Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

26
AUTO RELIABILITY 185 DETAILED AUTO RELIABILITY T he charts on the following pages give you a model's complete reli- ability picture for both its used versions (2005 through 2010) and the new one currently on sale. These detailed reliability Ratings are based on our 2010 Annual Car Reliability Survey, for which we received responses on 1.3 million vehicles. The Annual Car Reliability Survey is sent to subscribers of CONSUMER REPORTS and ConsumerReports.org. Respondents re- ported on any serious problems they had with their vehicles in any of the trouble spots included in the following charts, during the previous 12 months. These were considered serious because of cost, failure, safety, or downtime. Because high-mileage vehicles tend to have more problems than low-mile- age ones, problem rates are standardized to minimize differences related to mileage. The 2010 models were generally less than six months old at the time of the survey and had been driven an average of about 3,000 miles. Models with insufficient data are noted with a column of asterisks ("). How to use the charts MAJOR REDESIGNS A model year In boid iden- tifies the year the model was introduced or under- went a major redesign. TROUBLE SPOTS To assess a used car in more detail, look at the individual Ratings for each of the 17 trouble spots. They will pinpoint a model's strengths and weaknesses. Ratings are based on the percentage of survey respondents who reported problems for that trouble spot, compared with the average of all vehicles for that year. Models that score a are not necessarily unreli- able, but they have a higher problem rate than the Average Probiem Rates noiau SPOTS EKfliKltaJor EntlMWnot tngliw Coollni Tnas.llal> TnM. WMT DiheSyiMi Fuel syitem ElMrkll Otaau spurn SUIPMSI« Bnkn niiaiiit Paint/Trim My IntifrttT M) Harttm Mnrltul» «lidio Svinm USEOCM vfitnas lew o u mncim 00 3 8 6 3 3 5 10 7 9 8 9 4 8 9 12 9 3 01 3 6 5 3 3 5 12 7 8 8 9 3 7 9 11 8 3 02 3 5 4 2 3 5 9 6 7 7 8 2 5 8 10 7 3 03 2 4 4 2 2 5 7 5 6 6 8 2 4 7 9 7 3 04 1 3 3 1 2 4 5 4 4 5 7 1 4 6 8 7 3 OS 1 2 2 1 2 3 4 4 3 4 6 1 3 6 6 6 3 1 1 1 1 2 2 3 3 3 3 5 <l 2 5 5 5 3 07 <1 1 1 1 1 2 3 2 2 2 4 <1 2 S 4 S 2 08 <1 1 <1 4 1 1 2 1 1 1 2 <1 1 4 3 3 3 09 <1 <1 <1 <1 1 <1 1 I <1 <1 1 «1 1 2 2 2 2 average model. Similarly, models that score a © are not necessarily problem- free, but they had relatively few problems compared with other models. Because problem rates in some trouble spots are very low, we do not assign a • or © unless the model's prob- lem rate exceeds 3 percent. If a problem rate is beiow 2 percent, it will be assigned 8 9; below 1 percent, it will be assigned a ©. USED CAR VERDICTS To check the overall reli- ability of a used car, look at the Used Car Verdict. This Rating shows whether the model had more or fewer problems overall than the average model of that year.

description

Consumer report buying guide 2012

Transcript of Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

Page 1: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

A U T O R E L I A B I L I T Y 185

DETAILED AUTO RELIABILITY

The charts on the following pagesgive you a model's complete reli-ability picture for both its usedversions (2005 through 2010)and the new one currently on

sale. These detailed reliability Ratings arebased on our 2010 Annual Car ReliabilitySurvey, for which we received responses on1.3 million vehicles.

The Annual Car Reliability Survey is sentto subscribers of CONSUMER REPORTS and

ConsumerReports.org. Respondents re-ported on any serious problems they had

with their vehicles in any of the trouble spotsincluded in the following charts, during theprevious 12 months. These were consideredserious because of cost, failure, safety, ordowntime. Because high-mileage vehiclestend to have more problems than low-mile-age ones, problem rates are standardizedto minimize differences related to mileage.The 2010 models were generally less than sixmonths old at the time of the survey and hadbeen driven an average of about 3,000 miles.Models with insufficient data are noted witha column of asterisks (").

How to use the chartsMAJOR REDESIGNSA model year In boid iden-

tifies the year the model

was introduced or under-

went a major redesign.

TROUBLE SPOTS

To assess a used car in

more detail, look at the

individual Ratings for

each of the 17 trouble spots.

They will pinpoint a model's

strengths and weaknesses.

Ratings are based on the

percentage of survey

respondents who reported

problems for that trouble

spot, compared with the

average of all vehicles for

that year.

Models that score a •

are not necessarily unreli-

able, but they have a higher

problem rate than the

Average Probiem Ratesnoiau

SPOTS

EKfliKltaJor

EntlMWnot

tngliwCoollni

Tnas.llal>

TnM. W M T

DiheSyiMi

Fuel syitem

ElMrkll

Otaauspurn

SUIPMSI«

Bnkn

niiaiiit

Paint/Trim

M yIntifrttT

M)Harttm

Mnrltul»

«lidio Svinm

USEOCMvfitnaslew o u

mncim

003

8

6

3

3

5

10

7

9

8

9

4

8

9

12

9

3

013

6

5

3

3

5

12

7

8

8

9

3

7

9

11

8

3

023

5

4

2

3

5

9

6

7

7

8

2

5

8

10

7

3

032

4

4

2

2

5

7

5

6

6

8

2

4

7

9

7

3

041

3

3

1

2

4

5

4

4

5

7

1

4

6

8

7

3

OS1

2

2

1

2

3

4

4

3

4

6

1

3

6

6

6

3

0«1

1

1

1

2

2

3

3

3

3

5

<l

2

5

5

5

3

07<1

1

1

1

1

2

3

2

2

2

4

<1

2

S

4

S

2

08<1

1

<1

4

1

1

2

1

1

1

2

<1

1

4

3

3

3

09<1

<1

<1

<1

1

<1

1

I

<1

<1

1

«1

1

2

2

2

2

average model. Similarly,

models that score a © are

not necessarily problem-

free, but they had relatively

few problems compared

with other models.

