Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging...
Transcript of Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging...
![Page 1: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Digging Deeper in Imaging SurveysEric Suchyta
In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid
![Page 2: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
What is the problem?• Big surveys want to make (sub)
percent level measurements
• Large catalogs (measured sizes, fluxes, etc.) are primary data output
• Images —> catalogs is complex, subject to measurement biases that can be difficult to fully characterize
• Blending • Proximity effects • Star-galaxy separation • Measurement software
2
![Page 3: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
3
Size?
• Blending • Proximity effects • Star-galaxy separation • Measurement software
What is the problem?• Big surveys want to make (sub)
percent level measurements
• Large catalogs (measured sizes, fluxes, etc.) are primary data output
• Images —> catalogs is complex, subject to measurement biases that can be difficult to fully characterize
![Page 4: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
4
Brightness?
• Blending • Proximity effects • Star-galaxy separation • Measurement software
What is the problem?• Big surveys want to make (sub)
percent level measurements
• Large catalogs (measured sizes, fluxes, etc.) are primary data output
• Images —> catalogs is complex, subject to measurement biases that can be difficult to fully characterize
![Page 5: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
5
Stars or galaxies?
• Blending • Proximity effects • Star-galaxy separation • Measurement software
What is the problem?• Big surveys want to make (sub)
percent level measurements
• Large catalogs (measured sizes, fluxes, etc.) are primary data output
• Images —> catalogs is complex, subject to measurement biases that can be difficult to fully characterize
![Page 6: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
What is usually done?
6
![Page 7: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
What is usually done?
7
FainterBrighter
Turn over as objects get too faint to see
![Page 8: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
What is usually done?
Limit the study to a range with “easy” systematics
8
Use the brightest galaxies,their brightnesses shouldbe less corrupted
Brighter
![Page 9: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
What is usually done?
OR
9
Model the input population and noise, then simulate, and pass the images through survey measurement software (UFIG, Bergé et al. 2013)
Limit the study to a range with “easy” systematics
Brighter
![Page 10: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
ORModel the input population and noise, then simulate, and pass the images through survey measurement software (UFIG, Bergé et al. 2013)
What is usually done?…And what are the problems?
• Statistics much reduced
• Modelling uncertainties
10
Limit the study to a range with “easy” systematics
Brighter
![Page 11: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
We use a hybrid approach• Balrog software package
(https://github.com/emhuff/Balrog)
• Simulate objects into real DES images using GalSim, run DES measurement pipeline
• Automatically inherit difficult to simulate systematics
• Input distribution comes from COSMOS catalog (HST) (Jouvel et al. 2009, Mandelbaum et al., 2014) Red = Simulated
11
![Page 12: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Measure the survey likelihood function
12
• Factored into is the detection probability
![Page 13: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Visualizing the likelihood function
13
![Page 14: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Visualizing the likelihood function
• Below red line, likelihood well understood
• Above red line, likelihood gets messier
• Need to do analysis like ours if we want to use a larger range of the data
14
Most DESanalyses cutting tothis region
![Page 15: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
To reconstruct the data:
15
• Into last bin we incorporate non-detections, with
• Use as the likelihood function in MCMC chain
![Page 16: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Running the reconstruction on DES Science Verification images
16
Prelim
inary
• Able to reconstruct, even as the detections become incomplete
• Reconstruction- - COSMOS— DES Observed
• - Balrog Observed
![Page 17: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Running the reconstruction on DES Science Verification images
17
Prelim
inary
Galaxies
Stars
• Reconstruction- - COSMOS— DES Observed
• - Balrog Observed
• Able to reconstruct, even as the detections become incomplete
• Also recovering star/galaxy
![Page 18: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys APS April Meeting 2015 Eric Suchyta
Still to come…• More fully incorporate errors in building the likelihood into
the Markov Chain
• Make reconstruction maps and show we do not correlate with other systematics maps (e.g. background variation)
• Go beyond magnitude functions, the formalism is general
• Important: this formalism can be incorporated into any DES measurement and other surveys
18
![Page 19: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
![Page 20: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Backup Slides
20
![Page 21: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
Recovering DES with Balrog
![Page 22: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
Recovering DES with Balrog
![Page 23: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
• Want to recover a spatially uniform galaxy distribution, consistent with cosmic variance
Prelim
inary
Reconstruct in spatial bins (HEALPixels), sum magnitude bins between 22.5 - 24.5
![Page 24: Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveysesuchyta/index.html/documents/... · Digging Deeper in Imaging Surveys Eric Suchyta In Collaboration with: Eric Huff, Klaus Honscheid](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042919/5f605d4ee5d64247e1418100/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
24
Prelim
inary
• Want to recover a spatially uniform galaxy distribution, consistent with cosmic variance
Reconstruct in spatial bins (HEALPixels), sum magnitude bins between 22.5 - 24.5