Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

31
Project Gutenberg's Ezra Pound: His Metric and Poetry, by T.S. Eliot #5 in our series by T.S. Eliot o!yrig"t las are c"anging all o$er t"e orld. %e sure to c"ec& t"e co!yrig"t las or your country beore donloading or redistributing t"is or any ot"er Project Gutenberg e%oo&. T"is "eader s"ould be t"e irst t"ing seen "en $ieing t"is Project Gutenberg ile. Please do not re(o$e it. )o not c"ange or edi t t"e "eader it"out ritten !er(ission. Please read t"e *legal s(all !rint,* and ot"er inor(ation about t"e e%oo& and Project Gutenberg at t"e botto( o t"is ile. +ncluded is i(!ortant inor(ation about your s!eciic rig"ts and restrictions in "o t"e ile (ay be used. ou can also ind out about "o to (a&e a donation to Project Gutenberg, and "o to get in$ol$ed. --elco(e To T"e orld o /ree Plain 0anilla Electronic Te1ts-- --e%oo&s 2eadable %y %ot" Hu(ans and %y o(!uters, Since 343-- -----T"ese e%oo&s ere Pre!ared %y T"ousands o 0olunteers6----- Title: Ezra Pound: His Metric and Poetry 7ut"or: T.S. Eliot 2elease )ate: 8anuary, 95 ;E%oo& #95< ;es, e are (ore t"an one year a"ead o sc"edule< ;T"is ile as irst !osted on 7!ril =, 9>< Edition: 3 ?anguage: Englis" "aracter set encoding: 7S++ --- ST72T @/ THE P2@8ET GATEB%E2G E%@@C ED27 P@AB): H+S MET2+ 7B) P@ET2 --- Produced by 7ndrea %all, )a$id Starner, "arles /ran&s, 8uliet Sut"erland, and t"e @nline )istributed Prooreading Tea(

Transcript of Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 1/31

Project Gutenberg's Ezra Pound: His Metric and Poetry, by T.S. Eliot#5 in our series by T.S. Eliot

o!yrig"t las are c"anging all o$er t"e orld. %e sure to c"ec& t"eco!yrig"t las or your country beore donloading or redistributing

t"is or any ot"er Project Gutenberg e%oo&.

T"is "eader s"ould be t"e irst t"ing seen "en $ieing t"is ProjectGutenberg ile. Please do not re(o$e it. )o not c"ange or edit t"e"eader it"out ritten !er(ission.

Please read t"e *legal s(all !rint,* and ot"er inor(ation about t"ee%oo& and Project Gutenberg at t"e botto( o t"is ile. +ncluded isi(!ortant inor(ation about your s!eciic rig"ts and restrictions in"o t"e ile (ay be used. ou can also ind out about "o to (a&e adonation to Project Gutenberg, and "o to get in$ol$ed.

--elco(e To T"e orld o /ree Plain 0anilla Electronic Te1ts--

--e%oo&s 2eadable %y %ot" Hu(ans and %y o(!uters, Since 343--

-----T"ese e%oo&s ere Pre!ared %y T"ousands o 0olunteers6-----

Title: Ezra Pound: His Metric and Poetry

7ut"or: T.S. Eliot

2elease )ate: 8anuary, 95 ;E%oo& #95<;es, e are (ore t"an one year a"ead o sc"edule<;T"is ile as irst !osted on 7!ril =, 9><

Edition: 3

?anguage: Englis"

"aracter set encoding: 7S++

--- ST72T @/ THE P2@8ET GATEB%E2G E%@@C ED27 P@AB): H+S MET2+7B) P@ET2 ---

Produced by 7ndrea %all, )a$id Starner, "arles /ran&s,8uliet Sut"erland, and t"e @nline )istributed Prooreading Tea(

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 2/31

ED27 P@AB)

H+S MET2+ 7B) P@ET2

%@@CS % ED27 P@AB)

P2@0EB7, being !oe(s selected ro( Personae, E1ultations, andanzoniere. S(all, Maynard, %oston, 343F

THE SP+2+T @/ 2@M7BE: 7n atte(!t to deine so(e"at t"e c"ar(o t"e !rerenaissance literature o ?atinEuro!e. )ent,?ondon, 343 and )utton, Be or&F

THE S@BBETS 7B) %7??7TE @/ GA+)@ 707?7BT+. S(all, Maynard,%oston, 3439F

2+P@STES. Sit, ?ondon, 3439 and Mat"es, ?ondon, 343>F

)ES +M7G+STES: 7n ant"ology o t"e +(agists, Ezra Pound,7ldington, 7(y ?oell, /ord Maddo1 Hueer, and ot"ers

G7A)+E2%2DESC7: 7 (e(oir. 8o"n ?ane, ?ondon and Be or&,343=F

 B@H: 7 study o t"e lassical Stage o 8a!an it" Ernest/enollosa. 7lred 7. Cno!, Be or&, 343 and Mac(illan,?ondon, 343F

?AST27 it" Earlier Poe(s. 7lred 7. Cno!, Be or&, 343F

P707BBES 7H) )+0+S+@BS. Prose. +n !re!aration: 7lred 7. Cno!, Be or&F

ED27 P@AB)

H+S MET2+ 7B) P@ET2

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 3/31

+

*7ll tal& on (odern !oetry, by !eo!le "o &no,* rote Mr. arlSandburg in IPoetryI, *ends it" dragging in Ezra Poundso(e"ere. He (ay be na(ed only to be cursed as anton and(oc&er, !oseur, triler and $agrant. @r "e (ay be classed asilling a nic"e today li&e t"at o Ceats in a !receding e!oc".T"e !oint is, "e ill be (entioned.*

T"is is a si(!le state(ent o act. %ut t"oug" Mr. Pound is ell&non, e$en "a$ing been t"e $icti( o inter$ies or Sunday !a!ers, it does not ollo t"at "is or& is t"oroug"ly &non.T"ere are tenty !eo!le "o "a$e t"eir o!inion o "i( or e$eryone "o "as read "is ritings it" any care. @ t"ose tenty,t"ere ill be so(e "o are s"oc&ed, so(e "o are ruled, so(e"o are irritated, and one or to "ose sense o dignity isoutraged. T"e tentyirst critic ill !robably be one "o &nosand ad(ires so(e o t"e !oe(s, but "o eit"er says: *Pound is !ri(arily a sc"olar, a translator,* or *Pound's early $erse as beautiul "is later or& s"os not"ing better t"an t"e itc" or ad$ertise(ent, a (isc"ie$ous desire to be annoying, or ac"ildis" desire to be original.* T"ere is a t"ird ty!e o reader, rare enoug", "o "as !ercei$ed Mr. Pound or so(e years,"o "as olloed "is career intelligently, and "o recognizesits consistency.

T"is essay is not ritten or t"e irst tenty critics o literature, nor or t"at rare tentysecond "o "as just been(entioned, but or t"e ad(irer o a !oe( "ere or t"ere, "osea!!reciation is ca!able o yielding "i( a larger return. + t"ereader is already at t"e stage "ere "e can (aintain at once t"eto !ro!ositions, *Pound is (erely a sc"olar* and *Pound is(erely a yello journalist,* or t"e ot"er to !ro!ositions,*Pound is (erely a tec"nician* and *Pound is (erely a !ro!"et o c"aos,* t"en t"ere is $ery little "o!e. %ut t"ere are readers o  !oetry "o "a$e not yet reac"ed t"is "y!ertro!"y o t"e logicalaculty t"eir attention (ig"t be arrested, not by an outbursto !raise, but by a si(!le state(ent. T"e !resent essay ai(s(erely at suc" a state(ent. +t is not intended to be eit"er a biogra!"ical or a critical study. +t ill not dilate u!on*beauties* it is a su((ary account o ten years' or& in !oetry. T"e citations ro( re$ies ill !er"a!s sti(ulate t"ereader to or( "is on o!inion. e do not is" to or( it or 

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 4/31

"i(. Bor s"all e enter into ot"er !"ases o Mr. Pound'sacti$ity during t"is ten years "is ritings and $ies on artand (usic t"oug" t"ese ould ta&e an i(!ortant !lace in anyco(!re"ensi$e biogra!"y.

