Documentation of Public Dialogue...PUBLIC CONSULTATION FOR THE FOURTH RATE REBASING DOCUMENTATION...
Transcript of Documentation of Public Dialogue...PUBLIC CONSULTATION FOR THE FOURTH RATE REBASING DOCUMENTATION...
-
PUBLIC CONSULTATION FOR THE FOURTH RATE
REBASING DOCUMENTATION
Imus Sports Complex, General Castañeda St.,
Imus, Cavite
7 September 2018
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator MWSS Regulatory Office Katipunan Road, Balara, Quezon City
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Brief Background and Overview……………………….………………………………......2
Executive Summary….…………………………….………………………………………….....2
Objectives...……………………………………………………………………………………….….3
Discussion………………………………………………………………………………….….……...3
Highlights of the Open Forum……...………………….………………………….…………4
Annexes……………………………………………………………………….…..……….….……....9
Annex A Directory of Participants……..………………………………………………9
Annex B Presentation of TCI and CG&Co……………………………………….…22
Annex C Presentation of MWSS RO…………………………………………………35
Annex D Photos of the event, invitation, letters and programs…………37
Annex E Concept Note………………………………………………………………….…48
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
2
DOCUMENTATION OF PUBLIC INFORMATION DRIVE
PUBLIC CONSULTATION
BRIEF BACKGROUND AND OVERVIEW
The MWSS-RO is mandated to conduct a Rate Rebasing exercise every five years
pursuant to the Concession Agreement entered into by the MWSS and Manila Water
and Maynilad. Rate Rebasing is a periodic performance review and general tariff
adjustment that sets the maximum rates the Concessionaires may charge for their
services.
During the rate rebasing review, the MWSS-RO evaluates the two concessionaires
based on their compliance to key performance indicators (KPI) and business efficiency
measures (BEM) goals, taking into consideration expenditures and investments to
achieve the targets. In the same direction, the concessionaire’s business plans, which
lay the framework for new service obligations and anticipated future investments as
the concession moves forward, are also assessed by MWSS-RO.
When doing these, it becomes critical for the regulator to secure inputs from the
public and other stakeholders like LGUs to validate both performance and business
plans. Hence the need to conduct public consultations and other fora.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Public Consultation for the Fourth Rate Rebasing conducted on September 7, 2018
is the major public consultations that MWSS-RO will hold for the 2018 rate rebasing.
It is the fourth rate rebasing exercise under the Concession Agreement. It was held at
the Imus Sports Complex, Imus, Cavite.
Hosted by the MWSS-RO, the Public Consultation attracted a total of 409 participants
representing the Local Government Units and members of Homeowners Association,
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
3
officials from MWSS-RO and Maynilad were also present. Attached as Annex A is the
Directory of Participants.
OBJECTIVES
The Public Consultation for the Fourth Rate Rebasing aimed to:
1. To lay down the results of the Fourth Rate Rebasing 2. To inform customers and stakeholders on the basis of tariff adjustments,
factors and considerations included in the computation and how these translates into their water bill.
3. To gauge how the rate adjustments will be received. 4. To elicit comments and suggestions on the adjustments.
DISCUSSION
The Public Consultation began with presentations from the Consultants and followed
by the Chief Regulator of MWSS RO.
Test Consultants Inc. and Constantino Guadalquiver & Co. Presentation
Engr. Rolando Roca presented the approved and on-going projects of Maynilad Water
Services Inc. and how water rates are computed and how did MWSS arrived with the
indicative rates.
MWSS-RO Presentation
Chief Regulator, Patrick Lester N. Ty presented the Indicative rates or partial “r” for
Maynilad Water Services Inc. He also explained the effects of the rate adjustment to
the water bill of the consumers.
Attached as Annexes B and C are the presentation materials of MWSS RO and Test
Consultants Inc. and Constantino & Guadalquiver Co., respectively.
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
4
The participants were given time to raise their questions and concerns. In the open
forum, MWSS RO officials made sure that all inquiries and complaints were clarified
and resolved.
HIGHLIGHTS OF THE OPEN FORUM
The heads and participants in Cavite and Local Government Units in different areas of
Cavite raised several concerns and issues during the open forum. Below are the
highlights of the question and answer portion.
