dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i...

29

Transcript of dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i...

Page 1: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

������������ ���������������� ���������������

"!

#%$'&)(+*-,�.�/10�2�/",�.�354

687:98;+<>=?9A@CBED>7:F:GHDI6J<CGLKNM"OQP

RCSUTWV�X?Y?Z[S�\]Y>^`_ba"YcV�Y'dfegY?dfh�e6ji�S�k)\�dml]SUXce-dmY ! ^`_b9niNdfh�V�o`^9Ai�dfh�V�o`^Npq=srtrtdt\�^`dfe+P`u`PQv]wxQyNr !Nz GCh{Y?^ SUX}|�~Q~]w

���N�f*���$'&'*?����3����q$-���g$'����$'&C�"�Q�����Q�`�

�����`�����s�c���c�U�s�g�C�������� Q¡`¡�¢���£s�'¤H��¥C¡"�U��£§¦�¨C©n�U£s�ª¢�¥]��«�¬��c�ª�c¥`�'�b­"¢� `¥`¤]�U£s��¢�¥H®��g��¥�£s��¯n°±¬C²�³{´¶µ�³�µ�³�³A��¥`¤H¯A°±¬²�²·´¹¸�º{¸�»�¼�½�U¥]¤}¾%�s¿8¨�Àb�c���c�U�s�g�[ÁbÂH�c�j®U�g��¥�£b¯%¾:¾:ÃnÄUÅ�´¶²�Æ{´sº?´ÇÄQºcÄ�Æ�È���`���j¿C��¥� ]���?�s�ª¡`£j�����A¡`�s�'¡"�U�s�'¤± ]���ª¥`®É�'¢�¿+¡] Q£s�'�jÊ��U�c�ª«��ª£s�ª�c�A�� Q¡`¡�¢U��£s�c¤±��¥Ë¡"�U��£A¦�¨[£s�`�C©n�U£s��¢�¥"�U«�¬��'���'¥`�c�­]¢� `¥`¤"�{£s��¢�¥�®U�g��¥�£s�)¯A°±¬Ì¼�²{´ÇÄ�Æ�µ�²�µÍ��¥`¤1¯n°Ì¬�¼�¸c´ÇÄ�»�²UÅ�µÉ�c���{�s¤]�'¤1£s¢É£s�`��¯n�'¡"�U��£s¿+�c¥�£)¢�Ê:¬�£g�U£s���Σs�ª�c�)�U£���`�AÏ:¥]�ÑÐ��?�s���ª£¶¨�¢�ʧÒ��`���c��®�¢Q½"��¥`¤}¦�¨}���]�AÏ:¥`�ªÐ��?�s���ª£¶¨�¢�ʧÒ��]�ª�·�U®�¢CÓ�«ª¢��gÔ�­" `¥`¤�ÈÕ�Ö�×ËØ�ÙQØUÚ[ÛnÖ�Ü'Ý�Þ}ß�à5Ýâáqã"Ü?ß�ÞUØUÞ�äLå ¥`�'¢�¿+¡]«��?£s�c¥`�'���'½�¬�£g�U£s���Σs�ª�·�U«N `¥`�c�?��£g����¥�£¶¨�½`æç��«� `�8�U£I�s�ª�ÎÔ�Èè8é àqàqê�àë[ã�Øcß`Ý�ä Ò�¢�¥`���?��Ð��{£s�ªÐ��A¤`�c«Ñ£g�+�`�c¤`®��ª¥]®QÈ

Page 2: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

������������ ���������������� ���������������

"!

#%$'&)(+*-,�.�/10�2�/",�.�3546ji�S�k)\�dml]SUXce-dmY ! ^`_b9niNdfh�V�o`^

ì}í5îUï�ð5ñ§òWï

=�YÍdfeÍhU^`ZÍZ[^`\óY'^ôiqV�l`S�dt\]Y'SUX?lQV�r8TNX?S�õ�dfh{Y?dt^`\Ne[_�^`XÉl]^Qr�V�Y'dtrtdmY?dtS�eÌV�\Nõö^QY'i�S�X

÷ yqV�\]Y'dmY'dtS�e)o`^�l`S�X?\Ndt\�oÌe-S�h{yNX?dmY'dtS�e)T�X'dfh{S�eUKj6Ai�S�T�yNX?T�^`e?S�^`_�Y'i�dfe>TWV�T�S�X)dfe8Y?^[TNX?^�øl�dfõ�SùV�\úSUû�VQh{Y±Z[SUY?iN^õú_�^`X±hU^`\]l]SUX?Y?dt\Noöe-yNhciúdt\"Y?S�X-l`V�rfeÌdt\]Y'^öV�X dmY?XcV�o`S VQe-S�õTNX?dfh{S�e)^`_IüN\WV�\qh{d�V�rIõ�S�X?dml`V�Y'dml]S�eC^QX+dt\qõ�yNegY'X?d�V�r�^QXCh{^`\"Y?XcVQh{Y?yWV�r�^QT�Y?dt^`\qeUK>ýES}h�V�rtrY'i�dfe:T�X'^hUS�õ�yNX?SÉþ Ö�àNÞUØUÜ·ÿ�ß��¶ê�ÿQØHÝ]Ø����Îß�ã�ØcÝ�ë�ê�àë K%6AiNS>TNX?^QT�^]e-S�õ±V�TNT�X?^"VQh'i��>dtrtrWT�SUX-øZ[dmYjV�\Ìdt\NegY'dmY'y�Y'dt^Q\��ÑeAZËV�\WV�o`SUZ[S�\]Y8V�oQX?S�V�Y?S�X:^�l]SUX'e?dtoQi"Yj^Q_�dmYcenS{û�TW^]e-yNX?S)Y'^�X'dfeWK

�����`�����s�c���c�U�s�g���������� Q¡`¡�¢U��£s�c¤��ª¥�¡"�U��£�¦�¨�©n�U£s�ª¢�¥]��«q¬��'���'¥]�'�n­]¢� `¥`¤]�U£s��¢�¥�®U�g��¥�£I¯n°Ì¬â²�³{´¶µ�³�µ�³�³>��¥`¤�¯A°±¬²�²·´¹¸�º{¸�»�¼�½�U¥]¤}¾%�s¿8¨�Àb�c���c�U�s�g�[ÁbÂH�c�j®U�g��¥�£b¯%¾:¾:ÃnÄUÅ�´¶²�Æ{´sº?´ÇÄQºcÄ�Æ�È���`���j¿C��¥� ]���?�s�ª¡`£j�����A¡`�s�'¡"�U�s�'¤± ]���ª¥`®É�'¢�¿+¡] Q£s�'�jÊ��U�c�ª«��ª£s�ª�c�A�� Q¡`¡�¢U��£s�c¤±��¥Ë¡"�U��£A¦�¨[£s�`�C©n�U£s��¢�¥"�U«�¬��'���'¥`�c�­]¢� `¥`¤"�{£s��¢�¥�®U�g��¥�£s�)¯A°±¬Ì¼�²{´ÇÄ�Æ�µ�²�µÍ��¥`¤1¯n°Ì¬�¼�¸c´ÇÄ�»�²UÅ�µÉ�c���{�s¤]�'¤1£s¢É£s�`��¯n�'¡"�U��£s¿+�c¥�£)¢�Ê:¬�£g�U£s���Σs�ª�c�)�U£���`�AÏ:¥]�ÑÐ��?�s���ª£¶¨�¢�ʧÒ��`���c��®�¢Q½"��¥`¤}¦�¨}���]�AÏ:¥`�ªÐ��?�s���ª£¶¨�¢�ʧÒ��]�ª�·�U®�¢CÓ�«ª¢��gÔ�­" `¥`¤�ÈÕ�Ö�×ËØ�ÙQØUÚ[ÛnÖ�Ü'Ý�Þ}ß�à5Ýâáqã"Ü?ß�ÞUØUÞ�äLå ¥`�'¢�¿+¡]«��?£s�c¥`�'���'½�¬�£g�U£s���Σs�ª�·�U«N `¥`�c�?��£g����¥�£¶¨�½`æç��«� `�8�U£I�s�ª�ÎÔ�Èè8é àqàqê�àë[ã�Øcß`Ý�ä Ò�¢�¥`���?��Ð��{£s�ªÐ��A¤`�c«Ñ£g�+�`�c¤`®��ª¥]®QÈ

Page 3: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

��� �� �5����ç�����Q������� K ;>^�� e-iN^QyNrfõô^Q\NSÍi�S�õ�o`S±V�\ô^`T�Y'dt^Q\��>iNS�\ùY?iNS�X?SÉdfeâyN\NhUS�X-YcV�dt\"Y ! V ^`y�Y�Y?iNS

TNX?^ V dtrtdmY ! õ�dfegY?X'd y�Y?dt^`\}o`^�l]S�X?\�dt\No)Y?iNS%y�\qõ�S�X?r ! dt\�oHe-S�hUyNX?dmY !�� @)TWV�X-Y�_�X?^`Z Y'i�S:TW^]e?e-d dtrtdmY ! ^Q_�e-y e-YcV�\]Y'd�V�r� y�Z[Tqe�dt\ÉTNX?dfhUS�eUp`Y?iNdfeIdfeITWS�X?iWV�Tqe�Y'i�SjZ[^]egYIZ±V � ^`X�dfe?e?y�S8_ÇVQhUdt\�oâdt\Ne-Y?dmY'y�Y'dt^`\NebY?iWV�Y:e-S�rtrNV�\NõÉiNS�õ�oQS8^`T�Y'dt^Q\qeUK

=�YAe-iN^`y�rfõ S)S�Z[T�iWV�e?d��US�õ±X?dto`i"YjV��8V ! Y?iWV�Y:Y'i�S�X?SHV�X?S`p"dt\Ì_ÇVQh·Y�pY��j^}e-yNhci ÷ y�S�egY'dt^Q\qeUKAay�TNTW^]e-S+Y'iqV�Y� dfebY'i�S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY ! õ�dfegY'X?d y�Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_�Y?iNS>yN\Nõ�S�X?r ! dt\NoLe-S�hUy�X?dmY'dtS�eUK:GC\�S+h�V�\Ë\�^�� õ�dmldfõ�S>Y'iNS>TNX?^ rtS�Zdt\"Y?^��� ê! Y'iNS#"-T�X'^ V dtrtdfegY'dfh�T�X'^ rtSUZ�$%�&� dfe�ü�ûS�õ V�\qõ'\�^��>\§p y�Y�Y'iNS#"-X?dfeú\�S�y�Y?XcV�rHTNX?^ V dtrtdmY ! $(�*)+ ;+V�X'X?dfe-^`\ÍV�\Nõ-,CX'SUTqe + |�~]w�~/.cp;+V�X'X?dfe-^`\[V�\qõÉFbrtdfe10V + |�~32�|�.·p]RCS�r V�S�\[V�\qõ[a�h'iWV�hciNSUX?Z±V ! S�X + |�~`~�MNpW|�~`~]O�.4.dfe8yN\�"\N^5�)\165V�\qõ� ê�ê7 Y'i�S8"?egY·V�Y'dfegY'dfh�V�rçTNX?^ rtS�Z�$9�:� dfe>\�^QY;\�^��>\§K

6AiNS y�r�Í^`_5SUûdfegY'dt\No�rtdmY'SUX·V�Y'y�X'S)_�^�h{yqe-S�e%^`\[Y'i�S+h�VQe-S � ê! KI@ X'^]VQõ�S�Xn_�^`X?ZLy�r�V�Y'dt^Q\Ë^`_�Y'i�dfe:TNX?^ rtS�Zdfe�Y'^�e'V ! Y'iWV�YbY?iNS�X?S8dfebe-^`Z[Sj_�^`X?Z ^`_�dt\NhU^QZ[TNrtS{Y'S�\�S�e?e%^`XI^QY?iNS�X V�X?X?dtS�XIY?^âT�SUX?_�S�h·Y%i�S�õ�oQdt\No�K:6AiNdfebyNe-yWV�rtr !dfe>Y?iNS�e'V�Z[S}V�e)e'V ! dt\�oËY?iWV�Y<� ) dfe)y�\�"\N^��>\ + Y'i�^`y�o`i�e-SUS`pqdt\ TWV�X-Y?dfhUyNr�V�X�p5RCS�r V�SU\ùV�\Nõ�a�h'iWVQh'iNSUX'ZËV ! SUX+ |�~`~�MNp�|�~`~`O3..·K8a"Y?X·V�Y'SUo`dtS�e>dt\ e-yNhci hUdtX'h{yNZËegY·V�\qh{S�e>dt\qh{rtyqõ�SLe-yNTWS�X)iNS�õ�oQdt\No + dt\qh{rtyqõ�dt\�o�9:l�dmYcV�\Nd>=h + |�~`~323.·p9:l�dmYcV�\Nd>=h V�\qõ?,âV�X·V�Y@��VQe + |�~Q~/A"p[|�~Q~`v3.·p}9:ldmY·V�\�d>=hQp�FIiWV�Z V�\Nõ 6ç^Qy���d + |�~`~`wpÍ|�~`~Q~/.cp�7IrB,âV�X'^QyNd}V�\qõC yNSU\NS�� + |�~Q~]O�.·p�7 SUX'rtSUdt\�V�\Nõ x"V�hU^õ + |�~`~]w�.·p�,âV�XcV�Y4��V�e + |�~`~QP/.cpD,âV�XcV�Y4��VQe>V�\qõE,H^Qy + |�~`~QP�p�|�~`~323.·p�V�\qõ,CXcV�ZFQ^�l + |�~`~QP/..·p]Z[S�V�\}lQV�X?d�V�\NhUSjiNS�õ�o`dt\�o +HGJI^`rtrtZÍS�X%V�\Nõ[a�h'iK�AS�d��US�X + |�~Q~�|�.cp GLI^QrtrtZ[S�X%V�\qõ[a^Q\qõ�S�X?Z±V�\�\+ |�~32QP/.·p"ahci/�jSUd���SUX + |�~`~Qu�pN|�~`~�|�pq|�~`~/A"pN|�~Q~`v�pN|�~`~�MM.·p]V�\Nõ}r�V�Y'SUXbV�rfe-^CRCS�r V�S�\ÉV�\qõÉa�hciqVQh'iNS�X?Z±V ! SUX + |�~`~`P3.·pRCS�r V�SU\§pON ^Q\WV�Y�p%ahciWV�hci�S�X?Z±V ! S�X�p%ahciK�ASUd���S�XÉV�\qõóa"Y?X?dfhP`SUX + |�~`~`w3.cpbB�V�yNX?S�\]YÉV�\Nõ FbiqV�Z + |�~`~`~3.·pbV�\qõFIiWV�Z1p>D8i�S�dt\Nr IV�\qõ�S�X�pCV�\qõ a�hci/�AS�d���SUX + |�~Q~323.4. ÷ yWV�\"Y'dtrtS�e-Y ! rtS i�S�õ�oQdt\No + e-S�S`pjdt\ TWV�X?Y?dfhUy�r�V�X�pQ, Iy�rtrfõ�^QX@R+ |�~`~Qv/.·p"9:ldmY·V�\�d>=h + |�~`~�2/.·p"9:ldmY·V�\�d>=h8V�\qõÉaT�dml`VS + |�~`~323.·p]V�\qõ GLI^QrtrtZ[S�XIV�\qõLB§SUy�QS�X-Y + |�~Q~32pN|�~`~Q~/..·Kb6AiNSUX?Sdfe>V�rfe-^T�A^`X4[^`\�iNS�õ�oQdt\NoÍdt\ V�õNõ�dmY?dt^`\qV�rçZ±V�X4`SUYAY'XcV�õ�S�õ�e-S�hUyNX?dmY?dtS�eUp%�)i�dfhci1h�V�\ Sâõ�^Q\NS`p�_�^QXjSUûNV�Z[TNrtSQpNdt\Y'i�S)TNX?S�e-SU\qhUS)^`_çV�egY'^hciqVQegY'dfh)l`^`r�V�Y'dtrtdmY ! Z[^õ�S�r + e-SUS`p Ø�UªëKUWV V�rtr5V�\NõÌDj^`Z±V + |�~`~�MM.cpN;>^�R5ZËV�\§p�Fbr�V�Y'SU\1V�\qõa�h'iK�AS�d��US�X + |�~Q~/A�.·pW;>y�rtrçV�\qõ±ý i�dmY'S + |�~32`w3.·pqFIiWV�Z V�\qõ16ç^`y%��d + |�~Q~`P3.·pqV�\Nõ1D8SU\WV�yNrmY+V�\qõ16ç^`y%��d + |�~`~`P3.X6e-S�S�V�rfe-^ËRCy�YÍS + |�~`~`P3.·p59niqV�T�Y?S�XZ2�KÑ;<.cp

=s\ÌY?iNdfeATWV�TWS�X�pNi�^��ASUl`S�X�p9�ASâe-iWV�rtr§hU^Q\N_�X?^Q\"Y ÷ y�S�egY'dt^Q\ � ê�ê! �[�>iqV�Y>e-iN^QyNrfõ�^`\�Sâõ�^T�>i�S�\ÌY'i�SHTNX?^ V�ø dtrtdmY ! õ�dfe-Y?X?d y�Y?dt^`\8� ^`_�Y'iNSCyN\Nõ�SUX'r ! dt\No[e-S�h{yNX?dmY'dtS�ejdfeAyN\%\�^��>\§KAa"T�S�hUdtüqh�V�rtr ! pWe-yNTNTW^]e-SH^`\�SHiqVQe8V}e-SUYL\^`_Ie-yqh'i T�X'^ V dtrtdmY ! õ�dfegY'X?d y�Y'dt^Q\qeUKj=ge8Y?iNS�X?S}V]�8V ! ^`_�iNS�õ�o`dt\�o�VÉo`dml`S�\ ^`T�Y'dt^Q\�e-^[Y?iWV�Y)Y?iNS�e-Y?XcV�Y'SUo ! V�Y

Page 4: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

^rtS�V�egYHüN\qV�\qh{S�e)Y'i�SLTqV ! ^3R�\N^±Z±V�Y-Y'SUXZ�>iqV�Y+Y'i�SLT�X?^ V dtrtdmY ! � dfeCdt\_\ � =�\ ^QY'i�S�XZ�A^QXcõ�eUp5iN^5� h�V�\�^Q\NShU^Q\"l`S�X-YQ\ dt\]Y'^±VLX?S�T�rtdfh�V�Y?dt\No±e-Y?XcV�Y'SUo !��

ýES8e-iWV�rtrqe-iN^5� Y'iWV�Y:e-yqh'i[e-Y?XcV�Y'SUo`dtS�ebS{û�dfegY�pV�\NõLY'iWV�YbY?iNS8oQS�\�S�XcV�r�_�^`X?Z dfe%e-dtZ[dtr�V�XIY'^HY?iWV�Y%^ Y·V�dt\NS�õ_�^QX8e-yNT�SUX8i�S�õ�oQdt\NoÍ_�^QXjo`dml`S�\8� + a"S�h{Y?dt^`\Ne)v�pqOLV�\Nõ1P/.·KIýESâV�rfe-^Íe-iN^5� Y?iWV�YjY?iNSH_�^`X?Z ^`_�e-yqhci1egY'XcV�Y?S�o`dtS�eh�V�\ SLe-yNX?T�X'dfe-dt\�o`r ! e-dtZ[TNrtSQpçV�\qõ8�AS}TNX?^�l�dfõ�SLSUûTNX?S�e?e-dt^`\NeC_�^QXâ7by�X?^`T�S�V�\�^QT�Y?dt^`\qeZ�>dmY'iùh{^`\"l`SUû TqV ! ^3R5e+ a"S�h·Y'dt^`\Ne`AËV�\Nõ MM.cKâ6AiNSLX?SUr�V�Y'dt^Q\qe-iNdtT�Y'^ËY'i�SÉe-yNTWS�XCiNS�õ�o`dt\�o�rtdmY'S�XcV�Y'yNX?SÉhUdmY?S�õùV ^�l`SÉdfeCõ�dfe?h{yqe?e-S�õ � yNegYV�_�Y'SUX+6AiNS�^QX?S�Z vK�|QK

@ ZËV�dt\óhU^Q\"Y'X?d y�Y'dt^Q\ö^Q_j^`y�XLX?S�e?y�rmYce}dfe�Y?^ TNX?^�l�dfõ�S�Va�>V ! ^Q_8TNy�Y?Y?dt\NoôV�\ dt\"Y?S�X-l`V�rnX'SUTNX?S�e-SU\"Y'dt\�oyN\NhUSUX?YcV�dt\]Y ! V�X?^`yN\NõâY'i�Sbl`V�rtyNSn^Q_NV�\�dt\qegY?dmY'y�Y?dt^`\1�Ñe�TW^`X-Y'_�^`rtdt^NKI6ji�S:r�V�hPC^`_�e-yNhci�dt\"Y?S�X-l`V�rfeb�A^`y�rfõ}V�T�T�S�V�X�Y?^ SHV�e?SUX?dt^`yqe:TNX?^ rtS�Z�p�dt\ËY?iWV�YAdmYnX'S�õ�yNhUS�e%Y'iNS+ScR5S�h{Y?dml]S�\�S�e?en^`_§ZËV�\WV�o`SUZ[S�\]YA^�l`S�X'e-dto`i]Y>V�\Nõ±oQ^�l`S�X?\NZ[SU\"YX?S�oQyNr�V�Y?dt^`\�K�ayNhci�dfe'e-y�S�e}e-SUS�Z Y'^�iWV�l`S S�SU\óV�ZËV � ^QX�_¶V�h{Y?^`X SUiNdt\Nõ V1\"yNZ S�X�^`_AX?S�h{S�\]Y'r ! X'SUT�^QX?Y?S�õe-y e-YcV�\]Y'd�V�r�rt^]e?e-S�e�dt\"l]^Qrml�dt\�o�õ�SUX'dmlQV�Y?dml]S>e-S�hUyNX?dmY?dtS�eUK%;>S�VQõ�rtdt\�SUø¹o`XcV � dt\No�h�V�e-S�eIdt\NhUrtyNõ�SjY?iN^`e?Sj^Q_NY'i�S V V�\%^`_:6ç^3 ! ^�ødN�dmYce-y dfe-iNd + e-S�S`p�_�^`X+S{ûNV�ZÍTNrtS`p§V�X-Y?dfhUrtSe" V V�\�1^`_:6ç^3 ! ^ r�V�Z[S�e+rt^]e?e+^Q\ V�õ Z[^õ�S�rf$Ëdt\hg ã�Øi ß��j��ÕD�ÇÜ'ØcØ��lk%U p9N V�X'h'imA�2p�|�~`~]w"pT�K"@Cv3.·p<CV�Y'dt^Q\WV�rNýES�e-Y?Z[dt\qegY?S�X V V�\� + g ã�Ø]n é ß�Ü?Ý�ê¹ß�à p@+T�X�KWAQvp�|�~`~`wpaS�h{Y�KE|ËT�KoA�MM.cp%V�\qõ�Y'i�S�k>\Ndt^Q\ V V�\%ô^`_)aK�>dmY4��S�X?r�V�\qõ + e?SUSpg ã�ØFq þ Ö�à�Ö�×Éê�ÞX� pbx]V�\óv�|�p8|�~`~32pITNT�KE|52pV�\Nõów`O�øgw`w"p�dt\qhUrtyNõ�dt\�oôV�X-Y'dfh{rtSr" V rtdt\qõE_¶V�dmY'i�$K.·K1GC\ôY'^QTE^Q_AY?iWV�Y�p�Y'i�S�X?S[dfe�Y?iNS[X?^^`Zs�>i�dfhci�Y'i�SËr�V�hPù^Q_^�l`S�X'e-dto`i]Y+oQdml]S�ejY'^[egY'XcV�dto`i"Y?_�^QX4�8V�Xcõ1_�XcV�yqõ�K

@)\[VQe-T�S�h{Yb^`_NY'iNdfeIT�X'^ rtSUZ dfe�Y?iWV�Y:V�h�h{^`yN\]Y'dt\�o�X?yNrtS�e�Y'SU\qõLY?^CY'X ! Y'^HZ±V�X@âY'i�SjT�^QX?Y?_�^Qrtdt^âY?^HZËV�X4`S{YVQe�ZLyqh'i V�e}T�^`e?e?d rtS`K G ^`XLdtrtrtd ÷ yNdfõódt\qegY'X?yNZÍS�\"Y'eUpbY?iNdfeLe-^`Z[S{Y'dtZ[S�e}dt\"l`^`rml]S�eLyqe-dt\No�TNX?dfh{S�eÉV�X?dfe-dt\No�_�X?^`ZX?S�TW^`X-Y'S�õËY?XcV�\qe'V�h{Y'dt^Q\qet�>iNS�X?S)Y'i�S+T�X'dfh{S+dfe ÷ y�dmY'SZ�>X?^`\�oNKna"^`Z[S ^õ ! iqVQõÌV VQõ±õqV ! K:<>^Q\NSUY?iNSUrtS�e?eUpNe?yNhciV�TNX?dfhUS1dfeÍ_�^QXch{S�õö^`\ ^�Y'iNSUX'eÍ_�^QX±V�h�h{^`yN\]Y'dt\�oETNyNX?TW^]e-S�eUK 6AiNS1Z[SUY?iN^õ�^`rt^Qo ! õ�SUl]SUrt^`TWS�õ dt\öY'i�dfe[TqV�T�SUXTNX?^�l�dfõ�S�e+V�\ V�rmY'SUX'\qV�Y?dml]S�dt\1Y'i�dfe>X'S�e-T�S�h·Y�K

