Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No....

138
Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL HERBERT CRUICKSHANKS, DAVID TULL, MARTIN HENRY GRIFFEN, ANNA KARDISH, ELSIE KOTYK, Executrix of the Estate of Harry Kotyk, deceased and ELSIE KOTYK, personally Plaintiffs and THE CANADIAN RED CROSS SOCIETY, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN RIGHT OF ONTARIO and THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF CANADA Defendants and HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE PROVINCE OF ALBERTA, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE PROVINCE OF SASKATCHEWAN, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE PROVINCE OF MANITOBA, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE PROVINCE OF NEW BRUNSWICK, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE PROVINCE OF PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE PROVINCE OF NOVA SCOTIA, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE PROVINCE OF NEWFOUNDLAND, THE GOVERNMENT OF THE NORTHWEST TERRITORIES, THE GOVERNMENT OF NUNAVUT AND THE GOVERNMENT OF THE YUKON TERRITORY Intervenors Proceeding under the Class Proceedings Act, 1992 Court File No. 98-CV-146405 BETWEEN: JAMES KREPPNER, BARRY ISSAC, NORMAN LANDRY, as Executor of the Estate of the late SERGE LANDRY, PETER FELSING, DONALD MILLIGAN, ALLAN GRUHLKE, JIM LOVE and PAULINE FOURNIER as Executrix of the estate of the late PIERRE FOURNIER Plaintiffs and

Transcript of Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No....

Page 1: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

Court File No. 98-CV-141369

ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE

BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL HERBERT CRUICKSHANKS, DAVID TULL, MARTIN HENRY GRIFFEN, ANNA KARDISH, ELSIE KOTYK, Executrix of the Estate

of Harry Kotyk, deceased and ELSIE KOTYK, personally

Plaintiffs

and

THE CANADIAN RED CROSS SOCIETY, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN RIGHT OF ONTARIO and THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF CANADA

Defendants

and

HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE PROVINCE OF ALBERTA, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE PROVINCE OF

SASKATCHEWAN, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE PROVINCE OF MANITOBA, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE

PROVINCE OF NEW BRUNSWICK, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE PROVINCE OF PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN

THE RIGHT OF THE PROVINCE OF NOVA SCOTIA, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE PROVINCE OF

NEWFOUNDLAND, THE GOVERNMENT OF THE NORTHWEST TERRITORIES, THE GOVERNMENT OF NUNAVUT AND THE GOVERNMENT OF THE YUKON

TERRITORY

Intervenors

Proceeding under the Class Proceedings Act, 1992

Court File No. 98-CV-146405

BETWEEN:

JAMES KREPPNER, BARRY ISSAC, NORMAN LANDRY, as Executor of the Estate of the late SERGE LANDRY, PETER FELSING, DONALD MILLIGAN, ALLAN

GRUHLKE, JIM LOVE and PAULINE FOURNIER as Executrix of the estate of the late PIERRE FOURNIER

Plaintiffs

and

Page 2: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

THE CANADIAN RED CROSS SOCIETY, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF CANADA

and HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN RIGHT OF ONTARIO

Defendants and

HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE PROVINCE OF ALBERTA,

HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE PROVINCE OF SASKATCHEWAN, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE

PROVINCE OF MANITOBA, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE PROVINCE OF NEW BRUNSWICK, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF

THE PROVINCE OF PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE PROVINCE OF NOVA SCOTIA, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN THE RIGHT OF THE PROVINCE OF NEWFOUNDLAND, THE GOVERNMENT OF THE NORTHWEST TERRITORIES, THE GOVERNMENT OF NUNAVUT AND

THE GOVERNMENT OF THE YUKON TERRITORY

Intervenors

Proceeding under the Class Proceedings Act, 1992

_________________________________________________________________

RESPONDING MOTION RECORD

OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF CANADA _________________________________________________________________

April 10, 2015 PAUL B. VICKERY

Senior General Counsel Solicitor for the Defendant, The Attorney General of Canada PER: WILLIAM A. KNIGHTS DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Ontario Regional Office The Exchange Tower 130 King St. West Suite 3400, Box 36 Toronto, ON, M5X 1K6 LSUC # 16888F Tel: (416) 973-8219 Fax: (416) 973-5004

Page 3: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

TO: SUTTS, STROSBERG LLP Lawyers Suite 600-251 Goyeau Street Windsor, ON N9A 6V4

HARVEY T. STROSBERG, Q.C. LSUC #12460O HEATHER RUMBLE PETERSON LSUC #24671V Tel: 519-561-6216 Fax: 519-561-6203

Lawyers Representing the Joint Committee in Ontario

AND TO: PODREBARAC BARRISTERS PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION 701 – 151 Bloor Street West Toronto, ON M5S 1S4

KATHRYN PODREBARAC LSUC #35640P Tel: 416-348-7502 Fax: 416-348-7505

Lawyers Representing the Joint Committee in Ontario

AND TO: GOWLING LAFLEUR HENDERSON LLP Lawyers 1 First Canadian Place 100 King Street West, Suite 1600 Toronto, ON M5X 1G5

JOHN E. CALLAGHAN BELINDA BAIN Tel: 416-369-6174 Fax: 416-862-7661

Fund Counsel for Ontario

AND TO: MCCARTHY TÉTRAULT LLP Lawyers Toronto Dominion Tower 66 Wellington Street West Suite 5300 Toronto, ON M5K 1E6

CAROLINE ZAYID Tel: 416-601-7768 Fax: 416-868-0673

Counsel for the Intervenors

AND TO: MINISTRY OF ATTORNEY GEENRAL FOR ONTARIO Crown Law Office – Civil Law 8th Floor, 720 Bay Street Toronto, ON M7A 2S9

LISE G. FAVREAU KRISTEN SMITH Tel: 416-325-7078/416-326-4098 Fax: 416-326-4181

Counsel for the Province of Ontario

AND TO: STOCKWOODS LLP 77 King Street West, Suite 4130 Toronto ON M5K IHI

Luisa J. Ritacca Tel: 416-593-2492 Fax: 416-593-9345

Monitor for the Court in these Actions

Page 4: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

I N D E X

TAB DOCUMENT

1. Affidavit of Peter Gorham, sworn April 8, 2015

A. Exhibit “A” - Curriculum Vitae of Peter Gorham

B. Exhibit “B” - Morneau Shepell Report as of December 31, 2013

Page 5: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 6: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 7: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 8: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 9: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 10: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 11: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 12: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 13: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 14: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 15: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 16: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 17: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 18: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 19: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 20: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 21: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 22: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 23: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 24: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL
Page 25: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

!

! ! !

!

!!

! !

!

!

!

!"#$!%&!'(%)*+%#(!,,!""#$%&'(!&)#$*$+#*,!!"##$%$&'%()*#!!

!"#$%&'("!""#$%&'()*)*+$,$)-.!"#$%&'!!"#!$#%&#'()(*+(,#-.!"!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

"#$%&#$'!(!)%#*+!,-./!

Page 26: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! !

Table of Contents

.C! "D3"E8F!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!.!

,C! FGF@DHIJF!8DKK)3L!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!,!

MC! N)@OP3EDQR!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!<!

SC! RE@DKFQH8!"3EJIRFR!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!.-!

/C! RI8F)8F!"3EP3F88IEQ!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!.,!

=C! ?F")HIHI8!@!@T)IK)QH!@E?E3H!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!,(!

UC! )88FH8!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!M(!

(C! BIQ)Q@I)T!3F8DTH8!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!S,!

<C! )Q)TL8I8!EB!8FQ8IHIJIHL!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!//!

.-C! "3EVF@HFR!@)8?!BTEW!EB!@EK"FQ8)HIEQ!NFQFBIH8!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!/U!

..C! )@HD)3I)T!)88DK"HIEQ8!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!=-!

)""FQRIG!)!X!8DKK)3L!EB!NFQFBIH8!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!(M!

)""FQRIG!N!X!8DKK)3L!EB!@T)IK)QH!R)H)!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!((!

)""FQRIG!@!X!RF8@3I"HIEQ!EB!)@HD)3I)T!KERFT!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!<,!

)""FQRIG!R!X!8DKK)3L!EB!)@HD)3I)T!)88DK"HIEQ8!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!<S!

)""FQRIG!F!X!PTE88)3L!EB!HF3K8!D8FR!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!.-(!

!

!

!

!

!

!

Page 27: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .!

#$ !"#!$%&!

.C H;*5!#$%4#1!;&5!Y$$6!%#$%&#$'!&1!1;$!#$Z2$51!49!?$&+1;!@&6&'&!&6'!1;$!R$%&#1A$61!49!V251*0$!49!

1;$!P4[$#6A$61!49!@&6&'&C!!K4#6$&2!8;$%$++!\&5!#$1&*6$'!14!%$#94#A!&6!&012&#*&+![&+2&1*46!49!

1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'!]1;$!^!"#$_`!&5!49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.M!*6!4#'$#!14a!

&C %#4[*'$!&6!$[&+2&1*46!49!1;$!9*6&60*&+!%45*1*46!49!1;$!B26'!&5!49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.M!94#!52%%4#1!

49!1;$!,-.M!8299*0*$60:!?$&#*675b!

YC %#4[*'$!&6!&6&+:5*5!49!&012&+!14!$c%$01$'!$c%$#*$60$!94#!1;$!1;#$$!:$&#5!9#4A!M.!R$0$AY$#!

,-.-!14!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.Mb!

0C %#4[*'$!&6!*6'$%$6'$61!#$[*$\!49!1;$!,-.M!&012&#*&+!#$%4#1!%#$%&#$'!Y:!F0d+$#!94#!1;$!V4*61!

@4AA*11$$!]1;$!^%&'#()*&++'((,,_`!$51&Y+*5;$'!26'$#!5$01*46!<C-.!49!1;$!V&62&#:!.e!.<(=!14!

V2+:!.e!.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!8$11+$A$61!)7#$$A$61!]1;$!^-./#_`b!

'C %#4[*'$!&6!$[&+2&1*46!49!1;$!5$65*1*[*1:!49!1;$![&+2&1*46!#$52+15!14!0;&67$5!*6!1;$!d$:!&012&#*&+!

&552A%1*465b!&6'!

$C %#4[*'$!*694#A&1*46!14!1;$!9$'$#&+!74[$#6A$61!14!&55*51!1;$A!*6!#$[*$\*67!1;$*#!%45*1*46!\*1;!

#$5%$01!14!1;$!B26'C!

,C H;$!*61$6'$'!25$#5!49!1;*5!#$%4#1!&#$!?$&+1;!@&6&'&e!1;$!R$%&#1A$61!49!V251*0$!49!1;$!P4[$#6A$61!

49!@&6&'&e!1;$!V4*61!@4AA*11$$!&6'!1;$!042#15!;&[*67!f2#*5'*01*46!4[$#!1;$!"+&6!&6'!B26'C!!H;$!

+&\!A&:!#$Z2*#$!1;*5!#$%4#1!14!Y$!%#4[*'$'!14!41;$#!%&#1*$5!\;4!&#$!641!*61$6'$'!25$#5C!!H;$!

#$%4#1!A&:!641!Y$!%#4[*'$'!14!&6:46$!\;4!*5!641!&6!*61$6'$'!25$#!$c0$%1!&5!A&:!Y$!#$Z2*#$'!Y:!

+&\C!!H;$!9*6'*675!;$#$*6!A&:!641!Y$!25$'!4#!#$+*$'!2%46!Y:!&6:!%&#1:!41;$#!1;&6!&6!*61$6'$'!25$#!

\*1;421!1;$!%#*4#!\#*11$6!0465$61!49!K4#6$&2!8;$%$++C

Page 28: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! ,!

%$ !"!#$%&'!()$**+,-!

&'()*+,-./!

MC R2#*67!1;$!%$#*4'!.<(=!14!.<<-e!&!62AY$#!49!%$4%+$!\$#$!*69$01$'!\*1;!?$%&1*1*5!@!9#4A!Y+44'!

1#&65925*465C!!)!1#251!926'!\&5!$51&Y+*5;$'!14!%#4[*'$!04A%$65&1*46!14!%$4%+$!*69$01$'!'2#*67!1;*5!

1*A$!%$#*4'C!

SC )!52AA&#:!49!1;$!"+&6!Y$6$9*15!&6'!1;$!&A42615!%&:&Y+$!*5!0461&*6$'!*6!)%%$6'*c!)C!!)%%$6'*c!F!

%#4[*'$5!&!7+455&#:!49!1$#A5!25$'!*6!1;*5!#$%4#1C!

/C H;$!8$11+$A$61!)7#$$A$61!'*51*672*5;$5!Y$1\$$6!;&$A4%;*+*&05!&6'!646>;&$A4%;*+*&05C!!I6!1;*5!

#$%4#1e!1;$!646>;&$A4%;*+*&0!0+&*A&615!&#$!#$9$##$'!14!&5!^(0/#12"1,$_!0+&*A&615C!

=C H;*5!#$%4#1!%#4[*'$5!&6!*6'$%$6'$61!#$[*$\!49!1;$!9*6&60*&+!%45*1*46!49!1;$!B26'!&5!\$++!&5!&!

#$[*$\!49!1;$!F0d+$#!3$%4#1C!!

UC B4#!1;*5![&+2&1*46e!\$!\$#$!*651#201$'!14!\4#d!044%$#&1*[$+:!\*1;!F0d+$#!14!5$+$01!1;$!&012&#*&+!

A$1;4'5!&6'!&552A%1*465!f4*61+:C!!H;$!*61$61!*5!14!25$!1;$!5&A$!&552A%1*465!*6!42#!#$5%$01*[$!

[&+2&1*465!%#4[*'$'!1;&1!'*'!641!#$52+1!*6!04A%#4A*5*67!42#!%#49$55*46&+!*61$7#*1:!4#!#$52+1!*6!

25*67!&552A%1*465!1;&1!\$!Y$+*$[$'!\$#$!*6&%%#4%#*&1$!94#!1;$!%2#%45$C!!I9!\$!\$#$!26&Y+$!14!

&7#$$!\*1;!#$5%$01!14!&6!&552A%1*46e!1;$!#$&5465!1;$#$94#!&6'!9*6&60*&+!$99$01!\&5!14!Y$!'*50+45$'C!

(C W$!044%$#&1$'!\*1;!1;$!&6&+:5*5!49!1;$!'&1&!&6'!5;&#$'!42#!#$5%$01*[$!9*6'*675C!!N41;!&012&#*$5!

&00$%1!&++!49!1;$!&552A%1*465!25$'!*6!1;*5![&+2&1*46!X!1;$#$!&#$!64!'*99$#$60$5C!

<C W$!;&[$!5;&#$'!42#!#$5%$01*[$!#$52+15!&6'!*6!42#!4%*6*46e!1;$!'*99$#$60$5!&#$!*AA&1$#*&+!&6'!1;$!

#$52+15!5;42+'!Y$!0465*'$#$'!&5!$55$61*&++:!1;$!5&A$C!!B4#!1;*5!#$&546e!26+*d$!42#!%#*4#!#$%4#15e!\$!

'4!641!5;4\!1;$!F0d+$#!#$52+15!94#!04A%&#&1*[$!%2#%45$5C!

&012!01234'201!'./!5+,6313,.!7,+!'/60+10!/063'23,.1!

.-C I6!1;*5!#$%4#1e!\$!5;4\!#$52+15!46!&!Y$51!$51*A&1$!Y&5*5!&5!\$++!&5!#$52+15!*60+2'*67!&!%#4[*5*46!94#!

&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465C!!!

..C H;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!#$52+15!&#$!Y&5$'!46!&012&#*&+!&552A%1*465!1;&1!*6!42#!4%*6*46!#$%#$5$61!1;$!

A451!+*d$+:!$c%$01&1*46!94#!1;$!9212#$C!!H;*5!A$&65!1;&1!1;$#$!*5!&%%#4c*A&1$+:!&!/-g!0;&60$!1;&1!

9212#$!$c%$#*$60$!\*++!Y$!Y$11$#!1;&6!1;$!&552A%1*46!&6'!&!/-g!0;&60$!1;&1!*1!\*++!Y$!\4#5$C!!I6!

1;*5!\&:e!1;$!#$52+1*67!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&012&#*&+!+*&Y*+*1*$5!#$%#$5$61!1;$!&A4261!49!&55$15!#$Z2*#$'!

54!1;$#$!*5!&%%#4c*A&1$+:!&!/-g!0;&60$!49!;&[*67!144!A20;!A46$:!&6'!&!/-g!0;&60$!49!;&[*67!

144!+*11+$!A46$:C!!!

.,C I1!*5!6$*1;$#!&%%#4%#*&1$!64#!%#2'$61!14!&55$55!1;$!5299*0*$60:!49!1;$!B26'!25*67!Y$51!$51*A&1$!

&552A%1*465C!!8*60$!1;$#$!*5!&6!&7#$$A$61!1;&1!64!&''*1*46&+!A46*$5!\*++!Y$!%#4[*'$'!14!1;$!B26'!

Page 29: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! M!

Y:!1;$!74[$#6A$615e!*1!*5!%#2'$61!14!&55$55!1;$!9*6&60*&+!5299*0*$60:!49!1;$!B26'!21*+*h*67!&!Y&5*5!

1;&1!;&5!&!7#$&1$#!0;&60$!1;&6!/-g!49!;&[*67!5299*0*$61!&55$15!14!%&:!&++!9212#$!Y$6$9*15C!!H;*5!*5!

'46$!1;#427;!1;$!25$!49!0465$#[&1*5A!*6!1;$!&012&#*&+!&552A%1*465C!!@465$#[&1*5A!*5!*61#4'20$'!

1;#427;!1;$!25$!49!&552A%1*465!1;&1!#$%#$5$61!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!94#!1;$!9212#$!!"#$!%$&'()!%!&!

%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465C!!W;*+$!*1!*5!%455*Y+$!1;&1!&012&+!$c%$#*$60$!A&:!'$[*&1$!9#4A!42#!

Y$51!$51*A&1$!&552A%1*465!*6!&!%45*1*[$!\&:!]1;$#$Y:!#$'20*67!1;$!"+&6!+*&Y*+*1*$5`e!1;*5!5;42+'!641!

Y$!#$0476*h$'!261*+!520;!1*A$!&5!&!%45*1*[$!'$[*&1*46!;&5!4002##$'C!

.MC H;$!25$!49!Y$51!$51*A&1$!#$52+15!147$1;$#!\*1;!#$52+15!*60+2'*67!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!

%$#A*15!1;$!25$#!49!1;*5!#$%4#1!14!&55$55!1;$!'$7#$$!49!0465$#[&1*5A!*6;$#$61!*6!1;$!#$52+15C!!

D+1*A&1$+:e!*1!*5!&6!*552$!49!*6'*[*'2&+!f2'7$A$61!&5!14!1;$!&A4261!&6'!'$7#$$!49!%#4[*5*46!94#!

&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!1;&1!*5!%#2'$61!14!#$0476*h$e!;&[*67!#$7&#'!14!1;$!*61$#$51!49!&++!%&#1*$5!14!1;$!

8$11+$A$61!)7#$$A$61C!

.SC W$!;&[$!&+54!&''$'!&6!&''*1*46&+!Y299$#!94#!0&1&51#4%;*0!$[$615C!!H;*5!*5!14!%#4[*'$!&6!&++4\&60$!

\$!Y$+*$[$!1;$!B26'!A&:!#$Z2*#$!14!\*1;51&6'!&6:!&'[$#5$!$[$615!1;&1!;&[$!&![$#:!+4\!

%#4Y&Y*+*1:!49!4002##*67!Y21!1;&1!&#$!51*++!#$&546&Y+:!%455*Y+$C!!E6$!042+'!+*d$6!1;&1!14!#$0476*5*67!

$[$615!1;&1!A*7;1!4002#!460$!&!0$612#:!Y21!*764#*67!$[$615!1;&1!&#$!+$55!+*d$+:C!

805'23231!(!(9'34'.2!(,8,+2!

./C H;$!+&51!'&1$!94#!9*+*67!0+&*A5!94#!Y$6$9*15!9#4A!1;$!B26'!\&5!.!V2+:!,-.-e!]52Yf$01!14!54A$!

$c0$%1*465`C!!)5!49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.Me!1;$#$!\$#$!51*++!,<<!1#&65925$'!&6'!;&$A4%;*+*&0!0+&*A5!*6!

%#40$55!49!&'f2'*0&1*46C!!H;$#$!\*++!&+54!+*d$+:!Y$!&!62AY$#!49!&''*1*46&+!+&1$!0+&*A5!1;&1!&#$!

%$#A*11$'!26'$#!1;$!1$#A5!49!!@)".!&6'!@)",C!!3$7&#'+$55e!\$!Y$+*$[$!1;&1!A451!49!1;$!0+&*A&61!

04;4#1!*5!64\!d64\6C!!@4A%&#$'!\*1;!%&51!:$&#5e!1;$#$!*5!A20;!+$55!260$#1&*61:!&Y421!1;$!

0;&#&01$#*51*05!49!1;45$!:$1!14!0+&*AC!!!

.=C H&Y+$!.=!5;4\5!1;$!62AY$#!49!0+&*A&615!]Y41;!d64\6!&6'!26d64\6`!\$!;&[$!&552A$'!94#!1;*5!

#$%4#1C!!

Page 30: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! S!

!"#$%&'(&)&*+,+-.&/01%&2&34+54&"46&7484+54&*$"09"4.:&

3,140'5('&#)6#&7#)

*./'+/#(1)8#9#&7#)*./'+/#(1) :&(/.)

:0/#12"1,$)*&;&0()

• &+*[$!0+&*A&615!

• 0+&*A&615!\;4!'*$'!&91$#!.<<(!

• 0+&*A&615!\;4!'*$'!Y$94#$!.<<<!

!,e(,.!<.<!.(S!

!.UU!/,!,/!

!,e<<(!<U.!,-<!

:&(/.):0/#12"1,$)*&;&0() Me<,S! ,/S! Se.U(!

</,+&5;'.'/4)*&;&0())

• &+*[$!0+&*A&615!

• 0+&*A&615!\;4!'*$'!&91$#!.<<(!

• 0+&*A&615!\;4!'*$'!Y$94#$!.<<<!!

!(UU!.(.!M-.!

!.S!<!M!

!(<.!.<-!M-S!

:&(/.)</,+&5;'.'/4)*&;&0() .eM/<! ,=! .eM(/!

:&(/.)&2)/..)*./'+/#(1) /e,(M! ,(-! /e/=M!

!

/310'10!5+,*+0113,.!

.UC H;$!&A4261!49!'&1&!&Y421!1;$!d64\6!0+&*A&615!\&5!5299*0*$61!94#!1;$!KKWP!14!Y&5$!1;$*#!#&1$5!49!

'*5$&5$!%#47#$55*46!*6!1;$!,-.M!KKWP!3$%4#1!46!1;*5!"+&6i5!0+&*A&615C!!"#$[*425+:e!1;$:!

04AY*6$'!1;$!0+&*A&615i!'&1&!\*1;!#$52+15!9#4A!*61$#6&1*46&+!512'*$5C!!!

.(C H;$!,-.-!KKWP!3$%4#1!'*50255$'!1;$!1#$6'!94#!0;&67$5!14!1;$!%#47#$55*46!49!1;$!'*5$&5$!*6!1;$!

9212#$C!!"$4%+$!%#47#$55!1;#427;!?$%&1*1*5!@!&1!'*99$#$61!#&1$5C!!H;$:!0&6!Y$!'*[*'$'!*614!1;#$$!

7#42%5a!#&%*'e!*61$#A$'*&1$!&6'!5+4\!%#47#$554#5C!!)5!1;$!#&%*'!%#47#$554#5!'*$e!1;$!#$A&*6*67!

0+&*A&615!\*++!Y$!A&'$!2%!A4#$!&6'!A4#$!49!1;$!*61$#A$'*&1$!&6'!5+4\!%#47#$554#5C!!W$!Y$+*$[$!

1;&1!1;*5!\*++!+*d$+:!Y$!A&6*9$51$'!Y:!&!7#&'2&+!#$'201*46!*6!1;$!'*5$&5$!%#47#$55*46!#&1$5!&6'!&!

+$671;$6*67!*6!1;$!4Y5$#[$'!1*A$!14!%#47#$55!9#4A!'*5$&5$!+$[$+!14!+$[$+C!H;&1!$99$01!\*++!Y$!

#$0476*5$'!*6!9212#$!5299*0*$60:!#$[*$\5C!!W$!;&[$!641!&11$A%1$'!14!Z2&61*9:!*1!\*1;*6!1;*5!#$[*$\C!

.<C )!A&f4#!0;&67$!*6!1;$!$c%$01$'!9212#$!49!?@J!*5!1;$!#$0$61!&6'!$c%$01$'!*61#4'201*46!49!6$\!

'#275!94#!1#$&1A$61C!!H;$5$!'#275!7#$&1+:!*60#$&5$!1;$!$99*0&0:!49!1#$&1A$61!&6'!&#$!0465*'$#$'!14!

Y$!$&5*$#!14!1&d$C!!H;$!'#275!04A$!&1!&!;*7;!0451!\*1;!A451!1#$&1A$615!$51*A&1$'!14!0451!Y$1\$$6!

j=-e---!&6'!j(-e---!94#!&!.,>\$$d!%#47#&AC!!W$!$c%$01!1;&1!1;$!Y2+d!49!1;&1!0451!\*++!Y$!04[$#$'!

Y:!1;$!B26'!&5!%#4[*60*&+!'#27!%#47#&A5!&#$!&552A$'!14!641!&''!1;$!'#275!14!1;$*#!94#A2+&#*$5!

94#!54A$!1*A$C!!

,-C H;*5!*60#$&5$'!'#27!0451!*5!$c%$01$'!14!&00$+$#&1$!1;$!0&5;!9+4\5!49!1;$!B26'!94#!04A%$65&1*46!

&6'!#$52+1!*6!&!5*76*9*0&61!#$'201*46!*6!9212#$!04A%$65&1*46!%&:A$615!&5!A&6:!0+&*A&615!&#$!

&552A$'!14!0+$&#!1;$![*#25C!

,.C B4++4\*67!1;$!9*6&+*5&1*46!49!42#![&+2&1*46!#$52+15!\$!Y$0&A$!&\&#$!1;&1!)YY[*$!#$0$*[$'!?$&+1;!

@&6&'&!&%%#4[&+!46!,M!R$0$AY$#!,-.S!94#!?4+d*#&!"&de!&!MR>#$7*A$6!'#27C!!W$!26'$#51&6'!1;$!

%#*0$!49!1;$!'#27!*5!&Y421!j/=e---!94#!&!.,>\$$d!1#$&1A$61e!%+25!1;$!0451!49!#*Y&[*#*6e!*9!25$'C!!]W$!

Page 31: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! /!

;&[$!641!Y$$6!&Y+$!14!'$1$#A*6$!\;$1;$#!1;&1!%#*0$!94#!?4+d*#&!"&d!*5!\;4+$5&+$!4#!#$1&*+`C!!B4#!

1;$![&+2&1*46e!\$!&552A$'!1;&1!1;$!%#*0$!\42+'!Y$!5*A*+&#!14!?&#[46*e!&!54945Y2[*#!'42Y+$1!'#27e!

\;*0;!\$!\$#$!*694#A$'!0451!&Y421!j(/e---!Y&5$'!46!&6!&[$#&7$!49!.MC,>\$$d5!94#!1#$&1A$61C!!!!

,,C H;$!%#*0$!49!?4+d*#&!"&d!A&:!+$&'!14!&!#$'201*46!*6!1;$!%#*0$!49!?&#[46*!&6'!%455*Y+:!41;$#!?@J!

'#275C!

,MC I1!A&:!Y$!1;&1!1;$!0451!49!'#275!\*++!Y$!+$55!1;&6!&552A$'!*6!1;$![&+2&1*46!&6'!1;&1!\*++!#$52+1!*6!

$c%$#*$60$!7&*65C!!W$!;&[$!641!#$9+$01$'!1;*5!%455*Y*+*1:!*6!1;*5!#$%4#1C!!I9!1;$!%#*0$5!49!1;$!'#275!

&#$!+4\$#!1;&6!&552A$'e!1;$!7&*65!\*++!Y$!#$9+$01$'!*6!1;$!6$c1!5299*0*$60:!#$[*$\C!

;<=%::&>*?&@+-."$0.A&

,SC H;$#$!&#$!&!+&#7$!62AY$#!49!'$&1;5!4002##*67!&1!+$[$+5!,!14!/!1;&1!&#$!Y$*67!&%%#4[$'!&5!;&[*67!

4002##$'!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@JC!!H;$#$!*5!64!%#4[*5*46!*6!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+!4#!*6!1;$!KKWP!'*5$&5$!

%#47#$55*46!#&1$5!94#!&6:!'$&1;!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@J!14!4002#!&1!&!+$[$+!41;$#!1;&6!+$[$+!=C!!H;$5$!?@J!

#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!&1!+$[$+5!,!14!/!&#$!0465*51$61!\*1;!1;$!$c%$01$'!'$&1;5!26'$#!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+e!

Y21!1;$:!&#$!0465*'$#$'!Y:!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+!14!Y$!9#4A!646>?@J!#$+&1$'!0&25$5C!!W$!#$9$#!14!

1;$5$!'$&1;5!&5!'2$!14!^$c0$55!?@J!A4#1&+*1:_C!

,/C H;*5!$c0$55!?@J!A4#1&+*1:!&#*5$5!9#4A!1;$!'*99$#$60$!*6!1;$!A$'*0&+!&6'!+$7&+!'$9*6*1*465!49!^&5!&!

#$52+1!49!?@J_C!!H;$!A$'*0&+!'$9*6*1*46!25$'!Y:!1;$!KKWP!A&d$5!+*11+$!&++4\&60$!94#!?@J!

*61$#&01*67!\*1;!&641;$#!'*5$&5$!&6'!&00$+$#&1*67!1;$!1*A$!49!'$&1;C!!B4#!%2#%45$5!49!1;$!KKWP!

#$5$&#0;e!\$!&7#$$!1;&1!1;$!25$!49!1;$!A$'*0&+!'$9*6*1*46!*5!+*d$+:!1;$!A451!&%%#4%#*&1$C!!B4#!

%2#%45$5!49!1;$!&012&#*&+![&+2&1*46!94#!5299*0*$60:!%2#%45$5e!1;$!$c0$55!?@J!A4#1&+*1:!5;42+'!Y$!

#$0476*5$'C!!H;*5!\&5!'*50255$'!*6!&!0469$#$60$!0&++!*6[4+[*67!1;$!KKWPe!F0d+$#!&6'!K4#6$&2!

8;$%$++!&6'!\$!&++!&7#$$'!1;&1!1;$!&012&#*$5!\42+'!#$0476*5$!1;$!$c0$55!?@J!A4#1&+*1:C!

73.'.(3'9!+01-921!

,=C H&Y+$!,=!%#$5$615!&!52AA&#:!49!1;$!4[$#&++!9*6&60*&+!#$52+15!49!1;$!"+&6C!

Page 32: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! =!

!"#$%&B(&)&/C99"-A&+D&E04"4=0"$&F%:C$.:&G04&HIII:J&

) =,1()>1('+/(,) -0&?'1'&#)2&0)@$?,01,)3,?'/('&#1))

! ABCD) ABCB) ABCD) ABCB)

)55$15! j!.e.<-e.<<! j!.e.UUe,=,!! j!.e.<-e.<<! j!.e.UUe,=,!

T*&Y*+*1*$5! ! ! ! !

! H#&65925$'! !M(Ue..S!! S.,e-.,! !S<.e=.,!! /,(eS-S!

! ?&$A4%;*+*&05! ,,Me<=<! ,S,e,S-! ,=SeSU.! ,(Se./-!

! ?IJ!"#47#&A! !</-!! .e.--! !<U-!! .e.--!

! B$$5!k!Fc%$65$5! !/MeS//!! MSe-<.! !//e//,!! MSe=/(!

H41&+!"+&6!T*&Y*+*1*$5! !==/eS((!! =(<eSSM! !(.,e=-/!! (S(eM.,!

!"#$)E"05."1)F3,2'4'(G) HIAJKLCC) HJMLKMCN) HDLLKINJ) HDAMKNIB)

)''*1*46&+!Y299$#!&7&*651!0&1&51#4%;*0!$[$615!

!! ! !.,.e---!! >!!

>O4,11)@11,(1) ) !) HAIPKINJ) HDAMKNIB)

,UC R$1&*+$'!9*6&60*&+!#$52+15!Y:!04;4#1!&6'!Y$6$9*1!&#$!%#$5$61$'!*6!8$01*46!(C!!H;$!&55$15!&#$!

52AA&#*h$'!*6!8$01*46!UC!

,(C H;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!%#4'20$5!&!141&+!+*&Y*+*1:!&Y421!,,g!7#$&1$#!1;&6!1;$!Y$51!

$51*A&1$!+*&Y*+*1:C!!H;$!&''*1*46&+!Y299$#!&7&*651!0&1&51#4%;*0!$[$615!&''5!.(g!49!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!

+*&Y*+*1:!94#!&!141&+!Y299$#!49!&Y421!S-g!49!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!+*&Y*+*1:C!

,<C )''*1*46&+!*694#A&1*46!&Y421!1;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465e!1;$!0;&67$!*6!1;$!52#%+25!

&A4261!9#4A!,-.-!14!,-.M!&6'!1;$!5$65*1*[*1:!49!1;$!#$52+15!14!&552A%1*46!0;&67$5!&#$!*6!

8$01*465!(!&6'!<C!

M-C I6!A:!4%*6*46e!1;$!B26'!*5!5299*0*$61!&6'!1;$#$!&#$!$c0$55!&55$15!49!j,/=C=!A*++*46!&1!M.!R$0$AY$#!

,-.MC!

5+,63.(3'9:20++32,+3'9!(,.2+3&-23,.!,&93*'23,.!

M.C H;$!%#4[*60$5!&6'!1$##*14#*$5!&#$!7*[$6!&!0;4*0$!26'$#!1;$!8$11+$A$61!)7#$$A$61!14!$*1;$#!

0461#*Y21$!46!&!%&:>&5>:42>74!Y&5*5!4#!14!%#$926'!54A$!4#!1;$*#!$61*#$!0461#*Y21*46!4Y+*7&1*46C!!)5!

49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.Me!1;$#$!\&5!&!141&+!#$A&*6*67!0461#*Y21*46!49!j.=,!A*++*46!49!\;*0;!j.Se---!

;&'!Y$$6!%#$926'$'C!!H;$!#$A&*6*67!%#4[*60*&+l1$##*14#*&+!0461#*Y21*465!&#$!*60#$&5$'!&662&++:!

94#!*61$#$51!Y&5$'!46!1;$!#$12#6!49!<->'&:!H#$&52#:!N*++5C!!

M,C W$!;&[$!%#4f$01$'!1;$!9212#$!%#4[*60*&+l1$##*14#*&+!0461#*Y21*46!#$Z2*#$A$615!94#!$&0;!:$&#!

Y&5$'!46!1;$!0&5;!9+4\5!26'$#!Y41;!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&6'!1;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!

&552A%1*465C!

Page 33: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! U!

MMC D5*67!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&552A%1*465!94#!'$1$#A*6*67!1;$!&A4261!&6'!1*A*67!49!9212#$!Y$6$9*15e!

1;$!%#4[*60*&+l1$##*14#*&+!0461#*Y21*46!4Y+*7&1*46!*5!$c%$01$'!14!$c%*#$!*6!,-,SC!!)91$#!1;&1!1*A$e!

1;$#$!\*++!Y$!64!&''*1*46&+!926'5!%&:&Y+$!Y:!1;$!%#4[*60$5!&6'!1$##*14#*$5C!

MSC D5*67!1;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!&552A%1*465e!1;$!%#4[*60*&+l1$##*14#*&+!0461#*Y21*46!

4Y+*7&1*46!*5!$c%$01$'!14!$c%*#$!*6!,-,.C!

! !

Page 34: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! (!

(0+2373('23,.!

M/C I!;$#$Y:!0$#1*9:!1;&1a!

&C I6!A:!4%*6*46e!1;$!B26'!*5!5299*0*$61b!

YC I6!A:!4%*6*46e!1;$!'&1&!25$'!*5!5299*0*$61!&6'!#$+*&Y+$!94#!1;$!%2#%45$5!49!1;$!#$%4#1b

0C I6!A:!4%*6*46e!1;$!&012&#*&+!A$1;4'5!&#$!&%%#4%#*&1$!94#!1;$!%2#%45$!49!1;*5!#$%4#1b!

'C I6!A:!4%*6*46e!1;$!&552A%1*465!25$'!&#$e!*6!&77#$7&1$e!&%%#4%#*&1$!94#!1;$!%2#%45$5!49!1;$!

\4#db!

$C H;$!0&+02+&1*465!\$#$!%#$%&#$'!*6!&004#'&60$!\*1;!1;$!@&6&'*&6!I651*121$!49!)012&#*$5i!

81&6'&#'5!49!"#&01*0$b!

9C H;*5!#$%4#1!;&5!Y$$6!%#$%&#$'!&6'!A:!4%*6*465!7*[$6!*6!&004#'&60$!\*1;!&00$%1$'!&012&#*&+!

%#&01*0$!*6!@&6&'&b!

7C H;$#$!&#$!64!52Y5$Z2$61!$[$615!41;$#!1;&6!1;45$!'*50255$'!*6!1;*5!#$%4#1!1;&1!I!&A!&\&#$!49!

1;&1!\42+'!;&[$!&6!*A%&01!46!1;$!#$52+15!%#$5$61$'!;$#$*6b!&6'!

;C H;*5!#$%4#1!04694#A5!14!A:!'21:!14a!!

]*` %#4[*'$!4%*6*46!$[*'$60$!1;&1!*5!9&*#e!4Yf$01*[$!&6'!\*1;421!&'[40&0:!94#!$*1;$#!%&#1:!

&6'!#$+&1$'!46+:!14!A&11$#5!1;&1!&#$!\*1;*6!A:!&#$&!49!$c%$#1*5$b!!

]**` *9!0&++$'!2%46!14!7*[$!4#&+!4#!\#*11$6!1$51*A46:e!I!\*++!7*[$!1;&1!1$51*A46:!*6!&!9&*#e!

4Yf$01*[$!A&66$#!&6'!\*1;421!&'[40&0:!94#!$*1;$#!%&#1:b!&6'!

]***` &55*51!1;$!042#1!&6'!%#4[*'$!520;!&''*1*46&+!&55*51&60$!&5!1;$!042#1!A&:!#$&546&Y+:!

#$Z2*#$!14!'$1$#A*6$!1;$!A&11$#!&1!*552$C!!

M=C I!&A!&[&*+&Y+$!14!&65\$#!&6:!Z2$51*465!4#!14!%#4[*'$!&''*1*46&+!*694#A&1*46!#$7&#'*67!&6:!&5%$01!

49!1;*5!#$%4#1C!

3$5%$0192++:!52YA*11$'e!KE3QF)D!8?F"FTT!THRC!

!

!

!"$1$#!VC!KC!P4#;&Ae!B$++4\e!@&6&'*&6!I651*121$!49!)012&#*$5!B$++4\e!840*$1:!49!)012&#*$5!!!*%)+'&$,"&!'%-+'.$$/',$$&'&$0)$($1'.2'34"!!'3)5,+"/6'7898:8;86'7838;8

3$5%$0192++:!52YA*11$'eKE3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3Q3QF)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)F)D!8?F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"F"FTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTFTT!T!T!T!T!T!T!T!T!T!T!T!T!T!T!T!T!T!T!T!T!THRC

"$1$#!#!#!#!#!#!#!#!#!#!#!#!#!#!#!#!#!#!#!#!#!VCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVCVC!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!K!KC!P4#;&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&A&AeB$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$B$++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++4\e!@&6&'*&6!I6565656565656565656565656565656565656565656565651*121$!49!)012&#*$5B$++4\e!840*$1:!49!)012&#*$5

Page 35: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! <!

;$ !"#$%&'()*!

MUC R2#*67!1;$!%$#*4'!.<<=!14!.<<(e!&!62AY$#!49!0+&55!&01*46!+&\52*15!\$#$!Y#427;1!94#\&#'!&7&*651!1;$!

9$'$#&+e!%#4[*60*&+!&6'!1$##*14#*&+!74[$#6A$615!46!Y$;&+9!49!%$4%+$!\;4!\$#$!*69$01$'!\*1;!?$%&1*1*5!@!

9#4A!Y+44'!1#&65925*465!#$0$*[$'!Y$1\$$6!.!V&62&#:!.<(=!&6'!.!V2+:!.<<-C!!)!8$11+$A$61!)7#$$A$61!

\&5!#$&0;$'!&5!49!./!V26$!.<<<!1;&1!%#4[*'$'!94#!1;$!$51&Y+*5;A$61!49!&!1#251!926'!14!%&:!Y$6$9*15!14!1;$!

&99$01$'!0+&55C!!H;*5!8$11+$A$61!)7#$$A$61!5%$0*9*$5!1;$!%$#5465!$+*7*Y+$!14!#$0$*[$!Y$6$9*15e!1;$!&A4261!

49!Y$6$9*15!%&:&Y+$e!1;$!926'*67!49!1;$!Y$6$9*15!Y:!1;$!9$'$#&+e!%#4[*60*&+!&6'!1$##*14#*&+!74[$#6A$615!&6'!

1;$!*6[$51A$61!49!"+&6!&55$15C!

M(C N$6$9*15!26'$#!1;$!"+&6!&#$!'$%$6'$61!46!1;$!%#47#$55*46!49!&!0+&*A&61!1;#427;!1;$![&#*425!+$[$+5!49!1;$!

'*5$&5$C!!N$6$9*15!&#$!&+54!'$%$6'$61!46a!

• \;$1;$#!1;$!%$#546!*5!;&$A4%;*+*&0!]646>;&$A4%;*+*&05!&#$!#$9$##$'!14!&5!^1#&65925$'_`b!&6'!

• \;$1;$#!1;$!%$#546!'*$'!%#*4#!14!.<<<!4#!\&5!&+*[$!46!.!V&62&#:!.<<<C!

M<C H4!Y$!$+*7*Y+$!94#!04A%$65&1*46!9#4A!1;$!B26'e!0+&*A&615!A251!5;4\!0+*6*0&+!$[*'$60$!49!*69$01*46!9#4A!

?$%&1*1*5!@b!A251!;&[$!#$0$*[$'!Y+44'!%#4'2015!'2#*67!1;$!%$#*4'!.!V&62&#:!.<(=!14!.!V2+:!.<<-!\;$#$!

520;!Y+44'!%#4'201!0&6!Y$!5;4\6!14!;&[$!0461&*6$'!1;$!?$%&1*1*5!@![*#25!]1;#427;!&!1#&0$>Y&0d!

%#47#&A`b!&6'e!\*1;!1;$!$c0$%1*46!49!;&$A4%;*+*&05e!A251!Y$!&Y+$!14!'$A4651#&1$!1;&1!%#*4#!*69$01*46!*5!

641!+*d$+:!14!;&[$!4002##$'C!!@+&*A5!A251!Y$!9*+$'!\*1;!1;$!&'A*6*51#&14#!49!1;$!"+&6!%#*4#!14!.!V2+:!,-.-C!

S-C )!52AA&#:!49!1;$!"+&6!Y$6$9*15!&6'!1;$!&A42615!%&:&Y+$!94#!1;$![&#*425!+$[$+5!49!1;$!'*5$&5$!*5!

0461&*6$'!*6!)%%$6'*c!)C!!)%%$6'*c!F!*5!&!7+455&#:!49!1$#A5!25$'!*6!1;*5!#$%4#1C!

S.C I6!1;*5!#$%4#1e!1;$!1$#A!^.,?,._!*5!25$'!14!#$9$#!14!1;$!'*5$&5$!+$[$+5!94#!\;*0;!04A%$65&1*46!*5!%&*'!26'$#!

1;$!"+&6C!!H;$!1$#A!^1(/Q,_!*5!25$'!14!#$9$#!14!1;$!'*5$&5$!51&7$5!&5!A4'$++$'!*6!1;$!KKWP!3$%4#1!]5$$!

)%%$6'*c!F`C!!H;$#$!*5!&!04A%&#*546!49!1;$![&#*425!+$[$+5!&6'!51&7$5!0461&*6$'!*6!8$01*46!..!>!)012&#*&+!

)552A%1*465C!

S,C H;$!8$11+$A$61!)7#$$A$61!'*51*672*5;$5!Y$1\$$6!;&$A4%;*+*&05!&6'!646>;&$A4%;*+*&05C!!I6!1;*5!#$%4#1e!

1;$!646>;&$A4%;*+*&0!0+&*A&615!&#$!#$9$##$'!14!&5!^(0/#12"1,$_!0+&*A&615C!

SMC D6'$#!1;$!1$#A5!49!1;$!"+&6e!&6!&012&#*&+![&+2&1*46!49!1;$!Y$6$9*15!*5!14!Y$!%#4'20$'!&1!+$&51!$[$#:!1;#$$!

:$&#5!14!&55*51!1;$!042#15!\*1;!1;$*#!#$[*$\!49!1;$!5299*0*$60:!49!1;$!B26'C!!H;$!A451!#$0$61!&012&#*&+!

[&+2&1*465!94#!1;&1!%2#%45$!\&5!%#$%&#$'!Y:!F0d+$#!&5!49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.-!]'&1$'!V2+:!,-..`!&6'!Y:!

K4#6$&2!8;$%$++!&5!49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.-!]'&1$'!S!)%#*+!,-.,`C!!!

SSC )1!1;$!#$Z2$51!49!?$&+1;!@&6&'&e!K4#6$&2!8;$%$++!26'$#144d!&6!*6'$%$6'$61!#$[*$\!49!1;$!"+&6!&5!49!M.!

R$0$AY$#!,--Se!M.!R$0$AY$#!,--U!&6'!&5!49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.-C!!?$&+1;!@&6&'&!;&5!#$Z2$51$'!

K4#6$&2!8;$%$++!14!&7&*6!%$#94#A!&6!*6'$%$6'$61!#$[*$\!49!1;$!"+&6!&5!49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.M!&6'!

%#$%&#$!1;*5!#$%4#1!'$1&*+*67!1;$!#$52+15C!!!

Page 36: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .-!

<$ !"#!"#$%&'()*+,-#-!!

S/C W$!\$#$!%#4[*'$'!\*1;!1;$!94++4\*67!'&1&!&6'!'402A$615!1;&1!\$!;&[$!25$'!*6!1;$!%#$%&#&1*46!49!1;*5!

#$%4#1!

&C )!+$11$#!'&1$'!=!B$Y#2&#:!,-.S!9#4A!O$[*6!Ei@466$++!49!@#&\94#'!@+&55!)01*46!8$11+$A$615!147$1;$#!

\*1;!&!'402A$61!1*1+$'!^W4#d5;$$1!3$9$#$60$5_!&6'!'*5d!0461&*6*67!0+&55!A$AY$#!'&1&e!]*60+2'*67!

&%%+*0&615!\;45$!0+&*A5!;&[$!Y$$6!'$6*$'!4#!#$A&*6!%$6'*67!&!'$0*5*46`!&5!49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.M!

1;&1!I!&A!*694#A$'!\&5!%#$%&#$'!Y:!1;$!)'A*6*51#&14#!&1!1;$!#$Z2$51!49!1;$!V4*61!@4AA*11$$b!

YC !^F51*A&1*67!1;$!"#47645*5!49!@&6&'*&65!I69$01$'!W*1;!1;$!?$%&1*1*5!@!J*#25!H;#427;!1;$!N+44'!

82%%+:e!.<(=>.<<-!>!B*91;!3$[*5*46!49!?$%&1*1*5!@!"#476451*0!K4'$+!N&5$'!46!1;$!"451>H#&65925*46!

?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!@+&*A&61!@4;4#1_e!'&1$'!8$%1$AY$#!,-.S!Y:!W$6'467!@;$6e!KR!";Re!

m*+467!L*!KR!K80!";Re!W*++*&A!W467e!";R!&6'!K2##&:!O#&;6!KR!K80!B3@"@!]1;$!^RRST)

U,5&0(_`b!

0C H\4!@42#1!)%%#4[$'!"#41404+5!X!1;$!3$0$61!?@J!R*&7645*5!Fc0$%1*46!]^*@-C_`!&6'!I552&60$!49!

I6*1*&+!@+&*A5!"&0d&7$5!]^*@-A_`b!

'C @4%*$5!49!1;$!)662&+!3$%4#1!49!1;$!V4*61!@4AA*11$$!94#!:$&#5!.,e!.M!&6'!.S!]04[$#*67!4%$#&1*465!94#!

,-..!14!,-.M`e!\;*0;!*60+2'$'!&A467!41;$#!*1$A5e!1;$!&2'*1$'!9*6&60*&+!51&1$A$615!&6'!1;$!

I6[$51A$61!82AA&#:!3$%4#1!49!F0d+$#!94#!$&0;!49!1;$!1;#$$!:$&#5b!

$C )%%+*0&1*46!14!1;$!82%#$A$!@42#1!49!N#*1*5;!@4+2AY*&!94#!&%%#4[&+!49!1;$!L$&#!.S!)662&+!3$%4#1!49!

1;$!V4*61!@4AA*11$$C!

9C H;$!'$0*5*46!49!1;$!E61&#*4!82%$#*4#!@42#1!49!V251*0$!*6!1;$!A&11$#!49!R*&66&!T42*5$!"&#5465!$1!&+C![C!

H;$!@&6&'*&6!3$'!@#455!840*$1:!$1!&+C!'&1$'!,,!E014Y$#!.<<<e!147$1;$#!\*1;!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!

@!8$11+$A$61!)7#$$A$61!&6'!B26'*67!)7#$$A$61!A&'$!&5!49!./!V26$!.<<<!0461&*6*67!80;$'2+$5!)!

1;#427;!R!$61*1+$'!1;$!H#&65925$'!?@J!"+&6e!1;$!?$A4%;*+*&0!?@J!"+&6e!1;$!B$'$#&+!"#4[*60*&+!

H$##*14#*&+!)55*51&60$!"#47#&A!94#!8$046'&#*+:>I69$01$'!I6'*[*'2&+5e!&6'!1;$!B26'*67!)7#$$A$61!]1;$!

^E,((.,+,#()@Q0,,+,#(_!4#!^-./#_`b!!

7C )!'&1&!9*+$!0461&*6*67!0+&55!A$AY$#!'&1&!&5!49!M-!)27251!,-.M!1;&1!\&5!%#4[*'$'!14!1;$!K$'*0&+!

K4'$+!W4#d*67!P#42%!]1;$!^RRST_`!147$1;$#!\*1;!&!9*+$!0461&*6*67!1;$!#$52+15!49!&!52#[$:!49!54A$!

49!1;$!0+&*A&615!#$7&#'*67!%#*4#!1#$&1A$615!&6'!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25b!!

;C Q2A$#425!$A&*+!04##$5%46'$60$!Y$1\$$6!54A$!4#!&++!49!1;$!V4*61!@4AA*11$$e!R$%&#1A$61!49!V251*0$e!

@#&\94#'!@+&55!)01*46!8$11+$A$615e!1;$!KKWPe!F0d+$#!&6'!K4#6$&2!8;$%$++!*6!\;*0;!Z2$#*$5!\$#$!

#&*5$'e!&65\$#5!%#4[*'$'!&6'!52%%+$A$61&+!*694#A&1*46!%#4[*'$'e!&++!49!\;*0;!\&5!0&##*$'!421!

\*1;*6!1;$!5%*#*1!49!044%$#&1*46!Y$1\$$6!F0d+$#!&6'!K4#6$&2!8;$%$++b!!

*C R#27!H#$&1A$615!94#!?$%&1*1*5!@e!&!52AA&#:!49!1#$&1A$615!&6'!%2Y+*0+:!&[&*+&Y+$!04515!%#$%&#$'!Y:!

34Y$#1!P$#[&*5e!KRe!"2Y+*0!?$&+1;!K$'*0&+!)'[*54#e!"2Y+*0!?$&+1;!)7$60:!49!@&6&'&b!&6'!

Page 37: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! ..!

fC )6!$A&*+!9#4A!)A&6'&!T&#40Z2$!46!N$;&+9!49!Q&1&5;&!T$0+$#0!49!?$&+1;!@&6&'&!1;&1!%#4[*'$'!

*694#A&1*46!&Y421![&#*425!1#$&1A$615!&6'!'#275!&%%#4[$'!94#!?$%&1*1*5!@!&6'!*60+2'*67!&!

5%#$&'5;$$1!%#$%&#$'!Y:!1;$!N2#$&2!49!P&51#4$61$#4+47:!49!?$&+1;!@&6&'&!%#4[*'*67!'$1&*+5!49!

[&#*425!&%%#4[$'!'#275!&6'!#$04AA$6'$'!1#$&1A$61!%#41404+5C!

S=C I6!&''*1*46!14!1;$!&Y4[$!'402A$615!&6'!'&1&e!\$!4Y1&*6$'!1;$!94++4\*67!'402A$615!&6'!*694#A&1*46!

9#4A!1;$!I61$#6$1!1;&1!\$!;&[$!25$'!*6!1;$!%#$%&#&1*46!49!1;*5!#$%4#1a!

&C ^"&1*$61!H*A$!@4515!&6'!E21>49>%40d$1!@4515!*6!?$%&1*1*5!@_e!@&#4+$!)C!B$'$#*04e!"#*50*++&!@C!?52e!K$+!

O#&f'$6e!F#*0!KC!L45;*'&e!O&#$6!FC!N#$A6$#e!)+&6!)C!W$*55e!B#&6d!?C!)6'$#546e!K2##&:!RC!O#&;6b!

T*[$#!I61$#6&1*46&+C!,-.,bM,]/`a(./>(,/!]46+*6$+*Y#&#:C\*+$:C04Al'4*l.-C....lfC.SU(>

M,M.C,-..C-,U,,Ccl&Y51#&01`b!!

YC ^R*51#*Y21*46!49!;$%&1*1*5!@![*#25!7$641:%$5!*6!@&6&'&a!3$52+15!9#4A!1;$!T@R@!8$61*6$+!?$&+1;!D6*1!

82#[$*++&60$!8:51$A_e!3O!@;&2';&#:e!";Re!K!H$%%$#e!KRe!8!F*5&&'&6:e!&6'!"&2+!3!P2++:e!KRb!@&6!V!

I69$01!R*5C!.<<<!V&6>B$Yb!.-].`a!/MX/=C!!]\\\C60Y*C6+AC6*;C74[l%A0l&#1*0+$5l"K@M,/-USUl`b!

0C ^P$6$1*0!J&#*&1*46!&6'!?@J!P$641:%*67_e!?$%&1*1*5!@$61#&+e!

]\\\C;$%&1*1*50$61#&+C04Al;0[l7$641:%$l7$641:%*67C;1A+`b!

'C H;#$$!41;$#!\$Y5*1$5!\$#$!25$'!14!4Y1&*6!'#27!0451!*694#A&1*46!&6'!*694#A&1*46!&Y421!'#275!Y$*67!

#$A4[$'!9#4A!1;$!A&#d$1!4#!%2++$'!9#4A!1;$!&%%#4[&+!%#40$55a!

]*` \\\C;$%&1*1*50C2\C$'2l%&7$l1#$&1A$61l'#275l54945Y2[*#>'#27!

]**` \\\C$7:#$7C04Al,-./l84945Y2[*#n0451C;1A+!

]***` \\\C%#4f$01*694#AC4#7l260&1$74#*h$'lY#$&d*67>6$\5>;0[>'#27>9&+'&%#$[*#>%2++$'>9#4A>52YA*55*46>

94#>9'&>&%%#4[&+lb!&6'!

$C W$$d+:!B*6&60*&+!81&1*51*05e!N&6d!49!@&6&'&e!,(!B$Y#2&#:!,-.Sb!

!

! !

Page 38: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .,!

=$ !"#$%#$&'()*($##")+!

SUC H;$!94++4\*67!*5!&!;*7;!+$[$+!52AA&#:!49!?$%&1*1*5!

@!'*5$&5$!%#47#$55*46!&5!*1!;&5!&!Y$&#*67!46!1;*5!

[&+2&1*46e!Y&5$'!46!42#!26'$#51&6'*67!49!1;$!

KKWP!3$%4#1C!!W$!;&[$!21*+*h$'!1;$5$!9*6'*675!*6!

1;*5![&+2&1*46C!

S(C )!%$#546!*69$01$'!\*1;!?$%&1*1*5!@!\*++!252&++:!

5;4\!5*765!49!1;$!*69$01*46!1;#427;!Y+44'!1$515C!!)!

62AY$#!49!%$4%+$!*69$01$'!#$04[$#e!%455*Y+:!

\*1;421!d64\*67!1;&1!1;$:!;&[$!Y$$6!*69$01$'e!Y21!

\*++!51*++!;&[$!5*765!49!1;$!'*5$&5$!*6!1;$*#!Y+44'C!!

H;*5!*5!#$9$##$'!14!*6!1;*5!#$%4#1!&5!3Q)!6$7&1*[$e!

4#!&5!B-]3Q)>`C!!W$!26'$#51&6'!1;&1!1;$#$!A&:!Y$!

&!#$A41$!0;&60$!49!1;$!'*5$&5$!#$'$[$+4%*67!*6!1;$!

9212#$C!!?4\$[$#e!Y41;!1;$!%#4f$01*465!*6!1;$!

KKWP!#$%4#1!&6'!1;$!0&+02+&1*465!25$'!*6!1;*5!

#$%4#1!*764#$!1;&1!%455*Y*+*1:C!!)!%$#546!&1!51&7$!

B-]3Q)>`!*5!0465*'$#$'!14!Y$!#$04[$#$'C!

S<C H;$!#&1$!&1!\;*0;!?$%&1*1*5!@!'$[$+4%5![&#*$5!9#4A!%$#546!14!%$#546C!!I1!0&6!1&d$!A&6:!:$&#5!Y$94#$!

54A$!%$4%+$!\*++!641*0$!1;&1!1;$:!&#$!5*0d!&6'!'*504[$#!1;$:!;&[$!1;$!'*5$&5$e!\;$#$&5!41;$#5!\*++!

