Debate Adjudicator Workshop 2016 Latest Scoresheet

8/18/2019 Debate Adjudicator Workshop 2016 Latest Scoresheet

1/16

DEBATE ADJUDICATOR WORKSHOP 2016

SCORESHEET A

Government Speaer 1! """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

#atter $%0& 0'( 6'10 11'1( 16'20 S)ore

Definition(20)

No definitionWrong

definition

Vaguedefinition

Keywords- not

defined

Well defined No supporting

evidence

Well definedSupported with

evidence

(uote!dictionary)

Stand (20) No stand

Wrong scope

No

"ustification!

wrong

"ustification of

stand

#tte$pt to

"ustify stand

Solid stand

Supported with

evidence

#anner $%0& 0'2

Wea

$Rare*+&

,'(

#o-erate

$O.ten&

6'/

Goo-

$A*a+&

'10

E3)e**ent

$T4ro54o5t7

Con8tent&

S)ore

%ronunciation!

&nunciation

• Stress

• 'one

esture!&ye

contact

• eading!

$e$ori*ing

te+t

• ,se of space

• #udience

reaction

Voice %ro"ection

• u$.ling

•/lear andloud

• Slur

luency!%ace

• %auses

• 1esitant

• Speed

Repone $20& 0'2

None taen'aen .ut not

answer

,'(

#nswer wronglyVague #nswer

6'/

#ccurate#nswer

without solid

e+planation

'10

#nswer accuratelywith solid support

and e+planation

S)ore


2/16

%34 3ne (50)

%34 'wo (50)

Tota* S)ore


SCORESHEET A

Oppo8t8on Speaer 1! """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

#atter $%0& 0'( 6'10 11'1( 16'20 S)ore

Definition

(20)

No

definition

Wrong

definition

Vague definition

Keywords- not

defined

Well defined

No

supporting

evidence

Well defined

Supported with

evidence

(uote!dictionary)

Stand (20) No stand

Wrong

scope

No "ustification!

wrong "ustification

of stand

#tte$pt to

"ustify stand

Solid stand

Supported with

evidence

#anner $%0& 0'2

Wea

$Rare*+&

,'(

#o-erate

$O.ten&

6'/

Goo-

$A*a+&

'10

E3)e**ent

$T4ro54o5t7

Con8tent&

S)ore

%ronunciation!

&nunciation

• Stress

• 'one

esture!&yecontact

• eading!

$e$ori*ing

te+t

• ,se of space

• #udience

reaction

Voice %ro"ection

• u$.ling

• /lear and loud

• Slur

luency!%ace

• %auses

• 1esitant

• Speed

Repone $20& 0'2 ,'( 6'/ '10 S)ore

%34 3ne (50) None taen

'aen .ut not

answer

#nswer wrongly

Vague #nswer

#ccurate

#nswer without

solid

e+planation

#nswer

accurately with

solid support and

e+planation


3/16

e.uttal (50) Did not re.ut

State

disagree$ent

#tte$pt to re.ut

Wrong reasoning

e.ut with

good reasoning

e.ut with good

reasoning

Su.stantiate with

evidence

Tota* S)ore


SCORESHEET B

Government Speaer 2! """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

#atter

$%0&

0'6

Wea

9'1,

#o-erate

1%'20

Goo-

21'2(

E3)e**ent

S)ore

%resentatio

n!

&la.oration

eason

(26)

No point

!No reasoning

Wrong point!

Wrong reasoning

Vague point

eason

irrelevant

Well defined

point

Wea unclear

ela.oration

Well defined

point

Well ela.orated

with evidence

0'% ('/ '12 1,'1(

&+a$ple

(56)

No e+a$ple given

Wrong e+a$ple

4rrelevant

e+a$ple

Vague or

unclear e+a$ple

ood and

relevant e+a$ple

#anner $%0& 0'2

Wea

$Rare*+&

,'(

#o-erate

$O.ten&

6'/

Goo-

$A*a+&

'10

E3)e**ent

$T4ro54o5t7

Con8tent&

S)ore

%ronunciation!&nunciation

• Stress

• 'one

esture!&ye

contact

• eading!

