Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)

8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doe13-mtq-07252pa 1/20

XGO\HL ]\F\H] LO]\ÔM\ MCX^\

HF]\H^G LO]\ÔM\ CA THGG]_IQFGOF

TF\ÔME MCIIOG]) OGM' ;

;Tifog|oaa) ;

;

q' ; ; Moqoi Fm|ocg Gc'; 66"mq"0>8>"B]@

KCJG LCH] 6"6:) ; ;

Lhahglfg|}' ;

;

BHBC^FGLXB CA IFP OG ]XTTC^\ CA LHAHGLFG\ KCJG LCH

6=‟] BC\OCG \C ]HQH^ LHAHGLFG\] AC^ OBT^CTH^ KCOGLH^FGL \C QFMF\H \JH C^LH^ @^FG\OG@ IHFQH \C ]H^QH

\JO^L"TF^\_ ]XNTCHGF] FGL \C VXF]J \JH ]XNTCHGF

Mf}h >;66"mq"40>8>"B]@ Lcmxbhg| 1"6 Aoihl 4=#4:#6> Tf`h 6 ca >4

8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


o

\FNIH CA MCG\HG\]

O' OG\^CLXM\OCG '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 6 OO' AFM\XFI FGL T^CMHLX^FI JO]\C^_ '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' < OOO' F^@XBHG\ '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 8

F' Kcoglh~ ca Lhahglfg|} O} Obt~cth~ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 8 6' Ih`fi ]|fglf~l '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 8 >' Tifog|oaa Jf} Afoihl |c Bhh| |jh ^hvxo~hbhg|} ca ^xih >4*f/ fgl Lch

Lhahglfg|} >"6: ]jcxil Nh ]hqh~hl A~cb \jo} Fm|ocg ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 1 =' Kcoglh~ O} Gc| Ftt~ct~of|h fgl Lch Lhahglfg|} >"6: ]jcxil Nh ]hqh~hl

A~cb \jo} Fm|ocg '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' : N' C~lh~ @~fg|og` Th~bo}}ocg |c ]h~qh ]xntchgf ]jcxil Nh Qfmf|hl fgl |jh

]xntchgf ]jcxil Nh Vxf}jhl''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ? 6' Lhahglfg| Jf} ]|fglog` |c Mjfiihg`h |jh ]xntchgf Nhmfx}h Lhahglfg|

Jf} f Th~}cgfi Og|h~h}| og |jh ]xntchgfhl Bf||h~'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 64 >' \jh C~lh~ @~fg|og` Ihfqh |c ]h~qh \jo~l"Tf~|y ]xntchgf ]jcxil Nh

Qfmf|hl ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 64 =' \jh ]xntchgf ]jcxil Nh Vxf}jhl |c T~c|hm| Lhahglfg| A~cb

Xg~hf}cgfnih Fggcyfgmh) Hbnf~~f}}bhg| fgl Ctt~h}}ocg '''''''''''''''''''' 6= M' Fi|h~gf|oqhiy) f T~c|hm|oqh C~lh~ ]jcxil Nh Hg|h~hl T~hmixlog` Txniom Lo}mic}x~h

ca Lhahglfg|‟} Mcgaolhg|ofi Ogac~bf|ocg ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 6= OQ' MCGMIX]OCG ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 61

Mf}h >;66"mq"40>8>"B]@ Lcmxbhg| 1"6 Aoihl 4=#4:#6> Tf`h > ca >4

8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


oo

\FNIH CA FX\JC^O\OH]

Mf}h} Tf`h}

NB@ Bx}om q' Lch} 6">4=) >44< PI ?8=::: *H'L' Tf' Ft~' >) >44</ *Ghpmcbh~) K'/ '''''''''''''''' ?

Ncy ^fmh~) Ogm' q' Lch) >466 PI =18>8>6 *G'L'Mfi' >466/ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 66

N~ol`htc~| Bx}om) Ogm' q' 66M Bx}om) >4> A'^'L' >>? *B'L' \hgg' >446/ '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' :

Mccth~ q' Ao|{`h~fil ) >11 A'^'L' :1 *H'L' Tf' >464/ *Ehiiy) K'/ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 8

Lofnciom Qolhc T~clxm|ocg}) Ogm' q' Lch} 6">4??) >466 PI =644<4<*G'L' Mfi' Bfy =6) >466/ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 1

Acgcqo}f) Ogm' q' Mjh~~y Fxm|ocg) Ogm') 01 A'=l >8? *?|j Mo~' 6??1/''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 6>

Acgcqo}f) Ogm' q' Lch} 6"?) >44: PI ?6?046 *P'L' Tf' Ft~oi =) >44:/ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 1

@h~}jpog Txnio}jog` Mc~t' q' Mcixbnof F~|o}|} B`b|') Ogm') <<= A'>l 668?*>l Mo~' 6?06/'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 6>

Jf~l L~oqh T~cl}' q' Lch} 6"==) Gc' M' 66"4=:>0 IN) >466 PI 8=>88=4*G'L' Mfi' Gcq' =) >466/ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 0

Jf~l L~oqh T~clxm|ocg}) Ogm' q' Lch} 6"6::) :4? A' ]xtt' >l 6684 *G'L' Mfi' >466/'''''' 8) 1) :) ?

OC @~cxt) Ogm' q' Lch} 6"<=8) Gc' M 64"<=:> ]O) >466 PI <<84<=

*G'L' Mfi' Ahn' =) >466/'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' >

E"Nhhmj) Ogm' q' Kcjg Lch} 6":8) >466 PI <?68886 *H'L' Qf' Cm|' 60) >466/ '''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 1

Ehiiy q' F~~onf ]ca| Mc~t') ==1 A'=l :66 *?|j Mo~' >44=/ '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 66

Eolf q' HmcPf|h~ ]y}|hb} IIM ) >466 PI 6::=6?< *H'L' Tf' >466/ *Nfyi}cg) K'/ ''''''''''''''''''''' 64

IfAfmh ^hmc~l}) IIM q' Lch} 6"=:) >44: PI 8<<??> *H'L'G'M' Ahn' >0) >44:/ '''''''''''''''''''''''' 1

Bhlof T~clxm|}) Ogm' LNF Lhqoi‟} Aoib q' Lch} 6"6>80 ) Mf}h Gc' MQ 64"4<<06 ^] '''''''''''''''''' >

Bc}ihy q' @hgh~fi Bc|c~} Mc~t') <?0 A'>l 6==4 *M'F' Bc' 6?0</ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 8

Ghpnc~g q' _fjcc&) Ogm') =?6 A']xtt'>l 6:6 *L'L'M' >448/''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 6>

Tf|~ome Mciiog} Ogm) Q' Lch} 6"6)>6?) Mf}h <;64"mq"4<<1:"IN) Le|' >0*G'L' Mfi' Fx`' >?) >466/ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' =

Mf}h >;66"mq"40>8>"B]@ Lcmxbhg| 1"6 Aoihl 4=#4:#6> Tf`h = ca >4

8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


ooo

Tf|~ome Mciiog}) Ogm' q' Lch} 6"66:) Mf}h =;64"MQ"?>"KTN) Le|' <>*G'L'P'Qf Lhm' 61) >464/ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 0

Tf|~ome Mciiog}) Ogm' q' Kcjg Lch} 6"=8) Mf}h >;66"mq"4860>) Le|' =1*H'L' Tf' Lhmhbnh~ >?) >466/ *]fqf`h) K'/ '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 8) 0) ?