Because problem rates in

some trouble spots are very

low, we do not assign a • or

© unless the model's prob-

lem rate exceeds 3 percent.

If a problem rate is beiow

2 percent, it will be assigned

8 9; below 1 percent, it will

be assigned a ©.

USED CAR VERDICTSTo check the overall reli-

ability of a used car, look at

the Used Car Verdict. This

Rating shows whether the

model had more or fewer

problems overall than the

average model of that year.

Page 2: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

186 C O N S U M E R R E P O R T S B U Y I N G G U I D E 2 0 1 2

The verdict is calculated from

the total number of problems

reported by subscribers in all

trouble spots. Our calculations

give extra weight to problems

with major engine and trans-

mission systems, the cooling

system, and the drive system

because they can be serious

and expensive to repair.

NEW CAR PREDICTIONSTo determine the New Car Pre-diction, we averaged a model'sUsed Car Verdict for the mostrecent three years, providedthe vehicle did not changesignificantly in that time andwasn't redesigned for 2010or 2011. We have found thatseveral model years' data area better predictor than thesingle most recent model year.

One or two years' data maybe used if the model was rede-signed in 2010 or 2009, or ifthere were insufficient datafor more years. Sometimes weinclude a prediction for a mod-el that is new or has been re-designed, provided its reliabilityhistory or the manufacturer'strack record has been consis-tently above average. "NA"means there were insufficientdata for a prediction.

WHAT THE TROUBLE SPOTSINCLUDE

Engine, major: Enginerebuild or replacement,cylinder head, head gasket,turbo or supercharger,timing chain or timing belt.

Engine, minor. Oii leaks, acces-sory belts and pulleys, enginemounts, engine knock or ping.Engine, cooling: Radiator, cool-ing fan, antifreeze leaks, waterpump, thermostat, overheating.Transmission, major: Trans-mission rebuild or replace-ment, torque converter, pre-mature clutch replacement.Transmission, minor: Gearselector or linkage, coolersand lines, rough shifting, slip-ping transmission, leaks, trans-mission computer, transmis-sion sensor or solenoid, clutchadjustment, hydraulics (clutchmaster or slave cylinder).Drive system: Driveshaft oraxle, CV joint, wheel bearing(s),differential, transfer case,4WD/AWD components, drive-line vibration, electrical failure.Fuel system: Check enginelight, sensors (inciudes 02 oroxygen sensor), emission con-trol devices (inciudes EGR),engine computer, fuel cap,fuel gauge/sender, fuel injec-tion system, fuel pump, fuelleaks, stalling or hesitation.Eiectrlcai: Alternator, starter,hybrid battery and related sys-tems, regular battery, batterycables, engine harness, coil,ignition switch, electronic igni-tion, distributor or rotor failure,spark plugs and wires failure.Climate system: Blower(fan) motor, A/C compressor,condenser, evaporator, heatersystem, automatic climatecontrol, refrigerant leakage.

electrical failure.Suspension: Shocks or struts,ball joints, tie rods, wheelbearings, alignment, steeringlinkage (includes rack andpinion), power steering, wheelbalance, springs or torsionbars, bushings, electronic orair suspension.Brakes: Premature wear, pul-sation or vibration, squeaking,master cylinder, calipers,antilock brake system (ABS),parking brake, brake failure.Exhaust: Muffler, pipes,catalytic converter, exhaustmanifold, leaks.Paint/trim: Paint (fading, chalk-ing, cracking, peeling), looseexterior trim or moldings, rust.Body Integrity: Squeaks orrattles, seals, and/or weatherstripping, air or water leaks,loose interior trim and mold-ings, wind noise.Body hardware: Windows,locks and latches, tailgate,hatch or trunk, doors orsliding doors, mirrors, seatcontrols, safety belts, sunroof,convertible top, glass defect.Power equipment and acces-sories: Cruise control, clock,warning lights, body controlmodule, keyless entry, wipermotor or washer, tire pressuremonitor, interior or exteriorlight, horn, gauges, 12V powerplug, alarm or security system.Audio system: Audio systems,entertainment systems, naviga-tion system, backup camera/sensors, communication system.

Page 3: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

A U T O R E L I A B I L I T Y 187

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body Integrity

BodY Hardware

Power Eguip.

Audio System

TROUBLESPOTS

Page 4: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

1 8 8 C O N S U M E R R E P O R T S B U Y I N G G U I D E 2 0 1 2

TROUBLESPOTS

BMW 32Si,328i (RWD)

'05'06'07'08'09 '10

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

PalntArlm

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

©ee• oo©• 06

O eoe©e©oe©©o©©|©©©

©o©oo©©©©b©•©00©oo©©oa

opppppAverage O

BMW 525i ,528i, 53Oi

(RWD)

New Average o

'05'06'07'OS'09'10

©©oiobbo

• oem©

ooplala

oeeeeob©

©©©poa©©000*oaooo*©©©©o*obppl©*

***

*© *

*

'05'06W08'09'10

©©©©©©©

ooo

©©©©©©o

'©©©i©l©l©poa|a*|a|a©©•©oa©aoo©|©bb©

o

• •©o^o

Much worse thanaveraged

TROUBLESPOTS

Buick Enclave(AWD)

'05'OS'07'08'09'IO

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

©

©©©©©©©I©©

©©o©©©©©©• • ©©©o

Average o

BuickLaCrosse(V6. FWD)

•O5'06'07'08'0910

a Op©©©oo©ooolal©aaaoobo©©©• ••o©©© ooo

©•©©©©00©0©©©00©

©©oo©©oppppp

Average O

Buick Lucerne(V6)

•05'06'07'08'0910

O©o©

• o©©©©o©©

00©©©o©e|©©••©©0©©0©©©oooopppbAverage o

©©©©©I©©©a

©

Cadillac CTS(V6, RWD)

'0S'06WDe'0910

©©©I©©O©O

©

Cadillac DTS

©••©©0©0©©o

o

a©ee

oo©©©

©ppo©

©o©o©

O

©©••

©©

©©©••Oo

obpppbWorse thanaverage ©

•05W07'08'09'l0

*

O *

a*

©aee

a©o©©©©bb*o• ©©©oo

o o *

©pl©l©*Average O

*©I©*o © *

Page 5: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

A U T O R E L I A B I L I T Y 189

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body integrity

Body Hardware

Power Egiiip.

