EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR...

28
EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT NAS- d - 630 Prepared for NATIONAL AERONAUTICS AND SPACE ADMINISTRATION LEWIS RESEARCH CENTER CLEVELAND, OH I O GPO PRICE $ CFSTl PRICE(S) $ Hard copy (HC) <3.. D-0 Microfiche (MF) ,= 1 . M67 14886 I .m e E A (PAGES) a z I-AkR OR TMX OR AD NUMBER) ff 853 July 85 Aerospace Sciences Laboratory Lockheed Palo Alto Research Laboratory LOCKHEED MISSILES & SPACE COMPANY Sunnyvale, California .- (CODE) 22- (CATEGORY) https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=19670005557 2020-01-09T20:49:00+00:00Z

Transcript of EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR...

Page 1: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

EMISSIV ITY COATINGS

SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE

Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965

CONTRACT NAS- d - 630

Prepared f o r NATIONAL AERONAUTICS AND SPACE ADMINISTRATION

LEWIS RESEARCH CENTER CLEVELAND, OHIO

GPO PRICE $

CFSTl PRICE(S) $

Hard copy (HC) <3.. D-0

Microfiche (MF) ,=

1 .

M67 14886 I

. m

e E A (PAGES) a z

I-AkR OR TMX OR AD NUMBER)

ff 853 July 85

Aerospace Sciences Laboratory Lockheed Palo Alto R e s e a r c h Laboratory LOCKHEED MISSILES & SPACE COMPANY

Sunnyvale, Cal i forn ia

.-

(CODE)

22- (CATEGORY)

https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=19670005557 2020-01-09T20:49:00+00:00Z

Page 2: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

EMISSIV ITY COATINGS

SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW-TEMPERATURE

Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 December 1965

CONTRACT NAS-3-7630

Prepared for NATIONAL AERONAUTICS AND SPACE ADMINISTRATION

LEWIS RESEARCH CENTER CLEVELAND, OHIO

P r e p a r e d by: Approved by: F . 1. S m i t h and 1. 6. Grammer Sr . T h e r m o d y n a m i c s Engineers P r o j e c t l e a d e r

6 . R . Cunnington

Aerospace Sciences Laboratory Lockheed P a l o Alto Research l a b o r a t o r y LOCKHEED MISSILES & SPACE COMPANY

Sunnyvale, Cal i fornia

Page 3: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

FORE WORD

The results of the research activities carried out during the second

quarterly period (1 October through 31 December 1965) of Contract

NAS 3-7630. entitled Emissivitv Coatinns for Low-Temtxrature

Space Radiators, a r e reported in this document. This work is being

done by Lockheed Missiles & Space Company for the Lewis Research

Center of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration.

ii

Page 4: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

B - I' I I 1 I I I I 1 I I I I 1 t I I

CONTENTS

Section

FOREWORD

ILLUSTRATIONS AND TABLES

1 INTRODUCTION AND SUMMARY

2 LITERATURE SURVEY

3 EXPERIMENTAL APPARATUS

3.1 Description of Apparatus

3 . 2 Results of Initial Operation

4 PROPERTIES O F CANDIDATE COATINGS

4.1 Description of Coatings

4 . 2 Initial Optical Properties

5 REFERENCES

Page

ii

iv

1

2

4 4

4

13

13

16

23

iii

Page 5: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

ILLUSTRATIONS

Figure

3 -1

3-2

3 -3

3 -4

3-5

3-6

4-1

4-2

4-3

Total Irradiance of Lamp Unit

Filter Transmissions

Irradiance for Band Energy From 0.22 to 0 . 4 3 j i of Lamp Unit

Irradiance as a Function of Source Distance

Transverse Energy Distribution of Lamp Beam

Relative Spectral Distribution of Lamp Energy to 0 . 5 5 1.1 at

Power Inputs of 675 and 900 W

Typical Spectral Reflectance of TiOZ/Silicone Coating

Typical Spectral Reflectance of ZrSi04/K2Si04 Coating

Typical Spectral Reflectance of A1Si04/K2Si04

TABLE

4-1 Initial Room Temperature Optical Properties

iv

Page

7

8

9

1 0

11

1 2

18

19

20

17

Page 6: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

Section 1

INTRODUCTION AND SUMMARY

The major objective of this program is the evaluation of candidate coatings for low-

