Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron...
Transcript of Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron...
![Page 1: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Most challenges of calculating thermonuclear burning in supernova are resolved
Doron Kushnir
(Weizmann)
With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann)
8/8/19
![Page 2: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
~10% accuracy is required to resolve the type Ia supernova problem
§ Could
0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2
10-1
100
![Page 3: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
We want to calculate the ejecta from first principles
§ Collision of two 0.64 Msun CO WDs with an impact parameter of 0.2(R1+R2).
![Page 4: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
We want to calculate the ejecta from first principles
§ Collision of two 0.64 Msun CO WDs with an impact parameter of 0.2(R1+R2).
§ FLASH4.0, Δx≈8 km.
![Page 5: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
We want to calculate the ejecta from first principles
§ Collision of two 0.64 Msun CO WDs with an impact parameter of 0.2(R1+R2).
§ FLASH4.0, Δx≈8 km. § 13 isotope ⍺-net.
![Page 6: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
We want to calculate the ejecta from first principles
§ Collision of two 0.64 Msun CO WDs with an impact parameter of 0.2(R1+R2).
§ FLASH4.0, Δx≈8 km. § 13 isotope ⍺-net. § With burning limiter.
![Page 7: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Log10(Normalized integrated mass)
We can directly measure the 56Ni distribution in the ejecta with nebular spectra
![Page 8: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Log10(Normalized integrated mass) § Assume we have an isolated emission line
We can directly measure the 56Ni distribution in the ejecta with nebular spectra
![Page 9: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Log10(Normalized integrated mass)
θ=0
§ Assume we have an isolated emission line
ϕ=135°
We can directly measure the 56Ni distribution in the ejecta with nebular spectra
![Page 10: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Log10(Normalized integrated mass)
θ=0
θ=30°
§ Assume we have an isolated emission line
ϕ=135°
We can directly measure the 56Ni distribution in the ejecta with nebular spectra
![Page 11: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Log10(Normalized integrated mass)
θ=0
θ=30° θ=60°
§ Assume we have an isolated emission line
ϕ=135°
We can directly measure the 56Ni distribution in the ejecta with nebular spectra
![Page 12: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Log10(Normalized integrated mass)
θ=0
θ=30° θ=60°
θ=0
§ Assume we have an isolated emission line
ϕ=135°
ϕ=90°
We can directly measure the 56Ni distribution in the ejecta with nebular spectra
![Page 13: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
§ [CoIII] line profile near 5900 Å is the 56Ni distribution
SN2007ontakenbyFolatellietal.2013
Dong et. at, 2014
Double peak features are observed
![Page 14: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
§ [CoIII] line profile near 5900 Å is the 56Ni distribution
§ 2007on is a collision
SN2007ontakenbyFolatellietal.2013
Dong et. at, 2014
Double peak features are observed
![Page 15: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
§ [CoIII] line profile near 5900 Å is the 56Ni distribution
§ 2007on is a collision § 4/20 SNe have non-single-peak profile
SN2007ontakenbyFolatellietal.2013
Dong et. at, 2014
Double peak features are observed
![Page 16: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
§ [CoIII] line profile near 5900 Å is the 56Ni distribution
§ 2007on is a collision § 4/20 SNe have non-single-peak profile ⇒ 4 SNe are collisions, possibly consistent with all them being collisions (viewing angle effect).
SN2007ontakenbyFolatellietal.2013
Dong et. at, 2014
Double peak features are observed
![Page 17: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
§ [CoIII] line profile near 5900 Å is the 56Ni distribution
§ 2007on is a collision § 4/20 SNe have non-single-peak profile ⇒ 4 SNe are collisions, possibly consistent with all them being collisions (viewing angle effect).
SN2007ontakenbyFolatellietal.2013
Dong et. at, 2014
Double peak features are observed
See also Vallely+ 2019
![Page 18: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
100IAS survey
![Page 19: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
100IAS survey § Aims to systematically observe the nebular spectra of a complete sample of (100) low-z SNe (PI Dong).
![Page 20: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
100IAS survey § Aims to systematically observe the nebular spectra of a complete sample of (100) low-z SNe (PI Dong).
§ We have measured the 56Ni mass distribution in ~90 SNe.
Dong et. at, 2018
![Page 21: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
100IAS survey § Aims to systematically observe the nebular spectra of a complete sample of (100) low-z SNe (PI Dong).
§ We have measured the 56Ni mass distribution in ~90 SNe.
§ Can we compare it to calculations?
