Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

download Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

of 51

Transcript of Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    1/51

    ZLMFP[ GNZ HCC9AE@LEM @L[KZLOLEHPLNE HMHLE[P XQAAZ @A[LZA

    QE@AZ [AKPLNE ;==

    ]fnawaz wncqephzlc| fh{ khzehc lepazknqz{a hmhle{p pfa nz`az ng ehpqza }lpf he| ohe# }nohe# nzhelohc# {fhcc ja rqel{fa`

    H Knorlchplne j|

    Wnlka{ Hmhle{p ;==

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    2/51

    ZLMFP[ GNZ HCC9

    AE@LEM @L[KZLOLEHPLNE HMHLE[P XQAAZ @A[LZA

    QE@AZ [AKPLNE ;==

    ]fnawaz wncqephzlc| fh{ khzehc lepazknqz{a hmhle{p pfa nz`az ng ehpqza }lpf he| ohe# }nohe# nzhelohc# {fhcc ja rqel{fa`

    H Knorlchplne j|

    Wnlka{ Hmhle{p ;==

    :221

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    3/51

    Glz{p A`lplne 9 :220

    [akne` A`lplne 9 :220Pflz` A`lplne 9 :221

    Rzlepa` j| 9 @zl{fpl Wl{lne# Onjlca 9

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    4/51

    Xqaaz 9 he lekcq{lwa qojzacch pazo pfhp `a{lmehpa{ hcc pfn{a }fn hza }lcclem pn xqa{plne pfa enzo{ ng

    mae`az he` {avqhclp|

    Wnlka{ Hmhle{p ;== l{ h @acfl/jh{a` knhclplne ng mznqr{ }nzdlem ne }noae-{ zlmfp{# kflc` zlmfp{#

    fqohe zlmfp{# {avqhc zlmfp{# zlmfp pn fahcpf# he` ca{jlhe# mh|# jl{avqhc# he` pzhe{mae`az l{{qa{%

    Pfq{ ghz#oaojaz{ ng Wnlka{ Hmhle{p ;== lekcq`a9

    Hoea{p| Lepazehplnehc Le`lh# Khorhlme gnz Fqohe Zlmfp{

    Heiqohe# pfa IEQ [pq`aep{ Xqaaz Knccakplwa

    Jzahdpfznqmf# jqlc`lem fqohe zlmfp{ kqcpqza

    KZAH# Kzahplem Za{nqzka{ gnz Aorn}azoaep he` Hkplne

    Fhx# Kaepza gnz Kflc` Zlmfp{

    Ihmnzl# ]noae{ Pzhlelem# @nkqoaephplne he` Za{nqzka Kaepza

    Elmhf Oa`lh Knccakplwa# h {rhka gnz `l{kq{{lne{ hznqe` mae`az he` {avqhclp|

    Elzhephz# Kaepza ng Mae`az he` A`qkhplne

    Rhzpeaz{ gnz Ch} le @awacnroaep# Camhc Za{nqzka Mznqr

    RZL[O# h gnzqo gnz l{{qa{ zachplem pn {avqhc he` mae`az l`aeplpla{

    [hfacl ]noae{ Za{nqzka Kaepza# hqpnenonq{ }noae{ mznqr

    [HOH# Za{nqzka Mznqr gnz ]noae he` Fahcpf

    PHZ[FL# Phcdlem Hjnqp Zarzn`qkplwa he` [avqhc Fahcpf L{{qa{

    ]a lewlpa npfaz mznqr{.le`lwl`qhc{ }fn }nqc` clda pn cae` {qrrnzp nz cahze onza pn knephkp q{ hp

    wnlka{hmhle{p;==Bfnpohlc%kno%

    mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]
  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    5/51

    PHJCA NG KNEPAEP[

    Lepzn`qkplne 8

    [akplne ;==9 H Ghkp [faap 0

    Pa{plonelhc9 O| [pnz| 7

    [akplne ;== he` Kflc` [avqhc Hjq{a Pfa{a hza enp kh{a{ ng

    fqohe zlmfp{ wlnchplne jakhq{a pfa{a mznqr{ hza enp camhcc| zaknmel{a`% Cap pfao zarahc pfaLRK Hkp# }flkf jhe{ Fnon{avqhclp|%

    Hjnqp avpnzplne# Oz% Fam`a h`olppa` pfhp rnclkaoae hza enp hcc [hp|h

    Fhzl{fkfhe`zh{ he` lp }h{ rn{{ljca pfhp {noa ng pfao `n avpnzp onea| gzno fnon{avqhc{

    jqp pfa rznjcao }h{ pfhp fnon{avqhc{ `n enp knoa gnz}hz` pn cn`ma h knorchlep `qa pn

    {nklhc {plmoh% H{ zamhz`{ pfa ehpqza ng fnon{avqhclp|# Oz% Fam`a }h{ xqlpa kcahz pfhp lp }h{

    he helohc/clda jafhwlnqz%

    :;

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    29/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    [AKPLNE ;== HE@ FQOHE ZLMFP[ WLNCHPLNE[

    Pfa Mnwazeoaep ng Le`lh# le za{rne{a pn pfa raplplne khcclem gnz pfa `akzlolehcl{hplne ng h`qcp#

    kne{ae{qhc {av glca` le pfa @acfl Flmf Knqzp j| pfa Ehy Gnqe`hplne# {phpa` pfhp [akplne ;== LRK knqc` enp ja

    kfhccaema` jakhq{a Le`lhe {nklap| j| he` chzma `na{ enp hrrznwa ng fnon{avqhclp|% Le pfl{ h{{azplne# pfa

    mnwazeoaep fh{ ghlca` pn zaknmelya pfhp pfa ch}{ ng pfl{ che` hza oahep pn rznpakp he` rznonpa fqohe zlmfp{ ng

    hcc lp{ klplyae{# lzza{rakplwa ng }fhp lp kchlo{ pn ja pfa rnrqchz {aeploaep{ ng pfa ohinzlp|% Pfa ohinzlp|/

    olenzlp| gzhoa}nzd l{ kcahzc| h `qjlnq{ nea# kne{l`azlem pfhp {avqhc hkp{ `aaoa` pn ja hmhle{p pfa nz`az ng

    ehpqza lekcq`a nzhc he` hehc {av# lzza{rakplwa ng }fapfaz pfa{a hkp{ hza razgnzoa` jap}aae oae he` oae#

    }noae he` }noae nz# {lmelglkhepc|# }noae he` oae%

    Awae le pfn{a kh{a{ }faza pfa [phpa `na{ enp razrapzhpa nwazp wlnchplne{ lp{acg# pfa oaza avl{paeka ng h

    ch} {qkf h{ ;== {fn}{ `l{zamhz` gnz h zhema ng Gqe`hoaephc Zlmfp{ h{ mqhzhepaa` le Rhzp LLL ng pfa

