Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

download Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

of 41

Transcript of Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    1/41

    SIT Graduate Institute/SIT Study Abroad

    DigitalCollections@SIT

    ISP Collection SIT Study Abroad

    4-1-2011

    Duality in Bouazizi: Appraising the ContradictionAlec JacobsonSIT Graduate Institute - Study Abroad, [email protected]

    This Unpublished Paper is brought to you for free and open access by the SIT Study Abroad at DigitalCollections@SIT. It has been accepted for

    inclusion in ISP Collection by an authorized administrator of DigitalCollections@SIT. For more information, please contact

    [email protected].

    Recommended CitationJacobson, Alec, "Duality in Bouazizi: Appraising the Contradiction" (2011).ISP Collection. Paper 1009.http://digitalcollections.sit.edu/isp_collection/1009

    http://digitalcollections.sit.edu/http://digitalcollections.sit.edu/isp_collectionhttp://digitalcollections.sit.edu/study_abroadmailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://digitalcollections.sit.edu/study_abroadhttp://digitalcollections.sit.edu/isp_collectionhttp://digitalcollections.sit.edu/
  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    2/41

    D B:

    A C

    A J

    2011

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    3/41

    1

    W M B S B

    . W ,

    D 17, 2010, ,

    . T , ,

    ,

    . B , W,

    ,

    , M B,

    17

    J 2011.

    B

    ,

    W A S, M B

    .

    W ,

    ,

    . S ,

    . F , :

    , F , ,

    , F

    . A , T,

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    4/41

    2

    . I B,

    T I

    .

    T B ,

    I . M

    , . I

    , , B

    . F , S

    B

    . N

    , ,

    B

    : , B A

    . T,

    M B , , ,

    . T L M, I

    , , ,

    , . T

    B

    J 14

    . I T ,

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    5/41

    3

    . T M B

    . A

    , , ,

    . F

    , B

    , .

    I ,

    B T. M

    L M , I

    . I , ,

    I B,

    . F , I

    M B J

    R

    .

    R B

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    6/41

    4

    I G . T I .

    A, 21

    H . T , , ,

    B. M

    , ,

    , I

    R. W I ,

    14 J. T

    . S I .

    M B R, , I

    .

    I, 23, ,

    , , ,

    , ,

    . A

    , , B

    R,

    . B , , H

    R ? A , I :

    ,

    F. L T

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    7/41

    5

    . O ,

    , .

    B C T

    . N ,

    : ,

    , . T,

    , ,

    T . B ,

    . T , , ,

    ,

    . B ,

    C , T

    , S B

    . T

    . A C ,

    T , I

    T T (LS, 1955).

    A B F:

    P , . T

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    8/41

    6

    (105).

    L , F,

    E . B ,

    . W , ,

    , F. E , A

    L, L : .

    I , , I R. I .

    T B A

    B ,

    . P

    , ,

    :

    , .

    T B :

    ,

    , . T

    ,

    .

    D, F ,

    . T, , ,

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    9/41

    7

    . I B

    , ,

    . D ,

    . B

    , . W

    ,

    D ,

    A . B

    T , ,

    , . , ,

    S B,

    .

    T

    B , ,

    ,

    R. T

    , ,

    B. T

    B A.

    A R

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    10/41

    8

    T 17

    , . T B

    . M

    , ,

    . S

    ,

    , , , .

    A ,

    , :

    .

    O , B

    . T ,

    B . T

    . A

    , B . H

    . W

    M. A,

    B T ,

    . H ,

    . I

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    11/41

    9

    . I

    . R ,

    . L , B

    R F .

    B J 4.

    B , I

    . T

    ,

    M M E C A , I,

    T, P U (C G 2004:783). T

    , : 1)

    (

    ) ( )

    (K 2010:83), 2)

    (781). I ,

    ,

    (781). T

    ,

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    12/41

    10

    , ,

    .

    T . T , , , . F , . H 15 , , , , , (A, 1997:53).

    T,

    ,

    .

    T

    . T

    , ,

    , (C

    G 2004:788). K ,

    , ,

    . I T,

    K ,

    , , , ,

    (2010:77). T ,

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    13/41

    11

    ,

    . S

    ,

    .

    T B ,

    . I

    . I

    M (C G 2004),

    :

    , . B

    C A,

    . P ,

    , B .

    R ,

    , ,

    . T, M

    .

    T

    . L ,

    , . U

    , B

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    14/41

    12

    . T

    , .

    S B.

    W ,

    . T T

    , (B,

    G W T, 2011). A

    B ,

    , ( 2011) , M .

    T ,

    ,

    ,

    , . S,

    ,

    , B .

    P , , , , , . I , ,, (A 2006:102).