$e$ori*ing

te+t

• ,se of space

• #udience

reaction

Voice %ro"ection

• u$.ling

• /lear and loud

• Slur

luency!%ace

• %auses

• 1esitant

• Speed

Repone $20& 0'2 ,'( 6'/ '10 S)ore


4/16


'aen .ut not

answer

#nswer wrongly

Vague #nswer

#ccurate

#nswer without

solid

e+planation

#nswer

accurately with

solid support and

e+planation


State

disagree$ent

#tte$pt to re.ut

Wrong reasoning

e.ut with

good reasoning

e.ut with good

reasoning

Su.stantiate with

evidence

Tota* S)ore


SCORESHEET B

Oppo8t8on Speaer 2! """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

#atter $%0& 0'6

Wea

9'1,

#o-erate

1%'20

Goo-

21'2(

E3)e**ent

S)ore

%resentation!

&la.oration

eason (26)

No point

!No reasoning

Wrong point!

Wrong reasoning

Vague point

eason

irrelevant

Well defined

point

Wea unclear

ela.oration

Well defined

point

Well ela.orated

with evidence

0'% ('/ '12 1,'1(

&+a$ple

(56)

No e+a$ple given

Wrong e+a$ple

4rrelevant

e+a$ple

Vague or

unclear e+a$ple

ood and

relevant e+a$ple

#anner $%0& 0'2

Wea $Rare*+&

,'(

#o-erate$O.ten&

6'/

Goo-$A*a+&

'10

E3)e**ent$T4ro54o5t7

Con8tent&

S)ore

%ronunciation!

&nunciation

• Stress

• 'one

esture!&ye

contact

• eading!

$e$ori*ing

te+t

• ,se of space

• #udience

reaction

Voice %ro"ection

• u$.ling

• /lear and loud

• Slur

luency!%ace• %auses

• 1esitant

• Speed


5/16

Repone $20& 0'2 ,'( 6'/ '10 S)ore


'aen .ut not

answer

#nswer wrongly

Vague #nswer

#ccurate

#nswer without

solid

e+planation

#nswer

accurately with

solid support and

e+planation


State

disagree$ent

#tte$pt to re.ut

Wrong reasoning

e.ut with

good reasoning

e.ut with good

reasoning

Su.stantiate with

evidence

Tota* S)ore


SCORESHEET B

Government Speaer ,! """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

#atter $%0& 0'6

ea

9'1,

#o-erate

1%'20

Goo-

21'2(

E3)e**ent

S)ore

%resentation!

&la.oration

eason (26)

No point

!No reasoning

Wrong point!

Wrong reasoning

Vague point

eason

irrelevant

Well defined

point

Wea unclear

ela.oration

Well defined

point

Well ela.orated

with evidence

0'% ('/ '12 1,'1(

&+a$ple

(56)

No e+a$ple given

Wrong e+a$ple

4rrelevant

e+a$ple

Vague or

unclear e+a$ple

ood and

relevant e+a$ple

#anner $%0& 0'2

Wea

$Rare*+&

,'(

#o-erate

$O.ten&

6'/

Goo-

$A*a+&

'10

E3)e**ent

$T4ro54o5t7

Con8tent&

S)ore

%ronunciation!

&nunciation

• Stress

•

'oneesture!&ye

contact

• eading!

$e$ori*ing

te+t

• ,se of space

• #udience

reaction

Voice %ro"ection

• u$.ling

• /lear and loud

• Slur

luency!%ace


6/16

• %auses

• 1esitant

• Speed

Repone $20& 0'2 ,'( 6'/ '10 S)ore


'aen .ut not

answer

#nswer wrongly

Vague #nswer

#ccurate

#nswer without

solid

e+planation

#nswer

accurately with

solid support and

e+planation


State

disagree$ent

#tte$pt to re.ut

Wrong reasoning

e.ut with

good reasoning

e.ut with good

reasoning

Su.stantiate with

evidence

Tota* S)ore


SCORESHEET B

Oppo8t8on Speaer ,! """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

#atter $%0& 0'6

Wea

9'1,

#o-erate

1%'20

Goo-

21'2(

E3)e**ent

S)ore

%resentation!