^hioòcx} \hmj' M|~ q' Gh|mcb Cg"Iogh Mcbbm‟g ]h~q}') Ogm') ?40 A' ]xtt' 6=16*G'L' Mfi' 6??8/'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 66

ô`j|jfqhg IIM q' Lhbcm~f|om Xglh~`~cxgl) IIM ) Gc'>;64"mq"46=81) Le|' ?<*L' Ghq' Ft~' 6<) >466/ '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' >

ô`j|jfqhg IIM q' Joii) Gc' 6;66"MQ"44>66) Le|' 61 *L'Mcic' Ft~' 0) >466/ ''''''''''''''''''''''' =) 68

QT^ Og|h~gf|ocgfih q' Lch} 6"6460 ) Mf}h Gc' >;66"mq"4>41:"JFN) Le|' 68*M'L' Oii Ft~oi >?) >466/ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 6>) 68

^xih} Tf`h}

AHL' ^' MOQ' T' >4*f/*>/ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 8

AHL' ^' MOQ' T' >6 '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 1

AHL' ^' MOQ' T' >1*m/*6/*N/ ! *L/ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 6<

AHL' ^' MOQ' T' <8*f/*>/ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 64

AHL' ^' MOQ' T' <8*m/*=/*F/*oq/ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 6=

\~hf|o}h} Tf`h}

0 M' P~o`j|) Ahlh~fi T~fm|omh fgl T~cmhlx~h 618> f| >18 *6?0>/ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 1

Mf}h >;66"mq"40>8>"B]@ Lcmxbhg| 1"6 Aoihl 4=#4:#6> Tf`h < ca >4

8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


6

Tx~}xfg| |c Ahlh~fi ^xih} ca Moqoi T~cmhlx~h *AHL' ^' MOQ' T'/ >4 fgl >6) Lhahglfg|)

Kcjg Lch Gc' 6= *’Lhahglfg|‒/6) ~h}thm|axiiy }xnbo|} |jo} Bhbc~fglxb ca Ifp og }xttc~| ca

Lhahglfg|‟} Bc|ocg |c ]hqh~ Lhahglfg|} ac~ Obt~cth~ Kcoglh~ fgl |c Qfmf|h |jh C~lh~ @~fg|og`

Ihfqh |c ]h~qh \jo~l"Tf~|y ]xntchgf} fgl |c Vxf}j |jh ]xntchgf *’Bc|ocg‒/' Og o|} bc|ocg)

Lhahglfg| }hhe} 6/ }hqh~fgmh ca |jh lhahglfg|} ac~ obt~cth~ kcoglh~ fgl >/ |jf| |jh C~lh~ lf|hl

Kfgxf~y ><) >46> `~fg|og` Tifog|oaa) Tf|~ome Mciiog}) Ogm' *’Tifog|oaa‒/ ihfqh |c }h~qh |jo~l"tf~|y

}xntchgf xtcg Lhahglfg|‟} Og|h~gh| ]h~qomh T~cqolh~ *’O]T‒/) Mcbmf}| Mc~tc~f|ocg

*’Mcbmf}|‒/ nh qfmf|hl) fgl =/ |jf| |jh }xntchgf nh vxf}jhl'

O' OG\^CLXM\OCG

\jh og}|fg| mf}h o} tf~| ca f }y}|hbom haac~| |c nxoil f nx}ogh}} bclhi nf}hl cg phfe

fiih`f|ocg} ca mcty~o`j| oga~og`hbhg| fgl vxh}|ocgfnih x}h ca |jh ih`fi }y}|hb |c vxomeiy p~h}|

t~cao| |j~cx`j |jh `hgh~f|ocg ca }h||ihbhg|} a~cb lhahglfg|} mcphl ny |jh tc|hg|ofi |j~hf| ca f

bf}}oqh fpf~l ca }|f|x|c~y lfbf`h} *oa Tifog|oaa‟} kcog| fgl }hqh~fi |jhc~oh} f~h |c nh m~hloniy

nhiohqhl) mcxil fiih`hliy ~h}xi| og hzmh}} ca }hqh~fi boiiocg} ca lciif~} nf}hl }cihiy cg phfe

fiih`f|ocg} ca pjf| mfg cgiy nh lh}m~onhl f| nh}|) f} lh bogobx} fm|}/) f||c~ghy} ahh}) o`gc~fgmh

fncx| lhahg}h}) fgl th~jft} bc}| obtc~|fg|iy) |jh }|o`bf pjomj f||fmjh} |c lhahglfg|} pjhg

olhg|oaohl fgl f}}cmof|hl po|j oiih`fiiy lcpgicflog` tc~gc`~ftjom aoib} |c mch~mh vxome) fgl

t~cao|fnih mcg|og`hgmy"ahh }h||ihbhg|}' ]hh Bomjfhi ^cnh~|}) No|\c~~hg| Bc|ocg Fiih`h} Ih`fi

Nx}ogh}} Bclhi \f~`h|og` Tc~g Lcpgicflh~}) Lhgqh~ Ph}|pc~l) ]ht|hbnh~ 61) >466)

j||t;##nic`}'ph}|pc~l'mcb#if|h}|pc~l#>466#4?#tc~gSlcpgicflh~}Sno||c~~hg|Sifp}xo|'tjt)

f||fmjhl jh~h|c f} Hzjono| F'

6 Fi|jcx`j ogac~bhl ny Mcbmf}| Mc~tc~f|ocg *’Mcbmf}|‒/ f} nhog` |jh x}h~ ca |jh OT Fll~h}}olhg|oaohl f} Kcjg Lch Gc' 6=) |jo} bc|ocg o} nhog` bflh po|jcx| fgy pfoqh~ c~ t~hkxlomh ca Lhahglfg|‟} ~o`j| |c lo}tx|h |jf| Lhahglfg| o} |jh x}h~ ca |jh OT fll~h}} olhg|oaohl f}mc~~h}tcglog` |c Lch Gc' 6='


8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


>

F} |jh Jcgc~fnih ^c`h~ Jxg|) Mjoha Kxl`h ca |jh X']' Lo}|~om| Mcx~| ac~ |jh Lo}|~om| ca

Ghqflf gc|hl) }oboif~ tifog|oaa} ’jfqh f||hbt|hl |c m~hf|h f mc||f`h oglx}|~y ca aoiog` mcty~o`j|

mifob}) bfeog` if~`h mifob} ac~ lfbf`h} fgl |jhg }h||iog` mifob} ac~ thggoh} cg |jh lciif~) po|j

lhahglfg|} pjc lc gc| pfg| |c ogmx~ |jh mc}|} ca lhahglog` |jh ifp}xo|}'‒ ô`j|jfqhg IIM q'

Lhbcm~f|om Xglh~`~cxgl) IIM ) Gc'>;64"mq"46=81) Le|' ?< *L' Ghq' Ft~' 6<) >466/) f||fmjhl

jh~h|c f} Hzjono| N'

Og th~jft} |jh bc}| hztiomo| lhbcg}|~f|ocg fgl }xn}hvxhg| ~htxlof|ocg ca tifog|oaa} ac~

t~cao| io|o`f|ocg bclhi) Bfò}|~f|h Kxl`h Nhhih~ ca |jh X']' Lo}|~om| Mcx~| ac~ |jh Gc~|jh~g

Lo}|~om| ca Mfioac~gof) lo~hm|iy ~hnxehl Tifog|oaa Tf|~ome Mciiog}) Ogm') *|jh }fbh Tifog|oaa f} |jh

og}|fg| fm|ocg/ og fg olhg|omfi mf}h ogqciqog` 6:: Kcjg Lch lhahglfg|} }|f|og`;

U|Rjh mcx~| jf} gc mcgaolhgmh |jf| Tifog|oaa jf} nhhg loio`hg| ogbcqog` |c gfbh fgl }h~qh lhahglfg|}) lh}to|h o|} *xg}pc~g/mifob} |c |jh mcg|~f~y' Ac~ hzfbtih) Tifog|oaa} mcxg}hi }|f|h} |jf|jh jf} aoihl |hg c|jh~ mcty~o`j| mf}h} ogqciqog` f if~`h gxbnh~ ca Lch lhahglfg|}' HMA Gc' 60 f| <' \jh mcx~| ~hqohphl |jh lcmeh|}fgl gc|hl |jf| |jh tifog|oaa} og |jh}h mf}h} jfqh gc| aoihl t~cca ca }h~qomh ac~ hqhg f }ogìh lhahglfg| hqhg |jcx`j f gxbnh~ ca lhahglfg|} jfqh nhhg olhg|oaohl fgl lo}bo}}hl fa|h~ }h||iog` po|j|jh tifog|oaa}' ]hh) h'`') Bhlof T~clxm|}) Ogm' LNF Lhqoi‟} Aoib q'

Lch} 6"6>80 ) Mf}h Gc' MQ 64"4<<06 ^] *mcbtifog| aoihl cgCm|cnh~ <) >464 fgl gc t~cca ca }h~qomh aoihl ac~ fgy lhahglfg| f}ca Kxiy >?)>466) nx| acx~ Lch lhahglfg|} jfqh nhhg lo}bo}}hlfa|h~ }h||iog`/' \jo} tf||h~g jcil} |~xh og |jo} mf}h |cc' Jh~h)Tifog|oaa jf} gc| olhg|oaohl c~ }h~qhl fgy ca |jh 6)>6? LchLhahglfg|}' Jcphqh~) cg Bfy 64) >466) Tifog|oaa aoihl f}|otxif|ocg lo}bo}}og` po|j t~hkxlomh f Lch Lhahglfg| pjc }h||ihlpo|j Tifog|oaa' HMA Gc' 6= f| 6' Fgl) cg Fx`x}| 6:) >466)Tifog|oaa aoihl f }|otxif|ocg lo}bo}}og` po|j t~hkxlomh bc~h |jfg|jo~|y Lch Lhahglfg|} pjc }h||ihl' HMA Gc' f| 6">' \jh tifog|oaa}og |jh}h mf}h} ftthf~ mcg|hg| |c ac~mh }h||ihbhg|} po|jcx|ogmx~~og` fgy ca |jh nx~lhg} ogqciqhl og t~cqog` |jho~ mf}h}' Fgl)pjoih |jh mcx~|} afqc~ }h||ihbhg|}) ’aoiog` cgh bf}} fm|ocg ogc~lh~ |c olhg|oay jxgl~hl} ca lch lhahglfg|} |j~cx`j t~h"}h~qomhlo}mcqh~y fgl afmoio|f|h bf}} }h||ihbhg|) o} gc| pjf| |jh kcoglh~~xih} ph~h h}|fnio}jhl ac~'‒ OC @~cxt) Ogm' q' Lch} 6"<=8) Gc' M64"<=:> ]O) >466 PI <<84<=) f| +1 *G'L' Mfi' Ahn' =) >466/'


