DELIVERABLE 7 - vph-dare.euIT D7.3 1v0 Final.pdf · DELIVERABLE 7.3 First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT...
Transcript of DELIVERABLE 7 - vph-dare.euIT D7.3 1v0 Final.pdf · DELIVERABLE 7.3 First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT...
DELIVERABLE 7.3
First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform
Grant agreement no.: 601055 (FP7-ICT-2011-9)
Project acronym: VPH-DARE@IT
Project title: Dementia Research Enabled by IT
Funding Scheme: Collaborative Project
Project co-ordinator: Prof. Alejandro Frangi, University of Sheffield
Tel.: +44 114 22 20153
Fax: +44 114 22 27890
E-mail: [email protected]
Project web site address: www.vph-dare.eu
Due date of deliverable Month 24
Actual submission date Month 25
Start date of project April 1st 2013
Project duration 48 months
Work Package & Task WP 7, Task 7.2, 7.3, 7.4, 7.5
Lead beneficiary USFD
Editor PMO
Author(s) Alberto Biancardi Juan Arenas
Quality reviewer Felix Winter, Timo Urhema
Project co-funded by the European Union within the Seventh Framework Programme
Dissemination level
PU Public X
PP Restricted to other programme participants (including Commission Services)
RE Restricted to a group specific by the consortium (including Commission
Services)
CO Confidential, only for members of the consortium (including Commission
Services)
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 2 -
Issue Record
Version no. Date Author(s) Reason for modification Status
0.4 20/03/15 Juan Arenas,
Alberto Biancardi
Initial release Initial Draft
0.8 31/03/15 Alberto Biancardi Addressing feedback of
internal reviewers,
additional updates
Final
1.0 14/04/15 PMO Final Check Finalised
Copyright Notice
Copyright © 2013 VPH-DARE@IT Consortium Partners. All rights reserved. VPH-
DARE@IT is an FP7 Project supported by the European Union under grant agreement no.
601055. For more information on the project, its partners, and contributors please see
http://www.vph-dare.eu. You are permitted to copy and distribute verbatim copies of this
document, containing this copyright notice, but modifying this document is not allowed. All
contents are reserved by default and may not be disclosed to third parties without the prior
written consent of the VPH-DARE@IT consortium, except as mandated by the grant agreement
with the European Commission, for reviewing and dissemination purposes. All trademarks and
other rights on third party products mentioned in this document are acknowledged and owned
by the respective holders. The information contained in this document represents the views of
VPH-DARE@IT members as of the date of its publication and should not be taken as
representing the view of the European Commission. The VPH-DARE@IT consortium does not
guarantee that any information contained herein is error-free, or up to date, nor makes
warranties, express, implied, or statutory, by publishing this document.
Author(s) for Correspondence
Juan Arenas
T: +44 114 222 9736; E: [email protected]; W: www.cistib.org
Alberto Biancardi
T: +44 114 222 9736; E: [email protected]; W: www.cistib.org
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 3 -
Table of Contents
1. INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................................... 6
2. FIRST REALISATION OF THE VPH-DARE@IT RESEARCH PLATFORM .................... 7
2.1. GETTING ACCESS TO THE RESEARCH PLATFORM .................................................................... 7 2.2. DISCOVERING THE RESEARCH PLATFORM ............................................................................... 8 2.3. ACCESS TO DATASETS & COHORTS ......................................................................................... 9 2.4. ACCESS TO APPLICATIONS ..................................................................................................... 11 2.5. WORKFLOWS ......................................................................................................................... 13 2.6. INTERACTION BETWEEN THE CLINICAL AND RESEARCH PLATFORM ..................................... 15
3. CLINICAL USE CASES IMPLEMENTATION ...................................................................... 16
3.1. CONCEPTUAL APPROACH ....................................................................................................... 16 3.2. LARGE COHORT STUDIES PATTERN ....................................................................................... 16 3.3. CLINICAL USE CASE IMPLEMENTATION ................................................................................. 18
3.3.1. Exemplar 1: Integration of structural, functional, and cognitive based features of MCI
classification (USFD) .................................................................................................................... 18 3.3.2. Exemplar 2: Classification power of hippocampal subfield volumes to differentiate
early stage Alzheimer’s disease from early stage frontotemporal dementia (UEF) ...................... 19 3.3.3. Exemplar 3: Quantitative metrics of diffusion image quality (UCL-SO) ..................... 20 3.3.4. Exemplar 4: Comparison of biomarker methods across a large cohort (EMC) .......... 21
3.4. RESEARCH PLATFORM CAPABILITIES HIGHLIGHTED THROUGH THE EXEMPLARY CASES ........ 21
4. RESEARCH PLATFORM COMPONENTS ............................................................................ 22
5. CONCLUSIONS .......................................................................................................................... 23
