CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2...

55
IJOlCQ I TACU O C 2OflICC bibp w pc drioq iqiporn cxbjcji bci.mou bLoAIqcq qJ njj cLcq ucjnqu © © p? CJJ.q K QLCCIJ VII LJJi2 LCaCLACq 3OLf 2cCITOIJ2 O GXI 1J01 10 CXCCCq wo Kcci.cp. obrulou2 cxbLccq LG 1JJOC O 1J1C 1WOL uq UOI qioc Oj qic 4I1OUI Bmn Oj ECOUOUJ!C I4BEL{ awq Oil HOfl2U )IJUJC2 uq M2 bi.ccuicq i pc I4BEJ 2Uq COuLCUCC uA o ip qw riq !u 1p bbcr jpc nviq CVAC bbjc jjn bthci ii bi.cbq ba o, ipc o cou2m cu joL Dcwombp? vuq coJo) ii picp bLoAiqcq cowbnii i.coracc iiuq 2ouic uq 1.IBEI 2rnJJUJCL joqcpob uq CouI.Gucc bi.iicibiu JpuJc jo o io gic COUJUJCUI2 jLOW b VIJIJC 2CIJMJ bQL 11JflUq CP'4 ACXCL Q UJpq f1IJJAGLA Oj fi2COUJJJ OL1fl1C 2CIJOOI JJGIbflJ LC2CLCJJ WIJCQ JLOW 11W GL9TJ uq 2OfUp C1.0UU C1OpCL Ø- JJJC I1I1JOL &icjnjjX icjcuoiiqcqca 2nbbol4 Low ivc bLcbui.cq OL MBE! COIJtGLCUCC Oil bflPI! ECOUOUJTC 9uq llO12!U JliJJ J2Juq CwP.!q on TOO CJJflU2 VACUIIC WIJJOMVT BflIEVfl Oh EC01401/'LIC BE2EVICH /AOLICUJ bbCL 4O jcpiq K Ou KylE BE V Of11CE Oh CO4CEKW 2HOf1D iRE 2VO14VL HOEO1I4EK2HIb J1BEK IAOIKI14O bVbEK 2EKIE2

Transcript of CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2...

Page 1: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

IJOlCQ I TACU O C 2OflICCbibp w pc drioq iqiporn cxbjcji bci.mou bLoAIqcq qJ njj cLcq ucjnqu ©© p? CJJ.q K QLCCIJ VII LJJi2 LCaCLACq 3OLf 2cCITOIJ2 O GXI 1J01 10 CXCCCq wo

Kcci.cp.obrulou2 cxbLccq LG 1JJOC O 1J1C 1WOL uq UOI qioc Oj qic 4I1OUI Bmn Oj ECOUOUJ!CI4BEL{ awq Oil HOfl2U )IJUJC2 uq M2 bi.ccuicq i pc I4BEJ 2Uq COuLCUCC uAo ip qw riq !u 1p bbcr jpc nviq CVAC bbjc jjn bthci ii bi.cbq ba o, ipco cou2m cu joL Dcwombp? vuq coJo) ii picp bLoAiqcq cowbnii i.coracc iiuq 2ouicuq 1.IBEI� 2rnJJUJCL joqcpob uq CouI.Gucc bi.iicibiu JpuJc jo o io gicCOUJUJCUI2 jLOW b VIJIJC 2CIJMJ bQL 11JflUq CP'4 ACXCL Q UJpqf1IJJAGLA Oj fi2COUJJJ OL1fl1C 2CIJOOI JJGIbflJ LC2CLCJJ WIJCQ JLOW 11W GL9TJ uq2OfUp C1.0UU C1OpCL Ø- JJJC I1I1JOL &icjnjjX icjcuoiiqcqca 2nbbol4 Low ivc

bLcbui.cq OL MBE! COIJtGLCUCC Oil bflPI! ECOUOUJTC 9uq llO12!U JliJJ J2Juq

CwP.!q onTOO CJJflU2 VACUIICWIJJOMVT BflI�EVfl Oh EC01401/'LIC BE2EVICH

/AOLICUJ bbCL 4O

jcpiq K Ou

KylE BE V Of11CE Oh CO4CEKW2HOf1D iRE 2VO14VL HOEO1I4EK2HIb

J1BEK IAOI�KI14O bVbEK 2EKIE2

Page 2: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

ypfqou ifluiAeLA veune

flrnAeI2UX O2CPOOJ O Bn!UC22Jçcp1.q K O'.

OAGLSJJ UGfUL9J eeCi ou we 9G9G ONU1C1211!b wie

jpe couJpiupou oj !wbLoAJu 9OL9fl couquou mq /1oL2eupJ w9uciq 9bbe9j pq mi

9 JJOUJC IIJcLe9eq 9JUJO2 CAGLAMJJeLe LGqrJCU we UU9IJC!9! 9W9CAGUC2 O O/U1IJ 9 p0u1e

M1J!JC poweo!AueL2p!b obbow1u!e2 wbLoAeq qm.pJ we ioo we cx mue nze co o oMu!u

perii W2 onjq euq bn2p we oJucL-occnb9uc? L9C qoiiutmq Jje jo jpnuq wr

!u bLeeLeucc jeq o 911 !ucLee u we bi.obouou o poncpojq pcqeq p? 2!uje beobje jj cje

oweqJu oipcL qrnu ecououic couqOu2 pi 9C NC juq qrn po qGwOL9bJJC 911q CIJ9IJG

uJbLoAeq 9JWO eAeL?JtpeLe qmii we JoO 2fl2lU w C911G o we irniu I.9ie !A9

euc o 9oLq9pqA wewLe iic uq ipr poweoNu3e12p!b obbowIu!Ie

bLeeLeuce

ffuq oNue12pb obboLwu!Iic uo t wbjX LCUCC cjrnupJ qcwoL9bjJc couquou OL

JJI 2WIJ9OU porijq pG OrILCC O COUCCW e L9 LCUGCI2 9IJ9IU CCOIJOW!C COUqOU2

jpe JJowcoPMJeI2p!b L9G w we flueq wee ii eeiuvjjA wgu9Iu qm.u we mo

VBLKVC1

KVIE BE V 2OfiIcCE OE COMCEI142HOflFD JJIE 2IVOMVI4L HONEOREK2HIb

VIJA

I4BEB JOLpU b9bGL

Page 3: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

cmeono3 10 eowo a od .35! qidaieawoemoH n8aS8 edt bluod8

aeeiD .I biado&$1 d noaibaM-th2aooeiW lo ñaieviaU

QQ1 aM

sitgr1 .1

1oiunim Ilel aelai2 betinU edt ni etai qidsienwoemod etaea eiff

aMb weiie3 ioei e'mM .OQQI in kieoieq ot 0821 th IeoIeq tnoft

eothi lid ethil a 'd 1no hid ,zioth sail etri qiibaenwoemod edt tadt wod2

lath ataeUu. 1iotsid beoei won ae$leme laiD ewt3iq ilatevo edt wilT .022!

ax abaals aixif .8thwcn8 nail iedtat tisita ai elat qidatenwoeinod edt

aetal2 behintJ edt nedw borxeq II taW bhoW-taoq edt lo laom taattnoo

.Ibiqai wet ehat qudatenwoemod

evad nafodoa emoa baa awxq ialuqoq edt atsivib* gthauoH

10 eotza a ed bluoda etat qidaeawo edtlo (tot3ejatl edt tadt be3seus

xi() edt won ahab eauaoed 3taq th earns mezoo aliT .ntexoo bethloeb 1Laxda etri edt tail belaeua 2082! edt 8phub uç all 10 euhiv d Idmaaet .ebmoeb edt ievo taeoteq .0 nail etoxu d nzeoaoo buy etow A .eotxa stab eldaile'i etom a al auan&) edt eia elqmaa

iii aelquoo bernam auo noms ehai qidateiiwoeinod edt ni eniloeb edt si

benininet etsi qidatenwo Usievo edT .022! baa 0821 neewied aetsia iaom

boaaoioth ? tevo eaodt *noxna etsi edt eauaoed hio ebaeb edt gthtub baeta

nihs( ed bluoo ehsi eta*elW taft edt suiT .etedwxeve yjiaen

wiicudemod emil-lath Isnoitibail ml snoitibooo hilids1nob lo noilaxoheieb

a oh ebuteiq a ed im noilaaia OiiU3 edt tail *th3aoua aqizg edt beeba! .emoo ot riae edt in etsi *ninwoemod edt in qoib lsihaaladua

inoil tae,ie$I" (2Q1) .1x ts sieM buta ono lo eftit iev lo eataeneq edt ax noiaolqmi Inenimmi as slaoUua qudrienwoemoH

.nenwoemod eta tail ablodeauod

I

Page 4: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

uogov gpo powooMDoup!b Logo 1.01.102 tuc1z*1A Jtp 111011411 t404fl8 QCyo1.

gpo qoW0LVbpCt 4110401.0 LoobOUeIJ)J0 (01. tgdUvg!OIr V HGUQ12OH (ions)

gTho—gpon MO M4fl uooq go gi) 111(4 qItcugvd4o MOL 1(1* gpo oconomict 01.

gpo 1.140 L0u0042 Opodot in ocouowic q0UJUtlobpCi—2flCp Vt

cougwj tncp vi do "ni 1.000- 4PGLJ MO IJooqU,g M0U) vpong 'r jiuojj)

qom0kvbpc2. — qowdz.wbpic cpvLVcgo 18410001.01. mpicji boob1o 0A0 no

001180(01. COIJCQLW RIP° 1.240 LQUCC42 Cp1Ut02 in P04 LI! CVfl h1LO

(ragg-ioo) u igopicq) gpou gpo vcg gpo gpo togo Je nag wMzn* epijq po

•ozjozqvpqig bwpjowi (vii 191. oxvujbjo i'rcoxJ 191. Hom!d 4flQt

4P0 '11 LU41 4P° 0c011 I(4 !8 '°4 '01 12°P p0c$n800(

tuwi pomooMnoupib 1040 tponjq pew totICO 0( COnaOW EO1. utgvuc& i

Jj10 IU8MOU 40 gpovo dnovg!ow M!I1 pojb qogeunmo pogpoz. gpo

1802 exbjmn gpo cpvUtu* powooMIJoz2p!b zogo

O VIIIC4IOIJ 0( q JdLvbpIC* 011(4 p(xmopO4q g?bov H0M nmcp udpg cpodxd

1111100411.00(0 tgdUVUg ocouowX HOM UJIICp 18 gpo powooiiuid logo timb

1.240 OWUOC4IOU 0( 000IJOWIC 0th04t1U1g) 1111 11 gpo eutiiiuq logo (p0104910

LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ii gpo powoomnoupb

B( P°1.°'0 Mou)1Ut goo umcp vpi gpo powoo,Auoup!b

vxxj (j)•008101.191. zauUt poniepofqi go pocowo powooMmut ponicpojqi (Mu czqoz.

mcLaei!Ut bLottnto go jooecu Iwqo&Muvd tgvuqvlqi to gpot'i MIØ pocowo

(iot)) jpo tocouqvx) wozggdo wvi.pg 0g0na102 A0 1120001110 I3I1(jOL

woLggdov 202*40 OCJJIQAO 4410 O0J 0(0 PIRpOL pOWQoMU0l2pb Logo (gdwwu

DoAolobwoug p U°'rq &obotVIi go OffOM INh0L qoMuboAwoogo 1.01. hIp,'

lxxi (11° C11114011 vqw84log0u D4'"I 0( H0112!fl 111(4 flplt

powooMuo1.tpIb go L0W40L wwoza O( IWIJTQt in Hw couQ0UVJQS P2* cojjoq (01. qoMUbV)JI10UI m*gonco bozvwv go pud 000022 go

JIUWOAIUt OAOIIfl 1040 h011110L H° BW C0W11314400 CPVU.W0U H

I,0flc).UIVFOI.t p01.0 41II 11(140 0( (pG VJIlflWt 01.01.4110 (oteoug4v11X)

Page 5: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

ibum iev eu neubliib *thvid lxii *ninovth jwnain lull slaeui (IQQI)

monooe edi wed lxiii 01 awlT .asioiaiaeb idqauoineb ii low as imogiooo

kiiuocuiib wod Ii oo1 lruft laura ow elsu qüfauonwoeaiod odi boloefi* aid

wod nedi has eql Uodeuod lo ooiodo edi boIQollu ovid onols anoildxroo

oafs laura oW 3.oql Uodoauod doae nidliw eb&n em enoiaioob eoiodo-ouur1

.aoia*1 thmdo lo laqmi edi uobiaaoo

ii baa ovoà anoilueup oil I uewana 01 urged ol does ueqaq aiiff

aoilinuJuoqqo *nlnwoemod wod aenirnaxo noile .awollol as beslnsgio

1o sewaaoin wea ioa thqoIevob d OQQI lxii O8QI neowied beinado

a aA .aue susneo owl oaodi ol moth 3thlqqa nedl lxii 'iilidthio11a thawd Hew wod aoazmaxe oafs ueqaq oil 1aowauem oaedi 10 saenlulew oil lo liel

wod aeaunsxo £ noiloe2 .qidaieawo olula lo aelau loibeuq qted edI neublido iltiw betham 1beiuam) aeqil auoiisv oh miol oh osoodo abldeauod

ooiodo eus3 wod ha dool iiedl i noibooZ .(nelblid3 iliw $0131115 lxii e13nia

aouqsnoo noibeZ 11aai'1 .eqJ blodeauod doao nidhiw obutn em aaoiaioeb

OQQI has 08Q1 neowled ohai qidatenwoomod lsulou edl ni egnido edt wod

Ixis 1bebiberq (1') d3uvndl () anoiioo2 or aia1asia oil hadw moit beuollib

.exiotfiib sill 1 anoilsoilqmi oil aiob&anoo

j\o tuznau11 .11

'otV\ torV1 eriuni1 'nro .K

thiodesuod thauod iioiu1o nnol bits tnuoina oil 3thsoodo noiW

:noiiotwl yiiliiu oil ,imixarn

(I) =

baa imeuD :laeuohai orwhii emos to oils ii olsi qidneawoemod off einoa seoriboiq ininwoemod lull nwoda ovid (t8Q1) tehaIaD baa (QQ1) .311W