8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


=

C~lh~ Lo}bo}}og` Mcbtifog|) Tf|~ome Mciiog} Ogm) Q' Lch} 6"6)>6?) Mf}h <;64"mq"4<<1:"IN) Le|'

>0) f| < *G'L' Mfi' Fx`' >?) >466/) f||fmjhl jh~h|c f} Hzjono| M' Mcx~|} jfqh }thmoaomfiiy fgl

lo~hm|iy mcglhbghl }xmj ac~"t~cao| mcty~o`j| io|o`f|ocg bclhi}' ]hh h'`') ô`j|jfqhg IIM q' Joii)

Gc' 6;66"MQ"44>66) Le|' 61 *L'Mcic' Ft~' 0) >466/ *’Tifog|oaa‟} po}jh} |c |jh mcg|~f~y) |jh

mcx~|} f~h gc| bh~hiy |cci} ac~ hgmcx~fòg` fgl hzfm|og` }h||ihbhg|} a~cb Lhahglfg|} mcphl ny

|jh tc|hg|ofi mc}|} ca io|o`f|ocg fgl iofnoio|y‒/) f||fmjhl jh~h|c f} Hzjono| L'

Tf|~ome Mciiog}) Ogm' *|jh tifog|oaa og |jo} mf}h/) o} gc hzmht|ocg' O| jf} aoihl }oboif~ bf}}"

mcty~o`j| oga~og`hbhg| ifp}xo|} f`fog}| lch lhahglfg|}) }hheog` }h||ihbhg|} a~cb oggcmhg|

lhahglfg|}' ]hh No|\c~~hg| Bc|ocg Fiih`h} Ih`fi Nx}ogh}} Bclhi \f~`h|og` Tc~g Lcpgicflh~})

Hz' F *fg oggcmhg| |jo~l"`~flh |hfmjh~ pjc mfggc| faac~l |c nh fmmx}hl ca lcpgicflog`

tc~gc`~ftjy) ih}| }jh nh fmmx}hl ca nhog` f thlctjoih/5 fgl @hc~`h @cbnc}}y) @~fglbc|jh~

Pjc X}h Mcbtx|h~ Ac~ Nonih ]|xly ]xhl Ac~ Oiih`fiiy Lcpgicflog` Tc~g ) M\Pf|mjlc`'mcb)

Cm|cnh~ >8) >466) j||t;##m|pf|mjlc`'mcb#aogfgmh#`~fglbc|jh~"pjc"x}h}"mcbtx|h~"ac~"nonih"

}|xly"}xhl"ac~"oiih`fiiy"lcpgicflog`"tc~g) f||fmjhl jh~h|c f} Hzjono| H' F} ca Bf~mj >46>)

Tf|~ome Mciiog}) Ogm' jfl aoihl 664 }oboif~ ifp}xo|} f`fog}| bc~h |jfg 64)><4 ogloqolxfi Kcjg Lch

Lhahglfg|}) |jh bfkc~o|y ca pjomj jfl |h~bogf|hl po|jcx| Tifog|oaa aoiog` f t~cca ca }h~qomh ac~ f

}ogìh ogloqolxfi lhahglfg|'> Og |jo} Lo}|~om| ficgh) }ogmh Fx`x}| >466) Tf|~ome Mciiog}) Ogm' jf}

aoihl 8 }htf~f|h fm|ocg} f`fog}| 686 ogloqolxfi Kcjg Lch lhahglfg|}' F} ca |jh lf|h ca |jo}

bc|ocg) og |jc}h 8 fm|ocg}) Tifog|oaa jf} yh| |c aoih f t~cca ca }h~qomh ac~ f }ogìh ogloqolxfi

lhahglfg|5 jcphqh~) Tifog|oaa jf} aoihl gxbh~cx} qcixg|f~y lo}bo}}fi} po|j t~hkxlomh fa|h~

}h||iog` po|j qf~ocx} Lch Lhahglfg|}'

Gc| cgiy o} Tifog|oaa |feog` flqfg|f`h ca |jh mcx~|} |c hzfm| }h||ihbhg|} a~cb Lhahglfg|})

Tifog|oaa o} fnx}og` |jh t~cmhlx~fi ~xih}) o'h') |jh ^xih >4 kcoglh~ ~xih) |c fqcol |jh mc}| ca

> \jo} lf|f o} nf}hl cg f TFMH^ }hf~mj ca fii ahlh~fi mcx~|} ac~ Tf|~ome Mciiog} f} f tf~|y'


8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


<

ftt~ct~of|hiy aoiog` ogloqolxfi mf}h}' Og |jo} mf}h) pjh~h Tifog|oaa jf} bo}"kcoghl fii ho`j|hhg *6:/

lhahglfg|}) |jh aoiog` ahh} ficgh ac~ hfmj ca |jh 6: tx|f|oqh Lhahglfg|} pcxil nh cqh~ ,1)444'

Og io`j| ca |jh cnqocx} fnx}h ca |jh kxlomofi }y}|hb f} phii f} |jh }o`goaomfg| ~o}e ca

bo}olhg|oaomf|ocg ca tc|hg|ofi lhahglfg|} f} lo}mx}}hl nhicp) Lch Lhahglfg|} >"6: }jcxil nh

}hqh~hl a~cb |jo} fm|ocg fgl |jh C~lh~ `~fg|og` ihfqh |c }h~qh |jo~l"tf~|y }xntchgf} }jcxil nh

qfmf|hl fgl |jh }xntchgf }jcxil nh vxf}jhl'

OO' AFM\XFI FGL T^CMHLX^FI JO]\C^_

Tifog|oaa) Tf|~ome Mciiog}) Ogm') fi}c egcpg f} Hih`fg| Fg`hi T~clxm|ocg}) o} f

tc~gc`~ftjy aoib t~clxm|ocg mcbtfgy cpghl ny Tf|~ome Mciiog}) f tc~gc`~ftjy lo~hm|c~'

Tifog|oaa aoihl o|} mcbtifog| cg c~ fncx| Gcqhbnh~ >6) >466 fiih`og` |jf| ho`j|hhg *6:/ ’Kcjg

Lch}‒ x}hl |jh No|\c~~hg| t~c|cmci |c hg`f`h og lo~hm| fgl mcg|~onx|c~y mcty~o`j| oga~og`hbhg|

fgl lo~hm| fgl mcg|~onx|c~y |~flhbf~e oga~og`hbhg|' Tifog|oaa fiih`h} |jf| o| jfl olhg|oaohl |jh

Og|h~gh| T~c|cmci *’OT‒/ fll~h}}h} ca |jh ho`j|hhg Kcjg Lch} |jf| hbticyhl |jh No|\c~~hg|

t~c|cmci |c }jf~h Tifog|oaa‟} mcty~o`j|hl pc~e) f bcqoh |o|ihl ’If|og Ncc|y'‒

Cg c~ fncx| Lhmhbnh~ >6) >466) Tifog|oaa aoihl f Bc|ocg ac~ Ihfqh |c ]h~qh \jo~l Tf~|y

]xntchgf} T~oc~ |c f ^xih >1*a/ Mcgah~hgmh' Tifog|oaa }cx`j| |c }h~qh obbhlof|h lo}mcqh~y xtcg

hfmj Kcjg Lch Lhahglfg|‟} og|h~gh| }h~qomh t~cqolh~“jh~h) Mcbmf}| Mfnih) ^MG Mc~tc~f|ocg)

fgl Qh~o{cg Og|h~gh| ]h~qomh}“|c cn|fog th~}cgfi oglhg|oayog` ogac~bf|ocg ~h`f~log` |jh OT

fll~h}}h}' Xtcg mcg}olh~f|ocg ca Tifog|oaa‟} xgcttc}hl Bc|ocg) cg c~ fncx| Kfgxf~y ><) >46>)

|jh Mcx~| o}}xhl fg C~lh~ th~bo||og` Tifog|oaa |c }h~qh ^xih <8 }xntchgf} xtcg Kcjg Lch