++

Pound's irst boo& as !ublis"ed in 0enice. 0enice as a "alting !oint ater "e "ad let 7(erica and beore "e "ad settled inEngland, and "ere, in 34J, *7 ?u(e S!ento* a!!eared. T"e$olu(e is no a rarity o literature it as !ublis"ed by t"eaut"or and (ade at a 0enetian !ress "ere t"e aut"or as able !ersonally to su!er$ise t"e !rinting on !a!er "ic" as are(ainder o a su!!ly "ic" "ad been used or a History o t"e"urc". Pound let 0enice in t"e sa(e year, and too& *7 ?u(eS!ento* it" "i( to ?ondon. +t as not to be e1!ected t"at airst boo& o $erse, !ublis"ed by an un&non 7(erican in 0enice,s"ould attract (uc" attention. T"e *E$ening Standard* "as t"edistinction o "a$ing noticed t"e $olu(e, in a re$ie su((ing itu! as:

  ild and "aunting stu, absolutely !oetic, original,  i(aginati$e, !assionate, and s!iritual. T"ose "o do not  consider it crazy (ay ell consider it ins!ired. o(ing  ater t"e trite and decorous $erse o (ost o our decorous  !oets, t"is !oet see(s li&e a (instrel o Pro$ence at a  suburban (usical e$ening.... T"e unseizable (agic o !oetry  is in t"e Kueer !a!er $olu(e, and ords are no good in  describing it.

7s t"e c"ie !oe(s in *7 ?u(e S!ento* ere aterardsincor!orated in *Personae,* t"e boo& de(ands (ention only as adate in t"e aut"or's "istory. *Personae,* t"e irst boo&  !ublis"ed in ?ondon, olloed early in 344. /e !oets "a$eunderta&en t"e siege o ?ondon it" so little bac&ing e boo&so $erse "a$e e$er oed t"eir success so !urely to t"eir on(erits. Pound ca(e to ?ondon a co(!lete stranger, it"out eit"er literary !atronage or inancial (eans. He too& *Personae* to Mr.El&in Mat"es, "o "as t"e glory o "a$ing !ublis"ed eats'*ind 7(ong t"e 2eeds,* and t"e *%oo&s o t"e 2"y(ers' lub,* in"ic" (any o t"e !oets o t"e '4s, no a(ous, ound a !lace.Mr. Mat"es irst suggested, as as natural to an un&nonaut"or, t"at t"e aut"or s"ould bear !art o t"e cost o  !rinting. *+ "a$e a s"illing in (y !oc&et, i t"at is any use to

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 5/31

you,* said t"e latter. *ell,* said Mr. Mat"es, *+ ant to !ublis" it anyay.* His acu(en as justiied. T"e boo& as, itis true, recei$ed it" o!!osition, but it as recei$ed. T"ereere a e a!!reciati$e critics, notably Mr. Edard T"o(as, t"e !oet &non also as *Edard Eastaay* "e "as since been &illed

in /ranceF. T"o(as, riting in t"e *Englis" 2e$ie* t"en in its brig"test days under t"e editors"i! o /ord Mado1 HueerF,recognized t"e irst"and intensity o eeling in *Personae*:

  He "as ... "ardly any o t"e su!ericial good Kualities o   (odern $ersiiers.... He "as not t"e current (elanc"oly or   resignation or unillingness to li$e nor t"e &ind o   eeling or nature "ic" runs to (inute descri!tion and  decorati$e (eta!"or. He cannot be useully co(!ared it" any  li$ing riters... ull o !ersonality and it" suc" !oer   to e1!ress it, t"at ro( t"e irst to t"e last lines o (ost  o "is !oe(s "e "olds us steadily in "is on !ure gra$e,  !assionate orld.... T"e beauty o it +n Praise o soltF  is t"e beauty o !assion, sincerity and intensity, not o   beautiul ords and i(ages and suggestions ... t"e t"oug"t  do(inates t"e ords and is greater t"an t"ey are. Here  +dyll or GlaucusF t"e eect is ull o "u(an !assion and  natural (agic, it"out any o t"e !"rases "ic" a reader o   (odern $erse ould e1!ect in t"e treat(ent o suc" a  subject.

Mr. Scott 8a(es, in t"e *)aily Bes,* s!ea&s in !raise o "is(etres:

  7t irst t"e "ole t"ing (ay see( to be (ere (adness and  r"etoric, a $ain e1"ibition o orce and !assion it"out  beauty. %ut, as e read on, t"ese curious (etres o "is see(  to "a$e a la and order o t"eir on t"e brute orce o Mr.  Pound's i(agination see(s to i(!art so(e Kuality o   inectious beauty to "is ords. So(eti(es t"ere is a strange  beating o ana!aests "en "e Kuic&ens to "is subject again  and again "e une1!ectedly ends a line it" t"e second "al   o a re$erberant "e1a(eter:

  */les" s"rouded, bearing t"e secret.*

  ... 7nd a e lines later co(es an e1a(!le o "is a$ourite  use o s!ondee, olloed by dactyl and s!ondee, "ic" co(es  in strangely and, as e irst read it, it" t"e a!!earance  o discord, but aterards see(s to gain a curious and  distincti$e $igour:

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 6/31

  *Eyes, drea(s, li!s, and t"e nig"t goes.*

  7not"er line li&e t"e end o a "e1a(eter is

  *%ut i e'er + co(e to (y lo$e's land.*

%ut e$en so a$ourable a critic !auses to re(ar& t"at

  He bales us by arc"aic ords and una(iliar (etres "e  oten see(s to be scorning t"e li(itations o or( and  (etre, brea&ing out into any sort o e1!ression "ic" suits  itsel to "is (ood.

and counsels t"e !oet to *"a$e a little (ore res!ect or "isart.*

+t is, in act, just t"is ada!tability o (etre to (ood,an ada!tability due to an intensi$e study o (etre, t"atconstitutes an i(!ortant ele(ent in Pound's tec"niKue. /ereaders ere !re!ared to acce!t or ollo t"e a(ount o erudition "ic" entered into *Personae* and its close successor,*E1ultations,* or to de$ote t"e care to reading t"e( "ic" t"eyde(and. +t is "ere t"at (any "a$e been led astray. Pound is notone o t"ose !oets "o (a&e no de(and o t"e reader and t"ecasual reader o $erse, disconcerted by t"e dierence beteenPound's !oetry and t"at on "ic" "is taste "as been trained,attributes "is on diiculties to e1cessi$e sc"olars"i! on t"e !art o t"e aut"or. *T"is,* "e ill say o so(e o t"e !oe(s inPro$encal or( or on Pro$encal subjects, *is arc"aeology itreKuires &noledge on t"e !art o its reader, and true !oetrydoes not reKuire suc" &noledge.* %ut to dis!lay &noledge isnot t"e sa(e t"ing as to e1!ect it on t"e !art o t"e readerand o t"is sort o !edantry Pound is Kuite ree. He is, it istrue, one o t"e (ost learned o !oets. +n 7(erica "e "ad ta&enu! t"e study o 2o(ance ?anguages it" t"e intention o teac"ing. 7ter or& in S!ain and +taly, ater !ursuing t"ePro$encal $erb ro( Milan to /reiburg, "e deserted t"e t"esison ?o!e de 0ega and t"e P".). and t"e !roessorial c"air,and elected to re(ain in Euro!e. Mr. Pound "as s!o&en out"is (ind ro( ti(e to ti(e on t"e subject o sc"olars"i! in7(erican uni$ersities, its deadness, its isolation ro( genuinea!!reciation, and t"e acti$e creati$e lie o literature. He "asalays been ready to battle against !edantry. 7s or "is onlearning, "e "as studied !oetry careully, and "as (ade use o "is study in "is on $erse. *Personae* and *E1ultations*s"o "is talent or turning "is studies to account. He assu!ersaturated in Pro$ence "e "ad tra(!ed o$er (ost o t"e

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 7/31

country and t"e lie o t"e courts "ere t"e Troubadourst"ronged as !art o "is on lie to "i(. et, t"oug" *Personae*and *E1ultations* do e1act so(et"ing ro( t"e reader, t"ey donot reKuire a &noledge o Pro$encal or o S!anis" or +talian.0ery e !eo!le &no t"e 7rt"urian legends ell, or e$en Malory

i t"ey did t"ey (ig"t realize t"at t"e +dylls o t"e Cing are"ardly (ore i(!ortant t"an a !arody, or a *"aucer retold or "ildren*F but no one accuses Tennyson o needing ootnotes, or o su!erciliousness toard t"e uninstructed. T"e dierence is(erely in "at !eo!le are !re!ared or (ost readers could no(ore relate t"e (yt" o 7tys correctly t"an t"ey could gi$e a biogra!"y o %ertrand de %orn. +t is "ardly too (uc" to say t"att"ere is no !oe( in t"ese $olu(es o Mr. Pound "ic" needsuller e1!lanation t"an "e gi$es "i(sel. "at t"e !oe(s doreKuire is a trained ear, or at least t"e illingness to betrained.

T"e (etres and t"e use o language are una(iliar. T"ere arecertain traces o (odern inluence. e cannot agree it" Mr.Scott8a(es t"at a(ong t"ese are *. E. Henley, Ci!ling,"atterton, and es!ecially alt "it(an*least o all alt"it(an. Probably t"ere are only to: eats and %roning. eatsin *?a /raisne,* in *Personae,* or instance, in t"e attitudeand so(e"at in t"e $ocabulary:

  + ra!!ed (y tears in an ellu( lea   7nd let t"e( under a stone,  7nd no (en call (e (ad because + "a$e t"ron  7ll olly ro( (e, !utting it aside  To lea$e t"e old barren ays o (en ...