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    15/41

    13

    A ,

    . T ,

    ,

    . D A

    ,

    . W ,

    ,

    . I ,

    , B

    . B

    . H

    . T

    ,

    . O

    , B

    , .

    I

    , B

    . T,

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    16/41

    14

    B , I

    L W (2003).

    W EAC

    , (2175). A

    A ,

    :

    ,

    (2173). T

    ,

    . U , ,

    ,

    (2169). T

    . T

    , ,

    . T

    , ,

    . A

    , ,

    ,

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    17/41

    15

    .

    T

    A , , B

    W . W

    , , ,

    , ,

    , S B .

    P, , ' . I, , (D 1996:70).

    B ,

    , . H

    ,

    ,

    .

    T ( I

    ), T

    . I () S B,

    , A, ,

    .

    D

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    18/41

    16

    :

    ,

    . T

    B,

    ,

    .

    T B ,

    S B. T

    . L

    . L ,

    . T

    : ,

    .

    B , ,

    , .

    D, W ,

    ,

    (1996:70). T I

    (70). I

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    19/41

    17

    ,

    . T

    , ,

    ,

    . I

    .

    A K (1988)

    . I

    ,

    . T

    ,

    . T

    . A

    .

    U ,

    B , L! H ! T

    . T

    , T . T , ,

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    20/41

    18

    , , B ,

    ; B

    , . S B A,

    , , K K

    C C R (1994),

    ,

    . I B S B,

    , . T

    ,

    B,

    ,

    ;

    T , C, , , , (K K1994:718).

    I M B

    . W

    B ,

    . T ,

    ,

    B . M , B

    B, ,

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    21/41

    19

    , . T

    S B, , , ,

    B,

    ,

    .

    T N

    B ,

    ,

    . T

    . T

    B

    ,

    . T : , ,

    , , . T

    B

    . T B,

    ,

    , M B

    , .

    T T

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    22/41

    20

    B , :

    . A , B

    F,

    T ; W

    (L, F

    J R, 2011). F ,

    B .

    N M S N

    F 17, . A , B A

    2008 G,

    . A

    , . T F

    B A ,

    , ,

    . I

    ,

    . N

    ,

    .

    I , , ,

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    23/41

    21

    .

    T D 28 L M,

    ,

    . I

    B ,

    . I

    ,

    ? T , ,

    , (R, N T). T

    B R, I

    //

    .

    I ,

    ,

    . I ,

    ,

    , I ,

    . T ,

    , .

    I ,

    , . T

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    24/41

    22

    ,

    ,

    . T J R ,

    . I 13 J,

    T B A. T

    , , , J

    P B V ,

    , ,

    . T , ,

    , ,

    .

    I , B

    , , ,

    . T

    S B ,

    ,

    .

    T, ,

    B ,

    .

    B, ,

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    25/41

    23

    . O , B ,

    , , ,

    . N

    , .

    M F (W P, M 27)

    : ,

    R.

    O M B A , , .W , , I . T .

    H 10,000 ( $14,000) B A

    B , 1.4

    . T ,

    , ,

    .

    I L M

    . B

    : ,

    ,

    . W , B

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    26/41

    24

    , ;

    ,

    .

    T B

    , S B B

    . N

    T

    R. P

    B K M ,

    ,

    ? A , M B

    :

    . S

    S B L M ,

    I .

    T

    , ,

    , . M

    . J ,

    ,

    : M , ,

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    27/41

    25

    , . S

    S B,

    R

    S B. A ,

    I . A , ,

    ,

    . H ,

    , . T

    :

    , . T ,

    T .

    B A

    ,

    . J

    , B A

    . B

    S B,

    S. A M , B A

    . O D

    28, . N ,

    : B A ,

    ,

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    28/41

    26

    B. T B A

    ,

    B . T ,

    P, :

    B T

    . B

    ,

    B . I , , B A

    , ,

    . B A

    ,

    , B

    .

    B ,

    B .

    B A M

    . T

    . U,

    B , I

    . T ,

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    29/41

    27

    . B A

    . I

    T, I ,

    , . F

    , , T

    .

    PD C

    O J 14, B A . W ,

    T , . T

    A B , B A

    . N

    , ,

    , , ,

    . T

    B A

    , ,

    , , T :

    , T. I

    ,

    .

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    30/41

    28

    D , M

    B F, ,

    , ,

    , . T

    , : J

    M E B 3030 , M B

    L N D. RIP 1533, F V T D :

    172825 . D

    , ,

    , . I

    ,

    , I

    . W , B

    ,

    .

    F J 14 ,

    R. M

    B J 4

    , R

    ,

    T. E

    ,

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    31/41

    29

    B B A.

    ,

    .

    I , ,

    . T , I

    ,

    A H. T G

    , , M , A

    . S

    B , ,

    . W

    ,

    . F ,

    : .