temperature spacecraft radiators having long operational lifetimes. The surfaces

must show a high total hemispherical emittance at operating temperature with a low

absorptance to energy in the solar spectrum; the latter is important because of the

low operating temperature level of some radiators , 530°K or less. The stability of

the radiative properties of the coating in the space environment is a critical factor

as changes in either absorptance or emittance during the mission would result in

severe problems with the operating power system. Since little is presently known

about the long-term behavior of coatings considered for use on these low-temperature

radiators, a program was established to evaluate both organic and inorganic coatings.

The object of the initial program was the evaluation of the properties and stability of

candidate coatings under conditions of exposure to ultraviolet radiation, vacuum , elevated temperatures, and temperature cycling. During the first phase of the pro-

gram, candidate materials will be exposed simultaneously to ultraviolet radiation at -7 a 1-sun level, maximum operating temperature, and vacuum of 10

500-hr periods. The second phase of the program will be the exposure of tvro materials

selected on the basis of the results of the initial phase for 5,000 hr.

~ _*'

Torr or less for

The tasks undertaken during the second quarterly period and the accomplishment

under each were a s follows:

0 The literature survey to provide up-to-date information on the coatings as

well as provide data for the selection of a sixth coating was continued.

0 The exposure apparatus was checked, and initial calibration data were

obtained.

0 Al l test specimens of three of the five coating systems were received,

and pretest optical property measurements were made.

Detailed discussions of the activities for this quarter a r e presented in the following

sections, 1

Page 7: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

Section 2

LITERATURE SURVEY

During the period covered by this report several major findings have been reported

which bear directly upon the objectives of this program. Under a NASA-Marshall

Space Flight Center contract (NAS-8-11266) LMSC has investigated solar radiation-

induced damage to the optical properties of zinc oxide (Ref. 1 ) . That program

succeeded in demonstrating that the damage mechanism for ZnO pigments was based

on a photochemical evaluation of oxygen. Furthermore, on the basis of the first

reported in situ measurements of u-v radiation damage in vacuum, it was conclusively

demonstrated that u-v degraded zinc oxide rapidly recovered its initial optical properties

upon re-exposure to air.

.

Further in situ measurements on zinc oxide and titanium dioxide pigmented silicone

paints, along with a detailed description of the LMSC in situ bidirectional reflectance

apparatus was reported (Ref. 2) at the AIAA Thermophysics Specialists Conference,

Monterey , Calif; September 1965. That report specifically indicated that white pig-

mented silicone thermal control paints exhibit the same damage and recovery

phenomena as the free pigments.

A t the same meeting, preliminary results from the Ames emissivity experiment on

OSO-I1 were reported (Ref. 3) . These results are of imme6iate interest since four

of the coatings flown were identical to those being examined under this program (tita- nium dioxide/silicone), zinc oxide/silicone, zinc oxide/potassium silicate, and zirco-

nium silicate/potassium silicate). The results for the zinc oxide and titanium dioxide

pigmented silicones were in substantial agreement with the laboratory in situ results. However, gross disagreement was observed between the flight data and conventional

pre- and post-test measurements. On the other hand, the inorganic coatings appeared

to be more stable than pre- and post-test laboratory measurements indicated.

.

2

Page 8: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

The results of the in situ measurements coupled with the flight data lead to the

incontestable conclusion that all prior u-v radiation test data based on pre- and

post-test measurements of optical properties performed in a i r must be critically

re-examined. For this reason, considerable data of this nature which have been

published during the period of this report have not been included.

