Elusive Subjects Revised April 06

8/9/2019 Elusive Subjects Revised April 06

1/27

Open Research OnlineThe Open University’s repository of research publicationsand other research outputs

The elusive subjects of neo-liberalism

Journal Article

How to cite:

Barnett, Clive; Clarke, Nick; Cloke, Paul and Malpass, Alice (2008). The elusive subjects of neo-liberalism.Cultural Studies, 22(5), pp. 624–653.

For guidance on citations see FAQs.

c [not recorded]

Version: [not recorded]

Link(s) to article on publisher’s website:http://dx.doi.org/doi:10.1080/09502380802245902

Copyright and Moral Rights for the articles on this site are retained by the individual authors and/or other copy-right owners. For more information on Open Research Online’s data policy on reuse of materials please consultthe policies page.

oro.open.ac.uk

http://oro.open.ac.uk/help/helpfaq.htmlhttp://oro.open.ac.uk/help/helpfaq.html#Unrecorded_information_on_coversheethttp://oro.open.ac.uk/help/helpfaq.html#Unrecorded_information_on_coversheethttp://dx.doi.org/doi:10.1080/09502380802245902http://oro.open.ac.uk/policies.htmlhttp://oro.open.ac.uk/policies.htmlhttp://dx.doi.org/doi:10.1080/09502380802245902http://oro.open.ac.uk/help/helpfaq.html#Unrecorded_information_on_coversheethttp://oro.open.ac.uk/help/helpfaq.html#Unrecorded_information_on_coversheethttp://oro.open.ac.uk/help/helpfaq.html


2/27

"

!"# #%&'()# '&*+#,-' ./ 0#.%(*#12%('345#6.07 -"# 202%6-(,' ./ 8.)#103#0-2%(-6

"#$%& '()*&++, -$./ "#()/&, 0(1# "#2/&, 3#$.& 4(#5(66

377)&66 82) .2))&652*7&*.&9"#$%& '()*&++

:(.1#+; 28


3/27

#

!"# #%&'()# '&*+#,-' ./ 0#.%(*#12%('345#6.07 -"# 202%6-(,' ./ 8.)#103#0-2%(-6

95:!;9

&)-52(7'*$3( '0+ %((@ *- $0*()6(0( $0 %&(/$4$(+ ')('% -4 %-/$'2 2$4( %((7% .-)*# &1)%1$0,9A- *-- +-(% *#( 0-*$-0 -4 6')$-1% 7-+(% -4 (*#$/'2 &)-52(7'*$%'*$-0 *#)-1,# .#$/#

&(-&2( /-7( *- *'@( *#($) -.0 '/*$6$*$(% '% )(B1$)$0, 7-)'2 )(42(/*$-09 :0 0($*#() /'%(;#-.(6(); /'0 *#( '0'28*$/% -4 ,-6()07(0*'2$*8 &)-6$+( ' /-#()(0* *#(-)(*$/'2 '//-10* -4

#-. &-2$*$/'2 &)-/(%%(% -4 )12( '0+ '+7$0$%*)'*$-0 .-)@; -) $0+((+ -4 #-. *#(8 /-00(/*

1& .$*# /12*1)'2 &)-/(%%(% -4 %(24C4-)7'*$-0 '0+ %15D(/*$6$*89

"#$%&'()E

F-6()07(0*'2$*8; G-0%17&*$-0; H(-2$5()'2$%7; A15D(/*$6$*8; I*#$/'2 J)-52(7'*$%'*$-0


4/27

$

=>? @#.%(*#12% '&*+#,-'A:0 )(/(0* )(%(')/# $0 *#( /12*1)'2 %*1+$(% '0+ *#( %-/$'2 %/$(0/(%; *#()( #'% 5((0 ' %#$4*

*-.')+% 1%$0, $'0 *#(-)$(%

-4 0(-2$5()'2 ,-6()0'0/(9 "#$% 7-6( $% ' )(%&-0%( *- ' %&(/$4$/ /-0/(&*1'2 '0+ (7&$)$/'2

&)-52(7 *#'* #'10*% K')>$'0 *#(-)$3'*$-0% -4 0(-2$5()'2$%7 '0+ 0(-2$5()'2$3'*$-09 L0 *#(-0( #'0+; 0(-2$5()'2$%7 $% '&&')(0*28 ' /-#()(0*; &1)&-%$6( &)-,)'77( -4 %-/$-C

(/-0-7$/ '0+ &-2$*$/'2 *)'0%4-)7'*$-0 M(9,9 N')6(8 OPPQR9 L0 *#( -*#() #'0+; *#( 0-*$-0

-4 ' #(,(7-0$/ &)-,)'77( ,(0()'*(% *#( B1(%*$-0 -4 #-. *-&C+-.0 $0$*$'*$6(% *-

S0(-2$5()'2$3(T (/-0-7$(%; $0%*$*1*$-0%; -) %&'/(% '/*1'228 .-)@ -1* $0 &)'/*$/(9 "#$% $%

.#()( 0-*$-0% -4 ,-6()07(0*'2$*8 /-7( $0 #'0+8; .$*# *#($) 4-/1% -0 *#( &-2$*$/'2

)'*$-0'2$*$(% .#$/# *)8 *- %#'&( *#( /-0+1/* -4 $0+$6$+1'2% '0+ &-&12'*$-0% *- *#($) -.0 &1)&-%(%9 "#( /-06(),(0/( 5(*.((0 *#( K')>$'0 0'))'*$6( -4 0(-2$5()'2$%7 '0+

$%*(0/( 6')$-1% 4-)7% -4 0(-2$5()'2 %15D(/*9

$(% 4-) &)-/(%%(% -4 %15D(/*C4-)7'*$-09 "#(%( *.-7(*#-+C(44(/*% +(4$0( ' /-0/(&*1'2 %&'/( /#')'/*()$3(+ 58 ' %#')(+ $4 10'/@0-.2(+,(+

410/*$-0'2$%79 A((0 4)-7 *#( &()%&(/*$6( -4 ,-6()07(0*'2$*8 MV')0() OPPPR;

0(-2$5()'2$%7 $% 0-. )-1*$0(28 &)(%(0*(+ '% ' ?+$%/-1)%(? *#'* /-0%*$*1*(% &)'/*$/(%;

$0%*$*1*$-0% '0+ $+(0*$*$(%9 K'/)-C&)-/(%%(% -4 0(-2$5()'2 ,-6()0'0/( ')( &)(%17(+ *- 5(

7(+$'*(+ *#)-1,# 7$/)-C&)-/(%%(% -4 /'2/12'*$-0; )(,12'*$-0; '0+ %15D(/*$4$/'*$-0 $0 '


5/27

%

4-)712' *#'* 5(')% '0 10/'008 )(%(752'0/( *- ]2*#1%%()$'0 '//-10*% -4 $+(-2-,$/'2

$0*()&(22'*$-09

=( .'0* *- B1(%*$-0 .#(*#() 0(-2$5()'2$%7 $% ' /-#()(0*; '+-$%$"21 &)-,)'77( -4 )12(X

'0+ .#(*#() $* +-(% '$7 *- (>*(0+ $*%(24 58 5)$0,$0, $0*- (>$%*(0/( 41228C4-)7(+0(-2$5()'2 %15D(/*%9 =( &1)%1( *#$% 2$0( -4 B1(%*$-0$0, 58 '%@$0, %-7( B1(%*$-0% '5-1*

*#( /-0*(7&-)')8 &-2$*$/% -4 /-0%17&*$-0 '0+ /-0%17()$%79 =( .$22 42(%# -1* *#(

'),17(0* *#'* 58 ()'%$0, 4)-7 6$(. .#'* A'8() MOPPQ; QC^OR /'22% ?2'8 0-)7'*$6$*8?; *#(

? !"# 1#'C.0'(*(%(D2-(.0 ./ -"# ,.0'&3#1 L0( -4


6/27

&

a"#(%( 41%( *#( '$7 -4 7'014'/*1)()% *- %(22 &)-+1/*% '0+ $0/)('%( 7')@(* %#')(

.$*# *#( $+(0*$*8 (>&()$7(0*% -4 /-0%17()%9 "#(8 ')( 7(+$'*(+ 58 #$,#28

+(6(2-&(+ *(/#0$B1(% -4 7')@(* )(%(')/# '0+ 4$0(28 /'2$5)'*(+ '**(7&*% *- %(,7(0*

'0+ *'),(* %&(/$4$/ /-0%17() 7')@(*%9 ]+6()*$%$0, $7',(% '0+ *(2(6$%$-0

&)-,)'77(% $0*()&(0(*)'*( $0 *#( &)-712,'*$-0 -4 $7',(% -4 2$4(%*82(; 0'))'*$6(%-4 $+(0*$*8 /#-$/( '0+ *#( #$,#2$,#*$0, -4 *#( (*#$/'2 '%&(/*% -4 '+-&*$0, -0( -)

-*#() .'8 -4 /-0+1/*$0, -0(?% 2$4(a M$5$+; ^cdR9

]0+ '22 *#$% '7-10*% *- ' a0(. #'5$*'* -4 %15D(/*$4$/'*$-0a; -0( /#')'/*()$3(+ 58 a*#(

