eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello...

28
Abhay Deshpande, Nils Feege for the Magnetic Cloak Team and collaborators EIC Generic Detector R&D Advisory Committee Meeting Brookhaven National Laboratory, January 26, 2017 eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak

Transcript of eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello...

Page 1: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

Abhay Deshpande, Nils Feegefor the Magnetic Cloak Team and collaborators

EIC Generic Detector R&D Advisory Committee MeetingBrookhaven National Laboratory, January 26, 2017

eRD2 Progress ReportMagnetic Field Cloak

Page 2: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

The people behind the plots

2

Stony Brook University (SUNY)

Abhay Deshpande Nils Feege Klaus Dehmelt Thomas K. HemmickRichard LeffertsAndrzej Lipski

High School Students

Ayesha Chhugani

BNL Advisors

Ramesh GuptaBrett ParkerVadim Ptitsyn

RIKEN

Yuji GotoItaru Nakagawa

Alexander AdhyatmanGordon Arrowsmith-KronDylan AvilesGabriel Bello PortmannDaniel BhattiIlana BrombergKyle Capobianco-HoganJae Hyeok ChangBenjamin CoeSean JeffasPlaton KarpovYoungkwang KoThomas KrahulikYakov Kulinich

Raphael Cervantes

Stony Brook University (SUNY) Undergraduate Students

Joshua LaBounty Tiffany LaByerRachel LosaccoShameran MahmudAbmael OliveiraHaley PowersAmiel QuadriRourke SekelskyKartik SharmaVijay ShetnaShawn ThompsonAbraham Tishelman-CharnyHelena Van NieuwenhuizenNoor Ward

Stacy KarthasGraduate Students

Page 3: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

3

A Magnetic Field Cloak

Page 4: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

We have completed…

• beam shielding tests with the BNL Van de Graaff accelerator,

• high-field shielding tests with the MRI magnet at Argonne National Lab,

• high-field cloaking tests with the MRI magnet at Argonne National Lab.

4

Page 5: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

• beam shielding tests with the BNL Van de Graaff accelerator,

• high-field shielding tests with the MRI magnet at Argonne National Lab,

• high-field cloaking tests with the MRI magnet at Argonne National Lab.

5

Page 6: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

6Thanks to the staff at the BNL Van de Graaff for their support

Page 7: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

7

Initial tests with Hall sensors

no shield

with shield

position (mm)-500 0 500

B (m

T)0

5

10Field map in y-direction taken at BNL

withshield

no shield

Page 8: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

Beam Test with lithium-7 at BNL Van de Graaff

8

withshield

no superconductor shield

lines are linear fits to data (excluding )Published in Proc. 2nd

North American Particle Accelerator Conf. (NA-PAC’16)

Page 9: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

• beam shielding tests with the BNL Van de Graaff accelerator,

• high-field shielding tests with the MRI magnet at Argonne National Lab,

• high-field cloaking tests with the MRI magnet at Argonne National Lab.

9

Page 10: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

The 45 Superconductor Layer Cloak Prototype

10

Page 11: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

11Thanks to the staff at Argonne National Lab for their support

Page 12: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

12

Test setup with MRI magnet at Argonne National Lab

Page 13: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

Shielding MRI Magnet Field

13

Page 14: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

We shield 99% of 0.45 tesla!

14

no time dependence

time dependence

1% leakage

~95% shielding at 0.50 T

Page 15: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

• beam shielding tests with the BNL Van de Graaff accelerator,

• high-field shielding tests with the MRI magnet at Argonne National Lab,

• high-field cloaking tests with the MRI magnet at Argonne National Lab.

15

Page 16: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

16

Page 17: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

Permeabilities of different ferromagnets up to 0.5 T

17

‘ideal’ cloak (theory)good cloaking at 40 mT

good cloaking at 450 mT

Page 18: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

Cloak reduces front field distortions by 90% at 0.45 T

18

~ 10%

x

Page 19: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

Cloak reduces front field distortions by 79% at 0.50 T

19

~ 21%

x

Page 20: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

Magnetic field cloaking ‘across cloak’

20

x

Page 21: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

Long-range Cloaking Effect

21

superconductor only

cloak

x

z

Page 22: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

Getting ready for publication

22

Page 23: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

23

A magnetic field cloak seems to be a viable option for EIC. We think we understand its design

parameters, fabrication, and limitations.

We have demonstrated magnetic field cloaking with 99% field shielding and 90% reduced field

distortions next to the shield at 0.45 T.

Page 24: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

The people behind the plots

24

Stony Brook University (SUNY)

Abhay Deshpande Nils Feege Klaus Dehmelt Thomas K. HemmickRichard LeffertsAndrzej Lipski

High School Students

Ayesha Chhugani

BNL Advisors

Ramesh GuptaBrett ParkerVadim Ptitsyn

RIKEN

Yuji GotoItaru Nakagawa

Alexander AdhyatmanGordon Arrowsmith-KronDylan AvilesGabriel Bello PortmannDaniel BhattiIlana BrombergKyle Capobianco-HoganJae Hyeok ChangBenjamin CoeSean JeffasPlaton KarpovYoungkwang KoThomas KrahulikYakov Kulinich

Raphael Cervantes

Stony Brook University (SUNY) Undergraduate Students

Joshua LaBounty Tiffany LaByerRachel LosaccoShameran MahmudAbmael OliveiraHaley PowersAmiel QuadriRourke SekelskyKartik SharmaVijay ShetnaShawn ThompsonAbraham Tishelman-CharnyHelena Van NieuwenhuizenNoor Ward

Stacy KarthasGraduate Students

Page 25: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

25

ADDITIONAL SLIDES

Page 26: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

Shielding MRI Magnet Field

26

no time dependence

time dependence

Page 27: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

Cloaking at different fields

27

x

Page 28: eRD2 Progress Report Magnetic Field Cloak · Gordon Arrowsmith-Kron Dylan Aviles Gabriel Bello Portmann Daniel Bhatti Ilana Bromberg Kyle Capobianco-Hogan Jae Hyeok Chang Benjamin

28

Beam Test with oxygen-16 at BNL Van de Graaff