Page 9: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

I’ f 1 I E CI t It E E b 8

8

Section 3

EXPERIMENTAL APPARATUS

3 . 1 DESCRIPTION OF APPARATUS

The complete experimental apparatus which was described in detail in Ref. 4 remains

unchanged except for the modification of the,xenon source optics. The u-v source is

a 900-W Hanovia xenon lamp, Model 538-CL, that is mounted in an Orion Optics Corp . ,

universal lamp housing, Model (2-60-50-5-15. This lamp housing used a 2-in. focal

length, 1 .5 in. diameter quartz condensing lens a s a collector. The energy collected

by the lens is augmented by the use of a spherical mirror placed behind the lamp to

re-image the arc back on itself. In the process of relative spectral calibration of the

xenon source, a difficulty arose when the bright spot near the cathode was used as a

source to obtain a uniform approximately collimated beam. It became evident that

the percentage of energy in the u-v region increased a s the image distance increased.

With the lens set so that a nearly uniform intensity was produced over an area 2-in.

in diameter at a distance of 15 in. f rom the lamp housing (approximately the distance

to the sample) the percentage of energy in the u-v band was 25% of the total energy,

not the desired 11.8%. This change was related to the difference in focal length of

the quartz lens for the ultraviolet and near infrared. The effect of this chromatic

aberration may be reduced by using a longer focal length lens.

equipment lens has been replaced with a quartz 4.5-in. focal length lens of the same

diameter. Satisfactory results have been obtained with the updated optical system.

The original

3 . 2 RESULTS OF INITIAL OPERATIONS

The initial operation of the exposure apparatus commenced with a bake-out of the

chambers at approximately 250°F using sorption pumps to remove the initial gas

load. After bake-out, pumping with the electronic pumps was satisfactory.

4

Page 10: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

A pressure of

After approximately one week of operation, errat ic pump performance was observed.

The problem was traced to a badly contaminated high voltage feedthrough in the elec-

tronic pump which resulted in a high leakage current that inhibited proper pumping.

The contaminated parts were cleaned and the pumps restarted. Satisfactory operation

was achieved for a short time, but subsequent inspection of the feedthrough indicated

the contamination was again present. The pump manufacturer stated this contamina-

Torr was obtained without the liquid nitrogen cold wall being filled.

tion was the result of a faulty plating process during manufacturing. The manufacturer

provided new parts for the pump at no cost.

Calibration of the u-v source was completed utilizing the modified optical system.

The irradiance of the lamp unit was measured in air at a distance of 1 5 . 5 in. from the

front of the lens holder of the lamp unit. The irradiance was measured a s a function

of input power. The detector was a calibrated Epply thermopile and its output was

measured by a Kiethley voltmeter.

Figure 3-1 shows the measured irradiance of the lamp unit at a distance of 1 5 . 5 in.

(the distance of the sample in the chambers from the front of the lens holder) in air. These values include the transmission of the chamber special window.

of the lamp unit in the u-v transmission band of the Corning 7-54 filter was also

measured in air. A calibrated Epply thermopile was used as a detector. The u-v

irradiance in the transmission band was measured by measuring the transmission

of the 7-54 for the source energy and then measuring the transmission of a combination

7-54 and 3-72 filter for the source.

shown in Fig. 3-2. The energy in the 0 .22 to 0 . 4 3 band is calculated after correcting

for the transmission of the 7-54 band and the 3-72 filter. unit at the sample distance in the wavelength band 0 . 2 2 to 0 . 4 3 p is shown in Fig. 3-3.

A 617-W input is required for the lamp for its operating level to provide the u-v energy

output to match the solar radiance in the 0 . 2 to 0.4 p wavelength region. The irradi-

ance of the beam as a function of distance from the lamp unit around the sample position

is shown in Fig. 3-4. A traverse across the beam at the sample position is shown in

Fig. 3-5.

The irradiance

The spectral transmission of these filters are

The irradiance of the lamp

5

Page 11: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

The relative spectral irradiance of the lamp unit, Fig. 3-6, was measured with a

calibrated radiometer consisting of a monochromator and a photomultiplier detector.

A MgO reflectance plate was used to provide uniform illumination of the entrance

slit of the monochromator. The monochromator and detector unit was calibrated

by comparison with the irradiance of a tungsten standard lamp which was calibrated

by NBS.