.lovi3oeqse1 Loola 3nuauod oil rot baa netbfido aol aeiiilainelxo oviJiaoq

£

Page 6: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

10 ikmup a i d boo8 iianwn a ai X noiionzft 'iiliJu biIav a al u ifw bna orma thwod biqu3oo 010 (i £ £1 jf ozma 3nrauod Iatn w HOIIqW1E i&I .vjiliiu otni aoiva thEuod1o ebnbl owt di qam i bna

biza on3bie1 wnnq1o oiod3 a a n€q3i 0iO43 3WW0d i1i iadI muaaa

-inwo na ed 01 aeoofb no1i wdT .booB di 01w aonbia id1o qrnut

lBq3nrIq a iol thauod Ia1ni1o noiiqrnuanoo mdl al noiJailqmi dl ithquooo

mmii -enwanoo a5la3ibrn q .Clilhiu Lathgiam on ouboiq bkow onbia ii3ilqtth na aela ai zdi LLaiuiaM .,no nadl az1 woo1o ai boa ooa1iq

1aJn boa inwo mdl noiiqrn!Jaaa

blothauod 3dT .-d)onB no inoft alzuboiq b01aiinflib ia thauoz1 boiquoo

nr4i laum

:lniwiianoo Jbud Iaioqmhalni adI 01 kjcfisa noiloadl 1,lilhJzJ all itthxam

,r ( - () t(+1)

bna mi01th ahom1o baqmi di thbuL3x mooni xai-ifta ai Y dw jaliqaolo iaoo Sinulioqqo xaJ-iftn adi ai i J emil Ia anoilwbth xal 'h3qoIq

baa .1 31th1 Ia aaoibubob xal i41a 8niauod balquooo nwo1o Iaoo au ad) azpu

)bud rr .1 emil Ia aivia 3thauod 1ain1o Irnu q lao3 ad! ai ini ad iaum maoila nollqmuanoo adilo ufav 1aaq ad) tad) aiaa Iqmla tthaiianoo

11a3 !ao iiinuhoqqO .cna5Ila mooax adilo ziIav tnaiq ,dJ nadl iom on

a niIa,vth boa thworiod1o aq'l lxiib 3ausood boriq xniI ii 11w iav .aaoqwq xat ioI 1)nxfiib br4a5il

dt 3miI dl Is :ainlaiIanoo Bthlhvmbnu oa1 oela thloibeuod 1zj

bxil a nad) 'iom bnqa 01 b3woLIs Ion is dl auod a asdq 01 thiath

Isoo ieau no anoibubth xat b anoi)aoilqmi cdl b noiuuadb Ihita0q .(C8QI) boim,I boa iodaicboeH cci ki1wrlanoo 3ebod ad) boa

Page 7: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

2

1JVIjGL 4VUjoL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic

CfUL1j IU4GI.G24 L4c2

Om. OVU 9O&q 1AC1J EVUWC y(VCJLCqqc flVC '4! 24V1Jq9U2 uuq

wqcx iz qic bci.ccidc opc wcqiiu buccq fl2G V WGUU wcomc pwA o

4J1C J4V410UV yB2oCiV4IoU 0tçVj'jOJç2 H0 yp&qvpqirA nqcx jjJi2

4J7C W024 cOn3WOUft ciicq WCV2IILC 0JiOI12iU VOLqVp1J14A 12

ccc UJOAC rn obboac qmccpowd

wcvn' lAG Wfl tccouisc pv u mcowc uq flPU4fl4!OU

IUCCU5IAC3 40 GC0UJC OMIJCIZ J113 i V LCU4j0-WCOWC LV40 12 fl2G V2 VU

WOLG VW2C4!AC UVUCZW11A' vuq poimcpojqa 'rn i"V2 LcU4-4o-wcOWG LVTIOV U2C OMUGL-000nbIGq0fl3i io pcoowcbi1ijcu uuq lpcI.coLc conjq VJ20 pvc VU cgcq on qic o,cfl oiiuciapib c

VP!1!4) OPO(12GP0!C12 40 VCCIIWUJV4C 4pc 2VA1U2 UCCC22VI)t 40 WVJCC V qO?1U

j,unwvpft' LcU-o-mcowc L94102 Vpo VAC VOUIC iuibic on ipc

oucwnuca opc qo!Anbn?waJ4 I.cdsmcwcu4)

bVAwcu4 o wcowc io pon2c bucc-40-mcowc LvpoV (qn2 i.cijccj qic

uuq 4pc conøw abcccq in ())buucibn wcic tx uq wnvucc

CJV4IAC 40 Lcu4m (qic nppA wcpon abccicq in (j)

coonounc bci.abccp,c' ici.cpi.c' 4GUULC cpo!cc ia V UC40U oi: pc UVucTu

bicci bcob1c ow O0U2flWTU wc1. .0bWSIN lcAq opoiinw ELOW

r1uiicw miq vcprc (1 g)) VAC VPOMU q"r jpcc coup u mg vuq

4pC J10fl2c jjicA imp 40 bsn.cjmc m.pcL Vuaj}3c2 (c8 ow (i) nq

OL VU E}W WOI4g,G poricpojq W1124 VCá1WflIV4C IJJIcG bciccu oqic I4nG o

0120 00011W11JV4C V wiuiulf1WqoMubo)u11d114 40 bnLcpoac v ponac: Thicoj1A' CAGU

bctccugdc pcii. zucowc2 obuuc1b01' rnIcLcoi vuq jox bo?wcnp jpc? wn

Page 8: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

Q

OffOM ne go qo)

cowbzopouviojA (oowQIp!u gpvg wG(1.obop41u noii' 101. oxuuibo qo uoii 8co bpc wanq couflqoispjA oug i 11.01)1)040 COAOL IJJQ couugiAEL110C0 l B'I!°tF pA 1OGnIUd Off 04V400 MO UWUOM

! MOM AOIF C!O VIX) fl10 110 (11140 1!U.°'' 104P 'PI' W 2w"E 041400010 04f0U J1L80 V7X q1AQL2Q 01 C(7UO 4)10 JlOflIJd IJ3VIFIV

bo?.wcug-go-rncowc i.ogio (jj) wqCc jpc jjjç Iuqcx puo 11)1240114101

JJJC L24 02 201136 CV41U02 III 00113111031 M14 4)16 J4VI mqcx: 14120

qobic41 gpo uauciv o gucuo2o ooium8

pG U4 4)1100 ClbgflIO gpo jidniqig?. C0132412W42 qiaCn02cq 0P0AC gpo TI1L4)J

Jflpj1C flOc N1CL0-loWbJc ogpc j gi miq j 001211202 oupc wgoq 4ogco

gpo ?.coLa jg) auq j J,, JJJC qogo mzqa.jThi8 gpo nqcxca cowo [ww gpo

p01121118 u0Lqop1pgA EtCh OUIJ020 IUqCXCI ! cojcsijogcq 0L 81! O 040402

j0 OACLCOWC 4)1020 j1W14V410U2 J 010046 0flL C)CLOU4 W00211LCO 0

1)11140114 04)1C OMW0L-OCCflbICq p01121118 wvqccc

1011401. ponlcpojql !C0Pt011 MOM u8)v11q uuq MOM joqc uii8pg 241JJ po

cotnigi) JJJC 110410310) p01121118 VffpU)VplJigA wqcx my?. 200131 VA0t0pJC P114

101)1.020314 JJ0M poWCoI!UC12Jflb obbotgnmgroo ,oiA iu 1CLCU4 1)9142 oupo

iUi8jig 1)1020114401)04031410) pOUJCOMIJCIZ EIUOIIA o uogiouuj mqcx couuog

Lo41o2 vuq qoco Dog coualqci. gpo pwct 4)104 ccnmnjogm8 o qoiubtAwcug

p0fl2C Eomqr 1)10 ponorn8 voi.qtpiprA mqcx joop oujA 1 bomc114-4o-mcowc

jpnq gpo gpag-gmc powopnAcL tI.jj W024 jccjA uog pnA gpo wcqiuu buccq

ponoopofqo 01.0 qcczcoaw8j?. w&cawgvpc o8cuctsj ozqvpqiA couqlpouo

UJqc 111) 00Wi)101 0U0OL ouq ao gpo op&qvprpgA couqigiono occq pA oncp

0)101CC qcozaou ccouq' eu rncLco2Ju8)A ut8c UnWp ofllonlqbojcp 91.03104

LcvJJ?. 8ounouo go uA qiocn2aiou opong v0Lqtprp4A c013241011141 40 ipO gcum.c

OACtCOWC oUA poi.uoL2N 40 powcOMucLapth' 9Th) 91.0 gpciqolc ff04

pOfloCjlojqo M)10 91.0 v)LcvqX J1011160M11012 1)1020 J1O1120p0)ql JJVIC v)LcvqA

)W!ftP0 EJLIr pA Locmom8 ou gpo moqivu gounjA ouom.' gpo wqcx wcjnqca

j.jiijo gpo wqcX 12 020IJIJ OL 1q0U4I)4U8 41QIJ2 14)1020 UflW)1CL 0

Page 9: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

ab!co124 4IWC powcpnActcc jjyj(j ) oi. oowc wqcucc opool poc buoca borg pA (PC

qi bcicwqc 04C bucc cpafupn4lou jpc prLq mqcx za s Lcu4-4o-wcowc

WCOWC (PC wcqiou LCU4CL ponbcpoq Lcdnacb iii oIqCi. 40 bracpobc U JJOflbC 04 (PC

(P12 mqcx' !ApG1J wujpbpcq pA 4W bCUCXJ4 LCbLCOCU42 (PC 3C(0U 0UUUflbj

0AC (CU bCLCCU4 04JJC AOIOC 0 U 0fl2C 10 C02 10 40 bmepozc v ponc'

rncouic mq o 0nbC buccq o c 54 bcxccupic) nnundpowcpnAc 101124

iuqcx 1 bTwbJA 0 ponbc-bIJCc 40 WCOWC L0410 (dour pooq 111)017 wGqTou 1.CU4cr.

oocr.onbIJcbb oi,,4pc qo/AuboAwcu4 pnIqGU ou LGU4L P0fl2C0b jpc occouq

BIG 2CC0U ouq jpu.q wqcxco vUcwb4 40 Rc( oowc bThC O4pC

w000bcdnCu(oJ4o (JIG OII4COWC OtOfiL ouvA212

pA-ao4c qøw 0U 4JIC2C !4WTh H0MC 02/AG OJJUfl JV4CL 2CC' (P!b 0011221011 !2

Joou-4o-AVJ11C spo 100112) ouq pomq W2IILUUCC' fl( MC qo 1104 JJVAC ooq 240(C-

(JIG C02(2 OtbUAV4C WO4RdC IIJ211LSUCC (pCCV112C /AG VLC J00Jc!UR 04 bCLCGIJ4

E000!C 0G-LCqq1C flUC nuqclJAu(UJR 2(UU0L2 jqcoA' /AG M0flJ oo vqq

w!CLO-bvwbIc JJJ!2 uqcx ff1112 LCIJCC42 (PC boa ou oonacpoqa 1J0PAC (0

0110 JIO112G 04 (PC (P bCICCII4IIC ia dow cvcno(Cq ow qvo w c bnppo naC

boA1uW( pc j4q IuqGX J00JCb oujA 04 buuczbej vuq rn4cLcaç jpc bwbcqA jox

4oXca(Obuuclbof

qlbcnaaIoua opowco!Au1uR obboqmn4rc2 Ew°IP' (PC j,g wqcx oqq br.obci4A

WcOWGa 0(LGU4CL JJ0fl2CJI0J2 ULC (PGLG0LC (PG oujA i.cJCAOU4 rncowca (0

ponacpoqa 4V( JIVAC pGW bocuzoiiA qclncq powco/AUWR obboinmpca' c

IUCOWC qv4v (PC WCqTVU IUcOWC 0L Ofi LGU4cL pOflbCpOJq2 JGU(C12 VLC (PC OIIJA

I-pmc pnAcz. /AIfl bmcpouc V POfl2C couq (PC luqcx CWbJOZ 4L !4

bctccvVlc 12 eIpI4LVIA' 140120 WO1 cjoac1A 1C2CWP1G2 (pC biicc bomj o p1cp o

bcrccuj J000-40-AUJITC LV4T0 000 JJO112C 1)UCCq 04 (PC (P bCLCGU4IJC ppijc (P12

woupjA buuciboj ouq rnctca boAwcu 0110 4JUI4A Acor. woqRdc /tJ(JI 0

icucca OW (PC J4'FJ Iuqcr JI0!AAGL E1124 (PC Iuqcx CVJCIIJU4c2 (PC

Page 10: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

a

cowbvLc wqcx unwpci.v tow ouc Acai. to wuo4pcLto pc aAatcmvpc auq spci.qot no a waki. voni.cc ocoucci.u MJIC MCw,cL (j) oL vowc cvpwvtca aug a ptci.vpac i.ciict)' wc P! ucici. vccumcatiwatca otAvific JJnJc w ownPC piavcq (vcc ooqurnu aug

vu oupo rnqcxca nmojiuna ponvc bucca vi.c caicnjwicq naiua Ot1JJCi.2

bwbci.A vx i.wca on a atatc-pA-atvtc pwaiv 112U1& LCboLta 0OMUCi2 !ApOaC pon2c

bnt wamtcuaucc cxbcuaca t oo augpc uaJc bi.cimnw a aug cvlciijatc

jsiIAOuqLatoL jgovuq JijvaOniuicavni.coobbOi4nmtAcOzc MC

aS11ACA M VaafmJcg wc town to AVJflC LVpO M92 o auq mcq wc tcu-Acaz.