6. LIST OF KEY WORDS/ABBREVIATIONS ............................................................................ 23
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 4 -
Table of Figures
Figure 1: VDRP Home Page (Before User Authentication) ..................................................... 8 Figure 2: VDRP Home Page (After User Authentication) ....................................................... 8 Figure 3: VDRP Resource Discovery Page .............................................................................. 9 Figure 4: VDRP Dataset Resource Page .................................................................................. 9 Figure 5: VDRP Dataset Query. Output Field Selection ........................................................ 10 Figure 6: VDRP Dataset Query. Inclusion Criteria ................................................................ 10 Figure 7: VDRP Dataset Query. Subset Browsing and Export Format Selection .................. 11 Figure 8: VDRP Datasets. Application List ........................................................................... 12 Figure 9: VDRP Application. Resource Page ......................................................................... 12 Figure 10: VDRP Application. Additional Information ......................................................... 13 Figure 11: VDRP Search. Workflows .................................................................................... 13 Figure 12: VDRP Workflows Resource Page ........................................................................ 14 Figure 13: VDRP Workflows. Execution Configuration ....................................................... 14 Figure 14: VDRP Workflows. Execution Progress ................................................................ 15 Figure 15: VDRP Context. Conceptual Diagram ................................................................... 16 Figure 16: Large Cohorts Studies Pattern ............................................................................... 17 Figure 17: Dataset/Cohort Extraction Pattern ......................................................................... 17 Figure 18: Exemplar 1.Worflow Definition ........................................................................... 18 Figure 19: Exemplar 2.Worflow Definition ........................................................................... 19 Figure 20: Exemplar 3.Worflow Definition ........................................................................... 20 Figure 21: Exemplar 4.Worflow Definition ........................................................................... 21
Table of Tables Table 1: VDRP Components. ................................................................................................. 23
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 5 -
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The “Virtual Physiological Human: DementiA Research Enabled by IT” (VPH-DARE@IT)
project aims to provide a systematic, multifactorial and multiscale modelling approach to
enable improved diagnoses and prognoses of dementias. Its peculiar approach foresees a strict
interplay between two complementary approaches to disease investigation: a
phenomenological approach, where population-wide information is sieved to discover
statistical associations or anomalies, and a mechanistic approach, where virtual physiological
human simulations aim at supplying patient-specific insight into the disease and views of the
possible clinical evolutions for further investigation. The ultimate goal of the research
platform, by the end of the project, is to support both approaches in their implementation by a
user friendly interface that collects a number of components relevant to the dementia domain
(Tools, Model, Biomarker, Datasets) into a single coherent system in order to facilitate the
generation and execution of new studies that will be answering clinical questions.
After presenting at the last year review a first static mock-up of the research platform and
making it known and accessible, work has proceeded towards milestone M72 “Preliminary and
limited software version released and distributed to application partners for evaluation.”
Progress has developed on two fronts: on the one hand the research platform has started being
populated with domain specific datasets (selected retrospective cohorts), computational steps
(e.g., image-processing pipelines), workflows, and tools that are the initial components for the
integrative and extensible software environment; on the other hand collaboration with
VPH-Share (FP7-ICT-269978) has brought significant enhancements to the infrastructure.
The current version provides a workable environment that represents a good starting point for
more concrete applications and, in fact, it was decided at the Project Board level to work
towards a more ambitious goal to demonstrate the platform capabilities to answer clinical
questions in the dementia area; although this is a high risk task for a not yet fully developed
platform, it was reckoned that those additional use cases that need to be supported and taken
into consideration if the platform has to deliver any real value. Although it is not mature enough
product, the platform is well advanced thanks to the collaboration between different work
packages, partners, and projects and it is becoming ready to face the challenges of the coming
years where we expect additional and more complex VPH workflows to be deployed, hopefully
stimulating a new generation of studies to be carried out.