Audio System

Cadillac SRX(AWD)

p

Cadillac STS(V6)

Average o

o©le©a©

OOP©o©bto

o*a *

*****

*©topi©*ob©

aopb*

• • © •• •©©©©•©

Worse thanaverage ©

ChevroletAvalanche 1500

•OS'06^07'08'09'10

*

©o•totoi

• •©ao©©•aa*© a

O:

ao©a

obbbb**otetopp*©bbbb*©tobbb*

•|©|©pp*Average O

ChevroletAveo

•0S'06'O7'Oa'091O

OO©©*O©

o

o

o• • • t o t o©to©

o©!©•

oo©©

• ©©te•©•©to*©••o©ooo^©*

• •{•pp*Much worse than

average•

a*o*

TROUBLESPOTS

ChevroletCámaro (y8)

'OS'06'07'08'0910

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate Svstem

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body integrity

Body Hardware

Power Eguip.

Audio System

a

Better thanavera(

a©p©Opte

ChevroletCobalt Sedan

W06'07'08'09'10

a**

ate**

ototopp*o©oaa*©tobbb*

*o*

****

• • • • ©© © • o©©©• ©a• ©©•I©©©©•o• • © © • *• • • o © *©l©ppl©

Discontinued

ChevroletColorado (4WD)

'OS'06'07^08'09'10

• { • *© *

©to*©*

* a *

© o *

o©*|©*

a*p*oa*• • * t o

©to*©*o*

a *

• • * { © *Worse thanaverage©

ChevroletCorvette

•O5'06'07'08'09^10

I © **

I © **

©o•I©

o©©

• ©

© •

©©©.o©

| { {oa©*

o*

o*o*a*

*

o*o*

Average o

ChevroletEquinox (y6)

'05'06'07'08'09"10

Oa{a{©|©©a

ao©

©•••o© • oo©

©oo• •©a

oaa• •©©tooo©a©

©©•••o•oo©©o•ppppp

Average O

Page 6: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

1 9 0 C O N S U M E R R E P O R T S B U Y I N G G U I D E 2 0 1 2

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

•05'06'07'08'09'10

• ©

OO

© © *

• tol«• • • ©

*

*

fel©pp*e *

*

*obb©o©©*ooo©*©©•o*ooo

l

ChevroletImpala (V6)

05 06 07 08 09 10

©bb©06©

b• • ob

©o©••I©oo

• ©eleooo©o©o©©©©oe

• • • • e l ©• © • © M P

©©

o©oppb

Average o

Average o

'05'06'O7'08'09'10

©O

©©©©©©• •©©I©obbbo©

©•PPI©©o©eeeeoe©©o^oooooooo

0©©0©.•©oeo©oppppp;

Average O

ChevroletMaiibu (4-cyl.)

ChevroletMaiibu (V6)

•05'06'07'08'09'10 '0S'06'D7'08'D9'10 '05'06'07'08'09'lD

©©I©©

eao

•p©©|©

ooeo©©©o

©©

op|©p©o•|©b©o©

©OO©ppppp

Average O

ChevroletTrailBlazer

(6-cyl.)•05'06'07'08'09'10

©©telele• ee©

e©©ole

o©o|eoe

o©o|©o©©©

© •

• ©•©©©o©©o•pp

Discontinued

o

©OO

O

©bo©©©g©©©I©

©|©o©

obopbo

o p ©to• • • • I ©©•kkbo

©ole|

|o©©o

OO©• ©©• ©•pfel©oppppp

Average O

ChevroletTraverse (AWD)

'05'06'07'08W10

ChevroletSilverado 1500

(V8. 4WD)

©

oeee00eooe00

eeple©oo

efe©

• •00©©o©©o

o

©©I©

©o©

p©••OO

0 0 ©

o©©©©©©©©©

o

Average o

o©oop|©©bl©

|oAverage o

ChevroletUplander

'05'06'07'08'09'l0

eoo©©op• ©•©©•o©• •©•©©••

• ©• •©p• •••• •©•• ©©•

Discontinued

Page 7: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

A U T O R E L I A B I L I T Y 191

TROUBLESPOTS

Chrysler 300(V6)

'05'06'07'08'09 '10

Engine, maioi

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Ma|or

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

©ooo

o

9 0

o

oo• • ©

o*

*

*Ole*ee*ee*o©*oe*

o^©**

TROUBLESPOTS

©pboto*o©©*

©ppp*New

Chrysler TownS. Country(extended)

•OS'06'07'08'0910

Chrysler 300(V8)

'05'06'07'08'09'10

oooeoo

oe

oee*oeee

• ©

o*• ••©

e^oo*©eeooeo*

oo*

New

ooeo*©©©•

©©oo*

Dodge Caliber

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

*

O

©O©Oi

e

©©

o• •le©oe*©pp*

Average O

o**

o***

o o *

Chrysjer PTCruiser

(non-turbo)'OS'06'07'08'09'10

• •ele©©o

ooo

o©©|©*

• ©0|©*o©©

oo©booep*eoooolep*

o©p^p*

Discontinued

DodqeChallenger

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

*

*

o

eo

o

o

© •o©

eb

Much worse thanave rage •

Discontinged

Dodge Charger

'0S'06'07'0B'09't0

*

e|e|e|©*6*

*

*e*e*o*

totobo*

• •©6©b©©

be

©••e

• e©©bbk*oOp)6p*oooe*o©oo*

ooo

ChryslerSebring Sedan

'0S'06'D7'08'09'10

a *

e*oo*oe*

©te©oe*

©pe©*

©••k

Ob*©|©oe*

oo*

o © *

Dodge Dakota(4WD)

