Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

download Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

of 74

Transcript of Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    1/74

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    2/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f` }dh Kzkj Q`zgm

    :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    ^kghf Jhb Bk~~hz Kg C~fkcgs' Kyykb Kg&Jx~kcmc'

    Fcaxhg Nhzukb}h~ % Ezhm FnFkd`b

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c b `z Gcjhz}s

    Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b @fkb

    Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    :?;:

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    3/74

    cc / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    N`pszca :?;: js h Ezk~hz Cb~cxh" Kgg zca~ zh~hzuhm" B` pkz ` c~ j``l fks jh zhpz`mxnhm cb

    kbs fkbbhz qk~`huhz qc`x qzchb phzfc~~c`b htnhp cb h nk~h ` jzch {x`kc`b~ hfj`mchm cb

    nzccnkg kzcngh~ kbm zhuchq~"

    ]h kx`z~ ` c~ j``l kuh q`zlhm cbmhphbmhbgs kbm `pcbc`b~ htpzh~~hm js hf kzh' hzh`zh' hcz

    `qb' kbm m` b` bhnh~~kzcgs zhhn h p`~cc`b ` h Ezk~hz Cb~cxh' `z h uchq~ ` h ~xpp`zhz~'

    zx~hh~' `z ~k ` h Ezk~hz Cb~cxh" ]c~ pxjgcnkc`b cb b` qks cfpgch~ k h Ezk~hz Cb~cxh' c~

    ~xpp`zhz~' zx~hh~' `z ~k kzh cb ku`z `' `z `pp`~h h pk~~kah `' kbs jcgg< `z k hs ~xpp`z `z `p&

    p`~h kbs pkzcnxgkz p`gccnkg pkzs `z nkbmcmkh"

    ]h pzcbncpkg kx`z ` c~ pxjgcnkc`b' ^kghf Jhb Bk~~hz Kg C~fkcgs' c~ pz`h~~c`bkggs cbu`guhm cb h

    pz`f`c`b ` cbuh~fhb cb @fkb" ]hzh`zh' ` ku`cm k n`bcn ` cbhzh~' h htnx~hm cf~hg z`f

    nkgnxgkcba h cbmht `xa h xbmhz``l h jxgl ` h kbkgs~c~"

    Mkh ` c~~xh9 B`uhfjhz :?;:

    N`uhz mh~cab js Jcgg Zks

    _xjgc~hz9 Kg&Fkz`~k `z _xjgc~cba' _zh~~ ^hzucnh~' kbm Cb`zfkc`b

    Kmmzh~~9 Jg`nl 1>33' ^zhh :4 jzkbncba z`f ^zhh 3' Fxllkkf' Nkcz`' Hasp

    H&fkcg9 fkdz`~kOfkdz`~k"n`f

    Nc}h }dc~ pxjgcnk}c`b

    Kx`z~9 ^kghf Jhb Bk~~hz Kg C~fkcgs' Kyykb Kg&Jx~kcmc' Fcaxhg Nhzukbh~' kbm Ezhm FnFk`b

    cgh9Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    _xjgc~hz9 Ezk~hz Cb~cxh

    Mkh ` pxjgcnkc`b9 :?;:

    Mcackg n`ps kukcgkjgh z`f 7d}}p9//qqq"zhh}dhq`zgm"n`f2 kbm 7d}}p9//qqq"zk~hzcb~}c}x}h"`za2"

    Nk}kg`axcba Cb`zfk}c`b

    Jhb Bk~~hz Kg C~fkcgs' ^kghf' ;384

    Hn`b`fcn zhhm`f ` h Kzkj q`zgm9 :?;: kbbxkg zhp`z / ^kghf Jhb Bk~~hz Kg C~fkcgs'

    Kyykb Kg&Jx~kcmc' Fcaxhg Nhzukbh~' kbm Ezhm FnFk`b

    C^JB 314&?&44318&:5?&>$:?;: hmcc`b#

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    4/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / ccc

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    N`b}hb}~

    Kj`x} }dh Kx}d`z~ / cu

    Knlb`qghmafhb}~ / uc

    Kj`x} }dh N`&pxjgc~dhz~ / ucc

    Cb}z`mxn}c`b / ;

    Zh~hkznd b hn`b`fcn zhhm`f / =

    N`xb}zs ~xffkzch~ / 1

    ]dh cbmht ` Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f cb }dh Kzkj Q`zgm / ;5

    Mk}k }kjgh~ / :;

    Kpphbmct9 Htpgkbk}`zs b`}h~ kbm mk}k ~`xznh~ / =5

    Zhhzhbnh~ / 81

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    5/74

    cu / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Kj`x} }dh kx}d`z~

    ^kghf Jhb Bk~~hz Kg C~fkcgs^kghf Jhb Bk~~hz Kg C~fkcgs `gm~ mhazhh~ cb hghn`ffxbcnkc`b~' Gcjhzkg

    Kz~' Cbmx~zckg Hbacbhhzcba' Jx~cbh~~ Kmfcbc~zkc`b' Fkbkahfhb kbm

    _cg`~`ps z`f xbcuhz~cch~ cb Xbchm Lcbam`f kbm h Xbchm ^kh~" Kg

    C~fkcgs q`zlhm k h _xjgcn H~kjgc~fhb `z Cbmx~zckg H~kh~ $_HCH# z`f

    ;34= ` ;335 k~ h Fkbkacba Mczhn`z" Cb ;335' h qk~ kpp`cbhm k~ hMhpxs Nkczfkb kbm Hthnxcuh _zh~cmhb h @fkbc Nhbzh `z Cbuh~fhb

    _z`f`c`b kbm Htp`z Mhuhg`pfhb qhzh h n`bcbxh~ ` ~hzuh cb h ~kfh

    nkpkncs" Dh c~ h `xbmhz kbm nkczfkb Cbhzbkc`bkg Zh~hkzn E`xbmkc`b

    kbm k fhfjhz ` h Ezk~hz Cb~cxh~ J`kzm ` Mczhn`z~" Kg C~fkcgs k~ pxj&

    gc~hm ~huhzkg pkphz~ `b h ~xjihn ` nz`~~ nxgxzh' fkbkahfhb' kbm h

    hn`b`fs' cbngxmcba q` j``l~ `b n`zp`zkh nxgxzh" Dh kg~` ~hzuh~ k~ k j`kzm

    fhfjhz fkbs pzcukh n`fpkbch~ cb h hgm bkbnckg ~hzucnh~ kbm hbhzas

    `b c~ phz~`bkg nkpkncs"

    ^kghf Jhb Bk~~hz Kg C~fkcgs c~ pz`h~~c`bkggs cbu`guhm cb h pz`f`c`b

    ` cbuh~fhb cb @fkb" ]hzh`zh' ` ku`cm k n`bcn ` cbhzh~' h htnx~hm

    cf~hg z`f nkgnxgkcba h cbmht `xa h xbmhz``l h jxgl h kbkgs~c~"

    Kyykb jcb [k~~cf Kg&Jx~kcmcKyykb jcb [k~~cf Kg&Jx~kcmc' q`zlhm k~ kb hn`b`fc~ k ~huhzkg mhpkzfhb~

    zhghukb ` zh~hkzn' cbuh~fhb~' kbm fkzlhcba cb @fkb' k~ qhgg k~ q`zlcba k~

    h NH@ h Cbhzbkc`bkg Zh~hkzn E`xbmkc`b cb @fkb' qcn c~ kb cbmhphb&

    mhb' b`b&pz` cbl kbl" Dh `gm~ k mhazhh cb Hn`b`fcn~ z`f xgkb [kj``~

    Xbcuhz~cs cb @fkb kbm kb FJK z`f h Xbcuhz~cs ` ^zkngsmh cb ^n`gkbm"

    Fcaxhg Nhzukb}h~Fcaxhg Kbahg Nhzukbh~ c~ kb hn`b`fc~ q` xbmhzklh~ cbhzbkc`bkg zh~hkzn

    `z h Ezk~hz Cb~cxh" Dh `gm~ Jknhg`z~ kbm Fk~hz~ mhazhh~ cb Hn`b`fcn~

    z`f h Xbcuhz~cs ` htk~ k Hg _k~` kbm k~ ghnxzhm k Ukbchz N`gghah< h

    nxzzhbgs ghnxzh~ k DHN F`bzhkg Jx~cbh~~ ^n``g" Dh qk~ h n`&`zmcbk`z

    ` h :??4/:??3' :??3/:?;?' :?;?/:?;;' kbm :?;;/:?;: hmcc`b~ ` hEzk~hz

    Cb~}c}x}h Kbbxkg ^xzuhs ` Fcbcba N`fpkbch~< h :??3' :?;?' :?;;' kbm :?;:

    hmcc`b~ ` hEzk~hz Cb~}c}x}h Ag`jkg _h}z`ghxf ^xzuhs< kbm ` h :?;? kbm

    :?;; hmcc`b~ `Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f ` }dh Kzkj Q zgm"

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    6/74

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    7/74

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    8/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / ucc