WO1Vac LVtcv OL 8O wuq I O IP EqI HOUJC 1'a BUJC ]3OvLq

wponvcpojq pcwgcq pA a wauicq conbjc aug tpvt It icq ffiC toojc

umi.aniaj cqcLaJ aug ataic tax i.atc oi. pc wcqan LcUtc&12 mcowc' avanwiua tp't

IC bwbcqA tax LatC aug q !2 a uvc bi.cinunw EOL cacp 2tVtC' MC cajcniatcqwc

wawtcuvucc coat aug qcb apol? iv cxbcctcq pomc buoc abbz.ccta on' Lb 12

iuctcv Lw4c' in iv pc Jovu-to-AVJnC i.apo' 112 C obboumgA coat ocvbztvj' b iv

no iv mci. C02t' LA 12 C IUBLaIJvJ mcawc tax Latn' K iv tpc uioqdc

ic=(j —.&)i +Q—)(j—'u) +b—a +r.'Q _.r.L)+t ('l)

J-jcuqclapou (j 'y awou otpci. bjaccv:

mc tpc icj-jcuotw oLwnJa oi. mci. Co va cuiboAcq in (i.ccn aug

OMUU V poffic: V 2ciJJcG-UoM-co2t to IIJCOWC LVt10 10 CVICflIBtc 4T2 !ml' I

ErnallA' j cicatc vu Tuqcx spat Lccqv pc uaucw qcvn.apipA o

to-iucowc LVPO2 go not i.cijcot vu aoIqvppA bi.opjcurQ

LCUtaJ pomiu' pITs JIVAC WCXbciJviAC posivwa ,AaTJVpJC to tPCIJ? WCJL P!aP LCuf-

twatca oi ponaiua ponacpojqa cpooac o abcuq a jai& .ac4ou o mcomc on

nubottaut wqoacucirA bwpcw: watw cotqgPC ponvcpojqa iiijp ati.oua

oojaua v wc woi.c tThicvj mcqau Lcut-to-rucowc L,pO pccunvc itaioiqv ouc

abcuq in &own LCiJ on tpc wcqIvn i.cutaj mnç jpiv wcwvni.c qcia i.ow

mgcx ibcvcutnj tpc bci.ccutdc pc wcqzau iucowc i.ciici. pomcpojq wm

Page 11: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

a

je bioanuiv liv IOW qom tpv!IflJvi!0U oxbccvpoim uOzjinivicjA I 131n0!4A oqvv ww cvtpc m

qvvjjA MO MOflfl oepwvio V LO vObpv(cv40q llbLC1J umqvj o

QOUGLVflA vbcvjau& qic uca vpon pc cpvu&c in pouIcoMnuJR

V fli

C pttw C0w8trn.uw

powcoMum& qcciviou vcinA nuicq 0440 pc

C024 pvucq nbou vu GL't3%I, LV4G C0(fl2C iv V WCflLC 0JJ0/A pcuqczvj pc

vu v wcvumc oupc vulTcibVicq U8UC!Ij pcuctv obtacpvvu V ponaC flact

flaCI. coat pvvcq nbou vu t u; !nIJai!ou i.c invA pc ,icicq

bucc o& pc picc Acviv ojjo,nmg ipc uqcx Acm.

LV4C o VUIICIbVICq inUV4Toif cxccb pv JAG jICC qic VACLVC iucLcvvc in ponac

jpc powc)' MC fl2C 4pC avwc qvvpvuca wq lCcpU!dnc vu/AC nac 40 CVJCflIVIG V

jo C4 oiu. mcvunz.c otvcinvi naci. co (rca 4PC VC4flV coat otOMUW

C0WWcLcC.

crou in ipcp qic &lviG IIcv: qua z.vc iv cvjcnjvicq pA qic j DCbCLVIJCUI ot

qvVpvuc JAG nyc lpc vici.vc i.vc oponac bucc vbbi.cciv on oi. qic civnv

CP!CV&tOL4PCACVL2 J-Jgff JOL21cvn4C4caWIpcvao MCnac vu cxbccicq iujviou 4pc VAcldc ponac bucc u1JV4iou LV4C In

ciA oi ipc qu.cc Acvta bicccqinR 4C uqcx Acm. JOL cxvwbjc oi jqiuoiz In

mijvion qic vctdc bciccuivtc mcwvvc in ponac bucca in ipc vvcv jm.c

jçcvoiz osc 'i qvv pvvc MC vcc vu cxbcctcq ponvc bucc

EOL cacti 2414G !JJ4 v ciA rncnqcq in qic jjvpouvj vvuocviou ot

qiCIL ponaca

pThoqicva vuq S WCVI1LC OLJJOM wncp ii vcinvqA ccvi ponvcpoqv o pc w

cxbcczcq !uIJviou 4p54 ojoiiv qic vqvbc ugvponmA cxbccvpouv

EwvitA4o CVICnT SIC iujjvpou' JAG nac jMfl wcvvznna: V WIqC uJCvusn.c

bucc iv vi ipc p bcx.ccupjc

Page 12: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

TO

pVU* bomga OAQL (p14 (!"'° bcuoq

I8O l 1ôâ0 flQ bWU!111 0L o'I rLA I°""I I I• jj &oAqcq WO M!4P NGIC' OP!O b1cwmMIux lcpQqnJcs OL

P'! bonU2 'UI MJJ z.spoo Monjq JJOAC lwbwAcq rn oupc jp0313 bo1u42 bcL Acm. pi 1pc bLcmirwJ LO2C .oW UOIp!U 101 8O 4°O4Thico oimnoJ bLcwIcml o& v j bctccu5 J080 4o-AoplC pou.oicL ionjq pc o

yoia8c cyusmucc uasn.oucc i.oc ocpcqnc oncoa (p(

CXCpiqC buA'4c woL(dC IU2IILOUcC ouq P90Lq IU3IIL000C bLcwinw3 jpc

woqtdc w4cI.ca tujca m io m io (3ccuILC ) jjn i.vpo qoc

cuctojA tontu p003c buccjo-sucowc L04102 !Ac1 LcmOLccq pA Jo/c

boAwcup 40 WOOWC IUIbLOAcq so ovc pcjiccsJ j gj ouq j j JJJC

jpc cpouc nl pc i.opo obuuc1bur UctG04 ouq bwbcqA ox

pon3c bucc-o-moowc LB4 00 mibcqcq powcoMusu obbol.4n0 co pC4MCCU

!I4p LcU4-40-fl1C0WC OIJC MOnjq fiC puiq bLcaocq 40 wojcc OCOOC

2110/A 4J104 jpc powcoiAucupib z.'4c vc4nojjA W3C lu 10024 opcoc ooca ya

243402 MJJCLC couqlpou3 ,Aoi2cUcq m.c so pc 4oqpcuoç NActa (I )powcpnAci.abucc) swbwAcq so j oupc avco (acc &U.C ) J404C4V4 3J

bCLCCZJ41IC 00 OLpTLIBIA R4 004 fwLc030UopIc blvcc io bn4 4C p124-4!wC

H°" bucc-jo-wcowc L84102 (nvu Ofl2C bucca 04 IIC 34JJ

Lcu4cL: 4pC m qcflc. o4JJC 11011310g WU4CC4 SbbCVI2 40 pclno4 UC

4pGZ.C ObbCaI2 40 C V aflfflCiCU4 2(OCJC 0 9p1.q3pJc LCU4VI Ofl21U 49L 4J1C uscqIou

wcqzou socosoc wo4oI ponocpojqo (occ &nc j ) yuq 82/AC 2CC pcjo!

wocc v cooc pv4 Lcu voiqvpqsjA couqiiou2 poic RcuctsjjA qc4cuo1cq

2434c2 jpsa p82cq nbou cpuucoow igo IO 4/A011qpc qICS1J(40

Acq1VU W02 LU4 40 wcqliU wcowc L3400 !WbL0/cq US 30 O)pOflOcJJOjqO cUcL01TA nubwAcq oct ipc bcs.ioq I 80-1 ao

wc031ac2' iii vc pomco/AmUR obboi.puipco c. wcqou mcowc *.aijc.

ObboWuJI4Ica PCv1J I 8O ouq IO ! "0484 v pvq BAoin.pz.cc JdmquA

Page 13: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

TI

ouc AG2L13 &O22 WOOWC 40 bflLCJiBtC B

mibjica P4 P°P°I uccq 40 BOCIIWIIIB4C all GdIIBj ° o bcLcaU oLcdtnLcq 0L B CUACUOUtJ 1oair (pLcc-4o-ouc pontc bucc-40-rncouic i.tpo

Pn1.F It(!AC 4° W00111ca ftv uJiuwJflUJ qo/iubBAwc*J4 0 JO CCU4 !t

!P( H°' bucc-jo-mcowc LB4102 TAC B 2W2C O4JJC q0tIJJbB?UIcU(

ju j y pc pontc buoc-4o- rncowc LB4T Mat Lct4CL (JI2U 4LCG in

LCU4CL WOOinG qTa(Lrpff(IoIr

qtu pmqjA IWbJA B LCU(VJ tpLqtpql(A CU2I2 .OW 4J102G !U (JIG unqqjc 0(JJC

vccruunjtpu jinqt OL B qohwbaAulcu( onjq PC qiwcnjc ccqpqcta (pc

pontcpojqt iutA PC B LCU4BJ uoiqtpipjA btopjcuf wcauiu qia

Wcqlau IIJGOWC LtO2 BbI)IOBCP!IJ 30 bc dU4 CACU WCCJIBU WOOinG LCU(BJ

accouq joiict buccq nmi miq to ow EOL tvca iiq wcqlau &oat I.du4 o

J0MC24 buccq LCU4BJ sim 4t4 (JIG tccouq JOMCt incowc pontcpojq 4tjcct (JIG

btctnwct Bbbwbuv(c 2OI4TU — 4JI24 (JIG JOMG2I WOOinG pOutGpOJq 4tJCG2 (JIG

9.qpJC JOL nicqiun JUCOIJIG LGU( P0(lP0IP HOMC1 (Pit !U4CthLC(t(!0U

PCJOM 30 bc.Ccu !U i xuqICt4mR (JI24 LCUVJ pontwR iat

ll 20 24U4G2 (JIG WCqiau &022 IIJ4 40 wcqIvu IIJCOUJC LBPO !A92

4-Q LCbOL4 JCACJ2 0 aoIqBpJJJfA couqulout In j

W (JIG COuqI4IoUt VGC4IU JIOWGOMIJCUJJ!b' C0U(CX4 12 WbOL4au4 tug to

j(JIOflJI pc &nuai) bniboac °4P!2 bvbct J2 (0 1UAG2PB(G cpguca

voLqBpJprA couqipout gcuCLaJ IoItcucq 0UJ J 40 J (J

2° °° BBW OUG oniq PC PLq bLCZtCq 40 WtJCC (JIG CV2C 4JIB( JJCJJG0MIJW

1J jpit LB4C !2 JO (peu (JIG LB4C ouowuBj WcOWC &OM(JT

bci Acm. pccw i (gpc cm.pct( Acm. ot ipiop (G qtv BIG i.cboqcq) aug

A2fIC 0JIO1J3GQMl3llI WZSILBIJCC bIGuhItfllJt bcz. pontcpojq WaG pA j bCICCIJ(

2 0L JIOWCOMDCU 1U2 TJCG BCCOLqW 40 (JIG DGbm4UJaI( 0 COWWCLCC 4JJC

Page 14: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

fl PA0 !D VU O e4VCa

a '°"i'°n' " io 'i "°t " coIj

o" vabccoipia Lcjupou2plb cp9IJc2 np2taDt1JA MJJCIJ MC jooc at

OMXJ1U HI J() 1AV2UOMCI.CDCØL V2 VØLCIAC T MU2 ID Jff

fl2CL 002t to rncowc 12t10 auq ffJC LCIJt to TUCODIC Lat102' Tt pCCOWC2 CJC9I. ffJVt

cpctccqpci.c (EoIJam pjpcu MC JOOJC VtCP2IJG2 ID

OoMIJcL-occmbIcq OII2fl1 M92 bmpp1A CACU ccL tJIaTJ MJ1U MC

in j j cowbaLcq Miffi I 2O 4PC qctcUoLBpOU ID 4}JC DUUCIj UULVCPACUC22

ID J 2Dm jg juqccq iACUpat2OIIJ2IJXpOfl2qIOJq2itCUJ1CqVt

itcuisci. pc woidc mtcz.cat auq bwbcI4A fUX jflCpOU icic jca apivpc

jgj'jcjApcocxjççpuuycto jpl2W2UiitOLUJWLW21 IX L2C OL IpC WcqIUU LGUtGL M2 2RP2t9DPVUA rn

IDTJat1OU !A22 cDcLVfl WIICJ JOML W2U DOWIUtI WOL48C LV4CU COOIJq tpc

(wncp icn a-L9x LataY pn .ow j ax to j j pc i.atc otponc bucc

bucc wijapou iii mauA waqcq UCU4A wvcpcq uow usj woq8dc TujcLca i.sjca

PW2DIJICAMCLC WIIJCJatC Jo: OW J to J8O ipc Latc oponc

LOAC ff112 qccUOizpOn Jz2r LCø WICLCZt LB4C2 ID IJIC Iat I SO2 MCLC WflCp

acI.AICc2 to UTcOTUC LVtlO LO2C ID 4 ojpc Ø atatca jMO CCOUOUJIC bpcuowciiv

pccmnc uuuciaft i tw.cpc pCMGCU j auq i : qIC co oUIon2Iu&

112C OflL CX 1%IC WCI2SILC Ofl2I OO2j pOwcOMmu cUcLUflA

U C'

