015: deadline ques'onnaire assessment of implementa'on q  31-‐03-‐2015: deadline for new proposals/updates q  19-‐05-‐2015: dra` recommenda'on status 2008 & 2010 projects q  12-‐06-‐2015: decision on status 2008 & 2010 projects q  30-‐06-‐2015: dra` recommenda'ons from SWG & IG on proposals q  01-‐09-‐2015: hearings with proposed projects q  30-‐09-‐2015: dra` recommenda'on on proposed projects by SWG &

IG q  08-‐12-‐2015: decision on status new proposals/updates

Spring 2016: presenta'on 2016 ESFRI Roadmap under Dutch Presidency of Council of EU in Amsterdam

Timeline

| PAGE 25


Follow up ESFRI in general and IG in par'cular offer ad hoc targeted and specific (confiden'al and non-‐monetary) support to move projects towards full implementa'on Ø  decisions on the status of proposals/projects based on specific

recommenda'ons directed towards enabling learning and improvement

Ø  workshops for (future) projects informing about ESFRI providing for benchmarking and showcasing best prac'ces

Ø  projects assessed `under construc'on/under implementa'on` may ask IG to assess implementa'on of project in order to obtain status `constructed/implemented` at any 'me

Ø  every 2 to 3 years assessment of implementa'on by IG Ø  opportuni'es for new projects in 2018, 2020 etc. as others roll off

> IMPORTANCE OF NOT SUBMITTING PROJECTS THAT DO NOT MAKE ANY CHANCE, but rather prepare well for next roadmap update

| PAGE 26

Dr Pilar Garcia CIEMAT, Spain

[email protected]

Thank you for your anen'on!!

UR ICUnidad de Rela c iones Interna c iona les y C oopera c ion

www.ciemat.es

Human resources : 1,326 people

Budget (2013) : 98.1 M€

Income from R&D (2013) : 44.3 M€

CIEMAT Basic data

OPI: Public Research Organisa'on

Ministry of Economy and Compe''veness (MINECO)

Centro de Inves'gaciones Energé'cas, Medioambientales y Tecnológicas

CIEMAT objec'ves Ø Promote and execute R&D ac'vi'es, in accordance with ministerial guidelines, in the fields of energy, environment and technology, including specific fields of basic research

Ø Collaborate with other na'onal R&D centres, universi'es and enterprise

Ø Carry out ac'vi'es in the framework of the EU and cooperate with intergovernmental bodies and R&D centers from other countries

Ø Promote the ac'vi'es derived from its R&D in terms of scien'fic-‐technical communica'on and dissemina'on, educa'on and technology transfer

Ø Provide first-‐rate technical services in areas of its exper'se Ø Advise public administra'ons and public and private ins'tu'ons, and represent Spain in the appropriate interna'onal forums

Organisa'on Chart

Territorial centres

Madrid

Soria

Almería

Trujillo (Cáceres)

Centre for the Development of Renewable Energy Sources

(CEDER)

CIEMAT (Moncloa – Madrid)

Solar Platform of Almería (PSA)

Extremadura Advanced Technology Centre (CETA – CIEMAT)

International Centre for Studies in Enviromental Law

(CIEDA) Centre for Socio-Technical

Research (CISOT)

Barcelona

Technology Research IT

% ac'vity

0

10

20

30

40

IB IT DT E S

IB Basic Research

DT Technology Development

E Pilot and Demonstra'on

Services S

CIEMAT Profile

Ø Renewable energies and energy savings Ø Nuclear fission Ø Nuclear fusion Ø Fossil fuels (energy recovery) Ø Elementary par'cles and astropar'cles Ø Biology and biomedicine Ø Environment Ø  Ionizing radia'ons Ø Scien'fic instrumenta'on and medical physics Ø Materials analysis and characterisa'on Ø Computa'on and informa'on technology sciences Ø Energy and environmental system studies

Scien'fic and technical Areas

Department of Energy

RENEWABLE ENERGY

COMBUSTION & GASIFICATION

Life Cycle Analysis

PLATAFORMA SOLAR DE ALMERIA

CEDER (SORIA)

NUCLEAR FISSION

DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY

Photovoltaic Solar Energy

ü  Ac'vi'es included at Energy Department of CIEMAT ü  Public Research Body à Technological Development

ü  Pioneer team since 1985 with a strong interna'onal projec'on ü  Staff more than 300 people ü  Facili'es in Madrid, Almería (PSA) and Soria (CEDER)