6

Page 12: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

S W M 'U3MOd Cr3I'IddV

7

Page 13: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

B

8

I I I I

I I I I I I I I I co CD * c.l 00

rl d d d d NOISSIWSNV?€L

8

co d

(D

0

0

c.l

Page 14: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

\ d

I I I I

S W M ‘U3MOd a 3 I q d d V

9

Page 15: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

I I I I I I I I I 1

N 8 N

d d d d d d

m3/SwM '33NvIavxm 2

10

Q) 0 k =r 0 m

Q, 0 c cd 3 k k

I+

Page 16: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

0 v)

d 0 * d

0 M

d 0 0 c\1 PI

d d 0

11

Page 17: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

1' 8 8 I I

I

B 1 8

8 1

I I I I I I 1 I I I I I o o o w C \ I O o o W * c . 1 8 : c . 1 d 4 3 4 4

XLISN3;CNI 3AILV'I3?3

0 W

d

W In

d

c.1 In

d

oo * 0

* d

0 w 0

W m 0

N m d

m N

d

dl N

s

3 5l

d

W I

m

12

Page 18: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

I’ I ’ 8 8 8 I 8 I 1 8 8 1 8 8 8 1 I 1 8

Section 4

PROPERTIES OF CANDIDATE COATING

4 .1 DESCRIPTION OF COATINGS

Test specimens of three candidate coatings have been received during the report

period. The specimens on hand are the Hughes Aircraft Co., A1-SiO4/K2SiO4, .

the LMSC Ti02/silicone, and the LMSC ZrSi04/K2Si04 coatings. These coatings

a r e described in detail below. The initial optical properties a re also presented.

4 .1 .1 Thermatrol -A100 (Ti02/silicone)

Source and Cost - Lockheed Missiles & Space Company; price variable depending on

quantity; nominal price is $60 per gallon.

Starting Composition - Polymethyl-vinyl siloxane elastomer plus T i 0 pigment, 1:1 by weight.

2

0 Vehicle: Dow-Corning proprietary, Q92-009, 33% non-volatile content by

weight, 24 hr a t 70°C

Flash Point 60 to 65°F

Viscosity, cps 15 ,000

Specific Gravity 0 . 8 3 5

Diluted with VM and p NaPtha

0 Pigment: Titanox RA-NC, Titanium Pigment Corp., proprietary; calcined

rutile T i 0 93% Ti02. 2’

Particle Shape and Size - The weighted average particle size is 0 . 3 p . The particles

are spherical.

13

Page 19: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

8 - 8 ’ 8 I I I 8 I 8 8 I 8 1 I I 8 8 8

Substrate - 1-in. diameter disc, 0,050 in. thick of 6061 T-6 aluminum machined to a 30 r m s finish.

Method of Application - The finish is applied by spray techniques conforming to

MIL-F-18264 specifications. Prior to applying the top coat, the entire surface is

primed with one coat of silicone primer, Dow Corning Corp. A-4094 or equivalent,

to a thickness of approximately 0.2 mils.

prior to application of top coats. Thickness and cure times for the top coat a r e

as follows:

The primer is air cured 30 min minimum

Total dry film thickness, including primer, 3 . 5 to 5 . 0 mils

Curing time; 24 hr minimum after final coat

Coating Thickness - 3 . 5 to 5 . 0 mils.

3 Density - 1 . 5 gm/cm

Weight Loss During Vacuum Testing - Negligible after coating has been fully cured.

Final Composition - Specific gravity after curing (7 days at 150°F and 50% RH);

non-pigmented 1 . 1 5 ; pigmented 1 . 5 0 .

4.1 .2 LP 10A (ZrSi04/K2Si04)

Source and Cost - Lockheed Missiles & Space Company; price variable depending on

quantity; nominal price $740 per gallon.

Starting Composition -

0 Pigment to binder ratio: 3 . 5 to 1 by weight

0 Pigment: Metals and Thermit Corp, lOOOW grade, llUltroxll

zirconium silicate, acid leached and calcined by LMSC

0 Binder : potassium silicate

14

Page 20: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

8 8 8 I I I 8 8 8 1 8 8 I I 8 I 1

Particle Shape and Size - Particle shape, angular; particle size, < 1 . 0 p.