    D . T

    B, :

    , B

    I A L

    (M B: A O L),

    T , B A . T

    B

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    32/41

    30

    , R: (

    ) . T

    . T

    B ,

    T ;

    .

    C B

    . M ,

    , ,

    A B A

    . T ,

    , ,

    . T , ,

    P . T

    , F

    . W

    ,

    .

    T

    F P 7 N P M B.

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    33/41

    31

    T B A

    B, .

    T

    . S J 15

    R , 12489

    . H,

    ,

    14. T 15

    19, B ,

    5

    . P F,

    172000 B ,

    .

    T M B

    , I ,

    ,

    .

    A

    . I B ,

    . W

    R,

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    34/41

    32

    .

    S,

    .

    O J 22, S T

    A B M B 10

    T (A T ). I F,

    , T H, T B A

    M B. L F,

    B A

    B,

    .

    T ,

    (A T), B . T

    ,

    B O S F,

    . I ,

    , :

    . I ,

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    35/41

    33

    . T

    T ,

    , . I B

    S B (A T), T

    . T

    M B ,

    10 T

    . T

    , T,

    . D , T

    .

    B A ,

    2012 O. A ,

    : T, T ,

    T , ,

    B (R). M

    M B B A

    T . H

    , B ,

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    36/41

    34

    I' T T . A . B C TS J P C" (R).

    B

    A S, B A

    ,

    . L T,

    , .

    I , , B

    . T ,

    ,

    B

    S B L M I

    . A , , B

    , , ,

    . A ,

    B, ,

    , .

    C

    W M B , ,

    . T

    ,

    , S B . T 23

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    37/41

    35

    .

    F , ,

    . I ,

    . W M B

    (T), .

    W , ,

    . W

    , ,

    , ,

    . T

    M B

    ,

    . T ,

    M B /

    . I

    . I

    ,

    ,

    J R.

    T I B

    . R

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    38/41

    36

    . T B

    ,

    . I

    .

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    39/41

    37

    W C

    A. P . A. 2011.

    A, K. "T TK: I P S."108.1 (2006): 10013. P.

    A, J, L T, P S, K F, S B."P T A SI." 19 (1997): 5155. P.

    . W. 07 M2011. .

    A C T. .A C T, 2011. P.

    B, R. G W T. SIT T: E I

    N A. S B S. 24 M. 2011. L.

    "B A R L T E T E A L M ." . P.

    B, M. P . 25 A. 2011.

    C, E A., I . G. "MUSLIM CULTURE AND FEMALESELFIMMOLATION: IMPLICATIONS FOR GLOBAL WOMENS HEALTHRESEARCH AND PRACTICE." 24 (2004):78293. P.

    C. P . A. 2011.

    D, V. "L B: T C P."125.1 (1996): 6791.. W. 13 A. 2011.

    D, V. "V T." 75.1 (2002): 10512. P.

    F. P . A. 2011.

    F, M. "I T, A O F V U W R A W." 27 M. 2011. P.

    F V T D, F." . W. 12 A. 2011..

    I, L, M. "F J R: R T." SIT T: E I N A. S B S. 31M. 2011. L.

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    40/41

    38

    I. P . A. 2011.

    "J N V O J M E B F." .W. 20 M. 2011. .

    K, T, A M, R G. M. "M C C S: G D R L." 54.4 (2009): 93842. P.

    K, KH. O. "W SI S P." 49.1 (2010): 7591. P.

    K, A, J K. "H B R: S M B E C, R, D C' C R." 25.3 (1994): 70723. P.

    K, A, J K. "T A E; T D I: C A S O T." 124.1(1996): 123. P.

    K, A. "E T R M": S S, S, R O H E D W." 90.3 (1997): 31535.. W. 13 A. 2011..

    K, A. "T V P P V." , , . N :B, 1988. 5674. P.

    LS, C. T T. L P, 1955.

    "M B L N D. RIP F." . W. 20 M.2011. .

    "P Q L P 7 N E T S R P MBOUAII C.." . .15 J.2011. W. 20 M. 2011. .

    "P D T C A A J E." .25 D. 2010. W. 07 M 2011.

    .

    R. "14 K C W P V S T." 10 J. 2011. P.

    R, A. "T B A P F M B FC.." . .

  • 8/13/2019 Duality in Bouazizi- Appraising the Contradiction

    41/41

    25 F. 2011. W. 06 M 2011..

    S, D. P . 29 A. 2011.

    S, C., R. M, G. R, R. C. "G D M S S A: A S S I." 144.1 (2006): 7986. P.

    T. P . 20 A. 2011.

    W, L. "E C A B I F." 36.12 (2004): 2161178. P.