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Kj`x} }dh n`&pxjgc~dhz~

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b `z Gcjhz}s

    ]h Ezchmzcn Bkxfkbb E`xbmkc`b `z Gcjhzs $EBE# c~ kb cbmhphbmhb' b`b&

    pz`' b`ba`uhzbfhbkg `zakbcykc`b k c~ n`ffchm ` pz`f`cba gcjhzkg

    p`gcns kbm p`gccn~" E`xbmhm cb Ahzfkbs cb ;384' h E`xbmkc`b k~ q`b k

    zhpxkc`b `z pz`f`cba zhhm`f q`zgmqcmh" nzhkh kb `phb ~`nchs' EBE c~ axcmhm js h pzcbncpgh~ ` Gcjhzkgc~f

    kbm c~ fh~~kah fxxkg `ghzkbnh kbm knnhpkbnh mcuhz~cs" C~ n`zh n`bnhp~

    ~xn k~ h pz`hnc`b xfkb zca~' h kppgcnkc`b h zxgh gkq' gcjhzkg

    mhf`nzkns' kbm k zhh&fkzlh hn`b`fs kuh pz`uhb z`xa`x h nhbxzch~

    k Gcjhzkgc~f `hz~ kppz`pzckh ~`gxc`b~ `z h pzh~hb kbm h xxzh cb

    pxjgcn kbm phz~`bkg gch" @xz cbhb~cuh q`zl cb p`gccnkg hmxnkc`b' p`gccnkg n`b&

    ~xgkbns' zkcbcba' kbm mckg`axh c~ nkzzchm x cb Ahzfkbs kbm xz enh~ cb `uhz

    8? n`xbzch~ q`zgmqcmh"

    Qhj~ch9 7d}}p9// qqq"zhcdhc}"`za2"

    Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b

    ]h Cbhzbkc`bkg Zh~hkzn E`xbmkc`b $CZE#' ^xgkbkh ` @fkb' qk~ h~kj&

    gc~hm cb :??8 k~ k b`b&a`uhzbfhbkg' cbmhphbmhb' b`b&pz` cbl kbl

    jk~hm cb @fkb ` n`bmxn zh~hkzn `b m`fh~cn kbm cbhzbkc`bkg hn`b`fcn

    c~~xh~ qc hfpk~c~ b h Kzkj Q`zgm" ]h CZE k~ ~h c~ zh~hkzn kbm pxjgcn&

    kkcz~ kahbmk `b k n`gghackg jk~c~' zhgscba `b h cbpx ` c~ zh~hkznhz ~k' c~

    hmc`zckg j`kzm' kbm c~ hbc`z Ehgg`q~" C fkcbkcb~ k q`zlcba kzzkbahfhb qc

    a`uhzbfhbkg kbm b`b&a`uhzbfhbkg zakbcykc`b~ cb h zhac`b kbm hz pkz~

    ` h q`zgm" ]h CZE c~ h zhac`bkg fhfjhz h Ezk~hz Cb~cxh~ Hn`b`fcnEzhhm`f Bhq`zl"

    ]h uc~c`b ` CZE c~ ` nzhkh qhkg kbm i`j~ z`xa pz`f`c`b ` hn`&

    b`fcn zhhm`f" C~ fc~~c`b c~ ` fhk~xzh' zh~hkzn' kbm n`ffxbcnkh ` k ag`jkg

    kxmchbnh h cfpkn n`fphccuh fkzlh~ qc zhh hn`b`fcn p`gcnch~ b h

    qhgkzh cbmcucmxkg~"

    ]h J`kzm ` zx~hh~ ` h CZE n`b~c~~ ` ca&pz`gh pzcukh&~hn`z

    fhfjhz~ z`f mchzhb zakbcykc`b~" ]h CZE k~ cbcckhm h h~kjgc~fhb

    k bhq`zl ` knkmhfcn zh~hkznhz~ ` kncgckh zh~hkzn pz`ihn~' qcn qcgg hgp

    cb c~ hbmhku`z ` zh~hkzn hn`b`fcn c~~xh~ khncba h mkcgs gch cbmcucmxkg~"

    Qhj~ch9 7d}}p9//qqq"cz`fkb"`za/2"

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    9/74

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    10/74

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / ;

    Cb}z`mxn}c`b

    Hn`b`fcn zhhm`f c~ h hthb ` qcn `bh nkb pxz~xh hn`b`fcn kncucs qc&

    `x cbhzhzhbnh z`f a`uhzbfhb" Hn`b`fcn zhhm`f c~ jxcg xp`b phz~`bkg

    n`cnh' u`gxbkzs htnkbah' h zca ` lhhp qk s`x hkzb' kbm h ~hnxzcs `

    `bh~ pz`phzs zca~" ]h fhnkbcn~ ` hn`b`fcn zhhm`f kzh hk~s ` xbmhz&

    ~kbm" Kbs zkb~knc`b zhhgs hbhzhm cb` fx~ jhbh j` pkzch~" Kbs zkb~kn&

    c`b k m`h~ b` jhbh j` pkzch~ q`xgm jh zhihnhm js h pkzs k q`xgmn`fh xp ~`z" ]c~ k~ n`b~h{xhbnh~ z`xa`x h hn`b`fs" N`b~xfhz~

    q` kzh zhh ` n``~h qcgg `bgs jh kzknhm js ~xphzc`z {xkgcs kbm pzcnh" K

    pz`mxnhz fx~ n`b~kbgs cfpz`uh h pzcnh kbm {xkgcs htc~cba pz`mxn~ z

    cbuhb bhq pz`mxn~" Qc`x c~' nx~`fhz~ qcgg b` zhhgs hbhz cb` zkb~kn&

    c`b~ qc h pz`mxnhz" Fkbs jcggc`b~ fxxkggs jhbhnckg zkb~knc`b~ nnxz

    huhzs mks' p`qhzcba h msbkfcn k ~pxz~ cbnzhk~hm pz`mxncucs kbm pz`~phz&

    cs z`xa`x h hn`b`fs"

    ]c~ c~ h bcb zhp`z b hn`b`fcn zhhm`f cb h Kzkj q`zgm" ]h z~

    qk~ pxjgc~hm js h ~kfh kx`z~ cb h Kzkj Q`zgm N`fph}c}cuhbh~~ Zhp`z}

    :??8 $G`phy&Ngkz`~ kbm ^nqkj' :??8#" ]h ~hn`bm kbm ~xj~h{xhb hmcc`b~

    qhzh pxjgc~hm js h Cbhzbkc`bkg Zh~hkzn E`xbmkc`b $CZE# @fkb kbm h

    Ezk~hz Cb~cxh" Cb :??4' h Ezchmzcn Bkxfkbb E`xbmkc`b `z Gcjhzs' Nkcz`

    `enh' kg~` jhnkfh k n`&pxjgc~hz"

    ]h cbmht cb c~ hmcc`b kmm~ mkk `z :?;?' h f`~ zhnhb shkz `z

    qcn mkk kzh kukcgkjgh" K~ qhgg' h ~n`zh~ `z pzhuc`x~ shkz~ kuh jhhb zh&

    nkgnxgkhm x~cba zhuc~hm mkk z`f h Q`zgm Jkbl `z c~ M`cba Jx~cbh~~

    kbm Q`zgm Mhuhg`pfhb} Cbmcnk}`z~ mkkjk~h~" Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f ` }dh Kzkj

    Q`zgmc~ f`mhghm `b h kbbxkg zhp`z~ cb h ~hzch~'Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f ` }dh

    Q`zgm$Aqkzbhs kbm Gkq~`b' :??=:??3< Aqkzbhs' Dkgg' kbm Gkq~`b' :?;?< M`xn`xgcka`~ kbm Xgxjk~`agx' :??5< kbm Aqkzbhs' Gkq~`b' kbm Dkgg'

    :?;;9 ;="

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    14/74

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    15/74

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    16/74

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / 1

    N`xb}zs ~xffkzch~

    Cb h `gg`qcba ~hnc`b' qh g``l k `q hkn n`xbzs c~ ~n`zcba c~ shkz cb

    n`fpkzc~`b qc pzhuc`x~ shkz~" Qh kg~` g``l k h mkk k kzh kukcgkjgh `z

    :?;; ` ah kb cbmcnkc`b ` qk xxzh ~n`zh~ fca jh"

    ]h Kzkj ~pzcba k~ sh ` khn hn`b`fcn p`gcns mhhpgs cb f`~ bkc`b~'

    `xa c~ c~ lhs ` fhhcba h k~pczkc`b~ `z k jhhz gch knz`~~ h Kzkj

    q`zgm" E`z cb~kbnh' kg`xa h `uhzkgg ~n`zh `z Hasp' h gkzah~ ` Kzkjbkc`b~' zhfkcbhm xbnkbahm c~ shkz' mkk `z :?;; ~xaah~ k hzh qcgg jh

    k mhhzc`zkc`b cb c~ hn`b`fcn p`gcns" Lxqkc~ ~n`zh c~ kg~` gclhgs ` mhngcbh

    qcgh `b&a`cba n`bcn cb ^szck zhmxnh~ h ~pknh kbm ~khs `z zhh hn`b`fcn

    htnkbah qcgh xbmhzfcbcba h zxgh ` gkq" D`qhuhz' ~`fh bkc`b~ kzh gclhgs

    ` ~`q ~gca cfpz`uhfhb~ cb p`gcns' qc h ~cxkc`b cb F`z`nn`' xbc~ck'

    kbm Kgahzck ~`qcba pkzcnxgkz pz`fc~h' `xa' pkzcnxgkzgs cb Kgahzck' z`f

    ~fkgg hn`b`fcn jk~h~"

    ^xffkzs Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f Zk}cba~ e`z :?;? e Zkblhm N`xb}zch~ cb }dh Kzkj Q`zgm

    ? : = 5 4 ;?