Dong et. at, 2018
![Page 22: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Simulated 56Ni mass do not agree R
atio
to S
hen
et a
l. po
st-p
roce
ssed
Shen et al. 2018 hydro
Sim et al. 2010 Blondin et al. 2017
Shen et al. 2018 Townsley et al. 2016 method
Moll et al. 2014 Shigeyama et al. 92
Sub-Chandra - central ignition of a detonation wave
Shen et al. 2018
![Page 23: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Simulated 56Ni mass do not agree R
atio
to S
hen
et a
l. po
st-p
roce
ssed
Shen et al. 2018 hydro
Sim et al. 2010 Blondin et al. 2017
Shen et al. 2018 Townsley et al. 2016 method
Moll et al. 2014 Shigeyama et al. 92
Sub-Chandra - central ignition of a detonation wave
• In order to compare to nebular observations, we must be able to accurately calculate the 56Ni distribution (to ~10%).
Shen et al. 2018
![Page 24: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Major problems:
![Page 25: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Major problems:
1. The burning length scale is small (~1 cm)
![Page 26: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Major problems:
1. The burning length scale is small (~1 cm)
• Ignition
![Page 27: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Major problems:
1. The burning length scale is small (~1 cm)
• Ignition
• Detonation propgation
![Page 28: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Major problems:
1. The burning length scale is small (~1 cm)
• Ignition
• Detonation propgation
2. NSE scale can be small
![Page 29: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Major problems:
1. The burning length scale is small (~1 cm)
• Ignition
• Detonation propgation
2. NSE scale can be small
3. Many (>100) isotopes are required
![Page 30: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Major problems:
1. The burning length scale is small (~1 cm)
• Ignition
• Detonation propgation
2. NSE scale can be small
3. Many (>100) isotopes are required
![Page 31: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Simulations cannot resolve the detonation wave § Detonation wave scale – 1-10 cm <<<< WD scale 10000 km ⇒ unfeasible for simulations. Imshennik & Khokhlov 84
Khokhlov 89
![Page 32: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
106 107 108
100
102
104
106
108
1010
1012
Simulations cannot resolve the detonation wave § Detonation wave scale – 1-10 cm <<<< WD scale 10000 km ⇒ unfeasible for simulations. Imshennik & Khokhlov 84
Khokhlov 89
Dynamical scale
12C burning
Typical resolutions in multi-D simulations
![Page 33: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
106 107 108
100
102
104
106
108
1010
1012
Simulations cannot resolve the detonation wave § Detonation wave scale – 1-10 cm <<<< WD scale 10000 km ⇒ unfeasible for simulations. Imshennik & Khokhlov 84
Khokhlov 89
Dynamical scale
12C burning
Typical resolutions in multi-D simulations
§ Implication:
Ø free parameters for the location/time of ignition are introduced.
![Page 34: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
§ To ignite a detonation you need:
burning region > sound travelling distance
Ignition is achieved by fast burning
![Page 35: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
§ To ignite a detonation you need:
burning region > sound travelling distance
Inject nuclear energy
Ignition is achieved by fast burning
![Page 36: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Inject nuclear energy
Burning time × speed of sound
No ignition
§ To ignite a detonation you need:
burning region > sound travelling distance
Ignition is achieved by fast burning
![Page 37: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Ignition is achieved by fast burning
Inject nuclear energy
Burning time × speed of sound
Ignition
§ To ignite a detonation you need:
burning region > sound travelling distance
![Page 38: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
Planar
geometry
Temperature
![Page 39: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
Temperature
![Page 40: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
§ Converged Lagrangian 1D toy model
Hydrodynamical
Shock
50 km
upstream downstream
The ignition scale is 50 km
Temperature
[109 K]
12C depletion
[10%] Distance from contact surface [103 km]
![Page 41: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
§ Converged Lagrangian 1D toy model
Hydrodynamical
Shock
50 km
upstream downstream
The ignition scale is 50 km
Temperature
[109 K]
12C depletion
[10%] Distance from contact surface [103 km]
![Page 42: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
§ Converged Lagrangian 1D toy model
Hydrodynamical
Shock
50 km
upstream downstream
The ignition scale is 50 km
Temperature
[109 K]
12C depletion
[10%] Distance from contact surface [103 km]
![Page 43: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
§ Converged Lagrangian 1D toy model
Runaway! Δt=5 ms 2Δt×cs≈50 km
Hydrodynamical
Shock
50 km
upstream downstream
The ignition scale is 50 km
Temperature
[109 K]
12C depletion
[10%] Distance from contact surface [103 km]
![Page 44: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
The ignition scale is 50 km § Converged Lagrangian 1D toy model
Runaway! Δt=5 ms 2Δt×cs≈50 km
Hydrodynamical
Shock
Temperature
[109 K]
12C depletion
[10%]
50 km
upstream downstream Convergence can be achieved in 2D and 3D
Distance from contact surface [103 km]
![Page 45: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
1 mm detonation width is irrelevant for ignition
§ Detonation wave accelerates ⇒ higher T ⇒ faster burning ⇒ narrower width reaching 1 cm scale.
