Developmental Changes in Calcium Current Pharmacology and ... · niques in acutely isolated chick...

12
Developmental Changes in Calcium Current Pharmacology and Somatostatin Inhibition in Chick Parasympathetic Neurons Michael G. White, Mark A. Crumling, and Stephen D. Meriney Department of Neuroscience, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15260 Voltage-dependent calcium (Ca 21 ) currents were characterized and modulatory effects of somatostatin were measured in acutely dissociated chick ciliary ganglion neurons at embryonic stages 34, 37, and 40. This developmental time period coin- cides with the period of synapse formation between ciliary ganglion neurons and peripheral eye muscles. At all three de- velopmental stages Ca 21 current could be blocked almost completely by combined application of v-CgTX GVIA and ni- trendipine. At young embryonic ages there was significant over- lap in sensitivity, with ;75% of the current sensitive to either blocker applied independently. By stage 40, there was very little or no overlap in sensitivity, with ;75% of the current blocked by v-CgTX GVIA (N-type) and 30% blocked by nitrendipine (L-type). These data are consistent with earlier findings that the pharmacology of acetylcholine release from ciliary ganglion nerve terminals changes during development from sensitivity to both dihydropyridines and v-CgTX GVIA to selective sensitivity to v-CgTX GVIA (Gray et al., 1992). Somatostatin reduced Ca 21 current by 50–60% at all three developmental stages. At early developmental stages somatostatin receptors coupled predominantly to the current that was sensitive to both v-CgTX GVIA and nitrendipine. By stage 40, somatostatin primarily inhibited classically defined N-type current (selectively sensitive to v-CgTX GVIA). Thus, somatostatin receptor coupling to Ca 21 channels persisted throughout development as Ca 21 current pharmacology changed. Key words: calcium channel; somatostatin modulation; de- velopment; chick ciliary ganglion; FPL 64176; v-CgTX GVIA; dihydropyridines Using pharmacologic manipulations of acetylcholine (ACh) re- lease, previous investigators have concluded that N-type Ca 21 channels regulate transmitter release at the mature parasympa- thetic neuromuscular junction formed between chick ciliary gan- glion neurons and intrinsic eye muscles (Gray et al., 1992). Dur- ing the development of ciliary ganglion innervation of intrinsic eye muscles, Gray et al. (1992) have identified a switch in the pharmacology of calcium-dependent ACh release such that, at embryonic ages that correspond with synaptic maturation (em- bryonic stages 37–39), both N- and L-type channel blockers influence ACh release. These observations suggest that the types of calcium channels that are expressed or targeted to the nerve terminal change during development. Comparable studies in the hippocampus have revealed a developmental shift in the pharma- cologic sensitivities of transmitter release to selective blockers of N- and Q-type calcium channels (Scholz and Miller, 1995). Taken together, these investigations suggest that, at least in some prep- arations, the types of calcium channels coupled to transmitter release change during development. Changes in the expression patterns of ion channels are known to be an important feature of neuronal development (O’Dowd et al., 1988; Desarmenien et al., 1993; Spitzer, 1994), and because of the integral role of voltage- dependent C a 21 channels in neurotransmitter release, the types of calcium channels expressed are critical. In addition, the N-type calcium channels present at these and other synapses are often the target of G-protein-coupled receptors that have potent pre- synaptic neuromodulatory actions (Hille, 1994). As such, the capacity for neuromodulation may undergo developmental changes that are associated with changes in the expression of calcium channels. Thus, developmental changes in calcium chan- nel expression are likely to be important for the control of transmitter release as well as the effects of neuromodulators. We have studied the developmental changes in calcium current pharmacology and the neuromodulatory effects of somatostatin in chick ciliary ganglion neurons. Somatostatin is endogenous to choroid neurons in the chick ciliary ganglion (Epstein et al., 1988; Coulombe and Nishi, 1991; De Stefano et al., 1993) and is a potent inhibitor of transmitter release at choroid nerve terminals (Gray et al., 1989, 1990). Despite the selective expression of the somatostatin peptide in choroid neurons, somatostatin receptors are expressed on essentially all neurons in the embryonic ciliary ganglion (Meriney et al., 1994). We report a developmental change in the pharmacology of calcium channels expressed at three time points that correspond to the development of synapses with intrinsic eye muscles. Throughout this developmental change in calcium current pharmacology, somatostatin remains an effective modulator of calcium channels. MATERIALS AND METHODS Cell culture. Ciliary ganglia were dissected from White Leghorn chicken eggs [stages 34, 37, or 40, as determined by Hamburger and Hamilton (1951)] in sterile oxygenated Tyrode containing (in mM): 134 NaCl, 3 KCl, 3 CaCl 2 , 1 MgCl 2 , 12 glucose, and 20 NaH 2 CO 3 , pH 7.2. Ganglia were incubated in 0.08% trypsin in C a 21 - and Mg 21 -free T yrode for 12, 15, or 20 min at 37°C for stages 34, 37, and 40 ganglia, respectively. Trypsin was removed and inhibited by three washes in minimal essential media (MEM) plus 10% heat-inactivated horse serum. Ganglia were Received March 13, 1997; revised May 27, 1997; accepted May 30, 1997. This work was supported by the University of Pittsburgh Small Grants Program, a Winters Foundation award, and National Institutes of Health Grant NS 32345. We thank Guillermo Pilar, D. Bruce Gray, James Simples, Robert Poage, Debra Artim, and John Pattillo for many helpful discussions and critical evaluation of this manuscript and Melanie Kaszer for preparing cultured cells. Correspondence should be addressed to Dr. Stephen D. Meriney, Department of Neuroscience, University of Pittsburgh, 446 Crawford Hall, Pittsburgh, PA 15260. M.A. Crumling’s present address: David Mahoney Institute of Neurological Sci- ences, University of Pennsylvania, 215 Stemmler Hall, Philadelphia, PA 19104-6074. Copyright © 1997 Society for Neuroscience 0270-6474/97/176302-12$05.00/0 The Journal of Neuroscience, August 15, 1997, 17(16):6302–6313

Transcript of Developmental Changes in Calcium Current Pharmacology and ... · niques in acutely isolated chick...

Page 1: Developmental Changes in Calcium Current Pharmacology and ... · niques in acutely isolated chick ciliary ganglion neurons at three developmental stages (34, 37, and 40). As expected

Developmental Changes in Calcium Current Pharmacology andSomatostatin Inhibition in Chick Parasympathetic Neurons

Michael G. White, Mark A. Crumling, and Stephen D. Meriney

Department of Neuroscience, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15260

Voltage-dependent calcium (Ca21) currents were characterizedand modulatory effects of somatostatin were measured inacutely dissociated chick ciliary ganglion neurons at embryonicstages 34, 37, and 40. This developmental time period coin-cides with the period of synapse formation between ciliaryganglion neurons and peripheral eye muscles. At all three de-velopmental stages Ca21 current could be blocked almostcompletely by combined application of v-CgTX GVIA and ni-trendipine. At young embryonic ages there was significant over-lap in sensitivity, with ;75% of the current sensitive to eitherblocker applied independently. By stage 40, there was very littleor no overlap in sensitivity, with ;75% of the current blockedby v-CgTX GVIA (N-type) and 30% blocked by nitrendipine(L-type). These data are consistent with earlier findings that thepharmacology of acetylcholine release from ciliary ganglion

nerve terminals changes during development from sensitivity toboth dihydropyridines and v-CgTX GVIA to selective sensitivityto v-CgTX GVIA (Gray et al., 1992). Somatostatin reducedCa21 current by 50–60% at all three developmental stages. Atearly developmental stages somatostatin receptors coupledpredominantly to the current that was sensitive to both v-CgTXGVIA and nitrendipine. By stage 40, somatostatin primarilyinhibited classically defined N-type current (selectively sensitiveto v-CgTX GVIA). Thus, somatostatin receptor coupling toCa21 channels persisted throughout development as Ca21

current pharmacology changed.