%#47#$55!1;#427;!1;$![&#*425!51&7$5!A20;!A4#$!Z2*0d+:C!!H;$!%#47#$55*46!49!1;$!'*5$&5$!\&5!&552A$'!14!

Y$!5*A*+&#!*6!;&$A4%;*+*&05!&6'!646>;&$A4%;*+*&05C!!?4\$[$#e!'2$!14!1;$!:4267$#!&7$!&6'!;*7;$#!04>

*69$01*46!\*1;!?IJ!49!;&$A4%;*+*&05e!1;$#$!*5!&!7#$&1$#!0;&60$!49!'$[$+4%*67!0*##;45*5!&6'!49!'$&1;!9#4A!

?$%&1*1*5!@!&A467!;&$A4%;*+*&05!1;&6!1#&65925$'!0+&*A&615C!

/-C H;$!51&7$5!1;&1!&#$!A4'$++$'!*6!1;$!KKWP!#$%4#1!'*99$#!9#4A!1;$!+$[$+5!1;&1!&#$!25$'!94#!04A%$65&1*46!

26'$#!1;$!"+&6C!!N&5$'!2%46!&'[*0$!%#4[*'$'!Y:!1;$!&21;4#5!49!1;$!KKWP!#$%4#1e!F0d+$#!'$1$#A*6$'!&6!

&%%#4c*A&1$!#$+&1*465;*%!Y$1\$$6!1;$!+$[$+5!26'$#!1;$!"+&6!&6'!51&7$5!&5!A4'$++$'!*6!1;$!KKWP!

#$%4#1C!!W$!;&[$!21*+*h$'!1;$!5&A$!&552A$'!$Z2*[&+$60:!94#!%2#%45$5!49!1;*5!#$%4#1C!!W$!26'$#51&6'!1;&1!

646>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5!*5!&012&++:!*'$61*9*$'!*6!%&1*$615!54A$\;$#$!Y$1\$$6!51&7$5!B.!&6'!B,C!!N41;!

KKWP!&6'!F0d+$#!&552A$'!646>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5!4002#5!&1!0+*6*0&+!51&7$!B.e!$&#+*$#!1;&6!*1!\42+'!4002#!

94#!A451!%&1*$615C!!W$!;&[$!A&'$!1;$!5&A$!&552A%1*46C!!!

/.C I1!A&:!Y$!1;&1!1;*5!+*6d*67!49!T$[$+!M!]646>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5`!\*1;!51&7$!B.!*61#4'20$5!&!+$[$+!49!

0465$#[&1*5A!14!1;$!#$52+15C!!820;!0465$#[&1*5A!*5!%#$5$61!*6!&++!49!42#!#$52+15e!*60+2'*67!1;45$!*'$61*9*$'!

&5!^Y$51!$51*A&1$_C!!W$!;&[$!641!&11$A%1$'!14!&'f251!94#!1;*5!5*60$!1;$!+*6d&7$!Y$1\$$6!+$[$+!M!&6'!51&7$!

B.!&%%$&#5!14!Y$!0465*51$61!\*1;!1;$!\&:!1;$!0+&*A&61!'&1&!*5!%#$5$61$'!&6'!1;$!#$52+15!%#$5$61$'!*6!1;$!

KKWP!3$%4#1C!

/,C H;$!51&7$5!A4'$++$'!*6!1;$!KKWP!#$%4#1!&6'!1;$!+$[$+5!#$0476*h$'!26'$#!1;$!"+&6!&#$a!

In This Section….

We provide a brief summary of:

! the MMWG medical model and

the various stages of Hepatitis C

! Changes in the model from the

2010 version

! transition rates between stages

! treatment effect on transition

rates

! HIV co-infection effect on

progression of Hepatitis C

! develop an assumption for

recognition of excess HCV

mortality

Page 39: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .M!

!"#$%&KB&2&>%L".0.0:&*&M0:%":%&/."N%:&"46&O%P%$:&

RRST)E(/Q,)

RRST)E(/Q,)3,140'5('&#)

*&+5,#1/('&#)-./#)V,?,.1) *&+5,#1/('&#)-./#)3,140'5('&#)

B-]3Q)>`! B*Y#45*5!81&7$!-!X!3Q)!6$7&1*[$!

.! @+&*A&615!\;4!;&[$!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25!

8J@! 8%461&6$425!J*#&+!@+$&#&60$!

.! !

8J3! 8251&*6$'!J*#&+!3$5%465$! o! !

B-]3Q)p`! B*Y#45*5!81&7$!-!X!3Q)!%45*1*[$!

,! "@3!1$51!%45*1*[$!

B.! B*Y#45*5!81&7$!.! M! Q46>N#*'7*67!B*Y#45*5!

B,! B*Y#45*5!81&7$!,!

BM! B*Y#45*5!81&7$!M! S! N#*'7*67!B*Y#45*5!

BS! @*##;45*5! /! @*##;45*5!

?@@! ?$%&140$++2+&#!@&60$#! !=!

@&60$#!

R$04A%! R$04A%$65&1$'!0*##;45*5! T*[$#!'$04A%$65&1*46!

H#&65%+&61! T*[$#!H#&65%+&61! T*[$#!H#&65%+&61!

R$&1;! T*[$#!#$+&1$'!'$&1;! ! R$&1;!

o!!8J3!*5!1;$!51&1$!49!;&[*67!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25!&91$#!#$0$*[*67!1#$&1A$61C!!H;$!0+&*A&61i5!+$[$+!'4$5!641!0;&67$e!Y21!1;$:!#$A&*6![*#25!9#$$!&6'!\*++!641!%#47#$55!*6!1;$!'*5$&5$e!$c0$%1!&1!+$[$+!/e!0*##;45*5e!\;$#$!%#47#$55*46!4002#5!&1!;&+9!1;$!#$72+&#!#&1$C!!)6:!'&A&7$!'46$!Y:!1;$![*#25!*5!641!#$[$#5$'C!

/MC I6!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+e!1;$!'*5$&5$!\&5!A4'$++$'!#$0476*h*67!&!A&c*A2A!%#47#$55*46!49!46$!51&7$!*6!&!

:$&#C!!"#47#$55*46!14!52Y5$Z2$61!51&7$5!\42+'!4002#!*6!5$Z2$60$!$c0$%1!!

&C 46$!0&6!1#&65*1*46!9#4A!&6:!49!51&7$5!B.!14!BM!14!8J@!4#!8J3!&6'!9#4A!BS!14!8J3b!

YC 46$!0&6!1#&65*1*46!9#4A!&6:!49!1;$!51&7$5!B.!14!BS!14!?@@C!!!

/SC @;&#1!/S!5;4\5!1;$!%455*Y+$!5$Z2$60$5!49!'*5$&5$!%#47#$55*46!&5!#$0476*h$'!&6'!A4'$++$'!*6!1;$!#$%4#1C!!

I1!5;42+'!Y$!641$'!1;&1!1;$#$!A&:!Y$!41;$#!%&11$#65!14!1;$!'*5$&5$!%#47#$55*46e!*60+2'*67!#$7#$55*46!14!

&6!$&#+*$#!51&7$C!!?4\$[$#e!1;$:!\$#$!0465*'$#$'!14!;&[$!520;!&!+4\!%#4Y&Y*+*1:!&5!14!Y$!*AA&1$#*&+!14!

1;$!#$52+15C!!H;$!%$#0$61&7$5!5;4\6!46!1;$!0;&#1!&#$!1;$!KKWP!Y&5$+*6$!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!94#!&!1#&65925$'!

%$#546!49!1#&65*1*46*67!9#4A!46$!'*5$&5$!51&7$!14!&641;$#!4[$#!1;$!042#5$!49!&!:$&#C!!)5!'*50255$'!Y$+4\e!

1#&65*1*46!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!94#!?IJ!04>*69$01$'!%$4%+$!&#$!;*7;$#e!&6'!94#!1;45$!\;4!;&[$!Y$$6!5200$5592++:!

1#$&1$'!]8J3`!4#!&#$!51&125!8J@!]8%461&6$425!J*#&+!@+$&#&60$`!1;$!1#&65*1*46!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!&#$!+4\$#C!

! !

Page 40: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .S!

"#$%&!'(!)!*+,-$,-!.%/0%-,,+/1!$,!2/3-4-3!+1!&#-!2256!7-8/%&!

/CSg! .,C-g! .MC/g! .MC(g! UC(g! ./C,g!

.CUg! .CUg! .C-g! -C/-g! ! o!! MC<(g! ,C/-g!

!

! ! .(C,g!

! @&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$!,--<!X!,-..!94#!&++!&7$5!

! ! -CSgoo!

MCMg

! !(C=g!]:$&#!.`! !MC<g!]1;$#$&91$#`

!

H;*5!0;&#1!*5!1&d$6!9#4A!1;$!KKWP!3$%4#1C!!F&0;!Y4c!#$%#$5$615!&!;$&+1;!51&1$!94#!1;$!*6'*[*'2&+5!*69$01$'!'2$!14!Y+44'!1#&65925*46!*6!@&6&'&!Y$1\$$6!.<(=!&6'!.<<-C!F&0;!54+*'!&##4\!#$%#$5$615!%455*Y+$!1#&65*1*465!Y$1\$$6!;$&+1;!51&1$5!1;&1!A&:!4002#!$&0;!:$&#C!!H;$!%$#0$61&7$5!;&[$!Y$$6!&''$'!14!1;$!0;&#1!Y:!25!14!*6'*0&1$!1;$!&662&+!Y&5$+*6$!%#4Y&Y*+*1:!49!1#&65*1*46*67!Y$1\$$6!'*5$&5$!51&7$5C!

o!! )662&+!1#&65*1*46!#&1$5!14!?@@!'*99$#!Y:!51&7$a!! B-!! -C-.g!! B.! -C-.g!! B,! -C-.g!! BM! -C.-g!! BS! ,C/-g!! BS!]8J3`! .C,=g!! R$04A%! ,C/-g!!!oo!!H;$!-CSg!#&1$!49!1#&65*1*46!9#4A!R$04A%$65&1*46!14!H#&65%+&61!&6'!9#4A!?@@!14!1#&65%+&61!*5!*6!

&''*1*46!14!1;$!#&1$!49!1#&65*1*46!5;4\6!&Y4[$!*6!1;$!0;&#1!]./C,g!&6'!.(C,g`!94#!+*[$#!#$+&1$'!'$&1;C!

Page 41: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! ./!

4,+2'932>!7+,4!.,."9360+!+09'20/!('-101!

//C R2#*67!1;$!1*A$!1;&1!&!%$#546!;&5!?$%&1*1*5!@e!1;$:!0461*62$!14!Y$!52Yf$01!14!'$&1;!9#4A!0&25$5!

41;$#!1;&6!?$%&1*1*5!@C!!H;*5!*5!64!'*99$#$61!9#4A!41;$#5!\;4!'4!641!;&[$!?$%&1*1*5!@C!!N41;!1;$!

KKWP!#$%4#1!&6'!1;*5!#$%4#1!#$0476*h$!1;&1!%455*Y*+*1:!*6!1;$!%#4f$01*465!'46$C!!)!0+&*A&61!\;4!

'*$5!9#4A!646>+*[$#!#$+&1$'!0&25$5!#$A&*65!$61*1+$'!14!&6:!%&:A$615!A&'$!4#!'2$!Y&5$'!46!1;$!

51&7$!#$&0;$'!%#*4#!14!'$&1;e!Y21!*5!641!$61*1+$'!14!&6:!&''*1*46&+!%&:A$615!&5!&!#$52+1!49!'$&1;C!

/=C B4#!1;$!,-.M!A$'*0&+!A4'$+e!1;$!KKWP!&%%+*$'!A4#1&+*1:!#&1$5!'$#*[$'!9#4A!1;$!0+&*A&61!04;4#1!

04AY*6$'!\*1;!A4#1&+*1:!#&1$5!9#4A!1;$!@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$5!,--<>,-..C!!I6!42#!'*50255*465!\*1;!

1;$!&012&#*$5!9#4A!F0d+$#e!\$!&7#$$'!14!21*+*5$!1;$!@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$5!,--<>,-..!94#!&++!646>+*[$#!

#$+&1$'!A4#1&+*1:C!!H;$!*A%&01!49!1;*5!0;&67$!9#4A!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+!&552A%1*46!46!1;$!

%#4f$01*465!&6'!1;$!9*6&60*&+!#$52+15!*5!*AA&1$#*&+C!

0?(011!4,+2'932>!+09'20/!2,!280!(,./323,.!+0@-3+3.*!&9,,/!

2+'.17-13,.!

/UC K&6:!%$#5465!$61*1+$'!14!04A%$65&1*46!26'$#!1;$!"+&6!#$0$*[$'!&!Y+44'!1#&65925*46!'2#*67!1;$!

%$#*4'!.<(=!14!.<<-C!!H;$!,-.-!KKWP!#$%4#1!'*50255$'!1;$!%455*Y+$!$c*51$60$!49!$c0$55!

A4#1&+*1:!*6!#$+&1*46!14!&[$#&7$!%4%2+&1*46!A4#1&+*1:!&5!&!#$52+1!49!1;$!046'*1*46!1;&1!7&[$!#*5$!14!

1;$!6$$'!94#!1;$!1#&65925*46C!!I1!\&5!0460+2'$'!1;&1!&6:!520;!$c0$55!A4#1&+*1:!\42+'!#$'20$!14!

641;*67!4#!&6!*AA&1$#*&+!+$[$+!'2#*67!1;$!1$6!:$&#5!94++4\*67!1;$!1#&65925*46C!!8*60$!1;$!A451!

#$0$61!Y+44'!1#&65925*46!1;&1!042+'!Y$!#$+&1$'!14!1;$!1#&65A*55*46!49!?$%&1*1*5!@!94#!*69$01$'!

0+&*A&615!26'$#!1;*5!"+&6!4002##$'!A4#$!1;&6!.-!:$&#5!&74e!1;$!%455*Y*+*1:!49!$c0$55!A4#1&+*1:!

9&014#5!26#$+&1$'!14!?$%&1*1*5!@!*5!*764#$'C!

/(C I1!*5!%455*Y+$!1;&1!&!0+&*A&61!26'$#!1;$!"+&6!A*7;1!;&[$!#$0$*[$'!&!52Y5$Z2$61!Y+44'!1#&65925*46!

&6'!A&:!Y$!52Yf$01!14!$c0$55!A4#1&+*1:!&5!&!#$52+1!49!1;$!046'*1*46!1;&1!7&[$!#*5$!14!1;&1!

1#&65925*46C!!H;*5!%455*Y*+*1:!;&5!Y$$6!*764#$'!5*60$!1;$!A4#1&+*1:!1&Y+$!25$'!94#!1;*5!#$%4#1!

#$9+$015!520;!*552$5!Y:![*#12$!49!Y$*67!&!@&6&'*&6!%4%2+&1*46!A4#1&+*1:!1&Y+$C!

2+'.1323,.!5+,&'&3932301!

/<C H;$!%#47#$55!49!&!0+&*A&61!1;#427;!1;$![&#*425!'*5$&5$!51&7$5!*5!A4'$++$'!25*67!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5C!!

H;$!1#&65*1*46!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!25$'!*6!42#!0&+02+&1*465!&#$!1&d$6!9#4A!1;$!KKWP!3$%4#1!&6'!&#$!1;$!

5&A$!&5!\$#$!25$'!*6!1;$!KKWP!3$%4#1C!!H;$5$!#$%#$5$61!1;$!%#4Y&Y*+*1:!49!1#&65*1*46!14!&641;$#!

'*5$&5$!51&7$!'2#*67!1;$!042#5$!49!46$!:$&#C!!!

=-C I6!,-.-!&6'!%#*4#!KKWP!3$%4#15e!1;$!KKWP!$51&Y+*5;$'!1;$!Y&5$+*6$!1#&65*1*46!#&1$5!&5!&!Y+$6'!

49!1;$!$c%$#*$60$!49!1;$!0+&*A&61!04;4#1!&6'!#$52+15!49!%2Y+*5;$'!512'*$5!9#4A!&#426'!1;$!\4#+'C!!

W$!0465*'$#$'!*6!,-.-!1;&1!1;$!Y&5$+*6$!#&1$5!+*d$+:!*60+2'$'!&!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465C!!

Page 42: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .=!

W$!21*+*5$'!1;$!Y&5$+*6$!,-.-!#&1$5!&5!1;$!1#&65*1*46!#&1$5!94#!1;$!+*&Y*+*1*$5!*60+2'*67!&!%#4[*5*46!

94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465C!!B4#!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!+*&Y*+*1*$5e!\$!#$%+&0$'!1;$!Y&5$+*6$!1#&65*1*46!#&1$5!

Y$1\$$6!51&7$5!B-!&6'!BS!\*1;!#&1$5!'$[$+4%$'!Y:!1;$!KKWP!9#4A!1;$!0+&*A&61!04;4#1C!!!

=.C W*1;!1;$!,-.M!KKWP!3$%4#1e!1;$!Y&5$+*6$!1#&65*1*46!#&1$5!\$#$!'$1$#A*6$'!Y&5$'!46+:!46!1;$!

$c%$#*$60$!49!1;$!0+&*A&61!04;4#1C!!W$!0465*'$#!1;$5$!,-.M!#&1$5!&5!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!1#&65*1*465!

%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5C!!!

=,C B4#!%2#%45$5!49!1;$![&+2&1*46!A4'$+e!&!0+&*A&61!\;4!$c%$#*$60$5!8J@!4#!8J3!*5!1#&65*1*46$'!14!

51&125!8J@!Y21!#$1&*65!1;$*#!%#*4#!'*5$&5$!+$[$+C!!H;$!%#40$55!49!8J3!&6'!8J@!'4$5!641!26'4!&6:!

'&A&7$!1;&1!;&'!%#$[*425+:!4002##$'!&6'!*1!*5!1;$#$94#$!&%%#4%#*&1$!14!#$0476*5$!1;&1!&!0+&*A&61!

&1!8J@!]BS`!A&:!51*++!;&[$!&!'*5&Y*+*1:!&6'!9*+$!&!0+&*A!94#!T455!49!I604A$!4#!94#!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!*6!

1;$!?4A$C!!)!0+&*A&61!&1!8J@]B.`!*5!A20;!+$55!+*d$+:!14!;&[$!&!9212#$!'*5&Y*+*1:!&6'!54!\*++!+*d$+:!

6$[$#!;&[$!&!0+&*A!94#!T455!49!I604A$!4#!94#!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!*6!1;$!?4A$C!!

=MC H;$#$!&#$!1\4!\&:5!1;&1!&!%$#546!0&6!$c%$#*$60$!8J@!4#!8J3C!!)!5A&++!%$#0$61&7$!49!0+&*A&615!

\*++!'4!54!5%461&6$425+:!\*1;421!1#$&1A$61!$&0;!:$&#C!!K451!0+&*A&615!\*++!'4!54!&5!&!#$52+1!49!

Y$*67!5200$5592++:!1#$&1$'!\*1;!46$!49!1;$!?@J!'#27!#$7*A$65C!!H;$!%#*4#![$#5*465!49!1;$!A4'$+!

'*'!641!#$0476*5$!8J@!&6'!8J3!41;$#!1;&6!&5!&!#$52+1!49!1#$&1A$61e!&5!*1!\&5!0465*'$#$'!14!Y$!

*AA&1$#*&+C!!H;$!,-.M!A4'$+!;&5!'$1$#A*6$'!1#&65*1*46!#&1$5!94#!8J@!&6'!8J3!4002##*67!

5%461&6$425+:!&5!\$++!&5!Y:!1#$&1A$61C!

=SC )!0+&*A&61!\;4!$c%$#*$60$5!8J@!4#!8J3!5%461&6$425+:!*5!0465*'$#$'!&5!02#$'!&6'!*5!&552A$'!14!

641!&'[&60$!92#1;$#!*6!1;$!'*5$&5$C!

=/C H;$!1#$&1A$61!49!8J@!&6'!8J3!;&5!0;&67$'!9#4A!1;$!,-.-!&6'!%#*4#![&+2&1*465C!!)!0+&*A&61!\;4!*5!

5200$5592++:!1#$&1$'!&1!51&7$5!B-!14!BM!*5!0465*'$#$'!&5!02#$'!&6'!;&5!&!h$#4!%#4Y&Y*+*1:!49!

1#&65*1*46*67!14!&!;*7;$#!'*5$&5$!51&7$C!!W;*+$!1;$:!\*++!641!&'[&60$!*6!1;$!'*5$&5$e!1;$:!A&:!51*++!

$c%$#*$60$!41;$#!+*[$#!#$+&1$'!*552$5e!520;!&5!'*5&Y*+*1:!4#!$c0$55!?@J!A4#1&+*1:C!!)!0+&*A&61!\;4!

*5!5200$5592++:!1#$&1$'!&1!51&7$!BS!;&5!1;$!1#&65*1*46!#&1$5!14!R$04A%$65&1*46!#$'20$'!14!;&+9!49!

1;$!Y&5$+*6$!1#&65*1*46!#&1$C!!I6!%#*4#![&+2&1*465e!0+&*A&615!\;4!;&'!8J@!4#!8J3!\$#$!0465*'$#$'!

&5!;&[*67!&!#$'20$'!%#4Y&Y*+*1:!49!&'[&60*67!*6!1;$!'*5$&5$e!\*1;!1;$!%#4Y&Y*+*1:!49!&'[&60*67!

$Z2&+!14!.-g!49!1;$!%#4Y&Y*+*1:!1;&1!&%%+*$'!14!&!%$#546!\;4!;&'!641!Y$$6!5200$5592++:!1#$&1$'C!

==C H;$!Y&5*0!1#&65*1*46!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!&#$!9#4A!H&Y+$!.,!49!1;$!KKWP!#$%4#1C!!H;$!Y&5$+*6$!

%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!#$%#$5$61!1;$!A$&6!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!&6'!&#$!1;$![&+2$5!25$'!94#!1;$!Y41;!1;$!Y$51!

$51*A&1$!&6'!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!+*&Y*+*1*$5!*6!1;*5!#$%4#1C!!H;$!1#&65*1*46!

%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!&#$!&'f251$'!94#!1;$!$99$015!49!5200$5592+!1#$&1A$61!&6'!94#!1;$!$99$015!49!?IJ!46!

9*Y#45*5!%#47#$55*46!*6!1;$!5&A$!A&66$#!&5!\&5!'46$!*6!1;$!KKWP!3$%4#1C!!H;$!Y&5*0!1#&65*1*46!

%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!&#$a!

Page 43: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .U!

!"#$%&((&)&!-"4:0.0+4&F".%:&D+-&/04N$A&Q4D%=.%6&2&BI'R&@+6%$&50.,&=+9L"-".0P%:&D-+9&BI'I&"46&BIIS&

!0&+)E(/Q,) :&)E(/Q,)

:0/#1'('&#)U/(,1))ABBL))

:0/#1'('&#)U/(,1)

=,1()>1('+/(,)ABCB))

:0/#1'('&#)U/(,1))

ABCD)

B-]3Q)>`! B.! -C-g! -C-g! -C-g!

8J@o! B.! 6l&! 6l&! -C-g!

B-]3Q)p`! B-]3Q)>`! ,C-g! .CUg! .CUg!

B.! 8J@! 6l&! 6l&! .CUg!

B,! 8J@! 6l&! 6l&! .C-g!

BM! 8J@! 6l&! 6l&! -C/g!

B-]3Q)p`! B.! =C=g! ,C<g! /CSg!

B.! B,! .-CSg! ..C(g! .,C-g!

B,! BM! .=C,g! .MCUg! .MC/g!

BM! BS! .(CSg! .-CMg! .MC(g!

BS! R$04A%$65&1*46! /C/g! =C/g! UC(g!

R$04A%$65&1*46! H#&65%+&61! MCMg! MCMg! -CSg!

B.! ?@@! -C-.g! -C-.g! -C-.g!

B,! ?@@! -C-.g! -C-.g! -C-.g!

BM! ?@@! -C.g! -C.g! -C.g!

BS! ?@@! MC.g! MCMg! ,C/g!

R$04A%$65&1*46! ?@@! 6l&! 6l&! ,C/g!

?@@! H#&65%+&61! >! .-C-g! -CSg!

<'' 3=9')+'4"/+)1$&$1'!"')/4>?1$'3=@'A"&',?&,"+$+'"A'!%)+'!-.>$8'';'4>-)5-/!'-!'3=9'+!-#$+'7B'!"'7C')+'-++?5$1'!"'

/"!'-10-/4$'!"'-'%)#%$&'1)+$-+$'+!-#$8'';'4>-)5-/!'-!'3=9'7D')+'-++?5$1'!"'!&-/+)!)"/'!"'E$4"5,$/+-!$1'-!'

%->A'!%$'.-+$>)/$'&-!$'FGHI'"A'J8KIL'+%"(/'-."0$8'''

=UC W*1;!1;$!$c0$%1*46!49!646>?@J!#$+&1$'!A4#1&+*1:!]@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$5e!,--<>,-..e!1;&1!&#$!Y&5$'!

46!&7$!&6'!7$6'$#`e!1;$!1#&65*1*46!#&1$5!'4!641![&#:!Y:!&7$e!7$6'$#!4#!'2#&1*46!49!*69$01*46C!

=(C H;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!1#&65*1*46!#&1$5!94#!,-.M!;&[$!7$6$#&++:!*60#$&5$'!9#4A!1;45$!25$'!*6!,-.-!

\*1;!1;$!$c0$%1*46!49!B,!14!BMe!&6'!1;$!1#&65*1*465!14!H#&65%+&61!&6'!BS!14!?@@C!!H;$!46+:!0;&67$5!

1;&1!&#$!5*76*9*0&61!&#$!9#4A!B-]3Q)p`!14!B.!\;*0;!&+A451!'42Y+$'!&6'!1#&65*1*465!14!H#&65%+&61!

\;*0;!&#$!64\!&+A451!6$7+*7*Y+$C!!

;DD%=.&+D&.09%&+4&D0#-+:0:&L-+N-%::0+4&

=<C H;$!,-.-!KKWP!3$%4#1!51&1$5a!^)641;$#!0460$#6!CCC!*5!#$+&1$'!14!1;$!&552A%1*46!1;&1!?@J!

%&1*$615!&#$!;4A47$6425!&6'!;&[$!5*A*+&#!9*Y#45*5!%#47#$55*46!#&1$5C!!F[$6!\*1;*6!*6'*[*'2&+5e!

%#47#$55*46!#&1$5!A&:![&#:!&5!&!92601*46!49!9*Y#45*5!51&7$!&6'!&7$C!!J&#*&1*46!&0#455!*6'*[*'2&+5!

;&5!&+54!Y$$6!046[*60*67+:!'$A4651#&1$'C!!"4:6&#'!$1!&+Ce!94#!$c&A%+$e!5277$515!1;&1!1;$#$!&#$!&1!

Page 44: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .(!

+$&51!1;#$$!%4%2+&1*465!*6!1$#A5!49!'*5$&5$!%#47#$55*46a!#&%*'e!*61$#A$'*&1$!&6'!5+4\!

%#47#$554#5C_!]KKWP!,-.-!3$%4#1e!%&7$!,=`!

U-C ^)5!1;$!q#&%*'!%#47#$554#5i!'$%&#1e!1;$!A$&6!#&1$!94#!%#47#$55*46!94#!1;$!#$5*'2&+!04;4#1!\*++!9&++C_!

]KKWP!,-.-!3$%4#1e!%&7$!,U`!

U.C ^I9!1#&65*1*46!#&1$5!9&++!4[$#!1*A$e!&5!46$!\42+'!$c%$01!\*1;!1;$!0;&67*67!04A%45*1*46!49!9*Y#45*5!

;$&+1;!51&1$5!]9&51!%#47#$554#5!'$%&#1!A4#$!Z2*0d+:!+$&[*67!A4#$!5+4\!%#47#$554#5!4[$#!1*A$`e!1;$!

A4'$+!&5!02##$61+:!5%$0*9*$'!A&:!4[$#51&1$!%#47#$55*46!#&1$5!*6!1;$![$#:!+467!1$#AC_!]KKWP!

,-.-!3$%4#1e!%&7$!,U`!

U,C I1!;&5!Y$$6!46!&[$#&7$!&Y421!,,!:$&#5!5*60$!1;$!0+&55!0461#&01$'!?@JC!!W$!0&6641!'$1$#A*6$!9#4A!

1;$!KKWP!3$%4#1!\;&1!%$#0$61&7$!49!1;$!#&%*'!%#47#$554#5!\42+'!Y$!$c%$01$'!14!;&[$!#$&0;$'!

+$[$+!=!4#!'*$'e!54!*1!*5!641!%455*Y+$!14!$51*A&1$!1;$!$99$01!49!&!%455*Y+$!'$0#$&5$!*6!1#&65*1*46!#&1$5!

94#!1;$!9212#$C!!

UMC H;$!#$0$61!*61#4'201*46!49!6$\!'#275!94#!1#$&1*67!?@J!*5!$c%$01$'!14!;&[$!&!5*76*9*0&61!$99$01!46!

1;$!9212#$!49!1;$!'*5$&5$e!\*1;!&!5*76*9*0&61!62AY$#!49!0+&*A&615!$c%$01$'!14!Y$!02#$'C!!W*1;!9$\$#!

0+&*A&615!#$A&*6*67!\*1;!?@J!&6'!52Yf$01!14!1;$!92++!1#&65*1*46!$99$015e!9212#$!0;&67$5!*6!

1#&65*1*46!#&1$5!&#$!+*d$+:!14!;&[$!A20;!+$55!49!&6!*A%&01!46!1;$!926'i5!+*&Y*+*1*$5C!!!

;DD%=.&+D&.-%".9%4.&+4&D0#-+:0:&L-+N-%::0+4&

USC H;$#$!&#$!&!62AY$#!49!1#$&1A$615!&[&*+&Y+$!94#!?$%&1*1*5!@!1;&1e!*9!5200$5592+e!\*++!5+4\!'4\6!4#!

&##$51!%#47#$55*46!49!1;$!'*5$&5$C!!I6!1;$!%&51!1;#$$!:$&#5e!&!62AY$#!49!6$\!'#275!;&[$!Y$$6!

&%%#4[$'!1;&1!;&[$!5*76*9*0&61+:!*A%#4[$'!1#$&1A$61!%#47645*5!14!1;45$!%#$[*425+:!&[&*+&Y+$!

]Y40$%#$[*#e!+$'*%&5[*#!&6'!5*A$%#$[*#`.C!!H;$#$!&#$!54A$!&''*1*46&+!'#275!\;*0;!A&:!Y$!

&%%#4[$'!Y:!?$&+1;!@&6&'&!]'&0+&1&5[*#e!'&5&Y2[*#e!4AY*1&5[*#e!%&#*1&%#$[*#!&6'!#*146&[*#`!1;&1!

&#$!&61*0*%&1$'!14!92#1;$#!*A%#4[$!1;$!42104A$!49!1#$&1A$615C!

U/C H;$5$!6$\!'#275!&#$!1&d$6!*6!&!%*++!94#A!#&1;$#!1;&6!Y:!*6f$01*46e!;&[$!+$55!5$[$#$!5*'$>$99$015!

'2#*67!1#$&1A$61e!;&[$!&!5;4#1$#!#$04AA$6'$'!'2#&1*46!94#!1#$&1A$61!&6'!;&[$!&!5*76*9*0&61+:!

;*7;$#!$99*0&0:!#&1$!1;&6!1;$!%#$[*425!1#$&1A$615C!!H;$!A$'*0&+!A4'$+!;&5!#$0476*5$'!1;$5$!6$\!

'#275!\*1;!&!A&f4#!0;&67$!14!1;$!&552A%1*465!94#!9212#$!1#$&1A$615C!

U=C E6+:!46$!9212#$!1#$&1A$61!%$#!0+&*A&61!*5!&552A$'C!!)!0+&*A&61!\;4!#$0$*[$'!1#$&1A$61!%#*4#!14!

,-.S!1;&1!\&5!641!5200$5592+!*5!$+*7*Y+$!94#!&!9212#$!1#$&1A$61C!!?4\$[$#e!&!0+&*A&61!\;4!#$0$*[$5!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

.!! H\4!49!1;$!'#275!#$9$#$60$'!*6!1;$!KKWP!3$%4#1!;&[$!5*60$!Y$$6!\*1;'#&\6!X!9&+'$%#$[*#!\&5!\*1;'#&\6!9#4A!1;$!&%%#4[&+!%#40$55!Y:!1;$!A&629&012#$#!&6'!1$+&%#$[*#!\&5!\*1;'#&\6!9#4A!1;$!A&#d$1!&91$#!;&[*67!#$0$*[$'!&%%#4[&+C!

Page 45: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .<!

1#$&1A$61!&91$#!.!V&62&#:!,-.S!&6'!\;4!*5!641!02#$'!*5!&552A$'!14!6$[$#!#$0$*[$!&641;$#!

1#$&1A$61C!

UUC H;$!#&1$!49!1#$&1A$61e!1:%$!49!'#27!&552A$'!14!Y$!25$'!&6'!$99*0&0:!'*99$#!Y$1\$$6!1;45$!\;4!

;&[$!641!#$0$*[$'!1#$&1A$61!*6!1;$!%&51!]1#$&1A$61!6&r[$`!&6'!1;45$!\*1;!%&51!1#$&1A$615!

]%#$[*425+:!1#$&1$'`!&5!\$++!&5!Y$1\$$6!1;45$!04*69$01$'!&6'!641!04*69$01$'!\*1;!?IJC!

U(C H;$!#&1$!49!1#$&1A$61e!1:%$!49!1#$&1A$61!#$0$*[$'!&6'!$99*0&0:!49!1;$!'*99$#$61!1#$&1A$615![&#*$5!

Y&5$'!46!0$#1&*6!0;&#&01$#*51*05!49!1;$!0+&*A&615C!!H&Y+$!U<!52AA&#*5$5!1;$!1#$&1A$61!

%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!94#!,-.MC!!I1!*5!&552A$'!1;&1!1#$&1A$61!*5!46+:!0465*'$#$'!94#!0+&*A&615!&1!51&7$5!

B-]3Q)p`!14!BSC!!Q4!1#$&1A$61!*5!7*[$6!14!0+&*A&615!&1!B-]3Q)>`e!R$04A%$65&1*46!4#!?@@C!

U<C H;$!1#$&1A$61!#&1$5!5$1!421!46!1;$!KKWP!3$%4#1!7&[$!1;$!%$#0$61&7$!49!0+&*A&615!1;&1!&#$!

&552A$'!14!#$0$*[$!1#$&1A$61!&1!54A$!1*A$!'2#*67!1;$!%$#*4'!,-.S!14!,-.(C!!I6!42#!'*50255*465!

\*1;!1;$!&012&#*$5!9#4A!F0d+$#e!\$!&7#$$'!14!21*+*5$!&662&+!#&1$5!49!1#$&1A$61!&5!5$1!421!*6!H&Y+$!

U<C!!H;$5$!#&1$5!\;$6!&%%+*$'!4[$#!1;$!9*[$!:$&#5!,-.S!14!,-.(!*60+25*[$!#$52+1!*6!1;$!5&A$!

%$#0$61&7$!49!0+&*A&615!#$0$*[*67!1#$&1A$61!&5!5$1!421!*6!1;$!,-.M!KKWP!3$%4#1C!

!"#$%&ST&2&!-%".9%4.&U-+#"#0$0.0%:&2&BI'R&

)

:0,/(+,#()W/X?,))

S'(;&"()<YZ)

:0,/(+,#()W/X?,))

S'(;)<YZ)

-0,?'&"1.[):0,/(,$))

S'(;&"()<YZ)

-0,?'&"1.[):0,/(,$))

S'(;)<YZ)

:0,/(+,#()0/(,)F5,0)/##"+G) MSC-g! .<CMg! M(C,g! .UC/g!

-,04,#()&2):0,/(+,#(1)"1'#Q)\) ) ) ) )

• "FP>IBQl3NJ! -g! -g! -g! -g!

• "FP>IBQl3NQ!Y&5$'!1#*%+$!1;$#&%:! .SCMg! (CMg! UC.g! (CMg!

• 84945Y2[*#>Y&5$'!'42Y+$1! /-C-g! ,/g! M/CUg! (CMg!

• M'!#$7*A$6!%+25!3NJ! M/CUg! ==CUg! /UC.g! (MCSg!

:0,/(+,#()>22'4/4[) ) ) ) )

• "FP>IBQl3NJ! S/C/g! MUC.g! MUCSg! M-C/g!

• "FP>IBQl3NQ!Y&5$'!1#*%+$!1;$#&%:! U-C-g! UMC/g! /MC(g! /MC(g!

• 84945Y2[*#>Y&5$'!'42Y+$1! <SC=g! (-C,g! </CSg! (-C<g!

• M'!#$7*A$6!%+25!3NJ! <=C,g! (.C=g! <=CMg! (.CUg!

@##"/.)*"0,)U/(,]) M.C,g! ./C=g! M/C/g! .MC<g!

I^_,/0)*"0,)U/(,]]) MB`Aa) ID`Ba) MJ`Ia) JM`Na)

o! H;$!&662&+!02#$!#&1$!*5!1;$!%$#0$61!49!&++!0+&*A&615!*6!&!9212#$!:$&#!\;4!;&'!641!#$0$*[$'!&!1#$&1A$61!

5*60$!.!V&62&#:!,-.S!\;4!&#$!&552A$'!14!Y$!02#$'!1;#427;!1&d*67!'#27!1#$&1A$61C!H;$!A$'*0&+!A4'$+!

&552A$5!1;&1!46+:!46$!1#$&1A$61!#$7*A$6!\*++!Y$!7*[$6!%$#!0+&*A&61!46!&6'!&91$#!.!V&62&#:!,-.Se!

#$7&#'+$55!49!&6:!1#$&1A$615!#$0$*[$'!%#*4#!14!1;&1C!

oo! H;$!/>L$&#!@2#$!#&1$!*5!1;$!%$#0$61&7$!49!&++!0+&*A&615!\;4!&#$!&552A$'!14!Y$!02#$'!'2#*67!1;$!%$#*4'!

,-.S!14!,-.(C!

Page 46: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! ,-!

(-C )!0+&*A&61!\;4!;&5!Y$$6!02#$'!%#*4#!14!'*5$&5$!51&7$!BS!]+$[$+!/`!#$A&*65!&1!1;$*#!&11&*6$'!

'*5$&5$!+$[$+e!Y21!*5!&552A$'!14!641!&'[&60$!14!&!;*7;$#!+$[$+C!!?4\$[$#e!&!0+&*A&61!\;4!*5!02#$'!

&1!51&7$!BS!]0*##;45*5e!+$[$+!/`e!*5!&552A$'!14!&'[&60$!14!R$04A%$65&1*46!&6'!?@@!&1!;&+9!1;$!

Y&5$+*6$!#&1$,C!

(.C H4\&#'5!1;$!$6'!49!42#!\4#de!\$!Y$0&A$!&\&#$!1;&1!1;$!*61#4'201*46!49!1;$!6$\!'#27!1;$#&%*$5!

A*7;1!#$52+1!*6!+*11+$e!*9!&6:e!4674*67!25$!49!1;$!"FP>IBQl3NJ!Y&5$'!1#*%+$!1;$#&%:C!!I651$&'e!1;$!

A4#$!$c%$65*[$!84945Y2[*#>Y&5$'!'42Y+$1!&6'!1;$!MR!#$7*A$6!]\*1;!4#!\*1;421!#*Y&[*#*6`!A&:!Y$!

21*+*5$'C!!W$!&#$!641!*6!&!%45*1*46!14!'$1$#A*6$!&6!&+1$#6&1$!&552A%1*46!94#!1;$!%$#0$61!49!

1#$&1A$615!25*67!$&0;!'#27!#$7*A$6!&6'!54!\$!;&[$!21*+*5$'!1;$!5&A$!&552A%1*465!$A%+4:$'!Y:!

1;$!KKWPC!!I6!42#!4%*6*46e!1;$!*60#$&5$'!0451!49!1;$!'#275!\*++!+*d$+:!Y$!54A$\;&1!A4#$!1;&6!

4995$1!Y:!1;$!#$'201*46!*6!9212#$!Y$6$9*15!'2$!14!1;$!;*7;$#!$99*0&0:!#&1$5!49!1;$!A4#$!$c%$65*[$!

'#275C!!W$!1;$#$94#$!Y$+*$[$!1;&1!1;$!+*&Y*+*1*$5!%#$5$61$'!*6!1;*5!#$%4#1!&#$!5+*7;1+:!4[$#51&1$'C!!

(,C B4#!1;$!,-.-!KKWP!A4'$+e!1#$&1A$61!\&5!&552A$'!14!Y$!0465*'$#$'!94#!%&1*$615!&1!942#!51&7$5!>!

B.!1;#427;!BSC!!)1!$&0;!49!1;45$!51&7$5!&!%$#0$61&7$!49!1;$!%&1*$615!\$#$!&552A$'!14!#$0$*[$!

1#$&1A$61!$&0;!:$&#e!&6'!&!%$#0$61&7$!49!1;45$!1#$&1$'!#$5%46'!5200$5592++:!14!1;$!1#$&1A$61C!!)!

%$#546!042+'!#$0$*[$!A4#$!1;&6!46$!#$7*A$6!49!1#$&1A$61C!!H;45$!%$#0$61&7$5!\$#$a!

!"#$%&VB&)&!-%".9%4.&U-+#"#0$0.0%:&)&BI'I&

E(/Q,)

-,04,#(/Q,)&2)/..)5/(',#(1)0,4,'?'#Q)(0,/(+,#()'#)/)[,/0)

E"44,112".)0,15&#1,)/+&#Q)(;&1,)(0,/(,$)

E"44,112".)0,15&#1,)

/+&#Q)/..)5/(',#(1)

B.! .-C-g! S<C-g! SC<g!

B,! .-C-g! S<C-g! SC<g!

BM! .-C-g! S<C-g! SC<g!

BS! .-C-g! M.C-g! MC.g!

(MC B4#!,-.-e!%&1*$615!\;4!'*'!641!#$0$*[$!1#$&1A$61!4#!\;$#$!1;$!1#$&1A$61!\&5!641!5200$5592+!\$#$!

$+*7*Y+$!94#!1#$&1A$61!&7&*6!$&0;!:$&#!&6'!&1!52Y5$Z2$61!51&7$5!\;$#$!1#$&1A$61!*5!499$#$'C!!H;$!

KKWP!A4'$+!%#4[*'$'!94#!1#$&1A$61!14!Y$!7*[$6!14!&!5A&++$#!%$#0$61&7$!49!%&1*$615!&91$#!&7$!=/C!!

I6!H&Y+$!(,e!1;$!.-g!$+*7*Y+$!94#!1#$&1A$61!\&5!#$'20$'!14!MCMg!&1!$&0;!49!1;$!51&7$5!94#!1;45$!

4[$#!&7$!=/C!!!

(SC )!%&1*$61!\;4!\&5!5200$5592++:!1#$&1$'!\&5!&552A$'!14!Y$!52Yf$01!14!1#&65*1*46!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!&1!

&%%#4c*A&1$+:!.-g!49!1;$!Y&5$+*6$!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!5;4\6!94#!,-.-!*6!H&Y+$!==!&Y4[$C!!H;*5!#$'20$'!

%#4Y&Y*+*1:!&%%+*$'!&1!&++!51&7$5!2%!14!+*[$#!'$04A%$65&1*46!94#!1;$!%&1*$61i5!9212#$!+*9$C!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

,!! H;$!94#A2+&!25$'!*5a!!.!>!FG"]-C/!o!TQ].!>!Y&5$+*6$!%#4Y&Y*+*1:``C!

Page 47: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! ,.!

;DD%=.&+D&>Q?&+4&D0#-+:0:&L-+N-%::0+4&

(/C ?IJ!04>*69$01*46!;&5!&6!*A%&01!46!1;$!9*Y#45*5!%#47#$55*46!#&1$!49!?$%&1*1*5!@C!!?&$A4%;*+*&05!\;4!

&#$!04>*69$01$'!\*1;!?IJ!&#$!52Yf$01!14!&!'*99$#*67!5$1!49!1#&65*1*46!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!9#4A!51&7$5!

B-]3Q)p`!14!'$04A%$65&1*46C!!H;$!Y&5$+*6$!1#&65*1*46!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!&#$!*60#$&5$'!Y:!&!9&014#!49!

,C.,,CM!!H;*5!*5!260;&67$'!9#4A!1;$!,-.-!&552A%1*46C!

;DD%=.&+D&>Q?&=+)04D%=.0+4&+4&L+LC$".0+4&9+-."$0.A&

(=C )!62AY$#!49!0+&*A&615!&#$!*69$01$'!\*1;!Y41;!?$%&1*1*5!@!&6'!?IJC!!K451!49!1;$5$!&#$!&A467!1;$!

;&$A4%;*+*&0!04;4#1e!49!\;*0;!&Y421!,/g!49!1;$!&+*[$!;&$A4%;*+*&0!0+&*A&615!&6'!M(g!49!&++!

;&$A4%;*+*&0!0+&*A&615!&#$!04*69$01$'!\*1;!?IJC!!I1!*5!%#$52A$'!26'$#!1;$!"+&6!1;&1!1;$!?IJ!

*69$01*46!\&5!'2$!14!&!Y+44'!1#&65925*46C!!H;$!%#$5$60$!49!?IJ!*5!&552A$'!14!*60#$&5$!1;$!646>

+*[$#!'$&1;!A4#1&+*1:!#&1$5!Y:!&!9&014#!49!=C,S!]5&A$!&5!,-.-`C!!H;*5!*5!#$0476*h$'!*6!1;*5!#$%4#1!

46+:!94#!;&$A4%;*+*&05C!

(UC E9!1;$!d64\6!1#&65925$'!04;4#1e!&Y421!s!49!46$!%$#0$61!&#$!04>*69$01$'!\*1;!?IJC!!H;$!%4%2+&1*46!

A4#1&+*1:!1&Y+$!25$'!*6!Y41;!1;$!KKWP!3$%4#1!&6'!1;*5!#$%4#1!*5!Y&5$'!46!%4%2+&1*46!51&1*51*05!

1;&1!*60+2'$!%$4%+$!\*1;!?IJl)IR8C!!)5!&!#$52+1e!\$!0&6!&552A$!1;&1!&6:!$c0$55!A4#1&+*1:!'2$!14!

1;$!%#$5$60$!49!?IJ!&A467!1;$!1#&65925$'!04;4#1!*5!&'$Z2&1$+:!*60+2'$'!*6!1;$!%4%2+&1*46!

A4#1&+*1:!1&Y+$!25$'C!

9370!0?50(2'.(>!A328!8(6!!

((C N&5$'!46!1;$!'*5$&5$!%#47#$55*46!#&1$5e!\$!0&6!'$1$#A*6$!&6!&[$#&7$!+*9$!$c%$01&60:!94#!%$4%+$!

\*1;!?@JC!!H;*5!+*9$!$c%$01&60:!*5!Y&5$'!46!1*A$!5*60$!*69$01*46!&6'!*764#$5!64#A&+!A4#1&+*1:!

#&1$5C!!I9!64#A&+!A4#1&+*1:!#&1$5!\$#$!*60+2'$'e!1;$!&012&+!+*9$!$c%$01&60:!\42+'!Y$!5;4#1$#!X!

5*76*9*0&61+:!5;4#1$#!94#!1;45$!\;4!0461#&01!?@J!&1!4+'$#!&7$5C!!

(<C @;&#1!<-!5;4\5!1;$!&[$#&7$!62AY$#!49!:$&#5!&!%$#546!042+'!Y$!$c%$01$'!14!5%$6'!&1!$&0;!49!1;$!

'*5$&5$!+$[$+5!,!14!=C!!T$[$+!.!*5!641!5;4\6!5*60$!*1!*5!0465*'$#$'!14!Y$!#$04[$#$'!&6'!1;$!

&552A%1*46!*5!1;&1!64!%$#546!&1!+$[$+!.!\*++!%#47#$55!92#1;$#!*6!1;$!'*5$&5$C!!8*A*+&#+:e!1;45$!\;4!

;&[$!8J@l8J3!&#$!641!5;4\6!&5!1;$:!&#$!02#$'!&6'!&#$!$c%$01$'!14!641!&'[&60$!*6!1;$!'*5$&5$!

]$c0$%1!&1!51&7$!BS`C!!H;*5!0;&#1!5;4\5!1;$!$c%$01&60:!Y&5$'!46!1;$!'*5$&5$!%#47#$55*46!#&1$5!

&552A$'!*6!1;$!,--Se!,--U!&6'!,-.-![&+2&1*465!04A%&#$'!\*1;!1;$!#&1$5!&552A$'!94#!1;*5!

[&+2&1*46C!!!

<-C H;$#$!*5!&!5*76*9*0&61!'*99$#$60$!*6!1;$!+*9$!$c%$01&60:!&1!T$[$+!,!Y$1\$$6!1;$!,-.-!0+&55!'&1&!&6'!

,-.MC!!H;$!,-.M!KKWP!3$%4#1!51&1$5!1;&1!1;$!1#&65*1*46!#&1$5!&#$!Y&5$'!46!1;$!0+&55!'&1&C!!H;$!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

M!! H;$!94#A2+&!25$'!*5a!!!.!>!FG"],C.,,!o!TQ].!>!Y&5$+*6$!%#4Y&Y*+*1:``C!!

Page 48: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! ,,!

0;&67$5!&1!1;$!41;$#!+$[$+5!&#$!641!&5!5*76*9*0&61C!!H;$#$!*5!64!$c%+&6&1*46!%#4[*'$'!*6!1;$!KKWP!

3$%4#1!94#!1;*5!'*99$#$60$C!

*,"-.&TI&2&*,"4N%&04&>*?&O0D%&;<L%=."4=A&BIIW&2&BI'R&

&

/'2'!'/B-1240.21!'55930/!3.!44A*!4,/09!

<.C H;$!KKWP!1$&A!&%%+:!&'f251A$615!14!1;$!4Y5$#[$'!'&1&!%#4[*'$'!Y:!1;$!&'A*6*51#&14#C!!H;$5$!

&'f251A$615!&%%$&#!14!25!14!Y$!'2$!14!1;$!+&7!*6!1;$!'*&7645*5!49!&6'!#$%4#1*67!'*5$&5$!+$[$+5!14!

1;$!&'A*6*51#&14#C!!

<,C @+&55!A$AY$#5i!&012&+!'*5$&5$!+$[$+5!&#$!641!1;$!02##$61!+$[$+!*6!&++!0&5$5C!!)!%$#546!A&:!;&[$!

&'[&60$'!14!&!6$\!+$[$+!Y21!*5!641!:$1!&\&#$!49!*1!'2$!14!641!;&[*67![*5*1$'!1;$*#!'4014#!4#!641!

;&[*67!Y$$6!'*&7645$'!&1!1;$!6$\!+$[$+C!!)!%$#546!A&:!Y$!&\&#$!49!1;$!0;&67$!*6!+$[$+!Y21!641!:$1!

#$%4#1$'!*1!14!1;$!)'A*6*51#&14#C!!H;*5!\42+'!Y$!%&#1*02+&#+:!%#$[&+$61!94#!0;&67$5!9#4A!+$[$+!M!14!

+$[$+!Se!5*60$!1;$#$!*5!64!&''*1*46&+!04A%$65&1*46!&[&*+&Y+$!&1!+$[$+!S!26+$55!&6'!261*+!1;$!%$#546!

5299$#5!&!T455!49!I604A$!4#!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!*6!1;$!;4A$C!!!

<MC I1!&%%$&#5!14!25!Z2*1$!#$&546&Y+$!1;&1!1;$!KKWP!\42+'!A&d$!520;!&'f251A$615!14!1;$!$c1$61!1;&1!

1;$:!;&[$!*694#A&1*46!&[&*+&Y+$!14!A&d$!1;$5$!#$0+&55*9*0&1*465C!!H;$:!'*50255!1;$*#!&'f251A$615!

46!%&7$5!.U!14!,.49!1;$!KKWP!3$%4#1C!!B&*+*67!14!A&d$!1;$5$!&'f251A$615!A*7;1!#$52+1!*6!&!+4\$#!

%#4Y&Y*+*1:!49!1#&65*1*46!Y$1\$$6!51&7$5!1;&6!A&:!&012&++:!$c*51C!!

Page 49: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! ,M!

<SC W;*+$!\$!&#$!641!*6!&!%45*1*46!14!&55$55!1;$5$!&'f251A$615e!\$!Y$+*$[$!1;&1!1;$:!%#4Y&Y+:!A&d$!

5$65$!94#!%2#%45$5!49!'$1$#A*6*67!1#&65*1*46!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!&6'!1;$#$94#$!#$52+1!*6!A4#$!#$&+*51*0!

1#&65*1*46!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!1;&6!\42+'!Y$!4Y1&*6$'!*6!1;$!&Y5$60$!49!520;!&'f251A$615C!

</C ?4\$[$#e!1;$5$!&'f251A$615!&#$!641!&%%#4%#*&1$!94#!25$!*6!1;$!'*5$&5$!'*51#*Y21*46!49!1;$!0+&55!

A$AY$#5!94#!1;$!&012&#*&+![&+2&1*46C!!H;$!%2#%45$!49!1;$![&+2&1*46!*5!14!'$1$#A*6$!1;$!%#$5$61!

[&+2$!49!9212#$!Y$6$9*1!%&:A$615C!!N:!&'f251*67!1;$!51&#1*67!'*5$&5$!'*51#*Y21*46e!1;$!1*A*67!&6'!

%455*Y+:!1;$!Z2&612A!49!1;$!9212#$!Y$6$9*1!%&:A$615!\42+'!Y$!&99$01$'C!!I9!\$!&'f251!1;$!'*5$&5$!

+$[$+!14!$+*A*6&1$!1;$!+&7!Y$1\$$6!&'[&60$A$61!*6!1;$!'*5$&5$!+$[$+!\*1;!1;$!'*&7645*5!&6'!

#$%4#1*67!14!1;$!&'A*6*51#&14#e!\$!&#$!&'[&60*67!1;$!1*A*67!49!#$%4#1*67!&!0+&*AC!!

<=C I1!*5!6$0$55&#:!14!&++40&1$!0+&*A&615!&1!+$[$+!M!Y$1\$$6!B.!&6'!B,!&5!\$++!&5!0+&*A&615!&1!+$[$+!=!

Y$1\$$6!'$04A%$65&1$'e!?@@!&6'!1#&65%+&61C!!H;$5$!&'f251A$615!&#$!5$1!421!*6!%&#&7#&%;5!.SM!

14!.SSC!

0?(011!/0'281!/-0!2,!8(6!!

<UC H;$!"+&6!%#4[*'$5!Y$6$9*15!14!Y$!%&*'!14!0+&*A&615!\;45$!'$&1;!\&5!^0&25$'!Y:!;*5!4#!;$#!

*69$01*46!\*1;!?@J_C!!!I6!#$[*$\*67!1;$!%&51!$c%$#*$60$!49!1;$!"+&6e!\$!641*0$'!1;&1!1;$!*60*'$60$!

49!?@J>#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!'*99$#$'!A&#d$'+:!9#4A!\;&1!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+!%#$'*01$'C!!!

<(C I6!%&#1*02+&#e!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+!%#4[*'$5!94#!'$&1;!0&25$'!Y:!?@J!46+:!&1!+$[$+!=C!!H;$!0+&*A5!

$c%$#*$60$!*6'*0&1$5!1;&1!1;$#$!&#$!A&6:!*69$01$'!%$#5465!\;4!'*$!&1!41;$#!+$[$+5e!*60+2'*67!+$[$+!

,e!\;$#$!1;$!'$&1;!*5!0+&55*9*$'!&5!0&25$'!Y:!?@JC!!W$!#$9$#!14!1;$5$!&5!$c0$55!?@J!'$&1;5!4#!

$c0$55!?@J!A4#1&+*1:C!

<<C W$!26'$#51&6'!1;&1!1;$#$!*5!&!5*76*9*0&61!'*99$#$60$!*6!1;$!*61$#%#$1&1*46!49!1;$!%;#&5$!^0&25$'!

Y:_!Y$1\$$6!&!'4014#!&6'!1;$!+$7&+!%#49$55*46C!!W$!Y$+*$[$!1;&1!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+!%#4[*'$5!94#!

'$&1;!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@J!\;$#$!?@J!;&'!&!A&1$#*&+!0461#*Y21*46!14!'$&1;C!!H;$!&'A*6*51#&1*46!49!

1;$!"+&6!&%%$&#5!14!&++4\!94#!'$&1;5!14!Y$!0+&55*9*$'!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@J!\;$#$!?@J!;&'!&!+$55!1;&6!

A&1$#*&+!0461#*Y21*46!14!1;$!'$&1;C!!)5!&!#$52+1e!1;$#$!&#$!A&6:!0+&*A&615!\;4!&#$!&%%#4[$'!94#!

9&A*+:!&6'!'$%$6'&61!Y$6$9*15!\;$#$!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+!\42+'!641!#$0476*h$!1;$!'$&1;!Y$*67!&5!&!

#$52+1!49!?@JC!

.--C H;*5!5;42+'!641!Y$!04651#2$'!&5!&!0#*1*0*5A!4#!9&*+*67!49!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+C!!H;$#$!*5!641;*67!14!

5277$51!1;&1!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+!9&*+5!14!%#4[*'$!%#4%$#+:!94#!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;e!Y&5$'!46!1;$!

A$'*0&+!%#49$55*46i5!'$9*6*1*46!49!1;$!1$#AC!!H;$!#$&+!*552$!*5!1;&1!\$!6$$'!14!#$0460*+$!1;$!KKWP!

A4'$+!\*1;!1;$!&'A*6*51#&1*46!%#40$55!&6'!A&d$!&++4\&60$!*6!1;$![&+2&1*46!94#!1;*5!'*99$#$60$!*6!

0+&55*9*0&1*46!49!'$&1;5C!

