Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

42
www.designforcontext.com Duane Degler Principal, Design for Context [email protected] @ddegler Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous) The LAM (Libraries, Archives, Museums) Digital InformaDon Ecosystem MUSEUMS AND THE WEB 5 April 2014 • BalDmore, MD USA

description

The tide of available information continues to rise.The opportunities that come from open access, linked data, sharing resources with other institutions, and standards-based data are enticing - and perhaps overwhelming? Emerging design approaches help you find ways to make the most of your opportunities for new types of interactions and engagement with Information Objects. They focus on: - Exploration, serendipity, use: Rich, relevant design requires an intimate understanding of information and the way people interact with it. It's more than attractive styling - although that's important. It's about people engaging in ways that stimulate the intellect and the experience. People need to find information, use it, relate other information to it, and share it for decades to come. - Scalability, persistence, authority: Rich, relevant design also takes the long view. Understanding that the integrity of the information matters. This is increasingly important as we move toward more linked, open, and born digital cultural information. Your institution becomes a gateway to an ecosystem of artistic imagery, scholarly insights, history, perspectives, and related objects. Other people will use your information to create new interpretations and works, which then build on what you hold. Curating information may be perceived as a burden (to be made easier!), yet it is a significant opportunity to reinforce the value and authority of institutions that enhance the information ecosystem.

Transcript of Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Page 1: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

www.designforcontext.com  

Duane  Degler    Principal,  Design  for  Context    [email protected]    @ddegler  

Design  Meets  Data  (Linked,  Open,  Heterogeneous)              

The  LAM  (Libraries,  Archives,  Museums)  Digital  InformaDon  Ecosystem  

MUSEUMS  AND  THE  WEB  5  April  2014  •  BalDmore,  MD  USA          

Page 2: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  2   Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  2  

What  is  happening  in  cultural  insDtuDons?  

•  Digital  strategies  

•  Significant,  wide-­‐ranging  digital  iniDaDves  

•  Dispersing  digital  responsibiliDes  within  insDtuDons  

•  Open  access  

•  Linked  data  Open v

Page 3: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  3   Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  3  

FRAMING:  The  “InformaDon  Object”    and  the  LAM  Ecosystem  (Libraries,  Archives,  Museums)  

Page 4: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  4  

The  Informa@on  Object  

Physical  Object  A  thing  held  in  trust  by  an  insDtuDon  

• Work  of  art,  book,  arDfact,  archival  record  

Informa@on  Object  The  aggregate  set  of  informaDon  in  the  insDtuDon  that  illustrates,  describes,  interprets,  or  references  a  physical  object  

Images  

Structured  Data  

NarraDve  DescripDon  

Provenance  /  History  

InterpreDve  InformaDon  

Page 5: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  5  

Why  is  informa@on  object  cura@on  important  ?  

•  LAMs  hold  the  physical  object  and  key  informaDon  objects    in  trust  for  society  .  .  .  in  perpetuity    

•  We  don’t  know  to  what  uses  something  will  be  put  .  .  .  We  only  know  it  is  significant,  and  must  be  available  •  Findable  •  Usable  •  Shareable  •  Connectable  

Page 6: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  6  

From:  “Designing  for  InformaDon  Objects”,  Degler  &  Johnson,  EdUI  2013  hfp://www.designforcontext.com/publicaDons/designing-­‐for-­‐informaDon-­‐objects    

PARTNER  INSTITUTION  

•  -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐  •  -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐  •  -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐  

•  -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐  •  -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐  

External-­‐facing  informa@on  object  

Images  

Structured  Data  

NarraDve  DescripDon  

Provenance  /  History  

DATA  CARETAKER  

CURATOR  

METADATA  STORE  

DAM  

PROVENANCE  

HISTORIC  REFERENCES  

InterpreDve  InformaDon  

CONTROLLED  VOCABULARY  

Page 7: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  7  

PARTNER  INSTITUTION  

CONSERVATOR  

•  -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐  •  -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐  •  -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐  

