Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible...
Transcript of Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible...
![Page 1: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states
containing heavy quarks
J.-M. Richard
To cite this version:
J.-M. Richard. Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks.International Workshop on Heavy Quarkonium QWE 2003, Sep 2003, Batavia, United States.23 transparents-, 2003. <in2p3-00020383>
HAL Id: in2p3-00020383
http://hal.in2p3.fr/in2p3-00020383
Submitted on 30 Jan 2004
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinee au depot et a la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publies ou non,emanant des etablissements d’enseignement et derecherche francais ou etrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou prives.
![Page 2: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Multicharm and multiquark statesJean-Marc Richard
Laboratoire de Physique Subatomique et Cosmologie
Universite Joseph Fourier – IN2P3
53, avenue des Martyrs, F-38026 Grenoble Cedex, France
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.1/23
![Page 3: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
etc.Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.2/23
![Page 4: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Outline• Double-charm baryons• Brief survey of multiquark candidates• Tetraquarks with hidden or naked charm• not covered here: weak decays of double charm
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.3/23
![Page 5: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Single-charm baryons (as quark–diquark?)
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.4/23
![Page 6: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Single-charm baryons-2Qqq states tentatively described in a variety of models:potential, bags, etc.Many data in recent years on ground and excited states withS = 0, S = −1 and S = −2. Minor problems, e.g., isospinsplittings.Note: Hierarchy of lifetimes OKbut the spread of values is larger than expected.
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.5/23
![Page 7: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Spectroscopy of QQq baryonsProbably the most interesting among ordinary hadronsto study confinement dynamics.It combines:
the slow Q − Q relative motion, as in quarkonia
the relativistic q motion, as in D’s and B’s.
Two main strategies:• diquark–quark• Born– Oppenheimer
The first excitations are mainly in Q − Q.
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.6/23
![Page 8: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Diquark–quark pictureFor sure Q − Q clustering inside QQq.Two steps strategy:
1. Calculate QQ
2. Calculate [QQ] − q
Step #2 is O.K. But in step #1, care that V (QQ) iseffective.
In the H.O. model, V = K(r212 + r2
23 + r231) is exactly
V = 3/2Kr2QQ + 2Kr2
q−[QQ]. So 1/3 of QQ interactioncomes from the q field.
Similarly, in H+2 , the p − p force comes from the electron.
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.7/23
![Page 9: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Born–OppenheimerTheorem: The Born–Oppenheimer approximation works
always better than expected.
See, e.g., Fleck and R. (PTP, 1989). Two steps:
1. Freeze out rQQ. Calculate the “electronic energy”, i.e. theenergy of q in the 2-centre problem.
2. Veff(QQ) = this energy + direct Q − Q.Then solve the Q − Q problem
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.8/23
![Page 10: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
ResultsVariants of the bag model also tried. Not very stable v.s.parameter changes.
Results of potential models rather stable vs. choice ofpotential
Typically:• ccq ground-state near 3.6 GeV• hyperfine splitting about 80 MeV• orbital excitation about 300 MeV• flavour excitation (ccs) − (ccd) near 90 MeV.
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.9/23
![Page 11: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
InequalitiesUnder reasonable assumptions, (See Lieb, Martin et al.,Nussinov)flavour independence implies
M(M,M,m) ≤ 2M(M,m,m) −M(m,m,m) ,
relating ccq to cqq and qqq, leading to a potential-independent
M(ccq) ≤ 3.7GeV
for the average of the hyperfine multiplet. Can be refined. Also
q → s.
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.10/23
![Page 12: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Towards a better calculationStancu (Liege) + R. (project). Help welcome.Use the Born–Oppenheimer approximation,with a better treatment of light quark dynamics for fixed rQQ,e.g.,
• lattice QCD a
• relativistic equation probed for D mesons
Progress expected.aA direct lattice study (without Born– Opennheimer) recently
published by Flynn et al., UKQCD
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.11/23
![Page 13: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Multiquarks: 1. Possibly related to ourdiscussion
• many scalar mesons → qqqq?• including perhaps I = 2 exotics• Light pentaquark S = +1 seen in several experiments• D∗
s,J possibly a kind of multiquark
17) HINTS FOR A I = 2 PI PI RESONANT STATE IN THE ANTI-N P --> PI+ PI+ PI- ANNIHILATION REACTION.By OBELIX Collaboration (A. Filippi for the collaboration). 2001. Prepared for Biennial Conference on Low-Energy Antiproton Physics (LEAP 2000), Venice, Italy, 20-26 Aug 2000. Published in Nucl.Phys.A692:287-294,2001
LaTeX(US) | LaTeX(EU) | Harvmac | BibTeX | KeywordsScience DirectConference InfoEXP CERN-PS-201
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.12/23
![Page 14: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Multiquarks: 2. H
Jaffe: H (uuddss) 150 MeV below ΛΛ threshold
Due to chromomagnetic forces (or bag model analogue)
−g∑
i<j
λi.λj σi.σj
mimjδ(3)(rij)
Hardly survives:SU(3)F breakingOther terms in the HamiltonianA realistic 〈δ(3)(rij)〉
H search in many exp., e.g., 6ΛΛHe → H + α not seen.
