Determinants of Profitability in Indian Public Sector Banks Word - Copy

26

description

a dissertation/ project report

Transcript of Determinants of Profitability in Indian Public Sector Banks Word - Copy

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

INTRODUCTION:

The term 'profit' is an accounting concept which shows the excess of income over expenditure viewed during a specified period of time. Profit is the main reason for the continued existence of every commercial organisation. On the other hand, the term profitability is a relative measure where profit is expressed as a ratio, generally as a percentage. Profitability depicts the relationship of the absolute amount of profit with various other factors. Profitability is the most important and reliable indicator as it gives a broad indicator of the ability of a bank to raise its income level. Profitability of banks is affected by a number of factors. Some of these are endogenous, some are exogenous. Changes in policies made by RBI are exogenous to the system. These include changes in monetary policy, changes in quantitative credit control like changes in cash reserve ratio, statutory liquidity ratio, manipulation of bank rates, qualitative credit controls like selective credit control measures, credit deposit ratio, region-wise guidelines on lending to priority sector, changes in interest rates on deposits and advances, levy of tax on interest income etc. Various other factors like careful control of expenditure, timely recovery of loans are endogenous. In practice executives define profits in banks as the difference between total earnings from all earning assets and total expenditure on managing entire asset liabilities portfolio. In case of banks, the main source of income is interest earned and discount on bills discounted. Since banks accept various types of deposits from people so interest paid to customer is an important expenditure of the banks. The difference between interest earned and interest paid is known as spread and is a good indicator of bank's efficiency. Establishment expenses covering salaries, provident fund, allowances, and bonus and so on, form another important component of expenditure. Profit is the very reason for the continued existence of every commercial organisation. The rate of profitability and volume of profits are therefore rightfully considered as indicators of efficiency in the deployment of resources of banks. The study makes a profitability correlation analysis by taking certain dependent variables like the profitability in the one hand and independent variables like Net Interest income, interest income, interest expended, operating expense, NPAs.

OBJECTIVES:

To find out impact of various variables on the profitability of public sector banks.

To examine the variables having positive and negative relationship with the profitability of the banks.SCOPE OF THE STUDY Source of information collected from secondary data RESEARCH DESIGN: Analytical in nature Secondary data: Books websites database at Indian Bank library research

CHAPTER ILITERATURE REVIEW

Dr. K. Sriharsha Reddy (March 2012) has explained the nature of banking and the important role of banks in the economy in capital formation, banks should be more closely watched than any other type of economic unit in the economy. The CAMEL supervisory system in banking sector is a substantial improvement over the earlier systems in terms of frequency, coverage and focus. In the present study an attempt is made to evaluate relative performance of banks in India using CAMEL approach. It is found that public sector banks have significantly improved indicating positive impact of the reforms in liberalizing interest rates, rationalizing directed credit and Investments and increasing competition.Kusum W. Ketkar (2011):- In his article, he has explained to determine the impact of various market and regulatory initiatives on efficiency improvements and profitability of Indian banks since the implementation of financial sector reforms following the recommendations of the Narasimham Committee in 1992 and 1997. The reform process has shifted the focus of public sector dominated banking system from social banking to a more efficient and profit oriented industry. While the reform process has resulted in the private sector replacing the government as the source of resources for public sector banks (PSBs), the infusion of private equity capital has led to shareholders challenges to bureaucratic decision making. PSBs also face increasing competition not only from private and foreign banks but also from growing nonbanking financial intermediaries like mutual funds and other capital market entities. The competitive pressures to improve efficiency in the banking sector has resulted in a switch from traditional paper based banking to electronic banking, use information technology and shift of emphasis from brick and mortar banking to use of ATMs. For instance, by March of 2007, 86% of public sector bank branches were fully computerized and ATMs made up approximately 48% of total bank branches in the country.

Sultan Singh (2001) made an attempt to assess the impact of the reforms on the operational performance and efficiency of the commercial banks in India. The study revealed that total income, interest earned other income, spread, total expenses, interest expended, operating expenses and establishment expenses are comparatively more consistent in the post-reform period. T. T. Ram Mohan (2002, pp. 393-97) in his paper documented and evaluated the performance of the public, private and foreign banks since deregulation in absolute and in relative terms. It was observed that the efficiency of the banking system as a whole measured by declining spreads has improved. G P. Kapoor (2004, pp.58-131) in her book entitled "Commercial Banking" analysed the performance of banks from 1981-1982 to 1999-2000 and revealed that the deposits, advances, total business. Income, expenditure, net interest margin, working funds, branches and employees of the entire PSBs registered lower rates of growth in the post-reform period as compared to the pre-reform period.