Key words: calcium channel; somatostatin modulation; de-velopment; chick ciliary ganglion; FPL 64176; v-CgTX GVIA;dihydropyridines

Using pharmacologic manipulations of acetylcholine (ACh) re-lease, previous investigators have concluded that N-type Ca21

channels regulate transmitter release at the mature parasympa-thetic neuromuscular junction formed between chick ciliary gan-glion neurons and intrinsic eye muscles (Gray et al., 1992). Dur-ing the development of ciliary ganglion innervation of intrinsiceye muscles, Gray et al. (1992) have identified a switch in thepharmacology of calcium-dependent ACh release such that, atembryonic ages that correspond with synaptic maturation (em-bryonic stages 37–39), both N- and L-type channel blockersinfluence ACh release. These observations suggest that the typesof calcium channels that are expressed or targeted to the nerveterminal change during development. Comparable studies in thehippocampus have revealed a developmental shift in the pharma-cologic sensitivities of transmitter release to selective blockers ofN- and Q-type calcium channels (Scholz and Miller, 1995). Takentogether, these investigations suggest that, at least in some prep-arations, the types of calcium channels coupled to transmitterrelease change during development. Changes in the expressionpatterns of ion channels are known to be an important feature ofneuronal development (O’Dowd et al., 1988; Desarmenien et al.,1993; Spitzer, 1994), and because of the integral role of voltage-dependent Ca 21 channels in neurotransmitter release, the types

of calcium channels expressed are critical. In addition, the N-typecalcium channels present at these and other synapses are oftenthe target of G-protein-coupled receptors that have potent pre-synaptic neuromodulatory actions (Hille, 1994). As such, thecapacity for neuromodulation may undergo developmentalchanges that are associated with changes in the expression ofcalcium channels. Thus, developmental changes in calcium chan-nel expression are likely to be important for the control oftransmitter release as well as the effects of neuromodulators.

We have studied the developmental changes in calcium currentpharmacology and the neuromodulatory effects of somatostatin inchick ciliary ganglion neurons. Somatostatin is endogenous tochoroid neurons in the chick ciliary ganglion (Epstein et al., 1988;Coulombe and Nishi, 1991; De Stefano et al., 1993) and is apotent inhibitor of transmitter release at choroid nerve terminals(Gray et al., 1989, 1990). Despite the selective expression of thesomatostatin peptide in choroid neurons, somatostatin receptorsare expressed on essentially all neurons in the embryonic ciliaryganglion (Meriney et al., 1994). We report a developmentalchange in the pharmacology of calcium channels expressed atthree time points that correspond to the development of synapseswith intrinsic eye muscles. Throughout this developmentalchange in calcium current pharmacology, somatostatin remainsan effective modulator of calcium channels.

MATERIALS AND METHODSCell culture. Ciliary ganglia were dissected from White Leghorn chickeneggs [stages 34, 37, or 40, as determined by Hamburger and Hamilton(1951)] in sterile oxygenated Tyrode containing (in mM): 134 NaCl, 3KCl, 3 CaCl2 , 1 MgCl2 , 12 glucose, and 20 NaH2CO3 , pH 7.2. Gangliawere incubated in 0.08% trypsin in Ca 21- and Mg 21-free Tyrode for 12,15, or 20 min at 37°C for stages 34, 37, and 40 ganglia, respectively.Trypsin was removed and inhibited by three washes in minimal essentialmedia (MEM) plus 10% heat-inactivated horse serum. Ganglia were

Received March 13, 1997; revised May 27, 1997; accepted May 30, 1997.This work was supported by the University of Pittsburgh Small Grants Program,

a Winters Foundation award, and National Institutes of Health Grant NS 32345. Wethank Guillermo Pilar, D. Bruce Gray, James Simples, Robert Poage, Debra Artim,and John Pattillo for many helpful discussions and critical evaluation of thismanuscript and Melanie Kaszer for preparing cultured cells.

Correspondence should be addressed to Dr. Stephen D. Meriney, Department ofNeuroscience, University of Pittsburgh, 446 Crawford Hall, Pittsburgh, PA 15260.

M.A. Crumling’s present address: David Mahoney Institute of Neurological Sci-ences, University of Pennsylvania, 215 Stemmler Hall, Philadelphia, PA 19104-6074.Copyright © 1997 Society for Neuroscience 0270-6474/97/176302-12$05.00/0

The Journal of Neuroscience, August 15, 1997, 17(16):6302–6313

Page 2: Developmental Changes in Calcium Current Pharmacology and ... · niques in acutely isolated chick ciliary ganglion neurons at three developmental stages (34, 37, and 40). As expected

dissociated mechanically by gentle trituration. The final suspension ofcells was centrifuged at 100 3 g for 5 min. The pelleted cells wereresuspended in MEM plus 10% chick embryo extract, plated onto poly-L-lysine-coated 35 mm plastic dishes, and incubated at 37°C. Cells wereused for experiments after 2–6 hr of incubation, at which time there wereno neurites elaborated onto the poly-L-lysine substrate.

Perforated patch-clamp recordings. For most recordings, the perforatedpatch technique was used to gain electrical access to the cell interiorwhile allowing only the exchange of small monovalent ions between thepipette and the cell cytoplasm (Horn and Marty, 1988). To isolate theinward current through Ca 21 channels, we bathed the cells in an externalsaline of the following composition (in mM): 140 NaCl, 20 TEA-Cl, 10HEPES, 5 glucose, 5 KCl, 5 CaCl2 , and 2 MgCl2 plus 2 mM tetrodotoxin,pH 7.3. Pipettes were pulled in a two-step process, coated with SYL-GARD (Dow Corning, Midland, MI), and fire-polished (electrode resis-tances ranged from 0.5 to 2 MV). The pipette was filled in a two-stepmanner. The tip was filled by a 5 sec dip in an internal solution of (inmM): 75 Cs2SO4 , 55 CsCl, 8 MgCl2 , and 10 HEPES, pH 7.3. Theremainder of the pipette was back-filled with the above solution plus 400mg/ml of amphotericin B (Rae et al., 1991). Amphotericin B graduallyinduced a low-resistance pathway that reached equilibrium within 5–15min after seal formation (measured by changes in the area and decaytime constant of the capacitive transient associated with a 10 mV hyper-polarizing voltage step; see Fig. 1 D), with a series resistance of 13.93 66.34 MV (mean 6 SD; n 5 167). At this point, recordings of Ca 21

current were made for up to 1 hr without complications caused by the lossof cytoplasmic components. Except where noted, currents were activatedby depolarizing steps from 280 mV to 110 mV. Currents were activated,acquired, and leak-subtracted with a hyperpolarizing P/4 protocol by thepClamp (Axon Instruments, Foster City, CA) software package runningon a 486 microcomputer in concert with an Axopatch 200A patch-clampamplifier. The currents were four-pole Bessel-filtered at 5 kHz anddigitized at 20 kHz. With the exception of access resistance measuresreported in this section, all values expressed are means 6 SE.

Whole-cell patch-clamp recordings. In those cases in which pharmaco-logic effects were measured on calcium tail currents, the traditionalwhole-cell patch-clamp method was used. This was done to increase thereliability of recording tail currents immediately after the cessation of thetest pulse (see Fig. 6, inset). Measurements of FPL 64176-elongated tailcurrents were made 10 msec after the cessation of the test pulse and thuswere not influenced by the use of perforated or traditional whole-cellmethods. For experiments with whole-cell methods, the same pipette sizeand bath solution were used, but the pipettes were filled with thefollowing internal solution (in mM): 120 CsCl, 10 HEPES, 11 EGTA, 5TEA-Cl, 1 CaCl2 , and 4 MgCl2 , with 4 ATP-Mg, 0.3 GTP-Na, and 0.1leupeptin added fresh daily to slow the loss of Ca 21 current caused bycytoplasmic dialysis. After gigaseal formation, access to the cell interiorwas gained by applying further suction and rupturing the piece ofmembrane under the patch electrode (access resistance averaged 8.48 65.86 MV, mean 6 SD; n 5 72).