Substrate - l-in. diameter disc, 0.0050 in. thick of 6061 T-6 aluminum machined

to a 30 r m s finish.

Method of Application - Standard spray gun techniques, base coat reacts with substrate

and serves as primer; room temperature cure, approximately 12 hr.

Coating Thickness - 3 . 0 to 5. 0 mils.

3 Density - 4.0 gm/cm

Weight Loss During Vacuum Testing - Less than 5. Ocr,.

Final Composition - Zirconium silicate-potassium silicate composite (exact chemical

composition not known).

4 .1 .3 Hughes Inorganic White Coating (A1-Si04/K2SiOq)

Source and Cost - Hughes Aircraft Co. ; cost figures not stated by supplier.

Starting Composition -

0 Pigment to binder ratio: 4.4 to 1 by weight

0 Pigment: A naturally occurring china clay primarily aluminum

silicate; approximately 3.0% impurity level, namely Fe-0. 70%

Ti 0.42%, Ca 0.05%, Mg-l.28%, Na-O.47% andK-O.ll%; the clay

is calcined at 1275"C, then ball milled for 12 hr with water.

0 Binder: Sylvania PS-7 electronic grade potassium silicate

Particle Shape and Size - Particle size following milling less than 200 mesh; particle

shape is typical of a china clay.

15

Page 21: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

I' 8' 8 I 8 I 1 8 8 I 8 8 8 8 I I I I I

Substrate - 1 in. diameter disc, 0 .050 in. thick of 6061 T-6 aluminum machined to 30 rms finish.

Method of Application - The coating is applied in three coats, each coat being baked

for 1 hr at 225°F and the final coating baked for 1 hr at 260°F. An air brush is used

for painting,

Coating Thickness - 6.0 to 8.0 mils after curing.

Weight Loss During Vacuum Testing - The procedure is covered by Hughes Materials

and Process Specification, HMS 15-1374 and H P 4-135. A typical weight loss is

0.02% when exposed to vacuum at 250°F; the weight loss is water vapor.

Final Composition - Not known.

4 . 2 INITIAL OPTICAL PROPERTIES

The initial optical properties, the solar absorptance (a , ) and the infrared emittance

( E ) ~ have been determined and are tabulated in Table 4-1. Typical spectrum reflect-

ance curves for each of the coatings are presented in Figs. 4-1 through 4-3 . Data

obtained by use of the Cary spectrophotometer and the Gier-Dunkle intergrating

sphere a r e presented for comparison. The emittance values reported were obtained

by use of the Lion Research Corp. Optical Surface Comparator described in Ref. 4.

S

The solar absorptance of test samples was determined by two separate procedures.

The first method was by measurement of the spectral reflectance on a Cary Model 14

spectrophotometer with an integrating sphere attachment. This instrument has been

described previously (Ref. 4). the Johnson (Ref. 5) curve to obtain solar reflectance from which the solar absorptance

is inferred from Kirchoff's law.

