Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration...

56
Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder Prashant Bhanware & Bharath Reddy

Transcript of Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration...

Page 1: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

Demonstration of modeling of radiant

cooling system in design builder

Prashant Bhanware & Bharath Reddy

Page 2: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

2Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

CONTENTS

• Introduction to Design Builder

• Building Energy Simulation

• Modeling procedure

– Making a model

– DOAS modeling

– Chilled slab/ceiling modeling

• Results and comparisons

• Conclusion

Page 3: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

3Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Introduction

• Design Builder is a Graphical User Interface (GUI) for simulation tool “EnergyPlus”

• Design Builder is available in different versions

• Latest one is 4.6 (Energy Plus – 8.3)

Graphical User Interface Simulation engine

- Energy Plus

Page 4: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

4Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

History of Design Builder

• EnergyPlus– Developed by US Department of Energy

– Version 1.0 Launched April 2001; twice yearly updates

– It is a modular, structured software tool based on the most popular features and capabilities of BLAST and DOE-2.1E.

– It is primarily a simulation engine; input and output are simple text files.

• Design Builder– Developed by “DesignBuilder Software Ltd” based in London,

UK

– Version 1 of the product was launched in 2005; GUI to the EnergyPlus simulation engine

– Version 2 (May 2009) adding CFD calculations linked to EnergyPlus

– Version 3 (August 2011), advanced GUI to EnergyPlus HVAC systems & daylight evaluation tool using Radiance

– Version 4 (May 2014), renewable, optimization, etc.

Page 5: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

5Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Inputs and outputs of a building

simulation tool

Weather Data (DBT, RH, Wind speed,

Ground temp., etc.)

Building geometry & construction (zoning,

wall, roof, etc.)

Internal loads (Occupancy, lighting,

equipment, etc.)

System & controls (set points, fresh air, type,

COP, etc.)

Energy Simulation

Tool

Energy consumption for each end use

(lighting, cooling, etc.)

Comfort results (zone temperature, hours of

comfort, etc.)

Break up of cooling/heating load (envelope, internal,

etc)

Cooling/heating system size for peak load,

break up at zone level

Page 6: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

6Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Building Energy Simulation Procedure

– 2 Steps

Step 1: Making Building Simulation Model– Building envelope (walls, floors, ceilings, windows,

glass etc.)

– Loads (Occupancy, Lighting and equipment etc.)

– Schedules

Step 2: HVAC modeling– Air loops

– Chilled water loops

– Controls

Page 7: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

7Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

• Area = 625 m2 (25 x 25 m)

• Floor to floor – 3.5 m

• Office building

• Day time operation

• 3 storey building

– Ground floor

– Intermediate

– Top floor

(3 zones)

Step 1: Building a simulation model

Page 8: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

8Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Step 1: Building a simulation model

Building envelope:

• Wall: 230 mm brick (U value – 0.438 W/m2)

• Roof: RCC 150 mm + XPS Insulation (U value – 0.409 W/m2)

• Internal floor: RCC 150 mm (U value – 2.47 W/m2 )

• Ground floor: RCC 150 + XPS insulation (U value – 0.409 W/m2)

• Glazing: Double glazing– Window to Wall ratio = 30 %

– SHGC = 0.27

– VLT = 0.49

– U Value = 1.5 W/m2

Internal loads: (8 am to 6 pm; Monday to Friday)

• Occupancy = 9.29 m2 / person

• Equipment = 10 W / m2

• Lighting = 7 W / m2

• Ventilation rate = 5.2 liter / sec / person

Page 9: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

Click to edit

Master title style

Click to edit

Master title style

9Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

DEFINING SLAB COOLING IN

DESIGN BUILDER

Page 10: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

10Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Objective – Modeling radiant slab

cooling system

AHU for DOAS

Conditioned space

Cooling Tower

Radiant Slab / Radiant Panel

DOAS System Radiant

System

Page 11: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

11Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

AHU for DOAS

Conditioned space

Cooling Tower

Radiant Slab / Radiant Panel

DOASSystem

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling –

Dedicated Outdoor Air System (DOAS)

Page 12: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

12Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Step 2: Design Builder

– Way to build a model

Navigate:Site,

Buildings, Zones etc.

