CONTROVERSIES in KNEE INJURIES · 2017. 6. 25. · Management Non operative Activity restriction,...
Transcript of CONTROVERSIES in KNEE INJURIES · 2017. 6. 25. · Management Non operative Activity restriction,...
CONTROVERSIES
in
KNEE INJURIES
David Stock BSc FRCS(Orth.) Dip SEM
Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon
Lower limb arthroplasty and Sports Medicine
Northampton Sports Medicine and Science, 13th June 2017
Undergraduate
Royal Free Hospital School of Medicine
Post graduate
Royal National Orthopaedic Hospital Stanmore
Fellowship SPORTSMED.SA 2000
Diploma in Sports and Exercise Medicine 2013
2013
Northampton General Hospital 2001
Diploma in Sports and Exercise Medicine (DipSEM)
Rugby
Combined England Students World Cup side 1998
Saracens RFC
Honorary Orthopaedic Surgeon Northampton Saints
Ride London Surrey 100 Bike Ride 2016
London Marathon 2014
Golf, Tennis, Skiing
4 Orthopaedic surgeons General surgeon Psychologists Podiatrists with gait lab Ultrasound Shockwave therapy
BMI Three Shires
The Woodlands
CONTROVERSIES
in
KNEE INJURIES
“Is conservative better than surgical”
David Stock BSc FRCS(Orth.) Dip SEM
Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon
Lower limb arthroplasty and Sports Medicine
Northampton Sports Medicine and Science, 13th June 2017
Case study 1
MG 49 Male
Winner National Championship for Ironman 9’30’’
Qualified for Kona (14.10.2017)
Last year ↑ discomfort during exercise Rt Knee
(?on/off for years)
Some rest Jan/Feb worked on biomechanics – trunk
control, running mechanics
Extensive shockwave (x15-20)
Examination
Poor alignment in shallow knee bend
No effusion
FROM knee
Meniscal signs -ve
Ligaments stable
Tender over distal pole of patella
FROM hip
Slight tightness of quads and hamstrings
Ober’s test +ve
Differential Diagnosis
Patella tendinopathy
Fat pad impingement
PFJ OA
(all of the above)
Management
Already had extensive physiotherapy
Time scale of Kona (14.10.2017)
MRI
Case study 2
JC 25M Royal Marine
2yo ago manoeuvres in Wales
Pain over front of knee
Rx Painkillers, Physiotherapy
Deployed to Bahrain 18/52
More Physiotherapy
MRI “tiny trace high signal deep to prox part
patella tendon”
Arthroscopy 16.5.2015
MRI July 2016
ESWT discussed “insufficient time for recovery if failed”
August Open surgery – no op. notes available
Awaiting medical discharge
Patella tendinopathy
AKA
• Jumper’s knee
• Patella tendinosis
• Patella tendinitis
Incidence Athletes
13-20%, 35-50% jumping athletes
Jumping, heavy landing
Rapid accel/deceleration
Basketball highest incidence
♂˃♀
22% asymptomatic athletes have U/S changes
Career ending
53% of elite athletes with condition
(cf injury in 20% of athletes)
Aetiology
Extrinsic
Training frequency, intensity, surface, footwear
Intrinsic
Patella height, malalignment, LLD, muscle imbalance,
ankle dorsiflexion, body habitus
Muscular flexibility
Patella morphology – impingement of inferior pole on
dorsal fibres
Risk factors of tendinopathies
Diabetics, ↑ cholesterol, sero –ve arthropathy
Pathology
Traditional
Inflammation and degeneration secondary to tensile
forces
Recent
Impingement and compressive forces causing degeneration
Lesion limited to dorsal fibres of proximal patella insertion
Maximal force 50-70°
?adaptive process secondary to impingement
Continuum Model
Reactive tendinopathy
Tendon dysrepair
Degenerative tendinopathy
All interchangeable
Many differing states at
once
Pain
Structure
Function
No inflammatory cells
High levels neurotransmitter glutamate (?source of pain)
Tendon expanded, increased mucoid degeneration, intra
tendinous calcification, fibrinoid necrosis.
Inflammatory cells not typically seen
Management
Diagnosis
Hx
EX
Ix
Rx
?????