P.K. Gupta & Ashima Jain( 2010) have explained how the banks operate today in a more competitive and complex environment, which provides them opportunities to augment revenues quickly, but also poses huge risks. Creation of new products and aggressive marketing by banks has led to unmanageable credit risk that arises of poor credit assessment and follows up and also credit concentration. Financing is predominantly viewed from borrowers perspective and researches mainly focus on credit spreads collateral, long-term structures and commitments between borrowers and lenders over time. We attempt to explore the factors that are responsible for the origination of problem loans (Non-performing Assets) from the financier perspective. We focus on Indian Private Sector banks as a special case, which is relatively unexplored. We model the factors that are responsible for problem loans in the sample banks and suggest the policy implications for the central bank of the country-Reserve Bank of India (RBI). Though we find support for some explanatory variables like liquidity, interest margins, operating efficiency etc. in line with the earlier researches, yet some explored variables produced converse notions

CHAPTER II Research Methodology

The term profit is an accounting concept which shows the excess of income over expenditure viewed during a specified period of time. Profit is the main reason for the continued existence of every commercial organization. On the other hand, the term profitability is a relative measure where profit is expressed as a ratio, generally as a percentage. Profitability depicts the relationship of the absolute amount of profit with various other factors. Profitability is a relative concept which is quite useful in decision-making. Another main issue here is profit planning, which consists of various steps to be taken to improve the profitability of the bank.

Profit is the very reason for the continued existence of every commercial organization. The rate of profitability and volume of profits are therefore, rightfully considered as indicators of efficiency in the deployment of resources of banks. Profitability indicates earning capacity of the banks. It highlights the managerial competency of the banks. It also portrays work culture, operating efficiency of the bank.

Profitability is the most important and reliable indicator as it gives a broad indication of the ability of a bank to raise its income level. Profitability of banks is affected by a number of factors. Some of these are endogenous, some are exogenous and yet structural. Changes in policies made by RBI are exogenous to the system. This includes changes in momentary policy, changes in quantitative credit control like changes in CRR, SLR, manipulation of bank rates, qualitative credit controls like selective credit control measures, C/D ratio, region wise guidelines on lending to priority sectors, changes in interest rates on deposits and advances, levy of tax on interest income etc. Various other factors like careful control of expenditure, timely recovery of loans are endogenous. Various structural factors include geographical spread of bank branches, decentralization in the management and structural changes in deposits and advances. Banking structure and profitability structure of banking system across countries have a bearing on the profitability of banks. The profitability of banks is affected one way or the other by these factors, either individually or jointly. Bank profitability is causing concern to all. After liberalisation, profitability has regained its lost importance. Now efforts are being directed to achieve the profitability targets. The profitability of public sector banks has been indicating a fast declining trend in the past and the situation in future may not be different if all the concerned do not take timely preventive measures before the situation goes out of control. Since all the banks in the country function under similar environments, the low performance of any bank can be attributed to a larger extent to their managerial inefficiency and structural deficiency. Certain populist Central Government disregarding the basic banking principles, coupled with lethargic attitude of the management of nationalized banks lead toInefficiency, in-competency and deceleration in performance. The major reasons for this declining profitability can be summarized as under:

1. Non-Performing advances leading to bad debts..2. Legal Expenses to recovers the bad debts..3. Cut Throat competition among banks to lure deposits.4. Narrowing Spread.5. Branch Expansion on unviable consideration.6. Ineffective organizational restructuring.7. Lack of proper management of resources.8. More concentration on deposit orientation than profit orientation.9. Increasing burden of administrative expenses.10. Increasing establishment expenses.11. Ineffective marketing strategies resulting in reduction in market share.12. No turn-over strategies.13. Ineffective cost-oriented strategies.14. Subsidized service charges like concession granted.15. Ineffective environment scanning.The problem of low profitability and designing profitability has been historical to the banking system. The banks are virtually suffering from scissors crisis, with a declining rate of increase in earnings and rising costs. The profitability analysis of commercial banks used to be a frustrating experience as the financial statements of banks concealed much and revealed less. But now-a-days, after liberalization under pressure from regulatory agencies and the public, the trend has changed. So now the profitability analysis of commercial banks means something. The financial statements of commercial banks are now prepared keeping in mind are the various changes, so they reveal each and every aspect.Profits have been, and are under tremendous pressure. Declining trends in profits and profitability have become a major cause of concern for all and in order to ensure the survival and growth of this vital sector of economy, it becomes essential to identify various factors which have studiedly contributed towards the decline in bank profitability so that corrective action can be taken and future profitability is ensured. The major factors that have a bearing on the financial viability of the banks are:

1. Priority Sector Lending.2. Credit Policies.3. Massive Geographical Expansion.4. Industrial Sickness.5. Growing Competition. 6. Deposit Composition.7. Increasing Establishment Expenses.8. Low Income from Ancillary Business.9. Spread and Burden Their Backward Linkages and Movements.10. Miscellaneous Factors (Like declining credit AND mounting overdue).

The present trend of low and declining profitability can be arrested and reversed if the remedial measures are tried in right direction to ease the pressure on profitability. The profit rates obtained by using sales or value added as denominators will therefore give us a short-term perspective of profitability. The return on capital employed on investments or total assets or fixed assets as variously defined, on the other hand will give us long-term perspective of profitability.