'O5'06'07'08'Q9'1O

oeleob

l©te*• l©bo*epee*aee• • • © *•k©koole*©©•©*oeoeo9*eb©6*

©I©*Worse thanaverage ©

o*

Page 8: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

192 C O N S U M E R R E P O R T S B U Y I N G G U I D E 2 0 1 2

TROUBLESPOTS

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

PaintArim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

©©

© © • *©eo*

o^e*o©©*

o^o*o©© © •© © © *

O O © *

© © *

Dodge GrandCaravan

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

©00©• •©©

©poooe©

• ©©••

• • O O ©©ooo©©•••••©• • • o ©• • • • • I ©©©©©©©©o©©|©|©kl©o

oo

olebtopo• • • • • o

Dodge Journey

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

©

©©

o©©©• ©•b©•b• o• o©©

PNew

Dodge Nitro

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

© *

© © *©e*©©© © *• © *o©*© •

© o *

© •• ©• o*

• I ©Worse thanaverage©

Dodge Ram150(3 (2WD)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

©©I©e©OOOO• oppp©©©©©©•©©b©00oe©©©o©©©©oo©o©©©©00©eooo©eeoeoopp|©p|©

Average O

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

Dodge Ram1500(4WD)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

oe©

©o©©• ••©©• ©©o©©00©• ©©

• ©

ee©©©oeoooo©©©•©©oe©©©

©©©oooOO

Average o

Ford CrownVictoria

'OS'06'07'08'0910

©

©Op

©

©©©©©©

oo©o©o©©©©o©eoobbbo©pp|©p

Discontinued

O©Ooo©

Ford Edge(AWD)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

©©

•too•k©©

©

Ob©©o©|©b|©

b

ooee

©o©bo©

©op©ppbNew

Ford Escape(V6, AWD)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

©©©

©OO

©OO©©©©©•©©bbbo

©pp©oooo©©••o

©Q©©©©'o©ob©©o©©©©©©00©e©©©©©©ppppp

Average O

Ford Expedition(4WD)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

©©b

©©©oto

OO

OOo ©I©

• ©ob©

• © © • •

©bbb©•topbp©bbbbb

p©plepl©©•©©©b

IAverage o

Page 9: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

A U T O R E L I A B I L I T Y 193

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Eguip.

Audio System

Ford Explorer(4WD)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

bola

oaa• ••©• ©ooaaaoaoo©©boo

eefea©

oaaaoaaoalaoooooooooapoooo

TROUBLESPOTS

New

Ford FocusSedan

•05'06'07'08'09'10

a

ee

©a©©©

oo©©©

aop©op|a©00©©©©|©|©oo©©©bb|©l©b

New

Ford F-150(V8, 2WD)

'05'06W08'09'10

©©©©

oo©|©o©oo©|©ooo^©©©©©©• • © ©

ooaoaaaoola•©a©©©©o©©©©o©o©©ob|ep|ab

Average o

Ford Freestyle,Taurus X

'05'06'07'OB'09'10

o©©

©©

©p|©poop©ooobb^

o

o©aoaoaoaa©©00^©00©0©o©©©op|opp

Discontinued

Ford F-150(V8,4WD)

05'06'07'08'0910

©©©©©©©©©o|©bop|©

©bl©ob|©©oo©o|a|©

©©©o©

©©©©©I©©©bl©ao ©PI©©©©0©|©©o©©o©©©©©©©

ooppppi©

Average o

Ford Fusion(V6, FWD)

'05'06'07'08'09'10

©©

o©©©©oo©©©oa

oaao©©©©I© o

Much better thanaverage©

Ford FiveHundred, Taurus

•05'06'07'08'0910

©©©

©I©©Pl©

©I©©©©o©©

o©©©ooo

O00©0

©oo©©©©oo©©o©©©©o©©©©o©©©©©©ooobpppb

Better thanaverage ©

Ford Mustang(V6)

•05'06'07'08'09'10

©

'05'06'07'08'O9'10

©©

O

Ob• ©p

©©o

oo

oo

©•©• •©©pooo©

• ©o©obp|a|a

Better thanaverage a

©I© ao

oao• ©

©o©©o©o• o©b

Average o

Ford Mustang(V8)

'O5'06'07'08'09'10

O©bbbbl©

©©o•© oo©©

©o

o• ©a©©b©©©l©

©©©b©©

Better thanaverage©

Page 10: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

1 9 4 C O N S U M E R R E P O R T S B U Y I N G G U i D E 2 0 1 2

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Eiectricai

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

Ford Ranger(4WD)

•0S'06'07'D8W10

Î *

©©

©a©oboe©

© o

o

• ©•{©to©©©©©

o*****

a**

*

© •

ap*a©

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Eiectricai

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

opp{©p*Averaqe O

GMC Terrain(4-cyi.)

Worse thanaverage Ô

Ford TaurusSedan

OO

©©oa©©•

o

o©te

o©o©

a a o

opo©p|©a

o o ateteooaaoaaaao©o©©o©©

o©o

ooo|©pppi©

Better thanaverage©

GMC Acadia(FWD)

'OS'Oè'OTOB

aa©o

© •

• ©o•{•I©

Worse thanaverage ©

a©o©a©©• •©• •©

eee• • • a

O

o©oo

GMC yui<on XL1500

•OS'06^0708'09'10

ao©©©o©oo

oo• • • t e { ©O9i>eeo©^oa

©o©{aao©aapoo©aooo©^^^©••©©©b©©©©o©top|©|©te

Averaqeo

GMC Canyon(2WD)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

*

*

*

©O©©©I©©b©©o• ©o•totote©bo

© o *

©a©•p{^p*o©©o©*ooo^o*•©OOO*

*PI©*

*©{a*

toPtob**

Worse thanaverage©

Honda Accord(4-cyl.)