/or %roning, Mr. Pound "as alays !roessed strong ad(irationsee *Mes(eris(* in *Personae*F t"ere are traces o "i( in*ino* and */a(a( ?ibrosKue ano,* in t"e sa(e $olu(e. %ut it is(ore !roitable to co((ent u!on t"e $ariety o (etres and t"eoriginal use o language.

Ezra Pound "as been at"ered it" $ers libre in Englis", it"all its $ices and $irtues. T"e ter( is a loose oneany $erse iscalled *ree* by !eo!le "ose ears are not accusto(ed to itint"e second !lace, Pound's use o t"is (ediu( "as s"on t"ete(!erance o t"e artist, and "is belie in it as a $e"icle isnot t"at o t"e anatic. He "as said "i(sel t"at "en one "ast"e !ro!er (aterial or a sonnet, one s"ould use t"e sonnetor( but t"at it "a!!ens $ery rarely to any !oet to ind"i(sel in !ossession o just t"e bloc& o stu "ic" can !erectly be (odelled into t"e sonnet. +t is true t"at u! to

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 8/31

$ery recently it as i(!ossible to get ree $erse !rinted in any !eriodical e1ce!t t"ose in "ic" Pound "ad inluence andt"at no it is !ossible to !rint ree $erse second, t"ird, or tent"rateF in al(ost any 7(erican (agazine. "o is res!onsibleor t"e bad ree $erse is a Kuestion o no i(!ortance, inas(uc"

as its aut"ors ould "a$e ritten bad $erse in any or( Pound"as at least t"e rig"t to be judged by t"e success or ailure o "is on. Pound's $ers libre is suc" as is only !ossible or a !oet "o "as or&ed tirelessly it" rigid or(s and dierentsyste(s o (etric. His *anzoni* are in a ay aside ro( "isdirect line o !rogress t"ey are (uc" (ore nearly studies in(ediae$al a!!reciation t"an any o "is ot"er $erse but t"ey areinteresting, a!art ro( t"eir (erit, as s"oing t"e !oet at or& it" t"e (ost intricate Pro$encal or(sso intricate t"at t"e !attern cannot be e1"ibited it"out Kuoting an entire !oe(. M.8ean de %ossc"ere, "ose /renc" is translated in t"e *Egoist,*"as already called attention to t"e act t"at Pound as t"eirst riter in Englis" to use i$e Pro$encal or(s.F Luotationill s"o, "oe$er, t"e great $ariety o r"yt"( "ic" Pound(anages to introduce into t"e ordinary ia(bic !enta(eter:

  T"y gracious ays,  @ lady o (y "eart, "a$e  @'er all (y t"oug"t t"eir golden gla(our cast  7s a(ber torc"la(es, "ere strange (enatar(s  Tread sotly 'neat" t"e da(as& s"ield o nig"t,  2ise ro( t"e loing steel in !art relected,  So on (y (ailed t"oug"t t"at it" t"ee goet",  T"oug" dar& t"e ay, a golden gla(our allet".

it"in t"e ia(bic li(its, t"ere are no to lines in t"e "ole !oe( t"at "a$e an identical r"yt"(.

e turn ro( t"is to a !oe( in *E1ultations,* t"e *Big"t?itany*:

  @ God, "at great &indness  "a$e e done in ti(es !ast  and orgotten it,  T"at t"ou gi$est t"is onder unto us,  @ God o aters

  @ God o t"e nig"t  "at great sorro  o(et" unto us,  T"at t"ou t"us re!ayest us  %eore t"e ti(e o its co(ing

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 9/31

T"ere is e$ident, and (ore strongly in certain later !oe(s, atendency toard Kuantitati$e (easure. Suc" a *reedo(* as t"islays so "ea$y a burden u!on e$ery ord in a line t"at it beco(esi(!ossible to rite li&e S"elley, lea$ing blan&s or t"e

adjecti$es, or li&e Sinburne, "ose adjecti$es are !ractically blan&s. @t"er !oets "a$e (ani!ulated a great $ariety o (etresand or(s but e "a$e studied t"e or(s and (etres "ic" t"eyuse so careully as "as Pound. His ballad o t"e *Goodly /ere*s"os great &noledge o t"e ballad or(:

  + "a' seen "i( co a t"ousand (en  @n t"e "ills o' Galilee,  T"ey "ined as "e al&ed out cal( beteen  i' "is eyes li&e t"e grey o' t"e sea.

  ?i&e t"e sea t"at broo&s no $oyaging  it" t"e inds unleas"ed and ree,  ?i&e t"e sea t"at "e coed at Genseret  i' tey ords s!o&e suddently.

  7 (aster o (en as t"e Goodly /ere  7 (ate o t"e ind and sea,  + t"ey t"in& t"ey "a' slain our Goodly /ere  T"ey are ools eternally.

  + "a' seen "i( eat o' t"e "oneyco(b  Sin' t"ey nailed "i( to t"e tree.

7nd ro( t"is e turn to a $ery dierent or( in t"e*7ltaorte,* "ic" is !er"a!s t"e best sestina t"at "as been ritten in Englis":

  )a(n it all6 all t"is our Sout" stin&s !eace.  ou "oreson dog, Pa!iols, co(e6 let's to (usic6  + "a$e no lie sa$e "en t"e sords clas".  %ut a"6 "en + see t"e standards gold, $air, !ur!le, o!!osing,  7nd t"e broad ields beneat" t"e( turn cri(son,  T"en "ol + (y "eart nig" (ad it" rejoicing.

  +n "ot su((er "a$e + great rejoicing  "en t"e te(!ests &ill t"e eart"'s oul !eace,  7nd t"e lig"tnings ro( blac& "ea$en las" cri(son,  7nd t"e ierce t"unders roar (e t"eir (usic  7nd t"e inds s"rie& t"roug" t"e clouds (ad, o!!osing,  7nd t"roug" all t"e ri$en s&ies God's sords clas".

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 10/31

+ "a$e Kuoted to $erses to s"o t"e intricacy o t"e !attern.

T"e Pro$encal canzon, li&e t"e Elizabet"an lyric, as rittenor (usic. Mr. Pound "as (ore recently insisted, in a series o articles on t"e or& o 7rnold )ol(etsc", in t"e *Egoist,* on

t"e i(!ortance o a study o (usic or t"e !oet.

  - - - - -

Suc" a relation beteen !oetry and (usic is $ery dierent ro("at is called t"e *(usic* o S"elley or Sinburne, a (usicoten nearer to r"etoric or t"e art o t"e oratorF t"an to t"einstru(ent. /or !oetry to a!!roac" t"e condition o (usicPound Kuotes a!!ro$ingly t"e dictu( o PaterF it is notnecessary t"at !oetry s"ould be destitute o (eaning. +nstead o slig"tly $eiled and resonant abstractions, li&e

  Ti(e it" a git o tears,  Grie it" a glass t"at ran

o Sinburne, or t"e (ossiness o Mallar(e, Pound's $erse isalays deinite and concrete, because "e "as alays a deinitee(otion be"ind it.

  T"oug" +'$e roa(ed t"roug" (any !laces,  Bone t"ere is t"at (y "eart troet"  /air as t"at "erein air groet"  @ne "ose laud "ere interlaces  Tuneul ords, t"at +'$e essayed.  ?et t"is tune be gently !layed  "ic" (y $oice "erard u!raises.

7t t"e end o t"is !oe( t"e aut"or a!!ends t"e note:

  T"e or( and (easure are t"ose o Piere 0idal's *I7b  l'alen tir $as (e l'aireI.* T"e song is it only to be  sung, and is not to be s!o&en.

T"ere are, "ere and t"ere, deliberate arc"ais(s or odditiese.g., *"erard*F t"ere are deliberately arbitrary i(ages,"a$ing t"eir !lace in t"e total eect o t"e !oe(:

  2ed lea t"at art blon u!ard and out and o$er   T"e green s"ea o t"e orld ...

  T"e lotos t"at !ours

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 11/31

  Her ragrance into t"e !ur!le cu! ...