.-.C N&5$'!46!"+&6!$c%$#*$60$!14!'&1$e!&Y421!/,g!49!&++!%451!.<<<!1#&65925$'!'$&1;5!&6'!U,g!49!&++!

%451!.<<<!;&$A4%;*+*&0!'$&1;5!;&[$!Y$$6!0+&55*9*$'!&5!Y$*67!0&25$'!Y:!?@JC!

Page 50: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! ,S!

.-,C F99$01*[$!\*1;!1;$!,--U![&+2&1*46e!\$!&6&+:5$'!1;$!%&51!$c%$#*$60$!49!1;$!"+&6!&6'!0#$&1$'!&!

A4#1&+*1:!&552A%1*46!94#!$c0$55!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5C!!H;&1!&552A%1*46!\&5!#$1&*6$'!94#!1;$!,-.-!

[&+2&1*46C!!H;$!$c%$#*$60$!49!1;$!%&51!1;#$$!:$&#5!;&5!#$A&*6$'!0465*51$61!\*1;!42#!&552A%1*46C!

.-MC H;$!&6&+:5*5!&6'!'$[$+4%A$61!49!1;$!&552A%1*46!0&6!Y$!9426'!*6!1;$!,-.-!K4#6$&2!8;$%$++!

8299*0*$60:!3$%4#1!&6'!*5!641!#$%$&1$'!;$#$C!!!

.-SC I1!5;42+'!Y$!641$'!1;&1!1;$!&6&+:5*5!+44d$'!&1!'*99$#$60$5!Y$1\$$6a!!

&C 1#&65925$'!&6'!;&$A4%;*+*&0!0+&*A&615b!!

YC 1;45$!04*69$01$'!\*1;!?IJ!&6'!1;45$!641!04*69$01$'b!&6'!

0C '*99$#$61!&7$!7#42%5C!!!

H;$#$!\&5!+*11+$!51&1*51*0&++:!0#$'*Y+$!'*99$#$60$5!&6'!54!\$!'$1$#A*6$'!*1!\&5!&%%#4%#*&1$!14!

'$[$+4%!&6!&552A%1*46!1;&1!'4$5!641![&#:!Y$1\$$6!1;45$!0+&55*9*0&1*465SC!!H;$!46+:!0#$'*Y+$!

'*99$#$60$5!\$!9426'!\$#$!Y$1\$$6!0+&*A&615!&1!1;$![&#*425!'*5$&5$!+$[$+5C!

.-/C 8*60$!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+!'4$5!641!#$0476*h$!&6:!*60#$&5$!*6!A4#1&+*1:!'2$!14!?@J!*69$01*46!$c0$%1!

&1!+$[$+!=e!\$!'$1$#A*6$'!1;&1!\$!5;42+'!A&d$!64!0;&67$5!14!1;$!KKWP!&552A%1*465C!!B2#1;$#e!

\$!641$'!1;&1!1;$!62AY$#!49!'$&1;5!9#4A!&++!0&25$5!&1!+$[$+5!.!14!/!*5!\*1;*6!&!#$&546&Y+$!#&67$!49!

\;&1!\42+'!Y$!$c%$01$'!Y&5$'!46!1;$!@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$5C!!W$!;&[$!1;$#$94#$!&552A$'!1;&1!&++!

'$&1;5!&1!+$[$+5!.!14!/!\*++!Y$!*6!&004#'&60$!\*1;!1;$!@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$5!,--<>,-..!Y21!1;&1!\$!

5;42+'!&++40&1$!1;45$!'$&1;5!Y$1\$$6!?@J>#$+&1$'!&6'!641!?@J>#$+&1$'C!

.-=C H&Y+$!.-=&!5;4\5!1;$!62AY$#!49!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!&6'!646>?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!&1!$&0;!+$[$+!Y:!

&7$!7#42%*67C!!H&Y+$!.-=Y!5;4\5!1;$!#&1*4!49!?@J!#$+&1$'!14!646>?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!&1!$&0;!+$[$+!

Y:!&7$!7#42%*67C!!B4#!1;$5$!1&Y+$5e!\$!&6&+:h$'!46+:!'$&1;5!4002##*67!&91$#!.<<<e!54!1;$#$!*5!64!

4[$#51&1$A$61!9#4A!1;$!%#$>.<<<!'$&1;5C!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

S!! I6!+44d*67!&1!%455*Y+$![&#*&60$5!Y:!;&$A4%;*+*&0!51&125e!&7$!&6'!04>*69$01*46!51&125e!1;$!+$[$+!=!'$&1;5!\$#$!+&#7$+:!*764#$'!5*60$!A451!49!1;$A!&#$!$c%$01$'!26'$#!1;$!A$'*0&+!A4'$+!&6'!&#$!641!$c0$55!?@J!'$&1;5C!!W$!&+54!*764#$'!T$[$+!.!'$&1;5!5*60$!1;$:!&#$!02#$'!&6'!%#$52A&Y+:!;&[$!64!+*[$#!'&A&7$!'2$!14!?@JC!

Page 51: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! ,/!

9$:4-!;<=$!)!>?@:-%!/A!B"C!7-4$&-3!$13!>/1DB"C!7-4$&-3!*-$&#,E!;FFF!&/!G<;H!

) ) 3'1,/1,)V,?,.)

@Q,) )) C) A) D) J) I) P) :&(/.)

->M-! ?@J!R$&1;! !>!!!! !.!! !>!!!! !.!! !M!! !(!! .M!

! Q46>?@J!R$&1;! !S!! !S!! !,!! !.!! !>!!!! !.!! .,!

M->S/! ?@J!R$&1;! !>!!!! !,!! !(!! !>!!!! !U!! !SS!! =.!

! Q46>?@J!R$&1;! !=!! !(!! !.-!! !.!! !S!! !,!! M.!

S/>=-! ?@J!R$&1;! !>!!!! !>!!!! !U!! !,!! !.=!! !.-.!! .,=!

! Q46>?@J!R$&1;! !.=!! !,M!! !,-!! !U!! !U!! !=!! U<!

=->U/! ?@J!R$&1;! !>!!!! !=!! !(!! !=!! !M=!! !.SU!! ,-M!

! Q46>?@J!R$&1;! !S,!! !SS!! !.=!! !/!! !.M!! !=!! .,=!

U/>..-! ?@J!R$&1;! !>!!!! !..!! !U!! !/!! !,<!! !.MM!! .(/!

! Q46>?@J!R$&1;! !.-=!! !<<!! !.-!! !/!! !U!! !S!! ,M.!

:&(/.1) <*Z)3,/(;) -! ,-! M-! .S! <.! SMM! /((!

!! W&#^<*Z)3,/(;) .US! .U(! /(! .<! M.! .<! SU<!

! :&(/.) .US! .<(! ((! MM! .,,! S/,! .-=U!

!

9$:4-!;<=:!)!7$&+/!/A!B"C!7-4$&-3!$13!>/1DB"C!7-4$&-3!*-$&#,E!;FFF!&/!G<;H!

) ) 3'1,/1,)V,?,.)

@Q,) )) C) A) D) J) I) P) :&(/.)

->M-! ?@J!R$&1;! -g! ,-g! -g! /-g! .--g! (<g! /,g!

! Q46>?@J!R$&1;! .--g! (-g! .--g! /-g! -g! ..g! S(g!

M->S/! ?@J!R$&1;! -g! ,-g! SSg! -g! =Sg! <=g! ==g!

! Q46>?@J!R$&1;! .--g! (-g! /=g! .--g! M=g! Sg! MSg!

S/>=-! ?@J!R$&1;! -g! -g! ,=g! ,,g! U-g! <Sg! =.g!

! Q46>?@J!R$&1;! .--g! .--g! USg! U(g! M-g! =g! M<g!

=->U/! ?@J!R$&1;! -g! .,g! MMg! //g! UMg! <=g! =,g!

! Q46>?@J!R$&1;! .--g! ((g! =Ug! S/g! ,Ug! Sg! M(g!

U/>..-! ?@J!R$&1;! -g! .-g! S.g! /-g! (.g! <Ug! SSg!

! Q46>?@J!R$&1;! .--g! <-g! /<g! /-g! .<g! Mg! /=g!

:&(/.1) <*Z)3,/(;) Ba) CBa) DJa) JAa) LIa) NPa) IIa)

)) W&#^<*Z)3,/(;) CBBa) NBa) PPa) IMa) AIa) Ja) JIa)

.-UC H;$!KKWP!A4'$+!%#4[*'$5!94#!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;!&1!+$[$+!=!46+:C!!H;$#$94#$e!*1!*5!*A%4#1&61!14!

#$A$AY$#!1;&1!\$!$c%$01!&!+&#7$!62AY$#!49!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!&1!+$[$+!=C!!W$!&+54!$c%$01!54A$!

646>?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!&1!+$[$+!=e!5*60$!1;$#$!&#$!41;$#!0&25$5!49!'$&1;!1;&1!A&:!&99$01!$[$6!1;$!

A451!5$#*425!0&5$!49!?@JC!!"#*4#!14!,-.Me!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+!A&'$!%#4[*5*46!94#!1;&1e!Y21!\*1;!

$99$01!9#4A!1;$!,-.M!A4'$+e!1;$!KKWP!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!&++!'$&1;5!&1!+$[$+!=!\*++!Y$!&5!&!#$52+1!

49!?@JC!!W;&1!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+!'4$5!641!'4!*5!%#4[*'$!94#!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!&1!+$[$+5!.!14!/C!

Page 52: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! ,=!

.-(C W*1;!1;$!$c%$01&1*46!1;&1!1;$!62AY$#!49!02#$'!0+&*A&615!\*++!*60#$&5$!5*76*9*0&61+:!*6!1;$!6$c1!9$\!

:$&#5!&5!&!#$52+1!49!1;$!6$\!'#27!1#$&1A$615e!\$!'*50255$'!\*1;!F0d+$#!\;&1!$99$01!8J@!&6'!8J3!

A*7;1!;&[$!46!1;$!$c0$55!?@J!A4#1&+*1:C!!K$'*0&+!$c%$#15!&'[*5$'!25!1;&1!\;*+$!$c0$55!?@J!'$&1;5!

\*++!+*d$+:!Y$!+$55!94#!&!%$#546!02#$'e!1;$:!\*++!641!'*5&%%$&#C!!H;$!94++4\*67!9&014#5!\*++!*69+2$60$!

1;$!#&1$a!

&C &6:!'&A&7$!'46$!Y:!1;$!'*5$&5$!*5!641!26'46$!Y:![*#12$!49!Y$*67!02#$'!&6'!*1!\*++!%$#5*51!94#!

1;$!Y&+&60$!49!+*9$b!

YC &6:!41;$#!'*5$&5$5!1;$!0+&*A&61!;&5!\*++!#$A&*6!&6'!&6:!$99$01!46!1;&1!'*5$&5$]5`!9#4A!?@J!

\*++!+*d$+:!0461*62$!14!&99$01!1;$!%$#546!94#!54A$!1*A$b!&6'!

0C #$04[$#:!1*A$!94#!A451!0+&*A&615!*5!+*d$+:!14!Y$!&!9$\!A461;5!&1!+$[$+!M!14!&!9$\!:$&#5!&1!+$[$+!/!

\*1;!54A$!0+&*A&615!&1!+$[$+!/!&6'!&+A451!&++!&1!+$[$+!=!%455*Y+:!6$[$#!;&[*67!&!04A%+$1$!

#$04[$#:!9#4A!1;$!$99$015!49!?@JC!!!

W$!'$0*'$'!14!A&d$!5$%&#&1$!&552A%1*465!94#!$c0$55!?@J!A4#1&+*1:!Y&5$'!2%46!\;$1;$#!1;$!

0+&*A&61!;&5!641!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25!&6'!\;$1;$#!1;$:!&#$!02#$'C!

.-<C H&Y+$!...!%#4[*'$5!1;$!%$#0$61&7$!49!1;$!'$&1;5!Y&5$'!46!1;$!@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$!1;&1!\$!\*++!

0465*'$#!&5!Y$*67!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@JC!!H;$!#$51!49!1;$!'$&1;5!Y&5$'!46!1;$!@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$5!\*++!

Y$!0465*'$#$'!&5!646>?@J!#$+&1$'C!

..-C D5*67!1;*5!&552A%1*46!94#!$c0$55!?@J!A4#1&+*1:!'4$5!641!0;&67$!&6:!49!1;$!KKWP!%4%2+&1*46!

%#4f$01*465!41;$#!1;&6!14!1&d$!&!%$#0$61&7$!49!1;$!646>?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!&6'!#$0+&55*9:!1;$A!&5!

Y$*67!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@JC!!H;$!141&+!62AY$#!49!'$&1;5!%#4f$01$'!Y:!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+!*6!1;$*#!H&Y+$!

.Se!&6'!*6!%&#1*02+&#e!1;$!141&+!62AY$#!49!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!#$52+1*67!9#4A!1;$!KKWP!A4#1&+*1:!

&552A%1*46!&1!+$[$+!=!#$A&*65!260;&67$'C!!!

...C B4#!$c&A%+$e!&552A$!94#!&!%&#1*02+&#!7#42%!1;&1!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+!%#4f$015!,/!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!

&6'!U/!646>?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!Y:!,-S-C!!H;*5!$c0$55!?@J!#$+&1$'!A4#1&+*1:!&552A%1*46!\42+'!

&%%+:!14!1;$!U/!646>?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!&6'!#$0+&55*9:!54A$!49!1;$AC!!H;*5!A*7;1!#$52+1!*6!&6!

&''*1*46&+!M-!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!\*1;!S/!#$A&*6*67!&5!646>?@J!#$+&1$'C!!W$!\*++!51*++!;&[$!.--!

141&+!'$&1;5!&6'!\$!\*++!51*++!;&[$!,/!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!#$52+1*67!9#4A!1;$!?@J!#$+&1$'!A4#1&+*1:!

&552A%1*46!\*1;*6!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+!&1!+$[$+!=C!

Page 53: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! ,U!

!"#$%&'''&2&X::C9L.0+4&D+-&U%-=%4."N%&+D&M%".,:&*$"::0D0%6&":&>*?)F%$".%6&

) 3'1,/1,)V,?,.)

)) C) A) D) J) I) P)

>O5,4(,$)

@?,0/Q,)

*./'+/#(1)7;&);/?,)#&()4.,/0,$)(;,)?'0"1) ) ) ) )

?@J!R$&1;! -g! .-g! M/g! S/g! (-g! .--g! MMg!

Q46>?@J!R$&1;! .--g! <-g! =/g! //g! ,-g! -g! =Ug!

*./'+/#(1)7;&);/?,)4.,/0,$)(;,)?'0"1) ) ) ) )

?@J!R$&1;! -g! -g! -g! ,/g! =-g! .--g! ,,g!

Q46>?@J!R$&1;! .--g! .--g! .--g! U/g! S-g! -g! U(g!

..,C H;$!$c%$01$'!&[$#&7$!*6!H&Y+$!...!'4$5!641!*60+2'$!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!$c%$01$'!14!4002#!&1!+$[$+!

=!25*67!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+C!!W;$6!1;45$!'$&1;5!&#$!*60+2'$'e!1;$!4[$#&++!%$#0$61&7$!49!?@J!#$+&1$'!

'$&1;5!*5!/=g!94#!1;45$!\;4!;&[$!641!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25C!!H;&1!*5!&Y421!1;$!5&A$!&5!\$!4Y5$#[$'!

&A467!1;$!&012&+!'$&1;5!9#4A!.<<<!14!,-.MC!!I60+2'*67!1;$!$c%$01$'!?@J>#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!&1!+$[$+!=e!

1;$!4[$#&++!%$#0$61&7$!49!?@J>#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!94#!1;45$!\;4!;&[$!Y$$6!02#$'!*5!S(gC!

Page 54: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! ,(!

C$ !"#$%&%&'()()*$&+$,%!!"#"$%!

..MC N41;!1;$!Y$6$9*15!26'$#!1;$!"+&6!&6'!1;$!

&552A%1*465!94#!'*5$&5$!%#47#$55*46!'*99$#!Y$1\$$6!

1#&65925$'!&6'!;&$A4%;*+*&0!0+&*A&615C!!H;$#$94#$e!

\$!;&[$!5$%&#&1$'!1;$!0+&*A&615!*614!1\4!04;4#15e!

1#&65925$'!&6'!;&$A4%;*+*&05C!

..SC )5!49!1;$![&+2&1*46!'&1$e!1;$!B*#51!@+&*A5!R$&'+*6$!

;&5!%&55$'!&6'!1;$#$!*5!64\!46+:!+*A*1$'!4%%4#126*1:!

94#!&!%$#546!14!9*+$!&!0+&*A/C!!H\4!@42#1!)%%#4[$'!

"#41404+5!94#!1;$!&'f2'*0&1*46!&6'!&%%#4[&+!49!0+&*A5!

52YA*11$'!&91$#!M-!V26$!,-.-!]@)".!&6'!@)",`!;&[$!

Y$$6!&'4%1$'!5*60$!,-.-C!!!

../C H;$!2+1*A&1$!62AY$#!49!0+&*A&615!*5!26d64\6!&6'!&552A%1*465!&#$!#$Z2*#$'!&Y421!1;$!62AY$#!

&6'!'*5$&5$!51&7$!49!1;$!9212#$!0+&*A&615!]1;$!^26d64\6_!0+&*A&615`C!!H;$#$!&#$!&!+&#7$!62AY$#!49!

0+&*A5!1;&1!\$#$!52YA*11$'!%#*4#!14!1;$!B*#51!@+&*A5!R$&'+*6$!1;&1!&#$!51*++!26'$#!#$[*$\!&6'!94#!

\;*0;!&!'$0*5*46!&Y421!&%%#4[&+!;&5!641!:$1!Y$$6!A&'$C!!H;$#$!\*++!+*d$+:!Y$!54A$!&''*1*46&+!

0+&*A5!A&'$!26'$#!1;$!%#4[*5*465!94#!+&1$!0+&*A5C!

..=C K4#6$&2!8;$%$++!&6'!F0d+$#!A$1!&6'!;$+'!&!62AY$#!49!0469$#$60$!0&++5!'2#*67!\;*0;!1;$!$c%$01$'!

62AY$#!49!9212#$!&%%#4[&+5!\$#$!'*50255$'!&6'!&7#$$A$61!\&5!#$&0;$'!46!1;$!5*h$!49!1;$!

$c%$01$'!0+&*A&61!04;4#1C!!H;*5!5$01*46!'*50255$5!1;$!#&1*46&+$!25$'!Y:!Y41;!&012&#*$5!*6!5$11*67!

1;$!&552A$'!62AY$#!&6'!0;&#&01$#*51*05!49!1;$!0+&*A&61!04;4#1C!

..UC H;$!d64\6!0+&*A&615!&#$!&!9&01C!!H;$!d$:!&552A%1*465!#$Z2*#$'!&Y421!1;$!0+&*A&61!04;4#1!&#$a!

&C Q2AY$#!49!26d64\6!]9212#$`!0+&*A&615b!

YC H*A*67!49!1;$!9*+*67!49!1;$*#!0+&*A5b!

0C )%%#4[&+!#&1$!94#!&00$%1&60$!*614!1;$!@+&55b!

'C 81&125!&1!1;$!1*A$!49!&%%#4[&+!]\;$1;$#!1;$:!&#$!&+*[$e!'$0$&5$'!%#*4#!14!.<<<e!'$0$&5$'!5*60$!

.!V&62&#:!.<<<!&6'!\;$1;$#!'$&1;!\&5!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@J`b!

$C R*5$&5$!51&7$!49!1;$*#!*++6$55!&1!1;$!1*A$!1;$*#!0+&*A!*5!9*+$'C!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

/!! H4!Y$!&00$%1$'!&91$#!M-!V26$!,-.-e!1;$!0+&*A!A251!Y$!A&'$!\*1;*6!46$!:$&#!49!1;$!%$#546!&11&*6*67!;*5!4#!;$#!&7$!49!A&f4#*1:b!4#!1;$!0+&*A!A251!Y$!A&'$!\*1;*6!1;#$$!:$&#5!49!1;$!'&1$!1;$!%$#546!9*#51!+$&#6$'!49!;*5!4#!;$#!*69$01*46!&6'!1;$!042#1!7#&615!+$&[$!14!&%%+:!94#!04A%$65&1*46C!!B4#!&!5$046'&#*+:!*69$01$'!%$#546e!1;$!0+&*A!A251!Y$!9*+$'!\*1;*6!M!:$&#5!49!1;$!'&1$!1;$!%#*A&#*+:!*69$01$'!%$#546i5!0+&*A!\&5!9*+$'C!

In This Section, we….

! review the incidence of

historical claims submissions

and approval rates,

! develop our assumptions

about the number of future

unknown claimants and the

timing of their claims, and

! discuss the assumed

distribution of claimants by

disease level, HIV co-

infection and for deceased

claimants, cause of death.

Page 55: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! ,<!

..(C H;&1!*694#A&1*46!*5!d64\6!94#!1;$!$c*51*67!0+&*A&615C!!H;$!94++4\*67!'*50255$5!1;$!&552A%1*465!

A&'$!\*1;!#$5%$01!14!1;$!26d64\6!0+&*A&615C!

-.).,A.!2+'.17-10/!(9'34'.21!

..<C H;$#$!&#$!SSS!0+&*A5!94#!1#&65925$'!0+&*A&615!1;&1!;&[$!Y$$6!9*+$'!&6'!94#!\;*0;!6$*1;$#!&%%#4[&+!

64#!'$6*&+!;&5!Y$$6!*552$'!&5!49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.MC!!H;$!&'A*6*51#&14#!&'[*5$5!1;&1!.UM!49!1;45$!

0+&*A5!&#$!0465*'$#$'!&5!^&#0;*[$'_!X!94#![&#*425!#$&5465e!1;$!&'A*6*51#&14#!Y$+*$[$5!1;&1!1;$:!

;&[$!Y$$6!&Y&6'46$'C!!H;&1!+$&[$5!,U.!0+&*A5!%$6'*67!#$[*$\!Y:!1;$!&'A*6*51#&14#C!!I1!*5!+*d$+:!

1;&1!54A$!49!1;$5$!0+&*A5!\*++!Y$!&%%#4[$'!*6!1;$!9212#$C!

.,-C I6!&''*1*46!14!1;$5$!%$6'*67!0+&*A5e!1;$#$!\*++!0461*62$!14!Y$!54A$!6$\!0+&*A5!9*+$'!*6!1;$!9212#$!

1;&1!\*++!Y$!&'f2'*0&1$'!&5!+&1$!0+&*A5C!!

.,.C H47$1;$#e!1;$5$!0+&*A5!94#A!\;&1!*5!#$9$##$'!14!&5!1;$!26d64\6!0+&*A&615C!!W;*+$!\$!;&[$!'&1&!

9#4A!1;$!)'A*6*51#&14#!94#!&++!49!1;$!%$6'*67!0+&*A5e!1;$!*694#A&1*46!1;&1!\42+'!Y$!49!25$!*6!1;$!

[&+2&1*46!*5!5%&#5$C!!@465$Z2$61+:e!1;$#$!*5!+*11+$!4#!64![&+2$!14!25*67!1;$!%$6'*67!0+&*A!'&1&!&5!&!

Y&5*5!94#!1;$!26d64\6!0+&*A&615C!!

.,,C H&Y+$!.,,!*5!&!52AA&#:!49!1;$!52YA*11$'e!&%%#4[$'e!'$6*$'e!%$6'*67!&6'!&#0;*[$'!0+&*A5!14!1;$!

$6'!49!,-.Me!Y&5$'!46!'&1$!49!0+&*A!52YA*55*46C!!]Q41$!1;&1!&!0+&*A!52YA*11$'!*6!,--S!1;&1!;&5!

Y$$6!&%%#4[$'!042+'!;&[$!Y$$6!&%%#4[$'!*6!&6:!:$&#!,--S!14!,-.M`C!!H;$#$!&#$!&+54!.<!%$6'*67!

0+&*A5!641!*60+2'$'!*6!1;$!1&Y+$!94#!5$046'&#*+:!*69$01$'!%$#5465C!!!

& &

Page 56: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! M-!

!"#$%&'BB&2&>0:.+-0="$&YC9#%-&+D&*$"09:&/C#90..%6&2&!-"4:DC:%6&

_,/0) E"b+'((,$) @550&?,$) 3,#',$) -,#$'#Q) @04;'?,$)@550&?/.))U/(,])

,---! ,e<.,! ,e-/.! (-/! M! /M! U.g!

,--.! .e-<.! =//! S--! =! M-! =-g!

,--,! =-<! MM(! ,S(! M! ,-! /=g!

,--M! MM(! .<,! .,<! ,! ./! /Ug!

,--S! ,S<! .,U! ..S! ,! =! /.g!

,--/! ,.-! .-U! (/! U! ..! /Mg!

,--=! .U-! .--! //! (! U! =,g!

,--U! ..U! /,! /M! =! =! SUg!

,--(! .-,! /-! S.! (! M! /Mg!

,--<! .-.! /,! S,! /! ,! /Sg!

,-.-!V&6!>!V26$! M,.! </! (=! .,U! .M! S<g!

,-.-!V2+:! .S/! ./! M<! (/! =! ,/g!

,-.-!)27!>!R$0! /! -! S! .! -! -g!

,-..! S! .! ,! -! .! ,/g!

,-.,! /M! ,<! ,,! ,! -! /Ug!

,-.M! ,.! =! <! =! -! S-g!

H41&+!! =eSS(! Me(U-! ,e.MS! ,U.! .UM! =Mg!

o!H;$!&%%#4[&+!#&1$!*5!0&+02+&1$'!94#!$&0;!:$&#!&5!&!%$#0$61&7$!49!1;$!0+&*A5!46!\;*0;!&!'$0*5*46!;&5!Y$$6!A&'$C!!"$6'*67!0+&*A5!&#$!641!%&#1!49!1;&1!0&+02+&1*46C!!

!

.,MC H;$!62AY$#!49!0+&*A5!52YA*11$'!'$0+*6$'!*6!$&0;!:$&#!5*60$!,---!&6'!1;$6!*60#$&5$'!

52Y51&61*&++:!&5!1;$!B*#51!@+&*A5!R$&'+*6$!49!M-!V26$!,-.-!&%%#4&0;$'C!

.,SC I6!&''*1*46!14!1;$!%$6'*67!0+&*A5e!\$!$51*A&1$!1;&1!1;$#$!\*++!Y$!<(!9212#$!0+&*A5!9*+$'!26'$#!@)".!

&6'!UU!9212#$!0+&*A5!26'$#!@)",C!!!

*$"09&XLL-+P"$&F".%&&

.,/C H;$!&%%#4[&+!#&1$!5;4\6!*6!H&Y+$!.,,!51&#1$'!499!Y:!'$0+*6*67!*6!$&0;!:$&#e!&6'!1;$6!51&Y*+*h$'!&1!

&Y421!/-g!14!//gC!!8*60$!,-.-e!1;$!*6*1*&+!Y&10;!49!+&1$!0+&*A5!;&'!&![$#:!+4\!&%%#4[&+!#&1$!Y21!

1;&1!;&5!#$[$#1$'!14!&Y421!S/g!26'$#!@)".!&6'!&Y421!(/g!26'$#!@)",C!!!

.,=C W$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!//g!49!1;$!,U.!%$6'*67!0+&*A5!\*++!2+1*A&1$+:!Y$!&%%#4[$'e!S/g!49!1;$!<(!

9212#$!0+&*A5!26'$#!@)".!\*++!Y$!&%%#4[$'e!U-g!49!1;$!UU!9212#$!0+&*A5!26'$#!@)",!\*++!Y$!

&%%#4[$'!&6'!M(g!49!1;$!.<!5$046'&#*+:!*69$01$'!0+&*A5!1;&1!&#$!%$6'*67!\*++!Y$!&%%#4[$'C!!H;*5!

7*[$5!&!141&+!49!,/S!&%%#4[$'!0+&*A5!&552A$'!14!04A%#*5$!1;$!26d64\6!04;4#1C!

.,UC @4AY*6*67!1;$!d64\6!1#&65925$'!04;4#1!49!Me<,S!\*1;!1;$!,/S!26d64\6!1#&65925$'!04;4#1!7*[$5!&!

141&+!Y$51!$51*A&1$!04;4#1!49!Se.U(!0+&*A&615C!

Page 57: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! M.!

.,(C H;$!46+:!&61*0*%&1$'![&#*&Y*+*1:!*6!1;$!04;4#1!5*h$!\42+'!Y$!&5!&!#$52+1!49!&!'*99$#$60$!*6!1;$!0+&*A5!

26'$#!@)".!&6'!@)",C!!I6!42#!4%*6*46e!1;$![&#*&Y*+*1:!1;&1!A*7;1!4002#!*5!641!$6427;!14!Y$!

A&1$#*&+!&6'!54!\$!;&[$!641!*60+2'$'!&6:!A&#7*6!*6!1;$!04;4#1!5*h$!&5!%&#1!49!1;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!

&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465C!

*$"::0D0=".0+4&+D&.,%&7484+54&*$"09"4.:&

.,<C W$!;&[$!&++40&1$'!1;$!141&+!26d64\6!0+&*A&615!Y$1\$$6!1;45$!\;4!&#$!&+*[$!&6'!1;45$!\;4!'*$'!

Y&5$'!46!&!#$[*$\!49!1;$!6$\!0+&*A5!&%%#4[$'!5*60$!,--UC!!H;*5!#$52+1$'!*6!U-g!49!1;$A!Y$*67!94#!

&+*[$!0+&*A&615e!.-g!94#!1;45$!\;4!'*$'!%#*4#!14!.<<<e!.-g!94#!1;45$!\;4!'*$'!5*60$!.<<<!9#4A!

646>?@J!0&25$5!&6'!.-g!94#!1;45$!\;4!'*$'!5*60$!.<<<!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@JC!!

.M-C W$!&552A$'!1;&1!1;$!26d64\6!0+&*A&615!\*++!Y$!'*51#*Y21$'!Y:!'*5$&5$!+$[$+!1;$!5&A$!&5!1;$!

d64\6!04;4#1!\*1;!1;$!&+*[$e!'$0$&5$'!&91$#!.<<(!9#4A!?@J!&6'!'$0$&5$'!&91$#!.<<(!9#4A!646>

?@J!'*51#*Y21*465!5$%&#&1$C!!Q4!&++40&1*46!Y:!'*5$&5$!+$[$+!*5!#$Z2*#$'!94#!1;45$!\;4!'*$'!%#*4#!14!

.<<<C!

.M.C H;$5$!0+&55*9*0&1*465!&#$!#$9+$01$'!*6!H&Y+$!.S=!X!@4;4#1!8*h$!Y$+4\C!!!

-.).,A.!8'04,58393'(!(9'34'.21!!

.M,C H;$!,--S!V4*61!@4AA*11$$!3$%4#1!'*50255$'!1;$!$c%$01$'!0+&*A5!9#4A!;&$A4%;*+*&05!&6'!

0460+2'$'!1;&1!*1!*5!26+*d$+:!1;&1!A&6:!9212#$!;&$A4%;*+*&0!0+&*A5!\*++!Y$!A&'$C!!H;$#$!;&'!Y$$6!

&!0460$#1$'!$994#1!A&'$!14!0461&01!;&$A4%;*+*&05!&6'!1;$!V4*61!@4AA*11$$!\&5!49!1;$!Y$+*$9!1;&1!

A451!&99$01$'!;&$A4%;*+*&05!;&[$!52YA*11$'!1;$*#!0+&*A5C!!H;$!62AY$#!49!0+&*A5!52YA*11$'!5*60$!

,--S!52%%4#15!1;&1![*$\C!!R2#*67!1;$!%$#*4'!9#4A!,--/!14!,--<e!1;$#$!\$#$!&Y421!.-!0+&*A5!

52YA*11$'!$&0;!:$&#!&6'!A451!49!1;$A!;&[$!Y$$6!&%%#4[$'C!!I6!1;$!%&51!1;#$$!:$&#5e!1;$#$!\$#$!&!

141&+!49!9*[$!0+&*A5!52YA*11$'!49!\;*0;!1\4!;&[$!Y$$6!&%%#4[$'e!46$!'$6*$'!&6'!1\4!#$A&*6!

%$6'*67C!!!

.MMC H&Y+$!.MM!*5!&!52AA&#:!49!1;$!52YA*11$'e!&%%#4[$'e!'$6*$'e!%$6'*67!&6'!&#0;*[$'!;&$A4%;*+*&0!

0+&*A5!14!1;$!$6'!49!,-.Me!Y&5$'!46!'&1$!49!52YA*55*46C!!]Q41$!1;&1!&!0+&*A!52YA*11$'!*6!,--S!1;&1!

;&5!Y$$6!&%%#4[$'!042+'!;&[$!Y$$6!&%%#4[$'!*6!&6:!:$&#!,--S!14!,-.-`C!!!

& &

Page 58: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! M,!

!"#$%&'RR&2&>0:.+-0="$&YC9#%-&+D&*$"09:&/C#90..%6&2&>"%9+L,0$0"=:&

_,/0) E"b+'((,$) @550&?,$) 3,#',$) -,#$'#Q) @04;'?,$)@550&?/.))U/(,])

,---! (SM! (.U! ,.! .! S! <Ug!

,--.! ,<M! ,(,! <! .! .! <Ug!

,--,! .-.! <.! <! .! -! <.g!

,--M! (-! U/! M! .! .! </g!

,--S! MU! ,<! =! -! ,! U(g!

,--/! .M! .,! .! -! -! <,g!

,--=! ..! U! ,! ,! -! U(g!

,--U! <! (! .! -! -! (<g!

,--(! .-! (! -! ,! -! .--g!

,--<! .,! <! .! ,! -! <-g!

,-.-!V&6!>!V26$! .S! <! M! .! .! =<g!

,-.-!V2+:! <! ,! .! =! -! =Ug!

,-.-!)27!>!R$0! -! -! -! -! -! >!!!

,-..! -! -! -! -! -! >!!!

,-.,! S! ,! .! .! -! =Ug!

,-.M! .! -! -! .! -! >!!!

H41&+'' .eSMU! .eM/.! /(! .<! <! <=g!

o!H;$!&%%#4[&+!#&1$!*5!0&+02+&1$'!&5!&!%$#0$61&7$!49!1;$!0+&*A5!46!\;*0;!&!'$0*5*46!;&5!Y$$6!A&'$C!!"$6'*67!0+&*A5!&#$!641!%&#1!49!1;&1!0&+02+&1*46C!!

!

.MSC H;$!62AY$#!49!;&$A4%;*+*&0!0+&*A5!52YA*11$'!;&5!'$0#$&5$'!A20;!9&51$#!1;&6!&A467!1;$!

1#&65925$'!0+&*A&615e!\;*0;!*5!14!Y$!$c%$01$'!7*[$6!1;$!04AA26*0&1*465!0&A%&*76C!!W$!Y$+*$[$!

1;&1!*1!*5!+*d$+:!1;&1!1;$#$!\*++!Y$!9$\!+&1$!0+&*A5!1;&1!A$$1!1;$!0#*1$#*&!94#!&%%#4[&+C!

.M/C @465$Z2$61+:e!94#!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&552A%1*465e!\$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!1;$#$!\*++!Y$!.,!+&1$!

0+&*A5!52YA*11$'!26'$#!@)".!&6'!646$!26'$#!@)",C!!!

.M=C H;*5!7*[$5!.<!%$6'*67!0+&*A5!%+25!.,!0+&*A5!14!Y$!52YA*11$'!*6!1;$!9212#$C!!H4!1;$5$!62AY$#5e!\$!

6$$'!14!&%%+:!&6!&552A%1*46!&Y421!1;$!#&1$!49!&%%#4[&+C!

*$"09&XLL-+P"$&F".%&

.MUC W$!;&[$!#$[*$\$'!1;$!0+&*A!&%%#4[&+!#&1$!Y&5$'!46!1;$!'&1&!%#4[*'$'!14!25!94#!;&$A4%;*+*&05C!!

"#*4#!14!,-.-e!0+&*A5!\$#$!Y$*67!&%%#4[$'!&1!0+45$!14!.--!%$#0$61C!!K4#$!#$0$61!&%%#4[&+5!&#$!

5%&#5$e!Y21!&#$!&[$#&7*67!&Y421!U-gC!!N$0&25$!1;&1!*5!Y&5$'!46!54!9$\!0+&*A5e!\$!0465*'$#!Y&5*67!

&6!&552A%1*46!46!1;&1!U-g!&+46$!&5!*6&%%#4%#*&1$C!!W$!;&[$!1;$#$94#$!&552A$'!1;&1!(/g!49!1;$!

%$6'*67!0+&*A5!&6'!(-g!49!1;$!9212#$!0+&*A5!\*++!Y$!&%%#4[$'C!!

Page 59: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! MM!

.M(C H;*5!7*[$5!&!141&+!26d64\6!04;4#1!49!,=!;&$A4%;*+*&0!0+&*A&615C!!@4AY*6*67!1;&1!\*1;!1;$!d64\6!

;&$A4%;*+*&0!04;4#1!49!.eM/<!7*[$5!&!141&+!$c%$01$'!04;4#1!49!.eM(/!0+&*A&615C!!W$!;&[$!25$'!1;$!

5&A$!04;4#1!94#!Y41;!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&552A%1*46!&6'!1;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*46C!

*$"::0D0=".0+4&+D&7484+54&>"%9+L,0$0"=:&

.M<C W$!;&[$!&++40&1$'!1;$!141&+!26d64\6!0+&*A&615!Y$1\$$6!1;45$!\;4!&#$!&+*[$!&6'!1;45$!\;4!'*$'!

Y&5$'!46!&!#$[*$\!49!1;$!6$\!0+&*A5!&%%#4[$'!5*60$!,--UC!!H;*5!#$52+1$'!*6!//g!49!1;$A!Y$*67!94#!

&+*[$!0+&*A&615e!.,C/g!94#!1;45$!\;4!'*$'!%#*4#!14!.<<<e!,-g!94#!1;45$!\;4!'*$'!5*60$!.<<<!9#4A!

646>?@J!0&25$5!&6'!.,C/g!94#!1;45$!\;4!'*$'!5*60$!.<<<!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@JC!!

.S-C W$!&552A$'!1;&1!1;$!26d64\6!0+&*A&615!\*++!Y$!'*51#*Y21$'!Y:!'*5$&5$!+$[$+!1;$!5&A$!&5!1;$!

d64\6!04;4#1!\*1;!1;$!&+*[$e!'$0$&5$'!&91$#!.<<(!9#4A!?@J!&6'!'$0$&5$'!&91$#!.<<(!9#4A!646>

?@J!'*51#*Y21*465!5$%&#&1$C!!Q4!&++40&1*46!Y:!'*5$&5$!+$[$+!*5!#$Z2*#$'!94#!1;45$!\;4!'*$'!%#*4#!14!

.<<<C!

.S.C B4#!1;$!d64\6!0+&*A&615e!\$!;&[$!#$9+$01$'!1;$*#!&012&+!51&125!94#!?IJ!04>*69$01*46C!!

.S,C I6!42#!4%*6*46e!*1!*5!#$&546&Y+$!14!&552A$!1;&1!A451!49!1;$!&+*[$!04>*69$01$'!;&$A4%;*+*&05!\;4!

\*++!9*+$!&!0+&*A!;&[$!'46$!54e!5*60$!04>*69$01*46!#$52+15!*6!&!9&51$#!%#47#$55*46!49!1;$!'*5$&5$C!!

P*[$6!1;$!5A&++!62AY$#!49!26d64\6!;&$A4%;*+*&0!0+&*A&615!$c%$01$'e!\$!'$0*'$'!14!*764#$!1;$!

+*d$+*;44'!1;&1!1;$#$!\*++!Y$!9$\$#!9212#$!04*69$01$'!0+&*A&615!1;&6!&A467!1;$!d64\6!04;4#1C!!W$!

1;$#$94#$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!1;$!26d64\6!0+&*A&615!\*++!;&[$!&!5*A*+&#!#&1$!49!?IJ!*69$01*46!&5!

1;$!&+*[$!d64\6!;&$A4%;*+*&05!X!,/CUgC!

'11-40/!(9'34'.2!(,8,+2!

.SMC H&Y+$5!.S=&!&6'!.S=Y!5;4\!1;$!'*51#*Y21*46!49!0+&*A&615!Y:!+$[$+!Y&5$'!46!1;$!&'A*6*51#&14#i5!

'&1&!94#!1;$!d64\6!04;4#1!&6'!1;$!&552A%1*465!421+*6$'!&Y4[$!94#!1;$!26d64\6!04;4#1C!!W$!;&[$!

&'f251$'!1;$!0+&*A&615!&1!+$[$+!M!14!5%+*1!1;$A!Y$1\$$6!51&7$5!B.!&6'!B,C!!H;$!KKWP!&++40&1$'!

/-g!49!1;$!+$[$+!M!0+&*A&615!14!$&0;!49!1;45$!'*5$&5$!51&7$5!&6'!\$!;&[$!'46$!1;$!5&A$C!

.SSC H;$!KKWP!A&'$!54A$!&''*1*46&+!&'f251A$615!94#!'*5$&5$!51&7$5!Y&5$'!46!1;$*#!&6&+:5*5!49!1;$!

'&1&C!!W;*+$!1;45$!&'f251A$615!+*d$+:!*A%#4[$'!1;$!&002#&0:!49!1;$!'&1&!94#!1;$!%2#%45$5!49!

A4'$++*67!1;$!'*5$&5$e!1;$:!&#$!641!&%%#4%#*&1$!94#!$51*A&1*67!1;$!9212#$!9*6&60*&+!+*&Y*+*1:!49!1;$!

926'C!!]8$$!'*50255*46!&1!%&#&7#&%;5!<.!14!<=`C!!W$!;&[$!1;$#$94#$!*764#$'!1;$!&''*1*46&+!'&1&!

0;&67$5!A&'$!Y:!1;$!KKWPC!

.S/C B4#!1;45$!&1!+$[$+!=e!1;$!'&1&!0461&*6$'!*6'*0&14#5!94#!&++40&1*67!1;$!0+&*A&615!Y$1\$$6!

'$04A%$65&1$'!0*##;45*5e!0&60$#e!+*[$#!1#&65%+&61!&6'!]6$\!94#!,-.M`!#$6&+!9&*+2#$e!+:A%;4A&e!

7+4A$#2+46$%;#*1*5!&6'!0#:47+4Y2+*6$A*&C!!W$!\$#$!&'[*5$'!Y:!1;$!KKWP!1;&1!+:A%;4A&!

5;42+'!Y$!1#$&1$'!1;$!5&A$!&5!'$04A%$65&1$'!0*##;45*5C!!B4#!0+&*A&615!\*1;!7+4A$#2+46$%;#*1*5e!

0#:47+4Y2+*6$A*&!&6'!#$6&+!9&*+2#$!]#$9$##$'!14!&5!^&1:%*0&+!+$[$+!=_!0+&*A&615`e!\$!\$#$!&'[*5$'!

1;&1!1;$:!\42+'!Y$!$c0$++$61!0&6'*'&1$5!94#!1#$&1A$61!\*1;!54945Y2[*#!'42Y+$15C!!B4++4\*67!

Page 60: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! MS!

1#$&1A$61e!1;45$!\*1;!0#:47+4Y2+*6$A*&!&#$!$c%$01$'!14!;&[$!&!744'!#$04[$#:!&6'!+$&'!&!

#$+&1*[$+:!;$&+1;:!+*9$C!!W$!&552A$'!1;&1!1;$!41;$#5!\42+'!#$A&*6!*++!&6'!+*d$+:!0461*62$!14!#$Z2*#$!

&6:!'*5&Y*+*1:!Y$6$9*15!&6'!0451!49!0&#$!Y$6$9*15!*6!&004#'&60$!\*1;!1;$!&552A%1*465!94#!&++!41;$#!

0+&*A&615C!!!

.S=C W$!641$'!1;&1!&!62AY$#!49!&1:%*0&+!+$[$+!=!0+&*A&615!;&[$!Y$$6!46!'*5&Y*+*1:!Y$6$9*15!94#!54A$!

1*A$C!!W$!&552A$'!1;&1!94++4\*67!1#$&1A$61e!1;$!'*5&Y*+*1:!Y$6$9*15!\42+'!0461*62$!\*1;!64!

&552A$'!#$04[$#:C!!W$!&552A$'!1;&1!t#'!49!1;$A!]1;45$!\*1;!#$6&+!9&*+2#$`!\42+'!;&[$!9212#$!

0451!49!0&#$!0+&*A5!&6'!1;&1!u#'5!49!1;$!'$&1;5!\42+'!Y$!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@JC!! !

Page 61: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! M/!

.SUC H;$!94++4\*67!52AA&#*h$5!1;$!&552A%1*465!#$7&#'*67!04;4#1!5*h$C!!H;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&6'!

%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!&552A%1*465!&#$!1;$!5&A$!94#!,-.Me!Y21!'*99$#$'!*6!%#*4#!:$&#5C!

!"#$%&'W("&2&*+,+-.&/01%&2&!-"4:DC:%6&*$"09"4.:&)&BI'R&

3'1,/1,)V,?,.)) )3'1,/1,)E(/Q,)6#&7#)

*./'+/#(1)8#9#&7#)*./'+/#(1) :&(/.)

@.'?,)*./'+/#(1)) ) ) )

.! !B-!X!3Q)>!! !/.-!! M,! !/S,!!

,! !B-!X!3Q)p!! !<<M!! =,! !.e-/S/!

M! !B.!! !SS<!! ,(! !SUU!!

M! !B,!! !SS<!! ,(! !SUU!!

S! !BM! !.U/!! ..! !.(=!!

/! !@*##;45*5!! !./(!! .-! !.=(!!

=! !R$04A%$65&1$'!! !M=!! S! !S-!!

=! !T:A%;4A&! !/!! -! !/!!

=! !3$6&+! !(!! -! !(!!

=! !@#:47+4Y2+*6$A*&! !.-!! -! !.-!!

=! !P+4A$#2+46$%;#*1*5! !,!! -! !,!!

=! !H#&65%+&61!! !.=!! .! !.U!!

=! !?@@!! !.-!! .! !..!!

):&(/.)@.'?,)) )) )AKMAC)) )CLL)) )AKNNM))

3,4,/1,$)! ! ! !

R*$'!Y$94#$!.<<<! !)++! !.(S!! ,/! !,-<!!

R*$'!&91$#!.<<(!>!646!?@J! !B-!X!3Q)>!! !.U<!! .-! !.(<!!

!!B-!X!3Q)p!! !.==!! .-! !.U=!!

!!B.!! !S=!! M! !S<!!

!!B,!! !>!! -! !>!!

!!BM! !.U!! .! !.(!!

!!@*##;45*5!! !.(!! .! !.<!!

!! !T$[$+!=! !.M!! .! !.S!!

R*$'!&91$#!.<<(!>!?@J!! !B-!X!3Q)>!! !>!! -! !>!!

!!B-!X!3Q)p!! !.<!! .! !,-!!

!!B.!! !,M!! .! !,S!!

!!B,!! !>!! -! !>!!

!!BM! !..!! .! !.,!!

!!@*##;45*5!! !UM!! S! !UU!!

!!T$[$+!=! !M/S!! .<! !MUM!!

:&(/.)3,4,/1,$) )) )CKCBD)) )LL)) )CKCMB))

:&(/.)*&;&0() )) )DKNAJ)) )AIJ)) )JKCLM))

&

& &

Page 62: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! M=!

!"#$%&'W(#&2&*+,+-.&/01%&2&>"%9+L,0$0"=&*$"09"4.:&)&BI'R&

3'1,/1,)V,?,.)) )3'1,/1,)E(/Q,)6#&7#)

*./'+/#(1)8#9#&7#)*./'+/#(1) :&(/.)

@.'?,)*./'+/#(1)) ) ) )

.! !B-!X!3Q)>!! !.S=!! ,! !.S(!!

,! !B-!X!3Q)p!! !.<,!! M! !.</!!

M! !B.!! !.=M!! M! !.==!!

M! !B,!! !.=M!! M! !.==!!

S! !BM! !(.!! .! !(,!!

/! !@*##;45*5!! !(,!! .! !(M!!

=! !R$04A%$65&1$'!! !,=!! .! !,U!!

=! !T:A%;4A&! !M!! -! !M!!

=! !3$6&+! !>!! -! !>!!

=! !@#:47+4Y2+*6$A*&! !S!! -! !S!!

=! !P+4A$#2+46$%;#*1*5! !.!! -! !.!!

=! !H#&65%+&61!! !=!! -! !=!!

=! !?@@!! !.-!! -! !.-!!

):&(/.)@.'?,)) )) )MLL)) )CJ)) )MNC))

3,4,/1,$)! ! ! !

R*$'!Y$94#$!.<<<! !)++! !M-.!! M! !M-S!!

R*$'!&91$#!.<<(!>!646!?@J! !B-!X!3Q)>!! !<!! .! !.-!!

!!B-!X!3Q)p!! !.U!! ,! !.<!!

!!B.!! !.,!! ,! !.S!!

!!B,!! !>!! -! !>!!

!!BM! !.!! -! !.!!

!!@*##;45*5!! !(!! .! !<!!

!! !T$[$+!=! !M!! -! !M!!

R*$'!&91$#!.<<(!>!?@J!! !B-!X!3Q)>!! !>!! -! !>!!

!!B-!X!3Q)p!! !.!! -! !.!!

!!B.!! !<!! -! !<!!

!!B,!! !>!! -! !>!!

!!BM! !,!! -! !,!!

!!@*##;45*5!! !,,!! .! !,M!!

!!T$[$+!=! !<U!! ,! !<<!!

:&(/.)3,4,/1,$) )) )JMA)) )CA)) )JNJ))

:&(/.)*&;&0() )) )CKDIN)) )AP)) )CKDMI))

! !

Page 63: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! MU!

.S<C H&Y+$5!.S(&!&6'!.S(Y!52AA&#*5$!1;$!04;4#1!&552A%1*465!94#!1;$!,-.-!5299*0*$60:!#$[*$\C!

!"#$%&'WV"&2&*+,+-.&X::C9L.0+4&D+-&!-"4:DC:%6&*$"09"4.:&2&Z%:.&;:.09".%&BI'I&

E(/("1)6#&7#)

*./'+/#(1)8#9#&7#)*./'+/#(1) :&(/.)

)+*[$! ,e(--! .(U! ,<(U!

R$0$&5$'!%#*4#!14!.<<<! .U<! /! .(S!

R$0$&5$'!&91$#!.<<(! !! !! -!

!>!?@J!#$+&1$'! S,,! M/! S/U!

!>!Q46>?@J!#$+&1$'! M<=! .,! S-(!

H41&+!R$0$&5$'! <<U! /,! .-S<!

:&(/.):0/#12"1,$)*&;&0()^)ABCB) DKLNL) ADN) JKBDP)

&

!"#$%&'WV#&2&*+,+-.&X::C9L.0+4&D+-&>"%9+L,0$0"=&*$"09"4.:&)&Z%:.&;:.09".%&BI'I&

E(/("1)6#&7#)

*./'+/#(1)8#9#&7#)*./'+/#(1) :&(/.)

)+*[$! (<,! ,=! <.(!

R$0$&5$'!%#*4#!14!.<<<! M-.! (! M-<!

R$0$&5$'!&91$#!.<<(! !! !! -!

!>!?@J!#$+&1$'! ..M! =! ..<!

!>!Q46>?@J!#$+&1$'! SM! -! SM!

H41&+!R$0$&5$'! S/U! .S! SU.!

:&(/.)</,+&5;'.'/4)*&;&0()^)ABCB) CKDJN) JB) CKDMN)

&

'

Page 64: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! M(!

D$ !""#$"!

59'.!7-./3.*!

./-C B26'*67!49!1;$!"+&6!*5!5;&#$'!Y$1\$$6!1;$!9$'$#&+!

&6'!%#4[*60*&+l1$##*14#*&+!74[$#6A$615C!!H;$!

9$'$#&+!74[$#6A$61!;&5!%&*'!*15!92++!5;&#$!49!

j(S=eM,Ue/,U!](l..1;5!49!1;$!141&+`C!

./.C H;$!%#4[*60*&+l1$##*14#*&+!74[$#6A$615!%&:!1;$*#!

5;&#$!]*6*1*&+!&A4261!49!jM,Me<</e<-<!&5!49!,,!

E014Y$#!.<<<`!&5!Y$6$9*15!&6'!$c%$65$5!&#$!%&*'e!

\*1;!&6!4%1*46&+!%#$%&:A$61!%#4[*5*46C!!)6:!

26%&*'!Y&+&60$!7#4\5!\*1;!*61$#$51!Y&5$'!46!1;#$$>

A461;!H#$&52#:>Y*++!#&1$5C!

./,C H;$!*6[$51$'!&55$15!&#$!*6[$51$'!%#*A&#*+:!*6!#$&+!#$12#6!Y46'5e!\*1;!&!+$55$#!%4#1*46!*6[$51$'!*6!

$Z2*1*$5e!Y46'5e!&6'!5;4#1>1$#A!5$02#*1*$5C

./MC H;$!&55$15!&#$!5%+*1!Y$1\$$6!&!T467!H$#A!B26'e!&!8;4#1!H$#A!B26'!&6'!&!Q41*46&+!B26'C!!H;$!

A&*6!*6[$51A$615!49!1;$!926'!&#$!A&'$!1;#427;!1;$!T467!H$#A!B26'C!!H;$!8;4#1!H$#A!B26'!*5!

25$'!&5!1;$!542#0$!49!&55$15!14!%&:!Y$6$9*15C!!)5!Y$6$9*15!&#$!%&*'e!1;$!8;4#1!H$#A!B26'!*5!

#$%+$6*5;$'!Y:!&!1#&659$#!9#4A!1;$!T467!H$#A!B26'!&5!6$0$55&#:C!!H;$!Q41*46&+!B26'!#$%#$5$615!

1;$!0461#*Y21*465!4\*67!9#4A!1;$!%#4[*60*&+l1$##*14#*&+!74[$#6A$615C!

1-44'+>!,7!59'.!'11021!

./SC I6!H&Y+$!./Se!\$!;&[$!5;4\6!1;$!&55$1!*694#A&1*46!1&d$6!'*#$01+:!9#4A!1;$!F0d+$#!I6[$51A$61!

82AA&#:!3$%4#1!&5!49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.Me!\;*0;!\&5!*60+2'$'!*6!1;$!V4*61!@4AA*11$$i5!)662&+!

3$%4#1!94#!L$&#!.SC!!!

In This Section, we….

! summarize the Plan’s funding

principles,

! show the Plan’s assets by

type of investment,!

! summarize past investment

performance, and

! summarize the effect of

investment return on the

Plan’s surplus.

Page 65: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! M<!

!"#$%&'KW&2&/C99"-A&+D&U$"4&X::%.:&":&+D&R'&M%=%9#%-&BI'R&"46&BI'I[&

3,140'5('&#)

@11,(1)/()))))))))))))))DC)3,4)ABCD)FcBBB1G)

-,04,#()&2)Y#?,1(,$)@11,(1)

-,04,#()&2):&(/.)@11,(1)

@11,(1)/()))))))))DC)3,4)ABCB)

FcBBB1G)

Y#?,1(,$)@11,(1) ! ! ! !

3$&+!3$12#6!N46'5! j!=<Ue/S<!! =UC<g! /(C=g! j!!UU=e<U<!

N46'5! /=e,/M! /C/g! SCUg! SMe.-S!

@&6&'*&6!FZ2*1:! (,e=UU! (C-g! =C<g! /-eM=.!

DC8C!FZ2*1:! S<e///! SC(g! SC,g! .Ue<U,!

I61$#6&1*46&+!FZ2*1:! S<eS,-! SC(g! SC,g! .<e<S/!

@&5;!&6'!5;4#1!1$#A! SU/! -C-g! -C-g! (/!

T467!H$#A!B26'!H41&+! <M/e<,<! <.C-g! U(C=g! <-(eSS/!

8;4#1!H$#A!B26'! <,e..<! <C-g! UCUg! (.eM,<!

H41&+!I6[$51$'!)55$15! .e-,(e-S(! .--C-g! (=CSg! <(<eUU/!

W&('&#/.)@11,(1) ! !! !! !

"#4[*60*&+lH$##*14#*&+!EY+*7&1*46=!

.=,e./,! !! .MC=g! .(UeS(U!

:&(/.)-./#)@11,(1) H)CKCNBKABB) !! CBB`Ba) H)CKCLLKAPA)

<'*%$'-."0$'-5"?/!+'-&$'!-M$/'A&"5'!%$'N4M>$&':/0$+!5$/!'3?55-&2'@$,"&!'-+'"A'CB'E$4$5.$&'OHBC8''

.//C "&51!*6[$51A$61!#$12#65!&#$!52AA&#*h$'!*6!H&Y+$!.//!Y&5$'!46!*694#A&1*46!0461&*6$'!*6!1;$!

F0d+$#!I6[$51A$61!3$%4#1!94#!,-.M!&6'!94#!%#*4#!:$&#5C!

!"#$%&'KK&)&Q4P%:.9%4.&F%.C-4:&2&BIII&.+&BI'R&

_,/0) Y#?,1(,$)@11,(1) W&('&#/.)@11,(1) *&+b'#,$)

,---! ..CSg! /CSg! <C(g!

,--.! ,CS! SCS! MC.!

,--,! <CM! ,CS! UC=!

,--M! ..C(! ,C<! <CU!

,--S! .SCS! ,CM! ..CU!

,--/! .,CU! ,C=! .-C=!

,--=! -C(! SC-! .CS!

,--U! ,CM! SC,! ,CU!

,--(! >!.C=! ,C/! >!-C(!

,--<! .,C-! -CS! <C(!

,-.-! (C<! -C/! UC/!

,-..! ..CS! -C<! <C(!

,-.,! MC(! -C<! MCS!

,-.M! >,C(! .C-! >,CM!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

=!! )5!49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.Me!L2d46!;&5!%#$%&*'!j.Se---!49!1;$*#!4Y+*7&1*46C!!)5!49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.-e!)+Y$#1&!&6'!L2d46!;&'!%#$%&*'!jM<.e---!49!1;$*#!4Y+*7&1*46C!!H;$5$!%#$%&:A$615!&#$!5;4\6!&5!&6!*6[$51$'!&55$1C!

