Copy of CTQ Comparison_2

21
Screwdriver CTQ Housing Variants Inline (PRD Specs) Torque Variants (Nm) 1.5 2 3.5 4.2 5.1 5.1 Free Speed (RPM) 3000 2200 1000 1000 800 400 Clutch Mechanism ASO, CC, DD Side-Center Distance (mm) 16.5 Grip diameter (22.7 bell shape) Torque Capability Meet VDI specs for 1000 rpm and less (lass than 12% capability) Tool Length (for ASO model) (mm) 220 Weight (for ASO model) (kg) 0.6 Sound (dBa) 76 Actuation Type Push, Lever, (some) Push+Lever Reversibility Yes Reverse Button Style Push Button (Similar to 1 series) Grip Handle Style Round/Egg Shape Air Inlet Style Back Air Inlet Connection 1/4” NPT Drive Type and Capacity 1/4" Hex QC Angle Head NA Cost Target $136.00 Meeting CTQ Meeting CTQ but expected to be less Not meeting CTQ

description

egddf

Transcript of Copy of CTQ Comparison_2

ScrewdriversScrewdriver CTQScrewdriver - Low Torque PlatformHousing Variants

Inline (PRD Specs)Inline (Actual specs)Improvement scopePistol (PRD Spec)Pistol (Actual specs)Improvement scopeAngle (PRD Specs)Angle (Actual specs)Improvement scopeTorque Variants (Nm)1.523.54.25.15.11.523.54.55.15.12.33.54.55.26.36.811Free Speed (RPM)3000220010001000800400300022001000100080040018001100800650650400300Clutch MechanismASO, CC, DDASO, CC, DD and PJASO, CC, DDSide-Center Distance (mm)16.5 Grip diameter (22.7 bell shape)22.7 (Bell shape)16.516.59.2 R18 Head9.2 R18 Head13 R25 Head13 R25 HeadTorque CapabilityMeet VDI specs for 1000 rpm and less (lass than 12% capability)see comparision in tab 3Meet VDI specs for 1000 rpm and less (lass than 12% capability)see comparision in tab 3Meet VDI specs for 650 rpm and less (lass than 12% capability)Tool Length (for ASO model) (mm)220226220222320275/303Weight (for ASO model) (kg)0.60.670.590.70.890.70.880.8Sound (dBa)7676.5767675.17673.1Actuation TypePush, Lever, (some) Push+LeverPush, Lever, (some) Push+LeverTrigger, Trigger+Push To StartTrigger, Trigger+Push To StartLeverLeverReversibilityYesYesYesYesYesYesReverse Button StylePush Button (Similar to 1 series)Push Button (Similar to 1 series)Lever next to triggerLever next to triggerRingRingGrip Handle StyleRound/Egg Shape RoundFlat-Back & T-HandleFlat-Back & T-HandleRoundRoundAir Inlet StyleBackBackBottom air for Flat backBottom air for Flat backBackBackTop air T Handle, Top air T HandleBottom air T handle Bottom air T handle Top & Bottom air for T handleTop & Bottom air for T handleAir Inlet Connection1/4 NPT1/4" NPT1/4 NPT1/4" NPT1/4 NPT1/4" NPTDrive Type and Capacity1/4" Hex QC1/4" Hex QC1/4" Hex QC1/4" Hex QC1/4" Hex QC, 1/4" Square & 3/8 Square1/4" Hex QC, 1/4" Square & 3/8 SquareAngle HeadNANANANAR18 & R25 headsR18 & R25 headsCost Target$136.00$135.60Work with operations and sourcing to reduce cost$155.00$160.67Work with operations and sourcing to reduce cost$234.00$248.00Higher cost in Angle screwdrivers is acceptable to Product Mangement as volumes are less for angle toolsMeeting CTQMeeting CTQ but expected to be lessNot meeting CTQ

DrillsDrill CTQ

Drill 0.3hp PlatformHousing Variants

Inline (PRD Specs)Inline (Actual specs)Improvement scopePistol (PRD Specs)Pistol (Actual specs)Improvement scopeAngle (PRD Spec)Pistol (Actual specs)Improvement scopeFree Speed variants (RPM)500100017002800380047006000500100017002800380047006000500300038004800HP0.30.30.3Tool Length (single stage model) (mm)200201160195210203Chuck Capacity1/41/4"1/4 & 3/81/4" & 3/8"1/4 & 3/81/4" & 3/8"Tool Weight (kg) (Includes chuck)0.60.680.60.60.760.50.760.7Sound (dBa)7678.4767677.27676Yet to be testedC-S Distance (mm)16.516.516.515.5Use existing 20 series headsAngle Head Height (mm)NANANANAUse existing 20 series headsGrip Handle StyleRoundRoundFlat backFlat backRoundRoundActuation TypeLeverLeverTriggertriggerLeverLeverReversibilityNon reversibleNon ReversibleNon reversibleNon ReversibleNon reversibleNon ReversibleAir Inlet StyleBackBackBottomBottomBackBackAir Inlet Connection NPT NPT NPT NPT NPT NPTDrill Holder StyleKey chuckKey chuckKey chuckKey chuckKey & Threaded spindle outputKey & Threaded spindle outputPower Unit OfferingyesYesYesYesn/aYesCost Target$120.00$107.04$132.00$110.33$230.00$225.42Meeting CTQMeeting CTQ but expected to be lessNot meeting CTQ

Screwdriver capability summary

Ingersoll RandAtlas Copco Ingersoll RandTool #Breeze - 5.1 Nm , 800 rpmLUM PR5 - 5 Nm, 450 rpmBreeze - 5.1 Nm , 400 rpmSoft joint (80% of max. Torque)Tool 16.438.455.95Inline/Pistol Model matrix for Breeze Tool 26.267.26To meet VDI certification (