    Kne{plpqplne% Pfa{a lekcq`a pfa zlmfp pn clga he` cljazp|# h{ {phpa` le Hzplkca :8 &he` }flkf lekcq`a{ pfa zlmfp{

    pn fahcpf he` rzlwhk|,4 pfa zlmfp pn axqhclp| &Hzplkca 80,4 he`# qe`az Hzplkca 8

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    30/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    Pfa lepazehplnehc knooqelp| ng fqohe zlmfp{ h`wnkhpa{ fhwa lekzah{lemc| zaknmel{a` pfa eaa` pn

    aemhma }lpf pfa {raklglk wlnchplne{ ghka` j| mh|# ca{jlhe# jl{avqhc he` pzhe{mae`aza` ranrca% Pfl{ gacp eaa`

    fh{ jaae {qrrnzpa` j| knwaehep{ he` `akchzhplne{% Le 8

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    31/51

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    32/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    Pfa ch} kheenp zaknmel{a zlmfp{ nec| le rzlwhpa# }flca `l{n}elem pfao le rqjclk% Pfa ch} fh{ pn ja jh{a` ne

    fqohe zlmfp{ rzleklrca{ he` {phe`hz`{ he` kheenp jcle`c| gnccn} rqjclk nrlelne% Le`aa` lg pfhp }aza pn ja pfa

    kh{a pfa rzhkplka ng qepnqkfhjlclp|# kflc` ohzzlhma# kflc` chjnqz apk }nqc` hcc fhwa pn ja camhcl{a` mlwae pfalz

    }l`a{rzah` rzawhcaeka he` hkkarphjlclp| le {nklap|% Gqzpfaz {akplne ;== l{ le en }h| axqlrra` pn `ahc }lpf pfakzloa ng kflc` {avqhc hjq{a he` l{ le ghkp he lora`loaep le {akqzlem rzn{akqplne{ gnz kflc` {avqhc hjq{a%

    Pfaza fhwa jaae hppaorp{ j| pfa MnL he` npfaz{ pn rnzpzh| pfa l{{qa ng pfa zlmfp pn {avqhc l`aeplp| h{ h

    }a{paze knekaze% Pfl{ rn{lplne lmenza{ pfa ghkp pfhp le h mzn}lem eqojaz ng {nqpfaze knqepzla{

    `l{kzlolehplne ne pfa mznqe`{ ng {avqhc nzlaephplne l{ rznfljlpa`% Pfa{a lekcq`a Rflclrrlea{# [nqpf Hgzlkh#

    Oavlkn he` Jqcmhzlh% Npfaz {phpa{ lekcq`lem Le`nea{lh# Dhyhdf{phe# Kflca# Znohelh he` Hyazjhlihe `n enp

    kzlolehcl{a h`qcp kne{ae{qhc {hoa {av zachplne{%

    Pfa MnL{ {qjol{{lne le pfa Ehy kh{a knoa{ `a{rlpa pfa mzn}lem kne{klnq{ea{{ pn}hz`{ {avqhc nzlaephplne

    le H{lh j| Mnwazeoaep{ le Phl}he# Ihrhe# Pfhlche` he` [lemhrnza%

    Hoea{p| Lepazehplnehc Le`lh khcc{ gnz pfa looa`lhpa zarahc ng [akplne ;==# pfa camhc zaknmelplne ng pfa

    zlmfp enp pn `l{kzlolehpa` hmhle{p jakhq{a ng nea-{ {avqhc nzlaephplne nz l`aeplp| he` pfa aehkpoaep ng h

    {arhzhpa caml{chplne# le clea }lpf lepazehplnehc fqohe zlmfp{ {phe`hz`{# ne kflc` {avqhc hjq{a%

    Hoea{p| Lepazehplnehc Le`lh gqcc| {qrrnzp{ pfa khorhlme chqekfa` j| whzlnq{ klwlc {nklap| mznqr{ qe`az pfa

    jheeaz -Wnlka{ Hmhle{p [akplne ;==-% Hoea{p| Lepazehplnehc Le`lh jaclawa{ pfhp }fhp l{ hp {phda l{ enp

    le`lwl`qhc gzaa`no{ jqp pfa jh{lk fqohe zlmfp pn nea-{ rf|{lkhc he` oaephc lepamzlp| he` pfa zlmfp pn ja gzaa

    gzno `l{kzlolehplne%

    Pfl{ l{ enp he l{{qa ng nec| pfa ca{jlhe# mh|# jl{avqhc nz pzhe{mae`az knooqelp|# le{pah` lp l{ h fqohe zlmfp{l{{qa pfhp knekaze{ q{ hcc% Lg }a pncazhpa pfa `aelhc ng zlmfp{ pn he| mznqr# }a qe`azolea pfa }fnca rznpakplwa

    gzhoa}nzd ng fqohe zlmfp{ j| phdlem h}h| lp{ kaepzhc rched pfa axqhc zlmfp{ he` `lmelp| ng hcc fqohe jalem{%

    Hoea{p| Lepazehplnehc Le`lh pfazagnza hrrahc{ pn hcc {akplne{ ng klwlc {nklap| pn {qrrnzp pfl{ khorhlme pn zarahc

    he qeiq{p ch}%

    :=

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    33/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    [AKPLNE ;== WLNCHPA[ LEPAZEHPLNEHC FQOHE ZLMFP[ KNEWAEPLNE[

    Qelwaz{hc @akchzhplne ng Fqohe Zlmfp{En nea {fhcc ja {qjiakpa` pn pnzpqza nzpn kzqac# lefqohe nz `amzh`lem pzahpoaep nz rqel{foaep% &Hzplkca 1,%

    QE Fqohe Zlmfp{ Knoolppaale nea ng pfa kh{a{ enpa` pfhp zagazaeka pn {av le pfaene/`l{kzlolehplne kchq{a ng pfa LKKRZ {fnqc` lekcq`a {avqhc nzlaephplne%

    Pfa QE Fqohe Zlmfp{ Knool{{lne fh{ qzma` {phpa{ enp nec| pn zarahc ch}{kzlolehcl{lem fnon{avqhclp| jqp hc{n pn ae{fzlea pfa rznfljlplne ng l{kzlolehplne jh{a` ne

    {avqhc nzlaephplne lepn pfalz kne{plpqplne nz npfaz gqe`hoaephc ch}{%

    Jalilem RGHpfa fqohe zlmfp{ ng }noae lekcq`a pfalz zlmfp pn fhwa knepznc nwaz he``akl`a gzaac| he` za{rne{ljc| ne ohppaz{ zachpa` pn pfalz {avqhclp|# lekcq`lem {avqhc he`

    zarzn`qkplwa fahcpf# gzaa ng knazklne# l{kzlolehplne he` wlncaeka%

    %

    :6

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    34/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    NRAE CAPPAZ LE ZA[RNE[A PN PFA MNWAZEOAEP HGGL@HWLP NE[AKPLNE ;==