•  -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐  •  -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐  

Internal-­‐facing  informa@on  object  

Images  

Structured  Data  

NarraDve  DescripDon  

Provenance  /  History  

DATA  CARETAKER  

CURATOR  

METADATA  STORE  

DAM  

PROVENANCE  

HISTORIC  REFERENCES  

InterpreDve  InformaDon  

LAB  NOTES  /  REPORTS  

From:  “Designing  for  InformaDon  Objects”,  Degler  &  Johnson,  EdUI  2013  hfp://www.designforcontext.com/publicaDons/designing-­‐for-­‐informaDon-­‐objects    

CONTROLLED  VOCABULARY  

Page 8: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  8  

Digital  Cultural  Ecosystem  

Curate    InsDtuDonal  curaDon    of  InformaDon  Object  

Extend    RelaDonships    &  enhancement  

Enrich    ParDcipate  in  cultural  ecosystem  n  HumaniDes  /  Cultural  relaDonships  n  Societal  /  Contextual  relaDonships  

Page 9: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  9  

[Digital  &  linked]  cultural  ecosystem  

Cultural  Ins@tu@ons  Holding  or  exhibi@ng  Objects  

Search  &  Aggrega@on  Federated  access  to  DH  informa@on  

Cultural  Educa@on  Conduc@ng  &  promo@ng  scholarship  

Vocabulary    Standardized  discovery  

Historical  &  Social  Sites  Access  to  broader  contexts  

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  9  

Page 10: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  10  

Design  requirements  

•  Discovery  &  Serendipity  •  Discover  relevant  informaDon  objects  –  known  and  unknown  –    through  search/browse  

 (and  foster  that  serendipitous,  “A-­‐ha!”  moment)  

•  Extend  use    •  Take  away  informaDon  objects  relevant  to  my  interest  

•  Conveniently  re-­‐use  informaDon  in  my  own  work  products  

•  Persistence    •  Conveniently  link/reference  my  work  and  source  informaDon  objects  

•  Trust  that  informaDon  objects  to  which  I  link/reference  will  remain  available    

•  Sustainability  •  Flexibility  in  design  and  data  modeling  to  adapt  to  future  capabiliDes  and  topics  

 •  Scalability  

•  Comfortably  adapt  to  ever-­‐growing  collecDons  and  different  working  styles  across  insDtuDons  

Page 11: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  11   Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  11  

USABLE  DESIGN  Is  Linked  Open  Data  a  nice-­‐to-­‐have    or  a  game  changer  ?  

Page 12: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  12  

The  role  of  linked  open  data  

Subject   Object  Predicate  

played  

Verb v

painted  

Netherlands  

born  in  lived  in  

“Which  famous  non-­‐Scojsh  arDsts  painted  bagpipes?”  

Page 13: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  13  

The  Role  of  Linked  Open  Data  

Bal@more  

Rembrandt  Peale  

R.  Peale  Museum  

Has  museum  

Founded  by  

Displays  

Roman  Daughter  

Smithsonian  

Displays  

D.C.  

Has  museum  

1812  Flag  Displayed  

Ft.  McHenry  

Flew  

Has  site  

Painted  

Reubens  P.  w/Geranium  

Displays  

NGA  

Has  museum  

Page 14: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  14  

The  Role  of  Linked  Open  Data  

Bal@more  

R.  Peale  Museum  

Has  museum  

Ar@llery  memorabilia  

Displayed  

Paherson  Park  

Has  site  

Site  of  

Volunteer  Arch.  Dig  

Bal@more  Heritage  

Organizes  

Has  event  

April  15th  

On  date  

Find  

Philadelphia  

Charles  W.  Peale  

Son  of  

Lived  in  

Page 15: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  15  

ENGAGE  

•  NavigaDng  relaDonships  •  Viewing  content  •  Discovering  relevant  informaDon  •  Applying  to  broader  context  

Page 16: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  16  

ENGAGE              Naviga@ng  rela@onships    MOMA  “Inven@ng  Abstrac@on”  

Page 17: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  17  

Individual’s  Network  

Which  person  to  choose?    How  does  their  work  relate?    What  other  related  works?  

