ERRATA in Intuition Pumps Intuition Pumps and Other Tools ... · ERRATA in Intuition Pumps ......

12
ERRATA in Intuition Pumps Corrections of the mistakes, thinkos, typos, and other Useful Improvements to Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking. So far, these are the errors that have been pointed out to me by sharp-eyed readers. I especially want to thank Hugo Dixon and Sara Smollett, the first readers to point these out. If you find others, please point them out to me, and I will be very grateful. Daniel Dennett p20: Sixth line of the last paragraph corrected from "Asking the wrongs questions" to "Asking the wrong questions". p.22. I say that most errors in DNA copying are “of no consequence, since nothing reads them! They are as inconsequential as the rough drafts you didn’t, or don’t, hand in to the teacher for grading.” But, as Susan van Druten points out to me (in a note on 9 July), “you know this is not accurate because you yourself have counseled students (back on page 20) that a blurted-out rough draft will provide them with something to fix. Humans learn from rough drafts, but DNA does not.” So it is a bad analogy. p.116. revised flow graph:

Transcript of ERRATA in Intuition Pumps Intuition Pumps and Other Tools ... · ERRATA in Intuition Pumps ......

Page 1: ERRATA in Intuition Pumps Intuition Pumps and Other Tools ... · ERRATA in Intuition Pumps ... Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking. ... “960 and Seirawan Chess were used

ERRATAinIntuitionPumpsCorrectionsofthemistakes,thinkos,typos,andotherUsefulImprovementstoIntuitionPumpsandOtherToolsforThinking. Sofar,thesearetheerrorsthathavebeenpointedouttomebysharp-eyedreaders.IespeciallywanttothankHugoDixonandSaraSmollett,thefirstreaderstopointtheseout.Ifyoufindothers,pleasepointthemouttome,andIwillbeverygrateful.DanielDennettp20:Sixthlineofthelastparagraphcorrectedfrom"Askingthewrongsquestions"to"Askingthewrongquestions".p.22.IsaythatmosterrorsinDNAcopyingare“ofnoconsequence,sincenothingreadsthem!Theyareasinconsequentialastheroughdraftsyoudidn’t,ordon’t,handintotheteacherforgrading.”But,asSusanvanDrutenpointsouttome(inanoteon9July),“youknowthisisnotaccuratebecauseyouyourselfhavecounseledstudents(backonpage20)thatablurted-outroughdraftwillprovidethemwithsomethingtofix.Humanslearnfromroughdrafts,butDNAdoesnot.”Soitisabadanalogy.p.116.revisedflowgraph:

Page 2: ERRATA in Intuition Pumps Intuition Pumps and Other Tools ... · ERRATA in Intuition Pumps ... Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking. ... “960 and Seirawan Chess were used

p.117.line10oftheRAPprogramshouldhave8,not11,intheGOTOSTEPp.119.zeroonthefirst“branchonzero”line:

Page 3: ERRATA in Intuition Pumps Intuition Pumps and Other Tools ... · ERRATA in Intuition Pumps ... Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking. ... “960 and Seirawan Chess were used
Page 4: ERRATA in Intuition Pumps Intuition Pumps and Other Tools ... · ERRATA in Intuition Pumps ... Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking. ... “960 and Seirawan Chess were used

p.122.amissingzeroisnowadded:

Page 5: ERRATA in Intuition Pumps Intuition Pumps and Other Tools ... · ERRATA in Intuition Pumps ... Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking. ... “960 and Seirawan Chess were used
Page 6: ERRATA in Intuition Pumps Intuition Pumps and Other Tools ... · ERRATA in Intuition Pumps ... Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking. ... “960 and Seirawan Chess were used

p.176.Iinvitedreaderstosendmebetterambiguous(“Quinian”)crosswordpuzzles.Iwasremindedbyseveralreaders,firstbyIlanCaron,ofthefamous1996NewYorkTimescrosswordpuzzlethat“predicted”thewinneroftheupcomingpresidentialelection:BOBDOLEorCLINTON,withallthedefinitionsofthecrossingwordsequallyambiguous.Itcanbefoundonthewebat,forinstance:(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_New_York_Times_crossword_puzzle#Records_and_puzzles_of_note).