Pharmacologic agents. Stock solutions of nitrendipine [Research Bio-chemicals International (RBI), Natick, MA] were made fresh daily inDMSO and diluted to a final concentration of 2–20 mM into the bathsaline. FPL 64176 (the generous gift of Dr. David Rampe, MarionMerrell Dow, Cincinnati, OH) or Bay K 8644 (RBI) were solubilized inETOH at 1 mM and diluted into bath saline to 1 mM. DMSO or ETOHvehicles (0.1%) were without effect on calcium current. v-Aga IVA(Alamone Labs, Jerusalem, Israel) was solubilized in aqueous solutionwith 0.1% cytochrome c at 20 mM, stored at 280°C until the day of use,and diluted into bath saline to 200 nM with 0.1% cytochrome c. v-CgTXGVIA (Sigma, St. Louis, MO) was diluted into bath saline to a finalconcentration of 1–2 mM. Somatostatin (Sigma) was diluted into bathsaline to a final concentration of 100 nM. All other reagents wereobtained from Sigma and dissolved in saline. All pharmacologic agentswere applied through a pipette (20–30 mm tip diameter) directly to thecell under study.

RESULTSCalcium current expressed in developing ciliaryganglion neuronsCalcium current was studied via perforated patch-clamp tech-niques in acutely isolated chick ciliary ganglion neurons at threedevelopmental stages (34, 37, and 40). As expected from previousreports (Dourado and Dryer, 1992), voltage-activated Ca21 cur-

rents increased in both amplitude and density from developmen-tal stages 34 to 40. At stage 34, peak current amplitude averaged217.7 6 15.6 pA (mean 6 SEM; n 5 74), and current densityaveraged 42.8 6 2.1 pA/pF. At stage 37, peak current amplitudeincreased to 430.5 6 20.1 (n 5 68), while current density re-mained very similar (45.4 6 1.6), suggesting that calcium channelnumbers increased in parallel with cell size between these twodevelopmental stages (whole-cell capacitance increased from5.1 6 0.3 pF at stage 34 to 9.5 6 0.3 pF at stage 37). By stage 40,peak current amplitude increased to 704.8 6 38.4 pA (n 5 97),and current density increased to 64.3 6 2.2 pA/pF as cell sizeincreased further (whole-cell capacitance averaged 11.1 6 0.4pF). Thus, during the 6 d of development in vivo between stages34 and 40, current amplitude increased slightly more than three-fold, whereas current density increased by only ;50%, with theonly significant density increase occurring between stages 37 and40 ( p , 0.05; one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc test).Current–voltage relationships (Fig. 1A,B) differed only in theamount of current measured at each developmental stage. Whencurrent–voltage relationships for each developmental age werecorrected for estimated cell size (peak current divided by cellcapacitance; pA/pF), the curves overlapped for stages 34 and 37,with a slight increase in the current density (pA/pF) observed bystage 40 (Fig. 1C). Thus, despite increases in calcium currentamplitude, cell size, and current density by stage 40, current–voltage relationships appeared very similar.

To characterize the Ca21 current further, we performed apharmacologic dissection of Ca21 currents at stages 34, 37, and 40.At all three developmental stages, essentially all of the currentcould be blocked either by 100 mM cadmium (data not shown) or byusing a combination of 1 mM v-CgTX GVIA and 2–20 mM nitren-dipine (Fig. 2). At stage 34, when applied independently, v-CgTXGVIA inhibited 73.4 6 2.9% (n 5 14) of the peak Ca21 current,whereas nitrendipine blocked 72.9 6 2.2% (n 5 14; Fig. 2A). Thesedata suggest a substantial pharmacologic overlap of ;45%. Se-quential applications of nitrendipine, followed by v-CgTX GVIAplus nitrendipine (Fig. 2B), or v-CgTX GVIA, followed by nitren-dipine plus v-CgTX GVIA (Fig. 2C), revealed differences in thepercentage of current blocked by each antagonist, but the com-bined action of both antagonists inhibited 93.3 6 2.2% (n 5 9) ofpeak Ca21 current. This represents essentially complete block ofthe Ca21 current. At stage 37, v-CgTX GVIA alone inhibited70.3 6 2.5% (n 5 15) of the peak Ca21 current, whereas nitren-dipine blocked 51.2 6 2.0% (n 5 20; Fig. 2D). At this stage thedata suggest a pharmacologic overlap of ;20% among Ca21

channel types sensitive to v-CgTX GVIA and nitrendipine. Ap-plications of nitrendipine, followed by v-CgTX GVIA plus nitren-dipine (Fig. 2E), or v-CgTX GVIA, followed by nitrendipine plusv-CgTX GVIA (Fig. 2F), showed similar results to the datapresented above for stage 34, with almost all of the Ca21 currentblocked. At stage 40, v-CgTX GVIA alone inhibited an average of75.2 6 1.2% (n 5 23) of the peak Ca21 current, whereas nitren-dipine alone inhibited 31.9 6 2.8% (n 5 30; Fig. 2G; block by 2, 10,or 20 mM was identical). These numbers account almost exactly forthe total composition of the Ca21 current, with possibly ;5%pharmacologic overlap still present. Sequential application ofv-CgTX GVIA and nitrendipine in either order had similar ef-fects, and together inhibited 89.1 6 2.7% (n 5 6; Fig. 2H,I) of peakCa21 current. The presence of a small resistant current alsosuggests that some pharmacologic overlap still may be present atstage 40. The small percentage of uncharacterized current thatappears to be resistant to both blockers at all three developmental

White et al. • Development of Ca21 Current and Somatostatin Modulation J. Neurosci., August 15, 1997, 17(16):6302–6313 6303

Page 3: Developmental Changes in Calcium Current Pharmacology and ... · niques in acutely isolated chick ciliary ganglion neurons at three developmental stages (34, 37, and 40). As expected

stages could be attributed to incomplete block by the antagonists oranother minor Ca21 channel type. Application of 200 nM v-AgaIVA, a selective blocker of P/Q-type calcium channels, had nosignificant effect (data not shown). In summary, although 1 mM

v-CgTX GVIA blocked 70–75% of the current at all three devel-opmental stages studied, the magnitude of current sensitive tonitrendipine decreased from ;73% at stage 34 to only ;30% atstage 40. At stage 34 both pharmacologic agents appeared capable

of blocking a common subpopulation of Ca21 channels that rep-resented ;45% of the total current. At stage 37, this overlap wasreduced to only ;20%; by stage 40, pharmacologic overlap ap-peared to be ,10%. The pharmacologic sensitivity of calciumcurrents to v-CgTX GVIA and dihydropyridine antagonists re-ported here at stage 40 are similar to that previously reported atthis embryonic stage by Yawo and Momiyama (1993) (for review,see Dryer, 1994).

Figure 1. Developmental increase in the magnitude of calcium current recorded via perforated patch-clamp techniques from embryonic chick ciliaryganglion neurons. A, Representative examples of calcium current recorded from three embryonic stages (stage 40, top traces; stage 37, middle traces; stage34, bottom traces) in response to voltage steps from 280 to 240 mV through 10 mV. B, Current–voltage relationship of currents recorded at stage 34( filled circles), stage 37 (open triangles), and stage 40 ( filled triangles). Values represent the mean 6 SEM of 10 representative cells from each embryonicage. C, Current density–voltage relationship for the same data shown in B. D, Representative time course of the development of electrical access duringthe initiation of perforated patch recordings. Overlapping records were taken 5, 30, 60, 90, 120, 150, 180, and 360 sec after seal formation. In this example,at 360 sec the capacitance measured 9.7 pF, and the time constant for decay of the capacitive transient measured 0.08 msec (access resistance, 9.1 MV).