    Kgahzck ;1

    Fkxzc}kbck ;5

    ^szckb Kzkj Zhpxjgcn ;8

    F`z`nn` ;=

    Micj`x}c ;>

    Hasp}' Kzkj Zhpxjgcn ;:

    ]xbc~ck ;?

    N`f`z`~ ;?

    Shfhb' Zhpxjgcn 3

    ^kxmc Kzkjck 4

    [k}kz 1

    @fkb 8

    Ghjkb`b 8

    Lxqkc} =

    I`zmkb >

    Xbc}hm Kzkj Hfczk}h~ ;

    Jkdzkcb ; 4";

    4";

    1"3

    1"4

    1"5

    1"5

    1"=

    1">

    1":

    5"4

    5"4

    5"1

    5"5

    5"8

    5":

    5"?

    8"1

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    17/74

    4 / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    ; JkdzkcbJkzkcb lhp c~ zkbl' n`fcba z~ cb c~ shkz~ zhp`z qc k `kg ~n`zh 4";' k

    ~gca cfpz`uhfhb ?"; p`cb n`fpkzcba qc c~ ~n`zh cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" C

    fkcbkcbhm c~ ~n`zh cb h ~cyh ` a`uhzbfhb k 5"5 jx mz`pphm cb zkbl z`f

    3 pgknh cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" C~ ~n`zh mcm b` nkbah cb ghakg ~zxnxzh kbm ~hnx&

    zcs ` pz`phzs zca~ hchz' qc k `kg ~n`zh ` 1": pgkncba c cb 3 pgknh" C~

    p`~cc`b k~ k bkbnckg xj cb h zhac`b qk~ ~zhbahbhm js c~ cfpz`uhfhb cb

    h knnh~~ ` ~`xbm f`bhs kzhk' n`fcba z~ cb zkbl qc k ~n`zh ` 3"> p`cb~'

    n`fpkzhm ` 3"; kbm czm pgknh cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" Cb h kzhk ` zhhm`f `

    zkmh cbhzbkc`bkggs' Jkzkcb f`uhm ` h `p ` h cbmht' xp `bh pgknh n`f&

    pkzhm ` gk~ shkz' qc h ~kfh ~n`zh ` 4"= p`cb~" Ecbkggs' cb h zhaxgkc`b `

    gkj`z' nzhmc' kbm jx~cbh~~ hzh k~ jhhb kb cfpz`uhfhb ` ?"; p`cb lhhpcba

    Jkzkcb cb h z~ pgknh n`fpkzhm ` h zh~ ` h Kzkj q`zgm"

    g``lcbae`zqkzm gcgh nkbah< pzhgcfcbkzs mkk `z :?;; ~xaah~~ k Jkzkcb~

    `uhzkgg ~n`zh qcgg gclhgs zhfkcb k kj`x h ~kfh ghuhg"

    : Xbc}hm Kzkj Hfczk}h~]h Xbchm Kzkj Hfczkh~ $XKH# f`uhm xp h gc~ khz c~ `uhzkgg ~n`zh

    cfpz`uhm js ?": p`cb `uhz c~ ~n`zh cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z ` 4";" ]h ~n`zh cb h

    kzhk ` ~cyh ` a`uhzbfhb k~ cfpz`uhm js ?"8 p`cb' lhhpcba c cb czm pgknh'

    k~ c qk~ gk~ shkz" ]h ~n`zh kbm zkbl zhfkcbhm h ~kfh cb ghakg ~zxnxzh kbm

    ~hnxzcs ` pz`phzs zca~ k 1"1 p`cb~' pgkncba h XKH cb `xz pgknh" ]h

    phz`zfkbnh cb h knnh~~ ` ~`xbm f`bhs kzhk k~ cfpz`uhm js ?"; p`cb' gccba

    c~ zkbl z`f 3 ` 1 cb c~ shkz~ zhp`z" ]h XKH nkfh cb czm khz Jkzkcb

    kbm Shfhb `z zkmcba qc h q`zgm9 c lhp c~ zkbl qc kb cfpz`uhfhb `

    ?"; p`cb' n`fpkzhm ` gk~ shkz~ ~n`zh" Cb hzf~ zhaxgkc`b jx~cbh~~' gkj`z

    kbm nzhmc h ~n`zh cfpz`uhm js ?"; p`cb' zhhncba k f`uh ` q` pgknh~ cb

    h cbmht z`f 4 ` 5"

    g``lcbae`zqkzm gcgh nkbah< pzhgcfcbkzs mkk ~xaah~~ gcgh nkbah `z h

    XKH a`cba `zqkzm"

    > I`zmkbI`zmkb k~ htphzchbnhm k jca cfpz`uhfhb cb c~ `uhzkgg ~n`zh cb c~ shkz~

    zhp`z khz ~n`zcba 1"3' fklcba c h czm f`~ hn`b`fcnkggs zhh bkc`b cb

    h Kzkj q`zgm' n`fpkzhm qc k ~n`zh ` 1"= kbm k zkbl ` 4

    cb gk~ shkz~zhp`z" Cb h ~cyh ` a`uhzbfhb kzhk' I`zmkb fkmh kb cfpz`uhfhb ` :"8

    p`cb~ xp ` 1"8' zkblcba cb = pgknh n`fpkzhm ` ;5 pgknh gk~ shkz" Bhchz

    h zkbl b`z h ~n`zh nkbahm cb h ghakg ~zxnxzh kbm ~hnxzcs ` pz`phzs

    zca~ kzhk k 1"= kbm h 1 pgknh" Cb hzf~ knnh~~ ` ~`xbm f`bhs' h ~n`zh

    zhfkcbhm k 3"? p`cb~ jx I`zmkb f`uhm xp q` pgknh~ ` czm n`fpkzhm qc

    c~ zkbl gk~ shkz" ]hzh qk~ b` nkbah cb h zhhm`f ` zkmh cbhzbkc`bkggs

    kzhk< c zkblhm 8 qc k ~n`zh ` 1"3" Ecbkggs' h ~n`zh cb h jx~cbh~~' gkj`z

    kbm nzhmc kzhk cfpz`uhm js ?"; p`cb k 1"1' f`ucba c~ zkbl z`f 1 ` 8 cb

    c~ zhp`z"

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    18/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / 3

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    g``lcbae`zqkzm fcthm< pzhgcfcbkzs hucmhbnh ~xaah~~ k I`zmkb fks jh zhcb&

    cba cb ~`fh a`uhzbfhb ~phbmcba' nzhkcba f`zh ~pknh `z zhh hn`b`fcn kncucs'

    jx hzh c~ kg~` hucmhbnh mhhzc`zkc`b cb h zxgh gkq k~ k zh~xg fcgckzs

    cbhzhzhbnh"

    = Lxqkc}Lxqkc f`uhm m`qb `bh pgknh z`f c~ zkbl ` czm gk~ shkz' qc h ~kfh

    ~n`zh ` 1"4 p`cb~" C~ zkbl cb h ~cyh ` a`uhzbfhb kzhk mz`pphm q` pgknh~'

    cb ~pch ` c~ kucba h ~kfh ~n`zh ` 5"1 p`cb~' z`f 1 cb h :??3 mkk `

    3 cb c~ shkz~ zhp`z" Bhchz h ~n`zh b`z h zkbl cb h kzhk ` ghakg ~zxn&

    xzh kbm ~hnxzcs ` pz`phzs zca~1"4 p`cb~ kbm czm pgknhkuh nkbahm

    n`fpkzhm ` gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" Lxqkc ~kzhm h `p pgknh `z knnh~~ ` ~`xbm

    f`bhs qc Jkzkcb' ~n`zcba 3"> p`cb~ qc b` nkbah n`fpkzhm ` gk~ shkz'

    jx f`uhm xp `bh pgknh cb h zhhm`f ` zkmh cbhzbkc`bkggs z`f 4 ` 1

    qc kb cfpz`uhfhb ?"; p`cb ` k ~n`zh 1"1" Lxqkc~ ~n`zh `z zhaxgkc`b

    ` jx~cbh~~' nzhmc kbm gkj`z qhb m`qb js ?"8 p`cb cb n`fpkzc~`b ` gk~ shkz'qcn px~hm c~ zkbl m`qb ` 1 z`f 8 cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z"

    {g``lcbae`zqkzm m`qb9 _zhgcfcbkzs hucmhbnh ~xaah~~ k Lxqkc c~ cbnzhk~&

    cba c~ ~cyh ` a`uhzbfhb kbm c~ kgg`qcba f`bhs az`q ` knnhghzkh"