The resulting spectral data a r e then integrated against

16

Page 22: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

I' 8 ' 8 I I I 1 8 I I I 8 8 8 I 8 1 8 1

Sample

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

1 2

13

14

15

16

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Table 4-1

INITIAL ROOM TEMPERATURE OPTICAL PROPERTIES

Source Coating

LMSC

LMSC

LMSC

LMSC

LMSC

LMSC

LMSC

LMSC

LMSC

LMSC

LMSC

LMSC

LMSC

LMSC

LMSC

LMSC

Hughes

Hughes

Hughes

Hughes

Hughes

Hughes Hughes

Hughes

Ti02/sil icone

Ti02/silic one

Ti 0 2 /silicone

TiO2/silicone

T i O ~ / s i l i c o n e

Ti02/s i l icone

Ti02/s i l icone

Ti02/s i l icone

ZrSiOq/K2SiO4

ZrSi04/K2Si04

ZrSi04/K2Si04

ZrSi04/K2Si04

ZrSi04/K2Si04

Z r Si04 /K2 Si04

ZrSi04/K2Si04

Z r Si04/K2 Si04

A L -Si04 /K2 Si 0 4

AL-Si04/K~Si04

A L-Si 0 4 /K2Si04

A L -Si 04/K2 Si 0 4

AL-Si04/K2Si04

A L -Si 0 4 /K2 Si O4 A L -Si 0 4 / K2 Si O4

AL-Si04/K2Si04

Solar Absorptance

Gary Gier -Dunkle

0 .15 f 0 . 0 2

0 .15 f 0 . 0 2

0 .15 f 0 . 0 2

0 .17 f 0 . 0 1

0.16 f 0 . 0 1

0.18 f 0 . 0 2 ( 4 0.19 f 0 . 0 1

0 . 1 5 f 0 . 0 2

0 . 1 5 f 0.02

0 . 1 5 f 0 . 0 2

0 .15 f 0 . 0 2

0 . 1 1 f 0 . 0 2

0 . 1 1 f 0 . 0 2

0 . 1 4 f 0.02

0 . 1 1 f 0 . 0 2

0 . 1 3 f 0 . 0 2

0 . 1 1 It 0 . 0 2

0.14 f 0 . 0 2

0.10 f 0.02

0.14 f 0 . 0 2

0.14 f 0 . 0 2

0.14 -f 0 . 0 2

0 .14 f 0 . 0 2

0.14 f 0 . 0 2

0 . 1 4 f 0 . 0 2

0.14 f 0 . 0 2 0.13 f 0 . 0 2

(a) Coating not of proper thickness (< 5 mi l ) .

17

0.11 f 0.01

0 .15 f 0 . 0 1

0 . 1 1 f 0 . 0 1

0 .14 f 0 . 0 1

0 . 1 4 f 0 . 0 1

Emit tance

(Optical Surface Comparator)

0 .88 i 0 .03

0.82 f 0 . 0 3

0 .91 f 0 .03

0.85 f 0 . 0 3

0 .85 f 0 . 0 3

0.85 f 0.03

0 .87 & 0.03

0.86 f 0 . 0 3

0 .91 f 0 .03

0 . 8 7 & 0 . 0 3

0.90 f 0 . 0 3

0 . 9 0 f 0.03

0 . 9 1 f 0.03

0.90 f 0.03

0.90 f 0 . 0 3

0 .90 f 0 . 0 3

0.90 f 0 . 0 3

0 .88 f 0.03

0.90 f 0 . 0 3

0.90 f 0.03

0.89 f 0 . 0 3

0 .88 f 0 . 0 3

0.90 f 0 . 0 3 0 . 9 0 f 0 . 0 3

Page 23: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

I' 8' 8 8 8 I 1 B I I B 1 8

I 8 i 8 1

m

0

m'

00

si

W hl

* oi

hl

hi

0

hl

00

l-i

W l-i

dc 4

@J

l-i

0

Fi

00

d

W d

* d

hl

o d

/ /

W

0 00 W dc CJ

l-i d d 'd d 33NVIL3316 38 TV8IL3 3dS

18

M El cd 0 u a, El 0 0

m

.r( c,

.rl 4 .r(

'N

2 F-l u 0 a, 0

9

2

c, 0 a, G1

4 cd k 0 a, a m cd 0 a

*

4

.d

e l-i I * M G

Page 24: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

I' 8 - 8 8 8 8 I 8 I I I 1 I I 1 8 8 I I

I I I I I I

I /

/ /

/ //

33NVL331J38 1V8L33dS

19

0 0

bo c cd 0 u .+ 42

4 cd k 0 a, a v1

42

hl I TF

M i;z

Page 25: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

1- 1 I 1 B I I I I I I I D I I 1 I I

0

rl

I

I I

I I I I I I

CD * 00

d 0 0

3 3NVL 3 316 3H 1V8L3 3dS

20

0

M

4 cd 0 .d

E M

I * bn iz

Page 26: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

. The Cary sphere is small and has relatively large apertures for entrance and exit of

sample, reference, and sphere illumination beams. The sphere is illuminated by

external optics and the reflected sample energy is directed to the entrance slits of the

monochromator. Because of large apertures, a bright spot from the illuminating

beam, and the small sphere size, it is obvious that the instrument has significant

sources of e r ro r . The absolute magnitude of e r ro r is considerably reduced by

establishing operational procedures which circumvent the major difficulties. Normal

operations in this laboratory calls for calibration of the system against a known first

surface aluminum mirror . This is done by setting reflectance values at each wave-

length to correspond to the known mirror properties. Unknown samples a r e then run,

and the reading is obtained in absolute reflectance units. This procedure minimizes

but does not eliminate effects of the apertures and bright spot. The data obtained a re

relative in the sense that the instrument is initially calibrated against a known surface.