    Ne

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    35/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    {avqhc jafhwlnqz% [fnqc` pfa raplplne {qkkaa`# pfa {phpa{ hjlclp| pn q{a [akplne ;== le kflc`

    {avqhc hjq{a kh{a{ zaohle{ qehggakpa`%

    H{ le`lwl`qhc{ he` mznqr{ pfhp {qrrnzp he` hgglzo pfa zlmfp{ ng mh|# ca{jlhe# jl{avqhc# flizh# he`

    pzhe{mae`aza` ranrca# }a `aohe` pfhp pfa mnwazeoaep aehjca pfa rznpakplne j| pfa ch} ng hcc

    klplyae{# }lpfnqp `l{kzlolehplne jh{a` ne mae`az nz {avqhc nzlaephplne% Pn}hz`{ pfl{ ae`# pfaza l{

    he qzmaep eaa` pn `akzlolehcl{a {av jap}aae kne{aeplem h`qcp{% Lp l{ enp pfa jq{lea{{ ng

    mnwazeoaep pn `akl`a }fhp ranrca kfnn{a pn `n }lpf knorcapa kne{aep }lpfnqp legzlemlem ne pfa

    zlmfp{ ng he| npfaz klplyae% Lp l{ pfa jq{lea{{ ng pfa mnwazeoaep# fn}awaz# pn gzhoa aggakplwa ch}{

    pfhp rzn{akqpa falenq{ kzloa{ {qkf h{ kflc` {avqhc hjq{a%

    Pfa mnwazeoaep fh{ {phpa` le lp{ hggl`hwlp ahkf ng pfa gqe`hoaephc zlmfp{ hza {qjiakp pn

    zah{nehjca za{pzlkplne{% Za{pzlkplem pfa hkka{{ ng olcclne{ ng klplyae{ pn rznraz fahcpf khza# ghlclem

    pn h``za{{ zhorhep `l{kzlolehplne ne pfa jh{l{ ng pfalz {avqhc rzagazaeka# ghlclem pn rznpakp pfao

    gzno fhzh{{oaep j| pfa rnclka he` kzlolehcl{lem pfalz kne{ae{qhc {avqhc hkp{ }flca fl`lem jafle`

    pfa glm cahg ng rznpakplem Le`lhe kqcpqza# hza enp zah{nehjca za{pzlkplne{ j| he| {phe`hz`{% ]a qzma

    pfa mnwazeoaep pn zakne{l`az lp{ rn{lplne# jzlemlem lp le clea }lpf pfa zaxqlzaoaep{ ng pfa

    Kne{plpqplne ng Le`lh }lpf zamhz` pn Gqe`hoaephc Zlmfp{ ng awaz| klplyae he` }lpf pfa Qelwaz{hc

    @akchzhplne ng Fqohe Zlmfp{%

    ;2

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    36/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    RZL[O CAHGCAP NE [AKPLNE ;==

    @n |nq den}[akplne ;== ng pfa Le`lhe Raehc Kn`a>Lp kzlolehcl{a{ {avqhc hkplwlp|jap}aae kne{aeplemh`qcp{%

    @n |nq den} }a `nepfhwa h ch} pfhp rqel{fa{ {avqhc hjq{ang kflc`zae# jqp }a fhwa ch}{ pfhp {h| |nq kheenp kfnn{a pn

    fhwa nzhc {av le pfa rzlwhk| ng |nqzja`znnoawae lg |nq hzaohzzla`>

    @n |nq den} pfhp hkflc` onca{pnz}h{ hkxqlppa` jakhq{apfa

    kflc`fa

    hjq{a`}h{

    pnn |nqempn fhwa

    h {ae{a ng on`a{p|>

    @n |nq den} pfhp p}n }noae }aza ihlca` he` cn{p pfalz inj{

    jakhq{a pfa| }hepa` pn ohzz| ahkf npfaz>

    @n |nq den} pfhp [akplne ;== hccn}{ pfa {phpa pn `l{kzlolehpa

    jap}aae klplyae{4 pfhp lp aeknqzhma{ pfa rnclka pn fhzh{{

    he` jchkdohlc mh| oae>

    Wlnchpa{ pfa gqe`hoaephc zlmfp{ mqhzhepaa` pn hcc klplyae{ j|

    nqz Kne{plpqplne> Cah`{ pn cn{{ ng inj{he` clga>@n |nq den} fn} ohe| ranrca fhwa `la` gzno FLW jakhq{a pfa| }aza pnn

    {khza` pn pacc pfalz `nkpnz pfa| }aza mh|>

    knqepca{{

    @n |nq den} fn} ohe| mh| oae fhwa jaae zhra` j| rnclkaoae>

    knqepca{{

    @n |nq den} fn} ohe| ca{jlhe{ fhwa jaae gnzka` pn ohzz|>

    Knqepca{{

    Nrae |nqz ole`% Lp{ h ohppaz ng clga% Nz `ahpf%

    ;8

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    37/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    Cahgcap l{pzljqpa hgpaz pfa hzza{p ng EMN }nzdaz{ hp Cqkden} le Iqc| :228

    F H C C H J N C (

    Zacah{a Fqohe Zlmfp{ ]nzdaz{( [pnr fhzh{{lem EMN{(

    Ne =pf

    Iqc|# :228# pfa Qpphz Rzh`a{f rnclka zhl`a` pfa ngglka{ he` hzza{pa` oaojaz{ ng Jfhzn{h

    Pzq{p he` Ehy Gnqe`hplne Lepazehplnehc &EGL, le Cqkden}# jnpf EMN{ }nzdlem ne FLW. HL@[

    lepazwaeplne }lpf pfa oae }fn fhwa {av }lpf oae &O[O, knooqelp|% EGL {raklglkhcc| rznwl`a{

    pakfelkhc {qrrnzp pn FLW. HL@[ lepazwaeplne }nzd% Hcc pfa {phggaz{ }aza {qj{axqaepc| jahpae hp pfa

    rnclka {phplne%

    Pfa rnclka {alya` clpazhpqza he` ohpazlhc{ q{a` gnz a`qkhplem O[O ne {hgaz {av rzhkplka{# ne pfa

    jh{l{ ng }flkf pfa| kfhzma` pfa {phgg oaojaz{ }lpf {hca# apk%# ng nj{kaea ohpazlhc{% Awae onza

    `hemaznq{ hza kfhzma{ ng wlnchplne{ ng pfa Knr|zlmfp he` Le`akaep Zarza{aephplne ng ]noae