    8 Ghjkb`b^kzcba 8 pgknh cb c~ shkz~ zhp`z qc @fkb' Ghjkb`b~ ~n`zh cfpz`uhm js ?";

    p`cb z`f 1"8 p`cb~ cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" C qk~ h jh~ phz`zfhz cb h Kzkj

    q`zgm cb hzf~ ~cyh a`uhzbfhb c~ shkz qc kb cfpz`uhm ~n`zh ?"5 p`cb

    xp z`f 4": ` 4"4' `xa c km k zkhz g`q ~n`zh ` 5"; cb h ghakg ~zxnxzh

    kzhk' n`fcba cb ;> pgknh' `bh pgknh jhhz kb gk~ shkz~ zkbl" C g`~ ?": p`cb

    cb h knnh~~ ` ~`xbm f`bhs qc k ~n`zh ` 3"?' qcn n`bzcjxhm ` c~ zkbl

    a`cba m`qb ` czm cb n`fpkzc~`b ` ~hn`bm cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" Cb h kzhk `

    zhhm`f ` zkmh cbhzbkc`bkggs' c fkbkahm ` cbnzhk~h c~ ~n`zh js ?": p`cb xp

    ` 5": jx c~ mcm b` khn c~ zkbl ;8 z`f gk~ shkz< kbm cb h kzhk zhaxgk&

    c`b jx~cbh~~' nzhmc kbm gkj`z h ~n`zh cfpz`uhm js ?"; p`cb xp ` 4"; qc kb

    cfpz`uhfhb zkbl ` czm n`fpkzhm js 4"? p`cb~ kbm k zkbl = cb gk~ shkz"

    g``lcbae`zqkzm gcgh nkbah< pzhgcfcbkzs mkk `z :?;; ~xaah~ k Ghjkb`b~

    ~n`zh qcgg zhfkcb kczgs n`b~kb"

    5 @fkb@fkb ~kzhm 8 pgknh qc Ghjkb`b cb c~ shkz~ zhp`z khz lhhpcba k ~n`zh

    1"5 p`cb~ jx mz`ppcba z`f = pgknh cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" ]h ~cyh ` a`uhzb&

    fhb c~ @fkb~ fkcb qhklbh~~ kbm jzcba~ m`qb c~ `uhzkgg ~n`zh `z c~ kzhk9

    c km h ~kfh ~n`zh k~ gk~ shkz' 8"= p`cb~' kbm mz`pphm `bh zkbl ` ;8 pgknh"

    Ghakg ~zxnxzh kbm ~hnxzcs pz`phzs zca~ c~ kb kzhk qhzh @fkb phz`zf~

    qhgg' fkcbkcbcba k ~n`zh 4"? p`cb~' qc`x k nkbah' kbm zkblcba cb ~hn`bm

    pgknh" ]h ~n`zh `z knnh~~ ` ~`xbm f`bhs cfpz`uhm js ?"; p`cb xp ` 4"= ~`

    c lhp c~ zkbl ` ;? cb h cbmht" Bhchz h ~n`zh b`z h zkbl k~ nkbahm

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    19/74

    ;? / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    `z zhhm`f ` zkmh cbhzbkc`bkggs1"3 p`cb~ kbm 8 zkblqhzhk~ c~ ~n`zh

    cfpz`uhm cb h zhaxgkc`b ` jx~cbh~~' nzhmc kbm gkj`z js ?"; p`cb xp ` 4">'

    gccba c~ zkbl ` ~hn`bm' n`fpkzhm ` czm pgknh cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z"

    g``lcbae`zqkzm gcgh nkbah< pzhgcfcbkzs mkk ~xaah~~ @fkb~ ~n`zh qcgg jh

    gcgh nkbahm cb :?;;"

    1 [k}kz[kkz nkfh cb 1}d cb h `uhzkgg zkblcba qc k ~n`zh 1"= p`cb~" ]h ~cyh `

    a`uhzbfhb kzhk cfpz`uhm ~gcags js ?"; p`cb `z k `kg ~n`zh ` 5"= p`cb~'

    f`ucba c~ zkbl `bh pgknh cahz kb gk~ shkz k ;:}d< c~ ~n`zh cb h kzhk `

    ghakg ~zxnxzh cfpz`uhm k~ qhgg js ?"; p`cb ` 1"5 p`cb~' cbnzhk~cba c~ zkbl js

    `bh pgknh xp ` 8}d" [kkz htphzchbnhm k ~gca mhhzc`zkc`b ` ?": p`cb cb h

    knnh~~ ` ~`xbm f`bhs kzhk ` ~n`zh 4"=' f`ucba c~ zkbl bh pgknh m`qb ` ;?}d"

    ]h zhhm`f ` zkmh cbhzbkc`bkggs kzhk mz`pphm js ?"= p`cb ` 1"8' f`ucba c~

    zkbl m`qb zhh pgknh~ ` 4}d cb n`fpkzc~`b ` gk~ shkz< c~ ~n`zh `z zhaxgkc`b` jx~cbh~~' nzhmc kbm gkj`z kg~` mz`pphm js ?"= p`cb ` 1">' px~cba c~ zkbl

    m`qb ~gcags js `bh pgknh ` 1}d n`fpkzhm ` c~ zkbl ` 5}d cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z"

    pg``lcbae`zqkzm xp ~gcags< [kkz fks kuh k ~gcags cfpz`uhm ~n`zh cb :?;;

    mxh ` akcb~ cb ~`xbm f`bhs"

    4 ^kxmc Kzkjck^kxmc Kzkjck~ `uhzkgg zkbl ~kshm k 4}d cb c~ shkz~ zhp`z khz c km ~n`zhm

    1"> p`cb~ n`fpkzhm ` 1"= p`cb~ cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" Cb ~pch ` fkcbkcbcba k

    ~n`zh ` 8"? p`cb~ cb h ~cyh ` a`uhzbfhb kzhk' c~ zkbl hgg js q` pgknh~ `

    ;4 cb h Kzkj q`zgm' qcn ~xaah~~ k c c~ `bh ` h p``zh~ phz`zfhz~

    cb c~ kzhk" @b h `hz kbm' ^kxmc Kzkjck c~ h jh~ phz`zfhz cb h ghakg

    zca~ kzhk' fkcbkcbcba c~ ~n`zh 4": p`cb~ k~ cb gk~ shkz~ zh~xg~" ]h knnh~~

    ` ~`xbm f`bhs qk~ kb`hz kzhk qhzh ~n`zh kbm zkbl ~kshm h ~kfh k~ gk~

    shkz k 4"4 p`cb~ kbm 5 pgknh" ^kxmc Kzkjck~ ~n`zh `z zhhm`f ` zkmh qk~

    xbnkbahm k 5"5 p`cb~ jx h zkbl mz`pphm m`qb `bh pgknh z`f k ` gk~

    shkz ` ;>" Ecbkggs' h zhaxgkc`b ` jx~cbh~~' nzhmc kbm gkj`z kzhk ~kq k mz`p

    cb ~n`zh ` ?": p`cb n`fpkzhm ` gk~ shkz~ zh~xg ` 4">' qcn f`uhm ^kxmck

    Kzkjck~ zkbl m`qb ` czm z`f ~hn`bm"

    g``lcbae`zqkzm gcgh nkbah< pzhgcfcbkzs mkk `z kxmc Kzkjck ~xaah~~ gcgh

    nkbah a`cba `zqkzm"

    3 ShfhbShfhb zkblhm cb 5 pgknh cb h uhzkgg zkbl khz g`~cba ?"> p`cb `z k ~n`zh

    1":< c f`uhm m`qb zhh pgknh~ cb h uhzkgg zkblcba z`f gk~ shkz" Cb h ~cyh

    ` a`uhzbfhb kzhk' h ~n`zh q`z~hbhm js ?"4 p`cb m`qb ` 5"=' f`ucba c~

    zkbl ~ct pgknh~ m`qb z`f 8 gk~ shkz ` ;;' qcgh c fkcbkcbhm c~ ~n`zh 5"8

    p`cb~ k ;; pgknh cb h ghakg ~zxnxzh kzhk" Cb h knnh~~ ` ~`xbm f`bhs' c

    fkcbkcbhm c~ zkbl k 4 pgknh mh~pch g`~cba ?": p`cb `z k ~n`zh ` 4"8 p`cb~"

    Kg`xa c g`~ ?"> p`cb cb h zhhm`f ` zkmh kzhk' Shfhb fkcbkcbhm c~

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    20/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / ;;

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    z~ pgknh cb c~ kzhk qc k `kg ~n`zh ` 4"= p`cb~" ]h kzhk ` zhaxgkc`b `

    jx~cbh~~' nzhmc kbm gkj`z ~kq k ~cabcnkb mz`p ` ?"5 p`cb m`qb ` 5"; qcn

    px~hm Shfhb~ zkbl m`qb `xz pgknh~ ` ;8"

    g``lcbae`zqkzm fcthm< Shfhb c~ mhnzhk~cba h fktcfxf kt zkh z`f >8(

    ` ;8( `z g`nkg zh~cmhb~' kbm :?( `z b`b&zh~cmhb~' acucba c kb cfpz`uhm

    ~n`zh cb ~cyh ` a`uhzbfhb" D`qhuhz' c~ ~n`zh qcgg gclhgs mhnzhk~h `z fcgckzs

    cbhzhzhbnh kbm c~ fcthm xbmhz ~`xbm f`bhs"