FIX'S{l�dt^Qyqe8rtdmY'S�XcV�Y'yNX?S�^Q\�Y'iNdfe>e-y � S�h·Y)iWV�e8rt^^�`S�õ V�Y8Y'i�S�h�VQe-S<�>iNSUX'Su\ dfejY?iNS�e-SUY>^`_�V�rtrçõ�d�R�yqe-dt^Q\qe_�^QXQ�>iNdfh'i Y'i�S�l`^`r�V�Y?dtrtdmY ! _ÇV�rtrfeQ�>dmY'i�dt\ôVËh{S�X-Y·V�dt\ dt\"Y'SUX-l`V�rIV�YâV�rtrçY'dtZ[S�e;v{K + @)l`S�rtr�V�\NS�õNV�pçB�SUl ! V�\qõ�F�V�XcVQe+ |�~`~`O3.·p%V�\qõ B ! ^`\qe + |�~Q~]O�.·pIhU_sK 7�ûNV�Z[TNrtS±M dt\ aS�h{Y'dt^Q\öv�^`_AY?iNdfe}TqV�TWS�X�6%e?SUS�V�rfe?^ V S�X?o`ZËV�\§pOwCX?yN\qõ !V�\Nõ�ý dtSU\NSUX + |�~`~QP/.·p�7IrW,âV�X?^`y�d¶p�xQS�V�\ r�V�\qh·øsFIdfh ÷ yL=SÌV�\NõEa"iNX?SUl`S + |�~Q~323.·p�V�\qõô;>^ e?^Q\ + |�~`~�2/.cp§Y'i�^`yNoQiY'i�SËdt\"Y?S�\"YL^Q_AY'iNS�e-SËTWV�TWS�X'eLV�T�T�S�V�X'e}ZÍ^`X?S[Y?^ SÌV ^Qy�Y}X'^ yNe-Y?\NS�e'e�Y?iWV�\óV ^`y�YLT�X'S�õ�dfh·Y'dt^`\ X'SUo`dt^Q\qeP.·KýESÉe-iqV�rtrIe?SUS}Y'iqV�YCY'i�SLZ[^`X?SLoQS�\�S�XcV�rIh{^`\Ne-Y?X?yqh{Y?dt^`\ùTNX?^�ldfõ�S�õ�dt\ Y'i�dfeHTqV�T�SUXâh�V�\�TNX?^�ldfõ�SÍe-y egY·V�\]Y'd�V�rtr !rt^��ASUX}e-YcV�X-Y'dt\�o lQV�rtyNS�e�_�^`X�iNS�õ�oQdt\No�egY'XcV�Y?S�o`dtS�eUK1@)TWV�X-Y}_�X'^QZ Y?iNdfe�rtdmY'S�XcV�Y'yNX?SQpbh{^`\NüNõ�SU\qhUSË^`X�T�X'S�õ�dfh·Y'dt^`\

Page 5: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

xX?S�oQdt^`\qeâe-S�SUZ V�YHY?iNdfeCY'dtZ[S}Y'^�ZËV�dt\Nr ! SÉyNe?S�õ�dt\EV�\�VQõ�iN^hL_¶V�e?i�dt^`\�KÉ6AiNSLlQV�rtyNS{øsV�Y?øÎX?dfe rtdmY'SUX·V�Y'y�X'SÉdfeV�\�SUû�V�Z[T�rtS�^Q_�Y?iNdfe + e?SUS�RCy%Y[S�V�\qõ�F�V�\ + |�~`~]w�.n_�^`X)V}X?SUl�dtS>�y.·Kn<>Sc�z�A^`X4�p�iN^��AS{l]S�X�p "! 9:ldmY·V�\�d>=h}V�\qõ,âV�XcV�Y4��V�e + |�~`~�2/.CV�\qõe,âV�XcV�Y@��V�eâV�\Nõ�{�iWV�^ + |�~`~�2/.)e?SUS�Z Y?^ÌT�^Qdt\"YCY'^��8V�Xcõ�eCTNy�Y?Y'dt\�oÌl`V�rtyNSUø�V�Y-øÎX?dfe ^`\ôVZ[^QX'Sâe-^`rtdfõ1_�^^�Y'dt\�oNK

;>^�� dfe8Y'i�S}e-SUY;\ ^Q_�TNX?^ V dtrtdmY'dtS�e+o`dml`S�\ � =�Y+h�V�\ S}VÍhU^Q\NüNõ�S�\NhUS�^`X V V ! S�e-d�V�\�e-SUY�pq^`X>dmYCh�V�\ S V�e-S�õ}^`\e"gSUû�TWS�X-Y � yqõ�oQS�Z[SU\"Y@$�K�=s_N^`\�SAyqe-S�e�egY·V�Y'dfegY'dfh�V�r�Z[SUY?iN^�õ�eUpQY'i�S�X?SAdfeIV)e?y egY·V�\"Y?d�V�r�rtdmY'SUXcV�Y'y�X?Sj^Q\Ldt\�ø_�SUX?S�\qh{S+_�^`XnegY'^hciWV�egY'dfhCõ�d�R5SUX?S�\"Y?d�V�rWS ÷ yqV�Y?dt^`\qendt\±üN\qV�\qh{S`K%;)dtoQiNrtdtoQi"YceAdt\NhUrtyNõ�SH@ I dmY?øsa�V�iWV�rtd�V + |�~`~QP�p�|�~`~323.·p@)\qõ�S�X'e-S�\ V�\Nõ B�yN\Nõ + |�~`~]w�.·p V V�\Nõ�d + |�~`~�2/.cp V V�\Nõ�d8V�\qõ FIiNdtrtrtdtTNe + |�~`~�2/.·p V V�X?\qõ�^`X4RWøs<>dtS�rfe-S�\ + |�~`~]w�.·pV V�X?\qõ�^`X4RWøs<>dtS�rfe-S�\ V�\Nõ aiNSUTNiqV�X'õ + |�~Q~32/.cp V d � "! V�\Nõ aM|QX?S�\Ne-S�\ + |�~`~`Op±|�~`~`PQV�p±|�~`~QP .·pLRâVQh'iyN\qV�ø9jVQegY'SUrtrtS�V�\qõ G rt^QX'SU\qegø}{�Z[dtX?^Qy + |�~�2`P3.·pNRâV�\�dtS�rfe?e-^`\ + |�~Q~�MK.·p G rt^`X?S�\Ne-ød{�Z[dtX?^`y + |�~`~Qv/.·p G ^]egY?S�X>V�\Nõ1<>SUrfe?^Q\+ |�~`~QP/.·p�wâV�rtr�V�\"Y + |�~`~`P3.·p�;+V�\qe-S�\�V�\qõ�a�h'iNS�dt\%Z±V�\ + |�~Q~]O�.·p�;+V�\Ne-S�\§p�a�hci�S�dt\%Z±V�\§p�V�\qõô6ç^`y��Ud + |�~`~`P3.·px]VQh ÷ yNdtSUX�p�F�^Qrfe-^`\�V�\qõËD8^`e?e?d + |�~`~�MM.·p9,CS�e?e-rtS�XAV�\NõÌaM|QX?S�\Ne-S�\ + |�~`~�2/.·p9, Iyqhci�rtS�XAV�\qõ±a9|�X?S�\qe-SU\ + |�~Q~323.·p�V�\qõB�^ + |�~�2]w"p:|�~32�2/.·K G ^`XHX?SUr�V�Y'S�õùõ�dfe?hUX?S{Y'SÉY?dtZ[SLTNX?^�h{S�e?e-S�eUpçe?SUS V ^`rtrtSUX'e?rtS{l5p�9niN^`y�V�\qõ�,HX?^Q\NS�X + |�~Q~/A3.)_�^`XV�\1^�l]SUX-l�dtSc� ^`_�@CDj98; V�\qõ8wH@CD89j; Z[^�õ�S�rfeUK

=s\�^QY?iNS�XJ�A^`X'õNeUp�Y?iNdfe8TqV�TWS�X8dmYce-S�rt_�dfej\N^�Y+V ^`y�Y)e-YcV�Y?dfe-Y?dfh�V�rçdt\N_�S�X?S�\NhUS`Kb=s\qegY?S�VQõ5pNdmY>TNX?^�l�dfõ�S�e)VB�8V !^`_�h{^`\"l`S�X-Y'dt\�o[Y?iNS�X?S�e?y�rmYce8^`_�egY·V�Y'dfegY'dfh�V�rçdt\N_�SUX?S�\qh{S�dt\]Y'^ÍY?XcVQõ�dt\�oÌV�rto`^QX'dmY?iNZËeUK

~1 ������������ N�������ô�������� ���������Ç��� K 6AiNSÍV�TNTNX?^]VQhci_�ASÉV�X?o`y�SLdt\�Y?iNdfe+TWV�T�S�XCdfe)Y'iNS}_�^`rtrt^5�>dt\No��Y·VS`S�VôhU^Q\qe-S�X-l`V�Y'dml`SùegYcV V�YËTNX?S�õ�dfh{Y?dt\NoEY'i�S hUy�ZLyNr�V�Y'dml]S�l]^Qr�V�Y'dtrtdmY ! V�\qõ dt\]Y'S�X?S�e-Y±XcV�Y'S`K 6ji�S�\ i�S�õ�oQSVQhUhU^QXcõ�dt\No�Y'^ Y'iNS + V�T�TNX?^�ûdtZ±V�Y?SS.LVQh·Y'yqV�rAl]^Qr�V�Y?dtrtdmY ! V�\qõódt\"Y?S�X?S�egY�Kó6AiNdfeLyqe-S�eÉe-iqV�X?TNr ! Y'iNS��AS�rtrAT�^`e?S�õ_�S�V�Y?yNX?S[^`_A^`y�X}e ! e-Y?S�Z�� Y?iWV�Y}^Q\NS±V�TNT�X?^�û�dtZËV�Y'SUr ! ^ e-S�X-l]S�eâY'i�S±h{yNX?X?S�\"Y�dt\"Y'SUX?S�egY}XcV�Y'S±V�\qõùl]^`r�V�Y'dtrtdmY ! KG+\�Y?iNSn^QY?iNS�X�iWV�\Nõ�pQdmY�o`yqV�X'õNe�V�o"V�dt\qegYIS{û�hUS�e?e?dml`SAX?S�rtd�V�\qhUSA^`\�Y'i�SAdtrtrTW^]e-S�õ}^Q\NSQpQ\qV�Z[SUr ! Y'i�SAhU^QZ[TWV�XcV�Y'dml`Sr�VQh@Ì^`_�"\N^��>rtS�õ�o`SLV ^Qy�Yy�ÉK

6AiNS VQe-dfh}dfõ�S�V-�1V�\Nõ Y?iNS}_¶V�h{Y)Y'iWV�YCdmYy�A^QX@e��1h�V�\ S}dtrtrtyNegY'XcV�Y?S�õ�dt\ Y'i�SLhU^Q\"Y?SUûYC^`_:7IyNX?^QT�S�V�\h�V�rtrç^`T�Y'dt^Q\qeUKja"yNT�T�^]e-S�Y?iWV�Y+VÍegY?^�hP±_�^`rtrt^��)e

�9���r����������� vb��� �d���H�9�_� + AK��|5.V�\NõLTWV ! e�\N^Hõ�dmldfõ�SU\qõNeUp�V�\qõ}Y'iqV�Y�Y'i�S�X?SAdfe%V>X'dfe�_�X?S�Sndt\"Y'SUX?S�egYbXcV�Y'S:� � K V ^QY?iT� � V�\qõ]� � h�V�\ SjegY'^�h'iWV�e-Y?dfhV�\NõLXcV�\qõ�^`Z�KI6ji�S ! p"V�\Nõ ��� pQiWV�l`SAY'^ S8VQõNV�T�Y?S�õ}Y'^He-^`ZÍSjy�\qõ�SUX?r ! dt\Noâü�rmY'XcV�Y?dt^`\§p y�YbdmYIdfe�\N^�Yb\NS�hUS�e?e'V�X !

Page 6: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

�Y'^+e-T�S�h{dt_ ! Y'i�dfe�üNrmY?XcV�Y'dt^Q\L_�y�X-Y'iNSUX�K�ý�SAV�X?S:\N^�YIe'V ! dt\NoNpQ_�^QX�SUû�V�Z[T�rtS`pQi�^��óZ±V�\ ! "g_¶VQh·Y'^QXce4$>Y'i�S�X?S:ZLyNe-Y SQK6AiNdfejdfe8e-dtZ[dtr�V�X8Y?^Íe-T�S�h{dt_ ! dt\No±V]�5øÎü�S�rfõ�_�^QX8^Q\NS3� e8e?TqVQh{S�^Q_�^`y�YchU^QZ[S�ec�bdmY>dfeAY?iNS�X?SQp y�Y8dmY>dfe>V�\�^`\ ! Z[^QyqeUK

�L� ñb�Z���K�&��� 9A^Q\qe-dfõ�SUXCVÍ7by�X'^QT�S�V�\ h�V�rtr1�>dmY'i�e-Y?X?d�`S�T�X'dfh{SB� Y'iWV�Y)TWV ! e8^3RôV�Y8Y'dtZ[Su�âK:B§S{Y� + �[�@ B�P¡ . � �W¢ + � � .�£¤� SUû�T + £   . ¢ + �M¥ . � + AK��A�.

�>iNSUX'S � � � + rt^Qo + ��¦ �o.b�   � ¡W¦ A�. ¦K§ ¡ + AK�ªv3.V�\Nõ � ¥ � � � £ § ¡ KÌ<>^QY'SÍY'iqV�Y�dt_J��V�\Nõ¤���jSUX?S[ü�ûS�õEhU^Q\qegY·V�\"Y'e�p�Y?iNS�\ôY'i�S V r�VQh@"øsa�hci�^`rtS�e-ø�N�S�X-Y'^Q\+ V r�VQh@�V�\qõôa�h'iN^`rtS�e + |�~]w�v/.cpbN SUX-Y'^`\ + |�~`wQv3.4.>TNX?dfhUSL^`_IY'i�SÉ^QT�Y?dt^`\ôV�YCY?dtZ[SBv+V�\NõùegY'^hP�TNX?dfhUS � �A^`y�rfõ S � + ��� � + �'£�v4. � � ¥ + �(£�v@..·K>ýESLV�X?S`p�iN^5�ASUl]SUX�p5TNX?^`TW^]e-dt\NoÌY?^±yNe?S�Y'iNS}_�yN\qh·Y'dt^Q\ + AK�A�.�ø + AKÑv/.8_�^QX+Z[^`X?So`SU\NSUX·V�rçTNy�X?T�^]e-S�e�K

9n^`\Ne?dfõ�S�X8Y'i�S�dt\qegY'X?y�Z[S�\]Y;�>iN^]e-SâlQV�rty�SLV�Y>Y?dtZ[S<vAdfe¨ �r� � + ����P ;�4�@¡�� . � + AK� MK.

�>iNSUX'S  ;���z Z© £�ª �© �c« �/¬ V�\qõ ¡[�l�#¡[© £�ª�© � ¥« �/¬ � + AK��O�.

=s\ S ÷ yWV�Y?dt^`\ + AKªO3.·p�� � V�\qõ_� � V�X?S�Y?iNSÉV�h{Y?yWV�r�^ e?SUX-l]S�õ ÷ yWV�\]Y'dmY?dtS�eUKC@+e)ZÍS�\"Y?dt^`\�S�õ�V ^�l]SQp�Y'i�S ! h�V�\ SegY'^hciWV�egY'dfh�V�\qõ�X·V�\qõ�^`Z�K

<>^�� e-y�TNT�^`e-S�Y?iWV�Y

 Q©<­(ªr®© �c« �/¬ V�\Nõ ¡[©<­(ªr®© � ¥« �/¬ � + AK�ªP3.V ! yNe?dt\�oË=�Y°¯^��Ñe8_�^QX?ZLyNr�Vp��AS�e-iWV�rtr�e-S�SâY?iWV�Y+\�^ËZ±V�Y?Y?S�X>i�^��?� � V�\qõE� � VQh{Y?yWV�rtr ! ^�Y'i�S�X�>dfe?S SUiWVUl]S + V�\qõ�>iNS{Y'iNSUX%Y?iNS ! V�X'S8XcV�\Nõ�^QZ ^`X%\N^`\�XcV�\qõ�^`Zm.cp]Y'i�S�X?S>dfe:Vâe-S�rt_5ü�\WV�\NhUdt\�oLegY'XcV�Y?S�o ! _�^`XJ¨ � p VQe-S�õÍ^`\[i�S�õ�o`dt\Nodt\1Y?iNS�e-S�h{yNX?dmY !E�D� V�\qõ1ZÍ^`\NS ! Z±V�X@QSUY ^`\Nõ

± � � S{û�T_²�ª �© � « �/¬�³ � + AK��w�.6AiNSâX?S�V�e?^Q\´�>i ! ¨ � dfe)e-SUrt_�üN\qV�\qh{dt\No�pWdfejY'iqV�Y

|A �Lµ/µ � ¥ � �J¶ V�\qõ·£ �:¸ � � £ �Lµ � � + AK�!23.

Page 7: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

¹6AiNdfe)h�V�\ S�^ Y·V�dt\NS�õ õ�dtX?S�h{Y'r !1 ]! õ�d�R�S�X?S�\]Y'd�V�Y?dt\No + AK!A3.cKn@+rfe-^�pqY?iNS�üNX'egY)^Q_�Y'i�S�Y��A^[S ÷ yWV�Y?dt^`\Ne+dt\ + A"K!23.dfe:Y'iNSZ�AS�rtr�"\N^5�)\ÌX?S�r�V�Y'dt^`\Ne-iNdtT S{Yd�AS�SU\±Y'i�S´"go"V�ZÍZ±V�$LV�\Nõ±Y?iNSa"gl`S�o"V°$ + hU_�Kfp�_�^`XAS{ûNV�ZÍTNrtS`pW9niqV�T�Y?S�XH|UM^`_I;>yNrtr + |�~Q~]w�.4.·K

;>S�\NhUS`p "! =�Y°¯^��Ñe>B§SUZ[Z±V�p � ¨ � S ÷ yqV�rfec�� � + � � �P¡ � �P  �d. � �Jµ �9� �D� |A �Lµ/µ � ¥� � ¥� � vb� �J¶ �M¡ ��� �J¸ �M  �� �Jµ �9� �D� + � £ �Jµ � ��.d�c� � v

�#º |A � µ3µ � ¥� £ � ¶9» � ¥� � v@��#º � £ � µ ��� £ � ¸�» � ��� vX� + AK�ª~3.=s\öl�dtSc� ^Q_ + A"K!23.·pnY?iNS�r�VQegYËY��A^�rtdt\NS�eË^`_ + AKÑ~/.}lQV�\�dfe?i�p>V�\Nõ i�S�\qh{S�Y?iNSUX'S1dfe±Vôe-S�rt_CüN\WV�\qh{dt\No i�S�õ�o`dt\NoegY'XcV�Y?S�o ! _�^QXy¨ � dt\ ��� V�\qõ ± � K:6AiNSE"-õ�S�rmYcV�$ + Y'iNSâ\"yNZ S�X>^Q_IegY?^�hPe>i�S�rfõ�.jdfe �<¼µ + ���4�@ Q��P¡�� .·K

G yNX-Y'i�S�X?Z[^`X?SQpqe-dt\qh{S � + ���P¡J�@  .Adfejdt\qhUX?S�VQe-dt\NoËdt\ ¡ V�\qõ   p + AKÑP/. ! dtSUrfõNe>Y?iWV�Y¨ ® � � + � ® �P¡ ® �P  ® .­ rtdtZ¶�½ ©X¾ ¸�½ © � + � ® �P¡J�P  .� + � ® £¤�e.¿ + AM��|�u/.

V�rtZÍ^]egYHe?y�X?S�r ! K)=�\ ^�Y'iNSUXZ�A^`X'õNeUp�^`\�SLh�V�\ ^QY'i�e ! \]Y'i�SUY'dfh�V�rtr ! hUX?S�V�Y'S�Y?iNSLe-S�h{yNX?dmY ! ¨ � p�V�\qõ ^`\�SÉh�V�\ yqe-SY'i�dfe)e-S�hUyNX?dmY ! Y?^Ëh{^�l`S�X>^Q\NS3� e>^ rtdto]V�Y'dt^Q\qeUK

6AiNS�V ^�l`Sâdfeje?y%Y[hUdtS�\]Y'r ! dt\�\N^hUS�\]Y>rt^^3"dt\NoÉY'iqV�Y8dfe8e-iN^QyNrfõ SHSUZ[TNiqVQe-d���S�õÌY'iqV�Y8dmY8dfej\N^�YjY'X?dml�d�V�r¶K,CS�SUTódt\öZÍdt\qõEY?iWV�YÉdmYÉdfe�Y'X?yNS±_�^`X ß��j� T�X?^ V dtrtdmY ! õ�dfegY'X?d y�Y'dt^`\NeÉyN\qõ�S�X]�>iNdfh'i + AKÑP/.�dfeLe'V�Y'dfe-ü�S�õr�>dmY'iTNX?^ V dtrtdmY ! |QKâýESÍV�o"V�dt\ôS�Z[T�iWVQe-d��USÉY'iqV�YHY?iNdfeHdt\qh{rtyqõ�S�e�egY'^hciWV�egY'dfhLl]^Qr�V�Y'dtrtdmY ! V�\qõùegY'^hciqVQegY'dfhÉdt\"Y?S�X?S�egYXcV�Y?S�eUK

<>^QY?S}Y?iWV�Y�V[rt^QYH^Q_bY?iNdfe+SUû�V�Z[T�rtSÉh�V�X'X?dtS�eC^�l]S�X)Y'^±o`SU\NS�XcV�rb7by�X?^`T�S�V�\�^`T�Y'dt^`\NeUKH=�\�TqV�X-Y'dfh{yNr�V�X�p�_�^`XTWV ! ^�R¤À + � ® .·pN^Q\NS�h�V�\´�>X'dmY?SâY'i�S V r�V�hP"øsa�h'iN^`rtS�egødN�S�X-Y'^Q\ TNX?dfhUS�^Q_�Y'iNSâ^`T�Y?dt^`\ VQe

� + ���P¡J�@  . � SUû�T + £   .}Á]À + � S{û�T +   £ ¡t¦ A��(§ ¡t .4. � + AM��|Q|�.