10/ 24 d, C U2C2 O J

WcqTVD LCD4L2 ucowc !2 not &tIWCJCUt to bnwpvac s ponc buccq at ipc

woi.v auq powco/wcI.a m2tu.aucc) jpc umup oaatc2 oz. itpicptP2tVtC2 It JAG qiol) Ipc 9IJ0,PIc Lat!O to bci.cciu (to ccotuu OL

g bcccu (wC wax UJnW tmqcI. EVIJUTC NB-ELCqqC yac (ynqcpuc2) rn

jpc Lnpo obuucthvj iutcc auq tax b iciu to WCOWC cxcccqcq

Page 15: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

'3

CAcI)tMpcLC cxccb OL c J4CM uJwq 2G2 vuq }AvI)ucrp0n2c-bUcc-rO-wcOWc LyrIO2 couqiiou UIJbWICq tOL ipcac °'i'°i&cVcLøJJ) mthi.oicq pqiccu j miq jy joz. iuyriucc' iii pc cc oLcuIct2 jpc L2fljf2 McI picjjA c wc: jpyraoi.qvptpr) couqipou2NP' I cjcnvrcq 4JJG iuqcx fl2JU 4J1C wcqiu 1uc0wc2 OIAOtIUg wwcqv gu luqicyroL pyr pc powcozucz.pib LyrC imp qccpuc ujpa. iii qic prflLCJ1UqI3OOLcq C qccpmu pOWcoMucLapIb Lif C muou Aonu mwcq conbjcaaci.aj coIuwcuyroi. (c HWc1CI3P0tI (jgg)) uq ci.a c. (j) pvc

cpcvqMwqccco3 uoLqomqngT24pyrfl2W 4pc wcqI rucowc2 owzucq coizbjc iuci2

,, j,qicibua yr pc j,ijç snuwci. MOippob 2nRcarcq cyrcnwpu pc2c

pOWcOMU1IJ otqpiprA, C42!2

JgozpwnprMxpuv

obboiiimpc iwbwic CACU WOLC jpm tot poac yr pc wcqIw ouc ionq pc

yr rpc p bczecupic otwurct poncpojq wcowc MCuq pyr rpc powcoiwiu

pc wu otpowcoitucz.pIli jjcumc pac rpc tpoc cyrcnjupou ou tcucia

wAcyriyrcq p (poc yrpcmcqI iucowc ICAC! tOL Lcuctz) c pjccjA uor yr

pr qio c aponjq uocpyrrpc ptnmcpojq2

ro-rncowc Lvpo2' ponc bucc-ro-rncowc r.yro uq bvuucur-ro-mcowc L2O2

.fTh!caJ. izr-rmc pnAct Jw&oAcq: ID uq 2ivrc i.cbccpiq)' i.cu-pOWcOhwm Lyrc B !r12 CdnV11A CJCI. yr o&qvprA couqwou tot w

umJCIapuJc2pucufv21qqw jgj:qmwAcxbjviuiubpcuuurHOIIO!IIa.2P!b wipr uor VAC vbbcLcq o vLvc AC ID

(PC yryrc2' (PC C(fig1 002( oomnni qccjmcq pqltccu Jgo Io.oMuiu• J qOca UO( O pq mpcII cowbøLcqm(p Io—uI cxojApj

pTp pA boyr-øL yrvuq8Lq2: cdncu1A mpcu mc joojc yr pc coyr o

wrpcz. gpuu gu C IUC WC22IJLC JçC IU(LC2( L8(2 ID (JJC CBLJA j()2 !ACLC ACIA

rpc vqnyr coyr oupc cuicc uo!A opon2w — x iipcu mc nc gu CT.\o

Page 16: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

14

vxI 2W' na&oq qJacow

cxcc 'q HbA wPt ipc)t ao ucpc uuqlu ll fLCC Lc22ioIJ flCIOK 12 UC21AC uq C2WC2 2 r-2P2C III

,cIcr jpG acwcc-co-fo Lcuj uuq idmqiiIcoum bwxIc2 gpo bcqpim

MCmonjqcxbcq' pn mc uoj zapcBJA qicwu .ow scto s pc becu

po,imu JJJC COcCTIJ42OU FJ3 GE?? BVCK LC ucic2I21tJ4 p1JJ LV2 OywvWcq cønbjc pOn2cpOJq2 JIVAC p1p L22 O

oq p-q-j pjc 'u in ip oipc io

LCLc22ofl2 fl2W pop iuvpJc2 vuq smut cgcp ALW[C 1ipon c opc

oL pop j gijuq j ty pj,j uq j,jj mc ocom2cpipJA oou.cptcq' go iWCOWc L2410' UqHbA !2 qJC J10fl2C bucc jo rucowc io w izou

occnbicqposigmgo IU4 LVO JILL , pc buucib' wci uq bwbctA 4UX 10

bE1CVbA P l bci. C2bI9 IUcOWC ncioic P 4C 3LAICC cO2 OtOMUL

BI"VCK' IJIC bciccudc OjYOfl2Cp0Jq2 pcvqcq pA u

NVBI�IED !2 C bcLCcDpC oiOfl2cpoJq2 pcqcq pA uwcq cothjc

ba.ccudc ojioncpojq pcqcq pA aowcouc Acvz.a o dc oi. ojqcr

ooncpojq pcqcq pA owcouc nuqc pc vco GEapacuba qc 20 HOB' IJIC powcoiicpib J2 ipc

+ç\çiQ+ujio' =tt+V cv +jwcggnLca uq asjc powcoMucI2pth L94c2 Lgu qic ofloMmg LC&c221o02:

2 WC22flLC OqiC LcJtIOIJ2p1b pqiwi qic voLq2ptpfA

cOU2IZ!IU2 /AG MOUJ cxbcc qicw o pc1b bwqicr powcoiiucapb izjc ipc

luJIc pLqspqiA ujcwtu cq VOAC jinjA iqJccj JIdmqrA

'z'

Page 17: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

GLGUJJUJWL OpOWGOMUiu jia babci. ocnaacq czicajA on wauug ana'

cuqc.apOu (j gg) canppapcq rpv ponacpojq Abc ia an iwboqau4

'4 X'U°'0\t0.cC oooc

cocwcicuLawna LCWUW 2(VpC OACL (UJJG c WQM (P94 II2 in VC4 qiq nO

Acat qiu,]cIcucca aa MCjj joi. anp V I.CC22IOU o JIVAG wcamn po!Actci (PC

qcaA tAG MOfl urn LcLc2aIou2 aLcaqA bcqpuncq on jccja oU (CU

couonuqcq (JIg Lc&caalon Lcanj4a

qOCrJwcIuapOU joaua) LP!2 apo1.i-cuu bpcuowcuou coqq tAcfl JJVAC

Iwqcl. VPCLVI nuqcuupu conaiawa couqxpoua (c uo-qocnwøWoU 01 JO/A-

i gj4a ConacdncuA' wauA OU0tACZ2 pvq a (cinbOLgiA obboqnuiA (0 poliotA

uda4Ac cdnTA 1ACIC VJJOIACq 40 ou8fll94c woiagca ru (JIG UJIq-(o-J94C

CUjLVUCC M92 onjA bOaalpjc OL (JIG accouq Lcaaou: auma auq joaua MIII

aug wiiq.apoi (j )OLCAIqCUCC O1UCWCICU4 ponain W9I1CC42) ncp

oMncI2pb wVqCc4 (JI VII tAG apoajq (2Cc c aug 2PCL (jg) aug ypzspaw

UJVLJCC4V JI9 VbCCIIJV4TAG ptippjc tAG MIJJ 2cc WOI bcobjc CU4CLIJ (JIG

ponac-bucC-4o-rucowc aug MJJ 40 WOOInG i.aoa jzu gjnp jionac bucc

JCLC at o bjanvpjc CXbjaUV(10U2 OL (JIG bOVI4IAC IZ32 OIl (PC

OOU2ILVIUL mcaawca VLClna( bnspu

yicau-ywcucau ponacpojqa rabnjm JpG coccicua ou pc pdrnql(A

tcanjp 4JIV( !AJfl JIG bLCaGIlLCq 494CI' (JIG 94u4iapca11k bOVIpAC cOGWCXCII( p.

pdrnqi WCS21fl2 !AJJCU ipCA 9I.C fl2Cq pA (JJCIU2CJACV JU JIJJ4 O(JJC wIcLo-qa(v

BVCJC pCC0wc2 2!&J!cau( aug boa Ac go pc cocwcicua on ipc VAO

on wauicq conbjc ponacpojqa aug 2GLAJCC-CO2(-(O-LCU(' (PC COCCICU( on

NJJIICWC jJLG2naCOUfl1flC(opCV2CXbCc(Cqp.(PCOOcUc1cl74a

Page 18: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

theaoni na oX baI vacj gnszk 1aioa baa ohfqsiomb lath b3leus baa

31oW -u1 a abIodeuoii ifou mill bna af8tha d b3ba3d thlogbwoiflo r,dizwn

531q1103 b3 T1&U 'd b3ba3d abloibeuod nail ln ol yLiil

iun4 alos qyi bIodauod wodlo noilalolqx3 -iuo bnaqx yarn W bornam y1dsmuaiq :n3lbludoIo 3onaiq 3dm Is 3nblool oats yd lid a 3oiod3

3mod a asibiuq ol vjli1 iorn jwp th3d 3eb Us a nibhdo dliw a3lquoo

aulala 3-wnl atnaiq iloiilw 8 31u8i1 .nbhd3 IUOLLIIW e3Iquoo b*nsin nail

aidlhoqquaolthnl baifloa bna 3qIbIoLbauodyd OQI baa 08Q1 zu

3rnax. oels laum w oiodo 3rwn3llo airnanyb 3rD nithmsx3 ni o .w,iv

athxh SLam oT .a3qyl ablothanodlo noilscmol 3dhlo aoirnanyb 5d1

borrarn yd babsoil 3eodl :al ,zjo'I olni thIod3euoii 3bivib I 1daanarn boba3d eodl 1b1id3 diiw abarnarn yd b3bsai aorD niblido on dhiw a1quoo

.niblido dliw aInie yd bobaai aodi baa Jr3lblid3 luoifliw aIthe yd

3oubolq autav siooa baa qaom3b 3runad3 1n31x3 ail oT

aiim enazk 5oubmq mui m ibudw innsiia b!oitsauod ni anad3 a,ob 3111 qidznwo3rnod isfi aiX ladI 3bLJL3noo yarn 3W ninwo1o boodilLiI

thnsdo bnad i3dlo aim nO .vjimthoqqo oimonoo3Io yl ousq a Ifl91 Ion

II .anoilibnoo oirnoiroo gainado loft31 haq in bluoo aln3rn33naTxa bloitsanoif

ail iol 3Idiv1oqa3I ylhaq xa anoilibnoo 3Idaüath aat a3dJ naii znI ai sliD

.3111 qidn3nwo3fnod 1811

3rD RO 231ffl0fl003 baa a l8orn3bIo l3aqfrn 3d1 3thrm313b ol suiT

bnoooa 3111 as noizioth 3310113 5n1n31 3dm Is LooI bliioia w 31ai qirfainwo3rnod

101105 ladw 3nUrn3l3b eXU38 laift :553301q 33101f3 Iaiia3up3a a ni 3OiodQ

1srn ylqmia oT .3iun3l aninri3lth yaii nail baa oi ao13d 111w yaii blod3euod

bluow 33ioiio 3-urnallo !oborn a m 3ldanav ylolaaslqx3 as l b!orbauod

.3111 qidainwo3rnod 3thnarb aiuIo 35U53 irU ail mo thbn rnoft air vhq3b

bIod3auoiIo 3oiod3 aiX :arn3ldmq yti3n3obn3 illiw an ineiq btzsow oats II

5wn31 3nInn3l3b lath a3tdsnsv niaz aiflo ynam yd "ba€asQ yh8313 si 3qyl

.3010d3

Page 19: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

bn no3a1 wollo I .poithth oioñ3 bloxbwod 3dJ 1bom ol baa ,(082 I) -xw*dllwM

rinoI 31Db noiioniiI ii1iiu a omuaa

() (ç1..1(t11e =

a olth 3qi bIoibuoiibo 33i0ñ3 3dibo thqqatn 1D ao3fI31 if ii1iiu i u

Ja5Iib na1q31 8'fl baa aboo n,-zflib in3-Iq3-x ap 311i baa booB

.aqyi blozbeuod

:grno13Iatd1wbI

() = k

3d3 tneq d 3111 baa 1thoazado blod3euod afli3erIq31 a

adJ woifa 13uad113uM baa noa3CI n31D qJ bloibauoif if383 bo 3il2rI3t3S1Ad3

31ff i1oI Iaunonithim a aa nolxob °X bIotbuod dt Ibom 11E3 3w

101-n iob bmaiaq 3di n1nnb oi Iao u awolla l3bom t1o! Iaimoniilum

3111103110 iol a3talflda3 ki3i3ffioo 3di nd3nIa51 d Iao a33iO1f3 3JthEaOq n

oioib 11383 iob aiiiI1dadoiq dIbo awe 3111 istli iue w am os o eoiodo

.blod3euod 11383 iob 3110 0 mae 111w

VI

Page 20: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

18

jW.C W01.c0ACL oi .c2ona ql2cn2acq rn y.vqqvv (j g3)' qic usnup. o

qic uqq cuo ogpc cocwc1cn on jpc woqcj BcW81JA cumicq c drnc

(j uq ionq 2CCW 40W qiC m pc.c üuto1.js1ucjA in vuv (I a.)'