Name of Participant Question / Issue Response
a. From Makati City Nais kong maibahagi sa inyo na this is my first time na kunin sa isang public consultation na malinaw na malinaw ang pagdiscuss kung ano po ba itong public consultation, magmula po kay Charlie Espallardo at kay Ma’am Evelyn including our chief regulator, ako po ay nagpapasalamat sa inyong napakahusay na pamumuno dito sa regulatory office. Malinaw na malinaw po, hindi lang po siguro sa akin kundi sa ating lahat na nagpaliwanag ng tamang tama kung ano po ba talaga ang Rate Rebasing. Buti sa inyong pamumuno, regulator, proud po ako sa inyong lahat, mahusay na mahusay ang inyong pagpapatakbo at hindi
Maraming salamat po, mas lalo pa po naming pagbubutihin ang aming serbisyo.
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
5
lamang po ang maynilad ang inyong prinoprotektahan kundi ang buong customers. Maraming maraming salamat po .
b. Marycris Venturo
From tubig pagasa
Na magpasalamat po kami sa Maynilad.Sa ngayon magsasampung taon na kaming partnership ng Maynilad, not only to maynilad but also sa Muntinlupa. So for now, gusto ko pong magpasalamat on behalf of tubig pag asa and waterlines Philippines kay Ma’am Villar, sir Andrew Pangilinan in Muntinlupa, but off course sir Tuazon, gusto kong ipaalam sa lahat na maraming salamat sa tulong ninyo sa mga lugar dito sa cavite at sa muntinlupa na hanggang ngayon wala paring ma access na tubig. Ang tubig pag asa po ang siyang naging daan para makapasok si Maynilad sa lugar na iyon, so we have four areas na napasok sa tulong ng maynilad, meron po kami sa Cordillera, dalawa sa kawit and na expand po kami ngayon sa muntinlupa. So, sa tulong po ng mga tiga Maynilad maraming maraming salamat po at sana patuloy nyo paring suportahan ang tubig
Maraming salamat po Ma’am Marycris. Makakaasa po kayo na pagbubutihin pa po namin ang aming trabaho.
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
6
pagasa at waterlines Philippines sa mga proyektong na gagawin pa naming in the future at meron po kaming pangunahing project. We have partnership offcourse in Maynilad, yung aming existing is sanitation project na produce sila samin ng tulong para na makapag patayo kami ng appropriate project sa isang lugar samin sa Kawit at meron din po kami sa Muntinlupa.
c. North caloocan Magandang hapon po sa ating lahat, kami po ay ngapapasalamat galing po sa north Caloocan.
Mabilis na kumilos ang maynilad. 2015 hanggang 2016. Kaya nagpapasalamat kami kahit malayo ang tirahan namin makapunta lang dito para makapagpasalamat sa mabilis na pagkilos ng Maynilad. Maraming salamat po
Maraming salamat din po.
d. Regine Maranag From Caloocan
Magandang hapon po. Sa tulong po ng Maynilad dahil pabalik balik kami sa Maynilad Caloocan nag offer po sila na sila muna ang mag babayad ng aming red pay. Kaya pumayag po ang subdivision, sila ang nagbayad at nagkatubig kami,
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
7
hinuhulugan namin sa Maynilad.
Ngayon po tapos na kami, maginhawa at nagkaroon ng tubig, sawang sawa po ang ank nmin. Ngayon po salamat po sa tubig
Kaya maraming salamat po sa Maynilad.
e. Mrs. Cruz From Imus, Cavite
Unang una po nais kong magpasalamat sa Maynilad at MWSS. Naiayos po lahat, gumawa po kami ng sulat kay Mr. Mario Contabes at pagkatapos po ay na-actionan kagad ang tatlo pong bahay po.
Pangalawa po ay water subdivision ung pong maynilad nakita po naming nasa bawat
Salamat po ng marami kay sir Mario. Kay Atty. Ty last quarter po ng 2018 hindi po b pwedeng pamasko niyo napo sa mga consumers yun?
Maraming pong salamat, actually dapat ay January 1, 2018.October 1 2018 as target. Ten months’ delay na po tayo kaya kawawa naman po ang mga concessionaire natin, months na po ang delay, idedelay pa natin. Pero ,naiintindihan ko po ang iyong sentimento nakita ko po na mas mababa ang october kaysa january 1.
Gusto nating tulungan ang ating mga consumers’ para hindi gaanung kabigat, sana po konting tiis lang po.
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
8
Sinasabi kanina na okay lang na tumaas ang presyo ng tubig wag lang mawalan ng tubig kasi importante sa atin yan. Marami pong salamat.
f. Mr. Danie
From parañaque
Today, it’s my first time to attend a public consultation of Maynilad, so, napakalinaw po ang mga presentation. Dibale, magbigay ng paliwanag sa mga area pong nasasakupan po natin.
Ang tubig po ay isa sa pangunahing pangangailangan ng mga tao at syempre sa Parañaque po ay nagpapasalamat kami sa Maynilad, para tutukan po ang mga residente sa Parañaque .