Specific  Work  

Can  I  learn  more?    What  is  the  context?    How  does  this  relate  to  others  in  the  network?  

Big  Picture  

What  types  of  relaDonships  can  I  explore?  

ENGAGE              Naviga@ng  rela@onships    MOMA  “Inven@ng  Abstrac@on”  

Page 18: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  18  

ENGAGE              Naviga@ng  rela@onships  

HENDRICK  TER  BRUGGHEN  1588  –  1629    BIRTHPLACE      THE  HAGUE    PLACES                      UTRECHT  WORKED            ROME  

more…

Hendrick  ter  Brugghen  was  born  in  1588,  probably  in  The  Hague.  His  parents,  Jan  Egbertsz  ter  Brugghen  and  Feysgen  Dircx,  came  from  Utrecht,  but  lived  for  a  Dme  in  The  Hague  because  of  Jan’s  career  as  a  civil  servant.  He  served  as  secretary  to  the  court  of  Utrecht  in  1581  and  became  bailiff  of  the  States  of  Holland  in  1585.  By  1603  the  family  was  living  in  Abcoude,  a  village  midway  between  Utrecht  and  Amsterdam.  During  these  years,  Ter  Brugghen  may  have  been  apprenDced  to  the  Utrecht  mannerist  Abraham  Bloemaert  (1566–1651).    

all  

school  

influencers  

patrons  

locaDons  

mediums  

galleries    

 1619                                                          1621                                                              1623                                                1625                                                    1627                                                                    1629  RELATED  ARTISTS  

Gerard  van  Honthorst  

       Frans  Hals        

Type  of  work  icon   LocaDon  during  creaDon  icon  

Page 19: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  19  

ENGAGE              Naviga@ng  rela@onships  

The  Bagpipe  Player  HENDRICK  TER  BRUGGHEN,  1624  

12   7  

Gallery  Flow   Time  Browse  

Page 20: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  20  

ENGAGE              Naviga@ng  rela@onships  

The  Bagpipe  Player  HENDRICK  TER  BRUGGHEN,  1624  

1628-­‐29  1625-­‐27  1618-­‐20   1621-­‐23  

Gallery  Flow   Time  Browse  

12   7  

Page 21: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  21  

ENGAGE          Viewing  content  Rijksmuseum  “RijksStudio”  

Page 22: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  22  

Page 23: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  23  

Page 24: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  24  

ENGAGE:      Applying  to  Broader  Context  

Page 25: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  25  

ENGAGE              Viewing  content    Na@onal  Gallery  of  Art,  DC  “Dutch  Online  Edi@ons”  (OSCI)  

Page 26: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  26  

ENGAGE              Applying  to  broader  context    Cleveland  Museum  of  Art  “Gallery  One”  

An  immersive  experience  

Page 27: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  27  

ENGAGE              Applying  to  broader  context    Cleveland  Museum  of  Art  “Gallery  One”  

Users  take  their  selecDons  with  them  through  the  museum’s  galleries  

Page 28: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  28  

   Engage:      Applying  to  Broader  Context  

1  

2  

1  

Page 29: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  29  

Engage:      Applying  to  Broader  Context  

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  29  

Page 30: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  30  

CREATE  

•  Establishing  relaDonships  •  Applying  descripDons  &  classificaDon  

Page 31: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  31  

SITU

ATION  SIGNAL

S  SITU

ATION  SIGNALS  

LocaDon  

Co-­‐occurring  events  

Date  /  Dme  

CondiDons  

Devices  /  connecDvity  SITU

ATION  SIGNAL

S  USE

R  SIGNAL

S   Usage  paferns  

Experience  

Interests  /  profile  

History  

Community  

CONTENT  SIGN

ALS  

Link  relaDonships  

Text  paferns  

Categories  /  keywords  

Metadata  

TASK

 SIGNAL

S   Outcomes  /  goals  

Rules  /  requirements  

CriDcality  

Sequence  /  status  

Frequency  for  user  

From:  “SupporDng  Relevance  for  Users:  A  Design  Challenge”  Degler,  SemTechBiz  6.2013  hfp://www.designforcontext.com/publicaDons/supporDng-­‐relevance-­‐for-­‐users  