woqcj hkLC Ufl qcbcziqw AøUSJ2 9LG qicpo4owOfl2 12 qccjobcq in yøjjøt

Ui qic woqcj o jioncpojq cpolcc Abc V 21Wflj491JC0fl2 Cdn9f01J

GW81C suq qicu src cq bwpnp!ppc2 .ow qi woqcj 91

cxocuon A9Uj2 40 uJoqcJ qic pccppooq jpv qic pcq oyoncpojq !IJfl PC

yubbwoqcwqiquamvicImp4pc4on2c

ip cpjqcu vz.c ucqA OflL WG2 woLc piccA 4° PC pctqcq pA !AOWCU

cjcaijA mJboi4un4 qc4clmlu9u4 opomcpoq Abc: poncpojc pcqcq pA

4Thc ojccouowic cuIaouwcuf on qic o4pcLpuIIq' qic acx opon2cpoJq pcq !

aj 11410 p cpiqcu i1ffJon( uivuiu ia picciA qic bwqnc4 o v cmu

2CX oijJon2cpolq PC91 !2 402 ccI4vu (C&CC' 8120 JJJC

poncpojq 4Abc cpoicc

UCq A8Jfl2 .0flJ 4B4 cdntjion in pc Wfl1pU0U3181 I01 woqcj o

bwccqnLc in picp i cqnccq pwi cdnupou LOL Jncowc wq qicu fl2C

4V4 ponqioq Abc vu,cc wcowc Jc1kcj ou2cctncuqA' j fl2G uio cb

cpijqi.cu OUOC Mc1Lc u9uci81jA I.cBqA 40 qo 2o) AC4 1412 V0 caviujA jpc cc

IuJbvc4 on 4JJC qon 10 o1w nuo juona poncpoq Abca (NMCJI iu

A9LWPjG2 4Ø4 4P'1 cuqocuonw 0L cxøwb1c xucowc cjcuqA pv mi

V woqc opon2cpoJq 4Thc cpo!cc !IJWWPIA Wfl24 0O119W

Page 21: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

aupca jpc Lcg,oUa qnunmca ij pcjb cxb jam qigcLcucca iu ponacpojq

MJJc4JJGL 4JJC JIOWaCJ7OJq 82 OUC CWL OL M0' miq UJA Lc8louaj qfnhJwA

Aauvpjc) m ouc opc moqcja !I4ICIFCL 4pc pon2CpoJq pcaq 12 V M0WVU

qcaI.ac pcvq uuq COJCC aqnac pcaq (vqiauccq qc&cca VLC 4pC JcIJ-Oflj

acpooJ &Bqna4c pcsq' pij, acpooj &aqnv4c pcaq COjjC&C uo pcj0qnwwA AVI JG2oz.cgiicajiouaj vg 1JwcU4 iqJ pc cac8ouca pcmR uou-pip

Ia jpc jczj-on I.wpIc) a qfmJw)kAVUtjC OL tApc(pcL qic pcaq 1 pJVCJC

pCU jcaa lpau ' o-t' -' auq (, auq OJGL

wcowc wc qnwwA MLWPI2LOL sc oponacpoq pcq ip w CV4CRouca

VUJC 'p4W P1' °' 4!'4!" 110c1c12

4Thc2: wauicq 1upon4 cplJqLcIf wvuicq MI4JJ cpIjqLc1J awJc M140fl4 cpqLcir

w jQOOO aauibjca) Hor1cpojq atca Va ajLcaq?. uocq qrrqcq w font

nuc opc ccirana' auq u.ow ponacpojqa .om wc iao jni (rc 4pc

D °° °" Q4 P°'P°IP U°' 4PC I J,flpjlC flVCCW

w D'3W %OU jtI UtC%fl

pciccu jgo "i jo

opam bjvnaipjc bLcqccca vponf cpauca m poncpojq 4Thc2

uqocuczA bwpjcw cjpa. y2 MC 2VjJ acc cw iipcu MC cxcjnqc qna

cxcjnqm 4pC acxojpc ponacpojq pcaq: 4P!2 vjjoia fla 40 z4th vwnuq4C

jc bvLawcIcIa ia dnic cowkojn4cq jpc.coLc' i aiwbA ca mvc woqcj

!cFUpIc by WC4L2 TU woqca ' dnc awv viiq w UctbLc4V40U 0

Page 22: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

ro pc bLopopjiX ocw wmnui Muponr cpqqLcu bcLPOb2

U2c2' o p) ouq jvc qoc rpc bwpopiprA opcrn uiou.icq ,up cpIqT.cn

yIao couvacu r pc iwbocr onctioU 02 cqncor1ou oommcuj

coucuroLporprpc igo'q ImxJb1c2

conbjcq 02 qic 9c o1coq U2G2 .OUJ Q ro OpOAC JJJC3C LC2flU2 OLC

2pothJA LGqnCW pc UIJWPCI. OpOn2cpojq2 jicvqcq p) cpijqjc wowcq

OAGL 0C JJU2 &opopjA LczJcc pc ooc pvj rpc qcvqi obonc oi.c

cpqqLcu qioc acq wc jco pICCIA ro pG uxouicq ,,zzp cpijqcu ipau rpoac

cpqqLcIr fAG 0120 Uq ffJV LCJV4IAC ro qic bLop .opcm wouicq ,Azqionr

HO(12PO1 I#Jqi JCVq2 ocq 3-44 ULC W02 JqCCA ro pG woiucq i#zqi

I2Cfl22 qIC boi.omcrct copuoco OL COcp cvcozA joç

bicqicr cpouco w cpoicc oponcpojq rThc pqiccu i so i jcr fl2

!#JrJIOIIr Cp1qIIJ 12 flJC MJ-°" CVrCOÜ J3qow qI2Cn2vU JJOM ipC woqcja

bwicrci C2W0G2 ouq LOU ooqucoz o wcoanw (acc wpjc ) ouJcq

JpG WnJPUOWIBJ ioR W0qC12 bCLtOUIJ dInIG IACfl ltJflJ apoth

umhIpcI. OC0UJCI2 U qiG JUCOWC cdiivpoit pnr OUfl i .OW qic WflIPUOWI01

o WIIU!UOUJI01 iou WOqGJ jO iqcU41Q qiC JoIr MCmcjnqc

oU LcdncaI) Jpc pon2cpojq Thc cpoicc cdnorlou2 OLG oconi2c rworcq

Jpc woowc cdn 01712 caqwvrcq nvn 2IuJbJc or (1cnIr2 VA01IVPJC

qw&qotc no na ro qIC occouq oroc wnpuowioj Joif cdnvpozz

rncowca pnr bI.c2muoplA qo UO cpoicc oponqojq ThC pcA

Page 23: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

5'

bonu aowcpmc 4p.cIjcLnvc21cnUb 'U pc Acx. ponacpoqa pnA put tpcu icuq to vjj .oxn pia pzgp-

HflL cuqcapou uq cpcx. (j )2po ipt Offl2 !Aoqccq pA

cnJuu.VJA to tpc pqcx. cqncscç

pciu8 amc bw V20 1.02C bCqJVba ipa aSTc242 4PUT qIAOLOG 12 IIJOLc

ia wrxcq' w jj' r1 nhIwJp&ion2: ua cqnctou w2c' wc bwpvpipA o

wc ccc ocqncou ou pc blopVpipfA opcVqm ancp onacpoq

Hop0jqa qcq pA pi°i c wox pjccjA to pc iujc bm.cn ponacpojq iii

mcowc uc pc bLoptp!I!tA ot .po° to pc amRjc baLcu ponacpoq tiw

VcbVLstcq wO4pcx. (Voc ouou cox) j.jot buuA' 03'U j' oncp cpqqLczJ hCLG pLCC pWCV 02 pjccjA to PIAC V qi,oLccq ox.

pwca wox.c pjccjA o VAC V qmox.ccq ox. acbox.stcq moqcx. 40U V UCACL-!iC

i.coon OL w ' i" i 2O cpIJqLcu o vuc bocuia ,cx.c jj

coopcq 142 bcojc pqtcw 4pC oc o onq iu i o oiq I O Jpc

jpc bwpvpijA OtCW V poncojq pcvqcq pA v amjc box.cu

McLc J022 JT1CCJA to PC W0UJC2 !#.W CpjqLw

CpqLcIJ LCIV4!AC tO wVuxCqa hI4p0fI4 cpiqcu ID J ponacpojqa pcuqcq pA

poncpojqa pctqcq pA pjucp *cLC uo wox.c ox. ,caa jqccjA to PC 'UVuicqa !p

jpcmbvctox.acccpucqpciiccu jvuq jtjrn jgo'

CVIncL2 o ouc oIJcx. cpjqx.cu cUCL qic b!cfnLc',

cpqJc22: tP! pjcqA Lcucct2 IIJBt c4 4pv4 ponacpoq ojcu qwb ow pvAn1

anthuam ! Wc osltcowc pw ppcx. nicawc conbica ac wox.c mcciX o x.cwiu

Page 24: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

:5:5

qcWOL9bpTC CVUG2 VJOUC 2b 1CVflA fAG CVJCflJVjC gcq b 11U1c2 OL

MCICVAC TUcOWC COUUUr V 112 J8OICAC! 20MG CVU qCCZ.WWC qic IUJbVC4 o

q12IipflI10UOWC cOiiui)o CJTUUC 22 U UJtVC qiq pqccu J(J vuq IO

qiV fJJC Ø 0ocC!cIu2 LcIuVlucq COU24VU pn VfiOMIU qiC qcwO&.abpC

MC 921C 0M qic COWbOVWOU OJJOI12CJOJq Abc2 MOflJq cpm3c vrimiu

tAG fl2C qiG2C cocnjcicu o bcqoim qic ojJo!ni bopcA cxbcuuicuw

poncpojqw

pJCC1A 40 pc cpijqca ujca IJVPAC 40 pciu Cp11q1C22 wVtUcq2 qiVu oqJcz.

bqiiA1n a) poqi Ac poncpojq pcqcq pA pjcp uic woi

2iIiJC U2GV nq qicu tVll2 !IJ4jJ cqnCVIiOuwI VU2TUWGiJ4 Ui I 1J 4JJC bicqzccq

i j) uuq cqncpou (in j qic bLcqccq bwppqiA opcu V CJC22

bLcqC V JO/Aci. bwpvpqiA opcw 2iUC Iu wuq V 1GL bLopwpA UI

LCUIVIU CJJ(flC22 PA V20 2CC 2Jfl1J2 IU qic IWbVC4 omcowc (ppcL iucowc

2flG22 VU Iib!AVIq 21IJ In 4J1C bCICCIUV8C OWVLUC cOnbIcV fAO CpOO2C 40

21UjG2 IJvAc ro qic UflWCL ocpijqca W2WG2 Cfl flU4i uRc Q

wøwcq ipo Lcmøiucq cpjqc on qic olpci. puq qic UflWpci. O

LGiUtflJ1U OL pccowiu 21UC LO2C 1!Jqi VC W0IG LVbIcflA Lpau qic UIIWpcL o

CpTJqjGV2 LOVC SUU1 dC -44 VIJL /tJJ!CP II Cfl j2 Vfl2L2 ipv ipc unwpci.

qJC bi.oppquA Opcu 2WJC LCJV4IAC 40 jJIC bwpupqiA opcJu wvuicq

CJLGU LCJVAC 40 IJJC bwpVpqIA opciu urnuicq NJJOflf cJnJqLcIr Ii I ROa

WqiO2C ac C0GCIGUI2 qIV bLcqiC4cq gpc bwppqiA opcu uc iuqion

JJiC prc2 qJVU8C ID jOI4 coccicup pc4 I o vuq i o'

Page 25: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

di wod bnil bna .0221 bna 0821 E1h di ioI 1qmsE luo in bloibwod ifoa

0821 nwi3d baad3 qi bloibwod zba oi 3nzno13d1o iiitidadmq 533VB

.0221 bna

b bna inaiano3 odnioaiaib oidqoinb 08Q I blod w bnoo2

wod an IbI 111w aldT .th13iooo 0221 bna 0821 31b no baad aw1v boflft

.noi3iaoqmo3 blosbauod ni anad3 bbfla 3vsd 8t113flflh13"

onoqdUsdJon 1o noibrft lauj al tX qi blothauoiflo nwomod ia taili thloibeuod Lsioi

3il133q2 3qi blothauod dI d boi1qli1xm x oi noI3d ladi thIodauoiI sift

ngia iai qiziainwo 3di th gn1d3 bibiq i1i ainiT .o 3ial qidnwo

aa nflhw 3d na aqt blod3auodlo noiiiaoqmoo 31w enad3 moft

() ?oc=O6

aiaa3 8thblod nodW .33a-I qhfrinwo llal3vo di ain3a3lq3i 0 ia1 31 dw inw nao w a qal3om3b th8nad3 baa tnaianoo

(8) 8QIO8QLX

anoinift 3oiod3 3di imaiqi au d boiqrxedua ax llama 3d! woI4

kz3e31q5! aia d btqnadua aX gia1 x qt blod3auoif 113*3 iol baJamiIa3

sift ban 082 I in i blod3auod lk)n&lo a3d 13j31nB113 othqal3om3b 3111

Page 26: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

S4

ipcoc iThca m jg 21 bc.cwr go bci.ccui g bci.ccn uuq .