Page 8: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

Ã�>iNSUX'S  dfeLegY·V�\qõqV�X'õ \N^QX'ZËV�r + e-S�S`pI_�^QXLS{ûNV�Z[TNrtSQpn9ni§KùP�^`_>RCy�YÍS + |�~`~QP/.4.cKù;)SU\qh{S + A"K!2/.â_�^`rtrt^��)e "!õ�d�R�SUX'SU\"Y?d�V�Y'dt^Q\�_�^QX>V�rtrç7by�X?^`T�S�V�\�^`T�Y?dt^`\Ne�K G ^`Xj\N^Q\1h�V�rtr�^`T�Y?dt^`\Ne�pNi�^��ASUl`S�X�p�dmY8Z±V !Ë SCZ[^QX'SHe-yNdmYcV rtSHY?^e-T�S�hUdt_ ! dt\"Y?S�X-l`V�rfe>dt\ VÉõ�d�R�S�X?SU\"Y)Z±V�\N\�S�X8Y?^±V�e?e?y�X?S + A"K�|�u3.·K

k>\NrtS�e'e±Y?iNSùhUy�ZLyNr�V�Y'dml]Sùdt\"Y?S�X?S�egY�dfe1VQh{Y?yWV�rtr ! \�^��>\ SU_�^QX'SUiWV�\qõ�p+i�^��ASUl`S�X�p>Y'i�Sôe?hci�S�Z[S o`dml]SU\V ^�l`S+dfe:\�^QY ÷ yNdmY'S)X?dtoQi"Y�K%6AiNdfe:dfe%dt\[Y'i�S+e?SU\qe-S>Y'iqV�YjVârt^5�jSUX:TNX?dfhUS+h�V�\ËyNe?yqV�rtr !Ë S)_�^QyN\qõ±V�e%Y?iNS+egY·V�X?Y?dt\NoT�^Qdt\"Y)_�^QX+VÉe?SUrt_�üN\WV�\qh{dt\NoÌegY?X·V�Y'SUo ! e'V�Y'dfe-_ ! dt\No + AKf|�u/.cKn6AiNSâ_�^Qrtrt^��>dt\NoËdfe)V�\1SUûNV�Z[TNrtSâ^`_�Y'i�dfe�K

�L� ñb�Z���K�rÄ�� ý iqV�Y>Y'iNS�TNX?^hUS�õ�yNX?S�dt\ 7Iû�V�Z[T�rtS±|�^�l]S�X?rt^"^3�eUpWdfe8Y'iWV�Y)Y?iNS�T�X'dfh{SBÅ © ^`_�Y'iNS*��SUX?^hU^QyNTW^`\ ^`\Nõ�ZËV�Y'y�X?dt\No±V�YQ� dfe+V�h{Y'yqV�rtr ! "\N^��>\ + V�Y)rtS�VQegY)dt\�ZÍ^]egY>Z±V�X4`SUY'eP.·K:6AiNdfe ^`\Nõ e'V�Y'dfe-üNS�e

ÅW� � Á )*Æ S{û�T_²1£ ª ®� � « �/¬�³ÈÇ5É �ËÊ � + AM��|5A3.�>iNSUX'SF�*)�dfeCY'i�SÍX?dfe \NS�y�Y'XcV�rbõ�dfegY'X?d y�Y'dt^Q\§pIV�\Nõ�Y?iNSÍTNX?^�h{S�õ�yNX?ST�jSÉiqV�l`S[oQdml]SU\�dto`\�^`X?S�eHY?iWV�Y�KÉ@ hU^Q\�øe-S ÷ yNS�\NhUSQpI_�^`X�SUû�V�Z[T�rtS`p�dfeâY'iqV�Y}dt_j^`\�SËTNX?dfhUS�eLV�_�^QX4�8V�Xcõ�hU^Q\"Y?X·V�h{Y�Y'iNSËe'V�Z[S-�8V ! p�^Q\NSËoQSUYceâY'i�SËTNX?dfhUS�>X?^`\No�K

=�YZ�)dtrtrIe-^`Z[S{Y'dtZ[S�e S}Y'i�SÉh�V�e-SLY?iWV�Y+Y'iNSLSUûdfegY'S�\NhUSÉ^Q_:e-S�hUy�X?dmY ! Å � �>dtrtrbV�rfe-^�Z±VS`S}rt^��AS�X ^`y�\qõNe_�^QX;�ÍV�\qõE��VQh·Y'dml`S`p�V�\qõ1^Q\NS�h�V�\ h{^`\qe-dfõ�S�X)X?S�T�r�VQhUdt\�o + A"KªP/. ]!

  ¿ ­ ªr®© � « �/¬8­( `Ì V�\Nõ ¡ ¿ ­ ªr®© � ¥« �/¬8­p¡JÌ � + AM��|�v/.ýES}e-iWV�rtr�e-S�S�dt\ôa"S�h{Y?dt^`\�MËiN^5� Y'^±hU^QZ[TNy�Y'S�Y?iNS�l`V�rty�S}^`_�Y'i�SLh�V�rtr�^QT�Y?dt^`\�dt\�Y'iNdfe+h�VQe-SQK8ý�S}e?i�^�� Y'iqV�Ydt_�Í © e-^Qrml]S�e

¢ + � ¥ + � © � Í°© �P¡ ¿Î.. � S{û�T + £   Ì .�£¤Å ©SUû�T + £   Ì .[£ôS{û�T + £   ¿ . � + AM��|{MM.

�>iNSUX'S ¢ dfe%Y?iNS+hUy�ZLyNr�V�Y'dml`SC\�^`X?Z±V�r�õ�dfe-Y?X?d y�Y?dt^`\1V�\NõËdt\ËY?iNS+e'V�ZÍS)\�^QY·V�Y'dt^Q\1VQe%dt\ + AK!A3.H� + A"Kªv3.·p"Y'i�S�\±^Q\NSh�V�\ egY·V�X?Y+VÉe-yNTWS�X-øÎX?S�T�rtdfh�V�Y'dt\No±egY'XcV�Y?S�o ! �)dmY?i1Y'i�S�TNX?dfh{S}V�Y8Y'dtZÍS*�US�X?^Ío`dml`S�\�dt\1Y'i�S�_�^`rtrt^5�)dt\�o��

Í ©<­p  ¿r� � + �D©°�P  ¿ �P¡ ¿Î.  ¿¤ÏÐÍ © Ï  `Ì � � + �D©°� Í ©°�P¡ ¿Î.����ÒѶS{û�T + £�Í © .l£�SUûT + £   ¿Î.Ó ¢ Ñ �M¥ + �D©°� Í ©��@¡ ¿Î.Ó

Í ©<Ôp `Ì � � + �D©°�P `Ì[�P¡ ¿Î.��&�ÕѶSUûT + £  `Ì .�£¤Å © Ó+ AM��|�O3.

@)\1dtrtrtyqegY'XcV�Y?dt^`\ ^`_�Y'i�S�dtZ[TNX?^�l]S�ZÍS�\"Y>^�l]S�X+7�ûNV�ZÍTNrtSË|Hdfe8o`dml]SU\ dt\1üNo`y�X?SË|QK

º üNoQyNX?SâiNSUX'S�6qe?SUSâr�VQegY)TWV�o`S »

Page 9: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

Ö×:ØÚÙ �`���*Û áD�¶ê¶Ö�à�áWÜ·ê þ ØCß�Þ £1rt^Qo + Å © . ÿQß�Ü{ê¶ØUÞ;ÜcØc�¶ÛnØcØ{à   Ì ß�à5Ý   ¿ U g ã"Ü'ØcØ>Û:ß�ÚQÞ)Ö}Ý�áWÜ·ê þ ê�à�ë<q é Ü'Ö·á�Øcß�à þ ß��j�Ö·áD�Çê¹Ö�àNÞâê�àe�Çã�Ø>áWÜ'Ø{ÞUØUà þ ØÉÖ}ÝâÜ?ØUÞX�ÇÜ{ê þ �Çê¹Ö�àNÞ �HÞ UÚß�àX 3U g ã�Ø é á]áNØ{ÜLÝ]ß�Þ'ã�ØcÝ��ªê�à5Ø�ê�ÞBÜcß�ÞUØcÝÌÖ�àe�Çã�Ø�ÞX�ÇÜ'ß���Ø�ë�ÚQÝcÜ'Ö�×qOá"ß�×Cá��fØ´ß5â+ÛIã"êj�fØ���ã�Ø[ã�Øcß�ÿ�êÚ�ªÚùÝ]Ö°�H��ØcÝ8�ªê�à5Ø é ÞUØ{Þ-�Çã�ØËÞX�ÇÜ'ß��ÎØ�ëQÚ`Ý'Ü'Ö�×�qOá"ß�×+áD�tØ Þ U g ã�Ø�ß��ª×[Ö�ÞX�HÝ�ê¹ß�ë"Ö�à�ß���tÖ�ÛnØ{ÜB�ªê�à5Ø�ê�Þ*�Çã�Ø>áD� é ë3ãÎê�à�áWÜ·ê þ Øu� + � © � £1rt^QoJÅt© �@¡ ¿ . U g ã�ØB�fß°�H��Ø{Ü þ ß�àqà5Ö��LÜcØ é ÞUØcÝ�ß�Þ*�Çã�Ø}ÞX�Îß�Ü>�¶ê�àëËÿQß�� é ØÖÝ}ß þ Ö�àNÞUØUÜ·ÿ�ß��¶ê�ÿQØ�ã�ØcÝ�ë�ê�à�ëËÞX�¶Ü'ß��ÎØ�ëQÚSâLÜ é �nê�Þ�ê�à þ � é Ý]ØcÝZÝUÖ�Ü�Ü?ØHÝ{ØUÜ'Ø{à þ Ø5UZä>ß�Ü'ß�×[Ø��ÎØUÜ�ÿ�ß�� é Ø{ÞLß�Ü'Ø ¡ ¿ � u9�ªu�M â  Ì � u9�Ñu�M âAß�à�Ý   ¿ � u9�ªu`w U g ã�ØLÖ·áD�Çê¹Ö�à�ê�Þ�ß��:��ã�Ø�×[Ö�à5Ø{Ú � � �å� © 3U

=s\�Y?iNS�TNX?S�e-S�\NhUS�^`_IZ±V�X@QSUY>Y'XcVQõ�S�õ õ�S�X?dmlQV�Y'dml`S�eUp5^Q\NSLh�V�\ _�yNX-Y?iNS�X X?dt\No±õ�^5�)\�Y'i�SLegY·V�X?Y?dt\No[l`V�rty�S^`_�Y?iNSâY?X·V�õ�dt\�oËegY'XcV�Y?S�o !Ì "! i�S�õ�oQdt\NoËdt\1Y?iNS�e?Sâdt\ VQõ�õ�dmY'dt^Q\�Y'^ÉY'i�S*��SUX?^Ëh{^`y�T�^`\ ^Q\qõ5K

æ1 Tç ������ q�Jè`���"�W�é K9n^`\Ne?dfõ�S�X1V�üNrmY'SUX?S�õúe-TWVQh{S +Hê �}É´�}É�� .d©>ë%�Hë ® p+V�\Nõ VQõqV�T�Y?S�õ hU^`\]Y'dt\"yN^`yNeÌTNX?^�h{S�e?e-S�e �:ì �dí� � �f�f� �X�:ì î í� p

X?S�T�X'S�e-S�\"Y?dt\No�Y'XcVQõ�S�õ[e?S�hUy�X'dmY?dtS�e:TWV ! dt\�o}\N^�õ�dmldfõ�SU\qõNeUKW� � dfenV�\ÌV�õqV�T�Y'S�õËT�X'^hUS�e'e-S�e%X'SUTNX?S�e-SU\"Y'dt\�o�Y?iNS>X'dfe_�X?SUS>dt\]Y'SUX'S�egY:XcV�Y'SQp�V�\qõ ± ��� SUûT�ïSð �© ��« �/¬bñ dfeIY'i�S8l`V�rtyNS+V�YbY'dtZ[SLv�^`_�^Q\NS)õ�^`rtr�V�Xnõ�SUT�^]e-dmY?S�õ[dt\ÍY?iNS8Z[^`\�S !Z±V�X@QSUY)V�Y>Y?dtZ[S�u�KO\ dfe)VÍe-S{Y)^Q_�TNX?^ V dtrtdmY ! õ�dfe-Y?X?d y�Y?dt^`\Ne+^Q\ +Hê �}É .cK

ýES�üN\qõ ^`yNX'e-S�rml`S�e+dt\ Y'i�S}_�^`rtrt^5�>dt\No1e-dmY'yqV�Y'dt^Q\§K+ýESLegY·V�\NõùV�Y)Y'dtZ[S`v � up§V�\Nõ8�AS}iWVUl]S}Y?^±Z±V°QSVÍTWV ! ^�R�ò�V�YHV + \N^`\ XcV�\Nõ�^QZ ^QX+egY'^`T�TNdt\�oM.8Y?dtZ[S`ó§KLò1dfe É�ô øÎZ[S�VQe-yNXcV rtS`KjýES}õ�^Ë\N^QYZ\�^��h�>iWV�Y)Y?iNSTNX?^ V dtrtdmY ! õ�dfegY?X'd y�Y?dt^`\�_�^`XnY'iNdfeje ! e-Y?S�Z dfeUp y�YL�ASy"\N^5� Y'iqV�YjdmY8dfe8V�\�SUrtS�Z[SU\"Yjdt\a\ÍK�ýESâV�X?SCrt^^�dt\No_�^QX>iNS�õ�oQdt\NoËe-Y?XcV�Y'SUo`dtS�e>dt\ � ì �dí� � �f�f� �X� ì î í� � ± � Y'iWV�Y;�>dtrtr�e-yNTWS�X-øÎX?S�T�rtdfh�V�Y'SâY'iNSâTWV ! ^3R_�>dmY'i�T�X'^ V dtrtdmY ! ^`\�S`K

õ ��ö Øj÷1Ø ï ØÚøb÷ � @ TNX?^`TWS�X-Y ! �)dtrtr SCecV�dfõ±Y?^LiN^Qrfõm\У8ù���ú��dt_çdmYAiN^`rfõ�e;��£_ù��!ú3�_�^`X8V�rtr��üûE\ÍK G ^`XV�\ ! TNX?^hUS�e?e�ý � p�ýe)� � ± Ì � ý � p�V�\qõ�ldfhUSâl`S�X'e'V�K

@ TNX?^�h{S�e?ey¨%� � u Ô v Ô �âpqdfe)e'V�dfõ1Y'^ S�V[e-yNTWS�X-øÎX?SUTNrtdfh�V�Y'dt^Q\�^`_�TqV ! ^3ReòÌTNX?^�ldfõ�S�õo¨%�%dfe+VQõNV�T�Y'S�õ5pþ�þß]Ý9� þß�ë p�V�\qõ1T�X?^�l�dfõ�S�õ� ê7 ^`\�S�h�V�\ hU^�l]SUX>^`\�S3�Ñe8^ rtdto"V�Y'dt^`\Nec�

¨ ôÿ­ ò + vM��|5.\å£�ù���ú��f6qV�\Nõ

� ê�ê7 _�^QX)V�rtr��üû´\[p�Y?iNS�X?S�V�X?SâTNX?^hUS�e?e-S�e�� � V�\Nõ�� � pqe?^ÉY?iWV�Y�pq_�^QX)V�rtr�v·p�u Ô v Ô �âp¨ �r� � � ��� �� u Ô v Ô � � + vM��A�.

Page 10: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

��>iNSUX'S��m)� dfeCV[\N^Q\Ndt\NhUX?S�V�e?dt\�o�TNX?^�h{S�e?eUp§V�\NõE�)i�S�X?S�� � dfe+e?SUrt_büN\WV�\qh{dt\NoÌdt\ Y?iNS�Y'XcVQõ�S�õ e-S�hUy�X?dmY'dtS�e�:ì ��í� � �f��� �X�tì î í� K

"ca"S�rt_:ü�\WV�\NhUdt\�o/$1Z[S�V�\Ne�p ]! \y�Z[S�XcV�dtX?SLdt\"lQV�X?d�V�\NhUS + e-S�SQp§_�^`XCSUûNV�Z[TNrtSQp�aS�h·Y'dt^Q\EP�K V ^`_:RCy�YÍS + |�~Q~`P/..·pY'iqV�Y�� )� h�V�\ S>X'SUTNX?S�e-SU\"Y'S�õËVQe:VâegY'^hciqVQegY'dfh>dt\]Y'S�oQXcV�r��)dmY?iËX?S�e?TWS�h·Y%Y'^âY?iNS � ì í )� � eUpe-y � S�h{Y%Y'^�X?S�oQyNr�V�X'dmY !hU^Q\qõ�dmY'dt^`\NenY'^�S�rtdtZ[dt\qV�Y'SCõ�^`y rtdt\�oÍegY'XcV�Y'S�oQdtS�eUK:6Ai�S�X?S+dfene-^`Z[S>lQV�X?d�V�Y?dt^`\Ìdt\ËiN^5� Y?^}dtZ[T�rtS�Z[SU\"Y:Y'iNdfe + e-S�SQpS`K oNKtp�RCy�YÍS + |�~Q~`P/.cpI9niqV�T�Y?S�X}PK�9 + T�K1|�u`v�øc|�u`O3..·K G ^`XHY'i�dfeâX?S�VQe-^Q\§p§Y'iNSÉTNX?S�h{dfe-SËõ�S�ü�\NdmY'dt^Q\Edfe�õ�SU_�SUX'X?S�õyN\]Y'dtr�V�_�Y?S�X8Y?iNS�Z±V�dt\�Y'iNSU^`X?S�Z V�\Nõ�e-^`Z[SâS{ûNV�ZÍTNrtS�e + e-SUSLaS�h{Y'dt^Q\ùO�.·K

ý iqV�Y+e-iN^QyNrfõ1Y'iNS�TNX?dfh{S S�_�^`X+VÉTNX?^`ZÍdfe?Sâ^`_bVÉTWV ! ^3Reò � @ \qV�Y'y�XcV�rçiNS�õ�o`dt\�o V�e-S�õ V�TNT�X?^"VQh'i dfeVQeH_�^`rtrt^��)eUp�h{_sKÍ9:l�dmY·V�\Nd>=hËV�\qõ�,âV�XcV�Y4��V�e + |�~Q~/Ap%|�~`~Qv/.cp�7IrW,âV�X?^`y�d:V�\Nõ C yNSU\NSc� + |�~Q~]O3.cp�V�\Nõ�,HXcV�ZF`^�l+ |�~`~QP/.·K

õ ��ö Øj÷1Ø ï ØÚøb÷ � 6ji�SÍþ Ö�àqÞUØ{Ü{ÿ�ß��Çê�ÿ�Ø�ß�Þ'Ù>áWÜ·ê þ Ø + ^`XA^�R�S�XnTNX?dfhUS�.nV�YnY?dtZ[SHu�_�^`XjV�TWV ! ^3REòÉY'^ S+Z±VQõ�SV�Y+V}Y'dtZÍS*ó1dfe � � dt\�_cï°¨ © � + ¨ � .ndfe)VÍe-yNTWS�X-øÎX?S�T�rtdfh�V�Y'dt^`\ ^`_�Y'i�SâTWV ! ^3R ñ � + vM�ªv3.adtZÍdtr�V�X?r ! p�Y?iNS�þ Ö�àqÞUØUÜ·ÿ�ß��¶ê�ÿQØmÜ{ê¹ÝÍáWÜ·ê þ Ø h�V�\ S[õ�S�ü�\NS�õ VQeHY'iNS[e?y�TNX?S�Z}yNZ ^�l]SUXLV�rtrne-y øÎX?SUTNrtdfh�V�Y'dt^Q\qe}^Q_Y'i�S�TWV ! ^�R�pNdt\1Y?iNS�^ ldt^`yqe)e-SU\qe-S`K

6AiNS�hU^Q\qe-S�X-lQV�Y'dml`S dfõ1T�X?dfhUS � S ÷ yWV�rfe

� + ò�. � £ � + £�ò�. � + vM� MK.dt\ó^ ldt^`yNeÉ\N^�Y·V�Y'dt^`\�pAV�\qõóe-y � S�h·YÉY?^�Z[dtrfõ X'SUo`y�r�V�X?dmY ! h{^`\qõ�dmY'dt^Q\qeUK G ^QXLY?iNdfeLX?S�V�e?^Q\§pbdmYÉdfeLSU\N^`y�o`ióY?^egY'yNõ ! VQeËT�X'dfh{S�eUKtN�^`X?SHoQS�\�S�XcV�rtr ! pqdt_�^Q\NS�V�rtX'S�VQõ ! iWVQe8V}TW^`X-Y'_�^`rtdt^Í^`_ç^`T�Y'dt^Q\qeUpN^Q\NSHZ±V ! �>dfe-iÌY'^ÉhciqV�X?o`S� + TW^`X-Y'_�^`rtdt^ü��ò�.l£ � + T�^QX?Y?_�^Qrtdt^9.n_�^`XjY'iNSâTqV ! ^�Reò�K

6ç^Eo`dml`S Y?iNS oQS�\NSUXcV�r+_�^`X?Z ^Q_CY'i�SùVQeöTNX?dfhUS � pJ�AS h{^`\qe-dfõ�S�X1V�\ V�T�TNX?^`T�X?d�V�Y'S�e?S{Y�\B)Ì^`_´"gX'dfe\NSUy�Y?X·V�rf$[T�X?^ V dtrtdmY ! õ�dfegY?X'd y�Y?dt^`\qey� ) K

õ ��ö Øj÷1Ø ï ØÚøb÷ � aS{Y

� � ï ��� ê ���D�Èû´\��9Á � É � ��� Á V�\Nõ8� + ÁB. � u ñ � + vM��O�.\B)+dfe>\�^�� õ�SUüN\�S�õ VQe8Y?iNS�e-SUY)^Q_IT�X'^ V dtrtdmY ! Z[S�VQe-yNX?S�eZ�*)+^`\ É �>iN^`e-S�\"yNrtr�e-SUY'e>dt\NhUrtyqõ�S�Y'iN^`e-S�dt\ � pV�\Nõ�_�^`Xu�>i�dfhci �:ì �dí )� � �f��� �X�tì î í )� V�X?S[Z±V�X?Y?dt\No]V�rtS�eUK[ýESËV�rfe-^ õ�S�ü�\NS�\��}VQeHY'i�SËe-SUY�^Q_ASUû"Y'X?S�Z±V�rbS�rtS�ZÍS�\"Y'e

Page 11: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

�dt\�\B)�K-����dfeâS{ûY?X'SUZ±V�rIdt\�\])�dt_L���]û�\B)}V�\Nõôdt_�p��>iNSU\NSUl`S�XB��� � ù � ���� �pù ¥ ���¥ _�^QX*ù � � ù ¥ Ï u�V�\qõ� �� � � �¥ û´\ ) pqdmY>ZLyNegY SHY'iNS�h�VQe-SâY?iWV�Yy� � � � �� � � �¥ K

ay � S�h{YCY'^±X'SUo`y�r�V�X?dmY ! hU^Q\qõ�dmY?dt^`\Ne�p1�ASÉe-iWV�rtrbe-i�^�� Y'iWV�YCY'i�S�X?S}dfeâVËe?y�T�SUX?ø¹X?S�TNrtdfh�V�Y?dt\No�egY'XcV�Y?S�o ! ¨ ��>dmY'i�dt\�dmY'd�V�r"lQV�rtyNS � p`V�\qõ�h'iWV�XcV�h{Y'SUX?d���S:Y?iNSne-SUY�^`_�e-yqh'i}e-Y?XcV�Y'SUo`dtS�e�KIk>\qõ�S�Xb�jS�V°�V�õNõ�dmY?dt^`\qV�r�VQe?e-yNZ[T�Y'dt^Q\qeUpdmY;�>dtrtr SâY?iNS�h�VQe-SHY'iqV�Y

� � e-y�T�ï�Á ) + ò ) .J�/� ) �4\ ) ñ/� + vM�ªP3.�>iNSUX'S

ò ) � S{û�T1ï/£_ªr®© � « �/¬bñ òD� + vM��w�.6AiNSâX?S�e-yNrmY + v�KÑP/.Ai�dt\NoQS�e>^`\�Y?iNS�S{û�dfegY'SU\qhUS�^`_�Y?iNS8"gS�e?e-S�\"Y?d�V�r�e-yNTNX?SUZ±V�$

� )� � S�e?e>e-yNT1ïSÁ ) + ò ) Ç�É �d.:�K� ) �\ ) ñ � + vM�!23.+ vK!23.ËZ[S�V�\Ne±Y'iWV�Y � )� dfe + dt\ V e-yNdmY·V rtS�e-S�\Ne?S�.[Y?iNSôe-Z±V�rtrtS�egY1Z[S�V�e-yNXcV rtSùX·V�\qõ�^`Z l`V�X'd�V rtSôe?^ Y'iqV�Y� )� ­ Á]) + ò�) Ç5É�� .A_�^`X+V�rtr��*)QûE\B)�K%@)\�S{ûNVQh·Y+õ�SUüN\�dmY'dt^`\ ^`_�Y'i�dfe>^ � S�h{Y>dfe>oQdml]S�\�dt\1Y?iNS�@)TNTWS�\Nõ�dmû5K%ý�Sh�V�\1Y'i�S�\ egYcV�Y'S