&la.oration

eason (26)

No point

!No reasoning

Wrong point!

Wrong reasoning

Vague point

eason

irrelevant

Well defined

point

Wea unclear

ela.oration

Well defined

point

Well ela.orated

with evidence 0'% ('/ '12 1,'1(

&+a$ple

(56)

No e+a$ple given

Wrong e+a$ple

4rrelevant

e+a$ple

Vague or

unclear e+a$ple

ood and

relevant e+a$ple

#anner $%0& 0'2

Wea

$Rare*+&

,'(

#o-erate

$O.ten&

6'/

Goo-

$A*a+&

'10

E3)e**ent

$T4ro54o5t7

Con8tent&

S)ore

%ronunciation!&nunciation

• Stress

• 'one

esture!&ye

contact

• eading!

$e$ori*ing

te+t

• ,se of space

• #udience

reaction

Voice %ro"ection

• u$.ling


7/16

• /lear and loud

• Slur

luency!%ace

• %auses

• 1esitant

• Speed

Repone $20& 0'2 ,'( 6'/ '10 S)ore


'aen .ut not

answer

#nswer wrongly

Vague #nswer

#ccurate

#nswer without

solid

e+planation

#nswer

accurately with

solid support and

e+planation


State

disagree$ent

#tte$pt to re.ut

Wrong reasoning

e.ut with

good reasoning

e.ut with good

reasoning

Su.stantiate with

evidenceTota* S)ore


SCORESHEET B

Government Speaer %! """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

#atter $%0& 0'6

Wea

9'1,

#o-erate

1%'20

Goo-

21'2(

E3)e**ent

S)ore

%resentation!

&la.oration

eason (26)

No point!No reasoning

Wrong point!

Wrong reasoning

Vague pointeason

irrelevant

Well defined point

Wea unclear

ela.oration

Well defined point

Well ela.orated

with evidence

0'% ('/ '12 1,'1(

&+a$ple

(56)

No e+a$ple given

Wrong e+a$ple

4rrelevant

e+a$ple

Vague or

unclear e+a$ple

ood and

relevant e+a$ple

#anner $%0& 0'2

Wea $Rare*+&

,'(

#o-erate$O.ten&

6'/

Goo-$A*a+&

'10

E3)e**ent$T4ro54o5t7

Con8tent&

S)ore

%ronunciation!

&nunciation

• Stress

• 'one

esture!&ye

contact

• eading!

$e$ori*ing

te+t

• ,se of space

• #udience


8/16

reaction

Voice %ro"ection

• u$.ling

• /lear and loud

• Slur

luency!%ace

• %auses

• 1esitant

• Speed

Repone $20& 0'2 ,'( 6'/ '10 S)ore


'aen .ut not

answer

#nswer wrongly

Vague #nswer

#ccurate

#nswer without

solid

e+planation

#nswer

accurately with

solid support and

e+planation

e.uttal (50) Did not re.utState

disagree$ent

#tte$pt to re.utWrong reasoning

e.ut withgood reasoning

e.ut with goodreasoning

Su.stantiate with

evidence

Tota* S)ore


SCORESHEET B

Oppo8t8on Speaer %! """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

#atter $%0& 0'6

Wea

9'1,

#o-erate

1%'20

Goo-

21'2(

E3)e**ent

S)ore

%resentation

!&la.oration

eason (26)

No point

!No reasoning

Wrong point!

Wrong reasoning

Vague point

eason

irrelevant

Well defined

point

Wea unclear

ela.oration

Well defined

point

Well ela.orated

with evidence

0'% ('/ '12 1,'1(

&+a$ple

(56)

No e+a$ple given

Wrong e+a$ple

4rrelevant

e+a$ple

Vague or

unclear e+a$ple

ood and

relevant e+a$ple

#anner $%0& 0'2

Wea

$Rare*+&

,'(

#o-erate

$O.ten&

6'/

Goo-

$A*a+&

'10

E3)e**ent

$T4ro54o5t7

Con8tent&

S)ore

%ronunciation!