Lhahglfg|‟} O]T} *’C~lh~‒/'

]xn}hvxhg|iy) Tifog|oaa }h~qhl Mcbmf}|) Lhahglfg|‟} O]T) po|j f }xntchgf o}}xhl a~cb

|jh Lo}|~om| Mcx~| ca Ghp Kh~}hy) pjomj mcbbfglhl Mcbmf}| |c t~clxmh |c Tifog|oaa f|

Mf}h >;66"mq"40>8>"B]@ Lcmxbhg| 1"6 Aoihl 4=#4:#6> Tf`h : ca >4

8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


8

Tifog|oaa‟} mcxg}hi‟} caaomh og Jf~ihy}qoiih) Thgg}yiqfgof) |jh th~}cgfi olhg|oayog` ogac~bf|ocg

*|jh gfbh) fll~h}}) fgl |hihtjcgh gxbnh~/ ca |jh x}h~ f}}cmof|hl po|j |jh OT fll~h}} ny Bf~mj

6>) >46> *’]xntchgf‒/' Ny ih||h~ lf|hl Ahn~xf~y 64) >46>) Mcbmf}| ogac~bhl Lhahglfg| ca |jh

]xntchgf fgl oglomf|hl |jf| Mcbmf}| pcxil t~cqolh |jh ~hvxh}|hl ogac~bf|ocg |c Tifog|oaa cg |jh

ghz| nx}ogh}} lfy fa|h~ Bf~mj 6>) >46> xgih}} Lhahglfg| aoihl f bc|ocg |c vxf}j c~ qfmf|h |jh

]xntchgf fgl gc|oaohl Mcbmf}| ca Lhahglfg|‟} aoiog` ny gc if|h~ |jfg Bf~mj 6>) >46>'

OOO' F^@XBHG\

F' Kcoglh~ ca Lhahglfg|} O} Obt~cth~

\jo} hzfm| }fbh o}}xh jf} fi~hfly nhhg fll~h}}hl og |jo} lo}|~om| ny Kxl`h \obc|jy K'

]fqf`h f`fog}| |jh }fbh Tifog|oaa og Tf|~ome Mciiog}) Ogm' q' Kcjg Lch} 6"=8) Mf}h >;66"mq"

4860>) Le|' =1 *H'L' Tf' Lhmhbnh~ >?) >466/ *]fqf`h) K'/ og fg C~lh~ }hqh~og` fii nx| cgh Kcjg

Lch lhahglfg| a~cb |jh fm|ocg ac~ obt~cth~ kcoglh~' ]hh C~lh~ lf|hl Lhmhbnh~ >?) >466)

f||fmjhl jh~h|c f} Hzjono| A' Lhahglfg| ~h}thm|axiiy ~hvxh}|} |jf| |jo} Mcx~| ioehpo}h }hqh~ fii

nx| Kcjg Lch 6 a~cb |jh fm|ocg ac~ obt~cth~ kcoglh~ ca lhahglfg|}'

6' Ih`fi ]|fglf~l

Tx~}xfg| |c AHL' ^' MOQ' T' >4*f/*>/) th~bo}}oqh kcoglh~ ca lhahglfg|} o} t~cth~ oa;

*F/ fgy ~o`j| |c ~hioha o} f}}h~|hl f`fog}| |jhb kcog|iy) }hqh~fiiy)c~ og |jh fi|h~gf|oqh po|j ~h}thm| |c c~ f~o}og` cx| ca |jh }fbh|~fg}fm|ocg) cmmx~~hgmh) c~ }h~oh} ca |~fg}fm|ocg} c~cmmx~~hgmh}5 fgl

*N/ fgy vxh}|ocg ca ifp c~ afm| mcbbcg |c fii lhahglfg|} poiif~o}h og |jh fm|ocg'

AHL' ^' MOQ' T' >4*f/*>/' ]hh fi}c Mccth~ q' Ao|{`h~fil ) >11 A'^'L' :1) :: *H'L' Tf' >464/

*Ehiiy) K'/' Th~bo}}oqh kcoglh~ o} ’lh}o`ghl |c t~cbc|h kxlomofi hmcgcby fgl |~ofi mcgqhgohgmh'‒

Jf~l L~oqh T~clxm|ocg}) Ogm' q' Lch} 6"6::) :4? A' ]xtt' >l 6684) 6681 *G'L' Mfi' >466/' ]hh

fi}c Bc}ihy q' @hgh~fi Bc|c~} Mc~t') <?0 A'>l 6==4) 6==>"== *M'F' Bc' 6?0</ *mo|og` 0 M'

Mf}h >;66"mq"40>8>"B]@ Lcmxbhg| 1"6 Aoihl 4=#4:#6> Tf`h ? ca >4

8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


1

P~o`j|) Ahlh~fi T~fm|omh fgl T~cmhlx~h 618> f| >18 *6?0>//' Hqhg oa A HL' ^' MOQ' T' >4*f/‟}

~hvxo~hbhg|} f~h bh|) ’f lo}|~om| mcx~| bx}| hzfbogh pjh|jh~ th~bo}}oqh kcoglh~ pcxil ‚mcbtc~|

po|j |jh t~ogmotih} ca axglfbhg|fi afo~gh}}‟ c~ pcxil ~h}xi| og t~hkxlomh |c ho|jh~ }olh'‒ Jf~l

L~oqh T~cl}') :4? A' ]xtt' >l f| 6681' ^xih >6 ax~|jh~ t~cqolh} |jf| xtcg aoglog` bo}kcoglh~ ca

tf~|oh}) xtcg bc|ocg c~ cg o|} cpg) f mcx~| bfy) f| fgy |obh) fll c~ l~ct f tf~|y' ]hh AHL' ^'

MOQ' T' >6'

>' Tifog|oaa Jf} Afoihl |c Bhh| |jh ^hvxo~hbhg|} ca ^xih >4*f/

fgl Lch Lhahglfg|} >"6: ]jcxil Nh ]hqh~hl A~cb \jo} Fm|ocg

Kcoglh~ o} obt~cth~ nhmfx}h Tifog|oaa jf} afoihl |c h}|fnio}j |jf| |jh mifob} f~o}h cx| ca |jh

}fbh |~fg}fm|ocg) cmmx~~hgmh c~ }h~oh} ca |~fg}fm|ocg} c~ cmmx~~hgmh}) fgl mcg|fog mcbbcg

vxh}|ocg} ca ifp c~ afm|' \jh mifob |jf| kcoglh~ o} t~cth~ nf}hl cg Og|h~gh| aoih }jf~og` t~c|cmci}

ioeh No|\c~~hg| c~ c|jh~ thh~">"thh~ *’T>T‒/ t~c|cmci} jf} nhhg ~hqohphl fgl fibc}| xgoqh~}fiiy

~hkhm|hl ny qf~ocx} mcx~|}' ]hh Acgcqo}f) Ogm' q' Lch} 6"?) >44: PI ?6?046 *P'L' Tf' Ft~oi =)

>44:/ *aoglog` kcoglh~ obt~cth~ nhmfx}h ca |jh loaah~hg| afm|xfi mcg|hz|} ca |jh fiih`hl

oga~og`hbhg| ac~ hfmj lhahglfg| fgl fn}hgmh ca fgy hqolhgmh }jcpog` kcog| fm|ocg ny

lhahglfg|}) c|jh~ |jfg |jho~ x}h ca |jh }fbh Og|h~gh| aoih }jf~og` gh|pc~e |c fmmh}} mcty~o`j|hl

~hmc~log`}/5 IfAfmh ^hmc~l}) IIM q' Lch} 6"=:) >44: PI 8<<??> *H'L'G'M' Ahn' >0) >44:/

*~hkhm|og` kcoglh~ nf}hl cg |jh mifob |jf| lhahglfg|} x}hl |jh }fbh O]T fgl T>T gh|pc~e |c

fiih`hliy mcbbo| mcty~o`j| oga~og`hbhg|/5 Lofnciom Qolhc T~clxm|ocg}) Ogm' q' Lch} 6">4??)