Page 66: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! S-!

(8'.*01!3.!'11021!%E##!2,!%E#;!

./=C H;$!*694#A&1*46!*6!H&Y+$!./=!*5!1&d$6!9#4A!1;$!F0d+$#!3$%4#1!\;$#$!1;$!0;&67$5!*6!&55$15!'2#*67!

1;$!1;#$$>:$&#!%$#*4'!,-..!14!,-.M!&#$!52AA&#*h$'C!!H;$!%#$>%&:A$615!Y:!%#4[*60$5!&6'!

1$##*14#*$5!&#$!1#&659$##$'!9#4A!1;$!*6[$51$'!&55$15!14!1;$!641*46&+!&55$15!94#!1;*5!%#$5$61&1*46!54!

1;&1!1;$!&++40&1*46!49!Y$6$9*1!%&:A$615!&6'!9$$5!\*++!#$9+$01!1;$!(l..1;5!9$'$#&+!74[$#6A$61!&6'!

Ml..1;5!%#4[*60*&+l1$##*14#*&+!74[$#6A$615!5%+*1!26'$#!1;$!"+&6C!

!"#$%&'K(&2&*,"4N%:&04&X::%.:&2&BI''&.+&BI'R&G\]IIIH:J&

) Y#?,1(,$)@11,(1) W&('&#/.)@11,(1) :&(/.)

)55$15!&1!M.!R$0!,-.-! j<(<eUU/! j.(UeS(U! j.e.UUe,=,!

H#&659$#!%#4[*60*&+l1$##*14#*&+!%#$%&:A$615!14!641*46&+!&55$15!

>M<.! M<.! !>!!!!

@$d"1(,$)/11,(1)/()DC)3,4)ABCB) NMNKDMJ) CMLKMLM) CKCLLKAPA)

I6[$51A$61!*604A$! .,-e.UU! Se(MU! .,/e-.S!

N$6$9*1!%&:A$615! >U/e-SU! >,(e..<! >.-Me.==!

Fc%$65$5!&6'!9$$5! >=eS(-! >,eSM-! >(e<.-!

@$d"1(,$)/11,(1)/()DC)3,4)ABCD) CKBAMKBDJ) CPAKCPP) CKCNBKABB)

H#&659$#!%#4[*60*&+l1$##*14#*&+!%#$%&:A$615!14!*6[$51$'!&55$15!

.S! >.S! !>!!!!

@11,(1)/()DC)3,4)ABCD) HCKBAMKBJM) HCPAKCIA) HCKCNBKABB)

./UC H;$!,-.-![&+2&1*46!&552A$'!1;&1!1;$!141&+!&55$15!\42+'!$&#6!&!Y$51!$51*A&1$!#$12#6!49!MC/Mg!%$#!

&662A!&91$#!*6[$51A$61!A&6&7$A$61!9$$5!]\;*0;!*60+2'$5!,C,/g!14!04[$#!$c%$01$'!*69+&1*46`C!!

H;$!&552A%1*46!*60+2'*67!&!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!\&5!&!#$12#6!49!MCMgC!!R2#*67!1;$!

1;#$$>:$&#!%$#*4'e!*69+&1*46!&[$#&7$'!.C/g!%$#!&662AC!!H;$!&012&+!&[$#&7$!#$12#6!49!1;$!141&+!926'!

4[$#!1;$!%&51!1;#$$!:$&#5!\&5!MCMg!%$#!&662AC!

0770(2!,7!3.601240.2!+02-+.!,.!59'.!1-+59-1!

./(C W*1;!1;$!"+&6!&55$15!*6[$51$'!*6!1;$!$Z2*1:!&6'!Y46'!A&#d$15e!#&1$5!49!#$12#6!\*++!9+2012&1$!4[$#!

1*A$C!!)6!4Y[*425!542#0$!49!9+2012&1*67!#$12#65!\*++!Y$!1;$!$Z2*1:!*6[$51A$615e!\;*0;!&#$!52Yf$01!

14!1;$![4+&1*+*1:!49!1;$!A&#d$15C!!H;*5!\*++!7*[$!#*5$!14!0&%*1&+!7&*65!&6'!+455$5C!!H;$!4[$#&++!$99$01!46!

1;$!926'!\*++!Y$!A*64#!5*60$!1;$!$Z2*1:!*6[$51A$615!&#$!&!5A&++!%4#1*46!49!1;$!926'C!!!

./<C H;$!A&f4#!04A%46$61!49!9+2012&1*67!#$12#65!\*++!+*d$+:!Y$!9#4A!0;&67$5!*6!1;$!#&1$!49!#$12#6!

$c%$01&1*465!49!Y46'!*6[$514#5e!%#*A&#*+:!&5!1;*5!&99$015!1;$!#$&+!#$12#6!$c%$01&1*465C!!W;$6!

*61$#$51!#&1$5!'$0#$&5$e!1;$!A&#d$1![&+2$!49!Y46'5!\*++!*60#$&5$C!!E[$#!1;$!,--.!14!,-.,!%$#*4'e!

\$!5&\!&!7#&'2&+!&6'!51$&':!'$0+*6$!*6!*61$#$51!#&1$5e!\*1;!1;$!#$52+1!1;&1!1;$!3$&+!3$12#6!N46'!

&55$15!*60#$&5$'!*6![&+2$!9#4A!1;$!#$52+1*67!0&%*1&+!7&*65C!

.=-C R2#*67!,-.Me!*61$#$51!#&1$5!#45$!5+*7;1+:!&6'!1;&1!#$52+1$'!*6!&!0&%*1&+!+455!46!1;$!#$&+!#$12#6!

Y46'5!*6!1;$!%4#194+*4C!!!!

Page 67: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! S.!

.=.C ?4\$[$#e!Y$0&25$!49!1;$!6&12#$!49!1;$!"+&6!&55$15!&6'!1;$!"+&6!+*&Y*+*1*$5e!&6:!*60#$&5$!*6!&55$15!

'2$!14!'$0+*6*67!*61$#$51!#&1$5!\*++!Y$!4995$1!Y:!&6!*60#$&5$!*6!+*&Y*+*1*$5C!!H;$!046[$#5$!*5!&+54!1#2$C!!

I9!*61$#$51!#&1$5!5;42+'!0461*62$!14!*60#$&5$e!1;$!"+&6!&55$15!\*++!5299$#!0&%*1&+!+455$5e!Y21!1;$:!\*++!

Y$!4995$1!Y:!&!'$0#$&5$!*6!1;$!"+&6!+*&Y*+*1*$5C!

.=,C J*#12&++:!&++!49!1;$!"+&6!Y$6$9*15!&#$!52Yf$01!14!*69+&1*46!*60#$&5$5C!!)5!+467!&5!1;$!&A4261!49!"+&6!

&55$15!*6[$51$'!*6!#$&+!#$12#6!Y46'5!$Z2&+5!4#!$c0$$'5!1;$!"+&6!+*&Y*+*1*$5!]*60+2'*67!9$$5!&6'!

$c%$65$5`e!9212#$!0;&67$5!*6!*69+&1*46!\*++!;&[$!64!4#![$#:!+*11+$!$99$01!46!1;$!"+&6i5!9*6&60*&+!

%45*1*46C!!H;*5!*5!Y$0&25$!#$&+!#$12#6!Y46'5!%#4[*'$!&!#$12#6!$Z2&+!14!*69+&1*46!%+25!1;$!#$&+!#&1$!49!

#$12#6!46!\;*0;!1;$:!\$#$!%#*0$'C!!84!&6:!0;&67$5!*6!1;$!&A4261!49!Y$6$9*1!14!Y$!%&*'!'2$!14!

*69+&1*46!\*++!Y$!04[$#$'!Y:!1;$!#$12#6!9#4A!1;$!#$&+!#$12#6!Y46'5C!

.=MC "#4[*'$'!"+&6!+*&Y*+*1*$5!&#$!0&+02+&1$'!Y&5$'!46!&6!*61$#$51!#&1$!$Z2&+!14!1;$!02##$61!A&#d$1!:*$+'!

94#!#$&+!#$12#6!Y46'5e!0;&67$5!*6!1;$!#$&+!#&1$!49!#$12#6!\*++!Y$!+&#7$+:!4995$11*67!Y$1\$$6!1;$!

&55$15!&6'!+*&Y*+*1*$5C!

! !

Page 68: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! S,!

F$ !"#$#%"$&'()*+&,*!

.=SC H;$![&+2&1*46!A4'$+!25$'!*6!0&+02+&1*67!1;$5$!+*&Y*+*1*$5!*5!

'*50255$'!*6!)%%$6'*c!@C!!F55$61*&++:e!1;$!A4'$+!%#4f$015!

1;$!'*5$&5$!%#47#$55*46!49!?$%&1*1*5!@!94#!$&0;!%$#546!

Y&5$'!2%46!1;$!&662&+!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!94#!1#&65*1*46!1;#427;!

1;$![&#*425!51&7$5!49!1;$!'*5$&5$C!!H;$5$!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!\$#$!

1&d$6!9#4A!1;$!KKWP!#$%4#1!&6'!&#$!52AA&#*h$'e!&+467!

\*1;!&++!49!1;$!&012&#*&+!&552A%1*465!25$'e!*6!)%%$6'*c!R!X!

82AA&#:!49!)012&#*&+!)552A%1*465C!

.=/C I6!1;*5!#$%4#1e!\$!5;4\!#$52+15!46!&!Y$51!$51*A&1$!Y&5*5!&5!

\$++!&5!#$52+15!*60+2'*67!&!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465C!!!

.==C H;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!#$52+15!&#$!Y&5$'!46!&012&#*&+!

&552A%1*465!1;&1!*6!42#!4%*6*46!#$%#$5$61!1;$!A451!+*d$+:!

$c%$01&1*46!94#!1;$!9212#$C!!H;*5!A$&65!1;&1!1;$#$!*5!

&%%#4c*A&1$+:!&!/-g!0;&60$!1;&1!9212#$!$c%$#*$60$!\*++!Y$!

Y$11$#!1;&6!1;$!&552A%1*46!&6'!&!/-g!0;&60$!1;&1!*1!\*++!Y$!

\4#5$C!!I6!1;*5!\&:e!1;$!#$52+1*67!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&012&#*&+!

+*&Y*+*1*$5!#$%#$5$61!1;$!&A4261!49!&55$15!#$Z2*#$'!54!1;$#$!

*5!&%%#4c*A&1$+:!&!/-g!0;&60$!49!;&[*67!144!A20;!926'5!

&6'!&!/-g!0;&60$!49!;&[*67!144!+*11+$!926'5C!

.=UC I1!*5!6$*1;$#!&%%#4%#*&1$!64#!%#2'$61!14!&55$55!1;$!5299*0*$60:!49!1;$!B26'!25*67!Y$51!$51*A&1$!

&552A%1*465C!!8*60$!1;$#$!*5!&6!&7#$$A$61!1;&1!64!&''*1*46&+!A46*$5!\*++!Y$!%#4[*'$'!14!1;$!B26'!

Y:!1;$!74[$#6A$615e!*1!*5!%#2'$61!14!&55$55!1;$!9*6&60*&+!5299*0*$60:!49!1;$!B26'!21*+*h*67!&!Y&5*5!

1;&1!;&5!&!7#$&1$#!0;&60$!1;&6!/-g!49!;&[*67!5299*0*$61!&55$15!14!%&:!&++!9212#$!Y$6$9*15C!!H;*5!*5!

'46$!1;#427;!1;$!25$!49!0465$#[&1*5A!*6!1;$!&012&#*&+!&552A%1*465C!!@465$#[&1*5A!*5!*61#4'20$'!

1;#427;!1;$!25$!49!&552A%1*465!1;&1!#$%#$5$61!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!94#!1;$!9212#$!,>?+!&!%#4[*5*46!94#!

&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465C!!W;*+$!*1!*5!%455*Y+$!1;&1!&012&+!$c%$#*$60$!'*99$#*67!9#4A!42#!Y$51!$51*A&1$!

A&:!Y$!%45*1*[$!]#$'20*67!1;$!"+&6!+*&Y*+*1*$5`e!1;*5!5;42+'!641!Y$!#$0476*h$'!261*+!520;!1*A$!&5!&!

%45*1*[$!'$[*&1*46!;&5!4002##$'C!

.=(C H;$!25$!49!Y$51!$51*A&1$!#$52+15!147$1;$#!\*1;!#$52+15!*60+2'*67!&!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!

%$#A*15!1;$!25$#!49!1;*5!#$%4#1!14!&55$55!1;$!+$[$+!49!0465$#[&1*5A!*6;$#$61!*6!1;$!#$52+15!&6'!

1;$#$94#$!7&*6!&6!*65*7;1!*614!1;$!#$52+1*67!+$[$+!49!0465$#[&1*5AC!!D+1*A&1$+:e!*1!*5!&6!*552$!49!

*6'*[*'2&+!f2'7$A$61!&5!14!1;$!&A4261!&6'!'$7#$$!49!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!1;&1!*5!

%#2'$61!14!#$0476*h$e!;&[*67!#$7&#'!14!1;$!*61$#$51!49!&++!%&#1*$5!14!1;$!8$11+$A$61!)7#$$A$61

.=<C H;$!94++4\*67!1\4!1&Y+$5!52AA&#*h$!42#!#$52+15!Y:!Y$6$9*1C!!H;$!#$52+15!4Y1&*6$'!Y:!F0d+$#!&#$e!

9#4A!&!A&1$#*&+*1:!%$#5%$01*[$e!$55$61*&++:!1;$!5&A$!&5!1;$5$C!!

In This Section, we….

! discuss the appropriate use

of best estimate

assumptions, and the

importance of making a

provision for adverse

deviations in the liabilities,

! set out the present value

of future compensation

payments and

administration expenses;

! present a summary of the

overall financial position of

the Plan;

! discuss the amount of

provision for adverse

deviations that is

reasonable; and

! review the experience

gains and losses over the

past three years.

Page 69: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! SM!

!"#$%&'(T"&2&!-"4:DC:%6&*$"09"4.:&2&E04"4=0"$&F%:C$.:&":&".&R'&M%=%9#%-&BI'R&G04&HIII:J&

-./#)E,4('&#) =,#,2'() =,1()>1('+/(,)

Y#4."$'#Q)-0&?'1'&#)2&0)@$?,01,)

3,?'/('&#1)

SC-.].`]&`! T$[$+!.a!!j.-e---!X!%45*1*[$!&61*>?@J! jMe-(,!! jMe-(,!!

SC-.].`]Y`! T$[$+!,a!!j,-e---!X!"@3!H$51!%45*1*[$! !/e-MM!! !/e-MM!!

SC-.].`]0`! T$[$+!Ma!!jM-e---!X!Q46>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5! !<e<(-!! !.,eM/<!!

SC-.].`]'`! T$[$+!/a!!j=/e---!X!@*##;45*5! !.Me./U!! !,-e,SS!!

SC-.].`]$`! T$[$+!=a!!j.--e---!X!R$04A%l0&60$#! !,SeS,.!! !M,eU.<!!

SC-.]M`]&`! T455!49!*604A$>!646>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5! !/eMU-!! !/eU--!!

SC-.]M`]Y`! T455!49!5$#[*0$5>!646>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5! !.,eM=M!! !.Me-M=!!

SC-,! T455!49!*604A$! !.<e=-=!! !,=e,<,!!

SC-M! T455!49!5$#[*0$5! !/-eU(-!! !=Me,MS!!

SC-S! @451!49!0&#$! !.=e((U!! !M,e./S!!

SC-/! ?@J!'#27!1;$#&%:! !=e=U-!! !UeM..!!

SC-=! D6*652#$'!1#$&1A$61!!>!?@J!02#$!'#275! !</e=UU!! !.,<e,==!!

SC-=! D6*652#$'!1#$&1A$61!X!646>?@J!02#$!'#275! !,e<M/!! !Me-..!!

SC-U! E21>49>%40d$1!$c%$65$5! !Se-MM!! !/eU--!!

! 8$046'&#*+:!*69$01$'! !>!!!! !>!!!!

SC-(! ?IJ!5$046'&#*+:!*69$01$'! !>!!!! !>!!!!

! -0,^CNNN)$,/(;1! ! !

/C-.! X!+2A%!52A5! !,e(=U!! !,e<-<!!

/C-.].`! X!926$#&+! !.-(!! !.-<!!

=C-.].`! X!T455!49!82%%4#1! !,e/.(!! !,e//.!!

=C-.],`! X!T455!49!8$#[*0$5! !(eMUU!! !(e/M.!!

! -0,^CNNN)$,/(;1)1"b)(&(/.) !.Me(U-!! !.Se.--!!

! -&1()CNNN)$,/(;1! ! !

/C-,! X!926$#&+! !.e/((!! !,e-M.!!

=C-.].`! X!T455!49!82%%4#1! !.,e(=/!! !.=e.-.!!

=C-.],`! X!T455!49!8$#[*0$5! !//e/=(!! !=.e(SS!!

=C-,! T455!49!@&#$!&6'!P2*'&60$! !.<eS-,!! !,Se/=(!!

! E2151&6'*67!"&:A$615! !=eM<-!! !=eM<-!!

! )1:%*0&+!T$[$+!=!@+&*A&615! !UeSMU!! !UeSMU!!

) :&(/.) HDMLKCCJ)) HJNCKPCA))

!

Page 70: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! SS!

!"#$%&'(T#&)&>"%9+L,0$0"=:&2&E04"4=0"$&F%:C$.:&":&".&R'&M%=%9#%-&BI'R&G04&HIII:J&

-./#)E,4('&#) =,#,2'() =,1()>1('+/(,)

Y#4."$'#Q)-0&?'1'&#)2&0)@$?,01,)

3,?'/('&#1)

SC-.].`]&`! T$[$+!.a!!j.-e---!X!%45*1*[$!&61*>?@J! j,=<!! j,=<!!

SC-.].`]Y`! T$[$+!,a!!j,-e---!X!"@3!H$51!%45*1*[$! !/M(!! !/M(!!

SC-.].`]0`! T$[$+!Ma!!jM-e---!X!Q46>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5! !.e=,U!! !,e-(/!!

SC-.].`]'`! T$[$+!/a!!j=/e---!X!@*##;45*5! !/e=M.!! !(e.<.!!

SC-.].`]$`! T$[$+!=a!!j.--e---!X!R$04A%l0&60$#! !.MeM,U!! !.=e==,!!

SC-.]M`]&`! T455!49!*604A$>!646>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5! !<U,!! !.e.,U!!

SC-.]M`]Y`! T455!49!5$#[*0$5>!646>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5! !,e//U!! !,e=.S!!

SC-,! T455!49!*604A$! !,=e,.-!! !M-e-U<!!

SC-M! T455!49!5$#[*0$5! !,(e-.-!! !M.eU.(!!

SC-S! @451!49!0&#$! !.-e.S,!! !.(e-/<!!

SC-/! ?@J!'#27!1;$#&%:! !.e=/U!! !.e(.=!!

SC-=! D6*652#$'!1#$&1A$61!!>!?@J!02#$!'#275! !,-eM-,!! !,UeMM-!!

! D6*652#$'!1#$&1A$61!X!646>?@J!02#$!'#275! !MeU./!! !MeU<<!!

SC-U! E21>49>%40d$1!$c%$65$5! !,e(/=!! !Se,-M!!

! 8$046'&#*+:!*69$01$'! !>!!!! !>!!!!

SC-(! ?IJ!5$046'&#*+:!*69$01$'! !>!!!! !>!!!!

SC-(],`! j/-e---!+2A%!52A!4%1*46!94#!04>*69$01$'! !,-,!! !,-,!!

! -0,^CNNN)$,/(;1! ! !

/C-.! X!+2A%!52A5! !MS/!! !M/-!!

/C-.].`! X!926$#&+! !.M!! !.M!!

=C-.].`! X!T455!49!82%%4#1! !<e-S-!! !<e.(=!!

=C-.],`! X!T455!49!8$#[*0$5! !.MeUU<!! !.Se.MU!!

! -&1()CNNN)$,/(;1! ! !

/C-,! X!926$#&+! !U/U!! !<-M!!

=C-.].`! X!T455!49!82%%4#1! !,,e.=/!! !,Se<UM!!

=C-.],`! X!T455!49!8$#[*0$5! !S.e=M=!! !S/e<=M!!

=C-,! T455!49!@&#$!&6'!P2*'&60$! !.-e=U=!! !.,eU..!!

! E2151&6'*67!"&:A$615! !/e/,.!! !/e/,.!!

! )1:%*0&+!T$[$+!=!@+&*A&615! !,e-,,!! !,e-,,!!

) :&(/.) HAADKNPN)) HAPJKJLC))

!

Page 71: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! S/!

.U-C I6!&''*1*46!14!04A%$65&1*46!%&:&Y+$!14!?@J!0+&*A&615e!1;$!926'!A251!&+54!04[$#!1;$!$c%$65$5!49!

1;$!V4*61!@4AA*11$$e!1;$!&'A*6*51#&14#!&6'![&#*425!04652+1&615!&6'!41;$#!%&#1*$5C!!H;$!&662&+!

&A4261!49!1;$5$!$c%$65$5!*5!'$1&*+$'!*6!8$01*46!..!>!)012&#*&+!)552A%1*465C!!W$!;&[$!25$'!1;$!

5&A$!$c%$01$'!&662&+!9$$!&A42615!94#!Y41;!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&6'!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!

0&+02+&1*465C!!H;$!'*99$#$60$5!*6!+*&Y*+*1*$5!&#$!'2$!54+$+:!14!1;$!*61$#$51!#&1$5C!!Fc%$65$5!#$+&1$'!14!

*6[$51A$61!A&6&7$A$61!&#$!641!*60+2'$'!*6!1;*5!5$01*46!&5!1;$:!&#$!*A%+*0*1+:!#$0476*h$'!*6!1;$!

*6[$51A$61!#&1$!49!#$12#6C!

.U.C H;$!%#$5$61![&+2$!49!1;$!9212#$!$c%$01$'!$c%$65$5!*5!&5!94++4\5a!

!"#$%&'S'&2&U-%:%4.&?"$C%&+D&EC.C-%&E%%:&"46&;<L%4:%:&G04&HIII:J&

!,,1)/#$)>O5,#1,1) =,1()>1('+/(,)-0&?'1'&#)2&0)@$?,01,)

3,?'/('&#)

)012&#*&+! j!!(e-,=! j!!(eMS/!

)004261*67!&6'!$c%$#1!1$51*A46:!&6'!&55*51&60$! !S-<!! !S,/!!

)'A*6*51#&1*46! ./e,.<! ./e(M<!

)#Y*1#&14#5l3$9$#$$5! !,<S!! !M-/!!

)2'*1! ,e/-M! ,e=-=!

@&6&'*&6!N+44'!8$#[*0$5! !,/-!! !,=.!!

@4AA26*0&1*465! SMS! S/.!

B26'!@4265$+! .eM(=! .eSMS!

?vA&>m2vY$0! !U/!! !U(!!

I6'$%$6'$61!@4265$+! !,/-!! !,=.!!

V4*61!@4AA*11$$! .=e=-(! .Ue,M/!

K$'*0&+!K4'$++*67! !.e<-<!! !.e<(S!!

K46*14#! !<,S!! !</=!!

8491\&#$!R$[$+4%A$61! !,/-!! !,=.!!

H&c$5!!X!?8H!&6'!P8H! Se<.(! /e...!

9/&$4! H)IDKJII) H)IIKIIA)

!

836!5+,*+'4!

.U,C I6!&''*1*46!14!1;$!?@J!Y$6$9*15e!1;$!B26'!*5!&+54!#$5%465*Y+$!94#!A&d*67!Y$6$9*1!%&:A$615!26'$#!

1;$!?IJ!"#47#&A!49!j,S-e---!14!$&0;!$+*7*Y+$!0+&*A&61C!!H;*5!#$52+15!*6!&!Y$51!$51*A&1$!+*&Y*+*1:!49!

j</-e---!&6'!j<U-e---!*60+2'*67!&!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!94#!1;$!?IJ!"#47#&AC!!!

Page 72: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! S=!

73.'.(3'9!5,1323,.!,7!280!59'.!

.UMC H&Y+$!.UM!%#$5$615!&!52AA&#:!49!1;$!4[$#&++!9*6&60*&+!#$52+15!49!1;$!"+&6!147$1;$#!\*1;!

04A%&#&1*[$!+*&Y*+*1*$5!9#4A!,-.-C!!H;$!,-.M!#$52+15!&#$!5*A*+&#!14!1;45$!F0d+$#!4Y1&*6$'C!

!"#$%&'SR&)&/C99"-A&+D&E04"4=0"$&F%:C$.:&":&".&R'&M%=%9#%-&BI'R&50.,&BI'I&=+9L"-".0P%:&G04&HIII:J&

) =,1()>1('+/(,) -0&?'1'&#)2&0)@$?,01,)3,?'/('&#1))

! ABCD) ABCB) ABCD) ABCB)

)55$15! j!.e.<-e.<<! j!.e.UUe,=,!! j!.e.<-e.<<! j!.e.UUe,=,!

T*&Y*+*1*$5! ! ! ! !

! H#&65925$'! !M(Ue..S!! S.,e-.,! !S<.e=.,!! /,(eS-S!

! ?&$A4%;*+*&05! ,,Me<=<! ,S,e,S-! ,=SeSU.! ,(Se./-!

! ?IJ!"#47#&A! !</-!! .e.--! !<U-!! .e.--!

! B$$5!k!Fc%$65$5! !/MeS//!! MSe-<.! !//e//,!! MSe=/(!

H41&+!"+&6!T*&Y*+*1*$5! !==/eS((!! =(<eSSM! !(.,e=-/!! (S(eM.,!

!"#$)E"05."1)F3,2'4'(G) HIAJKLCC) HJMLKMCN) HDLLKINJ) HDAMKNIB)

)''*1*46&+!Y299$#!&7&*651!0&1&51#4%;*0!$[$615!

!! ! !.,.e---!! >!!

>O4,11)@11,(1) ) !) HAIPKINJ) HDAMKNIB)

!

.USC H;$!'*99$#$60$!*6!1;$!141&+!+*&Y*+*1*$5!\*1;!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!04A%&#$'!14!1;$!141&+!

Y$51!$51*A&1$!+*&Y*+*1*$5!*5!&!A$&52#$!49!1;$!'$7#$$!49!0465$#[&1*5A!*60+2'$'!*6!1;$!#$52+15C!!H;$!

%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!94#!,-.M!*5!&Y421!,,g!7#$&1$#!1;&6!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!+*&Y*+*1*$5C!!

)5!&1!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.-e!*1!\&5!&Y421!,Mg!7#$&1$#!1;&6!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!+*&Y*+*1:C!!!

.U/C W*1;!1;$!%&55&7$!49!1*A$e!1;$!'$7#$$!49!260$#1&*61:!&Y421!A&6:!49!1;$!&552A%1*465e!]520;!&5!1;$!

2+1*A&1$!04;4#1!5*h$e!0+&*A*67!%&11$#65e!&6'!'*5$&5$!%#47#$55*46`!*5!#$'20$'C!!W*1;!+4\$#!

260$#1&*61:e!1;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!5;42+'!&+54!'$0#$&5$C!

.U=C W*1;!1;*5![&+2&1*46e!1;$!*61#4'201*46!49!6$\!'#275!\*1;!1;$*#!;*7;!$99*0&0:!;&5!*60#$&5$'!1;$!

260$#1&*6+:!94#!*1$A5!1;&1!&#$!#$+&1$'!14!1#$&1A$61C!!W$!;&[$![$#:!+*A*1$'!'&1&!&Y421!1;$!0451!49!

1;$!6$\!'#275e!1;$!'$7#$$!14!\;*0;!%#4[*60*&+!;$&+1;!%+&65!&6'!%#*[&1$!*652#&60$!\*++!0461#*Y21$!

14\&#'!1;$!0451e!1;$!&012&+!$99*0&0:!49!1;$![&#*425!'#275!&6'!1;$!$99$01!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25!\*++!;&[$!

46!'*5&Y*+*1:!Y$6$9*15!&6'!$c0$55!?@J!A4#1&+*1:C!!Q$[$#1;$+$55e!\$!;&'!14!A&d$!&552A%1*465!&Y421!

1;$5$!*1$A5C!!H;*5!*60#$&5$'!260$#1&*61:!5277$515!&!+&#7$#!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!*6!

,-.MC!!

.UUC H;$#$!&#$!54A$!41;$#!&552A%1*465!\;$#$!\$!Y$+*$[$!1;$!'$7#$$!49!260$#1&*61:!;&5!'$0#$&5$'!14!

1;$!%4*61!1;&1![$#:!+*11+$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!*5!\&##&61$'C!!H;$!26d64\6!04;4#1!5*h$!

*5!26+*d$+:!14!'$[*&1$!A&1$#*&++:!9#4A!1;$!&552A$'!62AY$#e!$c*51*67!+455!49!*604A$!&6'!+455!49!

Page 73: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! SU!

5$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*15!&#$!+*d$+:!14!'$0#$&5$!*9!&6:1;*67!'2$!14!1;$!6$\!'#27!1#$&1A$615!&6'!$c*51*67!

+455!49!52%%4#1!&6'!+455!49!5$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*15!&#$!26+*d$+:!14![&#:!*6!1;$!9212#$C!

.U(C I61$#$51!&6'!*69+&1*46!&#$!491$6!A&f4#!#*5d!9&014#5!94#!A&6:!*6[$51$'!926'5C!!)5!'*50255$'!*6!

8$01*46!<!>!)6&+:5*5!49!8$65*1*[*1:e!*61$#$51!&6'!*69+&1*46!5;42+'!Y$!49!+*A*1$'!#*5d!94#!1;*5!"+&6!&5!&!

#$52+1!49!1;$!1:%$!49!*6[$51A$615!25$'C!!!

.U<C W;*+$!1;$#$!&#$!A&6:!41;$#!&552A%1*465!A&'$!*6!1;$!042#5$!49!1;*5![&+2&1*46e!1;$!#$51!49!1;$!

&552A%1*465!;&[$!&!#$+&1*[$+:!A*64#!$99$01!46!1;$!9*6&60*&+!#$52+15C!!!

.(-C )Y421!;&+9!1;$!+*&Y*+*1*$5!&#$!52Yf$01!14!&!+4\!'$7#$$!49!260$#1&*61:!&6'!&Y421!;&+9!14!&!;*7;!'$7#$$!

49!260$#1&*61:C!!I6!A:!4%*6*46e!&!M-g!14!M/g!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!94#!1;$!+*&Y*+*1*$5!

94#!\;*0;!1;$#$!*5!&!;*7;$#!260$#1&*61:!&6'!&!.-g!14!./g!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!94#!1;$!

+*&Y*+*1*$5!94#!\;*0;!1;$#$!*5!&!+4\!'$7#$$!49!260$#1&*61:!*5!&%%#4%#*&1$C!!@4AY*6$'e!1;&1!7*[$5!&6!

4[$#&++!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!49!&Y421!,-g!14!,/gC!

.(.C I6!42#!4%*6*46e!1;$!4[$#&++!&[$#&7$!,,g!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!*5!&%%#4%#*&1$!94#!1;$!

,-.M!5299*0*$60:!#$[*$\C!!!

.(,C H&Y+$!.(,!5;4\5!1;$!'$[$+4%A$61!49!1;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!+*&Y*+*1:!51&#1*67!9#4A!

1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&6'!&''*67!1;$![&#*425!04A%46$615!49!1;$!%#4[*5*46C!!@;&#1!.(,!5;4\5!1;$!

#$+&1*[$!5*h$!49!1;$5$!%#4[*5*465C!!!

!"#$%&&'VB&2&M%P%$+L9%4.&+D&U-+P0:0+4&D+-&X6P%-:%&M%P0".0+4:&O0"#0$0.A&

Y(,+)) )@+&"#())FeBBB1G)

N$51!F51*A&1$!T*&Y*+*1:!! j!==/eS((!!

R*504261!3&1$!! !.=eUSU!!

R#27!@4515!! !S-e<,,!!

R#27!F99*0&0:!! !=.e/-M!!

3$04[$#:!9#4A!R*5&Y*+*1:!! !Se/.,!!

@4515!49!@&#$!! !.=eUM=!!

E21>49>"40d$1!$c%$65$5!! !,eU.<!!

T455!49!I604A$e!82%%4#1!&6'!8$#[*0$5!! !Me<U(!!

.%/I+,+/1!A/%!J3I-%,-!*-I+$&+/1,!K+$:+4+&L!! M!N;GE=<'!'

)''*1*46&+!Y299$#!94#!0&1&51#4%;*0!$[$615! .,.e---!

:&(/.)V'/b'.'([)'#4."$'#Q)@$$'('&#/.)="22,0)) H)NDDKPBI))

!

!

Page 74: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! S(!

*,"-.&'VB&2&X9+C4.&+D&U-+P0:0+4&D+-&X6P%-:%&M%P0".0+4:&"46&*".":.-+L,0=&;P%4.:

&&

'//323,.'9!&-770+!'*'3.12!('2'12+,583(!060.21!

.(MC H;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!#$0476*h$5!1;&1!&552A%1*465!&Y421!1;$!9212#$!A&:!%#4[$!14!

Y$!\#467!&6'!*60#$&5$5!1;$!0469*'$60$!1;&1!1;$!141&+!+*&Y*+*1:!*60+2'*67!1;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!

'$[*&1*465!\*++!Y$!5299*0*$61!14!A$$1!$A$#7*67!Y$6$9*15!&5!1;$:!Y$04A$!%&:&Y+$C!!I1!*5!641!*61$6'$'!

14!04[$#!0&1&51#4%;*0!$[$615!1;&1!A&:!4002#C!!)6!&''*1*46&+!Y299$#!*5!#$Z2*#$'!*9!*1!*5!0465*'$#$'!

&%%#4%#*&1$!14!A&d$!&!%#4[*5*46!*6!0&5$!520;!$[$615!4002#C!

.(SC )6!&''*1*46&+!Y299$#!*5!641!&+\&:5!6$0$55&#:C!!H;$#$!A&:!Y$!5*12&1*465!\;$#$!*652#&60$!4#!

72&#&61$$5!&#$!&[&*+&Y+$!14!#$'20$!1;$!#*5d!49!*65299*0*$60:C!!)5!&!926'!\*1;!64!&[&*+&Y+$!542#0$!49!

&''*1*46&+!A46*$5e!*6!42#!4%*6*46e!1;$!B26'!*5!*6!&!%45*1*46!\;$#$!&6!&''*1*46&+!Y299$#!*5!

&%%#4%#*&1$C!

.(/C @&1&51#4%;*0!$[$615!0&6!Y$!7#42%$'!*614!1\4!0&1$74#*$5!>!1;45$!1;&1!&#$!#$&546&Y+$!14!*A&7*6$!

4002##*67!&6'!1;45$!1;&1!&#$!$c1#$A$+:!#$A41$C!!B4#!$c&A%+$e!*9!:42!\$#$!14!9+*%!&!04*6!.--!1*A$5!

&6'!;&'!14!%&:!421!j.e---!94#!$[$#:!;$&'!Y21!:42!#$0$*[$'!j.e---!94#!$[$#:!1&*+e!:42#!Y$51!

$51*A&1$!+*&Y*+*1:!\42+'!Y$!h$#4C!!]L42!\42+'!$c%$01!14!9+*%!/-!;$&'5!&6'!1;$#$Y:!%&:!j/-e---!&6'!

&+54!9+*%!/-!1&*+5!&6'!#$0$*[$!j/-e---`C!!)'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!\42+'!Y$!&6:!#$52+1!1;&1!%#4'20$'!

A4#$!;$&'5!1;&6!1&*+5!5*60$!1;&1!\42+'!7*[$!&!#$52+1!\;$#$!:42!\42+'!;&[$!14!%&:C!!H;$#$!*5!&Y421!

&6!(=g!%#4Y&Y*+*1:!1;&1!:42!\*++!9+*%!64!A4#$!1;&6!//!;$&'5e!4#!12#6*67!1;&1!&#426'e!&Y421!.Sg!49!

"#$%!&$'()%#!*+),+-+%.!

!/+$0123%!4)%#!!

!/526!71$%$!!

!/526!&80)0.!!

4#019#5.!:51(!/+$),+-+%.!

!71$%$!1:!7)5#!!

;2%<1:<=10>#%!#?@#3$#$!

*1$$!1:!A301(#B!C2@@15%!)3D!

C#59+0#$!

EDD+'13)-!"2F#5!:15!

0)%)$%51@G+0!#9#3%$!

Page 75: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! S<!

1;$!1*A$!:42!\*++!+45$!A4#$!1;&6!j.-e---C!!H;&1!A*7;1!Y$!&!#$&546&Y+$!&552A%1*46!14!A&d$!94#!

'$1$#A*6*67!&!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465C!

.(=C B+*%%*67!A4#$!1;&6!//!;$&'5!\42+'!Z2*0d+:!7$1!:42!*614!1;$!0&1&51#4%;*0!1$##*14#:!X!94#!$c&A%+$!

9+*%%*67!=-!;$&'5!\42+'!#$52+1!*6!&!+455!49!j,-e---C!!H;$!%#4Y&Y*+*1:!49!9+*%%*67!=-!4#!A4#$!;$&'5!

*6!.--!1455$5!*5!+$55!1;&6!,gC!!H;&1!042+'!Y$!1&d$6!&5!&!#$&546&Y+$!Y&5*5!14!Y$!25$'!94#!&6!

&''*1*46&+!Y299$#!94#!0&1&51#4%;*0!$[$615C!!

.(UC 8$11*67!&!Y299$#!94#!1;$!0&1&51#4%;$!1;&1!A*7;1!;&%%$6!460$!*6!.e---!4002##$60$5!*5!+*d$+:!641!

&%%#4%#*&1$C!!]I6!42#!04*6!9+*%!$c&A%+$e!1;&1!\42+'!Y$!5*A*+&#!14!7$11*67!&1!=/!4#!A4#$!;$&'5`C!!N21!

*1!*5!&%%#4%#*&1$!14!0465*'$#!&!0&1&51#4%;*0!$[$61!1;&1!A*7;1!4002#!64!A4#$!1;&6!.g!4#!,g!49!1;$!

1*A$!]=-!4#!=.!;$&'5`C!

.((C I6!A:!4%*6*46e!94#!1;$!04A%$65&1*46!926'e!&!#$&546&Y+$!Y299$#!&7&*651!0&1&51#4%;*0!$[$615!\42+'!

Y$!&6!&''*1*46&+!./g!49!1;$!141&+!+*&Y*+*1*$5!*60+2'*67!1;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465C!!H;&1!

%#4'20$5!&!Y299$#!49!j.,.!A*++*46C!

.(<C F0d+$#!;&5!'$1$#A*6$'!&!Y299$#!Y:!'$[$+4%*67!&6!?@J>5%$0*9*0!9#&A$\4#d!94#!&55$55*67!1;$!

&%%#4%#*&1$!&A4261!49!&''*1*46&+!&55$15!$51*A&1$'!14!Y$!5299*0*$61!14!A$$1!#$&546&Y+$!

0&1&51#4%;*0!$[$615C!!H;$:!#$9$#!14!1;*5!Y299$#!&5!^#$Z2*#$'!0&%*1&+_C!!H;$*#!&%%#4&0;!*5!5*A*+&#!14!

1;&1!21*+*h$'!*6!1;$!*652#&60$!*6'251#:!*6!@&6&'&C!!H;$!'$1$#A*6&1*46!49!1;$!#$Z2*#$'!0&%*1&+!

&11$A%15!14!+44d!&1!0&1&51#4%;*0!$[$615!&6'!Z2&61*9:!1;$!#$52+1*67!0451C!!I6!42#!,-.-!#$%4#1e!\$!

%#4[*'$'!04AA$61&#:!46!1;&1!&%%#4&0;!&5!*1!\&5!25$'!*6!,-.-C!!W$!;&[$!;&'!54A$!'*50255*465!

\*1;!F0d+$#!&Y421!1;$!Y&5*5!1;$:!;&[$!25$'!94#!,-.M!&6'!1;$!#$52+15!%#4'20$'C!!B4#!$c&A%+$e!46$!

49!1;$!0&1&51#4%;*0!$[$615!1;&1!1;$:!;&[$!A4'$+$'!*5!1;$!%455*Y*+*1:!1;&1!1;$!$99*0&0:!49!1;$!6$\!

'#275!\42+'!Y$!46+:!=Ug!49!1;$!$99*0&0:!#&1$5!5$1!421!*6!1;$!KKWP!#$%4#1C!!H;&1!\42+'!Y$!&!

0&1&51#4%;*0!$[$61!9#4A!1;$!%$#5%$01*[$!49!1;$!B26'!&5!*1!\42+'!*60#$&5$!1;$!+*&Y*+*1*$5C!!I1!*5!

#$A41$!$6427;!14!Y$!4215*'$!1;$!0465*'$#&1*465!1;&1!*69+2$60$!&!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465e!

Y21!641!54!#$A41$!1;&1!*1!5;42+'!Y$!*764#$'!94#!%2#%45$5!49!&6!&''*1*46&+!Y299$#C!

.<-C N&5$'!46!42#!'*50255*465!\*1;!F0d+$#!&6'!1;$!&A4261!49!1;$!&''*1*46&+!Y299$#!1;&1!F0d+$#!;&5!

'$1$#A*6$'e!\$!&7#$$!1;&1!1;$!Y&5*5!1;$:!25$'!&6'!1;$!&''*1*46&+!Y299$#!1;$:!'$1$#A*6$'!&#$!

#$&546&Y+$C!!!

'.'9>131!,7!0?50+30.(0!*'3.1!'./!9,1101!

.<.C I6!1;$![&+2&1*46!&5!49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.-e!\$!A&'$!&552A%1*465!&Y421!1;$!9212#$C!!R2#*67!1;$!%&51!

1;#$$!:$&#5e!&012&+!$c%$#*$60$!;&5!'$[$+4%$'!'*99$#$61+:!9#4A!1;45$!&552A%1*465C!!H;*5!*5!64#A&+!

&6'!14!Y$!$c%$01$'C!!I1!*5!744'!%#&01*0$!14!#$[*$\!1;$!542#0$5!49!1;$5$!$c%$#*$60$!7&*65!&6'!+455$5!

14!*'$61*9:!\;$#$!1;$5$!'*99$#$60$5!4002##$'C!!H&Y+$!.<.!52AA&#*h$5!1;$![&#*425!9&014#5!1;&1!

#$52+1$'!*6!&!0;&67$!*6!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!52#%+25!9#4A!,-.-!14!,-.MC!

.<,C H;*5!&6&+:5*5!*5!$c%$01$'!14!'*99$#!9#4A!1;$!82AA&#:!49!@;&67$!*6!Fc0$55!)55$15!0461&*6$'!*6!1;$!

F0d+$#!3$%4#1!&1!%&#&7#&%;!,-,C!!F0d+$#!51&#1!\*1;!1;$!&A4261!49!$c0$55!&55$15e!4#!52#%+25e!Y&5$'!

Page 76: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! /-!

46!1;$*#!,-.-!5299*0*$60:!&552A%1*465!\;$#$&5!K4#6$&2!8;$%$++!51&#1!\*1;!1;$!&A4261!49!52#%+25!

Y&5$'!46!1;$!,-.-!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&552A%1*465C!!H;$5$!'*99$#*67!Y&5$5!&#$!&%%#4%#*&1$e!0465*51$61!

\*1;!&012&#*&+!81&6'&#'5!49!"#&01*0$!&6'!'4!641!04651*121$!&!'*99$#$60$!49!4%*6*46!Y$1\$$6!1;$!1\4!

&012&#*$5C!

!"#$%&'T'&2&X4"$A:0:&+D&*,"4N%&04&/C-L$C:&D-+9&M%=%9#%-&BI'I&.+&M%=%9#%-&BI'R&

3,140'5('&#) )) ))HKBBB1)

82#%+25!&5!&1!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.-! !! jS(Ue(.<!

I61$#$51!46!1;$!52#%+25! !! !/Me</U!!

Fc%$01$'!52#%+25!&1!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.M! !! !/S.eUU=!!

>22,4()&2)>O5,0',#4,)$'22,0'#Q)20&+)/11"+5('&#1) )) ))

P&*6!46!I6[$51A$615!41;$#!1;&6!94#!*69+&1*46! !.=eSU(!! !!

T455!46!I6[$51A$615!'2$!14!@"I!*60#$&5*67!+$55!1;&6!$c%$01$'! !].Se,,-`! !!

P&*6!9#4A!%$65*46!*6'$c!0&25*67!Y$6$9*15!14!*60#$&5$!+$55!1;&6!&552A$'! !.,eUM(!! !!

T455!9#4A!Y$6$9*15!%&*'!'2#*67!%&51!1;#$$!:$&#5!7#$&1$#!1;&6!&552A$'! !]/e,-.`! !!

T455!46!$c%$65$5!&6'!9$$5!A4#$!1;&6!&552A$'!'2#*67!,--U!14!,-.-! !].e=UM`! !!

T455!9#4A!0;&67$5!14!1;$!0+&*A&61!04;4#1! !],=eS=.`! !].(eMM<`!

>22,4()&2)*;/#Q,1)'#)@11"+5('&#1) )) ))

@;&67$5!14!1;$![&+2&1*46!A4'$+! !]=-e(.M`!

T455!9#4A!0;&67*67!1*A*67!49!+&51!%&:A$61!94#!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!14!'$%$6'&615!

(8,670)

T455!9#4A!0;&67$5!14!1;$!KKWP!'*5$&5$!%#47#$55*46!#&1$5! !]/eM.=`! !!

P&*6!9#4A!0;&67$!14!$c%$01$'!A4#1&+*1:!#&1$5! !U.=!! !!

P&*6!9#4A!0;&67*67!$c%$01$'!%$#0$61!49!04;4#1!0+&*A*67!&!T455!49!I604A$!4#!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*1!

!<e=S-!! !!

P&*6!9#4A!&''*67!&552A%1*46!&Y421!#$04[$#:!9#4A!+455!49!*604A$!&6'!+455!49!5$#[*0$5!

!.-e.S<!! !!

T455!9#4A!0;&67*67!1;$!%$#0$61!49!04;4#1!0+&*A*67!&!0451!49!0&#$!Y$6$9*1! !]./e(=-`! !!

T455!9#4A!0;&67$5!14!E21>49>"40d$1!$c%$65$5! !]MeM<.`! !!

T455!9#4A!0451!49!6$\!'#27!1#$&1A$615! !]<Se=M-`! !!

P&*6!9#4A!6$\!1#$&1A$61!#&1$5!&6'!$99*0&0:! !.<Me-=-!! !!

T455!9#4A!*60#$&5$'!$c%$01&1*46!94#!9212#$!9$$5!&6'!$c%$65$5! !],Me,(<`! !!

P&*6!9#4A!&++!41;$#!&552A%1*46!0;&67$5! !,/,!! !!

K*50$++&6$425!7&*65l+455$5!! !]/US`! !.e,US!!

E"05."1)/()DC)3,4,+b,0)ABCD) )) )H)IAJKLCC))

&

.<MC I6!141&+e!1;$!&A4261!49!52#%+25!46!&!Y$51!$51*A&1$!Y&5*5!*60#$&5$'!Y:!&Y421!jMU!A*++*46!4[$#!1;$!

1;#$$!:$&#5!9#4A!,-..!14!,-.MC!!H;$!*6'*[*'2&+!04A%46$615!49!1;&1!0;&67$![&#*$'!\*1;!1;$!

Page 77: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! /.!

$c%$#*$60$!7&*65!141&++*67!j,<U!A*++*46!&6'!1;$!$c%$#*$60$!+455$5!141&++*67!j,=-!A*++*46e!7*[*67!&!

6$1!7&*6!49!jMU!A*++*46C!

.<SC Q4#A&++:e!\$!$c%$01!&!A*c12#$!49!7&*65!&6'!+455$5C!!E[$#!1*A$e!\$!\42+'!$c%$01!1;&1!1;$!Y$51!

$51*A&1$!7&*65!&6'!+455$5!\*++!Y&+&60$!421!X!%#4[*'$'!9212#$!$c%$#*$60$!46!&[$#&7$!*5!5*A*+&#!14!

1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&552A%1*465C!!!

.</C H;$!94++4\*67!%#4[*'$5!&!Y#*$9!$c%+&6&1*46!49!1;$![&#*425!04A%46$615!49!1;$!7&*65!&6'!+455$5!

5;4\6!*6!H&Y+$!.<.C!

&C O1&-%-,&!/1!&#-!P?%84?,Q!!H;$!52#%+25!&5!&1!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.-!\&5!%&#1!49!1;$!&55$15!&6'!&5!

520;!\&5!*6[$51$'!&6'!$&#6*67!*6[$51A$61!*604A$C!!H;*5!*61$#$51!*5!1;$!&A4261!49!*61$#$51!1;&1!

\$!\42+'!;&[$!$c%$01$'!14!A&d$!46!1;$!52#%+25!Y&5$'!46!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!*61$#$51!#&1$!49!

MC/Mg!25$'!*6!1;$!,-.-![&+2&1*46C!

YC 6$+1!+1!I$4?-!/A!+1I-,&@-1&,a!!W;$6!*61$#$51!#&1$5!'$0#$&5$e!1;$!A&#d$1![&+2$!49!Y46'5!

*60#$&5$C!!H;*5!7&*6!*5!+&#7$+:!'2$!14!1;$!*60#$&5$!*6![&+2$!49!1;$!#$&+!#$12#6!Y46'5!'2$!14!1;$!

'$0#$&5$!*6!*61$#$51!#&1$5C!!!

0C K/,,!/1!+1I-,&@-1&,!3?-!&/!".O!+1R%-$,-,a!H;*5!+44d5!&1!1;$!*A%&01!49!$c%$01$'!&6'!&012&+!

*69+&1*46!46!1;$!*6[$51A$61!$&#6*675!49!&++!1;$!B26'i5!&55$15C!!H;*5!+455!*5!%&#1*&++:!4995$1!Y:!1;$!

7&*6!'2$!14!0;&67$5!*6!1;$!%$65*46!*6'$c!'*50255$'!*6!*1$A!]'`!Y$+4\C!

'C 6$+1!A%/@!8-1,+/1!+13-Sa!H;$!*60#$&5$5!*6!1;$!%$65*46!*6'$c!'2#*67!1;$!%&51!1;#$$!:$&#5!\$#$!

+$55!1;&6!$c%$01$'!0&25*67!Y$6$9*15!14!*60#$&5$!+$55!1;&6!&552A$'C!!H;*5!;&'!&!5A&++!*A%&01!46!

1;$!Y$6$9*15!%&*'!'2#*67!1;$!%&51!1;#$$!:$&#5C!!H;$!Y2+d!49!1;*5!7&*6!*5!'2$!14!+4\$#!&A42615!49!

9212#$!Y$6$9*1!%&:A$615!&5!&!#$52+1!49!1;$!+4\$#!+$[$+!49!*60#$&5$5!9#4A!,-..!14!,-.MC!

$C K/,,!A%/@!:-1-A+&,!8$+3a!H;$!&012&+!Y$6$9*15!%&*'!14!0+&55!A$AY$#5!'2#*67!1;$!+&51!1;#$$!:$&#5!

\$#$!j/!A*++*46!7#$&1$#!1;&6!\&5!&552A$'!*6!1;$!+&51![&+2&1*46C!!

9C K/,,!/1!-S8-1,-,!$13!A--,a!H;$!&012&+!$c%$65$5!&6'!9$$5!%&*'!'2#*67!1;$!%$#*4'!,-..!14!,-.M!

\$#$!&Y421!j.CU!A*++*46!A4#$!1;&6!&552A$'!*6!,-.-C!

7C K/,,!A%/@!R#$10-,!&/!&#-!R4$+@$1&!R/#/%&a!!H;$!%#47#$55*46!49!1;$!d64\6!04;4#1!\&5!

'*99$#$61!1;&6!&552A$'!*6!1;$!,-.-![&+2&1*46C!!H;$#$!\$#$!9$\$#!#$04[$#*$5!9#4A!?@J!

#$%4#1$'!14!1;$!&'A*6*51#&14#!1;&6!\$!&552A$'!&6'!A4#$!0+&*A&615!&1!+$[$+5!M!&6'!=C!!)++!1;&1!

\&5!4995$1!Y:!9$\$#!0+&*A&615!&'[&60*67!14!+$[$+5!S!&6'!/!&6'!9$\$#!'$&1;5!1;&6!$c%$01$'C!!I6!

141&+e!1;$!1#&65*1*46!49!1;$!d64\6!04;4#1!%#4'20$'!&!A4'$51!7&*6C!!?4\$[$#e!1;$#$!\$#$!A4#$!

6$\!&%%#4[&+5!1;&6!$c%$01$'!&6'!1;$:!\$#$!54A$\;&1!A4#$!&'[&60$'!*6!1;$!'*5$&5$!1;&6!

&552A$'C!!W$!&+54!*60#$&5$'!1;$!62AY$#!49!9212#$!6$\!0+&*A&615!94#!1;$!9212#$e!&6!&552A%1*46!

0;&67$!1;&1!*5!#$%4#1$'!147$1;$#!\*1;!1;$!0;&67$5!9#4A!1;$!d64\6!04;4#1C!

Page 78: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! /,!

;C 2/3-4!"#$10-,a!!)5!&!#$52+1!49!'*50255*465!\*1;!1;$!KKWP!&6'!\*1;!F0d+$#e!&!62AY$#!49!

#$9*6$A$615!\$#$!A&'$!14!42#![&+2&1*46!A4'$+C!!H;*5!*5!1;$!9*6&60*&+!$99$01!49!&++!49!1;45$!

#$9*6$A$615C!

*C K/,,!A%/@!R#$10+10!&+@+10!/A!4$,&!8$L@-1&!A/%!K/,,!/A!P-%I+R-,!&/!3-8-13$1&,a!!I6!42#!

'*50255*465!\*1;!F0d+$#e!\$!9426'!1;&1!\$!;&'!&%%+*$'!1;$!9*6&+!%&:A$61!1*A*67!'*99$#$61+:C!!

H;*5!#$9+$015!Y#*67*67!42#!&552A%1*465!*614!5:60!\*1;!1;$!+&51!%&:A$61!14!'$%$6'&615!

4002##*67!&1!1;$!$6'!49!1;$!9*6&+!:$&#C!

fC K/,,!A%/@!R#$10-!&/!3+,-$,-!8%/0%-,,+/1!%$&-,a!H;$!9212#$!'*5$&5$!%#47#$55*46!#&1$5!

#$%4#1$'!*6!1;$!,-.M!KKWP!#$%4#1!\$#$e!46!&[$#&7$e!5+*7;1+:!;*7;$#!1;&6!1;$!04;4#1>Y&5$'!

%#47#$55*46!#&1$5!21*+*5$'!*6!1;$!,-.-![&+2&1*46C!!H;45$!;*7;$#!%#47#$55*46!#&1$5!#$52+1$'!*6!&!

+455!49!j/!A*++*46C!

dC 2/%&$4+&L!7$&-,a!!H;*5!7&*6!*5!A&'$!2%!49!1;#$$!04A%46$615e!$&0;!49!\;*0;!0461#*Y21$'!&!

%4#1*46!49!1;$!7&*6C!!H;$!?@J>#$+&1$'!A4#1&+*1:!&1!+$[$+!=!\&5!#$'20$'!94#!&++!*651&60$5!*6!1;$!

,-.M!KKWP!3$%4#1C!!H;$#$!\&5!&!5A&++!#$9*6$A$61!14!1;$!$c0$55!?@J!A4#1&+*1:!#&1$5C!!H;$!

%4%2+&1*46!A4#1&+*1:!1&Y+$!21*+*5$'!\&5!2%'&1$'!14!1;$!@&6&'*&6!T*9$!H&Y+$!,--<>,-..e!\;*0;!

0461&*6$'!#$'201*465!*6!&++!A4#1&+*1:!#&1$5!94#!&7$5!,(!&6'!4+'$#C!

+C 6$+1!A%/@!R#$10-!&/!K/,,!/A!O1R/@-!$13!K/,,!/A!P-%I+R-,a!?*514#*0&+!0+&*A5!94#!T455!49!

I604A$!&6'!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!5277$515!1;&1!1;$!%$#0$61&7$!49!0+&55!A$AY$#5!\;4!\*++!0+&*A!94#!

46$!49!1;$5$!+455$5!*5!54A$\;&1!+$55!*6!&77#$7&1$!1;&6!&552A$'!*6!1;$!,-.-![&+2&1*46C!!W$!

&'f251$'!42#!&552A%1*46!14!#$9+$01!1;*5C!!W$!&+54!&'f251$'!1;$!#$+&1*[$!%$#0$61&7$5!49!0+&*A&615!

\;4!&#$!&552A$'!14!0+&*A!+455!49!*604A$!4#!+455!49!5$#[*0$5!%#*4#!14!&7$!=/C!!

AC 6$+1!A%/@!%-R/I-%L!A%/@!3+,$:+4+&La!!)5!&!#$52+1!49!1;$!6$\!'#27!1#$&1A$615e!\$!&''$'!&6!

&552A%1*46!14!$51*A&1$!1;$!9212#$!#$04[$#:!49!0+&*A&615!9#4A!'*5&Y*+*1:!Y$6$9*15!]+455!49!

*604A$!&6'!+455!49!5$#[*0$5`!94++4\*67!&!5200$5592+!1#$&1A$61C!

6C K/,,!A%/@!R#$10-!&/!8-%R-1&!R4$+@+10!R/,&!/A!R$%-!:-1-A+&,a!!?*514#*0&+!0+&*A5!94#!0451!49!0&#$!

5277$515!1;&1!1;$!%$#0$61&7$!49!0+&55!A$AY$#5!\;4!\*++!0+&*A!94#!1;*5!*5!5+*7;1+:!+4\$#!1;&6!

