Datin indirec
-
Upload
hugo-ortega-turpo -
Category
Documents
-
view
227 -
download
0
Transcript of Datin indirec
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
1/38
Indirect Dating Methods:
1. Dating Alteration Assemblages
Dating hydrothermal mineral assemblages (e.g, sericite; biotite) in
altered wall rocks adjacent to a mineral deposit is probably the most
common way to indirectly date mineralization.
In relatively simple cases this should be straightforward.
2. Dating Host Rocks for Mineralization
This approach is obviously only applicable in situations where the
mineralization can be tied temporally and genetically to the host
rocks, and is therefore highly model-dependent. This method is probably reasonably accurate for VMS and SEDEX
type deposits and for porphyry deposits, if the causative pluton can
be conclusively identified.
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
2/38
3. Bracketing the Age of Mineralization
Obtaining precise and accurate crystallization ages for pre- and
post-ore intrusions is the only fool-proof method of dating
mineralization. This is particularly valuable when used in
conjunction with some of the other dating methods.
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
3/38
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
4/38
Common methods of indirect dating
K-Ar and 40Ar/39Ar
U-PbPb isotopes
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
5/38
K-Ar and 40Ar/39ArGeochronology
The conventional K-Ar dating methodand the derivative 40Ar/39Ar
methodare two of the most widely used geochronological tools for a
wide range of geological applications
Potassium is one of the most abundant elements and a major constituent
of the Earths crust; however the radioactive K isotope (40K) comprises
only a small fraction (0.017%) of the total K present in rock-forming
minerals
The relative proportion of naturally occurring K isotopes is fixed:39K 93.2581%
40K 0.0167%41K 6.7302%
40K decays to 40Ar with a half-life of 1250 m.y.
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
6/38
40K in a rock or mineral undergoes branching decay a small proportion
(~11.0%) decays to 40Ar by electron capture and the remainder decays to40Ca by beta decay.
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
7/38
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
8/38
Basis of K-Ar Dating Method
K is contained in the mineral lattice (or within volcanic glass)
Ar is inert, so is not present in rocks or minerals (or is present in very
small quantities)
With time, 40K decays to 40Ar*, which is trapped in the crystal lattice
The age is proportional to the relative abundances of40K and 40Ar*
To calculate an age, amounts of40K and 40Ar* must be determined
Age calculation:
T = 1/ (40Ar*/40K(/) + 1
Where = total decay constant of40K (=+)
= decay constant of40K to 40Ar*
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
9/38
Mass spectrometer
Extraction line
Conventional K-Ar Extraction Line and Mass
Spectrometer
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
10/38
Conventional K-Ar Dating Method:
40Ar* and 40K contents are measured on separate sample aliquots
K determination: Total K is measured and 40K content is calculated
using the constant ratio of K isotopes
Ar determination: Isotopic ratios are
measured using a 38Ar tracer (38Ar is the
least abundant naturally occurring Arisotope)
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
11/38
Calculating a K-Ar age:
Age is proportional to 40K/40Ar*
Determination of40Ar* requires corrections for other sources of40Ar
40Ar in a sample is not all 40Ar*; but also includes some non-
radiogenic 40Ar, usually of atmospheric origin
40Ar* = 40Ar(m) 36Ar(m) [295.5]
(m = measured)
Sources of analytical uncertainty:
1. Homogeneous monomineralic sample? Sample preparation orsingle mineral phase
2. Atmospheric Ar correction Inherent in samples, but also lab
3. Precision of analysis Laboratory care
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
12/38
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
13/38
K-Ar Isochrons
K-Ar data can also be portrayed and interpreted using an isochron approach
The age of the sample shouldbe proportional to the slope of the isochron
The lower intercept shouldcorrespond to the 40Ar/36Ar ratio of the
atmosphere (295.5)
The problem is that the non-radiogenic component of Ar present in the
different minerals (or whole rock samples) commonly does nothave exactly
the same isotopic composition; thus one of the basic premises of the isochronmethod is invalid
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
14/38
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
15/38
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
16/38
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
17/38
K-Ar and 40Ar/39ArGeochronology40Ar/39Ar method is a variation on the conventional K-Ar method.
It is analytically more difficult and time-consuming
A great deal more information can be obtained from an analysis
ability to recognize thermal disturbance,mixed mineral phases,
the presence of excess Ar,
complex thermal history
sample impurities
etc.