>466 PI =644<4< *G'L' Mfi' Bfy =6) >466/ *jcilog` |jf| |jh gf|x~h ca |jh Og|h~gh| aoih }jf~og`

t~c|cmci) No|\c~~hg|) lch} gc| bfeh kcoglh~ ftt~ct~of|h pjh~h lhahglfg|} fiih`hliy x}hl Og|h~gh|

aoih }jf~og` |c oga~og`h mcty~o`j|hl pc~e}/5 E"Nhhmj) Ogm' q' Kcjg Lch} 6":8) >466 PI <?68886

*H'L' Qf' Cm|' 60) >466/ *’bh~h fiih`f|ocg} |jf| Lch Lhahglfg|} 'jfqh x}hl |jh }fbh thh~"|c"

thh~ gh|pc~e |c mcty fgl ~ht~clxmh |jho~ qolhc} o} og}xaaomohg| |c bhh| |jh }|fglf~l} ca


8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


0

kcoglh~'‒/5 fgl Tf|~ome Mciiog}) Ogm' q' Lch} 6"66:) Mf}h =;64"MQ"?>"KTN) Le|' <> *G'L'P'Qf'

Lhm' 61) >464/ *}fbh/) f||fmjhl jh~h|c f} Hzjono| @'

Lh}to|h Tifog|oaa‟} mifob}) nf}hl cg fgl fmmc~log` |c |jh `~hf| pho`j| ca kxlomofi

fx|jc~o|y) |jh Lch Lhahglfg|} lol gc| tf~|omotf|h og |jh }fbh |~fg}fm|ocg c~ cmmx~~hgmh) c~ |jh

}fbh }h~oh} ca |~fg}fm|ocg} c~ cmmx~~hgmh}) f} ~hvxo~hl ac~ kcoglh~5 gc~) lol |jhy fm| og mcgmh~|

po|j cgh fgc|jh~' \jh bh~h afm| |jf| fgy ca |jh Lch Lhahglfg|} bfy jfqh fiih`hliy miomehl cg f

mcbbfgl |c tf~|omotf|h og |jh og|h~gh| aoih }jf~og` gh|pc~e lch} gc| bhfg |jf| hfmj) |c`h|jh~)

pf} tf~| ca |jh lcpgicflog` lcgh ny jxgl~hl} c~ |jcx}fgl} ca ogloqolxfi}' Bc~hcqh~) hqhg oa o|

ph~h |~xh |jf| fii Lch Lhahglfg|} tf~|omotf|hl og pjf| Tifog|oaa lh}m~onh} f} f ’}pf~b)‒ o| mfggc|

nh }fol |jf| hfmj lhahglfg| pf} tjy}omfiiy t~h}hg| f| |jh }fbh lfy fgl |obh' Og afm|) Tifog|oaa

flbo|} |jf| lcpgicflog` pf} lcgh f| loaah~hg| |obh} fgl lf|h} ~fgòg` |j~cx`jcx| f }hqhg"phhe

th~ocl a~cb Fx`x}| ><) >466 |c Cm|cnh~ 64) >466'

F} }|f|hl fncqh) og f ghf~iy olhg|omfi bf}}"mcty~o`j| oga~og`hbhg| fm|ocg n~cx`j| ny |jh

}fbh tifog|oaa) Tf|~ome Mciiog}) Ogm') Kxl`h \obc|jy K' ]fqf`h }hqh~hl fii nx| cgh lhahglfg| a~cb

|jh fm|ocg) aoglog` |jf| |jh kcoglh~ ca |jh qf~ocx} lhahglfg|} pf} obt~cth~' ]hh C~lh~ *]fqf`h)

K'/) Hz' A' Kxl`h ]fqf`h gc|hl |jf| ’hqhg f}}xbog` f} |~xh tifog|oaa‟} fiih`f|ocg |jf| |jh Lch}

lcpgicflhl fgl }jf~hl |jh }fbh aoih fgl ph~h tf~| ca |jh }fbh }pf~b) th~bo}}oqh kcoglh~ o} og

ftt~ct~of|h òqhg |jh ghf~iy |pc"bcg|j th~ocl lx~og` pjomj |jh Lch} fiih`hliy lcpgicflhl |jh

Pc~e'‒ Ol ' f| g' 6 *mo|og` Jf~l L~oqh T~cl}' q' Lch} 6"==) Gc' M' 66"4=:>0 IN) >466 PI

8=>88=4) f| += *G'L' Mfi' Gcq' =) >466/ *jcilog` kcoglh~ ca |jo~|y"|j~hh }pf~b bhbnh~}

ogftt~ct~of|h òqhg f }oboif~iy lo}tf~f|h ~fg`h ca fiih`hl oga~og`hbhg| lf|h}//' @oqhg |jh afm|

|jf| Tifog|oaa og |jo} fm|ocg }oboif~iy fiih`h} |jf| ho`j|hhg Lch} lcpgicflhl fgl }jf~hl |jh }fbh

aoih fgl ph~h tf~| ca |jh }fbh }pf~b cqh~ f ghf~iy |pc"bcg|j th~ocl) th~bo}}oqh kcoglh~ }jcxil


8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


:

ioehpo}h nh lhhbhl ogftt~ct~of|h og |jo} bf||h~ fgl fii Lch Lhahglfg|} >"6: }jcxil nh }hqh~hl

a~cb |jo} fm|ocg'

=' Kcoglh~ O} Gc| Ftt~ct~of|h fgl Lch Lhahglfg|} >"6: ]jcxil

Nh ]hqh~hl A~cb \jo} Fm|ocg

Hqhg oa) f~`xhglc) Tifog|oaa jf} bh| |jh ~hvxo~hbhg|} }h| ac~|j xglh~ AHL' ^' MOQ' T'

>4*f/) |jh kcoglh~ o} ghqh~|jhih}} gc| ftt~ct~of|h fgl Lch Lhahglfg|} >"6: }jcxil nh }hqh~hl

a~cb |jo} fm|ocg nhmfx}h |jh kcoglh~ ca |jh Lch Lhahglfg|} pcxil lhahf| kxlomofi hmcgcby) ~h}xi|

og f }h~oh} ca bogo"|~ofi}) `c f`fog}| gc|ocg} ca axglfbhg|fi afo~gh}}) fgl xi|obf|hiy mfx}h

t~hkxlomh |c lhahglfg|}'

Og Jf~l L~oqh T~cl}') }xt~f) |jh mcx~| acxgl |jf| th~bo||og` kcoglh~ pf} gc| cgiy

obt~fm|omfnih) nx| pcxil ’xglh~bogh ^xih >4*f/‟} tx~tc}h ca t~cbc|og` kxlomofi hmcgcby fgl

|~ofi mcgqhgohgmh nhmfx}h o| pcxil ~h}xi| og f ic`o}|omfiiy xgbfgf`hfnih mf}h'‒ Jf~l L~oqh

T~cl}') }xt~f) :4? A']xtt'>l f| 661< *mo|og` N~ol`htc~| Bx}om) Ogm' q' 66M Bx}om) >4> A'^'L'

>>?) >=>"== *B'L' \hgg' >446//' \jh mcx~| fi}c acxgl |jf|;

' ' ' th~bo}}oqh kcoglh~ ca |jh Lch Lhahglfg|} lch} gc| mcbtc~|po|j |jh ’gc|ocg} ca axglfbhg|fi afo~gh}})‒ fgl |jf| o| poii ioehiymfx}h t~hkxlomh |c |jh tx|f|oqh lhahglfg|}' ]hh Mcihbfg) >=> A'=lf| 6>?1' \jh kcoglh~ pcxil ~h}xi| og gxbh~cx} jx~lih} |jf| pcxilt~hkxlomh |jh lhahglfg|}' Ac~ hzfbtih) hqhg |jcx`j |jhy bfy nh}htf~f|hl ny bfgy boih} fgl jfqh gc|jog` og mcbbcg c|jh~ |jfg|jh x}h ca No|\c~~hg|) hfmj lhahglfg| bx}| }h~qh hfmj c|jh~ po|jfii tihflog`}“f }o`goaomfg| nx~lhg pjhg) f} jh~h) bfgy ca |jhlhahglfg|} poii nh ftthf~og` t~c }h fgl bfy gc| nh h"aoih~}' Hfmjlhahglfg| pcxil jfqh |jh ~o`j| |c nh f| hfmj c|jh~ lhahglfg|‟}lhtc}o|ocg“m~hf|og` f |jc~cx`jiy xgbfgf`hfnih }o|xf|ocg' \jhmcx~|~ccb t~cmhhlog`} pcxil nh xgpc~efnih“po|j hfmj ca |jh

6:: Lch} jfqog` |jh cttc~|xgo|y |c nh t~h}hg| fgl fll~h}} |jhmcx~| f| hfmj mf}h bfgf`hbhg| mcgah~hgmh c~ c|jh~ hqhg|' Aogfiiy)hfmj lhahglfg|‟} lhahg}h pcxil) og haahm|) ~hvxo~h f bogo"|~ofi'\jh}h nx~lhg} mcbtih|hiy lhahf| fgy }xttc}hl nhghao| a~cb |jh kcoglh~ ca fii Lch} og |jo} mf}h) fgl pcxil }xn}|fg|ofiiy t~hkxlomhlhahglfg|} fgl |jh flbogo}|~f|ocg ca kx}|omh'

Jf~l L~oqh T~cl}') :4? A' ]xtt' >l f| 661<'

Mf}h >;66"mq"40>8>"B]@ Lcmxbhg| 1"6 Aoihl 4=#4:#6> Tf`h 6> ca >4

8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


?