    Hkp{% Pfa{a ch{p p}n avrn{a pfa ole`{ap ng pfa QR rnclka# }flkf fh{ jaae fhzh{{lem he`leplol`hplem EMN }nzdaz{ hkzn{{ pfa {phpa% Lp oh| ja zakhcca` pfhp he EMN }h{ zakaepc| kfhzma`

    qe`az pfa Ehplnehc [akqzlp| Hkp# he` npfaz EMN }nzdaz{ fhwa hc{n jaae jzhe`a` ehvhclpa{% Le

    pfl{ kh{a pnn# pfa }nzdaz{ fhwa jaae lepazznmhpa` j| pfa Lepacclmaeka Jqzahq pn lewa{plmhpa

    rn{{ljca cled{ }lpf Rhdl{phe{ L[L(

    Pfa {phgg }aza hc{n kfhzma` qe`az pfa heplxqhpa` [akplne ;== ng pfa Le`lhe Raehc Kn`a }flkf

    kzlolehcl{a{ kne{ae{qhc {av% Pfhp pnn }fae en kh{a ng {n`no| avl{p{# hkknz`lem pn pfa rnclka{

    n}e zarnzp% \ap pfa Kflag Iq`lklhc Ohml{pzhpa he` pfa [a{{lne{ Knqzp fhwa `aela` pfao jhlc ne

    pfa mznqe`{ pfhp pfa| hza h kqz{a ne {nklap|% Pfa{a mznqe`{ hza enp hkkarphjca qe`az ch}%

    Pfl{ rnclka hkplne fh{ `hemaznq{ lorclkhplne{ gnz hcc {avqhc fahcpf rzniakp{ le Le`lh he` ne pfa

    }nzd jalem `nea j| FLW. HL@[ lepazwaeplne EMN{ }lpf wqceazhjca rnrqchplne{ clda {av }nzdaz{#

    `zqm q{az{ he` O[O# }fn jaknoa nrae pn {qkf hjq{a he` wlkplol{hplne j| nzmhe{ ng pfa {phpa#

    lekcq`lem pfa rnclka%

    Jfhzn{h }h{ }nzdlem }lpfle pfa mql`aclea{ {ap j| pfa Mnwazeoaep ng Le`lh razphlelem pn FLW.

    HL@[ lepazwaeplne }nzd% Pfa leiq{plka l{ knornqe`a` j| pfa ghkp pfhp pfa mnwazeoaep fh{ {phpa`

    qeaxqlwnkhcc| le lepazehplnehc gnzh clda pfa Qelpa` Ehplne{ Maeazhc H{{aojc| [raklhc [a{{lne

    &QEMH[[, ne FLW. HL@[ pfhp CMJP &Ca{jlhe# Mh|# Jl{avqhc he` Pzhe{{avqhc, ranrca hza h

    wqceazhjca {akplne pfhp oq{p ja lekcq`a` le FLW. HL@[ nqpzahkf }nzd% Pfa kfhzma{ hmhle{p pfa

    {phgg he` pfalz knepleqa` lekhzkazhplne le ihlc l{ h razwaz{lne ng iq{plka he` h `lzakp h{{hqcp enp nec|

    ne pfa hzza{pa` jqp hc{n ne pfa zlmfp{ ng O[O pn hkka{{ fahcpf legnzohplne hznqe` FLW. HL@[%

    Zlmfp pn fahcpf l{ knwaza` qe`az pfa Gqe`hoaephc Zlmfp pn Clga qe`az Hzplkca :8 ng pfa

    Kne{plpqplne# he` fahcpf legnzohplne kheenp ja `aela` pn O[O iq{p jakhq{a ng {nklhc razkarplne%

    En nea khe ja kzlolehcl{a` gnz rznwl`lem fahcpf legnzohplne%

    ]a `aohe` pfhp pfa hzza{pa` {phgg ja zacah{a` looa`lhpac| he` pfhp hcc pfa kfhzma{ hmhle{p pfao

    ja `znrra`%

    ;:

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    38/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    Cahgcap ne knepzh lkplne{ le pfa [phpa{ hkplne{ he aa { jznqmfp nqp hgpaz pfa hzza{p ng EMN }nzdaz{ hp

    Cqkden} le Iqc| :228

    PFA ZLMFP FHE@ DEN][ ENP ]FHP PFA CAGP FHE@ L[ @NLEM

    H mcheka hp zakaep Mnwazeoaep ng Le`lh {phpaoaep{.hkplne{ }lpf zamhz` pn {avqhcolenzlpla{%

    Ne :1 Ohzkf# :222 pfa Ch} Knool{{lne ng Le`lh# le lp{ 8=:e`

    zarnzp &zawla} ng zhra

    ch}{,# zaknooae`{ pfhp [akplne ;== ja `znrra`# kcahzc| {phplem pfhp }a hza ng pfa nrlelne pfhp [akplne

    ;== `a{azwa{ pn ja `acapa`%

    Ne :7 Iqea# :228 Le`lh wafaoaepc| nrrn{a{ he hppaorp j| 1= knqepzla{ &pfa Nzmhelyhplne ng pfa L{cholk

    Knegazaeka, pn avkcq`a pfa Lepazehplnehc Mh| he` Ca{jlhe Fqohe Zlmfp{ H{{nklhplne gzno `acljazhplne{

    hp pfa Qelpa` Ehplne{ Maeazhc H{{aojc| [raklhc [a{{lne ne FLW.HL@[% [phplem qeaxqlwnkhcc| pfhp

    avkcq`lem LMCFZK }nqc` {ap h waz| jh` rzaka`aep# pfhp pfa Le`lhe mnwazeoaep zaknmel{a` mh|{ he`

    ca{jlhe{ h{ h kzqklhc rnrqchplne }fn{a eaa`{ fh` pn ja h``za{{a` le pfa knepavp ng FLW.HL@[ he`

    pn}hz`{ pfhp kne`qkp{ {qrrnzp rznmzhooa{ khpazlem pn pfa fahcpf zl{d{ ng pfl{ knooqelp|%

    Ne 7 Iqc|# :228# pfa Qelne Olel{paz ng [phpa gnz Fahcpf# Oz% K%R% Pfhdqz hrrahz{ ne [phz Ea}{ pn

    zalpazhpa Le`lh{ knoolpoaep pn lekcq`lem mh|{# ca{jlhe{# jl{avqhc{ he` pzhe{mae`az ranrca le pfa

    Mnwazeoaep{ FLW lepazwaeplne aggnzp{%

    Ne = Iqc| :228# pfa Qpphz Rzh`a{f rnclka zhl`a` pfa ngglka{ he` hzza{pa` pfa {phgg oaojaz{ ng Jfhzn{h