CREATE  Models  support    rela@onships  

Page 32: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  32  

CREATE              Establishing  rela@onships    Conserva@onSpace  (PI:  NGA,  DC)  

EXAM

PLE  ONLY:  D

esign  wire

fram

es  

Page 33: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  33  

CREATE              Establishing  rela@onships    Conserva@onSpace  (PI:  NGA,  DC)  

EXAM

PLE  ONLY:  D

esign  wire

fram

es  

Page 34: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  34  

CREATE            Applying  descrip@ons  and  classifica@on  

Page 35: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  35  

CREATE            Applying  descrip@ons  and  classifica@on  

Page 36: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  36  

EVOLVE  

•  Learning  from  use  •  Monitoring  paferns  and  driu  •  CollaboraDng  with  others  

Page 37: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  37  

USE  

EVOLVE            Enhancement  ecosystem  MANAGE  

NEW  CONTENT  

LEGACY  CONTENT  

TAG  LINK  

ANNOTATE  

CRAWL  

TRACK  

COLLABORATE  

From:  “Enhancement  Ecosystems”,  Degler  &  Vander  Wal,  SemTechBiz  10.2013  hfp://www.designforcontext.com/publicaDons/enhancement-­‐ecosystems-­‐enriching-­‐structured-­‐content-­‐with-­‐user-­‐tagging-­‐and-­‐annotaDon  

EXTRACT  &  INDEX  

 •  -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐  

•  -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐  •  -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐  

•  -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐  •  -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐  

TAXONOMY  

REVIEW  &  ASSESS  

ENHANCE  &  

EVALUATE  

Page 38: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  38  

Focus  areas  for  Usable  Design  

Engage:  Interact  with  content  •  Viewing  content  •  NavigaDng  relaDonships  •  Discovering  relevant  informaDon  •  Applying  to  broader  context  

 Create:  Manage  content  and  sites  using  data  and  vocabularies  

•  Establishing  relaDonships  •  Applying  descripDons  &  classificaDon  

 Evolve:  Maintain/grow  data  and  vocabularies  over  Dme  

•  Learning  from  use  •  Monitoring  paferns  and  driu  

•  CollaboraDng  with  others  

Page 39: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  39   Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  39  

Now  what  ?  

Page 40: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  40  

Think  Globally  .  .  .  

Act  Locally  

Page 41: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

www.designforcontext.com  

Duane  Degler    Principal,  Design  for  Context    [email protected]    @ddegler  

Design  Meets  Data  (Linked,  Open,  Heterogeneous)              

The  LAM  (Libraries,  Archives,  Museums)  Digital  InformaDon  Ecosystem  

MUSEUMS  AND  THE  WEB  5  April  2014  •  BalDmore,  MD  USA          

Page 42: Design Meets Data (Linked, Open, Heterogeneous)

Design  Meets  Data  |  Museums  and  the  Web  |  5  April,  2014  |  ©  Degler  42  