&552A$'!*6!1;$!,-.-![&+2&1*46C!!H;&1e!;4\$[$#e!*5!4995$1!Y:!&!;*7;$#!&[$#&7$!Y$6$9*1!&A4261C!

4C T?&D/AD./RU-&!VS8-1,-,a!!W$!A&'$!1\4!0;&67$5!14!1;$!421>49>%40d$1!$c%$65$!&552A%1*46!94#!

,-.MC!!E6$!\&5!1;$!A$1;4'!25$'!14!&%%+:!1;$!&552A%1*46!&6'!1;$!41;$#!\&5!14!&''!&6!

&552A%1*46!94#!1;$!0+&*A&615!\;4!0+$&#!1;$![*#25!14!#$9+$01!1;$!+*d$+*;44'!1;&1!1;$#$!\*++!Y$!

54A$!94++4\!2%!A$'*0&+!&%%4*61A$615!#$Z2*#$'!&91$#!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25C!!H;&1!*5!&++!4995$1!Y:!

1;$!7&*6!'2$!14!9$\$#!0+&*A&615!;&[*67!9212#$!421>49>%40d$1!$c%$65$5!&5!&!#$52+1!49!Y$*67!

02#$'C!

%C K/,,!A%/@!1-W!3%?0!&%-$&@-1&,!XR/,&!/A!3%?0,Ya!H;$!6$\!'#27!1#$&1A$615!1;&1!\$!&552A$'!

\42+'!Y$!21*+*5$'!*6!1;$!9212#$!0451!5*76*9*0&61+:!A4#$!1;&6!%#*4#!1#$&1A$615!&6'!1;$:!&#$!

$c%$01$'!14!Y$!21*+*5$'!Y:!A451!49!1;$!0+&*A&61!04;4#1!&Y4[$!'*5$&5$!+$[$+!,C!!H;$!0451!49!1;$5$!

Page 79: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! /M!

'#275!*5!&!5*76*9*0&61!*60#$&5$!14!1;$!B26'C!!W;*+$!1;$!25$!49!1;$5$!'#275!*5!$c%$01$'!14!02#$!

A451!0+&*A&615!9#4A!?@J!&6'!1;$#$Y:!#$'20$!9212#$!0+&*A5e!1;*5!*1$A!5;4\5!1;$!$c%$01$'!

9212#$!0451!49!1;$!'#275!14!Y$!25$'!*6!9212#$!1#$&1A$615C!!

ZC 6$+1!A%/@!&%-$&@-1&!%$&-,!$13!-AA+R$RLQ!!H;*5!*1$A!A$&52#$5!1;$!7&*6!&#*5*67!9#4A!1;$!

*60#$&5$!*6!1;$!%$#0$61!49!0+&*A&615!&552A$'!14!Y$!1#$&1$'!&6'!1;$!7#$&1+:!*60#$&5$'!$99*0&0:!

49!1;$!6$\!'#275C!!H;*5!*5!&!A$&52#$!49!1;$!+*&Y*+*1:!#$'201*46!$c%$01$'!&5!&!#$52+1!49!1;$!6$\!

'#275C!!

#C K/,,!A%/@!-S8-R&-3!A?&?%-!-S8-1,-,!$13!A--,a!H;$!9212#$!$c%$01$'!$c%$65$5!&6'!9$$5!&#$!

%#4f$01$'!14!,-=Me!M/!:$&#5!+467$#!1;&6!\&5!%#4f$01$'!*6!,-.-C!!H;$!0;&67$!*6!1;$!&662&+!

$c%$65$5!94#!9212#$!:$&#5!*5!&6!*60#$&5$!49!&Y421!j,M!A*++*46C!

5C "#$10-!A%/@!$44!/&#-%!$,,?@8&+/1,a!H;$#$!\$#$!&!62AY$#!49!41;$#!&552A%1*46!0;&67$5!1;&1!

\$#$!A*64#!*6!$99$01C!!H;$!6$1!141&+!*A%&01!49!1;$5$!0;&67$5!\&5!&!7&*6!49!+$55!1;&6!j.!A*++*46C!

1C 2+,R-44$1-/?,!0$+1,!$13!4/,,-,a!H;$!&6&+:5*5!49!$c%$#*$60$!7&*65!&6'!+455$5!*6[4+[$5!

&552A%1*465!&6'!$51*A&1*465C!!)!'$1&*+$'!&6'!A4#$!&002#&1$!'$1$#A*6&1*46!*5!641!

$0464A*0&++:!9$&5*Y+$C!!Q4#A&++:e!1;$!&6&+:5*5!49!$c%$#*$60$!7&*65!&6'!+455$5!\*++!#$Z2*#$!1;$!

25$!49!&!Y&+&60*67!*1$A!1;&1!*5!1;$!141&+!$99$01!49!1;$!&552A%1*465!&6'!$51*A&1*465!25$'!*6!1;$!

&6&+:5*5C!!H;$!A*50$++&6$425!7&*6!*5!+$55!1;&6!j.!A*++*46C!

5+,63.(3'9:20++32,+3'9!(,.2+3&-23,.!18,+27'99!

.<=C H;$!B26'!*60+2'$5!*6[$51$'!&55$15e!\;*0;!&#*5$!9#4A!1;$!9$'$#&+!74[$#6A$61i5!0461#*Y21*46!49!

j(S=!A*++*46e!%+25!&!%#4[*60*&+l1$##*14#*&+!4Y+*7&1*46!14!0461#*Y21$!Ml..1;5!49!&++!Y$6$9*1!&6'!

$c%$65$5!%&*'!421!49!1;$!B26'C!!H;$#$!*5!&!0&%!14!1;$!%#4[*60*&+l1$##*14#*&+!0461#*Y21*46!4Y+*7&1*46e!

4#*7*6&++:!jM,S!A*++*46e!49!\;*0;!j.=,!A*++*46!#$A&*65!&5!49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.MUC!!H;$!

%#4[*60*&+l1$##*14#*&+!0461#*Y21*46!4Y+*7&1*46!*5!*60#$&5$'!Y:!*61$#$51!&1!1;$!1;#$$>A461;!H#$&52#:!

N*++!#&1$!&6'!#$'20$'!Y:!&6:!0461#*Y21*465!A&'$C!

.<UC N&5$'!46!9212#$!$c%$01$'!Y$6$9*1!%&:A$615!&6'!$c%$65$5!9#4A!1;$!926'!]5$$!8$01*46!.-!>!

"#4f$01$'!@&5;!B+4\!49!@4A%$65&1*46!N$6$9*15`e!\$!$51*A&1$!1;&1!1;$!%#4[*60*&+l1$##*14#*&+!

0461#*Y21*46!4Y+*7&1*46!\*++!Y$!92+9*++$'!Y:!1;$!$6'!49!,-,S!26'$#!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&552A%1*465!

&6'!Y:!,-,.!*60+2'*67!&!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465C!!)91$#!1;45$!'&1$5e!&6:!#$A&*6*67!

Y$6$9*15!042+'!46+:!Y$!%&*'!421!49!1;$!926'!\*1;!64!%#4[*60*&+l1$##*14#*&+!0461#*Y21*46C!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

U!! H;$!j.=,!A*++*46!%#4[*60*&+l1$##*14#*&+!0461#*Y21*46!4Y+*7&1*46!*60+2'$5!j.Se---!1;&1!;&5!Y$$6!%#$926'$'!Y:!L2d46C!

Page 80: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! /S!

.<(C I6!42#!,-.-!3$%4#1e!\$!;&'!%#4f$01$'!1;$!%#4[*60*&+l1$##*14#*&+!0461#*Y21*46!4Y+*7&1*46!\42+'!Y$!

92+9*++$'!&Y421!.,!:$&#5!+&1$#!X!,-M=!94#!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&6'!,-M,!94#!1;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!

'$[*&1*465C!!H;$!A&*6!#$&546!94#!1;$!A20;!$&#+*$#!'&1$!*5!'2$!14!1;$!04515!&5540*&1$'!\*1;!1;$!6$\!

1#$&1A$61C!!H;45$!04515!;&[$!&00$+$#&1$'!A&6:!49!1;$!$c%$01$'!0&5;!9+4\5!1;&1!\42+'!;&[$!

4002##$'!4[$#!1;$!9212#$!+*9$!49!1;$!926'!14!64\!4002#!4[$#!1;$!%$#*4'!,-.S!14!,-.(C!

!

!

Page 81: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! //!

In This Section, we….

! review the effect of changes

in the key assumptions on

the resulting liabilities, and

! discuss the reasons why the

Plan is largely protected

from changes in interest and

inflation rates.!

G$ !"!#$%&%'()'%*"%&+&,!"#!

.<<C H;$!#$52+15!%#$5$61$'!*6!1;*5!#$%4#1!&#$!Y&5$'!46!

&552A%1*465!&Y421!\;&1!\*++!;&%%$6!*6!1;$!9212#$C!!

K&6:!49!1;$5$!&552A%1*465!;&[$!&!#$+&1*[$+:!A*64#!

$99$01!46!1;$!#$52+1*67!+*&Y*+*1*$5C!!84A$!49!1;$!

&552A%1*465!;&[$!&!7#$&1$#!$99$01!46!1;$!#$52+15!1;&6!

41;$#5C!!!

,--C H;$!%2#%45$!49!&!5$65*1*[*1:!&6&+:5*5!*5!14!;$+%!1;$!25$#!

14!7&*6!&6!26'$#51&6'*67!49!1;$!%455*Y+$!9*6&60*&+!$99$01!49!0;&67$5!*6!1;$!A4#$!A&1$#*&+!

&552A%1*465C!

!"#$%&BII&2&/%4:0.0P0.A&X4"$A:0:&G04&HIII:J&

@11"+5('&#)*;/#Q,M) =,1()>1('+/(,)

-0&?'1'&#)2&0)@$?,01,)

3,?'/('&#1)

H41&+!T*&Y*+*1:!]1#&65925$'!&6'!;&$A4%;*+*&0!0+&*A&615`! !j==/eS(( ! !j(.,e=-/!!

I60#$&5$!1#&65925$'!04;4#1!Y:!.--!&+*[$!0+&*A&615! !.(e(--!! !,,e,--!!

I60#$&5$!1#&65925$'!04;4#1!Y:!.--!%451!.<<<!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5! !MSeM--!! !MSe/--!!

I60#$&5$!1#&65925$'!04;4#1!Y:!.--!%451!.<<<!646>?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5! !Ue.--!! !Ue.--!!

I60#$&5$!;&$A4%;*+*&0!04;4#1!Y:!.--!&+*[$!0+&*A&615! !M-e---!! !MSeS--!!

I60#$&5$!;&$A4%;*+*&0!04;4#1!Y:!.--!%451!.<<<!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5! !SSeU--!! !S/eM--!!

I60#$&5$!;&$A4%;*+*&0!04;4#1!Y:!.--!%451!.<<<!646>?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5! !.-e---!! !.-e---!!

I60#$&5$!1#&65*1*46!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!Y$1\$$6!'*5$&5$!51&7$5!14!..-g!49!1;$!Y&5$+*6$!#&1$5C!!]B4#!$c&A%+$e!*9!1;$!Y&5$+*6$!1#&65*1*46!%#4Y&Y*+*1:!*5!UC-ge!1;*5!\42+'!*60#$&5$!*1!14!UCUg`!

!=e-.M!! !(e(S,!!

R$0#$&5$!1#$&1A$61!$99*0&0:!14!<-g!49!1;$!&552A$'!#&1$5! !,<e,<(!! !,/e/-U!!

3$A4[$!&++!%#*[&1$!*652#&60$!04[$#&7$!94#!'#27!04515!X!54!1;$!B26'!%&:5!1;$!92++!0451!49!&++!'#275!

!M/e//<!! !SUe<.(!!

I60#$&5$!'#27!0451!14!j.--e---!]j.M-e---!94#!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465`!>!\*1;!&6!&[$#&7$!49!S-g!49!1;&1!%&*'!Y:!%#*[&1$!*652#&60$!94#!0+&*A&615!26'$#!&7$!=/!

!,=e/U-!! !,(eS<,!!

R$0#$&5$!#$04[$#:!9#4A!'*5&Y*+*1:!14!/-g!49!1;$!&552A$'!#&1$5! !Se<S=!! !,e(,<!!

Fc0$55!?@J!K4#1&+*1:!#$A&*65!260;&67$'!&91$#!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25! !MUe<<<!! !M=e=(,!!

I60#$&5$!1;$!*61$#$51!#&1$!Y:!.g!<! !j=Me(((!! !j(=e=MM!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

(!! )!'$0#$&5$!14!1;$!*6'*0&1$'!&552A%1*46!\*++!;&[$!&%%#4c*A&1$+:!1;$!5&A$!$99$01!Y21!*6!1;$!4%%45*1$!'*#$01*46C!!!

<!! )6!*60#$&5$!*6!1;$!*61$#$51!#&1$!\42+'!+*d$+:!Y$!'2$!14!&6!*60#$&5$!*6!1;$!9212#$!$c%$01$'!#$12#65!46!1;$!&55$15C!!I6!1;&1!5*12&1*46e!1;$#$!\42+'!Y$!&6!&%%#4c*A&1$+:!4995$11*67!+455!9#4A!*6[$51A$615C!!

Page 82: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! /=!

,-.C I6!1;*5!5$65*1*[*1:!&6&+:5*5e!$&0;!+*6$!5;4\5!1;$!$99$01!49!A&d*67!46+:!1;$!*6'*0&1$'!0;&67$!14!1;$!

5*67+$!&552A%1*46C!!)++!41;$#!&552A%1*465!&#$!;$+'!04651&61C!!H;$!&552A%1*46!0;&67$5!5;4\6!*6!

1;$!1&Y+$!&#$!641!02A2+&1*[$C!!B4#!$c&A%+$e!1;$!9*#51!+*6$!5;4\5!1;$!$99$01!49!0;&67*67!46+:!1;$!5*h$!

49!1;$!&+*[$!1#&65925$'!04;4#1C!!I6!1;$!5$046'!+*6$e!1;$!5*h$!49!1;$!&+*[$!1#&65925$'!04;4#1!*5!

#$12#6$'!14!1;$!51&#1*67!5*h$!&6'!1;$6!1;$!'$&1;5!'2$!14!?@J!5*h$!*5!0;&67$'C!!!

,-,C H;$!5$65*1*[*1:!#$52+15!A&:!Y$!&'f251$'!94#!&!'*99$#$61!5*h$!49!0;&67$!1;&6!1;&1!*6'*0&1$'C!!B4#!

$c&A%+$e!*9!1;$#$!*5!&6!*60#$&5$!]'$0#$&5$`!49!,-!&+*[$!1#&65925$'!A$AY$#5e!1;$!9*6&60*&+!$99$01!

\42+'!Y$!'$1$#A*6$'!Y:!1&d*67!,-!'*[*'$'!Y:!.--!&6'!A2+1*%+*$'!Y:!1;$!5$65*1*[*1:!&A4261!49!

j.(e(--e---C!!H;&1!\42+'!Y$!&6!*60#$&5$!49!jMeU=-e---!]4#!&!'$0#$&5$!49!1;$!5&A$!&A4261`C!

,-MC I1!5;42+'!Y$!641$'!1;&1!A2+1*%+$!0;&67$5!A&:!Y$!*61$#'$%$6'$61C!!H;&1!*5e!\;$6!A2+1*%+$!0;&67$5!

&#$!04AY*6$'e!1;$!141&+!$99$01!A&:!Y$!'*99$#$61!9#4A!\;&1!46$!7$15!Y:!&''*67!1;$!*6'*[*'2&+!

&A42615!147$1;$#C!!H;*5!$99$01!*5!5*A*+&#!14!1;$!'*99$#$60$!Y$1\$$6!5*A%+$!&6'!04A%426'!*61$#$51C!!

84A$!49!1;$!A2+1*%+$!&552A%1*465!0;&67$5!;&[$!&!04A%426'*67!$99$01C!!!

!

Page 83: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! /U!

#E$ !"#$%&'%()&*+,)-.#/)!"#$!%&'()*+,!(#-'('!"#$!

,-SC H;$!94++4\*67!0;&#1!5;4\5!1;$!9212#$!$c%$01$'!0&5;!

9+4\5!94#!,-.S!14!,.-,!Y&5$'!46!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!

&552A%1*465C!!H;$5$!&#$!1;$!Y$6$9*1!%&:A$615!&6'!

$c%$65$5!1;&1!26'$#+*$!1;$!+*&Y*+*1*$5!94#!1;$!"+&6C!

,-/C H;$#$!*5!&!+&#7$!$c%$01$'!141&+!14!Y$!%&*'!9#4A!,-.S!14!

,-.(!'2$!14!1;$!0451!49!1#$&1A$61!&552A$'!14!Y$!7*[$6!

'2#*67!1;&1!%$#*4'C!!

*,"-.&BIK&2&EC.C-%&*":,&E$+5:&2&Z%:.&;:.09".%&X::C9L.0+4:&G04&^IIIH:J&

&

,-=C H;$!'4++&#!&A42615!49!1;$!%&51!&6'!9212#$!0&5;!9+4\5!&#$!5;4\6!*6!H&Y+$!,-=&!94#!1;$!Y$51!

$51*A&1$!&552A%1*465!&6'!*6!H&Y+$!,-=Y!94#!1;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!&552A%1*465C!!

!>!!

!,-e---e---!!

!S-e---e---!!

!=-e---e---!!

!(-e---e---!!

!.--e---e---!!

!.,-e---e---!!

Year

B$$5!&6'!Fc%$65$5!

H#&65925$'!

?&$A4%;*+*&05!

In This Section….

! We show the projected

future payments from the

Plan (based on the

assumptions) in each of the

next 90 years.

Page 84: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! /(!

!"#$%&BI("&2&EC46&*":,&E$+5:&G>0:.+-0="$&_&U-+`%=.%6&.+&B'IBJ&2&Z%:.&;:.09".%&X::C9L.0+4:&G04&HIII:J[&

_,/0) :0/#12"1,$) </,+&5;'.'/41) !,,1)f)>O5,#1,1) :&(/.)

,---! j!...eUMM!! j!!!,-e=<=!! j!!!.Me<M<!! j!.S=eM=(!!

,--.! !<,eU((!! !S.e,MM!! !(eUSM!! !.S,eU=S!!

,--,! !/Ue=<S!! !,<e/-M!! !(e,(,!! !</eSU<!!

,--M! !//e.,.!! !./eSSS!! !=e//,!! !UUe..U!!

,--S! !MM<e=,M!! !,MeU/U!! !/e<<-!! !M=<eMU-!!

,--/! !M/eMUU!! !./e<.<!! !=e-=<!! !/UeM=/!!

,--=! !M-e<<=!! !.MeU<S!! !SeM<=!! !S<e.(=!!

,--U! !,<e..=!! !.,eUU,!! !Me<(S!! !S/e(U,!!

,--(! !,=e=(U!! !.<e((.!! !,eMS-!! !S(e<-(!!

,--<! !,,e<-.!! !.Me,U(!! !,e=S/!! !M(e(,S!!

,-.-! !,SeS=U!! !.,eU<M!! !,e(,S!! !S-e-(S!!

,-..! !,-e=//!! !..e=U-!! !Me/U(!! !M/e<-M!!

,-.,! !.UeM(-!! !..e-(,!! !.e(=.!! !M-eM,M!!

,-.M! !,-e-./!! !..e(=(!! !.eU<(!! !MMe=(.!!

,-.M!4l5! !=eM<-!! /e/,.!! !>!! !..e<..!!

,-.S! !(.e-U-!! !,SeMMM!! !,e<,(!! !.-(eMM.!!

,-./! !=Me<MS!! !,.e-S=!! !MeM./!! !((e,</!!

,-.=! !M.e/-S!! !./e..=!! !,e-U<!! !S(e=<<!!

,-.U! !,SeM=-!! !.Me=-=!! !Me-.(!! !S-e<(S!!

,-.(! !.<eU(,!! !.,e=,S!! !,e,MS!! !MSe=S-!!

,-.<! !.,e/M.!! !.-e<-,!! !.e</<!! !,/eM<,!!

,-,-! !.,eS,U!! !.-e<-(!! !,e<==!! !,=eM-.!!

,-,.! !.,eM,,!! !.-e<,/!! !,e.(U!! !,/eSMS!!

,-,,! !.,e.<<!! !.-e(/M!! !.e<=.!! !,/e-.M!!

,-,M! !.,e-.(!! !.-eUU<!! !Me.,M!! !,/e<,-!!

,-,S! !..e(M-!! !<eMMM!! !,eM.U!! !,MeS(-!!

,-,/! !..e=UM!! !<e,M=!! !,e-<=!! !,Me--/!!

,-,=! !..e//M!! !(e<(U!! !Me,S-!! !,MeU(-!!

,-,U! !..eM</!! !(e((.!! !,eM,(!! !,,e=-S!!

,-,(! !..e,U/!! !(eU(U!! !,e-S,!! !,,e.-S!!

,-,<! !..e.S/!! !(e///!! !Me.SU!! !,,e(SU!!

,-M-! !..e--.!! !(eM(.!! !,e,/S!! !,.e=M=!!

,-M.! !.-e(.<!! !(e,.S!! !.e<U.!! !,.e--S!!

,-M,! !.-e=M(!! !(e-=-!! !Me-,=!! !,.eU,S!!

,-MM! !.-e,<,!! !Ue(-.!! !,e./<!! !,-e,/,!!

,-M.!>!,.-,! !.=Me/<.!! !.,.e.=.!! !S<e(,.!! !MMSe/UM!!

:&(/.) HCKJJMKDBA)) HPBLKPNN)) HCLDKCLA)) HAKAANKCLD))

<'''';5"?/!+'5-2'/"!'-11'1?$'!"'&"?/1)/#8'

<<'9-+%'A>"(+')/4>?1$'A?!?&$'$P,$4!$1')/A>-!)"/'-/1'-&$'/"!'1)+4"?/!$1'A"&'A?!?&$')/!$&$+!'$-&/)/#+8''

Page 85: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! /<!

!"#$%&BI(#&)&EC46&*":,&E$+5:&G>0:.+-0="$&_&U-+`%=.%6&.+&B'IBJ&2&U-+P0:0+4&D+-&X6P%-:%&M%P0".0+4:&G04&HIII:J[&

_,/0) :0/#12"1,$) </,+&5;'.'/41) !,,1)f)>O5,#1,1) :&(/.)

,---! j!...eUMM!! j!!!,-e=<=!! j!!!.Me<M<!! j!.S=eM=(!!

,--.! !<,eU((!! !S.e,MM!! !(eUSM!! !.S,eU=S!!

,--,! !/Ue=<S!! !,<e/-M!! !(e,(,!! !</eSU<!!

,--M! !//e.,.!! !./eSSS!! !=e//,!! !UUe..U!!

,--S! !MM<e=,M!! !,MeU/U!! !/e<<-!! !M=<eMU-!!

,--/! !M/eMUU!! !./e<.<!! !=e-=<!! !/UeM=/!!

,--=! !M-e<<=!! !.MeU<S!! !SeM<=!! !S<e.(=!!

,--U! !,<e..=!! !.,eUU,!! !Me<(S!! !S/e(U,!!

,--(! !,=e=(U!! !.<e((.!! !,eMS-!! !S(e<-(!!

,--<! !,,e<-.!! !.Me,U(!! !,e=S/!! !M(e(,S!!

,-.-! !,SeS=U!! !.,eU<M!! !,e(,S!! !S-e-(S!!

,-..! !,-e=//!! !..e=U-!! !Me/U(!! !M/e<-M!!

,-.,! !.UeM(-!! !..e-(,!! !.e(=.!! !M-eM,M!!

,-.M! !,-e-./!! !..e(=(!! !.eU<(!! !MMe=(.!!

,-.M!4l5! !=eM<-!! /e/,.! !>!! ..e<..!

,-.S! !<Ue-</!! !,(e.SM!! !,e<,(!! !.,(e.==!!

,-./! !USe=,-!! !,Me(M.!! !MeM./!! !.-.eU==!!

,-.=! !M<e-.S!! !.Ue,(/!! !,e-U<!! !/(eMU(!!

,-.U! !,<e<S,!! !./eS.-!! !Me-.(!! !S(eMU-!!

,-.(! !,Se,.=!! !.Se,./!! !,e,MS!! !S-e==/!!

,-.<! !.SeU(M!! !..e<M(!! !.e</<!! !,(e=(-!!

,-,-! !.Se(.,!! !.,e--<!! !,e<==!! !,<eU(U!!

,-,.! !.Se(MM!! !.,e-<.!! !,e.(U!! !,<e...!!

,-,,! !.Se(,(!! !.,e-US!! !.e<=.!! !,(e(=M!!

,-,M! !.SeU/=!! !.,e-/-!! !Me.,M!! !,<e<,<!!

,-,S! !.Se==.!! !.-e=S=!! !,eM.U!! !,Ue=,S!!

,-,/! !.Se/</!! !.-e/(-!! !,e-<=!! !,Ue,U.!!

,-,=! !.Se//,!! !.-eM/M!! !Me,S-!! !,(e.S/!!

,-,U! !.SeS//!! !.-e,U.!! !,eM,(!! !,Ue-/S!!

,-,(! !.SeM<=!! !.-e.</!! !,e-S,!! !,=e=MM!!

,-,<! !.SeM./!! !<e<U/!! !Me.SU!! !,UeSMU!!

,-M-! !.Se,-(!! !<e(-.!! !,e,/S!! !,=e,=M!!

,-M.! !.Se-/.!! !<e=S,!! !.e<U.!! !,/e==S!!

,-M,! !.Me((M!! !<eS(S!! !Me-,=!! !,=eM<M!!

,-MS! !.Me/SU!! !<e,-U!! !,e./<!! !,Se<.M!!

,-M.!>!,.-,! !,MMe<,<!! !.SUe...!! !S<e(,.!! !SM-e(=.!!

:&(/.) HCKPBPKJDJ)) H)PPIKIAA)) H)CLDKCLA)) HAKJJIKCAM))

<'''';5"?/!+'5-2'/"!'-11'1?$'!"'&"?/1)/#8'

<<'9-+%'A>"(+')/4>?1$'A?!?&$'$P,$4!$1')/A>-!)"/'-/1'-&$'/"!'1)+4"?/!$1'A"&'A?!?&$')/!$&$+!'$-&/)/#+8''

Page 86: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! =-

##$ !"#$!%&!'(!))$*+#&,-!!!

,-UC B4#!1;*5![&+2&1*46e!\$!\$#$!*651#201$'!14!\4#d!

044%$#&1*[$+:!\*1;!F0d+$#!14!5$+$01!1;$!&012&#*&+!

A$1;4'5!&6'!&552A%1*465!f4*61+:!\*1;!1;$!*61$61!1;&1!

\$!\42+'!Y41;!25$!1;$!5&A$!&552A%1*465!*6!42#!

#$5%$01*[$![&+2&1*465C!!I9!\$!\$#$!26&Y+$!14!&7#$$!\*1;!

#$5%$01!14!&6!&552A%1*46e!1;$!#$&5465!1;$#$94#!&6'!

9*6&60*&+!$99$01!\$#$!14!Y$!'*50+45$'C!

,-(C W$!044%$#&1$'!\*1;!1;$!&6&+:5*5!49!1;$!'&1&!&6'!

5;&#$'!42#!#$5%$01*[$!9*6'*675C!!N41;!&012&#*$5!&00$%1!

&++!49!1;$!&552A%1*465!25$'!*6!1;*5![&+2&1*46!X!1;$#$!

&#$!64!'*99$#$60$5C!

,-<C H;$!&552A%1*465!&Y421!'*5$&5$!%#47#$55*46!&#$!'*50255$'!*6!8$01*46!/C!!H;$!&552A%1*465!&Y421!

1;$!0+&*A&61!04;4#1!&#$!'*50255$'!*6!8$01*46!=C!!!

,.-C H;*5!5$01*46!'*50255$5!&++!49!1;$!41;$#!&012&#*&+!&552A%1*465!25$'!94#!1;*5!#$%4#1!&+467!\*1;!

#$&5465!94#!1;$*#!&'4%1*46C!!!

,..C H;$5$!&552A%1*465!&#$!52AA&#*h$'!*6!)%%$6'*c!RC!

,.,C H;$!+*&Y*+*1:!*60+2'*67!&!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!\&5!'$1$#A*6$'!25*67!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!

&552A%1*465!147$1;$#!\*1;!&!A&#7*6!14!%#4[*'$!94#!%455*Y+$!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465C!!W$!*60+2'$'!&!

A&#7*6!46+:!94#!1;45$!&552A%1*465!1;&1!*6!42#!4%*6*46!A*7;1!;&[$!&!A&1$#*&+!9*6&60*&+!$99$01!*9!

&012&+!$c%$#*$60$!'*99$#$'!9#4A!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&552A%1*46C!!)5!&!#$52+1e!A&6:!49!1;$!%#4[*5*46!

94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*46!&552A%1*465!&#$!1;$!5&A$!&5!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&552A%1*465C!

!,%&?"$C".0+4&@+6%$:&

,.MC W$!&+54!\4#d$'!147$1;$#!14!#$[*$\!42#!#$5%$01*[$![&+2&1*46!A4'$+5!&6'!*'$61*9:!&6:!'*99$#$60$5C!!

)!62AY$#!49!520;!'*99$#$60$5!\$#$!9426'!&6'!1;$!A4'$+5!&'f251$'!14!;&6'+$!1;$!0&+02+&1*465!*6!&!

5*A*+&#!A&66$#C!!!

,.SC ?4\$[$#e!42#!A4'$+5!&%%#4&0;!1;$!0&+02+&1*46!49!+*&Y*+*1*$5!9#4A![$#:!'*99$#$61!%$#5%$01*[$5C!!!

&C H;$!K4#6$&2!8;$%$++![&+2&1*46!A4'$+!*5!'$1$#A*6*51*0C!!H;$!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!&#$!&%%+*$'!14!$&0;!

0+&*A&61!&6'!1;$!A&6:!%455*Y+$!f42#6$:5!1;#427;!1;$!'*5$&5$!51&7$5!94#!$&0;!0+&*A&61!*5!

'$1$#A*6$'C!!)!'$1$#A*6*51*0!A4'$+!*5!46$!*6!\;*0;!1;$!&552A%1*465!&#$!&%%+*$'!$c&01+:!&5!

51&1$'!*6!$&0;!:$&#!\*1;421!&6:!#&6'4A![&#*&1*46C!!I9!&!'$1$#A*6*51*0!A4'$+!*5!25$'!14!0&+02+&1$!

1;$!62AY$#!49!;$&'5!1;&1!\*++!4002#!*9!&!04*6!*5!1455$'!.e---!1*A$5e!1;$!#$52+1!\*++!Y$!$c&01+:!/--C!

YC H;$!F0d+$#![&+2&1*46!A4'$+!*5!5140;&51*0C!!I6!&!5140;&51*0!A4'$+e!$&0;!%#4Y&Y*+*1:!;&5!&!

'*51#*Y21*46!X!1;*5!042+'!Y$!$Z2&1$'!14!&!Y$++!02#[$!1;&1!\&5!54A$1*A$5!&%%+*$'!14!1$51!A&#d5!*6!

In This Section….

We discuss the actuarial

assumptions used in this

valuation and compare them to

those used by Eckler Partners

! K4#1&+*1:!

! I61$#$51!&6'!I69+&1*46!

! N$6$9*1!5%$0*9*0!&552A%1*465!

@4;4#1!&6'!'*5$&5$!%#47#$55*46!&552A%1*465!&#$!'*50255$'!*6!8$01*465!/!&6'!=C!

!

Page 87: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! =.!

;*7;!50;44+C!!8140;&51*0!A4'$+5!#$0476*5$!1;&1!\;$6!1;*675!;&%%$6!&004#'*67!14!&!%#4Y&Y*+*1:e!

1;$#$!*5!&!'$7#$$!49!#&6'4A6$55!*6!1;$!#$52+15C!!I9!&!5140;&51*0!A4'$+!*5!25$'!14!0&+02+&1$!1;$!

62AY$#!49!;$&'5!1;&1!\*++!4002#!*9!&!04*6!*5!1455$'!.e---!1*A$5e!1;$!#$52+1!\*++!+*d$+:!Y$!

54A$1;*67!0+45$!14!/--e!5&:!Y$1\$$6!S--!&6'!=--!*6!A451!0&5$5C!!N21!1;$!#$52+1!042+'!Y$!&5!+4\!

&5!-!&6'!&5!;*7;!&5!.e---e!&+1;427;!1;$!+*d$+*;44'!49!1;&1!;&%%$6*67!*5!A*621$C!

,./C N$0&25$!42#!A4'$+5!&#$!Y&5$'!46!'*99$#$61!A$1;4'4+47*$5e!04A%+$1$!$Z2*[&+$60:!49!1;$!#$52+15!*5!

641!%455*Y+$e!Y21!\$!&#$!5&1*59*$'!1;&1!1;$#$!&#$!64!A&1$#*&+!'*99$#$60$5!*6!1;$!&%%#4&0;!14!

0&+02+&1*67!+*&Y*+*1*$5C!

4,+2'932>!'11-4523,.1!

,.=C 9$:4-!!G;=!D!2/%&$4+&L!J,,?@8&+/1,!

@11"+5('&#)

ABCB)S'(;)-0&?'1'&#)2&0)@$?,01,)3,?'/('&#)

ABCD))

=,1()>1('+/(,)

ABCD)S'(;)-0&?'1'&#)2&0)

@$?,01,)3,?'/('&#)

K4#1&+*1:!9#4A!&++!0&25$5!41;$#!1;&[email protected]!!>!H#&65925$'!0+&*A&615!!>!?&$A4%;*+*&0!0+&*A&615!

!!@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$5!>!,---!14!,--,!.U/g!49!@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$5!>!,---!14!,--,!

!!@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$5!>!,--<!14!,-..!@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$5!>!,--<!14!,-..!

!!

8&A$!

K4#1&+*1:!9#4A!&++!0&25$5!41;$#!1;&6!?@J!94#!1;45$!04>*69$01$'!\*1;!?IJ!

=,Sg!49!1;$!@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$5!,--->,--,!

=,Sg!49!1;$!@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$5!,--<>,-..!

8&A$!

K4#1&+*1:!'2$!14!?@J!9#4A!T$[$+!=!X!R$04A%$65&1*46!

.(C=g! P#$&1$#!49!@&6&'&!T*9$!A4#1&+*1:o!&6'!./C,g!

8&A$!

K4#1&+*1:!'2$!14!?@J!9#4A!T$[$+!=!X!?@@!]0&60$#`!

M/C-g! P#$&1$#!49!@&6&'&!T*9$!A4#1&+*1:!o&6'!.(C,g!

8&A$!

K4#1&+*1:!'2$!14!?@J!9#4A!T$[$+!=!>!!+*[$#!1#&65%+&61!- 9*#51!:$&#!- 1;$#$&91$#!

!!

.SC=g!!!SCSg!

P#$&1$#!49!@&6&'&!T*9$!A4#1&+*1:o!&6'a!

(C=g!MC<g!

!!

8&A$!

D6*5$c!#&1*4!- H#&65925$'!@4;4#1!!

!N&5$'!46!0+&*A&61i5!7$6'$#C!!W;$#$!7$6'$#!641!51&1$'e!S(C(g!A&+$C!

!N&5$'!46!0+&*A&61i5!7$6'$#C!!W;$#$!7$6'$#!641!51&1$'e!S<C,g!A&+$C!

!8&A$!

- ?&$A4%;*+*&0!@4;4#1!!

N&5$'!46!0+&*A&61i5!7$6'$#C!!W;$#$!7$6'$#!641!51&1$'e!(/C-g!A&+$C!

N&5$'!46!0+&*A&61i5!7$6'$#C!!W;$#$!7$6'$#!641!51&1$'e!(SCUg!A&+$C!

8&A$!

o!!H;$!@&6&'&!T*9$!A4#1&+*1:!21*+*h$'!*60+2'$5!1;$!=,Sg!&'f251A$61!94#!04>*69$01$'!%$#5465C!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!.-!! H;$!'$&1;5!#$52+1*67!9#4A!1;*5!&552A%1*46!&#$!5%+*1!Y$1\$$6!?@J>#$+&1$'!&6'!646>?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;!Y&5$'!

46!1;$!Fc0$55!?@J!3$+&1$'!K4#1&+*1:!&552A%1*46C!

Page 88: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! =,!

,.UC I6!%&51![&+2&1*465e!\$!&'f251$'!1;$!A4#1&+*1:!#&1$5!&%%+*$'!14!;&$A4%;*+*&05!9#4A!.--g!14!.U/g!

49!1;$!@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$!A4#1&+*1:C!!H;&1!#$0476*h$'!1;&1!;&$A4%;*+*&05!$c%$#*$60$!7#$&1$#!

A4#1&+*1:!1;&6!1;$!&[$#&7$!@&6&'*&6..C!!H;&1!A4#1&+*1:!&552A%1*46!'*99$#$'!9#4A!\;&1!\&5!25$'!*6!

1;$!KKWP!3$%4#1C!!!

,.(C H;$!,-.M!KKWP!3$%4#1!51&1$5!1;&1!64!&'f251A$61!*5!A&'$!14!1;$!@&6&'&!T*9$!A4#1&+*1:!#&1$5!

^Y$0&25$!02##$61!0&#$!;&5!A&'$![*#25>9#$$!;$A4%;*+*05!&+A451!;&[$!1;$!5&A$!+*9$!$c%$01&60:!&5!

7$6$#&+!%4%2+&1*46_!]%&7$!M,`C!!B4#!1;$!,-.M![&+2&1*46e!\$!;&[$!1;$#$94#$!0$&5$'!A&d*67!&6!

&'f251A$61!&6'!&%%+:!51&6'&#'!@&6&'*&6!%4%2+&1*46!A4#1&+*1:!#&1$5!94#!;&$A4%;*+*&05C!

,.<C H;$!,-.M!KKWP!A4'$+!0;&67$'!1;$!&%%+*0&1*46!49!A4#1&+*1:!&1!+$[$+!=C!!I6!%#$[*425!A4'$+5e!Y41;!

1;$!51&7$!5%$0*9*0!A4#1&+*1:!&6'!1;$!@&6&'&!T*9$!1&Y+$5!\$#$!&%%+*$'!*6'$%$6'$61+:C!!B4#!,-.Me!&++!

+$[$+!=!'$&1;5!&#$!0465*'$#$'!14!Y$!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@J!&6'!1;$!A4#1&+*1:!#&1$!*5!1;$!7#$&1$#!49!1;$!

51&7$!5%$0*9*0!#&1$!&6'!1;$!@&6&'&!T*9$!#&1$C!

,,-C H;$!'$1$#A*6&1*46!49!$c%$01$'!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!*5!%$#94#A$'!*6!1;#$$!51$%5C!!B*#51e!$c%$01$'!

'$&1;5!9#4A!&++!0&25$5!41;$#!1;&6!?@J!*5!'$1$#A*6$'!Y&5$'!46!1;$!@&6&'&!T*9$!K4#1&+*1:!H&Y+$5C!!

H;&1!7*[$5!1;$!62AY$#!49!$c%$01$'!646>?@J!'$&1;5!%#$'*01$'!Y:!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+C!!8$046'e!1;$!

%$#0$61&7$5!9#4A!H&Y+$!,,-!X!Fc0$55!?@J!K4#1&+*1:!&#$!&%%+*$'!14!&++40&1$!&!%4#1*46!49!1;45$!

$c%$01$'!'$&1;5!14!Y$!1#$&1$'!&5!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5C!!H;*#'e!1;$!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!&5!$c%$01$'!Y:!

1;$!KKWP!A4'$+!&#$!'$1$#A*6$'e!25*67!1;$!A4#1&+*1:!9#4A!?@J!&5!5$1!421!*6!H&Y+$!,.=e!&6'!

&''$'!14!1;$!$c0$55!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5C!!

9$:4-!GG<!)!VSR-,,!B"CD7-4$&-3!2/%&$4+&L!

) 3'1,/1,)V,?,.)

)) C) A) D) J) I) P)

>O5,4(,$)

@?,0/Q,)

*./'+/#(1)7;&);/?,)#&()4.,/0,$)(;,)?'0"1) ) ) ) )

?@J!R$&1;! -g! .-g! M/g! S/g! (-g! .--g! MMg!

Q46>?@J!R$&1;! .--g! <-g! =/g! //g! ,-g! -g! =Ug!

*./'+/#(1)7;&);/?,)4.,/0,$)(;,)?'0"1) ) ) ) )

?@J!R$&1;! -g! -g! -g! ,/g! =-g! .--g! ,,g!

Q46>?@J!R$&1;! .--g! .--g! .--g! U/g! S-g! -g! U(g!

H;$!&552A%1*465!94#!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&6'!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!&#$!1;$!5&A$C!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

..!! ^N#&0d$6#*'7$i5!K$'*0&+!8$+$01*46!49!T*9$!3*5d5_e!B*91;!F'*1*46e!K&:!,--=e!$'*14#5!R#C!3C!RC!@C!N#&0d$6#*'7$e!R#C!3*0;&#'!8C!@#4c46e!&6'!R#C!3455!K&0O$6h*$C!I8NQa!.S-M<-=U=<!e!]&!#$9$#$60$!Y44d!94#!25$!*6!'$1$#A*6*67!1;$!&[$#&7$!$99$01!49![&#*425!A$'*0&+!046'*1*465!46!9212#$!A4#1&+*1:`!

Page 89: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! =M!

H;*5!&552A%1*46!*5!&!0;&67$!9#4A!,-.-C!!Q4!$c0$55!?@J!#$+&1$'!A4#1&+*1:!\&5!&552A$'!94#!

0+&*A&615!\;4!;&'!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25C!!B4#!1;45$!\;4!;&'!641!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25e!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!

&552A%1*46!\&5!A&#7*6&++:!;*7;$#!1;&6!1;$!&Y4[$!&6'!Y$1\$$6!.-g!&6'!,-g!;*7;$#!94#!1;$!

%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465C!!H;$!,-.-!&552A%1*46!*5!*60+2'$'!*6!)%%$6'*c!RC!

0(,.,43(!'11-4523,.1!

,,.C H;$!#$12#6!46!*6[$51$'!&55$15!5;4\6!*5!'$[$+4%$'!9#4A!&6!$c%$01$'!#$12#6!94#!&!%44+!49!&55$15!

*6[$51$'!*6!&!04AY*6&1*46!49!$Z2*1*$5!&6'!Y46'5e!+$55!&!%#4[*5*46!94#!*6[$51A$61!$c%$65$5C!!W$!

;&[$!&552A$'!1;$!+467!1$#A!926'!&55$15!\*++!Y$!*6[$51$'!Y&5$'!46!1;$!*6[$51A$61!Y$60;A&#d!A*cC!!

H;$!+467>1$#A!&55$15!A&d$!2%!&Y421!<SC/g!49!1;$!*6[$51$'!&55$15C!!H;$!5;4#1>1$#A!926'!&55$15!

]\;*0;!&#$!14!Y$!A&6&7$'!14!Y$!&Y421!j=/!A*++*46e!4#!/C/g!49!1;$!02##$61!926'!5*h$`!&#$!*6[$51$'!

$61*#$+:!*6!0&5;C!!I6[$51A$61!#$+&1$'!$c%$65$5!&#$!&552A$'!14!Y$!-C-Sg!49!1;$!*6[$51$'!&55$15e!

Y&5$'!46!&012&+!#$0$61!$c%$#*$60$C!!!

,,,C H;$!%#4[*60*&+!641*46&+!&55$15!&#$!&552A$'!14!$&#6!*61$#$51!&1!1;$!#$12#6!4[$#!1;$!+467>1$#A!9212#$!

94#!M!A461;!H#$&52#:!N*++5C!

,,MC H;$!A$1;4'4+47:!21*+*5$'!Y:!K4#6$&2!8;$%$++!&6'!Y:!F0d+$#!14!'$1$#A*6$!1;$!'*504261!#&1$5!

'*99$#e!Y21!1;$!#$52+1*67!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&6'!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!#&1$5!&#$!1;$!5&A$C!

,,SC 9$:4-!GG(!D!VR/1/@+R!J,,?@8&+/1,!

)ABCB)

)ABCD)

@11,()*./11) @..&4/('&#)>O5,4(,$)U,("0#)

*&#(0'b"('&#)(&)!"#$)U,("0#)

)@..&4/('&#)

>O5,4(,$)U,("0#)

*&#(0'b"('&#)(&)!"#$)U,("0#)

D6*[$#5$!N46'5! MCUg! ,C<-g! -C..g! ! /C-g! SC.-g! -C,.g!

8;4#1!H$#A!N46'5! =C<g! ,C/-g! -C.Ug! ! =CUg! SC.-g! -C,Ug!

3$&+!#$12#6!Y46'5! ==C-g! MCM/g! ,C,.g! ! =SC-g! ,C<-g! .C(=g!

FZ2*1*$5! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

!>!@&6&'&! SCMg! UC/-g! -CM,g! ! /CUg! UC=-g! -CSMg!

!>!!D8! .C/g! UC/-g! -C..g! ! ,C(g! UC=-g! -C,.g!

!>!!I61$#6&1*46&+! .CUg! UC/-g! -C.Mg! ! ,C(g! UC=-g! -C,.g!

Q41*46&+!&55$15! ./C<g! ,C/-g! -CS-g! ! .MC-g! MC.-g! -CS-g!

Fc%$01$'!#$12#6! .--C-g! !! MCS/g! !! .--C-g! !! MC=-g!

3$Y&+&60*67!$99$01! ! ! -C.,g! ! ! ! -C,Sg!

T$55!I69+&1*46! ! ! >,C,/g! ! ! ! >,C/-g!

T$55!Fc%$65$5! ! ! >-C-Sg! ! ! ! >-C-Sg!

3'14&"#()0/(,)^)=,1()>1('+/(,)

)) )) C`AMa) )) !! !! C`DBa)

K&#7*6!94#!)'[$#5$!R$[*&1*465!

! ! >-C,Mg! ! ! ! >-C,/g!

3'14&"#()U/(,)^)-2@3) )) )) C`BIa) )) )) )) C`BIa)

Page 90: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! =S!

'11-4523,.1!7,+!150(373(!&0.0732!5'>40.21!

,,/C W$!6$$'!14!A&d$!&552A%1*465!&Y421!$&0;!5%$0*9*0!Y$6$9*1!&[&*+&Y+$!26'$#!1;$!"+&6C!!Fc0$%1!\;$#$!

*6'*0&1$'!41;$#\*5$e!$&0;!49!1;$!94++4\*67!&552A%1*465!*5!25$'!94#!Y41;!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&6'!1;$!

%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465C!

,,=C K451!49!1;$!%&:A$61!&A42615!&#$!*60#$&5$'!9#4A!1;$!.<<<!+$[$+5!&5!5$1!421!*6!1;$!8$11+$A$61!

)7#$$A$61!14!#$9+$01!*69+&1*46C!!H;*5!*6'$c*67!*5!Y&5$'!46!1;$!*6'$c*67!+$[$+!26'$#!1;$!@&6&'&!

"$65*46!"+&6!$&0;!:$&#C!!I6!1;$!'*50255*46!49!Y$6$9*1!&A42615e!\$!#$9$#!14!1;$!&A4261!Y&5$'!46!1;$!

.<<<!+$[$+5C!!I6!1;$![&+2&1*46e!\$!#$0476*5$'!1;$!&012&+!*6'$c*67!1;&1!;&5!Y$$6!&%%+*$'!2%!14!

V&62&#:!,-.SC!

,,UC H;$!94++4\*67!&#$!1;$!*6'$c*67!#&1$5!1;&1!;&[$!Y$$6!25$'!14!*60#$&5$!1;$!%&:A$615!26'$#!1;$!"+&6C!!

H;$!#&1$5!94#!,--/!14!,--U!\$#$!1&d$6!9#4A!1;$!,--U!F0d+$#!3$%4#1C!!B4#!,-.S!&6'!1;$#$&91$#e!

%&:A$615!&#$!&552A$'!14!Y$!*6'$c$'!&1!1;$!#&1$!49!*69+&1*46C!!H;$5$!;*514#*0&+!*6'$c*67!#&1$5!&#$!

Y&5$'!46!9&01!&6'!&#$!1;$!5&A$!94#!&++!5$15!49!&552A%1*465C!

!"#$%&BBS&2&>0:.+-0="$&Q46%<04N&F".%:&

L$&#! I6'$c*67!3&1$!

.<<<! .C/Ug!

,---! ,C/S!

,--.! MC-.!

,--,! .C=M!

,--M! MC,.!

,--S! .CU,!

,--/! ,C,=!

,--=! ,C.M!

,--U! .C<.!

,--(! ,C/,!

,--<! -CM/!

,-.-! .C==!

,-..! ,C(S!

,-.,! .CU=!

,-.M! -C<.!

,,(C H;$!02A2+&1*[$!*6'$c*67!#&1$!5*60$!.<<<!*5!MSC/UUSgC!!84!1;$!j.-e---!+2A%!52A!%&:&Y+$!94#!+$[$+!

.!\42+'!Y$!%&*'!&1!j.MeS/UCUS!'2#*67!,-.SC!!

M;<E<<<!A/%!B"C!+1A-R&+/1!XK-I-4!;Y!

,,<C "&:A$615!&#$!&552A$'!14!Y$!A&'$!*AA$'*&1$+:!2%46!&!0+&*A&61!Y$*67!&%%#4[$'C!!)++!d64\6!

0+&*A&615!&#$!1;$#$94#$!&552A$'!14!;&[$!#$0$*[$'!1;*5!&A4261C!!H4!1;$!$c1$61!1;&1!&6:!&A42615!

#$A&*6!42151&6'*67e!1;$:!&#$!*60+2'$'!*6!1;$!141&+!49!42151&6'*67!%&:A$615C!

Page 91: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! =/!

,M-C B4#!1;$!26d64\6!0+&*A&615e!%&:A$615!&#$!&552A$'!14!Y$!A&'$!&1!9212#$!'&1$5!2%46!&%%#4[&+!49!

1;$*#!0+&*A!\*1;421!#$7&#'!14!1;$*#!'*5$&5$!51&7$C!!3$9$#!14!1;$!'*50255*46!49!1;$!@+&*A&61!@4;4#1!

94#!92#1;$#!'$1&*+5C!

MG<E<<<!)!8/,+&+I-!."7!&-,&!XK-I-4!GY!

,M.C "&:A$615!&#$!&552A$'!14!Y$!A&'$!*AA$'*&1$+:!2%46!&!0+&*A&61!#$&0;*67!+$[$+!,C!!8*60$!1;$#$!*5!&6!

&552A%1*46!1;&1!64!%$#546!\*++!%#47#$55!9#4A!+$[$+!.!14!&6:!41;$#!+$[$+e!1;*5!$55$61*&++:!#$52+15!*6!&!

%&:A$61!*AA$'*&1$+:!2%46!&!0+&*A!Y$*67!&%%#4[$'!94#!1;45$!&1!+$[$+!,!4#!Y$:46'C!!!!)++!d64\6!

0+&*A&615!41;$#!1;&6!1;45$!&1!+$[$+!.!&#$!1;$#$94#$!&552A$'!14!;&[$!Y$$6!%&*'!1;*5!&A4261C!!H4!1;$!

$c1$61!1;&1!&6:!&A42615!#$A&*6!42151&6'*67e!1;$:!&#$!*60+2'$'!*6!1;$!141&+!49!42151&6'*67!

%&:A$615C!

,M,C B4#!1;$!26d64\6!0+&*A&615e!%&:A$615!&#$!&552A$'!14!Y$!A&'$!2%46!&%%#4[&+!49!1;$*#!0+&*A!*9!

1;$:!&#$!+$[$+!,!]'*5$&5$!51&7$!B-]3Q)p``!4#!Y$:46'C!

MH<E<<<!)!>/1D:%+30+10!A+:%/,+,!XK-I-4!HY!

,MMC H;*5!%&:A$61!*5!&[&*+&Y+$!14!&++!0+&*A&615!\;4!;&[$!'$[$+4%$'!646>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5!4#!;&[$!

%#40$$'$'!Y$:46'!1;&1!+$[$+C!!H;$!KKWP!A4'$+!'4$5!641!*60+2'$!&!51&7$!'*#$01+:!04##$5%46'*67!

14!646>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5C!!?4\$[$#e!\$!26'$#51&6'!1;&1!646>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5!64#A&++:!4002#5!

54A$\;$#$!Y$1\$$6!51&7$5!B.!&6'!B,e!]B*Y#45*5!51&7$5!.!&6'!,`!&6'!\$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!&!

0+&*A&61!&1!51&7$!B.!*5!$61*1+$'!14!+$[$+!M!Y$6$9*15C!!H;*5!*5!0465*51$61!\*1;!1;$!F0d+$#!&552A%1*465!

&6'!\*1;!;4\!1;$!KKWP!&552A$'!1;$!+$[$+5!&6'!51&7$5!\42+'!Y$!1#$&1$'C!!

,MSC )!0+&*A&61!A&:!$+$01!14!\&*[$!1;*5!%&:A$61!&6'!#$0$*[$!*651$&'!&!T455!49!I604A$!4#!T455!49!

8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*1C!!H;$!'$0*5*46!&5!14!\;*0;!Y$6$9*1!14!#$0$*[$!A&:!Y$!'$9$##$'!&5!+467!&5!1;$!

0+&*A&61!\*5;$5C!!!

,M/C B4#!&++!d64\6!0+&*A&615!\;4!;&[$!A&'$!&6!$+$01*46!14!#$0$*[$!1;$!jM-e---!+2A%!52Ae!\$!;&[$!

&552A$'!%&:A$61!;&5!Y$$6!A&'$!&6'!14!1;$!$c1$61!1;&1!*1!;&5!641e!1;$!&A4261!*5!*60+2'$'!*6!1;$!

42151&6'*67!%&:A$615!141&+5C!

,M=C B4#!&++!26d64\6!0+&*A&615!&6'!&++!d64\6!0+&*A&615!\;4!;&[$!641!A&'$!&6!$+$01*46!4#!;&[$!641!

#$&0;$'!1;*5!51&7$e!\$!&552A$'!</g!49!1;45$!26'$#!&7$!=/!&6'!<Mg!49!1;45$!4[$#!&7$!=/!\42+'!

$+$01!14!#$0$*[$!1;$!jM-e---!+2A%!52A!&6'!1;$!Y&+&60$!\42+'!$+$01!1;$!T455!49!I604A$!4#!T455!49!

8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*1!&5!'$50#*Y$'!*6!1;$!94++4\*67!5$01*46C!!

M='E<<<!)!"+%%#/,+,!XK-I-4!'Y!

,MUC "&:A$615!&#$!&552A$'!14!Y$!A&'$!*AA$'*&1$+:!2%46!&!0+&*A&61!#$&0;*67!T$[$+!/!]51&7$!BS!>!

@*##;45*5`C!!)++!d64\6!0+&*A&615!&1!51&7$!BS!&6'!Y$:46'!&#$!&552A$'!14!;&[$!Y$$6!%&*'!1;*5!

&A4261C!!H4!1;$!$c1$61!1;&1!&6:!&A42615!#$A&*6!42151&6'*67e!1;$:!&#$!*60+2'$'!*6!1;$!141&+!49!

42151&6'*67!%&:A$615C!

Page 92: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! ==!

,M(C B4#!41;$#!0+&*A&615e!%&:A$615!&#$!&552A$'!14!Y$!A&'$!2%46!1#&65*1*46!14!51&7$!BSC!

M;<<E<<<!)!*-R/@8-1,$&+/1Z"$1R-%ZK+I-%!9%$1,84$1&!XK-I-4!=Y!

,M<C "&:A$615!&#$!&552A$'!14!Y$!A&'$!*AA$'*&1$+:!2%46!&!0+&*A&61!#$&0;*67!+$[$+!=!X!+*[$#!

'$04A%$65&1*46!&6'!?@@C!]W;*+$!+*[$#!1#&65%+&61!*5!#$0476*5$'!26'$#!1;$!"+&6e!1;$!A$'*0&+!A4'$+!

&552A$5!1;&1!&++!%&1*$615!\;4!#$0$*[$!&!+*[$#!1#&65%+&61!9*#51!74!1;#427;!1;$!+*[$#!'$04A%$65&1*46!

51&7$e!54!94#!%2#%45$5!49!1;*5![&+2&1*46e!64!&''*1*46&+!Y$6$9*15!&#$!&552A$'!%&:&Y+$!&1!+*[$#!

1#&65%+&61`C!!)++!d64\6!0+&*A&615!&1!51&7$5!'$04A%$65&1*46!4#!?@@!&6'!Y$:46'!&#$!&552A$'!14!

;&[$!Y$$6!%&*'!1;*5!&A4261C!!H4!1;$!$c1$61!1;&1!&6:!&A42615!#$A&*6!42151&6'*67e!1;$:!&#$!

*60+2'$'!*6!1;$!141&+!49!42151&6'*67!%&:A$615C!

,S-C B4#!41;$#!0+&*A&615e!%&:A$615!&#$!&552A$'!14!Y$!A&'$!2%46!1#&65*1*46!14!51&7$5!'$04A%$65&1*46!

4#!?@@C!

K/,,!/A!O1R/@-!$13!K/,,!/A!P-%I+R-,!$&!>/1D[%+30+10!\+:%/,+,!P&$0-!XK-I-4!HY!

,S.C T455!49!*604A$!*5!&[&*+&Y+$!14!0+&*A&615!26'$#!&7$!=/!\;4!;&[$!646>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5!]&552A$'!14!

4002#!&5!'$50#*Y$'!&Y4[$`!&6'!;&[$!$+$01$'!14!#$0$*[$!&!T455!49!I604A$!Y$6$9*1!*6!+*$2!49!1;$!

jM-e---!+2A%!52AC!

,S,C B4#!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&5!\$++!&5!1;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465![&+2$5e!d64\6!0+&*A&615!\;4!

&#$!&+#$&':!*6!#$0$*%1!49!1;*5!Y$6$9*1!&#$!&552A$'!14!0461*62$!14!#$0$*[$!%&:A$615!*6!1;$!5&A$!