  %lac& lig"tning ... in a (ore recent !oe(F

 but no ord is e$er c"osen (erely or t"e tin&le eac" "as

alays its !art in !roducing an i(!ression "ic" is !roducedalays t"roug" language. ords are !er"a!s t"e "ardest o all (aterial o art: or t"ey (ust be used to e1!ress bot"$isual beauty and beauty o sound, as ell as co((unicatinga gra((atical state(ent. +t ould be interesting to co(!arePound's use o i(ages it" Mallar(e's + t"in& it ill be oundt"at t"e or(er's, by t"e contrast, ill a!!ear alays s"ar! inoutline, e$en i arbitrary and not !"otogra!"ic. Suc" i(ages ast"ose Kuoted abo$e are as !recise in t"eir ay as

  Sur le Boel, (orte saison,  ?orsKue les lou!s $i$ent de $ent ...

and t"e rest o t"at (e(orable Testa(ent.

So (uc" or t"e i(agery. 7s to t"e *reedo(* o "is $erse, Pound"as (ade se$eral state(ents in "is articles on )ol(etsc" "ic"are to t"e !oint:

  7ny or& o art is a co(!ound o reedo( and order. +t is  !erectly ob$ious t"at art "angs beteen c"aos on t"e one  side and (ec"anics on t"e ot"er. 7 !edantic insistence u!on  detail tends to dri$e out *(ajor or(.* 7 ir( "old on (ajor   or( (a&es or a reedo( o detail. +n !ainting (en intent  on (inutiae gradually lost t"e sense o or( and or(  co(bination. 7n atte(!t to restore t"is sense is branded as  *re$olution.* +t is re$olution in t"e !"ilological sense o   t"e ter(....

  7rt is a de!arture ro( i1ed !ositions elicitous  de!arture ro( a nor(....

T"e reedo( o Pound's $erse is rat"er a state o tension due toconstant o!!osition beteen ree and strict. T"ere are not, as a(atter o act, to &inds o $erse, t"e strict and t"e reet"ere is only a (astery "ic" co(es o being so ell trainedt"at or( is an instinct and can be ada!ted to t"e !articular  !ur!ose in "and.

  - - - - -

7ter *E1ultations* ca(e t"e translation o t"e *Sonnets and

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 12/31

%allate o Guido a$alcanti.* +t is ort" noting t"at t"e riter o a long re$ie in t"e *ILuestI*s!ea&ing in !raise o t"etranslation, yet ound ault it" t"e aut"or not on t"e groundo e1cessi$e (ediae$alis(, but because

  "e is concerned rat"er it" t"e uture t"an it" a so(e"at  re(ote !ast, so t"at in s!ite o "is lo$e or t"e (ediae$al  !oets, "is $ery acco(!lis"(ent as a distinctly (odern !oet  (a&es against "is success as a "olly acce!table translator   o a$alcanti, t"e "eir o t"e Troubadours, t"e sc"olastic.

et t"e I)aily BesI, in criticising *anzoni,* "ad re(ar&edt"at Mr. Pound

  see(s to us rat"er a sc"olar t"an a !oet, and e s"ould li&e  to see "i( gi$ing "is unusual talent (ore to direct  translation ro( t"e Pro$encal.

and Mr. 8. . SKuire no t"e literary editor o t"e IBeStates(anIF, in an a!!reciati$e re$ie in t"e IBe 7geI, "adcounselled t"e !oet t"at "e ould

  gain and not lose i "e could orget all about t"e !oets o   )ante's day, t"eir roses and t"eir la(es, t"eir gold and  t"eir alcons, and t"eir literary a(orousness, and al& out  o t"e library into t"e res" air.

+n *2i!ostes* t"ere are traces o a dierent idio(.Su!ericially, t"e or& (ay a!!ear less i(!ortant. T"e dictionis (ore restrained, t"e lig"ts s"orter, t"e de1terity o tec"niKue is less arresting. %y ro(antic readers t"e boo& ould be considered less *!assionate.* %ut t"ere is a (uc" (ore solidsubstratu( to t"is boo& t"ere is (ore t"oug"t greater de!t",i less agitation on t"e surace. T"e eect o ?ondon isa!!arent t"e aut"or "as beco(e a critic o (en, sur$eying t"e(ro( a consistent and de$elo!ed !oint o $ie "e is (oreor(idable and disconcerting in s"ort, (uc" (ore (ature.T"at "e abandons not"ing o "is tec"nical s&ill is e$ident ro(t"e translation ro( t"e 7ngloSa1on, t"e *Seaarer.* +t isnot a slig"t ac"ie$e(ent to "a$e broug"t to lie alliterati$e$erse: !er"a!s t"e *Seaarer* is t"e only successul !iece o alliterati$e $erse e$er ritten in (odern Englis" alliterati$e$erse "ic" is not (erely a cle$er tour de orce, but "ic"suggests t"e !ossibility o a ne de$elo!(ent o t"is or(. Mr.2ic"ard 7ldington "ose on acco(!lis"(ents as a riter o $erslibre Kualiy "i( to s!ea&F called t"e !oe( *unsur!assed andunsur!assable,* and a riter in t"e IBe 7geI a literary organ

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 13/31

"ic" "as alays been strongly o!!osed to (etrical inno$ationsFcalled it *one o t"e inest literary or&s o art !roduced inEngland during t"e last ten years.* 7nd t"e roug", stern beautyo t"e 7ngloSa1on, e (ay re(ar&, is at t"e o!!osite !ole ro(t"at o t"e Pro$encal and +talian !oets to "o( Pound "ad

 !re$iously de$oted "is attention.

  May + or (y on sel song's trut" rec&on,  8ourney's jargon, "o + in "ars" days  Hards"i! endured ot.

%ut e can notice in *2i!ostes* ot"er e$idences t"an o $ersatility only certain !oe(s s"o Mr. Pound turning to (ore(odern subjects, as in t"e *Portrait d'une e((e,* or t"e(ordant e!igra(, *7n @bject.* Many readers are a!t to conuset"e (aturing o !ersonality it" desiccation o t"e e(otions.T"ere is no desiccation in *2i!ostes.* T"is s"ould be e$ident toanyone "o reads careully suc" a !oe( as *7 Girl.* e Kuote itentire it"out co((ent.

  T"e tree "as entered (y "ands,  T"e sa! "as ascended (y ar(s,  T"e tree "as gron in (y breast  )onard,  T"e branc"es gro out o (e, li&e ar(s.

  Tree you are,  Moss you are,  ou are $iolets it" ind abo$e t"e(.  7 c"ildIsoI "ig"you are,  7nd all t"is is olly to t"e orld.

*T"e 2eturn* is an i(!ortant study in $erse "ic" is reallyKuantitati$e. e Kuote only a e lines:

  See, t"ey return a", see t"e tentati$e  Mo$e(ents, and t"e slo eet,  T"e trouble in t"e !ace and t"e uncertain  a$ering6

*2i!ostes* belongs to t"e !eriod "en Mr. Pound as beingattac&ed because o "is !ro!aganda. He beca(e &non as t"ein$entor o *+(agis(,* and later, as t"e *Hig" Priest o 0orticis(.* 7s a (atter o act, t"e actual *!ro!aganda* o Mr.Pound "as been $ery s(all in Kuantity. T"e i(!ression "ic" "is !ersonality (ade, "oe$er, is suggested by t"e olloing note in*IPunc"I,* "ic" is alays a !retty reliable baro(eter o t"e

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 14/31

Englis" (iddleclass Grin:

  Mr. el&in Mar& e1actly o!!osite ?ong 8ane'sF begs to  announce t"at "e "as secured or t"e Englis" (ar&et t"e  !al!itating or&s o t"e ne Montana A.S.7.F !oet, Mr.

  Eze&iel Ton, "o is t"e (ost re(ar&able t"ing in !oetry  since 2obert %roning. Mr. Ton, "o "as let 7(erica to  reside or a "ile in ?ondon and i(!ress "is !ersonality on  Englis" editors, !ublis"ers and readers, is by ar t"e  neest !oet going, "ate$er ot"er ad$ertise(ents (ay say. He  "as succeeded, "ere all ot"ers "a$e ailed, in e$ol$ing a  blend o t"e i(agery o t"e unettered est, t"e $ocabulary  o ardour Street, and t"e sinister abandon o %orgiac  +taly.

+n 343>, so(eone riting to t"e Be or& IBationI ro( t"eAni$ersity o +llinois, illustrates t"e 7(erican, (ore serious,disa!!ro$al. T"is riter begins by e1!ressing "is objections tot"e *!rinci!le o /uturis(.* Pound "as !er"a!s done (ore t"ananyone to &ee! /uturis( out o England. His antagonis( to t"is(o$e(ent as t"e irst "ic" as not due (erely to unintelligentdisli&e or anyt"ing ne, and as due to "is !erce!tion t"at/uturis( as inco(!atible it" any !rinci!les o or(. +n "ison ords, /uturis( is *accelerated i(!ressionis(.*F T"e riter in t"e IBationI t"en goes on to analyze t"e (odern *"y!ertro!"yo ro(anticis(* into

  T"e e1aggeration o t"e i(!ortance o a !ersonal e(otion.  T"e abandon(ent o all standards o or(.  T"e su!!ression o all e$idence t"at a !articular co(!osition  is ani(ated by any directing intelligence.