Ioehpo}h) og |jh c|jh~ bf}}"mcty~o`j| oga~og`hbhg| mf}h n~cx`j| ny Tifog|oaa mx~~hg|iy

thglog` nhac~h Kxl`h \obc|jy K' ]fqf`h) |jh Mcx~| *mo|og` Jf~l L~oqh T~cl}' q' Lch} 6"6::/

lh|h~boghl |jf| hqhg oa tifog|oaa jfl bh| |jh ~hvxo~hbhg|} ca ^xih >4*f/) ’o| o} ftt~ct~of|h |c

}hqh~ fgl lo}bo}} fii nx| cgh Lch'‒ ]hh C~lh~ *]fqf`h) K'/) Hz' A' Og `~fg|og` }hqh~fgmh) |jh

Mcx~| acxgl |jf| og }to|h ca |jh }oboif~ mcglxm| fiih`hliy th~th|~f|hl ny |jh lhahglfg|}) loaah~hg|

lhahg}h} jfqh nhhg t~h}hg|hl fgl f~h ioehiy |c nh t~h}hg|hl }jcxil kcoglh~ ~hbfog' Ol' *]fqf`h)

K'/ *mo|og` NB@ Bx}om q' Lch} 6">4=) >44< PI ?8=:::) f| +6 *H'L' Tf' Ft~' >) >44</

*Ghpmcbh~) K'/ *lh}m~onog` f }oboif~ }mhgf~oc pjh~h ’Mcbmf}| }xn}m~onh~ Kcjg Lch 6 mcxil nh

fg oggcmhg| tf~hg| pjc}h og|h~gh| fmmh}} pf} fnx}hl ny jh~ bogc~ mjoil) pjoih Kcjg Lch > bo`j|

}jf~h f mcbtx|h~ po|j f ~ccbbf|h pjc oga~og`hl Tifog|oaa}‟ pc~e}' Kcjg Lch = |j~cx`j >4=

mcxil nh |johqh}) kx}| f} Tifog|oaa} nhiohqh'‒//'

]oboif~iy) og io`j| ca |jh loaah~hg| lhahg}h} |jf| f~h ioehiy |c nh t~h}hg|hl fgl |jh

}xn}|fg|ofi t~hkxlomh |c lhahglfg|}) |jh Mcx~| }jcxil ioehpo}h }hqh~ |jh fm|ocg f} |c Lch

Lhahglfg|} >"6:'

N' C~lh~ @~fg|og` Th~bo}}ocg |c ]h~qh ]xntchgf ]jcxil Nh Qfmf|hl

fgl |jh ]xntchgf ]jcxil Nh Vxf}jhl

Fa|h~ cn|fogog` ihfqh ca Mcx~| |c }h~qh |jo~l"tf~|y }xntchgf}) Tifog|oaa }h~qhl f ]xntchgf

xtcg Mcbmf}| |jf| pf} o}}xhl cx| ca |jh Lo}|~om| ca Ghp Kh~}hy *gc| |jo} lo}|~om|/ fgl t~h}xbfniy

}h~qhl xtcg Mcbmf}| f| Mcbmf}|‟} Ih`fi Lhbfgl Mhg|h~ icmf|hl og Bcc~h}|cpg) Ghp Kh~}hy'

Jcphqh~) |jh ]xntchgf ~hvxo~h} Mcbmf}| |c t~clxmh lcmxbhg|} |c Tifog|oaa f| Tifog|oaa‟}

mcxg}hi‟} caaomh) icmf|hl og Jf~ihy}qoiih) Thgg}yiqfgof'

]obxi|fghcx}iy po|j |jo} Bc|ocg) nhmfx}h |jh ]xntchgf pf} o}}xhl cx| ca |jh Lo}|~om| ca

Ghp Kh~}hy) Lhahglfg| jf} nhhg mfx}hl |c aoih f Bc|ocg |c Vxf}j |jh }xntchgf og |jh Lo}|~om| ca

Ghp Kh~}hy nf}hl cg |jh ]xntchgf nhog` lhahm|oqh ac~ afoix~h |c mcbtiy po|j A HL' ^' MOQ' T'

Mf}h >;66"mq"40>8>"B]@ Lcmxbhg| 1"6 Aoihl 4=#4:#6> Tf`h 6= ca >4

8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


64

<8*f/*>/ f} phii f} ac~ |jh ~hf}cg} }h| ac~|j nhicp' ]hh Bc|ocg |c Vxf}j) f||fmjhl jh~h|c f}

Hzjono| J' Jcphqh~) |c t~hqhg| Tifog|oaa a~cb }obtiy ~ho}}xog` f ]xntchgf |jf| mx~h} |jh lhahm|)

Lhahglfg| ~hvxh}|} |jf| |jh C~lh~ `~fg|og` Tifog|oaa ihfqh |c }h~qh |jo~l tf~|y }xntchgf} nh

qfmf|hl'

6' Lhahglfg| Jf} ]|fglog` |c Mjfiihg`h |jh ]xntchgf Nhmfx}h

Lhahglfg| Jf} f Th~}cgfi Og|h~h}| og |jh ]xntchgfhl Bf||h~

F tf~|y jf} }|fglog` |c mjfiihg`h f }xntchgf o}}xhl |c f |jo~l tf~|y pjhg |jh tf~|y jf} f

th~}cgfi ~o`j| c~ t~oqoih`h og |jh ogac~bf|ocg }cx`j| ny |jh }xntchgf' ]hh Eolf q' HmcPf|h~

]y}|hb} IIM ) >466 PI 6::=6?<) +> *H'L' Tf' >466/ *Nfyi}cg) K'/' Jh~h) nhmfx}h |jh }xntchgf

o}}xhl |c Mcbmf}| }hhe} Lhahglfg|‟} th~}cgfi olhg|oayog` ogac~bf|ocg) Lhahglfg| xglcxn|hliy

jf} f ’th~}cgfi ~o`j|‒ og |jh ogac~bf|ocg }cx`j| ny |jh }xntchgf' Ax~|jh~) cgmh Lhahglfg|‟}

gfbh o} |x~ghl cqh~ ny Mcbmf}|) Tifog|oaa) f} tf~| ca o|} nx}ogh}}"bclhi poii vxomeiy }hhe

}h||ihbhg|} a~cb fgy olhg|oaohl Lch Lhahglfg|}) fbcxg|og` |c |jcx}fgl} ca lciif~} hfmj) po|j gc

}h~ocx} og|hg|ocg ca gfbog` fgy Lhahglfg| fgl io|o`f|og` |jh bf||h~ cg |jh bh~o|}' Oa fg olhg|oaohl

Lch Lhahglfg| jf} f th~}cgfi ~o`j| }xaaomohg| |c tfy }hqh~fi |jcx}fgl} ca lciif~} xglh~ |jh |j~hf|

ca txniom hztc}x~h fgl io|o`f|ocg) mh~|fogiy Lhahglfg| jf} f th~}cgfi ~o`j| }xaaomohg| |c cnkhm|

t~oc~ |c |jf| lo}mic}x~h' Fmmc~log`iy) Lhahglfg| jf} }|fglog` |c mjfiihg`h |jh }xntchgf'

>' \jh C~lh~ @~fg|og` Ihfqh |c ]h~qh \jo~l"Tf~|y ]xntchgf

]jcxil Nh Qfmf|hl

Og fllo|ocg |c |jh afm| |jf| |jh lhahglfg|} jfqh nhhg obt~cth~iy kcoghl) |jh C~lh~

`~fg|og` ihfqh |c }h~qh |jo~l"tf~|y }xntchgf} }jcxil nh qfmf|hl nhmfx}h |jh |hmjgcic`y x|oio{hl

|c olhg|oay ogloqolxfi lhahglfg|} ac~ |jh fiih`hl mcty~o`j| oga~og`hbhg| o} xg~hiofnih fgl

Mf}h >;66"mq"40>8>"B]@ Lcmxbhg| 1"6 Aoihl 4=#4:#6> Tf`h 6< ca >4

8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


66

og}xaaomohg| |c }jcp f qcio|ocgfi fm| ca mcty~o`j| oga~og`hbhg|'= Bc~h }thmoaomfiiy) |jh~h o} gc|

cgiy }ca|pf~h mftfnih ca obth~}cgf|og` fgl#c~ afi}oayog` fg OT fll~h}} *’}tccaog`‒/<) nx| }xmj

|~fmog` }ca|pf~h o} xg~hiofnih nhmfx}h |jh }ca|pf~h o} ogmftfnih ca lh|hm|og` BFM fll~h}}h}'