    ;? N`f`z`~]h N`f`z`~ fkcbkcbhm c~ zkbl k ;? pgknh cb c~ shkz~ zhp`z' lhhpcba kb

    `uhzkgg ~n`zh ` 5"4 p`cb~" ]h ~cyh ` a`uhzbfhb kzhk kpphkz~ ` jh h kzhk

    k gchm c~ `uhzkgg ~n`zh ~cabcnkbgs9 c knchuhm k `kg ~n`zh ` 4"? p`cb~

    cb c~ kzhk' qc`x kbs nkbah n`fpkzhm ` gk~ shkz~ ~n`zh' kbm lhp ~hn`bm

    pgknh" ]h ~n`zh cb h ghakg ~zxnxzh kzhk cfpz`uhm js ?"; p`cb ` 5"= jx k ;:

    pgknh hzh qk~ b` nkbah cb zkbl `uhz gk~ shkz< qhzhk~ c~ ~n`zh q`z~hbhm cbh knnh~~ ` ~`xbm f`bhs kzhk khz c g`~ ?": p`cb m`qb ` 5"5 p`cb~' zkbl&

    cba c ;4 kf`ba h Kzkj q`zgm kbm fklcba c bh h ghk~ zhh cb h zhac`b"

    ]h `xz kzhk htphzchbnhm k ~cabcnkb cfpz`uhfhb z`f 5"1 ` 1"> p`cb~'

    px~cba c~ zkbl xp `bh pgknh ` 3 ' qhzhk~ c~ ~n`zh mz`pphm js ?"8 p`cb cb

    h gk~ kzhk m`qb ` 8"5 p`cb~' zkblcba c ;4 kbm ~xaah~cba k c c~ `bh `

    h ghk~ zhh cb hzf~ ` zhaxgkc`b ` jx~cbh~~' nzhmc kbm gkj`z"

    pg``lcbae`zqkzm xp ~gcags< h N`f`z`~ fks akcb ~gcags cb :?;; mxh `

    zhmxnhm f`bhs az`q"

    ;; ]xbc~ckxbc~ck ~kzhm h ;? pgknh qc h N`f`z`~ khz b` nkbah ``l pgknh cb

    c~ `uhzkgg ~n`zh ` 5"4 p`cb~ cb gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" ]h ~cyh ` a`uhzbfhb ~n`zh

    zhfkcbhm xbnkbahm k 1"= p`cb~ jx c~ zkbl hgg js zhh pgknh~ m`qb ` 8 ` ;=" Ecbkggs' c~ ~n`zh q`z~hbhm cb h

    kzhk zhaxgkc`b jx~cbh~~' nzhmc kbm gkj`z js ?"8 p`cb' kggcba ` 8"8 p`cb~

    kbm f`ucba Hasp~ zkbl m`qb q` pgknh~ z`f ;1 ` ;3' fklcba c `bh ` h

    ghk~ zhh cb h Kzkj q`zgm `z c~ kzhk"

    {g``lcba e`zqkzm m`qb< Hasp c~ gclhgs hkmhm `z k mhngcbh cb c~ ~n`zh"

    _zhgcfcbkzs mkk ~xaah~ cbnzhk~h~ cb a`uhzbfhb ~phbmcba pgx~ mhhzc`zkc`b

    cb zxgh gkq' pkzcnxgkzgs z`f fcgckzs cbhzhzhbnh kbm k mhngcbh cb h cbhazcs

    ` h ghakg ~s~hf"

    ;> Micj`x}c

    Micj`xc nkfh cb ;> c~ shkz khz c g`~ ?"; p`cb cb c~ uhzkgg ~n`zh mz`ppcbac~ zkbl `bh pgknh n`fpkzhm ` gk~ shkz~ zhp`z" C fkcbkcbhm k g`q ~n`zh cb

    h ~cyh a`uhzbfhb kzhk 8"> jx sh g`~ q` pgknh~ cb zkbl m`qb ` ;1 cb

    n`fpkzc~`b ` gk~ shkz" Cb kmmcc`b' c~ ~n`zh cb h kzhk ` ghakg ~zxnxzh hgg ?"=

    p`cb m`qb ` 8": p`cb~' px~cba c~ zkbl m`qb js bh pgknh ` ;3' ~xaah~cba

    c c~ k h j``f cb h Kzkj q`zgm cb c~ zhakzm" Cb h knnh~~ ` ~`xbm f`bhs

    kzhk' c g`~ ?"> p`cb `z k ~n`zh ` 4"8' pxggcba c~ zkbl m`qb q` pgknh~ ` 4 3 > " ;8 4" >

    Fkxzc}kbck " ;8 " ;4 " :? " ;8 " ;:

    F`z`nn` " ;= " 1 ;8 " ;4 " ;:

    @fkb " ;8 4 : 4" ;? "3 8 4" :

    [k}kz " ;; " 8 4" ;? " 4 " 1

    ^kxmc Kzkjck ;4 4" ; 4"4 5 " ;> 4" >

    ^szckb Kzkj Zhpxjgcn 4 " ;1 " ;4 " ;1 " ;;

    ]xbc~ck " 8 " 8 "4 ;1 ;3 " 3

    Xbc}hm Kzkj Hfczk}h~ "3 > " = 4" 1 4" > " 5

    Shfhb' Zhpxjgcn " ;; " ;; 4" 4 4" ; " ;8

    N`xb}zch~ xbzkblhm jhnkx~h mk}k xbkukcgkjgh

    Czk{ " :; " :; 4" = "4 ;1

    Gcjsk " ;; "4 ;5 " ;= " ;?

    _kgh~}cbckb ]hzzc} zch~ " 5 " ;? 3 > " ;:

    ^`fkgck " :: ;3

    ^xmkb " :? ;8 ;; " :?

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    32/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / :>

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    @uhzkgg Zk}cba kbm Zkbl< ]zhbm

    N`fp`bhb}~ Kzhk @uhzkgg

    Zk}cba $Zkbl#

    ]zhbm)

    K

    Nzhmc} Fkzlh}

    Zhaxgk}c`b~

    J

    Gkj`xz Fkzlh}

    Zhaxgk}c`b~

    N

    Jx~cbh~~

    Zhaxgk}c`b~

    Zk}cba Zkbl Zk}cba Zkbl Zk}cba Zkbl Zk}cba Zkbl

    Kgahzck " ;3 " ;5 " 4 " ;1 p

    Jkdzkcb 4" > ?"? ; 4" ; 4" ;

    N`f`z`~ " ;> "3 ;: "3 ;4 "4 ;? p

    Micj`x}c "4 ;? 4" 1 " ;5 " ;> p

    Hasp}' Kzkj Zhpxjgcn " ;= " :? " ;> " ;: {

    I`zmkb " ;; 3"? = " ;? "3 >

    Lxqkc} " 3 " ;? " ;; "4 = {

    Ghjkb`b 4" ; 4" 5 " ;: " 8

    Fkxzc}kbck " 4 " ;8 " ;8 "? ;5

    F`z`nn` " ;; "4 ;4 4"? = " ;= p

    @fkb " 8 3" : "3 8 " 8

    [k}kz " ;8 "3 4 "3 5 " 1 p

    ^kxmc Kzkjck 4" : " 3 4" > " 4

    ^szckb Kzkj Zhpxjgcn " ;4 " ;= " 3 " ;8 {

    ]xbc~ck " 1 " ;> 4" : "4 ;? p

    Xbc}hm Kzkj Hfczk}h~ " 5 3" > " ;= 4" ;

    Shfhb' Zhpxjgcn "3 ;5 " ;1 "4 1 " 3

    Czk{ " :? 4" 8 " :?

    Gcjsk "? :;

    _kgh~}cbckb ]hzzc} zch~ " = " ;; "3 ;3

    ^`fkgck

    ^xmkb "3 ;1 " ;3 " ;1

    ) ]zhbm c~ jk~hm b pzhgcfcbkzs mk}k `z ?' b } pk~} phz`zfkbnh" ]zhbm c~ b`} cbmcnk}hm

    `z bk}c`b~ }dk} nkbb`} jh zkblhm mxh }` gknl ` mk}k"p 6 xp

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    33/74

    := / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Kgahzck 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# " $;8# " $;=# " $;8# "1 $;=# "1 $;=# "5 $;8# " $;1# " $;1# "1 $;1#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} "1 " " " " " " " "

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c b ~phbmcba " $"# "3 $"# "? $"# " $"# " $"# "? $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah AM_ 4"? $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $# 4"? $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} "? "? "? "? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h "? $# "? $# "? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ " " "1 "1 "1 "1 "1 "3 "3

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ ?"? ?"? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf " " "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 " "

    c" Bxfjhz pz`nhmxzh~ " " " " " "? "

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# " " " " " " "

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "?

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 5"5 5"5 5" 5"5 5" 5" 5" 5" 1"5

    K" F`bhs az`q}d " $"# "4 $"# "? $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $"# 4"3 $"# 3" $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? "?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs "1 "3 " " 5" "4 "1 " "4

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh " "3 " "? "3 "3 "3 "? "?

    c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# "? $"# " $"# " $"# 4" $"# 4" $# 4" $# " $"# "4 $"# "4 $"#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h " $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ " $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# "4 $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 3"? 4" " 4" 4"

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"3 " " ?"4 ?"4 ?"?