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
18/38
40Ar/39Ar Method
Based on measuring K and Ar in the same sample aliquot
K content is determined indirectly from conversion of39K to 39Ar bybombardment with fast neutrons in the core of a nuclear reactor
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
19/38
Mass spectrometerExtraction line
Resistance furnace
Laser
A typical Ar-Ar extraction line and mass spectrometer
Ar isotopic measurement is similar to that used in the conventional K-Ar
method, but uses a more sensitive and more accurate mass spectrometer,
and a more precise sample heating method (to permit incremental
heating).
di i f b i i l h l k l b f
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
20/38
Irradiation of a K-bearing mineral or whole rock sample by fast neutrons
in the core of a reactor converts a small proportion of39K to 39Ar
39Ar is unstable and decays back to 39K with a half-life of 269 yrs
(fortunately this is slow enough that the delay between sample irradiationand analysis is not a problem)
Several other interfering isotopes of Ar are also produced by the
irradiation process. This is especially a problem with phases such as
hornblende or plagioclase that contain significant amounts of Ca inaddition to K. The relevant reactions are:
40Ca 36Ar
40Ca 37Ar
42Ca 39Ar
37Ar does not occur naturally; therefore we can measure the amount of37Ar
in the irradiated sample and use this conversion factor to estimate how
much reactor-induced36
Ar and39
Ar are present, and subtract these
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
21/38
We must accurately estimate the efficiency of conversion of39K to 39Ar in
the reactor. This will vary depending on the particular reactor that is used
and the actual position of the sample within the core region (neutron fluxwill vary to some extent within the reactor core)
This is done by usingflux monitors, which are natural mineral samples
whose K-content and age are very precisely known
Samples for irradiation are individually wrapped in Al foil, stacked in a
small sample can with interspersed flux monitors, and all irradiated
together. After irradiation, the flux monitors are removed from the sample
can and their Ar isotopic composition is measured on the mass
spectrometer. By knowing the age of the monitor mineral and its K-content we can back-calculate to get the conversion efficiency factor,
which is referred to as theJ-factor. This factor is then used in calculating
the age of unknown samples that were in close proximity to that particular
monitor in the sample can
40A /39A A C l l ti
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
22/38
40Ar/39Ar Age Calculation
The age is calculated from:
t = 1\ [ln(40Ar*/39Ar) J +1]
Where: J = the efficiency of conversion factor, and
40Ar*/39Ar = 40Ar/39Armeasured 295.5(36Ar/39Ar)
The J factor for the flux monitor is calculated as follows:
J = [e tm 1]/[40Ar*/39Ar]
Several flux monitors are in widespread use. One is either biotite or
sanidine from the ~28 Ma Fish Canyon Tuff in Colorado. It has recently
been shown that the actual age of this unit is slightly older than the age
that is being used to calculate J factors in most labs; hence many Ar-Ar
ages that have been reported in the literature of as much as 2% too old. In
order to evaluate published 40Ar/39Ar ages one must know which flux
monitor was usedand what age was inferred for the monitor.
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
23/38
Advantages of the 40Ar/39Ar Method over the Conventional K-
Ar Method
1. Avoids sample heterogeneity because only one sample aliquot is used
2. Age is more precise because the age is measured using only Ar
isotopes (conventional K analysis is relatively imprecise)
3. Can determine a total fusion age (which is analogous to a
conventional K-Ar age but more precise); or
4. Can analyze using step-heating methods, which helps detect episodic
Ar loss, contamination by non-atmospheric Ar, and the detailed
assessment of the thermal history of a sample
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
24/38
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
25/38
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
26/38
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
27/38
Total fusion orstep-heatingof samples can be done either using a
furnace or a CO2 (or UV) laser
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
28/38
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
29/38
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
30/38
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
31/38
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
32/38
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
33/38
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
34/38
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
35/38
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
36/38
One final problem!!!
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
37/38
One final problem!!!
Observed that when heating hydrous minerals (micas, hornblendes, etc.) in
vacuum, the minerals undergo phase changes.
Suggested that the release of Ar from a mineral may reflect these phase
changes rather than diffusive loss of Ar simply related to the heating.
For example
Biotite experiences major dehydration reactions at relatively lowtemperatures
These reactions are strongly correlated with episodic Ar loss.
Because of this, unambiguous interpretation of biotite Ar release spectra issomewhat questionable.
-
8/4/2019 Datin indirec
38/38
Hornblende undergoes a significant phase change at ~1000 degrees C
Hornblende structure begins to exsolve Fe oxides.
Another major phase change at 1030 degrees (usually the peaktemperature when most Ar loss occurs.
Hornblende structure decomposes into a fine-grained aggregate of cpx,
plagioclase and Fe-Ti oxides.
The release of Ar appears to be unaffected up to ~1000 degrees;
however the exact meaning of heating steps above this temperature are
somewhat uncertain.