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 6 -
1. INTRODUCTION
The “Virtual Physiological Human: DementiA Research Enabled by IT” (VPH-DARE@IT)
project aims to provide a systematic, multifactorial and multiscale modelling approach to enable
improved diagnoses and prognoses of dementias. Its peculiar approach foresees a strict
interplay between two complementary approaches to disease investigation: a phenomenological
approach, where population-wide information is sieved to discover statistical associations or
anomalies, and a mechanistic approach, where virtual physiological human (VPH) simulations
aim at supplying patient-specific insight into the disease and views of the possible clinical
evolutions for further investigation. The ultimate goal of the research platform is to support
both approaches in their implementation by a user friendly interface that collects a number of
components relevant to the dementia domain (Tools, Model, Biomarker, Datasets) into a single
coherent system in order to facilitate the generation and execution of new studies that will be
answering clinical questions.
At the last year review a first static mock-up of the research platform was presented; this
mock-up was also made accessible through the VPH-DARE site and presented in different
project meetings and in a webinar conducted to introduce the mock-up to all partners. An
updated version of that mock-up is also part of D7.2 “Use cases identification and workflows
definition for WP7,” together with the actual definition of the use cases for the VPH-DARE@IT
Research platform (VDRP). All these actions have brought valuable feedback into the first
realisation of the VDRP; the development activities have also benefited from the close contact
with the use case definition process, enabling us to anticipate the outcomes of the use cases
deliverable and take them into account for the development of this first release. Although the
initial release is intended to be a “Preliminary and limited software version released and
distributed to application partners for evaluation” as established in milestone M72, we believe
the current version provides a workable environment that represents a good starting point for
more concrete applications. In fact, it was decided collectively (at the Project Board level) to
work towards a more ambitious goal as it is to implement four exemplar clinically relevant use
cases that will be showing the capabilities of the platform to answer clinical questions in the
Dementia area, as detailed in section 3 Clinical use cases implementation. Clearly, this is a high
risk task for a not yet fully developed platform, but at the same time it provides additional use
cases that need to be supported and taken into consideration if the platform has to deliver any
real value.
Along this year we have been progressing in a first implementation of this mock-up in close
collaboration with VPH-Share (FP7-ICT-269978). This collaboration has proved to be fruitful
for both projects, but also for the VPH community. The collaboration has brought a number of
new functionalities that have been made available through the main VPH-Share infrastructure.
These functionalities improve the infrastructure support for VPH projects by enabling them to
set up a customized workspace (in minutes) that specializes the infrastructure in such a way
that each project can leverage project-wide access to their data, tools and workflows in order to
reuse and share them with their projects members and, optionally, external collaborators. These
enhancements have been the result of the collaborative effort between VPH-Dare@IT and
VPH-Share and are now available for the community to capitalize on in a similar way that
VPH-Dare@IT has done to deliver our VDRP infrastructure. Some of the reasons for this
collective benefit lie in the constructive role of VPH-DARE@IT has played, providing
VPH-Share with key requirements and proposals, and in the openness of VPH-Share in
adopting and implementing most of them as global features (i.e. not restricted to the
VPH-DARE@IT customized profile). Among these enhancements it is worth noting the group
(project) customization capability that facilitates and shortens the setting up of bespoke user
interface elements (based on the server IP address) thus enabling projects to take advantage of
the whole VPH-Share infrastructure and yet present to their users a project-specific appearance
and access control (project-wide permissions).
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 7 -
In addition to these foundation activities, the VDRP has started being populated with domain
specific datasets (selected retrospective cohorts), computational steps (e.g., image-processing
pipelines), workflows, and tools that are the initial components for the integrative and
extensible research platform where all the different multidisciplinary biomedical imaging and
simulation tools will be available from a single access point, which is our plan and expectation
to have fully available by the end of the project.
The current deliverable is organized as described below to provide a proper presentation of this
year activities, but also to introduce the activities currently planned for next year.
Section 2 - First realisation of the VPH-Dare@IT research platform
Section 3 - Clinical use cases implementation
Section 4 - Research Platform Components
2. FIRST REALISATION OF THE VPH-DARE@IT RESEARCH PLATFORM
In this section we will introduce the first version of the VDRP. The contents of this deliverable
are just a snapshot at the time of writing because integration and development activities are
on-going throughout the whole life of the project and, as a result, there will be some differences
due to new features, improvements, component deployment and maintenance activities carried
out on the platform.