6304 J. Neurosci., August 15, 1997, 17(16):6302–6313 White et al. • Development of Ca21 Current and Somatostatin Modulation

Page 4: Developmental Changes in Calcium Current Pharmacology and ... · niques in acutely isolated chick ciliary ganglion neurons at three developmental stages (34, 37, and 40). As expected

Figure 2. Pharmacologic sensitivity of calcium current recorded via perforated patch-clamp techniques at stages 34 (A–C), 37 (D–F), and 40 (G–I). Atstage 34, nitrendipine (Nit.) or v-CgTX GVIA (v-CgTX ) blocked a similar percentage of calcium current ( A ). When they were applied sequentially ineither application order (B, C), they blocked almost all of the current with a large amount of overlap in pharmacologic sensitivity. At stage 37, v-CgTXcontinued to block ;75% of the current, but the nitrendipine effect was reduced (D ). The apparent overlap in pharmacologic sensitivity at stage 37 wasless than at stage 34, as revealed by sequential application of v-CgTX and nitrendipine (E, F ). By stage 40, although v-CgTX continued to block ;75%of the current, the nitrendipine block was reduced to ;30% (G ). Furthermore, sequential application of both blockers in either application ordersuggested very little overlap in pharmacologic sensitivity (H, I ). For the experimental examples represented in plots F and I, v-CgTX was not presentduring nitrendipine application. Nitrendipine (20 mM) and v-CgTX GVIA (2 mM) were used in each representative time course shown. Numbers inparentheses represent the number of cells studied.

White et al. • Development of Ca21 Current and Somatostatin Modulation J. Neurosci., August 15, 1997, 17(16):6302–6313 6305

Page 5: Developmental Changes in Calcium Current Pharmacology and ... · niques in acutely isolated chick ciliary ganglion neurons at three developmental stages (34, 37, and 40). As expected

To examine further the apparent sensitivity of a subpopulationof Ca21 channels to both v-CgTX GVIA and nitrendipine atstage 34 and stage 37, we used traditional whole-cell recordings ofCa21 current to evaluate the effects of v-CgTX GVIA on elon-gated L-type tail currents induced by the L-type channel agonistFPL 64176 (1 mM). FPL 64176 is a benzoylpyrrole calcium chan-nel activator (McKechnie et al., 1989; Kunze and Rampe, 1992)that is selective for L-type calcium channels and is more potentthan Bay K 8644 (Rampe et al., 1993; Randall and Tsien, 1995).v-CgTX GVIA (1 mM) reversibly blocked (see Fig. 3E), by 50.6 66.4% at stage 34 (n 5 13) and 20.2 6 2.2% at stage 37 (n 5 13),the FPL 64176-elongated L-type tail current (Fig. 3A–E). Bystage 40, only 12.5 6 3.5% (n 5 9) of the tail current was blockedby v-CgTX GVIA (Fig. 3A,F,G). The percentages reported hereare strikingly similar to the pharmacologic overlap estimatedabove, based on blockade of peak current. These data support theconclusion that a significant percentage of the calcium channelsexpressed at stage 34 and stage 37 is sensitive to two pharmaco-logic agents that traditionally distinguish N-type from L-typecalcium channels.

Somatostatin modulation of calcium currentThe effect of 100 nM somatostatin on the Ca21 channel typesexpressed in ciliary ganglion neurons at different developmentalstages also was studied via perforated patch recording techniques.Somatostatin has been shown to be a potent modulator of calciumcurrent in stage 40 ciliary ganglion neurons (Dryer et al., 1991;Meriney et al., 1994). We have extended these observations tomodulatory effects at different developmental stages. The effect ofsomatostatin on peak Ca 21 current at stages 34, 37, and 40appeared to be relatively constant. At stage 34, 58.8 6 4.6% (n 58; Fig. 4A) of peak Ca21 current was blocked. Stage 37 cellsshowed a 50.5 6 1.7% (n 5 8; Fig. 4C) inhibition by somatostatin,and at stage 40, somatostatin blocked 51.8 6 2.2% (n 5 18; Fig.4E) of the peak Ca 21 current. When it was recorded with theperforated patch technique, somatostatin-mediated modulationat all developmental stages was persistent and reproducible onrepeated application (Fig. 4B,D,F; see also Meriney et al., 1994).

The calcium channel blockers v-CgTX GVIA and nitrendipinewere used to determine whether the contribution of Ca 21 chan-nel types to the current inhibited by somatostatin changed withthe progressive developmental alterations in calcium currentpharmacology described above. At stage 34, pretreatment withv-CgTX GVIA reduced the somatostatin effect to 4.7 6 0.7%(expressed as a percentage of peak current before pharmacologicmanipulation; n 5 8; Fig. 5A,C), occluding ;90% of the soma-tostatin effect at this stage. Similarly, pretreatment with nitren-dipine reduced the somatostatin effect to 11.1 6 1.2% (n 5 7; Fig.5A,B), occluding ;80% of the somatostatin effect at stage 34.These data indicate that, at stage 34, somatostatin inhibits almostexclusively the mixed pharmacologic channel type sensitive toboth v-CgTX GVIA and nitrendipine.

At stage 37, pretreatment with v-CgTX GVIA reduced thesomatostatin effect to 7.6 6 1.5% (n 5 15; Fig. 5D, F), occluding;85% of the somatostatin inhibition. Pretreatment with nitren-dipine reduced the effect of somatostatin to 29.3 6 2.6% (n 5 15;Fig. 5D,E), occluding ;45% of the somatostatin inhibition. Thus,at stage 37, somatostatin affected the mixed pharmacologic chan-nel type sensitive to both v-CgTX GVIA and nitrendipine aswell as a significant percentage of the current that was sensitiveselectively to v-CgTX GVIA.

At stage 40, pretreatment with v-CgTX GVIA diminished the

somatostatin effect to 7.7 6 0.6% (n 5 19; Fig. 5G,I), blocking;85% of the somatostatin-mediated inhibition. Pretreatmentwith nitrendipine at stage 40 had only a slight effect, reducing theSOM-mediated Ca 21 current inhibition to 40.0 6 1.9% (n 5 20;Fig. 5G,H), occluding only ;20% of the control somatostatineffect. Because there seemed to be ,10% overlap in calciumcurrent pharmacology (see Fig. 2G above), these data indicate apredominant effect of somatostatin at stage 40 on classicallydefined N-type calcium channels, along with a smaller effect onmixed pharmacologic or L-type Ca21 channels. In fact, the effectof somatostatin at stage 40 may be restricted to N-type and thesmall percentage of mixed pharmacologic type that remains atthis stage.