��� � ø ð1�������Ú��� (+*?* ����$H�¶�5$"!¶��,t,��$#b�t3&%('U��3�4`�¶�¹����3N*+��3��¶�5$>*s2N*U�s$c� � + ÉL� .%�f*n&?�)%]�W��'{��3��¶�t3*�]�&�Q*,+ É;©�f*��¹��$â*-�Ì.�,t,�$c*U�L�.-0/�$c,Ç41'U��3��s.��t3N�t3&% � +��¶�5$ � ì í� .�&{$y\?£rù���ú��2'{��3��¶�t3*�]�&�Q*�.�3�41."4�.U���s$�43+I�¹��$â*-�5��&��n&·.�s$��&{�4'U$·*?*J� � �f*>."4�.U���s$�4N��.�354Í�t3��g$5%]&·.N��,�$Q\(£où���ú3�)+�$���$c&g2a�Èû´\ ��.�*).�3 $763���¹�{.�,�$'3��%�Ì.�&��¹�t38%.�,�$>��${.�* ��&{$���¹�W.���f*>�g�H*c.{2��¶��.�:�¶�5$'&U$A�f*A.*� ) ûE\ ) �¶��."���f*>$763���¹�U.�,�$'3��A�s�u�:9�(),f*·��.�*'* ����$C�¶�5$;!¹��,t,��<#b�t38%='U��3�4]�¶�¶����3N*��3ô�¹�5$j��.{2N� >I�%u Ô ó Ô �H�2#b�5$'&U$Q�J�f*835��3N&·.�354���� .�3�4?/N3N�¶�s$���òÌ�f* É�ô -���$U.�* ��&·.N��,�$���.�3�4

e-yNT@2ACBEDFA Á ) Ç ò ) ÇHGJI �K�$L/�35$��¹�5$�!¶��,t,��<#%�t3&%M'U��3�4`�¶�¹����3N* 9�NjÁ �CO �HP��Q!lý �f*).����&��3�4�$�4Ë&·.�354���� �{.�&?��.N��,�$H.�3�41�¹��$c&{$)�f*>.]�`)Qû´\])*·�Ë�¹��."�tÁ ) + ýe.JÏ u�ç�¹��$c3ô�¹��$c&{$)�f*+.T� � ûE\ � *{�Ë�¶��.�tÁ � + ýe.:ÏúuSR<9TNjÁ ¥ O �HP��¶�5$'&U$)�f*+.�&{$U.�,�3*������$'&Z�*·�Ë�¹��."��ï5ò�) ­ � ñ U � � RV9XW�$�� � �$�%]�¹��$c3ó�·2YN¹�Z9�� O 9N�� O �*��������*{$â�¹�W.� + ¨%��.b�f*>.�3�.]4�.U���g$�4}�W&{�&'U$c*?*j*c.�¶�f*5!f2��t3&%[N¹�Z9f� O 9�(+*'* ����$+$c�¶�¹��$c&T'U��3�4]�¶�¶����3\N Á � O ��&]NjÁQ¥ O ���&Ì�¹�W.� + ¨ � .��f*='{��3W�¹�t3*�]�&��*^9ú���5$'3 + ¨ � .��f*[. * ����$c&L-�&U$g��,t�0'·.�¹����3 �V!�òE�Q!+.�3�4 ��3�,�2ó�Q! + ¨])� .��f*[.óþ�þß]Ý9� þß�ë* ����$c&?�Ì.�&��¶�t38%�.�,�$�!¹��&C.�,t,��*)Qû´\])V9

Page 12: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

�`_N��t� O �*��������*{$��¹��."�â.�* ����$c&L-Ç&{$-�W,t�0'{."�¹����3ú�V!Jòö$5a��f*U�Î*{�n.�3�4�.�*'* ����$b'{��3�4`�¶�¹����3�NjÁ �CO ��&H'{��3�4`�¶�¹����3�N Á ¥ O 9���5$'3��¹��$c&{$)�f*C.L* ����$c&L-Ç&{$-�W,t�0'{."�¹����3 *·�±�¹�W.�:¨ ©Q� � 9N��t�t� O (+*?* ����$[�¶��.�H�¹��$�&?�)%]�W�8��.�3�4 *-�Ç4�$É�V!�N¶�49c O �f*�#%$c,t,j4�$L/�35$�4�!¶��&}.�,t,Îvc��u Ô v Ô � 9�(+*?* ����$É$'�¶�¹�5$'&'U��3�4`�¶�¹����3�N Á � O ��&"NjÁQ¥ O �]��&:�¹�W.� + � ��.F'·.�3Ì��$A�s.�/�$'3Ë�s���$d'U��3W�¹�t3e�"�&��* 9>���5$'3 + � �d.5��.�*�.j&?�)%]�W�2'U��3��¹�t3e�"�4�Q*���4]�f/*'·.�¶����3g#b�N�0's� �f*+.L*^����$'&h-�&{$-��,t�0'·.�¶����3��^!lò�� � ©;� � ��.�3�4 � �f*;%]�¹��$c3ó�{2YN¶�49fi O 9

<>^QY?S[Y'iWV�YLy�\qõ�SUXLhU^`\Nõ�dmY?dt^`\ + 7 ¥ .cpb6Ai�S�^`X?SUZ vK�| + d .âdfeLV�h{^`X?^`rtr�V�X ! Y?^�6ji�S�^QX'SUZ AK�| + T§K�M"P�|5.â^Q_,CXcV�ZFQ^�l + |�~`~QP/.·K)6ji�dfe+dfe S�h�V�yNe-S]\B)Cdt\NhUrtyNõ�S�e)Y'i�S}y�\Ndt^`\ ^`_�Y'i�S}S ÷ yNdmlQV�rtSU\"YHZ±V�X-Y'dt\�o"V�rtSLZÍS�VQe-y�X'S�e)^Q_Y'i�S+SUrtS�Z[SU\"Yce:dt\�\ÍK G ^QXnX?S�V�e-^`\qe:^`_§e ! Z[ZÍSUY'X ! p"iN^��AS{l]S�X�pM�AS)iqV�l]SHV�rfe?^Le-^`y�o`i]YAY?^LegY'yNõ ! Y'iNSCh�VQe-SQ�>iNSUX?Sò�):dfe%\�^QY ^`y�\qõ�S�õ S�rt^5��pK�>iNSU\qh{S>Y?iNS)hU^`\Nõ�dmY?dt^`\ + 7 � .cK%6Ai�S)\�S�S�õ[_�^`X:e ! Z[Z[S{Y'X ! V�X?dfe-S�e%_�X'^QZ Y?iNS)õ�S�e?dtX?SY'^�V�rfe?^Ìe-Y?yqõ ! dfõ TNX?dfhUS�eUp�hU_�K + v�K MM.·K G ^QXCSUû�V�Z[T�rtS`p5\NSUdmY'iNSUX�VËe-iN^QX-Yâh�V�rtr�\�^QY�VËe-iN^QX-YHT�y�YâV�X?S ^QyN\Nõ�S�õ SUrt^���KAaS�S}a"S�h{Y?dt^`\ùO"K

@)rfe-^}\N^�Y'S>Y'iWV�Y:Y'i�S+Z±V�dt\±õ�d�R�S�X?S�\NhUS S{Yd�AS�SU\ËY?iNdfe:TWV�T�S�XjV�\qõ[Y?iNS)rtdmY'S�XcV�Y'yNX?S)^`\Ìe-y�T�S�X?i�S�õ�oQdt\NoL_�^`Xo`dml`S�\�� + e-yqh'i�V�eu,HXcV�ZF`^�l + |�~`~QP/.+V�\Nõ�^QY'i�S�XHTqV�T�SUX'eâhUdmY?S�õ�dt\ Y'i�SÉdt\"Y'X?^õ�yqh·Y'dt^Q\D.+dfe+Y'iqV�Yy�jSLiWVUl]SLY?^õ�S�V�r��>dmY'iÍY'iNdt\�o]e%rtd�`S)S�e?e-S�\]Y'd�V�r�e?y�TNX?S�ZËVHdt\[Y'i�S>yN\Nõ�^`ZÍdt\WV�Y?S�õ±h�V�e-S`Kb6ji�S�e-S)õ�^�\N^QYAV�y�Y'^QZ±V�Y?dfh�V�rtr ! S{û�dfegY�pe-S�SLV�rfe-^ËY'iNS}õ�S{l]S�rt^QTNZ[SU\"YHdt\ Y?iNSL@)TNT�SU\qõ�dmû5KH6Ai�dfeCegY'X?yqh·Y'yNX?S�e)Y?iNS}hU^`\Nõ�dmY?dt^`\qeUp§õ�S�üN\�dmY'dt^Q\qe�V�\qõ X?S�e-yNrmY'edt\1Y?iNdfe>e?S�h{Y?dt^`\§K

@ X?S ÷ y�dtX?S�Z[SU\"YÌdt\ Y?iNSùV ^�l]S Y?iNS�^QX?S�Z Y?iWV�YÌõ�^"S�e±\�S�S�õúe-^`ZÍS�hU^QZ[Z[SU\"Y±dfe[Y'i�S�^Q\NS dt\"l`^`rmldt\NoSUû"Y'X?S�ZËV�r8T�X?^ V dtrtdmY?dtS�eUK 9n^Q\qõ�dmY?dt^`\ + 7 � .}dfeËV�h{Y?yWV�rtr ! ÷ y�dmY'S´�AS�V°�pAVQeÉdmY[dfe[e'V�Y?dfe?ü�S�õ��>i�S�\&\B)ËdfeÉY?iNShU^Q\"l`SUûúiy�rtrH^`_�dmYceÌSUûY?X?S�Z±V�rCT�^Qdt\"YceUK ay%YËh{dtS�\]Y h{^`\Nõ�dmY'dt^Q\qe1_�^`X1V X?S�e?y�rmY1^`_âY'i�dfeÌY ! T�SôV�X?S�o`dml]SU\ dt\6AiNSU^`X?S�ZËe)|�O"K�Ap�|�O"Kªv}V�\qõ |�OKf|�A + T§KIM]~`P�øÎM"~�2/.Idt\�x]VQhU^õ + |�~]w�~/.cK G ^`XnS{ûNV�Z[TNrtSQpY?iNS)üNX'egYn^Q_5Y'iNS�e-S+X?S�e-yNrmY'eo`dml`S�ejY'i�S�_�^Qrtrt^��>dt\NoÌV�e)VÍe-T�S�hUd�V�rçh�VQe-S + e-S�S}aS�h{Y'dt^Q\�P/.cKn6Ai�dfe��>dtrtr�h{^�l]SUX>^`y�X>SUû�V�Z[T�rtS�eUK

j ð ø � ø î Ø ï ØÚøl÷ �1�fÄD� (+*?* ����$j�¹��$;'U��3�4`�¶�¹����3N*n�V!����5$���&{$c� �49f�$9��*��������*{$8�¹�W.���c���f*8���4��3�4�$�4±�$c,��$#�{2ù.[3���3�&{.�3�4����k'U��3q*U�s.�3�� Nf%]&{$U."�g$'&L�¹�W.�y£ I O 9C�*���N����*·$[�¶��."� + ÉL� .8�f*}�¶�5$�*-�Ì.�,t,�$·*U�A&?�)%]�W�T'U��3��¹�t3e�"�4�Q*/N,¶�¶&·.�¹����3l!¶��&�#b���0'g� + ± �4�X� ì ��í� � �f��� �P� ì î í� .8�f*â."4.����g$�4 .�3541*·���¹��."� � � É�© 9�W�$�� � û É ® 9+�*��������*{$Í�¹�W.�\B)â$763�`.�,f*��¹��$+*{$��A�^!b.�,t,���&{���Q.N���t,t�¶�¶��$·*y�*)+*·�±�¶��."� + �:ì �dí )� . � ���f� � + �tì î í )� .j.�&{$y�*),-Ç�±.�&��¹�t3&%�.�,�$c*{��.�354±*·�Ë�¹�W.�� ) + � . � |m9)����$c3\n%��3�4]�¶�¶����3oN Á � O �f*>*·."�¹�f*`/5$�4p9

�L� ñb�Z���K�q��� 6ç^He-S�SAiN^5�öY'iNS8V ^�l`SJ�j^QX4�eUp]h{^`\qe-dfõ�S�X%e ! e-Y?S�ZËel�>dmY'iL^`\�r ! ^`\�S8egY?^�hP +)r � |�.cK�ý�SrtSUY + ± �4�P��� .8o`SU\NSUX·V�Y'S + ÉL� .cK+@ e-SUY � û É ® �>dtrtr�õ�S�e'h{X?d S}^`y�XCX?S�e-Y?X?dfh{Y'dt^Q\qeUK G ^`X)SUû�V�Z[T�rtS � h�V�\ S�Y?iNS

Page 13: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

�X�e-SUY+o`dml]SU\ "! + AKªP3.·p�^`X + AK�|�v/.cp5^QX + v�Kf|`|5. S�rt^5��KC6AiNS}_ÇVQh·Y+Y'iqV�Y<� � dfe+^`\�r ! õ�S�ü�\NS�õ o`dml`S�\ôVÍTNX?^ V dtrtdmY !õ�dfegY?X'd y�Y?dt^`\ dfeL\�^QY[V õ�d�Y[h{yNrmY ! iNSUX'S��-�AS�hU^Q\qe-dfõ�SUX��HeLe?^ Y'iWV�YÉY?iNS�e-S{Y � iWV�eLTNX?^ V dtrtdmY ! | + �>iNSUX?S÷ yqV�\]Y'dmY'dtS�e)rtd�QSB� � V�X'S�õ�S�üN\�S�õ1yN\Nõ�S�XZ�*.·K

G+\NSHh�V�\�V�rfe?^]�A^QX@-�>dmY'iÌ^QY?iNS�XAY ! TWS�ej^Q_çX?S�egY'X?dfh·Y'dt^`\NeUK G ^QXjS{ûNV�Z[TNrtSQp � h�V�\±Y'i�SCY?iNSCTNX?^ V dtrtdmY?dtS�ee-^�Y'iqV�Y + AKf|�v/.Hdfe�e'V�Y'dfe-ü�S�õ�p%V�\qõ V�rfe-^[s Ì Ô º � � � » ® Ô s ¿ K G+\Nr ! Y?iNSËdtZ±V�oQdt\WV�Y?dt^`\ódfeâY'i�S±rtdtZ[dmY}iNS�X?SQKG+_+hU^QyNX'e-S`pjV�e]�AS�e-iqV�rtr)V�X?o`yNS�dt\ 7Iû�V�Z[T�rtS�M�pne-^`Z[S&"gTNX?S�õ�dfh{Y'dt^Q\�$�e-SUYce[V�X'S SUY-Y'S�XÉY?iWV�\ö^QY?iNS�X'eUpjV�\qõõ�S{Y'SUX'ZÍdt\Ndt\No[o`^"^�õ�e-yqhci�e?S{Yce8dfe)V�\1dt\]Y'S�X?S�e-Y?dt\No ÷ yNS�egY?dt^`\�_�^`X8_�yNX-Y?iNS�X8X'S�e-S�V�X'h'i§K

;>S�\NhUS`p�\ dfejY'i�S�e-SUY>^`_IV�rtrçTNX?^ V dtrtdmY ! õ�dfegY'X?d y�Y'dt^`\Ney� e-^ÍY?iWV�Y �D©Q� ú © + Y?iNS�VQh·Y'yWV�r§l`V�rtyNS�.·p�9���r� ���d����� v���� �d���H�9�_�� + vM�ª~3.

�>dmY'iE� � dt\"Y?S�oQX·V rtS]�#£¤ù��!ú3�fpWV�\qõ ^`y�\qõ�S�õ S�rt^5� "! VÉ\N^Q\NXcV�\Nõ�^`Z hU^Q\qegY·V�\"Y�p�e-^ÍY?iWV�YHF + 9�. � |Qp�V�\qõe-^ÉY'iWV�Y

S{û�T:t:£oª �©gu « �9� «u£ |A ª �©gu ¥« �/¬wv dfe+V-�+øÎZ±V�X-Y'dt\No]V�rtSQp + v9��|�u/.�>iNSUX'S u « � + � «�£E�c«M. ¦ �%«NK%6AiNSHh{^`\Nõ�dmY'dt^Q\ + vK�|�u3.bdfe:�>iWV�YA^`\NS+\�S�S�õ�eA_�^`X;w+dtXce'V�\N^�lD�Ñej6AiNS�^QX?S�Z + e-S�SQp�_�^`XSUû�V�Z[T�rtS`p�,âV�XcV�Y4��V�e)V�\Nõ a"iNX?SUl`S + |�~`~�|�.cp�6Ai�S�^`X?SUZ v�KªOK�|5.:Y?^ÍiN^Qrfõ�p��>i�dfhci1dfeJ�)iqV�Y+VQe?e-yNX?S�ejY?iNSHX'S ÷ y�dtX'S�õSUûdfegY'S�\NhUSL^`_bS ÷ yNdmlQV�rtS�\]Y�Z±V�X-Y'dt\No]V�rtSLZÍS�VQe-y�X'SQKH;)SU\qh{S`p5dt\ ldtSc� ^`_:FIX'^QT�^`e?dmY?dt^`\�vK�Apç9n^`\Nõ�dmY'dt^Q\ + 7 � .8dt\6AiNSU^`X?S�Z v�Kf|âdfejY·VS`SU\ h�V�X'Sâ^Q_sK

6ç^Ëo"V�dt\ Z[^QX'S�xNS{û�d dtrtdmY ! p�^Q\NS}h�V�\ rtS{Y + ÉL� . S�o`SU\NSUX·V�Y'S�õ "! Z[^`X?SâY'iqV�\ ^Q\NS}egY'^hPWp�V�\Nõ � yqegY+rtSUYY'i�S�e-S�egY?^�hPeÍX?S�Z±V�dt\ "?V�\N^Q\ ! Z[^`yNe@$�K G+\NS�h�V�\óY'iNSU\ e-Y?dtrtr8yNe?S1hU^Q\qõ�dmY?dt^`\ + 7 � .·Kó@)rmY'SUX'\qV�Y?dml]S�r ! pAdt_)Y?iNSTWV ! ^�Rùdfe ^`y�\qõ�S�õ SUrt^���pW^Q\NS�h�V�\�yqe-S�h{^`\Nõ�dmY'dt^Q\ + 7 ¥ .·K

�L� ñb�Z���K�(�%� 6AiNdfeCh�V�\ _¶V�rtr�y�\qõ�SUXâ7�ûNV�ZÍTNrtSÉv±V ^�l]SQp "! Y·V°"dt\No � Y'^ S�Y'i�SLe-SUYQ�>iNS�X?S + A"KªP3.iN^QrfõNeUKË=s\ùY?iNdfe�h�V�e-S`p�iN^5�ASUl]SUX�pçY'iNSÍTNX?^ rtS�Z dfe�V�rtX?S�V�õ ! e?^Qrml]S�õ�dt\óaS�h{Y'dt^Q\�A "! oQyNS�e?e-dt\No�Y?iNS[_�^`X?Z ^Q_� � V�\Nõ�Y?iNS�\óV�T�TNr ! dt\�o�=�Y°¯^�� eLB�S�Z[Z±VK�6Ai�S±X?S�V�e?^Q\��>i ! Y?iNdfe�dfe�Y?iNSËrtS�VQegYLS{û�T�SU\qe-dml]SÌe-Y?XcV�Y'SUo ! dfe�Y'iqV�YY'i�S}egY·V�Y?S�õ1yNT�T�S�X ^`yN\Nõ h{^`dt\qh{dfõ�S�eQ�>dmY'i�Y'i�S V r�VQh@"øsa�hci�^`rtS�e + |�~]w�v/.ÎødN�S�X-Y'^Q\ + |�~]w�v/.jTNX?dfhUS�_�^`X)hU^`\NegY·V�\]YhU^"S�Y[hUdtSU\"Y'eB� �   © ¦ � V�\Nõr� ¥ � ¡ © ¦ �âK 6AiNdfe�dfe�^Q\NS±TW^]e?e-d rtSÌX?S�V�rtd���V�Y'dt^Q\ e'V�Y?dfe-_ ! dt\�o Y'iNS±hU^Q\qegY'XcV�dt\]Y+ A"KªP3.·K:6AiNS�^QX?S�Z v�K�|�pNiN^��AS{l]S�X�pNo`dml`S�e+VÉe ! egY'SUZ±V�Y?dfh<�8V ! ^Q_IV�X?X?dml�dt\No±V�Y8Y?iNS�e'V�Z[SâX?S�e-yNrmY�K

Page 14: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

�4^�L� ñb�Z���K��ÄD� + 7IyNX?^`TWS�V�\ùh�V�rtrË65iNS�õ�o`dt\�oÌdt\ Y'i�S}e-Y?^�h@ V�\qõ V-��S�X?^±hU^`y�T�^Q\ ^`\Nõ�.·K+;>S�X?S`p r � A"p�:ì ��í� �h��� p �:ì ¥ í� � Å � K86AiNdfe)õ�^"S�e)\�^QY+_ÇV�rtrçyN\qõ�S�XH7�ûNV�ZÍTNrtSLv�K G yNX-Y'i�S�X+õ�S{Y·V�dtrfeHV�X?S�S{û�TNrt^QX?S�õ dt\ùaS�h{Y'dt^Q\

MNK

�L� ñb�Z���K�1yb� + @>l]SUrtr�V�\NS�õqVp�B§S{l ! pqV�\qõ1F�V�XcVQe + |�~`~`O3..·K:6AiNSHe?S{Y'y�T1h�V�\ Sâh{^�l`S�X?S�õ "! 7Iû�V�Z[T�rtSv�p y�Y)\�^��JY?iNS�dt\]Y'S�X?S�e-Y>X·V�Y'Su�Ldfe>hU^Q\qegY·V�\"YCV�\qõ�\N^`\�XcV�\qõ�^`Z�pWV�\qõ � dfejY'i�S�e-SUY>_�^QX��>i�dfhci

� � �Sº � ÌÎ� �b¿ » _�^QX)V�rtr�v`�Sº u � � » � + v9��|Q|�.6ç^ Z±V°QS±Y?iNS�e-S{Y � ZÍS�VQe-y�X·V rtSQp%^Q\NS�h�V�\öe-y�TNT�^`e-S`pb_�^QXLSUû�V�Z[T�rtS`pIY'iqV�Y-� � dfe�þ�þß]Ý9� þß�ë K ý dmY'iEY'iNdfeÍV�egøe-yNZ[T�Y'dt^Q\§p�VÌe?y�T�SUX?ø¹X?S�TNrtdfh�V�Y?dt\No e-Y?XcV�Y'SUo ! dfeâhU^Q\qegY'X?yNh{Y'S�õù_�^`X�7by�X?^`T�S�V�\ô^`T�Y'dt^Q\qe VQe-S�õù^`\�Y?iNS�" V r�VQhP]øa�h'iN^QrtS�egø V V�X?S�\ r�V�Y?YP$ËS ÷ yWV�Y'dt^Q\ + hU_�K V V�X'SU\ r�V�Y?Y + |�~]w°2/.4.cKG ^`X:Y?iNS+ecV�Z[S)X?S�V�e?^Q\qeAVQe%dt\�7Iû�V�Z[T�rtSL|Qp"Y?iNS+T�X?dfhUS+oQdml]SU\ ]! @>l]SUrtr�V�\�S�õqVpqB§S{l ! V�\NõÌF�V�XcVQe + |�~`~`O3.dfejY?iNS�h{^`\Ne?SUX-l`V�Y?dml]S}VQe±TNX?dfhUSQKn<>^QY?S`pNi�^��ASUl`S�X�p�Y'iqV�Y8Y'i�SâiNS�õ�oQdt\NoËe-Y?XcV�Y'SUo ! TNX?S�e?SU\"Y?S�õ ]! Y'iqV�Y>TWV�T�SUX>dfe\N^�YnY?iNS)^`\�S+yNe?S�õËi�S�X?S`KI=�\qegY'S�VQõË^`_ VQe-dt\No�Y'i�S�ZËe-SUrml]S�e:^Q\ËY'i�SHV�h{Y'yqV�rtr ! V�h�h{X'y�S�õÍl]^`r�V�Y'dtrtdmY ! + VQe:dt\ + AK�O�.4.cpY'i�S ! i�S�õ�oQS V�e?S�õÌ^`\1V`�A^QXcegY8h�V�e?SC\N^Q\�ø¹^ e-SUX?l`S�õ±l]^`r�V�Y'dtrtdmY ! KA6AiNSCX?S�VQe-^Q\m�)i ! Y?iNS ! h�V�\Ìo`S{Y)V��8V ! �>dmY'iY'i�dfe>dfe8Y'iqV�Y>Y'iNSâZ[SUY?iN^�õ1^`_�e?TWS�h{dt_ ! dt\�oÌh{^`\qe-SUX?lQV�Y?dml]S�\�S�e?e+dfe8TWV�X?Y?dfhUy�r�V�X?r ! hU^`\Ne-S�X-l`V�Y'dml]S�6�dt_�^Q\NS�e-yNTNTW^]e-S�eV}l]^Qr�V�Y'dtrtdmY ! Z[^õ�SUr¶pWe'V ! p � � ���{z + � � . � v��}| + � � . � � �4� + v9��|5A3.VÍ~`O:~ + e'V ! . ^`yN\Nõ1^`_çY'i�SâY ! TWS + v�Kf|`|�. ! dtS�rfõNe)VLZLyqh'i1i�dto`iNSUX)T�X?dfhUSHY'iqV�\1^`\�S�^Q_�Y?iNSHY ! T�S + A"KªP/.cpqe-dt\qh{SY'i�Snr�V�Y?Y?S�X�dt\]l]^Qrml]S�e�Y'i�S8VUl]SUX·V�o`Sn^`_�� ¥� �>iNdtrtSnY'i�Sn_�^`X?Z[SUX�õ�S�T�SU\qõ�e�^`\�Y'i�SAZËV�û�dtZ}yNZ V�\qõ�Y'i�SAZÍdt\NdtZLy�Z ^Q_Y'i�dfe:TNX?^�h{S�e?eUK%6ji�S)iNdtoQiÌT�X?dfhUS�e%Y?iWV�YjV�X?S)dt\NiNSUX?S�\"YAdt\[Y?iNSC@>l`S�rtr�V�\�S�õNV�pNB§S{l ! V�\qõ±FIV�X·V�e + |�~`~`O3.%V�TNT�X?^"VQh'iiWV�e SUS�\EhU^`ZÍZ[S�\]Y'S�õù^Q\ ]! @)iN\§pÎN�yN\�dnV�\Nõóa/�>dt\qõ�rtS + |�~`~`PQV�p .cpb�>iN^ e?y�o`oQS�egY`�8V ! eâ^`_8V�rtrtSUl�d�V�Y'dt\�oY'i�S�S�R�S�h{Y�K