In this section we do not intent to describe the whole underlying infrastructure because there is
already extensive documentation on VPH-Share generated along the four years of the project;
instead we will be presenting the specific features that have been developed in collaboration
with VPH-DARE and also the generics parts that are more relevant to the end user in order to
be able to make the most of the platform. As mentioned in the introduction, one of the main
outcomes of this collaboration have been the project oriented features that have been developed
as a consequence of VPH-DARE@IT specific requirement and needs. These features (even in
their initial version) enable any institution or project to start up in minutes his own personalized
web workspace, where they can deploy their data, tools and workflows for internal used or to
be shared with other institutions and/or researchers/clinicians.
The VDRP is currently being populate with a number of cohorts (datasets) and applications in
order to facilitate the next generation of workflows to be build. This deployment of components
is being driven by the implementation of the clinically relevant use cases (defined by project’s
partners) that have been selected as good examples of large cohort phenomenological studies;
next year the prioritization of component deployment will be guided by mechanistic
(VPH-based) workflows. Through this process we are making available various outcomes from
Work Packages (WPs) across the project, as well as third-party tools that are used by the
community.
2.1. GETTING ACCESS TO THE RESEARCH PLATFORM When a new users access the portal, they will be presented with the VPH-DARE@IT Research
Platform home page, which is shown in Figure 1.
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 8 -
Figure 1: VDRP Home Page (Before User Authentication)
To be able to explore and access the content of the platform the user first needs to log in through
the login option in the header of the portal page; once logged in the user is properly
authenticated therefore he can start to use the platform in a secure way. Figure 2 shows a
capture of the home page after the user is properly authenticated.
Figure 2: VDRP Home Page (After User Authentication)
Potential users need to be granted access to the VDRP by the administrator of VPH-DARE@IT;
currently the process is not yet fully automated, but a VDRP administrator will always be
reachable at [email protected].
2.2. DISCOVERING THE RESEARCH PLATFORM Once the user has been authenticated, the search option can be used to discover the available
resources in the system; in this view the total number of resources available are shown as well
as the different types: Datasets, Workflows, Applications (computational steps and standalone
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 9 -
application, as explained in subsection 2.4Access to Applications), files and web services, as
shown in Figure 3.
Figure 3: VDRP Resource Discovery Page
2.3. ACCESS TO DATASETS & COHORTS Users can interact with any available dataset, once they have been granted access, by just
pressing the arrow icon to the right of the resources; this will bring the user to the resource
detail page where the different options are displayed in Figure 4.
Figure 4: VDRP Dataset Resource Page
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 10 -
The “Query the dataset” option is probably the most useful for a new user. It provides the user
with a friendly interface where the user can select graphically by drag-and-drop the fields that
she or he wants to include in the result (“select” tab) table from the different entities that
constitute the dataset, while in the “where” tab the user can define the criteria for the selection
of output items, as shown in Figure 5 and Figure 6
Figure 5: VDRP Dataset Query. Output Field Selection
Figure 6: VDRP Dataset Query. Inclusion Criteria
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 11 -
As a result the user will get the subset that matches the criteria; this subset, as seen in Figure
7, can now be exported to csv, excel or pdf for local browsing or further processing, if required.
Figure 7: VDRP Dataset Query. Subset Browsing and Export Format Selection
Note: on a further upgrade of the research platform there will be the possibility to feed the query
results directly into a workflow in order to process the data and also to run federate queries, i.e.
queries that span across multiples datasets.
2.4. ACCESS TO APPLICATIONS There are currently two kinds of modalities where software tools can be deployed on the
platform depending on whether they expose a web-service interface or not:
computational workflow steps – these applications will take advantage of the facilities
of the platform to operate Windows and Linux virtual machines (VM) with preinstalled
tools that have been preconfigured to expose the application interfaces as web-services,
thus enabling the applications to be used as computational steps in any workflow that
relies on them. When VMs are used in this way, the workflow execution engine
(namely Taverna server) takes the responsibility to start the VM when it is required and
switch it off when it is no longer needed;
standalone applications – in this case the (Windows and Linux) VMs have been
preconfigured with preinstalled tools to give the user access to their usual environment
by means of a cloud-based on-demand modality, taking advantage of established
remote display protocols. The platform interface allows its users to start/switch off
effortlessly a cloud machine instance, according to their respective needs thanks to a
user friendly interface; however, knowledge of the file system structure and therefore
some form of training may be required to fully leverage the preinstalled tools.