To test further the hypothesis that somatostatin targets calciumchannels sensitive to L-type calcium channel agents, we per-formed traditional whole-cell recordings at stages 34, 37, and 40of FPL 64176-elongated tail currents, and we tested the effects ofsomatostatin. The only differences between somatostatin effectsmeasured via traditional whole-cell and perforated whole-cellmethods are the activation kinetics of the modulated current(slowed in traditional whole-cell, but not in perforated, methods)and the desensitization rate (faster in traditional whole-cell meth-od; see Meriney et al., 1994). Differences in somatostatin effectsare limited to these characteristics of the inhibition that aredependent on cytoplasmic second messengers, and there is nodifference in the types of calcium channels recorded or thesensitivity of these channels to somatostatin. At all three stagessomatostatin had little or no detectable effect on FPL 64176-elongated tail currents (Fig. 6), although somatostatin did reducethe fast component of the tail current (see Fig. 6, inset). In someexperiments perforated patch techniques were used with identicalresults (data not shown). Similarly, somatostatin was withouteffect on tail currents elongated by treatment with 1 mM BAY K8644 (3.2 6 2.4%; n 5 5 at stage 34). The lack of somatostatin-mediated modulation of FPL 64176-elongated tail currents wouldhave been expected if the current types present in FPL 64176-elongated tail current were distinct from those contributing to thefraction of peak current that was sensitive to somatostatin-mediated modulation. However, because nitrendipine occludedsomatostatin effects on peak current (see Fig. 5), this suggests thatcalcium channels sensitive to L-type blockers are affected bysomatostatin. Furthermore, somatostatin seemed to target pre-dominantly the peak current characterized by mixed pharmaco-logic sensitivity at stage 34 (Fig. 5), and v-CgTX GVIA blocked;50% of the FPL 64176-elongated tail current at this earlyembryonic stage (Fig. 3). These data suggest that the FPL 64176-elongated tail current recorded at stage 34 (Fig. 6A) includes asignificant percentage of the mixed pharmacologic channel typethat has been shown to be sensitive to somatostatin. Thus, it issurprising that somatostatin had no effect on this mixed pharma-cologic calcium tail current.

To characterize the effect of somatostatin further, we per-formed an examination of the somatostatin effect on calciumcurrent activated at different voltages at stage 34 and revealed anapparent biphasic voltage dependence (Fig. 7). There was noapparent effect of somatostatin on calcium current when it wasmeasured at membrane potentials more positive than approxi-mately 135 mV or more negative than approximately 215 mV. Asimilar voltage dependence was observed at stages 37 and 40(data not shown) (see also Meriney et al., 1994). To compare theeffects of somatostatin and pharmacologic blockers on currentactivated by test potentials with relatively hyperpolarized poten-

6306 J. Neurosci., August 15, 1997, 17(16):6302–6313 White et al. • Development of Ca21 Current and Somatostatin Modulation

Page 6: Developmental Changes in Calcium Current Pharmacology and ... · niques in acutely isolated chick ciliary ganglion neurons at three developmental stages (34, 37, and 40). As expected

tials (220 mV) with current activated by test pulses that activatepeak Ca 21 current (110 mV), we used a double-pulse protocol.The somatostatin effect in stage 34 neurons was within controlranges when tested with steps to 110 mV (52.3 6 2.4%), butwhen tested with steps to 220 mV, the somatostatin effect effec-tively was eliminated (4.1 6 4.4%, n 5 6; see Fig. 8A). The lackof effect of neuropeptides and modulators at depolarized poten-tials is commonly observed (Bean, 1989; Boland and Bean, 1993),but the apparent lack of effect at hyperpolarized potentials usu-ally is not reported. When an apparent lack of neuromodulatoreffect at hyperpolarized potentials has been observed, it has beenattributed to the predominance of calcium channel types at hy-perpolarized potentials that are relatively insensitive to modulation(see Viana and Hille, 1996). To test this possibility, we activatedcalcium current in stage 34 neurons with the same double-pulseprotocol described above, and we examined the pharmacologic

sensitivity of current activated by test potentials to 220 and 110mV. v-CgTX GVIA blocked a large percentage of the currentactivated by steps to 110 mV (74.0 6 2%; n 5 7; Fig. 8A; see alsoFig. 2) but had a much smaller effect on current activated by stepsto 220 mV (21.0 6 4.4%; Fig. 8B). Nitrendipine blocked a largepercentage of the current at both test potentials (77.0 6 3.8 at 110mV; 58.2 6 4.4 at 220 mV; n 5 3; Fig. 8C). Thus, currentsactivated by relatively weak depolarizations (steps to 220 mV) arecarried predominately by L-type channels (see Kasai and Neher,1992). The mixed pharmacologic and N-type currents activatedwith test potentials more positive than 220 mV.

DISCUSSIONDevelopmental changes in Ca21 currentThe development of Ca21 channel types is critical for regulatingthe development and strength of synapses as well as synaptic

Figure 3. v-CgTX GVIA blocked FPL 64176-elongated tailcurrents recorded via traditional whole-cell recording tech-niques at early embryonic stages. A, Plot of the effects ofv-CgTX GVIA (v-CgTX ) on FPL 64176-elongated tail cur-rents measured 10 msec after the cessation of the test pulseat stage 34 (solid bar), stage 37 (hatched bar), and stage 40(open bar). Numbers in parentheses represent the number ofcells studied. The stage 34 effect was significantly differentfrom the other groups ( p , 0.005; one-way ANOVA withTukey’s post hoc test). Shown is a representative example ofcalcium current recorded at stages 34 (B ), 37 ( D ), and 40 (F )at the points indicated on the plots (C, E, F, respectively) ofpeak current ( filled circles) and tail current (open circles). Inall cases, currents were measured isochronally: peak currentwas measured at the time when control currents peak; tailcurrent was measured 10 msec after the cessation of the testpulse.

White et al. • Development of Ca21 Current and Somatostatin Modulation J. Neurosci., August 15, 1997, 17(16):6302–6313 6307

Page 7: Developmental Changes in Calcium Current Pharmacology and ... · niques in acutely isolated chick ciliary ganglion neurons at three developmental stages (34, 37, and 40). As expected

Figure 4. Somatostatin-mediated mod-ulation of calcium current recorded viaperforated patch-clamp techniques atstages 34 (A, B), 37 (C, D), and 40 (E,F ). A, C, E, Representative recordingsof calcium current elicited by step depo-larizations from 280 mV to 110 mV.At all three developmental stages 100nM somatostatin reduced calcium cur-rent by ;50–60% without altering thekinetics of the current. B, D, F, Plots ofthe time course of somatostatin-mediated modulation. The somatostatinmodulation occurred with little or nodesensitization over the time coursemeasured and could be observed re-peatedly on subsequent somatostatin(SOM ) application.

6308 J. Neurosci., August 15, 1997, 17(16):6302–6313 White et al. • Development of Ca21 Current and Somatostatin Modulation

Page 8: Developmental Changes in Calcium Current Pharmacology and ... · niques in acutely isolated chick ciliary ganglion neurons at three developmental stages (34, 37, and 40). As expected

Figure 5. Pharmacologic sensitivity of somatostatin-mediated modulation of calcium current recorded via perforated patch-clamp techniques. At stage34, somatostatin (SOM ) modulation of calcium current was strongly occluded by pretreatment with either nitrendipine (Nit) or v-CgTX GVIA(v-CgTX ) (A; *significantly different from control, but not each other) as shown in representative time courses (B, C). At stage 37, v-CgTX was ableto strongly occlude somatostatin modulation, but nitrendipine could occlude the effect of somatostatin only partially (D; **significantly different fromcontrol and each other). Representative examples are shown in E and F. At stage 40, v-CgTX still was able to strongly occlude somatostatin modulation,but the effect of nitrendipine was very weak (G ), as demonstrated by representative time courses in H and I (**significantly different from control andeach other). Nitrendipine (20 mM) was used in the representative time courses shown in B and E. Nitrendipine (2 mM) was used in the representativetime course shown in H. v-CgTX GVIA (2 mM) was used in the representative time courses shown in C, F, and I. Numbers in parentheses represent thenumber of cells studied. Statistical analyses were performed with a one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc test; significance was defined as p , 0.05.