&nunciation

• Stress

• 'one

esture!&yecontact

• eading!

$e$ori*ing


9/16

te+t

• ,se of space

• #udience

reaction

Voice %ro"ection

• u$.ling

• /lear and loud

• Slur

luency!%ace

• %auses

• 1esitant

• Speed

Repone $20& 0'2 ,'( 6'/ '10 S)ore


'aen .ut notanswer

#nswer wrongly

Vague #nswer

#ccurate

#nswer withoutsolid

e+planation

#nswer

accurately withsolid support and

e+planation


State

disagree$ent

#tte$pt to re.ut

Wrong reasoning

e.ut with

good reasoning

e.ut with good

reasoning

Su.stantiate with

evidence

Tota* S)ore


SCORESHEET C

Government Speaer (! """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

#atter $%0& 0'1

Wea

2'(

#o-erate

6'/

Goo-

'10

E3)e**ent

S)ore

e.uttal of stand

(50)

Did not re.ut

State

disagree$ent

#tte$pt to re.ut

Wrong reasoning

e.ut with good

reasoning

e.ut with good

reasoning

Su.stantiate with

evidence

e.uttal 3ne (50) Did not re.utState

disagree$ent




Su.stantiate with

evidence

e.uttal 'wo (50) Did not re.ut

State

disagree$ent

#tte$pt to re.ut

Wrong reasoning

e.ut with good

reasoning

e.ut with good

reasoning

Su.stantiate with

evidence

e.uttal 'hree

(50)

Did not re.ut

State

disagree$ent

#tte$pt to re.ut

Wrong reasoning

e.ut with good

reasoning

e.ut with good

reasoning

Su.stantiate with

evidence

#anner $%0& 0'2

Wea

$Rare*+&

,'(

#o-erate

$O.ten&

6'/

Goo-

$A*a+&

'10

E3)e**ent

$T4ro54o5t7

S)ore


10/16

Con8tent&

%ronunciation!

&nunciation

• Stress

• 'one

esture!&ye

contact

• eading!

$e$ori*ing te+t• ,se of space

• #udience reaction

Voice %ro"ection

• u$.ling

• /lear and loud

• Slur

luency!%ace

• %auses

• 1esitant

• Speed

Repone $20& 0'2

None taen

'aen .ut not

answer

,'(

#nswer wrongly

Vague #nswer

6'/

#ccurate

#nswer without

solid e+planation

'10

#nswer accurately

with solid support

and e+planation

S)ore

%34 3ne (50)

%34 'wo (50)

Tota* S)ore


SCORESHEET C

Oppo8t8on Speaer (! """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

#atter $%0& 0'1

Wea

2'(

#o-erate

6'/

Goo-

'10

E3)e**ent

S)ore

e.uttal of stand(50)

Did not re.utState

disagree$ent




Su.stantiate with

evidence

e.uttal 3ne (50) Did not re.ut

State

disagree$ent

#tte$pt to re.ut

Wrong reasoning

e.ut with good

reasoning

e.ut with good

reasoning

Su.stantiate with

evidence

e.uttal 'wo (50) Did not re.ut

State

disagree$ent

#tte$pt to re.ut

Wrong reasoning

e.ut with good

reasoning

e.ut with good

reasoning

Su.stantiate with

evidence

e.uttal 'hree (50) Did not re.ut

State

disagree$ent

#tte$pt to re.ut

Wrong reasoning

e.ut with good

reasoning

e.ut with good

reasoning

Su.stantiate with

evidence


11/16

#anner $%0& 0'2

Wea

$Rare*+&

,'(

#o-erate

$O.ten&

6'/

Goo-

$A*a+&

'10

E3)e**ent

$T4ro54o5t7

Con8tent&

S)ore

%ronunciation!

&nunciation

• Stress

• 'one

esture!&yecontact

• eading!