In WP7 various applications are being deployed, installed and made accessible to VDRP users
once they are properly validated. The current focus is on applications that are being developed
by the rest of the WPs or requested by VDRP users or are needed to implement specific steps
in clinically relevant use cases. While web-services are accessed through the workflow
framework (editing/execution), standalone applications are accessible through the search option
as shown in Figure 8
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 12 -
Figure 8: VDRP Datasets. Application List
The process to start a standalone application requires the user to go to the application resource
detail page with the arrow button and click on the “Start application” button, as shown in Figure
9. There is also an alternative way to do that through the application tab. In any case a new VM
is started and made available for the user to interact with it; access to the VM is made possible
through a standard ssh-based command line access and through any additional network ports
(TCP or UDP) that have been defined for that machine, as detailed in and Figure 10.
Figure 9: VDRP Application. Resource Page
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 13 -
Figure 10: VDRP Application. Additional Information
2.5. WORKFLOWS A computational workflow is a collection of computational steps that, connected in a particular
way, can perform tasks of various complexities; in the context of VPH-DARE@IT typically
they help answering questions that are relevant to the clinical or research environments. These
workflows can be fed with data from various datasets to generate new results that will be
evaluated. Workflows can also be easily accessed through the search option (see Figure 11).
Figure 11: VDRP Search. Workflows
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 14 -
Through the arrow icon the user will get access to the resource specific page where the
different option available are shown (see Figure 12).
Figure 12: VDRP Workflows Resource Page
By clicking in “Configure to execute” button the workflow can be started with the default
input or provided with a different input file to run it (see Figure 13).
Figure 13: VDRP Workflows. Execution Configuration
Through the “Initialize execution” button the workflow can be started. The process behind the
scene will:
Create a workflow execution engine (Taverna Server) application instance on the fly
Send the workflow together with its input file (pre-defined or execution-specific one)
to the execution engine to start the execution
A specific component, the Taverna Plugin deployed on the server, will analyse the
workflow to identify the different applications that are required to execute the
different computational steps starting them in advance.
The workflow would then start to be processed with the input list and data, as shown
in Figure 14.
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 15 -
Once computational steps are no longer needed the Taverna Plugin will shut them
down, releasing platform resources, while data is stored either in the distributed
FileStore (VPH-Share persistent file system) and/or in a dataset depending on the
kind of results generated.
Additional information on workflows are detailed in section 4 “Workflows composition,
integration and execution” of VPH-Share deliverable D6.5, downloadable at
https://www.biomedtown.org/biomed_town/vphshare/reception/public_repository/deliverable
s/VPH-Share_D65_1v1.pdf?action=download
Figure 14: VDRP Workflows. Execution Progress
2.6. INTERACTION BETWEEN THE CLINICAL AND RESEARCH PLATFORM The research platform is also designed to serve the role of service provider, i.e. to facilitate
access by authenticated external entities to the remote execution of workflows with specific
inputs provided by these entities. In this case the original and derived data are being stored
temporarily in a secure folder of the persistent FileStore until the results are collected by the
external application; once collected all the data is wiped-out from the research platform.
The following use case have been defined in collaboration with the clinical platform to enable
this process to happen and to validate the current implementation, and would be implemented
before the second year review.
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 16 -
3. CLINICAL USE CASES IMPLEMENTATION Early this year four exemplary uses cases where defined. These use cases have been defined by
the project board were elicited to demonstrated how the VDRP platform can be used to
implement large scale studies and how then can be reused or extended. The emphasis next year
will be on the mechanistic VPH-oriented workflows, even though some progress has also been
accomplished this year.
3.1. CONCEPTUAL APPROACH As mentioned in the Introduction, the ultimate goal of the research platform is to enable
researchers to answer clinical question by means of a user friendly infrastructure that collects a
number of components relevant for the dementia domain (Tools, Model, Biomarker, Datasets)
and streamlines its use in order to facilitate the generation of new studies that will be answering
clinical questions (see Figure 15).
Figure 15: VDRP Context. Conceptual Diagram
The focus of this year is on the use of large scale data cohorts where we aim to progress in the
implementation of four selected workflows that are presented in the following sections.