GMC Sierra 1500I (V8,2WD) ,

'OS'06'07'08'0910

O

©

aaoooobtoo©

p{©•{©a©©te• • o ©o©©oo

©oo©oooo©©o©••oaa©

obbbbbAverage O

Honda Accord(V5)

p{©te|©

•05'06'07^08'09 '10 •05'06'07^08'09 '10

e o a

eeeeabaopp

©©©oo

o{ateAverage O

p a

ee

eee©teo©©©

eeee©00©©©a©opb

Average o

Page 11: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

A U T O R E L I A B I L I T Y 195

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

PaintArim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

TROUBLESPOTS

Honda AccordCrosstour

•05 '06 '0708W10

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooiing

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

ee

e

©

ee

Much better thanaverage ©

•0S'O6'07'O8W1O

* *

Much better thanaverage ©

Honda CivicHybrid

•05'06'07'08'09'10

©©ol©

^p•tetebteb©

©©©

©©©©©©

© © ©

o©©

o

Better thanaverage©

•05'06'07'08'09'10

©I©

©©e

©I©©©©©©©oeoee©••©lei©©•••o

ooe©©©oo^oeoooooo

©OO©©

o©©o©©©©

Honda CivicSedan

•OS'06'07'08'09'10

e

©I©©e

eooeeeae©

ooe©ee©©©©©eee©©eeee©

Better thanaverage ©

•0S'06'07W09'l0

e|ee©

eo

eee©©eeleebb©©©

©OO©|©|©©o©

eee©

Better thanaverage ©

'05'06'07'08'09'10

o©©|©|©|©l©b©©©©©©©••pte

©eo©

©leteeebbl©

oe|epb

Average O

•05'06W08'09'10

eeo©

©©©©©o

©©©b©

eoolete©©eo©©bbe©

ee©

oBetter thanaverage©

Page 12: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

1 9 6 C O N S U M E R R E P O R T S B U Y I N G G U I D E 2 0 1 2

TROUBLESPOTS

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

ea©b

o

6 0 *

O

oee*

© e ©

* *

* *

o *

Discontinued

© *

O *

* e

o *

e*e*o*o*o*

o *

666*

660*60*

laNew

Hyundai Azera

'05'06'07'08'0910

*

0 6

6©©|©*©0^0*9060*

O

oa

ee©9 ©

po©e*oao*

000Ä*aa©©*oppp*Average O

oae*

o © *

e*

HyundaiEiantra Sedan

'OS'06'07'08'D910

eoo

o616

aa©

©ooe

©ooeeoeeleteooeeoeOa6666O66OO6

ob|©|e|ebBetter thanaveragee

O

e

Hyundai GenesisSedan(V6)

'OS'O6'D7'08'O9't0

ee©aea

ao60oo

Better thanaveragee

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Braiies

Exhaust

PaintArIm

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

Hyundai SantaFe (V5)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

aoaoa

ee©po©

eooleoee©oeooe

oeeleeeaeoeoooaateoeeo| b |

Better thanaverage©

HyundaiSonaia (4-cyl.)

'OS'06'07'08'0910

O• e

e©oooa©aee©©kbteo

oblateoaaaoaoo^oa©ooeooooeeoaobp|e|eb

Better thanaverage a

HyundaiSonata (V6)

'OS'06'07'08'0910

eeeoalaeea

ao appleeo©bb• a6 6ep|epeeee

• ©©eeoeoeo©e©©oeoOOO666oeeo©©op|a|ap|o

Discontinued

HyundaiTucson (4-cyl.)

'05'06'07'08'0910

©O

eee©o

© e *oo

a*a*

oo

* *eo©*e e ^ * *oee*

606*OOO*660*

Average O

* *

e * *e*

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

ooaao:• ©6• •6 '66OO9'o©|e

eootop996©• ©OO©©96op|©b

Average O

O

Page 13: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

A U T O R E L I A B I L I T Y 197

TROUBLESPOTS

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

PaintArim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

eBetter thanaverage ©

O

'OS'06'a7'08'0910

©Op

O

bo

©o©o ob©

• ©toi©©©©bp©©©©oobbboo

©b©©o

©©o©

Average O

Infiniti GSedan (AWD)

'05'06'07'08'09'10

o

ee

o©©©©• • © • b

o ©oobtetetee

eo©©©oeeeo©o©©ob|©|©|©b

Better thanaverage ©

Infiniti GSedan (RWD)

'OS'06'07'08'0910

©©O©O©

o

ee

©o©o

ooobb

©©I©©

o©© o©©

Better thanaverage ©

Infiniti M35(RWD)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

*

*b*

*b*

©o

© *o©

o©bl©***

©bpp*©|©©o*

© e *© *

o*Better thanaverage©

TROUBLESPOTS

Jaguar S-Type,

'OS'06'07'08'0910

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

©• *

• *o*o*• *o*© *© *© *© *© *© *o*

Much worse thana v e r a g e •

• ©©

©

Jeep Compass

'OS'06'07'OB'09'10

O O *O © *o

o*© *

• o*

© •

o©*o©*

© o *

Average

Jeep GrandCherokee

(6-cyi., y6)

'05'06'07'08'09'10

*

*

*

*

*

OO©p©ooo©

©©©la©©ab©©

oo

©ppob*©bl©©

o

o***

optepp*

©o©oo*o©o©©*©bppp*

New

Jeep GrandCherokee(y8)

'05'06'07'08'09'10

Ooeb

ee©©oep

•{•©e©©ee

• • ©

ole©©

00ooe

©

©ooo©©©©o©o©ppoooook©©©•

•bppptoNew

Jeep Liberty

'OS'06'07'08'0910

oe• ©eeo• •pb©eoeoOO

©a©

©

• ••©ob©

0 0be

oboooo©ootoooo^o

e©o

• o©ppppto

Worse thanaverage ©

Page 14: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

1 9 8 C O N S U M E R R E P O R T S B U Y I N G G U I D E 2 0 1 2

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Eiectrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

PaintArim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

Jeep Patriot I I JeepWrangier 11 Jeep WranglerI I (2-door) I I (4-door)

05'06'07'08'09

TROUBLESPOTS

OS'06'07'08'0910 'OS'06'07'08'09 'tO

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electricai

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

PaintArim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

©••©©•••»

Page 15: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

A U T O R E L I A B I L I T Y 199

TROUBLESPOTS

•0506 07'08'09'10

oaee

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuei System

Eiectricai

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Eguip.