Therefore, continuous checks must be made to assure the validity of the values used

for the calibration. The instrument is used a s a control for large numbers of samples

since it is easily operated, is fast, and within limits has reasonable accuracy. Where

changes in spectrum or comparisons among identical samples a re desired it is a highly

useful laboratory tool.

In view of the relative nature of Cary results it is also necessary to obtain a limited

number of absolute measurements to verify the Cary spectrum. These measurements

are performed on a single beam Gier-Dunkle integrating sphere attached to a Perkin-

Elmer, Model 98 monochromator. This sphere is much larger than the Cary (9.5 in.

diameter), has only two small apertures (entrance port 1 in. diameter , detector area

N 1-in. diameter), and does not suffer from direct sample illumination of the detector.

The sample is centrally mounted in the sphere and may be rotated at angles from 0 to

90 deg relative to the entrance port. When the sample is normal to the port its shape

factor to the hole is approximately 0.011. This construction permits direct measure-

ments of the absolute reflectance of test samples and also permits cross checks which

verify the validity of data obtained.

Page 27: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

In normal operation a 1-in. disc sample is mounted on the sample holder and rotated

10 deg off axis from the entry port. Monochromatic energy is then directed alternatively

to the sphere wall and then to the sample. Detector response is rated for each beam

position with the ratio of response being directly the absolute reflectance of the Sam-

ple. This procedure is repeated for each required wavelength throughout the spectral

region 0 , 2 7 5 to 2 .75 p . The data are then integrated against the Johnson curve to

obtain the solar absorptance.

Thc Crier-Dunkle instrument has an inherent accuracy of 1% in determination of spectral

reflectance and can be cross checked to assure that operation is producing this precision.

Sample rotation may also be used to determine the extent of entry port losses so corrections can be applied for this effect. However, because of its manual operation

the measurements a re time consuming and must be accomplished bb highly skilled

personnel, Therefore, only a limited number of such determinations a r e made on

test samples.

m e n initial measurements a re made using the Gier-Dunkle sphere and the results

used to calibrate Cary measurements on identical samples, it is possible to obtain

accuracies of f 2% in reflectance. This procedure is often used where large numbers

of identical surfaces must be measured.

2 2

Page 28: EMISSIVITY COATINGS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE - NASA · EMISSIVITY COATINGS SPACE RADIATORS FOR LOW=TEMPERATURE Quarterly Progress Report No. 2 For Quarter Ending 31 Dec mber 1965 CONTRACT

I 1. I I I 1 I I R 1 1 I I I I i I I I

Section 5

REFERENCES

1. "Solar Radiation-Induced Damage to the Optical Properties of ZnO-Type Pigments,

(NAS 8-11266), LMSC M-50-65-2, September 1965

2. H. F. MacMillan, Jr. , A . F. Sklevsky, and L. A . McKellar, "In Situ Bidirectional

Reflectance Apparatus,

Monterey, Calif., September 1965

presented at AIAA Thermophysics Specialists Conference,

3 . B. P. Pearson, Jr . , "Preliminary Results From the Ames Emissivity Experiment

on OSO-II, presented at A N A Thermophysics Specialists Conference, Monterey,

Calif. , September 1965

4. F. J. Smith, "Emissivity Coatings for Low-Temperature Space Radiators-Progress

Report No. 1, LMSC, L-23-65-1, Lockheed Missiles & Space Company, Sunnyvale,

Calif ,

5. F. S. Johnson, ed. , Satellite Environment Handbook, Stanford University Press,

1961

23