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.13/23
![Page 15: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Multiquarks: 3. Heavy pentaquark P
P Proposed by Gignoux et al. and by Lipkin (1987)P = Qqqqq with qqqq = uuds, udds or udss.150 MeV below D + Λ threshold?
Also due to chromomagnetic forces
Binding suffers from:
M(Q) < ∞SU(3)F breakingOther terms in HamiltonianA realistic 〈δ(3)(rij)〉
P search at Fermilab (Ashery et al.). Next: Compass
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.14/23
![Page 16: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
4. Hidden-charm tetraquarks QQqq
Cf. Belle state at 3.8 GeV
Already proposed for Ψ(4.03), which turned out to be cc
A long history, see Okun, Voloshin, De Rujula et al.,Törnqvist , Manohar and Wise, Ericson and Karl, etc.
D∗
D
D D∗
π
Yukawa potential V = −g exp(−µr)/r, g weaker than forNN , but mg OK. DD
∗
nearly bound. BB∗
probably.
Short range interaction? (repulsive?)
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.15/23
![Page 17: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
5. Double-charm tetraquarks QQqq
QQqq studied in quark model or lattice by Ader et al.(then at CERN), Heller et al. (Los Alamos), Zouzou et al.(Grenoble), Lipkin (Argonne), Silvestre-Brac et al.(Grenoble), Brink and Stancu (ECT*, Trento), Rosina etal. (Slovenia), Michael et al. (UKQCD), etc., See, also,T. Barnes.(Oak Ridge), Nussinov
All agree! stable, i.e., below the threshold (Qq) + (Qq), ifM/m large enough.
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.16/23
![Page 18: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
QQqq (Cont.)This is a chromoelectric effect. In a flavour-independentpotential, heavy particles enjoy more binding.
If flavour independence is taken seriously, even for lightquarks, then close analogy with
atomic physics:Ps2(e
+, e+, e−, e−) weakly b.H2(p, p, e
−e−) more deeply b.HH(p, e+, p, e−) unstable
In simple quark models:(qqqq) unbound(QQqq) stable if Q � q
(QqQq unbound without LR
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.17/23
![Page 19: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
QQqq (Cont.)
In the limit of large M/m, remarkable structure• Q + Q → (Q,Q) with colour 3 as in baryons.• (Q,Q)3 + q + q → colour singlet like in every antibaryon.
So well known colour structures and wave functions, unlike themore speculative colour chemistry of Chan H.M. et al.
Charmed quark c perhaps not heavy enough, BUT
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.18/23
![Page 20: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
QQqq (Cont.)Other approach by Törnqvist (Helsinki), Manohar andWise, Ericson and Karl
D∗ D
D D∗
π
Yukawa potential V = −g exp(−µr)/r between D andD∗.Coupling g weaker than for NN , but m(D) > m(N).What matters is mg.
π- exchange a little marginal to bind DD∗.
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.19/23
![Page 21: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
QQqq (end)A proper combination of
short-range attraction, as given by UKQCD or quarkmodels
long-range attraction, due to π-exchange
could well give a stable tetraquark with charm = 2
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.20/23
![Page 22: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Conclusion: double charmInteresting weak decay
ccq: laboratory for confinement, in particular
Aspects of light quark dynamics enhanced
Possibility of exotics with heavy flavour
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.21/23
![Page 23: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Lessons from recent findingsLight quark dynamics might be more subtle than thesimple chromomagnetic interaction of Jaffe, Lipkin, etc.
QQqq Arguments based on flavour independence, analogywith atomic physics probably OK. However, the role ofmeson–meson long-range interaction is crucial.
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.22/23
![Page 24: Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states ... · Double-charm baryons : Possible multiquarks states containing heavy quarks J.-M. Richard To cite this version: J.-M. Richard.](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022031508/5ca1cbd488c993f7068cc863/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Beyonddoublecharm
TRIPLECHARMcccUltime goalof baryonspectroscopy(Bjorken)
Multicharms & Multiquarks, QWG, FNAL, 2003 – p.23/23