&A4261!Y21!*6'$c$'!$&0;!:$&#C!!

,SMC B4#!41;$#!0+&*A&615!\;4!;&[$!641!A&'$!&6!$+$01*46!#$7&#'*67!1;$!jM-e---!%&:A$61e!]Y41;!d64\6!

&6'!26d64\6!0+&*A&615`e!/g!49!1;45$!26'$#!&7$!=/!&6'!Ug!49!1;45$!4[$#!=/!&#$!&552A$'!14!\&*[$!

$61*1+$A$61!14!1;$!jM-e---!+2A%!52A!&A4261C!!E9!1;45$!26'$#!&7$!=/e!=-g!49!1;*5!/g!]4#!Mg!49!

1;45$!&1!646>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5!51&7$`!&#$!&552A$'!14!#$0$*[$!&!T455!49!I604A$!Y$6$9*1C!!)1!&7$!=/e!

1;$:!\*++!5\*10;!14!&!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*1C!!H;$!#$51!49!1;45$!\;4!\&*[$!1;$!jM-e---!Y$6$9*1!],g!

49!1;45$!26'$#!&7$!=/!&6'!Ug!49!1;45$!4[$#!&7$!=/`!&#$!&552A$'!14!#$0$*[$!&!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!

Y$6$9*1C!!B4#!1;$!,-.-![&+2&1*46e!1;$!&552A%1*465!\$#$!1;$!5&A$!\*1;!1;$!$c0$%1*46!1;&1!1;$!Ug!

&6'!<Mg![&+2$5!\$#$!/g!&6'!</g!#$5%$01*[$+:C!

,SSC T455!49!I604A$!Y$6$9*15!&#$!&552A$'!14!Y$!jM<e---!]jM/e---!*6!,-.-![&+2&1*46`!%$#!:$&#!94#!1;$!

1#&65925$'!04;4#1!&6'!jS(e---!]jM(e---!*6!,-.-![&+2&1*46`!%$#!:$&#!94#!1;$!;&$A4%;*+*&0!04;4#1C!!

T455!49!8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*15!&#$!&552A$'!14!Y$!j.=e---!]j./e---!*6!,-.-`!%$#!:$&#!94#!Y41;!1;$!

1#&65925$'!&6'!;&$A4%;*+*&0!04;4#15C!!H;$5$!'4++&#!&A42615!&#$!&++!*6!,-.S!'4++&#5C!

K/,,!/A!O1R/@-!$13!K/,,!/A!P-%I+R-,!$&![%+30+10!\+:%/,+,!P&$0-!$13![-L/13!XK-I-4,!(!&/!=Y!

,S/C F61*1+$A$61!14!1;$5$!Y$6$9*15!*5!'$50#*Y$'!*6!)%%$6'*c!)!>!82AA&#:!49!N$6$9*15C!!T455!49!I604A$!*5!

&[&*+&Y+$!14!0+&*A&615!26'$#!&7$!=/C!!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!*5!&[&*+&Y+$!14!&6:!0+&*A&61!#$7&#'+$55!49!&7$e!

%#4[*'$'!1;$:!&#$!641!*6!#$0$*%1!49!&!T455!49!I604A$!Y$6$9*1C!

Page 93: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! =U!

,S=C B4#!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&5!\$++!&5!1;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465![&+2$5e!d64\6!0+&*A&615!\;4!

&#$!&+#$&':!*6!#$0$*%1!49!1;$5$!Y$6$9*15!&#$!&552A$'!14!0461*62$!14!#$0$*[$!%&:A$615!&1!1;$!5&A$!

+$[$+!Y21!*6'$c$'!$&0;!:$&#C!!!

,SUC B4#!1;$!d64\6!0+&*A&615!\;4!&#$!&1!4#!Y$:46'!Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5!]+$[$+5!S!14!=`!&6'!\;4!&#$!641!

02##$61+:!*6!#$0$*%1!49!1;*5!Y$6$9*1e!\$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!1;$#$!A&:!Y$!&!9212#$!0+&*A!*6!

&004#'&60$!\*1;!1;$!94++4\*67!1&Y+$5C!!H;$!%$#0$61&7$!94#!9212#$!0+&*A5!9#4A!d64\6!0+&*A&615!

\;$6!&''$'!14!1;$!#$5%$01*[$!%$#0$61&7$!49!d64\6!0+&*A&615!\;4!&#$!&+#$&':!#$0$*[*67!&!Y$6$9*1!

7*[$5!&!141&+!1;$!5&A$!&5!]4#!*6!54A$!0&5$5!7#$&1$#!1;&6`!1;$!26d64\6!0+&*A&615C!

!"#$%&BWS&2&F".%&+D&EC.C-%&*$"09:&D+-&O+::&+D&Q4=+9%a/%-P0=%:&Z%4%D0.&&

=,#,2'()-/[+,#() ABCB) ABCD)^)=>) ABCD)^)-2@3)

K/,,!/A!O1R/@-)X!T$[$+!M!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!

!Mg!$+$01!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!$+$01!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!Mg!$+$01!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!$+$01!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!8&A$!

K/,,!/A!P-%I+R-,'X!T$[$+!M!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!

!,g!$+$01!26'$#!&7$!=/!/g!$+$01!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!,g!$+$01!26'$#!&7$!=/!Ug!$+$01!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!8&A$!

K/,,!/A!O1R/@-!X!T$[$+5!S!&6'!/!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!X!

26d64\6!!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!>!

d64\6.,!

!.(g!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!Ug!1#&65925$'!

-g!;&$A4%;*+*&0!

!,.g!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!/C(g!1#&65925$'!

MC,g!;&$A4%;*+*&0!

!8&A$!

K/,,!/A!O1R/@-!X!T$[$+!=!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!>!

26d64\6!!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!>!d64\6!!

!.Ug!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!-g!1#&65925$'!

-g!;&$A4%;*+*&0!

!,/g!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!-g!1#&65925$'!

-g!;&$A4%;*+*&0!

!8&A$!

K/,,!/A!P-%I+R-,!X!T$[$+5!S!&6'!/!!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!>!

26d64\6!!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!>!d64\6!!

- H#&65925$'!!- ?&$A4%;*+*&0!

!M<g!26'$#!&7$!=/!/Ug!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!!

..g!26'$#!&7$!=/!,/g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!/g!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!M-g!26'$#!&7$!=/!/.g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!!

=CUg!26'$#!&7$!=/!,UCMg!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!-g!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!8&A$!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

.,!! H;$!d64\6!%#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!&%%+*$5!14!d64\6!0+&*A&615!&+#$&':!&1!1;$!*6'*0&1$'!+$[$+!\;4!;&[$!641!:$1!04AA$60$'!&!0+&*AC!!)++!d64\6!0+&*A&615!&+#$&':!46!0+&*A!&#$!&552A$'!14!0461*62$C!!)++!d64\6!0+&*A&615!\;4!+&1$#!1#&65*1*46!*614!1;$!+$[$+!&#$!&552A$'!14!0+&*A!Y&5$'!46!1;$!%#4%4#1*465!94#!26d64\6!0+&*A&615C!

Page 94: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! =(!

=,#,2'()-/[+,#() ABCB) ABCD)^)=>) ABCD)^)-2@3)

K/,,!/A!P-%I+R-,!X!T$[$+!=!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!>!

26d64\6!!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!>!d64\6!!

- H#&65925$'!!- ?&$A4%;*+*&0!

!

!/Ug!26'$#!&7$!=/!USg!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!!

,/g!26'$#!&7$!=/!.(g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!.-g!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!S-g!26'$#!&7$!=/!=/g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!!

/CMg!26'$#!&7$!=/!S-C<g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!-g!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!8&A$!

,S(C "&:A$615!&#$!&552A$'!14!0461*62$!94#!1;$!+*9$1*A$!49!1;$!0+&*A&61C!

,S<C H;$![&+2&1*46!A4'$+!&552A$5!1;&1!1;45$!\;4!0+&*A!&!T455!49!I604A$!4#!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*1!'4!

54!04*60*'$61!\*1;!1#&65*1*46*67!*614!+$[$+!SC!!]B4#!1;$!*60#$&5$!9#4A!/.g!14!=/g!49!0+&*A&615!&1!

+$[$+!=e!1;$!$c1#&!.Sg!&#$!&552A$'!14!0+&*A!04*60*'$61!\*1;!1;$*#!1#&65*1*46!14!+$[$+!=`C!!I6!#$&+*1:e!

A&6:!49!1;$5$!0+&*A5!\*++!04AA$60$!&1!&!+&1$#!1*A$C!!H;*5!&552A%1*46!\*++!4[$#51&1$!1;$!+*&Y*+*1*$5C!!

H;*5!*552$!46+:!&99$015!1;$!0+&*A&615!\;4!1#&65*1*46!14!+$[$+!S!\*1;421!;&[*67!0+&*A$'!&1!&6!$&#+*$#!

+$[$+C!!W$!\*++!#$9$#!14!1;*5!7#42%!&5!O64\65!\*1;!R$9$##$'!N$6$9*15C!

,/-C D6'$#!1;$!"+&6e!&!0+&*A&61!&1!+$[$+!S!\;4!;&5!&!T455!49!I604A$!4#!8$#[*0$5!1;&1!04AA$60$'!%#*4#!

14!#$&0;*67!+$[$+!S!A&:!0+&*A!#$1#4&01*[$!Y$6$9*15!X!$[$6!*9!1;$:!;&'!#$0$*[$'!1;$!jM-e---!+2A%!

52A!%&:A$61!&1!+$[$+!MC!!H;*5!A&:!&99$01!&!5A&++!%$#0$61&7$!49!1;$!0+&*A&615!\;4!1#&65*1*46!14!

+$[$+!SC!!W$!\*++!#$9$#!14!1;*5!7#42%!&5!O64\65!\*1;!3$1#4&01*[$!N$6$9*15C!

,/.C W;$6!&6!26d64\6!0+&*A&61!&1!+$[$+!S!4#!Y$:46'!9*+$5!&!0+&*Ae!1;$#$!A&:!Y$!&!T455!49!I604A$!4#!

T455!49!8$#[*0$5!1;&1!04AA$60$'!%#*4#!14!1;$!9*+*67!49!1;$!0+&*AC!!820;!&!+455!*5!$+*7*Y+$!94#!

%&:A$61C!!W$!\*++!#$9$#!14!1;*5!7#42%!&5!D6d64\65!\*1;!3$1#4&01*[$!N$6$9*15C!

,/,C I6!42#!4%*6*46e!1;$!4[$#51&1$A$61!49!+*&Y*+*1*$5!94#!1;$!O64\65!\*1;!R$9$##$'!N$6$9*15!*5!

5*76*9*0&61+:!7#$&1$#!1;&6!1;$!+*&Y*+*1:!94#!1;$!O64\65!&6'!D6d64\65!\*1;!3$1#4&01*[$!N$6$9*15C!!

W$!;&[$!1;$#$94#$!&552A$'!1;&1!1;$!+*&Y*+*1:!94#!O64\65!\*1;!R$9$##$'!N$6$9*15!\*++!$c0$$'!1;$!

141&+!+*&Y*+*1:!94#!O64\65!\*1;!3$1#4&01*[$!N$6$9*15!&6'!D6d64\65!\*1;!3$1#4&01*[$!N$6$9*15C!!

3&1;$#!1;&6!1#:*67!14!Z2&61*9:!1;$!&A42615!*6[4+[$'e!94#!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&6'!%#4[*5*46!94#!

&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!&552A%1*465e!\$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;$#$!*5!64!&'f251A$61!#$Z2*#$'!14!#$0476*h$!

1;$!#$1#4&01*[$!Y$6$9*15!%&:&Y+$!&6'!1;&1!1;$#$!A&:!Y$!&6!*AA&1$#*&+!4[$#51&1$A$61!49!+*&Y*+*1*$5!

&5!&!#$52+1C!

,/MC B2#1;$#e!*6!42#!4%*6*46e!*1!*5!+*d$+:!1;&1!&6:!0+&*A5!04AA$60$'!&1!+$[$+!=!\*++!;&[$!64!4#![$#:!+*11+$!

#$1#4&01*[$!%&:A$615!'2$C!

,/SC W$!26'$#51&6'!1;&1!1;$#$!A&:!Y$!5*12&1*465!\;$#$!0+&*A&615!&#$!#$0$*[*67!T455!49!I604A$!4#!T455!

49!8$#[*0$!Y$6$9*15!'2$!14!&!1$A%4#&#:!'*5&Y*+*1:C!!H;$!'&1&!'4$5!641!*'$61*9:!1;$5$!0+&*A&615e!54!\$!

;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!1;$#$!&#$!64!1$A%4#&#:!%$#*4'5!49!'*5&Y*+*1:C!!H4!1;$!$c1$61!1;&1!54A$!49!1;$5$!

Page 95: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! =<!

0+&*A&615!\*++!#$04[$#!&6'e!$*1;$#!%$#A&6$61+:!4#!1$A%4#&#*+:e!0$&5$!#$0$*[*67!T455!49!I604A$!4#!

8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*15e!1;$!+*&Y*+*1:!\*++!Y$!4[$#51&1$'!5+*7;1+:C!

,//C B4#!0+&*A&615!02##$61+:!#$0$*[*67!Y$6$9*15e!1;$!&A4261!%&*'!*5!&552A$'!14!0461*62$!\*1;!*6'$c*67!

94#!1;$!9212#$C!!B4#!0+&*A&615!641!02##$61+:!#$0$*[*67!1;*5!Y$6$9*1e!1;$!T455!49!I604A$!%&:A$615!&#$!

&552A$'!14!Y$!jM<e---!]jM/e---!*6!,-.-`!%$#!:$&#!94#!1;$!1#&65925$'!04;4#1!&6'!jS(e---!

]jM(e---!*6!,-.-`!%$#!:$&#!94#!1;$!;&$A4%;*+*&0!04;4#1C!!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*15!&#$!&552A$'!14!

Y$!j.=e---!]j./e---!*6!,-.-`!%$#!:$&#!94#!Y41;!1;$!1#&65925$'!&6'!;&$A4%;*+*&0!04;4#15C!!H;$5$!

'4++&#!&A42615!&#$!&++!*6!,-.S!'4++&#5C!

7-R/I-%L!A%/@!K/,,!/A!O1R/@-!$13!K/,,!/A!P-%I+R-,!

,/=C "#*4#!14!,-.Me!\$!&552A$'!1;&1!&6:!0+&*A&61!\;4!04AA$60$'!&!T455!49!I604A$!4#!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!

Y$6$9*1!\42+'!#$A&*6!*6!#$0$*%1!49!*1!]&91$#!5\*10;*67!14!&!+455!49!5$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*1!&1!&7$!=/`!94#!1;$!

Y&+&60$!49!1;$*#!+*9$C!!W;*+$!1;$#$!\$#$!0+&*A&615!94#!\;4A!1;$!'*5&Y*+*1:!\&5!1$A%4#&#:e!1;$:!

\$#$!9$\!*6!62AY$#!&6'!*764#*67!1;$!%455*Y*+*1:!49!#$04[$#:!9#4A!'*5&Y*+*1:!*5!641!A&1$#*&+C!

,/UC W*1;!1;$!6$\!1#$&1A$615!&[&*+&Y+$e!\$!Y$+*$[$!1;&1!#$04[$#:!9#4A!'*5&Y*+*1:!\*++!Y$!A&1$#*&+!&6'!

\$!;&[$!1;$#$94#$!A&'$!&6!&552A%1*46C!!W$!;&'!+*11+$!*694#A&1*46!46!\;*0;!14!Y&5$!1;$!

&552A%1*46C!!W$!\$#$!&'[*5$'!1;&1a!!

&C '&A&7$!'46$!Y:!?@J!*5!641!#$[$#5$'!Y:!#$04[$#:b!!!

YC 04A4#Y*'*1:!*552$5!\*++!+*d$+:!0461*62$!&6'!&6:!%#*4#!$99$01!49!?@J!46!1;$!04A4#Y*'*1:!042+'!

0461*62$!&99$01*67!1;$!%$#546!94#!54A$!1*A$b!&6'!

0C #$04[$#:!1*A$!94#!A451!0+&*A&615!&1!+$[$+!M!*5!+*d$+:!14!Y$!&!9$\!A461;5!Y21!*60#$&5$!14!&!9$\!

:$&#5e!*9!&1!&++e!&1!+$[$+!/C!

,/(C N&5$'!46!1;$!&Y4[$e!\$!&552A$!1;&1!1;$!94++4\*67!%$#0$61!49!0+&*A&615!\;4!;&[$!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25!

&6'!1;45$!\;4!\*++!0+$&#!1;$![*#25!\*++!#$04[$#!&6'!;&[$!1;$*#!+455!49!*604A$!&6'!+455!49!5$#[*0$5!

Y$6$9*1!0$&5$C!

) )

Page 96: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! U-!

:/b.,)AIM)g)U,4&?,0[)U/(,1)20&+)V&11)&2)Y#4&+,)/#$)V&11)&2)E,0?'4,1)

@2(,0)*.,/0'#Q)(;,)Z'0"1)))

3"0/('&#)E'#4,)3'1/b'.'([) V,?,.1)D)f)J) V,?,.)I) V,?,.)P)

.! /-C-g! ,/C-g! -g!

,! M-C-g! ./C-g! -g!

M! ,/C-g! .,C/g! -g!

S! ,/C-g! .,C/g! -g!

/! ./C-g! UC/g! -g!

=! .-C-g! /C-g! -g!

U! /C-g! ,C/g! -g!

(! /C-g! ,C/g! -g!

<p! -C-g! -C-g! -g!

)

"/,&,!/A!"$%-!XK-I-4!=Y!!

,/<C H&Y+$!,/<!5;4\5!1;$!%&51!5*c!:$&#5!49!0+&*A5!94#!0451!49!0&#$!&A467!&++!0+&*A&615!&1!+$[$+!=C!!!

!"#$%&BKT&2&*+:.&+D&*"-%&*$"09:&

>HIJ!

.KLMHJ!(NIOLOPQ!

(RST!RU!(IJH!

5HJVHPTIQH!RU!'NN!

9HWHN!C!(NIOLIPTS!

'WHJIQH!(NIOL!

'LRKPT!

HIIJ! KJ! LJMNO! P!HQBHLR!!

HIIS! TL! LSMLO! !HTBRRT!!

HIQI! TH! LNMNO! !HJBJLT!!

HIQQ! TR! KIMLO! !HRBSRR!!

HIQH! TI! LNMLO! !LRBTIQ!!

HIQL! TL! LJMKO! !KNBSQK!!

E9#5)6#! TH! LJMRO! P!LQBHRQ!

,=-C I6!42#!'*50255*465!\*1;!F0d+$#!&Y421!&552A%1*465e!\$!&552A$'!1;&1!1;$!+&#7$!*60#$&5$!*6!&[$#&7$!

&A4261!94#!,-.M!*5!+*d$+:!&!51&1*51*0&+!&64A&+:e!Y21!'$0*'$'!14!#$9+$01!*1!&5!&6!&552A%1*46!94#!1;$!

%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*46C!

,=.C F&0;!:$&#!46!&[$#&7$e!S-g!]S/g!*6!,-.-`!49!0+&*A&615!&1!+$[$+!=!]'$04A%$65&1*46e!?@@!&6'!+*[$#!

1#&65%+&61`!\*++!#$Z2*#$!0&#$!\*1;!&6!&[$#&7$!0+&*A!49!jM-e---!]j.=e---!*6!,-.-`!\;$#$!1;$!

&A4261!*5!51&1$'!*6!,-.S!'4++&#5C!!B4#!1;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465e!1;$!&552A%1*465!&#$!

S-g!]//g!*6!,-.-`!&1!&6!&[$#&7$!0+&*A!49!jS/e---!]j,.e---!*6!,-.-`C!

Page 97: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! U.!

*%?0!9#-%$8L!!

,=,C W*1;!1;$!6$\!'#27!1#$&1A$61!#$7*A$65!#$0$61+:!*61#4'20$'!&6'!$c%$01$'!14!Y$!*61#4'20$'!*6!1;$!

6$&#!9212#$e!1;$!0+&*A5!94#!'#27!1;$#&%:!Y$6$9*15!\*++!+*d$+:!0;&67$!5*76*9*0&61+:!9#4A!1;$!%&51C!!H;$!

6$\!1#$&1A$615!&#$!$c%$01$'!14!1&d$!+$55!1*A$!&6'!Y$!A20;!+$55!'$Y*+*1&1*67!'2#*67!1#$&1A$61C!!I6!

42#!'*50255*465!\*1;!F0d+$#e!\$!'$0*'$'!1;&1!%&51!1#$&1A$61!51&1*51*05!\42+'!Y$!49!+*11+$!4#!64!25$!

*6!A&d*67!&6!&552A%1*46!94#!1;$!9212#$C!

,=MC N&5$'!46!*694#A&1*46!%#4[*'$'!Y:!1\4!A$'*0&+!'4014#5.M!147$1;$#!\*1;!#$04AA$6'$'!1#$&1A$61!

%#41404+5!%#4[*'$'!Y:!8;&#46!K&11;$\5!49!1;$!V4*61!@4AA*11$$!&6'!*694#A&1*46!46!1;$!%#$[&+$60$!

49![&#*425!7$641:%$5!*6!@&6&'&.Se!\$!'$[$+4%$'!&6!&[$#&7$!1#$&1A$61!+$671;!94#!25$!*6!42#!

A4'$+5C!!H;$!*694#A&1*46!*6'*0&1$'!1;&1!1;$![&51!A&f4#*1:!49!0+&*A&615!\*++!#$Z2*#$!.,!\$$d5!49!

1#$&1A$61e!Y21!1;$#$!&#$!54A$!\;4!\*++!46+:!#$Z2*#$!(!\$$d5!&6'!41;$#5!2%!14!,S!\$$d5C!!E6!

&[$#&7$e!1#$&1A$61!+$671;!*5!$c%$01$'!14!Y$!&Y421!.MC,!\$$d5C!!B4#!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&552A%1*46e!

\$!&552A$!&!1#$&1A$61!+$671;!49!.MC,!\$$d5!]MCM!A461;5`!&6'!94#!1;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!

'$[*&1*465e!\$!&552A$!&6!&[$#&7$!1#$&1A$61!+$671;!49!.SC/!\$$d5!]MC=!A461;5`C!!H;$!Y$6$9*1!

&A4261!*5!j.e---!].<<<!'4++&#5`!%&:&Y+$!94#!$&0;!A461;C!!!

,=SC W$!;&[$!1;$#$94#$!&552A$'!94#!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!1;&1!.--g!49!0+&*A&615!\*++!#$0$*[$!&!'#27!

1;$#&%:!Y$6$9*1!49!jMeM--!].<<<!'4++&#5`!04*60*'$61!\*1;!#$0$*[*67!&!1#$&1A$61!]5$$!H&Y+$!U<!94#!

1;$!1#$&1A$61!&552A%1*465`C!!B4#!1;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465e!\$!;&[$!&552A$'!&6!

&[$#&7$!Y$6$9*1!49!jMe=--C!

,=/C B4#!,-.-e!\$!&552A$'!1;&1!=-g!49!+$[$+!M!0+&*A&615e!U-g!49!+$[$+!S!0+&*A&615!&6'!(-g!49!+$[$+!/!

0+&*A&615!\42+'!#$0$*[$!46$!%&:A$61!%$#!+$[$+!49!j..e---!]*6!.<<<!'4++&#5`C!!

]1+1,?%-3!9%-$&@-1&!^!2-3+R$&+/1!

,==C W*1;!1;$!6$\!1#$&1A$615!#$0$61+:!&[&*+&Y+$!&6'!$c%$01&1*465!94#!&''*1*46&+!1#$&1A$615!14!Y$04A$!

&[&*+&Y+$e!\$!$c%$01!1;$!04515!94#!26*652#$'!1#$&1A$61!&6'!A$'*0&1*46!\*++!0;&67$!5*76*9*0&61+:!

9#4A!\;&1!;&5!Y$$6!$c%$#*$60$'!*6!1;$!%&51C!!W$!1;$#$94#$!#$Z2$51$'!1;$!&'A*6*51#&14#!14!

5$%&#&1$!&++!%&51!0+&*A5!94#!26*652#$'!1#$&1A$61!&6'!A$'*0&1*46!Y$1\$$6!04515!94#!1#$&1A$61!

&*A$'!&1!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25!&6'!04515!94#!&++!41;$#!1:%$5!49!1#$&1A$61C!

,=UC W$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!1#$&1A$61!04515!94#!%2#%45$5!41;$#!1;&6!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25!\*++!0461*62$!94#!

1;$!9212#$!&A467!1;45$!\;4!;&[$!641!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25!*6!5*A*+&#!%#4%4#1*465!14!1;$!%&51C!!W$!;&[$!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

.M!! R#C!W467!]#$1&*6$'!Y:!1;$!R$%&#1A$61!49!V251*0$`!&6'!R#C!N&*6!]#$1&*6$'!Y:!1;$!V4*61!@4AA*11$$`C!

.S!! ^R*51#*Y21*46!49!?$%&1*1*5!@!J*#25!P$641:%$5!*6!@&6&'&a!3$52+15!94#A!1;$!T@R@!R$61*6$+!?$&+1;!D6*1!82#[$*++&60$!8:51$A_b!3O!@;&2';&#:e!";Re!K!H$%%$#!KRe!8!F*5&&'&6:e!"&2+!3!P2++:!KRb!@&6&'*&6!V42#6&+!49!*69$01*425!R*5$&5$5e!J4+!.-e!Q4!.!V&62&#:lB$Y#2&#:!.<<<C!

Page 98: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! U,!

&552A$'!1;&1!1#$&1A$61!04515!94#!%2#%45$5!49!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25!\*++!Y$!5*76*9*0&61+:!'*99$#$61!9#4A!

1;$!%&51!&6'!\$!'$[$+4%$'!&6!&552A%1*46!Y&5$'!46!$c%$01$'!04515!94#!1;$!6$\!'#275C!

,=(C H&Y+$!,=(!5;4\5!1;$!%$#0$61&7$!49!d64\6!0+&*A&615!\;4!;&[$!Y$$6!#$*AY2#5$'!&1!&6:!1*A$!*6!1;$!

%&51!6*6$!:$&#5!94#!26*652#$'!1#$&1A$61!\;$#$!1;$!04515!\$#$!641!'*#$01+:!*602##$'!94#!%2#%45$5!

49!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25C!!H;$!&[$#&7$!0+&*A!4[$#!1;$!+&51!M!&6'!=!:$&#5!*60+2'$5!&6!&'f251A$61!94#!

*69+&1*46!14!,-.S!'4++&#5C!

!"#$%&B(V&2&34+54&*$"09"4.:&50.,&7404:C-%6&!-%".9%4.&*$"09:&4+.&F%$".%6&.+&*$%"-04N&.,%&?0-C:&&

)) :0/#12"1,$) </,+&5;'.'/4)

_,/0)-,04,#()*./'+'#Q)

@?,0/Q,)*./'+)

-,04,#()*./'+'#Q)

@?,0/Q,)*./'+)

2005 5.1% $ 1,014 6.2% $ 2,330

2006 4.7% 1,559 8.2% 2,189

2007 4.4% 1,290 7.3% 2,357

2008 4.8% 1,213 6.9% 2,101

2009 4.5% 1,197 7.2% 2,443

2010 4.0% 1,142 6.9% 2,011

2011 4.0% 1,067 7.0% 3,329

2012 3.6% 1,448 6.6% 3,728

2013 4.3% 1,162 8.1% 2,562

Average - Last 3 Years 4.0% $ 1,249 7.2% $ 3,253

Average - Last 6 Years 4.2% $ 1,250 7.1% $ 2,790

,=<C W$!&#$!0460$#6$'!1;&1!0+&*A&615!\;4!*602#!$c%$65$5!641!#$+&1$'!14!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25!A&:!;&[$!&!

7#$&1$#!+*d$+*;44'!49!Y$*67!&A467!1;$!0+&*A&615!\;4!'4!641!#$0$*[$!9212#$!1#$&1A$61!4#!'4!641!

0+$&#!1;$![*#25C!!]I1!*5!&+54!%455*Y+$!1;&1!1;$!4%%45*1$!A&:!Y$!1;$!0&5$`C!!H4!&++4\!94#!1;*5!%455*Y*+*1:e!

\$!;&[$!&++4\$'!94#!&6!*60#$&5$!*6!1;$!*60*'$60$!#&1$!&6'!&[$#&7$!0+&*A!&A4261C!

,U-C B4#!42#!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&552A%1*465e!\$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!$&0;!:$&#!SC/g!49!1#&65925$'!0+&*A&615!

\*++!*602#!&6!$c%$65$!46!&[$#&7$!49!j.e/--!&6'!1;&1!UC/g!49!;&$A4%;*+*&05!\*++!*602#!&6!$c%$65$!

49!jMe/--!*6!,-.S!'4++&#5C!!H;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!&552A%1*46!*5!1;$!5&A$C!

,U.C H;$!&Y4[$!26*652#$'!1#$&1A$61!0451!&552A%1*465!&#$!&%%+*$'!*6!$&0;!9212#$!:$&#!14!&++!&+*[$!

0+&*A&615!\;4!;&[$!641!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25C!

,U,C I6!&''*1*46e!\$!6$$'!14!#$0476*5$!1;&1!1;$#$!\*++!Y$!9212#$!0+&*A5!94#!'#27!1#$&1A$615!94#!%2#%45$5!

49!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25C!!H4!'&1$e!\$!;&[$!46+:!+*A*1$'!'&1&!46!1;$!0451!49!1;$!6$\!'#27!1#$&1A$615C!!

E6!&[$#&7$e!1#*%+$!1;$#&%:!04515!&#$!141&++*67!&Y421!j//e---!%$#!.,>\$$d!1#$&1A$61e!&6'!

84945Y2[*#!'42Y+$15!]1#&'$!6&A$!?&#[46*`!&#$!0451*67!&Y421!jU(e---!%$#!1#$&1A$61C!!H;$#$!*5!64!

0451!'&1&!94#!MR!#$7*A$6!64#!94#!84945Y2[*#!'42Y+$15!\*1;!R&0+&15&[*#C!!W$!&61*0*%&1$!1;&1!1;$#$!

A&:!Y$!41;$#!'#275!26'$#!'$[$+4%A$61!1;&1!042+'!Y$!*61#4'20$'!*6!1;$!9212#$C!!!

Page 99: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! UM!

,UMC W$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!1;$!0451!%$#!1#$&1A$61!49!1;$!'#275!14!Y$!*61#4'20$'!*6!1;$!9212#$!\*++!6$$'!

14!Y$!%#*0$'!5*A*+&#+:!14!?&#[46*!*6!4#'$#!14!0&%12#$!A&#d$1!5;&#$C!

,USC B4#!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&552A%1*46e!\$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!1#$&1A$61!\*++!Y$!7*[$6!&5!5$1!421!*6!1;$!

KKWP!3$%4#1!&6'!\*++!1&d$!&6!&[$#&7$!1#$&1A$61!49!.MC,!\$$d5!]MCM!A461;5`C!!B4#!1;$!%#4[*5*46!

94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465e!\$!&552A$!1;&1!1;$!6$\!'#275!\*++!Y$04A$!%#$'4A*6&61!&6'!1#$&1A$61!

\*1;!H#*%+$!H;$#&%:!\*++!+&#7$+:!'*5&%%$&#C!!W$!&+54!&552A$!1;&1!94#!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!

'$[*&1*465!1;$!&[$#&7$!1#$&1A$61!+$671;!\*++!Y$!.SC/!\$$d5!]MC=!A461;5`!&6'!1;&1!1;$!0451!49!1;$!

'#275!\*++!*60#$&5$!Y:!&Y421!./g!9#4A!1;$!%#$5$61!04515C!!H;*5!#$52+15!*6!1;$!94++4\*67!04515!%$#!

1#$&1A$61C!

!"#$%&BSW&2&*+:.&+D&M-CN:&L%-&!-%".9%4.&

:0,/(+,#() =,1()>1('+/(,)

-0&?'1'&#)2&0)

@$?,01,)3,?'/('&#1))

"FP>IBQl3NJ>Y&5$'!H#*%+$!H;$#&%:! j!=-e---! j!..-e---!

84945Y2[*#>Y&5$'!R42Y+$1! (/e---! ..-e---!

MR!3$7*A$6!%+25!3NJ! (/e---! ..-e---!

,U/C B4#!7#$&1$#!0$#1&*61:e!1;$!'#27!04515!94#!%2#%45$5!49!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25!&#$!*602##$'!46+:!460$!%$#!

0+&*A&61!*6!046f2601*46!\*1;!1;$!1#$&1A$61!#&1$5!5$1!421!*6!H&Y+$!U<C!

,U=C H;$!0451!49!'#27!1#$&1A$61!A&:!Y$!04[$#$'!Y:!%#4[*60*&+!;$&+1;!*652#&60$!%#47#&A5!4#!Y:!%#*[&1$!

*652#&60$!%+&65e!520;!&5!&#$!491$6!&[&*+&Y+$!1;#427;!$A%+4:A$61C!!H;$!B26'!#$*AY2#5$5!1;$!04515!

6$1!49!&6:!&A42615!%&:&Y+$!Y:!&!%#4[*60$!4#!;$&+1;!*652#&60$C!

,UUC "#4[*60*&+!'#27!%#47#&A5!\4#d!46!1;$!Y&5*5!49!&!94#A2+&#:e!4#!&!+*51!49!'#275!1;&1!&#$!$+*7*Y+$!94#!

#$*AY2#5$A$61C!!I1!0&6!1&d$!A&6:!A461;5!94++4\*67!&%%#4[&+!49!&!'#27!Y:!?$&+1;!@&6&'&!94#!1;$!

%#4[*60$5!14!#$[*$\!*1!&6'!14!'$1$#A*6$!\;$1;$#!14!&''!*1!14!1;$*#!94#A2+&#:C!!F[$6!1;427;!&!'#27!

A&:!Y$!46!1;$!94#A2+&#:e!1;$#$!A&:!Y$!#$51#*01*465!14!1;$!5*12&1*465!*6!\;*0;!*1!\*++!Y$!04[$#$'!Y:!

1;$!'#27!%#47#&AC!

,U(C )5!49!1;$!'&1$!49!1;$!#$%4#1e!646$!49!1;$!'#275!25$'!*6!84945Y2[*#!Y&5$'!'42Y+$15!4#!MR!#$7*A$6!

;&5!Y$$6!&%%#4[$'!Y:!&6:!%#4[*60$C!!W$!1;$#$94#$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!94#!1;$!1*A$>%$#*4'!'2#*67!

\;*0;!1;$!0+&*A&615!&#$!&552A$'!14!#$0$*[$!1#$&1A$61e!1;$#$!\*++!Y$!64!%#4[*60*&+!#$*AY2#5$A$61!

&[&*+&Y+$!94#!&6:!49!1;$!'#275!25$'C!

,U<C "#*[&1$!*652#&60$!04[$#&7$!*5!A451!+*d$+:!14!Y$!&[&*+&Y+$!94#!0+&*A&615!\;4!&#$!$A%+4:$'C!!)Y421!

U/g!49!1;$!\4#d*67>&7$!%4%2+&1*46!*5!$A%+4:$'C!!H;$5$!%+&65!7$6$#&++:!%#4[*'$!#$*AY2#5$A$61!49!

Y$1\$$6!(-g!&6'!.--g!49!1;$!0451!49!'#275C!!8*60$!641!&++!$A%+4:$'!%$#5465!&#$!A$AY$#5!49!&!

'#27!%+&6!&6'!641!&++!'#27!%+&65!\*++!&214A&1*0&++:!04[$#!1;$5$!?@J!'#275e!\$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!

46!&[$#&7$!(-g!49!1;$!0451!49!1;$!'#275!\*++!Y$!#$*AY2#5$'!94#!1\4>1;*#'5!49!1;$!U/g!49!0+&*A&615!

&552A$'!14!Y$!\4#d*67C!!H;&1!7*[$5!&6!&[$#&7$!#$*AY2#5$A$61!49!S-g!%$#!0+&*A&61!26'$#!&7$!=/!

&6'!64!#$*AY2#5$A$61!94#!0+&*A&615!4[$#!&7$!=/C!!

Page 100: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! US!

,(-C B4++4\*67!1;$!9*6&+*5&1*46!49!42#![&+2&1*46!#$52+15!\$!Y$0&A$!&\&#$!1;&1!)YY[*$!#$0$*[$'!?$&+1;!

@&6&'&!&%%#4[&+!46!,M!R$0$AY$#!,-.S!94#!?4+d*#&!"&de!&!MR>#$7*A*6!'#27C!!W$!26'$#51&6'!1;$!

%#*0$!49!1;$!'#27!*5!&Y421!j/=e---!94#!&!.,>\$$d!1#$&1A$61!%+25!1;$!0451!49!#*Y&[*#*6e!*9!25$'C!!]W$!

;&[$!641!Y$$6!&Y+$!14!'$1$#A*6$!\;$1;$#!1;&1!*5!&!#$1&*+!4#!\;4+$5&+$!%#*0$C`!!B4#!1;$![&+2&1*46e!\$!

&552A$'!1;&1!1;$!%#*0$!94#!1#$&1A$61!\42+'!Y$!5*A*+&#!14!?&#[46*e!&1!&Y421!j(/e---!Y&5$'!46!&6!

&[$#&7$!49!.MC,>\$$d5!94#!1#$&1A$61C!!!

,(.C H;$!%#*0$!49!?4+d*#&!"&d!A&:!+$&'!14!&!#$'201*46!*6!1;$!%#*0$!49!?&#[46*!&6'!%455*Y+:!41;$#!?@J!

'#275C!

,(,C I1!A&:!Y$!1;&1!1;$!0451!49!'#275!\*++!Y$!+$55!1;&6!&552A$'!*6!1;$![&+2&1*46!&6'!1;&1!\*++!#$52+1!*6!

$c%$#*$60$!7&*65C!!W$!;&[$!641!#$9+$01$'!1;*5!%455*Y*+*1:!*6!1;*5!#$%4#1C!!I9!1;$!%#*0$5!49!1;$!'#275!

&#$!+4\$#!1;&6!&552A$'e!1;$!7&*65!\*++!Y$!#$9+$01$'!*6!1;$!6$c1!5299*0*$60:!#$[*$\C!

,(MC I6!,-.-e!\$!&552A$'!&!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&552A%1*46!49!Sg!49!0+&*A&615!&1!'*5$&5$!+$[$+5!M!14!=!\42+'!

*602#!&6!$c%$65$!$&0;!:$&#!46!&[$#&7$!49!jMe---!94#!1#&65925$'!0+&*A&615!&6'!1;&1!=C/g!49!

;&$A4%;*+*&05!&1!+$[$+5!M!14!=!\42+'!*602#!&6!$c%$65$!49!jSe---!*6!,-..!'4++&#5C!!E[$#!&!9*[$>:$&#!

%$#*4'e!1;&1!\42+'!#$52+1!*6!&Y421!.<g!49!0+&*A&615!;&[*67!*602##$'!&6!$c%$65$e!&6'!4[$#!.-!

:$&#5e!*1!\42+'!Y$!&Y421!MSgC!

T?&D/AD8/RU-&!VS8-1,-,!

,(SC W*1;!1;$!+&#7$!62AY$#!49!0+&*A&615!$c%$01$'!14!0+$&#!1;$![*#25!'2#*67!1;$!04A*67!9*[$!:$&#5!9#4A!

1;$!6$\!1#$&1A$61!#$7*A$65!&[&*+&Y+$e!\$!5$%&#&1$'!1;$!421>49>%40d$1!$c%$65$5!14!&6!&552A%1*46!

1;&1!&%%+*$5!14!1;45$!\;4!;&[$!641!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25!&6'!1;45$!\;4!;&[$!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25C!

,(/C ?&[*67!#$[*$\$'!1;$!&'A*6*51#&14#i5!%&:A$61!%#41404+!94#!1;*5!$c%$65$e!*1!5$$A5!1;&1![$#:!9$\!

0+&*A&615!&1!+$[$+!.!\42+'!Y$!+*d$+:!14!*602#!A4#$!1;&6!46$!421>49>%40d$1!$c%$65$e!&5!1;$:!;&[$!

0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25C!!)5!\$++e!0+&*A&615!\;4!+*[$!*6!+&#7$!A$1#4%4+*1&6!&#$&5!&6'!&#$!*6!0+45$!

%#4c*A*1:!14!;$&+1;!9&0*+*1*$5!5;42+'!;&[$!64!4#![$#:!+*11+$!$c%$65$5C!!?4\$[$#e!94#!5*A%+*0*1:!*6!

*A%+$A$61*67!1;*5!Y$6$9*1!*6!1;$![&+2&1*46!A4'$+5e!\$!'$0*'$'!14!A&d$!&6!&552A%1*46!&Y421!1;$!

&[$#&7$!*60*'$60$!&6'!&[$#&7$!&A4261!49!0+&*A5!$&0;!:$&#!&0#455!&++!0+&*A&615C!

,(=C H;$!94++4\*67!1&Y+$5!5;4\!1;$!%&51!*60*'$60$!&6'!&A42615!49!421>49>%40d$1!$c%$65$5!94#!1;$!

d64\6!0+&*A&615C!!)++!&A42615!;&[$!Y$$6!&'f251$'!14!1;$!$Z2*[&+$61!,-.S!'4++&#5C!!F&0;!

#$*AY2#5$A$61!*5!1#$&1$'!&5!&!5$%&#&1$!0+&*AC!!

& &

Page 101: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! U/!

!"#$%&BV(&2&XP%-"N%&X9+C4.&+D&bC.)+D)U+=8%.&;<L%4:%:&#A&c%"-&&

)) :0/#12"1,$) </,+&5;'.'/4)

_,/0)&2)*./'+)

-,04,#()7'(;)/)*./'+) @?,0/Q,)*./'+)

-,04,#()7'(;)/)*./'+) @?,0/Q,)*./'+)

2001 22.7% 1,557 24% 1,682

2002 9.7% 1,841 12% 2,231

2003 12.0% 1,698 13% 3,648

2004 9.4% 1,726 12% 2,094

2005 8.6% 1,473 13% 2,165

2006 7.4% 1,863 13% 2,826

2007 7.9% 1,859 11% 3,456

2008 6.0% 1,855 10% 1,956

2009 5.7% 1,523 11% 2,192

2010 5.2% 1,828 10% 2,451

2011 5.1% 1,546 9% 2,542

2012 4.9% 1,501 11% 1,666

2013 5.0% 1,929 11% 1,932

Total* 901 $1,484 374 $2,256

<'*%$'!"!->'/?5.$&'"A'4>-)5-/!+')+'/"!'!%$'+?5'"A'!%$'/?5.$&'A&"5'$-4%'2$-&6'+)/4$'+"5$'4>-)5-/!+'%-1'5?>!),>$'"?!Q"AQ,"4M$!'$P,$/+$+8''

!

,(UC W;*+$!1;$!%$#0$61&7$5!;&[$!'$0#$&5$'!7#&'2&++:!4[$#!1;$!:$&#5!14!&Y421!/C.g!94#!1#&65925$'e!..g!

94#!;&$A4%;*+*&0!&6'!&!\$*7;1$'!&[$#&7$!49!=CMge!\$!'$0*'$'!14!A&d$!&6!&++4\&60$!94#!&!%455*Y+$!

*60#$&5$!*6!1;$!9212#$C!!)5!A&6:!0+&*A&615!0+$&#!1;$![*#25e!\$!&#$!0460$#6$'!1;&1!1;45$!\;4!#$A&*6!

\*1;!?@J!A&:!Y$!A4#$!+*d$+:!14!*602#!4674*67!421!49!%40d$1!$c%$65$5C!!!

,((C B4#!42#!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&6'!\*1;!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!&552A%1*465e!\$!&552A$'!1;&1!

(g!49!&++!0+&*A&615!&1!+$[$+5!.!14!=!\;4!;&[$!641!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25!\*++!*602#!&6!421>49>%40d$1!

$c%$65$C!!H;$!&[$#&7$!$c%$65$!*5!&552A$'!14!Y$!j.e(--!]j.eU--!94#!,-.-`!94#!1#&65925$'!&6'!

j,e=--!]j,e/--!94#!,-.-`!94#!;&$A4%;*+*&0!0+&*A&615e!Y41;!*6!,-.S!'4++&#5C!

,(<C B4#!,-.Me!\$!;&[$!&''$'!1\4!6$\!&552A%1*465!&Y421!421>49>%40d$1!$c%$65$5C!!!

,<-C W$!&552A$!1;&1!.--g!49!0+&*A&615!\;4!0+$&#!1;$![*#25!\*++!*602#!&6!421>49>%40d$1!$c%$65$!

04*60*'$61!\*1;!1;$*#!1#$&1A$61!94#!j.e,--!94#!1#&65925$'!&6'!j/e---!94#!;&$A4%;*+*&05C!

,<.C E60$!&!0+&*A&61!;&5!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25e!*1!*5!+*d$+:!1;&1!1;$#$!\*++!Y$!54A$!94++4\!2%!A46*14#*67!&6'!

1;&1!54A$!&''*1*46&+!421>49>%40d$1!$c%$65$5!&#$!+*d$+:!14!Y$!*602##$'C!!W$!&6&+:5$'!1;$!421>49>

Page 102: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! U=!

%40d$1!$c%$65$5!9#4A!&++!0+&*A&615!\;4!*6'*0&1$'!1;&1!1;$:!;&[$!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25!%#*4#!14!,-.MC!!

W;*+$!1;$#$!\$#$!54A$!0+&*A&615!\*1;!$c%$65$5!A&6:!:$&#5!&91$#!1;$:!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25e!A451!421>

49>%40d$1!0+&*A5!0$&5$'!\*1;*6!&!9$\!:$&#5!49!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25C!

!"#$%&BT'&2&bC.)bD)U+=8%.&;<L%4:%:&E+$$+504N&/C==%::DC$&!-%".9%4.&

):0/#12"1,$) </,+&5;'.'/4)

Q2AY$#!49!0+&*A&615!d64\6!14!;&[$!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25! ,.(! //!

Q2AY$#!49!E21>49>"40d$1!0+&*A5!94++4\*67!5200$5592+!1#$&1A$61!

M-=! .U-!

)[$#&7$!62AY$#!49!94++4\>2%!0+&*A5!%$#!%$#546!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25!

.CS! MC.!

)[$#&7$!&A4261!49!&++!94++4\>2%!$c%$65$5!%$#!0+&*A&61! j!.e..M!! j!Se<=<!!

,<,C W$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!460$!&!0+&*A&61!0+$&#5!1;$![*#25e!1;$#$!\*++!Y$!54A$!421>49>%40d$1!$c%$65$5!

94#!94++4\>2%!&%%4*61A$615C!!F&0;!5200$5592++:!1#$&1$'!0+&*A&61!*5!&552A$'!14!;&[$!&!141&+!421>49>

%40d$1!$c%$65$!49!j.e,--!94#!1#&65925$'!&6'!j/e---!94#!;&$A4%;*+*&05C!!B4#!1;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!

&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465e!\$!&552A$!1;$!141&+!0+&*A!\*++!Y$!j,eS--!94#!1#&65925$'!&6'!j.-e---!94#!

;&$A4%;*+*&05C!!W;*+$!1;$5$!0+&*A5!&#$!+*d$+:!*602##$'!4[$#!&!,!:$&#!4#!+467$#!%$#*4'!94++4\*67!

1#$&1A$61e!94#!5*A%+*0*1:!\$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;$!&A4261!*5!*602##$'!*AA$'*&1$+:!94++4\*67!

5200$5592+!1#$&1A$61C!

7-&%/$R&+I-![-1-A+&,!A/%!]1U1/W1!"4$+@$1&,!?8/1!J88%/I$4!

,<MC W;$6!&6!26d64\6!0+&*A&61!*5!&%%#4[$'e!1;$:!A&:!;&[$!%#$[*425+:!*602##$'!$c%$65$5!1;&1!&#$!

$+*7*Y+$!94#!#$*AY2#5$A$61C!!W$!;&[$!'*50255$'!1;$!*552$!49!#$1#4&01*[$!Y$6$9*15!94#!T455!49!

8$#[*0$5!&6'!T455!49!I604A$!&Y4[$C!!W$!'*50255!#$1#4&01*[$!Y$6$9*15!%&:&Y+$!14!'$%$6'&615!Y$+4\C!

,<SC H;$!41;$#!Y$6$9*15!1;&1!A&:!%#4'20$!&!#$1#4&01*[$!%&:A$61!2%46!0+&*A!&%%#4[&+!&#$!

&C E21>49>%40d$1!$c%$65$5!

YC D6*652#$'!1#$&1A$61!

0C @4515!49!0&#$!

,</C N$0&25$!1;$!'&1&!1;&1!\&5!&6&+:5$'!94#!5$11*67!1;$!&552A%1*465!*60+2'$'!&6:!#$1#4&01*[$!0+&*A!

&A4261!94#!1;$!0+&*A&615e!*1!*5!42#!4%*6*46!1;&1!1;$!&552A$'!0+&*A!&A42615!25$'!&+#$&':!#$9+$01!&6!

&A4261!94#!&6:!#$1#4&01*[$!0+&*A5C!!W$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!1;$#$!*5!64!6$$'!14!A&d$!&6:!&''*1*46&+!

&552A%1*465!&Y421!#$1#4&01*[$!0+&*A5C!

P-R/13$%+4L!O1A-R&-3!.-%,/1,!!

,<=C W$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!&++!5$046'&#*+:!*69$01$'!0+&*A&615!&#$!$*1;$#!d64\6!0+&*A&615!4#!&#$!

*60+2'$'!*6!1;$!26d64\6!04;4#1C!

Page 103: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! UU!

M'<E<<<!\?44!P-&&4-@-1&!A/%!B$-@/8#+4+$R,!W+&#!B"C!$13!BOC!

,<UC H;$#$!*5!&!%#4[*5*46!94#!&!;&$A4%;*+*&0!\;4!*5!Y41;!?@J!&6'!?IJ!%#*A&#*+:!*69$01$'!14!0+&*A!&!

+2A%!52A!49!j/-e---!*6!92++!5&1*59&01*46!49!&++!0+&*A5C!!!

,<(C D6'$#!1;$!%+&6e!&!%$#546!&1!+$[$+!.!*5!$61*1+$'!14!&!j.-e---!%&:A$61C!!H;$!KKWP!3$%4#1!*6'*0&1$5!

1;&1!*1!*5!26+*d$+:!1;&1!&!+$[$+!.!%$#546!\42+'!&'[&60$!*6!1;$!'*5$&5$e!&6'!1;$!A$'*0&+!A4'$+!

*764#$5!1;&1!#$A41$!%455*Y*+*1:C!!B4#!0465*51$60:e!*1!A&d$5!5$65$!14!25!1;&1!&6:!04>*69$01$'!

;&$A4%;*+*&0!&1!+$[$+!.!\42+'!A451!+*d$+:!$+$01!1;*5!j/-e---!4%1*46!#&1;$#!1;&6!1;$!j.-e---!

41;$#\*5$!&[&*+&Y+$C!

,<<C B4#!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&6'!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465e!\$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!1;$!d64\6!04>

*69$01$'!;&$A4%;*+*&05!\;4!;&[$!A&'$!&6!$+$01*46!\$#$!%&*'!Y&5$'!46!1;$!$+$01*46!A&'$C!!B4#!&++!

26d64\6!04>*69$01$'!;&$A4%;*+*&05e!\$!&552A$'!.--g!&1!+$[$+!.!\42+'!$+$01!1;*5!4%1*46C!

B"C!%-4$&-3!3-$&#!:-A/%-!;!_$1?$%L!;FFF!

M--C H;$#$!&#$!1\4!4%1*465!&[&*+&Y+$!14!'$0$&5$'!1#&65925$'!0+&*A&615!X!&!5*67+$!+2A%!52A!49!j.,-e---!

%+25!26*652#$'!926$#&+!$c%$65$5!4#!&!j/-e---!+2A%!52A!%+25!26*652#$'!926$#&+!$c%$65$5!%+25!

9&A*+:!A$AY$#!Y$6$9*15!%+25!'$%$6'&61i5!&662&+!4674*67!Y$6$9*15C!!!

M-.C I6!&''*1*46!14!1;$!4%1*465!&[&*+&Y+$!14!1#&65925$'!0+&*A&615!\;4!'*$!%#*4#!14!.<<<e!;&$A4%;*+*&05!

\;4!&#$!04>*69$01$'!\*1;!?IJ!A&:!$+$01!&!jU,e---!+2A%!52A!&A4261!\*1;421!52YA*11*67!$[*'$60$!

49!*69$01*46!1;#427;!1;$!Y+44'!52%%+:!*6!1;$!.<(=!14!.<<-!%$#*4'C!!W$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!1;$#$!

\*++!Y$!64!92#1;$#!$+$01*46!49!1;*5!Y$6$9*1!&A467!1;$!26d64\6!;&$A4%;*+*&0!0+&*A&615!]5&A$!&5!

,-.-`C!

M-,C B4#!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&6'!\*1;!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465e!\$!&552A$'!1;&1!&++!%&:A$615!

%#$5$61+:!Y$*67!A&'$!14!'$%$6'$615!\*++!0461*62$!&1!1;$!5&A$!+$[$+!&5!%#$5$61e!Y21!*6'$c$'!$&0;!

:$&#C!!H;$!$6'!'&1$!94#!1;$5$!%&:A$615!*5!5%$0*9*$'!*6!1;$!'&1&C!!

M-MC B4#!1;$!26d64\6!0+&*A&615e!\$!&552A$'!1;&1!S(g!\42+'!$+$01!14!#$0$*[$!1;$!j.,-e---!%&:A$61!

4%1*46!&6'!1;&1!/,g!\42+'!$+$01!1;$!j/-e---p!4%1*46!]&+467!\*1;!0+&*A5!94#!'$%$6'&615!&6'!

9&A*+:!A$AY$#5`C!!H;*5!*5!1;$!5&A$!&5!94#!,-.-C!!

M-SC )A467!1;$!d64\6!1#&65925$'!0+&*A&615e!1;$#$!&#$!/!\;4!;&[$!$+$01$'!1;$!j/-e---p!4%1*46!Y21!94#!

\;4A!141&+!Y$6$9*15!%&*'!14!'&1$!&#$!+$55!1;&6!1;$!j.,-e---!1;&1!\42+'!;&[$!Y$$6!%&*'!;&'!1;$!

0+&*A&615!5$+$01$'!1;$!41;$#!4%1*46C!!E6$!49!1;45$!0+&*A&615!#$0$*[$'!&!+455!49!5$#[*0$5!%&:A$61!*6!

$&#+:!,-.S!04[$#*67!%&51!:$&#5!49!4[$#!j,--e---C!!B4#!1\4!49!1;$!41;$#5e!*1!+44d5!+*d$!&!92#1;$#!

0+&*A!*5!+*d$+:!&6'!1\4!+44d!+*d$!1;$#$!\*++!Y$!64!A4#$!0+&*A5!]1;$!+&51!0+&*A!%&*'!\&5!*6!,--S!&6'!

,--U!#$5%$01*[$+:`C!!I9!&++!942#!49!1;$5$!0+&*A&615!\$#$!14!9*+$!&!'$%$6'&61!4#!9&A*+:!0+&*A!94#!1;$!

&A4261!6$$'$'!14!$c0$$'!j.,-e---!]%+25!*6'$c*67`e!1;$!141&+!\42+'!Y$!&Y421!j,=/e---!*6!,-.S!

'4++&#5C!!I60+2'*67!1;$!j,-/e---!#$0$61+:!%&*'!14!1;$!9*91;!0+&*A&61!7*[$5!&!141&+!49!jSU-e---C!!I1!*5!

%455*Y+$!1;&1!1;$!9212#$!0+&*A5!9#4A!1;$5$!9*[$!0+&*A&615!042+'!Y$!A4#$e!Y21!*1!&+54!%455*Y+$!1;&1!

Page 104: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! U(!

1;$:!042+'!Y$!+$55!4#!64!&''*1*46&+!0+&*A5C!!W$!;&[$!1;$#$94#$!&552A$'!1;&1!9212#$!0+&*A5!94#!1;$5$!

9*[$!%#$>.<<<!'$&1;5!\*++!141&+!j/--e---C!

M-/C E2#!&6&+:5*5!49!1;$!26*652#$'!926$#&+!0+&*A5!*6'*0&1$'!1;&1!46+:!&Y421!U/g!49!&++!$+*7*Y+$!0+&*A&615!

9*+$!&!0+&*A!94#!926$#&+!$c%$65$5!&6'!1;$!&[$#&7$!&A4261!%&*'!*5!jSe(--!]&++!%&51!%&:A$615!

&'f251$'!14!,-.S!'4++&#5`C!!W$!641$'!1;&1!1;$#$!*5!491$6!&!'$+&:!*6!9*+*67!&!926$#&+!0+&*A!&6'!1;&1!1;$!

%$#0$61&7$!49!0+&*A&615!94#!\;4A!&!0+&*A!;&5!Y$$6!9*+$'!;&5!Y$$6!*60#$&5*67!51$&'*+:!$&0;!:$&#C!!

W$!1;$#$94#$!&552A$'!1;&1!<-g!49!&++!9212#$!'$&1;5!49!0+&*A&615!9#4A!?@J!\42+'!*6[4+[$!&!0+&*A!

94#!26*652#$'!926$#&+!$c%$65$5!49!&6!&[$#&7$!jSe(--!$&0;C!!!

M-=C B4#!5*A%+*0*1:!*6!42#!A4'$+5e!\$!A4'*9*$'!1;&1!&552A%1*46!14!.--g!49!&++!9212#$!'$&1;5!\42+'!

0+&*A!94#!26*652#$'!926$#&+!$c%$65$5!49!jSeM--!$&0;C!!]B4#!,-.-e!\$!&552A$'!.--g!\42+'!0+&*A!&!

926$#&+!$c%$65$!49!j/e---!$&0;`C!

M-UC B4#!1;45$!\;4!$+$01!1;$!j/-e---!%+25!4%1*46e!\$!;&[$!&552A$'a!