� �� �` q�����U�����bé��}�����5���Z�\�y����S�:� q�ö�S�����������B�������W��� �Ç�ö ��U���b� �ó q���ö 1�]�����Q�D���%����:����� K @Ce)dt\ô7Iû�V�Z[T�rtSFAp r � A"p �:ì ��í� �È��� p �:ì ¥ í� � Å � KZ\ dfeHVQe?e-yNZÍS�õ Y?^ S�Y'iNSLe?S{YC^`_bTNX?^ V dtrtdmY !Z[S�VQe-yNX?S�eJ�)i�S�X?S

� ��� V�\qõ�Å � V�X?S�hU^Q\"Y'dt\"yN^QyqeËV�\qõ V�õqV�T�Y'S�õ e-S�ZÍdmøÎZ±V�X?Y?dt\No]V�rtS�eUpW�>dmY'i �D©´� ú © V�\qõ�Å ©E� u © + Y?iNSVQh·Y'yqV�r§lQV�rtyNS�eP.X6�� � dfe)VQõNV�T�Y'S�õ5pWdt\]Y'SUo`XcV rtSLV�\qõ ^`y�\qõ�S�õ S�rt^5� "! VL\�^`\NXcV�\qõ�^QZ hU^Q\qegY·V�\"Y56

Page 15: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

�x� º rt^Qo ��� rt^`o � » � dfe)V e-^Qrty�Y'SUr ! h{^`\"Y?dt\y�^`yqe + ��K X�K Y�K:B�S S�e-o`y�S�ZÍS�VQe-y�X'S�.·p9�)dmY?i õ�SUX?dml`V�Y?dml]SB� ¥� 6� + A"K�|�v/.Ai�^`rfõNec6�V�\qõ� SUl`S�X ! � û8\ iWV�eCV�\ S ÷ y�dml`V�rtSU\"YHZËV�X-Y'dt\�o"V�rtS�Z[S�V�e-yNX?SB�*)�p êËU�Ø5U p��*)"�?�Lp�e-^[Y?iWV�Y � )� V�\Nõ8ÅL)� V�X?S�*)'ø¹Z±V�X-Y?dt\No"V�rtS�eUK

=s\ÌldtSc�J^`_Îw+dtXce'V�\N^�lD�Ñe>6AiNSU^`X?S�Z�p�Y?iNSHr�V�e-Y>hU^Q\qõ�dmY?dt^`\�dfenY·V�\"Y·V�Z[^`y�\"YjY'^ÉdtZ[TW^]e-dt\No[hU^Q\qõ�dmY'dt^`\Ne+V�rt^Q\NoÉY?iNSrtdt\NS�e>^`_I7�ûNV�ZÍTNrtSË|QK

ýESÍhU^`\Ne-dfõ�S�X}VQe TNX?dfh{S�eâ^`_n^QT�Y?dt^`\qeu�>dmY?i�TqV ! ^3R�ò � À + � ® .CV�Y + \�^`\NXcV�\qõ�^QZm.)Y'dtZ[S-�âp��>iNSUX?SmÀdfe}hU^Q\"l]S{û5K 6Ai�dfe}dt\NhUrtyNõ�S�eLh�V�rtrfeÉV�\NõET�y�YceUK G ^`X}h{^`\]l]S�\�dtS�\NhUS`pÎ�AS±e-yNT�T�^]e-SËY'iqV�Y-Àódfe ^`y�\qõ�S�õ S�rt^���K;>S�\NhUS�h�V�\´�ASâdt\"l`^3`SL9n^`\Nõ�dmY'dt^Q\ + 7 ¥ .n^Q_b6Ai�S�^`X?SUZ vK�|QK

G dtXcegY}^`_>V�rtr¶p%V�e�_¶V�XLV�e + AKf|�v3.âdfe}hU^Q\qhUSUX?\NS�õ5p ¡ ¿ dfeLV�Y?Y·V�dt\NS�õ�K�6AiNdfe�dfe S�h�V�yNe-S`pIdt_8\�^QY�pI^Q\NSÌh�V�\X?S�e?h�V�rtS�Y?dtZ[S���c� � � ��� ì � Ì B í p �� � �?� ��� ì � Ì B í _�^`X)u Ô v Ô � + |�£}�P.·p��>dmY'iM��c� � uÉ_�^QX + |�£g�X.�� Ô v Ô � V�\qõrtSUY ���� X'y�\Ey�T�Y?iNS[_�y�rtr:yN\yNe-S�õôl]^Qr�V�Y?dtrtdmY ! ^Q\�Y?iNSËecV�Z[S[dt\]Y'S�X-lQV�r¶pIecV ! � � ¥� � + ¡ ¿ £ ¡ ® Ì B . ¦ �UK±=s\�^�Y'iNSUX�A^`X'õNeUp§e-yNT�T�^`e?SLY?iWV�Y �� ©·� Á])NSUû�T1ï3£ ð ®© ��« �/¬bñ À + � ® .>dfeZ�)dmY?iNdt\��Í^`_bY?iNSÉZ±V�û�dtZLy�Z�K�6AiNS�\ùX?S>�)X?dmY?S�� ©�� ÁB)qSUûT�ï3£_ð ® Ì B© ���« �/¬bñ À + �� ® Ì B .·KÉ=s_t�ASÍTNX?^Qrt^`\No(�� � V�\Nõ��� ¥� VQeâdt\Nõ�dfh�V�Y'S�õ�^`\ùY'i�SÉY'dtZ[SÍdt\"Y?S�X-l`V�r¶p�AS�oQSUY<ÁB)WS{û�T1ï/£_ð ®© ��c« �/¬bñ À + �� ® . ­ �� © K86AiNdfe)dfe S�h�V�yqe-S �� )� dfeCVÉZ±V�X-Y'dt\�o"V�rtS`p��>iNS�\NhUS�dmY+_�^`rtrt^��)e>Y'iqV�YSUûT + £_ð �© ���« �/¬ .À + ���� .ndfe)VÍe-y Z±V�X?Y?dt\No]V�rtS�_�X?^QZ + |L£g�X.��JY?^-��pNe-dt\qhUS���c«[dfe���SUX'^Í^Q\1Y'i�dfe8Y?dtZ[Sâdt\"Y'SUX-l`V�r¶K

=s\�h{^`\qe-S ÷ yNSU\qh{S`pqY'i�S�hU^`\Ne-S�X-l`V�Y'dml]SLV�eÌTNX?dfhUS�V�Y8Y'dtZ[S�uLdfe8dt\1Y'i�dfe)h�VQe-S� ©Q� e-yNT� Á ) ýeÀ + � )® ¦ ýe. � + M%��|5.

�>iNSUX'Sârt^`o � )® £�rt^`o � )© dfe>\�^`X?Z±V�r�� + £ �¥ ¡ ¿ �P¡ ¿ .cp�V�\qõ1Y?iNS�e-yNT�X?S�ZLy�Z dfe>^�l]S�X+V�rtrçXcV�\Nõ�^`Z lQV�X?d�V rtS�e;ý_�^QX��>iNdfh'i

SUûT + £  <¿ . Ô ý Ô S{û�T + £   Ì . + M%��A�.V�\Nõ�e'V�Y?dfe?_ ! dt\�o Á ) ý � Å © � + M%�ªv3.6AiNdfe8dfe>T�X?^�l�dfõ�S�õa�AS�h�V�\ e-i�^��JY?iWV�Y�pq_�^QXjY'iNSâX'SUrtSUlQV�\"Yy� ) p�Y?iNS�X?Sâdfe)V ± � V�\qõ�V-Å � e?^ÉY?iWV�Y ± ® � ý Ì � K

adt\NhUST�b����À + ú ¦ �D.Idfe:h{^`\]l]SUû + _�^`Xw� � ú*Ï u/.·p]Y?iNS>_�y�\qh{Y?dt^`\qV�rDý�� Á ) ýeÀ + � )® ¦ ýe.IdfenV�rfe-^}h{^`\]l]SUû�pV�\Nõöe-^ Y'i�S1e-yNT�X?S�ZLy�Z dt\ + MNK�|5.�dfeÍV�Y?YcV�dt\NS�õó_�^QX[V�\�ý �>i�dfhciö^`\�r ! Y·VS`S�e}Y?iNS±l`V�rtyNS�eLSUûT + £   Ì .}V�\qõSUûT + £   ¿ .·K

Page 16: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

� �B�SUY���� � ï��(�/ý + �:. � S{û�T + £   �Î. ñ _�^`X�� � � ^`X*£�K:=�Y)_�^Qrtrt^��)e)_�X'^QZ Y?iNS}V ^�l]S�Y?iWV�YQ�ASu�)dfe-i

Y'^ÍZ±V�û�dtZ[d��USÁ ) SUûT + £  <¿ .4À + S{û�T +  <¿ . � )® .����� F��Á ) SUûT + £   Ì .4À + S{û�T +   Ì . � )® .�����¡ + M%� MK.

e-y � S�h·Y>Y'^S{û�T + £   ¿Î.}� ) + �]¿[.��óSUûT + £  `Ì .� ) + � Ì . � Å © � + M%��O�.

<>^�� rtS{Y

�B¿ � ï7�&� � )® ­ �� ñ/� + M%�ªP3.�>iNSUX'S �� dfeCõ�S{Y'S�X?Z[dt\�S�õ "! + MNKªO3.·p§V�\Nõ rtSUY �� � SÍV�\ ! ^�Y'i�S�XCTWV�dtXH^Q_%e?S{YceCe'V�Y'dfe-_ ! dt\No + MNKªO3.·Kâadt\qh{S�ÀùdfehU^Q\"l`SUû5pDú�� SUû�T + £   Ì .4À + SUûT +   Ì .4úS.l£�SUûT + £   ¿ .4À + S{û�T +   ¿ .4úS.ndfe)VL\N^`\�dt\qh{X'S�VQe-dt\NoË_�y�\qh{Y?dt^`\�KA;>S�\NhUSQp

S{û�T + £  <¿ .4À + SUûT +  <¿ . � )® . + � �  �£g� ���  .1�óSUûT + £   Ì .4À + S{û�T +   Ì . � )® . + � � ¡�£g� ��F¡ .­ + SUû�T + £   ¿Î.4À + S{û�T +   ¿[. ��e..[£ôS{û�T + £  `Ì .4À + SUûT +  `Ì . ��e.4. + � ��  £g� ���  . �V�\Nõ�e-^�Y'iNS[h'iN^`dfh{S + M�KªP3.CZËV�û�dtZÍd���S�e + MNK MM.Ce-y � S�h·Y�Y'^ + MNK�O�.·KÉ=s\ùY'i�S[\�^QYcV�Y'dt^Q\ + AK!A3.�ø + A"Kªv/.cp �� dfeâ_�^`yN\Nõ_�X?^QZ + M�K�O3. ]!

¢ + � ¥ + � © � �� � u �@¡ ¿Î.4. � S{û�T + £   Ì .�£¤Å ©SUûT + £   Ì .l£�SUûT + £   ¿ . � + M%��w�.

<>^QY?SâY?iWV�Y>Y'i�dfe>S ÷ yWV�Y'dt^Q\�V�r �8V ! e>iWVQe>V + y�\Nd ÷ y�SS.je-^`rty�Y?dt^`\ S�h�V�yqe-S�SUû�T + £   Ì . ­ Å ©y­ S{û�T + £   ¿ .cK6ç^�e-S�SAY'iqV�YbY?iNS8Z±V�û�dtZLy�Z dfeIdt\qõ�SUS�õÉY?iNS>VQe}TNX?dfhUSQp/�AS8\�^�� hU^Q\qegY'X?yNh{YnVu� ) ûE\ ) V�eb_�^Qrtrt^��)eUK G dmûv}©âe-^ÍY'iqV�YCu G v}© G �âKjG+\�º u � vd©�.·p%�AS�rtSUY �9� )� � � � )� �9� �gp��>dmY'i8� ¥ �å¡ ¿ ¦ v}©�pWV�\qõ´�AS�e-SUYQ�c� �#  Ì ¦ v}©�KG X'^QZüvd©nY?^u�âp � )� dfebh{^`\qegYcV�\"Y + �å� )�E¢ ¡ .cK�=s_ � )� ¢ û1� Ì pQY'i�S�\-�c� � up]^QY?iNSUX4�>dfe-S��c� � +   ¿ £   Ì . ¦ + �m£Bvd©�.cK

6AiNdfe8o`dml`S�e>yqe>V�\ V�rtrt^��8V rtS ± �?pWV�\qõEÅ )� dfe8^ ldt^`yNe?r !Å )� � SUûT + £  <¿ .}� + � ¿&Ç���� .��óS{û�T + £   Ì .}� + � Ì Ç��D� .X� + M%�!23.

6AiNS V ^�l`S oQdml]S�eÉY'i�S1Z±V�ûdtZLyNZ _�^QX-v � u�p y�YÍY'iNS�e'V�ZÍS V�X?o`yNZÍS�\"YËh�V�\ S h�V�X?X?dtS�õ ^Qy�Y[_�^QX±V�rtrLv·pu Ô v Ô �âp§Y'i�S�X?S ]! V�rfe-^ VQe?e-yNX?dt\�o1Y'i�SÍSUûdfegY'S�\NhUS[^`_%Y'iNSÍS�e'e-SU\"Y'd�V�r%e?y�TNX?S�Z}yNZ�K}ýESÍiqV�l`SÍY?iyNeâTNX?^�l`S�õY'i�S�_�^Qrtrt^��>dt\No

Page 17: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

�4¹j ð ø � ø î Ø ï ØÚøl÷ y��Ú��� �*�N��£{$ '����g�C�¶�5$%.�*?* ���}���¹����3q*I.���¶�5$8��$5%]�t3N3��t38%}�V!N�q$7'��¹����3:¤"���¶�5$w'U��3N*·$c&��U."�¹�¹��$

.�*-/[�W&?�0'U$â."�>�¶�t��$�¥�$'&U� !¶��&A��.{2N� >�À + � ® .j.�>�¶�t��$Q�J�f*

� � Á ) SUû�T + £   ¿[.4À + SUûT +   ¿Î. � .C� ¦ µ&§ �¨ª© ��Á ) SUûT + £  `Ì .4À + S{û�T +  `Ì . � .�� ¦ µ&« �¨;© � + M%�ª~3.#b�5$'&U$ �� �f*ª%`�¹��$'3ö�·2YN�¤89�¬ O �5.�3�4M#%��$c&{$)rt^`o � �f*835��&?�Ì.�,�� + rt^Qo ��© £ �¥ ¡ ¿ �@¡ ¿ .�9

@)rmY'SUX'\qV�Y?dml]S�r ! pW^`\�S�h�V�\�^ l�dt^`yNe-r ! �)X?dmY?S� � � + �D©°�P <¿t�@¡W¿W� À + úS.�� + ú ­ �� SUûT +  <¿ .4.�� � + ��©°�P  Ì �P¡O¿t� À + ú�.C� + ú G �� S{û�T +  <¿ .4. � + M���|�u/.

�>iNSUX'S � + � © �P B�P¡J�L­ + úS..ndfe8Y?iNS V r�V�hP]øga�h'iN^QrtS�egødN�S�X-Y?^`\ TNX?dfhUSâ_�^`X8TWV ! ^3R ­ + � ® .jV�Y8Y'dtZÍS*�âK<>^QY?S>Y'iWV�YAdt_�^`\NS;�>dfe?i�S�e%Y'^}õ�dfe-X'SUo"V�Xcõ[Y?iNS ^`\NõmÅ � + VQe%dt\�7�ûNV�ZÍTNrtSL|�.cp^`\�S � yqegYAZ±V�û�dtZ[d��US�e + M�K MK.�>dmY'i�^`y�Y + M�K�O�.·K@)\qõ1\�^�� _�^`X8Y?iNS�7IyNX?^`TWS�V�\ h�V�rtr¶K

�L� ñb�Z���K��Ä + h{^`\"Y?dt\y�S�õ�. � =s_t� dfe)Y'i�SÉegY?X'd�QS}TNX?dfhUSQplÀ + ú�. � + úQ£��e. ¿ KC6Ai�SÉe-^Qrty�Y'dt^Q\ùoQdml]SU\ùdt\+ A"K�|{MM.�� + A"K�|�O�.j_�^`rtrt^5�+e>õ�dtX?S�h{Y'r !1 ]! e?S{Y?Y?dt\NoFÍ�© � rt^`o + � ¦ ��o.·K®1 ���°¯b���Ç���E������±³²5¯I�� q�[�`�Ç���ó�U��� ����"������� K

=s\1S�e'e-SU\qhUSQpp� �b SUdt\NoËe?SUrt_�ø¹üN\WV�\qh{dt\No±ZÍS�V�\NejY'iqV�Y;�AS�h�V�\�X?S�T�X'S�e-S�\"YT�o)� "!� )� � � )© � î´

Eµ � ª�©g¶ ì í· �9� ì í A· � + OK��|5.

6AiNdfe8dfe>dt\�l�dtSc� ^`_�\"yNZ[SUX·V�dtX?S�dt\]l`V�X'd�V�\qh{S + e-S�SQp Ø5U�ë/U p�a"S�h{Y?dt^`\ P�K V ^`_�RCy%Y[S + |�~`~QP/..·KG dmûE�Èû´\ÍpWV�\Nõ1X?S�h�V�rtr§Y'iqV�Y>Y?iNS �:ì í )� V�X?S�hU^Q\"Y?dt\yN^QyqeUK:ý�S�e-iWV�rtrçYcV°`SHY'iNS�egY'^hciqVQegY'dfhâdt\"Y?S�o`XcV�rçY?^

S8õ�SUüN\NS�õT�>iNSU\ ¶ ì �dí� � �c��� � ¶ ì î í� dfe%V�\ÍS�rtSUZ[S�\]Y%dt\=¸ ¥¹»ºL¼ + �*.cp3�>iNdfhciÍdfeIY?iNS8e?S{Y%^Q_ r ø�õ�dtZ[S�\Ne?dt^Q\WV�rqTNX?S�õ�dfh{YcV rtSTNX?^hUS�e?e-S�eHe-^ÌY?iWV�YBð �© ¶ ì í¾½« � º � ì í A �X� ì í A » « dfeCrt^�h�V�rtr ! dt\"Y?S�o`XcV rtS��+øsV�K eUKL6AiNSÉegY'^hciWV�egY'dfhÉdt\"Y?S�o`XcV�r + OKf|�.>dfeY'i�S�\Ëõ�SUüN\NS�õ ]! Y?iNS>TNX?^�h{S�e?e%dt\Ì6AiNS�^QX?S�ZËeb=·K MNKªv�|+V�\qõÍ=·K MNK M]u + T§K]M"P5�"MK23.Idt\Ìx]VQh{^�õ±V�\qõ±aiNdtX ! V�SUl + |�~32]w�.·K

@ X?S�egY'X?dfh{Y?dt^`\[dfeI\NS�S�õ�S�õÍY?^ S)V rtS8Y?^�X?y�rtS>^Qy�Y:õ�^Qy rtdt\NoLegY?X·V�Y'SUo`dtS�eUK%6AiNSAYd�A^âZ[^]egYbT�^`T�yNr�V�XW�8V ! e^`_§õ�^Qdt\No}Y?iWV�YjV�X?S)Y?^}dt\Ne?dfegYAS�dmY?iNSUXnY'iqV�Yª�o)� S+dt\1V�\q¸ ¥ øÎe-TWVQh{S`p�^QX:Y?iWV�YAdmY S ^`y�\qõ�S�õ S�rt^5� + ;+V�X?X?dfe-^`\

Page 18: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

�ÃV�\Nõ-,CX'SUTqe + |�~]w�~/.cp"RCS�r V�S�\[V�\qõ[ahciWV�hci�S�X?Z±V ! S�X + |�~Q~]O�.·p"R ! l�dto�V�\qõÍ;>yWV�\No + |�~�2323.·pK,âV�XcV�Y4��VQe + |�~`~`P3.X6e-S�S�V�rfe-^ËRCy�YÍS + |�~`~`P3.·p5a"S�h·Y'dt^`\ P�Kª9�.·K�ýES�e-iqV�rtrçi�S�X?S�o`^T�>dmY'i VÍhUX?dmY'SUX?dt^`\1Y?iWV�Y>S�\qh{^`Z[TqVQe?e-S�e ^�Y'i§K

õ ��ö Øj÷1Ø ï ØÚøb÷ � @ T�X'^hUS�e'e�� � pWu Ô v Ô �âpNdfe ÞUØc� ÝPã¿bà5ß�à þ ê�à�ë �>dmY'i�X?S�e-TWS�h{Y8Y'^ �:ì �dí� � ����� �P�:ì î í� dt_��e)�e'V�Y?dfe?ü�S�e + OKf|�.·p"V�\qõLdt_lï^� ) ÌÀ � u Ô u Ô � � u egY'^QTNTNdt\�o[Y?dtZ[S ñ dfeIyN\Ndt_�^`X?Z[r ! dt\"Y?S�oQX·V rtS>y�\qõ�S�X:V�rtr��`)Qû´\])Y'iqV�YCV�X?S�S ÷ y�dml`V�rtSU\"Y)Y?^��LK

6AiNSÉX?S�V�e-^`\ù_�^QXâe-S�S�"dt\NoÌY'^�V�l`^`dfõ Y'iNSÉX?S ÷ yNdtX?SUZ[S�\]YHY'iWV�Y]�o)� S ^`y�\qõ�S�õ S�rt^5� dfeCY'iqV�Y�p§Y?^ÌY?iNSSUû"Y'SU\"Y>TW^]e?e-d rtSQpNY'i�S�e'V�Z[S+Y'i�S�^QX ! e-iN^`y�rfõ V�T�TNr ! S ÷ yWV�rtr ! Y'^ dfõ V�\qõ1VQe±T�X'dfh{S�eUKnadt\NhUSHY'i�S dfõÌTNX?dfhUSHdfe\N^QX?Z±V�rtr ! o`dml`S�\ ]! + v�K MK.·pNe?S�hUy�X'dmY?dtS�ejY?iWV�Y+V�X?SHyN\ ^`y�\qõ�S�õ S�rt^5�å�>dtrtr S�VÉh{^`Z[Z[^Q\�TNi�S�\N^QZ[S�\�^`\�K G ^`XSUû�V�Z[T�rtS`pp� +4+ � £r�e. ¿ . � £ � + £ + � £¤�e. ¿ .·pqV�\Nõ�£ + � £r�o. ¿ dfe8y�\ ^QyN\Nõ�S�õ SUrt^���K

=�Y)e?i�^`y�rfõ S�S�Z[T�iWVQe-d��US�õ1Y'iqV�Y)^`y�X+õ�S�üN\�dmY'dt^Q\ùõ�^S�e�pqdt\qõ�S�S�õ�pWTNX?S�hUrtyqõ�S}õ�^Qy rtdt\�oËY ! TWS}egY?X·V�Y'SUo`dtS�eUK6AiNSâ_�^Qrtrt^��>dt\NoËdfe)VÉõ�dtX?S�h·YCh{^`\Ne?S ÷ y�S�\qh{S�^Q_�^`T�Y?dt^`\qV�r�egY'^QTNTNdt\�oÌV�\Nõ G V�Y'^Qy��Ñe)B�S�Z[Z±VK

j ð ø � ø î Ø ï ØÚøl÷ÂÁ �Ú�%� W�$��T� ûÈ\É�C.�3�4ö* ��������*{$ù�¶��.�±�¶�5$c&{$Ì�f*1."�},�${.�*U�[��35$E�*)¤ûÈ\B)ù�¶��.���f*$ 68���¹�{.�,�$c3W�L�g�a�:91�*���N����*·$1�¶��."���e)� �f*�*{$',Q!�/N3W.�3*'?�t38%��t3ú�¶�5$É*·$c3N*·$ %]�¹��$'3 .����`��$<9�����$c35�I�Q!C�¶�5$'&U$[.�&{$*U�g�{�N���t3&% �¹�t��$c* u .�354 � ��u Ô u Ô&��Ô �H�W*·�±�¶��."�d� )à ­ � )À �D��-Î.&9 * 9��ç�¶�5$c3�� )à � � )À �D��-Î.&9 * 9

<>^QY?SCY?iWV�Y>FIX'^QT�^`e?dmY?dt^`\ OK�|+dfeUp�dt\1V}e?SU\qe-S`pqV�\ÌS ÷ yNdmlQV�rtS�\NhUSQK:=s_§Y?iNSHhU^`\NhUrtyNe?dt^Q\1iN^`rfõ�ej_�^`X8V�rtr.�e)� p�dmYZLyNe-Yndt\ÌTWV�X-Y'dfhUy�r�V�XAiN^QrfõÌ_�^`X:Y'i�^]e-S)Y'iWV�YjRCS�r V�S�\1V�\qõ1ahciqVQhci�S�X?Z±V ! S�X + |�~Q~]O�.bY'SUX'Z V�õ�Z[dfe?e-d rtSQKn;>S�\qh{S`p "! 6ji�S�^QX'SUZ |QK M + T�K:~/AQ~3.A^`_�Y?iNS�dtX��A^`X4�p�� ) SUûdfegYceUK

Ä1 ]Å ����p±��:±¹�WMÆ��9�Q������� æ KänÜ'Ö�Ö}Ý}ÖÝ g ã�ØcÖ�Ü'Ø{×ÕàKUÚß � ê! 3U 6AiNS8"-^Q\Nr ! dt_4$[TWV�X-Y)^`_�Y'i�S�X?S�e-y�rmY+dfe>^ l�dt^QyqeUp5e-^[dmY+X?SUZ±V�dt\Ne8Y'^Ëe-iN^5�

Y'i�S8"-dt_4$ÉTWV�X-Y�K� ßX ÉÕD�ÇÜ éqþ � é Ü'ØLÖ}Ý*��ã�Ø�Ç}Ö�Ö3Ü�ãÉÈùØUÚ]Ø{ÜLÝ]Ø þ Ö�×+áNÖ�ÞcêÚ�¶ê¶Ö�à�ÖÝ + ¨B)� .cK G dmûE�*)QûE\B)�K:B�SUY

¨ )� � � )� �Y� )� � � ©Q� u + PM��|5. SLY'i�SÍRC^^ ødN�S ! S�X�õ�S�h{^`Z[TW^]e-dmY'dt^Q\�^`_L¨ )� y�\qõ�SUXâY'i�dfeâõ�dfegY'X?d y�Y'dt^Q\§K[6AiNSÍõ�S�h{^`Z[TW^]e-dmY'dt^Q\�dfeCl`V�rtdfõ "! p_�^QX+S{ûNV�ZÍTNrtS`p56AiNS�^QX?S�ZÒ2�K!A3A + T§K;2`v/.jdt\ù7Irtrtdt^QY + |�~�2/A3.cK)6ji�S�\�ïV� ) ÌÀ � u Ô u Ô � � u egY'^QTNTNdt\�o[Y'dtZ[S ñ dfeyN\�dt_�^QX'ZÍr ! dt\"Y?S�o`XcV rtSLyN\qõ�S�Xu�*)�KC6AiNdfe)dfe S�h�V�yNe-S:� ) Ì� Ô ¨ ) Ì� Ô Á]) + Ç ò�) Ç�Ç�ÊÉ�� .·pWY?iNS}r�V�Y-Y'S�X+dt\NS ÷ yWV�rtdmY !