3.2. LARGE COHORT STUDIES PATTERN Before presenting the different use cases, we describe the common pattern that is followed by
the Large Cohorts Studies. Being able to implement this pattern in the research platform is
allowing us to implement the specific realisation that the four selected studies will require. The
pattern is presented in Figure 16
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 17 -
Figure 16: Large Cohorts Studies Pattern
The Large Cohorts Study Pattern include:
Large Data Cohorts: Large datasets have to be made available to run these studies, the
VPRP provide the means to publish these cohorts into the platform, to select a subset
when needed, to store the results and also to exploit them through an user friendly web
interface.
Computational Steps: The selected cohorts (or a subset) are required to be processed
through a number of computational steps in order to facilitate a classification of the
input data to happen. These steps will generate large amount of potential biomarkers,
usually named features, that will be used by the following stages to reach the results.
Classification Step: One or more classification steps will be required to establish a new
characterization of the original dataset (Diagnosis, Quality validation, …)
Results: Final concrete results (Diagnosis, Quality validation …) need to be accessible
to the platform users.
The goal is to bring/build clinical relevant workflows to the VDRP, where the researcher will
benefit from accessing the larges data cohorts that will be made available along the project as
well a cloud base infrastructure designed to facilitate this task.
Any component deployed on the platform will required some degree of validation in order to
guarantee the deployment is successful and can be therefore share with the user community.
This deployment will required, depending on the case, additional development and integration
effort as some components have not been designed or developed to process hundreds or
thousands of cases in a smooth and efficient way, therefore each components are not just
deployed as they are, but also optimized to streamline their execution, when possible (e.g.
removing user intervention, transform stateful components into stateless ...). Once deployed
the workflow execution will take advantage of the features and flexibility provided by the
VDRP platform to be executed multiple cloud instances on demand, in order to speed up the
process and reduce the execution time.
As commented above Cohorts and Results need to be generated in a way that users can query
and select different subsets depending on their specific needs; to make that happen a second
pattern has been also identified and it is shown in Figure 17.
Figure 17: Dataset/Cohort Extraction Pattern
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 18 -
3.3. CLINICAL USE CASE IMPLEMENTATION In the following section the four exemplar use cases are described together with the concrete
realisation of the patter in each case.
3.3.1. Exemplar 1: Integration of structural, functional, and cognitive based features of
MCI classification (USFD)
3.3.1.1. Use Case Original Definition
Objective: To determine whether resting state fMRI contributes any differential
diagnostic power to MCI determination
Study Database: Functional MRI cohort (Venice/USFD), ADNI(2nd phase), others
available with rs-fMRI and structural MRI data
Requirements Obtain detailed parameter information on fMRI data from proposed studies
Build pre-processing and analysis pipelines appropriate for fMRI sequences
and desired endpoints for classification
Run parcellation on structural images
Run pre-processing and analysis pipelines on fMRI data
Perform classification algorithm and cross-validation
Challenges: Reducing variability in rs-fMRI endpoints, definition of healthy control
vs MCI to avoid circular logic in classification
3.3.1.2. Implementation
Figure 18: Exemplar 1.Worflow Definition
Implementation plan:
Import Venice data into the VRDP platform (SHT, USFD)
Deploy Conn Toolbox pre-processing computational step removing user interaction to
facilitate study (USFD)
Deploy Conn Toolbox analysis step computational step (USFD)
Validation of computational steps (USFD)
Process Limited Venice Dataset for validation purposes with the workflow deployed
in the research platform. (USFD)
Process whole Venice Dataset with the workflow (USFD)
Results evaluation (USFD)
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 19 -
Import/Select specific ADNI data (SHT, USFD)
Notes: For the second phase ADNI dataset, availability of image data with the appropriated
level of quality needs to be confirmed.
At the moment of writing this deliverable the initial execution of the workflow with a limited
subset of Venice data is being carried out.