&C 9&A*+:!Y$6$9*15!]94#!+455!49!72*'&60$e!0&#$!&6'!04A%&6*465;*%`!49!jU/e---!94#!1#&65925$'!&6'!

j(/e---!94#!;&$A4%;*+*&05!]j(-e---!94#!Y41;!7#42%5!94#!,-.-`C!

YC )++!$c*51*67!'$%$6'&61!0+&*A5!&#$!&552A$'!14!0461*62$C!

0C B4#!9212#$!&%%#4[$'!0+&*A&615!1;&1!&#$!26'$#!&7$!=/!&1!1;$!'&1$!49!'$&1;e!\$!&552A$!1;&1!,-g!

49!1#&65925$'!&6'!/-g!49!;&$A4%;*+*&05!\42+'!$+$01!&!T455!49!82%%4#1!&6'!1;$!#$51!&!T455!49!

8$#[*0$5!],-g!94#!Y41;!1#&65925$'!&6'!;&$A4%;*+*&05!94#!,-.-`C!!B4#!1;45$!4[$#!&7$!=/e!&++!&#$!

&552A$'!14!$+$01!&!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*1C!

'C T455!49!82%%4#1!Y$6$9*15!94#!9212#$!&%%#4[$'!0+&*A&615!\*++!&[$#&7$!jM-e---!%$#!&662A!94#!

1#&65925$'5!&6'!jMSe---!94#!;&$A4%;*+*&05!]jM-e---!&6'!jM,e---!#$5%$01*[$+:!94#!,-.-`e!

%&:&Y+$!14!&7$!=/e!\*1;!&!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!1;$#$&91$#C!!!

$C T455!49!8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*15!94#!9212#$!&%%#4[$'!0+&*A&615!&#$!%&:&Y+$!94#!1;$!+*9$!$c%$01&60:!49!

1;$!'$0$&5$'!0+&*A&61!$Z2&+!14!&6!&[$#&7$!49!j.=e---!%$#!&662A!]j./e---!94#!,-.-`C!

B"C!%-4$&-3!3-$&#!$A&-%!;D_$1D;FFF!!

M-(C W;$#$!'$&1;!4002#5!94#!#$&5465!41;$#!1;&6!?@Je!64!Y$6$9*15!&#$!%&:&Y+$!&5!&!#$52+1!49!1;$!'$&1;C!!

W;$#$!'$&1;!*5!'2$!14!?@Je!&6:!26*652#$'!926$#&+!$c%$65$5!&#$!%&:&Y+$!&+467!\*1;!+2A%!52A!

&A42615!%&:&Y+$!14!9&A*+:!A$AY$#5!%+25!4674*67!T455!49!82%%4#1!4#!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!%&:&Y+$!14!

'$%$6'&615C!

M-<C B4#!&++!d64\6!0+&*A&615!\;4!&#$!'$0$&5$'e!\$!&552A$'!1;&1!&6:!926$#&+!$c%$65$5!&6'!9&A*+:!

A$AY$#!0+&*A5!;&[$!Y$$6!%&*'!]4#!&#$!*60+2'$'!*6!1;$!42151&6'*67!%&:A$615`C!!)6:!T455!49!

82%%4#1!4#!5$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*15!02##$61+:!Y$*67!%&*'!\*++!0461*62$!&1!1;$!5&A$!&A4261e!*6'$c$'!94#!

1;$!9212#$e!&6'!1;$!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!%&:A$615!\*++!0$&5$!\;$6!1;$!'$0$&5$'!0+&*A&61!\42+'!;&[$!

#$&0;$'!&7$!(/C!

Page 105: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! U<!

M.-C B4#!&++!26d64\6!0+&*A&615!&6'!&++!d64\6!&+*[$!0+&*A&615!\;4!+&1$#!'*$!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@Je!\$!

&552A$'a!

&C .--g!\*++!#$0$*[$!26*652#$'!926$#&+!$c%$65$5!49!jSeM--!]j/e---!94#!,-.-`!*6!,-.S!'4++&#5C!

YC .--g!\*++!#$0$*[$!9&A*+:!Y$6$9*15!49!j/-e---!]j//e---!94#!,-.-`!94#!1#&65925$'!&6'!j=-e---!

]j//e---!94#!,-.-`!94#!;&$A4%;*+*&0!0+&*A&615C!

0C B4#!&!'$&1;!49!&!d64\6!0+&*A&61!1;&1!4002#5!%#*4#!14!&7$!=/!\;$#$!1;$!0+&*A&61!*5!*6!#$0$*%1!&5!

49!1;$![&+2&1*46!'&1$!49a!!

]*` &!T455!49!I604A$!Y$6$9*1e!1;$6!&!T455!49!82%%4#1!Y$6$9*1!Y$04A$5!%&:&Y+$!14!1;$!

0+&*A&61i5!'$%$6'&615!$Z2&+!14!U-g!49!1;$!T455!49!I604A$!Y$6$9*1!&A4261e!%+25!9212#$!

*6'$c*67b!

]**` &!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*1e!1;$6!&!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*1!Y$04A$5!%&:&Y+$!14!1;$!

0+&*A&61i5!'$%$6'&615!$Z2&+!14!j.=e---e!%+25!9212#$!*6'$c*67b!

'C B4#!&!'$&1;!49!&!d64\6!0+&*A&61!\;$#$!1;$!0+&*A&61!*5!641!*6!#$0$*%1!49!&!T455!49!I604A$!4#!&!

T455!49!8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*1!&5!49!1;$![&+2&1*46!'&1$a!!

]*` W;$#$!1;$!0+&*A&61!\&5!26'$#!&7$!=/!46!1;$!'&1$!49!'$&1;e!S/g!49!'$%$6'&615!\*++!

#$0$*[$!&!T455!49!82%%4#1!Y$6$9*1!49!jM.e---!94#!1#&65925$'!&6'!jMMe---!94#!

;&$A4%;*+*&05!%&:&Y+$!14!1;$!0+&*A&61i5!&7$!=/!&6'!046[$#1$'!14!&!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!

Y$6$9*1!&1!&7$!=/!%&:&Y+$!14!1;$!0+&*A&61i5!&7$!(/e!*6!,-.S!'4++&#5b!

]**` W;$#$!1;$!0+&*A&61!\&5!26'$#!&7$!=/!46!1;$!'&1$!49!'$&1;e!/g!49!'$%$6'&615!\*++!

#$0$*[$!&!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*1!49!j.=e---!%&:&Y+$!14!1;$!0+&*A&61i5!&7$!(/e!*6!,-.S!

'4++&#5b!

]***` W;$#$!1;$!0+&*A&61!\&5!4[$#!&7$!=/!46!1;$!'&1$!49!'$&1;e!S-g!49!'$%$6'&615!\*++!

#$0$*[$!&!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*1!49!j.=e---!%&:&Y+$!14!1;$!0+&*A&61i5!&7$!(/e!*6!,-.S!

'4++&#5b!

$C B4#!&!'$&1;!49!&6!26d64\6!0+&*A&61a!!

]*` W;$#$!1;$!0+&*A&61!\&5!26'$#!&7$!=/!46!1;$!'&1$!49!'$&1;e!//g!49!'$%$6'&615!\*++!

#$0$*[$!&!T455!49!82%%4#1!Y$6$9*1!49!jM.e---!94#!1#&65925$'!&6'!jMMe---!94#!

;&$A4%;*+*&05!%&:&Y+$!14!1;$!0+&*A&61i5!&7$!=/!&6'!046[$#1$'!14!&!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!

Y$6$9*1!&1!&7$!=/!%&:&Y+$!14!1;$!0+&*A&61i5!&7$!(/e!*6!,-.S!'4++&#5b!

]**` W;$#$!1;$!0+&*A&61!\&5!26'$#!&7$!=/!46!1;$!'&1$!49!'$&1;e!,-g!49!'$%$6'&615!\*++!

#$0$*[$!&!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*1!49!j.=e---!%&:&Y+$!14!1;$!0+&*A&61i5!&7$!(/e!*6!,-.S!

'4++&#5b!

Page 106: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! (-!

]***` W;$#$!1;$!0+&*A&61!\&5!4[$#!&7$!=/!46!1;$!'&1$!49!'$&1;e!=-g!49!'$%$6'&615!\*++!

#$0$*[$!&!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*1!49!j.=e---!%&:&Y+$!14!1;$!0+&*A&61i5!&7$!(/e!*6!,-.S!

'4++&#5b!

M..C H;$!%$#0$61&7$5!94#!'$&1;5!1;&1!#$52+1!*6!&!T455!49!82%%4#1!&6'!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*15!]41;$#!

1;&6!94#!1;$!d64\6!0+&*A&615!02##$61+:!*6!#$0$*%1!49!&!T455!49!I604A$!Y$6$9*15!&5!49!1;$![&+2&1*46!

'&1$`!\$#$!'$[$+4%$'!9#4A!51&1*51*05!&Y421!@&6&'*&65!1;&1!&#$!*6!1;$!+&Y42#!94#0$!]$*1;$#!

$A%+4:$'!4#!+44d*67!94#!\4#d`./!&6'!5%425&+!51&125.=C!!!

&C H;45$!\*1;!&!5%425$!&6'!*6!1;$!+&Y42#!94#0$!26'$#!&7$!=/!&#$!&552A$'!14!#$0$*[$!&!T455!49!

82%%4#1!Y$6$9*1C!!!

YC H;45$!\*1;!&!5%425$!&6'!641!*6!1;$!+&Y42#!94#0$!26'$#!&7$!=/!&5!\$++!&5!1;45$!4[$#!&7$!=/!\*1;!

&!5%425$!&#$!&552A$'!14!#$0$*[$!&!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*1C!!!

0C H;45$!\*1;421!&!5%425$!&#$!&552A$'!14!#$0$*[$!6$*1;$#!T455!49!82%%4#1!64#!T455!49!8$#[*0$5C!

T?&,&$13+10!.$L@-1&,!$&!H;!*-R-@:-%!G<;<!

M.,C )5!49!1;$![&+2&1*46!'&1$!1;$#$!&#$!&!62AY$#!49!Y$6$9*1!%&:A$615!42151&6'*67C!!N&5$'!46!

*694#A&1*46!%#4[*'$'!Y:!1;$!&'A*6*51#&14#!&6'!1;$!V4*61!@4AA*11$$!\$!;&[$!'$1$#A*6$'!1;&1!1;$!

42151&6'*67!%&:A$615!141&++$'a!

• E2151&6'*67!%&:A$615!94#!1#&65925$'! ! j!!=eM<-e---!

• E2151&6'*67!%&:A$615!94#!;&$A4%;*+*&05!! j!!/e/,.e---!

• H41&+!42151&6'*67!%&:A$615! ! ! j..e<..e---!

BOC!P-R/13$%+4L!O1A-R&-3!"4$+@$1&,!

M.MC )6!?@J!*69$01$'!%$#546!\;4!*5!&+54!&!5$046'&#*+:!*69$01$'!?IJ!%$#546!A&:!46+:!#$0$*[$!

04A%$65&1*46!9#4A!1;*5!"+&6!460$!1;$*#!0+&*A5!\42+'!41;$#\*5$!;&[$!$c0$$'$'!j,S-e---C!!H;$!

V4*61!@4AA*11$$!$c%$015!1;*5!7#42%!14!Y$!646>$c*51$61!4#![$#:!5A&++C!!W$!1;$#$94#$!;&[$!&552A$'!

1;&1!1;$#$!\*++!Y$!64!520;!0+&*A5C!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

./!! )%%#4c*A&1$+:!UMg!49!@&6&'*&65!26'$#!=/!]\*1;!A451!$A%;&5*5!%+&0$'!46!1;45$!&7$'!S/!14!=/`!&#$!*6!1;$!+&Y42#!94#0$!]81&1*51*05!@&6&'&!X!@)Q8IK!,(,>---,!94#!,-.M`!

.=!! )%%#4c*A&1$+:!U/g!49!@&6&'*&65!26'$#!&7$!=/!&6'!=-g!4[$#!&7$!=/!;&[$!&!5%425$C!!]81&1*51*05!@&6&'&!X!@)Q8IK!-/.>--S,!94#!,-.S!

!

Page 107: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! (.!

BOC!.%/0%$@!

M.SC H;*5!"+&6!%&:5!&!+2A%!52A!49!j,S-e---!14!@&6&'*&65!\;4!&#$!5$046'&#*+:!*69$01$'!\*1;!?IJ!Y:!

[*#12$!49!Y$*67!&!%&#16$#!4#!0;*+'!49!&!%#*A&#*+:!*69$01$'!?IJ!%$#546!\;4!*5!&6!&%%#4[$'!

Fc1#&4#'*6&#:!)55*51&60$!"#47#&A!#$0*%*$61C!!)!A&c*A2A!49!,S-!520;!Y$6$9*15!&#$!%&:&Y+$C!

M./C H;$!V4*61!@4AA*11$$!&'[*5$'!1;&1!1;$:!$c%$01!14!#$0$*[$!&!141&+!49!9*[$!&''*1*46&+!0+&*A5!94#!

j,S-e---!$&0;!26'$#!1;*5!%#4[*5*46e!46$!*6!,-.S!&6'!46$!*6!$&0;!1;*#'!:$&#!2%!14!,-,=C!!H;$!

%#$5$61![&+2$!49!1;$5$!9212#$!Y$6$9*15!*5!j</-e---!94#!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&552A%1*46!&6'!j<U-e---!

*60+2'*67!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465C!

\--,!$13!VS8-1,-,!

M.=C F0d+$#!\4#d$'!\*1;!1;$!V4*61!@4AA*11$$!14!5$1!1;$!&552A%1*465!&Y421!9212#$!9$$5!&6'!$c%$65$5C!!

W$!#$[*$\$'!1;$*#!\4#d!&6'!;&[$!&00$%1$'!*1!&5!1;$!&552A%1*46!94#!Y41;!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&6'!

%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465C!

M.UC H;$!'4++&#!&A42615!&#$!*6!,-.S!'4++&#5!&6'!&#$!52Yf$01!14!&662&+!*60#$&5$5!94#!*69+&1*46!9#4A!,-.S!

14!1;$!:$&#!49!%&:A$61C!!J&#*425!1&c$5!]P8He!?8He!%#4[*60*&+!5&+$5!1&c`!\$#$!&[$#&7$'!Y&5$'!46!1;$!

%#4[*60$5!\;$#$!1;$!$c%$65$5!&#$!$c%$01$'!14!Y$!*602##$'!&6'!25*67!02##$61!1&c!#&1$5C!!H;$!

&A42615!#$A&*6!&%%#4c*A&1$+:!1;$!5&A$!94#!$&0;!1;#$$!:$&#!0:0+$!1;#427;!14!,-,/!&91$#!\;*0;!

1;$:!'$0+*6$!*6!&%%#4c*A&1$!#$+&1*46!14!1;$!$c%$01$'!62AY$#!49!&+*[$!0+&*A&615C!

&C ;4!?-&)->a!jSM=e---!*6!,-.Se!j/S-e---!*6!,-./e!&6'!j.,/e---!*6!,-.=e!%+25!/g!P8HC!!)91$#!

,-.=e!1;$!141&+!*6!$&0;!1;#$$!:$&#!0:0+$!*5!j<,/e---C!

YC ;44"?/!)/#'$P,$&!'!$+!)5"/2'-/1'-++)+!-/4$a!j,-e---!%$#!:$&#!261*+!,-,-!&6'!j./e---!%$#!:$&#!

1;$#$&91$#e!%+25!.Mg!?8HC!!

0C ;15)/)+!&-!)"/a!jUS-e---!*6!,-.Se!'$0+*6*67!7#&'2&++:!14!j=--e---!94#!,-.U!&6'!1;$#$&91$#e!

%+25!.Mg!?8HC!!

'C ;&.)!&-!"&+R@$A$&$$+a!j,-e---!%$#!:$&#!261*+!,-.Ue!'$0+*6*67!j/e---!%$#!:$&#!261*+!*1!#$&0;$5!

j.-e---!&6'!j.-e---!%$#!:$&#!1;$#$&91$#e!%+25!..CS<g!&[$#&7$!1&c$5C!!

$C ;?1)!a!j<,e---!%$#!:$&#e!%+25!j,/e---!*6!,-.=!&6'!$[$#:!1;*#'!:$&#!94#!5%$0*&+!%#4f$015e!%+25!

.Mg!?8HC!!

9C 9-/-1)-/'S>""1'3$&0)4$+a!j.-e---!%$#!:$&#C!!Q4!1&c$5C!!

7C 9>-++'T$5.$&'9"55?/)4-!)"/+a!j/-e---!*6!$&0;!1;*#'!:$&#e!%+25!.Mg!?8HC!!

;C 7?/1'9"?/+$>a!j<-e---!%$#!:$&#!261*+!,-.U!&6'!'$0+*6*67!j<e---!%$#!:$&#!261*+!*1!#$&0;$5!

jS/e---e!&6'!jS/e---!%$#!:$&#!1;$#$&91$#e!%+25!..CS<g!&[$#&7$!1&c$5C!

*C UV5-QW?V.$4a!jMe---!%$#!:$&#C!!Q4!1&c$5C!!

Page 108: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! (,!

fC :/1$,$/1$/!'9"?/+$>a!j.-e---!%$#!:$&#e!%+25!.Mg!?8HC!!

dC :/0$+!5$/!'$P,$/+$+e!*60+2'*67!9$$5!94#!*6[$51A$61!04265$+e!02514':!49!&55$15e!&6'!41;$#!#$+&1$'!

*1$A5!&#$!641!*60+2'$'!*6!1;*5!5$01*46!&5!1;$:!;&[$!Y$$6!*A%+*0*1+:!#$0476*h$'!*6!1;$!

'$1$#A*6&1*46!49!1;$!6$1!*61$#$51!#&1$C!

+C X")/!'9"55)!!$$a!j/(-e---!94#!,-.Se!j=/-e---!94#!,-./!'$0+*6*67!Y:!j/-e---!%$#!:$&#!261*+!

,-,-!&6'!jS--e---!%$#!:$&#!1;$#$&91$#C!!I6!&''*1*46e!94#!9*6&60*&+!5299*0*$60:e!jMM-e---!*6!,-.Se!

j(--e---!*6!,-./e!j.--e---!*6!,-.=!&6'!*6!$&0;!1;#$$!:$&#!%$#*4'!1;$#$&91$#e!&!141&+!49!

j=--e---e!%+25!.-CM<g!&[$#&7$!1&c$5C!!

AC T$1)4->'T"1$>)/#a!j,,-e---!*6!,-.Se!&6'!$[$#:!1;*#'!:$&#!1;$#$&91$#C!!Q4!1&c$5!!

6C T"/)!"&a!j=-e---!%$#!:$&#!261*+!,-.Ue!'$0+*6*67!Y:!j=e---!%$#!:$&#!261*+!*1!#$&0;$5!jM-e---!&6'!

jM-e---!%$#!:$&#!1;$#$&91$#e!%+25!.Mg!?8HC!!

4C 3"A!(-&$'E$0$>",5$/!a!j.-e---!%$#!:$&#e!%+25!.Mg!?8HC!!

!

Page 109: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! (M!

!""#$%&'(!(X!!"##$%&'()'*!"!#$%&!

H;*5!52AA&#:!*5!1&d$6!9#4A!1;$!"+&6!1$#A5!&6'!*60+2'$5!*1$A5!1;&1!;&[$!&!Y$&#*67!46!1;$!#$52+15!

49!1;$![&+2&1*46C!!H;$!"+&6!1$#A5!*60+2'$!41;$#!'$1&*+5!&Y421!Y$6$9*15!1;&1!&#$!641!A&1$#*&+!14!1;$!

#$52+15!%#$5$61$'!;$#$*6C!!)A42615!&#$!$c%#$55$'!*6!.<<<!'4++&#5e!$c0$%1!\;$#$!*6'*0&1$'!

41;$#\*5$C!!K451!49!1;$5$!%&:A$615!&A42615!&#$!*6'$c$'!9#4A!1;$*#!.<<<!+$[$+5!14!1;$!'&1$!49!

%&:A$61!14!#$9+$01!*69+&1*46C!!

I6!1;$!94++4\*67!52AA&#*$5e!1;$!5%$0*9*0!5$01*46!#$9$#$60$!49!1;$!"+&6!*5!5;4\6!*6!Y#&0d$15C!

M;<E<<<!A/%!B"C!+1A-R&+/1!wSC-.].`]&`x!

)!04A%$65&1*46!%&:A$61!49!j.-e---!*5!A&'$!2%46!&!0+&*A&61!Y$*67!&%%#4[$'!94#!1;$!"+&6C!

MG<E<<<!)!8/,+&+I-!."7!&-,&!wSC-.].`]Y`x!

)!%&:A$61!49!j,-e---!*5!A&'$!2%46!&!0+&*A&61!'$+*[$#*67!&!%45*1*[$!"@3!1$51!#$%4#1C!!"#*4#!14!V2+:!

,--,e!1;*5!Y$6$9*1!\&5!5%+*1!*614!1\4!%&#15e!\*1;!j./e---!%&*'!*AA$'*&1$+:!&6'!j/e---!52Yf$01!14!&!

^;4+'Y&0d_!261*+!520;!1*A$!&5!*1!042+'!Y$!'$A4651#&1$'!1;&1!1;$!926'!\&5!5299*0*$61!14!52%%4#1!

%&:A$61!49!1;$!92++!j,-e---C!!H;$!;4+'Y&0d!&A42615!\$#$!&21;4#*5$'!Y:!1;$!042#1!14!Y$!%&*'!

$99$01*[$!V2+:!,--,C!

MH<E<<<!)!>/1D:%+30+10!A+:%/,+,!wSC-.].`]0`x!

H;*5!%&:A$61!*5!&[&*+&Y+$!14!&++!0+&*A&615!\;4!;&[$!'$[$+4%$'!646>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5!4#!;&[$!

%#40$$'$'!Y$:46'!1;&1!51&7$C!!)5!\$++e!0+&*A&615!\;4!;&[$!#$0$*[$'!4#!A$$1!&!%#41404+!94#!

@4A%$65&Y+$!?@J!R#27!H;$#&%:!]\;$1;$#!4#!641!1#$&1A$61!*5!26'$#1&d$6`!&#$!$+*7*Y+$!94#!1;*5!

Y$6$9*1C!

)!0+&*A&61!A&:!$+$01!14!\&*[$!1;*5!%&:A$61!&6'!14!#$0$*[$!*651$&'!&!T455!49!I604A$!4#!T455!49!

8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*1C!!H;$!'$0*5*46!&5!14!\;*0;!Y$6$9*1!14!#$0$*[$!A&:!Y$!'$9$##$'!&5!+467!&5!1;$!

0+&*A&61!\*5;$5C!

K/,,!/A!O1R/@-!wSC-,x!

F&0;!0+&*A&61!26'$#!1;$!&7$!49!=/!\;4!\&5!*6!#$0$*%1!49!$&#6$'!*604A$!&6'!\;4!5299$#5!&!T455!49!

I604A$!0&25$'!Y:!1;$*#!*69$01*46!\*1;!?$%&1*1*5!@!*5!$61*1+$'!14!%$#*4'*0!&662&+!%&:A$615!

%#4[*'$'a!

.C 1;$!0+&*A&61!*5!&1!1;$!Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5!+$[$+!4#!Y$:46'e!4#!

,C 1;$!0+&*A&61!*5!&1!1;$!646>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5!+$[$+!&6'!*5!26&Y+$!14!\4#d!A4#$!1;&6!,-g!49!1;$!

252&+!\4#d>\$$d!&6'!;&5!\&*[$'!1;$!jM-e---!+2A%!52A!%&:A$61!'$50#*Y$'!&Y4[$C!

H;$!&A4261!49!Y$6$9*1!*5!$Z2&+!14!.--g!49!1;$!&A4261!49!+451!*604A$!'$1$#A*6$'!&91$#!64#A&+!

%&:#4++!'$'201*465!]6$1!*604A$`C!!H;$!+451!*604A$!*5!Y&5$'!46!1;$!&[$#&7$!&662&+!6$1!*604A$!

'2#*67!1;$!1;#$$!%#*4#!:$&#5C!!N$6$9*1!&A42615!&#$!*6'$c$'!9#4A!1;$!A*''+$!49!1;$!1;#$$>:$&#!

Page 110: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! (S!

%$#*4'!25$'!14!'$1$#A*6$!1;$!&A4261!49!+455!14!1;$!:$&#!49!%&:A$61!Y&5$'!46!1;$!*6'$c*67!#&1$!

26'$#!1;$!@&6&'&!"$65*46!"+&6C!!H;$#$!*5!&!;4+'Y&0d!\;$#$Y:!&6:!+451!*604A$!4[$#!jM--e---!

].<<<!+$[$+`!\*++!641!Y$!%&*'!261*+!1;$!042#15!&#$!5&1*59*$'!1;&1!1;$!926'!&55$15!&#$!5299*0*$61!14!

A&d$!520;!%&:A$615C!!"#*4#!14!E014Y$#!,--Se!1;$!;4+'Y&0d!\&5!Y&5$'!46!&!+451!*604A$!&A4261!49!

jU/e---C!!)+54e!%#*4#!14!E014Y$#!,--Se!1;$#$!\&5!&!;4+'Y&0d!$Z2&+!14!M-g!49!1;$!+451!*604A$!

%&:&Y+$!14!0+&*A&615!&1!1;$!646>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5!51&7$C!

I6!,--(e!1;$!042#15!&%%#4[$'!%&:A$61!49!+451!*604A$!94#!1;#$$!0+&*A&615!49!2%!14!j,CM!A*++*46C!!

)6:!9212#$!0+&*A!94#!+451!*604A$!1;&1!$c0$$'5!1;$!jM--e---!+$[$+!\*++!Y$!52Yf$01!14!1;$!&%%#4[&+!49!

1;$!042#15!%#*4#!14!%&:A$61C!!

K/,,!/A!P-%I+R-,!wSC-Mx!

F&0;!0+&*A&61!\;4!64#A&++:!%$#94#A$'!;425$;4+'!'21*$5!*6!1;$*#!;4A$!&6'!*5!26&Y+$!14!'4!54!&5!&!

#$52+1!49!1;$*#!*69$01*46!\*1;!?$%&1*1*5!@!*5!$61*1+$'!14!%$#*4'*0!&662&+!%&:A$615!94#!T455!49!

8$#[*0$5!%#4[*'$'a!

.C 1;$!0+&*A&61!*5!&1!1;$!Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5!+$[$+!4#!Y$:46'e!4#!

,C 1;$!0+&*A&61!*5!&1!1;$!646>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5!+$[$+!&6'!;&5!\&*[$'!1;$!jM-e---!+2A%!52A!

%&:A$61!'$50#*Y$'!&Y4[$C!

H;$!&A4261!49!Y$6$9*1!*5!$Z2&+!14!j.,!%$#!;42#!49!;4A$A&d$#!&55*51&60$!#$Z2*#$'!14!&!A&c*A2A!

49!j,S-!%$#!\$$dC!

)!0+&*A&61!*5!641!$61*1+$'!14!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!Y$6$9*15!*9!1;$:!&#$!#$0$*[*67!T455!49!I604A$!Y$6$9*15C!

M='E<<<!)!"+%%#/,+,!wSC-.].`]'`x!

)!%&:A$61!49!j=/e---!*5!A&'$!2%46!&!0+&*A&61!Y$*67!'*&7645$'!\*1;!0*##;45*5C!!!

M;<<E<<<!)!*-R/@8-1,$&+/1Z"$1R-%ZK+I-%!9%$1,84$1&!wSC-.].`]$`x!

)!%&:A$61!49!j.--e---!*5!A&'$!2%46!&!0+&*A&61!Y$*67!'*&7645$'!\*1;!+*[$#!'$04A%$65&1*46!4#!

;$%&140$++2+&#!0&60$#!4#!;&5!#$0$*[$'!&!+*[$#!1#&65%+&61C!!H;$#$!&#$!54A$!41;$#!046'*1*465!1;&1!

\*++!7*[$!#*5$!14!1;*5!Y$6$9*1e!Y21!1;$:!&#$!641!A4'$+$'!5$%&#&1$+:!*6!1;$!KKWP!#$%4#1C!!

*+:.:&+D&*"-%!UKMIKV&

)!0+&*A&61!\;4!A$$15!1;$!046'*1*465!94#!1;$!j.--e---!%&:A$61!&Y4[$!&6'!\;4!;&5!*602##$'!04515!

94#!0&#$!1;&1!&#$!641!04[$#$'!Y:!&6:!%2Y+*0!4#!%#*[&1$!;$&+1;!%+&6!*5!$61*1+$'!14!#$*AY2#5$A$61!94#!

&++!#$&546&Y+$!04515!14!&!A&c*A2A!49!j/-e---!%$#!:$&#C!

Page 111: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! (/!

*%?0!&#-%$8L!wSC-/x!

)!0+&*A&61!\;4!#$0$*[$5!04A%$65&Y+$!?@J!'#27!1;$#&%:!]*61$#9$#46e!#*Y&[*#*6!4#!520;!41;$#!

1#$&1A$61!&%%#4[$'!Y:!1;$!042#15`!*5!$61*1+$'!14!Y$!%&*'!j.e---!94#!$&0;!04A%+$1$'!A461;!49!520;!

1;$#&%:C!

]1+1,?%-3!9%-$&@-1&!^!2-3+R$&+/1!wSC-=x!

)!0+&*A&61!\;4!#$0$*[$5!&!7$6$#&++:!&00$%1$'!1#$&1A$61!&6'!A$'*0&1*46!94#!?@J!1;&1!*5!641!

41;$#\*5$!#$04[$#&Y+$!9#4A!&!%#*[&1$!4#!%2Y+*0!;$&+1;!%+&6!*5!$61*1+$'!14!Y$!#$*AY2#5$'!94#!&++!

520;!#$&546&Y+$!04515C!

T?&D/AD8/RU-&!VS8-1,-,!wSC-Ux!

)!0+&*A&61!\;4!*602#5!421>49>%40d$1!$c%$65$5!'2$!14!*69$01*46!Y:!?@J!1;&1!&#$!641!41;$#\*5$!

#$04[$#&Y+$!9#4A!&!%#*[&1$!4#!%2Y+*0!;$&+1;!%+&6!*5!$61*1+$'!14!Y$!#$*AY2#5$'!94#!&++!520;!

#$&546&Y+$!04515C!!H;*5!*60+2'$5!&A42615!94#!1#&[$+e!;41$+5e!A$&+5e!1$+$%;46$!&6'!41;$#!5*A*+&#!

$c%$65$5!&11#*Y21&Y+$!14!5$$d*67!A$'*0&+!&'[*0$!4#!1#$&1A$61!&6'!A$'*0&1*46!&5!\$++!&5!04515!

*602##$'!*6!$51&Y+*5;*67!&!0+&*A!26'$#!1;$!"+&6C!

P-R/13$%+4L!O1A-R&-3!.-%,/1,!

)!5%425$!4#!0;*+'!49!&6!?@J!*69$01$'!0+&*A&61!]4#!&6!?@J!*69$01$'!%$#546!\;4!;&5!4%1$'!421!49!

1;$!"+&6`!\;$#$!1;&1!%$#546!\&5!*69$01$'!\*1;!?@J!&5!&!#$52+1!49!1;$!#$+&1*465;*%!A&:!A&d$!;*5!4#!

;$#!4\6!0+&*A!94#!04A%$65&1*46!26'$#!1;$!"+&6C!!H4!Y$!$+*7*Y+$e!1;$!5%425$!A251!9*+$!&!0+&*A!

\*1;*6!1;#$$!:$&#5!49!1;$!'&1$!1;$!%#*A&#*+:!*69$01$'!%$#546!52YA*15!1;$*#!0+&*AC!!H;$#$!*5!64!520;!

+*A*1&1*46!46!0+&*A5!52YA*55*465!Y:!0;*+'#$6C!!N$6$9*15!14!5$046'&#*+:!*69$01$'!%$#5465!&#$!1;$!

5&A$!&5!94#!%#*A&#*+:!*69$01$'!%$#5465C!

B"C!%-4$&-3!3-$&#!:-A/%-!;!_$1?$%L!;FFF!w/C-.x!

I9!&6!&%%#4[$'!?@J!*69$01$'!%$#546!'*$'!%#*4#!14!.!V&62&#:!.<<<!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@Je!1;$*#!%$#546&+!

#$%#$5$61&1*[$!&6'l4#!9&A*+:!A$AY$#5!&#$!$61*1+$'!14!#$0$*[$!$*1;$#a!

.C j/-e---!%+25!&6:!26*652#$'!926$#&+!$c%$65$5!*602##$'!14!&!A&c*A2A!49!j/e---!%+25!1;$!

04A%$65&1*46!14!'$%$6'&615!&6'!&%%#4[$'!9&A*+:!A$AY$#5!&5!421+*6$'!Y$+4\b!4#e!

,C j.,-e---!%+25!26*652#$'!926$#&+!$c%$65$5C!

B"C!%-4$&-3!3-$&#!$A&-%!;D_$1D;FFF!w/C-,x!

I9!&!0+&*A&61!'*$5!&91$#!.!V&62&#:!.<<<!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@Je!&6:!26*652#$'!926$#&+!$c%$65$5!

*602##$'!14!&!A&c*A2A!49!j/e---!&6'!04A%$65&1*46!14!'$%$6'&615!&6'!&%%#4[$'!9&A*+:!

A$AY$#5!&5!421+*6$'!Y$+4\!&#$!%&:&Y+$C!!H;*5!*5!*6!&''*1*46!14!&6:!41;$#!Y$6$9*1!$61*1+$A$61!1;$!

0+&*A&61!;&5!26'$#!1;$!"+&6C!

Page 112: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! (=!

"/@8-1,$&+/1!&/!*-8-13$1&,!w=C-.x!

B4++4\*67!1;$!'$&1;!49!&!%$#546!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@Je!1;$!'$%$6'&615!49!1;&1!%$#546!&#$!$61*1+$'!14!

#$0$*[$!!

.C T455!49!82%%4#1!X!9#4A!1;$!'&1$!49!'$&1;!14!1;$!'&1$!1;$!*69$01$'!%$#546!\42+'!;&[$!&11&*6$'!

&7$!=/e!'$%$6'&615!\*++!Y$!%&*'!&6!&662&+!&A4261!$Z2&+!14!1;$!6$1!*604A$!49!1;$!'$0$&5$'!

%$#546e!#$'20$'!Y:!M-g!14!&004261!94#!1;$!%$#546&+!+*[*67!$c%$65$5!49!1;$!'$0$&5$'C!

,C T455!49!8$#[*0$5!X!9#4A!1;$!'&1$!49!'$&1;!49!1;$!*69$01$'!%$#546e!'$%$6'&615!\*++!Y$!%&*'!&6!

&662&+!&A4261!$Z2&+!14!j.,!%$#!;42#!14!&!A&c*A2A!49!j,S-!%$#!\$$d!&5!04A%$65&1*46!94#!

T455!49!8$#[*0$5!*6!1;$!;4A$!49!1;$!'$0$&5$'C!!H;$!"+&6!0461&*65!64!#$9$#$60$!&5!14!;4\!+467!

1;$5$!%&:A$615!&#$!14!Y$!A&'$e!;4\$[$#!\$!26'$#51&6'!1;&1!1;$!&'A*6*51#&14#!*5!%&:*67!1;*5!

T455!49!8$#[*0$5!94#!1;$!+*9$!$c%$01&60:!49!1;$!'$0$&5$'e!0&+02+&1$'!&004#'*67!14!1;$!@&6&'*&6!

T*9$!H&Y+$5!&5!%2Y+*5;$'!Y:!81&1*51*05!@&6&'&C!

W;$#$!1;$!'$%$6'&615!&#$!$61*1+$'!14!Y41;!T455!49!82%%4#1!&6'!T455!49!8$#[*0$5e!46+:!46$!*5!

%&:&Y+$C!!8;42+'!1;$!T455!49!82%%4#1!%&:A$615!0$&5$!2%46!1;$!'&1$!1;$!'$0$&5$'!\42+'!;&[$!

&11&*6$'!&7$!=/e!1;$6!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!%&:A$615!&#$!%&:&Y+$!1;$#$&91$#C!

H;$!&A4261!49!Y$6$9*1!%&:&Y+$!*5!14!Y$!5%+*1!&A467!&++!'$%$6'&615!*6!520;!A&66$#!&5!1;$!

'$%$6'&615!4#!&'A*6*51#&14#!'$1$#A*6$C!

"/@8-1,$&+/1!&/!J88%/I-3!\$@+4L!2-@:-%,!w=C-,x!

B4++4\*67!1;$!'$&1;!49!&!%$#546!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@Je!1;$!9&A*+:!A$AY$#5!49!1;&1!%$#546!&#$!$61*1+$'!

14!#$0$*[$!

&C j,/e---!94#!1;$!5%425$!

YC j./e---!94#!$&0;!0;*+'!26'$#!1;$!&7$!49!,.!&1!1;$!'&1$!49!'$&1;!

0C j!/e---!94#!$&0;!0;*+'!&7$'!,.!4#!4[$#!&1!1;$!'&1$!49!'$&1;!

'C j!/e---!94#!$&0;!%&#$61!

$C j!/e---!94#!$&0;!5*Y+*67!

9C j!/--!94#!$&0;!7#&6'%&#$61!

7C j!/--!94#!$&0;!7#&6'0;*+'!

BOC!P-R/13$%+4L!O1A-R&-3!"4$+@$1&,!wSC-(x!

)6!?@J!*69$01$'!%$#546!\;4!*5!&+54!&!5$046'&#*+:!*69$01$'!?IJ!%$#546!A&:!46+:!#$0$*[$!

04A%$65&1*46!9#4A!1;*5!"+&6!460$!1;$*#!0+&*A5!\42+'!41;$#\*5$!;&[$!$c0$$'$'!j,S-e---C!

Page 113: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! (U!

'//323,.'9!&0.07321!7,+!8'04,58393'(1!A328!805'23231!(!

H;$!94++4\*67!Y$6$9*15!&#$!%&:&Y+$!2%46!&!0+&*A&61i5!$+$01*46!*651$&'!49!1;$!&Y4[$!+*51$'!Y$6$9*15e!

&6'!&#$!46+:!&[&*+&Y+$!14!&6!&%%#4[$'!;&$A4%;*+*&0!0+&*A&61C!!8$01*46!#$9$#$60$5!&#$!14!1;$!

?&$A4%;*+*&0!"+&6C!

B$-@/8#+4+$R!+1A-R&-3!W+&#!:/&#!B"C!$13!BOC!wSC-(],`x!

I9!1;$!0+&*A&61!*5!&!%#*A&#*+:!*69$01$'!;&$A4%;*+*&0!&6'!*5!&+54!*69$01$'!\*1;!?IJe!&!+2A%!52A!

&A4261!49!j/-e---!A&:!Y$!$+$01$'!*651$&'!49!&++!41;$#!04A%$65&1*46!26'$#!1;$!"+&6!&6'!*5!*6!92++!

5&1*59&01*46!49!&++!0+&*A5C!

*-$&#!8%+/%!&/!;!_?4L!;FFF!w/C-.]S`x!

I9!&6!&%%#4[$'!?@J!*69$01$'!%$#546!'*$'!%#*4#!14!.!V&62&#:!.<<<!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@Je!1;$*#!%$#546&+!

#$%#$5$61&1*[$!&6'l4#!9&A*+:!A$AY$#5!&#$!$61*1+$'!14!#$0$*[$!$*1;$#a!

.C j/-e---!%+25!&6:!26*652#$'!926$#&+!$c%$65$5!*602##$'!14!&!A&c*A2A!49!j/e---!%+25!1;$!

04A%$65&1*46!14!'$%$6'&615!&6'!&%%#4[$'!9&A*+:!A$AY$#5!&5!421+*6$'!&Y4[$b!4#e!

,C j.,-e---!%+25!26*652#$'!926$#&+!$c%$65$5b!4#e!

MC jU,e---!*9!1;$!0+&*A&61!\&5!&!%#*A&#*+:!*69$01$'!;&$A4%;*+*&0!&6'!\&5!&+54!*69$01$'!\*1;!?IJ!

&6'!*9!&++!'$%$6'&615!&6'!41;$#!9&A*+:!A$AY$#5!&7#$$!14!&00$%1!1;*5!&A4261!*6!92++!

5&1*59&01*46!49!&++!0+&*A5C!

836!5+,*+'4!

"$#5465!\;4!&#$!*69$01$'!\*1;!?IJ!#$52+1*67!9#4A!&!#$+&1*465;*%!]%&#16$#!4#!0;*+'`!49!&!%#*A&#*+:!

*69$01$'!%$#546!\;4!*5!&6!&%%#4[$'!Fc1#&4#'*6&#:!)55*51&60$!"+&6!#$0*%*$61!&#$!$+*7*Y+$!14!#$0$*[$!

j,S-e---!04A%$65&1*46!9#4A!1;*5!"+&6C!!H;$#$!*5!64!#$Z2*#$A$61!1;&1!1;$!%$#546!Y$!*69$01$'!\*1;!

?@JC!!)!A&c*A2A!49!,S-!520;!0+&*A5!\*++!Y$!&00$%1$'C

Page 114: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! ((!

!""#$%&'()(X!!"##$%&'()'*+$,#$-.'!"#"!

1,-+(0!,7!/'2'!

H;$!0+&*A&61!'&1&!25$'!14!%#4'20$!1;$!#$52+15!*6!1;*5!#$%4#1!0&6!Y$!5%+*1!*614!1\4!7#42%5e!1;$!

02##$61!d64\6!04;4#1!&6'!1;$!&552A$'!26d64\6!04;4#1C!!!

H;$!'&1&!94#!1;$!02##$61!d64\6!04;4#1!\&5!%#4[*'$'!Y:!1;$!V4*61!@4AA*11$$!&6'!94#\&#'$'!14!25!

[*&!1;$!R$%&#1A$61!49!V251*0$C!!H;$!'&1&!\&5!5%+*1!Y$1\$$6!&!A&51$#!+*51!&6'!5$[$#&+!52%%4#1*67!

+*515C!!B4#!$&0;!d64\6!0+&*A&61e!&5!&1!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.Me!1;$!A&51$#!+*51!5%$0*9*$'!1;$!0+&*A&61!

7#42%!]1#&65925$'!4#!;&$A4%;*+*&0`e!7$6'$#e!'&1$!49!Y*#1;e!?IJ!51&125e!02##$61!'*5$&5$!+$[$+e!$10C!!

H;$!52%%4#1*67!+*515!0461&*6$'!*694#A&1*46!46!Y$6$9*15!%&*'!&6'!Y$6$9*15!02##$61+:!*6!%&:!14!1;$!

0+&*A&61!&6'l4#!1;$*#!Y$6$9*0*&#*$5e!&5!'*01&1$'!Y:!1;$!0+&*A&61i5!02##$61!'*5$&5$!+$[$+C!!H;$!

A&51$#!+*51!&6'!52%%4#1*67!+*515!\$#$!04654+*'&1$'!*614!46$!9*+$!0461&*6*67!&++!49!1;$!*694#A&1*46!

#$Z2*#$'!14![&+2$!1;$!02##$61!d64\6!04;4#1C!!

H;$!'&1&!94#!1;$!&552A$'!26d64\6!04;4#1!\&5!0#$&1$'!Y&5$'!46!1;$!&552A%1*465!5$1!421!*6!

8$01*46!=!>!?$%&1*1*5!@!@+&*A&61!@4;4#1C!!H;$!26d64\6!0+&*A&615!&#$!&552A$'!14!A*##4#!1;$!

d64\6!0+&*A&615!\*1;!#$5%$01!14!&7$e!51&125!]&+*[$!4#!'$0$&5$'`!&6'!'*5$&5$!+$[$+C!!

/'2'!(80()1!,.!280!(-++0.2!).,A.!(,8,+2!

)91$#!04654+*'&1*67!1;$!A&51$#!+*51!&6'!52%%4#1*67!+*515!*614!46$!9*+$e!\$!%$#94#A$'!&!62AY$#!49!

0;$0d5!94#!#$&546&Y+$6$55C!

• @4A%&#$!1;$!62AY$#!49!0+&*A&615!&1!$&0;!51&125!\*1;!1;$!62AY$#!9#4A!1;$!,-.-!'&1&C!

• @4A%&#$!1;$!,-.-!'&1&!94#!$&0;!d64\6!0+&*A&61!\*1;!1;$!,-.M!'&1&!94#!&6:!0;&67$5!1;&1!

\42+'!641!Y$!#$&546&Y+$!]520;!&5!&!+&#7$!62AY$#!49!0;&67$'!'&1$5!49!Y*#1;e!*6&%%#4%#*&1$!

0;&67$!*6!'*5$&5$!+$[$+!4#!51&125`C!!

• 3$[*$\$'!1;$!,-.-!&6'!,-.M!'&1&!94#!A*55*67!0+&*A&615C!!H;$#$!\$#$!64!A*55*67!0+&*A&615C!

• @4A%&#$!1;$!042615!49!1;$!0+&*A&615!\;4!\$#$!&+*[$e!'$0$&5$'!&91$#!.<<<!&6'!'$0$&5$'!

Y$94#$!.<<<!94#!1;$!d64\6!0+&*A&615!14!1;$!5*A*+&#!62AY$#5!#$%4#1$'!Y:!F0d+$#C!

W$!A&'$!1;$!94++4\*67!&'f251A$615!14!1;$!'&1&!%#4[*'$'!94#!1;$!02##$61!d64\6!04;4#1a!

• B4#!0+&*A&615!&1!'*5$&5$!+$[$+!Me!\$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!/-g!&#$!&1!0+*6*0&+!51&7$!B.!&6'!/-g!

&1!51&7$!B,C!!H;*5!*5!Y&5$'!46!1;$!#&1*45!%#$5$61$'!*6!1;$!KKWP!#$%4#1C!!!

• B4#!0+&*A&615!&1!'*5$&5$!+$[$+!=!94#!\;4A!&!1#&65%+&61!*5!*6'*0&1$'e!\$!;&[$!&552A$'!1;&1!

1;$:!;&[$!52#[*[$'!94#!&1!+$&51!.,!A461;5!94++4\*67!1;$!1#&65%+&61C!!!

• B4#!0+&*A&615!&1!+$[$+!=!\;4!&#$!*6'*0&1$'!14!;&[$!#$6&+!9&*+2#$e!@#:47+4Y2+*6$A*&!4#!

P+4A$#2+46$%;#*1*5!]^&1:%*0&+!+$[$+!=_`e!\$!94++4\$'!1;$!&'[*0$!#$0$*[$'!9#4A!1;$!KKWP!&6'!

9#4A!R#C!N&*6e!&!7&51#4$61$#4+47*51!\;4!%#4[*'$5!&'[*0$!14!1;$!V4*61!@4AA*11$$C!!W$!

0465*'$#$'!1;$:!\42+'!Y$!5*A*+&#!14!41;$#!+$[$+!=!0+&*A&615e!Y21!!

Page 115: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! (<!

o &552A$'!1;$:!\42+'!&++!#$0$*[$!1#$&1A$61!25*67!54925Y4[*#>Y&5$'!'42Y+$15b!

o &552A$'!1;&1!1;$#$!\42+'!Y$!64!#$04[$#:!9#4A!'*5&Y*+*1:!]+455!49!*604A$!4#!+455!49!

5$#[*0$5`b!

o A4'*9*$'!1;$!*60*'$60$!49!@451!49!@&#$!14!Y$!t#'!49!42#!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&552A%1*465b!

&6'!

o A4'*9*$'!1;$!A4#1&+*1:!14!0465*'$#!u#'5!49!'$&1;5!14!Y$!?@J>#$+&1$'!&6'!1;$!Y&+&60$!

&5!641!?@J>#$+&1$'.UC!!!

• B4#!0+&*A&615!&1!+$[$+!=!\;4!&#$!*6'*0&1$'!14!;&[$!+:A%;4A&e!\$!94++4\$'!1;$!&'[*0$!

#$0$*[$'!9#4A!1;$!KKWP!&6'!A4'$++$'!1;$A!1;$!5&A$!&5!'$04A%$65&1$'!0+&*A&615C!

(,8,+2!/312+3&-23,.1!'1!'2!;#!/0(04&0+!%E#;!

H&Y+$!.S=!5;4\5!1;$!0+&*A&61!04;4#15!25$'!*6!1;$![&+2&1*46C!!H&Y+$5!NC.!&6'!NC,!Y$+4\!5;4\!1;$!

'*5$&5$!+$[$+!&5!&1!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.M!94#!1;$!d64\6!0+&*A&615!147$1;$#!\*1;!1;$*#!'*5$&5$!+$[$+!&5!

49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.-C!

H;$!94++4\*67!A&:!&55*51!*6!26'$#51&6'*67!1;$!1&Y+$C!!!

T44d*67!&1!1;$!9*#51!#4\!*6!H&Y+$!NC.e!1;$!#*7;1!;&6'!04+2A6!5;4\5!1;&1!1;$#$!\$#$!S<,!1#&65925$'!

0+&*A&615!&1!+$[$+!.!&5!49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.-C!!

)5!46$!#$&'5!&0#455!1;$!#4\!9#4A!1;$!+$91e!\$!5$$!1;&1!&5!49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.Me!S(S!49!1;45$!

0+&*A&615!#$A&*6!&1!+$[$+!.b!1;#$$!49!1;$A!&#$!64\!&1!+$[$+!,!&6'!9*[$!49!1;$A!;&[$!'*$'!9#4A!646>

?@J!0&25$5C!!T44d*67!&1!1;$!1&Y+$!#4\!Y:!#4\e!\$!0&6!5$$!;4\!0+&*A&615!&5!49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.-!

;&[$!%#47#$55$'C!

B#4A!&641;$#!%$#5%$01*[$e!+44d!&1!1;$!04+2A6!;$&'$'!^R)<!?@J_C!!H;*5!04+2A6!5;4\5!1;$!

1#&65925$'!0+&*A&615!&5!49!M.!R$0$AY$#!,-.M!\;4!;&[$!'*$'!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@JC!!H;$#$!&#$!&!141&+!

49!S(-!]Y4114A!#4\`C!

T44d*67!&1!1;$!5$046'!+&51!#4\!*6!1;$!R)<!?@J!04+2A6e!\$!5$$!1;&1!<!49!1;$5$!'$&1;5!&#$!6$\!

$61#&615!X!1;&1!*5!1;$*#!0+&*A!\&5!&%%#4[$'!&1!54A$!1*A$!*6!1;$!%$#*4'!.!V&62&#:!,-..!14!M.!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

.U!! H;*5!'*99$#$'!9#4A!1;$!&'[*0$!\$!#$0$*[$'!9#4A!1;$!KKWP!1;&1!1;$5$!0+&*A&615!\42+'!;&[$!64!4674*67!?@J>#$+&1$'!*552$5!&6'!'$&1;!\42+'!641!Y$!?@J>#$+&1$'C!!W$!525%$01!1;&1!1;$!'$9*6*1*46!49!^?@J>#$+&1$'_!25$'!Y:!1;$!KKWP!*6!1;$*#!#$5%465$!\&5!Y&5$'!46!&!A$'*0&+!#&1;$#!1;&6!&!+$7&+!'$9*6*1*46!49!0&25&1*46C!!B4#!1;$!%2#%45$5!49!Y$6$9*1!$61*1+$A$61e!\$!&#$!*694#A$'!1;&1!1;$!+$7&+!'$9*6*1*46!*5!21*+*h$'C!!?4\$[$#e!1;$!4%*6*46!46!#$04[$#:!9#4A!'*5&Y*+*1:!\&5![$#:!'*99$#$61e!\*1;!1;$!KKWP!$c%$01*67!92++!#$04[$#:!&91$#!&Y421!5*c!A461;5!&6'!R#C!N&*6!5277$51*67!1;$#$!A&:!Y$!46+:!%&#1*&+!#$04[$#:!*6!54A$!%&1*$615C!!R2$!14!*AA&1$#*&+*1:!49!1;$!+*&Y*+*1:!*6[4+[$'e!\$!'$0*'$'!14!21*+*h$!R#C!N&*6i5!A4#$!0465$#[&1*[$![*$\C!

Page 116: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! <-!

R$0$AY$#!,-.MC!!S,,!49!1;$!1#&65925$'!\;4!'*$'!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@J!\$#$!0+&*A&615!&5!49!M.!

R$0$AY$#!,-.-C!!!I6!1;$!1;*#'!+&51!#4\!&#$!.M!0+&*A&615!1;&1!\$#$!0+&55*9*$'!&5!&!646>?@J!'$&1;!*6!

,-.-!\;4!;&[$!5*60$!Y$$6!#$0+&55*9*$'C!!H;$!Y&+&60$!49!1;$!#4\5!&Y4[$!5;4\5!0+&*A&615!\;4!\$#$!

&+*[$!*6!R$0$AY$#!,-.-!\;4!;&[$!5*60$!'*$'!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@JC!

!"#$%&Zd'&2&M0:%":%&O%P%$:&04&BI'I&"46&BI'R&2&!-"4:DC:%6&*$"09"4.:&&&

) ABCD)3'1,/1,)V,?,.)

ABCB)3'1,/1,)V,?,.) C) A) D) J) I) P) 3=NCM)

3@N^<*ZCN)

3@N)#&#^<*ZCN)

:&(/.)b[)V,?,.)'#)

ABCB)

.! S(S! M! ! ! ! ! ! ! /! S<,!

,! ! <=-! /,! ,! U! M! ! .! .U! .-S,!

M! ! ! (.,! =! .,! =! ! M! .-! (S<!

S! ! ! ! .=,! =! ,! ! ,! S! .U=!

/! ! ! ! ! .,S! /! ! .S! /! .S(!

=! ! ! ! ! ! =<! ! .=! /! <-!

RN<.(! ! ! ! ! ! ! .U<! ! ! .U<!

R)<>?@J.<! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! S,,! ! S,,!

R)<>646.<! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! .M! M(M! M<=!

Q$\!$61#&61! ,=! M-! MS! /! <! ,! /! <! .-! .M-!

:&(/.)b[)V,?,.)'#)ABCD) ICB! NND! MNM! CLI! CIM! ML! CMJ! JMB! JDN! DNAJ!

!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

.(!! RN<!X!R$0$&5$'!%#*4#!14!.<<<C!

.<!! R)<!X!R$0$&5$'!&91$#!.<<<!X!$*1;$#!?@J!#$+&1$'!4#!641>?@J!#$+&1$'!

Page 117: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! <.!

!"#$%&ZdB&2&M0:%":%&O%P%$:&04&BI'I&"46&BI'R&2&>"%9+L,0$0"=&*$"09"4.:&&

) ABCD)3'1,/1,)V,?,.)

ABCB)3'1,/1,))V,?,.) C) A) D) J) I) P) 3=NAB)

3@N^<*ZAC)

3@N)#&#^<*ZAC)

:&(/.)b[)V,?,.)'#)

ABCB)

.! .SM! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! .SM!

,! ! .<-! U! ,! ! .! ! .! .! ,-,!

M! ! ! M.U! U! /! M! ! M! M! MM(!

S! ! ! ! U.! .! .! ! .! .! U/!

/! ! ! ! ! U=! /! ! .! S! (=!

=! ! ! ! ! ! S-! ! (! ! S(!

RN<,-! ! ! ! ! ! ! M-.! ! ! M-,!

R)<n?@J,.! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ..M! ! ..M!

R)<>646!,.! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! S! M<! SM!

Q$\!$61#&61! M! ,! ,! .! ! ! ! ! ,! .-!

:&(/.)b[)V,?,.)'#)ABCD) CJP! CNA! DAP! MC! MA! IB! DBC! CDC! IB! CDIN!

!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

,-!! RN<!X!R$0$&5$'!%#*4#!14!.<<<C!

,.!! R)<!X!R$0$&5$'!&91$#!.<<<!X!$*1;$#!?@J!#$+&1$'!4#!641>?@J!#$+&1$'!

Page 118: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! <,!

!""#$%&'()(X!!"#$%&'(&)*+),+-$(.-!"#$%&'()$!

H;$!A4'$+!\$!;&[$!Y2*+1!*5!04A%45$'!49!5$[$#&+!A4'2+$5e!421+*6$'!&5!94++4\5a!

M"."&;4.-A&@+6C$%&

I6!1;*5!A4'2+$e!&++!#$+$[&61!'&1&!9*$+'5!&#$!%4%2+&1$'!25*67!'&1&!%#4[*'$'!Y:!1;$!&'A*6*51#&14#e!

\;*0;!#$9+$015!1;$!&012&+!0+&*A&615!&1!1;$*#!&012&+!&7$!&6'!'*5$&5$!51&7$C!!)!5*A*+&#!5$1!49!'&1&!*5!

0#$&1$'!94#!1;$!26d64\6!0+&*A&615!Y&5$'!46!1;$!&552A$'!'*5$&5$!51&7$e!&7$!'*51#*Y21*46e!51&125!

]&+*[$e!'$0$&5$'!9#4A!?@Je!'$0$&5$'!9#4A!41;$#!0&25$5`e!04;4#1!]1#&65925$'!4#!;&$A4%;*+*&0`e!&6'!

41;$#!&552A%1*465!&5!'*50255$'!*6!8$01*46!=!>!?$%&1*1*5!@!@+&*A&61!@4;4#1C!

X::C9L.0+4:&@+6C$%& &

H;*5!A4'2+$!*5!25$'!14!Y2*+'!5$15!49!&552A%1*465!0&++$'!50$6&#*45e!\;*0;!&#$!*6!12#6!25$'!14!

0&+02+&1$!#$52+15C!!H;$#$!&#$!5$%&#&1$!5$15!49!&552A%1*465!94#!1;$!1#&65925$'!&6'!;&$A4%;*+*&0!

7#42%5C!

!-"4:0.0+4&@".-0<&@+6C$%&

H;$!1#&65*1*46!A&1#*c!0461&*65!1;$!KKWP!A$1;4'4+47:!&6'!1#&65*1*46!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!25$'!*6!4#'$#!14!%#4f$01!$&0;!0+&*A&61i5!'*5$&5$!%#47#$55*46C!!H;*5!A4'2+$!&+54!*604#%4#&1$5!1;$!$c0$55!A4#1&+*1:!9#4A!?@J!&552A%1*46C!