5(2$(4 *#'* $0+$6$+1'2% /'0 %#'&( '0 '1*-0-7-1% $+(0*$*8 4-) *#(7%(26(% *#)-1,# /#-$/(%

$0 *'%*(; 71%$/; ,--+%; %*82(% '0+ #'5$*%a M$5$+9R9

Z-%(?% '//-10* -4 '+6'0/(+ 2$5()'2$%7%? %1*1)$0, *-,(*#() -4 /$*$3(0 '0+ /-0%17() $7&2$(%

' %#$4* *-.')+% ' 7-)( ?(*#$/'2? 7-+( -4 /$*$3(0%#$& &)'/*$/( '0+ $+(0*$*8C4-)7'*$-09

?I*#$/'2? #()( )(4()% *- *#( '/*$6( %#'&$0, -4 2$6(% $0 )(2'*$-0 *- $0+$6$+1'2%? -.0 %(0%( -4

4124$227(0*; )'*#() *#'0 58 )(4()(0/( *- 7-+(2% -4 /$*$3(0%#$& $0 .#$/# -52$,'*$-0 '0+ &)(%/)$&*$-0 ')( *#( +-7$0'0* )(,$%*()% -4 %15D(/*C4-)7'*$-09 :0 %- 4') '% *#()( $% '

/-0*(7&-)')8 *)(0+ 4-) *#( &-2$*$/% -4 &"*12+!%$"* *- 5( ')*$/12'*(+ *#)-1,# 6')$-1%7-+(% -4 a(*#$/'2 &)-52(7'*$%'*$-0a; .#()(58 &(-&2( ')( (>&(/*(+ *- *)('* *#($) /-0+1/*

'% &"*12+)31 '% %15D(/* *- '22 %-)*% -4 7-)'2 $0D10/*$-0%; *#(0 Z-%(?% '//-10* -&(0% 1& '

&-*(0*$'228 /)('*$6( ',(0+' 4-) )(%(')/# -0 /$*$3(0%#$& '0+ /-0%17&*$-09 ?K-5$2$3$0, *#(/-0%17()? 7$,#* .(22 #'6( 5(/-7( ' @(8 '%&(/* -4 /1))(0* )'*$-0'2$*$(% -4 &-2$*$/'2 )12(

MK$22() '0+ Z-%( ^bbcR9 :4 *#$% $% *#( /'%(; .#'* *#$% '&&)-'/# $7&2$(% $% *#'* .( %#-12+

'6-$+ %$7&28 5(7-'0$0, *#( +('*# -4 /$*$3(0%#$& '0+ *#( (/2$&%( -4 &152$/ 6$)*1( $0 *#(4'/( -4 ' /'&'/$-1% /-0%17()$%79 ]% Z-%( '/@0-.2(+,(%; ,-6()0$0, *#)-1,# /$*$3(0%#$&

$% $0#()(0*28 )$%@8; $0 %- 4') '% *#( 5(')()% -4 /$*$3(0%#$& %*'*1% ')( '2.'8% 2$@(28 *-

)($0*()&)(* '%/)$5(+ )$,#*% '0+ 7'@( /-10*()C/2'$7% ','$0%* *#-%( '/*-)% *- .#-%('1*#-)$*8 *#(8 ')( %15D(/*(+9 "#$% $0+(*()7$0'/8 $% -028 2$@(28 *- 5( (>'/()5'*(+ .#(0

?/$*$3(0? ,(*% ')*$/12'*(+ .$*# ?/-0%17()? '% ' &)(6'2(0* )(,$%*() -4 %15D(/*C4-)7'*$-09 =(

/'0 (>&(/*; *#(0; *#'* /-0%17&*$-0 $% 2$@(28 *- 5( ' 4$(2+ -4 $0*(0%( /-0*(%*'*$-0 5(*.((0/-7&(*$0, )'*$-0'2$*$(% -4 *#( 4)((C7')@(*; -4 )$,#*% '0+ &')*$/$&'*$-0; '0+ 5-*# *#(

#(+-0$%*$/ '0+ /')$0, +$7(0%$-0% -4 (6()8+'8 /-0%17() &)'/*$/(9

:0 .#'* 4-22-.%; .( 4-/1% 0-* -0 *#( (7&$)$/'2 B1(%*$-0 -4 .#(*#() '0+ #-. *#(%(

)'*$-0'2$*$(% &2'8 -1* -0 *#( ,)-10+ M/49 G2')@( OPPW; cPCc^R9 "#$% .-12+ /-0/(+( *--

71/# *- *#( &)(6'2(0* )(0+$*$-0 -4 ,-6()07(0*'2$*8 '0+ $*% +(&2-87(0* *- 5-2%*() &-2$*$/'2C(/-0-7$/ '//-10*% -4 0(-2$5()'2$%79 :0 *#( 0(>* %(/*$-0 .( .'0* %*(& 5'/@ 4)-7

/-0%17&*$-0 !)3 1); '0+ '%@ #-. *#( $77'0(0/( -4 /-0*(%*'*$-0 *- &-2$*$/'2 )'*$-0'2$*$(%'0+ *(/#0$B1(% -4 ,-6()0$0, $% *#(-)$3(+ 4)-7 *#$%


7/27

'

J')*28 5(/'1%( -4 *#( +$%/$&2$0')8 4-/1% -4 %- 71/# .-)@ -0 *#$% *-&$/; *#( '0'28*$/% -4

,-6()07(0*'2$*8 #'% /-7( *- 5( ' )(%-21*(28 ?&-2$/8C/(0*)$/? '&&)-'/# *- 10+()%*'0+$0,

%-/$-C/12*1)'2 /#'0,(9 I6()8+'8 2$4( '0+ %-/$'2 )(2'*$-0% ')( )(+1/(+ *- )(%$+1'2 (44(/*% -4

$0$*$'*$6(% (7'0'*$0, 4)-7 +$%&()%(+; 51* 0(6()*#(2(%% /-#()(0* /-0/(0*)'*$-0% -4

'1*#-)$*89 ?"#( %-/$'2? $% +(4$0(+ '% ' 410+'7(0*'228 3)('&%$5) 4$(2+; )'*#() *#'0 -0( 4)-7.#()( +80'7$/% -4 %-/$-C/12*1)'2 /#'0,( 7$,#* '/*1'228 (7(),(9 "#$% +-(% 0-* -028

7$%/-0%*)1( *#( +$6()%( 7-+(% -4 &-2$*$/'2 '/*$-0 *#'* 7$,#* $* 7$,#* 5( &-%%$52( *- &1)%1(

*#)-1,# &)'/*$/(% -4 /-0%17&*$-09 K-)( *#'0 *#$%; *#( .'8 $0 .#$/# *#( $77'0(0/( -4

/-0*(%*'*$-0 *- ,-6()07(0*'2 )'*$-0'2$*$(% $% *#(-)$3(+ 7('0% *#'* *#$% '&&)-'/# /'00-*; $0

*#( 4$0'2 '0'28%$%; '/*1'228 '//-10* 4-) ?%1//(%%? -) ?4'$21)(? ($*#() (7&$)$/'228 -)

/-0/(&*1'2289 ]0+ *#$% 7$,#* 7('0 .( 0((+ *- '%/)$5( *- ?&-2$*$/'2 )'*$-0'2$*$(%? ' 7-)(7-+(%* $0421(0/( $0 %#'&$0, *#( &'*#.'8% -4 %-/$'2 /#'0,(9

E>?


8/27

(

'%&$)'*$-0%; $0*()(%*% '0+ 5(2$(4%; 4-) +(4$0$*( 51* %#$4*$0, (0+% '0+ .$*# ' +$6()%(

%(* -4 )(2'*$6(28 10&)(+$/*'52( /-0%(B1(0/(%; (44(/*% '0+ -1*/-7(%9 Mf('0; ^bbb;

^^R

"#()( '* 2('%* *#)(( .'8% *- &')%( *#$% +(4$0$*$-09 ()/$%( -4 &-2$*$/'2 &-.(); -0( .#$/# '%/)$5(% ' /-0%$+()'52( +(,)(( -4 /'1%'2

%$,0$4$/'0/( *- *#( &2'8 5(*.((0 /-7&(*$0, %*)'*(,$/ )'*$-0'2$*$(%9 ]% %1/#; $* )(%*% -0

B1$*( +$%*$0/*$6( $2-%-$/'2 4-10+'*$-0%9 "#( '0'28*$/% -4 ,-6()07(0*'2$*8 $% )(%-21*(28*"+$*'#$1%$& M$5$+9; O^R9 :* $% '0 '&&)-'/# .#$/# #-2+% *#'* .'8% -4 6$%1'2$3$0,

(0-7(0' #'6( ' #$,# +(,)(( -4 (44(/*$6$*8 $0 '/*1'228 5)$0,$0, *#-%( (0-7(0' $0*-(>$%*(0/(; '% %- 7'08 ?/-0*$0,(0* 2'%#C1&% -4 *#-1,#* '0+ '/*$-0?9 "#$% 0-7$0'2$%7 $%; $0

*1)0; '**'/#(+ *- ' /-0/(&* -4 ,-6()07(0*'2 '/*$-0 '% '0 a'))'8 -4 2$0(% -4 *#-1,#*; -4