    Pzq{p he` Ehy Gnqe`hplne Lepazehplnehc &EGL, le Cqkden}%

    Ne ;2 Iqc|# :228# Le`lh wnpa{ }lpf pfa Nzmhel{hplne{ ng pfa L{cholk Knegazaeka pn `ae| pfa LepazehplnehcCa{jlhe he` Mh| H{{nklhplne h rchka hp pfa Qelpa` Ehplne{ ]nzc` Knegazaeka Hmhle{p Zhkl{o pn ja fac`

    le [arpaojaz le @qzjhe# [nqpf Hgzlkh%

    Mnwazeoaep rnclk| ne EMN{ }nzdlem ne FLW.HL@[9 Pfa Ehplnehc Hl`{ Knepznc Rnclk|#

    {raklglkhcc| oaeplne{ oae fhwlem {av }lpf oae &O[O, h{ nea ng pfa khpamnzla{ }lpf flmf zl{d

    jafhwlnqz he` pfazagnza le eaa` ng lepazwaeplne%

    ;;

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    39/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    [HOA [AV @A[LZA HE@ OAEPHC FAHCPF9 HE LEPAZEHPLNEHCNWAZWLA]

    Hkzn{{ pfa }nzc`# oa`lkhc h{{nklhplne{ he` ngglklhc jn`la{ ng eqoaznq{ oaephc fahcpf `l{klrclea{

    fhwa `a/{plmohplya` fnon{avqhclp| he` hc{n avrclklpc| rznfljlpa` hppaorp{ hp zarhzhplwa pfazhr|#

    nz knewaz{lne pfazhr|% Pfa Hoazlkhe R{|kfnhehc|plkhc H{{nklhplne{ 8

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    40/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    @z% [he`aar Wnfzh# [aelnz kne{qcplem R{|kflhpzl{p ng pfa Hrnccn Fn{rlphc he` Rza{l`aep

    ng pfa @acfl R{|kflhpzlk [nklap|# h{ }acc h{ h oaojaz ng pfa Le`lhe R{|kflhpzlk

    [nklap| fh{ pfl{ pn {h|9 Nqz {phe` zaohle{ pfa {hoa% Fnon{avqhclp| l{ enp h `l{ah{a#

    he` }a }lcc knepleqa pn pzahp lp pfhp }h|%8

    H{lh

    Pfa Kflea{a R{|kfnhehc|plkhc H{{nklhplne h`nrpa` h za{ncqplne le :228 }flkf

    hkkarpa` pfa mql`aclea{ ng pfa 8

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    41/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    [nqpf Hoazlkh9Mnwazeoaep{ ng Hzmaepleh# Jzhylc# he` Akqh`nz# he` pfa knqepzla{ ng

    Kaepzhc Hoazlkh# lekcq`lem Mqhpaohch he` Jaclya# hcc rznfljlp `l{kzlolehplne hmhle{p

    fnon{avqhclp| he` zaknmelya pfa zlmfp{ ng {hoa/{av knqrca{%

    H{lh9Fnon{avqhclp| l{ camhc le Kfleh# [nqpf Dnzah# Phl}he# Ihrhe# Pfhlche`# Chn{#

    Khojn`lh# he` Wlapeho%8

    8 Legnzohplne klpa gzno }}}%qprnrlh/h{lh%kno

    ;7

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    42/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    RZL[O CAHGCAP NE AXQHC HE@ LEHCLAEHJCA ZLMFP[

    ]fazah{ zaknmelplne ng pfa lefazaep `lmelp| he` ng pfa axqhc he` lehclaehjca zlmfp{ ng hcc oaojaz{

    ng pfa fqohe gholc| l{ pfa gnqe`hplne ng gzaa`no# iq{plka he` rahka le pfa }nzc`)

    ]a hza ca{jlhe# mh|# pzhe{mae`az# jl{avqhc# pzhe{wa{plpa# aqeqkf# fapazn{avqhc# pzhe{{avqhc he`

    ]a fhwa pfa zlmfp pn clga# cljazp| he` {akqzlp| ng raz{ne)

    ]a {fhcc enp ja {qjiakpa` pn lepazgazaeka }lpf nqz rzlwhk|# fnoa nz knzza{rne`aeka# enz hpphkd{ qrnenqz fnenqz he` zarqphplne)

    ]a fhwa pfa zlmfp pn zaknmelplne awaz|}faza h{ h raz{ne jagnza pfa ch})

    ]a fhwa pfa zlmfp pn ja axqhc jagnza pfa ch} he` hza aeplpca` }lpfnqp he| `l{kzlolehplne pn axqhcrznpakplne)

    ]a fhwa pfa zlmfp pn gzaa`no ng nrlelne he` avrza{{lne# lekcq`lem pfa gzaa`no pn fnc` nrlelne{}lpfnqp lepazgazaeka he` pn {aad# zakalwa# he` lorhzp legnzohplne he` l`ah{ pfznqmf he| oa`lhzamhz`ca{{ ng gzneplaz{)

    ]a fhwa pfa zlmfp pn gzaa`no ng rahkagqc h{{aojc| he` h{{nklhplne)

    ]a fhwa pfa zlmfp pn h gqcc he` }fnca{noa clga%

    )Qelwaz{hc @akchzhplne ng Fqohe Zlmfp{# Qelpa Ehplne{ Maeazhc H{{aojc|%

    ;=

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    43/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    RZA[[ ZACAH[A

    RQJCLK HKPLNE HMHLE[P [AKPLNE ;== LE EA] @ACFL

    Iqc| 8# 8:ro pn :ro# Ihephz Ohephz# Ea} @acfl

    Pfa rqjclk hkplne l{ h `aone{pzhplne ng {ncl`hzlp| hmhle{p pfa leiq{plka oapa` nqp pfznqmf [akplne

    ;==% Hcc rznmza{{lwa mznqr{ he` le`lwl`qhc{ hza qelpa` le pfalz aggnzp pn knojhp he hzkfhlk he`

    nrrza{{lwa ch} pfhp rznwl`a{ hj{ncqpac| en rznpakplne pn pfa{a knooqelpla{ hmhle{p {phpa he`

    ene/{phpa wlnchpnz{ ng fqohe zlmfp{% Le h``lplne pn rznpa{plem pfa {lcaeka hznqe` l{{qa{ ng {avqhclp|

    he` fnonrfnjlh le Le`lhe {nklap|# h{ }acc h{ knepa{plem fnonmaenq{ wla}{ ng rqjclk onzhclp|#

    }a }lcc ja ohdlem h `lzakp hrrahc pn pfa ea}c| gnzoa` Knemza{{/ca` Qelpa` Rznmza{{lwa Hcclheka