3.3.2. Exemplar 2: Classification power of hippocampal subfield volumes to differentiate
early stage Alzheimer’s disease from early stage frontotemporal dementia (UEF)
3.3.2.1. Use Case Original Definition
Objective: To determine whether hippocampal subfields (or subregions) add power to
classification between AD and FTD
Study Database: ADNI (but no FTD available), Kuopio FTD (UEF)
Requirements Identify FTD cohort to use and differences between imaging parameters if any
Source hippocampal subfield atlas or have rater provide anterior/posterior
boundary on current hippocampal labels
Run parcellation (including hippocampal subfields/subregions) on structural
images)
Alternatively: Perform VBM analysis on cohort using small volume of MTL
GM (hippocampus, amygdala, entorhinal/perirhinal cortex)
Challenges: Obtaining hippocampal subfield atlas, reliable hippocampal subfield
segmentations from 3T structural scans (possibly 1.5T, but resolution might be too low
and noise too high), understanding differences in biomarkers when trying to pool across
cohorts
3.3.2.2. Implementation
Figure 19: Exemplar 2.Worflow Definition
Implementation plan:
Import ADNI dataset into the VRDP platform (STH, UCL-SO)
Import retrospective Kuopio FTD dataset into the VRDP platform (STH, UEF)
Import retrospective Sheffield FTD dataset into the VRDP platform (STH, USFD)
Deploy Segmentation computational step and made it available as a web service
(UCL-SO, USFD)
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 20 -
Deploy ROI statistics computational step and make it available as a web service
(UCL-SO, USFD)
Build computational workflow, testing it with a limited subset from the different
cohorts to validate it before whole execution is started (USFD)
Process all datasets with the workflow (USFD)
Results evaluation (UEF, USFD)
3.3.3. Exemplar 3: Quantitative metrics of diffusion image quality (UCL-SO)
4.3.2.1. Use Case Original Definition
Objective: To determine automatic quantitative metrics that clearly identify poor scans
with minimal user interaction
Study Database: ADNI (2nd phase)
Requirements Run structural pre-processing and diffusion pre-processing
Identify metrics that most correlate with image quality
Provide evidence that images to be excluded contribute significantly to
variability in biomarker measures
Challenges: EPI distortion cannot be corrected if field mapping unavailable, overall
suitability of ADNI data for detecting subtle changes in AD
3.3.3.1. Implementation
Figure 20: Exemplar 3.Worflow Definition
Implementation plan:
Import ADNI dataset into the VRDP platform (STH, UCL-SO)
Deploy quality control computational step and made it available as a web service
(UCL-SO, USFD)
Deploy Diagram analysis computational step and made it available as a web service
(UCL-SO, USFD)
Build computational workflow, testing it with a limited subset from the different
cohorts to validate it before whole execution is started (USFD)
Process all datasets with the workflow (USFD)
Results evaluation (UCL-SO)
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 21 -
3.3.4. Exemplar 4: Comparison of biomarker methods across a large cohort (EMC)
3.3.4.1. Use Case Original Definition
Objective: To determine agreement between similar biomarkers (developed from
different sites) on a large ageing cohort
Study Database: Rotterdam
Requirements:
If allowed, Rotterdam to provide some exemplar data representative of study
images for testing/optimising parameters of structural pipelines
Interested groups submit optimised structural MR pipelines to Rotterdam in
format to be run locally.
Structural pipelines run on site at Rotterdam
Generation of key curves (age, sex, etc.)
Comparison of these curves and individual measures from different groups
Challenges: Optimising pipelines to data, checking results of such a large cohort,
packaging pipelines for on-site execution
3.3.4.2. Implementation
In this case as the study database would be Rotterdam the processing components will be
deployed and executed on EMC environment, once the local execution is completed the
different computational steps will be deployed into the VDRP to facilitate the validation of
the results on different datasets. Also the results would be made available as they would be
required to inform models or being accessed by the clinical platform for research purpose.
Figure 21: Exemplar 4.Worflow Definition
Implementation plan:
Pipelines would be deployed and tested on VDRP (UCL-SO,USFD)
Pipelines would be re-deployed and executed on EMC (EMC, UCL-SO, USFD)
Curves would be uploaded into the research platform (EMC, STH)
3.4. RESEARCH PLATFORM CAPABILITIES HIGHLIGHTED THROUGH THE EXEMPLARY
CASES The selected use cases will be able to demonstrate the capabilities of the research platform in:
Handling of Multiple Datasets
o e.g. Venice, ADNI, Kuopio FTD (Exemplar Studies #1, #2, #3)
Integration of new High Throughput Pipelines
o e.g. Anterior/Posterior Hippocampus Segmentation (Exemplar Study #2)
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 22 -
Integration of third-party tools
o e.g. ConnToolbox & SPM (Exemplar Study #1)
Interoperability across sites
o e.g. with private DB (Exemplar Study #4)
These capabilities are complemented by established value adding features of the VDRP:
Multiple Datasets
o on-line browsing and web-based query tool
o other DBs (MIRIAD, OASIS)
Processing steps can be interactive or non-interactive
o interactive workflows with remote visualization
(no installation required)
Growing library of processing steps
Complex task creation with desktop and web-based composition tools
4. RESEARCH PLATFORM COMPONENTS The following table shows the specific components that are deployed or being deployed at the
time of writing this deliverable on the platform, these components would constitute the building
blocks to be used by the user to generate the workflows that will implement the different studies.
