DoD Architecture and Standards Governance

NDIA Systems Engineering Conference

John P. Skudlarek, CISSPOctober 29, 2009

Enterprise Architecture & Standards DirectorateOffice of the DoD Deputy Chief Information Officer

3

DoD Architecture Federation

Dept of Air Force

DoD Enterprise Architecture

SOC

OM

DIS

AD

LAN

SAN

RO

NG

AD

IA

Oth

er Solu

tion

Arc

hite

ctur

es

Force Application

Building Partnerships

Command & Control

Protection

Logistics

Force Support

Corporate Management & Support

Net-centric

Battlespace Awareness

Join

t Cap

abili

ty A

reas

Tech Stds

DISRArch Guidance

DoDAFRef Models

DoD EA RMLaws, Regs, and Policy

Laws Regs PolicyTools

DITPRDARS

Dept of Army Dept of Navy

Army Architecture

DON Architecture

Air Force Architecture

Air Force

3

Info

rmat

ion

Ente

rpris

e A

rchi

tect

ure

DOD CIO Governance Restructure Memo- Signed 8/11/09

STRATEGIC ADVISOR

FEDERAL INFORMATION SHARING INITIATIVEINFORMATION SHARING STRATEGY / IMPLEMENTATION

PLANCUI

Federal Information Sharing Executive

PROGRAM ANALYSIS & SUPPORT

CIO GOVERNANCEINFORMATION QUALITYDOMAIN NAME & WEB

POLICYPRIVACY IMPACT

ASSESSMENTSE-GOVERNMENT (OMB)RESOURCE MANAGEMENT SECTION 508IT WORKFORCE ACADEMIA OUTREACHOMB LIAISONGAO LIAISONCONGRESSIONAL LIAISONCIO ROLE – 8000.01FORMS MGMTINFO COLLECTIONWEB ADMIN/MGMT

CIO Management Services

DOD FEDERATED ENT. ARCHSTANDARDS (DISR)DoD INFO ENT ARCH 2.0 DADAF 2.0DARSREFERENCE ARCH SUPPORT

Enterprise Architecture & Standards

STRATEGIC PLAN PERFORMANCE MEASUREMENTPOLICY FRAMEWORKFUTURE OF THE CIOINTERNET GOVERNANCEAGENCY/ASSOC. OUTREACHFEA LIAISON

Strategic Planning & Policy

COMMAND OPS & OUTREACH

EXECUTIVE ASSISTANT

Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Information Management, Integration, and Technology

MR. DAVID WENNERGREN

*

RECORDS MGMT DATA STRATEGY / COIsSERVICES STRATEGY /

SOANCES, MCEITS, CANESIDENTITY MGMT. &

ATTRIBUTE SERVICESSPECIAL ASST TO THE

VCJCSCLOUD COMPUTINGWEB 2.0 – DoD UseDOD APPS STORE

Enterprise Services Integration

NETOPSIPv6UNIFIED CAPABILITIESENTERPRISE OPERATIONS &

OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE OSD CIO LIAISONPACCRISK MANAGEMENTGIG WAIVERS/CONNECTION

APPROVAL PROCESS

Enterprise Operations

TITLE 40 / CCA OVERSIGHTCPI / LSSINDUSTRY OUTREACH CLEARINGHOUSEACQUISITION SUPPORTCOTS TECH REVIEW &

MARKET RESEARCHINFORMATION SUPPORT

PLANSENTERPRISE SYSTEMS

HEALTH CARE, ERPs,DIMHRS, etc.

INTEROPERABILITY

Commercial Technologies & Systems

ENTERPRISE SOFTWAREINITIATIVE

IT ASSET MANAGEMENT & COMMODITY BUYING

IT INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT

ENTERPRISE GUIDANCEBOARD

DoD IT INFRASTRUCTURE LIBRARY (ITIL)

COMPUTING INFRASTRUCTURE

DITPRDBSMC – BTA/IRB

LIAIASONNGEN OVERSIGHTJOINT BASINGCPM COORDINATION

Portfolio Management & Enterprise Infrastructure

DIRECTORS

NET-CENTRIC EDUCATION (JPME)JCTDSSAG

Special Assistant for Net-Centric Operations

JULY 2009

DoD CIO Executive Board

Direct Reporting Compliance/Coordination

CIO/C4

Architecture & Standards Review Group

Chairs: Dir, Enterprise Architecture & Standards

& DISA CSE (GES-E)

Enterprise Guidance BoardChair: DoD DCIO

IA Enterprise Review Group

Chair: PD DASD CIIA

Information Assurance Senior Leaders

Chair: DASD (CIIA)

DoD CIO

• IA Architecture approval and engineering guidance

• IA Standards and configuration management

• Assure integration and compliance of capabilities & solutions

• ES strategic planning, policy & implementation

• Data/Service strategies coord• Solution synchronization• Information sharing• Service registries• Interoperability • ES to tactical edge

• Compliance/Enforcement of Net Ops/Operational IA (policy, guidance)