White et al. • Development of Ca21 Current and Somatostatin Modulation J. Neurosci., August 15, 1997, 17(16):6302–6313 6309

Page 9: Developmental Changes in Calcium Current Pharmacology and ... · niques in acutely isolated chick ciliary ganglion neurons at three developmental stages (34, 37, and 40). As expected

plasticity and modulation. We have demonstrated a developmen-tal change in Ca 21 current pharmacology in ciliary ganglia cellsomata during the period of synapse formation between theseneurons and intrinsic eye muscles. Our data suggest the presenceof a Ca 21 channel type with the pharmacologic properties of bothN- and L-type Ca 21 channels at early embryonic stages. How-ever, by the end of the period of synapse formation with theperiphery, the ciliary ganglion neurons express Ca21 channels,the majority of which seem to fall into classically defined N- andL-type categories.

Previously, Gray et al. (1992) demonstrated that the dihydro-pyridine nifedipine blocked potassium-evoked ACh release fromintact ciliary ganglion nerve terminals in the choroid coat at stage40, but not at post-hatch synapses, whereas v-CgTX GVIAinhibited ACh release much less effectively at stage 40 than atpost-hatch synapses. Because Gray et al. (1992) were measuringthe pharmacology of potassium-evoked ACh release, they couldnot determine whether two different channel types participated inthe regulation of release at early stages or whether there was anembryonic channel with mixed pharmacology. Our data confirmthe expression at early embryonic stages of a mixed pharmaco-logic channel in ciliary ganglion cell somata. The developmentalperiod during which we measured a shift in Ca21 current phar-macology is earlier than the shift in ACh release pharmacologydescribed previously at periphery synapses (Gray et al., 1992).These differences in the developmental timing of the pharmaco-logic shift may be attributable to differences in the timing of ionchannel expression changes between the soma and nerve termi-nal. However, differences in the methods of measuring this phar-macologic shift may make a direct comparison of these datadifficult.

Developmental changes in Ca21 current in neurons have beenreported previously, but, in general, these reports have been lim-ited either to changes in the magnitude of Ca21 current expressionduring development (Dourado and Dryer, 1992; Desarmenien et

Figure 6. Somatostatin modulation of FPL 64176-elongated calciumcurrents recorded via traditional whole-cell recording techniques. Shownare representative examples of calcium current recorded before FPL64176 application (Cont), after FPL 64176 application (FPL), and aftersomatostatin modulation of the FPL 64176-altered current (SOM ) in

Figure 7. Representative somatostatin-mediated modulation of calciumcurrent evoked by a 500 msec voltage ramp from 280 to 160 mV in astage 34 neuron. Somatostatin (SOM ) modulation was absent at voltagesbelow 215 and above 135 mV.

4

stages 34 ( A ), 37 ( B ), and 40 ( C ) neurons. Calibration bars in B apply toA also. Inset, Enlargement of a representative effect of somatostatin atstage 40 on the fast component of the FPL 64176-elongated tail current(similar effects on the fast component of the tail current were observed atall three developmental stages). This inset current record begins 100 msecafter the cessation of the test pulse. D, Plot of the somatostatin effect onFPL 64176-altered peak (open bars) and FPL 64176-elongated tail (solidbars) currents at all three developmental stages (mean 6 SEM measuredat 10 msec after the cessation of the test pulse). Numbers in parenthesesrepresent the number of cells studied. *Significantly different from effectson peak current; Student’s t test, p , 0.05.

6310 J. Neurosci., August 15, 1997, 17(16):6302–6313 White et al. • Development of Ca21 Current and Somatostatin Modulation

Page 10: Developmental Changes in Calcium Current Pharmacology and ... · niques in acutely isolated chick ciliary ganglion neurons at three developmental stages (34, 37, and 40). As expected

al., 1993) or to changes in the relative expression of low-voltage andhigh-voltage-activated current types (Yaari et al., 1987; Gottman etal., 1988; Kostyuk, 1989; McCobb et al., 1989; Thompson andWong, 1991; Gruol et al., 1992; Mynlieff and Beam, 1992; Rothe

and Grantyn, 1994; Lorenzon and Foehring, 1995). In contrast, wereport the expression in embryonic neurons of a mixed pharmaco-logic type of high-voltage-activated current that is replaced byhigh-voltage-activated current types that are blocked selectively byv-CgTX GVIA or dihydropyridine antagonists.

Transmitter release at some central synapses has been shown tobe sensitive to multiple calcium channel antagonists (Luebke etal., 1993; Turner et al., 1993; Wheeler et al., 1994). These dataoften have been interpreted as evidence for the existence ofmultiple calcium channel types regulating release at central syn-apses, and this has been demonstrated in some cases (Wheeler etal., 1996). However, it is also possible that other synapses mayexpress a calcium channel type that has pharmacologic sensitivityto several antagonists previously used as selective agents. Alongthese lines, Fisher and Bourque (1995) have identified a compo-nent of calcium current selectively expressed at rat supraopticnerve terminals that is sensitive to both v-Aga IVA and v-CgTXGVIA. This novel pharmacology is not consistent with classicaldefinitions of N-, P-, or Q-type calcium current and may representa novel calcium channel type. Post-translational modificationsand/or novel subunit combinations of pore-forming a-1 subunitswith one or more of the auxiliary calcium channel subunits (b,a2d, or g) may result in a current with mixed pharmacologicsensitivity. Along these lines, N-type Ca 21 channels in rabbitbrain have been shown to incorporate a subunit homologous tothe b subunit of L-type channels in skeletal muscle (Sakamotoand Campbell, 1991). The existence of an as yet uncharacterizedsplice variant for the a-1 subunit is also possible. Our data mightbe explained by alterations in subunit translation and/or assemblyas development proceeds. Alternatively, post-translational modi-fications at early embryonic stages may differ from those at laterstages. Calcium current with sensitivity to both N- and L-typechannel blockers has been reported in other preparations (Jonesand Jacobs, 1990; Werth et al., 1991; Wang et al., 1992; Williamset al., 1992; Reeve et al., 1994), but these have not been examinedfrom a developmental perspective. Until the expression of cal-cium channel subunit genes has been determined in developingchick ciliary ganglion neurons, the molecular relationship, if any,between channels with mixed pharmacologic sensitivity and thosemediating other currents sensitive selectively to one pharmaco-logic agent will remain unknown.

Because the mixed pharmacologic channel type expressed atearly embryonic stages does not activate at relatively hyperpolar-ized test potentials (220 mV) at which L-type channels are active(Figs. 7, 8), we suggest that the mixed pharmacologic type may bean “N-type” channel that is sensitive to dihydropyridines and FPL64176 at early embryonic stages. Along these lines, it is interest-ing to note that the slowly decaying component of control tailcurrents (not elongated by FPL 64176) shown in Figure 8 isblocked only by nitrendipine (Fig. 8C). These tail currents re-corded from stage 34 neurons are unaffected by somatostatin orv-CgTX GVIA (Fig. 8A,B), in contrast to FPL-elongated tailcurrents at this stage, which were blocked by v-CgTX GVIA(Fig. 3B). This comparison suggests that all current sensitive tov-CgTX GVIA at stage 34 (primarily the mixed pharmacologictype) normally deactivates much more quickly than the popula-tion of purely dihydropyridine-sensitive (L-type) currents presentat this stage. Therefore, the mixed pharmacologic and N-typecurrents activated at similar test potentials and deactivated withsimilar time courses, and both were clearly distinct from L-typecurrent activation and deactivation. Taken together, these datasuggest that the mixed pharmacologic type current may be carried

Figure 8. Measurement of pharmacologic sensitivity and somatostatineffects on calcium current in stage 34 neurons activated by test pulses to220 and 110 mV, recorded via perforated patch-clamp techniques. A,Somatostatin (SOM ) modulated calcium current activated by steps to 110mV but was without effect on current activated by steps to 220 mV. B,v-CgTX GVIA (v-CgTX; 2 mM) had a small effect on current activatedby steps to 220 mV but had a strong effect on current activated by stepsto 110 mV. C, Nitrendipine (Nit; 20 mM) had a strong effect on currentactivated at both 220 and 110 mV. D, Plot of the effects of somatostatin(SOM ), v-CgTX GVIA (v-CgTX ), and nitrendipine (Nit) tested with220 and 110 mV test potentials (mean 6 SEM). Currents shown are anaverage of three sweeps. Numbers in parentheses represent the number ofcells studied. *Significantly different from block of peak current measuredat 110 mV; Student’s t test, p , 0.05.