![Page 46: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
1 mm detonation width is irrelevant for ignition
§ Detonation wave accelerates ⇒ higher T ⇒ faster burning ⇒ narrower width reaching 1 cm scale.
§ irrelevant for the ignition.
![Page 47: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
1 mm detonation width is irrelevant for ignition
§ Detonation wave accelerates ⇒ higher T ⇒ faster burning ⇒ narrower width reaching 1 cm scale.
§ irrelevant for the ignition.
§ If your simulation resolves 50 km, then it is not OK to ignite by hand anymore.
![Page 48: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
Be Careful of false ignition at low resolution
Inject nuclear energy
Burning time × speed of sound
Numerical ignition - not physical
Numerical cell
§ e.g., Hawley, Athanassiadou, Timmes 2012 (Δx=130 km)
![Page 49: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
Be Careful of false ignition at low resolution
Inject nuclear energy
Burning time × speed of sound
Numerical ignition - not physical
Numerical cell
§ e.g., Hawley, Athanassiadou, Timmes 2012 (Δx=130 km)
§ A solution is to use a burning limiter (DK et al. 2012):
burning time > Δx/cs
![Page 50: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
Major problems:
1. The burning length scale is small (~1 cm)
• Ignition
• Detonation propgation
2. NSE scale can be small
3. Many (>100) isotopes are required
![Page 51: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
106 107 108
100
102
104
106
108
1010
1012
Heavy elements synthesis scale can be smaller than a cell size
Dynamical scale
12C burning
Typical resolutions in multi-D simulations
Iron group synthesis
![Page 52: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
106 107 108
100
102
104
106
108
1010
1012
Heavy elements synthesis scale can be smaller than a cell size
Dynamical scale
§ Implication:
Ø Impose detonation speed and burning from steady state solutions.
12C burning
Typical resolutions in multi-D simulations
Iron group synthesis
![Page 53: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
106 107 108
100
102
104
106
108
1010
1012
Heavy elements synthesis scale can be smaller than a cell size
Dynamical scale
§ Implication:
Ø Impose detonation speed and burning from steady state solutions. Ø Ignore this.
12C burning
Typical resolutions in multi-D simulations
Iron group synthesis
![Page 54: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
We first need the exact (ODE) solution
![Page 55: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
We first need the exact (ODE) solution Upstream density = 3×108 g cm-3
![Page 56: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
We first need the exact (ODE) solution
§ Khokhlov 89 used an erroneous EOS (twice the radiation pressure).
Upstream density = 3×108 g cm-3
![Page 57: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
We first need the exact (ODE) solution
§ Khokhlov 89 used an erroneous EOS (twice the radiation pressure).
§ Good comparison to Townsley et al. 2016.
10-2 100 102 104 106 1081.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
Upstream density = 3×108 g cm-3 Upstream density = 107 g cm-3
ρ/ρ0
![Page 58: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
10-210-1 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 1080
1
2
3
4
5
Resolved scales are accurate with burning limiter
178 isotopes
§ The exact solution with a limiter is compared to a hydro code:
ρ/ρ0
X(56Ni)×10
![Page 59: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
10-210-1 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 1080
1
2
3
4
5
Resolved scales are accurate with burning limiter § The exact solution with a limiter is compared to a hydro code:
ρ/ρ0
X(56Ni)×10
FLASH 178 isotopes
Δx=8 km
![Page 60: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
Resolved scales are accurate with burning limiter § The exact solution with a limiter is compared to a hydro code:
10-210-1 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 1080
1
2
3
4
5
ρ/ρ0
X(56Ni)×10
FLASH
new scheme (unlimited distance)
178 isotopes
Δx=8 km
![Page 61: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
Resolved scales are accurate with burning limiter
§ The small-length-scale problem of thermonuclear detonation waves is efficiently solved with a burning limiter.
§ The exact solution with a limiter is compared to a hydro code:
10-210-1 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 1080
1
2
3
4
5
ρ/ρ0
X(56Ni)×10
FLASH
new scheme (unlimited distance)
178 isotopes
Δx=8 km
![Page 62: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
Major problems:
1. The burning length scale is small (~1 cm)
• Ignition
• Detonation propgation
2. NSE scale can be small
3. Many (>100) isotopes are required
Solution:
Limiter
![Page 63: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
Major problems:
1. The burning length scale is small (~1 cm)
• Ignition
• Detonation propgation
2. NSE scale can be small
3. Many (>100) isotopes are required
Solution:
Limiter
![Page 64: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
106 107 108
100
102
104
106
108
1010
1012
NSE scale can be smaller than the dynamical scale
Dynamical scale
12C burning
Typical resolutions in multi-D simulations
Iron group synthesis
NSE
T=6×109 K
![Page 65: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
106 107 108
100
102
104
106
108
1010
1012
NSE scale can be smaller than the dynamical scale
Dynamical scale
12C burning
Typical resolutions in multi-D simulations
Iron group synthesis
NSE
T=6×109 K
§ The burning calculation becomes both extremely slow and inaccurate.