$e$ori*ing te+t

• ,se of space

• #udience reaction

Voice %ro"ection

• u$.ling

• /lear and loud

• Slur

luency!%ace

•

%auses• 1esitant

• Speed

Repone $20& 0'2

None taen

'aen .ut not

answer

,'(

#nswer wrongly

Vague #nswer

6'/

#ccurate

#nswer without

solid e+planation

'10

#nswer accurately

with solid support

and e+planation

S)ore

%34 3ne (50)

%34 'wo (50)

Tota* S)ore


SCORESHEET D

Government Speaer 6! """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

#atter $60& 0'%

Wea

('/

#o-erate

'12

Goo-

1,'1(

E3)e**ent

S)ore

edefine $otion and

stand (56)

No stand

Wrong scope

No "ustification!

Wrong

"ustification of

stand

#tte$pt to

"ustify stand

Solid stand

Supported with

evidence

No definition

Wrong

definition

No reasoning

Wrong

reasoning

Vague definition

Keywords- not

defined

Stating reasons

Well defined

No supporting

evidence

&la.orate

vaguely

Well defined

Supported with

evidence

(uote!dictionary)

Well ela.orated

with evidence

eaffir$ point 5 (56)


12/16



#anner $%0& 0'2

Wea

$Rare*+&

,'(

#o-erate

$O.ten&

6'/

Goo-

$A*a+&

'10

E3)e**ent

$T4ro54o5t7

Con8tent&

S)ore

%ronunciation!

&nunciation

• Stress

• 'one

esture!&ye

contact

• eading!

$e$ori*ing te+t

• ,se of space• #udience

reaction

Voice %ro"ection

• u$.ling

• /lear and loud

• Slur

luency!%ace

• %auses

•

1esitant• Speed

Tota* S)ore


SCORESHEET D

Oppo8t8on Speaer 6! """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

#atter $60& 0'%

Wea

('/

#o-erate

'12

Goo-

1,'1(

E3)e**ent

S)ore

edefine $otion and

stand (56)

No stand

Wrong scope

No "ustification!

Wrong

"ustification of

stand

#tte$pt to

"ustify stand

Solid stand

Supported with

evidence

No definitionWrong

definition

No reasoning

Vague definitionKeywords- not

defined

Stating reasons

Well defined No supporting

evidence

&la.orate

Well definedSupported with

evidence

(uote!dictionary)


13/16

Wrong

reasoning

vaguely Well ela.orated

with evidence




#anner $%0& 0'2

Wea

$Rare*+&

,'(

#o-erate

$O.ten&

6'/

Goo-

$A*a+&

'10

E3)e**ent

$T4ro54o5t7

Con8tent&

S)ore

%ronunciation!

&nunciation

• Stress

• 'one

esture!&yecontact

• eading!

$e$ori*ing te+t

• ,se of space

• #udience

reaction

Voice %ro"ection

• u$.ling

• /lear and loud

• Slur

luency!%ace

• %auses

• 1esitant

• Speed

Tota* S)ore


Government 1 $Open8n& Team Oppo8t8on 1 $Open8n& Team


14/16

atte

r

anne

r

esponse

s

'otal atte

r

anne

r

esponse

s

'otal

5 5

2 2

7 7

%34 (Deduct $a+ of 50) %34 (Deduct $a+ of 50)

Gran- Tota* Gran- Tota*

Government 1 $Open8n& Team Oppo8t8on 1 $Open8n& Team


15/16

atte

r

anne

r

esponse

s

'otal atte

r

anne

r

esponse

s

'otal

8 8

6 6

9 9

%34 (Deduct $a+ of 50) %34 (Deduct $a+ of 50)

Gran- Tota* Gran- Tota*

W8nn8n team

,r- ! :::::::::::

2n- ! :::::::::::

1t ! :::::::::::

Bet Speaer ! ::::::::::::


16/16

Debate Adjudicator Workshop 2016 Latest Scoresheet

Documents

Transcript of Debate Adjudicator Workshop 2016 Latest Scoresheet