Audio System

O

oaaa

a©©op

iee*•Pteo©*

)ao*a©*

a*

New

'OS'06^07'08'09'10

©bl©

aao

eee

eoee

©paoo©©o©

Better thanaverage©

• ee

©©©©

©©oo

oo©

eee

©©©ao© •a©©

a*

'OS'06'07'08'09 10

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

O

Oeea

**

a{atep|©*aooaa*©bbb©*

© *

atepbb*Better thanaverage©

aaao

oooaob©oap

©boa©©

op©o

©abbBetter thanaverage ©

Lexus iS 250Sedan (RWD)

'OS'06'07'08'09^»

a©lato^tote

I©©©{©a©©|©a©©o©

o© ©

©I©

©©

tol©teoobb

©©

©

a

Average O

'OSW07'O8'091O

•{©PI©

©©©©I©©b©te

©o©©©•a

totob©©©b

Average O

'OS'06'07'08'09

©laba

a

©a©

ba©o

o

o

pa©©©o©{©

te©©©|©|©|©

Much better thanaverage ©

Lincoin MKS

•OS'06'07'08^09'10

© •• •

•pMuch worse than

averaged

Page 16: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

2 0 0 C O N S U M E R R E P O R T S B U Y I N G G U I D E 2 0 1 2

TROUBLESPOTS

Lincoln MKX(AWD)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooiing

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuei System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

O

o©©•

oa©

o

©oe©

©©©©

©pppNew

O©©O

'051)6'07'08'09 "10

© •o

©©

• • I © I©|b• •

00o

©©

o©ee©pooeote

o©©eoop|e|©pBetter than

© © O

Ib

LincolnNavigator

'05'06'07'08'0910

eee

o

oo oie le*o©ptole*

• ©oleee*

©e*

o©e©o• ©•©©©o

• ©

* *

* *

oppp*Better thanaverage©

Lincoln TownCar

•OS'06'07'08'09'10

*

*

*

*

*

©**

o*o***

o*o*o*

©p©o

o

©©o©•tete

oO

©te ©teo©oop*oe©oo*epppp*

Averageo

Mazda B-Series(2WD)

•05'06'07'08'D9'10

Oo

oool©

OO

oo|©OO

o©©e

©©©¡

©©

oop

© O Ooe

©©Discontinued

TROUBLESPOTS

Mazda CX-7(turbo)

©O•05'06'07'08'09'10

*

P **

©I©*©©©©e*• o©*©bb*

o*

• ©<

©o00

o• ©0 0 © *o©o*o©o*

o *Averageo

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

o©o©©•©

© •©o©©©©ooooooo©

o|©Better thanaverage ©

Mazda MX-5Miata

'05'06'07'08'09'10

O

ale

©o©ob©

©

o

oee

• ©©

OO

Much better thanaverage©

Mazda Tribute(V6, FWD)

'05'06'07'08'09'IO

e©©©

o

© ©

o©©

©©©beepOO

©©

ote©

o

o©op000obe

oopp

Averageo

e

Mazda3 Sedan

'05'06'07'08'09

I

oe©©

©©

oeee

o

00

opoee©©oo©ooo

o©©©©©©©

©©

Better thanaverage ©

Page 17: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

A U T O R E L I A B I L I T Y 201

TROUBLESPOTS

'OS'06'07'08'0910

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

O

6O Opte60eeote• • • • ©©••e

oeo• ©©©6• e©ee066061eeeee©pppbAverage o

Maz(la6 Sedan(4-cyl.)

'OS'06'07'08'0910

ee|a

o©pp{e|e©bl©eee

66

O66©a

eemo^pppoo ooooeo©abbboo

©o60

o|a{6|appAverage o

OO

Mercedes-BenzC-Class

(y6, RWD)

'OS'06'07'08'0910

O

©Oae©e

oee60OO6

© 6

aa

ee

oee©ooop

*|©eoo|©oo

o|e|e|ekAverage O

Mercedes-BenzCLK

'OS'06'07'08'0910

©eepeo

eo

eeeo

©o©

• • • © •

op|a|apDiscontinued

Mercedes-BenzE-Class Sedan

(V6, RWO)

'OS'06'07'08'0910

©©©

eo© •ee©©o|eao

oo

eeop

{©teboa

aaee

©•©©eb|||

Better thanaverage a

TROUBLESPOTS

Mercedes-BenzGL-Class (V8)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuei System

Electrical

Ciimate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

e©*e*

e©o©0 6 *O©*© • *0 6 *• • *Op*

•{a*a o *

© © *

Much worse thana v e r a g e •

* *

Mercedes-BenzGLK

•OS'06'07'08'0910

Much worse thanaverage •

Mercedes-BenzM-Ciass (V6)

'OS'06'07'08'0910

©a

Mte6©60

O©{apaoa©aoo©

• e©^p• 0^0©©|apppAverage O

©aoee

|

Mercedes-BenzR-Ciass

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

o© • ©

oo©*000*

eo*

o

e *

ooo*• ©

6 0 *

bb*o|ap*ooa**

• • o *• •a|k

* *

Much worse thanaverage•

Mercedes-BenzS-Ciass

'OS'06'07'08'0910

ee9ooo

©eo©e©oe• ep*ee

e*opo*©o

©pBetter thanaverage©

Page 18: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

2 0 2 C O N S U M E R R E P O R T S B U Y I N G G U I D E 2 0 1 2

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

PaintArim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

Mercury Grand 1 1 Mercury MarinerMarquis 1 1 Hybrid (AWD)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

©eOO• • • toeaaeee

©*****

©*oa*)O*lO*)O*la*

)*apptep*

© © ©

o©ao*

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

• a©©©©©I©©•©©

o©© •

aoaoo©bp©oabb©a

• atete

appBetter thanavérai

Mercury Milan(4-cyl.)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

oaao©©a

a|eab

aa|aBetter thanaverage a

'05'0607'08'0910

©

ee©©bpbaaaa©©oaao©©a©oooooo©o©••©o

OO©©©ooaaoeeeeoaaao©eeeeooppjop

Discontinued

MercuryMountaineer

(2WD)'OS'06'07'08'09

*

*

*

opbb*

optop*•I© Ote*

*appb*©©

• 00b*©©©o*• •o©©©o^ooo©*©•©o*

oaa

ooa• ••b

Discontinued

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

PaintArim

Body integrity

Body Hardware

Power Eguip.

