DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12...

65
DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013

Transcript of DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12...

Page 1: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

DVCS at JLab

Como, 11/06/2013

Page 2: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

JLab published 6 GeV results

JLab 6GeV analysis in progress

JLab 12 GeV program

Page 3: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

JLab published 6 GeV results

JLab 6GeV analysis in progress

JLab 12 GeV program

Page 4: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

JLab

Duty cycle 100% Emax6 GeV Pmax80%

Page 5: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

22 '' qkpkM X LH2 / LD2 target

Polarized Electron Beam

Scattered Electron

g

N

Nucleon Detector

Left HRS

Charged ParticleTagger Electromagnetic Calorimeter

HALL AHALL ADVCS@JLab

ep epg

Page 6: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

H(e,e’)X

H(e,e’p)

H(e,e’)X - H(e,e’’)X'

H(e,e’)N

DVCS : exclusivity

• Good resolution : no need for the proton array• Remaining contamination 1.7%

HRS+calorimeterep -> epep -> ep0 0->ep -> ep0ep -> ep0N…

HRS+calorimeter + proton array

Page 7: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

DVCS Bethe-Heitler

GPDs

Page 8: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

Using the (first version) of the BKM formalism, one can extract a combination of the “Im” CFFs and their Q2-dependence

Page 9: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

e’

p

epa epg

g

420 PbWO4 crystals : ~10x10 mm2, l=160 mm Read-out : APDs +preamps

JLab/ITEP/Orsay/Saclaycollaboration

HALL BHALL B

DVCS@JLab

Page 10: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

CLAS DVCS ALU

x~0.16,-t~0.31,Q2~1.82

CLAS DVCS AUL

Page 11: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

Given the well-established LT-LO DVCS+BH amplitude

DVCS Bethe-Heitler

GPDs

Can one recover the 8 CFFs from the DVCS observables?

Page 12: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

In general, 8 GPD quantities accessible (Compton Form Factors)

with

Page 13: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

Given the well-established LT-LO DVCS+BH amplitude

DVCS Bethe-Heitler

GPDs

Obs= Amp(DVCS+BH) CFFs

Can one recover the 8 CFFs from the DVCS observables?

Two (quasi-) model-independent approaches to extract, at fixed xB, t and Q2 (« local » fitting),

the CFFs from the DVCS observables (leading-twist formalism)

Page 14: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

1/ «Brute force » fitting 

c2 minimization (with MINUIT + MINOS) of the available DVCS observables at a given xB, t and Q2 pointby varying the CFFs within a limited hyper-space (e.g. 5xVGG)

M.G. EPJA 37 (2008) 319 M.G. & H. Moutarde, EPJA 42 (2009) 71

M.G. PLB 689 (2010) 156 M.G. PLB 693 (2010) 17

The problem can be (largely) undersconstrained:JLab Hall A: pol. and unpol. X-sectionsJLab CLAS: BSA + TSA

2 constraints and 8 parameters !

However, as some observables are largely dominated bya single or a few CFFs, there is a convergence (i.e. a well-definedminimum c2) for these latter CFFs.

The contribution of the non-converging CFF entering in the error bar of the converging ones.

Page 15: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

DsUL ~ sinfIm{F1H+x(F1+F2)(H + xB/2E) –xkF2 E+…}df~ ~DsLU ~ sinf Im{F1H + x(F1+F2)H -kF2E}df~

2/ Mapping and linearization

If enough observables measured, one has a system of 8 equations with 8 unknowns

Given reasonnable approximations (leading-twist dominance, neglect of some 1/Q2 terms,...), the system can be linear(practical for the error propagation)

K. Kumericki, D. Mueller, M. Murray, arXiv:1301.1230 hep-ph, arXiv:1302.7308 hep-ph

Page 16: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

unpol.sec.eff.

+

beam pol.sec.eff.

c2 minimization

Page 17: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

unpol.sec.eff.

+

beam pol.sec.eff.

c2 minimization

beam spin asym.

+

long. pol. tar. asym

Page 18: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

unpol.sec.eff.

+

beam pol.sec.eff.

c2 minimization

beam spin asym.

+

long. pol. tar. asym

beam charge asym.

+

beam spin asym

+

linearization

Page 19: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

unpol.sec.eff.

+

beam pol.sec.eff.

c2 minimization

beam spin asym.

+

long. pol. tar. asym

beam charge asym.