Maayos na patubig sa tulong po ng Maynilad.
We appreciate po your comment. Maraming Salamat po.
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
9
ANNEXES
ANNEX A DIRECTORY OF PARTICIPANTS
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
10
NAME ADDRESS / LOCATION CONTACT NUMBER
1. Dazzly S. Zamora Brgy. Staff 09215946108
2. Irma Corpuz President-HOA 09178366644
3. Crismelito Reyes Maligaya SWBP 09204818412
4. Rosemarie Reyes Auditor 09453578402
5. Maricel Saliba 09554713527
6. Rosana Naleon
7. Jocelyn Mondina 09355383083
8. Nemie Saldaga
9. Daisy Canida Cavite
10. Charmy Dela Cruz
11. Rowena Decaro
12. Loida Briones Richfield Subd. 09155718814
13. David Sanchez Jr. Kabankai 09496086237
14. Bernardo Ferrer Jr. Jade Residences 09284453541
15. Alex Aquino Supervisor 09177189832
16. Lerma Soriano President 09277368568
17. Lorito De Vera President 09325449326
18. Lezeil Climaco 09497634843
19. Peter Veriño Imus, Cavite
20. Juditha Sembrano President 09493008893
21. Sonny Marao Board 090947555000
22. Nelia Balauro SMCAI 09198442371
23. Rebecca Sanchez ISLA 09398234569
24. Marivic Lobesto ISLA
25. Norma Navarro ISLA 09182598675
26. Elena Emaro ISLA 09081323692
27. Riza Solayen ISLA
28. Luticia Entoma ISLA 09105481640
29. Nelson Alpabete ISLA
30. Patrick Clima Sec. Gen. BK3 09393836277
31. Jinky Toledo Chairman FOSHAI 09179178484
32. Audrey De Jesus IBON 09165314607
33. Xandra Bisurio IBON 09451224153
34. Josefin Bautista BNT 09107080722
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
11
35. Amante Turla San Juan City Hall 09368093570
36. Rene Escobra Toclong. IC 09171660511
37. Jhun Camia Bayan Luma 7 0932-844-3237
38. Roniel Gonzaga Kawit 09168920144
39. Genel John Poniente Kawit 09328853039
40. Arlyn Reyes QC Planning Office 09759085014
41. Allan Z. Abella Imus City HOA 09381677799
42. Rodel Prudente Centro/Staff 283-0695
43. Vergil Catayong Centro Navotas 283-0695
44. Christian Mervin Sarno City Engineer Imus 283-0695
45. Noel Cuevas Engineer II 09274478888
46. Ronnie Ramirez Brgy. Chairman 09166891934
47. Dr. Norberto Rayupa Municipal Admin LGU Kawit 09176324939
48. JD Marquez LGU Kawit 09174785558
49. Emmanuel Maliksi Imus City Mayor
50. Mayor Security 1 Imus City
51. Mayor Security 2 Imus City
52. Mayor Security 3 Imus City
53. Mayor Security 4 Imus City
54. Mayor Security 5 Imus City
55. Mayor Security 6 Imus City
56. Mayor Security 7 Imus City
57. Mayor Security 8 Imus City
58. Mayor Security 9 Imus City
59. Roy Buencamino Brgy. Teacher 09287259964
60. Geraldine Ordañez Treasurer 09154436785
61. Imelda Oraño
62. Kim Tovancisca Engineer 09171396308
63. Nolan Clemente Empl 09285220425
64. Maria Victoria Las Piñas
65. Pedro Ragudo Cavite 09178042495
66. Blesilda Tolentino
67. David Yolores Las Piñas 09985490280
68. Cherry Canepalao Cavite
69. Bernard Martinez Parañque 09075073185
70. Mary Grace Benliro Branch Manager 09985740992
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
12
71. Federico Rivera Rivera Compound 09364334979
72. Edna Tsilog Rivera Compound 09364334979
73. Mercy Mangundapas VP-Dev. Charter Builders
74. Adelina Satina 09493525627
75. Vercel Reyes
76. Raymond Gratela FFZ HOA Pres.
77. Gina Lavicia Teacher Dep Ed
78. Almaylyn Saguban SMV Pres. 09219420275
79. Miko Arianne Racelis IMUS 09985972207
80. Gina Ollev Pres. BHOACI 09174554091
81. Ronaldo Digo Secretary BHOA 09173651172
82. Lailani Manabat BHW Cluster 9 09224464434
83. Soledad Ferrer Pres. Pabahay Housing 09217872867