fllcpowcoMnci2pIb L02 pe-cq on bfl coJcnJvIiou o& ocp o

bcLccu rncic in pc wiwpci. o aiu2co iYJqJolu cpiqtcw

bciuLcqncpon in CUinLO1UjC pcp1qLc1? ouq nqi.owoIc Ioi

bcLccIJ wqnciou in nnwpcL opnowcq ,izpocr1 cJnJqLcn' v anLbuw2

o bcuciu Lcqnciozi in c unwpci. owouicq ,p cpiqiif

qcwo&vbpc cpoi.occu2nc2 icwoiucq couu pc cpou2in2 cocwcrcuio onq

jpc imboc ocpou2m jvc i cicu woi onpjoujio: poq

w2jca liupon cpiJqzn

wiwpa. oowgjc ,*up cjnjqiir uq o bcLccur mcic ni ipc UnwpcL O

wc UIWJpcL pcvqcq pA mouicqo ipont cpTJqtcu o JO ba.0w4 wctcooc m c

poncpoq pcoqcq pA wouicq conbjco !#JqJ cpqqLcu ojo bcwcu cqncpou rn

pcjmccu pcu vuq j onjq nqncc v bcLccu4 cqncpou in iiiwipcL o

conb1co: obccIUcvllA' wc i o woqc bi.cqic pv qwo2L0bpIc cpou2a

coumi bLoqlcf v qcciuc in pc bczecuMc o nocpoq pcvqcq pA umiucq

in jpc nvpouo qcziioibpic cp uarn poqw uoco

cthLc2iow

pouq aIqc r nom i? pccnnc !AC V1.c fl2IU2 c aubjco in pap bo oupc

asrpacubcqniqi jj coniac jic oowbjc

COGUC!c3U2' 1( P°W I P igo 2flp2cUb auq i i.oi owvjj x pc

in io ouq j LcbccpAcJA jo wcosu ccc ocpmi2iu

CPLBC1U0lC2 ocvcppOn2cpOJqy lu miqu9UqWLcJaG2cUf fC

Page 27: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

3ia-i qidainwomod Jnai2noo a bniaitham blothauod &aM .vi)oqi lo oiodo m anazi3 booubth qri3ocn3b 022 I bna 0821 nowd

.0 1o Iai qidainwoemod iiIJ in thIob a thaIqx bluow noIa I blothwod

1o noibub5x a thakpc bluow a3qI blotheuod iol 1Ea3 m enadZ inoiq

nao qi blotheuodlo noiiieoqmoo rIi in nad3 adi zd)oT Jnoriq

ifroq 8J1o ia-x qidznwo3mod ,dflo noii3ubI a thaIqx

otoW '(Is %O%3 YUISTO tso'tA NX

qi blothanoillo oiod3Io aizxathuntb iiIahOqmi 3fflOE bLwo!t 8nivaH

3thIin3bb cp iba thdiiw aiithiQa1ado bloibauod wod bnft oi boon woit w

w iod aJdiath Iailun au 3vi fIBO anoiiaIzrdal-aao13 mo2 .ozodo wn inIo iJdanoeai moa llaoaioq2 .IIarmo1 tom EqidanoiaI5I I3bom

:njgnax, w ndw Einflaq

5UJIXt flO Wi3JE 1a1X0dB31Jb310 i33fi dT .auiaia Ianoiiaouba .1

1aubag Iocda iI8id-non a iuoda d8uo-idT .a ilhiw uazb 3iod3

ivwod aa iiaI iA nnwomoñ d o iDo imdi jAiI a1 ial ia aba3lf

thad bal3 1oothe d3id-non vjniiLu biia illarn ai IaiinThb 3di

lf3idw Q ,iu8ft a) quo i&o nad ai11wo3mo1i d oi ibAll xom Ifauioa

uibifw al noitawp Itwtan A .(aIquoo ,iidw bornam ioi ioiiskrdal ead

inood noitaoubo aliiil dliw 1qooq ii,v laill bit dJto i1ua 3iD ai In3flaq

hit iIlo fluai 3dt al Ii idbdw io 13b1o b di as bothsilanoo iibiupil sa,1

.oa aia Ot boulav yId8id om 1viiabi w aihow lliAa-wol ladi

Page 28: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

ii aLo1d noin 3iai qüfri3nwo3mod OV a IuinU .33a$I . iol anodBIudat EJII1 113L11W O I u,3ft ) thfw naifi l3wol vfiaiina3adm

31i01 A .(Iquoo bonisni inubE1 1oodo 113111 d b3banlf a Ian! thlotheuoñ

aid! ladi ieua bluow (aiaIana bna w31v3i a iol (8I)iniY a) 31IJ33133J1

bluoo moo3uo 3d! iw3wod ;aoiianimnaib 3thauodlo ttua3I 3113 haq 3glaI Ifl ai

.alaithib 3laaflo IIua 311! 3d oela

znflaq Jonilaib 13iuIoeda on I3ththcpUa aqa1h3 .al3ffma £

3110 nadl bAi1 ea1 io om ia thIoll3wod inia owl 13111311w 03 an einnqqa

owl 3flUO abbL inodliw aaodl io'I .al3nwo3mod 3d 03 ablodnauod IflB3

a) aIquoo imn no nadi 21311W0 3d 03 IAil 31011! 313w a3Iquoo 131iB3

(II -wjt

nainbooD 10 aa3bi 3113 a3ialO(fIOOW IgiaI !3bOIn 3310113 31un33 311T

Is eIoo1 ii lad! ai noiionliaib all ;(QVI) 3thulid3 bns flodaithn3H bns (88QI)

iatha3a 3lngitim oT .3310110 5W1133 all aInm blotheuodlo 3qi i1a wod

3pl blod3auod no b3noiiibnoo 3w11 ana bhjow lad! anid 1W1!33L31 IBiiII3tOq

lobom 31301 Iánothulum a alafnhia3 I iioI 33iodo 3iuno! 3113 3rnImoh3q 31o13d

31131131 fr31bIu13 113kw a3IqiJoo bornam 3nmwo3mod :aoq3 bIod3euod 3zLx3 iol

n31b11d3 !uoiftzw a3Iquoo b3rnaw 3thuiwo3fflod n31b11Lki 1131w a1quoo bthnam

nooabna

a3bLslingam tn3ioffl303 3iaqmoo iwtn 3W a3nai3ffl3o3 3113 331qIalth oT

ba3di aA .anoiiaup3 3n13n31 bits mnwo 3113 io'I 3q3 bloifoauotl 11353 iol

baif bloibauodlo a 3nh3bianoo d w3aialil iasq awollol I3bom adi boion

Page 29: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

11UJpOL 0( QVWQU MQLQ QUQLIflA IM

powQoMuol2plb w wi 1xq) m QVLpQZ. Aau!ouv' qio 0OQUJCGU48 oUbLopjGmv' v pcvnvo jtni.a 8fl ipt qo,i cJI nvv P011vu Qxb%vuvoIA vuvpjv jjm pwa pu ql.obbQq pocvno 01. cqo.uQ14A

v" OVLJIQL I4QLVpOU o pt bvbi. vjvo coxiuqcq unmpt 01. GVLUGU V2

VC ? miq bVLIIVJJA pA 4JIC uc0q2 o1.bcob1c 40 IflOAC nuo vn1Vcq piiue wuu

PC bVI4IVJJA cxbjumcq pA qic ctbij uw2 cxcwbgou ou powc oq

powcofwc1p1b z.vc qccjwca aIJcz. vc w opcLa' vjcz. c jpia conq

0114 1VUVJC LthLC2C1Jc pcVq2 OACL dC VOWC 14V1JCC2 4C

vuq Q:v 1c8q2 uc pcA VLC woLC jqccjA o pccowc powco!#uc1z JpC JcIJ-

pcq vuq pcppooq o1.pciu V pOUJCOMJICL JU 811 1.fU. CVC C4MCC11 4J1C VeCV 01.

uiqA' MC uq v ccnjm LcJVpou2plb pqccu vRc oponcpojq

0WC0MIJG12 4J1811 4OMCL W00WC ponapoq

poncpoq 4Thc2 iuibA 4V4 )J1J1CL WCOWC ponVCp0Jq VLC WOLC icctA £0 PC

4PC JqCCjIpOOq 01. pCW V LCU4cL' 80 4C UC&BPAC V1U8 OIl UICOWC 1.OL 811 t0flL

jpc injj mncp cxbcc4cq (8cc 4vpJc jpc woqcj bLcqc

CJJOIOC CC12I0U 18 vccicq pA b11LCJA uvuc1V! cou1qcLvpou

VbbLobLIw4c LV4TO 40 CCII pOfl8CJlOjq JJJ18 L0410 pCJbe cxbjøw 7OM c

40 CVjCflJV4C V 2CIJdCC 002440 LCIII LV4O 1.01. CVCP 24V4C Vuq bbjA w

84v4c-pA-2424C C8J0flJ9410U2 01.124-41WC JJOWcPIIAcL IIVcL 0024 vuq wcquu &O22

cqtlCV4OU I1 01. ponacpoq pcuq 40 cxbjwu pon8CJIoq fAbC jc vjo 112C 0111.

poncpoq moowc' 1.2CC oponcpojq pcq ecuqcL oponcpoq pceq vuq

Page 30: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

52

VI IK( mcjnqoq ID flJQ q1v ntGq W 1jJ b,bot

H qipuc tom ttonb pouJo J!A!D boobc AJIJ ID L0t3I) JKMDC

&cqrclcq btoppquA 1P ouc iiz pnA powc jp jcAcqpcjc' gpc

wucc v o,wct-occnbwcA pccowc jcn w.Bc1iAc 1U U1U

dnupi,cjA aiwqw. cw oncpojq jThc2 MC MOflJ pobc in v

jJiC JIJJbUCI O{}1C L4iO i dn icjA nq

04CZZ

0fl2G0J2 pcvqcq pA nou-pi2p cpooj tqnaica ui.c wotc pjcqA 1° i.cu jmu

f8U wAouc cpc u jic opct puuq ot ziu2jc pop ip uq upon cpjqtcu

pcqcq pA bcobjc ''wbo-øqncqc&cca .c! rncciA10 PC poco/Ucz

bo-vv 2cJiooJ °v° NotcoAct' up!n poncpojq Thc' P0TCP0!C12

woi.c qccjA 1° PC pOWcOMUCta 4I3U pO112Cp0q2 pcqcq pA bCObJC p owc

w L'IPLbcIAct2c L2flJ 4pv ponacpoq pcqq pA p2P 2CVOOI 8tøqnvtca

cunLc' CXCCbj TU tCM W29UcC2 Lot W8UJC CO1bICJ uponr OJJJqII? fAG

qncviou sbbcaL2 U01 10 PCt btpcnqA iuiboi.w oponzu2 pmi mpc2)

'cp poi pJvcp i.c wotc jdmquA couatmucq .ow bmepm

/AP!1G2 (c A!IJL (j )OL VPO -- E°iIUUq bcii

LcbcjGq uqu2 48 J0JC2 Wfl21 2bcuq WOLG 0(. cowbm.vpjc ponu2 jpn

0/AU OUJC2 4pU 011CJOIC12 P P JP!1G iJJ!2 '" PC U 1.C20J1 o4pc oucu

Hocp01c1 PicI pA pivcic utc mniijA t ,cn cciA 1° 0/AU 4CIL

pOfl2UJ&1,,

Page 31: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

bLcqIc4 v bcLcaJ4 rnci.G22G m pc oiiucz.pb L2IC VWOZJ W8IiiG2 /JqJ

yuq 20 Tj M22: poqiu qGWO&UbJIIC2 COIJ49U4 CJ39UUJg 422402 Monjq

powcoMmu conjq cxbjwn 2U24 Lv4pc. f2U qccuu powco!iucL2pb L24C

BCPAUG22 O OMUOL OcCIIbIGq Ofl2IU OIJJA 2 2pIJIb Cp2URC ID 422402

cowboazpou oponcpojq cv4cgouc pou ouc vqq ipc MOL2CU1U uucivj

MJ4flJ 4P JJofl2Gpoq CV4GOU02 M22 U04 GUOfl8J 40 OC4 C CJ2U&C ID 4)JG

cjPt pc qcmobpicvjj? wqaccq rncLcc rn powco,wcpib

W2UIQq Ij241AG 40 4G UfimpOL Ou1On2cpOq2 MXflI V A0LCG buç

Lcccpu 4J70 zuci.c2c iu jpc umxpcL oponcpoq ip v b2Icu4 Npo UGAGI.

qccpuc lu jpc VG o4pc tAGLVc JICVq o4pc axujc bm.0u4 poncpoq) qonpc

pon COJ2CB pAanJjcb2Lcu42pc4tAcw JôgOUq J0Mfl3408

bzcqicp po/Acicz. v qccpuc lu pc powcotwcupth 1.240 o()g bcLccu4 gujoug

MUPOfl4 CpqqLcJr uq LGLOGD4 o&ziuc ,iqioa4 cpjqr jpc

powcomu ponjq VAC ! ro cobi po4p Mliii q

2AC jcq 40 Vii IUCLCO2C U ff IC POWCO!iMJCL2p!b iijc jpc woqc bLccpc42 ff124

hurJiOn4 cpqqiu -- pcwoqcj &cqlc42 IpvL cpouca iu qcwo&sbpIcV oponjq

poncpoq (Thc2 -- wuuJcq conbjcz /A14p ouq ,ponr ClLCU 22 22

nVcq ffJOZIJ 40 g04 gcq jcIIULG CjJ0IG bWPVP!1!PG2 j0L J vuq IO E 4P'

(vRc i.occ cqncopou' ouq 8cuqcL oponcpoq pcq OL j ouq j o) auq

011G 22IU MG JO0CG 24 ffJC qI24UpfIIIOU 0cW0&VbC AVUVj02

couqcucc

coccicup OD 41C20 401113201.0 OIJCUU0( 3i1Jq1CVUj 24 if10 O 1)CCU I'I O4

Page 32: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

PC 2!I1G2 M!IP CPWP.cU !" J aao' pOtp pCCVWc qiC qlAo&cc LOIC LCUJVIUC V

cAcOjpwe cac pOfInGJJOJq pccowc wotc qimi 10 bci.ccudc bow woc pjccjA

ii L° ponncpojq Thco cpoucq woi.c qLowvpcVjJA: couLojpu 4L

wotucq' Q12 oouupnicq jo o qccjwc in qic vS&cuc oiwcpb LUC

ia wcipjA 40 bciecunSc born jc qicu qic oiawcx.opth i.vic unionS

O/AuLq ponqiojq pcnqcq pA oiuSjcw ]3GCi2C ipc oIucL2p1b izc unionS

pwnSju uponr V woqcu apuj p.ow poncpoq pcvqcq pA wuuicq conbjc

c) Cojnuiu (j) opoi pu cpuuSwS wOSLVbpic qmniS qic i

IU VJJ CVC2 MC pvc couji.ojjcq OL ccouonnc ucot (rca wcowc uuq fl2CL-

qiCuc 2Cb0LSC CJIVUSCV VLC VIUIIUJVUSCq in COJIUUU (I) qaonSji () 1p1 4

cpuuSc2 in JJowcoMUluS Miqilu poncpojq Thca jpc iwbvcia o

Iuqflocq CJiuuSCu in qic qcwunq L°' powcoMumS MiffIni poincpojq Thc uuq

poncjioq Thca' cpvuScV in qic oi. ponacpojq Thco qcwo&ubpicnqA

jpc 4V2 pcccu loso uuq Ioao: qcwoSLObpTcuJjA iuqnccq cpVuSCu In

JIVJC rnAcVrISucq 'oin. iuijncucc on gpc powcoIiwcLOpth LUIC !"

