David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M...
Transcript of David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M...
![Page 1: David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M AgriLifeagrilifecdn.tamu.edu/briske/files/2013/01/GrazingPolicy... · 2013. 1. 15. · J. Derner – What does the experimental evidence](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022071407/60ff166c43def9272939be24/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Development of Comprehensive Grazing Policy Guidelines: A Case for
Adaptive Collaboration within the Rangeland Profession
David D. Briske Justin D. Derner
Rangeland Ecology and ManagementTexas A&M University & USDA-ARS
High Plains Grassland Research Station
![Page 2: David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M AgriLifeagrilifecdn.tamu.edu/briske/files/2013/01/GrazingPolicy... · 2013. 1. 15. · J. Derner – What does the experimental evidence](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022071407/60ff166c43def9272939be24/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Symposium Objectives
Explore means to strengthen science –management interactions in SRM.Evaluate grazed ecosystems as social-ecological systems to emphasize these critical linkages.Develop a perspective of adaptive collaboration to promote meaningful dialogue regarding grazing systems.
![Page 3: David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M AgriLifeagrilifecdn.tamu.edu/briske/files/2013/01/GrazingPolicy... · 2013. 1. 15. · J. Derner – What does the experimental evidence](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022071407/60ff166c43def9272939be24/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Speakers and TitlesD. Briske – Context and perspectives on the grazing debate.N. Sayre – Roles of science and management within the profession. J. Derner – What does the experimental evidence tell us?F. Provenza – Limits of the experimental evidence.B. Budd – Management perspective of prescribed grazing.L. Huntsinger – Grazing management within the context of social-ecological systems.M. Fernandez-Gimenez – Strengthening science-management linkages by collaborative adaptive management.
![Page 4: David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M AgriLifeagrilifecdn.tamu.edu/briske/files/2013/01/GrazingPolicy... · 2013. 1. 15. · J. Derner – What does the experimental evidence](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022071407/60ff166c43def9272939be24/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Two Valuable Knowledge Sources
Experiential knowledge associated with management of grazing systems.
Experimental data derived from grazing experiments by researchers.
![Page 5: David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M AgriLifeagrilifecdn.tamu.edu/briske/files/2013/01/GrazingPolicy... · 2013. 1. 15. · J. Derner – What does the experimental evidence](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022071407/60ff166c43def9272939be24/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Experimental Data
Majority (84-92%) of experiments show no advantage of rotational grazing for plant and animal production.
Briske et al. 2008
Suggests ecological processes are minimally effected by grazing systems.
![Page 6: David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M AgriLifeagrilifecdn.tamu.edu/briske/files/2013/01/GrazingPolicy... · 2013. 1. 15. · J. Derner – What does the experimental evidence](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022071407/60ff166c43def9272939be24/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Managerial Documentation
Strong support for rotational grazing.Minimal documentation of potential benefits.Source of potential benefits uncertain, but ecological processes often emphasized.
![Page 7: David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M AgriLifeagrilifecdn.tamu.edu/briske/files/2013/01/GrazingPolicy... · 2013. 1. 15. · J. Derner – What does the experimental evidence](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022071407/60ff166c43def9272939be24/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
“A Failure to Communicate”
Two knowledge sources may not be mutually exclusive.Ecological process may be marginally affected.Management benefits may be realized.
![Page 8: David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M AgriLifeagrilifecdn.tamu.edu/briske/files/2013/01/GrazingPolicy... · 2013. 1. 15. · J. Derner – What does the experimental evidence](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022071407/60ff166c43def9272939be24/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Roles of Science and Management
Science can help deal with subjectivity by using methods to minimize human influences and frailties (Stern 2005 BioScience 55:976).“It’s what we know that ain’t so that get us in trouble” - Mark Twain
![Page 9: David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M AgriLifeagrilifecdn.tamu.edu/briske/files/2013/01/GrazingPolicy... · 2013. 1. 15. · J. Derner – What does the experimental evidence](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022071407/60ff166c43def9272939be24/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Misconception: Researchers
Science provides the complete and final solution to all issues.Experimental data invalidates rotational grazing systems and adaptive management.Experiential information is not a valid source of knowledge.