.$22; -4 $06(0*$-0; -4 &)-,)'77(% '0+ 4'$21)(%; -4 '/*% '0+ /-10*()C'/*%a M$5$+9R9 Z-%(

M^bbb; OccR %&(22% -1* #-. *#( 4-/1% -0 *#( %*)'*(,$/ +80'7$/ -4 /-0*(%*'*$-0 '0+#(*()-,(0($*8 $% 7('0* *- +$%*$0,1$%# *#( '0'28*$/% -4 ,-6()07(0*'2$*8 4)-7 %$7&2$%*$/

7-+(2% -4 *-&C+-.0 &-.() '0+ 5-**-7C1& )(%$%*'0/(E

a"#()( $% 0-* ' %$0,2( +$%/-1)%( -) %*)'*(,8 -4 &-.() /-04)-0*(+ 58 4-)/(% -4

)(%$%*'0/(; 51* ' %(* -4 /-042$/*$0, &-$0*% '0+ $%%1(% -4 -&&-%$*$-0; '22$'0/( '0+

+$6$%$-0 -4 2'5-1)a9


9/27

)

A-; *#( /2'$7 *#'* *#(-)$(% -4 ,-6()07(0*'2$*8 $7&-%( /2-%1)( -0 *#( -1*/-7(% -4

&)-,)'77(% -4 )12( $% 7$%&2'/(+9 N-.(6(); .#'* *#(8 /()*'$028 +- $% +()$6( *#$% %*'*(+

/-77$*7(0* *- #(*()-,(0($*8 '0+ /-0*$0,(0/8 4)-7 ' 0'))-.28 /-0%*)1(+ /-0/(&*$-0 -4

*#( 6')$'*$-0 $0 /-75$0'*$-0% -4 7('0%; (0+% '0+ -1*/-7(%9

"#$% $% -0( &2'/( .#()( -*#() 1%(% -4


10/27

*

.-)@ -0 #-. ,-6()07(0*'2 )'*$-0'2$*$(% ')( &2'8(+ -1*; %$0/( *#$% ('%$28 2('+% *- '0

'0'28%$% -4 +$441%$-0 '0+ )(%$%*'0/( *#'* 2('6(% $0*'/* *#( 410+'7(0*'2 %-/$'2C*#(-)(*$/

'%%17&*$-0% -4 *#( '0'28*$/% -4 ,-6()07(0*'2$*89 "#( $+(' -4 2--@$0, '* *#( )+)36)*%

3'%$"*'#$%$)1 -4 $0*()'/*$-0 .-12+ $7&28 ' +$44()(0* %*82( -4 $06(%*$,'*$-0; -0( 2(%%

/-0/()0(+ .$*# 10/-6()$0, ,-6()07(0*'2 )'*$-0'2$*$(%; '0+ 7-)( 4-/1%(+ -0 #-. *#(/-0/'*(0'*$-0 -4 %*)'*(,$/ $0*()(%*% -4*(0 2('+% *- 6')$-1% 4-)7% -4 /--&()'*$6( 5(#'6$-1)

C 5'),'$0$0,; #(2&$0,; /-7&)-7$%$0,; '0+ %(24C5$0+$0, MI2%*() ^bdbR9 [1* *#$% 7-6(

.-12+ )(B1$)( ' 41)*#() -0(E ' %#$4* '.'8 4)-7 ' .#-228 %*)'*(,$/ /-0/(&*$-0 -4 '/*$-0 '0+

$0*()'/*$-0; %$0/( *#$% /-0/(&*$-0 $% 0-* '52( *- '/@0-.2(+,( *#( /'&'/$*$(% 4-)

/-7710$/'*$6(28 7(+$'*(+; 0-)7'*$6(28 -)$(0*(+ $0*()'/*$-0 *#)-1,# .#$/# %1/#

(7(),(0* /--&()'*$6( )'*$-0'2$*$(% /'0 +(6(2-&9


11/27

"+

)(%$+1'2$3'*$-0 $0 %- 71/# .-)@ -0 '+6'0/(+ 2$5()'2 ,-6()07(0*'2$*8 '0+ #(,(7-0$/

0(-2$5()'2$%7 '2$@(9 :0 -)+() *- +- %-; $* $% 0-* (0-1,# *- '44$)7 *#( /)('*$6(; $06(0*$6(;

)(%$%*'0* )(%&-0%(% -4 %15D(/*% &-%$*$-0(+ 58 -6()5(')$0, +$%/-1)%(% '0+ *(/#0-2-,$(% -4

%15D(/*$-0; &')*$/12')28 $4 *#$% /'&'/$*8 $% ,$6(0 0- %*)-0,() (>&2'0'*$-0 *#'0 ' *#$028

*#(-)$3(+ '//-10* -4 *#( 6$*'2$%7 -4 ?2$4( $*%(24? ,(0()'*$0, 6')$-1% (44-)*% '* ?+(C%15D(/*$4$/'*$-0?9 :0 *#( 0(>* *.- %(/*$-0%; .( .'0* *- *1)0 5'/@ *- B1(%*$-0% -4

/-0%17&*$-0 '0+ /-0%17()$%7 $0 -)+() *- %1,,(%* *#'* *#(


12/27

""

$06(%*(+ $0 *#($) %*'*1% '% /-0%17()%9 "#$% 2'**() &-%$*$-0 &)-6$+(% ' +(,)(( -4 /)$*$/'2

&1)/#'%( -0 &)-C7')@(* +$%/-1)%(%; 51* -028 58 /-7&-10+$0, *#( 10+()28$0, '%%17&*$-0

-4 *#-%( +$%/-1)%(%; 0'7(28 *#'* &(-&2(%? $+(0*$*$(% ')( $0 4'/* 7-)( '0+ 7-)( &'**()0(+

'4*() *#($) )-2(% '% /-0%17()%9 [8 2--@$0, '* *#( /'7&'$,0% '0+ 7-6(7(0*% ')-10+

(*#$/'2 /-0%17()$%7; '% +$%*$0/* 4)-7 %*'*(C4-/1%(+ &-2$/8 +(5'*(%; .( .'0* *- %1,,(%**#'* *#( '%%17&*$-0 *#'* ,-6()0$0, /-0%17&*$-0 0(/(%%')$28 $06-26(% ,-6()0$0, &(-&2(

$+(0*$*$(% '% ?/-0%17()%? 7$,#* 5( ' 4') 2(%% -56$-1% -0( *#'0 $% -4*(0 %1&&-%(+9

L0( -4 *#( 7-%* &)-+1/*$6( ')('% $042(/*(+ 58 *#(-)$(% -4 ,-6()07(0*'2$*8 $% )(%(')/# -0

*#( +$6()%$*8 -4 ?/'2/12'*$6( &)'/*$/(%? '%%-/$'*(+ .$*# *#( )$%( '0+ *)'0%4-)7'*$-0 -4 *#(

7-+()0 %*'*(9 :0 #$% +$%/1%%$-0 -4 *#( #$%*-)$/'2 %$,0$4$/'0/( -4 '//-10*$0, '0+'//-10*'0/8; K$22() MOPP^; OUbR %1,,(%*% *#'* /'2/12'*$6( &)'/*$/(% a'2*() *#( /'&'/$*$(% -4

',(0*%; -),'0$3'*$-0% '0+ *#( /-00(/*$-0% '7-0, *#(7a; '0+ *#'* *#(8 a(0'52( 0(. .'8%

-4 '/*$0, 1&-0 '0+ $0421(0/$0, *#( '/*$-0% -4 $0+$6$+1'2%a9 "#( 410+'7(0*'2 B1(%*$-0 2(4*

'%$+( $0 *#$% '%%()*$-0 $% .#'* %-)* -4 ?&-.()? *#$% $%e N-.; (>'/*28; +- /'2/12'*$6( &)'/*$/(% (0'52( *#$% '/*$0,C1&-0 '0+ $0421(0/$0,e :0 D1%* .#'* %(0%( /'0 -0( *#$0@ -4

/'2/12'*$6( &)'/*$/(% '% '$+$0, $0 *#( ?/-0%*)1/*$-0 -4 ,-6()0'52( &()%-0%? MK$22() '0+L?V(')8 ^bdcRe Z(%(')/# -0 0(-2$5()'2 %15D(/*$6$*$(% *(0+% *- +(&2-8 *#( 0-*$-0 -4

,-6()07(0*'2$*8 %- *#'* $* '&&(')% *#'* 6')$-1% &)'/*$/(% '0+ *(/#0-2-,$(% '$7 *-

4'/$2$*'*(; 7-)( -) 2(%% %1//(%%41228; /-04-)7$*8 *- *#( 0-)7% -4 7')@(*C)12( M(9,9 K$*/#(22OPPU; OPPl R9 [1* $4 *#( )(&)-+1/*$-0 -4 0-)7% $% 7(+$'*(+ 58 *#( -&()'*$-0 -4 0-)7%;