Page 19: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

� Ö S�h�V�yqe-S�¨ ) Ì� � + £Z¨])� . ¿ p��>iNdfh'iùdfeHV±e-y Z±V�X-Y?dt\No"V�rtS[e-dt\qh{S�¨B)� dfeâV±e-yNT�SUX?Z±V�X-Y'dt\�o"V�rtS`K�;>S�\qh{SLyN\�dt_�^QX'Zdt\"Y?S�oQX·V dtrtdmY ! _�^Qrtrt^��)e "! pqecV ! pW6AiNSU^`X?S�Z =·Kf|QK MKA + . + T§K>|`|5.A^`_Ix]VQhU^õ V�\Nõ ai�dtX ! V�S{l + |�~32]w�.·K

� Üd k>\qõ�S�XHh{^`\Nõ�dmY'dt^Q\ + 7 � .cp + ¨%�d.�þ ß�àrÜcØLÛbÜ·êj�H��Ø{à ¨B)� � ¨B) U� �(¨B)�Ë� p Û�ã�ØUÜ?Ø + ¨B) U� . ê�ÞÉß þ Ö�à��¶ê�à é Ö é ÞÞ é á�ØUÜ·×[ß�Ü>�¶ê�à�ë"ß°�fØlÝUÖ�ÜCß°�j� �*)QûE\B)�p ß�à5Ý + ¨])ÌË� . ê�Þ)ß�à5Ö�àqê�à þ Ü'Øcß�Þcê�àë8áqÜ'Ö þ Ø{ÞcÞ Kb9n^`\qe-dfõ�S�XbY?iNS>e-S{Y � ^Q_Í�Ðû êe-^ËY'iWV�Y�Î�¨B)� Ô u[_�^`XHV�rtr�Y�p�V�\qõ e?^ËY?iWV�Y*¨B)�Ë� � Ï · ë%� Î�¨B)· dfeQ�ASUrtrIõ�S�ü�\NS�õ5K+ýES*�>V�\"Y+Y'^Ìe-iN^5� Y'iqV�YY'i�SLhU^`ZÍTNrtS�ZÍS�\"Y � U û � KH6ç^ËY'i�dfe+S�\Nõ�p5dt\"l]^�`S[9n^`\qõ�dmY'dt^Q\ + 7 � .cpD�>i�dfhci�Z[S�V�\qe>Y'iqV�Yy�AS}^Q\Nr ! iWVUl]S}Y?^TNX?^�l]SâY?iWV�YZ��� + � . � |â_�^`X+V�rtrl���;û´\]��K

G dmû5p"Y?iNSUX'SU_�^QX'SQp9���;ûE\���p�V�\qõ[rtS{Y��o)� V�\Nõ=��)� S)oQdml]S�\ ]! Y'i�S+RC^"^ ødN�S ! S�Xnõ�S�hU^QZ[T�^`e?dmY?dt^`\ + PK�|5.yN\Nõ�SUXâY?iNdfeâõ�dfegY?X'd y�Y?dt^`\§K V ! FIX?^`TW^]e-dmY'dt^Q\ |`|�K�|UM + T�v�MO3.)dt\Ex]VQh{^�õ + |�~]wQ~3.·p����âdfeHS{ûY'X?SUZ±V�r�dt\ùY?iNS[e-S{YÐ + ï � ì �dí ) � �f��� �X� ì î í ) ñ . + dt\öx]VQh{^�õ1� e}\N^�Y·V�Y'dt^`\�.·p:V�\Nõ e?^ dmYL_�^`rtrt^5�)e}_�X?^`Z 6AiNSU^`X?S�Z |`|QK!A + T§K v`v323.âdt\ Y?iNSe'V�Z[S`�j^QX4�p�Y'iWV�Y + �o)� .)h�V�\ SLX?S�T�X'S�e-S�\"Y?S�õùVQeHV±egY'^hciWV�egY'dfhLdt\"Y?S�oQX·V�rI^�l`S�X+Y'iNS + �:ì í )� .X�ÑeUpD�>iNS�\NhUS + �o)� .dfe>hU^`\]Y'dt\"yN^`yNeUKJ��� + � . � |H_�^Qrtrt^��)eUK

6ç^ôe-S�S�Y?iWV�Y + ¨ ) U� .�dfeËV�e-yNT�SUX?Z±V�X-Y'dt\�o"V�rtS�_�^QXËV�\ ! oQdml]S�\p� ) ûå\ ) p%\N^�Y'S�Y'iqV�Y±9A^Q\qõ�dmY'dt^`\ + 7 � .V�o]V�dt\ÌZ[S�V�\qe%Y'iqV�YJ�AS)^`\Nr ! iWVUl]S)Y'^}T�X'^�l]S+Y?iNdfen_�^`XjV�rtr1� � û´\ � K%6ji�S+r�V�Y?Y?S�X�p�iN^��AS{l]S�X�p�_�^`rtrt^5�+en_�X?^QZ Y?iNSõ�S�hU^QZ[T�^`e?dmY?dt^`\ dt\1Y'i�S�T�X?SUl�dt^Qyqe>TqV�XcV�oQX·V�TNi�K + .n_�^Qrtrt^��)eUK

� þ + ¨B)� . ê�ÞËß�Þ é áNØ{Ü>ãÎÜ'ØsáD�ªê þ ß��Çê¹Ö�à ÖÝ ò�K±k>\qõ�SUX}h{^`\Nõ�dmY'dt^Q\ + 7 ¥ .cpçY?iNS[X'S�e-yNrmY�_�^`rtrt^��)e�õ�dtX'S�h{Y?r ! _�X?^`Z6AiNSU^`X?S�Z AKf| + T§KLM]P�|�.)^`_J,HXcV�ZF`^�l + |�~Q~`P3.·KÍk)\Nõ�SUXâY?iNSÉ^QY'i�S�X�hU^Q\qõ�dmY'dt^`\Ne�egY·V�Y?S�õ5p "! + .CV ^�l]SQp�^Q\NSh�V�\�Y·V°QS + ¨ )� .:Y?^ S�hU^`\]Y'dt\"yN^`yNe��>dmY'iN^Qy�Y)rt^]e-dt\No[o`SU\NSUX·V�rtdmY ! KA;>S�\NhUSQp ]! rt^�h�V�r ^QyN\Nõ�S�õ�\NS�e'eUpqY?iNSâX?S�e-yNrmYV�rfe-^[dt\�Y'iNdfe)h�VQe-Sâ_�^Qrtrt^��)e>_�X?^`Z Y'iNS�h{dmY'S�õ�Y'i�S�^QX'SUZ ^`_Î,CXcV�ZFQ^�lD�ÑeUK

änÜ'Ö�Ö}Ý ÖÝ g ã�ØcÖ�Ü?ØU× àKUÚß � ê�ê! 3U B�SUY + ¨-ìÑ í� . S V�e-y�T�S�X-ø¹X'SUTNrtdfh�V�Y'dt^Q\ ecV�Y'dfe-_ ! dt\No�¨-ìÑ í© Ô � � | ¦^Ò KaS{Ym¨�� � dt\N_ Ñ ¨TìÑ í� K + ¨%�d.�dfe±Vùe-yNTWS�X?Z±V�X?Y?dt\No]V�rtS�_�^`XËV�rtrQ� ) ûh\ ) K V ! FbX?^QT�^]e-dmY?dt^`\ |QKÑv�Kf|UM + T�K |�P/.dt\r,�V�XcV�Y@��VQe}V�\qõ aiNX?S{l]S + |�~Q~�|5.·p + ¨ )� ¿ . + Y·VS`S�\ VQe�V�rtdtZ[dmY�Y?iNX?^`y�o`i�XcV�Y'dt^Q\WV�rfeX.HSUûdfe-Y'e}V�\Nõ�dfe}VEþ�þß]Ý9� þß�ëe-yNTWS�X-øÎZ±V�X-Y'dt\No]V�rtSLSUû�hUS�T�YH^`\ùV[e?S{YCdt\ � KC;>S�\NhUS + ¨ )� ¿ .8dfeHVËe-yNTWS�X-øÎX?SUTNrtdfh�V�Y'dt^Q\ô^`_Îò5p��>dmY'i dt\NdmY?d�V�r�l`V�rty�S\N^Ío`X?S�V�Y'S�XjY'iWV�\ � K:6ji�SâX'S�e-yNrmY)_�^`rtrt^��)e>_�X'^QZ 6AiNSU^`X?S�Z vK�| + d .cK

änÜ'Ö�Ö}Ý}ÖÝ g ã�ØcÖ�Ü'Ø{×ÒàKUjß � ê�ê�ê! 3U B�SUY � )� e'V�Y?dfe?_ ! + vK!2/.cK86AiNdfe>T�X'^hUS�e'e>dfe8Y'i�S�\ V[e-yNTWS�X?Z±V�X?Y?dt\No]V�rtS}_�^`XV�rtr[�*)uûo\B)�p "! FbX?^QT�^]e-dmY?dt^`\ù@}Kf|�dt\ Y'iNS}@)TNT�SU\qõ�dmû5K+=�_I^`\�S}_�^QX?ZËe + � )� ¿ .)VQe>dt\ Y'iNS�TNX?^^Q_b^Q_%6ji�S�^QX'SUZv�Kf| + dtd .)V ^�l`S`pWi�^��ASUl`S�X�p � )� ¿ Ô � � \B)'ø�V�KÑeUK>a"dt\qh{S`p�i�^��ASUl`S�X�pW_�^QXCV�rtr[�*)<û8\B) � )� ¿ ­ ÁB) + ò�) ÇSÉL� .·p � )� ¿

Page 20: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

�`�ZLyNe-Y�S ÷ yWV�r � � \])?øsVKÑeUKÌadt\qh{S`p�^ l�dt^Qyqe-r ! p�Y'i�S[X?dto`i"Y�iWV�\NõEe-dfõ�S[dt\ + v�KªP3.Cdfe�V�rt^��AS�X ^QyN\Nõ�_�^`X � pçY?iNSX?S�e-yNrmY>_�^`rtrt^5�)e>_�X?^`Z 6AiNSU^`X?S�Z v�Kf| + d .·K

änÜ'Ö�Ö}ÝâÖ}Ý;änÜ'Ö·á�Ö�Þcêj�¶ê¹Ö�àoàKU Þ U ayNT�T�^`e?SCY?iWV�YL� �O­ £�Ó8_�^`XAe?^QZ[S�Ó GÔI K�ýES+yqe-Sâ6AiNSU^`X?S�Z |�O"K�A�h + T�KM"~QP/.�dt\Lx"V�hU^�õ + |�~]wQ~3.·Kb6Ai�dfeçY'i�S�^QX'SUZ X'S ÷ y�dtX'S�eçY?iNSn\�^QYcV�Y'dt^Q\ � úQ� + ýe.·pS�>i�dfhci}dt\�dfeçY'iNSne-S{Y�^`_�TNX?^ V dtrtdmY?dtS�eyN\Nõ�SUXt�>iNdfh'i±Y?iNS)T�X'^hUS�e'eWý � dfe%dt\qõ�dfe-Y?dt\NoQyNdfe-iWV rtSâ_�X?^`Z Vâe-y Z±V�X-Y'dt\�o"V�rtSHe-^�Y?iWV�YLÁ�e-yNT ©cë · ë%� Ç ý · ÇZGÔI_�^QX+V�rtr1v + dt\1^`yNX>h�VQe-SQp�vAdfe ^QyN\qõ�S�õ5p�e?^ÉY?iNdt\No`e)e-dtZ[TNrtdt_ ! .·K + h{_sKbT§K:v`OQv[V�\qõ v`OQPÉ^Q_bx]VQh{^�õ + |�~`wQ~/.cK

x]VQhU^õ1� eçX?S�e-y�rmYn|�OK!A�h%egY'yNõ�dtS�e�pQV�Z[^`\�o>^�Y'i�S�X§Y?iNdt\No`eUp�Y'i�S:e-S{Y + dt\}x]VQhU^õ1� e§\N^�Y·V�Y?dt^`\�. ���{Õ ��B0Ö � ú � + ýe.·pV�\Nõ1yN\Nõ�SUX+h{^`\qõ�dmY'dt^Q\qe;�>iNdfhci V�X?S�ecV�Y'dfe-üNS�õ�dt_l�jSHYcV°`S × Y?^ËhU^Q\qe-dfegY)^`_�^QyNX>TNX?^�h{S�e?e-S�e� ì ��í )� � ���f� �P� ì î í )� � £ � ì �dí )� � �f��� � £ � ì î í )� � ± �ÌØ7U � �ÚÙ �?K>;>S�X?SQp Ù � � |�_�^QXQv G ��p5V�\qõ��7Ûö_�^`X;v � �âK + =�_I\�S�h{S�e?e'V�X ! p± � Ø U � h�V�\ S�rt^�h�V�rtd���S�õ Y'^ S ^`y�\qõ�S�õ�pD�>iNdfh'i�Z±V°QS�e>Y'i�dt\No`eCZ[S�e?e?dtSUX y�Y ! dtSUrfõNe+Y'i�SLe'V�ZÍS}X?S�e-yNrmYX.·K)=�\^QY?iNSUX;�A^`X'õ�e�p � dfe8Y?iNS�e?S{Y)^`_�TNX?^ V dtrtdmY ! õ�dfe-Y?X?d y�Y?dt^`\NeCe-^ÍY'iqV�Y>Y'iNS �:ì ��í )� � �f��� �X�tì î í )� V�X?S�ZËV�X-Y'dt\�o"V�rtS�eUp�� �dfe ^`y�\qõ�S�õ S�rt^5� "! Ó�pWV�\qõ�Y?iNS�T�X?^ V dtrtdmY ! ^`_ � dfe8^Q\NSQK

6AiNSU^`X?S�Z |�OK!A + h5.A\N^5� VQe?e-S�X-Y'e)VLX?S�T�X?S�e-S�\]Y·V�Y?dt^`\�^`_�V�rtr§Y?iNSâS�rtSUZ[S�\]Yce8dt\1Y?iNS�e-SUY � dt\�Y'SUX?ZËej^`_�dmY'eSUû"Y'X?S�ZËV�r%TW^`dt\"Y'eUK�=�\ETqV�X-Y'dfh{yNr�V�X�pbV�\ ! e-SUY�Y'iqV�Y}iqVQe�TNX?^ V dtrtdmY ! �US�X?^�_�^`XâY'i�SËS{ûY?X'SUZ±V�rbS�rtS�ZÍS�\"Y'e�^Q_ �V�rfe-^[iqVQe8TNX?^ V dtrtdmY ! �US�X?^Í_�^QX+V�rtr§^QY?iNSUX)SUrtS�Z[SU\"Yce8^`_ � K

;>^��ASUl`S�X�p �h��ÜÐ + ï � ì ��í ) � ���f� �P� ì î í ) ñ . + V�o"V�dt\ódt\öx"V�hU^�õ��Ñe}\�^QYcV�Y'dt^Q\§pbe?SUS±T�K v�M"O�^Q_jY?iWV�Y`�A^`X4�.Z�Y'i�dfe�dfeHY'i�SËe-SUY�^Q_nSUûY?X?S�Z±V�r%T�X?^ V dtrtdmY?dtS�eÉV�Z[^`\]Y�Y?iN^`e?S[Z±VSdt\No � ì �dí ) � �f��� �X� ì î í )}V�Z±V�X-Y?dt\No"V�rtS`K±;>S�\qh{S`p^`y�XC9n^`\Nõ�dmY'dt^Q\ + 7 � .ndfe8TNX?^�l`S�õ5K

Ý ÂÞ ����S���"Yß1�����U��������� K 6AiNS V ^�l]S1iWV�eÍT�X?^�l�dfõ�S�õ V o`SU\NS�XcV�r8Z[S{Y'iN^õ�^Qrt^`o ! _�^`XÍhU^Q\"l]SUX-Y'dt\Noe-SUY)^`_�TNX?^ V dtrtdmY'dtS�eCdt\]Y'^ËT�X'dfh{S�e+V�\qõ�iNS�õ�o`dt\�oÌegY'XcV�Y'S�oQdtS�eUK;N V�\ ! ÷ yNS�egY'dt^`\Ne+^`_�dtZ[T�rtS�Z[SU\"Y·V�Y'dt^Q\�X?SUZ±V�dt\�piN^5�ASUl]SUX�pQdt\�Y?iNS:X?S�V�rtZ ^Q_�_�y�Y'yNX?S:X?S�e-S�V�X'hci�Kb9jV�\�^Q\NSAe-y egY·V�\"Y'd�V�rtr ! rt^5�AS�X�Y?iNS:T�X'dfh{Sn^Q_�Y'iNSne-y�T�S�X�iNS�õ�o`S "!hci�^^`e?dt\�oLV�\[^`T�Y'dtZ±V�rNTNX?S�õ�dfh{Y'dt^Q\ËX?S�o`dt^Q\ � G+X "! i�S�õ�o`dt\No�dt\±V�õNõ�dmY?dt^`\qV�rWZ±V�X@QSUYIY'XcVQõ�S�õ[e-S�h{yNX?dmY'dtS�e � ;>^��õ�^"S�eâ^`\�SËh{^`Z[T�y�Y?S±V�eôV�\qõ dfõôTNX?dfh{S�eâ_�^`XâZ[^QX?SÍSUû^QY?dfh[õ�SUX'dmlQV�Y?dml]S�eâY?iWV�\EhU^Q\"l]S{û�7IyNX?^`TWS�V�\�TWV ! ^�R�e �ý iqV�Y+V ^`y�Y+õ ! \WV�Z[dfh�V�rtr ! VQõ � yNe-Y?S�õ�hU^Q\"Y'dt\�o`SU\qh ! X?S�e?SUX-l]S�e �

G+\�Y?iNSnZÍ^`X?SnegYcV�Y'dfegY?dfh�V�r_�X?^`\]Y�p�dmY�dfeIV�rfe-^Q�A^QX?Y?i}T�yNX'e-yNdt\NoHV>e-Y?X?^`\NoQS�X�X?S�e-yNrmY�Y'iqV�\}^`y�Xb6Ai�S�^`X?SUZ vK�A"pVQe�_�^`rtrt^5�)e�K�=s_N^Q\NSAiqVQeIV)T�X?S�õ�dfh·Y'dt^Q\Édt\"Y'SUX-l`V�r�^`_�Y?iNSn_�^QX'Z + AKÑP/.cp"V�\Nõ}^`\�SAyqe-S�eIh{^`\qe-SUX?lQV�Y?dml]Sjõ�S�rmYcV+i�S�õ�o`dt\NoVQejõ�S�e'h{X?d S�õ5p�Y?iNSHTNX?^ V dtrtdmY ! ^`_ç_¶V�dtrtyNX?SâdfenY'iNSâe'V�Z[S�V�eAY?iNSHTNX?^ V dtrtdmY ! ^Q_çY?iNSHT�X'S�õ�dfh·Y'dt^`\1dt\"Y'SUX-l`V�r�\�^QY

Page 21: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

�`�hU^�l]SUX'dt\�o[Y?iNS�X?S�V�rtd���S�õ1l`V�rtyNS�eUK:=se8X?S�Z±V�dt\qe8yN\qe-^Qrml]S�õ´�>i�SUY'i�S�X8Y'i�dfe>dfe8Y?iNS�h�V�e?Sâdt\�Y?iNS�oQS�\NSUXcV�r�e-SUY-Y'dt\�oË^Q_6AiNSU^`X?S�Z v�Kf|QK

6AiNSUX'Sâdfe)VLrt^QY)^Q_�y�\WV�\qe}�AS�X?S�õ ÷ y�S�egY'dt^Q\qeUKì j�j;��àTõ�á5â

ýES�i�S�X?S}õ�S�V�rb�>dmY'i�Y'i�S}Z[S�VQe-yNX?SâY'iNSU^`X?SUY?dfh}õ�SUYcV�dtrfe+iqV�ldt\NoËY'^±õ�^��>dmY'i�Y'iNS�S�e?e?SU\"Y?d�V�r�e-y�TNX?S�ZLy�Z^`_�hU^Q\qõ�dmY?dt^`\qV�rçSUû�TWS�h·Y·V�Y?dt^`\Ne�pWdt\ÌY'i�S + V�T�TWV�X?SU\"Y>.jV e-S�\NhUS�^Q_IVÉõ�^`Z[dt\qV�Y?dt\No[TNX?^ V dtrtdmY ! õ�dfegY'X?d y�Y'dt^Q\§K:=�_e-yqh'iôV[õ�dfegY'X?d y�Y'dt^Q\o�AS�X?S�Y?^±SUûdfegY�p5^Q\NSLhU^QyNrfõ�p5_�^QX+S{ûNV�ZÍTNrtS`p�yqe-S�Y'iNS�X?S�e-yNrmYCdt\ùFbX?^QT�^]e-dmY?dt^`\äãC=�ø'|{øc| + T�K|�A|�.)^`_A<>SUl`S�y + |�~]w`O�.·K}=s\ù^`y�X�h�V�e-S`p��ASÍe-iWV�rtr:õ�S�ü�\NSÉY?iNSÉX'SUrtSUlQV�\"Y�^ � S�h{Y'eâdt\EV�\WV�rt^Qo ! Y?^�<>SUl]SUy§p y�Y�AS±\�S�S�õ egY'X?^Q\No`SUXÍVQe?e-yNZÍT�Y'dt^Q\qe�Y'^ TNdt\óõ�^��>\ Y'i�S±T�X'^QT�SUX?Y?dtS�e}\NSUS�õ�S�õ�Kù6AiNSUX'SËZ±V !ô S±^QY?iNSUXB�8V ! e}^Q_Y·V�hP"rtdt\No[Y'i�S�Z[S�VQe-yNXcV dtrtdmY ! T�X'^ rtSUZËeUpWe-SUS`pN_�^QX>SUû�V�Z[T�rtS`p5a"X'dmlQVQegY·VUl`V + |�~`~323.·K