84. Lolita Sion Baseo Brgy. Lida 09076699667
85. Mane Punzalan District Officer 09178241190
86. Mervic Mangui Caloocan 09284452703
87. Rostico Cruz Noveleta 09284453812
88. Vince Delos Santos Las Piñas City 09985944347
89. Ma. Josephine Cafancat Muntinlupa 09171450818
90. Gretchen Joy Martinez Parañaque City 09178223288
91. Ricardo Casillano III FC Tubig Pag-asa 09172042297
92. Rolando Torres Parañaque City
93. Eloida Lotarino Parañaque City 09507238153
94. Cherrian Alcones Parañaque City 09100128684
95. Vhersie del Rosario Cavite 09985516386
96. Cecilde Catas Muntinlupa City 09569352927
97. Teresa Alferez Muntinlupa 09569352927
98. Leonora Cabacado Putatan Mnt. 09124082201
99. Soprina Mesa Putatan Asst. Head 09207426007
100. Benjamin Flores Sgt. Arms
101. Marivic Somona Bacoor Cavite 0999885685
102. Marilyn Cachuela Cavite City 09353362212
103. Nelia Reyes Cavite City
104. Raquel Cañero Cavite City
105. Clea Gellecanato Cavite Bacoor
106. Leny Rabans
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
13
107. Shiela Montecilla Bacoor, Cavite 09488022444
108. Velos Liezel Member 0995087768
109. Amante Tu
110. Ricardo Manalo Sampaloc
111. Arqueste Tejeda President
112. Elenita Del Rosario Sec. Alex Ville 09329254367
113. Ruby Riguindi Pascualer Ville 092943144570
114. Restie Cinco Greenlane Subd.
115. Dee Estacio Telstra CSR 09454136100
116. Ann Lyn Donillo BHDAAC 09162282973
117. Meldy Saron BAOACI 09420178939
118. John Pangan WMD
119. Madel Zaide Corplan/ Head HR
120. Reynando Redata NCAL-Z5 09284452552
121. Raimond Pascual Zore Can 09778266001
122. Rico Rosello Jr. Zore Specialist 09284452524
123. Dumindin Arro ZS 09952743541
124. Shigeliko Kurata Finance 09992205315
125. Phoebe Alitona HOA Sec.
126. Delia Danganan HOA Assoc.
127. Xaven Ciadra HOA Pres.
128. JiJi R. De Guzman Security 09425269910
129. MAmitog Arnel G. Security 09997289416
130. Lerio Alex A. Security 09471060431
131. Joemar Balia Utility
132. Jerico A. Mangada Utility 09655818755
133. Escalente Arnido Security 09192554915
134. Charlemaine Avila Security 09237136872
135. Antonio paruga Security 09063869396
136. Renald Alolino Security 09275643388
137. John G. Security 09103887360
138. Nathalie R. Tejada CPSC 09293209040
139. Jojie Colopa Utility
140. James Ika Utility
141. Belmor Rucio Utility
142. Michael Valdez Sec
143. Dominic Gaguia Sec
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
14
144. Lymiel Miranda Utility
145. Dazzly s. Zamora Brgy. Staff 09215946108
146. Lerma Corpuz President 09178366644
147. Crismelito Reyes Maligaya Subdivisi 09204818412
148. Rosemarie R. Reyes Auditor 0945357840
149. Maricel saliba 09554713527
150. Rosana Nalcon
151. Jocelyn Momdina 09355383083
152. Nemie R. Salballer
153. Luiz Carmola Cavite City
154. Charmy dela Cruz
155. Rowena Gue
156. Loida Briones Redifield Subd. 09155718814
157. David G. Sanchez Jr. Kabankat 09496086237
158. Bernardo C. Perrer Jr. Jade Residences 09984453541
159. Alex B. Aquino Supervisor 09177189832
160. Lerma Soriano President 09277368568
161. Berto D. del Vera President 0932544935
162. Lezeil Climanco 09497634843
163. Peter G. Verino Imus City
164. C. Sembrano President/GHAI 09493008893
165. Sonny Imaw Board 09094755500
166. Sandra Carpio B.N. T
167. Alexandra valdez B.N. T
168. Minerva Angeles B.N. T
169. Crisanto Rosas B.N. T
170. Felma Mundanes Las Piñas
171. Katrina Bello Las Piñas
172. Kyla Baltazar Las Piñas
173. Carlito Panganiban Las Piñas
174. Luis Santos Muntinlupa
175. Klarisse Mendoza Muntinlupa