    Mnwazeoaep pn phda {par{ pn ae` `l{kzlolehplne qe`az [akplne ;==% Pfa avl{paeka ng pfl{ ch} hc{n

    fle`az{ pfa `zhgplem ng h {qj{pheplwa ea} ch} ne Kflc` [avqhc Hjq{a h ch} pfhp l{ kzlplkhcc|

    eaa`a` he` jalem kne{phepc| aohe`a` j| kflc` zlmfp{ mznqr{ hkzn{{ pfa knqepz|%

    ]a }nqc` hc{n clda pn `zh} pfa hppaeplne ng pfa QRH Mnwazeoaep pn pfa raplplne glca` hmhle{p

    [akplne ;== le pfa @acfl Flmf Knqzp% Pfa eavp fahzlem ng pfa raplplne l{ ne Iqc| =# :220% Pfa

    raplplne khcc{ gnz h zah`lem `n}e ng [akplne ;==# }flkf }nqc` lorc| pfhp kne{ae{qhc {hoa/{av

    {avqhc hkplwlp| jap}aae h`qcp{ he` le rzlwhpa }nqc` en cnemaz ja h kzlolehc nggaeka%

    [akplne ;==# h{ lp avl{p{ pn`h|# wlnchpa{ axqhc hkka{{ pn pfa zlmfp{ ng clga# fahcpf# rznrazp| he`

    kfnlka% Pfl{ l{ h ch} pfhp hggakp{ hcc ng q{# zamhz`ca{{ ng nqz {avqhc nzlaephplne he` mna{ hmhle{p

    pfa gqe`hoaephc jaclag{ ng pfl{ ehplne `aonkzhk|# axqhclp|# h jaclag le fqohe zlmfp{# `lmelp| he`

    gzaa`no gzno wlncaeka gnz hcc% @L[KZLOLEHPLNE NG HCC DLE@[ QE@AZ [AKPLNE ;== OQ[P

    AE@ EN](

    Wnlka{ Hmhle{p ;== l{ h @acfl/jh{a` knhclplne ng mznqr{ }nzdlem ne }noae-{ zlmfp{# kflc` zlmfp{#

    fqohe zlmfp{# {avqhc zlmfp{# zlmfp pn fahcpf# he` ca{jlhe# mh|# jl{avqhc# he` pzhe{mae`az l{{qa{%

    Pfl{ mznqr {aad{ pn `zh} rqjclk hppaeplne pn [akplne ;== ng pfa Le`lhe Raehc Kn`a# 8672 pfa ch}

    pfhp raehclya{ khzehc lepazknqz{a hmhle{p pfa nz`az ng ehpqza he` aggakplwac| kzlolehclya{ {hoa/

    {av {avqhc hkplwlp| jap}aae kne{aeplem h`qcp{# he` awae kazphle {avqhc rzhkplka{ honem

    fapazn{avqhc kne{aeplem h`qcp{# le rzlwhpa% Lp l{ h ch} pfhp fh{ mlwae camlplohk| pn mzn{{ he`

    {q{phlea` fqohe zlmfp{ wlnchplne{ hmhle{p ca{jlhe# mh|# flizh# pzhe{mae`az he` jl{avqhc ranrca#

    pfq{ eamhplem pfa kne{plpqplnehc kchlo ng axqhc klplyae{flr he` rznpakplne gnz hcc%

    Pfq{ ghz# oaojaz{ ng Wnlka{ Hmhle{p ;== lekcq`a9 Hoea{p| Lepazehplnehc Le`lh# Heiqohe#

    Jzahdpfznqmf# KZAH# Fhx# Ihmnzl# Elmhf Oa`lh Knccakplwa# Elzhephz# Rhzpeaz{ gnz Ch} le

    @awacnroaep# RZL[O# [hfacl# [hoh he` PHZ[FL% ]a lewlpa npfaz mznqr{.le`lwl`qhc{ }fn }nqc`

    clda pn cae` {qrrnzp nz cahze onza pn inle q{ hp pfa rqjclk hkplne# he`.nz knephkp q{ hp

    wnlka{hmhle{p;==Bfnpohlc%kno%

    ;6

    mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]
  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    44/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    0

    PLOA CLEA GNZ [AKPLNE ;== RLC

    :228# Ehy Gnqe`hplne Le`lh glca{ raplplne le @acfl Flmf Knqzp# pfznqmf Ch}|az{ Knccakplwa# h{dlem gnz zah`lem`n}e ng [akplne ;== LRK l%a% h{d{ gnz rzlwhpa# kne{ae{qhc {av jap}aae h`qcp{ pn ja akzlolehclya`

    Ihe :22:# @acfl Flmf Knqzp l{{qa{ enplka pn Hppnzea| Maeazhc

    [arp :22;# Le`lhe mnwazeoaep glca{ lp{ za{rne{a# nrrn{lem raplplne

    Enw :220# @acfl Flmf Knqzp l{ol{{a{ raplplne {h|lem en rzn{akqplne rae`lem hmhle{p Ehy gnqe`hplne Le`lh he`raplplne enp whcl` qeca{{ glca` j| pfa knooqelp| pfhp l{ `lzakpc| hggakpa`

    Nkp :220# Zawla} raplplne glca` jagnza Flmf Knqzp zamhz`lem whcl`lp| ng RLC

    Enw :220# @acfl Flmf Knqzp zaiakp{ hrrclkhplne gnz zawla}

    Gaj :221# [raklhc Cahwa Raplplne glca` le [qrzaoa Knqzp ne clolpa` rnlep ng whcl`lp| ng RLC

    Hrz :221# [qrzaoa Knqzp ohda{ nzhc nj{azwhplne{ pfhp pfa kh{a lewncwa{ h rqjclk lepaza{p l{{qa he` nea pfhpl{ jalem l{kq{{a` hcc nwaz pfa }nzc`% Knqzp l{{qa{ enplka pn pfa mnwazeoaep%

    ;

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    45/51

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    46/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    7

    pnmapfaz# clda h xqlcp% Le `nlem {n# }a fnra hc{n pn {pzaempfae nqz cledhma{ he` }l`ae pfa {rakpzqo

    ng mznqr{ pfhp }hcd }lpf q{ hkplwl{p mznqr{# EMN{# {pq`aep{# oa`lkhc rzhkplplneaz{# camhc

    khorhlmeaz{# pfa }nzd{%

    J| pfa ae` ng pfa |ahz# ne Fqohe Zlmfp{ @h|# 82pf @akaojaz :221# }a fnra pn ja {pznemaz

    pnmapfaz he` onza aggakplwa le ohdlem nqz{acwa{ fahz` cnq` he` kcahz%

    Nqz aohlc h``za{{9 wnlka{hmhle{p;==Bza`lggohlc%kno

    [rzah` pfa }nz`4 pfa onza wnlka{# pfa jappaz

    08

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    47/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    =