*#(0 $* $% 4') 4)-7 /2(') *#'* ?/-04-)7$*8? $% *#( 7(/#'0$%7 *#)-1,# .#$/# %15D(/*C

4-)7'*$-0 /-12+ 5( &1)%1(+9

L0( .'8 -4 10+()%*'0+$0, *#( )(2'*$-0%#$& 5(*.((0 /'2/12'*$6( &)'/*$/(% '0+ %15D(/*C

4-)7'*$-0 $% *- *1)0 *- N'/@$0,?% MOPPOR '//-10* -4 #-. *#( ?'6'2'0/#( -4 0175()%?*#)-1,# .#$/# 7-+()0 %*'*(% #'6( /'*(,-)$3(+ &(-&2( %$0/( *#( 0$0(*((0*#C/(0*1)8 #'6(

,(0()'*(+ 0(. .'8% -4 ?7'@$0, 1& &(-&2(?9 A8%*(7% 4-) /-10*$0, &-&12'*$-0% +(&(0+ -0

4-)7$0, /'*(,-)$(% ')-10+ &(-&2(; '0+ *#(%( /'*(,-)$(% $0 *1)0 #(2& 4-)7 *#-%( &(-&2(*#(7%(26(%; $0 %- 4') '% *#(8 7-5$2$3( ')-10+ *#-%( /2'%%$4$/'*-)8 $+(0*$*$(%9 N'/@$0,

'22-.% ' 71/# ,)('*() +(,)(( -4 &)-'/*$6( '1*-0-7-1% &)(%%1)( 4)-7 ?5(2-.? *#'0 -*#()


13/27

"#

7')@(* $0 (*#$/'228 &)-+1/(+ '0+ *)'+(+ ,--+% '0+ %()6$/(%9 H-.; .#'* $% 7-%*

$0*()(%*$0, '5-1* *#$% *8&( -4 %1)6(8 +'*' $% *#( )'0,( -4 ')(0'% $0 .#$/# $* $% +(&2-8(+9

"#( IJ: '**)'/*% .$+(%&)('+ 0(.%&'&() '0+ 5)-'+/'%* 7(+$' /-6()',( .#(0 &152$%#(+;

'0+ $% &')* -4 ' )-22$0, %*)('7 -4 %1/# %1)6(8 )(%(')/#9 L0( %(* -4 '++)(%%((% 4-) *#$% *8&(

-4 %1)6(8 ')( ?*#( &152$/?; '0+ *#(%( (>()/$%(% ')( /()*'$028 &')* -4 5)-'+ %*)'*(,$(% -4)'$%$0, '.')(0(%% -4 ' 5)-'+ )'0,( -4 ?(*#$/'2? /-0%17&*$-0 $%%1(%9 j1%* '% $7&-)*'0*;

#-.(6(); $% *#( +(&2-87(0* -4 *#(%( %-)*% -4 /'2/12'*$6( *(/#0-2-,$(% *- 2-558

,-6()07(0* '0+ 51%$0(%%(% *- (>*(0+ %1&&-)* 4-) (*#$/'2 /-0%17() $0$*$'*$6(%9 :* .-12+ 5(

.)-0,; *#(0; *- '%%17( *#'* *#( &)$7')8 -5D(/*$6( -4 *#(%( (>()/$%(% $% +$)(/*28 /#'0,$0,

/-0%17()?% -.0 /-0%/$-1% 5(#'6$-1)9 Z'*#(); *#( $0*(0*$-0 $% 4-/1%(+ -0 (0#'0/$0, *#(

%1&&28 -4 ?(*#$/'2? /-77-+$*$(% *#)-1,# (>()*$0, &)(%%1)( -0 )(*'$2()% '0+ %1&&2$()%X '0+ D1%* '% $7&-)*'0*28; *- )(&)(%(0* /-0%17() /#-$/( '% !"#$%$&'# &)(4()(0/( $0 2-558$0, -4

&-2$/8 7'@()%; )(,12'*-)% '0+ /-)&-)'*$-0%9

"#(%( *8&(% -4 (>()/$%(% $0 (017()'*$0, (*#$/'2 /-0%17()$%7 %((7 *- .-)@ ' 2-* 2$@(N'/@$0,?% +80'7$/ 2--&$0, (44(/*%9 G'7&'$,0% *- )'$%( '.')(0(%% '0+ (0/-1)',( &(-&2(

*- (>()/$%( /-0%17() /#-$/( ?(*#$/'228? 2('+ *- ' +$%&')'*( %(* -4 &1)/#'%$0, '/*% *#'* ')(/2'%%$4$(+; /-10*(+; '0+ )(&)(%(0*(+ $0 0(. .'8% $0 *#( (44-)* *- '2*() )(*'$2$0, &)'/*$/(%;

'0+ &)-/1)(7(0* '0+ %1&&28 &-2$/$(%9 :0 %- 4') '% *#(%( '2*()'*$-0% *'@( &2'/(; *#(8 $0 *1)0

4'/$2$*'*( 41)*#() '/*% -4 ?(*#$/'2? &1)/#'%$0, 58 '0-087-1% /-0%17()%; /2'%%$4$(+ '0+/-10*(+ ','$0 $0 0(. )-10+% -4 %1)6(8$0,9 "#( &-$0* $% *#'* *#( /'2/12'*$6( &)'/*$/(%

$06-26(+ #()( '/* -0 &(-&2(?% '/*$-0% $0 ' 6()8 $0+$)(/* .'8 C 58 %*)1/*1)$0, &-%%$5$2$*$(%

/()*'$028; 51* #')+28 58 (0+('6-1)$0, *- *)'0%4-)7 *#($) %15D(/*$6$*$(% '% %1/#9 :0+((+;'0+ *- 5-))-. 4)-7 N'/@$0, ','$0; 2--@(+ '* '0-*#() .'8 *#( +(&2-87(0* -4 %1)6(8 +'*'

$0 (*#$/'2 /-0%17() /'7&'$,0$0, $0+$/'*(% *#'*; '% ' 7-+( -4 /2'%%$48$0, &(-&2(; ?*#(

/-0%17()? 7$,#* .(22 5( ' )(2'*$6(28 a$0+$44()(0* @$0+a; $0 /-0*)'%* *- *#( %-)*% -4a$0*()'/*$6( @$0+%a .#()( *#()( $% ' %*)-0, +(,)(( 5(*.((0 /2'%%$4$/'*$-0 '0+ /2'%%$4$(+

.#$/# $% 7(+$'*(+ 58 (>&2$/$* $+(0*$4$/'*$-0 .$*# /'*(,-)$(%9 [($0, /2'%%$4$(+ '% '

?/-0%17()?; (*#$/'2 -) -*#().$%(; $% -028 )')(28 *'@(0 1& '% ' %*)-0, &-$0* -4 &()%-0'2$+(0*$4$/'*$-09 "#$% $% 0-* *- %'8 *#'* *#( /2'%%$4$/'*$-0 +-(% 0-* #'6( (44(/*%; -028 *#'* *#$%

$% 0-* 0(/(%%')$28 7(+$'*(+ *#)-1,# %*)-0, $0*()&(22'*$6( %15D(/*C(44(/*% '* '229

L1) 4$)%* &-$0* +)'.0 4)-7 2--@$0, '* (*#$/'2 /-0%17()$%7 '% '0 (>'7&2( -4 ,-6()0$0,

/-0%17&*$-0 $%; *#(0; *#'* *#()( $% 0- 0((+ *- %1&&-%( *#'* (44-)*% '* %#'&$0, /-0+1/* '$7

*- 5)$0, -44 %*)-0, %15D(/*C(44(/*% -0 $0+$6$+1'2% .#- $+(0*$48 *#(7%(26(% '% ?(*#$/'2?/-0%17()%9 V--@$0, '* ."8 /'2/12'*$6( *(/#0-2-,$(% (0'52( 0(. .'8% -4 '/*$0, -0

$0+$6$+1'2% %1,,(%*% *#'* *#( '0'28*$/% -4 ,-6()07(0*'2$*8 /-12+ +- .(22 *- 2(')0 ' 2(%%-04)-7 '0-*#() 4$(2+ -4 )(%(')/# $042(/*(+ 58


14/27

"$

)(,12'*$0, *#( $0+$6$+1'2 '% ' %&('@$0,; .-)@$0,; +(%$)$0, %15D(/*X '0+ )(,12'*$0, *#(

?%&(/$(% 5-+8?; )(,12'*$0, .#-2( &-&12'*$-0%9 "#$% %1,,(%*% *#'* *#( ',(0*% 2$@(28 *- 5( *#(

%15D(/*% -4 ,-6()07(0*'2 )'*$-0'2$*$(% ')( 0-* 0(/(%%')$28 78)$'+ +$%&()%(+ -)+$0')8

&(-&2(9 :0 &')*$/12'); &)-4(%%$-0'2% '0+ (>&()*% ')( 0-* D1%* *#( &'%%$6( ',(0*% -4

'0-087-1% ,-6()07(0*'2 )'*$-0'2$*$(%X *#(8 ')( D1%* '% -4*(0 *#( %15D(/*% -4 %1/#$0*()6(0*$-0%9 "'@( *#( (>'7&2( -4 '0 $00-6'*$6( /'7&'$,0 $0 *#( k`; *#( *(0+(+ *- $0/21+( 7(+$17C%$3(+ *-.0%; '0+ 7-%* )(/(0*28 2'),(