Audio System

Mini CooperHatchback

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

oaa

a•pa

op

©o©©

ao

oa

©p©a

o

o

aaoo©

o©©o©o

a

oa

• • • o

•MpppI©Average o

Mini CooperHatchback S

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

•toteteoa

otetepa©eee

o

op© •

aaa©

oa

o •©toboaa

b

00©

Worse thanaverage ©

MitsubishiOutiander

'0S'06'07'08'09't0

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*ee

eoa*

***

o*opaao*©OO*a|©©*

*Much better than

average©

Nissan 3S0Z,370Z Coupe

'OS'06'07'08'0910

o **

b**

© *a*

**

© •

o©b*o

© •*

Op*a©*ao*

o*o

Much worse thana v e r a g e •

OO*ao*o

Nissan Altima(4-cyl.)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

© O

O

©bool©

o ©©

obeo Ob

e^peeaoop

a©©|©|©p|©p

Better thanaverage©

Page 19: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

A U T O R E L I A B I L I T Y 2 0 3

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

PaintArim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

Nissan Altima(V6)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

©©b©©©I©oa

beb©a

o©o©I©

©

©e

oaa©oa©bbbbb©

• • ©

o

oeoe000

ppp|aAverage O

'OS'06'07'08'0910

O

ep*©a*

© •

© © *©a*

o*

a*o*ka©*k*

*p*o*

• ©*|©*o©*o*©|o*|o*

Average o

•O5'06'07'O8'O9'10

Worse thanaverage©

NissanFrontier (4WD)

•05'06'07'08'09'10

OO©p©b©• • ©

©la©

o©©eee©oi©opaoo©o©©•o©aooobte©©

©

• ©©©©©

•pppppAverage O

©©©O

©••©o©

oo

o © o©©•©

©©• •o©b|©o©©©oo©©©©oo©©o©©©o©©ooopp|©pp

Average O

TROUBLESPOTS

•0S'06'07'0B'09'10

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

PaintArim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

©oo©©©©0|©

©©©oo•0000

oaaoa

oaoa

aopp a|©

Better thanaverage ©

NissanPathfinder

'05'06'07'08'09'10

*

©O©o©

!• • • ©ooo

a©o©©o*• ©©•ol©*• 000*o©©o*o©©o*ooo©*• ©pp*

Better than

average ©

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

©©©O©

O©©o

©• t e

******

o|©**

© ******

•{•pía*•bbb*

New

© o• • • I ©• ©© • © { •

Nissan Rogue

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

©ool©o©©©©©©©

©©I©©aa|©

Better thanaverage a

'05'06'07'08'09'10

OOo©©

• ©ao©a

©o

• •©©ooo©a©©o©©ooo ©bbb©•©pp©ooo©o©©

©a©

©popppBetter thanaverage©

Page 20: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

2 0 4 C O N S U M E R R E P O R T S B U Y i N G G U I D E 2 0 1 2

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drivt Systtm

Fuel System

ElKtricai

Ciimate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

PaintArtm

Body integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

Nissan Titan(4W0).

'05'06'07'08'09'10

a©©{©©©

©p©oo

apo• •© •

o

o © * *

op©o

•{•3a©©

• *

o©o©*

©©o*

© *

o*

TROUBLESPOTS

Worse thanaverage ©

•OS'06'07 08-09'10

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooiing

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuei System

Eiectricai

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body inteqrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip,

Audio Systemoaa

©bbhMuch better than

average ©

©©

o©^ba

obbtea{©

ate{©tebl©I©

©©o{©{©{©oaoao©

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

©©aoo©o©©b©oa©©te

oa©©©©©oao©o©oo©

oo ooAverage o

•05'06'07^08'09'10

a*

o******

* { ©

*

*

*

a{a*****

o *l©tob*

*p*

******

o*

• ©oaoo©bl©oAverage o

•05'06'07'08'09 '10

• 03©p ©

OO

O

o•o©©aa©{©|©{©•tol©b©3

o©otetoba©

oao©©©

aaatebb©b

obbboa

oa©

©{©teo©o,ooa©ao

©{©bbbkAverage O

•05'06'07'08'09'10

© © •

©©

©©

© ©• ! © •

* *

o{a|©Much better than

average©

Pontiac G6Sedan(V6)

'O5'06'07'08'09't0

oo © o

©©o

o©©pp000

oa©o• • • • ©

• • • •b©©©©©©o• •©©o©oa©a

oooo•|©|©|©b

Discontinued

'OS'06^07'08'09'10

O

aap©•o

p©a oteoa^a*

o

©Ola

©•©

a *

aoo

• ©tob*oo©bp

Better thanaverage ©

Pontiac GrandPrix

•OS'06'07'08'09'10

O©Ote©

©3

ooee

©0©|©OOO©©l©l©©o• • l^too©©a{©|o

pi©

©00

ob|©pDiscontinued

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

©

•tole

ao•{©©tob*

O *

© o

©ao*©©b**oo

o{o**©

New

* *

* *

Page 21: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

A U T O R E L I A B I L I T Y 2 0 5

TROUBLESPOTS

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

Saturn Aura(V6)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

b

epeepi©a©©• • ©• •o

©OOooo©OO©©©OO©pp

Discontinued

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

©©

© •oeoeeee

©eee©©©eoebeeel©

ee

Saturn Outlook(FWD)

'OS'M'07'08'09'10

©©©ee©ee©oeoe©00©©OO

• •o©©©©©o©

©©•©©•• ©o

Much better thanaverage ©

Discontinued

'05'06'07'Oa'09'10

*

*

*

*

O O *• © *eob*

**

©p*0 0 *OO*©©*

•p*Worse thanaverage ©

Saturn Vue(V6)

'0S'06'O7'O«'O9'tO

©

©©ee!