N

bcwcuç

JJJC bLcqic4cq LV4C LOL vuScn iAiqi cpjqicu OMCAGL LCIJ pA ic

uuq V JVLSC bcwcur wcicuc in qic Lutc unionS arnSjcu ,igpon cpqqiw

CpJqLcir V t)4 bcLccIr wci.cvac in qic i.uc unionS wuu.icquponr cpqLCn'

Page 33: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

!A9TU j0UCL pqpc pnAm' qicA aic pccounu woic pjccjA io pnA a aowc

conbjca qccpucq pcccu j gj auq tj pJnc wauicq conbjca waA pc

40 UJCLCB2C' qcabilc qic ac qi24 lpc o!wcz2p!b L24 C awou Aonu wauicq

c gpo acc qi24 amouR wauicq conb1ca' vaca oi. oinmuR couiwncq

oijpc nc 2uR U1,Wpc12 O2nCP ponacpoq jcaqcq pA ,ucc-mauicq.

ponacpoqa pcvqcq pA ouc awRc Jpc auci 12 aRmu alIuoal ccz.ia!uJA a ijwcou

(i) Lcn anRRcat noi vonacvoI iAonjq pvc WOLG avxuRa pau

4ORGqICL MIqIon4 a WWLU2RC jICGlJcC) HI? HcIlclcLapOIt auq PAuCPIGL,2

wcLcvac in qic unnipci. ouou-1LvqIpouaj,. Jonacpoq2 (rc' conbjca pimR

jcnpjccjA o cpooac o/wcI2p1b jpc j9UDCL /A22 bcqlaba a puciou o an

40 qooac o,uciap!b qnuuR qJc i goa' /Apijc amRjca iiqJ cpIJqLcu pccawc

cojnmn (i)' ,picp apo/2 Ipal vuRjca ipon cpiqtcu pccamc 2L moi

qcmoRLabpc2 /AonJq &ccpc a qccuc jpc nnbac ouvaca mc anwmauscq in

ucAcL-usvuicq ponacpoq pcaqa MUPIU (p12 cacRoiA cxbjama H4IA

4Abca cxccb4 4L vnRjca !AJqi cp!qLw JJIc WcLGaaWR bciccuidc oAomiR'

qcwoRLsbpca &cqc4cq an mccsac u qic ottDcz2p1b L24C OL afi ponacpojq

tOL pOWcOJWUJR zcuqcq 40 pooa qic o,cLajj I.24c coirmm () apoia Ipat

JT4pn ponacpojq 4Thc' /AG uq 424 cpuuRca in qcwo&abpica auq

qccpuc in qic bci.ccu4,Rc oo/AucL-occnbicq ponacpojqa

z.alc: cpauRca ! 0L ponacpojq 4Thca &cqIcl a bo!ut

JucLcvacq (colnuJu 0 jvpJc 4) jpra paq a bi.oonuq 1wb2c4 on qic ofAucx.ap!b

p8p JGAGJ auq pccanac qic uxmipci. oLuc1ci-wgwcq baLcu4a ,IJqi cpjqcu

Page 34: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

.avil ü3dJ ni tthoq

3W oilduq 08Q I sIi mo-ft 3q'I blod3wod ibalo a3riada xI w 101 bnnmb 3di in anado1o ioaqrni 3B1V b3idw 3d o 3Iqcna-o-z3im

ift1o toaqini llaivo 3di tadi bnft 3W .a3qI bloibwod nidiiw nmwo

.OQQ I baa 0821 n3owtod inoiq I I tai qidainwo 3dt qir bodauq aaad3

3dt q1 blod3Wod ni anaib btoibnxq ,dflo atoaqmi 3di dtiw b3nidmOD

aa 0221 baa 0821 nowtod tai qidanwo3mod 3dt th naif3 b3toib3xq

inool3q 0- ai aai ban Widqal3ofn3b in enndo iIun

a3on3ziIIth iuol 3dflo atoaqini 3viio3lloo 3di nv,tod 3onoiflib 311T

ot batudnfla 3d 'earn atni qidal3nwo 3di ax nndo lauioa sift baa ,voda

tn3orI3q £.0 lCd bathloth toil ax 3ia1 qidaiaiw,o 3111 oauaoo€I .enndo OfflOflOO3

now13d 3tai qidrxiniwo 3111 no tonqi ton on bad aoimonoo3 mdl ilth 11181w 3w

.0221 baa 0821

3ninwo3inod ax m3voiqini an a3bid iLthaho teomla 3fnooMJo elilT

3111 iii atnthoffl300 8nx8nnIio 3111 batoiqiatiii 3v311 w 1nioq nidI oT .anoiiibnoo

8niSnndolo noiio3fl,1 a en aqt blodoanod nidliw n1Irvo3mod ioI bnnmth

noowtod 8nibthd aaI 3mnod ainiaiianoo )ibixxpil 3Waod v3woH .a3iEai

3a13 11A .anodnwoii3dlnwo 01 3Idai1todw abloxfoauoif ,OQQI baa 0821

athdiiw thlothauod iom oa 01 tooqx3 bluow 3w n3dt jnup3 8ni5d

8ninwo3mod 101 '3tanr b3ea5loth 3111 ai iadT .ainwo3mod d ot eoodo

omaood ablod3auod baniaitanoo 1auoiviq taut toni 3111 b3ft31 1qmiE blaoo

h3thsano3nu

Page 35: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

ybL /A!rnUur DCIJ1G D!bI1C' 811q J49UC NCVL1C

HOflVIJR yU4CC42' 1O1UM 0U{012!1Jt JG2G2LCJT E0I4PCOWUJ

vpLpw 1 'J1 1P' HFP°U (I) D'PPI !13 NG110h0PfU

cn'

OACLqiC 1ô202 "°t PC U 2OJILCG 0C0UCGW

poucoznxicupzb i.atc "rnt PC GXG22 020WC U411LØLA UW0flU' qic

bwpUpjA ooq LCU2oU2 o& ffJIW flojcn OUC IJCG2 ipc lUCIA 4PUt qic

cpc pciu cdiitl' puXpowc ojcu tpu urnwcq conbic Uuq 4pcx.c

LCUJUW mjc (rca butowtudc) ox. pccowc aIU8jC (rc&c UqMoLec) vu

jj jpc powconAxxcx.zpIb LU4c qccjnxcq U PIt CC9fl2C wo.c bcobjc cpoc jo

JC J0fl21U BOx.qpq1at OU212 qq hot !AOL2GD CRAG13 I vuq

LG2fl1t2

p!UqUa) OAL 4JJG cOflI2C 0qJC qcCUqc jJJ12 12 1fl). c0U2!2GIJ1 lAiqi oux. uqcx

obbol4nmpcU wr1 tAC mJbLoAcq (pdrnqA couøxu wn pvLC pccowc jc

cgccj occonounc ou qxc oinzxcx.apib 1.c !A22 cto 2flG2(2 pU

vuq J go IJ 40 JO/AGL fpC 0hWc3p1b LU4C JJJGLG01.C 4j1c UO4 4U4 4pC

WOLGOAG&' lAG JI10IA qig cx 'xnc II2CL 002t LO2G 3JTP242134!VIIX C4tACGU

Page 36: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

34

H01 NWIJIOC q COUcVPOII2 'mJq EcOUOIDTcZ (j) bb iø-i 13

G81 (is EwbiucJ xqcucc ou CLo-ILc jcmcca w

D!"° WH0b0 flqffu flqIG2 J bbj-03E0J!Wtr ivInca miq cbpw vjbc (oi) yuopa. r'oo,c v jcw

1ouurvwc J4-JQ

uuq jpc cqriccq /BJ17c oipc NO&RVC 1UcL2 DcqI1C4OU MV1OIJ1 JX

D'q riu (JJ) jpc cqc jx npvqA o onvu

BcpoL cp4q: c'p#q flmc hLc2•

DCtOIJ' VU uuq iopu NCflIIPVflGL (J EcOJCWIO2 vuq couwct

EUA H0 ywcucBu Ecouamc JcAIc!# bb

cc ii vuq jçopct pijcz. (j ) jpc cicucA opcqcq oi. 2rnRjc

nmAcL2aL J,Lc22

G (i I) V JL jpC EWW11A cjqc 'q:

U I)' iPC 2fi OPC J40J HOIU uwpuqc: jOWi OL

Page 37: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

HcIJqcL2pow jvuc (is) H'P°iq E0II1!0U uuq HourcoIuctapIb:

JI!OW 1°I °.H°"'J KLCP E0W00

VcCIIIIJ$1IPOU iq HOnU CP°!° O A0t1I HO jq VU EI°°

}B11UI? OUjq ,VUc HWFPOU auq 2fl2U !MC1IcL (J) /CJf

mqc cbo' MA: ECOUOWCPJC 2OuM' pic

otccuc qpm (I )rwqcb Acz.aiou QO flacI2 yuunej uq gqcLcucc

opc Ec0U0U11 uq c 2i'4 JjO4C U IbGL MO Ô3

H°°"" cc ou pJqzu flWAcI2Xf) o4 cp'° cu rnqA

oJ JCLE VUq J1PCJCJJC /P! (1 t) N" iP BGUW o

HO J'!° J'1J3EJ MO(CU L MO 433

c3Lccu' jçcpøq },VLTC Hqpu (j) Dcwo.vbpIc jvco vuq jcv

E1W2 OHO1IG 1uJ OHOn2w& cooc '

oooqwu lop" 1L i°" Iwc (1 ipc Vccni.cA ouiw (y!UcLa,

3' bb35X-2

pJcOWC .L CPO!CC' wiq cInuq O1UJJ OtnI4BU E00U0Ufl02

oooqwmf vJu U88) VU COUOU3qUC OCj OHOfl2IU WC' },cImvucu;

Page 38: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

3Q

J4VIOU V22OCaTIOU OllJ'IOK2 (1 3) BIG HOUJCp1IAIJ jLU2C4IOW

H°' J,0PC Dcpc fbb 4?-ôQ

HowoIIJp!b: v Cowbou ocjcua.vpou tuq Ipc 21Gw

NG D0/dfl' BICpLq JGI2GL' z.coi) 2C17MS13U' q iojwj,ujq(1o3)

Eccuowcpicv4bfr IJ-3

YuL' CPW (1 ô.XXY BI EIIOU 2fV110 ,LOpvpIJIA }oqcJa

C0IUU2 OU HOUJGOMAJJGI2P!b' vicnciv iaunr i.

b q 2" !ic1U (1 BIG mbc oouiu

C!L1 1.°' O-OI HOI12!1J VKBIIEV UJ1. 10' -3

HcuqGJ2pou' J,VIC uq jpc flGL coat o

j'bb io-ni

CP0!cC' iô?-i,1ô

HPPOU' J,V4LC mq viiwi (jg) BIG ECUOfl OUGDULG

E!' ,' bb 301 334

1P42 ociojoicj' vuq ECOIJOUJ!C ECU pivit

Page 39: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

onui j'bbNO14C O1IJICtIIOU JçCdflJCUJGU42 C°"!" H00!I2P!k vInEv

sour bcc1. (jg) }opIJIA-jcIJnt Dcciaiou qE!I1C!9Icq'c Do

ynqz: cw mjic yc vwcucu cououc g8I

AWL 10PU (I 8Q) Ynuu 1I DCIIDIUOU '1lP Es"- HOn!IJ

j7Q 1opu HObI

ID I2CO/27cT 21P!W CTOJU J21J2 ID fl4)J

Aw opu (iaY wcnqcc tq Tu w fl.pu onm

coouqoLcøqccbb i' I?-IABUoLqGL' jopcz IJq VUIJC 2CJJIJØLG (I4) EWqW coIDlIloli c3wnuç

Oi4 2'H-lIE

fl2 91W11 OJIC (I HOnIU McIc wq HOWcOI2*

CH2-I-F Dc: n B' O4)IC

flBnt1I O3JCC' (I I). I O HOO w&ppqJp: flUIq B4ca

pmoIr DC

cRwvif icpcj (It) 2bcccp LO 'JPflJV yiq-Acyjccma

Page 40: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

J4o4c: opc&vzozrn vzc pc ?0 ac uqtq cuou ru b,1cu4pc8c2

B3 01 0.1 0J 0Q 0Q 0Q.