7(*)-&-2$*'0 /$*$(%9 L1) )(%(')/# #'% *)'/@(+ *#( 8(')C2-0, &)-/(%% $0 OPPWCQ *#)-1,#.#$/# *#( /$*8 -4 [)$%*-2 $0 *#( %-1*#C.(%* -4 I0,2'0+ &)(&')(+ 4-) '0+ %1//(%%41228

'/#$(6(+ '7&2( '2%- $0+$/'*(% *#( +$6()%( )'0,( -4 %15D(/*% .#- /'0 5( (7&-.()(+ 58 %1/#

&)-,)'77(%9 ] 410+'7(0*'2 +(*()7$0'0* -4 *#( &'*# *#'* /'7&'$,0% %1/# '%


15/27

"%

'/*-)% ')( '52( *- $*%)3!3)% +$44()(0* )12(%; )(,12'*$-0%; '0+ &-2$/8 ',(0+'%9 "#($) &-$0*;

-0( 5-)0( -1* 58 -1) -.0 (>'7&2( -4 *#( [)$%*-2 &2$/$*28 ?(*#$/'2? -) ?%1%*'$0'52(? .'8%; .( #'6( '2%- $0+$/'*(+ *#( 0((+ *- 5( 7-)(/$)/17%&(/* '5-1* *#( ,(0()'2 '&&2$/'5$2$*8 -4 ,)'0+ /2'$7% '5-1* *#( $0+$6$+1'2$3'*$-0 -4

/-0*(7&-)')8 ,-6()0'0/(9 :0 *#( 0(>* %(/*$-0; .( .'0* *- &$/@ 1& *#( &-$0* 7'+( '5-6(

'5-1* *#( $7&-)*'0/( *#'* *#( $*%)3!3)%'%$"* -4 )12(% '0+ )(,12'*$-0% &2'8% $0 %#'&$0, *#(0(*.-)@% *#)-1,# .#$/# ?,-6()07(0*'2? $0*()6(0*$-0% &2'8 -1*9 "#$% %(0%( *#'* )12(% '0+

)(,12'*$-0% -028 .-)@ *#)-1,# *#( 7(+$17 -4 $0*()&)(*'*$-0 /1*% %*)'$,#* *- *#(

/-0/(&*1'2 '0+ (7&$)$/'2 '!"3$' ')-10+ .#$/# ? !"# #-"(,2% C1.*%#32-(D2-(.0 ./ -"# ,.0'&3#1


16/27

"&

)($04-)/$0, *#(-)(*$/'2 /)$*$/$%7; 4-) .#$/# $%* '% &)-&()*$(% *#(8 #-2+ &)$-) *- $0*()'/*$-0 $*%(249 J-.(); $0 *#$% '//-10*; $%10+()%*--+ .$*# )(4()(0/( *- *#( 6')8$0, %1//(%% $0 5)$0,$0, '5-1* -0(?% -.0 -5D(/*$6(%9

:0 4'/*; *#( $+(' *#'* &-2$*$/'2 &)-/(%%(% ')( 7()(28 ' %(* -4 %*)'*(,$/ /-042$/*% '7-0,%*

/-7&(*$0, '/*-)% $% ' /-0/(&*$-0 0-* 6()8 4') )(7-6(+ 4)-7 ' 2$5()'2C&21)'2$%* /-0/(&*$-0-4 &-2$*$/'2 &-.() M[')0(** OPPU; G#9WR9 N-00(*# $+(0*$4$(% $0 *#$% /-0/(&* -4 %*)'*(,$/

/-042$/* *#( %-1)/( -4 *#( /-0%$%*(0* (2$%$-0 -4 /-7710$/'*$6( 0-)7'*$6$*8 $0


17/27

"'

+$7(0%$-0; .#'* .( ')( 2(4* .$*# $% ' &$/*1)( -4 a52--+2(%% 4$,1)(% .#- %((7$0,28 +)$4*

*#)-1,# 2$4(; 5(#'6$0, $0 .'8% .#$/# 5(') *#( 7')@% -4 *#($) %-/$'2 &-%$*$-0 '0+ )(2'*$-0%

-4 .$+() +$%/-1)%(%; +$%/$&2$0$0, *#(7%(26(% -028 5(/'1%( $* $% )(B1$)(+ -4 *#(7; 51* '% $4

0-*#$0, 7'**()(+ *- *#(7n MA'8() OPPQ; Q^R9

"#$% %(0%( *#'* -0( /'0 -028 10+()%*'0+ *#( )(2'*$-0%#$& 5(*.((0 $0+$6$+1'2% '0+ .$+()

%8%*(7% -4 0-)7% '0+ )(,12'*$-0 58 *'@$0, '//-10* -4 ?.#'* 7'**()% *- *#(7? $% /)1/$'2 *-

10+()%*'0+$0, *#( +80'7$/% -4 (*#$/'2 /-0%17()$%7 '% ' %15C%(/*-) -4 /-0*(7&-)')8

/-0%17&*$-0 &)'/*$/(%9 :* $% *#( -028 .'8 *- 10+()%*'0+ *#( )(%&-0%$5$2$3'*$-0? -4

$0+$6$+1'2% '% /-0%17()%; (7&-.()(+ .$*# /#-$/( *#)-1,# 6')$-1% 7')@(*$3(+ &)'/*$/(%

-4 &152$/ '0+ &)$6'*( &)-6$%$-0 -4 *#( 7('0% -4 %-/$'2 )(&)-+1/*$-09 :4 /-0%17()$%7 $%$0+((+ '0 $7&-)*'0* /-0*(7&-)')8 &-2$*$/'2 )'*$-0'2$*8; *#(0 $* .-)@% 0-* *#)-1,# *#(

&)-7-*$-0 -4 104(**()(+ #(+-0$%7 '0+ %(24C$0*()(%*; 51* 58 7'@$0, &)-52(7'*$/ *#(

(>()/$%( -4 /-0%17() /#-$/( $0 *()7% -4 6')$-1%; (6() &)-2$4()'*$0, )(%&-0%$5$2$*$(% '0+

(*#$/'2 $7&()'*$6(%9 =( .'0* 0-. *- 42(%# -1* #-. *#( 0-*$-0 -4 2'8 0-)7'*$6$*8 /'01%(41228 %1&&2(7(0*


18/27

"(

*#( %(24 a.#$/# $% *#( '%&(/* -) &')* -4 78%(24 -) 78 5(#'6$-1) .#$/# $% /-0/()0(+ .$*#

7-)'2 /-0+1/*a M'7&2(; *#( '/*$-0% *#)-1,# .#$/# *#( (2'5-)'*$-0 -4(*#$/'2 %(26(% $% $0/)('%$0,28 5($0, &1)%1(+ ')( *#-%( 6()8 #17+)17; +'$28 '/*$6$*$(% 2$@(

%#-&&$0, -) +$%&-%$0, -4 #-1%(#-2+ )155$%#9


19/27

")

4)'7(% *#'* 4-/1% -0 #-. &(-&2(?% %15D(/*$6$*$(% ')( a%-/$'228 /-0%*)1/*)/ a $0 ' *-&C

+-.0_5-**-7C1& )(2'*$-0%#$&; *-.')+% ' 4-/1% -0 #-. &(-&2( ')( '2.'8% a%-/$'228

/-0%*)1/*$*6 a %15D(/*$6$*$(% *#)-1,# -0,-$0, D-$0* '/*$-0 M"#)$4* ^bbYR9

:0 *#( &)(6$-1% %(/*$-0; .( '),1(+ *#'* (44-)*% '* ,-6()0$0, /-0%17&*$-0 +- 0-* '2.'8%'$7 *- /-0%*)1/* *#( $0+$6$+1'*(+ /-0%17() '% *#( &)$7')8 ?*(/#0-2-,8? 4-) '/#$(6$0, *#($)

,-'2%9 L4 /-1)%(; .( +-0?* +(08 *#'* ' ,)('* +('2 -4 *#( /-0*(7&-)')8 &)-52(7'*$3'*$-0 -4

/-0%17&*$-0 +-(% '++)(%% $0+$6$+1'2%9 [1* .#'* .( +- .'0* *- '),1( $% *#'* ."8 *#$%

$0+$6$+1'2$3(+ '++)(%% *- /#--%8 /-0%17()% .-)@% 0((+% *- 5( 7-)( /')(41228 %&(/$4$(+;

58 +$%*$0,1$%#$0, 5(*.((0 '/*$-0; $+(0*$*8 '0+ %15D(/*$6$*89 :0 &-2$/8 /$)/2(%; '0+ &-2$/8C

)(2'*(+ '/'+(7$/ .-)@; *#()( $% -4*(0 '0 '%%17&*$-0 *#'* &(-&2(?% /-0%17() 5(#'6$-1)/'0 5( )(,12'*(+ 58 &)-6$+$0, 2-*% -4 $04-)7'*$-0 '5-1* .#()( /-77-+$*$(% /-7(% 4)-7;

.#- 7'+( *#(7; *#($) (06$)-07(0*'2 $7&'/*; *#($) 2$@(28 #('2*# $7&'/*%; '0+ %- -09 "#(