OtherambiguouspuzzlesintheBritishcrosswordtradition(crypticclues,muchlessconstraintonwordcrossings)havebeensenttomebyRogerPhillipsandseveralotherreaders.p.252.Ispeakof“thefour-strokeOttocycleandthetwo-strokeDieselcycle”whereIshouldhavesaid“theOttocycleandtheDieselcycle,inbothtwo-strokeandfour-strokeversions”ThankstoBruceHymanforpointingthisout,December26,2017.p.275.IquoteAlain“everyboatiscopiedfromanotherboat....itistheseaherselfwhofashionstheboats,choosingthosewhichfunctionanddestroyingtheothers.”RogerDePledgepointsoutthatAlain(pseudonymofÉmileAugustChartier]waswriting“notaboutPolynesianbutBretonfishermenontheÎledeGroix(47°38'N,3°28'W)offLorient.Thiswasmymistake,sincethearticlebyRogers,D.S.,andEhrlich,P.R.(2008).“Naturalselectionandculturalratesofchange.”ProceedingsoftheNationalAcademyofSciencesDOI:10.1073/pnas.0711802105isaboutPolynesiancanoesandcitesAlainbutdoesnotclaimhewasspeakingaboutcanoes.Idrewthatinferencebymistake.p.398.Ihadn’tfoundtheFrenchversionofFabre’swordsaboutSphex,butthesehavebeensuppliedbyRogerDePledge:Aprèsdeuxoutroisépreuves…lesaisitaveclesmandibulesparlesantennesetl'entraîneimmédiatementdansleterrier.Quifutsot?p.420,ThegameInamed“chmess”andopinedtobeprobablynotworthplayinghasindeedbeenexploredindepth,asIsurmised,andisknownasSuperKing,accordingtoanote(19June)fromBenjaminConover.Itandothervariantssuchas“960andSeirawanChesswereusedasawayfortopgrandmasters(BobbyFischerandYasserSeirawan)toimprovetheirowngames.SoChmessisusefulforimprovingyourChessgame!”

p434:IntheRAPprogramfortheanswerto"Exercise2"(subtraction),instep10,the"REGISTER"columnshouldread"2",not"1".p.435.Line7shouldhave3inBRANCHTOSTEP:

Page 7: ERRATA in Intuition Pumps Intuition Pumps and Other Tools ... · ERRATA in Intuition Pumps ... Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking. ... “960 and Seirawan Chess were used
Page 8: ERRATA in Intuition Pumps Intuition Pumps and Other Tools ... · ERRATA in Intuition Pumps ... Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking. ... “960 and Seirawan Chess were used

p.436.newflowgraph:

P437:NewRAPprogramforexercise3b:

Page 9: ERRATA in Intuition Pumps Intuition Pumps and Other Tools ... · ERRATA in Intuition Pumps ... Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking. ... “960 and Seirawan Chess were used
Page 10: ERRATA in Intuition Pumps Intuition Pumps and Other Tools ... · ERRATA in Intuition Pumps ... Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking. ... “960 and Seirawan Chess were used

p.441.revisedflowgraphwithzero-outarrowsonsteps2-4:

Page 11: ERRATA in Intuition Pumps Intuition Pumps and Other Tools ... · ERRATA in Intuition Pumps ... Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking. ... “960 and Seirawan Chess were used
Page 12: ERRATA in Intuition Pumps Intuition Pumps and Other Tools ... · ERRATA in Intuition Pumps ... Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking. ... “960 and Seirawan Chess were used

p.451.ALAIN[ÉmileAugustChartier].....

***TheseventoolsdrawnfromPartIIexcerptedintheGuardianinspiredacomicstripbynoxnbekwhichcanbefoundathttp://nbek.org/blog/?p=2020AndhereisacartoondrawnbyNeilCohn,inspiredbyastick-figurecartoonIsawonadooratMIT’sAILabintheearly1980s.(Idon’tknowwhodrewtheoriginal.)