Ax~|jh~bc~h) bc}| O]T} lc gc| }|c~h BFM fll~h}} lf|f fgl |jhy jfqh gc fnoio|y |c lh|hm| BFM

fll~h}}h} |jf| jfqh nhhg afi}oaohl' Nhmfx}h |jh |hmjgcic`y x|oio{hl ny Tifog|oaa |c ’olhg|oay‒

Lhahglfg| o} xglcxn|hliy xg~hiofnih) Tifog|oaa o} }x~hiy ogmftfnih ca fmmx~f|hiy qh~oayog`

ogloqolxfi} pjc lcpgicflhl mcty~o`j|hl bf|h~ofi) fgl a~cb pjh~h |jh bf|h~ofi o} lcpgicflhl'

Nhmfx}h OT fll~h}}h} oglomf|hl cg Tifog|oaa‟} }xntchgf} f~h xg~hiofnih) Tifog|oaa mfggc| nf}h o|}

}xntchgf} cg }xmj xg~hiofnih ogac~bf|ocg'

8

Bc~hcqh~) |c t~cqh oga~og`hbhg|) f tifog|oaa bx}| ao~}| t~cqh |jf| |jh lhahglfg| mctohl |jh

t~c|hm|hl pc~e *}hh Ehiiy q' F~~onf ]ca| Mc~t') ==1 A'=l :66) :60 *?|j Mo~' >44=/ *’|jh tifog|oaa

bx}| }jcp cpgh~}jot ca |jh mcty~o`j| fgl mctyog` ny |jh lhahglfg|‒//) fgl |jf| |jh mctyog` pf}

f ~h}xi| ca f qcio|ocgfi fm|' ]hh ^hioòcx} \hmj' M|~ q' Gh|mcb Cg"Iogh Mcbbm‟g ]h~q}') Ogm' ) ?40

A' ]xtt' 6=16) 6=1?"04 *G'L' Mfi' 6??8/' Jcphqh~) Tifog|oaa‟} fiih`f|ocg} f~h pchaxiiy

ogflhvxf|h fgl lc gc|) fgl mfggc| fmmcxg| ac~ gxbh~cx} o}}xh}) a~cb cthg po~hih}} gh|pc~e}

nhog` oiih`fiiy ogqflhl) OT fll~h}} }tccaog` |c jxbfg fgl mciihm|ocg h~~c~}' Mcx~|} f`fog jfqh

|cxmjhl cg |jo} }obtih yh| x||h~iy icòmfi olhf; fg OT fll~h}} o} gc| f Mcty~o`j| Oga~og`h~ ' F}

|jh Mhg|~fi Lo}|~om| ca Oiiogco} Mcx~| gc|hl;

UTifog|oaaR o`gc~h} |jh afm| |jf| OT }xn}m~onh~} f~h gc| ghmh}}f~oiymcty~o`j| oga~og`h~}' Mf~ciyg \jcbt}cg p~o|h} og fg B]GNMf~|omih ca f ~fol ny ahlh~fi f`hg|} cg f jcbh |jf| pf} iogehl |clcpgicflhl mjoil tc~gc`~ftjy' \jh olhg|o|y fgl icmf|ocg ca |jh

= ]hh Kfbh} \hbtih) ]|hiih Jfg}bhoh~ l~ct} }xo| f`fog}| ‚tc~g `~fggy‟) ]fg A~fgmo}mcMj~cgomih) Fx`' =6) >466) j||t;##ppp'}a`f|h'mcb#mò"nog#f~|omih'mò3a2#m#f#>466#4:#=6#NXFM6E\N<<'L\I) f||fmjhl jh~h|c f} Hzjono| O'< ]hh h'`') j||t;##T~czy'c~`#'8 F bc~h |jc~cx`j lo}mx}}ocg ca No|\c~~hg| |hmjgcic`y mfg nh acxgl og Ncy ^fmh~) Ogm' q' Lch)>466 PI =18>8>6 *G'L'Mfi' >466/'


8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


6>

}xn}m~onh~ ph~h t~cqolhl ny |jh O]T' \jh lh}e|ct mcbtx|h~)oTjcgh}) fgl oTfl} ca |jh jcbhcpgh~ fgl jo} poah ph~h }ho{hl og|jh ~fol' Ahlh~fi f`hg|} ~h|x~ghl |jh hvxotbhg| fa|h~ lh|h~bogog`|jf| gc cgh f| |jh jcbh jfl lcpgicflhl |jh oiih`fi bf|h~ofi'F`hg|} hqhg|xfiiy |~fmhl |jh lcpgicfl} |c f gho`jnc~ pjc jfl

x}hl bxi|otih OT }xn}m~onh~}‟ Po"Ao mcgghm|ocg} *ogmixlog` f}hmx~h mcgghm|ocg a~cb |jh ]|f|h Xgoqh~}o|y ca Ghp _c~e/'

QT^ Og|h~gf|ocgfih q' Lch} 6"6460 ) Mf}h Gc' >;66"mq"4>41:"JFN) Le|' 68) f| > *M'L' Oii Ft~oi

>?) >466/) f||fmjhl jh~h|c f} Hzjono| K' Jcphqh~) ’pjh|jh~ ycx‟~h `xoi|y c~ gc|) ‚ycx icce ioeh

f }x}thm|'‟‒ Ol' f|='

Tifog|oaa‟} mifob} fgl fiih`hl OT hqolhgmh fi}c afoi |c t~cqolh fgy hqolhgmh ca iofnoio|y

xglh~ f |jhc~y ca mcg|~onx|c~y oga~og`hbhg|' ]thmoaomfiiy) Tifog|oaa bx}| }jcp ’UcRgh pjc) po|j

egcpihl`h ca |jh oga~ogòg` fm|oqo|y) oglxmh}) mfx}h} c~ bf|h~ofiiy mcg|~onx|h} |c |jh oga~ogòg`

mcglxm| ca fgc|jh~'‒ Acgcqo}f) Ogm' q' Mjh~~y Fxm|ocg) Ogm') 01 A'=l >8?) >1< *?|j Mo~' 6??1/

*mo|og` @h~}jpog Txnio}jog` Mc~t' q' Mcixbnof F~|o}|} B`b|') Ogm') <<= A'>l 668?) 661> *>l Mo~'

6?06//' ]hh `hgh~fiiy Ghpnc~g q' _fjcc&) Ogm') =?6 A']xtt'>l 6:6 *L'L'M' >448/' ]ogmh f} f

bf||h~ ca ifp) fg OT fll~h}} o} gc| f th~}cg xglh~ fgy lo~hm| oga~og`hbhg| fgfiy}o}) o| o} }obtiy

icòmfi ny hz|hg}ocg |jf| fg xg~hiofniy jf~qh}|hl OT fll~h}} afoi} |c fiih`h fgy egcpihl`h ca c~

mcg|~onx|ocg |c fgy oga~ogòg` fm|oqo|y'

Nf}hl cg |jh |hmjgcicòmfi hf}h po|j pjomj pjciiy oggcmhg| Lhahglfg|} mfg nh }c hf}oiy

afi}hiy olhg|oaohl“ac~ hzfbtih pjhg |jh gho`jnc~) xgnhegcpg}| |c fgycgh) oiih`fiiy hzhmx|og` f

No|\c~~hg| t~c|cmci |j~cx`j f tx|f|oqh Lhahglfg|‟} po~hih}} }o`gfi) c~ th~jft} f th~}cg }obtiy

fmmh}}og` |j~cx`j ogm~hf}ogìy tctxif~ a~hh txniom ’Po"Ao‒“mcxtihl po|j |jh lhqf}|f|og` haahm|

}xmj f afi}h fmmx}f|ocg mcxil jfqh) Tifog|oaa‟} fiih`f|ocg} afoi |c t~cqolh }xaaomohg| fmmx~fmy) gc~

f qcio|ocgfi fm| f}}cmof|hl |c fg fmmcxg| jcilh~ }xaaomohg| |c }xttc~| o|} mifob' \jx}) |jh C~lh~

`~fg|og` ihfqh |c }h~qh |jo~l tf~|y }xntchgf} }jcxil nh qfmf|hl fgl |jh }xntchgf }jcxil nh

vxf}jhl'


8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


6=

=' \jh ]xntchgf ]jcxil Nh Vxf}jhl |c T~c|hm| Lhahglfg| A~cb

Xg~hf}cgfnih Fggcyfgmh) Hbnf~~f}}bhg| fgl Ctt~h}}ocg

\jh C~lh~ `~fg|og` ihfqh |c }h~qh |jo~l"tf~|y }xntchgf} }jcxil nh qfmf|hl fgl |jh