7s or t"e irst !oint, "ere are Mr. Pound's ords in anser tot"e Kuestion, *do you agree t"at t"e great !oet is ne$er e(otional*

  es, absolutely i by e(otion is (eant t"at "e is at t"e  (ercy o e$ery !assing (ood.... T"e only &ind o e(otion  ort"y o a !oet is t"e ins!irational e(otion "ic"  energises and strengt"ens, and "ic" is $ery re(ote ro( t"e  e$eryday e(otion o slo!!iness and senti(ent....

7nd as or t"e !lator( o +(agis(, "ere are a e o Pound's*)on'ts or +(agists*:

  Pay no attention to t"e criticis(s o (en "o "a$e ne$er   t"e(sel$es ritten a notable or&.

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 15/31

  Ase no su!erluous ord and no adjecti$e "ic" does not  re$eal so(et"ing.

  Go in ear o abstractions. )on't retail in (ediocre $erse

  "at "as already been done in good !rose.

  )on't i(agine t"at t"e art o !oetry is any si(!ler t"an t"e  art o (usic or t"at you can !lease t"e e1!ert beore you  "a$e s!ent at least as (uc" eort on t"e art o $erse as  t"e a$erage !iano teac"er s!ends on t"e art o (usic.

  %e inluenced by as (any great artists as you can, but "a$e  t"e decency eit"er to ac&noledge t"e debt outrig"t or try  to conceal it.

  onsider t"e deiniteness o )ante's !resentation as  co(!ared it" Milton's. 2ead as (uc" o ordsort" as does  not see( to be unutterably dull.

  + you ant t"e gist o t"e (atter go to Sa!!"o, atullus,  0illon "en "e is in t"e $ein, Gautier "en "e is not too  rigid, or i yon "a$e not t"e tongues see& out t"e  leisurely "aucer.

  Good !rose ill do you no "ar(. T"ere is good disci!line to  be "ad by trying to rite it. Translation is also good  training.

T"e e(!"asis "ere is certainly on disci!line and or(. T"e"icago ITribuneI recognized t"is as *sound sense,* adding:

  + t"is is +(agis( ... e are or establis"ing +(agis( by  constitutional a(end(ent and i(!risoning it"out recourse to  in& or !a!er all *literary* ladies or gents "o brea& any o   t"ese canons.

%ut ot"er re$ieers ere less a!!ro$ing. "ile t"e riter in t"e IBationI, Kuoted abo$e, dreads t"e anarc"y i(!ending, Mr.illia( 7rc"er as terriied at t"e !ros!ect o "ieraticor(alisation. Mr. 7rc"er belie$es in t"e si(!le untaug"t (use:

  Mr. Pound's co((and(ents tend too (uc" to (a&e o !oetry a  learned, selconscious crat, to be culti$ated by a guild  o ade!ts, ro( "ose austere laboratories s!ontaneity and  si(!licity are e1cluded.... 7 great deal o t"e best !oetry  in t"e orld "as $ery little tec"nical study be"ind it....

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 16/31

  T"ere are scores and "undreds o !eo!le in England "o could  rite t"is si(!le (etre i.e. o *7 S"ro!s"ire ?ad*F  successully.

To be "anged or a cat and droned or a rat is, !er"a!s,

suicient e1cul!ation.

Probably Mr. Pound "as on odiu( not so (uc" by "is t"eories as by "is unstinted !raise o certain conte(!orary aut"ors "oseor& "e "as li&ed. Suc" e1!ressions o a!!ro$al are usuallyta&en as a grie$ance(uc" (ore so t"an any !ersonal abuse,"ic" is co(!arati$ely a co(!li(entby t"e riters "o esca!e"is (ention. He does not say *7., %., and . are bad !oets or no$elists,* but "en "e says *T"e or& o N., ., and D. is insuc" and suc" res!ects t"e (ost i(!ortant or& in $erse or  !roseF since so and so,* t"en 7., %., and . are aggrie$ed.7lso, Pound "as reKuently e1!ressed disa!!ro$al o Milton andordsort".

7ter *2i!ostes,* Mr. Pound's idio( "as ad$anced still art"er.+nas(uc" as *at"ay,* t"e $olu(e o translations ro( t"e"inese, a!!eared !rior to *?ustra,* it is so(eti(es t"oug"tt"at "is neer idio( is due to t"e "inese inluence. T"is isal(ost t"e re$erse o t"e trut". T"e late Ernest /enollosa leta Kuantity o (anuscri!ts, including a great nu(ber o roug"translations literally e1actF ro( t"e "inese. 7ter certain !oe(s subseKuently incor!orated in *?ustra* "ad a!!eared in*Poetry,* Mrs. /enollosa recognized t"at in Pound t"e "inese(anuscri!ts ould ind t"e inter!reter "o( "er "usband ould"a$e is"ed s"e accordingly orarded t"e !a!ers or "i( to doas "e li&ed it". +t is t"us due to Mrs. /enollosa's acu(en t"ate "a$e *at"ay* it is not as a conseKuence o *at"ay* t"at e"a$e *?ustra.* T"is act (ust be borne in (ind.

Poe(s aterard e(bodied in *?ustra* a!!eared in *Poetry,* in7!ril, 343>, under t"e title o *onte(!oranea.* T"ey includeda(ong ot"ers *Tenzone,* *T"e ondolence,* *T"e Garret,**Salutation t"e Second,* and *)ance /igure.*

T"ere are inluences, but de$iously. +t is rat"er a gradualde$elo!(ent o e1!erience into "ic" literary e1!eriences "a$eentered. T"ese "a$e not broug"t t"e bondage o te(!oraryent"usias(s, but "a$e liberated t"e !oet ro( "is or(er restricted s!"ere. T"ere is atullus and Martial, Gautier,?aorgue and Tristan orbiere. "it(an is certainly not aninluence t"ere is not a trace o "i( any"ere "it(an and Mr.Pound are anti!odean to eac" ot"er. @ *onte(!oranea* t"e

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 17/31

 I"icago E$ening PostI discri(inatingly obser$ed:

  our !oe(s in t"e 7!ril IPoetryI are so (oc&ingly, so  delicately, so unblus"ingly beautiul t"at you see( to "a$e  broug"t bac& into t"e orld a grace "ic" !robablyF ne$er 

  e1isted, but "ic" e disco$er by an i(aginati$e !rocess in  Horace and atullus.

+t as a true insig"t to ally Pound to t"e ?atin, not to t"eGree& !oets.

ertain o t"e !oe(s in *?ustra* "a$e oended ad(irers o t"e$erse o t"e *Personae* !eriod. "en a !oet alters or de$elo!s,(any o "is ad(irers are sure to dro! o. 7ny !oet, i "e is tosur$i$e as a riter beyond "is tentyit" year, (ust alter "e(ust see& ne literary inluences "e ill "a$e dierente(otions to e1!ress. T"is is disconcerting to t"at !ublic "ic"li&es a !oet to s!in "is "ole or& out o t"e eelings o "isyout" "ic" li&es to be able to o!en a ne $olu(e o "is !oe(sit" t"e assurance t"at t"ey ill be able to a!!roac" it e1actlyas t"ey a!!roac"ed t"e !receding. T"ey do not li&e t"at constantreadjust(ent "ic" t"e olloing o Mr. Pound's or& de(ands.T"us "as *?ustra* been a disa!!oint(ent to so(e t"oug" it(aniests no alling o in tec"niKue, and no i(!o$eris"(ento eeling. So(e o t"e !oe(s including se$eral o t"e*onte(!oranea*F are a (ore direct state(ent o $ies t"anPound's $erse "ad e$er gi$en beore. @ t"ese !oe(s, M. 8ean de%ossc"ere rites:

  E$ery"ere "is !oe(s incite (an to e1ist, to !roess a  beco(ing egotis(, it"out "ic" t"ere can be no real  altruis(.

  + beseec" you enter your lie.  + beseec" you learn to say *+*  "en + Kuestion you.  /or you are no !art, but a "ole  Bo !ortion, but a being.

  ... @ne (ust be ca!able o reacting to sti(uli or a (o(ent,  as a real, li$e !erson, e$en in ace o as (uc" o one's on  !oers as are arrayed against one... T"e $irile co(!laint,  t"e re$olt o t"e !oet, all "ic" s"os "is e(otion,t"at  is !oetry.

  S!ea& against unconscious o!!ression,  S!ea& against t"e tyranny o t"e uni(aginati$e,

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 18/31

  S!ea& against bonds.

  %e against all or(s o o!!ression,  Go out and dey o!inion.