Thus to undertake this study, the data of all the Public sector Banks in India was collected through basically secondary sources. After that the data was organized and a thorough analysis was done of the same and the statistical tool used for the purpose was basically the Correlation Analysis. The following pages contain the analysis of the determinants of the profitability of the banks.

CHAPTER IIIAnalysis and Interpretation

Correlation Analysis becomes imperative to evaluate the overall profits and profitability performance of commercial banks. It clearly indicates the magnitude and direction of operations over a period of time; it also helps to identify certain banks in respect of their level of efficiency in operations. It shows the trend pattern in order to identify the historical development. The study attempts to assess the profits and profitability of banks, through correlation analysis of the following parameters:-1. Net Profit2. Total Income3. Total Expenditure4. Spread5.Operating expense6.NPA

1. Net Profit:

Every business exists in order to earn profit. Without profit no commercial activity can sustain for a long period. Similarly, profit earning has become the main motive of commercial banks operating in India. Profit earning and timely growth in the profit earning is an essential feature for the continued success of a bank. On the basis of correlation and the following data reveals that Net profit is the independent variables and it also correlated to `

1.Total Income2. Total Expenditure3. Spread4.Operating expense5.NPA

Correlation between Net profit and the independent variables. Variables 201020112012

Interest earned0.091043451

0.258919002

0.017097491

Interest expended-0.013238549

-0.018929453-0.027502713

NII0.614241748

0.001333062

0.02563553

NPAs

-0.098857897

-0.298859568

-0.313113346

Operating Expense

-0.051163142

-0.188027256

-0.166113872

1. Total Income

YearsCorrelation of total income & Net profit

20100.091043451

20110.258919002

20120.017097491

The total income of a bank depends upon the interest and discount earned, commission, exchange and brokerage and the other miscellaneous receipts. The correlation analysis reveals that the banks income is positively related to the net profit which is good for the overall performance for the PSUs. On the basis of trends in total income of the 23 PSBs under study, there is positive correlation, this means that when the interest income is high the net profit will be high and vice versa.

2. Total Expenditure

Year Correlation of total expenditure & Net profit

2010-0.013238549

2011-0.018929453

2012-0.027502713

As far as the expenditure of public sector banks is concerned, it is fixed to a large extent because these banks cannot reduce labour force as the other industries can do in order to minimize their expenditure but in the recent years banks have taken some steps in this respect. The main components of the bank expenditure are interest on deposit, establishment expenditure and other expenditure. On the basis of the correlation analysis the total expenditure also determine the effect on the net profit of the banks, which is quite visible. There is negative correlation, this means that when the interest expended is high the net profit will be low and vice versa.

3. Spread (NII)

Years

Correlation of Spread and Net profit

20100.614241748

20110.001333062

20120.02563553

Spread, which is the difference between the interest earned on loans and advances and interest paid on deposits and borrowings by the banks. It is the net amount available to banks for meeting the various expenses. To make an analysis of the profitability of commercial banks, it is necessary to make a study of exponential growth rate of trends. Higher the value higher wills the profit. On the basis of correlation the spread show the positive trend. It is quite good for evaluating the bank performance.

4. NPAs

Years Correlation of NPAs & Net profit

2010-0.098857897

2011-0.298859568

2012-0.313113346

Nonperforming assets are the asset which ceases to generate income. NPA is a classification used by financial institutions that refer to loans that are in jeopardy of default. Once the borrower has failed to make interest or principal payments for 90 days the loan is considered to be a non-performing asset. Non-performing assets are problematic for financial institutions since they depend on interest payments for income. Troublesome pressure from the economy can lead to a sharp increase in non-performing loans and often results in massive write-downs. On the basis of correlation analysis more NPAs can affect the profitability of the banks. So its always shows the negative trends.

5. Operating Expenses

YearCorrelation of operating expense & Net profit

2010-0.051163142

2011-0.188027256

2012-0.166113872

Operating expenses arise during the ordinary course of running a business. Operating expense consists of salaries paid to employees, research and development costs, legal fees, accountant fees, bank charges, office supplies, electricity bills, business licenses, and more. A category of expenditure that a business incurs as a result of performing its normal business operations. One of the typical responsibilities that management must contend with is determining how low operating expenses can be reduced without significantly affecting the firm's ability to compete with its competitors. Under this study there is negative correlation, this means that when the operating expense are high the net profit will be low and vice versa.

CONCLUSION

To conclude it can be said that evaluation of banks in terms of profitability is very essential. In order to study the trend in independent variables like operating expenditure, NII, NPAs, interest expenditure and interest income affect the profitability of the public sector banks.

ANNEXUREList of the Public Sector Banks studied:

REFERENCES Narinder Kaur and Reetu Kapoor 2011, Profitability Analysis of Public Sector Banks in India, article Indian management studies. Dr. K. Sriharsha Reddy (2012) ,Relative performance of commercial banks in India using CAMEL approach. Kusum W. Ketkar (2010) Performance and Profitability of Indian Banks in the Post Liberalization Period. www.moneycontrol.com www.rbi.gov.in