%'7( '%%17&*$-0 $% -4*(0 '* .-)@ $0 7-)( &-2$*$/$3(+ 4-)7% -4 /-0%17() '/*$6$%79

]/'+(7$/ '0'28%$% $04-)7(+ 58 /12*1)'2 *#(-)8 '0+ &-%*%*)1/*1)'2$%7 .-12+ *(0+ *- %(( $0*#(%( 7-+(% -4 '++)(%% '**(7&*% *- /-0%*)1/* &(-&2(?% %15D(/*$6$*8 58 #'6$0, *#(7

)(/-,0$3( *#(7%(26(% '% *#( %15D(/*% -4 6')$-1% $7',(% -4 %-5)$(*8; )(%&-0%$5$2$*8;/-77$*7(0* '0+ %- -09 ]22 -4 *#(%( 4$(2+% C &-2$/8; /'7&'$,0; '0+ /)$*$/'2 '/'+(7$/ C

%#')( ' )'*#() *#$0; '*(7&-)'2 /-0/(&*$-0 -4 *#( %(249 ]0+ $0 *#$% )(%&(/*; '/'+(7$/

'0'28%$% 7$,#* 5( 2',,$0, 5(#$0+ *#( 7-%* $00-6'*$6( &)'/*$/(% -4 /'7&'$,0 ,)-1&% $0*#$% %(/*-); .#- ')( $0/)('%$0,28 %#$4*$0, '.'8 4)-7 *#( $04-)7'*$-0C7-+(2 -4 /-0%17()

/#-$/( *-.')+% 01'0/(+ 10+()%*'0+$0,% -4 #-. &(-&2( $0*(,)'*( *#($) '/*$-0% '%

/-0%17()% $0*- 5)-'+() &)'/*$/(% -4 '//-10*'52( %(24C4-)7'*$-09 '7&2(; $0 *#( k`*#$0@C*'0@% %1/# '% *#( F)((0 ]22$'0/( '0+ f(7-% #'6( )(/(0*28 '),1(+ *#'* *#( @(8 *-

$0421(0/$0, /-0%17() /#-$/( $% *- 5(**() 10+()%*'0+ &)-/(%%(% -4 %#')(+ 2(')0$0, *#)-1,#

&(() ,)-1&% '0+ %-/$'2 0(*.-)@%9 "#$% $7&2$(% ' 4-/1% -0 *#( p')*% -4 $0421(0/$0,n;$+(0*$48$0, '0+ )(/)1$*$0, ?$0*()7(+$')$(%T $0 &(() 0(*.-)@% .#- &()%1'+( '0+ $0421(0/(

-*#()% $0 /-06()%'*$-0E p5(#'6$-1) %&)('+% *#)-1,# /-06()%'*$-0%; %-/$'2 2(')0$0, '0+

&(() ,)-1& 0(*.-)@%a; '0+ %- *#( '$7 -4 /'7&'$,0% %#-12+ 5( *- a,(* &(-&2( *'2@$0,;$0%&$)( /1)$-%$*8a MG-22$0% )% '# OPPUE WbR9

=( +- 0-* 7('0 *- %$7&28 (0+-)%( *#(%( %-)*% -4 4-)712'*$-0%; 51* .( +- 0((+ *-

)(/-,0$3( #()( ' %$,0$4$/'0* %#$4* $0 *#( .'8 $0 .#$/# $0421(0*$'2 '/*-)% %((@$0, *- %#'&(

&152$/ &-2$/8 +(5'*(% ')( *#(7%(26(% )(*#$0@$0, *#( 7-%* (44(/*$6( ?*(/#0-2-,$(%? 4-)

)(,12'*$0, $0+$6$+1'2 /-0%17() /#-$/(9 "#(%( *#$0@ *'0@% ')( )(/-77(0+$0, *#'*,-6()0$0, /-0%17&*$-0 )(B1$)(% 7-)( *#'0 %$7&28 #(/*-)$0, /-0%17()% *- 5( 7-)(

)(%&-0%$52( '0+ &)-6$+$0, *#(7 .$*# 7-)( $04-)7'*$-09 :* /()*'$028 +-(% 0-* $06-26('**(7&*% *- 7'@( &(-&2( /-04-)7 *- (>*()0'228 $7&-%(+ 0-)7%9 Z'*#(); .#'* $% 104-2+$0,

#()( $% ' %(0%( *#'* $0421(0/$0, 5(#'6$-1) /'0 .-)@ *#)-1,# *#( /2'%%$/'2 ')*% -4 )#(*-)$/9

]0+ *#( )('%-0 .#8 .( *#$0@ *#$% $% .-)*# *'@$0, %()$-1%28 $% &)(/$%(28 5(/'1%( $*

'/@0-.2(+,(% *#'* &(-&2( ')( '362+)*%'%$5) 12-=)&%1 *#)-1,# '0+ *#)-1,#9 "#$% $%)(2(6'0* 4-) #-. .( /-0/(&*1'2$3( *#( )'*$-0'2$*$(% 5(#$0+ *#( (*#$/'2 &)-52(7'*$%'*$-0 -4

/-0*(7&-)')8 /-0%17&*$-0; '0+ '2%- 4-) #-. .( 7$,#* ,- '5-1* (7&$)$/'228

$06(%*$,'*$0, -)+$0')8 &(-&2(?% (0,',(7(0*% .$*# *#(%( $0*()6(0*$-0% $0 .'8% *#'* +-

D1%*$/( *- *#($) -.0 /-7&(*(0/$(% '% '/*-)% '0+ %(26(%; '0+ 0-* D1%* %15D(/*%9


20/27

"*

V(* 1% )(*1)0 0-. *- *#( *#(-)(*$/'2 *())'$0 -4 '+6'0/(+ 2$5()'2$%7; ,-6()07(0*'2$*8; '0+

0(-2$5()'2 %15D(/*$6$*89 "#( '%%17&*$-0 *#'* ,-6()07(0*'2$*$(% .-)@ *#)-1,#

(0+('6-1)$0, *- %80(),$3( )'*$-0'2$*$(% '0+ %15D(/*$6$*$(% 5(*)'8% ' /')(2(%% 0-7$0'2$%7

-4 *#( %(24; /#')'/*()$%*$/ -4 ,(0()$/ &-%*%*)1/*1)'2$%7 7-)( 5)-'+289 :* $% ' %/#-2'%*$/

/-0/($* *- %1&&-%( *#'* *#( ?+$%/-6()8? *#'* %15D(/*$6$*8 $% )(2'*$-0'2; &()#'&% (6(0 +(6-$+-4 &-%$*$6( /-0*(0*; $7&2$(% *#'* %15D(/*$6$*$(% ')( 7'22('52( '0+ '7(0'52( *-

*)'0%4-)7'*$-09 F(0()$/ &-%*%*)1/*1)'2$%7 *(0+% *- 4-/1% -0 (>*)(7(28 *#$0 /-0/(&*% -4

7'22('52( %15D(/*$6$*8X -0( *#$0, .( 2$@( '5-1* *#( $+(' -4 (*#$/'2 &)-52(7'*$%'*$-0 $% *#'*

$* )(%*-)(% %-7( %(0%( -4 #-. %15D(/*$6$*8 $% (75(++(+ $0 5)-'+() &)'/*$/(% -4 %(24C

7'@$0, '0+ &()%-0#--+9 =( .'0* *- 4-22-. N'))o?% %1,,(%*$-0 M^bb^; Q^R *#'*

&()%-0#--+ *1)0% -0 ' +1'2$*8 -4 *#( %(24Ep"#( %(24 -4 &()%-0'2 $+(0*$*8 4-) '08 -0( #17'0 5($0, %((7% *- 5( ' 0(/(%%')8

%$0,12')$*8 .#$2( *#( A(26(% *#'* ')( 7'0$4(%*(+ $0 %-/$'2 (0/-10*()% /'0 ('%$28 5(

%#-.0 *- 5( +$6()%( '0+ '/*1'228 712*$&2(n MQ^R9

"#( $+(' *#'* &()%-0#--+ )(B1$)(% ' %(0%( p-4 5($0, -0( %(24 '0+ /-0*$01-1%28 -0( %(24nMKq#2r1%2() '0+ N'))o ^bbP; dcR +-(% 0-* )(B1$)( '08 %1&&-%$*$-0 *#'* *#$% %(0%( $%

'0/#-)(+ $0 ' 4-10+'*$-0'2 $+(0*$*8 -) $00() (,-9 &2-)$0, *#( (*#$/'2

&)-52(7'*$3'*$-0 -4 /-0%17()$%79 :0 &')*$/12'); 4-/1% ,)-1& 7(*#-+-2-,$(% ')( (44(/*$6(

'* (2'5-)'*$0, *#( $0*()'/*$6( +80'7$/% *#)-1,# .#$/# &(-&2( 0(,-*$'*( 6')$-1% ?6()*$/'2?