  T"is is t"e old cry o t"e !oet, but (ore !recise, as an  e1!ression o ran& disgust:

  Go to t"e adolescent "o are s(ot"ered in a(ily.  @, "o "ideous it is  To see t"ree generations o one "ouse gat"ered toget"er6  +t is li&e an old tree it"out s"oots,  7nd it" so(e branc"es rotted and alling.

  Eac" !oe( "olds out t"ese cries o re$olt or disgust, but  t"ey are t"e result o "is still "o!ing and eeling:

  ?et us ta&e ar(s against t"is sea o stu!idities. Pound ...  "as e1!erience o t"e olly o t"e P"ilistines "o read "is  $erse. 2eal !ain is born o t"is stu!id inter!retation, and  one does not realize "o dee! it is unless one can eel,  t"roug" t"e ejaculations and t"e laug"ter, "at "as caused  t"ese ounds, "ic" are (ade dee!er by "at "e &nos, and  "at "e "as lost....

  T"e tone, "ic" is at once jocund and &een, is one o   Pound's Kualities. @$id, atullus"e does not dison t"e(.  He only uses t"ese accents or "is a(iliars it" t"e  ot"ers "e is on t"e edge o !arado1, !a(!"leteering, indeed  o abuse....

T"is is t"e !ro!er a!!roac" to t"e !oe(s at t"e beginning o *?ustra,* and to t"e s"ort e!igra(s, "ic" so(e readers ind*!ointless,* or certainly *not !oetry.* T"ey s"ould read, t"en,t"e *)ance /igure,* or *Bear Perigord,* and re(e(ber t"at allt"ese !oe(s co(e out o t"e sa(e (an.

  T"ine ar(s are as a young sa!ling under t"e bar&  T"y ace as a ri$er it" lig"ts.

  "ite as an al(ond are t"y s"oulders  7s ne al(onds stri!!ed ro( t"e "us&.

@r t"e ending o *Bear Perigord*:

  %eildering s!ring, and by t"e 7u$ezere  Po!!ies and day'seyes in t"e green e(ail

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 19/31

  2ose o$er us and e &ne all t"at strea(,  7nd our to "orses "ad traced out t"e $alleys  Cne t"e lo looded lands sKuared out it" !o!lars,  +n t"e young days "en t"e dee! s&y beriended.  7nd great ings beat abo$e us in t"e tilig"t,

  7nd t"e great "eels in "ea$en  %ore us toget"er ... surging ... and a!art ...  %elie$ing e s"ould (eet it" li!s and "ands ...

  T"ere s"ut u! in "is castle, Tairiran's,  S"e "o "ad nor ears nor tongue sa$e in "er "ands,  Gone, a", goneuntouc"ed, unreac"able6  S"e "o could ne$er li$e sa$e t"roug" one !erson,  S"e "o could ne$er s!ea& sa$e to one !erson,  7nd all t"e rest o "er a s"iting c"ange,  7 bro&en bundle o (irrors...6

T"en turn at once to *To a /riend riting on abaret )ancers.*

+t is easy to say t"at t"e language o *at"ay* is due to t"e"inese. + one loo&s careully at 3F Pound's ot"er $erse, 9Fot"er !eo!le's translations ro( t"e "inese e.g., Giles'sF, itis e$ident t"at t"is is not t"e case. T"e language as ready or t"e "inese !oetry. o(!are, or instance, a !assage ro(*Pro$incia )eserta*:

  + "a$e al&ed  into Perigord  + "a$e seen t"e torc"la(es, "ig"lea!ing,  Painting t"e ront o t"at c"urc",  7nd, under t"e dar&, "irling laug"ter,  + "a$e loo&ed bac& o$er t"e strea(  and seen t"e "ig" building,  Seen t"e long (inarets, t"e "ite s"ats.  + "a$e gone in 2ibeyrac,  and in Sarlat.  + "a$e cli(bed ric&ety stairs, "eard tal& o roy,  al&ed o$er En %ertran's old layout,  Ha$e seen Barbonne, and a"ors and "alus,  Ha$e seen E1cideuil, careully as"ioned.

it" a !assage ro( *T"e 2i$er Song*:

  He goes out to Hori, to loo& at t"e ingla!!ing stor&s,  He returns by ay o Sei roc&, to "ear t"e ne nig"tingales,  /or t"e gardens at 8orun are ull o ne nig"tingales,

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 20/31

  T"eir sound is (i1ed in t"is lute,  T"eir $oice is in t"e tel$e !i!es "ere.

+t (atters $ery little "o (uc" is due to 2i"a&u and "o (uc" toPound. Mr. /ord Mado1 Hueer "as obser$ed: *+ t"ese are

original $erses, t"en Mr. Pound is t"e greatest !oet o t"isday.* He goes on to say:

  T"e !oe(s in *at"ay* are t"ings o a su!re(e beauty. "at  !oetry s"ould be, t"at t"ey are. 7nd i a ne breat" o   i(agery and "andling can do anyt"ing or our !oetry, t"at  ne breat" t"ese !oe(s bring....

  Poetry consists in so rendering concrete objects t"at t"e  e(otions !roduced by t"e objects s"all arise in t"e  reader....

  "ere "a$e you better rendered, or (ore !er(anently  beautiul a rendering o, t"e eelings o one o t"ose  lonely atc"ers, in t"e out!osts o !rogress, "et"er it be  @$id in Hyrcania, a 2o(an sentinel u!on t"e great all o   t"is country, or (erely oursel$es, in t"e lonely recesses o   our (inds, t"an t"e *?a(ent o t"e /rontier Guard*...

  %eauty is a $ery $aluable t"ing !er"a!s it is t"e (ost  $aluable t"ing in lie but t"e !oer to e1!ress e(otion so  t"at it s"all co((unicate itsel intact and e1actly is  al(ost (ore $aluable. @ bot" t"ese Kualities Mr. Pound's  boo& is $ery ull. T"ereore, + t"in& e (ay say t"at t"is  is (uc" t"e best or& "e "as done, or, "oe$er closely "e  (ay "a$e olloed "is originalsand o t"at (ost o us "a$e  no (eans o judgingt"ere is certainly a good deal o Mr.  Pound in t"is little $olu(e.

*at"ay* and *?ustra* ere olloed by t"e translations o Bo" !lays. T"e Bo" are not so i(!ortant as t"e "inese !oe(scertainly not so i(!ortant or Englis"F t"e attitude is lessunusual to us t"e or& is not so solid, so ir(. *at"ay* ill,+ belie$e, ran& it" t"e *Sea/arer* in t"e uture a(ong Mr.Pound's original or& t"e Bo" ill ran& a(ong "is translations.+t is rat"er a dessert ater *at"ay.* T"ere are, "oe$er, !assages "ic", as Pound "as "andled t"e(, are dierent bot"ro( t"e "inese and ro( anyt"ing e1istent in Englis". T"ereis, or e1a(!le, t"e ine s!eec" o t"e old Cage&iyo, as "et"in&s o "is yout"ul $alour:

  He t"oug"t, "o easy t"is &illing. He rus"ed it" "is

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 21/31

  s!ears"at gri!!ed under "is ar(. He cried out, *+ a(  Cage&iyo o t"e Hei&e.* He rus"ed on to ta&e t"e(. He  !ierced t"roug" t"e "el(et $izards o Miyanoya. Miyanoya  led tice, and again and Cage&iyo cried: *ou s"all not  esca!e (e6* He lea!ed and renc"ed o "is "el(et. *Eya6*

  T"e $izard bro&e and re(ained in "is "and, and Miyanoya  still led aar, and aar, and "e loo&ed bac& crying in  terror, *Ho terrible, "o "ea$y your ar(6* 7nd Cage&iyo  called at "i(, *Ho toug" t"e s"at o your nec& is6* 7nd  t"ey bot" laug"ed out o$er t"e battle, and ent o eac" "is  on ay.

T"e *Ti(es ?iterary Su!!le(ent* s!o&e o Mr. Pound's *(astery o  beautiul diction* and "is *cunningly r"yt"(ically !rose,* inits re$ie o t"e *Bo".*

E$en since *?ustra,* Mr. Pound "as (o$ed again. T"is (o$e is tot"e e!ic, o "ic" t"ree cantos a!!ear in t"e 7(erican *?ustra*t"ey "a$e already a!!eared in *Poetry*Miss Monroe deser$esgreat "onour or "er courage in !rinting an e!ic !oe( in t"istentiet" centurybut t"e $ersion in *?ustra* is re$ised and isi(!ro$ed by re$isionF. e ill lea$e it as a test: "en anyone"as studied Mr. Pound's !oe(s in Ic"ronologicalI order, and "as(astered *?ustra* and *at"ay,* "e is !re!ared or t"e antos but not till t"en. + t"e reader t"en ails to li&e t"e(, "e "as !robably o(itted so(e ste! in "is !rogress, and "ad better go bac& and retrace t"e journey.