+

beam spin asym

+

linearization

VGG modelKM10 model/fit

Moutarde 10 model/fit

Page 20: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

Current extractions of CFFs from DVCS

The sea quarks (low x) spread to the periphery of the nucleon while the valence quarks (large x) remain in the center

HIm:the t-slope reflects the size of the probed object (Fourier transf.)

c2 minimization

linearizationVGG model

Moutarde 10 model/fitKM10 model/fit

Page 21: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

Nucleon tomography

Page 22: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

The axial charge (~Him) appears to be more « concentrated » than the electromagnetic charge (~Him)

~

c2 minimization

linearizationVGG model

Page 23: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

JLab published 6 GeV results

JLab 6GeV analysis in progress

JLab 12 GeV program

Page 24: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

CLAS :

« e1-dvcs 1» (2005) and « e1dvcs2 » (2008)Analysis of the (pol. and unpol.) DVCS cross-sections

Several DVCS analysis under way with JLab 6 GeV data:

Page 25: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

CLAS :

« e1-dvcs 1» (2005) and « e1dvcs2 » (2008)Analysis of the (pol. and unpol.) DVCS cross-sections

Four main analyzers:

H.-S. Jo, F.-X. Girod, B. Guegan, N. Saylorfrom whom I borrowed a lot of material/slides andwhom contribution is greatly acknowledged

Several DVCS analysis under way with JLab 6 GeV data:

Page 26: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

CLAS :

« e1-dvcs 1» (2005) and « e1dvcs2 » (2008)Analysis of the (pol. and unpol.) DVCS cross-sections

Four main analyzers:

H.-S. Jo, F.-X. Girod, B. Guegan, N. Saylorfrom whom I borrowed a lot of material/slides andwhom contribution is greatly acknowledged

« eg1dvcs » (2008)Analysis of the long.pol. target asymmetries

Several DVCS analysis under way with JLab 6 GeV data:

Page 27: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

CLAS :

« e1-dvcs 1» (2005) and « e1dvcs2 » (2008)Analysis of the (pol. and unpol.) DVCS cross-sections

Four main analyzers:

H.-S. Jo, F.-X. Girod, B. Guegan, N. Saylorfrom whom I borrowed a lot of material/slides andwhom contribution is greatly acknowledged

« eg1dvcs » (2008)Analysis of the long.pol. target asymmetries

Several DVCS analysis under way with JLab 6 GeV data:

Hall A :

Rosenbluth separation of the DVCS cross-section(separation of DVCS and BH contributions)

Page 28: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

Samples of CLAS « e1-dvcs2 » analysis

5.88 GeV beam energy

Page 29: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

Samples of CLAS « e1-dvcs2 » analysis

5.88 GeV beam energy

Page 30: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 31: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 32: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 33: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 34: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

Data

MC

Ratio

Acceptances

Page 35: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 36: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

Elastic cross section from « e1-dvcs2 »

Page 37: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 38: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 39: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 40: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 41: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

Thanks to I. Akushevich

Page 42: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 43: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 44: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 45: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 46: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 47: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

How to go from momentum coordinates (t) to space-time coordinates (b) ?

(with error propagation)

Burkardt (2000)

From CFFs to spatial densities

Applying a (model-dependent) “deskewing” factor:

and, in a first approach, neglecting the sea contribution

Page 48: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 49: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 50: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 51: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 52: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 53: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 54: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

JLab published 6 GeV results

JLab 6GeV analysis in progress

JLab 12 GeV program

Page 55: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

JLab Upgrade to 12 GeV

CHL-2

Enhance equipment in existing halls

Add new hall

Page 56: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 57: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

GPD program at JLab 12 GeV (Halls A, B and C)

DVCS beam asymmetry ALU on proton&neutron

DVCS long. target spin asymmetry AUL on proton&neutron

DVCS long. target spin asymmetry AUT on proton&neutron

DVCS unpolarized cross sections on proton

DVMP: pseudoscalar mesons

DVMP: vector mesons

Page 58: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

Simulations Hall A@12GeV

Precision study of the Q2 scaling law

Validation of the GPD formalism,Estimation of the higher twist corrections90 days of DVCS

L~1038cm-2s-1

Page 59: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

E12-06-119Similar studies for AUL,AUT,ALL,ALT,… as well

Page 60: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

Projections for CLAS12 for HIm

Page 61: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

Corresponding spatial densities

Page 62: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.
Page 63: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

f= 60°xB = 0.2Q2 = 2 GeV2

t = -0.2 GeV2

DVCS BSA: sensitivity to Ju,d

DVCS on the proton Ju=.3, Jd=.1

Ju=.8, Jd=.1

Ju=.5, Jd=.1

Ju=.3, Jd=.8

Ju=.3, Jd=-.5

Ee = 11 GeV

Page 64: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.

f= 60°xB = 0.17Q2 = 2 GeV2

t = -0.4 GeV2

n-DVCS BSA is:• very sensitive to Ju, Jd • can be as strong as for the protonAccording to the kinematics and Ju, Jd

DVCS on the neutron Ju=.3, Jd=.1

Ju=.8, Jd=.1

Ju=.5, Jd=.1

Ju=.3, Jd=.8

Ju=.3, Jd=-.5

Ee = 11 GeV

DVCS BSA: sensitivity to Ju,Jd

Page 65: DVCS at JLab Como, 11/06/2013. JLab published 6 GeV results JLab 6GeV analysis in progress JLab 12 GeV program.