• ©•e©©©©fe©o©^©©00©©©•••o• •tebeeople• •••oeoo©^eee©©eo©oeopppp

Discontinued

Subaru B9Tribeca, Tribeca

'DS'O6'O7'D8'O9'IO

*

eooeb

ep

o©*

| | |©•e©

bb

*

o|e|e|e**

op©©*©ooo*©pp|e*Average O

b**

©p*© © *

e

eeebb*oe

bBetter thanaverage ©

Subaru Forester

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

o

eeeeoeoe

ee©I©©©©©©p©©©©ooopbp©©©©©©©beebb

e

Much better thanaverage ©

'OS'06'07'08'0910

© *O

© e

O

eeeeeOO

e

***

*© I © *© © *ee*© © *©b*

**

I© I © **

lele*e *

*Much better than

average©

Subaru Impreza(non-turbo)

'OS'06'07'08'09'tO

eb

ee©

eooee

e

o©o©©

pp|©©00^©ee

eee?eleeeee©b|©|©|©|©

Better thanaverage©

Page 22: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

2 0 6 C O N S U M E R R E P O R T S B U Y I N G G U I D E 2 0 1 2

TROUBLESPOTS

SubaruImpreza WRX

'OS'06'OT'08'09'IO

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooiing

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuei System

Eiectricai

Ciimate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

PaintArim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

|©*l©

* teo*e*te

e©*e©a*e

e*

*oo*

*

**bp*

O *

*tea*

ap*pp*Worse thanaverage ©

Subaru Legacy

'05'06'07'08'0910

aao

oaooeoeoabaoeeoo©ate

©a©e

aeeoe

OOOOoeoo

ee

aeeeteteaee

| | |Much better than

average ©

Subaru Outback(4-cyl.)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

Oe©e

e•tea©eae

eee©ooao

oe

oaee

oeeapb

o

eeoeo

ab

Better thanaverage a

©a

o

eo

e*

oee*

©o*o*

o*

Toyota4Runner(V6)

'OS'06'07'08'0910

oooaaeele

eeeoeeaao©p

apAverage O

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooiing

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuei System

Eiectricai

Ciimate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

PaintArim

Body integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

Toyota Avaion

'05'06'07'08'09'10

ee

ee©©eeoe©©ee©e

oooeeeeeaaeeee©eooo©eeooe©a|a|a|e|e

Average o

Toyota Camry(4-cyi.)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

O

ee

aaee

eteeaaooe

eeeeleete

oooeeopba

oteeteo

ob ao

Better thanaverage a

Toyota Camry(V6)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

OO

eaeeoeeaee

epeeeea©ooa

aoaeee

eeee©eeea©

o©oo

Average o

00

Toyota CamryHybrid

'OS'06'07'08'0910

a

©e

eeooo

aea a'

©{eteiBetter thanaverage©

Toyota CamrySolara (V6)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

ea

ate©©o

eoo00eeeo

eDiscontinued

Page 23: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

A U T O R E L I A B I L I T Y 2 0 7

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

PaintArim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electricai

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

PaintArim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

Toyota Corolla

'05'06'07'08'09'10

Toyota FJCruiser

ToyotaHighlander (V6)

I Toyota I¡Highlander Hybridl

'OS'06'07'08'0910

o©©

a©a|©e

)©©bbbb©

©ao

Average O

Toyota RAV4(4-cyl.)

'OS'06'07'08'0910

O

aaa©o

ee

eeeapoa

a©©©oa a

Much better thanaverage ©

'OS'06'07'08'0910 'OS'06'07'08'09'10

Toyota RAV4(V6)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

a

Ob©aoo

oa

eeeOO

aa©©©op

Much better thanaverage ©

aa

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

ao

eee

ooo©©©©o• •©o©

©o©o

o

oBetter thanaverage a

Toyota Matrix

'0S'06'07'08'O9'i0

©o©

eeOO • ©

eeo©ooa

ab

OO

a

oap©a

b

Better thanaverage a

Toyota Sienna(V6, FWD)

'OS'06'07'0B'09'1O

©©

a|©©bpeeeeweeeeee

oooaaoooao•©oobbao

a|aop|aaBetter thanaverage ©

Page 24: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

2 0 8 C O N S U M E R R E P O R T S B U Y i N G G U i D E 2 0 1 2

T R O U B L ES P O T S

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Electrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

PaintArim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

Toyota Tacoma|V6,4WD)

Volkswagen CC

TROUBLESPOTS

Engine, major

Engine, minor

Engine Cooling

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuei System

Eiectrical

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

PaintArim

Body Integrity

Body Hardware

Power Equip.

Audio System

Page 25: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

A U T O R E L I A B I L I T Y 2 0 9

TROUBLESPOTS

yolkswagenNew BeetieConvertible

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

Engine, major

Enqine, minor

Engine Cooiing

Trans. Major

Trans. Minor

Drive System

Fuel System

Eiectricai

Climate System

Suspension

Brakes

Exhaust

Paint/Trim

Body integrity

Body Hardware

Power Eguip.

Audio System

a©tob©

©©©

• ©oo*©©©©*

• ©a©• tob |©*

©{©0 © 0 *

New

yoikswaaenPassat

(4-cyl., FWD)

VolkswagenTiguan

New

Volvo S80(6-cyl.)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

*

*

*

*

*

© *O *© *

3©OO

OO©O©*© © • *• © •©©o*

Averaqeo

'OS'06'07'08'09 •»

©

Better thanaverage©

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

*

© { © *©©*©©*

3 *oo*3 © *3 0 *

*©*

O*©*©*

©©*©*

Better thanaverage 3

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

*

*

*

*

O© a©obbo*

© *oto©

©poal©*©a©

©©o©*

©bo©©*©oo*

atea©a*

©bbbb*Average o

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

*

*

*

*

©{©I©*©©*

©a©*©©©*©©©*o©©*o©©*

• © a *© © • *©©o*0 0 © *• ©

*bbBetter thanaverage ©

Voivo XC90(6-cyl.)

'OS'06'07'08'09'10

©©

© © ©

O©©{©©©©{©• ©©a©

00©oop©oo• © © •

•{3ppAverage O

Page 26: Consumer Reports Buying Guide 2012 - Auto Reliability

Copyright of Consumer Reports is the property of Consumers Union and its content may not be copied or

emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission.

However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.