%+%?+@G27PH @/

%@@CS 7B) P72T+7? %+%?+@G27PH @/ B@T7%?E 2+T+7? 72T+?ES

% ED27 P@AB)

P@EMS

7 ?AME SPEBT@ 3 co!iesF. 7ntonelli, 0enice, 8une, 34J.

7 LA+BD7+BE /@2 TH+S A?E.  /irst 3 !rinted by Polloc&, ?ondon, )ece(ber, 34J.

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 22/31

  Second 3 !ublis"ed under El&in Mat"es' i(!rint, ?ondon,  )ece(ber, 34J.

PE2S@B7E. Mat"es, ?ondon, S!ring, 344.

ENA?T7T+@BS. Mat"es, ?ondon, 7utu(n, 344.

P2@SE

THE SP+2+T @/ 2@M7BE. )ent, ?ondon, 343.

P@EMS

P2@0EB7 a selection o !oe(s ro( *Personae* and  *E1ultations* it" ne !oe(sF. S(all Maynard, %oston, 343.

7BD@B+. Mat"es, ?ondon, 3433.

THE S@BBETS 7B) %7??7TE @/ GA+)@ 707?7BT+ translatedF.  S(all Maynard, %oston, 3439.

  7 c"ea!er edition o t"e sa(e, Sit and o., ?ondon, 3439.  T"e bul& o t"is edition destroyed by ire.

2+P@STES. Sit, ?ondon, 3439.  IBoteI.T"is boo& contains t"e irst announce(ent o   +(agis(, in t"e oreord to t"e !oe(s o T. E. Hul(e.F

@THE2 PA%?+7T+@BS

*7 /E )@B'TS % 7B +M7G+STE,* in *Poetry,* or Marc", 343>.

*@BTEMP@27B+7* !oe(sF, in *Poetry,* 7!ril, 343>.

P@EMS

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 23/31

PE2S@B7E, ENA?T7T+@BS, 7BD@B+, 2+P@STES, !ublis"ed in to  $olu(es. Mat"es, ?ondon, 343>.

/+2ST @/ THE B@TES @B 87MES 8@E, *Egoist,* 8anuary, 343O.

/+2ST @/ THE 72T+?ES @BE2B+BG G7A)+E2%2DESC7, *Egoist,*  /ebruary, 343O.

@THE2 PA%?+7T+@BS

*)ES +M7G+STES,* !oe(s by se$eral aut"ors selected by Ezra  Pound, !ublis"ed as a nu(ber o *T"e Glebe,* in Be or&.  /ebruary, 343O.

  7lred Crey(borg as at t"is ti(e editor o *T"e Glebe.* T"e  irst arrange(ents or t"e ant"ology ere (ade t"roug" t"e  &ind oices o 8o"n ournos during t"e inter o 34393>.

  T"e Englis" edition o t"is ant"ology !ublis"ed by T"e Poetry  %oo& S"o!. ?ondon, 343O.

72T+?E @B B)H7M ?E+S, *Egoist,* 8une 35, 343O.

@BT2+%AT+@BS T@ /+2ST BAM%E2 @/ *%last,* 8une 9, 343O.

*0@2T++SM,* an article in *T"e /ortnig"tly 2e$ie,* Se!te(ber,  343O.

*G7A)+E2%2DESC7,* an article in *T"e Be 7ge,* /ebruary O,  3435.

@BT2+%AT+@BS to second nu(ber o *%last,* 3435.

P@EMS

7TH7. Mat"es, ?ondon, 7!ril, 3435. Translations ro( t"e  "inese ro( t"e notes o Ernest /enollosa.F

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 24/31

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 25/31

Produced by 7ndrea %all, )a$id Starner, "arles /ran&s,8uliet Sut"erland, and t"e @nline )istributed Prooreading Tea(

Project Gutenberg e%oo&s are oten created ro( se$eral !rinted

editions, all o "ic" are conir(ed as Public )o(ain in t"e ASunless a co!yrig"t notice is included. T"us, e usually do not&ee! e%oo&s in co(!liance it" any !articular !a!er edition.

e are no trying to release all our e%oo&s one year in ad$anceo t"e oicial release dates, lea$ing ti(e or better editing.Please be encouraged to tell us about any error or corrections,e$en years ater t"e oicial !ublication date.

Please note neit"er t"is listing nor its contents are inal til(idnig"t o t"e last day o t"e (ont" o any suc" announce(ent.T"e oicial release date o all Project Gutenberg e%oo&s is atMidnig"t, entral Ti(e, o t"e last day o t"e stated (ont". 7 !reli(inary $ersion (ay oten be !osted or suggestion, co((entand editing by t"ose "o is" to do so.

Most !eo!le start at our eb sites at:"tt!:gutenberg.net or "tt!:!ro(o.net!g

T"ese eb sites include aardinning inor(ation about ProjectGutenberg, including "o to donate, "o to "el! !roduce our nee%oo&s, and "o to subscribe to our e(ail nesletter ree6F.

T"ose o you "o ant to donload any e%oo& beore announce(entcan get to t"e( as ollos, and just donload by date. T"is isalso a good ay to get t"e( instantly u!on announce(ent, as t"einde1es our cataloguers !roduce ob$iously ta&e a "ile ater anannounce(ent goes out in t"e Project Gutenberg Besletter.

"tt!:.ibiblio.orggutenbergete1t> or t!:t!.ibiblio.org!ubdocsboo&sgutenbergete1t>

@r ete1t9, 3, , 44, 4J, 4, 4=, 45, 4O, 4>, 49, 49, 43 or 4

8ust searc" by t"e irst i$e letters o t"e ilena(e you ant,as it a!!ears in our Besletters.

+nor(ation about Project Gutenberg one !ageF

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 26/31

e !roduce about to (illion dollars or eac" "our e or&. T"eti(e it ta&es us, a rat"er conser$ati$e esti(ate, is ity "oursto get any e%oo& selected, entered, !rooread, edited, co!yrig"tsearc"ed and analyzed, t"e co!yrig"t letters ritten, etc. @ur  !rojected audience is one "undred (illion readers. + t"e $alue

 !er te1t is no(inally esti(ated at one dollar t"en e !roduce Q9(illion dollars !er "our in 99 as e release o$er 3 ne te1tiles !er (ont": 39O (ore e%oo&s in 93 or a total o ORe are already on our ay to trying or 9 (ore e%oo&s in 99+ t"ey reac" just 39 o t"e orld's !o!ulation t"en t"e totalill reac" o$er "al a trillion e%oo&s gi$en aay by year's end.

T"e Goal o Project Gutenberg is to Gi$e 7ay 3 Trillion e%oo&s6T"is is ten t"ousand titles eac" to one "undred (illion readers,"ic" is only about O o t"e !resent nu(ber o co(!uter users.

Here is t"e brieest record o our !rogress - (eans esti(atedF:

e%oo&s ear Mont"

  3 343 8uly  3 3443 8anuary  3 344O 8anuary 3 344 7ugust 35 344J @ctober  9 3444 )ece(ber  95 9 )ece(ber  > 93 Bo$e(ber  O 93 @ctoberBo$e(ber  = 99 )ece(ber- 4 9> Bo$e(ber-3 9O 8anuary-

T"e Project Gutenberg ?iterary 7rc"i$e /oundation "as been createdto secure a uture or Project Gutenberg into t"e ne1t (illenniu(.

e need your donations (ore t"an e$er6

7s o /ebruary, 99, contributions are being solicited ro( !eo!leand organizations in: 7laba(a, 7las&a, 7r&ansas, onnecticut,)elaare, )istrict o olu(bia, /lorida, Georgia, Haaii, +llinois,+ndiana, +oa, Cansas, Centuc&y, ?ouisiana, Maine, Massac"usetts,Mic"igan, Mississi!!i, Missouri, Montana, Bebras&a, Be$ada, BeHa(!s"ire, Be 8ersey, Be Me1ico, Be or&, Bort" arolina, @"io,@&la"o(a, @regon, Pennsyl$ania, 2"ode +sland, Sout" arolina, Sout")a&ota, Tennessee, Te1as, Ata", 0er(ont, 0irginia, as"ington, est

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 27/31

0irginia, isconsin, and yo(ing.

e "a$e iled in all 5 states no, but t"ese are t"e only onest"at "a$e res!onded.

7s t"e reKuire(ents or ot"er states are (et, additions to t"is listill be (ade and und raising ill begin in t"e additional states.Please eel ree to as& to c"ec& t"e status o your state.

+n anser to $arious Kuestions e "a$e recei$ed on t"is:

e are constantly or&ing on inis"ing t"e !a!eror& to legallyreKuest donations in all 5 states. + your state is not listed andyou ould li&e to &no i e "a$e added it since t"e list you "a$e, just as&.