Info, help

Main tabs

Page 13: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

13Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – D O A S

• Go to help/info tab

– Add zone group using (3 zones)

• Go to navigate tab, zone level

– Define set points: 240C (operative); RH – 50%

– Define fresh air rate (5.2 l/s-person)

– Target all 3 zones

• Ground floor

• Intermediate

• Top floor• Ground floor

• Intermediate

• Top floor

Page 14: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

14Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Page 15: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

15Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – D O A S

• Go to help/info tab

– Add generic air loop

Add a generic air loop

Page 16: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

16Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling - D O A S

Go to navigate tab

– Select AHU

– Go to edit at info tab

– Define supply air flow rate as 1.05 m3/sec (fresh air only)

– Add Schedule

Page 17: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

17Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – D O A S

• AHU data:

Outdoor air

system

– No

recirculation

– Heat recovery

(75% Sensible &

Latent)

Page 18: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

18Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – D O A S

• In AHU Unit

– Add cooling coil

Page 19: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

19Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – D O A S

• Go to Water

cooling coil

data

– Add scheduling

– Select control

type:

3-temperature

and humidity

control

Page 20: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

20Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – D O A S

• Navigate tab

– Go to air loop

supply side

– Add set point

manager for

humidity control

Page 21: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

21Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – D O A S

• Go to zone level• Add air

distribution unit

to the zones

• Add extract unit

to the zones

Air distribution unit- Air in

Extract unit- Air out

Page 22: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

22Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – D O A S

Connect the air loop to the zones

Page 23: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

23Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – D O A S

Add chilled water plant loop• Name it as CHW loop – D O A S

Page 24: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

24Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – D O A S

• Chilled water loop – D O A S

– Define chilled water loop schedule

– Specify values under sizing header

Page 25: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

25Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – D O A S

– Chiller

selection –

VSD

– Auto-size

capacity

– Auto-size

flow rates

Chiller selection - Type

Flow sizing options

Page 26: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

26Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Chilled water loop – D O A S

– Control: Outdoor air set point

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – D O A S

Page 27: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

27Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

• Go to navigate tab

• Select CHW loop – D O A S demand side supply– Connect chilled water loop to cooling coil

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – D O A S

Page 28: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

28Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

• Go to info tab

– Add condenser loop

• Select condenser loop

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – D O A S

Page 29: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

29Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

• Go to navigate tab

• Select Condenser loop

demand side supply

– Connect cooling tower to

the chiller

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – D O A S

Page 30: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

30Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

DOAS system – Modeling completed

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – D O A S

Page 31: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

31Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Radiant system modeling

• Add Chilled ceiling at zone level

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – Radiant

system

Page 32: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

32Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Define parameters for chilled ceiling

– Tube dia., circuit length limited to 107 m,

– Zone control operative temperature

– Add cooling set point schedule

– Dew point offset (20C)

– Define operation schedule

– Target “All”

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – Radiant

system

Page 33: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

33Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Add chilled water plant loop• Name it as CHW loop - Radiant

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – Radiant

system

Page 34: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

34Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

• Radiant

CHW loop

– Define

chilled

water loop

schedule

– Specify

values

under

sizing

header

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – Radiant

system

Page 35: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

35Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

• Radiant CHW

loop

– Chiller

selection –

VSD

– Auto-size

Capacity

– Auto-size

flow rates

Chiller selection - Type

Flow sizing options

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – Radiant

system

Page 36: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

36Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Radiant Chilled water loop

– Control: Outdoor air set point

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – Radiant

system

Page 37: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

37Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Connection between condenser loop & Chilled water loop