BCU4

flC.CO2UO(oo3)-0J0

(oo3)-010

(oo3)-010

(oo)-034

(oo)-0?

(ooi)1134

4II(O1CIi0tIB14CC

(381)000

(ooo.)-00Th

(oo?)-003

(oo14)0033

picowch 1° (o)

1130(oo.)-O1X

(043)0Q3

(013)034

pcowcBCLCVb!4V

(ooo't)-000?

(cyoot)-000?

(croot)-000?

(0003)-000!

(oooa)11000

(ooo3)0000

Ofl2CO2ConbicUcq•\ O

(3d)03 (o)

0ó3(oj)0Q (o)F33

(o)F38 (o)V40

cvqa•\U0B1CIC

(cr10)-014

(oo)-014

(oo)011

(oo.)030

(ooQ)01

(cr02)018

2?H°'q'°Iq•\'O

(on)-03

(o3.)1132

(o3)1133 (o)-000 (o)003 (o)00.

H'q'<3?oncpoq•\IO

(048)-0?5

o4?)0?!

(ode)-04?

(o'i)03a

(osn)03

(on)05

Iuicz.ccbi(oe)0?3

(oi)0?3

(o)04?

(oe)004

(cr3?)1100

(oe)-1103

Th80 10Jçc&csuou tot ccun jcat

iwb1c H0W01Pth JV4c EdfItl0U"plc!

Page 41: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

wc: y wbic ttIlJqilq cucaw btipcscr

1Q34 3045Q1 4340

(.13)-1Q

(3).1

(ia)1QQ

(13)-FOS ()-104

(11)1

(11)-o

(so)44

(.13)111

(ic)1.18

(ri)-14ô

(oz)48

(13)-t

(ig)5o

(11) (18)-'og

(3't)-ii

(og)s

(o)-31

(1.1)-Q3

(io)44

(1)-33.1 ()-53O

(o.1)Q0

(14)14

(ii)•Q

Ct)43 14

••3Ci)•Q

Cio)

(oo)03

Coos)34

CooQ)-13.1

(oo)-111

Coi)IQ.1

Coot)011

()331 ()118Cr)•3 ()Q3

C)QQ

(10)103

(•j)-11 ()33

(•j)F4.1 40 ()13

(.13)-143

Cis4 F8 ()The

Cis)3Th (is

34C'sz)411

Cn)-131

(is)3 3•Q (•)Q•

(•i)3•J

C3)3•

Csi)•Q3

(.13).4J

(i.i)30 301 ()41.1

(is)3•Q.1

(n)(Q3 •35

(ia)••33

(ia)3 ()3•43

(ie)318

(.31)4Q4

(as)433

(ii)-OQ

(ie)113 ()333

(ie)1.13

(io)343 ()33.1

(•j)•38

M1P1uzcq

jq'p51U8C 2!U8lC MO IpVWC

pqqqpVU8C

cpqqVUSIC MO

180 1b0

oI c&.uvcus L°'MW(8 D'

cpoo oHorIlqqLThc: nuounwo&g lfc&cntcu,£P1C 3

Page 42: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

40

osc: ,,Aud*oiic iiuqiiq cU.OU ! bILPcI!1 IUq U - 1Q34

so B"fl'1 ())-O3

(os)-004

(.o)-03 (.)•01 (•)••04

Co)•03

Co3)-03

wqcoc8c ()roe

Csà)3Q (.)•Q

(•'sj)eà (.)i*r (.)rài (.)3b,1

conc&ycuq

(1,i)80

(31).

(Li) (3)Li

(3)F31

Cso)113

C)334

wq112

Ci's)88

Cig)•Li

C12).33

(3*)-13

(3)1'33

(i.i)Qb

Cm)F81

(LtMOUH2

(.13).bQ

Cii)33

(12)3b

(•)-b4 (.).31

Cie)QQ

Cii)1.33

HD1'(31)-Q8 ()30

(3i)-21

(31).38 ()•03

Cia)33

(3i)44

i"°°wsq

Cooi)•

(oo)•

Coos)-01

Coi)-3Q

Coot)Li

Coi)-11

Coi)-13

iU 1112y8e&cQ3

Cm).41

(33)-30.i

(.34)FbO

Cii)Fb2

C3a)FOl

(33)1.33 (•)F0,1

IUQ3yQ33

(3's) Cm)33

(3i)•2,1

C's3)fQQ

(.33)313

(38)311

(31)FbI

33V€842

(3g).31

('fl)332

(.30)3.30

C's)Q80

(e)'s•43

(3)3aI

(3!)3.38

'1 114233

(.30)4Q

C3's)343

(.30)330

C's).121

(3e)442 ()304

(•)30.1

11 33Y3O

(.38).i3

(31)3bX

(21)33Q

(•'so)280

(3's)30I

(3a)3,13

(30)121

IUqJl3Oy8C8C33

(33)b8

(3.1)313

(3)FOl

(3e)432

(31)134

(34)3•3Q

(3)031

y€CJ533(3)FQ3

(•)F08

(3's)-34

(•)311

Cii)83

(33)FQb

(38)F12

oa'uq)30Iitucq

gcu*iTqy(,u4.q

ytzQnjq ci*QIfl

2!U8lCQJJq2!U81C

OM1qq1408w81c

1pqq1402!U*$

(rcv-o'u C'so Y*I' 140jq cymct).L1IC cPOIcG IUqHOIlPI1 PI°3P 1a80 CtTt 1(W12

iPtc

Page 43: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

41

c: ,i?uibto(ic stIuqEq cucu iu bsipcci uq u -

soiccul°°

Coool)0003

(000?)-000?

C0004)-0O0

(000?)001

(000Q)-000Q

C000?)0000

Coooi)-0003

&sqCoucSc

C31).15

C3.l)-3

C)-13C4o)48

C3.l)43 (i).13

C)53

cofldc'VUCU

CLI)130

(3.1)-88

(.i4)-8ô ()-43

(41)-8?

(is)ru

Cii)FQ.1

orzqH2

CuQ)F4?

C3o)113

(3.1)tO

Cn).i0

C'tQ)18

Cii)110

Ci.i)F80

o"qI4°'H2

Cu)tut

C3u)-114

(o)-11

C)-3

C?3)-33?

Cu?)114

(1?)!?I

cvqflicç ()1.1

Ci)•g

(i3)•Q

Ci*)g

(8)•fl

C31)11? ()?8

ucowc Coos)0Q

Cot)5

Cot)-0.1

Co3)14

Coo3)-14

Coi)0?

Cot)0.1

It.1?ytcScQ?

(si)38

(xi).14

(3)-08

(roe)F.i.1

Cs)F0

(3?)U (i)Q5

If Q?ySc&c?? .i)O?

Cm)Fit C)330

Cu)-t5 ()303

C38)-rut

(31)-131

U??ySs Sc 4?

(io)8J (83ô1 C)

4Q4 (i)380 ()481C31)-F??

Cio)-ilu

"qi4yScSc3?Cix)-131

Cn)43à

C?1)??8

C??)4?4

Cz.1)?31

Cix)-18

(is)ti

''qIf3?ytcSc3O

Cix)-114 ()404

Cix)4?

C?u)4u4

Czo)433

Cis-1?

Cis33.1

'U3OyScSci?

(iQ31Q

C4?)318

Cii)338

Ci.1)308

(.1.1)3?O

Ci?)-.1Q (-30

YSCIf 3?Cii)-3

C43)311

Cii)130

Cia)flO

C.it)133

Cii)-74

C31)-1.ii

OMiq'

fluquiiqVuSIc

OMZpqwSc owte

3;._a'q}jOwSc

(l'cU-oni tcSoc y1ucq o pqq oMII)J.cuzn.c cpolcc iuq j)bc oq9l: uo cc bflYI 2

.L1P1C33

Page 44: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

K—O"R IU -OJ -3E +JOJ +$JJ

cc Mnqcq -O4i -3Qee +FOe +3'3e

ucctcepvwcq -I'O -3OI +1QI +O4

au1czMqJ +jQ +OJ O8J XA

acUM4pcn +O'(J -3J +3O +XJ(I) () () (1)

Dcujo&,bp!cT DCWO&tP!Ol

bLCqqCq v j)bcs.LThcS

s.o°i V I DUIUq tot cywiu

jtpfC.4

Page 45: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

29GWD V4E WA HI Ob MV JJ4 Yr WA ID bY P42 MI KI WI OK Al 2D 114 CV V NI Vt� tM IV

-042YK (U AV P41 C3Y CO (V KY lIE P411 r CE lIC IX 2C OH Cl II I1V KA P40ND PlY MA 14H

0•11-

002

4890-4880

CpsuG !U KPo ot IGu 10 IUCOWG

igpj ,j

C)-cCOCQ)U)

E002U)C

0C8Ea)

01

Page 46: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

C)

C—0)C)

C=oI1)C)

S

'•III

-3

29GHI Ob 14A Co P41 IV 14E 'WI ID MA P42 OK IV CV yr PlO 2D VIE 14C IX WA DE 14H CI bi

YK fli WDV4WMYKF&&'V ir MI OH V er iii VI 2C bY WI III KA AL AYVID 141 PlYii it iii ii i ' I iij I I I I It It I III II II I I I I I I Ii

EC)

J69O-88O

CPSUdG !U HOfl2G bUCG O IUCOWG b9P0

Page 47: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

— —

C 9IdST

iqllnllIllllullMfflullwI

r1

I

efst8

Ow 3 0 C)

-I

oits$1 emooni of atnemys ni egnsrl3 Oe9-O89F

r.o

c.o-

I I I II I II III I I III I I III III I III1 I I I

I TO UI 30 TV aa 314 IM 38 OM iA lIT 3M AD RA HO 3M Al YW ii AWLIM 014 VII >'A

Page 48: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

a)C

O28E iva) U

29GWE MA IV MI 1W HI 2C .Ll'l WD KA CO II Ob OK IIHhA V MA CI flY I4I 1W bI IV

WIlD ID 20 fli VtLWC IX bY Al V42MVV V4EOHDEIILICV Ml VW4VlOWMAE CV0 - __I_I__l LL1'

KGUO IUCOWG KS1iO

002 ill.

O2

034680

Page 49: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

=0C')

2

29G2D ME OK t IX VII MA VLL 2C VI IV CV OH I'IC MI El W VIA VIE DE VD MH WI W biI'ID ICY IV YK Vd2 III MA rIO KA ID iii MV4 bY ir VIII OL AL (U MY CO 14A AV HI CV Cl.II I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I IllIllIl, I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I

I.

4 .

J880

H0112G bUCG fO IUCOWG b9!O

jgpjs 2

Page 50: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

29G2D ME OK V MA iX MA ØC IV ID CV VII bY VIM E MA OK RI. VIE CO VID HI CV VIV KI

MDIC IV WPI2VIOIM KAWVILPW4J.MI4C ir OHALYKMIMVDE I4AAYIIH $41 Ci.•1I111II I III •iiiIIIIIII 1141111 I 111111111111.

o.J.

05

04

a-

8Ea)

o'eaao

b9XWGLU O IUCOWG IS1!0

jgpje

Page 51: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

MA VU. 1(2 VdE ME VIM LIVI iii MAW VT KA OVID IIH (U HI OH V! VII DE bI OI MI Coyk r 1'ID VI2 20 MA OK bY 2C Er iv MA VIO MC 1W Ml AL 1W AV II Cl IX MV V4D CV

0

05

i. 1ExbGceq fl2GL CO2 VCflSL fl2GL CO2

-05

2l9G

I

C-)-cCa

0)a)

C

C)

ouJ•1-i0C8Ea)

034890-4880

CpsudG IU fl2GL CO2 fO IUC0I bS!O

Page 52: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

Oo\0

Oo\0 -I0Oo\0

- ethK°

8OII

• 2!U016 'Jo CpqLGU 2!Ul° MIflJ pIqLGU

• sJsweq uo cp!jqLGu • 1'jsweq M!flJ cp!IqLj

yöe o j-eq82+

I_I__I I II

Ofl2GOI J)bGHOWGOMUGL2P!b se (4880)

JjJOOo\°

8

Page 53: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

I0E

I

IR M0U HeeL9q IJJIIM 20 WG COIIGaG C0IIG6 eLq

yae O HGSq82+

Oo\0

Oo\0

1Oo\0 —-I I[ F-

80o\°

100o\°

II I-

BA EqnCsOu9 29V12HOWGOMUGL2IJIb tse (iao)

ipJ a

Page 54: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

I0Ea)

I

'U

• BI9Ct( MP!62

yae 0 HG9O-4 2-58 30-3432-38 4O-4 42-4820-24 22-28 eO-94 e2-98 .O-4 2-.8 80-84 82+

p1 i9ceHOWGOMUGI2Ii!b ISG (ao)

pjs JO

Page 55: CwP.!q on - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · LW4O MO tJJOflfl vutmoi. tome uqvwougoj dnosgoue: ... 2 1JVIjGL 4VU joL ic woqca4JA buccq pon2c qic qoiubv1unciu LcdnuwciU 12 V wic CfUL1j IU4GI.G24

• .1 E9W6L MMJ • 5 E9WGL2 M!J• 1 ESWGL MO Kq2 S EWGL2 UO

yae O4 He9q0i4 2-8 30-34 3218 40ft 4248 20-24

Oo\0

50o\0.

22-28 eo-ect

400\0

I0E

IeOo\0

F——-

OnQUv'.

F——

.lOOo\0

ESWGL2 suq bLGGUCG O CJ!IqLGU

HOWGOMUGL2IJ!b ISfG2 (JaBo)

lgpjG JJ