176. Chynthia Cruz Cavite
177. Lindo Dizon Imus Cavite
178. Jerwin Quinto Imus Cavite
179. Claire Jane P. Reyes Imus Cavite
180. Mylene Rapanut Imus Cavite
181. Dennis David Imus Cavite
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
15
182. Flor Coronado Imus Cavite
183. Rodrigo Banta Imus Cavite
184. Arnel Cruz Imus Cavite
185. Jane Banal Imus Cavite
186. Jordan Brtilino Kawit
187. Marcelo Mayo Kawit
188. Samuel Rivera Imus
189. Charlene Chuares Imus
190. Eldon Ballena Muntinlupa
191. Sabina Martinez Muntinlupa
192. Sofhia Santos Imus
193. Ysabelle Dura Imus
194. Jackylyn Abejar Las Piñas
195. Prudelyn Chan Las Piñas
196. Abigail Jane Santiago Cavite
197. Melanie Sanchez Cavite
198. Robert Bayani Parañaque
199. Micaella Mae N. Lundag Parañaque City
200. Joel John O. Antolin Parañaque City
201. Ryan De Guzman Parañaque
202. Angela Chavez Imus
203. Emilio Trinidad Kawit
204. Melody Velasco Cavite
205. Sandra B. Gomez Las Piñas
206. Jose Allan S. Labaro Imus
207. Elmer Severino Muntinlupa
208. Adelan Mendoza Cavite
209. Reymart T. Sunaga Kawit
210. Shane Ramirez Cavite
211. Abby Jane ty Cavite
212. Lanie Dean Cruz Imus
213. Raymond Equias Las Piñas
214. Marlyn Solomon Paranaque city
215. Dwaine Perez Muntinlupa
216. Cassandra Alfar Muntinlupa
217. Greg Capulong Cavite
218. Joselyn C. Loquiro Cavite
219. Chek david Makati City
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
16
220. Gian Mariano Imus
221. Allen Matic Kawit
222. Beverly Joy Campos Imus
223. Arianne Olicia Cavite
224. Marley Osan Imus
225. Mike Iram Brgy. Pagasa I
226. Melanie Bani Cavite
227. Jayson Domingo Imus
228. Florentino S. Santos Kawit
229. Albert san Diego Cavite
230. Kaye Marquez Cavite
231. Mark david Imus
232. Marie Santos Imus
233. Princess Sagani Makati City
234. Andrew Vilog Makati
235. Awen Drew Barit Makati
236. George sandoban Imus
237. Rowena Uy Makati
238. Nilo M. Natividad Kagawad 0917366975
239. Luth Magno Labor Leader 09399171855
240. PO1 Ryan Joy D. Duaza PNP 09173766307
241. PO1 Mark Ian B. Parominog PNP 09102502293
242. PO1 Gerald Ashley V. Gervacio PNP 09173183386
243. PO1 Michael John P. Callilan PNP 09666772132
244. PO1 Irah C. Sumagaysay PNP 09558649929
245. PO1 Soltan Ros Sarmiento PNP
246. Efren T Cortez HRep/Com. Sec
247. Noli S. Lubay LGU/Paranaque 09985480387
248. Daddy Dalton LGU/Paranaque 09436459864
249. Janet Eselo Buhay na Tubig 09466533610
250. Juvelindo Caraballe Buhay na Tubig 09291512909
251. Ofilia Anabil B.N. T 09978507952
252. Lalaine S. Gracia B.N. T 09332406898
253. Eduardo Germeneta Jr. B.N. T 09053325855
254. Karl Ramirez B.N. T 09058824738
255. Rosalinda Custa Brgy. 13
256. Rowena A. Bilang Brgy. 13 09264860558
257. Dalisay Castañeda Brgy. 13
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
17
258. Rowel Mansalim Kawit
259. Diane Lusantos Kawit
260. Mark Daniel Andres Kawit
261. Melvin Angala Cavite
262. Carlo Manzano Cavite
263. Shiela Marie Galdonez Cavite
264. Lyn Lyn Roca Imus
265. Robert Aguinaldo Las Piñas
266. Jocelyn Aquino Las Piñas
267. Clarisse Mae Antolin Las Piñas
268. Andrea Dulan Cavite
269. Alvin Angala Jr. Kawit Cavite
270. Bea Santiago Kawit
271. Deo Manlangit Kawit Cavite
272. Alice Uy Imus
273. Jonathan Rabe Imus
274. Elbert John Cora Cavite
275. Yang Aguilar Imus
276. Angelo Mark Ruetas TCI
277. F.F. Paderenac TCI
278. RE. Roca TCI
279. R.C. Roca TCI
280. Evelina P. Alvarad TCI
281. Antonio Constantino TCI
282. L. Sanchez TCI
283. Marcello Villaforte TCI
284. Hdifijn Torum TCI