&-%$*$-0$0,% Mf'6$(% '0+ N'))o ^bbPR; 58 2-/'*$0, *#$% &)-/(%% $0 *#( ?#-)$3-0*'2? &)'/*$/(%

-4 (>&)(%%$0, '**$*1+(%; &)-6$+$0, 4'/*1'2 6()%$-0% -4 )('2$*8; '0+ (>&)(%%$0, )(,)(*% '0+


21/27

#+

,$6$0, D1%*$4$/'*$-0%9 "#( ?)(%&-0%$5$2$3'*$-0? -4 (6()8+'8 2$4( 7$,#* 5( '% 71/# '5-1*

*#(%( ?#-)$3-0*'2? +80'7$/% -4 %-/$'2 $0*()'/*$-0 '% $* $% '5-1* ?6()*$/'2? &)-/(%%(% -4

&-%$*$-0$0, 58 #(,(7-0$/ +$%/-1)%(%9 "#(8 ')(; .( .-12+ '),1(; '0 '&&)-&)$'*(

7(*#-+-2-,8 4-) (>&2-)$0, -0( -4 *#( @(8 &)$0/$&2(% -4 +$%/1)%$6( '//-10*% -4 *#( %(24;

0'7(28 *#'* *'@$0,C1& -) +$%%(0*$0, 4)-7 &-%$*$-0% $% %#'&(+ 58 7-*$6'*$-0% -4'//-10*'5$2$*8 M=(*#()(22 ^bbd; UbWR9 [(2-. .( )(&)-+1/( '0 (>*)'/* 4)-7 -0(

+$%/1%%$-0 -4 (*#$/'2 )(%&-0%$5$2$*8 '0+ /-0%17() /#-$/( '7-0,%* ' ,)-1& -4 .-7(0 .#-

'22 2$6( $0 ' 7$++2(C$0/-7( )(%$+(0*$'2 ')(' -4 [)$%*-29 =( .'0* *- 1%( $* #()( *- $221%*)'*(

#-. *#$% 7(*#-+-2-,$/'2 '&&)-'/# *#)-.% 2$,#* -0 #-. *- /-0/(&*1'2$3( *#( &)-/(%%(% -4

+$%/1)%$6( &-%$*$-0$0, *#)-1,# .#$/# *#( (*#$/'2 &)-52(7'*$%'*$-0 -4 /-0%17&*$-0 .-)@%E

A'&$#$%'%"3B

C"2#/ 4"2 )5)3 8"334 '-"2% 0""/1 %.'% '3) .)'5$#4 !'&D'6)/E

:**)B ? %.$*D !'3% "0 %.) 3)'1"* ? 6" %" ' 032$% '*/ 5)6 1."!F ? /"*G% 3)'##4 8'*% %.$*61

%.'% .'5) -))* $* ' !"#4 -'6 "3 %.$*61 %.'% .'5) 6"% &"+!#)%)#4 )@&)11 !'&D'6$*6H ?%G1 3$/$&2#"21 %.) '+"2*% "0 !'&D'6$*6 4"2 6)%H

I2&4BC) '3) +)'*% %" 0))# 62$#%4 '-"2% $%F #$D) $%G1 "23 0'2#% -2% $%G1 *"%H

:**)B J2% $% $1 "23 0'2#% $0 8) &.""1) %" -24 '!!#)1 $* ' !"#4 -'6H

I2&4B ?%G1 %.) !)"!#) 8." !3"/2&) $% '3) %.) 62$#%4 "*)1F *"% 21H

>5)#4*B :% 9)1&"1F ? 0))# %.'% 4"2 &'*G% -#'+) 9)1&"1 0"3 D*"&D$*6 /"8* 12!!#$)31F +"1% "0

$%G1 %.)$3 &21%"+)31 %.'% '3) /)+'*/$*6 %.) !3$&)1 '3) %.) 1'+)H

K'3"#)B

L'$*1-2341F 8.)3) %.)4 '3) /"$*6 %.) -)'*1F %.)4 21)/ %" 1)## %.)+ '## #""1) '*/

%.)4 "*#4 6$5) 4"2 %.) !'&D'6)/ "!%$"* ?0 4"2 .'5)*G% 6"% %.'% &."$&)H

:**)B

?0 4"2 6" %" %.) 63))*63"&)3 4"2 6)%F 4"2 %'D) 4"23 "8* !"#4 -'6F 8.$&. ? /"*G%F

-2% 4"2 6)% ' !"#4 -'6F '*/ 4"2 1'4 G? 8'*% %."1) !"%'%")1GF 1.) !2%1 %.)+ $* %.)

-"%%"+F '*/ G? 8'*% %."1) '!!#)1GF %.)4 '3) '## =21% &.2&D)/ $* %.) -'6F 0$*)H 9.'%$1*G% '*4%.$*6 )@%3' '% '##H

"#()( $% ' /-77-0 7-+( -4 '0'283$0, *'2@C+'*' -4 *#$% %-)* $0 (06$)-07(0*'2 %*1+$(% '0+

%1%*'$0'52( /-0%17&*$-0 )(%(')/# *-.')+% $0*()&)(*$0, *#(%( %-)*% -4 (>/#'0,( $0 *()7% -4

*#( ?6-/'512')$(% -4 7-*$6(? *#)-1,# .#$/# $0+$6$+1'2% +$%&2'/( )(%&-0%$5$2$*8 '.'8 4)-7


22/27

#"

*#(7%(26(% -0*- -*#() '/*-)%9 *(0* *- .#$/# /()*'$0 7'>$7% +- '0+ %#-12+ #-2+ 4-) *#(7; 58 *'@$0,

*#($) -)+$0')8 &)'/*$/(% '% -5D(/*% -4 )(42(/*$-09 ]0+ *#( &-%$*$-0$0, -4 %15D(/*% *'@(% &2'/( '2-0, *.- &2'0(%9 /#'0,( $% 7')@(+ 58 +$%',)((7(0* '7-0,%* *#( &')*$/$&'0*% ')-10+ *#( $7&2$(+

7-+(2 -4 '&&)-&)$'*( )(%&-0%(X ?#-)$3-0*'2? &-%$*$-0$0, 7'8 -) 7'8 0-* ,(0()'*(',)((7(0* '5-1* *#( 2-/1% '0+ 0'*1)( -4 ?)(%&-0%$5$2$*8?9 L0 -*#() -//'%$-0% $0 *#(%( %-)*%

-4 +$%/1%%$-0%; $* $% &')*$/$&'0*% *#(7%(26(% .#- ?+-? 6()*$/'2 &-%$*$-0$0,; 58 $0*)-+1/$0,

(>'7&2(% '% +$2(77'% *- 5( *'2@(+ *#)-1,# 58 *#( ,)-1& &')*$/$&'0*%9 "#)-1,#-1* *#(4-/1% ,)-1& (>/#'0,(% ')-10+ *#(%( %-)*% -4 *-&$/%; .( 4$0+ &(-&2( ',)(($0, '0+

+$%',)(($0,; $0*)-+1/$0, *-&$/% $0*- /-06()%'*$-0% '% (>'7&2(% *- /-0%$+() 4)-7 +$44()(0*

'%&(/*%; '0+ /-0%$+()$0, *#( +$44()(0* )('%-0% *#(8 7$,#* #'6( 4-) '%%(0*$0, *- %-7($7&()'*$6(% '0+ +$%%(0*$0, 4)-7 -*#()%9

=( +-0?* .'0* *- 7'@( *-- 71/# -4 *#$% &$/*1)( -4 4-/1% ,)-1& &')*$/$&'0*% '% '/-22(/*$-0 -4 2$**2( N'5()7'%$'0%9 ]22 *#'* *#(%( .-7(0 ')( +-$0, $% %*)'$,#*4-).')+ 7-)'2

)('%-0$0,E *#(8 ')( '2$,0$0, (>*()0'228 '++)(%%(+ 0-)7% .$*# *#($) -.0 4)'7(% -4 7-)'2

'0+ &)'/*$/'2 )(4()(0/( '% ' &)(C/-0+$*$-0 4-) /-0%$+()$0, *#($) 6'2$+$*8 4-) *#(79 "#$% $% '

4-)7 -4 $0*()'/*$6(; D-$0* '/*$-09 ]0+ $* $% ' 4-)7 -4 )('%-0$0, *#'* *#(8 /'0; (6$+(0*28;

(0,',( $09 "#$% $% *#( *#(-)(*$/'2 2(%%-0 .( .'0* *- +()$6( 4)-7 *#(%( .-7(0 $0 [)$%*-2

+$%/1%%$0, .#(*#() -) 0-* *#(8 %#-12+ 518 #('6$28 &'/@',(+ &)-+1/*% $0 *#( %1&()7')@(*9I*#$/'2 /-0%17() /'7&'$,0$0, .-)@%; .( '),1(; 58 '++)(%%$0, /()*'$0 7-)'2 +$2(77'% *-

-)+$0')8 &(-&2(X *#( '**$*1+(% *#'* &(-&2( (>&)(%% '5-1* *#( *-&$/% )'$%(+ 58 *#(%(/'7&'$,0% $0 *1)0 0((+ *- 5( '0'283(+ $0 *#($) )#(*-)$/'2; '),17(0*'*$6( /-0*(>*; )'*#()

*#'0 '% (>&)(%%$-0% -4 &)(C(>$%*$0, 7-*$6'*$-0% -) 7-)'2 +$%&-%$*$-0% M[$22$, ^bbYR9

L1) )('%-0 4-) (7'%$3$0, *#$% &-$0*; '0+ 4-) 1%$0, $0*()'/*$6( *'2@C+'*' *- +- %-; $% *-%1,,(%* *#'* ,-6()0$0, *#)-1,# *#( '/*$-0 -4 0-)7% )(B1$)(% '0 '//-10* -4 #-. 0-)7% ')(