![Page 10: David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M AgriLifeagrilifecdn.tamu.edu/briske/files/2013/01/GrazingPolicy... · 2013. 1. 15. · J. Derner – What does the experimental evidence](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022071407/60ff166c43def9272939be24/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Misconceptions: RG Advocates
Short-term rest consistently benefits vegetation and ecosystems.Multiple grazing events with a cycle are eliminated by rotational grazing.Experimental data have no relevance to managed ecosystems.Continuous grazing does not involve adaptive management.
![Page 11: David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M AgriLifeagrilifecdn.tamu.edu/briske/files/2013/01/GrazingPolicy... · 2013. 1. 15. · J. Derner – What does the experimental evidence](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022071407/60ff166c43def9272939be24/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Components of Grazed Ecosystems
WeatherStocking rateHuman dimensions
i) adaptive management i.e., forage inventory, drought management, animal care
ii) agribusiness/economics i.e., labor cost, cost/animaliii) goals, capabilities, and values
Grazing systemsi) short successive rest ii) improved animal distribution & harvest efficiencyiii) moderate SR required to maintain animal production
![Page 12: David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M AgriLifeagrilifecdn.tamu.edu/briske/files/2013/01/GrazingPolicy... · 2013. 1. 15. · J. Derner – What does the experimental evidence](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022071407/60ff166c43def9272939be24/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
RANGESTOCK
![Page 13: David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M AgriLifeagrilifecdn.tamu.edu/briske/files/2013/01/GrazingPolicy... · 2013. 1. 15. · J. Derner – What does the experimental evidence](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022071407/60ff166c43def9272939be24/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
More Relevant Questions
Can adaptive management be more effective in rotational systems?What management component is most responsive?What management skills are most important? What percentage of managers possess these skills?How can these skills best be shared?
![Page 14: David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M AgriLifeagrilifecdn.tamu.edu/briske/files/2013/01/GrazingPolicy... · 2013. 1. 15. · J. Derner – What does the experimental evidence](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022071407/60ff166c43def9272939be24/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Professional Implications Beyond Grazing Systems
Expand professional culture to more effectively address conflict resolution.
Increase communication and trust.Promote management – science interactions.
Establish a research agenda that emphasizes adaptive management.
Central to the profession, but little addressed.Why is this the case? Viewed as unnecessary?
![Page 15: David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M AgriLifeagrilifecdn.tamu.edu/briske/files/2013/01/GrazingPolicy... · 2013. 1. 15. · J. Derner – What does the experimental evidence](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022071407/60ff166c43def9272939be24/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Option One: Retain Status Quo
Retain two independent interpretations of grazing systems.
1. Maintain and potentially increase divisiveness.2. Reduce effectiveness in addressing grazing issues.
Advocacy without documentation and in direct opposition to experimental data.Human inability to visually assess ecosystem responses over the long-term.
3. Potential for less effective management and policy recommendations.
Conclusion: Unacceptable and indefensible position.
![Page 16: David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M AgriLifeagrilifecdn.tamu.edu/briske/files/2013/01/GrazingPolicy... · 2013. 1. 15. · J. Derner – What does the experimental evidence](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022071407/60ff166c43def9272939be24/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Option Two: Resolve Controversy
Link experimental data and management perceptions.Science does not provide the final answer, but it provides important benchmarks. Document purported benefits with monitoring data and records of management decisions and activities.Strengthen profession by providing unified and effective management and policy recommendations.
Conclusion: Only viable professional option.
![Page 17: David D. Briske Justin D. Derner - Texas A&M AgriLifeagrilifecdn.tamu.edu/briske/files/2013/01/GrazingPolicy... · 2013. 1. 15. · J. Derner – What does the experimental evidence](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022071407/60ff166c43def9272939be24/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
What’s at Stake?Internal disputes question our professionalism, and marginalizes our effectiveness.Our profession faces multiple challenges; our collective inputs are required to address them. We can not let controversies languish for decades and divert us from this responsibility.