285. Jenny Fueras TCI
286. Charmaine Tiraña TCI
287. Mark Kevin A. Ascaño TCI
288. To Dexter TCI
289. Efren tabra TCI
290. Razelle Narciso TCI
291. Rachelle de Jesus TCI
292. Nadera Claire C. TCI
293. Javenal J. Binarao TCI
294. Rey Thomas Edison TCI
295. Christian Morota TCI
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
18
296. Josef Mark b. Barcoma TCI
297. James Balaoro Imus
298. Bryan Poloma Imus
299. Mary jane Viernes Las Piñas
300. Christopher Dela Cruz Las Piñas
301. Agnes bati Kawit
302. Lyka Shane Quilop Kawit
303. Alejandro S. Reyes Kawit
304. Ramel Perez Kawit
305. Frederick Sarcia Imus
306. Bea Bernardo Reporter 09558992960
307. Larry Doon Cameraman
308. Ruel Velasco Asst. Cameraman
309. Leileon Mincias Reporter 09998138544
310. Susan Enriquez GMA 7 924 3082
311. Jojo Quibral GMA 7 924 3082
312. Mel Estrella GMA7 924 3082
313. Carmelo R. Dizon GMA7 09162966855
314. Dennis Calda GMA7 09162966855
315. Phillip Dalawis GMA7 0916296685
316. Norman BAcsal GMA7 09162966855
317. Gull Gabatino Maynilad 09288071908
318. Nenida Dela Cruz Maynilad 09285009848
319. Elmer Magacay Maynilad 09285009891
320. Nelo S. Marcelo Maynilad 09209183207
321. Jun Domingo Maynilad 09285009853
322. Job Cavares Maynilad 09285010249
323. Ricardo Arguel Maynilad 09188630125
324. Harold Lopez Maynilad 09088686243
325. Grace Coxa Maynilad 09285012730
326. Jewel Ong Maynilad 09988347996
327. Valentino Del Rosario Maynilad 09088674874
328. Jessica Nebriza Maynilad 09081649966
329. Dino Buen Maynilad 09209183218
330. Maricon Concepcion Maynilad 09209183059
331. Jen Rufo Maynilad 09285011905
332. Edgardo Dimapily Maynilad 09209463421
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
19
333. Jaime Bartolome Maynilad 09285010131
334. Anette De Ocampo Maynilad
335. Il Dimaano CNRW 09285010254
336. Ryan Jamora CNRW 09285009865
337. Steve Aspacio CXRO 09285012552
338. Ma. Cherry Marilla CNRW 09285578185
339. Christ Nasayao CNRW 09088948581
340. Gilberto Tanay CNRW 09331580592
341. Bernard Padilla CXRO 09285009897
342. LM Espiritu Maynilad 09189630208
343. MD De Jesus Maynilad
344. Jerome Cruz Maynilad
345. Ma. Elena Paguyao Maynilad
346. Camille Peña Maynilad 09321659270
347. Joana Calma Maynilad 09202019849
348. Ampy Bonoreo Maynilad
349. Alba Santos Maynilad 09198484586
350. Eric Romero 2s Cav BA
351. Silvester Viojan 2s Cav BA 09994328826
352. Fernando Luyan CAV BA 09284453620
353. Jee-Ann Racoma SMPM
354. Johanne Remaneses SMPM
355. Jeffrey Parilla Utility
356. Ronald Ledesma Utility
357. Eugene Alonzo Sounds Supplier
358. John Kristopher Virias AC Maintenance
359. Marcello Arollo AC Maintenance
360. Toto Cantella AC Maintenance
361. Danielle Reyes Supplier Projector
362. Isaganiel Santos Supplier Projector
363. Jonathan Cruz Scriptor
364. Arnold Setarios Sounds Supplier
365. Patrick Lester N. Ty MWSS-RO, OCR
366. Darrell John S. Magsambol MWSS-RO, OCR
367. Lorna C. Medina MWSS-RO, OCR
368. Karl mark N. Zapanta MWSS-RO, OCR
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
20
369. Renato L. Rodriguez Jr. MWSS-RO, OCR
370. Charlie Espallardo MWSS-RO, CSRA
371. Randolph Q. Marcial MWSS-RO, CSRA
372. Kim Soliven MWSS-RO, CSRA
373. Joshua Aquino MWSS-RO, OCR
374. Lee Robert M. Britanico MWSS-RO, CSR
375. Leo James Abaloyan MWSS-RO, OCR
376. Lorna C. Balingit MWSS-RO, CSRA
377. Olivia O. Tolentino MWSS-RO, CSRA
378. Ma. Karmela B. Bueno MWSS-RO, OCR
379. Sheena Guinaling MWSS-RO, OCR
380. Joshua Aquino MWSS-RO, OCR