Connection between chilled ceiling & Chilled water loop

Page 38: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

Click to edit

Master title style

Click to edit

Master title style

38Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

OVERALL SYSTEM

MODELING

Page 39: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

39Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

AHU for

DOAS

Conditioned

space

Supply

Air Return

Air

CHW Supply

CHW Return

Chiller for

Radiant System

Chiller for

DOAS System Cooling

Tower

CHW

Supply

CHW

Return

Radiant Slab /

Radiant Panel

Fresh Air

Exhaust Air

Page 40: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

40Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Step 2: Slab cooling modeling – Internal

source activation

• In design builder, chilled pipes are considered

as internal source

• Add internal source at ceiling/roof

– Go to construction tab

– Enable internal heat source option for ceiling/roof

Page 41: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

41Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Radiant Slab Cooling Schematic

Radiation

ConvectionRadiation

Radiation

Convection

Radiant cooling pipes

Slab

FinishingInsulation

Radiant cooling pipes

Slab

Finishing with tiles

Convection

Modelling of slab cooling construction• Roof• Internal floors

Ground floor

Roof

Internal floor

Page 42: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

42Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Design Builder – Roof slab construction

Outer surface (Ambient)

Inner surface (Ceiling of top floor)

• Construction is defined layer by layer

• Layer numbering always starts from outer surface

• Insert the cooling pipes (internal source) above the inner surface, which gives

more cooling effect to the zone below

2

1

3

4

Page 43: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

43Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Building level

Design Builder – Roof slab Construction

Page 44: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

44Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Building level

Design Builder – Roof slab Construction

Page 45: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

45Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Design Builder – Internal floor slab

construction

2

1

3

4

Outer surface (zone below the floor)

Inner surface (zone above the floor)

• Construction is defined layer by layer

• Layer numbering always starts from outer surface

• Insert the cooling pipes (internal source) above the outer surface, implies

more cooling effect to the zone below

Page 46: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

46Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Design Builder – Internal floor slab

construction

Page 47: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

47Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Model Ready for Simulation

Page 48: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

48Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Slab cooling - Simulation results

No End useEnergy Consumption (kWh/year)

1 Lighting 46500

2 Equipment 32550

3 HVAC 61551

4 Total 140602

5 EPI (total) 79

6 EPI (HVAC) 34.5

No Chiller Load share

1 DOAS 37%

2 Radiant 63%

Room Electricity

33%

Lighting23%

HVAC44%

Page 49: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

Click to edit

Master title style

Click to edit

Master title style

49Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

INPUTS FOR RADIANT PANEL

Page 50: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

50Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Radiant panels modelling

Panel cooling systems

Source: Jingjuan Feng, PhD Thesis, “Design and Control of Hydronic

Radiant Cooling Systems”, University of California, Berkeley

Page 51: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

51Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Design Builder – Roof panel construction

• Insert the cooling pipes (internal source) above the aluminum panel

2

1

3

45

Page 52: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

52Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Design Builder – Roof panel construction

Page 53: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

53Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Design Builder – Internal floor panel

construction

• Insert the cooling pipes (internal source) above the aluminum panel

2

1

3

4

56

Page 54: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

54Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Design Builder – Internal floor panel

construction

Page 55: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

55Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

Panel cooling - Simulation results

No End useEnergy Consumption (kWh/year)

1 Lighting 46500

2 Equipment 32550

3 HVAC 58880

4 Total 137930

5 EPI (total) 77

6 EPI (HVAC) 33

No Chiller Load share

1 DOAS 37%

2 Radiant 63%

Room Electricity

33%

Lighting23%

HVAC44%

Page 56: Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in ... - Demonstration of... · Demonstration of modeling of radiant cooling system in design builder ... Cooling Tower Radiant

Click to edit

Master title style

Click to edit

Master title style

56Indo-Swiss Building Energy Efficiency Project

THANK YOU