References  and  image  notes  

IMAGES    Slide  4:  hfp://www.nga.gov/content/ngaweb/CollecDon/art-­‐object-­‐page.144298.html    Slide  9:  hfp://www.hendrickbrugghen.org  hfp://www.khm.at/en/    hfp://www.louvre.fr/en  hfp://www.hermitagemuseum.org  hfp://yalepress.yale.edu/yupbooks/book.asp?isbn=9780300074512  hfp://www.hendrickbrugghen.org/Woman-­‐Playing-­‐the-­‐Lute-­‐1624-­‐26.html  hfp://www.cambridge.org/sg/academic/subjects/arts-­‐theatre-­‐culture/western-­‐art/golden-­‐age-­‐dutch-­‐painDng-­‐historical-­‐perspecDve  hfp://press.princeton.edu/Dtles/8513.html  hfps://www.rijksmuseum.nl/en/explore-­‐the-­‐collecDon/Dmeline-­‐dutch-­‐history  hfp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Slag_bij_Nieuwpoort.jpg    Slide  12:  hfp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:P._Bodart_Portrait_of_Henric_Ter_Brugghen.jpg  hfp://www.music.iastate.edu/anDqua/bagpipe.htm    Slide  13:  hfp://explore.balDmoreheritage.org/items/show/78#.U0BUz1zQnA2    Slides  14  and  28:  hfp://openstreetmap.org      Slide  40:  Image:  Earth  from  Space,  10.17.2000,  NASA  Earth  Observatory  hfp://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/IOTD/view.php?id=885  Quote:  AfribuDon  unclear.  hfp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_globally,_act_locally    

Slides  4-­‐10  from:  “Designing  for  Informa@on  Objects”,  Degler  &  Johnson,  EdUI  2013  hfp://www.designforcontext.com/publicaDons/designing-­‐for-­‐informaDon-­‐objects      Slide  31  from:    “Suppor@ng  Relevance  for  Users:  A  Design  Challenge”  Degler,  SemTechBiz  6.2013  hfp://www.designforcontext.com/publicaDons/supporDng-­‐relevance-­‐for-­‐users    Slide  37  from:    “Enhancement  Ecosystems”,  Degler  &  Vander  Wal,  SemTechBiz  10.2013  hfp://www.designforcontext.com/publicaDons/enhancement-­‐ecosystems-­‐enriching-­‐structured-­‐content-­‐with-­‐user-­‐tagging-­‐and-­‐annotaDon    

EXAMPLES  IN  PRESENTATION    MOMA  InvenDng  AbstracDons  exhibiDon:  hfp://www.moma.org/interacDves/exhibiDons/2012/invenDngabstracDon/    Rijksmuseum  RijksStudio:  hfps://www.rijksmuseum.nl/en/rijksstudio    NaDonal  Gallery  of  Art  (Online  EdiDons  -­‐  OSCI):  hfp://nga.gov  Cleveland  Museum  of  Art,  Gallery  One  and  ArtLens:  hfp://www.clevelandart.org/gallery-­‐one    ConservaDonSpace  project:  hfp://www.conservaDonspace.org    ADDITIONAL  SITES  USED  AS  BACKGROUND    eCulture  data  broswer  prototype:  hfp://e-­‐culture.mulDmedian.nl/demo/session/search  Smithsonian  cross-­‐selecDon  search:  hfp://collecDons.si.edu/search/    ResearchSpace  project:  hfp://researchspace.org  Kindred  Britain  person  relaDonship  browser:  hfp://kindred.stanford.edu/#    StackLife  book  browser:  hfps://stacklife-­‐dpla.law.harvard.edu      VisualizaDon  of  Museums  and  the  Web  AAT  LOD  hierarchy:  hfp://mafhewlincoln.net/2014/02/21/hierarchies-­‐of-­‐the-­‐Museums  and  the  Web.html    RKD  Dutch  art  search:  hfp://www.rkd.nl/en/    SerendipomaDc  enDty  extracDon  search:  hfp://serendipomaDc.org    mSpace  semanDc  browser:  hfp://mspace.fm  Parallax  data  relaDonship  browser:  hfp://parallax.freebaseapps.com  Smithsonian  community  transcripDon  site:  hfps://transcripDon.si.edu  NY  Times  topics  as  LOD:  hfp://data.nyDmes.com