    Wnlka{ Hmhle{p ;==9 Cahgcap

    PFA ]NOAE[ ONWAOAEP HE@ [AVQHCLP\9 [PZAEMPFAELEM NQZ [PZQMMCA[

    Raz{nehc l{ rnclplkhc fh{ cnem jaae h zhcc|lem rnlep gnz pfa }noae{ onwaoaep# he` eawaz

    fh{ lp jaae h{ oqkf hrrclkhjca h{ le pfa zahco ng {avqhclp|% Gzno hjnzplne zlmfp{ pn pfa q{a ng

    knepzhkarplne# }noae{ mznqr{ fhwa khorhlmea` gnz pfa zlmfp pn knepznc {avqhclp| he` jn`lc| lepamzlp|%

    Gnz }noae# pfa nec| camlplohpa avrza{{lne ng {avqhclp| fh{ jaae }lpfle fapazn{avqhc ohzzlhma#

    zlml`c| klzkqo{kzlja` j| kh{pa he` knooqelp|% [av gnz rcah{qza fh{ pzh`lplnehcc| jaae phjnn gnz

    }noae# }fn hza avrakpa` pn oazac| {qjolp pn pfa {avqhc hkp pn {hpl{g| pfalz fq{jhe`{ he` rzn`qkakflc`zae# rzagazhjc| h {ne% Ng knqz{a# }fnza{. rzn{plpqpa{. {av }nzdaz{ hza hp pfa npfaz ae` ng pfa

    {khca# pfalz aeplza avl{paeka kne{pzqkpa` hznqe` {av% Rhpzlhzkfhc knepznc ng }noae{ {avqhclp| l{

    zalegnzka` j| ch}{# h{ }acc h{ jlh{a{ ng pfa iq`lklhz|# pn jnc{paz hppaorp{ pn ohlephle pfa qelp ng

    gholc| fn}awaz nrrza{{lwa nz wlncaep lp oh| ja%

    [avqhclp| aeknorh{{a{ h jznh` {rakpzqo ng avrazlaeka{ zachplem pn nqz jn`|# nqz pfnqmfp{#

    nqz aonplne{# nqz zachplne{flr{# nqz rzagazaeka{# he` nqz kfnlka{% Pfq{# {avqhclp| l{ h rhzp ng hcc

    nqz clwa{% Nqz kch{{# kh{pa# zaclmlne# mae`az he` {avqhc nzlaephplne lorhkp pfa }h| le }flkf }a

    avrazlaeka {avqhclp|% Pfa{a gnzka{ `n enp fn}awaz nrazhpa le l{nchplne% Mae`az he` {avqhclp| h{

    }a den} h{ rhzp ng pfa }noae{ onwaoaep ngpae lepazhkp le h }h| pfhp {pzaempfae{ rhpzlhzkf|% Pfa

    chjac ng pfa mnn` }nohe he` pfa jh` }nohe hza nc` pnnc{ ng rhpzlhzkf|% Henpfaz avhorca l{rznwl`a` j| pfa eaka{{lp| ng ohzzlhma% Rhpzlhzkf| aohe`{ pfhp oae he` }noae aepaz lepn ohzzlhma

    he le{plpqplne pfhp fh{ jaae q{a` pn knepznc }noae{ {avqhclp| le nz`az pn h{kazphle pfa l`aeplp|

    ng pfa ghpfaz# {n pfhp pfa rhpzlcleahc on`a ng lefazlpheka ng rzlwhpa rznrazp| khe ja ohlephlea`%

    Pfaza l{ h eaa` en} pn `aarae nqz qe`az{phe`lem hjnqp fn} pfa le{plpqplne ng knorqc{nz|

    fapazn{avqhclp| zachpa{ pn {qkf gnzka{% He` fn} he| avrza{{lne ng {hoa {av `a{lza pfzahpae{

    rhpzlhzkf|% Pfa waz| rn{{ljlclp| ng p}n }noae a{lzlem ahkf npfaz {pzlda{ hp pfa knza ng pfa rhpzlhzkf|%

    Rhpzlhzkf| zaxqlza{ pfhp oae &}fn cnnd# `za{{ he` jafhwa clda oae, he` }noae &}fn cnnd# `za{{

    he` jafhwa clda }noae, inle le ohzzlhma# rznkzahpa he` gnzo h gholc|% He| hcpazehpa avrza{{lne ng

    }noae{ {avqhclp| l{ {aae h{ gcnqplem pfa enzo{ ng }fhp l{ kne{l`aza` pn ja hrrznrzlhpa jafhwlnqz

    gnz h mnn` }nohe% Pfazagnza {avqhc `lwaz{lp| kfhccaema{ pfa fapazn{avqhc enzo he` {fhda{

    pfa waz| gnqe`hplne ng rhpzlhzkf|%

    Ohle{pzaho {nklap| l{ {n pfzahpaea` j| pfa{a hcpazehpa avrza{{lne{ ng {avqhclp| pfhp lp lepae{lgla{

    pfa rza{{qza pn ohzz| ne lp{ |nqem oae he` }noae% Pfl{ fh{ `zlwae ohe| |nqem ca{jlhe{ pn knoolp

    {qlkl`a pn a{khra gzno pfl{ rza{{qza% Gnz le{pheka# le Dazhch }noae gzno rnnz# }nzdlem kch{{

    jhkdmznqe`{ rchephplne }nzdaz{# hmzlkqcpqzhc chjnqzaz{ fhwa za{nzpa` pn pfl{ `zh{plk oah{qza%

    Pfl{ kcahzc| jacla{ pfa o|pf pfhp {hoa {av `a{lza l{ he qrraz kch{{ rfaenoaene%

    ]a hc{n den} pfhp gnzka{ ng zaclmlnq{ gqe`hoaephcl{o hza aarc| pfzahpaea` j| avrza{{lne{

    ng {avqhc lwaz{lp|% He njwlnq{ avhorca }nqc` ja pfa lepncazheka avfljlpa` j| pfa zlmfp }lem pn}hz`{

    0:

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    48/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    6

    pfa onwla Glza% Nz pfa on{p zakaep avhorca rznwl`a` j| pfa Hdhc Phdfp{ Ihpfa`hz Inmle`az [lemf

    }fn lewnda` pfa hzmqoaep{ ng zaclmlne he` pzh`lplne he` {hl` pfhp {hoa {av `a{lza l{ he bhepl/

    fqohe pae`aek|%

    Lp l{ kcahz pfa aoheklrhplne ng }noae kheenp ja eahpc| `lwl`a` lepn pfa zlmfp{ ng

    fapazn{avqhc }noae he` pfa zlmfp{ ng {hoa {av `a{lzlem }noae lekcq`lem ca{jlhe he`

    jl{avqhc }noae% He aemhmaoaep }lpf l{{qa{ ng {avqhc lwaz{lp| khe nec| aarae nqz qe`az{phe`lem

    ng rhpzlhzkf| he` gnzka{ clda gqe`hoaephcl{o% Lp khe hc{n knepzljqpa pn jznh`aelem pfa {knra ng nqz

    lewncwaoaep }lpf l{{qa{ ng {avqhclp|# }flkf fh{ {n ghz jaae clolpa` pn }noae{ zarzn`qkplwa fahcpf.