õ ��ö Øj÷1Ø ï ØÚøb÷ � ayNT�T�^`e?SCY'iqV�Y å dfe8V}hU^`rtrtS�h{Y?dt^`\1^`_çT�X?^ V dtrtdmY ! õ�dfegY'X?d y�Y'dt^Q\qe8^Q\ É pNV�\qõ±rtSUY�æ SVÉe-y ø��5ø¹üNS�rfõ�^Q_ É K:B�SUY;ý S�VÉXcV�\Nõ�^`Z l`V�X?d�V rtS�e'V�Y?dfe?_ ! dt\�o

e-yNT@eBÌç Á Ç ý ÇHGèI � + � ��|5.+ V3.n=s_"åJdfe)h{^`y�\"Y·V rtSQpqY?iNS�\1S�e?e�e-yNT@eB�ç Á + ý Ç æO.:dfe8Y?iNSâXcV�\Nõ�^`Z lQV�X?d�V rtS  _�^QXL�)i�dfhci+ d .  dfe�æ�øÎZ[S�VQe-yNXcV rtS36+ dtd . Âå­ Á + ý Ç æO.·p��+øsVKÑeUKfpN_�^`X)V�rtr����Vå*6WV�\qõ+ dtdtd .�dt_ � V�rfe-^Ëe'V�Y'dfe-ü�S�e + d .jV�\qõ + dtd .·p�Y'iNSU\ �Âå­' pD�+ø�V�KÑeUKtpq_�^`X)V�rtrl���VåâK+ . G ^`XËoQS�\�S�XcV�r:åâpjS�e?e�e-yNT@*BÌç Á + ý Ç æO.}dfe[Y'i�S XcV�\qõ�^QZ lQV�X?d�V rtS  _�^`XF�>iNdfh'i + d .[V�\qõ + dtd .ÉiN^Qrfõ�p)V�\qõe'V�Y?dfe?_ ! dt\�o

+ dtdtdË��.Ì_�^QXCV�rtr�� ûYåâpNY'i�S�X?S�dfe+VÉe?y e-SUY�é ^Q_�å�pSé h{^`yN\]Y·V rtS`p��Èû�é±pWe-^ÍY?iWV�Y Âz� S�e'eqe-yNT¸ BEê Á ¸ + ý Ç æO.�+øsVKÑeUKFIX'^�l�dfõ�S�õ�Y?iNdfe ÷ yqV�\]Y'dmY ! S{û�dfegYceUp§dmYâdfeUp§^ l�dt^Qyqe-r ! pçyN\�d ÷ yNSÍy�T�Y'^ � ^Qdt\"Yâ\"yNrtr%e-S{YceC^`_�åâK}@)rfe-^Np + dtdtdË�!.

dtZ[T�rtdtS�e + dtdtd .·K =�_?å dfeÍyN\Nõ�^`ZÍdt\WV�Y?S�õ dt\öY'SUX?ZËeÉ^Q_HV e-^`rty�Y?S h{^`\]Y'dt\y�dmY ! pji�^��ASUl`S�X�pnS{û�dfegY'SU\qhUS õ�^"S�eÍ\�^QYV�T�T�S�V�X8Y'^ S}V�e?e?y�X?S�õ�K

j ð ø � ø î Ø ï ØÚøl÷ ìm�Ú��� (+*?*^����$L�¹��$�'{��3�4`�¶�¹����3q*��V!)����$���&{$'� �Z9f�$98(),f*{�[.�*?* ����$L�¶��."� � )� �Í%]�¹��$c3 �{2N¹�Z9ëc O �q�f*â4�$L/�35$�4Í9C����$c3 � )� �f*+.�3 + ÉL� .C-¶* ����$c&?�Ì.�&��¶�t38%�.�,�$�!¹��&C.�,t,��*)QûE\B)<9

Page 22: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

^L_änÜ'Ö�Ö}ÝÍÖ}Ý*änÜ'Ö·á�Ö�Þcêj�¶ê¹Ö�àlì*UÚß3U G dmûo�*)`û�\B)�V�\qõ rtSUY�u Ô ú Ô v Ô �âK�B�SUY�é � ï<í � � í ¥S� �f��� ñL S

e-yqh'i1Y'iqV�Y � )� � S�e?eWe-y�T¸ BEê Á + ò ) Ç5É�� .L� ) ø�V�K e�K:ay�TNT�^`e-S�Y'iWV�Y�í � � � ) KnaS{Yí � î´ï µ �

|A ï í ï � + � ��A�.G ^`X+V�rtr   �`é±pWõ�S�ü�\NS �Á ¸ + ò ) ÇSÉL� ."íCø�V�K e�K "! e?S{Y?Y?dt\No±dmY>Y'^E£ I ^`\1Y'i�S}e?S{Y ê £ �:¸ V�\qõ1Y?^mÁ ¸ + ò ) ÇSÉL� .í+øsV�K eUK%^Q\ �J¸ p%�>iNSUX?S�í G�G(  ^`\ �J¸ V�\Nõ   +Hê £ �J¸ . � u�KnaS{Y

 ìÑ í � e-y�T� ë ë Ñ �Á�ðeñ + ò ) Ç�É�� . � + � �ªv3.

V�\Nõ1rtSUY � �ªò[� | � �f��� �5Òù S}V É �¶øÎZ[S�VQe-yNXcV rtS�TWV�X-Y'dmY'dt^Q\ ^`_ ê e-^ÉY'iqV�Y  ìÑ í � �Á�ðeñ + ò ) Ç5É �d.n^`\ � K:B§S{Yó SHY'iNSâZ[S�V�e?y�X?Sâo`dml`S�\ "!

ó + � . � Á ) Ñ´Eµ � í + � Ç5É�� .C�7Û&ñ}�

adt\NhUS:óhûE\ ) p�dmY)_�^Qrtrt^��)e8Y'iqV�Y� )· ­ ÁTô + ò ) Ç�É · .� Á ) +  ìÑ í Ç5É · .� Á ) + � )� Ç5É · . + � � MK.

VQe Ò � I "! Z[^Q\N^QY?^`\�S�hU^Q\"l]SUX?o`S�\NhUSQp�e-dt\qh{S]ÁB) Ç Â ì �díPÇKÔ ÁB) Ç ò�) Ç°GõI "! VQe?e-yNZ[T�Y'dt^`\�K

� �^�ç���&öË������W�4÷�������� K 6AiNS>V�y�Y?iN^`XÎ�A^`y�rfõÉrtd�`SjY?^CY'iqV�\�ÉF�V�Y?X'dfh@ V dtrtrtdt\No`e?rtS ! p�wCSU^`X?o`S)9A^Q\qegY·V�\�øY'dt\�dfõ�S�e�p V � |�X'\ G rtS�e'V°QS�X�pÍø%yNrtdÎw+y§p56ç^`ZÕ,CyNX-Y4�`p5xQ^]egY'SUdt\�FIV�yNrfe-S�\�pçaWK!N�K�aX?dmlQVQegY·VUl`V�p�N�dfhciWV�S�rçý dfhci"yNXcV�pV�\Nõ Y?iNSÉ@+e'e-^hUd�V�Y?S[7bõ�dmY?^`X�V�\qõ X?S�_�S�X?S�S}_�^QXHSU\NrtdtoQi"Y'SU\Ndt\�o�SUû�hciWV�\NoQS�eUp�V�\qõeN dmY4��db<+V°QV�Yce-y��V±_�^QXCY ! TNdt\�oY'i�S�^`X?dtoQdt\WV�r§l]SUX'e?dt^Q\�^`_�Y?iNS�Z±V�\yNe'h{X?dtT�Y�K

Page 23: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

^��ù*�Q×L�Tù`��à?ú<��û

@)iN\�p§;�Ktp1N�yN\�d¶p§@�Kfp5V�\Nõôa/�>dt\qõ�rtSQplw}K + |�~`~QP`V/.cKyN�dfe?e-T�S�hUdtüNS�õôVQe?e-SUY+TNX?dfhUS}Z[^õ�S�rfeCV�\qõ X?^ yqegYCi�S�õ�o`dt\NoegY'XcV�Y'S�oQdtS�eUK + FbX?S�T�X?dt\"Y>.cK

@)iN\�p:;�KfpWN�yN\�d¶p%@}Ktp%V�\Nõ a/�)dt\Nõ�rtSQpJwLK + |�~`~`P .cK�G+T�Y'dtZËV�rniNS�õ�o`dt\�oôegY'XcV�Y?S�o`dtS�eL_�^`XLZÍdfe'e-TWS�hUdtü�S�õöVQe?e-SUYT�X'dfh{S�Z[^õ�S�rfeUK + FbX?SUTNX?dt\"YX.·K

@ I dmY?øsa�V�iqV�rtd�Vp$øLK + |�~`~QP/.·KI<>^`\�TWV�X·V�Z[SUY?X?dfhnFbX?dfhUdt\�o+^Q_�=�\"Y'SUX?S�egYID>V�Y?SnRCSUX?dml`V�Y?dml]SjaS�h{yNX?dmY'dtS�eUK q þ Ö�à5Ö�×[Ø��ÇÜ{ê þ ßÄ � O3A`w�øgO�P`u�K

@ I dmY?øsa�V�iqV�rtd�Vp8øLK + |�~`~�2/.cKtN V�ûdtZLyNZÍø¹rtd�`SUrtdtiN^^õ�S�egY'dtZ±V�Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_§õ�dfe?hUX?SUY?S�r ! ø�e'V�Z[T�rtS�õÌõ�d�R�yqe-dt^Q\qec�%@Jh{rt^]e-S�õø_�^`X?Z V�T�TNX?^"V�hci + TNX?S�T�X?dt\"Y>.cK

@)\qõ�S�X'e-S�\§pq6CKtpNV�\Nõ1B�yN\Nõ�pqx�K + |�~`~]w�.·K%7%egY'dtZËV�Y'dt\�o[h{^`\"Y?dt\y�^`yqegø¶Y'dtZ[Sâe-Y?^�h'iWVQegY?dfh+l]^`r�V�Y'dtrtdmY ! ZÍ^�õ�SUrfeA^`_§Y?iNSe-iN^QX-Y>Y?S�X?Z dt\]Y'S�X?S�e-Y>X·V�Y'SQK k9Ubq þ Ö�à5Ö�×[Øc�¶Ü·ê þ Þ ÝÍÝ�v�M"v�øsv`w`wK

@>l]SUrtr�V�\NS�õqVp*NEKtpHB�SUl ! pC@�KfpCV�\NõJF�V�XcVQeUp+@}K + |�~`~`O3.·K FbX?dfh{dt\No V�\qõ iNS�õ�o`dt\�o õ�S�X?dml`V�Y'dml`SEe-S�hUyNX?dmY?dtS�e1dt\Z±V�X4`SUY'eJ�)dmY?i�yN\NhUSUX?YcV�dt\�l`^`r�V�Y?dtrtdmY'dtS�e�p ìAá]á��fU"Èùß���ã%U"übê�à5ß�à þ Ø ~ wQv�ød232K

V V�\qõ�d¶p G K V K + |�~Q~323.·K)B§^h�V�r�Y'dtZÍS�dt\ Y'i�S}S�hU^`\�^`Z[S{Y'X?dfh�e)^Q_%hU^Q\"Y?dt\yN^Qyqegø¹Y?dtZ[SLü�\WV�\NhUS��>V�\ùV�TNT�rtdfh�V�Y?dt^`\�Y?^Y?iNS�e-iN^`X-Y-ø¹Y'SUX?Z dt\"Y?S�X?S�egY)XcV�Y?S�õ ! \qV�Z[dfhUeUKAFIX?S�TNX?dt\]Y

V V�\qõ�d¶p G K V KfpWV�\qõ FIiNdtrtrtdtTNe�p5F�Kª9+K V K + |�~`~�2/.·K:7%h{^`\N^QZ[SUY?X?dfh�e>S�egY?dtZ±V�Y?dt^`\�^`_�õ�d�R�yqe-dt^Q\ Z[^õ�SUrfe�K:FbX?S�T�X?dt\"Y�KV V�X?\qõ�^`X4RWøs<>dtS�rfe-S�\�p"G}KÑ78K + |�~`~`w3.·K�FbX?^hUS�e?e-S�eç^Q_\N^`X?Z±V�r`dt\"l]SUX'e?S:wâV�yNe'e-d�V�\�Y ! TWS`p übê�à5ß�à þ Ø8ß�à5Ý>ÕD��Ö þ ã�ß�ÞX�¶ê þ Þ

~ Mq|{ø�P32KV V�X?\qõ�^`X4RWøs<>dtS�rfe-S�\�p�G}Kª7jKfpV�\qõËai�S�TNiqV�X'õ�p�<�K + |�~`~�2/.cKb@+oQo`X?S�o]V�Y?dt^`\±V�\qõÉZ[^�õ�S�rNh{^`\qegY?X'yNh{Y?dt^`\[_�^`X�l]^Qr�V�Y'dtrmø

dmY ! Z[^�õ�S�rfeUKA9A@ G �A^`X4dt\�o[TWV�T�S�X>\N^�K)|�upWk)\�dml]SUX'dfe-dmY ! ^`_�@CV�X?iyNe�KV V�rtr¶p"9+KÑ@�KfpQV�\qõLDj^`ZËV�pQ@}K + |�~`~�MM.·Kba"Y'^hciqVQegY'dfh%l]^Qr�V�Y?dtrtdmY ! ^`T�Y?dt^`\}TNX?dfh{dt\NoNp k9U&übê�à5ß�à þ ê¶ß���ß�à5Ý�ý é ß�à��¶êÚ�Îß��¶ê�ÿQØ

ì>à5ß��ªÚQÞcê�Þ ~Íþ O�2Q~�øsPQu]w"KV V�X?S�\ r�V�Y-Y�p<wLK =·K + |�~]w°2/.·K ÕWê�×Éêj�fß�Ü{êj�¶ÚSâÉÕ�Øc� ÝPãÎÞcê�×LêÚ�tß�Ü·êÚ�ÇÚ ß�à�Ý�ÿcà���Ø{Ü{×[ØcÝ�ê¶ß���Ø�ìCÞcÚQ×+áD�ÎÖ��¶ê þ Þ + 9A^Q\qe-yNrmYcV�\]Yce

V yNX?S�V�y§p�<>S>�{ø%^`X4�.cKV S�X?o`Z±V�\§p�øLK�{�KtpQwCX?y�\qõ ! p V KÑRLKtp>V�\qõ ý dtS�\NSUX�pZ{�K + |�~Q~`P/.cKhwCSU\NSUX·V�r)TNX?^`TWS�X-Y'dtS�eË^`_C^`T�Y?dt^`\úTNX?dfh{S�eUp k9U

übê�à5ß�à þ Ø ® |�OQwQv�ø'|�P�|�u�K

Page 24: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

^X^V d N "! p V K7N�KfpnV�\qõ a9|�X?S�\qe-SU\§pJN�K + |�~`~`O3.·K�N V�X?Y?dt\No]V�rtS1S�egY'dtZ±V�Y'dt\Noù_�y�\qh{Y?dt^`\NeÍ_�^QXÍõ�dfe'h{X?SUY'SUr ! ^ e-S�X-l]S�õ

õ�d�R5yNe-dt^`\�TNX?^�h{S�e?e-S�eUK�� ØUÜ·à5Ö é �j�ªê � |�w�øsvQ~�KV d N "! p V K!N�Kfp�V�\qõ±a9|�X'SU\qe-S�\�p%N�K + |�~`~QP`V3.·K:G+\ËS�egY'dtZ±V�Y'dt^`\[_�^QXnõ�dfe?hUX?SUY?S�r ! ^ e-S�X-l]S�õËõ�d�R5yNe-dt^`\qec�%VHX?S{l�dtSc��K

g ã�ØUÜ�U>ÕD�ÎÖ þ ã�ß�ÞX�Çê þ äAÜ?Ö þ U ~ M"~�øsOQPKV d N "! p V K7NEKtp�V�\Nõ a9|�X'SU\qe-S�\�pÎNEK + |�~`~QP .·K±@ i ! T�SUX ^`rtdfhËõ�d�R�yqe-dt^Q\EZ[^�õ�S�r%_�^`X�egY'^hP�T�X?dfhUS�eUK ü%ê�à5ß�à þ Ø

ß�à�Ý[ÕD�ÎÖ þ ã�ß�ÞX�Çê þ Þ � A`O�øÎMq|�KV r�VQhPWp G KtpqV�\qõ�a�h'iN^`rtS�eUpDN�K + |�~`wQv3.·Kn6AiNSHT�X?dfhUdt\NoÍ^`_�^`T�Y'dt^Q\qe)V�\qõ1h{^`X?T�^QXcV�Y'SHrtd�V dtrtdmY'dtS�eUp k%U1ä>Ö��ªêj��ULq þ Ö�àDU

�1� P`v]w�øsP`O�MNKV ^`rtrtS�X'e-rtSUl�p�6CKfp9Ai�^`y�p�DâK øÉKtpV�\NõF,HX?^Q\NS�X�pM,LK G K + |�~Q~/A�.·Kb@CD89j; ZÍ^�õ�SUrtdt\No�dt\ G dt\qV�\qh{S`p k%U�q þ Ö�à5Ö�×ËØc�¶Ü·ê þ Þ

®�~ O�øgO�~�K9:l�dmYcV�\Nd>=h�pçxNK + |�~`~323.·K<N�dt\NdtZ[d��Udt\No�SUû�TWS�h·Y'S�õ rt^]e?eC^Q_biNS�õ�o`dt\�o�dt\�dt\NhU^QZ[TNrtS{Y'SÍV�\qõ h{^`\qegY?X·V�dt\NS�õ�Z±V�X4`S{YceUp

T�X'SUTNX?dt\"Y�K

9:l�dmYcV�\Nd>=h�pçx�Kfp5V�\Nõe,âV�X·V�Y@��VQeUp�=·K + |�~`~3A3.·KC9n^`\]l]SUû õ�yWV�rtdmY ! dt\�h{^`\qegY?X·V�dt\NS�õ T�^QX?Y?_�^Qrtdt^Ì^`T�Y'dtZ[d���V�Y'dt^Q\§p ì>àqà�Uìná]áD��U�äAÜ?Ö/Ücß/Ü5U ~ wQP`w5�92�|52K9:l�dmYcV�\Nd>=h�p:x�KfpIV�\Nõ�,âV�XcV�Y@��V�eUpI=cK + |�~Q~`v3.·K ;>S�õ�oQdt\No ^`_8h{^`\]Y'dt\NoQS�\]YÍhUr�V�dtZËe*�)dmY?ióh{^`\qegY?X·V�dt\NS�õ T�^QX?Y?_�^Qrtdt^]eUpì>àqà�U;ìAá]áD��U�änÜ'Ö/Ücß/Ü5U æ P]O3A�øsP�2�|QK9:l�dmYcV�\Nd>=h�p�xNKtpçV�\qõe,�V�XcV�Y@��VQeUp�=·K + |�~`~Q~/.cK}G+\ôR ! \WV�Z[dfhTN�S�V�e?y�X?S�eC^`_:D8dfe�K�6ç^1V�TNT�S�V�XHdt\ ü%ê�à5ß�à þ ØËß�à5Ý

ÕD�ÎÖ þ ã�ß�ÞX�Çê þ Þ K9:l�dmYcV�\Nd>=h�p:x�KfpIFIiWV�Z1pb;�KfpIV�\Nõó6ç^`y%��d¶p%<�K + |�~Q~]w3.cK ayNTWS�X-øÎX?SUTNrtdfh�V�Y'dt^Q\ödt\ a"Y?^�h'iWVQegY?dfhHã%^Qr�V�Y'dtrtdmY ! N�^õ�S�rfe

y�\qõ�SUXCF�^`X-Y?_�^`rtdt^Ì9n^`\Ne-Y?XcV�dt\"Y'eUpNY'^ËV�T�T�S�V�X)dt\ ìná]áD��U�äAÜ?Ö/Ücß/Ü5UZk%U9:l�dmYcV�\Nd>=h�p:xNKtp%FIiWV�Z�p%;�Ktp%V�\qõö6ç^`y%��d¶p%<�K + |�~Q~`~/.cK�@ hUrt^]e-S�õ _�^QX'Z e-^`rty�Y'dt^Q\óY?^ Y?iNSËTNX?^ rtS�Z ^`_>e-y�T�S�X-ø

X?S�T�rtdfh�V�Y'dt^`\ y�\qõ�S�X8Y'XcV�\NecV�h{Y?dt^`\ hU^`egY�p ü%ê�à5ß�à þ ØLß�à5ÝÍÕD�ÎÖ þ ã�ß�ÞX�Çê þ Þ æ v]O�øgO�MNK9:l�dmYcV�\Nd>=h�p5x�KfpWV�\qõ a"TNdml`VS�p�wLK + |�~`~323.·K:N V�û�dtZ[d��Udt\NoËY?iNSâTNX?^ V dtrtdmY ! ^`_IVÉT�SUX?_�S�h·Y>iNS�õ�o`SQpqTNX?S�T�X?dt\"Y�KRâVQh{yN\�iWV�øs9jVQegY'SUrtrtS`p%RLK�� G rt^`X?SU\qegø}{�Z[dtX?^`y�pbRLK + |�~32QP/.·K 7begY'dtZ±V�Y'dt^`\ ^Q_AY'iNS±h{^ScYËh{dtS�\]Yce}^Q_>V�õ�d�R�yqe-dt^`\

_�X'^QZ õ�dfe?h{X'S{Y'S�^ e-S�X-lQV�Y'dt^Q\qeUp ÕD��Ö þ ã�ß�ÞX�¶ê þ Þ �8þ AQP`v5�%A°2�MNKRâV�\�dtS�rfe?e-^`\�p�xNK + |�~`~�MM.cKËa]Y'^�h'iWV�e-Y?dfhÍl`^`r�V�Y'dtrtdmY ! dt\EVQe?e-SUYâTNX?dfhUS�e���7%egY?dtZ±V�Y?dt^`\e�>dmY'i�e-dtZLyNr�V�Y'S�õùZ±V�ûdtZLyNZ

rtd�QS�rtdtiN^"^�õ5p k9Ubq þ Ö�à5Ö�×[Øc�¶Ü·ê þ Þ Ä � v`w`O�ø¹M"uQu�K

Page 25: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

^PxRCS�r V�SU\§p G KfpCV�\qõ a�h'iWVQh'iNSUX'ZËV ! SUX�p)ý K + |�~`~�MM.·K @)X dmY?X·V�o`S�V�\qõú_�X?S�S�rty�\qh'i'�)dmY?i ^`y�\qõ�S�õ X?dfe _�^`X

y�\ ^QyN\Nõ�S�õ h{^`\]Y'dt\y�^`yNe+T�X?^�hUS�e?e?S�e Èùß���ã%Uªü%ê�à5ß�à þ Ø � v�M"v�øsv�M/2�KRCS�r V�SU\§p G KfpWV�\Nõ a�h'iWV�hciNSUX?Z±V ! S�X�p�ý K + |�~`~`O3.cKn6AiNS�S{û�dfegY'SU\qhUS�^`_�V e?^Qrty�Y?S�r ! h{^`\]Y'dt\y�^`yNe)rt^�h�V�rçZËV�X-Y'dt\�ø

o]V�rtS�Z[S�VQe-yNX?S�e�K ì>àqà�UªìAá`áD��U�äAÜ'Ö3Ücß/Ü�U ® ~/AQP�øs~�MOKRCS�r V�SU\§p G Kfp�V�\Nõ1a�h'iWVQh'iNSUX'ZËV ! SUX�p�ý K + |�~`~QP/.cK:6AiNS+lQV�X?d�V�\NhUS{øÎ^`T�Y'dtZ±V�r�Z±V�X-Y?dt\No"V�rtSCZ[S�VQe-yNX?S+_�^QXjhU^Q\"Y'dt\�ø

y�^`yqe8TNX?^hUS�e?e-S�eUK�� Ø{Ü{à�Ö é �j�ªê ~ 2�|·øc|�u]OKRCS�r V�SU\§p G KfpKN�^`\qV�Y�p"F�Ktpa�h'iWV�hciNSUX?Z±V ! S�X�p`ý Ktpa�h'iK�AS�d��US�X�pMN�K`V�\qõ[a"Y?X'dfh@`SUX�p9+K + |�~Q~]w�.·K�ýES�dtoQi"Y'S�õÉ\�^`X?Z

dt\�S ÷ yqV�rtdmY?dtS�eHV�\qõ1i�S�õ�oQdt\NoËdt\�dt\NhU^QZ[TNrtS{Y'S�Z±V�X4`S{YceUK ü%ê�à5ß�à þ ØLß�à5ÝÉÕD��Ö þ ã�ß�ÞX�¶ê þ Þ � |52�|·ø}A�A`wKRCy�YÍSQpWRLK + |�~`~`P3.·K ÇHÚQà5ß�×Éê þ ìHÞcÞUØc�ÎäAÜ·ê þ ê�àë g ã�ØcÖ�Ü·Ú + A�\qõ1S�õ�K�. + FbX?dt\qh{SUY?^`\D.cKRCy�YÍSQpWRLKtpWV�\qõ F�V�\�p�xNK + |�~`~]w�.·K:@)\�^�l]SUX?ldtSc� ^`_�l`V�rtyNS}V�Y>X?dfe�p k9U2Ç}Ø{Ü·ê�ÿ�ß��¶ê�ÿQØ{Þ ��� v[w5�"M]~�KR !� l�dto�pâF�KfpCV�\qõ ;>yWV�\�oNpâ9+K ø G K + |�~�232/.cK <>^Q\N\NSUo"V�Y'dml]So�AS�V�rmY?i§pHV e-S�\qh{Sù^`_}V�X dmY?XcV�o`SQpHV�\qõ _�S�V�e?d rtS

h{^`\qe-y�Z[T�Y?dt^`\�TNr�V�\NeUp§è ØUÿ°Uªübê�à5ß�à þ ê¶ß��5ÕD� é Ý�ê¹Ø{Þ � v`w`w�øÎM"u�|QK7 S�X?rtSUdt\§p�7jKfpqV�\qõ�x]VQh{^�õ�pWx�K + |�~`~]w�.·KAG+\ÌY'iNSâXcV�\�o`SH^`_�^QT�Y?dt^`\qe8TNX?dfh{S�eUp ü%ê�à5ß�à þ ØLß�à5ÝÉÕD��Ö þ ã9U � |�v�|{ø'|UM"uK7Ir�,âV�X?^QyNd¶p<�Kfp]x`S�V�\ r�V�\Nh{ø�Fbdfh ÷ yL=SQp%N�Kfp]V�\Nõ[aiNX?S{l]S`pa�Kª7jK + |�~Q~323.·KbD8^ yqegY?\NS�e?eI^`_NY'i�S V r�V�hPLV�\qõ[ahci�^`rtS�e