}xntchgf vxf}jhl |c t~hqhg| Lhahglfg| a~cb }xaah~og` xgpfg|hl fggcyfgmh) hbnf~~f}}bhg|)

fgl ctt~h}}ocg) c~ c|jh~po}h) }xaah~og` fg xglxh nx~lhg' ]hh AHL' ^' MOQ' T' <8*m/*=/*F/*oq/'

Jh~h) Tifog|oaa) f} tf~| ca o|} ac~"t~cao| nx}ogh}} bclhi) }hhe} Lhahglfg|‟} mcgaolhg|ofi th~}cgfi

olhg|oayog` ogac~bf|ocg a~cb Lhahglfg|‟} O]T }c |jf| Tifog|oaa mfg fggcy fgl hbnf~~f}}

Lhahglfg|) fgl mch~mh f vxome fgl t~cao|fnih }h||ihbhg| xglh~ |jh |j~hf| ca txniomiy cx|og`

Lhahglfg| ca oiih`fiiy lcpgicflog` tc~gc`~ftjy“lh}to|h hqolhgmh mfiiog` og|c vxh}|ocg

pjh|jh~ Lhahglfg| hqh~ hg`f`hl og }xmj fm|}'

Tifog|oaa‟} }xntchgf o} og|hglhl |c mfx}h fg xglxh fggcyfgmh) hbnf~~f}}bhg|) fgl

ctt~h}}ocg |jf| pcxil ~h}xi| oa Lhahglfg|‟} th~}cgfi olhg|oayog` ogac~bf|ocg ph~h f}}cmof|hl)

po|jcx| }xaaomohg| hqolhg|of~y }xttc~|) ca oiih`fiiy lcpgicflog` tc~gc`~ftjy' ]xmj f}}cmof|ocg

pcxil nh jo`jiy hbnf~~f}}og` |c Lhahglfg|) xgkx}|oaofniy }|o`bf|o{og` |c Lhahglfg|) ogkx~ocx} ca

|jh Lhahglfg|‟} mjf~fm|h~ fgl ~htx|f|ocg) fgl tc|hg|ofiiy khctf~lo{og` |c |jh Lhahglfg|‟}

hbticybhg|' Bc~hcqh~) hqhg fa|h~ Lhahglfg| o} fnih |c lhbcg}|~f|h |jf| Tifog|oaa‟} fiih`f|ocg} og

|jo} }xo| f~h afi}h) |jh hbnf~~f}}bhg| fgl ~htx|f|ocgfi lfbf`h a~cb Tifog|oaa‟} afi}h txniom mifob

poii }|oii th~}o}|' Jcphqh~) ny qfmf|og` o|} C~lh~ `~fg|og` Tifog|oaa ihfqh |c }h~qh |jo~l"tf~|y

}xntchgf fgl ny vxf}jog` |jh Tifog|oaa‟} }xntchgf) |jh Mcx~| mfg t~hqhg| Lhahglfg| a~cb nhog`

xgkx}|iy jf~bhl fgl hbnf~~f}}hl ny t~hbf|x~h fiih`f|ocg} ca lcpgicflog` oiih`fi tc~gc`~ftjy'

Xglh~ |jh}h mo~mxb}|fgmh}) |jh C~lh~ }jcxil nh qfmf|hl fgl |jh }xntchgf }jcxil nh vxf}jhl'

M' Fi|h~gf|oqhiy) f T~c|hm|oqh C~lh~ ]jcxil Nh Hg|h~hl T~hmixlog`

Txniom Lo}mic}x~h ca Lhahglfg|‟} Mcgaolhg|ofi Ogac~bf|ocg


8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


68

T~cjono|og` txniom lo}mic}x~h ca Lhahglfg|‟} mcgaolhg|ofi ogac~bf|ocg o} ghmh}}f~y |c

t~hqhg| Lhahglfg| a~cb }xaah~og` xglxh fggcyfgmh) hbnf~~f}}bhg|) fgl ctt~h}}ocg |jf| pcxil

~h}xi| oa Tifog|oaa) po|jcx| }xaaomohg| hqolhg|of~y }xttc~|) txniomiy fmmx}h} Lhahglfg| ca oiih`fiiy

lcpgicflog` tc~gc`~ftjy' Og fllo|ocg) }xmj t~c|hm|ocg poii mcbtc~| po|j |jo} Mcx~| ~cih f} fg

obtf~|ofi flkxlomf|c~ ca ih`fi lo}tx|h} fgl gc| ’bh~hiy |cci} ac~ hgmcx~fòg` fgl hzfm|og`

}h||ihbhg|} a~cb Lhahglfg|} mcphl ny |jh tc|hg|ofi mc}|} ca io|o`f|ocg fgl iofnoio|y'‒ ô`j|jfqhg

IIM q' Joii) }xt~f) Gc' 6;66"mq"44>66) Le|' 61) Hz' L'

F} gc|hl oga~f) ’|jh hbnf~~f}}bhg| ca txniom hztc}x~h bo`j| nh |cc `~hf|) |jh ih`fi

}y}|hb |cc lfxg|og` fgl hzthg}oqh) ac~ }cbh |c f}e pjh|jh~ UTifog|oaaR jf} mcbth|hg| hqolhgmh

|c t~cqh o|} mf}h'‒ QT^ Og|h~gf|ocgfih) }xt~f) Mf}h Gc' >;66"mq"4>41:"JFN) Le|' 68) f| = Hz' K'

O} o| |jhg oiicòmfi c~ xg|jogefnih |c |joge |jf| fg fgcgybcx} Lhahglfg|“o~~h}thm|oqh ca fm|xfi

`xoi| c~ oggcmhgmh“afmhl po|j |jh t~cah}}ocgfi#th~}cgfi ~xog) ficg` po|j |jh xgmh~|fog|y fgl

mc}| ca f ahlh~fi ifp}xo| pcxilg‟| }obtiy lhmolh |c tfy f ahp |jcx}fgl lciif~} |c bfeh ’o|‒ fii `c

fpfy3 ]xmj T~c|hm|ocg C~lh~ ax~|jh~} |jo} ftt~ct~of|h kxlomofi ~cih fgl pcxil gc| t~hkxlomh

Tifog|oaa‟} ~o`j|} og fgy pfy'

Fmmc~logìy) oa |jh Mcx~| lch} gc| }hqh~ Kcjg Lch Lhahglfg|} > |j~cx`j 6: a~cb |jo}

fm|ocg) lch} gc| qfmf|h o|} C~lh~ fgl lch} gc| vxf}j |jh ]xntchgf) |jh Mcx~| }jcxil hg|h~ f

t~c|hm|oqh c~lh~; *6/ t~cjono|og` |jh txniom lo}mic}x~h ca fgy ogac~bf|ocg ~hif|og` |c Lhahglfg|

cn|foghl a~cb Lhahglfg|‟} O]T |j~cx`j Tifog|oaa‟} ]xntchgf po|jcx| Lhahglfg|‟} mcg}hg| c~ |jh

Mcx~|‟} t~oc~ fx|jc~o{f|ocg5 fgl *>/ ~hvxo~og` fgy tf~|y aoiog` f tihflog` og |jo} fm|ocg |jf|

mcg|fog} c~ ~hah~hgmh} fgy ogac~bf|ocg ~hif|og` |c Lhahglfg| t~clxmhl og ~h}tcg}h |c |jh

]xntchgf |c aoih xglh~ }hfi'

Mf}h >;66"mq"40>8>"B]@ Lcmxbhg| 1"6 Aoihl 4=#4:#6> Tf`h 6? ca >4

8/2/2019 Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)


61

OQ' MCGMIX]OCG

Ac~ fii ca |jh fncqh }|f|hl ~hf}cg}) Lhahglfg| ~hvxh}|} |jf| |jh Mcx~| `~fg| Lhahglfg|‟}

Bc|ocg og |jh ac~b ca C~lh~ }xnbo||hl jh~hpo|j'

^h}thm|axiiy }xnbo||hl)

AHIIJHOBH^ ! HOMJHG IIT

#}# Kcjg K' Kfmec) OOO

Kcjg K' Kfmec) OOO) H}vxo~h]x}fg B' C) H}vxo~h\pc Ionh~|y Tifmh

84 ]cx|j 61

|j

]|~hh|) =<

|j

Aicc~Tjoiflhitjof) TF 6?64>Tjcgh; *>68/ >8="11=< F||c~ghy} ac~ Lhahglfg|

Kcjg Lch 6=

Lf|hl; Bf~mj :) >46>

Mf}h >;66"mq"40>8>"B]@ Lcmxbhg| 1"6 Aoihl 4=#4:#6> Tf`h >4 ca >4

Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)

Documents

Transcript of Doe13 MTQ_-07252(PA)