Single leg decline squat test
25˚ decline board
Squat to 90˚
V I C T O R I A N I N S T I T U T E O F S P O R T A S S E S S M E N T (VISA)
1. For how many minutes can you sit pain free?
0 mins 100 mins 0-10
2. Do you have pain walking downstairs with a normal gait cycle?
strong severe no pain 0-10
3. Do you have pain at the knee with full active non-weightbearing knee extension?
strong severe no pain 0-10
4. Do you have pain when doing a full weight bearing lunge?
strong severe no pain 0 -10
5. Do you have problems squatting?
Unable no problems 0-10
6. Do you have pain during or immediately after doing 10 single leg hops?
strong severe no pain 0-10
7. Are you currently undertaking sport or other physical activity? 0 ❒ Not at all 4 ❒ Modified training ± modified competition 7 ❒
Full training ± competition but not at same level as when symptoms began 10 ❒ Competing at the same or higher level as when
symptoms began
8. Please complete EITHER A, B or C in this question.
8a. If you have no pain while undertaking sport, for how long can you train/practise?
NIL 1-5 mins 6-10 mins 7-15 mins >15 mins
8b. If you have some pain while undertaking sport, but it does not stop you from completing your training/practice for how long can you
train/practise?
NIL 1-5 mins 6-10 mins 7-15 mins >15 mins
8c. If you have pain which stops you from completing your training/practice for how long can you train/practise?
NIL 1-5 mins 6-10 mins 7-15 mins >15 mins
TOTAL VISA SCORE ❒
0-100
≤80 equals dysfunction
Minimally clinically significant difference 18
points
Imaging
Plain x-ray
Ultrasound
Areas of hypoechogenic signal
↑ tendon thickness
↑ vascularity and neovascularisation
MRI
↑ tendon thickness
Classification Stage 0 No pain
Stage 1 Pain on intense sports activity
No functional limitation
Stage 2 Pain ant beginning and after sports activity
Able to perform satisfactorily
Stage 3 Pain during sports activity
Difficulty performing at satisfactory level
Stage 4 Pain during sports activity
Unable to perform at satisfactory level
Stage 5 Pain during daily activity
Unable to perform at any level
Roels J. Patellar tendinitis(jumper’s knee). Am J Sports Med.1978;6:362-368
Management
Poor understanding of how the condition develops,
limited knowledge of risk factors.
Paucity of effective and time efficient Rx
Rx protocols derived from of other tendon pathologies
Management Non operative
Activity restriction, Ice, NSAID, Biomechanics, Stretching,
McConnell taping, Patellofemoral brace
• Eccentric strengthening (ECC)
b.d., 3x15 25° incline board, 12/52
• Heavy slow resistance training (HSR)
Squat, leg press, hack squat
x3/52, x4 sets, 15 max rep
Kongsgaard M. Scan Journ.of medical science in Sport 2009
Patella tendinopathy: Clinical Dx, load Mx and advice for
challenging case presentations.
Malliaras P. Cook J. J. Orth. Sports Physical therapy. 2015. 45(11). 887-98
Phase of rehabilitation Aim of treatment Intervention Example exercises
Pain management Reduce pain
Isometric exercises in mid-range as
tolerated. Reduce loading and
activity modification
Sustained holds on leg extension;
45 s, 4 repetitions, 2 times/day.
Strength progression
Improve strength Heavy slow resistance as tolerated
(isotonic)
Leg extension/press, 4 sets of 6-8
repetitions, 3-5 times/wk
Functional strengthening
Progressive resistance exercise
program, functional tasks, address
movement patterns, kinetic chain
and endurance training as required
Walk lunge with body weight or
extra weight, stair walking
Increase power
Increase speed of muscle
contraction, lower the number of
repetitions
Split squats, faster stairs, skipping
exercises
Energy-storage/stretch-shorten
cycle
Develop stretch-shorten cycle Plyometric exercises, graded
gradually
Jumping, deceleration and change
of direction tasks
Training sport-specific Drills specific to sport including
endurance training
Sports specific drills at set intensity
and duration
Maintenance Management of symptoms and
prevention of flare ups
Education, continue strength
training and manage loading as
tolerated
Continue leg extension strength or
Spanish squat exercise while
training and playing
Injections
Steroid only short term relief
Sclerosants
Polidocanol
33pts/42 tendons
VISA 51-62
Hoksrud A. Am J Sports Med 2006;34:1738-38
VISA
≤ 80 dysfunction
Min. Clin. Sign. Change 18 points
Autologous blood
44pts/ 47 knees
x2 injections, 4/52 apart
VISA 39.8→ 74.3
James SL. Br J Sports Med. 2007 Aug 41(8):518-21
PRP
Comparable with ESWT short term?