'/*(+ 1&-0 *#'* ,-(% 5(8-0+ ' %$7&2$%*$/ -&&-%$*$-0 -4 /-04-)7$*8 -) )(%$%*'0/(9 [8

+(4$0$*$-0; 0-)7% +- 0-* .-)@ 58 5($0, /-04-)7(+ *-X 0-) +-(% *#( -5%()6'*$-0 -4

&)'/*$/(% *#'* +- 0-* '//-)+ *- ,-6()0$0, 0-)7% $0+$/'*( *#( &)(%(0/( -4 )(%$%*'0/(

MK/H'8 OPPP; llR9 :* $% $7&-)*'0* *- #-2+ '&')* ?0-)7'*$6(? 4)-7 ?0-)7'2$3$0,?9 H-)7% +-


23/27

##

0-* /-7( .$*# $0%*)1/*$-0 2'5(2% )('+$0, aH-)7aE

a%$0/( 0-)7% ')( 0-* -5D(/*$6( +'*'; '0+ '% %1/# +$)(/*28 -5%()6'52(; *#(

(0-7(0' *- .#$/# *#(8 ,$6( )$%( ')( 0-* *#( %*'*$/ (0-7(0' -4 ' ?0-)7'2$*8?;

51* *#( +80'7$/ (0-7(0' -4 ' a0-)7'*$6$*8aa MK'/#()(8 ^bbd; ^^PR9

L1) )('%-0 4-) 2--@$0, '* *#( -)+$0')8 4-)7% -4 )('%-0$0, *#'* &(-&2( +(&2-8 .#(0/-04)-0*(+ .$*# +(7'0+% *- /-0%17( 7-)( ?)(%&-0%$528? $% *#'* $* #(2&% 5(**() 10+()%*'0+

*#( 7(+$17% -4 2'8 0-)7'*$6$*8 *#)-1,# .#$/# %1/# +(7'0+% -&()'*(E a"#()( $% '2.'8%

'0 (2(7(0* -4 *#( +$%/)(*$-0')8; (2'5-)'*$6(; '0+ '+ #-/ '5-1* #-. .( '&&28 )12(% '0+

%/#(7(%; 4-) *#(8 +- 0-* +(4$0( *#($) -.0 '&&2$/'*$-0%a MK/G')*#8 ^bbU; UPR9

H-)7% -028 410/*$-0 '% 0-)7% '* '22 5(/'1%( -4 *#( /'&'/$*$(% -4 &(-&2( *- )(42(/* -0%*)'*(,$(% '0+ +(4$0( -5D(/*$6(%; ' %(24C)(42(>$6( /'&'/$*8 *#'* $% /()*'$028 $0*()&)(*'*$6(;

51* '5-6( '22 $% /-7710$/'*$6( '0+ $0*()'/*$6(9 :* $% *#$% '%&(/* .#$/# *#( '0'28*$/% -4

,-6()07(0*'2$*8 -44()% 2$**2( #(2& $0 10+()%*'0+$0,9 J)(6'2(0* /-0%*)1/*$-0% -4 a?


24/27

#$

*#()( ')(; $0+((+; ' %(* -4 /-0*(7&-)')8 )'*$-0'2$*$(% '$7(+ '* ,-6()0$0, /-0%17&*$-0 $0

)(2'*$-0 *- &')*$/12') (0+%X *#'* *#(%( +- #(2& %1%*'$0 *#( ?)(%&-0%$5$2$3'*$-0? -4 $0+$6$+1'2%

'% /-0%17()%X '0+ *#'* *#(%( )'*$-0'2$*$(% 7$,#* 5( '0'283(+ $0 *()7% -4 *#( (*#$/'2

&)-52(7'*$%'*$-0 -4 /-0%17&*$-09 [1* -1) )(/-1)%( *- *#(%( $7$3(%9 "#(8

*(22 &(-&2( *#'* '% /-0%17()% *#(8 ')( %15D(/* *- ' 0(. )'0,( -4 7-)'2 )(%&-0%$5$2$*$(%; 51*

'2%- (7&-.()(+ *- '/* -0 *#(%( $0 0(.; $00-6'*$6( .'8%9 "#( +$%/1)%$6( &-%$*$-0$0,% -4?/-0%17()%? $0 *#$% %(/*-) .-)@ 58 &)-52(7'*$3$0, /-0%17&*$-0; 58 &)(%(0*$0, &(-&2(

.$*# +$2(77'% '0+ /-010+)17%X '0+ *#(8 &)(%17( ' /'&'/$*8 4-) -)+$0')8 7-)'2

)('%-0$0, *#'* /-0*(7&-)')8 /12*1)'2 '0+ %-/$'2 *#(-)8 $% -4*(0 2-'*# *- '/@0-.2(+,(9]0+ .#(0 .( *1)0 *- *#( .'8% $0 .#$/# &(-&2( )(%&-0+ *- *#(%( %-)*% -4 /'7&'$,0%; .(

4$0+ &(-&2( +(2$0('*$0, *#( '%&(/*% -4 *#($) 2$6(% *#'* *#(8 ')( .$22$0, '0+ &)'/*$/'228 '52(

*- &)-52(7'*$3( $0 *#( 78)$'+ .'8% *#'* $% 0-. '%@(+ -4 *#(79 =#(0 .( *'2@ *- &(-&2('5-1* .#'* *#(8 7'@( -4 *#(%( $0D10/*$-0% *- 518 4'$)*)'+( /-44(( -) -),'0$/ 6(, -)

5-8/-** H$@( -) )(/8/2( *#($) 5(() /'0% -) .(') .#$*( .)$%*5'0+%; .( +-0?* 4$0+ #()-$/'228

?'/*$6(? -) ?/)('*$6(? /-0%17()% -) &()4(/*28 6$)*1-1% /$*$3(0%9 =( 4$0+ &(-&2( .$*# 51%82$6(% '0+ *-)0 2-8'2*$(% '0+ 712*$&2( /-77$*7(0*% '0+ %/')/( )(%-1)/(% .#- +- .#'* *#(8

/'0; '0+ .#- )(%&-0+ &-%$*$6(28 *- $0$*$'*$6(% *- 7'@( *#(7 $0*- 7-)( ?)(%&-0%$52(

/-0%17()%? .#(0 *#$% /'0 5( 7'+( *- 4$* $0*- *#($) -0,-$0, (2'5-)'*$-0% -4 *#( %(249 ]0+

*#(%( (2'5-)'*$-0% 2--@ ' 2-* 7-)( 2$@( &)'/*$/'2 '0+ 0'))'*$6( '/#$(6(7(0*% -4 ?,--+

(0-1,# 7-)'2$*$(%? MA7')* '0+ H('2( ^bbcR *#'0 *#( /$)/12') )(/-,0$*$-0 (44(/*% -4 &-%*C

]2*#1%%()$'0; &-%*C


25/27

#%

'0+ #-)$3-0*'2 &-%$*$-0$0,% -4 $0*()'/*$0, %15D(/*%9 [1*


26/27

#&

&"*"+4 '*/ L"&$)%4 UU; OccCUPO9

N'0%%(0; [9 MOPPPR9 K3$%$W2) "0 S$"#)*&)9 V-0+-0E Z-1*2(+,(9N'))o; Z9 M^bb^R9 S"#( +$%/1)%$6( &)-+1/*$-0 -4 %(26(%T; 9.)"34 '*/ ;14&."#"64 ^; Q^CYU9

N'))$%-0; Z9; H(.#-27; "9; '0+ A#'.; f9 MOPPQR9 9.) >%.$&'# K"*12+)3 9 V-0+-0E A',(9

N-+,(%; :9 MOPPWR9 SK-6$0, 5(8-0+ .-)+%E *#()'&(1*$/ +$%/-1)%( '0+ (*#$/'2

&)-52(7'*$3'*$-0T; N$1&"231) L%2/$)1 W; WQQCWcb9N-00(*#; ]9 M^bb^R9 9.) K3$%$W2) "0 ;"8)3 9 G'75)$+,( K]E K:" J)(%%9

j'/@%-0; "9 MOPPWR9


27/27

#'

O)1)'3&.; YdEO; UcbCbY9

K$22(); J9 '0+ L?V(')8; "9 M^bdcR9 ?]//-10*$0, '0+ *#( /-0%*)1/*$-0 -4 *#( ,-6()0'52(

&()%-0?; :&&"2*%$*6F R36'*$7'%$"*1 '*/ L"&$)%4 ^OMUR; OUQCOYQ9

K$22(); J9 '0+ Z-%(; H9 M^bbcR9TK-5$2$3$0, *#( /-0%17()E '%%(752$0, *#( %15D(/* -4

/-0%17&*$-0T 9.)"34F K2#%23) '*/ L"&$)%4 ^W; ^CUY9K$*/#(22; `9 MOPPUR9 ? I+1/'*$0, *#( 0'*$-0'2 /$*$3(0 $0 0(-2$5()'2 *$7(%E *5$3"*+)*%'# $**"5'%$"* $* %.) 2%$#$%4 $*/21%3$)19 V-0+-0E I')*#%/'09='2@()+$0(; m9 MOPPQR9 ?

Elusive Subjects Revised April 06

Documents

Transcript of Elusive Subjects Revised April 06