*"$=C$".0+4&@+6C$%&

E60$!1;$!'&1&!;&5!Y$$6!$61$#$'!&6'!&!50$6&#*4!*5!0;45$6e!*6'*[*'2&+!0+&*A&615!&#$!&214A&1*0&++:!

#26!1;#427;!1;$!0&+02+&1*46!$67*6$!46$!&1!&!1*A$C!!H;*5!*5!04AA46+:!#$9$##$'!14!&5!&!5$#*&1*A!

[&+2&1*46C!!

H;$!'&1&!94#!$&0;!0+&*A&61!*5!04AY*6$'!\*1;!1;$!50$6&#*4i5!&552A%1*465!&6'!1;$!"+&6!5%$0*9*05!*6!

4#'$#!14!%#4'20$!+*&Y*+*1*$5!&6'!9212#$!$c%$01$'!:$&#>Y:>:$&#!0&5;!9+4\5C!!

F&0;!0+&*A&61!*5!%#4f$01$'!94#\&#'!46$!:$&#!&1!&!1*A$C!!F&0;!:$&#e!1;$!A4'$+!&55$55$5!1;$!

%#4Y&Y*+*1:!49!1;$A!#$A&*6*67!&1!1;$!5&A$!'*5$&5$!51&7$e!0;&67*67!14!&641;$#!'*5$&5$!51&7$e!':*67!

9#4A!?@Je!':*67!9#4A!646>?@J!0&25$5e!26'$#74*67!&!5200$5592+!1#$&1A$61e!*602##*67!&6!$+*7*Y+$!

$c%$65$!]$C7C!'#27!1;$#&%:e!421>49>%40d$1`e!*602##*67!&!T455!49!I604A$!4#!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!0+&*A!

&6'!#$04[$#*67!9#4A!'*5&Y*+*1:!&6'!1;$#$Y:!0$&5*67!14!#$0$*[$!T455!49!I604A$!4#!T455!49!8$#[*0$5C!!!

F0464A*0!&6'!'$A47#&%;*0!&552A%1*465!&+467!\*1;!$+*7*Y+$!Y$6$9*1!&A42615!&#$!1;$6!1&d$6!*614!

&004261!14!0&+02+&1$!1;$!9212#$!0&5;!9+4\5!94#!2%!14!.--!:$&#5e!&5!\$++!&5!1;$!%#$5$61![&+2$5!49!1;$!

+*&Y*+*1*$5C!!N41;!0&5;!9+4\5!&6'!%#$5$61![&+2$5!&#$!52AA&#*h$'!Y:!0+&*A&61!&6'!Y:!Y$6$9*1!14!

9&0*+*1&1$!&6&+:5*5C!

Page 119: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! <M!

*+,+-.&U-+N-%::0+4&@+6C$%&

)!Y:>%#4'201!49!1;$!A4'$+!*5!1;$!&Y*+*1:!14!%#4'20$!9212#$!04;4#1!'*5$&5$!'*51#*Y21*465!5*A*+&#!14!

1;45$!%#$5$61$'!*6!1;$!KKWP!3$%4#1!&1!H&Y+$5!.MC.!14!.SC(C!!!

F%:C$.:&@+6C$%&

H;$!#$52+15!&#$!1;$6!52AA&#*h$'!*6![&#*425!#$%4#15!14!9&0*+*1&1$!#$[*$\!&6'!0;$0d*67!49!1;$!A4'$+e!

14!%#4[*'$!1;$!*694#A&1*46!6$0$55&#:!94#!*60+25*46!*6!1;*5!#$%4#1!&6'!14!Z2&61*9:!$99$015!49!

&552A%1*46!0;&67$5!&6'!5$65*1*[*1*$5C

Page 120: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! <S!

!""#$%&'(%(X!!"##$%&'()'$*+"$%,$-!!""#$%&'()"!

H;*5!*5!&!52AA&#:!49!1;$!A&*6!&012&#*&+!&552A%1*465!25$'!*6!1;*5!#$%4#1C!!H;$!,-.M!&552A%1*465!

\$#$!5$+$01$'!f4*61+:!\*1;!F0d+$#!&6'!&#$!1;$!5&A$!&5!F0d+$#!25$'!94#!1;$*#!,-.M!#$%4#1C!!H;$!,-.-!

&552A%1*465!25$'!Y:!K4#6$&2!8;$%$++!&#$!&+54!5;4\6!94#!04A%&#*546C!!84A$!49!1;$!&552A%1*465!

25$'!Y:!F0d+$#!*6!,-.-!'*99$#$'!9#4A!1;$!K4#6$&2!8;$%$++!&552A%1*465C!!H;$!&552A%1*465!&#$!

$c%+&*6$'!*6!A4#$!'$1&*+!*6!1;$!Y4':!49!1;*5!#$%4#1C!!

R*5$&5$!"#47#$55*46!! >!8$01*46!/!

@4;4#1!)552A%1*465!! >!8$01*46!=!

E1;$#!)552A%1*465! >!8$01*46!.!

/310'10!12'*01!

H;$!@4A%$65&1*46!"+&6!25$5!'*99$#$61!'$50#*%1*465!49!1;$![&#*425!+$[$+5!49!1;$!'*5$&5$!9#4A!1;$!

51&7$5!1;&1!&#$!25$'!*6!1;$!KKWP!3$%4#1C!!B2#1;$#e!54A$!51&7$5!25$'!*6!1;$!KKWP!3$%4#1!'4!641!

04##$5%46'!'*#$01+:!14!1;$!+$[$+5!46!\;*0;!04A%$65&1*46!*5!Y&5$'C!!

I6!%&#1*02+&#e!\$!26'$#51&6'!1;&1!646>Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5!64#A&++:!4002#5!54A$1*A$!'2#*67!1;$!

51&7$5!*'$61*9*$'!&5!B*Y#45*5!.!&6'!B*Y#45*5!,!*6!1;$!KKWP!3$%4#1C!!N:!&552A*67!1;&1!646>

Y#*'7*67!9*Y#45*5!4002#5!04*60*'$61!\*1;!B*Y#45*5!.e!\$!&#$!*60+2'*67!&!+$[$+!49!0465$#[&1*5A!*6!1;$!

#$52+15e!*60+2'*67!1;$!Y$51!$51*A&1$!#$52+15C!

H;$!94++4\*67!1&Y+$!5;4\5!1;$!1$#A5!1;&1!&#$!'$$A$'!14!Y$!$Z2*[&+$61!94#!%2#%45$5!49!&%%+:*67!

1;$!KKWP!51&7$5!14!1;$!"+&6i5!04A%$65&1*46!+$[$+5C!!!

!"#$%&Md'&2&>%L".0.0:&*&M0:%":%&/."N%:&"46&O%P%$:&

RRST)E(/Q,) RRST)E(/Q,)3,140'5('&#)

*&+5,#1/('&#)-./#)V,?,.1) *&+5,#1/('&#)-./#)3,140'5('&#)

B-]3Q)>`! B*Y#45*5!81&7$!-!X!3Q)!6$7&1*[$!

.! @+&*A&615!\;4!;&[$!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25!

B-]3Q)p`! B*Y#45*5!81&7$!-!X!3Q)!%45*1*[$!

,! "@3!1$51!%45*1*[$!

B.! B*Y#45*5!81&7$!.! !M!

Q46>N#*'7*67!B*Y#45*5!

B,! B*Y#45*5!81&7$!,!

BM! B*Y#45*5!81&7$!M! S! N#*'7*67!B*Y#45*5!

BS! @*##;45*5! /! @*##;45*5!

?@@! ?$%&140$++2+&#!@&60$#! !=!

@&60$#!

R$04A%! R$04A%$65&1$'!0*##;45*5! T*[$#!'$04A%$65&1*46!

H#&65%+&61! T*[$#!H#&65%+&61! T*[$#!H#&65%+&61!

R$&1;! T*[$#!#$+&1$'!'$&1;! ! R$&1;!

Page 121: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! </!

(,8,+2!'11-4523,.1!

!"#$%&MdB"&)&*+,+-.&/01%&2!-"4:DC:%6&*$"09"4.:&&

Disease Level Disease Stage Known Claimants

Unknown Claimants Total

Alive Claimants

1 F0 – RNA- 510 32 542

2 F0 – RNA+ 993 62 1,055

3 F1 449 28 477

3 F2 449 28 477

4 F3 175 11 186

5 Cirrhosis 158 10 168

6 Decompensated 36 4 40

6 Lymphoma 5 0 5

6 Renal 8 0 8

6 Cryoglobulinemia 10 0 10

6 Glomerulonephritis 2 0 2

6 Transplant 16 1 17

6 HCC 10 1 11

Total Alive 2,821 177 2,998

Deceased

Died before 1999 All 184 25 209

Died after 1998 - non HCV F0 – RNA- 179 10 189

F0 – RNA+ 166 10 176

F1 46 3 49

F2 - 0 -

F3 17 1 18

Cirrhosis 18 1 19

Level 6 13 1 14

Died after 1998 - HCV F0 – RNA- - 0 -

F0 – RNA+ 19 1 20

F1 23 1 24

F2 - 0 -

F3 11 1 12

Cirrhosis 73 4 77

Level 6 354 19 373

Total Deceased 1,103 77 1,180

Total Cohort 3,924 250 4,166

Page 122: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! <=!

H&Y+$!RC,Y!>!@4;4#1!8*h$!X?&$A4%;*+*&0!@+&*A&615!&

Disease Level Disease Stage Known Claimants

Unknown Claimants Total

Alive Claimants

1 F0 – RNA- !.S=! , !.S(!

2 F0 – RNA+ !.<,! M !.</!

3 F1 !.=M! M !.==!

3 F2 !.=M! M !.==!

4 F3 !(.! . !(,!

5 Cirrhosis !(,! . !(M!

6 Decompensated !,=! . !,U!

6 Lymphoma !M! - !M!

6 Renal !>! - !>!

6 Cryoglobulinemia !S! - !S!

6 Glomerulonephritis !.! - !.!

6 Transplant !=! - !=!

6 HCC !.-! - !.-!

Total Alive )MLL) )CJ) )MNC)

Deceased

Died before 1999 All !M-.! M !M-S!

Died after 1998 - non HCV F0 – RNA- !<! . !.-!

F0 – RNA+ !.U! , !.<!

F1 !.,! , !.S!

F2 !>! - !>!

F3 !.! - !.!

Cirrhosis !(! . !<!

Level 6 !M! - !M!

Died after 1998 - HCV F0 – RNA- !>! - !>!

F0 – RNA+ !.! - !.!

F1 !<! - !<!

F2 !>! - !>!

F3 !,! - !,!

Cirrhosis !,,! . !,M!

Level 6 !<U! , !<<!

Total Deceased )JMA) )CA) )JNJ)

Total Cohort )CKDIN) )AP) )CKDMI)

B4#!;&$A4%;*+*&05e!,/CUg!49!1;$!26d64\6!0+&*A&615!&#$!&552A$'!14!Y$!04*69$01$'!\*1;!?IJC!

!

Page 123: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! <U!

/310'10!5+,*+0113,.!

!"#$%&MdR&)&!-"4:0.0+4&U-+#"#0$0.0%:&

!0&+)E(/Q,) :&)E(/Q,):0/#1'('&#)U/(,1))ABCB)^)-2@3))

:0/#1'('&#)U/(,1)ABCD)^)=>)

:0/#1'('&#)U/(,1)

ABCD)^)-2@3)

B-]3Q)>`! B.! -C-g! -C-g! 8&A$!

B-]3Q)p`! B-]3Q)>`! .CUg! .CUg! !

B.! 8J@! 6l&! .CUg! !

B,! 8J@! 6l&! .C-g! !

BM! 8J@! 6l&! -C/g! !

B-]3Q)p`! B.! /CUg! /CSg! !

B.! B,! .SC/g! .,C-g! !

B,! BM! ./C-g! .MC/g! !

BM! BS! .,C-g! .MC(g! !

BS! R$04A%$65&1*46! =C/g! UC(g! !

R$04A%$65&1*46! H#&65%+&61! MCMg! -CSg! !

B.! ?@@! -C-.g! -C-.g! !

B,! ?@@! -C-.g! -C-.g! !

BM! ?@@! -C.g! -C.g! !

BS! ?@@! MCMg! ,C/g! !

R$04A%$65&1*46!! ?@@! 6l&! ,C/g! !

?@@! H#&65%+&61! .-C-g! -CSg! !

!

;DD%=.&+D&!-%".9%4.&+4&E0#-+:0:&U-+N-%::0+4&

H#$&1A$61!*5!&552A$'!14!Y$!0465*'$#$'!94#!&++!%&1*$615!&1!51&7$5!B-]3Q)p`!14!BSC!!)1!$&0;!49!1;$5$!

51&7$5!&!%$#0$61&7$!49!1;$!%&1*$615!&#$!7*[$6!1#$&1A$61e!&6'!&!%$#0$61&7$!49!1;45$!1#$&1$'!#$&01!

5200$5592++:!14!1;$!1#$&1A$61C!!!

B4#!,-.Me!\$!&552A$'!1;&1!=-g!49!0+&*A&615!\;4!;&[$!%#$[*425+:!Y$$6!1#$&1$'!;&[$!0+$&#$'!1;$!

[*#25C!

B4#!,-.Me!&++!d64\6!0+&*A&615!\;4!;&[$!641!%#$[*425+:!Y$$6!1#$&1$'!4#!;&[$!641!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25!

94++4\*67!&!%#*4#!1#$&1A$61!&#$!$+*7*Y+$!94#!46$!#426'!49!1#$&1A$61!'2#*67!1;$!%$#*4'!,-.S!14!

,-.(!\*1;!64!&''*1*46&+!1#$&1A$615!&552A$'!1;$#$&91$#C!!B4#!1;$!26d64\6!0+&*A&615e!\$!&552A$'!

$&0;!%$#546!\42+'!Y$!$+*7*Y+$!94#!46$!#426'!49!1#$&1A$61!*6!&004#'&60$!\*1;!1;$!1#$&1A$61!#&1$5!

Y$+4\!'2#*67!1;$!9*[$>:$&#!%$#*4'!94++4\*67!1;$*#!&%%#4[&+C!!!

Page 124: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! <(!

!"#$%&MdW"&)&!-%".9%4.&U-+#"#0$0.0%:&2&BI'R&

)

:0,/(+,#()W/X?,))

S'(;&"()<YZ)

:0,/(+,#()W/X?,))

S'(;)<YZ)

-0,?'&"1.[):0,/(,$))

S'(;&"()<YZ)

-0,?'&"1.[):0,/(,$))

S'(;)<YZ)

:0,/(+,#()0/(,)F5,0)/##"+G) MSC-g! .<CMg! M(C,g! .UC/g!

-,04,#()&2):0,/(+,#(1)"1'#Q\) ) ) ) )

• "FP>IBQl3NJ! -g! -g! -g! -g!

• "FP>IBQl3NQ!Y&5$'!1#*%+$!1;$#&%:! .SCMg! (CMg! UC.g! (CMg!

• 84945Y2[*#>Y&5$'!'42Y+$1! /-C-g! ,/g! M/CUg! (CMg!

• M'!#$7*A$6!%+25!3NJ! M/CUg! ==CUg! /UC.g! (MCSg!

:0,/(+,#()>22'4/4[) ) ) ) )

• "FP>IBQl3NJ! S/C/g! MUC.g! MUCSg! M-C/g!

• "FP>IBQl3NQ!Y&5$'!1#*%+$!1;$#&%:! U-C-g! UMC/g! /MC(g! /MC(g!

• 84945Y2[*#>Y&5$'!'42Y+$1! <SC=g! (-C,g! </CSg! (-C<g!

• M'!#$7*A$6!%+25!3NJ! <=C,g! (.C=g! <=CMg! (.CUg!

@##"/.)*"0,)U/(,]) M.C,g! ./C=g! M/C/g! .MC<g!

I^_,/0)*"0,)U/(,]]) MB`Aa) ID`Ba) MJ`Ia) JM`Na)

o! H;$!&662&+!02#$!#&1$!*5!1;$!%$#0$61!49!&++!0+&*A&615!\;4!;&'!641!#$0$*[$'!1#$&1A$61!5*60$!.!V&62&#:!,-.S!

\;4!&#$!&552A$'!14!Y$!02#$'!1;#427;!1&d*67!'#27!1#$&1A$61C!H;$!A$'*0&+!A4'$+!&552A$5!1;&1!46+:!46$!

1#$&1A$61!#$7*A$6!\*++!Y$!7*[$6!%$#!0+&*A&61!46!&6'!&91$#!.!V&62&#:!,-.Se!#$7&#'+$55!49!&6:!1#$&1A$615!

#$0$*[$'!%#*4#!14!1;&1C!

oo! H;$!/>L$&#!@2#$!#&1$!*5!1;$!%$#0$61&7$!49!&++!0+&*A&615!\;4!&#$!&552A$'!14!Y$!02#$'!'2#*67!1;$!%$#*4'!

,-.S!14!,-.(C!

)!%&1*$61!\;4!*5!5200$5592++:!1#$&1$'!*5!&552A$'!14!#$A&*6!&1!1;$*#!'*5$&5$!+$[$+!94#!+*9$e!\*1;!1;$!

$c0$%1*46!49!1;45$!&1!BS!\;4!&#$!&552A$'!14!1#&65*1*46!14!'$04A%$65&1*46!&1!;&+9!1;$!#$72+&#!#&1$C!

B4#!1;$!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465e!\$!&552A$'!1;$!1#$&1A$61!$99*0&0:!\*++!Y$!(-g!49!1;$!

Y$51!$51*A&1$!$99*0&0:!#&1$5C!

B4#!1;$!,-.-![&+2&1*46e!\$!&552A$'!1;&1!1#$&1A$61!\&5!7*[$6!&1!&6:!1*A$!94#!51&7$5!B.!14!BS!\*1;!

64!+*A*1!14!1;$!62AY$#!49!%455*Y+$!1#$&1A$615!%$#!0+&*A&61!]1#$&1A$61!&91$#!&7$!=/!\&5!&552A$'!

\*1;!1;$!.-g!#&1$!#$'20$'!14!MCMg`C!

!"#$%&MdW#&)&!-%".9%4.&U-+#"#0$0.0%:&)&BI'I&

E(/Q,)

-,04,#(/Q,)&2)/..)-/(',#(1)7;&)U,4,'?,)

:0,/(+,#()E"44,112".)U,15&#1,)@+&#Q):;&1,):0,/(,$)

E"44,112".)U,15&#1,)

@+&#Q)/..)-/(',#(1)

B.! .-C-g! S<C-g! SC<g!

B,! .-C-g! S<C-g! SC<g!

BM! .-C-g! S<C-g! SC<g!

BS! .-C-g! M.C-g! MC.g!

Page 125: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! <<!

I6!,-.-e!&!5200$5592++:!1#$&1$'!%&1*$61!\&5!&552A$'!14!Y$!52Yf$01!14!1#&65*1*46!%#4Y&Y*+*1*$5!&1!

.-g!49!1;$!1#&65*1*46!#&1$5C!!H;$!#$'20$'!%#4Y&Y*+*1:!&%%+*$'!&1!&++!51&7$5!14!+*[$#!'$04A%$65&1*46!

94#!1;$!%&1*$61i5!9212#$!+*9$!Y21!'*'!641!&99$01!1;$!1#&65*1*46!#&1$5!14!0&60$#!]?@@`C!!

!

,280+!'11-4523,.1!

@+-."$0.A&X::C9L.0+4:&

9$:4-!*`'!D!2/%&$4+&L!J,,?@8&+/1,aa!

@11"+5('&#) ABCB) ABCD)^)=>) ABCD)^)-2@3)

K4#1&+*1:!9#4A!&++!0&25$5!41;$#!1;&6!?@J!

@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$5!,---!14!,--,!94#!1#&65925$'C!.U/g!49!@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$5!,---!14!,--,!94#!;&$A4%;*+*&05C!

@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$5!,--<!14!,-..!94#!1#&65925$'!&6'!;&$A4%;*+*&05C!!

8&A$!

K4#1&+*1:!9#4A!&++!0&25$5!41;$#!1;&6!?@J!94#!1;45$!04>*69$01$'!\*1;!?IJ!

=,Sg!49!1;$!@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$5!!,---!14!,--,!

=,Sg!49!1;$!@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$5!,--<!14!,-..!

8&A$!

K4#1&+*1:!'2$!14!?@J!9#4A!T$[$+!=!X!R$04A%$65&1*46!

.(C=g! P#$&1$#!49!@&6&'&!T*9$!A4#1&+*1:o!&6'!./C,g!

8&A$!

K4#1&+*1:!'2$!14!?@J!9#4A!T$[$+!=!X!?@@!X!0&60$#!

M/C-g! P#$&1$#!49!@&6&'&!T*9$!A4#1&+*1:o!&6'!.(C,g!

8&A$!

K4#1&+*1:!'2$!14!?@J!9#4A!+*[$#!1#&65%+&61!- 9*#51!:$&#!- 1;$#$&91$#!

!!.SC=g!!!SCSg!

P#$&1$#!49!@&6&'&!T*9$!A4#1&+*1:o!&6'a!(C=g!MC<g!

8&A$!

P$6'$#!94#!A4#1&+*1:!1&Y+$!- H#&65925$'!@4;4#1!!

!N&5$'!46!0+&*A&61i5!7$6'$#C!!W;$#$!7$6'$#!641!51&1$'e!S(C(g!A&+$C!

!N&5$'!46!0+&*A&61i5!7$6'$#C!!W;$#$!7$6'$#!641!51&1$'e!S<C,g!A&+$C!

!8&A$!

- ?&$A4%;*+*&0!@4;4#1!!

N&5$'!46!0+&*A&61i5!7$6'$#C!!W;$#$!7$6'$#!641!51&1$'e!(/C-g!A&+$C!

N&5$'!46!0+&*A&61i5!7$6'$#C!!W;$#$!7$6'$#!641!51&1$'e!(SCUg!A&+$C!

8&A$!

<''*%$'9-/-1-'Y)A$'5"&!->)!2'?!)>)Z$1')/4>?1$+'!%$'[ODI'-1\?+!5$/!'A"&'4"Q)/A$4!$1',$&+"/+8'

<<'7"&'OHBH6'!%$'5"&!->)!2'-++?5,!)"/+'($&$'!%$'+-5$'A"&'.$+!'$+!)5-!$'-/1',&"0)+)"/'A"&'-10$&+$'1$0)-!)"/+8'

!

! !

Page 126: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .--!

9$:4-!*`=$!)!VSR-,,!B"CD7-4$&-3!2/%&$4+&L!D!G<;H!

) 3'1,/1,)V,?,.)>O5,4(,$)

@?,0/Q,))) C) A) D) J) I) P)

*./'+/#(1)7;&);/?,)#&()4.,/0,$)(;,)?'0"1) ) ) ) )

?@J!R$&1;! -g! .-g! M/g! S/g! (-g! .--g! MMg!

Q46>?@J!R$&1;! .--g! <-g! =/g! //g! ,-g! -g! =Ug!

*./'+/#(1)7;&);/?,)4.,/0,$)(;,)?'0"1) ) ) ) )

?@J!R$&1;! -g! -g! -g! ,/g! =-g! .--g! ,,g!

Q46>?@J!R$&1;! .--g! .--g! .--g! U/g! S-g! -g! U(g!

B4#!,-.Me!1;$!&552A%1*465!94#!Y$51!$51*A&1$!&6'!%#4[*5*46!94#!&'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465!&#$!1;$!5&A$C!!

H;$!%$#0$61&7$5!94#!$c0$55!?@J>#$+&1$'!A4#1&+*1:!&#$!&%%+*$'!14!&++40&1$!'$&1;5!Y&5$'!46!1;$!@&6&'&!T*9$!H&Y+$5!Y$1\$$6!1;45$!1;&1!&#$!0465*'$#$'!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!&6'!1;45$!1;&1!&#$!641!0465*'$#$'!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5C!!H;$5$!?@J!#$+&1$'!'$&1;5!&#$!*6!&''*1*46!14!1;45$!&552A$'!26'$#!1;$!KKWP!A4'$+!&5!5$1!421!*6!8$01*46!/C!!!

H;$!KKWP!A4'$+!\&5!0;&67$'!94#!,-.M!14!&552A$!1;&1!&++!'$&1;5!&1!+$[$+!=!&#$!&5!&!#$52+1!49!?@JC!!

!

H;$!,-.-!&552A%1*465!\$#$!&%%+*$'!46+:!14!1;45$!\;4!;&'!641!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25C!

9$:4-!*`=:!)!VSR-,,!B"CD7-4$&-3!2/%&$4+&L!D!G<;<!

) 3'1,/1,)V,?,.)

)) C) A) D) J) I) P)

>O5,4(,$)

@?,0/Q,)

=,1()>1('+/(,)?@J!R$&1;! -g! .-g! S-g! /-g! (-g! (-g! MMg!

Q46>?@J!R$&1;! .--g! <-g! =-g! /-g! ,-g! ,-g! =Ug!

-0&?'1'&#)2&0)@$?,01,)3,?'/('&#) ! ! ! ! !

?@J!R$&1;! -g! ,-g! /-g! =/g! <-g! <-g! S/g!

Q46>?@J!R$&1;! .--g! (-g! /-g! M/g! .-g! .-g! //g!

!

!

& &

Page 127: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .-.!

;=+4+90=&X::C9L.0+4:&

9$:4-!*`b!D!VR/1/@+R!J,,?@8&+/1,!

)ABCB)

)ABCD)

@11,()*./11) @..&4/('&#)>O5,4(,$)U,("0#)

*&#(0'b"('&#)(&)!"#$)U,("0#)

)@..&4/('&#)

>O5,4(,$)U,("0#)

*&#(0'b"('&#)(&)!"#$)U,("0#)

D6*[$#5$!N46'5! MCUg! ,C<-g! -C..g! ! /C-g! SC.-g! -C,.g!

8;4#1!H$#A!N46'5! =C<g! ,C/-g! -C.Ug! ! =CUg! SC.-g! -C,Ug!

3$&+!#$12#6!Y46'5! ==C-g! MCM/g! ,C,.g! ! =SC-g! ,C<-g! .C(=g!

FZ2*1*$5! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

!>!@&6&'&! SCMg! UC/-g! -CM,g! ! /CUg! UC=-g! -CSMg!

!>!!D8! .C/g! UC/-g! -C..g! ! ,C(g! UC=-g! -C,.g!

!>!!I61$#6&1*46&+! .CUg! UC/-g! -C.Mg! ! ,C(-g! UC=-g! -C,.g!

Q41*46&+!&55$15! ./C<g! ,C/-g! -CS-g! ! .MC-g! MC.-g! -CS-g!

Fc%$01$'!#$12#6! .--C-g! !! MCS/g! !! .--C-g! !! MC=-g!

3$Y&+&60*67!$99$01! ! ! -C.,g! ! ! ! -C,Sg!

T$55!I69+&1*46! ! ! >,C,/g! ! ! ! >,C/-g!

T$55!Fc%$65$5! ! ! >-C-Sg! ! ! ! >-C-Sg!

3'14&"#()0/(,)^)=>) )) )) C`AMa) )) !! !! C`DBa)

"#4[*5*46!94#!)'[$#5$!R$[*&1*465!

! ! >-C,Mg! ! ! ! >-C,/g!

3'14&"#()U/(,)^)-2@3) )) )) C`BIa) )) )) )) C`BIa)

!

& &

Page 128: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .-,!

X::C9L.0+4:&X#+C.&Z%4%D0.&X9+C4.:&

N$6$9*1!&A42615!\*1;!&![&+2$!5;4\6!94#!.<<<!&#$!&A42615!5$1!421!*6!1;$!"+&6C!!W;$#$!1;$#$!*5!64!

[&+2$!5;4\6!94#!.<<<e!1;$!&A42615!&#$!-++?5,!)"/+!&Y421!1;$!$c%$01$'!&A4261!49!&!0+&*AC!!

!"#$%&MdV&2&X::C9L.0+4:&"#+C.&Z%4%D0.&X9+C4.:& !

! !

=,#,2'() CNNN)@+&"#() ABCBOO) ABCD)^)=>) ABCD)^)-2@3)

T$[$+!.! .-e---! .,eUSSC,M! 13,457.74 ! 8&A$!

T$[$+!,! ,-e---! ,/eS((CS=! 26,915.48 ! 8&A$!

T$[$+!M! M-e---! M(e,M,C=<! 40,373.22 ! 8&A$!

T$[$+!/! =/e---! (,e(MUC/-! 87,475.30 ! 8&A$!

T$[$+!=! .--e---! .,UeSS,CM-! 134,577.39 ! 8&A$!

T455!49!5$#[*0$5!>!A&c*A2A! .,eS(-! ./e<-SC(-! 16,795.26 ! 8&A$!

T455!49!5$#[*0$5!X!&552A$'!Y$6$9*1!

• 1#&65925$'!

• ;&$A4%;*+*&0!

! !./e---!./e---!

!.=e---!.=e---!

!8&A$!

T455!49!*604A$!>!A&c*A2A! M--e---!,M! M(,eM,U! 403,732! 8&A$!

T455!49!*604A$!X!&552A$'!Y$6$9*1!

• 1#&65925$'!

• ;&$A4%;*+*&0!

! !M/e---!M(e---!

!M<e---!S(e---!

!SMe---!/Me---!

@451!49!@&#$!]+$[$+!=`! ! .=e---,S! M-e---! S/e---!

?@J!R#27!H;$#&%:!A461;+:!&A4261! .e---! .e,US! 1,346! 8&A$!

?@J!R#27!H;$#&%:!141&+!0+&*A! ! .Se-.<! 4,440 ! Se(S/!

D6*652#$'!1#$&1A$61!&6'!A$'*0&1*46!94#!1;45$!\;4!;&[$!641!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25a!

• 1#&65925$'!

• ;&$A4%;*+*&0!

H#$&1A$61!04515!&5540*&1$'!\*1;!1#$&1A$61!94#!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25!

• "FP>IBQl3N@>Y&5$'!1#*%+$!1;$#&%:!

• 84945Y2[*#>Y&5$'!'42Y+$15!

• MR!#$7*A$6!%+25!3NJ!

"$#0$61!49!1#$&1A$61!04515!#$*AY2#5$'!Y:!1;$!B26'!

• @+&*A&615!26'$#!=/!

• @+&*A&615!4[$#!=/!

! !!

Me---,/!Se---!

!!

!*60+C!&Y4[$!

!!

.e/--!Me/--!

!!

!=-e---!(/e---!(/e---!

!

!!

=-g!.--g!

!!

.e/--!Me/--!

!!

!!

..-e---!!

!!!

=-g!.--g!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

,,!! H;$!,-.-!&552A%1*465!&Y421!Y$6$9*15!&A42615!&#$!1;$!5&A$!94#!Y$51!F51*A&1$!&6'!"#4[*5*46!94#!)'[$#5$!'$[*&1*465e!\*1;!1;$!$c0$%1*46!49!@451!49!@&#$!&6'!D6*652#$'!H#$&1A$61!&6'!K$'*0&1*46C!

,M!! I6!,--(e!1;$!042#15!*60#$&5$'!1;$!A&c*A2A!T455!49!I604A$!14!j,eM--e---e!Y21!+*A*1$'!*1!14!1;#$$!d64\6!0+&*A&615C!!B212#$!0+&*A&615!\*1;!+455$5!*6!$c0$55!49!jM--e---!].<<<!'4++&#5`!A&:!&%%+:!14!1;$!042#15!94#!&!#$[*$\!49!1;$*#!+455C!

,S!! B4#!,-.-e!1;$!"9)R!&552A%1*46!94#!@451!49!@&#$!*5!&6!&[$#&7$!49!j,.e---!%$#!:$&#C!!

Page 129: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .-M!

!"#$%&MdV&2&X::C9L.0+4:&"#+C.&Z%4%D0.&X9+C4.:& !

! !

=,#,2'() CNNN)@+&"#() ABCBOO) ABCD)^)=>) ABCD)^)-2@3)

E21>49>%40d$1!Fc%$65$5a!

0+&*A&615!\;4!;&[$!641!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25!

• 1#&65925$'!

• ;&$A4%;*+*&0!

0+&*A&615!2%46!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25!

• 1#&65925$'!

• ;&$A4%;*+*&0!

! !

!

.eU--!

,e/--!

!

6l&!!

6l&!

!

!

.e(--!

,e=--!

!

.e,--!

/e---!

!

!

.e(--!

,e=--!

!

,eS--!

.-e---!

D6*652#$'!B26$#&+!Fc%$65$5!!

• A&c*A2A!

• &552A$'!&[$#&7$!0+&*A!

!!

/e---!6l&!

!=eMU,!/e---!

!=eU,<!SeM--!

!8&A$!

?&$A4%;*+*&0!@4*69$01$'!\*1;!?IJ!+2A%!52A!4%1*46!

/-e---! =MeU,.! =Ue,(<! 8&A$!

3,/(;)50'&0)(&)CNNN)T2A%!82A!E%1*465!

• j/-e---!%+25!

• j.,-e---!

• jU,e---!]04*69$01$'!;&$A4%;*+*&0`!

!!

/-e---!.,-e---!U,e---!

!!

=MeU,.!./,e<M.!<.eU/(!

!!

=Ue,(<!.=.eS<M!<=e(<=!

!!

8&A$!

B&A*+:!N$6$9*15!!

• 1#&65925$'!

• ;&$A4%;*+*&0!

! !(-e---!(-e---!

!U/e---!(/e---!

!8&A$!

R$%$6'&61!Y$6$9*15!X!T455!49!82%%4#1!

• 1#&65925$'!

• ;&$A4%;*+*&0!

! !M-e---!M,e---!

!M-e---!MSe---!

!MSe---!M=e---!

R$%$6'&61!Y$6$9*15!X!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!

• 1#&65925$'!

• ;&$A4%;*+*&0!

! !./e---!./e---!

!.=e---!.=e---!

!8&A$!

3,/(;)/2(,0)CNNN)B&A*+:!N$6$9*15!!

• 1#&65925$'!

• ;&$A4%;*+*&0!

! !!

//e---!//e---!

!!

/-e---!=-e---!

!!

8&A$!

R$%$6'&61!Y$6$9*15!X!T455!49!82%%4#1!

• I9!02##$61+:!#$0$*[*67!+455!49!*604A$!

• H#&65925$'!

• ?&$A4%;*+*&0!

! !M-e---!M-e---!M,e---!

!U-g!49!TEI!

M.e---!MMe---!

!U-g!49!TEI!

MSe---!M=e---!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

,/!! B4#!D6*652#$'!H#$&1A$61!&6'!K$'*0&1*46e!1;$!"9)R!&552A%1*46!94#!,-.-!*5!&6!&[$#&7$!0+&*A!*6!,-..!49!jMe---!94#!1#&65925$'!&6'!jSe---!94#!;&$A4%;*+*&05!\*1;!1;$!&A4261!*60#$&5*67!&662&++:!1;$#$&91$#!Y:!/g!*6!&''*1*46!14!*69+&1*46C!!

Page 130: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .-S!

!"#$%&MdV&2&X::C9L.0+4:&"#+C.&Z%4%D0.&X9+C4.:& !

! !

=,#,2'() CNNN)@+&"#() ABCBOO) ABCD)^)=>) ABCD)^)-2@3)

R$%$6'&61!Y$6$9*15!X!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!

• @2##$61+:!#$0$*[*67!+455!49!5$#[*0$5!

• H#&65925$'!

• ?&$A4%;*+*&0!

! !./e---!./e---!./e---!

!.=e---!.=e---!.=e---!

!8&A$!

?IJ!"#47#&A! ,S-e---! M-/e(=,! M,,e<(=! 8&A$!

!

!

!"#$%&MdT&2&X::C9L.0+4:&"#+C.&;$0N0#0$0.A&"46&!0904N&+D&*+9L%4:".0+4&U"A9%4.:&

=,#,2'()-/[+,#() ABCB) ABCD)^)=>) ABCD)^)-2@3)

K/,,!/A!O1R/@-)X!T$[$+!M!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!

!Mg!$+$01!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!$+$01!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!Mg!$+$01!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!$+$01!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!8&A$!

K/,,!/A!P-%I+R-,'X!T$[$+!M!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!

!,g!$+$01!26'$#!&7$!=/!/g!$+$01!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!,g!$+$01!26'$#!&7$!=/!Ug!$+$01!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!8&A$!

K/,,!/A!O1R/@-!X!T$[$+5!S!&6'!/!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!X!

26d64\6!!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!>!

d64\6,=!

!.(g!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!Ug!1#&65925$'!

-g!;&$A4%;*+*&0!

!,.g!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!/C(g!1#&65925$'!

MC,g!;&$A4%;*+*&0!

!8&A$!

K/,,!/A!O1R/@-!X!T$[$+!=!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!>!

26d64\6!!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!>!d64\6!!

!.Ug!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!-g!1#&65925$'!

-g!;&$A4%;*+*&0!

!,/g!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!-g!1#&65925$'!

-g!;&$A4%;*+*&0!

!8&A$!

K/,,!/A!P-%I+R-,!X!T$[$+5!S!&6'!/!!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!>!

26d64\6!!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!>!d64\6!!

- H#&65925$'!!- ?&$A4%;*+*&0!

!M<g!26'$#!&7$!=/!/Ug!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!!

..g!26'$#!&7$!=/!,/g!4[$#!&7$!=S!/g!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!M-g!26'$#!&7$!=/!/.g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!!

=CUg!26'$#!&7$!=/!,UCMg!!4[$#!&7$!=S!-g!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!8&A$!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

,=!! H;$!d64\6!%#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!&%%+*$5!14!d64\6!0+&*A&615!&+#$&':!&1!1;$!*6'*0&1$'!+$[$+!\;4!;&[$!641!:$1!04AA$60$'!&!0+&*AC!!O64\6!0+&*A&615!&+#$&':!46!0+&*A!&#$!&552A$'!14!0461*62$C!!O64\6!0+&*A&615!\;4!1#&65*1*46!*614!&!+$[$+!&#$!&552A$'!14!0+&*A!Y&5$'!46!1;$!#&1$5!94#!26d64\6!0+&*A&615C!

Page 131: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .-/!

!"#$%&MdT&2&X::C9L.0+4:&"#+C.&;$0N0#0$0.A&"46&!0904N&+D&*+9L%4:".0+4&U"A9%4.:&

=,#,2'()-/[+,#() ABCB) ABCD)^)=>) ABCD)^)-2@3)

K/,,!/A!P-%I+R-,!X!T$[$+!=!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!>!

26d64\6!!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!>!d64\6!!

- H#&65925$'!!- ?&$A4%;*+*&0!

!

!/Ug!26'$#!&7$!=/!USg!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!!

,/g!26'$#!&7$!=/!.(g!4[$#!&7$!=S!.-g!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!S-g!26'$#!&7$!=/!=/g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!!

/CMg!26'$#!&7$!=/!S-C<g!!4[$#!&7$!=S!-g!26'$#!&7$!=/!-g!4[$#!&7$!=S!

!8&A$!

"/,&!/A!"$%-!!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!!

!S/g!$&0;!:$&#!

"9)Ra!//g!$&0;!:$&#!

!S-g!$&0;!:$&#!

!8&A$!

*%?0!9#-%$8L!! I60*'$60$!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!

! T$[$+!,!! T$[$+!M!! T$[$+!S!! T$[$+!/!

!T$[$+!M!&6'!Y$:46'!

!-g!=-g!U-g!(-g!

!.--g!49!0+&*A&615!

04*60*'$61!\*1;!26'$#74*67!1#$&1A$61!

!.--g!49!0+&*A&615!

04*60*'$61!\*1;!26'$#74*67!1#$&1A$61!

]1+1,?%-3!9%-$&@-1&!^!2-3+R$&+/1!"#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!]49!1;45$!\;4!;&[$!641!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25`a!! H#&65925$'!! ?&$A4%;*+*&0!@+&*A&615!Y$*67!1#$&1$'!94#!%2#%45$!49!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25!

!!!!

Gb!!

!!!!

SC/g!UC/g!

I6!&004#'&60$!\*1;!H&Y+$!RCS&!

!!!!

8&A$!

T?&D/AD8/RU-&!-S8-1,-,!!! I60*'$60$!!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!!

- H#&65925$'!- ?&$A4%;*+*&0!

!Q$\!0+&*A&615!&6'!!&++!&1!+$[$+5!M!14!=!

,/g!49!6$\!0+&*A&615!/g!&1!+$[$+5!M!14!=!Ug!&1!+$[$+5!M!14!=!

!@+&*A&615!\;4!;&[$!641!0+$&#$'!1;$![*#25!

!(g!&1!+$[$+5!.!14!=!(g!&1!+$[$+5!.!14!=!

.--g!04*60*'$61!\*1;!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25!!

!8&A$!

P-R/13$%+4L!O1A-R&-3!.-%,/1,!!! )++!8I"!0+&*A&615!*60+2'$'!*6!d64\6!

&6'!26d64\6!04;4#1C!

)++!8I"!0+&*A&615!*60+2'$'!*6!d64\6!

&6'!26d64\6!04;4#1C!

8&A$!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

,U!! D6*652#$'!H#$&1A$61!&6'!K$'*0&1*46!&552A%1*46!94#!,-.-!\&5!Sg!49!1#&65925$'!&6'!=C/g!49!;&$A4%;*+*&0!0+&*A&615!&1!+$[$+5!,!14!=!\*++!;&[$!&!0+&*A!$&0;!:$&#C!!H;$#$!\&5!64!5$%&#&1$!&552A%1*46!#$+&1$'!14!1;$!0451!49!1#$&1A$61!94#!1;$!%2#%45$!49!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25C!

Page 132: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .-=!

!"#$%&MdT&2&X::C9L.0+4:&"#+C.&;$0N0#0$0.A&"46&!0904N&+D&*+9L%4:".0+4&U"A9%4.:&

=,#,2'()-/[+,#() ABCB) ABCD)^)=>) ABCD)^)-2@3)

M'<E<<<!\?44!P-&&4-@-1&!T8&+/1!!! I60*'$60$!!! "#4%4#1*46!0+&*A*67!

!?&$A4%;*+*&05!\*1;!

?@J!&6'!?IJ!.--g!+$[$+!.!&6'!,-g!+$[$+!,!\;4!;&[$!641!:$1!A&'$!&6!$+$01*46!

!?&$A4%;*+*&05!\*1;!

?@J!&6'!?IJ!.--g!+$[$+!.!

!8&A$!

B"C!%-4$&-3!3-$&#!:-A/%-!!;D_$1D;FFF!>!H#&65925$''! O64\6!0+&*A&615!

!! D6d64\6!0+&*A&615!!

!!

"&:&Y+$!&5!$+$01$'C!!

S(g!$+$01!j.,-e---!/,g!$+$01!j/-e---p!

!.--g!>!926$#&+!$c%$65$!

.--g!>!9&A*+:!Y$6$9*15!,-g!>!T455!49!82%%4#1!(-g!>!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!

!!

"&:&Y+$!&5!$+$01$'C!!

S(g!$+$01!j.,-e---!/,g!$+$01!j/-e---p!

!.--g!>!926$#&+!$c%$65$!

.--g!>!9&A*+:!Y$6$9*15!,-g!>!T455!49!82%%4#1!(-g!>!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!

!!

8&A$!

B"C!%-4$&-3!3-$&#!:-A/%-!!;D_$1D;FFF!>!?&$A4%;*+*&0''! O64\6!@+&*A&61!

!D6d64\6!@+&*A&615!

!!

"&:&Y+$!&5!$+$01$'!!

-g!$+$01!!!jU,e---!S(g!$+$01!j.,-e---!/,g!$+$01!j/-e---p!

!.--g!>!926$#&+!$c%$65$!

.--g!>!9&A*+:!Y$6$9*15!,-g!>!T455!49!82%%4#1!(-g!>!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!

!!

"&:&Y+$!&5!$+$01$'C!!

-g!$+$01!!!jU,e---!S(g!$+$01!j.,-e---!/,g!$+$01!j/-e---p!

!.--g!>!926$#&+!$c%$65$!

.--g!>!9&A*+:!Y$6$9*15!/-g!>!T455!49!82%%4#1!/-g!>!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!

!!

8&A$!

B"C!%-4$&-3!3-$&#!$A&-%!;FFNGN!! R$&1;5!%#*4#!14!,-.S!94#!

d64\6!0+&*A&615!!

! B212#$!'$&1;5!&6'!26d64\6!0+&*A&615!

!@461*62$!&1!02##$61!

&A4261!%+25!*6'$c*67!!!

.--g!>!926$#&+!$c%$65$!.--g!>!9&A*+:!Y$6$9*15!.-g!>!T455!49!82%%4#1!S-g!>!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!

!@461*62$!&1!02##$61!

&A4261!%+25!*6'$c*67!!!

.--g!>!926$#&+!$c%$65$!.--g!>!9&A*+:!Y$6$9*15!//g!>!T455!49!82%%4#1,<!,-g>T455!49!8[05!y=/M-!=-g>T455!49!8[05!z=/M.!

!8&A$!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

,(!! B4#!'$&1;5!\;*+$!#$0$*[*67!T455!49!I604A$!4#!8$#[*0$5e!\$!&552A$!1;$!'$%$6'&615!\*++!0+&*A!&!T455!49!82%%4#1!4#!8$#[*0$5!.--g!49!1;$!1*A$!&6'!T455!49!82%%4#1!\*++!Y$!U-g!49!1;$!+451!*604A$!&A4261C!!

,<!! !T455!49!82%%4#1!%#*4#!14!'&1$!0+&*A&61!\42+'!;&[$!&11&*6$'!=/!\*1;!T455!49!8$#[*0$5!&91$#C!O64\6!0+&*A&615!641!02##$61+:!46!T455!49!I604A$e!S/g!\*++!7$1!T455!49!82%%4#1!&6'!/g!T455!49!8$#[*0$5C!

M-!! T455!49!8$#[*0$5!&%%+*$5!94#!'$&1;5!%#*4#!14!=/!&6'!*5!%&:&Y+$!94#!+*9$!$c%$01&60:!49!0+&*A&61C!O64\6!0+&*A&615!641!02##$61+:!46!T455!49!I604A$e!S/g!\*++!7$1!T455!49!82%%4#1!&6'!/g!T455!49!8$#[*0$5C!!

M.!! T455!49!8$#[*0$5!&%%+*$5!94#!'$&1;5!&91$#!&7$!=/!&6'!*5!%&:&Y+$!94#!+*9$!$c%$01&60:!49!0+&*A&61C!B4#!d64\6!0+&*A&615!641!02##$61+:!46!T455!49!I604A$e!S-g!\*++!7$1!T455!49!8$#[*0$5C!

Page 133: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .-U!

!"#$%&MdT&2&X::C9L.0+4:&"#+C.&;$0N0#0$0.A&"46&!0904N&+D&*+9L%4:".0+4&U"A9%4.:&

=,#,2'()-/[+,#() ABCB) ABCD)^)=>) ABCD)^)-2@3)

T?&,&$13+10!.$L@-1&,! "#4[*'$'!Y:!&'A*6*51#&14#!

"#4[*'$'!Y:!&'A*6*51#&14#!

8&A$!

BOC!P-R/13$%+4L!O1A-R&-3!! I764#$'! Q4!0+&*A5! 8&A$!

BOC!.%/0%$@! =!9212#$!%&:A$615!49!j,S-e---!$&0;!%+25!

&'A*6!04515!49!j.,e---!14!,-..!

/!9212#$!%&:A$615!49!j,S-e---!$&0;!

4002##*67!$[$#:!M!:$&#5!

8&A$!

!

!!!

9$:4-!*`;<!)!7-R/I-%L!7$&-,!A%/@!K/,,!/A!O1R/@-!$13!K/,,!/A!P-%I+R-,!JA&-%!"4-$%+10!&#-!C+%?,!!!

) =,1()>1('+/(,) ) -2@3)

L$&#5!8*60$!R*5&Y*+*1:!T$[$+5!M!k!S! T$[$+!/! T$[$+!=! !

T$[$+5!M!k!S! T$[$+!/! T$[$+!=!

.! /-C-g! ,/C-g! -g! ! ,/g! .Mg! -g!

,! M-C-g! ./C-g! -g! ! ./g! (g! -g!

M! ,/C-g! .,C/g! -g! ! .Mg! Ug! -g!

S! ,/C-g! .,C/g! -g! ! .Mg! Ug! -g!

/! ./C-g! UC/g! -g! ! (g! Sg! -g!

=! .-C-g! /C-g! -g! ! /g! Mg! -g!

U! /C-g! ,C/g! -g! ! Mg! ,g! -g!

(! /C-g! ,C/g! -g! ! Mg! .g! -g!

<p! -C-g! -C-g! -g! ! -g! -g! -g!

Page 134: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .-(!

!""#$%&'(#(X!!"#$$%&'(#)(*+&,$(-$!"!

)'A*6*51#&14#! @#&\94#'!@+&55!)01*46!8$#[*0$5e!&!'*[*5*46!49!@#&\94#'!k!@4A%&6:!

F0d+$#!3$%4#1! )012&#*&+!3$%4#1!14!1;$!V4*61!@4AA*11$$!)55$55*67!1;$!B*6&60*&+!

8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!H#251!&5!49!R$0$AY$#!M.e!,-.-e!

%#$%&#$'!Y:!3*0;&#'!N4#'$#e!BI)e!B@I)e!&6'!W$6':!?&##*546e!B8)e!B@I)C!

?&$A4%;*+*&0!@4;4#1! H;$!7#42%!49!&%%#4[$'!0+&*A&615!\;4!&#$!;&$A4%;*+*&05C!

?IJ!"#47#&A! )!04A%$65&1*46!%#47#&A!94#!%$4%+$!\;4!&#$!5$046'&#*+:!*69$01$'!\*1;!

?IJ!&6'!\;$#$!1;$!%#*A&#*+:!*69$01$'!%$#546!*5!$+*7*Y+$!94#!Y$6$9*15!9#4A!

1;$!Fc1#&4#'*6&#:!)55*51&60$!"#47#&AC!H;$#$!*5!64!#$Z2*#$A$61!1;&1!

1;$:!&+54!Y$!*69$01$'!\*1;!?@JC!

?IJ!@4>*69$01*46! R$50#*Y$5!&!%$#546!\;4!*5!*69$01$'!\*1;!Y41;!?@J!&6'!?IJC!!H;$#$!&#$!

&''*1*46&+!Y$6$9*15!&[&*+&Y+$!14!;&$A4%;*+*&05!\;4!&#$!?IJ!04>*69$01$'C!

?IJ!8$046'&#*+:!

I69$01$'!"$#546!

)!;&$A4%;*+*&0!*69$01$'!\*1;!?@J!\;4!*5!&+54!5$046'&#*+:!*69$01$'!\*1;!

?IJC!!Q4!Y$6$9*15!&#$!%&:&Y+$!9#4A!1;*5!"+&6!26+$55!1;$!141&+!14!\;*0;!

1;$:!\42+'!;&[$!Y$$6!$61*1+$'!$c0$$'5!j,S-e---C!

V4*61!@4AA*11$$! H;$!04AA*11$$!$51&Y+*5;$'!26'$#!5$01*46!<C-.!49!1;$!"+&6C!

V4*61!@4AA*11$$!3$%4#1! 3$%4#1!49!1;$!V4*61!@4AA*11$$!3$+&1*67!14!B*6&60*&+!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!

.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!H#251!&5!&1!R$0$AY$#!M.e!,-.-e!'&1$'!V2+:!,U!

,-..C!!!

O64\6!0+&*A&615! H;45$!0+&*A&615!\;4!;&[$!Y$$6!&%%#4[$'!&5!49!1;$!'&1$!49!1;$![&+2&1*46!

&6'!&#$!*60+2'$'!*6!1;$!'&1&!%#4[*'$'!Y:!1;$!)'A*6*51#&14#C!

T$[$+!! )!'*5$&5$!+$[$+!&5!'$9*6$'!26'$#!1;$!"+&6C!!T$[$+5!&#$!#$+&1$'!14!51&7$5!&5!

A4'$++$'!*6!1;$!KKWP!3$%4#1C!

KKWP!3$%4#1! ^F51*A&1*67!1;$!"#47645*5!49!@&6&'*&65!I69$01$'!W*1;!1;$!?$%&1*1*5!@!

J*#25!H;#427;!1;$!N+44'!82%%+:e!.<(=>.<<-!>!B*91;!3$[*5*46!49!?$%&1*1*5!

@!"#476451*0!K4'$+!N&5$'!46!1;$!"451>H#&65925*46!?$%&1*1*5!@!

@4A%$65&1*46!@+&*A&61!@4;4#1_e!'&1$'!8$%1$AY$#!,-.S!Y:!W$6'467!

@;$6e!KR!";Re!m*+467!L*!KR!K80!";Re!W*++*&A!W467e!";R!&6'!K2##&:!

O#&;6!KR!K80!B3@"@!

Q46>;&$A4%;*+*&0!

@4;4#1!

8$$!H#&65925$'!@4;4#1!!

"+&6! H#&65925$'!?@J!"+&6!&6'!1;$!?&$A4%;*+*&0!?@J!"+&6!&5!&11&0;$'!14!&6'!

94#A*67!%&#1!49!1;$!f2'7$A$61!49!1;$!?4642#&Y+$!K#C!V251*0$!W&##$6!OC!

W*6d+$#!'&1$'!,,!E014Y$#!.<<<e!]042#1!9*+$!62AY$#!<(>@J>.S.M=<`C!

"+&6!H$#A5! H;$!%#4[*5*465!#$7&#'*67!%&:A$61!49!Y$6$9*15!&5!5$1!421!*6!1;$!"+&6C!!

"#$[*425+:!H#$&1$'! H;45$!0+&*A&615!\;4!;&[$!#$0$*[$'!1#$&1A$61!%#*4#!14!,-.S!Y21!

1#$&1A$61!\&5!265200$5592+C!!H;$:!&#$!&552A$'!*6!1;$!A$'*0&+!A4'$+!14!

Y$!$+*7*Y+$!94#!46$!&''*1*46&+!042#5$!49!1#$&1A$61!'2#*67!1;$!%$#*4'!

,-.S!14!,-.(C!

Page 135: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

)012&#*&+!3$%4#1!)55$55*67!8299*0*$60:!49!1;$!.<(=>.<<-!?$%&1*1*5!@!@4A%$65&1*46!B26'! .-<!

81&7$5! )!'*5$&5$!51&7$!&5!A4'$++$'!26'$#!1;$!KKWP!3$%4#1C!!81&7$5!&#$!

#$+&1$'!14!1;$!04A%$65&1*46!+$[$+5!26'$#!1;$!"+&6C!

8J@! 8%461&6$425!J*#&+!@+$&#&60$!X!1;*5!*6'*0&1$5!&!%$#546!*5!02#$'C!!

8J3! 8251&*6$'!J*#&+!3$5%465$!X!1;*5!*5!&6!*6'*0&14#!94#!0+$&#*67!1;$![*#25!4#!

Y$*67!02#$'C!!8J3!*5!1;$!&Y5$60$!49!'$1$01&Y+$!3Q)!49!1;$!;$%&1*1*5!@!

[*#25!*6!Y+44'!5$#2A!94#!&1!+$&51!,S!\$$d5!&91$#!'*50461*62*67!1;$!

1#$&1A$61M,C!

H#&65925$'!@4;4#1! H;$!7#42%!49!&%%#4[$'!0+&*A&615!\;4!&#$!641!;&$A4%;*+*&05C!

H#$&1A$61!Q&r[$!! H;45$!0+&*A&615!\;4!;&[$!641!#$0$*[$'!1#$&1A$61!%#*4#!14!,-.SC!!H;$:!

&#$!&552A$'!*6!1;$!A$'*0&+!A4'$+!14!Y$!$+*7*Y+$!94#!46$!042#5$!49!

1#$&1A$61!'2#*67!1;$!%$#*4'!,-.S!14!,-.(C!

D6d64\6!0+&*A&615! H;45$!0+&*A&615!\;4!&#$!&552A$'!14!Y$!&%%#4[$'!&5!&!0+&55!A$AY$#!&1!

54A$!'&1$!*6!1;$!9212#$C!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

M,!! W*d*%$'*&!X!^8251&*6$'!J*#&+!3$5%465$_!

Page 136: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!K4#6$&2!8;$%$++!T1'C!(</!R46!K*++5!3'Ce!H4\$#!E6$e!82*1$!U--!H4#4614!EQ!!KM@!.WM!!";46$a! ]S.=`!SS/>,U--!B&ca! ]S.=`!SS/>U<(<!

!

Page 137: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

Court File No. 98-CV-141369

Parsons, et al. AND Canadian Red Cross Society, et al. Plaintiffs Defendants

ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE

(PROCEEDING COMMENCED AT TORONTO)

AFFIDAVIT OF PETER GORHAM

PAUL B. VICKERY

Senior General Counsel Solicitor for the Defendant, The Attorney General of Canada PER: WILLIAM A. KNIGHTS DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Ontario Regional Office The Exchange Tower 130 King St. West Suite 3400, Box 36 Toronto, ON, M5X 1K6 LSUC # 16888F Tel: (416) 973-8219 Fax: (416) 973-5004

Page 138: Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF ... Hearing/Hep C... · Court File No. 98-CV-141369 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: DIANNA LOUISE PARSONS, MICHAEL

Court File No. 98-CV-141369

Parsons, et al. AND Canadian Red Cross Society, et al. Plaintiffs Defendants

ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE

(PROCEEDING COMMENCED AT TORONTO)

RESPONDING MOTION RECORD OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF

CANADA

PAUL B. VICKERY

Senior General Counsel Solicitor for the Defendant, The Attorney General of Canada PER: WILLIAM A. KNIGHTS DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Ontario Regional Office The Exchange Tower 130 King St. West Suite 3400, Box 36 Toronto, ON, M5X 1K6 LSUC # 16888F Tel: (416) 973-8219 Fax: (416) 973-5004