"ile e cannot solicit donations ro( !eo!le in states "ere e arenot yet registered, e &no o no !ro"ibition against acce!tingdonations ro( donors in t"ese states "o a!!roac" us it" an oer todonate.

+nternational donations are acce!ted, but e don't &no 7BTH+BG about"o to (a&e t"e( ta1deductible, or e$en i t"ey 7B be (adedeductible, and don't "a$e t"e sta to "andle it e$en i t"ere areays.

)onations by c"ec& or (oney order (ay be sent to:

Project Gutenberg ?iterary 7rc"i$e /oundationPM% 33>3>4 Ani$ersity 7$e.@1ord, MS >J=55O34

ontact us i you ant to arrange or a ire transer or !ay(ent(et"od ot"er t"an by c"ec& or (oney order.

T"e Project Gutenberg ?iterary 7rc"i$e /oundation "as been a!!ro$ed byt"e AS +nternal 2e$enue Ser$ice as a 53cF>F organization it" E+B;E(!loyee +dentiication Bu(ber< =O=9935O. )onations areta1deductible to t"e (a1i(u( e1tent !er(itted by la. 7s undraisingreKuire(ents or ot"er states are (et, additions to t"is list ill be(ade and undraising ill begin in t"e additional states.

e need your donations (ore t"an e$er6

ou can get u! to date donation inor(ation online at:

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 28/31

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 29/31

under t"e *P2@8ET GATEB%E2G* trade(ar&.

Please do not use t"e *P2@8ET GATEB%E2G* trade(ar& to (ar&etany co((ercial !roducts it"out !er(ission.

To create t"ese e%oo&s, t"e Project e1!ends considerableeorts to identiy, transcribe and !rooread !ublic do(ainor&s. )es!ite t"ese eorts, t"e Project's e%oo&s and any(ediu( t"ey (ay be on (ay contain *)eects*. 7(ong ot"er t"ings, )eects (ay ta&e t"e or( o inco(!lete, inaccurate or corru!t data, transcri!tion errors, a co!yrig"t or ot"er intellectual !ro!erty inringe(ent, a deecti$e or da(ageddis& or ot"er e%oo& (ediu(, a co(!uter $irus, or co(!uter codes t"at da(age or cannot be read by your eKui!(ent.

?+M+TE) 7227BT )+S?7+ME2 @/ )7M7GES%ut or t"e *2ig"t o 2e!lace(ent or 2eund* described belo,;3< Mic"ael Hart and t"e /oundation and any ot"er !arty you (ayrecei$e t"is e%oo& ro( as a P2@8ET GATEB%E2Gt( e%oo&F disclai(sall liability to you or da(ages, costs and e1!enses, includinglegal ees, and ;9< @A H70E B@ 2EME)+ES /@2 BEG?+GEBE @2 AB)E2 ST2+T ?+7%+?+T, @2 /@2 %2E7H @/ 7227BT @2 @BT27T,+B?A)+BG %AT B@T ?+M+TE) T@ +B)+2ET, @BSELAEBT+7?, PAB+T+0E@2 +B+)EBT7? )7M7GES, E0EB +/ @A G+0E B@T+E @/ THEP@SS+%+?+T @/ SAH )7M7GES.

+ you disco$er a )eect in t"is e%oo& it"in 4 days o recei$ing it, you can recei$e a reund o t"e (oney i anyFyou !aid or it by sending an e1!lanatory note it"in t"atti(e to t"e !erson you recei$ed it ro(. + you recei$ed iton a !"ysical (ediu(, you (ust return it it" your note, andsuc" !erson (ay c"oose to alternati$ely gi$e you a re!lace(entco!y. + you recei$ed it electronically, suc" !erson (ayc"oose to alternati$ely gi$e you a second o!!ortunity torecei$e it electronically.

TH+S E%@@C +S @THE2+SE P2@0+)E) T@ @A *7S+S*. B@ @THE2 7227BT+ES @/ 7B C+B), ENP2ESS @2 +MP?+E), 72E M7)E T@ @A 7ST@ THE E%@@C @2 7B ME)+AM +T M7 %E @B, +B?A)+BG %AT B@T?+M+TE) T@ 7227BT+ES @/ ME2H7BT7%+?+T @2 /+TBESS /@2 7P72T+A?72 PA2P@SE.

So(e states do not allo disclai(ers o i(!lied arranties or t"e e1clusion or li(itation o conseKuential da(ages, so t"eabo$e disclai(ers and e1clusions (ay not a!!ly to you, and you(ay "a$e ot"er legal rig"ts.

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 30/31

+B)EMB+Tou ill inde(niy and "old Mic"ael Hart, t"e /oundation,and its trustees and agents, and any $olunteers associatedit" t"e !roduction and distribution o Project Gutenbergt(te1ts "ar(less, ro( all liability, cost and e1!ense, including

legal ees, t"at arise directly or indirectly ro( any o t"eolloing t"at you do or cause: ;3< distribution o t"is e%oo&,;9< alteration, (odiication, or addition to t"e e%oo&,or ;>< any )eect.

)+ST2+%AT+@B AB)E2 *P2@8ET GATEB%E2Gt(*ou (ay distribute co!ies o t"is e%oo& electronically, or bydis&, boo& or any ot"er (ediu( i you eit"er delete t"is*S(all Print6* and all ot"er reerences to Project Gutenberg,or:

;3< @nly gi$e e1act co!ies o it. 7(ong ot"er t"ings, t"is  reKuires t"at you do not re(o$e, alter or (odiy t"e  e%oo& or t"is *s(all !rint6* state(ent. ou (ay "oe$er,  i you is", distribute t"is e%oo& in (ac"ine readable  binary, co(!ressed, (ar&u!, or !ro!rietary or(,  including any or( resulting ro( con$ersion by ord  !rocessing or "y!erte1t sotare, but only so long as  -E+THE2-:

  ;-< T"e e%oo&, "en dis!layed, is clearly readable, and  does -not- contain c"aracters ot"er t"an t"ose  intended by t"e aut"or o t"e or&, alt"oug" tilde  WF, asteris& -F and underline IF c"aracters (ay  be used to con$ey !unctuation intended by t"e  aut"or, and additional c"aracters (ay be used to  indicate "y!erte1t lin&s @2 

  ;-< T"e e%oo& (ay be readily con$erted by t"e reader at  no e1!ense into !lain 7S++, E%)+ or eKui$alent  or( by t"e !rogra( t"at dis!lays t"e e%oo& as is  t"e case, or instance, it" (ost ord !rocessorsF  @2 

  ;-< ou !ro$ide, or agree to also !ro$ide on reKuest at  no additional cost, ee or e1!ense, a co!y o t"e  e%oo& in its original !lain 7S++ or( or in E%)+  or ot"er eKui$alent !ro!rietary or(F.

;9< Honor t"e e%oo& reund and re!lace(ent !ro$isions o t"is  *S(all Print6* state(ent.

8/13/2019 Eliot, T. S. - Ezra Pound- His Metric and Poetry[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eliot-t-s-ezra-pound-his-metric-and-poetry1 31/31

;>< Pay a trade(ar& license ee to t"e /oundation o 9 o t"e  gross !roits you deri$e calculated using t"e (et"od you  already use to calculate your a!!licable ta1es. + you  don't deri$e !roits, no royalty is due. 2oyalties are  !ayable to *Project Gutenberg ?iterary 7rc"i$e /oundation*

  t"e = days olloing eac" date you !re!are or ere  legally reKuired to !re!areF your annual or eKui$alent  !eriodicF ta1 return. Please contact us beore"and to  let us &no your !lans and to or& out t"e details.

H7T +/ @A -7BT- T@ SEB) M@BE E0EB +/ @A )@B'T H70E T@Project Gutenberg is dedicated to increasing t"e nu(ber o  !ublic do(ain and licensed or&s t"at can be reely distributedin (ac"ine readable or(.

T"e Project grateully acce!ts contributions o (oney, ti(e, !ublic do(ain (aterials, or royalty ree co!yrig"t licenses.Money s"ould be !aid to t"e:*Project Gutenberg ?iterary 7rc"i$e /oundation.*

+ you are interested in contributing scanning eKui!(ent or sotare or ot"er ite(s, !lease contact Mic"ael Hart at:"artU!obo1.co(

;Portions o t"is e%oo&'s "eader and trailer (ay be re!rinted only"en distributed ree o all ees. o!yrig"t F 93, 99 byMic"ael S. Hart. Project Gutenberg is a TradeMar& and (ay not beused in any sales o Project Gutenberg e%oo&s or ot"er (aterials bet"ey "ardare or sotare or any ot"er related !roduct it"oute1!ress !er(ission.<

-EB) THE SM7?? P2+BT6 /@2 PA%?+ )@M7+B E%@@CS-0er.9339-EB)-