Renewable Energy

Pretreat. raw material Enzymatic hydrolysis Fermentation

Biofuels

Isolated Wind E. systems Wind resource prediction

Wind Energy

E. Analys Components & Buildings E. Analys. Urban Environm.

Solar Energy in Buildings

PV materials and devices PV components and systems

Solid biofuels Smart Grids

CEDER

Solar Resources gTIGER

Concentrating solar systems Environmental aplications Solar treatment of water

PSA Territorial Centres

Renewable Energy ac'vi'es

Geographic Informa'on Technologies and Renewable Energy

Ins'tu'onal Presence

Ins'tu'onal Presence European Energy Research Alliance (EERA)

Ø  Founded in 2008, composed of 250 organiza'ons (3,700 researchers ready to be commi_ed)

Ø  Alliance of the best research ins'tutes in energy in Europe To speed up the development of new technologies for energy Through the implementa'on of joint programmes suppor'ng the public and industrial policy priori'es of the SET-‐Plan

Ø  EERA aims for: §  Advising na'onal governments and European Commission about

research policies in the field of low carbon energies §  Being the major actor for European research

Ø  CIEMAT is strongly involved in the EERA §  Member of the Execu've Commi_ee §  Involved in 12 out of 15 joint programmes §  2 Joint Programmes’ coordina'on à CSP & Bioenergy

Ins'tu'onal Presence European Energy Research Alliance (EERA)

Joint Programmes (15 JP): •  Photovoltaic, Wind, Geothermal and Smart Grids (launched Jun 2010)

•  Carbon Capture and Storage, Materials for Nuclear and Bio Energy (launched Nov 2010)

•  Concentra'ng Solar Power and Ocean Energy (launched Nov 2011)

•  Smart Ci'es, Advanced Materials and Processes for Energy Applica'ons, Energy Storage, and Fuel Cells and Hydrogen (submi_ed Nov 2011)

•  Economical, Environment and Social Impacts, and Shale Gas (launched April 2013)

KIC InnoEnergy – A European Company with Relevant Shareholders

700M€ 2011-2015

The Leading Engine for Innovation and Entrepreneurship in Sustainable Energy

Ins'tu'onal Presence


2016 ESFRI Roadmap: Process

Evalua'on of scien'fic case: Lead SWG is responsible for evalua'on of: ü  scien'fic excellence ü  pan-‐European relevance ü  socio-‐economic impact ü  e-‐needs (infrastructure, services and contribu'on to e-‐infrastructures commons)

Assessment of maturity: In parallel, IG will assess maturity of proposals (ex ante) as stakeholder commitment, user strategy & access policy, preparatory work, planning and other aspects.

Scoring &recommenda'on: Reviewers and Experts will score dimensions of 1) scien'fic case and 2) assessment of maturity.

| PAGE 40



Status & link to roadmap: Ø  ‘emerging‘ i.e. concept screening completed and ready for design study

> not on roadmap Ø  ‘feasible’ i.e. completed design study, planned business case/delivery strategy,

obtained commitment and ready for preparatory phase > on roadmap

Ø  ùnder construc'on` (single-‐sited) & ùnder implementa'on` (distributed), i.e. completed preparatory phase, sound, reviewed and agreed business case/delivery strategy, all investment decisions taken, started construc'on (single-‐sited) OR services delivered to scien'fic community l and from central hub to na'onal nodes (distributed) > `success stories` in landscape analysis

Ø  `constructed` (single-‐sited) & ìmplemented` (distributed) i.e. opera'on started, delivering services & achieving excellent scien'fic results > `success stories` in landscape analysis

Ø  ‘withdrawn’ i.e. no'fica'on to be withdrawn OR aèr removal due to passing ten years

| PAGE 41



Status & link to roadmap: SWG and IG will forward coherent and consistent recommenda'on per proposal to EB: candidate projects, emerging projects, rejected projects

Final check & proposal: Ø  EB will execute final check on following criteria:

•  balance between thema'c fields of SWG •  relevance of projects for EU policies •  global dimension of projects

Ø  EB will present recommenda'on per project containing: •  project summary and result eligibility check

•  scien'fic excellence •  pan-‐European relevance •  social-‐economic impact •  e-‐needs •  assessment of maturity •  overall recommenda'on (candidate, emerging or rejected)

| PAGE 42

ESFRI ENE-SW by Pilar García - Maghrenov workshop on research infrastructures for renewable energy...

Environment

Transcript of ESFRI ENE-SW by Pilar García - Maghrenov workshop on research infrastructures for renewable energy...