Crisis Management – Case studies€¦ · Crisis Management – Case studies ... Crisis. Quality ....
Transcript of Crisis Management – Case studies€¦ · Crisis Management – Case studies ... Crisis. Quality ....
![Page 1: Crisis Management – Case studies€¦ · Crisis Management – Case studies ... Crisis. Quality . Defects . Supply. Threats. Pharmacovigilance. ... Meta- analysis identified IHD](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050918/5b8861837f8b9a770a8b4bec/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
An agency of the European Union
Crisis Management – Case studiesReinforcing patient safety in Europe 14-15 June 2011Zagreb, Croatia
Presented by: Tony HumphreysHead of Regulatory, Procedural and Scientific Committee Support
![Page 2: Crisis Management – Case studies€¦ · Crisis Management – Case studies ... Crisis. Quality . Defects . Supply. Threats. Pharmacovigilance. ... Meta- analysis identified IHD](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050918/5b8861837f8b9a770a8b4bec/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Crises Management - Case studies1
Crises
“A time of intense difficulty or danger”
Crises Management
“The process by which a business or other organisation deals with a sudden emergency situation” OED (2011)
![Page 3: Crisis Management – Case studies€¦ · Crisis Management – Case studies ... Crisis. Quality . Defects . Supply. Threats. Pharmacovigilance. ... Meta- analysis identified IHD](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050918/5b8861837f8b9a770a8b4bec/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Crises Management - Case studies2
Regulation of pharmaceuticals
Classical Crisis
Quality Defects
SupplyThreats
PharmacovigilanceS/E
![Page 4: Crisis Management – Case studies€¦ · Crisis Management – Case studies ... Crisis. Quality . Defects . Supply. Threats. Pharmacovigilance. ... Meta- analysis identified IHD](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050918/5b8861837f8b9a770a8b4bec/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Crises Management - Case studies3
Regulation of Pharmaceuticals
Atypical
Crisis
Emerging Disease Threats
Pandemic Influenza
2009 / 2010
Bioterrorism
2001 / 2002
![Page 5: Crisis Management – Case studies€¦ · Crisis Management – Case studies ... Crisis. Quality . Defects . Supply. Threats. Pharmacovigilance. ... Meta- analysis identified IHD](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050918/5b8861837f8b9a770a8b4bec/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Crises Management - Case studies4
Reaction timing
QUALITY
SUPPLY THREATS
PHARMACOVIGILANCE
![Page 6: Crisis Management – Case studies€¦ · Crisis Management – Case studies ... Crisis. Quality . Defects . Supply. Threats. Pharmacovigilance. ... Meta- analysis identified IHD](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050918/5b8861837f8b9a770a8b4bec/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Crises Management - Case studies5
I
Quality
II
Life threatening Serious risk PH
Illness / mistreatment
No significantHazard to health
defects
![Page 7: Crisis Management – Case studies€¦ · Crisis Management – Case studies ... Crisis. Quality . Defects . Supply. Threats. Pharmacovigilance. ... Meta- analysis identified IHD](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050918/5b8861837f8b9a770a8b4bec/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Crises Management - Case studies6
Quality defect Octagam
•Recent increase in
thromboembolic events
•Exact cause could not be
identified
•Suspension until problem rectified
September 2010
•Suspension lifted April 2011
•Unexpected presence of a pro-
coagulent factor XIa main cause
•Mfg process changes to remove
and control for presence
•Post-marketing safety studies
Art 107
Art 31
![Page 8: Crisis Management – Case studies€¦ · Crisis Management – Case studies ... Crisis. Quality . Defects . Supply. Threats. Pharmacovigilance. ... Meta- analysis identified IHD](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050918/5b8861837f8b9a770a8b4bec/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Crises Management - Case studies7
Presence Endotoxins
Peritoneal Dialysis Solutions
Risk Aseptic Peritonitis
Castlebar production site tested
unexpected levels
Root cause identified =
March 2011 stock resolution
Life sustaining medicines = supply critical
Communicate to HCP / patients
December 2010
Root cause not identified =
Import equivalent products
outside EU
CHMP updating December
recommendations
In depth review of the
manufacturing process of
Castlebar
January 2011
Quality Defect Dialysis solutions
Art 5(3)
Art 31
![Page 9: Crisis Management – Case studies€¦ · Crisis Management – Case studies ... Crisis. Quality . Defects . Supply. Threats. Pharmacovigilance. ... Meta- analysis identified IHD](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050918/5b8861837f8b9a770a8b4bec/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Crises Management - Case studies8
Supply shortages Cerezyme and Fabrazyme
Sept / Oct 2009
Rare inherited enzyme deficiency
Cerezyme – Gaucher disease
Fabrazyme – Fabry disease
Cause = shut down Allston Landing
(USA) due to viral contamination
affecting quality of enzyme product
Interim recommendations:
Priority for children
½ dose / frequency adults
April 2010
Genzyme reported new Mfg problem related to plant water supply
Shortages to continue to Sept 2010
Cerezyme treatment recommendations to continue
Fabrazyme treatment recommendations modified as a result of deterioration of patients receiving a reduced dose
New recommendation introduced with regard to additional monitoring of
dose patients
Examination of QA system at Genzyme
![Page 10: Crisis Management – Case studies€¦ · Crisis Management – Case studies ... Crisis. Quality . Defects . Supply. Threats. Pharmacovigilance. ... Meta- analysis identified IHD](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050918/5b8861837f8b9a770a8b4bec/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Crises Management - Case studies9
Pharmacovigilance - Avandia
Initial authorisation Rsg associated
fluid retention / risk HF
= 2nd line use
= restrict to exclude patients
HF / history of HF
= Monitoring effect
2007 – 2010: CTs / OBS studies /
Meta- analysis identified IHD risk
– further label restriction
Art 20 initiated 9 July 2010
response publications
risk AMI stroke HF death
CHMP Opinion Sept 2010 to
suspend Avandia
o No further restrictions to be
introduced which would risk.
o Benefits no longer outweigh
risks
Art 20
![Page 11: Crisis Management – Case studies€¦ · Crisis Management – Case studies ... Crisis. Quality . Defects . Supply. Threats. Pharmacovigilance. ... Meta- analysis identified IHD](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050918/5b8861837f8b9a770a8b4bec/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Crises Management - Case studies10
Pharmacovigilance - Sibutramine
DSMB – SCOUT study
Oct 2009 informed EMA association
Sibutramine CVS problems vs placebo
Nov 2009 referral started
CHMP review (incl SAG)
Most SCOUT pts CI SPC label
But obese + overweight risk CV disease
-ve B/R product + suspension
recommendation
Authorised MRP – Referral to
CHMP 1999 + 2002 concerns
Re CVS
Conduct study patients with
Cardiac risk factors – SCOUT
study
Art 107
![Page 12: Crisis Management – Case studies€¦ · Crisis Management – Case studies ... Crisis. Quality . Defects . Supply. Threats. Pharmacovigilance. ... Meta- analysis identified IHD](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050918/5b8861837f8b9a770a8b4bec/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Crises Management - Case studies11
Conclusions
Speed to react to internal and external “triggers”
Role of QP + QPPV within EU system
= ensure 24 / 7 availability with back-ups
Communication and Decision Making
within corporate structure
with Regulatory Authorities
Stakeholders – patients / HCPs 1˚
![Page 13: Crisis Management – Case studies€¦ · Crisis Management – Case studies ... Crisis. Quality . Defects . Supply. Threats. Pharmacovigilance. ... Meta- analysis identified IHD](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050918/5b8861837f8b9a770a8b4bec/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Crises Management - Case studies12
Questions