    " Zhaxgk}c`b "3 "3 "3 "3 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " " " " "

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht "4 "4 "4 " " " " "3 "3

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht " " " " " " " "

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 4"4

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3"4 3"4 3"3 3"4 3"4 3"3 3"3 3"4

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " " " " " " "

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " " " " " " " "

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    34/74

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    35/74

    :5 / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    N`f`z`~ 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 5"1 $;:# 5"4 $;?# 5"4 $;?#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} 4" 4" 4"

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba "3 $"# " $"# "3 $# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4"? $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah ` AM_

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb}

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h 4"? $# 4"? $# 4"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ " "

    J" Cb}hazc}s ` }dh ghakg ~s~}hf "? "?

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? 4"

    c" Bxfjhz ` pz`nhmxzh~ 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# " " " " "

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# " " " " "

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 5" 5" 5" 5"4 1" 1" 5"3 5"4 5"5

    K" F`bhs az`q}d " $"# " $"# " $"# 4" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4"4 $"# 4" $"# " $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $# 3" $"# 3"4 $"# 3"4 $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $"# 3" $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 5" 5" 5" 5" "1 "3 5"1 5"1 1"

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh "? "? " " "

    c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ "4 $"# "4 $"# " $# " $# " $#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ " " " " "? "4 " " "

    " Zhaxgk}c`b " " "1 " " " "1 5" "5

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " "4 " " " "4 " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ 4"? 4"?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ 3"? 3"? ?"? 3"? 3"? 3"? ?"? 3"? 3"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " 4" "3

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht " " " " " " " "? "

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht " " " " " " " "

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# " " " " " " " " "?

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "3 "3 "3 "3

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " " " " " " "4

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " "

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 3"? 3"? 3"? 4"3 4"3

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# " " " "4 "3

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    k" ]cfh $shkz~#

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h#

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    36/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / :1

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Micj`x}c 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 5"5 $;># 5"1 $;:# 5"5 $;>#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} " " "

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba "? $"# " $"# "4 $"# "? $"# " $"# " $# " $# " $# " $#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah ` AM_

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb}

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h 4"? $# 4"? $# 4"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" "5 "

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ "4 "?

    J" Cb}hazc}s ` }dh ghakg ~s~}hf " "

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz ` pz`nhmxzh~ "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# " " " " "

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 3"1 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 4" 4"4 4"

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 3" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# "3 $"# " $# "4 $"# "4 $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# 4" $# 4" $#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3"3 $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $# " $# 3" $"# 3" $#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 5" 5" 5" 5" 1" 5"3 1" 5"1 5"1

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh "4 "4 "4 "4 " " " " "

    c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h "4 $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# "3 $"# "3 $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ " " " " " " " "4 "4

    " Zhaxgk}c`b 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"3 1"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " "4 "4

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ ?"? ?"?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " " "

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ 4" 4" 4" 4" " " " " 4"

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht " " " " " " " " "

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht 4" 4" 4" " " " " "

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? 4"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# " " " " " " " " "

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" ?"?

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " " " " " " "

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " "

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# " " " " 4"?

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 4"3 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# " " " " " " " "

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# " " " " " " " "

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " " " " " " " "

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    37/74

    :4 / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Hasp}' Kzkj Zhpxjgcn 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 5" $;># 5" $;># 5" $;;# 5"1 $;?# 5"4 $;?# 1" $;?# 5"4 $;?# 5"1 $;:# 5"1 $;:#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} "1 "1 "5 "4 5" 1" 1" 5" 1"

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# "3 $"# "3 $# "3 $#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah AM_ 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# "? $"# " $"# "? $"# " $"# "3 $#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? "? "? "? "? "?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h "? $# "? $# "? $# 4"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf " " " " " "4 "4 "4 "4

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s " " " " " 4" 4" 4" 4"

    c" Bxfjhz ` pz`nhmxzh~ "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 3" 3" 3"

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# "4 "4 "3 3" 3" 3" 3"4

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " "3 "3

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 3" 3" 4"1 4"3 4"1 4" 4" 4" 4"

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 3"? $"# 4"3 $"# 4" $"# 4"? $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" }k bmk zm mh uck }c b cb k}c` b 3"4 $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4"4 $"# 4"? $"# 4"? $"# 4" $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3" $"# 3" $"# " $"# 3"? $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs " " 5"1 1" 1" 1" 1" 5" 5"

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh " " " "3 "4 " "3 "3 "4

    c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# "3 $"# " $"# "4 $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4"? $"# "3 $"#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $# " $# " $#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ " " ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ " " " " " " " " "

    " Zhaxgk}c`b " " " " " "4 "3 5" "

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? 3"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " "4 " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " " 4" ?"? ?"?

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht " " " " " " " " "

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# " " " " " " " " "

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# " " " " " " " " ?"?

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " "? " " "

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " "3 4" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 4" 4" 3"? 3" 3" 3"4 3"4 3"4

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3" 3" 4" 3" 3" 3"4 3"4 3"3

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 4" 4" 4" 4" ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# "? "? "? "? "? "? " "?

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# " " " " " " " "

    n"Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " " " "4 "4 "4 "4 "3

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    38/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / :3

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    I`zmkb 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 1"5 $1# 1"5 $1# 1"5 $1# 1"1 $8# 1"5 $8# 1"5 $=# 1" $># 1" 4"? 1"3 $>#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} "3 "4 "4 5"1 5" 5"5 5" " 1"

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c b ~phbmcba " $"# "? $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $# "4 $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah AM_ 3" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $# " $"# 4" $"#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} "? "? "? "? "? "? "? ?"? "?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# ?"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf " " " " " " " " "

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s " " " " " " " 4" 4"

    c" Bxfjhz p z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " "? "?

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# " " " " " " "

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 3"1 3" 3" 3" 4"3 3" 4" 3" 3"

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 3" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# "3 $"# " $"# "3 $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 3" $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 3" $# 3"4 $"# 3" $# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# " $"# "4 $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# 4"3 $"# "? $"# 3"3 $&"# 3"? $#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 1"3 4" 4" 4" 1"3 1"3 4" 1"3 1"3

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh " " " " " "4 "? "4 "3

    c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# "4 $"# 4"? $# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# 4"3 $"#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h "4 $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# 4"? $"# 4"? $#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ "4 $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# "? $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ " " " " "3 "3 "3 "3 "3

    " Zhaxgk}c`b 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"5 1"1

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ "3 "3 "3 " " " " " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? 3"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " " " " "

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"3 3"?

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? " 4"?

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? ?"? ?"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 ?"?

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " "4 "3 "? " " "

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " " "4 4" 4" 4"4 4"4

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ "3 " " " " " " "

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# " 4" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 4"4 4"4 3"? 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# " "4 4"? 4" 4" ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ "3 "3 "3 "? "? "? "3 "3 "3

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# "3 "4 "? "? "? "3 "3 "3

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    39/74

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    40/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / >;

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Ghjkb`b 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 1"1 $5# 1"1 $5# 1"1 $8# 1" $1# 1" $1# 1"5 $=# 1" $1# 1" $5# 1"5 $8#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"4

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba " $"# "3 $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $# " $# " $"# "4 $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah AM_ 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# "4 $"# " $# " $"# " $# " $"# " $"#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} ?"?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ " " " " " " " " "

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf " " " " " " " " "

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    c" Bxfjhz p z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 3"5 3" 3" 3"5 3" 3" 4"4 3" 3"

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $# 3" $"# 3"? $# 4"3 $"# 4" $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"3 $&"# 4"3 $"# 3" $"# "4 $"# 3"4 $"# 3" $#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 1" 1" 5"3 "3 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh "3 4" 4" " " " " " "?

    c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# " $# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ "4 $"# "4 $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ "4 "4 " " " " " " "

    " Zhaxgk}c`b 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"3 4" 4" 4"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b 4"? 4"? 4"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"?

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} "4 "4 "4 "4 " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " 4" 4" 4" 4"

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht " " " " " " " " "

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht " " " " " " " "

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" ?"?

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b "? "? "? "? "? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " "4 "4 "3 "3 " " "

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 3" 3" 3"

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " 4" 4" 4"

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 3" 3" 3"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 4" 4" 4" 4"3 4"3 3"? 3" 3"

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3"4 3"4 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " " " " " " "

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# " " " " " " " "

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# " " " " " " " "

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " "4 "? " " " " "

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    41/74

    >: / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Fkxzc}kbck 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 5" $;?# 5" $;?# 5" $;;# 5" $;;# 5" $;># 5" $;:# 5" $;=# 5" $;8# 5" $;5#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} "1 5" 5" 5" "3 5" 5"5 5" "

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba " $"# "? $"# " $"# "3 $# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# " $"# " $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah ` AM_

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? "? 4"? 4"? 4"? "?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 1"5 1"5 1"5 1"5 1"5 1"1 1"1 " "

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ " "

    J" Cb}hazc}s ` }dh ghakg ~s~}hf " "

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4

    c" Bxfjhz pz`nhmxzh~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# "4 "4 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 4" 4" 4"ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 1" 1" 1" 5"3 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" F`bhs az`q}d " $# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $# 4"? $"# " $"# "3 $"#

    J" }k bmk zm mh uck }c b cb k}c` b 3" $"# 3" $"# 4"3 $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4"4 $"# 3"? $"# 4" $"# 3" $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3" $"# 3"? $"# "3 $"# " $"# 4"4 $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ "? "? "? "? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh " " " " " " " " "

    c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h "3 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# 4" $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $# " $# " $# " $#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 " " "? "? "?