• GIG certification & accreditation • Compliance/Enforcement of

sustained operations through:- Configuration management- Architecture- GIG Waivers- Operational connections process- Test & integration- Interoperability and supportability• Architecture approval at the

enterprise level• Manage architecture federation• Define architecture compliance

criteria• Maintain authoritative sources of IT

standards and implementation-level specifications

Enterprise Operations Oversight Committee

Chairs: Dir, Enterprise Operations & STRATCOM

Rep

• Vision high level interpretation & compliance• “Top cover”• Recommends directly to the DoD CIO• “Tie breaker”• Escalated problem resolution

•DoD CIO vision interpretation,strategies & policies

•Capability architectures approval•Acquisition oversight (Non-MAIS & MDAP)•DBSMC Cert/IRB• Issue adjudication • IA policy and

guidance• GIAP guidance

Enterprise Services Review Group

Chairs: DISA (PEO GES); Dir,

Enterprise SvcsIntegration; DNI

DCIO

CIO Governance Framework

ASRG Mission

The Architecture and Standards Review Group (ASRG) serves within the Department of Defense (DoD) Chief Information Officer (CIO) Enterprise Governance framework. The ASRG is subordinate to the DOD CIO EGB. It is chartered to: review architecture policy and guidance; identify DoD Information technology (IT) technical standards; oversee IT standards management; review architectures and enforce architecture policy; oversee DoD EA Federation; and enforce DoD Information Enterprise Architecture (IEA) compliance.

ASRG Organizational Structure

8

Authoritative Sources of Approved Architectures & Standards

DoD PolicyDoDD 5000, DoDD 4630, DoDD 8210,

CJCSI 6212, CJCSI 3170

DARS

Approved

Architectures

DISR

Appro

ved

IT S

tand

ards

ASRGASRG

ITSCITSCFACFAC

https://dars1.army.mil/IER2/

https://disronline.disa.mil/

GTG CMB Governance StructureGTG CMB Governance Structure

Wiki Comment & Review Cycle

Approval

ASRG

Non-Attribution Open SourceProject Model

Agencies StakeholdersServices

Chair/Configuration Manager: DISA OUSD(AT&L), OASD(NII), OASD(DCIO), JS(J6)

PolicyIssues

NGA JFCOM DNI CIO J2 J4 DTRA M&SCO MDA

GTG CM Board

ASD(NII)/DCIO USD (AT&L) USA USN USAF USMC USCG Joint Staff/J6 DISADLA

DISA NSA DOT&E

Periodic ReviewCoordinationTechnical Collaboration

Management DirectionIssue Adjudication

Priority SettingProject OversightCross Functional Integration

Adoption ASRG/ITSC/DISRIntegration Recommend

GESP

Promulgation

NRO DARPA STRATCOM DIA

GESP GESP GESP GESP GESP GESP GESP GESP GESP GESP GESP GESP

SecuredAvailability

Comm.Data/

ServicesNetOps

GESP GESP GESP GESPGESP GESP GESP GESP

Development Groups

Annual GIG Technical

Solution Set

Review & SynchCycle

Synchronized GTG Content

Recommendation and Approval

EWSE IPTs

ComputingInfrastructure

GTG/GTG Online

Co-Chair(s):

ASD(NII)/DNI/ICSR

http//www.disa.mil/ge/ge3/ge33.html

DoDAF V2.0 Focus

Focus: architecture DATA,

not Products

Results: Better ANALYSIS and

Decisions.

DoDAF V2.0 provides overarching architecture concepts, guidance, best practices, and methods to enable and facilitate architecture development.

14

DoDAF V2.0 Viewpoints That Fit-the Purpose

Architecture viewpoints are composed of data that has been organized to facilitate understanding. 16

All View

pointO

verarching aspects of architecture context that relate to all m

odels

Data and Inform

ation Viewpoint

Articulate the data relationships and alignm

ent structures in the architecture content

Standards Viewpoint

Articulate applicable O

perational, Business, Technical, and

Industry policy, standards, guidance, constraints, and forecasts

Systems ViewpointArticulate the legacy systems or

independent systems, their composition, interconnectivity, and context providing for,

or supporting, DoD functions

Services Viewpoint Articulate the performers, activities,

services, and their exchanges providing for, or supporting, DoD functions

Operational ViewpointArticulate operational scenarios,

processes, activities & requirements

Capability Viewpoint Articulate the capability requirement,

delivery timing, and deployed capability

Project Viewpoint

Describes the relationships betw

een operational and capability requirem

ents and the various projects being implem

ented; D

etails dependencies between capability m

anagement and the

Defense A

cquisition System process.

“Fit for Purpose” DoDAF Architecture Descriptions

DoDAF V 2.0 Delivery

DoDAF V2.0 is available at:

https://www.us.army.mil/suite/page/454707

http://www.defenselink.mil/

http://www.defenselink.mil/cio-nii/docs/DoDAF%20V2%20-%20Volume%201.pdf

http://www.defenselink.mil/cio-nii/sites/diea/

19

http://www.defenselink.mil/cio- nii/policy/index.shtml

Save the date!

May 10-14, 2010

DoD Enterprise Architecture Conference 2010, San Antonio, TX