28 pts. x3 inj. 1/52 apart
MRI 1/12+3/12
Complete return to normal 16 pts
7 no RTS, 3 lower level, 1 change sport, 3→surgery
Significantly improved symptoms and function in athletes with chronic PT and
allowed for recovery to their presymptomic sporting level.
Charousset C. Am J Sports Med. 2014 Ap;42(4) 906-11
Extracorporeal shockwave therapy (ESWT)
No benefit over placebo, jumping athletes with
symptoms 3-12/12
Zwerver J. Am J Sports Med. 2011 Jun.39(6):1191-9
Comparable to surgery
Peers KH. Clin J Sport Med.2003 Mar. 13(2):79-83
Operative
(?stage 4, stage 5)
3/12 eccentric quads prior to surgery
Open
tendon, patella, both
drilling/debriding/excision distal pole of patella
54-100% success
return to elite sport 46-91%
no difference bony vs non bony
RTP 6-10 months
Closed (arthroscopic)
with/without bony procedures
debriding/excision distal pole of patella
RT sport 46-85%
RTP 2-6 months
20 pts. Distal pole resected.
Assessed 6/52, 3+6+12+24/12
Stage 0/1 in 18/20 patients
Lorbach O. Arthroscopy 2008; 24: 167-73
No difference surgical vs conservative (Grade 4)
Success rate (RTS no/mild pain)
45% surgical
55% eccentric
Bahr R Surgical treatment compared with eccentric training for patella
tendinopathy (Jumper’s knee): a randomised, controlled trial. JBJS
(Am) 2006; 88-A:1689-98
BASK Meeting 29th March 2017
Omega 3 1g daily
Ibuprofen 400mg tds
Vit D esp if bone oedema
Physiotherapy
Kongsgaard M. Scan Journ.of medical science in Sport 2009
Cook J. Physiotherapy management of patella tendinopathy (jumper’s
knee). J Physiotherapy Sept 2014. Vol 60 (3) 122-9
Injections
Steroid to fat
Dry needling /PRP
High volume strip
Patella strap, Shockwave
MG 49 Male
Winner National Championship for Ironman 9’30’’
Qualified for Kona (14.10.2017)
Set expectations
Omega 3 1g daily,Vit D
U/S guided injection
Ensure correct physiotherapy
Heavy slow resistance training
Patella tendinopathy: Clinical Dx, load Mx and advice for challenging case presentations.
Malliaras P. J. Orth. Sports Physical therapy. 2015. 45(11). 887-98
Closed surgery with resection of distal patella pole.
Case 3
AH 13 ♀
County hockey
Knee pain and swelling
September 2016
Both knees , mainly left.
Inferolateral aspect patella, sharp
Most of time
Some night pain
Aggravated by bending and exercise
Feels will lock
Recent growth spurt (September)
Ex
Orthotics for pes planus, Normal gait
Poor stability shallow knee bend with pain
Wasted VMO
Effusion – patella tap
No pain on PFJ movements, repetitive resisted led
extension reproduces pain.
Tenderness lateral to patella ligament
ligament and meniscal tests –ve
Poor ankle DF,
Tight hamstrings and quads
Ober’s +ve
Weak gluts
DDX
Fat pad impingement
???PFJ
ITB syndrome
Ix
MRI
B A R F
V O M I T
Brainless Application Of Radiological Findings
Victim Of Modern Imaging Technology
Rx
Wait and see
Scope reattach fragment
Microfracture
Microfracture + (scaffolds)
Osteochondral Autologous Transplantation
Cartilage regeneration (ACI/MACI)
Surgical treatments of cartilage defects of the knee:
Systematic review of RCT’s Devitt, B. Knee Vol 24. Issue 3, June 2017
Age 18-55
1-15cm lesions
10 RCI’s 861pts
4 MFx vs ACI
2 ACI, 2 same
3 MFx vs OAT
2 OAT, 1same
1 MFx vs BST Cargel
Same
All better than nothing
MFx never superior to other Rx’s
Poor long term F/U
Early results favour OATS/Cartilage regeneration
5+ years no difference
Prognosis worse lesions ˃ 2cm
Large lesions ˃ 4.5cm OAT, ACI˃ MFx
No single recommendation
Thank you