    " Zhaxgk}c`b " " " " " "5 "4 5" 5"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ ?"? ?"?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 4"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " " " " "

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ "4 "4 "4 " " " " " "

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht "? "? "? " " " " " "

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht " " " " " " " "

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? 4"? 4"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# " " " " " " " " "

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" "

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ "4 "4 "4 "4 "? " 4" 4" 4"

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " "3 "3 "3

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# "? "? "? "? "3 3" 3" 3"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 4" 4" 4" 4" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 4" 4" 4" 4"4 3"? 3" 3" 3"

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ "? "? " "? "? "? "3 "3 "?

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# " " " " " " " "

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# ?"4 "4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?" ?" "

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    42/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / >>

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    F`z`nn` 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 5" $;?# 5" $;;# 5"5 $;?# 5" $;;# 5" $;:# 5" $;:# 5" $;8# 5" $;=# 5" $;=#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} 5" 5" 5"1 5"1 5"1 5"4 5"1 5" 5"

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba " $# " $# " $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# " $"# " $"# "3 $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah ` AM_ 4" $"# 3"? $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# " $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} 4"? 4"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? 4"? 4"?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 1"3 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ " " " " " " " " "

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf ?"? 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"?

    c" Bxfjhz p z`nhmxzh~ 4"? 4"? 4"? " " " "

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# "3 " 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " " "?ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 1" 1" 1" 1" 5"4 5"4 5"1 5"3 1"

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 3" $"# 3" $# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# 4"? $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3" $"# 3"4 $"# 3" $"# 3"4 $# 3" $"# 3" $# 3" $"# 3"4 $# 3"4 $#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs "5 "5 "3 " "1 " " " "

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh " " " " " "4 " " "

    c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# " $"# "? $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# 4"? $# 4" $"# "3 $"# 4" $"#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ "4 $"# "4 $"# "4 $"# ?" $"# ?" $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# "4 $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ "3 "3 3" 3" 4" ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ " " ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"? ?"4 ?"4

    " Zhaxgk}c`b 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " "4 "4 "4 "? " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ "? "? "? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b 4"? 4"? 4"? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ 3"? 3"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " " " 4" 4"

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht "? "? "? " " " " "? "

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? " "

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? 4"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# " " " " " " " " "

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# 4" 4" 4" " " " " " "3

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " "4 "4 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ "4 "4 4"3 4"3 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 4" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3" 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"3 3"3 3"4 3"4

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 4" 4" 4" 3"3 3"3 3"3 ?"? ?"?

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " " " " " " "4

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# " " " " " " " "

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " " "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    43/74

    >= / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    @fkb 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 1"4 $=# 1"4 $># 1"4 $># 1"5 $5# 1"1 $># 1" $1# 1" $># 1"5 $=# 1"5 $8#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} "3 " " "3 " " " " "

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba ?"? $"# ?"4 $"# ?" $"# ?"? $"# ?" $"# "? $"# " $"# " $# " $#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah AM_ 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    c" Bxfjhz ` pz`nhmxzh~ 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"?

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 3"1 3"5 3" 3" 3" 4" 1"3 4" 4"

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 3" $"# 4" $"# 4" $# " $"# 4" $"# " $# "4 $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" }k bmk zm mh uck }c b cb k}c` b 3" $# 3" $# 3" $# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# 4" $# 4" $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3"3 $&"# ?"? $"# 3"4 $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4"4 $# " $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 4"5 4"5 4"5 4" 4" 4" 4" 1"3 1"3

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh 3" 3" 3" " " 4" "4 "3 "3

    c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h 4" $# 4" $# 4" $# 3" $"# 4"3 $"# 4"3 $"# 4"3 $"# 4"3 $"# 4"3 $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# " $# " $# "3 $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ " " " " "3 "3 " "4 "4

    " Zhaxgk}c`b 4" 4" 4" 1"5 1"3 1"3 1"3 4" 4"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ "3 "3 "3 " " " " " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b 4"? 4"? 4"? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? 3"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " " " " "

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"3 4"3 4"3 3" 3"

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht " " " " " " " 4" ?"?

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht " " " " " " ?"? ?"?

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? ?"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 ?"?

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " "3 "3

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"3 3" 3"

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " 4" 4"

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 3" 3" 3"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 ?"? ?"? ?"?

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 4" 4" 4" 4"3 4"3 3" 3" 3"

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " " " " " " "

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# " " " " " " " "

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " " " "4 "4 "4 "4 "4

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    44/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / >8

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    [k}kz 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 4 $:# 4 $;# 1"3 $;# 1"3 $;# 1"5 $8# 1"5 $=# 1" $># 1"5 $=# 1" $1#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah ` AM_ 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"4 $"# 3" $"# 3"3 $"# 3"4 $"# 3"? $"# 3" $"#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb}

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"5

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ " " " " " " " " "

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"3

    c" Bxfjhz p z`nhmxzh~ " " " "?

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"3

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " "

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3" 3" 3" 3"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 3"3 3"1 3" 4"3 4"5 4" 4" 4"5 4"

    K" F`bhs az`q}d "4 $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 3" $# 3" $"# 3"? $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# "4 $"# " $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz ?"? $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# " $"# " $"# "? $"# 3"? $&"# 3" $&"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 3" 3" 3" 3" 4" 4" 1"4 1"3 1"

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh 3" 3" 3" 3" 4" 4" 4" 4" "3

    $c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $# 3"? $# 3"? $#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ "? $"# "3 $"# "? $# " $"# " $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ " " " " " " " " "

    " Zhaxgk}c`b 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"1 1"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? 3"? 3"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " "

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"3 "3

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht " " " " " " " 4" 3"

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? 4"? 4"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? ?"?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs#

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" "

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4" "3

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 4"3

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " "

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3"4 3"3 3"3 3"4

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# " " " "

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# " " " "

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " " " "

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    45/74

    >5 / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    ^kxmc Kzkjck 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 1" $4# 1" $4# 1" $4# 1" $4# 1" $3# 1" $3# 1" $1# 1" $4# 1" $4#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} " " " " " " " " "

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $"# ?"? $# ?"? $"# ?" $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah ` AM_

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb}

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"4 3"4 3"4

    c" Bxfjhz ` pz`nhmxzh~ 4" 4" 4" 3" 3" 3"

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"?

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 3"5 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 4"5 4"4 4"4

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 4"4 $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4"3 $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz ?"? $"# 3"3 $"# 3"3 $"# 3"3 $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4"? $"# 3"? $"# 4"3 $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 1" 1" 1" 5"3 "3 "4 5" 5"5 5"5

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh 4" 4" 4" 3" " "3 "3 4" 4"

    $c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ " $# "4 $# "4 $"# " $"# " $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ " " " " " " " " "

    " Zhaxgk}c`b 1" 1" 1" 1"1 1"4 4" 4" 4" 4"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ "? "? "? 4"? 4"? 4" 4" 4" 4"

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} "? "? "? " " "? "? " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht ?"? 4" 4" ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4 4"4 4" 4" 4" "

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 4" 4" 4" ?"?

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? "? "? "? ?"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "?

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " "3 4" 4"

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " "4 " 3"? 3" 3" 3"

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " 4"4 4"4

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# " " "3 4" 3" 3" 3"3 3"3

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"4 3"3 3"3

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# "? "? " "3 ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ "3 "3 " "3 "3 "? " " "

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# " " " " " 4"3 4"3 4"3

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# " " " " " " " "

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " " " "3 " "? " "?

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    46/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / >1

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    ^szckb Kzkj Zhpxjgcn 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# " $;=# " $;=# "5 $;=# "5 $;8# "5 $;8# 5 $;=# "3 $;5# 5" $;5# 5" $;8#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} "3 "4 " "5 " 5" 1" 5"1 1"

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba " $"# " $"# "? $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah AM_ 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $"#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} ?"? ?"? "? "? ?"? "? "? "? "?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h 4"? $"# 4"? $"# 4"? $"# 4"? $"# 4"? $"# 4"? $"# ?"? $# 3"? $# 3"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ "5 "5 "5 "5 "1 "1 "1 "1 "1

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ " " " " " " " " "

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz p z`nhmxzh~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"4 3"4 3"4

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# ?"? ?"? ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ ?" ?" ?" ?" ?" ?" ?" ?"

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 1"4 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"3 5" 5"5 5"5

    K" F`bhs az`q}d " $"# "3 $"# " $"# " $"# 4" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 4"3 $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4"3 $"# 4" $"# 3"? $"# 4" $"# "3 $"# "4 $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz ?"? $&"# 4"4 $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# 4"? $# 3" $"# "3 $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ "? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs " " " " " "5 " " "5

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh " " " " " " " " "?