![Page 66: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
106 107 108
100
102
104
106
108
1010
1012
NSE scale can be smaller than the dynamical scale
Dynamical scale
§ Implication:
Ø Impose NSE at some arbitrary conditions.
12C burning
Typical resolutions in multi-D simulations
Iron group synthesis
NSE
T=6×109 K
§ The burning calculation becomes both extremely slow and inaccurate.
![Page 67: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
106 107 1080
1
2
3
4
5
The solution is to group isotopes in detailed balance
ρ/ρ0+0.5
![Page 68: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
106 107 1080
1
2
3
4
5
The solution is to group isotopes in detailed balance
0 10 20 30 400
5
10
15
20
25
30
§ This is done adaptively at each time step (ASE). The number of effective isotopes (n) reduces dramatically (generalization of Hix+ 2007).
ρ/ρ0+0.5
log10(n)
cell 1
![Page 69: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
106 107 1080
1
2
3
4
5
The solution is to group isotopes in detailed balance
0 10 20 30 400
5
10
15
20
25
30
0 10 20 30 400
5
10
15
20
25
30
ρ/ρ0+0.5
log10(n)
cell 1 cell 2
§ This is done adaptively at each time step (ASE). The number of effective isotopes (n) reduces dramatically (generalization of Hix+ 2007).
![Page 70: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
106 107 1080
1
2
3
4
5
The solution is to group isotopes in detailed balance
0 10 20 30 400
5
10
15
20
25
30
0 10 20 30 400
5
10
15
20
25
30
0 10 20 30 400
5
10
15
20
25
30
ρ/ρ0+0.5
log10(n)
cell 1 cell 2
cell 3
§ This is done adaptively at each time step (ASE). The number of effective isotopes (n) reduces dramatically (generalization of Hix+ 2007).
![Page 71: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
106 107 1080
1
2
3
4
5
The solution is to group isotopes in detailed balance
0 10 20 30 400
5
10
15
20
25
30
0 10 20 30 400
5
10
15
20
25
30
0 10 20 30 400
5
10
15
20
25
30
0 10 20 30 400
5
10
15
20
25
30
ρ/ρ0+0.5
log10(n)
cell 1 cell 2
cell 3 cell 4
§ This is done adaptively at each time step (ASE). The number of effective isotopes (n) reduces dramatically (generalization of Hix+ 2007).
![Page 72: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
The solution is to group isotopes in detailed balance
106 107 1080
1
2
3
4
5
0 10 20 30 400
5
10
15
20
25
30
0 10 20 30 400
5
10
15
20
25
30
0 10 20 30 400
5
10
15
20
25
30
0 10 20 30 400
5
10
15
20
25
30
§ The code is more accurate and faster by orders of magnitude.
ρ/ρ0+0.5
log10(n) log10(told/tnew)
cell 1 cell 2
cell 3 cell 4
§ This is done adaptively at each time step (ASE). The number of effective isotopes (n) reduces dramatically (generalization of Hix+ 2007).
![Page 73: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
Major problems:
1. The burning length scale is small (~1 cm)
• Ignition
• Detonation propgation
2. NSE scale can be small
3. Many (>100) isotopes are required
Solution:
Limiter
Solution:
ASE
![Page 74: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/74.jpg)
Summary § We have developed a novel algorithm to calculate supernovae explosions:
![Page 75: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/75.jpg)
Summary § We have developed a novel algorithm to calculate supernovae explosions:
§ Accurate
![Page 76: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/76.jpg)
Summary § We have developed a novel algorithm to calculate supernovae explosions:
§ Accurate
§ Efficient
![Page 77: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/77.jpg)
Summary § We have developed a novel algorithm to calculate supernovae explosions:
§ Accurate
§ Efficient
§ Can be easily implemented in multi-dimensional codes.
![Page 78: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/78.jpg)
Summary § We have developed a novel algorithm to calculate supernovae explosions:
§ Accurate
§ Efficient
§ Can be easily implemented in multi-dimensional codes.
§ Large nuclear networks.
![Page 79: Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) - CASbps.ynao.cas.cn/xzzx/201908/W020190820419301094697.pdf · Doron Kushnir (Weizmann) With: Boaz Katz (Weizmann) 8/8/19 ~10% accuracy is required to resolve](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070110/6046ea6e806b3d256819f985/html5/thumbnails/79.jpg)
Summary § We have developed a novel algorithm to calculate supernovae explosions:
§ Accurate
§ Efficient
§ Can be easily implemented in multi-dimensional codes.
§ Large nuclear networks.
§ Next step: apply it to different scenarios.