_�^`X?ZLyNr�Vp Èôß���ã%Uªübê�à5ß�à þ Ø � ~`v�ø'|�A�P�K7Irb,�V�X?^`yNd¶pq<�KqV�\qõ C y�S�\NSc�`p�N�K øs9CK + |�~`~`O3.·K%R ! \WV�Z[dfhCTNX?^Qo`XcV�Z[ZÍdt\No[V�\Nõ�T�X'dfh{dt\NoÍ^`_�h{^`\]Y'dt\NoQS�\]Y+hUr�V�dtZËe

dt\ V�\�dt\qh{^`Z[T�rtSUY?S�Z±V�X4`SUY�p Õ8ÿ5ìTÈ k9U��bÖ�à��¶Ü�U Û áD��U æ�æ AQ~�øsPQP�KG rt^`X?S�\Ne-ød{�Z[dtX?^`y§p�RLK + |�~`~Qv/.·KËG+\ùS�egY'dtZ±V�Y'dt\�o1Y'i�SËõ�d�R�yqe-dt^`\Eh{^ScYËh{dtS�\]Y}_�X'^QZ õ�dfe'h{X?SUY'SÍ^ e-SUX?lQV�Y?dt^`\qeUp k9U

ìná]áD��U�äAÜ?Ö/Ü�U æ� wQ~`u�ød2Qu�MNKGJI^`rtrtZ[SUX�pW;�KqV�\Nõ B§SUy�QS�X-Y�p�F�K + |�~`~323.·Kn7ÎY[hUdtSU\"Y)iNS�õ�o`dt\�o��j9n^]egY8l]SUXce-yNe>e-iN^`X-Y?_¶V�rtr§X'dfeWKnFbX?SUTNX?dt\"Y�KGJI^`rtrtZ[SUX�pW;�KqV�\Nõ B§SUy�QS�X-Y�p�F�K + |�~`~`~3.·K C yqV�\"Y?dtrtSL;>S�õ�oQdt\No�p übê�à5ß�à þ Ø�Õ���Ö þ ã�ß�ÞX� æ AQO�|·ø}A`w�v�KGJI^`rtrtZ[SUX�p�;�K�V�\qõùahciK�ASUd���S�X�p1N�K + |�~`~�|5.·K+;>S�õ�o`dt\�oÌ^`_:9n^Q\"Y'dt\�o`SU\"Y�9nr�V�dtZ[e+y�\qõ�S�XC=�\qhU^QZ[TNrtS{Y'S�=s\N_�^`X?Z±V�ø

Y?dt^`\§pbdt\ódt\ ìAá`áD�ªê¹ØcÝ ÕD��Ö þ ã�ß�ÞX�¶ê þ ì)à�ß��ªÚQÞcê�Þ pIS�õNeUK�N�KÑ;�K @�KIRâVUl�dfeÉV�\NõöDâKÑxNKI7Irtrtdt^QY + wC^`X'õ�^Q\ V�\qõV X?S�VQh'iD.cK

GJI^`rtrtZ[SUX�p�;�KçV�\NõEa"^`\qõ�S�X?Z±V�\N\§pçRLK + |�~32QP/.cKÍ;>S�õ�o`dt\�o1^`_:\N^Q\�ø¹X'S�õ�y�\qõqV�\"Y}hU^Q\"Y'dt\�o`SU\"Y�hUr�V�dtZËeUpçdt\E;>dtrfõ�S{ø X·V�\qõ5pý K�V�\qõmN VQegøs9A^QrtS�rtr¶p�@�K + S�õ�eP. �%Ö�à��¶Ü·êHÜ é �Çê¹Ö�àqÞ;��Ö]Èôß°�Çã�Ø{×Ëß°�¶ê þ ß°��q þ Ö�à5Ö�×Éê þ Þ p"T§KtAQu`O�ødA3AQvK

Page 26: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

^ �G ^]egY'SUX�pqRLKªF�KfpWV�\Nõ <>S�rfe-^Q\§p�RLK V K + |�~`~`P3.·K89n^`\]Y'dt\y�^`yNe+X?S�hU^`X'õ V�e ! Z[T�Y'^QY?dfh�e>_�^`X8X'^Qrtrtdt\No±ecV�Z[TNrtSâl`V�X?d�V�\qh{S

S�e-Y?dtZ±V�Y?^`X'eUp q þ Ö�à�Ö�×ËØc�¶Ü·ê þ ß Ä � |�v`~�øgw�MNK

wâV�rtr�V�\"Y�p�@}KÑDâK + |�~`~`P3.·K 7ÎYËh{dtS�\]Y Z[S{Y'i�^�õ ^`_�Z[^`Z[SU\"Y'ea�>dmY?i V�T�TNrtdfh�V�Y'dt^Q\ Y'^ S�e-Y?dtZ±V�Y?dt\No egY'^�h'iWV�e-Y?dfhõ�d�R5SUX?S�\"Y?d�V�rçS ÷ yWV�Y?dt^`\Ne + TNX?SUTNX?dt\"YX.·K

;+V�\Ne?SU\§p�BIKªF�KfpqV�\qõ ahci�S�dt\�"Z±V�\�p5x�KÑ@�K + |�~`~`O3.cK V V�hPËY'^ÉY?iNSâ_�y�Y'yNX?S��Jw+S�\NSUXcV�Y'dt\�oËZÍ^`Z[SU\"Y8dtZ[T�rtdfh�V�Y?dt^`\Ne_�^`X>hU^Q\"Y'dt\"yN^Qyqegø¹Y?dtZ[STN V�X4Q^�l�T�X'^hUS�e'e-S�e�p q þ Ö�à5Ö�×[Øc�¶Ü·ê þ ß Ä�æ w�P]w�ø�2`u�MNK

;+V�\Ne?SU\§p�BIKªF�Kfp�a�h'iNSUdt\�ZËV�\§pNx�KÑ@�Kfp�V�\qõ±6ç^`y%��d¶p�<�K + |�~`~QP/.cKb=gõ�S�\]Y'dtüqh�V�Y?dt^`\1V�\qõ[dtZ S�õ�õqV dtrtdmY ! ^`_bN V�X@Q^�lõ�d�R5yNe-dt^`\�Z[^�õ�S�rfe8_�X?^`Z õ�dfe?hUX?SUY?SâY'dtZ[S�õNV�Y·VpqTNX?SUTNX?dt\"Y�K

;+V�X?X?dfe-^`\§p�x�K!N�KtpâV�\Nõ?,CX'SUTqeUpHRLK!N�K + |�~]w�~/.cK N V�X-Y'dt\�o"V�rtS�e V�\Nõ V�X dmY?XcV�o`Sôdt\JZLyNrmY?dtT�SUX'dt^õ e-S�hUy�X?dmY'dtS�eZ±V�X4`SUY'eUp k%U�q þ Ö�à�U g ã�ØcÖ�Ü{Ú ~� v32�|{øÎM]u32K

;+V�X?X?dfe-^`\§pbx�K[N�KfpIV�\qõ Fbrtdfe10V�p:a�K�DHK + |�~32�|�.·K8N V�X-Y?dt\No"V�rtS�eÉV�\Nõ egY'^hciWV�egY'dfh±dt\]Y'S�oQXcV�rfe}dt\�Y'iNS[Y?iNSU^`X ! ^Q_h{^`\"Y?dt\y�^`yqe8Y'XcVQõ�dt\No�p ÕD�ÎÖ þ ULäAÜ'Ö þ UªìAá]áD��U ��� A|�O�øLAQPQu�K

;>^ e?^Q\§p�RLK�wLK + |�~`~323.·KFã:^Qr�V�Y?dtrtdmY ! Z[dfe?e-T�S�hUdtüqh�V�Y?dt^`\§pN^QT�Y'dt^Q\�T�X?dfhUdt\NoÍV�\NõÌe-yNTWS�X?X?S�TNrtdfh�V�Y?dt^`\�ld�V}hU^QyNT�rtdt\NoNKì>àqà�U;ìAá]áD��U�änÜ'Ö/Ücß/Ü5U � |�~`v5�%A�u]OK

;>^`_�Z±V�\�\§pj<�KfpAFIr�V�Y'SU\§p87jKfpAV�\Nõúa�h'iK�AS�d��US�X�p�N�K + |�~`~3A3.cK G+T�Y'dt^`\ TNX?dfh{dt\No�yN\qõ�S�X[dt\NhU^QZ[TNrtS{Y'S�\�S�e?eÌV�\qõegY'^hciqVQegY'dfhHl]^Qr�V�Y'dtrtdmY ! p Èôß���ã%Uªübê�à5ß�à þ Ø ~ |�OQv�øc|�2]wK

;>yNrtr¶p�xNKª9+K + |�~`~`w3.·K Û áD�¶ê¶Ö�àqÞ@â�ü é � é Ü'Ø{Þ�ß�à5Ý Û �Çã�ØUÜ�Ç}Ø{Ü·ê�ÿ�ß��¶ê�ÿQØ{Þ + v�X'õ�7%õ5K�.·K + FbX?S�\]Y'dfh{SL;+V�rtr .cK;>yNrtr¶pçxNKª9CKtpçV�\qõ ý iNdmY?S`p§@�K + |�~32`w3.cK�6AiNSLTNX?dfhUdt\�o�^`_%^QT�Y?dt^`\qeC^`\ôVQe?e-SUY'eZ�)dmY?iôegY?^�hciqVQegY'dfh}l`^`r�V�Y'dtrtdmY'dtS�eUp k9U

übê�à5ß�à þ Ø � ~ A�2�|{øsvQu`uKx]VQhU^õ�pqxNK + |�~`wQ~/.cK �%ß°� þ{é �WÕD��Ö þ ã�ß�ÞX�¶ê� é Ø}Øc�ÎänÜ'Ö/Üc� þØ{×ËØ{Þ�Ý]Ø�Èùß�Ü>�¶ê�à�ë"ß°�fØ{Þ pNB§S�h{Y�K%<�K�N V�Y?i§Knw�|{M + a"TNX?dt\NoQS�X-ø

ã%S�X?r�V�oM.·Kx]VQhU^õ�p�x�KfpqV�\Nõ ai�dtX ! V�S{l5pW@}KW<�K + |�~�2]w3.cK � ê�×Éêj� g ã�ØcÖ�Ü·ÚZÝ{Ö�ÜâÕD�ÎÖ þ ã�ß�ÞX�Çê þ änÜ'Ö þ ØUÞcÞUØ{Þ p + a"TNX?dt\NoQS�X-øÉã%SUX'r�V�oM.cKx]VQh ÷ yNdtSUX�pç78KtpçF�^`rfe-^Q\§p�<�K§V�\qõùD8^`e?e?d¶pçF�KÑ78K + |�~Q~�MK.·K V V ! S�e-d�V�\�V�\WV�r ! e-dfeH^`_:e-Y?^�h'iWVQegY?dfh}l]^`r�V�Y'dtrtdmY ! ZÍ^�õ�SUrfe

k9U �8é ÞcUbq þ Ö�à�UçÕD��ß��Çê�ÞX��U �%~ v`w�|P��v32Q~�K,âV�XcV�Y4��V�e�pN=cK + |�~Q~`P/.cK�� Ø þ � é Ü'ØUÞ�Ö�àe��ã�Ø�Èôß���ã�Ø{×Ëß��Çê þ Þ}ÖÝTübê�à5ß�à þ Ø + 9jDQN Z[^`\�^`oQX·V�TNi e-SUX'dtS�eP.·K,âV�XcV�Y4��V�e�pN=cKfpWV�\Nõ_{�iWV�^�p��LK + |�~`~�2/.cK V V ! S�e?d�V�\�VQõNV�T�Y?dml]S�T�^QX?Y?_�^Qrtdt^Ë^`T�Y?dtZ[d���V�Y'dt^Q\§KAFIX'SUTNX?dt\"Y�K

Page 27: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

^X¹,âV�XcV�Y4��V�e�p�=·KtpçV�\qõ�,C^`y§p�a�K!wLK + |�~Q~`P/.cKÉG+\�Y?iNSLTNX?dfhUdt\�o�^Q_nh{^`\]Y'dt\NoQS�\]Y}h{r�V�dtZËeCyN\Nõ�S�XâhU^Q\qegY'XcV�dt\]YceUp ì>àqà�Uìná]áD��U�äAÜ?Ö/Ücß/Ü5U Ä v/A|X��vQP`~K,âV�XcV�Y4��V�e�p�=cKfpNV�\Nõ´,C^`y�pWa�K!wLK + |�~Q~32/.cK:;)S�õ�oQdt\No[@)Z[S�X?dfh�V�\1h{^`\]Y'dt\NoQS�\]Y+h{r�V�dtZËe:�>dmY?i1hU^`\NegY'XcV�dt\�S�õ�T�^QX?Y?_�^�ø

rtdt^`e�p ü%ê�à5ß�à þ ØLß�à5ÝÍÕD��Ö þ ã�ß�ÞX�¶ê þ Þ ~ A�|�O�ø}AQO�2K,âV�XcV�Y4��V�e�pL=·KtpÍV�\Nõ a"iNX?SUl`S`p[a�Kª7jK + |�~`~�|�.·K�� Ü'Ö�ÛIàqê¹ß�à ÈôÖ°�¶ê¹Ö�à ß�à5ÝúÕD�ÎÖ þ ã�ß�ÞX�Çê þ �%ß�� þ{é � é Þ + A�\Nõ 7%õ5K�.+ aTNX?dt\�o`S�X-ø³ã:SUX?r�V�oM.cK,CS�e?e-rtS�X�p3NEKtp`V�\NõÉaM|QX?S�\Ne?SU\§p/N�K + |�~`~�2/.·KI7%egY'dtZËV�Y'dt\�o+S ÷ yqV�Y?dt^`\qe V�e-S�õ�^Q\}SUdto`S�\�_�y�\qh{Y?dt^`\NeI_�^QX�V)õ�dfe'h{X?SUY'SUr !

^ e-S�X-l]S�õ�õ�d�R�yNe?dt^Q\ TNX?^�h{S�e?eUp�Y'^±V�TNT�S�V�X>dt\�� ØUÜ·à5Ö é �j�ªê K,CXcV�ZFQ^�l5pçRLKªGLK + |�~`~QP/.·KÍGCT�Y'dt^Q\WV�r%õ�S�hU^QZ[T�^`e-dmY'dt^`\Ne�^`_ne-yNTWS�X?Z±V�X?Y?dt\No]V�rtS�e�V�\Nõùi�S�õ�oQdt\No�dt\ùdt\qh{^`Z[T�rtSUY'S

e-S�h{yNX?dmY ! Z±V�X4`S{YceUK äAÜ?Ö/Ücß/Ü5U g ã�ØcÖ�Ü·Ú è Øc�tß���U;übê¹Øc�fÝ�ÞcU ���p® M"OQ~�ø¹Mw�~�K

, Iyqh'iNrtS�X�p>k�K:V�\Nõ a9|QX?SU\qe-S�\�p;N�K + |�~Q~323.·K qOá{á�Ö�à5Ø{à��¶ê¶ß��düçß�×LêÚ�ªê¶ØUÞ ÖݱÕD��Ö þ ã�ß�ÞX�¶ê þ änÜ'Ö þ ØUÞcÞUØ{Þ K a"TNX?dt\NoQS�X-øã%S�X?r�V�oNKBçV�yNX?SU\"Y�pWxNKÑF�KtpWV�\Nõ FIiWV�Z1pW;�K + |�~Q~`~3.·K:R ! \WV�ZÍdfhâTNX?^`oQXcV�Z[Z[dt\�oËV�\qõ�Z[S�V�\�ø¹lQV�X?d�V�\NhUS�iNS�õ�o`dt\�oNp ü%ê�à5ß�à þ Ø

ÕD�ÎÖ þ ã�ß�ÞX� æ 2Qv�øc|Q|�uKB�^Np�@�K ý K + |�~32`w3.cKnaSUZ[dmøÎTqV�XcV�ZÍSUY'X?dfh)yNT�T�SUX ^QyN\qõ�eA_�^`Xn^`T�Y'dt^Q\ÌTNX?dfhUS�ejV�\NõËSUû�TWS�h·Y'S�õËTqV ! ^�R5e�p k%Ueübê�à�ß�à�ã

þ ê¹ß��Dq þ Ö�à5Ö�×Lê þ Þ �8þ v]w�v�øsv�2]w"KB�^NpC@�K ý K + |�~32�2/.·KÿN V�ûdtZLyNZ rtd�`SUrtdtiN^"^�õ S�egY'dtZ±V�Y'dt^Q\ ^`_�o`SU\NSUX·V�rtd���S�õ =ÎY'^óTNX?^�h{S�e?e-S�e��)dmY?iJõ�dfe'h{X?SUY'SUr !

e'V�ZÍTNrtS�õ1õqV�YcV�K q þ Ö�à5Ö�×ËØc�¶Ü·ê þEg ã�Ø{Ü5U � AQv�|·ø}A�MwKN�S�X-Y'^Q\§pçDHK�9+K + |�~]w�v/.cK}6Ai�S�^`X ! ^`_%XcV�Y'dt^`\qV�r�^`T�Y'dt^`\NeHTNX?dfhUdt\�oNp�� Øc�j��k9UÎq þ Ö�à�UËß�à5ÝbÈùØcß�Þ é Ü'Ø{×[ØUà��nÕ þ êHU �+ aTNX?dt\�oM.H|UMq|·øc|�2`v�K<>SUl`S�y§pWxNK + |�~`w`O�.·K Çâê�Þ þ Ü'Øc��ØcãfáNß�Ü?ß�×ËØc��Ø{Ü�Èôß�Üc�Çê�à�ë]ß��tØ{ÞcU + <>^QX?Y?i�ø�;)^Qrtr�V�\Nõ�p�@)ZËegY'SUXcõNV�Zm.cKFIiWV�Z1p�;�K�V�\qõE6ç^`y%��d¶pI<�K + |�~Q~`P3.·K[=s\"Y?S�X-Y'SUZ[T�^QXcV�rbS ÷ yNdtrtd X?dty�Z X?dfe4 TNX?S�Z[d�VÌdt\ V1egY'^hciWV�egY'dfhÍl]^Qr�V�Y?dtrtdmY !

Z[^õ�SUr¶p Èùß���ã%U"übê�à5ß�à þ Ø Ä A�|�O�ø}A�v`PKFIiWV�Z1pC;�Kfp)D8i�S�dt\Nr IV�\qõ�S�X�pâ6CKfp+V�\qõ a�h'iK�AS�d��US�X�pyN�K + |�~Q~32/.cK N�S�V�\�ø¹lQV�X?d�V�\NhUSôi�S�õ�o`dt\Noö_�^QX�hU^Q\"Y'dt\"yN^Qyqe

T�X'^hUS�e'e-S�e��:<)S>� TNX?^"^`_Çe>V�\qõ�SUûNV�Z[TNrtS�eUp ü%ê�à5ß�à þ ØLß�à5ÝÍÕD�ÎÖ þ ã�ß�ÞX�Çê þ Þ ~ |�w�v�ø'|�~32KDjS�\WV�yNrmY�p�78KtpV�\qõÍ6�^Qy��Ud¶p<�K + |�~Q~`P3.·K%GCT�Y'dt^Q\[i�S�õ�o`dt\No�V�\qõLdtZ[TNrtdfh{dmY%l]^Qr�V�Y?dtrtdmY'dtS�e%dt\[VCegY'^�h'iWV�e-Y?dfhjl]^Qr�V�Y?dtrtdmY !

Z[^õ�SUr¶p Èùß���ã%U"übê�à5ß�à þ Ø Ä pDAQwQ~�ø�v`u3AKa�h'iK�AS�d��US�X�pDN�K + |�~`~`u3.·KnD8dfe]øÎZ[dt\�dtZ±V�rtdmY ! V�\qõ1^`X-Y?iN^`oQ^`\qV�rtdmY ! ^Q_�Z±V�X-Y'dt\�o"V�rtS�e ÕD�ÎÖ þ ã�ß�ÞX�Çê þ Þ æ� |�A�v�ø'|�v�|�K

Page 28: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

^PÃa�h'iK�AS�d��US�X�pDN�K + |�~`~�|5.·KAG+T�Y'dt^Q\ i�S�õ�o`dt\No[_�^QX)e-S�Z[dtZËV�X-Y'dt\�o"V�rtS�e ÕD��Ö þ ã%U�äAÜ?Ö þ Uªìná]áD��U æ Ý�v`v`~�ønv`P`vKa�h'iK�AS�d��US�X�pDN�K + |�~`~/A�.·K:N�S�V�\�ø¹lQV�X?d�V�\NhUS�iNS�õ�oQdt\NoË_�^QX8o`S�\�S�XcV�rçhUr�V�dtZ[e ì>àqà�U;ìAá]áD��U�äAÜ'Ö3Ü�U ~ |�w�|·øc|�w�~�K

a�h'iK�AS�d��US�X�p[N�K + |�~`~Qv/.cKËaS�ZÍdtZ±V�X-Y'dt\�o"V�rtS�e}V�\NõùiNS�õ�o`dt\�o dt\ôdt\qh{^`Z[T�rtSUY?SËZ±V�X4`SUY'eog ã%U�äAÜ?Ö/Ü�U=ìná]áD��U æ Ý|�P`~�ø)|�w�|QK

a�h'iK�AS�d��US�X�p�N�K + |�~Q~�MM.cK+@)T�TNX?^�ûdtZ±V�Y?dt\NoÌX·V�\qõ�^`Z lQV�X?d�V rtS�e "! egY'^�h'iWV�e-Y?dfh}dt\"Y?S�oQX·V�rfeUp ì)àqàDUuäAÜ'Ö3Ücß/Ü�U ~�~|�OQv`P�øc|�O`w`O"K

aX?dmlQVQegY·VUl`V�p5a�K7N�K + |�~Q~32/.cK ì��bÖ é Ü·ÞUØÉÖ�à � Ö�Ü'Øc�5Õ�Øc�¶ÞcU + aT�X'dt\�o`SUX?ø³ã%S�X?r�V�oK.·KRCS�TqV�X-Y'ZÍS�\"Y>^Q_%a]Y·V�Y'dfegY'dfhUek>\Ndml`S�X'e-dmY ! ^`_b9niNdfh�V�o`^O`w�v�M±k>\�dml]S�X'e-dmY ! @>l]SU\yNS9niNdfh�V�o`^�pW=�rtrtdt\N^QdfeHPQu`PQv]wZ ! r�V�\Nõ��+o"V�rmY'^Q\§K yNhci�dfh�V�oQ^NK S�õ�y

Page 29: dml]SUXce-dmY ^` b9niNdfh V o`^galton.uchicago.edu/~mykland/paperlinks/TR456_990923.pdf · dfebY'i S>Y?X?yNS>TNX?^ V dtrtdmY! õ dfegY'X?d y Y'dt^Q\Ì^`_Y?iNS>yN\Nõ SX?r dt\NoLe-S

^ Ö

•••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••

- log value of zero coupon bond

price for conservative hedging strategy �

0.040

0.045

0.050

0.055

0.060

0.065

0.070

10.010.511.011.5