381. Mark Billy Antonio MWSS-RO, FRA
382. Charmaine Sheila Abia MWSS-RO, FRA
383. Emy Romero MWSS-RO, FRA
384. Maria Sharlene Zausa MWSS-RO, FRA
385. Mary Ann Monic Pena MWSS-RO, FRA
386. John Oliver Medina MWSS-RO, ALA
387. Roberto Colloso MWSS-RO, ALA
388. Edgar Lumbres MWSS-RO, ALA
389. Ranjev Garcia MWSS-RO, ALA
390. Roberto Diala MWSS-RO, ALA
391. Jun Avila MWSS-RO, ALA
392. Crisanto Nagtalon MWSS-RO, ALA
393. Alex Limin MWSS-RO, ALA
394. Francisco Manuyag Jr. MWSS-RO, ALA
395. Crescenciano B. Minas Jr. MWSS-RO, ALA
396. Emyl Angelique Fulgeras MWSS-RO, FRA
397. Rachelle Pamatmat MWSS-RO, ALA
398. Christopher D. Chuegan MWSS-RO, FRA
399. Evelyn B. Agustin MWSS-RO, TRA
400. Angela Sigrid J. Along MWSS-RO, ALA
401. Claudine Orocio-Isorena MWSS-RO, ALA
402. Virginia V. Octa MWSS-RO, ALA
403. Carla N. Benito MWSS-RO, TRA
404. Mario Macatangay MWSS-RO, TRA
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
21
405. Joel Dominguez MWSS-RO, TRA
406. Clarissa Jallorina MWSS-RO, FRA
407. Ronnie Alegre MWS-RO, CSRA
408. Justine Ignacio MWSS-RO, FRA
409. Elena Cheng MWSS-RO, FRA
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
22
ANNEX B
PRESENTATION OF THE TCI AND CG&CO.
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
23
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
24
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
25
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
26
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
27
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
28
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
29
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
30
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
31
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
32
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
33
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
34
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
35
ANNEX C PRESENTATION OF THE MWSS RO
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
36
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
37
ANNEX D
PHOTOS OF THE EVENT, INVITATION LETTER
AND PROGRAM
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
38
PHOTOS
RO staff welcome customers at the registration area with information
materials.
Atty. Angela Along and DM Charlie Espallardo as the Masters of Ceremony.
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
39
DA Evelyn B. Agustin giving her opening remarks.
Engr. Rolando E. Roca, Sewerage and Sanitation Specialist, presenting the rate
determination, procedure and approved projects.
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
40
Chief Regulator Patrick N. Ty, as he announce the 2018 Indicative
Rates.
The Imus City Mayor Emmanuel Maliksi giving his warm message.
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
41
DM Karl Mark N. Zapanta as the Moderator during the Q&A
portion.
Maynilad Customer expressing his support and encourage everyone
to help Maynilad in performing a better service.
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
42
Maynilad Customer raise some concerns and q ueires.
MWSS Regulators promptly answers customer’s issues and concerns.
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
43
DA Evelyn B. Agustin addressing customer’s queries.
DA Lee M. Britanico during his Closing Remarks.
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
44
INVITATION LETTER
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
45
List of Invitees:
CITY / MUNICIPALITY MAYOR'S NAME
1 Angono Gerardo V. Calderon
2 Antipolo Casimiro A. Ynares III
3 Baras Kathrine B. Robles
4 Binangonan Engr. Cesar M. Ynares
5 Cainta Atty. Johnielle Keith P. Nieto
6 Cardona Bernardo P. San Juan Jr.
7 Jala - Jala Elionor I. Pillas
8 Morong Armando D.S. San Juan
9 Pililla Dan V. Masinsin
10 Rodriguez Cecilio C. Hernandez
11 San Mateo Cristina C. Diaz
12 Tanay Rex Manuel Tanjuatco
13 Taytay George Ricardo R. Gacula II
14 Teresa Raul S. Palino
15 Makati Mar-Ien Abigail Binay-Campos 16 Marikina Marcelino R. Teodoro
17 Manila Joseph E. Estrada 18 Mandaluyong Carmelita Aguilar Abalos
19 Pasig Robert C. Eusebio
20 Pateros Miguel F. Ponce III
21 Quezon City Herbert M. Bautista
22 San Juan Guia G. Gomez
23 Taguig Ma. Laarni Lopez Cayetano
24 Caloocan Oscar Malapitan
25 Las Piñas Imelda T. Aguilar
26 Malabon Antolin A. Oreta III
27 Navotas John Reynald M. Tiangco 28 Parañaque Edwin D.L. Olivarez
29 Valenzuela Hon. Rex Gatchalian
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
46
30 Cavite Bernardo S. Paredes
31 Bacoor Lani Mercado Revilla 32 Imus Emmanuel L. Maliksi
33 Kawit Angelo Emilio Aguinaldo
34 Noveleta Dino Reyes Chua
35 Rosario Jose V. Ricafrente III 36 Muntinlupa Atty. Jaime R. Fresnedi 37 Pasay Antonio G. Calixto
38 Media Organizations All Media Networks
39 PCOO Sec. Jose Ruperto Martin M. Andanar
40 EON Carlos Mori Rodriguez
41 Bayan Muna Nelson Colmenares
42 Laban Konsyumers Inc. Victorio Dimagiba
43 Water for All Refund Movement Rodolfo Javellana Jr.
44 Water for the People Network Teodoro Casiño
45 Home Owners Associations
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
47
PROGRAM
FOURTH RATE REBASING PUBLIC CONSULTATION PROGRAM September 7, 2018 / 2:00 pm – 5:00 pm
Imus Sports Complex, General Castañeda st., Imus, Cavite
2:00PM – 2:10PM INVOCATION THE PHILIPPINE NATIONAL ANTHEM
2:10PM – 2:25PM OPENING REMARKS
Evelyn B. Agustin Deputy Administrator, Technical Regulation Area
2:25PM – 3:05PM PRESENTATION OF APPROVED PROJECTS AND RATE DETERMINATION
Engr. Rolando E. Roca Test Consultants Inc.
3:05PM – 3:35PM 2018 INDICATIVE RATES
Patrick Lester N. Ty
Chief Regulator
SNACKS
3:35PM – 4:45PM QUESTION AND ANSWER PROPER
Mr. Karl Mark N. Zapanta
Moderator
Manager, Public Information Department
4:45PM – 5:00PM CLOSING REMARKS
Lee M. Britanico
Deputy Administrator, Customer Service
Regulation Area
Masters of Ceremony Ms. Angela J. Along and Mr. Charlie Espallardo
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
48
ANNEX E CONCEPT NOTE
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
49
CONCEPT NOTE
Public Consultation Fourth Rate Rebasing Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator MWSS Regulatory Office
7 September 2018
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
50
I. Public Consultation Schedule.
Date Time Venue
September 5, 2018 2:00 – 5:00 PM Cainta Elementary School Auditiorium A Bonifcacio Ave. Cainta, Rizal
September 7, 2018 2:00 – 5:00 PM Imus Cavite Sports Complex General Castaneda St. Imus Cavite 4103, Cavite
II. Participants. We recommend the attendance of 45 RO Employees.
Breakdown is as follows: Regulators 5 pax RO Staff Including Drivers 40 pax
III. Estimated Budgetary Requirement.
Particulars Cost Amount
Venue:
September 5 – Cainta Elementary School
September 7 – Imus Cavite Sports Complex
25,000.00
20,000.00
45,000.00
Sound System (2 days) 24,000.00 x 2 48,000.00
Tarpaulin (8 x 8) 7,000.00 7,000.00
Budgetary Allocation for Meals
96,450.00 96,450.00
Courier (delivery of invitations for LGus)
MM 85 x 16 (1,360.00) Luzon 110 x 21 (2, 310)
3,670.00
Newspaper Advertisement 50,000.00 50,000.00
-
Public Information Department Office of the Chief Regulator
Documentation of Public Consultation 7 SEPTEMBER 2018
51
Supplies and Miscelleanous (candies, coffees, sticker papers, ball pens)
10,000.00 10,000.00
Contingency (10% of total) 26,012 26,012
TOTAL Php286,132.00
Budgetary Allocation for Meals
Head Count
Amount Rizal Cavite
RO 45 325 (Lunch 250.00 and
snacks 75.00)
14,625.00 14,625.00
Security 15 325 (Lunch 250.00 and
snacks 75.00)
4,875.00 4,875.00
Technical 12 325 (Lunch 250.00 and
snacks 75.00)
3,900.00 3,900.00
Expected Participants
200 75(snacks only) 15,000.00 15,000.00
Media 34 75(snacks only) 2,550.00 2,550.00
Guests/ EON 37 75 (snacks only)
2,775.00 2,775.00
Manila Water 30 75 (snacks only)
2,250.00 2,250.00
Maynilad 30 75(snacks only) 2,250.00 2,250.00
48,225.00 48,225.00
GRAND TOTAL
96,450.00