White et al. • Development of Ca21 Current and Somatostatin Modulation J. Neurosci., August 15, 1997, 17(16):6302–6313 6311

Page 11: Developmental Changes in Calcium Current Pharmacology and ... · niques in acutely isolated chick ciliary ganglion neurons at three developmental stages (34, 37, and 40). As expected

by an N-type channel with sensitivity to dihydropyridines andFPL 64176, instead of an L-type channel with sensitivity tov-CgTX GVIA. In any event, our data suggest a developmentalregulation in chick ciliary ganglion neurons of those processesthat result in the expression of calcium channels with mixedpharmacologic sensitivity.

Developmental changes in somatostatin-mediatedinhibition of Ca21 currentThroughout the changes in calcium current pharmacology de-scribed above, somatostatin consistently blocked ;50–60% ofpeak Ca 21 current. Our data demonstrate that, at the beginningof the period of synapse formation with peripheral eye muscles(stage 34), the mixed pharmacologic channel type is the predom-inant type modulated by somatostatin. However, as developmentproceeds and the expression of the mixed pharmacologic channelis diminished, the proportion of nitrendipine-sensitive Ca21 cur-rent modulated by somatostatin is reduced, whereas the propor-tion of v-CgTX GVIA-sensitive current modulated by soma-tostatin remains essentially unchanged. By stage 40 somatostatintargets predominantly the classically defined N-type Ca21 chan-nel. In summary, despite changes in calcium current pharmacol-ogy, somatostatin-mediated modulation persists.

On the basis of the data showing a significant occlusion of thesomatostatin effect on peak Ca 21 current by nitrendipine and theeffects of v-CgTX GVIA on FPL 64176-elongated tail currents,especially at stage 34, one would have expected somatostatin tomodulate FPL 64176-elongated tail currents at early embryonicstages. However, we were unable to demonstrate an effect ofsomatostatin on FPL 64176-elongated tail currents at stage 34.There are at least two possible explanations for these data. Theremay be two subpopulations of mixed pharmacologic channels,only one of which is sensitive to FPL 64176. If this were the case,one would have to postulate that both subpopulations are sensi-tive to dihydropyridines and v-CgTX GVIA and that somatosta-tin only modulates the subpopulation that is insensitive to FPL64176. We consider this unlikely, because somatostatin did notaffect dihydropyridine-elongated (Bay K 8644) tail currents ei-ther. Alternatively, it is possible that FPL 64176 alters calciumchannels such that interactions with G-proteins are affected (seeScott and Dolphin, 1987; Dolphin and Scott, 1988, 1989). Becausethe b subunit of calcium channels has been hypothesized tointeract with the a-1 subunit in such a way as to affect bothG-protein interactions (Campbell et al., 1995) and dihydropyri-dine binding (Lacerda et al., 1991; Varadi et al., 1991; Mitterdor-fer et al., 1994), the binding sites for G-proteins and dihydropy-ridines may be close enough to each other that the two ligandsinteract. If FPL 64176 binds to the calcium channel in a similarlocation, it may affect G-protein interactions. Along these lines,the effects of somatostatin on FPL 64176-enhanced peak currentwere smaller than observed with control currents (compare solidbars in Fig. 5A,D,G with open bars in Fig. 6D); however, it isdifficult to make a direct comparison, given the effects of FPL64176 on peak current kinetics and amplitude.

In summary, during the early period of synapse formation withtarget muscle, ciliary ganglion neurons express a small percentageof classically defined N- and L-type calcium current and a largepercentage of calcium current with mixed pharmacologic sensi-tivity to v-CgTX GVIA, nitrendipine, and FPL 64176. Thismixed sensitivity is eliminated as these neurons mature, such thatby the end of the period of synapse formation ;75% of thecurrent can be defined as N-type (irreversibly inhibited by

v-CgTX GVIA), and 25% can be defined as L-type (selectivelysensitive to dihydropyridines). Despite this change in calciumcurrent pharmacology, sensitivity to somatostatin persiststhroughout this phase of embryonic development.

REFERENCESBean BP (1989) Neurotransmitter inhibition of neuronal calcium cur-

rents by changes in channel voltage dependence. Nature 340:153–155.Boland L, Bean BP (1993) Modulation of N-type calcium channels in

bullfrog sympathetic neurons by luteinizing hormone-releasing hor-mone: kinetics and voltage dependence. J Neurosci 13:516–533.

Campbell V, Berrow NS, Fitzgerald EM, Brickley K, Dolphin AC (1995)Inhibition of the interaction of G-protein Go with calcium channels bythe calcium channel beta-subunit in rat neurones. J Physiol (Lond)485:365–372.

Coulombe JN, Nishi R (1991) Stimulation of somatostatin expression indeveloping ciliary ganglion neurons by cells of the choroid layer. J Neu-rosci 11:553–562.

Desarmenien MG, Clendening B, Spitzer NC (1993) In vivo develop-ment of voltage-dependent ionic currents in embryonic Xenopus spinalneurons. J Neurosci 13:2575–2581.

De Stefano ME, Ciofi Luzzatto A, Mugnaini E (1993) Neuronal ultra-structure and somatostatin immunolocalization in the ciliary ganglionof chicken and quail. J Neurocytol 22:868–892.

Dolphin AC, Scott RH (1988) Actions of Ca 21 channel ligands dependon G-proteins. Ca 21 agonists/antagonists and GTP. Trends PharmacolSci 9:394–395.

Dolphin AC, Scott RH (1989) Interaction between calcium channel li-gands and guanine nucleotides in cultured rat sensory and sympatheticneurons. J Physiol (Lond) 413:271–288.

Dourado MM, Dryer SE (1992) Changes in the electrical properties ofchick ciliary ganglion neurons during embryonic development. J Physiol(Lond) 449:411–428.

Dryer SE (1994) Functional development of the parasympathetic neu-rons of the avian ciliary ganglion: a classic model system for the studyof neuronal differentiation and development. Prog Neurobiol43:281–322.

Dryer SE, Dourado MM, Wisgirda ME (1991) Properties of Ca 21 cur-rents in acutely dissociated neurons of the chick ciliary ganglion: inhibi-tion by somatostatin-14 and somatostatin-28. Neuroscience 44:663–672.

Epstein ML, Davis JP, Gellman LE, Lamb JR, Dahl JL (1988) Cholin-ergic neurons of the chicken ciliary ganglion contain somatostatin.Neuroscience 25:1053–1060.

Fisher TE, Bourque CW (1995) Distinct v-agatoxin-sensitive calciumcurrents in somata and axon terminals of rat supraoptic neurons.J Physiol (Lond) 489:383–388.

Gottman K, Dietzel ID, Kux HD, Huck S, Rohrer H (1988) Develop-ment of inward currents in chick sensory and autonomic neuronalprecursor cells in culture. J Neurosci 8:3722–3732.

Gray DB, Pilar GR, Ford MJ (1989) Opiate and peptide inhibition oftransmitter release in parasympathetic nerve terminals. J Neurosci9:1683–1692.

Gray DB, Zelazny D, Manthay N, Pilar G (1990) Endogenous modula-tion of ACh release by somatostatin and the differential roles of Ca 21

channels. J Neurosci 10:2687–2698.Gray DB, Bruses JL, Pilar GR (1992) Developmental switch in the

pharmacology of Ca 21 channels coupled to acetylcholine release. Neu-ron 8:715–724.