    zlmfp{%

    Pfa }noae{ onwaoaep le Le`lh fh{ aemhma` ghz onza lepae{ac| }lpf pfa wlncaep h{rakp{ ng

    {av% Hjnqp :1 |ahz{ hmn jamhe pfa khorhlme pn hoae` ch}{ zachplem pn zhra% Pfa }noae{ onwaoaep

    hzplkqchpa` pfa qe`az{phe`lem pfhp {avqhc wlncaeka avl{p{ jakhq{a ng rn}az avazkl{a` j| oae nwaz

    }noae }lpfle pfa rhpzlhzkfhc {nklaphc {pzqkpqza{# }flkf hza gqzpfaz mzh`a` pfznqmf kh{pa# kch{{

    he` zaclmlnq{ `lwl{lne{%

    ]a eaa` pn aemhma en} }lpf l{{qa{ npfaz pfhe `l{kzlolehplne he` wlkplol{hplne pn hc{n phcd

    hjnqp }noae{ rcah{qza% He` faza }a eaa` pn h``za{{ hcc }noae% He h{{qorplne pfhp rcah{qza l{

    h cqvqz| oahep nec| gnz qrraz kch{{ }noae {aao{ pn h{{qoa pfhp {pzqmmca{ zachpa` pn rnwazp|

    ohzmlehcl{a }noae{ zlmfp pn a{lza }fn# }fae he` fn} pfa| }hep% H{ hkplwl{p{ }fn }nzd }lpf rnnz

    }noae zqzhc he` qzjhe }a den} pfhp pfl{ enp pzqa%

    Hcc onwaoaep{ hza {pzaempfaea` j| `zh}lem kneeakplne{ }lpf ahkf npfaz% Pfl{ knepzljqpa{

    pn h fncl{plk qe`az{phe`lem ng `l{kzlolehplne# he` h``{ pn pfa rznka{{ ng `aohe`lem he` hkka{{lem

    zlmfp{% ]a eaa` pn }nzd pnmapfaz }lpf he qe`az{phe`lem ng h oqcplpq`a ng lepazcleda` l{{qa{% Lp hc{n

    ae{qza{ lekcq{lne ng le`lwl`qhc{ he` knooqelpla{ ohzmlehcl{a` awae }lpfle {pzqmmca{ gnz iq{plka%

    ]lpfle pfa ch}# [akplne ;== ng pfa Le`lhe Raehc Kn`a {phpa{ &ng qeehpqzhc nggaeka{, ]fnawaz

    wncqephzlc| fh{ khzehc lepazknqz{a hmhle{p pfa nz`az ng ehpqza }lpf he| ohe# }nohe# nz helohc# {fhcc

    ja rqel{fa`Pfl{ ch}# pfznqmf lp{ `aglelplne# hrrcla{ pn hcc gnzo{ ng ene/rznkzahplwa {av jap}aae

    he| raz{ne{% \ap# lp l{ lepazrzapa` pn hrrc| pn fnon{avqhc jafhwlnqz he` l{ q{a` chzmac| j| ch}

    aegnzkaoaep hqpfnzlpla{ pn fhzh{{ he` kzlolehclya oae aemhmlem le fnon{avqhc jafhwlnqz% Lp ohda{

    lewl{ljca {hoa {av `a{lzlem }noae pfznqmf lp{ ehzzn} `aglelplne ng }fhp kne{plpqpa{ {avqhc

    lepazknqz{a% \ap# lp l{ q{a` j| {nklhc le{plpqplne{ lekcq`lem gholcla{ pn fhzh{{ ca{jlhe }noae he`

    knorac pfao lepn fapazn{avqhc ohzzlhma{%Hp pfl{ iqekpqza# }fae pfa {pzqmmca hmhle{p wlnchplne{ jh{a` ne {avqhc `lwaz{lp| l{ mhlelem

    onoaepqo# pfaza l{ h eaa` gnz hcc onwaoaep{ pn knoa pnmapfaz he` zhl{a pfalz wnlka{% Pfl{ l{

    lornzphep enp iq{p pn ae{qza iq{plka gnz pfn{a }fn hza ohzmlehcl{a` he` kzlolehclya` ne pfa

    jh{l{ ng pfalz {avqhclp|# jqp {qkf he aemhmaoaep }nqc` aehjca HCC ranrca pn avrza{{

    {avqhclp| gzaa gzno wlncaeka he` {plmoh%

    Nwaz pfa ch{p ga} |ahz{# }a fhwa fh` {awazhc hkplwa aemhmaoaep{ }lpf }noae{ mznqr{

    }fn fhwa fac` whz|lem rn{lplne{ ne pfa l{{qa ng {avqhclp| he` {avqhc zlmfp{% Pn`h|# }a }nqc` clda pn

    phda pfl{ aemhmaoaep gqzpfaz% Pn `aarae nqz qe`az{phe`lem{% Pn {pzaempfae nqz {pzqmmca{%

    0;

  • 8/9/2019 Ending Discrimination Against Queer Desire Under Section

    49/51

    Zlmfp{ gnz Hcc

    Hrhzp gzno zhra# {avqhc fhzh{{oaep he` jzl`a jqzelem# wlncaeka hmhle{p }noae fhrrae{ awaz| ploa h }nohel{ ohzzla` hmhle{p faz }lcc% Lp fhrrae{ awaz| ploa h }nohe gaac{ mqlcp| gnz }heplem pn ja fhrr| he` awaz| ploapfhp h }nohe oq{p `la jakhq{a {fa l{ qehkkarphjca pn {nklap|%

    Ca{jlhe {qlkl`a{ hza h za{qcp ng {nklap|{ hppaorp pn za{pzlkp }noae{ kfnlka{ he` knepznc pfalz clwa{%

    ]A RZNPA[P PFA[A @AHPF[H[ WLNCAEKA HMHLE[P HCC ]NOAE

    H{fzh| H`fldhz Hjfl|he# Hkplne Le`lh# Jzahdpfznqmf# KZAH# Fqohe Zlmfp{ Ch} Eap}nzd# Ihmnzl# DZLPLpaho# Elzhephz# Rzl{o# [hfacl# [HEMHP# Wldh{lel# Ch}|az{ Knccakplwa / FLW . HL@[ Qelp he` ]%Z%L%