    $c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ "3 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# " $# " $#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ " " ?"? ?"? 3" ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ ?"? ?"? "? "? " " ?"4 ?"4 ?"4

    " Zhaxgk}c`b " " " " " " " 5" 5"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " "4 "4 " "4 " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ "? "?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? 3"? 3"? ?"? 3"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} ?" ?" ?" ?" ?" ?" ?" ?" "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? "

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht "? "? "? " "? " " 4"? "?

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht ?"? ?"? 4"3 ?"? "4 4"3 4"3 "

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? ?"? "?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 ?"?

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " "? "? " " "

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ " " " " "3 "3 " 4" 4"4

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 3" 3" 3"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"4 3" 3"

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# ?"? ?" ?"? " "4 " 4"? 3"

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ "? "? "? "? " " " " "?

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# " " " " " " " "

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " " " " " " " "?

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    47/74

    >4 / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    ]xbc~ck 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 5" $;?# 5" $;;# 5" $;># 5" $;;# 5"4 $;?# 5"4 $;;# 5"4 $;?# 5"4 $;?# 5"4 $;?#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} "5 " " " 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah AM_ 4" $"# " $# " $# " $# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# "? $"# "? $"#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} "? "? "? "? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 1"5 1"5 1"5 1"5 1"5 1"5 1"5 1"5 1"5

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ " " " " " " " " "

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    c" Bxfjhz ` pz`nhmxzh~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " " "ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 5"3 5"4 5"4 5"4

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4"4 $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $#

    J" } kbmk zm mh uck }c b cb k} c b 3"4 $"# 3"3 $"# 3"4 $"# 3" $"# 3" $# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs "1 "4 " " "4 "3 "3 " "

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh " "4 " " " " "3 "4 "

    $c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4"4 $"# 4"3 $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h "? $"# "? $"# "3 $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ "? $"# "? $"# "? $"# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# " $"# " $"# " $#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ "4 "4 3" 3" 3" 3" 4" 4" "

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4 ?"4

    " Zhaxgk}c`b 5"3 5"3 5"5 5"3 5"3 1" 1" 1" 1"

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " "4 " " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " "? " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " "? 4" 4" 4"

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 "3 " "

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht " " " " " " " "? "

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht " " " " " " " 4"

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? 4" ?"?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 4"4

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ 4" 4" " 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3" 3" 3"3 3"3 ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ "3 "3 " "3 "3 "3 4"? 4"? "3

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " ?"? " " " " " "

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    48/74

    Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z} / >3

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Xbc}hm Kzkj Hfczk}h~ 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 1"4 $=# 1"4 $># 1"1 $8# 1"4 $># 1"4 $:# 1"1 $># 1"1 $:# 1"3 $:# 4" $;#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} 1" 1" 1" 1"5 1"5 1"1 1"1 1" 1"3

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c`b ~phbmcba 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4"3 $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4"? $"# 4" $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah ` AM_ 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"#

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} ?"? ?"? ?"? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"1 1"1

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf " " " " " " " " "

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"4 3"4

    c" Bxfjhz p z`nhmxzh~ 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? 3"? ?"? ?"?

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 3"3 ?"? ?"?

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " "? "?

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "? "?

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# " " " " " " "4 "4ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 3" 3" 4"1 4" 4" 1"4 1"3 4"5 4"1

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 4" $"# "3 $"# " $"# "? $"# " $"# "4 $"# " $# " $"# " $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 3"? $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $"# 3"? $"# 4" $"# 4"4 $"# 4" $"# "4 $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz 3" $"# 3" $"# 3"? $# 4"4 $"# 4" $"# "4 $"# " $"# 3" $"# 3"4 $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4"3 4" 4" 4" 4"

    $c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $# ?"? $#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h 3" $# 3" $# 3" $# 3"? $"# 3"? $# 3"? $# 3"? $# 3"? $"# 3"? $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# " $"# "? $"# "? $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Nkpc}kg n`b}z`g~ " " " " " " "4 "4 "

    " Zhaxgk}c`b 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"5

    K" Nzhmc} fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" @qbhz~dcp ` jkbl~ "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    cc"E`zhcab jkbl n`fph}c}c`b 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"? 4"?

    ccc" Cb}hzh~} zk}h n`b}z`g~/bhak}cuh zhkg cb}hzh~} zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cu" Ah}}cba Nzhmc} " " " " " " " " "

    k" Ghakg Zcad}~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? "?

    j" Nzhmc} Cb`zfk}c`b Cbmht " " " " 4" 4" 4"

    J" Gkj`z fkzlh} zhaxgk}c`b~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 3"

    c" Zcacmc}s ` Hfpg`sfhb} Cbmht 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 3" 4"

    k" Mcenxg}s ` Dczcba Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    j" Zcacmc}s ` D`xz~ Cbmht "? "? "? "? "? "? 4"? "?

    n" Mcenxg}s ` Eczcba Cbmht ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    cc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} ` dczcba $( ` ~kgkzs# " " " " " " " " "

    ccc" Fkbmk}hm n`~} q`zlhz mc~fc~~kg $qhhl~ qkah~# " " " " " " " " ?"?

    cu" N`b~nzcp}c`b ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    N" Jx~cbh~~ Zhaxgk}c`b~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" ^}kz}cba k jx~cbh~~ 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"3 4"3

    k" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " " "

    j" Mxzk}c`b $mks~# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    n" N`~} $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"4 3"3 3"3

    m" Fcb" nkpc}kg $( ` cbn`fh phz nkpc}k# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" ?"? ?"?

    cc" Ng`~cba k jx~cbh~~ " " "4 " " " " " "

    k" ]cfh $shkz~# " " " " " " " "

    j" N`~} $( ` h~}k}h# " " " " " " " "

    n" Zhn`uhzs zk}h $nhb}~ `b }dh m`ggkz# " ?"? " " " " " "

  • 7/30/2019 Economic Freedom of the Arab World 2012 Annual Report

    49/74

    =? / Hn`b`fcn Ezhhm`f `e }dh Kzkj Q`zgm9 :?;: Kbbxkg Zhp`z}

    Ezchmzcnd Bkxfkbb E`xbmk}c`b / Cb}hzbk}c`bkg Zh~hkznd E`xbmk}c`b / Ezk~hz Cb~}c}x}h

    Shfhb' Zhpxjgcn 5 1 4 3

    ^xffkzs Zk}cba~ $Zkbl# 1" $3# 1" $4# 1" $3# 1" $4# 1" $1# 1" $4# 1" $1# 1" $5# 1" $3#

    Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k# Zk}cba $Mk}k#

    " ^cyh ` A`uhzbfhb} 5"1 5"3 1" 1" 5"3 5"4 1" 1" 5"

    K" Ahbhzkg a`uhzbfhb} n`b~xfp}c b ~phbmcba " $"# "4 $# " $"# " $# "3 $"# " $"# " $# " $# 4" $"#J" ]zkb~hz~ kbm ~xj~cmch~ k~ k phznhb}kah ` AM_

    N" A`uhzbfhb} hb}hzpzc~h~ kbm cbuh~}fhb} "?

    M" ]`p fkzacbkg }kt zk}h "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $# "? $#

    " Ghakg ^s~}hf % _z`phz}s Zcad}~ 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5" 5"

    K" Fcgc}kzs cb}hzhzhbnh cb zxgh gkq kbm p`gc}cn~ " " " " " " " " "

    J" Cb}hazc}s }dh ghakg ~s~}hf " " " " " " " " "

    N" Zhaxgk}`zs zh~}zcn}c`b~ b }dh ~kgh zhkg pz`phz}s 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    c" Bxfjhz ` pz`nhmxzh~ " " " " " " "

    cc" ]cfh$mks~# 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4 3"4

    ccc" N`~}$( ` pz`phz}s ukgxh# 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"4 4"4 4"4

    M" Ghakg Hb`znhfhb} n`b}zkn}~ " " " " " " " " "

    c" Bxfjhz _z`nhmxzh~ "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "4 "? "?

    cc" ]cfh $mks~# "? "? "? "? "? "? "? "?ccc" N`~} $( ` ngkcf# 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3" 3"

    " ^`xbm F`bhs 4"5 4"1 4"5 3" 4"3 4"3 4" 4"1 4"

    K" F`bhs az`q}d 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4"? $"# "3 $"# "3 $"# 4"? $"# 4" $"#

    J" }kbmkzm mhuck}c`b cbk}c`b 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 3" $"# 4" $"# "3 $"# 4"? $"#

    N" Cbk}c`b9 f`~} zhnhb} shkz " $"# "4 $"# " $"# " $"# "4 $"# 4" $"# " $# 4"3 $"# "4 $"#

    M" Ezhhm`f }` qb `zhcab nxzzhbns jkbl knn`xb}~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"?

    " Ezhhm`f }` ]zkmh Cb}hzbk}c`bkggs 4" 4" 4" 4"4 4"1 4"1 4"5 4"1 4"

    K" ]kth~ b cb}hzbk}c`bkg }zkmh 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4" 4"

    $c" Zhuhbxh z`f }zkmh }kth~ $( ` }zkmh ~hn}`z#

    cc" Fhkb }kzc zk}h 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#

    ccc" ^}kbmkzm mhuck}c`b ` }kzc zk}h~ 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"# 4" $"#

    J" Jgknl fkzlh} htndkbah zk}h~ ?"? ?"? ?"? ?"