Gruol DL, Deal CR, Yool AJ (1992) Developmental changes in calciumconductances contribute to the physiological maturation of cerebellarPurkinje neurons in culture. J Neurosci 12:2838–2848.

Hamburger V, Hamilton HL (1951) A series of normal stages in thedevelopment of the chick embryo. J Morphol 88:49–92.

Hille B (1994) Modulation of ion channels by G-protein-coupled recep-tors. Trends Neurosci 17:531–535.

Horn R, Marty A (1988) Muscarinic activation of ionic currents mea-sured by a new whole-cell recording method. J Gen Physiol 92:145–159.

Jones SW, Jacobs LS (1990) Dihydropyridine actions on calcium cur-rents of frog sympathetic neurons. J Neurosci 10:2261–2267.

Kasai H, Neher E (1992) Dihydropyridine-sensitive and v-conotoxin-sensitive calcium channels in a mammalian neuroblastoma–glioma cellline. J Physiol (Lond) 448:161–188.

Kostyuk PG (1989) Diversity of ion channels in cellular membranes.Neuroscience 28:253–261.

6312 J. Neurosci., August 15, 1997, 17(16):6302–6313 White et al. • Development of Ca21 Current and Somatostatin Modulation

Page 12: Developmental Changes in Calcium Current Pharmacology and ... · niques in acutely isolated chick ciliary ganglion neurons at three developmental stages (34, 37, and 40). As expected

Kunze DL, Rampe D (1992) Characterization of the effects of a newCa 21 channel activator, FPL 64176, in GH3 cells. Mol Pharmacol42:666–670.

Lacerda AE, Haeyoung SK, Ruth P, Perez-Reyes E, Flockerz V, Hof-mann F, Birnbaumer L, Brown AM (1991) Normalization of currentkinetics by interaction between the alpha1 and beta subunits of theskeletal muscle dihydropyridine-sensitive Ca 21 channel. Nature352:527–530.

Lorenzon NM, Foehring RC (1995) Characterization of pharmacologi-cally identified voltage-gated calcium channel currents in acutely iso-lated rat neocortical neurons. II. Postnatal development. J Neuro-physiol 73:1443–1451.

Luebke JI, Dunlap K, Turner TJ (1993) Multiple calcium channel typescontrol glutamatergic synaptic transmission in the hippocampus. Neu-ron 11:895–902.

McCobb DP, Best PM, Beam KG (1989) Development alters the expres-sion of calcium currents in chick limb motoneurons. Neuron2:1633–1643.

McKechnie R, Killingback P, Naya I, O’Connor S, Smith G, Wattam D,Wells E, Whitehead Y, Williams G (1989) Calcium channel activatorproperties in a novel non-dihydropyridine, FPL 64176. Br J Pharmacol98:673P.

Meriney SD, Gray DB, Pilar GR (1994) Somatostatin-induced inhibitionof neuronal Ca 21 current modulated by cGMP-dependent proteinkinase. Nature 369:336–339.

Mitterdorfer J, Froschmayr M, Grabner M, Striessnig J, Glossmann H(1994) Calcium channels: the beta-subunit increases the affinity ofdihydropyridine and Ca 21 binding sites of the alpha1-subunit. FEBSLett 352:141–145.

Mynlieff M, Beam KG (1992) Developmental expression of voltage-dependent calcium currents in identified mouse motoneurons. Dev Biol152:407–410.

O’Dowd DK, Ribera AB, Spitzer NC (1988) Development of voltage-dependent calcium, sodium, and potassium currents in Xenopus spinalneurons. J Neurosci 8:792–805.

Rae J, Cooper K, Gates P, Watsky M (1991) Low access resistanceperforated patch recordings using amphotericin B. J Neurosci Methods37:15–26.

Rampe D, Anderson B, Rapien-Pryor V, Li T, Dage RC (1993) Com-parison of the in vitro and in vivo cardiovascular effects of two struc-turally distinct Ca 21 channel activators, BAY K 8644 and FPL 64176.J Pharmacol Exp Ther 265:1125–1130.

Randall A, Tsien RW (1995) Pharmacological dissection of multipletypes of Ca 21 channel currents in rat cerebellar granule neurons.J Neurosci 15:2995–3012.

Reeve HL, Vaughan PFT, Peers C (1994) Calcium channel currents inundifferentiated human neuroblastoma (SH-SY5Y) cells: actions andpossible interactions of dihydropyridines and v-conotoxin. Eur J Neu-rosci 6:943–952.

Rothe T, Grantyn R (1994) Retinal ganglion neurons express a toxin-resistant developmentally regulated novel type of high-voltage-activated calcium channel. J Neurophysiol 72:2542–2546.

Sakamoto J, Campbell KP (1991) A monoclonal antibody to the betasubunit of the skeletal muscle dihydropyridine receptor immunopre-cipitates the brain v-conotoxin GVIA receptor. J Biol Chem266:18914–18919.

Scholz KP, Miller RJ (1995) Developmental changes in presynaptic cal-cium channels coupled to glutamate release in cultured rat hippocampalneurons. J Neurosci 15:4612–4617.

Scott RH, Dolphin AC (1987) Activation of a G-protein promotes ago-nist responses to calcium channel ligands. Nature 330:760–762.

Spitzer NC (1994) Development of voltage-dependent and ligand-gatedchannels in excitable membranes. Prog Brain Res 102:169–179.

Thompson SM, Wong RKS (1991) Development of calcium current sub-types in isolated rat hippocampal pyramidal cells. J Physiol (Lond)439:671–689.

Turner TJ, Adams ME, Dunlap K (1993) Multiple Ca 21 channel typescoexist to regulate synaptosomal neurotransmitter release. Proc NatlAcad Sci USA 90:9518–9522.

Varadi G, Lory P, Schultz D, Varadi M, Schwartz A (1991) Accelerationof activation and inactivation by the beta subunit of the skeletal musclecalcium channel. Nature 352:159–162.

Viana F, Hille B (1996) Modulation of high-voltage-activated calciumchannels by somatostatin in acutely isolated rat amygdaloid neurons.J Neurosci 16:6000–6011.

Wang X, Treistman SN, Lemos JR (1992) Two types of high-thresholdcalcium currents inhibited by v-conotoxin in nerve terminals of ratneurohypophysis. J Physiol (Lond) 445:181–199.

Werth JL, Hirning LD, Thayer SA (1991) v-Conotoxin exerts function-ally distinct low and high affinity effects in the neuronal cell lineNG108-15. Mol Pharmacol 40:742–749.

Wheeler DB, Randall A, Tsien RW (1994) Roles of N-type and Q-typeCa 21 channels in supporting hippocampal synaptic transmission. Sci-ence 264:107–111.

Wheeler DB, Randall A, Tsien RW (1996) Changes in action potentialduration alter reliance of excitatory synaptic transmission on multipletypes of Ca 21 channels in rat hippocampus. J Neurosci 16:2226–2237.

Williams ME, Feldman DH, McCue AF, Brenner R, Velicelebi G, EllisSB, Harpold MM (1992) Structure and functional expression of al-pha1, alpha2, and beta subunits of a novel human neuronal Ca 21

channel subtype. Neuron 8:71–84.Yaari Y, Hamon B, Lux HD (1987) Development of two types of

calcium channels in cultured mammalian hippocampal neurons. Science235:680–682.

Yawo H, Momiyama A (1993) Re-evaluation of calcium currents in pre-and postsynaptic neurons of the chick ciliary ganglion. J Physiol (Lond)460:153–172.

White et al. • Development of Ca21 Current and Somatostatin Modulation J. Neurosci., August 15, 1997, 17(16):6302–6313 6313