Type Name Status Comments Provider Provider
Contact
Platform
Contact
Due
by
Pipeline XNAT Data
Dowload
Installed UCL-SO Nicolas
Toussaint
Alberto
Biancardi
April
2015
Pipeline Field Bias
Correction
Installed UCL-SO Nicolas
Toussaint
Alberto
Biancardi
April
2015
Pipeline Pairwise
Registration
Installed UCL-SO Nicolas
Toussaint
Alberto
Biancardi
April
2015
Pipeline Groupwise
Registration
Installed UCL-SO Nicolas
Toussaint
Alberto
Biancardi
April
2015
Pipeline Tensor Diffusion
Processing
Installed UCL-SO Nicolas
Toussaint
Alberto
Biancardi
April
2015
Pipeline ASL Processing Installed UCL-SO Nicolas
Toussaint
Alberto
Biancardi
April
2015
Pipeline Full Brain
Parcelation
Installed Preliminary
version
UCL-SO Nicolas
Toussaint
Alberto
Biancardi
April
2015
Pipeline GradWarp
Correction
Installed UCL-SO Nicolas
Toussaint
Alberto
Biancardi
April
2015
Pipeline fMRI Processing Alberto
Biancardi
April
2015
Application Free Surfer Installed 3rd party Alberto
Biancardi
Alberto
Biancardi
April
2015
Application SPM Installed 3rd party Alberto
Biancardi
Alberto
Biancardi
April
2015
Application Conn Toolbox Exposed 3rd party Alberto
Biancardi
Alberto
Biancardi
April
2015
Workflow Exemplary 1 Received USFD Leandro
Beltrachini
Alberto
Biancardi
April
2015
Workflow Exemplary 2 Requested UEF Anne
Remes
Alberto
Biancardi
April
2015
Workflow Exemplary 3 Requested UCL Nicolas
Toussaint
Alberto
Biancardi
April
2015
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 23 -
Type Name Status Comments Provider Provider
Contact
Platform
Contact
Due
by
Workflow Exemplary 4 Requested EMC Stefan
Klein
Alberto
Biancardi
April
2015
Application SubCortical
Segmentation
Received GIMIAS CLP Philips Fabian
Wenzel
Alberto
Biancardi
April
2015
Dataset Venice Released Lido Annalena
Venneri
Steven
Wood
April
2015
Dataset Miriad Released Miriad Steven
Wood
Steven
Wood
April
2015
Dataset ADNI Deployed ADNI@UCL-SO Steven
Wood
April
2015
Dataset OASIS Deployed OASIS Steven
Wood
Steven
Wood
April
2015
Dataset Kuopio FTD Requested UEF Hilkka
Soininen
Steven
Wood
April
2015
Table 1: VDRP Components.
5. CONCLUSIONS Coming back to the original milestone M72 Preliminary and limited software version released
and distributed to application partners for evaluation. We think that, although is it not still
mature enough, the platform is well advanced thanks to the collaboration between different
work packages, partners, and projects and it is becoming ready to face the challenges of the
coming years where we expect additional and more complex VPH workflows to be deployed.
Those workflows will bring new building blocks that will enable new generation of studies to
be carried out.
6. LIST OF KEY WORDS/ABBREVIATIONS
AD Alzheimer's Disease
ADNI Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative
CLP Command Line Plugin (See deliverable D7.1)
fMRI functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging
FTD Fronto-Temporal Dementia
GIMIAS Graphical Interface for Medical Image Analysis and Simulation
GUI Graphical User Interface
HTTP HyperText Transfer Protocol
MIRIAD Minimal Interval Resonance Imaging in Alzheimer's Disease
MRI Magnetic Resonance Imaging
MCI Mild Cognitive Impairment
FP7-601055: VPH-DARE@IT D7.3 – First Prototype of VPH-DARE@IT Research Platform 14/04/2015
- 24 -
SPM Statistical Parametric Mapping
OASIS Open Access Series of Imaging Studies
rs-fMRI resting state functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging
VDRP VPH-DARE Research Platform
VPH Virtual Physiological Human
XNAT Extensible Neuroimaging Archive Toolkit